VMware PEX Boot Camp - The Future Now: NetApp Clustered Storage and Flash for the Enterprise
All-Flash Versus Hybrid VMware Virtual SAN™: Performance vs. Price
-
Upload
western-digital -
Category
Technology
-
view
746 -
download
1
Transcript of All-Flash Versus Hybrid VMware Virtual SAN™: Performance vs. Price
1
Jack Poller, ESG Analyst
The All-Flash Versus Hybrid Virtual SAN™:
Performance vs. PriceMay 2016
Patric Chang, Senior Director, SanDisk
Jase McCarty, Sr Technical Marketing Architect, VMware
2
Forward Looking StatementDuring our meeting today we will make forward-looking statements. Any statement that refers to expectations, projections or other characterizations of future events or circumstances
is a forward-looking statement, including those relating to market growth, industry trends, future products, product performance and product capabilities. This presentation also contains forward-looking statements attributed to third parties, which reflect their projections as of the date of issuance.
Actual results may differ materially from those expressed in these forward-looking statements due to a number of risks and uncertainties, including the factors detailed under the caption “Risk Factors” and elsewhere in the documents we file from time to time with the SEC, including our annual and quarterly reports.
We undertake no obligation to update these forward-looking statements, which speak only as of the date hereof or as of the date of issuance by a third party, as the case may be.
3
Speakers OverviewPatric Chang, Sr Director, Strategic Partner Ecosystems, Western DigitalPatric Chang works in SanDisk’s Strategic Partner Ecosystems. He has deep experience in solution and business development in virtualization, End User computing or Virtual Desktop Infrastructure and cloud computing. Patric has broad industry experience in working with leading ISVs and OEMs to utilize flash, server, storage and networking products for enterprise applications, IaaS, SaaS and other cloud solutions. Patric Chang has spoken at numerous leading trade shows and events including various VMUGs, VMworld and Oracle Open World.
Jack Poller, Sr Lab Analyst, Enterprise Strategy Group (ESG)As a Lab Analyst at Enterprise Strategy Group, Jack Poller provides independent, hands-on validation and analysis of emerging IT hardware and software products including software-defined networking and storage, virtualization, security, and IT systems management. Jack brings more than 25 years of IT industry experience to his role. Prior to joining ESG, he spent 10 years as a marketing consultant for storage and networking startups. Jack’s formative years in the industry were spent as a software and hardware engineer, developing 3D graphics, storage and networking chips and systems at vendors like Novel, NeTpower, Chromatic Research, Rendition, and Silverback Systems. Jack received a BSc in Applied Math and Computer Science from Carnegie Mellon University, and an MBA from the Leavy School of Business at Santa Clara University.
Jase McCarty, Staff Technical Marketing Architect, VMware StorageJase McCarty has a diverse history in technology over the past 25 years. As a customer, he has worked in academics, health insurance, financials, and the military, in positions ranging from administration, architecture, web development, instruction, & training. Previous to coming to VMware, he was a vSpecialist at EMC, supporting the Federal Government. He has co-authored two books on VMware virtualization, maintains a technical blog at jasemccarty.com, and is active on Twitter as @jasemccarty.
4
Topics Covered Today
All-Flash Versus Hybrid VMware Virtual SAN™: Performance vs. Price – Jack Poller
Key features and highlights of Virtual SAN – Jase McCarty SanDisk® Flash Product Portfolio and Reference Architectures
for Virtual SAN – Patric Chang Q&A
5
Optimize VMware Virtual SAN 6 with SanDisk SSDs – ESG Lab Report
5
6
Storage Challenges
Device management
Power and cooling costs
Need to support growing virtual server environments
Running out of physical space
Management, optimization and au-tomation of data placement
Data migration
Staff costs
Data protection (e.g. backup/re-covery, etc.)
Rapid data growth rate
Hardware costs
18%
18%
20%
20%
20%
23%
23%
26%
26%
27%
5%
6%
5%
6%
4%
4%
6%
8%
8%
7%
In general, what would you say are your organization’s biggest challenges in terms of its stor-age environment? Which would you characterize as the primary storage challenge for your
organization? (Percent of respondents, N=373, top ten shown)
Primary storage challenge
Source: ESG Research Report, 2015 Data Storage Market Trends, October 2015 © 2016 by The Enterprise Strategy Group, Inc.
7
Top 10 IT Priorities
Source: ESG Research Report, 2015 Data Storage Market Trends, October 2015 © 2016 by The Enterprise Strategy Group, Inc.
Business continuity/disaster recovery programs
Improving collaboration capabilities
Desktop virtualization
Increasing use of server virtualization
Major application deployments or upgrades
Improving data backup and recovery
Data integration
Managing data growth
Business intelligence/data analytics initiatives
Cybersecurity initiatives
18%
19%
20%
20%
20%
20%
21%
22%
23%
37%
Top 10 most important IT priorities over the next 12 months. (Percent of re-spondents, N=633, ten responses accepted)
8
VMware Virtual SAN
3—64 NodesVMware VSAN
Virtual Data Store
VirtualMachines
VMware VSAN 6Hyper-Converged
Infrastructure
9
SanDisk® Optimus SSDs
10
Test Bed
VMware VSANVirtual Data Store
8 Virtual Machines2 per Physical Server
4 Industry Standard ServersVMware VSAN 6
SQL ServerAll-FlashHybrid
11
Hybrid All Flash0
1,000,000
2,000,000
3,000,000
1,702,776
2,542,760
HammerDB Performance ResultsVMware VSAN with SanDisk SSDs
New
Ord
ers p
er M
inut
e (N
OPM
)
49%
Test Results: Performance NOPMs
12
Hybrid All Flash0
100,000
200,000
300,000
400,000
HammerDB Results for Each Individual VMVMware VSAN with SanDisk SSDs
New
Ord
ers p
er M
inut
e (N
OPM
)
Test Results: NOPMs for each VM
13
Hybrid All Flash0.00
0.05
0.10
0.15
0.20
0.25
0.20
0.14
HammerDB Price/Performance: $/New Orders Per MinuteVMware VSAN with SanDisk SSDs
$ / N
ew O
rder
s Per
Min
ute
($/N
OPM
)
Test Results: Price/Performance
14
Why This Matters Storage performance can be a limiting factor in database and virtual environments
A hybrid four-node Virtual SAN cluster with SanDisk SSDs delivered 1,702,776 new orders per minute
An all-flash four-node Virtual SAN cluster with SanDisk SSDs delivered 2,542,760 new orders per minute
The all-flash configuration delivered 49% better performance and 26% better price/performance
Higher performance means less hardware, saving on power, cooling and application software licensing© 2016 by The Enterprise Strategy Group, Inc.
15
Key features and highlights of Virtual SAN
15
Infrastructure Complexity
• Purpose-built hardware requiring specialized skills
• Complex management and scaling with poor integration
• Challenging to size for VDI
Traditional Infrastructure Hyper-Converged Infrastructure
• Simple storage deployed on commodity x86 servers
• Pay-as-you-grow scaling• High, predictable performance• Policy based storage
IT Shift Virtual SAN+ vSphere + Horizon
VMware HCI: A Single, Seamlessly Integrated Software Layer
17
Scale-OutHyper-Converged
Solution
• Compute, storage, networking delivered as software
• Tightly integrated software stack
• Elastic Scale-Out across x86 building blocks
Software
Software
• Convergence of physical storage on x86 hardware
• Building-block approach
Hardware
Virtual SAN
vSphere
Networking
VMware Virtual SAN: Radically Simple Storage
18
Hyper-Converged Storage Designed for Virtual Machines
vSphere + Virtual SAN…
• Resource efficient hyperconverged solution
• Enterprise-level availability, scalability and performance on standard x86 servers
• Richest set of deployment options
• Deeply integrated with the VMware stack
• All-flash and hybrid configurations
• Scales from 2 to 64 nodes
• Policy-based SLA automation
Overview
Hard disksSSDHard disks
SSDHard disks
SSD
Virtual SAN Datastore
Virtual SAN Simplifies And Automates Storage Management
19
Per-VM Storage Service Levels From a Single Self-tuning Datastore
Storage Policy-Based Management
Virtual SAN Shared
Datastore
vSphere + Virtual SAN
SLAs
Software Automates Control of Service Levels
No more LUNs/Volumes!
Policies Set Basedon Application Needs
Capacity
Performance
Availability
Per VM Storage Policies
20
Virtual SAN Architecture
• Minimum of 3 hosts in a cluster configuration or 2 hosts + witness
• All 3 host must contribute storage
• Recommended that hosts are configured with similar hardware
• Hosts: Scales up to 64
• Disks: Locally attached storageo Hybrid: Magnetic disks and flash deviceso All-Flash: Flash devices only
• Networko 1GB Ethernet ORo 10GB Ethernet (preferred)
• “Witness” component (only metadata) acts as tie-breaker during availability decisionsesxi-01 esxi-02 esxi-03
VSAN network
vSphere Cluster
REPLICA-1 REPLICA-2
VSAN datastore
Witness
21
Tiered All-Flash and Hybrid Options
Caching
DataPersistenceVirtual
SAN
All-Flash
100K IOPS per Host+
sub-millisecond latency
Writes cached first,Reads from capacity tier
Capacity TierFlash Devices
Reads primarily from capacity tier
SSD PCIe NVMe
Hybrid
40K IOPS per Host
Read and Write Cache
Capacity TierSAS / NL-SAS / SATA
SSD PCIe NVMe
Virtual SAN Delivers 6-Nines, Enterprise-Class Availability
22
99.9999%Availability
• With FTT=2 VSAN delivers 6x9s protection less than 32 seconds of downtime/year
• Typical hardware components provides about 2x9s availability level (3.65 days downtime/year)
• Virtual SAN exponentially increases the availability through mirroring across the cluster
• With default availability policy, Virtual SAN delivers 5x9s protection less than 5 minutes of downtime/year
• Assign level of availability on a per-VM basis and adjust on the fly
Available with 2 Failures
<32 sec
Unprecedented Customer Momentum
3500+ Customers in the first 24 months
In my experience VMware solutions are rock solid…we’re ready to nearly double our VSAN deployment.
“”
It really did work as advertised…the fact that I have been able to set it and forget it is huge!
“”
Why Customers Love Virtual SAN
CHOICE
Choose preferred vendorMeet exact needs, no waste
SIMPLICITY
2-click provisioningIntegrated workflows
Policy-driven management
COST
50% TCO savingsSimple to operate
and learn
$
3
PERFORMANCEAND SCALABILITY
1.5 - 5x faster than competitorsPredictable, elastic scaling
VMware Virtual SAN 6.2 Ready For All vSphere Workloads
VMware vSphere + Virtual SAN
End User Computing Test/Dev
ROBOStagingManagementDMZ
BusinessCritical Apps DR / DA
Best storage for VMs
Optimized for vSphere
Enterprise-class resiliency
Business critical app ready
26
SanDisk Certified Products for Virtual SAN and Reference Architectures – Patric Chang
26
27
Flash Family
Fusion ioMemory™ SX350, PX600
Lighting Ascend™, Eco™ and Ultra™ Gen
II
Optimus Ascend ™ Gen II
Optimus Eco™, Optimus MAX™
CloudSpeed, Ascend™, Eco™ and Ultra™
Storage Tier
Caching
Caching, Capacity
Caching, Capacity
Capacity
Capacity, Caching
Capacities
1.0TB - 6.4TB
200GB - 1.6TB
200GB - 1.6TB
2TB, 4TB
100GB - 800GB, 240GB - 960GB
Industry’s Broadest Portfolio For Virtual SAN 6Device Types
PCIe
SAS
SATA
SAS
SAS
Performance
Class F
Class E
Class E
Class E, C
Class C, C, D
28
Reference Architectures with SanDisk Enterprise Flash1 OEM Partner Solution Proof Point Flash-Enabled By
Optimus Ascend & Optimus MAX on Lenovo System X 3650 M5 Servers
3.08 Million New Orders Per Minute1 using HammerDB and SQL Server 2014 on All-Flash 4-node Virtual SAN
Lightning Ascend and Eco Gen. II on Dell R730 Gen13 Servers
800 Horizon View 6 Desktops using Login VSI on All-Flash 4-node Virtual SAN
Lightning Ascend and Eco Gen. II on Dell R730 Gen13 Servers
Tested for Online Transaction Processing using HammerDB and Oracle 12c on All-Flash 4-node Virtual SAN
Fusion ioMemory (PCIe) on HP ProLiant DL360 Gen9 Servers
300 Horizon View 6 Desktops on 3-node Hybrid Virtual SAN tested using VMware View Planner
Optimus Ascend & Optimus MAX on Lenovo System X 3650 M5 Servers
Business Critical Applications and VDI DesktopsVDI tested using VMware Horizon View Planneron All-Flash 4-node Virtual SAN
Lightning Ascend and Eco Gen. II on Dell FX2 Servers
1.18 Million Orders Per Minute using DVD Store Version 2.1 and All-Flash 4-node Virtual SAN
1 Reference Architectures developed with VMware and our OEM Partners in VSAN Smart Play directory here.
29
Business Critical Application Solution with All-Flash Virtual SANHigh performance and low cost solution for Business Critical Applications and Databases
3.08 Million New Orders Per Minute (NOPMs) on 4-Node Virtual SAN Cluster1
1 Based on Performance tests conducted by SanDisk using HammerDB and SQL Server Database.
Disk Group 2
4 node VSAN Cluster for OLTP Workload
vSphere 6.0 and Virtual SAN 6.0
SQL
Disk Group 1
Disk Group 2Disk
Group 1
Disk Group 2Disk
Group 1
Disk Group 2Disk
Group 1
Node 4Node 3Node 2Node 1
SQL
SQL SQL SQL
SQL SQL SQLServer Platform 4 Nodes of Lenovo System X 3650 M5 series servers 2 Disk Groups per node (1:2)
Caching: SanDisk Optimus Ascend Gen II 6G SAS Drive (800 GB) Capacity: SanDisk Optimus Max SAS Drive (4.0 TB)
Disk Controller: M5210 RAID ControllerVM Configuration 16 vCPU and 96 GB RAM 8 VMs – each node running 2 VMs and 2 database instances 10 disk files @ 800GB Total for each VM (OS 100GB & DB 800GB & Log 100GB), Software Virtual SAN 6.0 vSphere 6, vCenter Server 6 SQL Server 2014 Standard without SA HammerDB - OLTP 5000 Warehouse workload
30
Business Critical Application Solution and VDI with SupermicroHigh performance and low cost solution for Business Critical Applications and VDI Desktops
128 TB of Raw Flash Capacity in 4-Node VSAN Cluster
Disk Group 2
4 node VSAN Cluster for OLTP Workload
vSphere 6.0 and Virtual SAN 6.0
Disk Group 1
Disk Group 2Disk
Group 1
Disk Group 2Disk
Group 1
Disk Group 2Disk
Group 1
Node 4Node 3Node 2Node 1
Server Platform 4 Nodes of TwinPro2 Server w/3008 8 E5-2670V3 CPUs per node 1024GB Memory per node 64TB Raw Flash Capacity per node
4 Disk Groups per node (1:2) Caching: SanDisk Optimus Ascend Gen II 6G SAS Drive (800 GB) Capacity: SanDisk Optimus Max SAS Drive (4.0 TB)
Disk Controller: SMC3008 12GB SAS/HBA/2Software Virtual SAN 6.0 vSphere 6 vCenter Server 6
31
Virtual SAN 6 Ready Nodes with SanDisk Enterprise Flash1 Partner Certified VSAN Ready Nodes Reference Architecture Flash-Enabled By
Optimus Ascend & Optimus MAX on Lenovo System X M5 Servers:AF-6: Lenovo System x3550/x3650 M5, 15.3TB per nodeAF-8: Lenovo System x3650 M5, 30.7TB per node
3.08 Million New Orders Per Minute4 using HammerDB and SQL Server 2014 on All-Flash 4-node Virtual SAN
Optimus Ascend & Optimus MAX on Supermicro Servers: AF-6: SMC TwinPro2 2U, 32TB per node
730 Horizon View 6 VDI Desktops5
on All-Flash 4-node Virtual SAN tested using VMware Horizon View Planner
Fusion ioMemory on HP ProLiant DL360 Gen9 Servers: HY-8 Series DL360 Gen9 VDI 12TB per node
300 Horizon View 6 Desktops3 on 3-node Hybrid Virtual SAN tested using VMware View Planner
With Lightning II on Dell FX2 Platform:AF-6: DELL FX2 FC430, 4-Nodes, 8TB per NodeAF-6: DELL FX2 FC630, 3-Nodes, 8TB per NodeAF-6: DELL FX2 FC830, 3-Nodes, 8TB per NodeAF-8: DELL FX2 FC630, 3-Nodes, 12TB per NodeAF-8: DELL FX2 FC830, 3-Nodes, 12TB per Node
1.18 Million Orders Per Minute2 using DVD Store Version 2.1 and All-Flash 4-node Virtual SAN
Lightning Ascend on Dell R730 Gen13 Servers: HY-6: DELL 730xd, 8TB Per Node
Horizon View 6 Desktopsusing Login VSI on All-Flash 4-node Virtual SAN
1 Posted on VMware Compatibility Guide for Virtual SAN here.
32
All-Flash Virtual SAN
32
Unprecedented Customer Momentum
3500+ Customers in the first 24 months
In my experience VMware solutions are rock solid…we’re ready to nearly double our VSAN deployment.
“”
It really did work as advertised…the fact that I have been able to set it and forget it is huge!
“”
34
Oregon State University: High Performance for VDI with Budget-friendly Scaling
Corvallis, OregonAcademic Institution 26,000 students
Challenge• Storage overburdened by VDI workloads
• User login took over 20 minutes during peak times
• Recomposing VDI environment took 10+ hours
• Limited storage budget
Solution
• Virtual SAN on industry standard x86 servers
Results
• Drastically better performance: user login time reduced from 20 minutes to 1 minute
• Increased VDI scale: support 170+ additional users on existing servers/network
• Simplified management: resetting desktops reduced from 10 hours to <2 hours
• Lower cost and ease of scale: lowered acquisition costs by 75% and enabled easier scaling for future needs
Boot Time20x
Faster
VDI Density6x
Greater
35
Q&A
36
Patric Chang [email protected]+1-408-597-1442
Jase McCarty [email protected]@jasemccarty
Customer OfferApply for VSAN Assessment now: http://tinyurl.com/vsan-assessment
Or contact us to apply for a free Proof of Concept (POC) or other additional information. We’re here to help.
37
© 2016 Western Digital Corporation or its affiliates. All rights reserved. SanDisk and the SanDisk logo are trademarks of Western Digital Corporation or its affiliates, registered in the U.S. and other countries. Fusion ioMemory, Optimus, Lightning and CloudSpeed are a trademark of Western Digital Corporation or its affiliates. Other brand names mentioned herein are for identification purposes only and may be the trademark(s) of their respective holder(s).