Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements - North · PDF file1 Airport and Airline Use and...

24
1 Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements Capital Program Control & Consultation, Leasing Policies & Space Management, and Rates & Charges Approaches ACI-NA Airport Economics and Finance Conference General Session II May 21, 2007

Transcript of Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements - North · PDF file1 Airport and Airline Use and...

Page 1: Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements - North · PDF file1 Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements Capital Program Control & Consultation, Leasing Policies & Space Management,

1

Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements

Capital Program Control & Consultation, Leasing Policies & Space Management, and Rates & Charges Approaches

ACI-NA Airport Economics and Finance ConferenceGeneral Session II

May 21, 2007

Page 2: Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements - North · PDF file1 Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements Capital Program Control & Consultation, Leasing Policies & Space Management,

2

Introduction At a majority of US airports Airport-Airline Use Agreements form the basis for the business model for the financial operations and space management at US Airports.

A wide range of approaches used at various airports – what is right for your airport will depend on the objectives of and circumstance at your airport.

Airport and airlines may “occasionally” have differing perspectives on what is the optimal approach as well.

During this panel we are going to explore some of pros and cons the different approaches taken by airports in three focal areas, as viewed by some airports that have recently negotiated new agreements, airline representatives, an airport consultant who has negotiated a number of airline agreements.

Page 3: Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements - North · PDF file1 Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements Capital Program Control & Consultation, Leasing Policies & Space Management,

3

PanelSusan Warner-Dooley, Deputy Executive Director, Finance & Administration, Minneapolis-St. Paul Metropolitan Airports Commission

Vince Granato, General Manager, Financial Services, Portland International Airport

Luis Navarro, Manager-Aviation Properties, Seattle-Tacoma International Airport

R. Borgan Anderson, Manager, Aviation Finance and Budget, Seattle-Tacoma International Airport

Trey Hettinger, Airport Properties Representative, United ParcelService

Steve Sisneros, Regional Director, Southwest Airlines

Warren Adams, Director, Jacobs Consultancy

Page 4: Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements - North · PDF file1 Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements Capital Program Control & Consultation, Leasing Policies & Space Management,

4

Format for the Session

Three Areas of Focus:

Capital program control and consultation processes

Leasing policy/space management

Rates & charges methodologies

Process For Each Topic:

Overview

Airport Approach

Airline Perspective

Q&A

Capital Program Control

Leasing Policies

Rates & ChargesMethod

Page 5: Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements - North · PDF file1 Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements Capital Program Control & Consultation, Leasing Policies & Space Management,

5

Construction Control & Consultation

Page 6: Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements - North · PDF file1 Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements Capital Program Control & Consultation, Leasing Policies & Space Management,

6

Airline Involvement in Capital Project Decision Making

Degree of Airline InvolvementApproveDisapprove (deemed approved unless airline expressly disapproves)DeferralConsult Only

Areas Of The Airport That Are CoveredAirfieldTerminalLandside & Other

Page 7: Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements - North · PDF file1 Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements Capital Program Control & Consultation, Leasing Policies & Space Management,

7

Trends: Capital Project Pre-Approval and Exemptions

Approved Programs and ThresholdsTotal Budget vs Approved List of ProjectsDiscretionary Projects

Typical ExclusionsSafety, security, judgments, replacement …

Emerging Trends/Concepts in ExclusionsCapacity-Enhancing Additional Passenger Terminal Improvement Project / space for new or expanding carrier Expenditures for Planning & Preliminary Design

Potential New ExclusionAIP or PFC funded projects at certain funding levels

Page 8: Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements - North · PDF file1 Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements Capital Program Control & Consultation, Leasing Policies & Space Management,

8

Capital Consultation Q&A

Page 9: Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements - North · PDF file1 Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements Capital Program Control & Consultation, Leasing Policies & Space Management,

9

Leasing Policies and Space Management

Page 10: Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements - North · PDF file1 Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements Capital Program Control & Consultation, Leasing Policies & Space Management,

10

Leasing Approach

TrendsTrend away from historical standard of exclusive gates to preferential, common use, or combination Shorter term airline agreements allow airlines to “resize” more frequently and to allow airport to reevaluate the use of their space

IssuesCommon Use Terminal Equipment (CUTE) Vacancy risk for airport operators may be increasing

New ApproachesFormulas or changing ratio of preferential & common gatesDifferent gate use ratios based on number of gates leasedLink gate use to airline approval of new gatesShift of financial risks of vacancies to airlines

Page 11: Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements - North · PDF file1 Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements Capital Program Control & Consultation, Leasing Policies & Space Management,

11

About 40% of future capital needs focused on terminal facilities

Challenges with terminal projects

Lack of “institutional”criteria for proceedingLimited sources of “non-rate based”capitalVacancy riskChanging mix of airline usage

Terminal Buildings—The Next Big Investment

44%

24%31% 30%

27%

25% 17% 19%

9%

18%11% 12%

33% 42% 38%20%

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

Small Medium Large 100 sampleairports

TerminalOther*LandsideAirside

Source: ACI-NA.

Page 12: Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements - North · PDF file1 Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements Capital Program Control & Consultation, Leasing Policies & Space Management,

12

Leased Space: No Airport Control

Low cost carriers are twice as efficient as legacy carriers in use of terminal spaceNear-term issue: More vacancy risk in terminalOngoing risk:Constant airline restructuring

Ratio of Passengers to Leased Space at Large Hub Airport X

0.00

10.00

20.00

30.00

40.00

50.00

60.00

70.00

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005

EPA

X to

leas

ed s

quar

e fo

otag

e

Legacy CarriersLow Cost Carriers

Note: A higher bar means more passengers per leased square foot of space.

Page 13: Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements - North · PDF file1 Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements Capital Program Control & Consultation, Leasing Policies & Space Management,

13

Space Management Q&A

Page 14: Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements - North · PDF file1 Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements Capital Program Control & Consultation, Leasing Policies & Space Management,

14

Rates & Charges

Page 15: Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements - North · PDF file1 Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements Capital Program Control & Consultation, Leasing Policies & Space Management,

15

Industry Snapshot: Rate Making Methodologies

Broad Categories of Residual, Compensatory & Hybrid

There is no defined or standard approach structure within the categories

The use of a particular rate-making approach is typically integrally linked to other negotiated factors, such as

Facility useAirline consultation or MII

RATE MAKING METHODOLOGIESTop 29 Large Hub Airports

Residual, 39.7%

Hybrid, 23.0%

Hybrid with Revenue Sharing, 37.3% Hybrid

total--60.3%

Percent of total based on passengers. Hybrid includes the use of compensatory and residual rate-making methodologies. Results do not include HNL.

Page 16: Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements - North · PDF file1 Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements Capital Program Control & Consultation, Leasing Policies & Space Management,

16

Rate Making Methodology and Level of Cost Per Enplaned Passenger—No Clear Link

LARGE HUB AIRPORTS ESTIMATED 2005/6 CEP

$-

$5.00

$10.00

$15.00

$20.00

$25.00

Airp

ort C

harg

es P

er E

npla

ned

Pass

enge

r

Average

Residual -9 Revenue Sharing - 12 No Revenue Sharing - 6 Other -1

Page 17: Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements - North · PDF file1 Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements Capital Program Control & Consultation, Leasing Policies & Space Management,

17

Rate & Charges Components

Getting to the Bottom LineAirport Discretionary Funds or Accumulated Surpluses

Allocation of Risks/ Sharing of Revenues

Cost Allocations and Recoveries Revenue Sharing Bottom Line Protections

Page 18: Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements - North · PDF file1 Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements Capital Program Control & Consultation, Leasing Policies & Space Management,

18

Discretionary Funds and Accumulation of Surpluses: Taking Rating Agency Metrics into Account

2005 comparisons

Best PracticesLink airline deal with key rating agency metricsEstablish airport goals regarding RA metrics to frame business deal

UNRESTRICTED CASH BALANCES AT LARGE HUB AIRPORTS

-

200

400

600

800

1,000

1,200

1,400

1,600

1,800

2,000

Days

of a

nnua

l ope

ratin

g ex

pens

es

MSP

SEA

Page 19: Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements - North · PDF file1 Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements Capital Program Control & Consultation, Leasing Policies & Space Management,

19

Interdependence: Allocation of Revenues and Costs, and Business Deal

Allocation of revenues and costs has implications for:

RatesRisksManagement

Key issue--What portions get allocated to airline cost centers and how are they distributed to the airline rate-bases

Page 20: Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements - North · PDF file1 Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements Capital Program Control & Consultation, Leasing Policies & Space Management,

20

•Main Terminal Building•Concourses•Terminal Aprons•Terminal Concessions•Enplaning Roadway•Deplaning Roadway•Commercial Roadway

TERMINAL

•Runways•Taxiways•Aircraft Parking

AIRFIELD PORT

•Parking Facilities•Cargo Facilities •Aircraft Maintenance •General Aviation•Roadway Systems•Inflight Kitchens•Hotels•Waterfront Property•Rental Cars

Portland: Cost Center and Rates and Charges Methodologies

INDIRECT EXPENSES•Administration•Operations•Maintenance•Police and Fire & Rescue•Utilities•Corporate OverheadResidual Cost Centers

Page 21: Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements - North · PDF file1 Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements Capital Program Control & Consultation, Leasing Policies & Space Management,

21

Seattle-Tacoma: Rates and Charges Fundamentals

CAPITAL COSTSOperations Airport Admin Debt serviceMaintenance Port Admin Equity amortizationFire Police

Based on project funding(Excludes grant, PFC funded projects)

AIRFIELD COSTS TERMINAL COSTS PORT COSTSOffsets: Divide by sq. ft. of +

Aircraft parking Rentable space Port share of terminalApron rents costs (18%)Airfield rents = Total Port CostsRamp tower fees Airline Terminal Port Revenues:

= Airfield requirement Requirement (82%) Terminal concessionsNon-airline terminal rents

Divide by land wgt. Divide by Rented Parkingsquare feet Rental car

Properties = Landing fee rate = Terminal rental Ground Transportation

rates Utilities= Net Income

OPERATING COSTS

Directly charged or allocated

Business DealAirfield is a cost center residualTerminal is commercial compensatory residual (no vacancy risk)

AllocationsRoadway cost allocation: 25% terminal, 25% Airfield and 50% PortDebt service coverage: rate base coverage = zero unless needed to achieve 1.25x overall coverage

Page 22: Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements - North · PDF file1 Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements Capital Program Control & Consultation, Leasing Policies & Space Management,

22

Revenue Sharing—Industry Trends

About 77% of large hub airports have revenue sharing

Cost center specific orAirport-wide

Why? Emerging Trends/Concepts

Extraordinary coverage protectionShare revenues after all costs are reimbursed (including Airport equity)

RATE MAKING METHODOLOGIESTop 29 Large Hub Airports

Residual, 39.7%

Hybrid with Revenue Sharing,

37.3%

Hybrid, 23.0%

Ranked by passengers. Hybrid includes the use of compensatory and residual rate-making methodologies. Results do not include HNL.

Revenue-sharing total--

77%

Page 23: Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements - North · PDF file1 Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements Capital Program Control & Consultation, Leasing Policies & Space Management,

23

“Bottom-Line” Protections & Incentives: Any Difference between Compensatory and Residual?

Residual DealsGuaranteed payment of operating expenses and debt service Increased discretionary funds through expense savings

Hybrid with/without Revenue SharingRate covenant protectionsMinimum coverage levelsExtraordinary coverage protection

Page 24: Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements - North · PDF file1 Airport and Airline Use and Lease Agreements Capital Program Control & Consultation, Leasing Policies & Space Management,

24

Rates & Charges Q&A