AECL-8381, 'Hydrogen-Induced Delayed Cracking: 2. Effect ... · HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING:...

37
ATOMIC ENERGY OF CANADA LIMITED HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING: 2. EFFECT OF STRESS ON NUCLEATION GROWTH AND COARSENING OF ZIRCONIUM HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES by M.P. Pula Whiteshell Nuclear Research Establishment Pinawa, Manitoba ROE 1LO 1984 December AECL-8381 - 11 -

Transcript of AECL-8381, 'Hydrogen-Induced Delayed Cracking: 2. Effect ... · HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING:...

Page 1: AECL-8381, 'Hydrogen-Induced Delayed Cracking: 2. Effect ... · HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING: 2. EFFECT OF STRESS ON NUCLEATION GROWTH AND COARSENING OF ZIRCONIUM HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES

ATOMIC ENERGY OF CANADA LIMITED

HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING:

2. EFFECT OF STRESS ON NUCLEATIONGROWTH AND COARSENING OF ZIRCONIUM

HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES

by

M.P. Pula

Whiteshell Nuclear Research EstablishmentPinawa, Manitoba ROE 1LO

1984 DecemberAECL-8381

- 11 -

Page 2: AECL-8381, 'Hydrogen-Induced Delayed Cracking: 2. Effect ... · HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING: 2. EFFECT OF STRESS ON NUCLEATION GROWTH AND COARSENING OF ZIRCONIUM HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES

HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING:

2. EFFECT OF STRESS ON NUCLEATION,

GROWTH AND COARSENING OF ZIRCONIUM

HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES

by

M.P. Pula

[COULD NOT BE CONVERTED TO SEARCHABLE TEXT]

. 13 -

Page 3: AECL-8381, 'Hydrogen-Induced Delayed Cracking: 2. Effect ... · HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING: 2. EFFECT OF STRESS ON NUCLEATION GROWTH AND COARSENING OF ZIRCONIUM HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES

1. INTRODUCTION

[COULD NOT BE CONVERTED TO SEARCHABLE TEXT]

-15-

Page 4: AECL-8381, 'Hydrogen-Induced Delayed Cracking: 2. Effect ... · HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING: 2. EFFECT OF STRESS ON NUCLEATION GROWTH AND COARSENING OF ZIRCONIUM HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES

-2-

[COULD NOT BE CONVERTED TO SEARCHABLE TEXT]

Page 5: AECL-8381, 'Hydrogen-Induced Delayed Cracking: 2. Effect ... · HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING: 2. EFFECT OF STRESS ON NUCLEATION GROWTH AND COARSENING OF ZIRCONIUM HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES

- 3 -

[COULD NOT BE CONVERTED TO SEARCHABLE TEXT]

Page 6: AECL-8381, 'Hydrogen-Induced Delayed Cracking: 2. Effect ... · HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING: 2. EFFECT OF STRESS ON NUCLEATION GROWTH AND COARSENING OF ZIRCONIUM HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES

-4-[COULD NOT

BE CONVERTED

TO SEARCHABLE TEXT]

Page 7: AECL-8381, 'Hydrogen-Induced Delayed Cracking: 2. Effect ... · HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING: 2. EFFECT OF STRESS ON NUCLEATION GROWTH AND COARSENING OF ZIRCONIUM HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES

-5-

[COULD NOT BE CONVERTED TO SEARCHABLE TEXT]

Page 8: AECL-8381, 'Hydrogen-Induced Delayed Cracking: 2. Effect ... · HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING: 2. EFFECT OF STRESS ON NUCLEATION GROWTH AND COARSENING OF ZIRCONIUM HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES

-6-

[COULD NOT BE CONVERTED TO SEARCHABLE TEXT]

Page 9: AECL-8381, 'Hydrogen-Induced Delayed Cracking: 2. Effect ... · HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING: 2. EFFECT OF STRESS ON NUCLEATION GROWTH AND COARSENING OF ZIRCONIUM HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES

- 7-

[COULD NOT BE CONVERTED TO SEARCHABLE TEXT]

Page 10: AECL-8381, 'Hydrogen-Induced Delayed Cracking: 2. Effect ... · HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING: 2. EFFECT OF STRESS ON NUCLEATION GROWTH AND COARSENING OF ZIRCONIUM HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES

- 8-

[COULD NOT BE CONVERTED TO SEARCHABLE TEXT]

Page 11: AECL-8381, 'Hydrogen-Induced Delayed Cracking: 2. Effect ... · HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING: 2. EFFECT OF STRESS ON NUCLEATION GROWTH AND COARSENING OF ZIRCONIUM HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES

- 9 -

[COULD NOT BE CONVERTED TO SEARCHABLE TEXT]

Page 12: AECL-8381, 'Hydrogen-Induced Delayed Cracking: 2. Effect ... · HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING: 2. EFFECT OF STRESS ON NUCLEATION GROWTH AND COARSENING OF ZIRCONIUM HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES

- 10 -

[COULD NOT BE CONVERTED TO SEARCHABLE TEXT]

Page 13: AECL-8381, 'Hydrogen-Induced Delayed Cracking: 2. Effect ... · HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING: 2. EFFECT OF STRESS ON NUCLEATION GROWTH AND COARSENING OF ZIRCONIUM HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES

- 11 -

[COULD NOT BE CONVERTED TO SEARCHABLE TEXT]

Page 14: AECL-8381, 'Hydrogen-Induced Delayed Cracking: 2. Effect ... · HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING: 2. EFFECT OF STRESS ON NUCLEATION GROWTH AND COARSENING OF ZIRCONIUM HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES

- 12 -

[COULD NOT BE CONVERTED TO SEARCHABLE TEXT]

Page 15: AECL-8381, 'Hydrogen-Induced Delayed Cracking: 2. Effect ... · HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING: 2. EFFECT OF STRESS ON NUCLEATION GROWTH AND COARSENING OF ZIRCONIUM HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES

-13-

- 13 -

[COULD

NOT

BE CONVERTED TO SEARCHABLE TEXT]

Page 16: AECL-8381, 'Hydrogen-Induced Delayed Cracking: 2. Effect ... · HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING: 2. EFFECT OF STRESS ON NUCLEATION GROWTH AND COARSENING OF ZIRCONIUM HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES

-14-

[COULD NOT BE CONVERTED TO SEARCHABLE TEXT]

Page 17: AECL-8381, 'Hydrogen-Induced Delayed Cracking: 2. Effect ... · HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING: 2. EFFECT OF STRESS ON NUCLEATION GROWTH AND COARSENING OF ZIRCONIUM HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES

- 15 -

[COULD NOT BE CONVERTED TO SEARCHABLE TEXT]

Page 18: AECL-8381, 'Hydrogen-Induced Delayed Cracking: 2. Effect ... · HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING: 2. EFFECT OF STRESS ON NUCLEATION GROWTH AND COARSENING OF ZIRCONIUM HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES

- 16 -

[COULD NOT BE CONVERTED TO SEARCHABLE TEXT]

Page 19: AECL-8381, 'Hydrogen-Induced Delayed Cracking: 2. Effect ... · HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING: 2. EFFECT OF STRESS ON NUCLEATION GROWTH AND COARSENING OF ZIRCONIUM HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES

17

[COULD NOT BE CONVERTED TO SEARCHABLE TEXT]

Page 20: AECL-8381, 'Hydrogen-Induced Delayed Cracking: 2. Effect ... · HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING: 2. EFFECT OF STRESS ON NUCLEATION GROWTH AND COARSENING OF ZIRCONIUM HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES

-18-

[COULD NOT BE CONVERTED TO SEARCHABLE TEXT]

Page 21: AECL-8381, 'Hydrogen-Induced Delayed Cracking: 2. Effect ... · HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING: 2. EFFECT OF STRESS ON NUCLEATION GROWTH AND COARSENING OF ZIRCONIUM HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES

- 19 -

[COULD NOT BE CONVERTED TO SEARCHABLE TEXT]

Page 22: AECL-8381, 'Hydrogen-Induced Delayed Cracking: 2. Effect ... · HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING: 2. EFFECT OF STRESS ON NUCLEATION GROWTH AND COARSENING OF ZIRCONIUM HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES

-20-

[COULD NOT BE CONVERTED TO SEARCHABLE TEXT]

Page 23: AECL-8381, 'Hydrogen-Induced Delayed Cracking: 2. Effect ... · HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING: 2. EFFECT OF STRESS ON NUCLEATION GROWTH AND COARSENING OF ZIRCONIUM HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES

21 -

[COULD NOT BE CONVERTED TO SEARCHABLE TEXT]

Page 24: AECL-8381, 'Hydrogen-Induced Delayed Cracking: 2. Effect ... · HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING: 2. EFFECT OF STRESS ON NUCLEATION GROWTH AND COARSENING OF ZIRCONIUM HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES

-22 -

[COULD NOT BE CONVERTED TO SEARCHABLE TEXT]

Page 25: AECL-8381, 'Hydrogen-Induced Delayed Cracking: 2. Effect ... · HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING: 2. EFFECT OF STRESS ON NUCLEATION GROWTH AND COARSENING OF ZIRCONIUM HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES

- 23 -

TABLE 1

SUMMARY OF TSS DATA FOR HYDROGEN IN ZIRCONIUM AND ZIRCALOY-2

USED TO DETERMINE THE CHEMICAL FREE ENERGY FOR NUCLEATION

[COULD NOT BE CONVERTED TO SEARCHABLE TEXT]

Page 26: AECL-8381, 'Hydrogen-Induced Delayed Cracking: 2. Effect ... · HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING: 2. EFFECT OF STRESS ON NUCLEATION GROWTH AND COARSENING OF ZIRCONIUM HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES

- 24 -

TABLE 2

VALUES OF UNDERCOOLING FROM THE CONSTRAINED SOLVUS DERIVED FROM

THE TSS DATA (SUMMARIZED IN TABLE 1) FOR ZIRCONIUM AND ZIRCALOY-2

[COULD NOT BE CONVERTED TO SEARCHABLE TEXT]

Page 27: AECL-8381, 'Hydrogen-Induced Delayed Cracking: 2. Effect ... · HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING: 2. EFFECT OF STRESS ON NUCLEATION GROWTH AND COARSENING OF ZIRCONIUM HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES

- 25 -

TABLE 3

CRITICAL HOMOGENEOUS NUCLEATION ENERGIES

FOR AND HYDRIDES IN ZIRCALOY-2 AND ZIRCONIUM

[COULD NOT BE CONV

ERTED TO SEA

RCHABLE TEXT]

Page 28: AECL-8381, 'Hydrogen-Induced Delayed Cracking: 2. Effect ... · HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING: 2. EFFECT OF STRESS ON NUCLEATION GROWTH AND COARSENING OF ZIRCONIUM HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES

TABLE 4

VALUES OF SOME PHYSICAL CONSTANTS AND CRITICAL NUCLEI DIMENSIONS

THAT GIVE ACCEPTABLE NUCLEATION RATES AT ZERO EXTERNAL STRESS

[COULD NOT BE CONVERTED TO SEARCHABLE TEXT]

Page 29: AECL-8381, 'Hydrogen-Induced Delayed Cracking: 2. Effect ... · HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING: 2. EFFECT OF STRESS ON NUCLEATION GROWTH AND COARSENING OF ZIRCONIUM HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES

- 27 -

TABLE 5

EFFECT OF A UNIAXIAL EXTERNAL TENSILE STRESS ON TEH ORIENTING TENDENCY

OF v- AND HYDRIDES DURING NUCLEATION, USING THE HYDRIDE MISFIT STRAINS

DETERMINED BY CARPENTER [18]

[COULD NOT BE CONVERTED TO SEARCHABLE TEXT]

Page 30: AECL-8381, 'Hydrogen-Induced Delayed Cracking: 2. Effect ... · HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING: 2. EFFECT OF STRESS ON NUCLEATION GROWTH AND COARSENING OF ZIRCONIUM HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES

- 28 -

TABLE 6

TIME, At, TO INCREASE THE INITIAL MEAN HYDRIDE RADIUS

BY 60% DURING COARSENING[COULD

NOT BE CONVERTED TO SEARCHABLE

TEXT]

Page 31: AECL-8381, 'Hydrogen-Induced Delayed Cracking: 2. Effect ... · HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING: 2. EFFECT OF STRESS ON NUCLEATION GROWTH AND COARSENING OF ZIRCONIUM HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES

- A-l --

APPENDIX A

EXPRESSIONS FOR THE CRITICAL NUCLEATION ENERGY

FOR DELTA AND GAMMA HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES

A. Delta Hydrides

We assume that the hydrides precipitate as disca on the basal

plane of. the hop zirconium lattice. For the purpose of calculating the

strain energy. the plate is approximated by an oblate spheroid with major

axis a and minor axis c. To simplify the calculation for the total inter-

facial energy, it is convenient to consider the plate as a disc of radius

'a' and thickness '2c'. It in then assumed that the face of the disc is

coherent with the matrix, with a specific interfacial energy y, whereas

the sides are incoherent, with a specific interfacial energy The total

free energy for nucleation, AG. for the oblate spheroid having volume

Vplate 4/3 * a c Is given by

[COULD NOT BE CONVERTED TO SEARCHABLE TEXT]

where Ag is the absolute value of the Gibbs free energy of transform-

ation per unit volume, excluding strain energy contributions (the chemical

free energy), and Ag and Ag are the self-strain and interaction

energies per unit volume, respectively. In the notation of I,

Page 32: AECL-8381, 'Hydrogen-Induced Delayed Cracking: 2. Effect ... · HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING: 2. EFFECT OF STRESS ON NUCLEATION GROWTH AND COARSENING OF ZIRCONIUM HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES

A-2

[COULD NOT BE CONVERTED TO SEARCHABLE TEXT]

Page 33: AECL-8381, 'Hydrogen-Induced Delayed Cracking: 2. Effect ... · HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING: 2. EFFECT OF STRESS ON NUCLEATION GROWTH AND COARSENING OF ZIRCONIUM HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES

- A-3 -

[COULD NOT BE CONVERTED TO SEARCHABLE TEXT]

Page 34: AECL-8381, 'Hydrogen-Induced Delayed Cracking: 2. Effect ... · HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING: 2. EFFECT OF STRESS ON NUCLEATION GROWTH AND COARSENING OF ZIRCONIUM HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES

- A-4 -

[COULD NOT BE CONVERTED TO SEARCHABLE TEXT]

Page 35: AECL-8381, 'Hydrogen-Induced Delayed Cracking: 2. Effect ... · HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING: 2. EFFECT OF STRESS ON NUCLEATION GROWTH AND COARSENING OF ZIRCONIUM HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES

- A-5 -

[COULD NOT BE CONVERTED TO SEARCHABLE TEXT]

Page 36: AECL-8381, 'Hydrogen-Induced Delayed Cracking: 2. Effect ... · HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING: 2. EFFECT OF STRESS ON NUCLEATION GROWTH AND COARSENING OF ZIRCONIUM HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES

- A-6 -

[COULD NOT BE CONVERTED TO SEARCHABLE TEXT]

Page 37: AECL-8381, 'Hydrogen-Induced Delayed Cracking: 2. Effect ... · HYDROGEN-INDUCED DELAYED CRACKING: 2. EFFECT OF STRESS ON NUCLEATION GROWTH AND COARSENING OF ZIRCONIUM HYDRIDE PRECIPITATES

[COULD NOT BE CONVERTED TO SEARCHABLE TEXT]