ZnO Nanostructures for Dye-S

By Qifeng Zhang,* Christopher S. Dandeneau

in the past, it is expected that new technology could make themmore practical and price competitive with fossil fuels, thusenabling an eventual transition away from fossil fuels as ourprimary energy sources. Solar energy is considered to be theultimate solution to the energy and environmental challenge as acarbon-neutral energy source.

The conversion from solar energy to electricity is fulfilled bysolar-cell devices based on the photovoltaic effect. Manyphotovoltaic devices have already been developed over the pastfive decades.[13] However, wide-spread use is still limited by twosignificant challenges, namely conversion efficiency and cost.[46]

One of the traditional photovoltaic devices is the single-crystallinesilicon solar cell, which was invented more than 50 years ago andcurrently makes up 94% of themarket.[7] Single-crystalline siliconsolar cells operate on the principle of pn junctions formed byjoining p-type and n-type semiconductors. The electrons andholes are photogenerated at the interface of pn junctions,separated by the electrical field across the pn junction, and

and have high optidemonstrated sing1632%.[19] Althoughor compound semefficiency for practicato meet the long-term

To aim at further losolar cells (DSCs) badyes or metallorganpromising approachDSCs are a photoeleporous-structured oxphotosensitized ano(FTO) glass acts asliquid electrolyte thatserves as a conductor to electrically connect the two electro-des.[2025] During operation, photons captured by the dyemonolayer create excitons that are rapidly split at the nanocrys-

injected into theuples in the liquidventional single-tor thin-film solar

otovoltaicand cost

btained on

REVIEW

www.advmat.de

University of Washington, Seattle, WA 98195 (USA)

Z

n

fi

r

ff

u

s

ro

roDOI: 10.1002/adma.200803827cells, DSCs are thought to be advantageous as a phdevice possessing both practicable high efficiencyeffectiveness. To date, the most successful DSC was o

E-mail: qfzhang@u.washington.edu; gzcao@u.washington.educollected through external circuits. In principle, the single- tallite surface of the oxide film. Electrons areoxide film and holes are released by the redox coelectrolyte (Fig. 1a). Compared with the concrystal silicon-based or compound-semiconduc

[*] Dr. Q. F. Zhang, C. S. Dandeneau, Dr. X. Y. Zhou, Prof. G. Z. CaoDepartment of Materials Science and EngineeringGuozhong Cao*

1. Introduction

The increasing demand for fossil fuels and the environmentalimpact of their use are continuing to exert pressure on analready-stretched world energy infrastructure. Significant pro-gress has been made in the development of renewable-energytechnologies, such as solar cells, fuel cells, and biofuels. However,although these alternative energy sources have beenmarginalized

This Review focuses on recent developments in the use of

nanostructures for dye-sensitized solar cell (DSC) applicatio

that carefully designed and fabricated nanostructured ZnO

advantageous for use as a DSC photoelectrode as they offe

areas than bulk film material, direct electron pathways, or e

light-scattering centers, and, when combined with TiO2, prod

structure that reduces the combination rate. The limitation

DSCs are also discussed and several possible methods are p

expand the knowledge of ZnO to TiO2, motivating further imp

power-conversion efficiency of DSCs.Adv. Mater. 2009, 21, 40874108 2009 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheical absorbance.[1618] These devices havele-junction conversion efficiencies ofthose photovoltaic devices built on siliconiconductors have been achieving highl use, they still require major breakthroughsgoal of very-low cost (US$0.40 kWh1).[1]

wering the production costs, dye-sensitizedsed on oxide semiconductors and organicic-complex dyes have recently emerged asto efficient solar-energy conversion. Thectrochemical system, which incorporate aide film with adsorbed dye molecules as thede. A platinized fluorine-doped tin oxidethe counter electrode (i.e., cathode), and atraditionally contains I/I3

redox couplesensitized Solar Cells

, Xiaoyuan Zhou, and

crystalline silicon semiconductor can reach92% of the theoretical attainable energyconversion, with 20% conversion efficiencyin commercial designs. However, becauseof the considerably high material costs,thin-film solar cells have been developed toaddress the product costs.[810] Amorphoussilicon (a-Si) is a candidate for thin-filmsolar cells because its defect energy level canbe controlled by hydrogenation and theband gap can be reduced so that thelight-absorption efficiency is much higherthan crystalline silicon.[11,12] The problem isthat amorphous silicon tends to be unstableand can lose up to 50% of its efficiency

within the first hundred hours. Today, commercial roof productsare available that operate at 15% efficiency. Bridging the gapbetween single-crystalline silicon and amorphous silicon is thepolycrystalline-silicon film, for which a conversion efficiency ofaround 18% is obtained.[1315] Compound semiconductors, suchas gallium arsenide (GaAs), cadmium telluride (CdTe), andcopper indium gallium selenide (CIGS), receive much attentionbecause they present direct energy gaps, can be doped to eitherp-type or n-type, have band gaps matching the solar spectrum,

nO

s. It is shown

lms are

larger surface

ective

ce a coreshell

of ZnO-based

posed so as to

vement in them 4087

REVIEW

www.advmat.de

TiO2 nanocrystalline film (Fig. 1b) combined with a rutheniumpolypyridine complex dye, as first reported by ORegan andGratzel in 1991.[26] Following this idea, a certified overallconversion efficiency of 10.4% was achieved on aTiO2RuL(NCS)3 (black dye) system, in which the spectralresponse of the complex dye was extended into the near-infraredregion so as to absorb far more of the incident light.[20,2729] Theporous nature of nanocrystalline TiO2 films drives their use inDSCs due to the large surface area available for dye-moleculeadsorption. Meanwhile, the suitable relative energy levels atthe semiconductorsensitizer interface (i.e., the position of theconduction-band edge of TiO2 being lower than the excited-stateenergy level of the dye) allow for the effective injection ofelectrons from the dye molecules to the semiconductor.[30]

The achievement of acceptable conversion efficiency puts greatconfidence in the ability of DSCs to challenge the high cost ofcommercially available solar cells based on silicon or compoundsemiconcuctors. However, a further increase in conversionefficiency has been limited by energy loss due to recombination

on ZnO-nanostructure-based DSCs have delivered many newconcepts, leading to a better understanding of photoelectro-chemically based energy conversion. This, in turn, would speedup the development of DSCs that are associated with TiO2.

One of the defining features of nanostructures is their basicunits on the nanometer scale. This, first of all, provides thenanostructures with a large specific surface area. It may also

Qifeng Zhang received his Ph.D. degree from Peking Uni-versity (China) in 2001. He iscurrently working in Universityof Washington as an ActingAssistant Professor-Temp. Hisresearch interests involveengineering applications ofnanostructured materials onelectrical devices includingsolar cells, UV light-emitting

diodes (LEDs), field-effect transistors (FETs), and gassensors.

Guozhong Cao is Boeing-Steiner Professor of MaterialsScience and Engineering andAdjunct Professor of Chemical

research is focused mainly on nanomaterials for energyconversion and storage, including solar cells, lithium-ionbatteries, supercapacitors, and hydrogen-storage materials.

. a) Schematic of the construction and operational principle of the device.nes Ltd. b) SEM image of an oxide (TiO2) electrode film with nanocrystallites7, The Royal Society. c) Electron transport in nanocrystalline oxide electrodes,band (denoted as c.b.) of the nanocrystallite (1), the dye is regenerated byation may take place between the injected electrons and the dye cation (2) orant loss mechanism. Electron trapping in the nanocrystallites (5) is also ast unoccupied molecular orbital and the highest occupied molecular orbital of04, Elsevier.

4088between electrons and either the oxidized dye molecules orelectron-accepting species in the electrolyte during the charge-transport process.[3133] Such a recombination is predominatelyderived from the lack of a depletion layer on the TiO2nanocrystallite surface, and becomes significantly serious whenthe thickness of the photoelectrode film is increased. Tounderstand this issue, DSC technology based on ZnO has beenexplored extensively. ZnO is a wide-band-gap semiconductor thatpossesses an energy-band structure and physical propertiessimilar to those of TiO2 (Table 1), but has higher electronicmobility that would be favorable for electron transport, withreduced recombination loss when used in DSCs. Many studieshave already been reported on the use of ZnO material forapplication in DSCs. Although the conversion efficiencies of0.45.8% obtained for ZnO are much lower than that of 11% forTiO2, ZnO is still thought of as a distinguished alternative to TiO2due to its ease of crystallization and anisotropic growth. Theseproperties allow ZnO to be produced in a wide variety ofnanostructures, thus presenting unique properties for electro-nics, optics, or photocatalysis.[3441] In particular, recent studies

Figure 1. A dye-sensitized solar cell based on an electrochemical systemReproduced with permission from [20]. Copyright 2001, Macmillan Magazi(20 nm in diameter). Reproduced with permission from [29]. Copyright 200in which photoexcited electrons are injected from the dye to the conductionelectron transfer from a redox couple in the electrolyte (3), and a recombinredox couple (4). The latter (4) is normally believed to be the predominmechanism that causes energy loss. LUMO and HOMO represent the lowethe dye, respectively. Reproduced with permission from [30]. Copyright 20 2009 WILEY-VCH Verlag Gmband Mechanical Engineering atthe University of Washington.He has published over 200refereed papers, and authoredand edited 4 books includingNanostructures and Nano-materials. His currentH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim Adv. Mater. 2009, 21, 40874108

REVIEW

www.advmat.de

d w

ng

10

lmresult in many particular behaviors in electron transport or lightpropagation in view of the surface effect, quantum-confinementeffect, or photon localization.[4951] Those nanostructural forms ofZnO developed during the past several decades mainly includenanoparticles,[52,53] nanowires (or nanorods),[54,55] nanotubes,[56]

nanobelts,[57] nanosheets,[54,58] and nanotips.[34,38] The produc-tion of these structures can be achieved through solgelsynthesis,[53] hydrothermal/solvothermal growth,[54] physical orchemical vapor deposition,[55,57] low-temperature aqueousgrowth,[56,59] chemical bath deposition,[60] or electrochemicaldeposition.[58,61,62] In this article, recent developments in ZnOnanostructures, particularly for application in DSCs, arereviewed. It will show that photoelectrode films with nanos-tructured ZnO can significantly enhance solar-cell performanceby offering a large surface area for dye adsorption, direct transportpathways for photoexcited electrons, and efficient scatteringcenters for enhanced light-harvesting efficiency. In addition, ZnOmay be combined with TiO2 via a coreshell structure for reducedcombination rates. The limitations of ZnO-based DSCs are alsodiscussed. In the final section, several attempts to expand ZnOconcepts to TiO2 are presented to motivate further improvementin the conversion efficiency of DSCs.

2. Nanostructures Offering Large SpecificSurface Area

A large internal surface area is the foremost requirement of thephotoelectrode film in DSCs, so that sufficient dye molecules canbe adsorbed to act as an antenna for the capture of incidentphotons. Nanomaterials can satisfy this requirement due to theformation of a porous interconnected network in which thespecific surface area may be increased by more than 1000 timeswhen compared with bulk materials.[63] The abundant forms ofZnO nanostructures provide a great deal of opportunities toobtain high surface-area-to-volume ratios, which in turn

Table 1. A comparison of physical properties of ZnO and TiO2.

ZnO

Crystal structure rocksalt, zinc blende, an

Energy band gap [eV] 3.23.3

Electron mobility [cm2 V s1] 205300 (bulk ZnO), 1000 (siRefractive index 2.0

Electron effective mass [me] 0.26

Relative dielectric constant 8.5

Electron diffusion coefficient [cm2 s1] 5.2 (bulk ZnO), 1.7(nanoparticulate ficontribute to dye adsorption, as well as light harvesting, in DSCs.

2.1. ZnO Nanoparticulate Films

ZnO films with nanoparticles for application in DSCs have beenextensively studied, partially due to the direct availability of porousstructures with assembled nanoparticles and the simplicity ofsynthesis of nanoparticles via chemically based solution methods.Due to the mechanism of charge transfer between the dye andsemiconductor, the strategy for studying DSCs with nanoparticu-late ZnO films is almost the same as that adopted for

Adv. Mater. 2009, 21, 40874108 2009 WILEY-VCH Verlag Gnanocrystalline TiO2. It can be somewhat regarded as a straightimplantation of TiO2-based Gratzel-type solar-cell technology, inwhich the TiO2 nanoparticles are replaced by ZnO nanoparticleswhile the dye sensitizer and the electrolyte remain unchanged.

2.1.1. SolGel Derived Nanocrystalline Films

A traditional method of synthesizing ZnO nanoparticles isachieved by the preparation of ZnO sols in the liquid phase fromhomogeneous ethanolic solutions with precursors of lithiumhydroxide and zinc acetate.[6466] The resulting sol contains ZnOnanoparticles with an average diameter ranging from ten to severaltens of nanometers. A further process is performed on the sol toyield film by spin coating or dip coating, duringwhich the system isconverted from liquid sol into solid wet gel. Following drying andheat treatment, the gel is thermalized so as to generate a porousstructured film on the substrate. The doctor-blade method[67,68] isalso a frequently adopted approach for the preparation of ZnOnanocrystalline film, during which Triton X-100 (1% by volume) isconventionally added to the sol to facilitate the film formation.Residual organics are removed by a subsequent heat treatment,typically at temperatures between 300 8C and 400 8C. For DSCapplications, the film is sensitized by immersion in rutheniumpolypyridine-complex dyes (so-called N3, N719, or black dye that iscommercially available) for a given amount of time.[6971] For use asworking electrode, the as-sensitized film is constructed to a celldevice by assembling it with a counter electrode consisting of a thinplatinum layer deposited on FTO glass. An electrolyte solutioncontaining KI (0.5M) and I2 (0.03M) in a mixed solvent withethylene carbonate and acetonitrile (60%:40% by volume) is thenintroduced to the interval of the two electrodes. The performance ofthe solar cell is characterized by recording the currentvoltage(IV) behavior when the cell is irradiated under AM 1.5-typesimulated sunlight. The overall power conversion efficiency, h, canbe calculated according to

TiO2 Reference

urtzite rutile, anatase, and brookite [42,43]

3.03.2 [4244]

le nanowire) 0.14 [42,43,45]

2.5 [46]

9 [44]

170 [44]4

)

0.5 (bulk TiO2), 108104(nanoparticulate film)

[47,48]h FF VOC ISCPin

(1)

and the fill factor (FF) is defined as

FF Vmax ImaxVOC ISC (2)

where Pin is the input power density (i.e., the intensity of incidentlight, in mW cm2), VOC is the open-circuit voltage (mV), ISC isthe short-circuit current density (mA cm2), and Vmax and Imax

mbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim 4089

REVIEW

www.advmat.de

4090are the voltage and current at maximum power output,

respectively.At the early developmental stage, using solgel-derived

ZnO-nanoparticle films, the reported conversion efficiencies ofDSCs are fairly low, with values generally around0.42.22%.[66,67,72] The scattered distribution of efficienciesimplies that the solar-cell performance is sensitive to manyfactors, including the size and shape of the nanoparticles, theporosity of film, the film-fabrication technique, and thepost-treatment of the photoelectrode.

With regard to the improvement of conversion efficiency inZnODSCs, Keis et al. reported a compressionmethod for the filmfabrication to achieve a highly active ZnO surface for dyeadsorption.[73,74] In this process, ZnO nanoparticles with anaverage size of 150 nm (Fig. 2) were synthesized via a solgelroute, and, in particular, the film was prepared by compressingthe nanoparticle powder under a pressure of 1000 kg cm2. Whenthe obtained film was used in a DSC under illumination with anintensity of 10mWcm2, an overall conversion efficiency as highas 5% was achieved.[7375] Comparing this result with the 22.1%conversion efficiencies attained for ZnO films with 150-nm

Figure 2. SEM image of a ZnO-nanoparticle electrode prepared with acompression method. Reproduced with permission from [73]. Copyright2002, Elsevier.nanoparticles prepared using the aforementioned doctor-blademethod without compression,[76,77] the authors explained that theimprovement in solar-cell performance was due to the increasedinterfacial kinetics inherent in the compression method thatdidnt involve a heat-treatment process. It had been demonstratedthat such increased interfacial kinetics could result in a moreefficient injection of electrons from the dye molecules to the ZnOsemiconductor. In this work, although the light-scattering effectis not addressed as a significant reason promoting the lightharvesting, it is likely that ZnO nanoparticles with sizes of150 nm play a role in the generation of light scattering, leadingto additional contribution to the light harvest.

2.1.2. Electrostatic Spray Deposition Technique for Nanoparticulate

Films

Highly efficient conversion can be also obtained for nanoparti-culate-ZnO films fabricated by using an electrostatic spraydeposition (ESD) technique developed by Jansen et al. for coating

2009 WILEY-VCH Verlag Gmbelectrode films.[78,79] The basic principle of ESD is the generationof an aerosol using organic solvents containing inorganic ororganometallic precursors under the influence of a high voltage.An aerosol is defined as a dispersion of solid particles or liquiddroplets in a gaseous ambient. In order to obtain such an aerosolof micrometer-sized droplets, the precursor liquid is pumpedthrough a metal nozzle. Usually a spherical droplet is formed atthe tip of the nozzle, but if a high voltage is applied (typically615 kV) between the nozzle and a grounded substrate, thisdroplet at the tip of the nozzle transforms into a conical shape andfans out to form a spray of highly charged droplets. The generatedspray droplets are attracted by the grounded and heated substrateas a result of the applied potential difference. Consequently, thedroplets impinge on the heated substrate, where they lose theircharge. After complete solvent evaporation, a thin layer consistingof the inorganic product is left on the substrate surface.[78] Theadvantages of the ESD technique are (1) the great variety oftailored film morphologies, (2) the possibility of controlling thechemical composition of the deposited coatings, and (3) the highdeposition efficiency, since the electric field directs the chargeddroplets to the substrate.

As for a typical preparation of nanoparticulate ZnO films withthe ESD technique,[80] a colloidal solution of precursor wasprepared through the hydrolysis of zinc salts in the presence of anamine and then mixed with polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) that wasdissolved in a mixture of ethanol and water. The nanoparticle-containing precursor solution thus obtained was subsequentlyused for the ESD deposition of ZnO film. PVA was employed toprevent the agglomeration of ZnO during the high-temperaturecalcination process. With this fabrication, both the porosity andthe specific surface area of the films can be controlled byadjusting the weight ratio of nanoparticles to PVA. It has beenreported that a ratio of 1.8 may yield a maximum specific surfacearea of 12.55 m2 g1 and a peak photovoltaic efficiency of 3.4%.Recently, this technique was also exploited in the synthesis ofTiO2 nanofibers, achieving an overall conversion efficiency ofaround 5%.[81,82]

2.2. Nanoporous Structured ZnO Films

Besides nanoparticulate films, nanoporous structured ZnO filmswere also studied as photoelectrodes in DSCs due to their highporosity. Many techniques have been reported for the preparationof nanoporous ZnO films.[61,62,83,84] Among these methods,electrochemical deposition and chemical bath deposition showcharacteristics advantageous to forming nanoporous films withnanowalls vertically grown on the substrate. Such a structure isthought to be favorable for electron transport from the point ofgeneration to the collection electrode in DSCs and, also, favorablefor electrolyte diffusion through the intervals between thenanowalls, resulting in a decrease in both the series resistanceand recombination rate of the cell.

2.2.1. Electrochemical Deposition Fabrication

Electrochemical deposition is a simple and low-cost route for thepreparation of nanoporous films possessing a large surface area.The advantage of this method is that the growth orientation,morphology, and thickness of the films can be modestlyH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim Adv. Mater. 2009, 21, 40874108

REVIEW

www.advmat.de

controlled by adjusting the deposition parameters (depositionvoltage, current density, temperature, etc.). A typical fabricationprocess for the electrochemical deposition of nanoporous ZnOfilms at low temperature was described by Xi et al.[61] In thisfabrication, a two-electrode system was used, consisting of a Znsheet as the anode and glass coated with indium tin oxide (ITO) asthe cathode. The electrolyte contained 0.04 M zinc nitrate and0.04 M hexamethylenteramine (HMT) in a solvent formed by amixture of distilled water and ethanol with a volume ratio of 1 to 1.HMT was employed in the electrolyte as a buffer to obtain apH value of around 6. The additional ethanol in the electrolyteacted as a wetting agent to improve the thickness uniformity andsurface coverage. The deposition of porous ZnO films was carriedout at 40 8C in a water bath with a bias voltage of 0.50.7V. It wasdemonstrated that, in the case of an applied voltage of 0.5 V only,

the obtained films presented a sheet-like morphology and, underhigh scanning electron microscopy (SEM) magnification, thefilms were observed to comprise of pellet-like polycrystallineparticles of about 250 nm in diameter (2030 nm grain size).These particles were interconnected with pore sizes ranging from500 nm to 2mm (Fig. 3a). Other applied voltages produced filmswith a more irregular porous structure. The as-deposited filmthickness is correlated to both the bias voltage and the depositiontime. Typically, a thickness of about 2.6mm can be obtained at0.5 V for 30min, 2.4mm at 0.7 V for 20min, and 3.4mm at 0.7 Vfor 30min. The temperature of the water bath also shows aninfluence on the film structure. Increasing the temperature to70 8C would result in a ZnO film with a compact structure,showing a much lower photovoltaic efficiency than the porousfilm due to the decreased internal surface area.

In electrochemical deposition, the nucleation rate cansignificantly affect the film structure, especially in terms of theporosity. Through the use of a surfactant to mediate thenucleation, ZnO films with a more porous structure have beendeveloped for DSC application. Poly (vinyl pyrrolidone) (PVP) wasreported as a highly efficient surfactant that had been combinedwith the electrochemical deposition method to produce nanopor-ous ZnO films with very impressive photovoltaic efficiencies.[85] Itwas demonstrated that as-obtained films possessed a structurecomprised of interconnected crystal grains. The grain size, andthus the surface morphology of ZnO films, could be stronglyinfluenced by the PVP concentration. That is, increased PVPconcentration would result in a reduced grain size. Typically,when the PVP concentration was 4 g L1, the grain size was

Figure 3. SEM images of nanoporous ZnO films. a) Electrochemicallydeposited film without using reagent. Reproduced with permission from[61]. Copyright 2008, The Electrochemical Society. b) Chemical-bath-deposited nest-like ZnO film. Reproduced with permission from[89]. Copyright 2003, Elsevier.Adv. Mater. 2009, 21, 40874108 2009 WILEY-VCH Verlag Greduced to 2040 nm. However, no ZnO film could be formed ifthe concentration was larger than 6 g L1. The DSCs with ZnOfilms synthesized by this method exhibit an extremely highconversion efficiency of 5.08% under 53 mW cm2 illumination,while the photoelectrode consists of electrochemically depositeddouble-layer ZnO films, typically containing 8-mm-thick nano-porous film on a 200-nm-thick compact nanocrystalline film.

2.2.2. Chemical Bath Deposition Fabrication

Chemical bath deposition (CBD), developed for producing ceramicfilms from aqueous solutions at low temperatures by pyrolysis oflayered metal hydroxides, has also been used for the fabrication ofnanoporous ZnO films.[86,87] A typical process for this fabricationcan be described in the following steps: (1) the formation of layeredbasic zinc acetate (LBZA), Zn5(OH)8(CH3COO)2 2H2O, byhydrolysis of zinc acetate dihydrate in methanol, (2) the depositionof the LBZA film on a substrate at 60 8C through heterogeneousnucleation, and (3) a heat treatment at a temperature above 150 8Cso as to transform the LBZA film into crystalline ZnO. A similarmethod was also reported for the formation of nanoporous ZnOfilms via layered hydroxide zinc carbonate (LHZC) using a solutionof zinc nitrate hexahydrate and urea in water.[88] Films synthesizedthrough this method show a nest-like morphology and porousstructure (Fig. 3b).[89] Studies in greater detail pointed out thatfilms fabricated by CBD were composed of sheet-like grains with11nm ZnO crystallites, pore sizes of 12nm, and surface areasof about 25 m2 g1.[90,91]

Hosono et al.[88,89,92] systematically studied the DSC perfor-mance of nanoporous structured ZnO films fabricated by the CBDtechnique. They achieved an overall conversion efficiency of 3.9%when as-prepared 10-mm-thick ZnO films were sensitized by N719dye with an immersion time of 2 h.[88] Further improvement to4.27% in the conversion efficiency was reported recently byHosono et al. when the dye of N719 was replaced with a metal-freeorganic dye named D149 and the immersion time was reduced to1 h.[92] The enhancement in solar-cell performance was attributedto the use of D149 dye and a nanoporous structure that containedperpendicular pores. This allowed for a rapid adsorption of the dyewith a shorter immersion time and thus prevented the formationof a Zn2/dye complex. This complex is believed to be inactive andmay hinder electron injection from the dye molecules to thesemiconductor.[73] In another study, a high photovoltaic efficiencyof up to 4.1% was also obtained for nanoporous ZnO filmsproduced by the CBD.[90] However, the excellence of the solar-cellperformance was ascribed to the remarkably improved stability ofas-fabricated ZnO films in acidic dye. According to this report, a20-mm-thick ZnO film prepared via CBDwas used for the DSC andthe film was sensitized with N719. The results showed that, evenfor a prolonged dye-loading time (6h), only a monolayer ofdye molecules adsorbed on the ZnO surface and no Zn2/dyecomplex was formed. This scenario is very different from the caseof ZnO films sensitized with ruthenium-based dye reportedelsewhere and has resulted in a relatively high overall conversionefficiency. It was also demonstrated that, for this cell, the dye-loading amount was estimated to be about 1.4 107mol cm2.This was comparable to the 1.3 107mol cm2 obtained for a10-mm-thick nanocrystalline TiO2 photoanode (h 10%) sensi-tized with N3 dye. In this study, although approximately equal dyembH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim 4091

REVIEW

www.advmat.de

loading is obtained for ZnO films with doubled thickness(20mm) in comparison to 10mm of TiO2, the results are veryexciting in view of the unusual stability of as-prepared ZnO inruthenium-based dyes.

2.3. Other Nanostructured ZnO Films

ZnO nanostructures with other morphologies, such asnanosheets, nanobelts, and nanotetrapods, have also beenstudied for DSC applications on account of the fact that theyalso have a large specific surface area. However, for thesenanostructures, the specific surface area is not the only factor thatdetermines the photovoltaic efficiency of the DSC. Solar-cellperformance is also believed to be significantly affected by thegeometrical structure of the photoelectrode films, which providesparticular properties in terms of the electron transport and/orlight propagation.

2.3.1. Nanosheets

ZnO nanosheets are quasi-two-dimensional structures that can befabricated by a rehydrothermal growth process of previouslyhydrothermally grown ZnO nanoparticles.[93] A film with dispersedZnO nanosheets (Fig. 4a) used in a DSC has been shown to possessa relatively low conversion efficiency, 1.55%, possibly due to aninsufficient internal surface area. It seems that ZnO nanosheet-

2.3.2. Nanobelts

ZnO films with ndeposition methodfabricating these nin the electrolyte ashows a highly pothickness of 5 nmphotovoltaic effici

2.3.3. Tetrapods

A ZnO tetrapodconsisting of fo(Fig. 4d).[96,97] Ththe range of 120100 nm to 2mmoxygen partial presdeposition can resform a porous netThe films with Znconversion efficiethe internal surfincreased by incoleading to signifimance.[96]

between trap states on neighboring particles

tshy.aerintr.

4092spheres (Fig. 4b) prepared by hydrothermal treatment using oxalicacid as the capping agent may have a significant enhancement ininternal surface area, resulting in a conversion efficiency of up to2.61%.[94] As for nanosheet-spheres, the performance of the solarcell is also believed to benefit from a high degree of crystallinity and,therefore, low resistance with regards to electron transport.

Figure 4. SEM images of nanostructured ZnO films: a) Dispersed nanosheepermission from [93]. Copyright 2007, Elsevier. b) Nanosheet-assembled spwith permission from [94]. Copyright 2008, Elsevier. c) Nanobelt arrapermission from [95]. Copyright 2007, Elsevier. d) A ZnO tetrapod formed instructure with four arms extending from a common core. Reproduced with pCopyright 2008, American Institute of Physics. e) Networked film withtetrapods. Reproduced with permission from [97]. Copyright 2009, Elsevie 2009 WILEY-VCH Verlag Gmbor by diffusive transport within extended statesslowed down by trapping/detrappingevents.[21,30] An electron is estimated to cross103106 particles when traveling in the photo-electrode film.[99] While an 11% efficiency hasbeen achieved on dye-sensitized TiO2 nano-crystalline films, the nanoparticulate oxides dopossess deficiencies. Electron transportbecomes more difficult with an increase inphotocurrent due to the also-increased recom-bination between the electrons and theoxidized dye or redox mediator in the electro-lyte.[100] Recombination, intrinsically, arisesfrom the absence of a depletion layer at theTiO2 nanoparticleelectrolyte interface. InDSCs with a film in the form of nanoparticles,the recombination has been found to be acrucial factor that causes energy loss and limitsthe further increase of conversion effi-ciency.[101]

In the past few years, a variety of one-dimensional nanostructures based on differ-ent oxides have been developed so as to reducethe recombination rate in DSCs.[102] Theseone-dimensional nanostructures are usuallysingle crystal or quasi single crystal and can,

. Reproduced witheres. ReproducedReproduced withthree-dimensionalmission from [96].erconnected ZnO3. Nanostructures with Direct Pathways forElectron Transport

Electron transport in DSCs based on nanoparticulate films hasbeen proposed to occur either by a series of hopping events

[99]H & Co. KGaA, Weinheanobelt arrays prepared through an electro-were also studied for DSC applications.[95] Inanobelts, polyoxyethylene cetylether was addeds a surfactant. The ZnO nanobelt array obtainedrous stripe structure (Fig. 4c) with a nanobelt, a typical surface area of 70 m2 g1, and aency as high as 2.6%.

possesses a three-dimensional structureur arms extending from a common coree length of the arms can be adjusted withinmm, while the diameter can be tuned fromby changing the substrate temperature andsure during vapor deposition.[98] Multiple-layerult in tetrapods connected to each other so as towork with a large specific surface area (Fig. 4e).O tetrapods used in DSCs have achieved overallncies of 1.20 3.27%.[96,97] It was reported thatace area of tetrapod films could be furtherrporating ZnO nanoparticles with these films,cant improvement in the solar-cell perfor-im Adv. Mater. 2009, 21, 40874108

REVIEW

www.advmat.de

therefore, serve to increase the electron diffusion length byproviding a direct pathway for electron transport from the point ofelectron injection to the substrate of the collection electrode. Inother words, the transport of electrons occurs in the interior of acontinuous crystal and, consequently, the electrons would notsuffer any grain-boundary scattering. This is different from thecase of nanoparticulate films in a DSC configuration, whereelectrons, during their traversal, take a random walk among thenanoparticles and undergo numerous collisions at the grainboundary or the semiconductor/electrolyte interface. Among allthe oxides with one-dimensional nanostructures, ZnO has beenthe most reported due to the ease of controllable anisotropicgrowth and, especially, the development of physical or chemicaltechniques that allow for a flexible tailoring of ZnO morphology(for example, shape, diameter, length, density, etc.). Typical

Nanowires were grown by immersing the seeded substrates inaqueous solutions containing 25mM zinc nitrate hydrate, 25mMhexamethylenetetramine, and 57mM polyethylenimine (PEI) at92 8C for 2.5 h. After this period, the substrates were repeatedlyintroduced to fresh solution baths in order to obtain continuedgrowth until the desired film thickness was reached. The use ofPEI, a cationic polyelectrolyte, is particularly important in thisfabrication, as it serves to enhance the anisotropic growth ofnanowires. As a result, nanowires synthesized by this methodpossessed aspect ratios in excess of 125 and densities up to35 billion wires per square centimeter. The longest arrays reached2025mm with a nanowire diameter that varied from 130 to200 nm. These arrays featured a surface area up to one-fifth aslarge as a nanoparticle film. Figure 5b shows a typical SEMcross-section image of an array of ZnO nanowires. It was foundthat the resistivity values of individual nanowires ranged from

israone-dimensional ZnO nanostructures used for DSCs involvetypes of nanowires/nanorods, nanotubes, nanotips, and otherderivatives, synthesized through vaporliquidsolid processes,[55]

metalorganic chemical vapor deposition (MOCVD),[103,104]

thermal evaporation,[104,105] chemical-solution synthesis at lowtemperature,[106] electrodeposition,[107,108] and chemical-spraypyrolysis.[109] In general, the vapor-phase or physical-depositionmethods possess an inherent advantage in forming both thin andlong one-dimensional nanostructures with a high degree ofcrystal quality while affording the ability to precisely control thegrowth rate. Chemical-solution-based methods possess thecapability for large-scale mass production at low temperaturesand, therefore, a flexible substrate can be used.

3.1. ZnO Nanowires

ZnO nanowire arrays were first used in DSCs by Law et al. in 2005with the intention of replacing the traditional nanoparticle filmwith a consideration of increasing the electron diffusionlength.[110,111] A schematic of the construction of a nanowireDSC is shown in Figure 5a. Arrays of ZnO nanowires weresynthesized in an aqueous solution using a seeded-growthprocess. This method employed fluorine-doped tin oxide (FTO)substrates that were thoroughly cleaned by acetone/ethanolsonication. A thin film of ZnO quantum dots (dot diame-ter 34 nm, film thickness 1015 nm) was deposited on thesubstrates via dip coating in a concentrated ethanol solution.

Figure 5. ZnO-nanowire dye-sensitized solar cells. Reproduced with permdiagram of the cell with a photoelectrode comprised of the ZnO-nanowire arperformance of nanowire and nanoparticle cells.Adv. Mater. 2009, 21, 40874108 2009 WILEY-VCH Verlag G0.3 to 2.0V cm, with an electron concentration of15 1018 cm3 and a mobility of 15 cm2 V1 s1. Conse-quently, the electron diffusivity could be calculated as0.050.5 cm2 s1 for a single nanowire. This value is severalhundred times larger than the highest reported electron diffusioncoefficients for nanoparticle films in a DSC configuration underoperating conditions, that is, 107104 cm2 s1 for TiO2 and105103 cm2 s1 for ZnO. This, to some extent, demonstratesthe very good electrical conductivity of ZnO nanowires. (It mustbe noted, however, that the electron diffusivity and the electrondiffusion coefficient reflect different charge transport processesin individual nanowires and nanoparticle films, respectively.Moreover, these two parameters are usually obtained throughdifferent methods, that is, by employing the Einstein equationwith the measured Hall mobility to calculate the electrondiffusivity for individual nanowires and using, for example,intensity-modulated photocurrent experiments to measure thecollection time of electron diffusion and then calculate theelectron diffusion coefficient for nanoparticle films.[47,112]) At afull sun intensity of 100 3 mW cm2, the highest-surface-areadevices with ZnO nanowire arrays were characterized byshort-circuit current densities of 5.35.85mA cm2, open-circuitvoltages of 610710mV, fill factors of 0.360.38, and overallconversion efficiencies of 1.21.5%.

The superiority of ZnO nanowires as a direct pathway forelectron transport is illustrated by Figure 5c, in which theshort-circuit current densities as a function of the internal

sion from [110]. Copyright 2005, Nature Publishing Group. a) Schematicy. b) Cross-sectional SEM image of the ZnO-nanowire array. c) ComparativembH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim 4093

REVIEW

www.advmat.de

[120]

4094roughness factor (defined as the ratio of actual surface area to theprojected surface area) are compared for cells with ZnOnanowires, TiO2 nanoparticles, and ZnO nanoparticles. The plotshows that a rapid saturation and a subsequent decline in theshort-circuit current density can be observed on the cells builtwith either 12-nm TiO2 nanoparticles or 30-nm and 200-nm ZnOnanoparticles. This confirms that the transport efficiency ofnanoparticle films falls off above a certain film thickness due tocritical recombination. However, the nanowire films show anearly linear increase in the short-circuit density that mapsalmost directly onto the TiO2 data even though the films are asthick as 25mm, indicating a highly efficient transport ofelectrons in nanowires with decreased recombination rate. Inaddition, the nanowire cells generate considerably higher currentdensities than the ZnO nanoparticle cells over the accessiblerange of roughness factors (approximately 5575% higher at aroughness of 200, as shown in Fig. 5c). This is also a confirmationthat the nanowires offer better electron transport when comparedto nanoparticles. The mechanism has been attributed to both thehigh crystallinity of nanowires and an internal electric field withinthe nanowires that can assist carrier collection by separatinginjected electrons from the surrounding electrolyte and sweepingthem towards the collection electrode. The establishment of aninternal electric field within the nanowires is due to the existenceof charge diffusion at the semiconductorelectrolyte interface andthe formation of a space-charge layer in the nanowires around theinner surface. In oxide semiconductors, the Debye screeninglength, which is defined as the distance over which significantcharge separation can occur, has been estimated to be roughlyone-third of the thickness of the space-charge layer.[110] As forZnO with a carrier concentration of 1018 cm3, the Debyescreening length is about 4 nm. It is important that the dimensionof the as-discussed ZnO nanowires ismuch larger than the Debyescreening length so that an internal electric field can beestablished. Owing to the upward band bending in the nanowiresaround the inner surface, the internal electric field is thought tobe able to (1) corral the injected electrons so as to reduce therecombination rate, and (2) accelerate the diffusion of injectedelectrons towards the interior of the nanowires. Moreover, theaxial field may serve to sweep the electrons to the collectionelectrode. Similar investigations can be found elsewhere inliterature regarding the application of ZnO nanowires in DSCseven with the attainment of higher conversion efficien-cies.[113118] However, it seems that the results are quitedependent on the experimental conditions, specifically on thesynthesis method, substrate treatment, growth parameters,geometrical structure of the nanowires and array (pattern,diameter, length, density, etc.), and the measuring method(sensitization process, electrolyte composition, light-sourceintensity, and active area of photoelectrode film, etc.).

Besides the one-dimensional structure of nanowires/nanor-ods, the feature of nanowire/nanorod arrays with verticallyaligned growth on the FTO substrate is also addressed as one ofimportant aspects that provide the direct pathway for electrontransport in DSCs. This has been demonstrated convincingly inprevious research. For example, one study found that a ZnOnanorod array led to a ten-fold increase in the photovoltaicefficiency when compared to a randomly oriented nanorodfilm.[119] However, the insufficient surface area of nanowire/ 2009 WILEY-VCH Verlag Gmbporosity and may offer a larger surface area than that ofnanowires. The synthesis of ZnO nanotube arrays can beachieved by using a modified method for the aqueous growth ofZnO nanowires at low temperatures.[56,123] An overall conversionefficiency of 2.3% has been reported for DSCs with ZnOnanotube arrays possessing a nanotube diameter of 500 nm and adensity of 5.4 106 per square centimeter.[124] ZnO nanotubearrays can be also prepared by coating anodic aluminum oxide(AAO)membranes via atomic layer deposition (ALD). However, ityields a relatively low conversion efficiency of 1.6%, primarily dueto the modest roughness factor of commercial membranes.[125]

3.3. ZnO Nanotips

By using MOCVD processing methods, ZnO nanotip arrays withdifferent lengths can be synthesized. The DSC performance ofthese nanotips has been investigated in previous studies.[126,127]

The results confirmed that the energy-conversion efficiency of thecells increased with the length of the ZnO nanotips due to theincrease in surface area of the photoelectrode film. An overallconversion efficiency of 0.55% was obtained for 3.2-mm-longZnO nanotips. It has been reported that ZnO nanotips present amaximum overall conversion efficiency at higher light intensitiesthan in the case of TiO2 nanoparticles. This implies anontrap-limited electron transport in the respect that the nanotipsprovide a faster conduction pathway for electron transport. Thislength). By blending the nanowires with nanoparticles, ZnOnanowirenanoparticle-composite films have been also proved tobe effective in optimizing the surface area. Ku et al. reported asignificant promotion in the overall DSC conversion efficiencyfrom 0.84% to 2.2% when ZnO nanoparticles with diameters of530 nmwere added to ZnO nanowires.[121] As for the fabricationof nanowirenanoparticle-composite films, a pretreatment per-formed by immersing the ZnO nanoparticle powder in amethanol solution containing 2% titanium isopropoxide and0.02 M acetic acid has proved to be favorable for the attachment ofnanoparticles onto nanowire surfaces.[122]

3.2. ZnO Nanotubes

Nanotubes differ from nanowires in that they typically have ahollow cavity structure. An array of nanotubes possesses highnanorod arrays seems to be the primary factor that limits theamount of dye adsorption as well as the conversion efficiency ofthe cells. Many attempts have been made to solve this problem.One such approach is to reduce the diameter size of thenanowires/nanorods, thus increasing the density of thearray.[113,116,117] Gao et al. reported a simple method thatemployed ammonium hydroxide to change the supersaturationdegree of Zn2 precursors during the process of solution-basedgrowth of a ZnO nanowire array. This served to regulate thelength-to-diameter aspect ratio of the individual nanowires. Theresulting nanowires possessed an aspect ratio of about 100200with a length of 14mm and a diameter of 120150 nm. This leadto an overall DSC conversion efficiency of 1.7%, which is almostthree times that obtained for ZnO nanorod arrays with relativelylow aspect ratios (about 500 nm in diameter and 10mm inH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim Adv. Mater. 2009, 21, 40874108

REVIEW

www.advmat.de

the fabrication of

Figure 6b, have dimensions of about 200 nm in diameter. The

grew 100-nm-diameter ZnO nanowires with20-nm secondary nanowire branches thatnucleated and grew from the primary nano-wire backbone. It was indicated that each of thenanowires was crystalline with grain bound-aries separating secondary nanowires from theprimary nanowire. The substrate with bothprimary nanowires and secondary nanowirebranches was then used to continue thenanowire growth, called secondary genera-tion growth. During the growth of a secondgeneration of nanowires, the outstretchednanowire branches act as new nucleation sitesfor nanowire growth. The growth can also becontinued for third and fourth generations for

the attainment of a dendrite-like branched ZnO nanostructure

matic to indicate the difference in lightharvest for films with nanowires and nanoflowers. b) SEM images of a ZnO-nanoflower film.

007, American Institute of Physics.solar-cell performance of ZnO nanoflower films was character-ized by an overall conversion efficiency of 1.9%, a current densityof 5.5mA cm2, and a fill factor of 0.53. These values are higherthan the 1.0%, 4.5mA cm2, and 0.36 for films of nanorod arrayswith comparable diameters and array densitiesthat were also fabricated by the hydrothermalmore stable and efficient DSCs under high illumination. It hasalso been demonstrated that the overall conversion efficiencycould be increased to 0.77% by combining the ZnO nanotips witha Ga-doped ZnO film as a transparent conducting layer.[127]

3.4. ZnO Nanoflowers

The use of ZnO films with nanoflowers consisting ofupstanding nanowires and outstretched branches have beenalso reported for application in DSCs. This is based on theconsideration that the nanowires alone may not capture thephotons completely due to the existence of intervals inherent inthe morphology. Nanoflower structures, however, have nanoscalebranches that stretch to fill these intervals and, therefore, provideboth a larger surface area and a direct pathway for electrontransport along the channels from the branched petals to thenanowire backbone (Fig. 6). Nanoflower films can be grown by ahydrothermal method at low temperatures, typically by employ-ing a 5mM zinc chloride aqueous solution with a small amount ofammonia.[128] These as-synthesized nanoflowers, as shown infeature allows for the use of ZnO nanotips in

Reproduced with permission from [128]. Copyright 2Figure 6. Flower-like ZnO nanostructures. a) A schemethod.[129]

3.5. Dendritic ZnO Nanowires

Dendritic ZnO nanowires, which possess afractal structure more complicated than that ofnanoflowers, are formed by a nanowire back-bone with outstretched branches, on which thegrowth of smaller-sized nanowire backbonesand branches is reduplicated. Baxter et al.described a MOCVD fabrication for dendriticZnO nanowires by using a route of so-calledmultiple-generation growth.[103] They first

Figure 7. Dendritic ZnO nanowires for DSwith dendritic ZnO nanowires (after two gecurrent (filled squares) and efficiency (with insets showing images of nanowirepermission from [103]. Copyright 2005, E

Adv. Mater. 2009, 21, 40874108 2009 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, WeinC application. a) Cross-sectional SEM image of a filmnerations of growth). b) Semi-log plot of short-circuitopen circles) versus nanowire growth generation,morphology for generations 02. Reproduced withlsevier.(Fig. 7). DSC characterization showed that the short-circuitdensity increased with increasing growth generation due to thelarger surface area, which in turn led to increased adsorption ofdye molecules. A total improvement of over 250 times in currentdensity and over 400 times in efficiency has been observed whenthe film morphology was changed from smooth nanowires tobranched second-generation nanowires (Fig. 7b). The efficienciesobtained using fourth-generation dendritic nanowire films with abranched nanostructure and a 10-mm thickness displayed anoverall conversion efficiency of 0.5%, a more than 600-foldimprovement over smooth nanowires. By integrating ZnOnanoparticles within the film of dendritic nanowires, the specificsurface area was increased, leading to an improved conversionefficiency of 1.1% for these cells.

The dendritic ZnO nanowires are intentionally developed toincrease the specific surface area of the photoelectrode film bymultiple-generation growth of ZnO nanowires. However, thephotovoltaic efficiency, 0.5%, obtained for dendritic ZnOnanowires is lower than the 1.5% value for ZnO nanowirearrays achieved by Law et al. This is possibly due to the lowernanowire density and the insufficient nanowire length (or aspectratio) of dendritic ZnO nanowires. Another possible cause is thedifference in the crystallinity of nanowires produced by differentfabrication methods, that is, MOCVD for dendritic ZnOnanowires and seed-assisted solution-based epitaxy growth forZnO nanowire arrays.heim 4095

REVIEW

www.advmat.de

Reduced Recombination Rate

4096Coreshell structures are a configuration designed for electrodefilms in DSCs to reduce the recombination rate at the electrode/electrolyte interface. A coreshell nanostructured electrodeusually consists of a nanoporous TiO2 matrix that is coveredwith a shell of another metal oxide or salt (Fig. 8).[130] Theconduction-band potential of the shell should be more negativethan that of the core semiconductor (TiO2). This establishes anenergy barrier which hinders the reaction of electrons in the corewith the oxidized dye or redox mediator in the electrolyte.[131]

Several shell materials such as ZnO, Al2O3, SiO2, Nb2O5, WO3,MgO, SrTiO3, and CaCO3 have been reported to form an energybarrier (or a surface dipole layer) on TiO2, enhancing the solar-cellperformance by providing a 35% increase in the overallconversion efficiency.[132143] Among all those materials studied,ZnO has been attracting the most attention in view of its lowelectron affinity, high isoelectric point, and more negativeconduction-band edge when compared to TiO2.4. CoreShell Structures with ZnO Shell for

Figure 8. Schematic of a typical TiO2ZnO coreshell structure used inDSCs. The ZnO shell provides an energy barrier at the interface betweenthe TiO2 and the dye or electrolyte to reduce the recombination of electronswith oxidized dye molecules or those accepting species in the electrolyte.Reproduced with permission from [130]. Copyright 2004, AmericanChemical Society.4.1. Fabrication of CoreShell Structures and Influence of Shell

Thickness

There have been several reports on the fabrication of ZnO shellsfor the TiO2 surface. In general, the fabrication approach ofcoreshell structures can be classified into two cases. Oneinvolves the initial synthesis of coreshell structured TiO2ZnOnanoparticles and then application onto a conducting substrate soas to obtain a film.[135,144] The consequence of this fabricationmethod is the formation of an energy barrier not only at theelectrodeelectrolyte interface but also between the individualTiO2 particles. Thus, at least conceptually, resistance to thetransport of photoinjected electrons through the TiO2 networkshould increase. In a second approach, a nanoporous TiO2electrode film is fabricated. This film then serves as a matrix forcoating of a thin ZnO shell layer.[145,146] As a result, the coreparticles are connected directly to each other, allowing for electrontransport through the TiO2 network.

2009 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbZnO shell on TiO2 nanoparticles by directly soaking the TiO2powder (Degussa, P25) in a 10mM solution of ZnCl2 in absoluteethanol. This suspension solution was then sprayed into liquidN2. A powder sample was finally obtained after a freeze-dryingprocess, followed by sintering at 500 8C.[144] The thickness of theZnO layer synthesized by this method was measured to be0.50 nm, which was thin enough for electron tunneling in theprocess of particle-to-particle transport.

By first preparing the TiO2 nanocrystalline film and thendepositing theZnO shell using a layer-by-layer technique, Han et al.made a series of systematic studies on the construction of ZnOshells with varying thicknesses.[145,147] The influence of thisparameter was evaluated with regards to DSC performance. It wasfound that, for TiO2 photoelectrodes coatedwith a 30-nm-thickZnOlayer, the overall conversion efficiency reached 4.51%, while it was3.31% for bare TiO2 without modification. The thickness of theZnO shell could significantly affect the short-circuit density, whichdecreased when the shell thickness turned out to be larger than30nm, partially because of the small effective mass of electrons(0.3 me) in ZnO.[148,149] A radio frequency (RF)- magnetronsputtering method was also reported for the deposition of a ZnOcoating layer on the TiO2 nanocrystalline films.

[150] It wasdemonstrated that the conversion efficiency of TiO2 DSCs wasimproved from 4.76% to 6.55% due to the ZnO modification.

4.2. The Role of the ZnO Shell

As for coreshell structures in DSC applications, the role of theZnO shell has most often been demonstrated to provide anenergy barrier at the interface between the TiO2 and the dye orelectrolyte, so as to reduce the recombination of electrons withoxidized dye molecules or those accepting species in theelectrolyte. Fig. 9 presents an energy-level diagram thatschematically indicates the function of the ZnO shell in aTiO2ZnO coreshell structure.[147] That is, the bottom ofconduction band (4.0 eV) and the top of valence band (6.8 eV)of ZnO are lower than the lowest unoccupied molecular orbital(LUMO, 3.8 eV) and the highest occupied molecular orbital(HOMO, 5.4 eV) energy levels of the dye, and are also higherthan those of 4.2 eV and 7.4 eV for TiO2, respectively. Thosephotogenerated electrons in the dye molecules with high kineticWang et al. reported a hydrothermal method for the formationof TiO2ZnO nanoparticles with a coreshell structure.[135] Theresearchers mixed 0.5mol % ZnCl2 with 2M TiCl4 aqueoussolution and adjusted the pH value to 5 with KOH. Afterhydrothermal growth at 170 8C and annealing of the precipitatesat 450 8C, 0.46mol % ZnO was found in the TiO2Zn product.Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) images revealed theTiO2 nanoparticles to be about 10 nm in diameter and that thecovering layer of ZnO had no influence on the growth of TiO2nanoparticles. X-ray diffraction (XRD) analysis indicated that theZnO-covered TiO2 was still in the pure anatase phase and noseparated ZnO phase (or other phase) was detected. Therefore,the possibility of Zn2 substituting the lattice position of Ti4wasexcluded and it was inferred that the Ti4 ions were firstprecipitated, followed by the precipitation of Zn2 on the TiO2surface. The Zn2 forms ZnO after annealing. Based on a similarmechanism, Kim et al. also reported a simple route to obtain aH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim Adv. Mater. 2009, 21, 40874108

REVIEW

www.advmat.deenergy can readily tunnel through the ZnO shell and inject intothe TiO2. However, the transport of electrons in the reversedirection may be blocked due to the presence of an energy barrierprovided by the ZnO shell, thereby reducing the recombinationrate of photogenerated electrons.

Although the energy-barrier model can sufficiently explain theenhanced DSC performance by ZnO-coated TiO2, Zabanet al.[131,137] and Bandara et al.[151] believe that this enhancementresults from the conduction-band-shift mechanism, rather thanthe formation of an energy barrier at the surface. The shift of theTiO2 conduction band is attributed to the existence of a dipolelayer at the electrodeelectrolyte interface due to the differencesbetween the shell and core materials with respect to the higherisoelectric point and lower electron affinity of ZnO compared toTiO2. Thus, the TiO2 conduction band is moved towards arelatively negative direction, resulting in a higher open-circuitvoltage for the DSCs. Some arguments insist that the enhance-ment of the ZnO shell with regards to the DSC performance is aresult of the prolonged lifetime of photogenerated electrons inZnO over that in TiO2. Hagfeldt et al. studied charge-transportproperties in a nanostructured ZnO thin-film electro-deelectrolyte system with time-resolved laser-flash-inducedphotocurrents and compared with results on TiO2. They observed

Figure 9. Schematic diagramof the energy levels of a coreshell-structured(TiO2ZnO) photoelectrode in DSCs. Reproduced with permission from[147]. Copyright 2006, American Institute of Physics.that the electrons existed longer in ZnO than in TiO2, and thusthe electron losses to acceptors in the electrolyte were less forZnO than for TiO2.

[152,153] In addition, the ZnO shell has beenproposed to increase the free-electron concentration in theconduction band with respect to pure TiO2 based on anexperimental observation that the electrode of TiO2 with aZnO coating presents an optical absorbance larger than that forTiO2 alone.

[135] It is thought that the optical absorbance isproportional to the concentration of free electrons in theconduction band of the semiconductor while the electrode ischaracterized by using a variable-potential spectroscopy techni-que developed by Rothenberger et al.[154]

However, opinions can also be found in literature that deny theimprovement in efficiency of TiO2-based DSCs by formingouter-shell structures of insulator or semiconductor materi-als.[130,155] These viewpoints originate from experimental phe-nomena showing that ZnO modification of nanocrystalline TiO2may indeed increase the open-circuit voltage, but may also

nanocrystalline films for light scattering, Nishimura et al.[166][167]

Adv. Mater. 2009, 21, 40874108 2009 WILEY-VCH Verlag Gand Halaoui et al. also succeeded in enhancing thelight-harvesting capability of the photoelectrode. However, theintroduction of large-sized particles into nanocrystalline films hasthe unavoidable effect of lowering the internal surface area of thephotoelectrode film. This serves to counteract the enhancementeffect of light scattering on the optical absorption, whereas theincorporation of a photonic-crystal layer may lead to anundesirable increase in the electron transport length and,consequently, increase the recombination rate of photogeneratedcarriers. A recently reported hierarchically structured film withZnO aggregates, which provides the photoelectrode with both alarge surface area and efficient light-scattering centers, can, tosimultaneously cause a decrease in the short-circuit currentdensity, ultimately resulting in a reduced conversion efficiency.This has been explained by either poor dye adsorption to zinc siteson the TiO2 surface or a low electron-injection efficiency due tothe buildup of a thin insulating ZnO surface layer. As such, therole of the ZnO shell on the TiO2 surface is still under discussion.The difference in the observed effects of the ZnO shell is perhapsdue to the dye adsorption and the electron injection process thatare both sensitive to the surface or interface of semiconductors.Also, the status of the ZnO shell is quite dependent on thefabrication method as well as other experimental variables.

5. Light Scattering Enhancement Effect

In DSCs, the dynamic competition between the generation andrecombination of photoexcited carriers has been found to be abottleneck restricting the development of higher conversionefficiencies. That is, the film thickness was expected to be largerthan the light-absorption length so as to capture more photons.Furthermore, the film thickness was constrained to be smallerthan the electron-diffusion length so as to avoid or reducerecombination.[31,32] The approaches outlined above serve mostlyto overcome the recombination by either using one-dimensionalnanostructures that provide a direct pathway for electrontransport or using coreshell structures with an oxide coatingon TiO2 to minimize the recombination rate. Besides thoseapproaches, a series of methods that address the generation ofphotoexcited carriers by combining nanostructured films withoptical effects (light scattering or optical confinement)[156] havealso been demonstrated to be effective in enhancing thelight-harvesting capability of the photoelectrode film so as toimprove DSC performance.

Usami,[157] Ferber and Luther,[158] and Rothenberger et al.[159]

theoretically demonstrated that the optical absorption ofdye-sensitized nanocrystalline TiO2 films could be promotedby additionally admixing large-sized TiO2 particles as thelight-scattering centers. The light-scattering efficiency has beenshown to correlate with both the size of the scattering centers andthe wavelength of the incident light.[160] The scattering reaches amaximum when the size of the scattering centers is about kl,where k is a constant and l is the wavelength. Experimentally, ithas been verified that the performance of DSCs can besignificantly improved when the TiO2 nanocrystalline films arecombined with large-sized SiO2, Al2 O3, or TiO2 particles.

[161165]

By coupling a photonic-crystal layer to conventional TiO2mbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim 4097

REVIEW

www.advmat.de

some extent, resolve such an inconsistency. When this type ofnanostructured film was used for DSCs, a very impressiveenhancement in the overall conversion efficiency wasobserved.[168170]

5.1. ZnO Aggregates

Hierarchically structured ZnO films consist of submicrometer-sized ZnO aggregates. The synthesis of ZnO aggregates can beachieved by hydrolysis of zinc salt in a polyol medium at160 8C.[168] By adjusting the heating rate during synthesis andusing a stock solution containing ZnO nanoparticles of 5 nm indiameter, ZnO aggregates with either a monodisperse orpolydisperse size distribution can be prepared.[169,170] Fig. 10shows the morphology of a hierarchically structured ZnO filmand the structure of the aggregates. It can be seen that the film is

well packed by ZnO aggrewhile the spherical aginterconnected nanocrysseveral tens to several huThe structural features ofporosity and geometricalvisible light. Four kindsaggregation, were prepperformance. Sample 1 iZnO aggregates, sampledistortion of the spheriaggregates and nanocrystno aggregates but disperdemonstrated that all thsame crystallite size of aarea of 80 m2 g1. Howa significant difference

iati

microstructure of aggregated ZnO comprised of closely packed nanocrystallitesgatonl coep

4098of N3-dye-adsorbed ZnO-film samples with differences in the degree of aggreOptical absorption spectra for (d). f) Schematic of light scattering and phoconsisting of submicrometer-sized aggregates. g) Dependence of the overalsize and size distribution of aggregates in dye-sensitized ZnO solar cells. Rfrom [169,170]. Copyright 2008, Wiley-VCH.Figure 10. ZnO-aggregate dye-sensitized solar cells. a) Cross-sectional SEMfilm. b) Magnified SEM image of an individual ZnO aggregate. c) Schem 2009 WILEY-VCH Verlag Gmbtransfer from the valence band to theconduction band. However, absorptionat wavelengths above 400 nm variessignificantly, revealing the highestintensity for sample 1, a lower intensityfor samples 2 and 3, and minimumintensity for sample 4. In the spectrashown in Figure 10e, only sample4 presents an absorption peak centeredaround 520 nm. This corresponds to thevisible t2!p* metal-to-ligand chargetransfer (MLCT) in N3 dye,[69] butcompared with that of pure N3, theabsorption peak is slightly shifted toshorter wavelengths (a blue-shift) due tothe electronic coupling between N3 andZnO. All the other samples show amonotonic increase in the absorption

mage of a ZnO-aggregatec diagram illustrating the. d) Photovoltaic behaviortion of nanocrystallites. e)localization within a filmnversion efficiency on theroduced with permissionH & Co. KGaA, Weinheimgates with a highly disordered stacking,gregates are formed by numeroustallites that have sizes ranging fromndreds of nanometers (Fig. 10b and c).the aggregates are their possession of asize comparable with the wavelengths ofof ZnO films, differing in the degree ofared for a comparison of their DSCs comprised of well-packed polydisperse2 consists of aggregates with slight

cal shape, sample 3 includes parts ofallites, and sample 4 is constructed withsed nanocrystallites alone. It has beenese samples present approximately thebout 15 nm and similar specific surfaceever, their photovoltaic behaviors exhibitin the short-circuit current density,resulting in a difference of overallconversion efficiency. Typically, a max-imum short-circuit current density of19mA cm2 and conversion efficiencyof 5.4% are observed for sample 1, whileminimum values of 10mA cm2 and2.4% respectively are observed forsample 4. Intermediate current densitiesand efficiencies are found for samples 2and 3 (Fig. 10d). An obvious trend is thatthe overall conversion efficiencydecreases as the degree of the sphericalaggregation is gradually destroyed. Inother words, the aggregation of ZnOnanocrystallites is favorable for achiev-ing a DSC with high performance.

Figure 10e shows the optica-l-absorption spectra of the four kindsof ZnO films previously discussed afterbeing sensitized with N3 dye. All theZnO samples exhibit an intrinsicabsorption with similar absorptionintensity below 390 nm, caused by theZnO semiconductor with electronAdv. Mater. 2009, 21, 40874108

REVIEW

www.advmat.de

efforts have been made on ZnO-based DSCs with eitherc-

tures that are highly efficient in electron transport and/or photoncapture. However, so far, the results obtained for dye-sensitized

of these dyes have carboxyl groups that connect with TiO2.intensity as the wavelength varies from visible to ultraviolet. Thisportion of the absorption is contributed by the dye molecules thatare adsorbed on the ZnO surface, and the difference in theabsorption intensity implies that the absorption is structurerelated. It has been suggested that the difference in the absorptionof samples 13 arises from the submicrometer-sized aggregatesthat cause the light scattering. This weakens the transmittance ofthe films and causes pseudo absorption in the spectra. Theperformance of the solar cell is improved due to the presence oflight scattering in hierarchically structured ZnO films, by whichthe traveling distance of light within the photoelectrode film canbe significantly extended (Fig. 10f). As such, the opportunities forincident photons to be captured by the dye molecules areincreased. The difference in the optical absorption of the fourkinds of film implies that an improvement in the degree ofaggregation of nanocrystallites would induce more effective lightscattering in the visible region. A photon-localization effect mayalso occur on these films due to their highly disordered structurethat confines the light scattering in closed loops.

Further studies reinforce the light-scattering mechanism. Ithas been demonstrated that the performance of DSCs withhierarchically structured ZnO films can be significantly affectedby either the average size or the size distribution of aggre-gates.[170] The films with polydisperse aggregates, which result ina more disordered structure and achieve better packing, establishhigher conversion efficiencies than those with monodisperseaggregates. The enhancement effect becomesmore intense whenthe maximum size of the aggregates in polydisperse films, or theaverage size of the aggregates in monodisperse films, increases tobe as large as, or comparable to, the wavelength of visible light(Fig. 10g). These results confirm the rationality of enhancedsolar-cell performance arising from light scattering, generated byhierarchically structured ZnO films and promoting the light-capturing ability of the photoelectrode.

Compared with those using large-sized TiO2 particles orphotonic-crystal layers reported elsewhere,[162,166,167] the methodusing controlled ZnO aggregation of nanocrystallites in DSCspresents obvious advantages in the generation of light scattering,without causing detrimental loss in the internal surface area ofthe photoelectrode film. That is, the size of these aggregates is ona submicrometer scale comparable to the wavelength of visiblelight, so that efficient scattering of the incident light wouldbe established within the photoelectrode film and thus extend thetraveling distance of photons, leading to increased opportunity forthe photons to be absorbed by dyemolecules. Meanwhile, the filmwith aggregates consisting of interconnected nanosized crystal-lites provides a highly porous structure, ensuring a large specificsurface area for dye adsorption, unlike the large-sized TiO2particles with solid cores that consume the internal surface areaor the photonic-crystal layer that is added to generate lightscattering but with increased film thickness as well as electrondiffusion length.

5.2. One-Dimensional ZnO Nanostructures for Light

Scattering

Recently, the enhancement effect of light scattering on DSCperformance was also observed in films consisting of one-Adv. Mater. 2009, 21, 40874108 2009 WILEY-VCH Verlag GHowever, direct use of these dyes with ZnO is difficult becausethe surface structure of the ZnO crystals may be destroyed whenthey are soaked in an acidic dye solution containing a Ru complexfor an extended period of time. By preparing N3-adsorbedZnO-nanoparticle films and comparing the transient absorptionand fluorescence spectra of those films immersed in dye solutionfor different durations of time, Horiuchi et al. studied theformation of the Zn2/dye-complex layer on ZnO nanoparticlesurface.[172] They found that such a complex layer could always beobserved if the immersion time was longer than 3 h. Below animmersion time of 10min, no complex was formed. Westermarket al.[173] and Chou et al.[174] verified that a short sensitization timemay be favorable to avoid the formation of Zn2/dye complex.However, the formation of the Zn2/dye complex seems to bevery sensitive to the experimental conditions, resulting in aZnO solar cells have still shown relatively low overall conversionefficiencies when compared with TiO2-based systems. Thelimited performance in ZnO-based DSCs may be explained bythe instability of ZnO in acidic dye (i.e., protons from the dyescause the dissolution of Zn atoms at ZnO surface, resulting in theformation of excessive Zn2/dye agglomerates) and the slowelectron-injection kinetics from dye to ZnO.

6.1. Instability of ZnO in Acidic Dyes

6.1.1. Formation of Zn2/Dye Complex

Commercially available dyes such as N3, N719, or black dyederived from rutheniumpolypyridine complexes have beenwidely used as a sensitizer for TiO2-based DSCs. The moleculesnanocrystalline films or films consisting of various nanostrudimensional ZnO nanostructures.[171] The films were typicallyfabricated using a spray deposition technique, where10-nm-diameter ZnO nanoparticles dispersed in 1-butanol wereprepared as a precursor. Based on such a precursor, variousnanostructures (nanorods, nanoflakes, or nanobelts) had beenproduced by an electric-field-induced self-assembly process,which could cause dipoledipole interactions of nanoparticles.Films fabricated through this technique displayed large surfaceareas. Moreover, it was speculated that these highly disorderedstructures contributed to the light-harvesting efficiency of thephotoelectrodes by causing random multiple light scattering, aswell as possible photon localization because of the formation ofoptical traps. Typically, an overall conversion efficiency of 4.7%was achieved on films with randomly oriented nanorods.

6. Limitation on ZnO-Based DSCs

It has been demonstrated that ZnO has approximately the sameband gap and band position as TiO2. Furthermore, ZnOpossesses a high electron mobility, low combination rate, andgood crystallization into an abundance of nanostructures. ManymbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim 4099

REVIEW

www.advmat.de

considerable difference in the optimization of the sensitizationtime. The Zn2/dye complex can agglomerate to form a thickcovering layer instead of a monolayer, and is therefore inactive forelectron injection. This means that the sensitization time of ZnOin acidic dyes is limited by its stability, resulting in insufficientdye adsorption and electron injection and thus poor performanceof DSCs.

The spatial images of both the distribution of dye adsorbed onsemiconductor surface and the electron-injection process from anexcited dye into nanocrystallites can be reflected by transientabsorption microscopy, a newly developed technique for studyingheterogeneous photochemical systems.[175] A typical example ofusing transient absorption microscopy for the study ofN3-adsorbed ZnO films is based on the experimental observa-

4100tions that (1) ZnO films immersed in dye for an extremely shorttime (3min) can obtain an adsorbed monolayer of dye moleculeson the surface, whereas a long-time immersion (12 h) leads toserious agglomeration of the Zn2/dye complex, (2) the images ofground-state absorption are not homogeneous across the films,revealing that the ground-state absorption is not due solely to N3dye directly adsorbed on the ZnO surface, but also due to the dyein the agglomerates, (3) fluorescence emission can only beobtained for concentrated N3/ZnO film, instead of diluted N3/ZnO film, indicating that the fluorescence emission originatesfrom the excited Zn2/dye agglomerates, which is consistent withthe observed heterogeneous image, and (4) the image of transientabsorption, in which the intensity is proportional to the efficiencyof electron injection, is shown to be homogeneous in the filmregion. That is, in spite of the heterogeneity of the distribution ofZn2/dye agglomerates, the electron injection is distributedhomogeneously on the ZnO film. In other words, those Zn2/dyeagglomerates are inactive for electron injection. Accordingly, amodel is proposed to exhibit the structure of dye adsorption onZnO and the distribution of Zn2/dye agglomerates (Fig. 11).With this model, a monolayer of dye molecules is formedhomogeneously on the ZnO-nanoparticle surface. These dyes areactive and contribute to electron injection. On the exterior of themonolayer, agglomeration of Zn2/dye complex is evenly yieldedto form micrometer-sized crystals. These agglomerates areinactive since those photogenerated electrons in the agglomeratesare separated from the ZnO semiconductor by the layer of activedyes.

The formation of Zn2/dye complex has been attributed to thedissolution of surface Zn atoms by the protons released from thedye molecules in an ethanolic solution. The instability of ZnO

Figure 11. Proposed structure of a N3-dye-sensitized ZnO film withZn2/dye agglomerates. Reproduced with permission from [183].Copyright 2006, American Chemical Society. 2009 WILEY-VCH Verlag Gmbresults from its surface properties in acidic dyes. In general, in asolution, the surface of the oxide is predominantly positivelycharged at a pH below the point of zero charge and negativelycharged above this value, while the point of zero charge of metaloxides is defined as the pH at which the concentrations ofprotonated and deprotonated surface groups are equal. For theZnO sensitization process with Ru-complex dye, the pH (pH 5)is much lower than the point of zero charge of ZnO (9). Thatmeans that the ZnO surface is positively charged. Thus, theprotons adsorbed on the ZnO surface will dissolve the ZnO.[73]

Bahnemann has shown that dissolution of ZnO colloids occursbelow pH 7.4.[176] Theoretical investigations by Persson et al. alsoindicate that adsorption of formic acid (HCOOH) on the ZnO(1010) surface may increase the bond length between Zn and Oatoms, and thus weaken the ZnO bond, resulting in thedissolution of surface Zn atoms.[177] Another recent study reportsthat temperature may have an effect on the adsorption andaggregation of dye on the surface of ZnO.[178] A highertemperature can effectively reduce the occurrence of dyeaggregation and increase the amount of dye adsorbed on theZnO.

6.1.2. Coating on ZnO for Improved Stability

In order to avoid the formation of Zn2/dye complexes, manycoreshell structures have been developed to improve the stabilityof ZnO in acidic dye solution by coating a buffer layer on the ZnOsurface. SiO2 has been demonstrated to be a very effective shellmaterial on ZnO, preventing the generation of Zn2/dyeagglomerates due to the strong interaction between Si4 andO2 ions. Typically, when 5-nm-diameter ZnO nanoparticles werecoated with a SiO2 layer (molar ratio of Si to Zn around 0.2), for a13-mm-thick film, an overall conversion efficiency of 5.2% wasachieved.[179] The role of the SiO2 shell was demonstrated to(1) suppress the formation of Zn2/dye agglomerates andestablish adequate dye adsorption on the electrode surface, and(2) reduce the recombination sites at ZnO surface.

TiO2 is also a representative material that may be used for thesurface modification of ZnO to prevent the surface Zn atomsfrom being dissolved and forming Zn2/dye agglomerates. Asimple route for coating a TiO2 layer on ZnO can be implementedby directly soaking or dip coating ZnO film in a solution of 10mMtitanium alkoxide (Ti(OBu)4) dissolved in 2-propanol, followed byheat treatment at 400 8C.[180] It can also be achieved byelectrochemical deposition in a solution containing 0.15 M LiNO3,0.005M Zn(NO3)2 hydrate, and 0.05 M ZnCl2 in propylenecarbonate.[181] However, these methods are not without theirdrawbacks on account of the fact that the film thickness is hard tocontrol. ALD is a newly developed technique for thin-filmfabrication and has been also reported for coating TiO2 layers onthe surface of nanostructured ZnO.[182] With the ALD technique,the growth rate as well as the shell thickness can be preciselycontrolled on the order of 1 nm. Figure 12 shows typical TEMimages of ZnOTiO2 coreshell nanowires and nanotu-be-structured TiO2 shells prepared by the ALD method.

[183]

The crystal phase of the deposited TiO2 shell has beendemonstrated to be dependent on its thickness, being completelyamorphous for less than 5 nm and polycrystalline anatase forthicker films. Besides the protection effect of the TiO2 shellH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim Adv. Mater. 2009, 21, 40874108

REVIEW

www.advmat.de(which may improve the stability of ZnO nanowires in acidic dyeand, therefore, avoid the formation of Zn2/dye agglomerates),the TiO2 shell is also believed to play a role in suppressing therecombination rate by passivating the recombination sites onthe ZnO surface and by forming an energy barrier that preventsthe injected electrons from approaching the nanowire surface. Asa result, solar cells with TiO2-coated ZnO nanowire arrays havedemonstrated significant enhancements in both the open-circuitvoltage and fill factor, leading to as much as doubly improvedoverall conversion efficiencies. Typically, it was reported that theoverall conversion efficiency was increased from 0.85% for bareZnO nanowire array to 1.72.1% with a crystalline TiO2 coatinglayer (1035 nm thick) on ZnO.[183] In a related set ofexperiments, amorphous Al2O3 was also studied as a coatingmaterial on ZnO nanowires. However, in contrast to the caseusing TiO2

[183] or the result reported for ZnO nanoparticlescoated with SiO2,

[179] the Al2O3 shell was proven to act as an

Figure 12. Characterization of a ZnOTiO2 coreshell-structured nano-wire and nanotube-structured TiO2 shell prepared by ALD. Reproducedwith permission from [183] Copyright 2006, American Chemical Society.a) TEM image of a coreshell structure with ZnO-nanowire core and TiO2shell. b) Selected-area electron diffraction pattern of the coreshell struc-tured nanowire. c) Energy-dispersive spectroscopy (EDS) elemental profilealong the dashed line in (a). d) TEM image of a nanotube-structured TiO2shell, where the ZnO-nanowire core was removed using 1 M aqueous HCl.insulating barrier, leading to a slight increase in the open-circuitvoltage (VOC) of the cell but a larger decrease in short-circuitcurrent density (JSC) with increasing shell thickness and,ultimately, a decrease in the power-conversion efficiency of thesolar cells. The increase in VOC was attributed to the Al2O3 shellhaving the capacity to passivate the recombination sites on thesurface of ZnO nanowires, whereas the decrease in JSC wasbecause the Al2O3 shell could simultaneously lower or blockelectron injection at the semiconductorelectrolyte interface.

Although the use of oxides, such as SiO2, TiO2, and Al2O3, asshells on ZnO is based on a basic consideration of improving thesurface stability of ZnO in acidic dye, the resultant effect on thephotovoltaic efficiency by these materials is obviously different. Itseems that better insight into how to select the shell material forZnO and achieve an optimal enhancement of the photovoltaicefficiency is still in need of further investigation. However, ingeneral, it is believed that the surface-modification effect is relatedto (1) the chemical bonding between O2 ions and the cations (i.e.,Si4, Ti4, or Al3), which may lead to a difference in interfacestates and thus affect the electron-injection process, and (2) themethods used for the formation of oxide shells. As mentioned

Adv. Mater. 2009, 21, 40874108 2009 WILEY-VCH Verlag Gabove, these methods, which can be greatly different, typicallyinclude soaking ZnO nanoparticles in tetramethylorthosilicate(TMOS) for the coating of SiO2 or using the ALD technique for thedeposition of a TiO2 or Al2O3 layer on ZnO nanowires. Theseprocesses are likely to result in different qualities of the coatinglayer in terms of, for example, the crystallinity, the surfaceroughness, and the coverage density. Furthermore, the enhance-ment effect is also thought to be related to the morphology of thenanostructures. For example, in the case of ZnOmentioned above,the nanoparticles and nanowire arrays possess different specificsurface areas and porosities and, therefore, the dye-diffusion andadsorption dynamics would be different. This would lead to adifference in the degree of photovoltaic-efficiency enhancementafter being coated with a SiO2 or TiO2 shell.

6.2. Low Electron-Injection Efficiency

Electron-injection efficiency describes the probability of photo-generated electrons transferring from the dye molecules tosemiconductor. In term of DSC performance, the electroninjection efficiency, winj, and the incident photon-to-currentconversion efficiency (IPCE) are related by IPCE(l) L-LHE(l)winj hC, where LHE(l) is the light-harvesting ef-ciency, l is the wavelength of incident light, and hC is thecollecting efciency for injected electrons at the back contact.[69]

The electron-injection efciency is, above all, determined by the

electronic coupling between the dye and semiconductor, and it is

also judged by the relative energy levels of the dye and

semiconductor, the residential lifetime of photogenerated

electrons in the dye molecules, and the density of electro-

n-accepting states in the semiconductor. In particular, for ZnO

sensitized with Ru-complex acidic dyes, it has been demon-

strated that the injection process may also be inuenced by the

formation of Zn2/dye-complex agglomerates, resulting in a lowelectron-injection efciency.

For either ZnO or TiO2, the injection of electrons fromRu-based dyes to a semiconductor shows similar kinetics thatinclude a fast component of less than 100 fs and slowercomponents on a picosecond time scale.[184189] Such biphasickinetics are caused by competition processes between theultrafast electron injection and molecular relaxation.[190] How-ever, for ZnO with Ru-based dyes, the electron injection isdominated by slow components, whereas for TiO2 it is dominatedby fast components, leading to a difference of more than100 times in the injection rate constant. Based on a two-stateinjection model[186] and using ultrafast infrared transientabsorption spectroscopy, a quantitative study has been given todescribe the electron-injection dynamics from Rupolypyridylcomplexes to nanocrystalline ZnO or TiO2 film, revealing that theinjection time scales from unthermalized and relaxed excitedstates to ZnO are estimated to be 1.5 and 150 ps, respectively, bothof which are one order of magnitude slower than those ofTiO2.

[184] The different injection dynamics most likely originatefrom the conduction-band structures of the semiconductors. Thatis, the ZnO conduction bands are largely derived from theempty s and p orbitals of Zn2, while the TiO2 conduction band iscomprised primarily of empty 3d orbitals from Ti4.[190] Thedifference in band structure results in a different density of statesand, possibly, different electronic coupling strengths with thembH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim 4101

REVIEW

www.advmat.de

4102adsorbate. Enright et al. estimated that the density of conduction-band states near the band edge is as much as two orders ofmagnitude higher in TiO2 by reason of the larger effective mass ofthe conduction-band electron in TiO2 (510me) than that in ZnO(0.3me).[149]

The slower electron-injection dynamics for ZnOwith Ru-baseddyes is also proposed to be a result of the electron injectionproceeding stepwise via intermediate states, as described by[191]

N3 ZnO !hv N3 ZnO !

REVIEW

www.advmat.de

5]

93

]

]

]Table 2. Summary of DSCs based on ZnO nanostructures.

Structure Photosensitizer Efficiency Ref.

Nanoparticles N719 0.44%, 2.1%

(0.06 sun), 2.22%

[72,77,11

N719 5% (0.1 sun) [73,74]

N3 0.4%, 0.75%, 2%

(0.56 sun), 3.4%

[67,76,80,

heptamethine

cyanine

0.16%, 0.67 [192,193

unsymmetrical

squaraine

1.5% [194]

eosin-Y 1.11% [66]

acriflavine 0.588% [200]

mercurochrome 2.5% [195,196

Nanoporous films N3 5.08% (0.53 sun) [85]

N719 3.9%, 4.1% [88,90]

N719 0.23%(hybrid ZnO/N719) [62]

D149 4.27% [92]

eosin-Y 2.0%, 2.4% [198,199

eosin-Y 3.31% (0.1 sun) [198]with ZnO or TiO2 aggregates. These films have the capability togenerate light scattering within the photoelectrode film so as toenhance the light-harvesting efficiency. In this case, it is possibleto use a photoelectrode film with a reduced thickness. Thelight-absorption length may remain unchanged, or even increase,due to the extended light-traveling distance caused by thelight-scattering actions of the aggregates. This would result in adecreased recombination rate so as to benefit the photocurrentdensity as well as the power-conversion efficiency of a solar cell.

However, when a similar light-management strategy to theZnO case is employed with TiO2, it is hampered by the availabilityof synthesis methods in the production of appropriate nanos-tructures. Although the mechanism of growth in ZnO aggregateshas been proposed to be a result of the dipole nature of ZnOnanocrystallites in a supersaturation colloidal solution,[206] itseems to be unsuitable for TiO2. As a