Accelerating the advancement of women in …...Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 5...
Transcript of Accelerating the advancement of women in …...Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 5...
Acceleratingtheadvancementofwomeninleadership:Listening,Learning,LeadingMaleChampionsofChange2013
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 2
StephenFitzgeraldNon-ExecutiveDirectorLieutenantGeneralDavidMorrison,AOChiefofArmyKevinMcCann,AMNon-ExecutiveDirectorAlanJoyceManagingDirectorandChiefExecutiveOfficer,QantasAirwaysLimitedGrantO’BrienManagingDirectorandChiefExecutiveOfficer,WoolworthsLimitedSimonRotheryChiefExecutiveOfficer,GoldmanSachsAustraliaandNewZealandGordonCairnsNon-ExecutiveDirectorMikeSmith,OBEChiefExecutiveOfficer,ANZAndrewStevensManagingDirector,IBMAustralia&NewZealandGeoffWilsonChiefOperatingOfficer,KPMGAsiaPacificIanNarevManagingDirectorandChiefExecutiveOfficer,CBASirRalphNorrisNon-ExecutiveDirectorGlenBorehamNon-ExecutiveDirectorElmerFunkeKupperManagingDirectorandChiefExecutiveOfficer,ASXDrMartinParkinson,PSMSecretary,TheTreasuryGiamSwiegersChiefExecutiveOfficer,DeloitteAustraliaMichaelRennieManagingPartner,McKinsey&CompanyAustralia&NewZealandDavidThodeyChiefExecutiveOfficer,TelstraStephenSedgwick,AOPublicServiceCommissioner,AustralianPublicServiceCommissionStephenRobertsCitiCountryOfficer,CitiAustraliaDrIanWatt,AOSecretary,TheDepartmentofthePrimeMinisterandCabinet
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 3
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 4
November2013
Listening,Learning,LeadingDearcolleagues,TheMaleChampionsofChangecollaborationhastheambitiontoachievesignificantandsustainableincreasesintherepresentationofwomeninleadershipinAustralia.EstablishedinApril2010byElizabethBroderick,theSexDiscriminationCommissioner,ourgroupcomprises21CEOs,departmentheadsandnon-executivedirectorsfromacrossbusinessandfederalgovernment.Inour2011lettertoyou,wewantedtostartaconversationaboutwhatwecouldalldoasleaderstoachievefasterprogressonwomen’srepresentationatseniorlevels.Wewereheartenedbytheresponse,withmanyconversationsandover100,000downloads.Overthelasttwoyearswehavesharedideaswitheachotherandfocusedontakingactionwithinourorganisations.Wehavebenefittedsubstantiallyfromtheresearchandinsightsofmany–nonemoresothantheviewsofourownpeople,whichwesoughtaspartofthisprocess.Whenwestepbackfromthisexperience,weseefourthemesforleaderswantingtoattractandadvancemorewomenandcapitaliseontheadvantagesofagender-balancedorganisation.Thesethemesare:1)steppingupasleaders;2)creatingaccountability;3)disruptingthestatusquo;and4)dismantlingbarriersforcarers.Herewedescribewhatwehavetriedandhowitisgoingsofar.Noneofushaseverythingright.Weshareafrustrationthatwomen’srepresentationinleadershiphasn’tincreasedasmuchaswewouldlike.However,wesensethatgenuinemomentumforchange,togetherwithfocusedaction,istranslatingintomeaningfulprogress.Wetrustthatsharingourexperienceswidelywillhelpsupportprogressinyourorganisationsandacrossourcommunity.
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 5
AcceleratingprogressTappingintothefulltalentpoolwillgiveusadiversityadvantage,creatingcommercial,societalandeconomicvalue.Ifwewantgenderbalancetobethenorminourorganisations,wemustcreatetheconditionsandculturesthatenablebothmenandwomentothrive.Asalltheresearchsays,thereisno‘silverbullet.’Withwideconsultation,wehaveidentifiedaninterconnectedsetofhighimpactactionsthatleaderscantaketo‘changethegame.’Theseactionsfallintofourkeythemes.
1Steppingupasleaders3Disruptingthestatusquo2Creatingaccountability4Dismantlingbarriersforcarers[IMAGE:Interlinked‘molecule’diagramofalliconsfor‘actionstoconsider’]
DevelopedbyMaleChampionsofChangeAustralia,2013
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 6
Actionstoconsider
SteppingupasleadersItstartswithus.Reflectonyourownleadershipandwhetheryouaresendingtherightsignalsaboutwomenandgenderbalanceinyourorganisation.Bringyourtopteamwithyou.Takeactiontoensurethatyourteamiseffectiveinbringingtogetherdifferentpointsofview.Endtheleadershiplotteryforwomen.Activelydevelop,promoteandadvanceinclusiveleadersacrossyourorganisation.
CreatingaccountabilityLeadongenderreporting.Takereportingtoadeeperlevel,withconsistentreportingstandards,tocreateamoretransparentandgranularviewofthepipelineandprogress.ImplementPlusOneinitiatives.Breakentrenchedpatternsbyusingasimplecommitmenttoengagemanagerstoaddatleastonewomantotheirteams,asrolesarise.Driveasuppliermultiplier.Communicatetosuppliershowimportantgenderbalanceistoyou.Encourageandsupportsupplierswhobuildandpresentmoregender-balancedteams.
DisruptingthestatusquoAsk‘50/50:Ifnot,whynot?’Ask‘whynot50/50?’acrosscareerlifecycles,fromrecruitmentandtalentdevelopmenttocommitteesandpanels.Broadenyoursearchesandchallengeresultsbelowyourobjectives.Raisethebaronwomen’scareers.Understandthetypesofexperiencesyourorganisationrequiresandbroadenthesuccessprofilesyouconsiderforseniorroles.Ensurewomengetcriticalexperiencesin‘hotjobs.’Personallysponsortalentedwomenandexpectyourseniorexecutivestodothesame.Mainstreamflexibility.Reflectonworkpatternsand‘whatittakestosucceed’inyourorganisation.Changethepresumption–askwhatcan’tbedoneflexibly,ratherthanwhatcanbedoneflexibly.
DismantlingbarriersforcarersGetthebasicsright.Celebrateparenthoodandunambiguouslyencouragereturn.Stayintouchwithparentalleaversandmakethetransitionseasy.Buildenvironmentswhereparentsandcarersthrive.Getunderthenumberstoseewhetherwomenreturningfromleavecontinuetodeveloptheircareers.Questiondecelerationandintervenewhenneeded.Supportanexpansivereviewofcaring,includingchildcareoptions.Theissuesaresystem-wideandneedtobeaddressedattheappropriatelevel,whichourprivatesectororganisationsbelievetobetheProductivityCommission.
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 7
‘IwilladmitthatIamverycompetitive.Icareaboutresults.Thatsaid,howleadersachieveresultsisjustasimportant.Mutualrespect,thoughtfulconversationsandcollaborationarecritical.Ihavelearnedoverthepastfiveyearsthatwhensomeoneisnotdemonstratingtherightbehavioursyoushouldn’twaitandhopethey’llseethelight.Youneedtostepinearlytoaddresstheproblem.Youneedtobepreparedtomaketoughdecisionsifthosebehavioursdon’tchange.’
AlanJoyce,QantasAirwaysLimited‘Youcanacceptthingswillchangeovertimeandjustdoyourpart,oryoucangrabthenettleanddoit.That’swhatIamtryingtodoandIammostproudthatwehavegonefromasedentaryplacetoaplacewheremomentumisunstoppable.’
LieutenantGeneralDavidMorrison,Army‘In2001wehadtherecruits,wehadtherolemodels,wehadtheinfrastructure,soIthoughteverythingwasreadytoflowthrough…butitdidn’t.Irealisedthewayweworkedhadtochange.IhadtoaddresstheculturalbarriersandaddresstheminawaythatsuitedTreasury–throughharnessingthepowerofdata.’
DrMartinParkinson,TheTreasury‘Menwhohaveatrackrecordofhiring,developingandadvancingwomenareactuallyquiterare.Wecelebratethemasexceptional.Ifwewantmorewomeninourseniorranks,suchleadersshouldbethenorminourbusinessesratherthantheexception.Let’sendthelotteryandunlockthepotentialofallourpeople.’
MikeSmith,ANZ‘Ultimately,thebuckstopswithme.Ineedtomakesurethatalloftheleadersinmyorganisationareinclusive.Idon’twantthistobeadiversityproject–ithastounderpinthewaywedobusiness.’
GiamSwiegers,Deloitte
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 8
1Steppingupasleaders
Ataglance
HeartoftheissueWeknowhowmuchouractionscreatemomentumforchange.Wealsoknowthatinthecaseofincreasingtherepresentationofwomeninleadership,creatingmomentummeansmorethanweanticipated.Itrequiressteppingupandchangingourways,demonstratingourcommitmentandprioritisingtheissue.Itmeanstakingaction,notjusttalkingaboutit.Achievinganymajorchangealsotakescommitmentfromeveryleaderinanorganisation,notjustitsmostsenior.Wehavefoundthatwomen’sexperiences,andtheiradvancement,areoftentoodependentonwhethertheyareluckyenoughtohaveamanagerorsponsorwhoissupportiveandinclusive.Weneedtoendtheleadershiplottery.
ActionstoconsiderItstartswithus.Reflectonyourownleadershipandwhetheryouaresendingtherightsignalsaboutwomenandgenderbalanceinyourorganisation.Bringyourtopteamwithyou.Takeactiontoensurethatyourteamiseffectiveinbringingtogetherdifferentpointsofview.Endtheleadershiplotteryforwomen.Activelydevelop,promoteandadvanceinclusiveleadersacrossyourorganisation.
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 9
Maleorfemale,thereisnosubstituteforseniorleaderswhoarefullycommittedtoincreasingtherepresentationofwomeninleadershipintheirownorganisation.Ourpeoplelooktoustosetthevisionandthenorm.Weallneedtoreflectonwhetherwearetrulytreatingthisissuelikewewouldanyotherstrategicimperativeandhowwecandemonstratestrongerleadershipfromthetop.Weneedtoextendinclusiveleadershipthroughoutourorganisationstoo.Leadershipfromthetopiscritical,butnotenough.Middlemanagersdeterminetheday-to-dayexperienceinourorganisations.Wheninclusiveleadershipisn’tclearlyvaluedaboveotherstyles,weendupwithapotlucksituationthatcanadverselyandacutelyimpacttheprogressionofwomen.Wealsofailtocapitaliseonthestrengthadiversityofperspectivesbringsourorganisations.Weneedtochangewhatwethinkofandrewardasgreatleadership.
ItstartswithusUnlessweasleadershaveapersonalbeliefintheneedforchange,progressisunlikely.Formanyofus,therehasbeenapersonalconversion.Wehavemovedfromanintellectualunderstandingtofullengagementoftheheartandmind.ForformerIBMCEOGlenBoreham,thisconversioncameattheintersectionofabusinessrevolutionandpersonalcircumstances.GlenwasrunningIBMwhentheshifttoglobalbusinesstookoff.Hesays‘ItwasclearAustraliacouldnotcompeteonscale,sotheonlywaytoremaincompetitivewaswithskillsandinnovation–andyoujustcan’tdothatwithonlyhalftheavailableworkforce.’Ontopofthisbusinessreality,Glenfoundthethoughtthathisdaughterwouldhavefeweropportunitiesthanhertwinbrotherunacceptable.ForDavidMorrison,thisconversionwasinfluencedheavilybytheopportunitytotalktowomenwhohadexperiencedabhorrentgender-basedtreatmentbyArmycolleagues.WhileDavidMorrisonhadbeensupportiveandproactiveingenderbalanceefforts,speakingtothesewomenfollowinganextensivesex-discriminationcrisistransformedhissupporttopersonaldedication;‘Asaperson,asaman,andasChiefoftheArmy,Ihadtocreatemomentumforchangethatwasunstoppable.’Westartedbyaskingourselveswhetherwewerelivinguptoourownaspirationstochampionwomeninleadership.Toanswerthisquestionwedeveloped,incollaborationwithChiefExecutiveWomenandPineStreet(GoldmanSachs’LeadershipDevelopmentpractice),amodelforeachofustoreflectonwhetherourcommitmenttogenderbalanceisdemonstratedinwhatwedo,whatwesay,whatwemeasureandinwhatweprioritise(Figure1).WeusethemetaphorofaLeadershipShadowtodescribehowdeeplyandhowsharplyourleadershipiscastthroughourorganisations.GordonCairns,AlanJoyce,DavidMorrison,SimonRothery,GiamSwiegersandIanWatttrialledthemodel.Theyeachtookawaysomethingtheycoulddobetter.Forexample,SimonRotheryrealisedheneededtotalkabouttheimportanceofgenderbalancemoreoften–asfrequentlyashespokeaboutotherbusinesspriorities.AlanJoycekepta‘leadershipdiary.’Thisincludedreviewinghiscalendartotestwhetherhewasactuallymakingtimeforwomenmenteesandreflectingonhowpromotionshehadmadereflectedhisdiversityaspirations.Healsoreviewedrecentspeeches,andtop100andtop500internaleventstoidentifyhowmuchtimewasfocussedontheissue.EveryleadercanlearnsomethingaboutthemselvesbytakingtimetoreflectonhisorherLeadershipShadow.ChiefExecutiveWomenandtheMaleChampionsofChangewillbereleasingacomprehensiveversionofthemodelinearly2014.
BringyourtopteamwithyouAcommittedtopteamamplifiesourpersonalleadership.SaysAlanJoyce,‘Ihaveworkedhardtoensurethatmyteamisastrongworkingunitthatrolemodelstheleadershipwewanttostandfor.WhenIcommencedasGroupCEO,Ihad11directreports,noneofwhomwerewomen.Ofmyeightcurrentdirectreports,threearewomen,twoofwhomareresponsibleforrunninghalfthebusinessunits.Inanindustrydominatedbymen,thisisasignificantstepchange.Iseethebenefitsofdiversityeverysingleday,includingbetterriskassessmentanddecisionmaking.’Afullycommittedtopteamisessentialtoovercomingresistance.AtTreasury,MartinParkinsonsaysthesinglebestthinghedidwasengageinfluentialbutunexpectedleadersaschampions.Shapingatopteamthatisinclusiveandcommittedcanalsohelpsustainprogressintheeventofaleadershipchange.Anumberofourorganisationshaveundergonethistransitioninrecentyears.Aswellasasupportivetopteamculture,wehavefoundpersonaladvocacyfromtheincumbenttotheincomingleadertobeacommonthreadinsuccessfultransitions.Genderbalanceinthetopteamisalsorelevantattheboardlevel.Women’sparticipationonboardsmaybenefitfromaconsciousdecisionbytheChairtoensurewomenareconsidered.SaysKevinMcCann,‘whiletherewereanumberofverytalentedmen
Figure1.ChiefExecutiveWomen–MaleChampionsofChangeLeadershipShadow
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 10
ExtractfrommaterialstobelaunchedinMarch2014.TheLeadershipShadowforgenderbalancehasbeenadaptedfromamodelprovidedbyPineStreet,theleadershipdevelopmentgroupofGoldmanSachswhocouldfilltherole,twoofmyboardsdeterminedthattheywishedtoappointawomanasdirectorwhohadtheskillsrequiredfortheposition.Havingmadethatdecision,weweredelightedwiththefieldoftalentedandqualifiedwomenwhowereavailable.Theyequalled,andinsomecases,exceededthecapabilitiesofsomeofthepotentialmalecandidates.’
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 11
EndtheleadershiplotteryforwomenInourfocusgroups,womenstatedthathaving‘agreatmanager’–variouslydescribedas‘inclusive’,‘constructive’or‘strongonvalues’–wasthesinglemostimportantingredienttoadvancement.Thisisclearlytheexceptionratherthanthenorm.Weheardofwomencalculatingthataslowerprogressionwaspreferableto‘takingachance’onamanagerperceivedtobelessinclusive.Otherssaidadvancementopportunitiesdriedupaftertheirinclusivemanagermovedtoanotherrole.Torealisetheculturewewant,weneedtoembedourleadershipexpectationsatalllevelsoftheorganisation,especiallymiddlemanagement.Qantashasinvestedingivingpeopletherightskillsandtoolstobeinclusiveleaders.Managerscametogethertodescribethe‘DarthVader’ofamanageranditsinverse–theidealmanagerprofile.Skilldevelopmenthasbeensupportedbycomprehensivemeasurement,includingleadershipassessments,engagementsurveys,360degreefeedbackprocessesandexternalreviewsofthetopteam.Byrolemodelling,buildingtherightsystemsandmeasuringalldimensions,Qantashasseenprogressonitsculture,withrecordcustomerandemployeeengagementdespitemajorindustrialaction(Figure2).Someofushavetriedunconsciousbiasawarenessprogramstobetterequipourleaderstoself-reflectandrecognisebiasintheirattitudes(Figure3).AsGiamSwiegerssays,‘Theonlywayyougetinclusiveleadersisbytalking–actuallyhavinganhonestconversationaboutthebiasesoutthere.’Treasurycoupledcompulsoryunconsciousbiastrainingforallmanagerswithabroadenedaccountabilityforfosteringdiversity.Leveragingthedata-drivennatureofTreasury,employeesatalllevelswereengagedinidentifyingtheneedforchangeandfindingsolutionsintheirownareas.EachofTreasury’sfivegroupspresentedtheiranalysisandactionplantotheInclusiveWorkplaceCommittee,anewlyestablished,seniordecisionmakingbody.Thefirstgroupsetthetone,bravelyexposingtheirownvulnerabilities.TheseeffortsarepartofamultiprongedapproachtotransformthecultureofTreasury,engagingallemployees(Figure4).Weneedtocomplementtheseprogramsbychangingincentivesandmakinginclusiveleadershiptheexpectationinourorganisations.TheLeadershipShadoworanalternativemodelcanbecascadedthroughtheorganisationtoextendthisconversation,orintegratedintotalentandfeedbackprocesses.Ultimately,wewanttoseeanewstandardofleadershipforAustralianorganisations.
‘Womeninleadershiphastobemadepersonalformenwhohaveinfluenceandacapacitytoacttochangethestatusquo…Makingitpersonalmeansit’smyresponsibility.’
DrIanWatt,theDepartmentofthePrimeMinisterandCabinet
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 12
Figure2.LeadershiptransformationatQantasAirwaysLimitedContextAlanJoycecommencedasGroupCEOin2008.SincethenQantashasexperiencedtheeffectsoftheburstcreditbubble,aglobalfinancialcrisis,asovereigndebtcrisisacrossEurope,environmentalandindustrialchallengesandlowornogrowthinmanydevelopedeconomies.AlanJoyceviewsconstructiveandinclusiveleadershipascriticaltorespondingtothischallengingenvironmentandcreatingamajortransformationacrosstheQantasgroup.Actions• AlanJoycemadehisleadershipvaluesexplicit–‘Youcan’tdoitalone’,‘Asktherightquestions’,
‘Developtherightbehaviours’,‘Bringpeopleonthejourney’and‘Keeponlearning’• AppointedseniorleaderstoheadtheDiversityCouncil• Shiftedaccountabilityfordiversity,talent,flexibilityandleadershipfromHRtoseniorlineroles• Tookabroadviewoftalent,whichhadpreviouslyfocusedontechnicalcapability.• Particularjobmovesdemonstratedthepotentialforunconventionalcareers• Investedindevelopmentandsupportincludingbiasawareness,changeleadershipandcoachingfor
theTop500• Institutedabroadsetofdiversityperformancemeasuresincluding:LSIs,KPIs,360degreefeedback,
externalassessmentsofthetopteamandengagementsurveysImpactandLearnings• ToneofExecutiveLeadershipchangedquickly• Changeswerevisibletostaffwhosawdifferentbehavioursintheirimmediatemanagers–Qantas
EngagementIndexincreased8percentin2013• Acadreofdiverseseniorleadershasbeenbuilt,withmanydifferentcareerpathways• ExecutiveLeadershipchampionscanshifttheadvocacyfromtheCEOtothebroaderteamand
accelerateimpact• Effectivefeedbackmechanismsarerequiredtodevelopinclusiveleadership• Divisionshavedifferentstartingpointsandchallengeswhichrequiredifferentapproaches–onesize
doesnotfitallevenwithinoneorganisation
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 13
Figure3.Deloitte’sinclusiveleadershipprogramContextWithadiverseworkforce,reflectingAustralia’stalentpool,inclusiveleadershipisanexpectationandrequirementforsuccessatDeloitte.GiamSwiegerswaslookingforawaytotakethistothenextlevel.Actions• Launchedapilotandusedthefeedbackandlessonslearnedtosupportthebusinesscaseforboard
endorsementofanationalfirm-wideroll-out• Madeinclusiveleadershippartofpartnerdevelopmentprograms• Ensuredallcommunicationscamefromthetop• Builtinclusiveprinciplesintoallinitiativesatalllevels• Appointedachampionineachregionalofficetoencourageattendance• Includedlearningobjectivesintheprogram:understandingtheattributesofaninclusiveleader,
potential‘blindspots,’andthedevelopmentofapersonalimprovementactionplan• FollowedthenationalprogramwithActionPlanningWorkshopstoaddresssystemicissuesidentified
Impactandlearnings• Conductedmorethan30inclusiveleadershipprogramswithover360partnersattending• Holdingworkshopscanstartimportantconversations• Embeddinginclusiveleadershiplanguageandapproachinallpeoplerelatedworkshopscanreiterate
commitmentandbuildworkplaceculture• Developinginclusiveleaderssupportstheachievementofbusinessobjectivesandbroadercultural
diversity
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 14
Figure4.Treasury’sProgressingWomenActionPlanContextTreasuryhasformanyyearsworkedtoincreasetherepresentationofwomeninleadership.Initiativesaddressedrecruitment,rolemodels,childcareandflexibleworkpolicies.Despitethis,progresswastooslowandwomenremainedunderrepresentedintheseniorranks.Recognisingtheorganisation’scultureneededtochange,MartinParkinsonembarkedonaholisticapproachtotheprogressionofwomen.Actions• Commissionedanexternally-ledsystematicreviewofTreasury’sculturethroughagenderlens• Developedamulti-prongedstrategytobuildaninclusiveculture–ProgressingWomenwaspersonally
launchedbyMartinParkinson• EstablishedanInclusiveWorkplaceCommitteewithexternalmembersanduniquedecision-making
powers• Setmeasurabletargetsfortheproportionofwomeninseniorleadershippositions–afirstfor
Treasury• BroadenedaccountabilitywitheachofTreasury’sfivegroupspresentingtheirownanalysisandplan.
Thefirstgroupsetthetone,bravelyexposingtheirownvulnerabilities• Introducedan‘ifnot,whynot’approachtoflexiblework,whichchallengesexistingbiasesabout
workingnorms• Madeunconsciousbiastrainingmandatoryforallmanagerswithaviewtorollingouttothewhole
department–MartinParkinsonandtheExecutiveBoardundertookthefirstroundoftrainingImpactandlearnings• Thereisnosubstituteforvisiblepersonalleadership• Adeepunderstandingoftheviewsofwomenandmenintheorganisationisacriticalfirststep;
barriersfoundwereduetosubtleattitudesandbehaviours• Externalexpertisecanprovidecredibilityandasafespacetoexploreconfrontingissues• Acceptingdifficultmessagesstrengthensresolve.‘ThisisnottheorganisationthatIthoughtwewere
leading,’remarkedoneboardmember• Engagingunexpectedchampionscanstemresistanceandexpandconviction• Makingallleadersaccountableforinclusivenessintheirworkplaceenablesgreatermomentum• Buy-inisrequiredfromalllevels–notjustseniormanagement.AtTreasury,thiswasachievedby
allowingstafftoanalysethedataandgoontheirownjourneyaswellassharingexperiencespublicly
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 15
‘Havingtargetsandreportingthembringsclaritytothevision,sharpensthefocusandsetsthestandardbywhichwejudgeperformance.Noonewantstocomebackandadmit,‘Wepromised,butwedidnotdeliver.’
ElmerFunkeKupper,ASX‘IfmyOperatingCommitteedoesnotthinkthathowImeasuretheirperformanceincludestheircommitmenttoandoutcomesongenderbalance,thenthey’resimplynotgoingtofocusonitlikeanyotherbusinesspriority.SofirstItoneedmakemyprioritiesclearandactuallymeasureperformanceagainsttheplanasIwouldanyotherbusinesspriority.’
SimonRothery,GoldmanSachs‘IamintentonCBAbeingaplacewherebothmenandwomencanthrive.IthinkthattheclearerIamwithpeoplethatthisisabasicexpectationthattheyareaccountablefor,themorechangeIamseeing.That’swhytargetsmatter.’
IanNarev,CBA‘Weknowbalancedteamsperformbetter.Itfollowsthat,overtime,purchaserswillincreasinglyreflectthisintheirbuyingdecisions.Themagicwillbewhenthebroaderbusinesssystemworkstogethertomakethechange.Wewillshareideas.Wewillholdeachothertoaccount.’
StephenFitzgerald,Non-ExecutiveDirector
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 16
2Creatingaccountability
Ataglance
HeartoftheissueWemakechangehappeninourorganisationsbysettingcleargoals,workingtoachievethemandremovingthingsthatwefindaregettingintheway.Yetcomparedtootherbusinessprioritieslikeincreasingmarketshare,costmanagementandsafety,wearemorelikelytoleaveachievingourgenderbalanceobjectivetochance.Wetreatitasaseparatetypeofobjective,outsidecoretargets.Wefailtointegrateitwithbusinessprocessesandstillwonderwhyprogressislimited.Sharpeningourfocusandbringingourfullmanagementsystemtobearisessential.
ActionstoconsiderLeadongenderreporting.Takereportingtoadeeperlevel,withconsistentreportingstandards,tocreateamoretransparentandgranularviewofthepipelineandprogress.ImplementPlusOneinitiatives.Breakentrenchedpatternsbyusingasimplecommitmenttoengagemanagerstoaddatleastonewomantotheirteams,asrolesarise.Driveasuppliermultiplier.Communicatetosuppliershowimportantgenderbalanceistoyou.Encourageandsupportsupplierswhobuildandpresentmoregender-balancedteams.
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 17
LeadongenderreportingInour2011letter,weobservedthat‘gettingunderthenumbers’istheprerequisitetotreatingtherepresentationofwomeninleadershipasabusinesspriority.Wechallengedourselvestoensurethatwewereusingourmanagementsystems–suchastargets,monitoringandtroubleshooting–todriveimprovementtobesteffectinthesamewaywedootherbusinesspriorities.Poolingourdataandpractices,weidentifiedtheissuesandactionstoresolvethem(Figure5).Thisworkbuiltontheanalysisandresearchofothers,includingChiefExecutiveWomen,FinancialServicesInstituteofAustralasia(FINSIA),WomenonBoardsandtheWorkplaceGenderEqualityAgency(WGEA).ImprovegranularityandstandardisationofgenderreportingGreatertransparencyandconsistentmeasurementisrequiredtoassisttroubleshootingandidentifybestpractice.InJune2013,agroupofuscalledonthebusinesscommunitytosetanewstandardforreporting–onethatispublic,moregranularandlinkedtoscorecards.Granularity,toatleastthreelayersofmanagement,improvesthequalityofthediscussion.Manyofourorganisationswilladoptthisapproachinournextreportingcycle,asexemplifiedbytheASX(Figure6).Reportingmayseembasicbuttheimpactissignificant.SaysKevinMcCann,‘OnthetwoboardsIchair,Iwasunabletocomparetherelativeperformanceintermsofwomeninseniorpositionsbecauseeachcompanyadoptedadifferentdefinitionofseniorexecutive.TheMCCinitiativehascreatedcommoncriteria,whichmeanscomparisonwillsoonbepossible.’LinktargetstoscorecardsBylinkinggenderbalancetargetstoscorecards,wecreatetheindividualaccountabilitythatmakesgenderbalanceoutcomesastandardbusinesspriority.Westartedwithourselves,includinggendertargetsinourownindividualscorecards.Someofusarenowcascadingthesetothenexttwolevels.Wearestrengtheningthelinktoscorecardsintwoways.Someofusareusinggenderbalanceorvaluesystemsinrewardallocations.Othersarereflectingthisinpromotiondecisions.AtASX,ElmerFunkeKuppersays,‘Progressionisoftenaboutleadinglargergroups.Ifyoucan’tachievebalancetargetsnow,thatwillimpactmyevaluationofyouasafutureleader.’
Figure5.MCCgenderreportingrecommendationsContextMaleChampionsofChangeandASXCorporateGovernanceCouncilrecognisedtheneedtohaveaconsistentgenderreportingframework.InconsultationwiththeWGEA,bestpracticeguidelineshavebeendevelopedand14MCCorganisationshavesignedupIssuesidentified• Limitedconsistencymadecomparingprogressandidentifyingbestpracticedifficult• Individualaccountabilityandpipelinetrackingisnotpossiblewithoutgranularreporting,
disaggregatedtobusinessunits• Culturalindicators,suchasengagementsurveyscores,areoftenoverlookedandnotintegratedinto
diversitytargetsBestpractice• Externallyandannuallyreportthegenderrepresentationofi)theBoard,ii)atleastthreelayersof
management,andiii)theoverallorganisation• Reportprogressagainstnumericalrepresentationtargets• Reportdefinitions,inclusionsandexclusionstoavoidnumbersbeinggamed• Targetsshouldbeincludedinscorecardsofindividualseniorleaders• Reportingshouldspecifydetailsincludingthenumberofdirectors/employees,andwhetherdataisfor
full-timeequivalentorheadcount
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 18
ApplyrigourandafactbasetomorecomplexbusinesstopicsRobustreportingallowssomeofthemorecomplextopicstosurface.Forexample,payequitycanonlybetackledwhenthefactsareavailabletodiscussitproperly.TheWGEAestimatesthenationalpaygaptobe17.5percent.Debatesaboutthisgapareoftenside-trackedbycaveatsaroundgenderskews,roletypesandnotcomparinglike-for-like.Arigorousfactbaseenablesustohaveconstructivereviewsofourownorganisations’paygaps.Whileweacknowledgelegacyissuesinaveragepayatseniorlevels,wherewomenareyettoreachcriticalmass,thereshouldbenopaydifferencesforjuniorandmid-managerroles.Toaddressthisweneedcredible,factbasedprocesses.Reviewsmustbuildintimetoallowforanalysisandtoinfluencedecisions.Atoneofourorganisations,managersmustsignoffthatthereisnogenderbiasinremunerationoutcomes.Thiscreatesanearlyreminderformanagerstobeawareoftheimplicationsoftheirdecisions.MartinParkinsonnownotifiesallstaffoftheRemunerationCommitteeoutcomesbygender.SaysMartin,‘Treasuryisexposingtheprogressionofwomen,holdingourselvestoaccount.’Beyondrepresentationnumbers,thereareinternalandculturalindicatorsthatcanflagcurrentissuesandleveragepointstoincreasegenderbalance.Wesetouttoidentifyabestpracticesetoftheseindicators.Thishasnotbeenasstraightforwardaswehopedduetothevariationbetweenorganisations.ASXarenowworkingwithWGEAinanefforttodevelopthisbestpracticeset.
ImplementPlusOneinitiativesOurconvictionandinfluencecandirectlyimprovegenderbalanceonourownteams.However,engagementandcommitmenttendstofadeatotherlevelsofmanagement.Butitistheday-to-daypromotionandrecruitmentdecisionsofindividualleaderswhich,whenaddedup,determineourabilitytoachievetheshiftsnecessaryforourorganisations.Weneedsimple,practicalactionsthatcanmakeastepforwardinwinningtheheartsandmindsofallpeoplemanagers.AsuccessfulactiontrialledbyANZandTelstraisthePlusOneinitiative.TheinspirationwasCiti’s‘JustOneMore’approachwheregoalswereset
Figure6.Reportingexample–ASX
ASXlevel #ofASXdirectors/employees
#ofASXwomen(asat30/06/13)
%ofASXwomen(asat30/06/13)
%ofASXwomenFY16target
Non-executivedirectors 8 2 25 33CEO 1 0 0 n/aGroupExecutives(CEO-1) 9 3 33 40GeneralManagers(CEO-2) 31 8 26 40Managers(CEO-3) 71 24 34 40TeamLeaders/Supervisors(CEO-4) 25 12 48 50Professional/technical 394 154 39 40Administrative 40 33 83 n/aEntireorganisation 571 234 41 45
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 19
tohireaminimumofoneseniorwomanintoanapprovedopenrole.Theimpactwassignificant–in2011,75percentofCiti’sbusinessachievedthegoalwitha9percentyear-on-yearincreaseinwomenSeniorVicePresidentrolesandabove.Momentumhascontinuedwitha24percentyear-on-yearincreasein2012.ThroughthePlusOneinitiatives,acommitmentismadeopenlybythetopleadertoincreasethenumberofwomendirectreportsbyatleastone.Theythenasktheirdirectreportstomakeasimilarcommitment;thedirectreportsthendothesameandsoon.Inthebestcase,pledgesaremadepubliclyandtracked.‘PlusOne’offersasimple,non-bureaucraticmetricthatcanbeusedtocreatepersonalengagementandaccountability.Theaimistostartaconversationwithmanagersabouttheroletheycanplayinachievinggenderbalance.Localisedmomentumanddiscussionisgenerated.Mindsetsarejolted.Granularinsightsaroundresistanceandbarriersareidentifiedandtackled.ANZCEOMikeSmithwaslookingforawaytoinspirehisteamtohelpachieveANZ’stargettoincreasewomeninmanagementbyatleast1percentin2013towardsalongtermgoalofatleast40percent.Despiteeffortsacrossthebank’s47,000staff,recruitment,promotionandturnovertrendsstillfavouredmen.ANZ’sPlusOneinitiativewasofficiallylaunchedtoallemployeesaspartofInternationalWomen’sDay2013,withthemajorityofMike’sdirectreportsleadingthechargehavingalready‘banked’theirpledgepriortothelaunch.Asimple,onlinesign-upprocessallowedmanagerstomaketheirpledgeandreviewthelistofcolleagueswhohadalsosignedup.Morethan500leaderssignedupwithinsixweeksofthelaunch,with2,000pledgestodate.Teamswithlowerrepresentationofwomenintheirmanagementrankswerevisiblyseentobemakingthemostpledges.ThereisevidencethatthePledgehasalreadyhelpedshiftrepresentationatseniorlevels,andmomentumisnowbuildingamongstmid-levelmanagerswhomakethemajorityofhiringdecisionswithintheorganisation.Justassignificantwastheconversationcreatedthroughoutthebankaroundtheimportanceofgenderbalance,aroundMike’sandhisteam’scommitmenttothetargets,andaroundtheneedforallmanagerstoactivelyreversethetrendsthatfavouredmeninordertoreachANZ’saspirations.Telstrarecentlylaunchedasimilarinitiative,theGenderEqualityPOP(PlusOnePromise).Telstrainitiateditseffortsatameetingofthetopteam.Within-principlesupport,thediversityteamthenmetwithindividualleaderstogainbroadanddeepcommitment.TheGenderEqualityPOPisnowbeingpromotedasavoluntarycommitmentforallTelstrapeopletoachievethemeasurableobjectivesestablishedbytheTelstraBoardinlinewiththeASXreportingguidelines.Earlysign-upsarepromisingwith200pledgesinthefirsttwoweeks,andagoaltoreach1,000bytheendof2013.
DriveasuppliermultiplierWeareintegrated,interlinkedanddependentonourbusinesspartnersandsuppliers.Yetourcommitmenttogenderbalanceisnotalwayscleartothem.Webelievethereisvalueinbeingmoreexplicitaboutthis.Engagingsuppliersintheconversationisessential.Thismeanstellingourstoryandlisteningtotheirs.Workingwithoursuppliers,wecanbuildmomentumandmoreopportunitiesforwomen,sothattogetherwecanbemoreproductiveandsuccessfulorganisations.Newideasandapproacheswillnodoubtresult.DrawingontheexpertiseofagroupofourChiefPurchasingOfficersandbusinessleaders,welookedforsimplewaystoencouragegreaterconversationandactiontogetherwithoursuppliers.InOctober2013,agroupofusannouncedourSupplierMultiplierinitiative(Figure7).Inthisinitiative,someofourorganisationscommittedtoensuringourgenderbalanceaspirationsarereflectedinpoliciessuchasourSupplierStandardsandCodesofPractice.ThisgroupofMCCsalsoagreedtofocusononeormoreofthefollowingareas:recruiters,largesuppliers,sectorsororganisationsknowntohavelowrepresentationofwomenandwomen-ownedorledbusinesses.Thesecommitmentshavethepotentialtoimpact54,000suppliersand$30billionofprocurementspendingacrosstheMaleChampionsofChangegroup.Changingsupplierrequirementscanbeasignificantchangetoprocesses.CBAistakingaphasedapproach.InPhase1,supplierconditionswerechangedtoincludeequalpayandparental/carersleaveprovisions.Phase2willdevelopadatabaseofwomen-ownedbusinessestofacilitateincreasedprocurementfromthesebusinesses.Ourexperiencehasreinforcedthevalueofatwo-wayconversation.Weneedtocommunicateourexpectationsclearly–relyingonthefineprintofsupplieragreementswon’twork.Wealsoneedtounderstandtheimpactoftheimplicitandexplicit
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 20
incentiveswecreate.Somesupplierssharedeffortsalreadyunderway,othersseemedtostepup.Someaskedforhelp.ANZconducted‘wartsandall’workshopswith150peoplerepresentingANZ’srecruitmentpartnerstooutlinetheirexpectationsongenderbalance.Recruiterssharedtheirthoughtsonpotentialbarrierssuchasshorttimeframes,whichoftenmadesearchingbeyondtheirexistingmale-dominatednetworksdifficult.Overlyprescriptiveexperiencerequirementscouldalsomeanthatcandidateswerelesslikelytobewomen.TheseworkshopshelpedrecruitersunderstandtheirindividualimpactonANZ’sbusinesstargets.AtTelstra,inspiredbyaspeechbyHelenConwayoftheWGEA,theGroupGeneralCounselopenedadialogueaboutgenderbalancecommitmentswithkeypartnerlawfirms,requestingfeedbackonhowTelstracouldimproveandinformingthemthatgenderbalancewouldbeafactorconsideredinanupcomingpanelreview.
‘WebelievetherewillbeimmensebenefitstoAustraliawhenallorganisationsactivelypursuegenderbalance.Imagineiftheingenuityofallbusinesspartnersacrossournetworkscouldbeharnessed.Thepipelinewillincrease,diversityofperspectiveswillhelpinnovationandbetterdecisionmaking.Wecanleadthewayincapturingthediversityadvantageforimprovedproductivityandperformance.’
MikeSmith,ANZ
Figure7.TheSupplierMultiplierInitiativeStartingyourownsuppliermultiplier1.UpdateyourSupplierCodeofConductorequivalentpolicies/contractstofeaturetheimportanceofgenderbalance2.Implementoneormoreofthefollowingtoeffectchange:
a. Recruitmentproviders:communicatetheneedforchange;putinplacemoreexplicittrackingofcandidatepoolsandoutcomes;encouragetheidentificationofbarrierstorecruitingmorewomen.Inthemediumterm,thiscouldalsoincludeincentivesformeetinggender-balanceobjectives
b. Mostsignificantsuppliers(calledTier1insomeorganisations):setclearexpectationsongender-balancegoals,performancemeasuresandmake-upofsupplierteams
c. Laggardsectorsororganisations:targetonesectoror2–3organisationswithlowrepresentationofwomeninmanagementandseektoinfluenceandsupportimprovedperformance
d. Women-ledorownedbusiness:understand,trackandsetgoalsaroundtheincreaseinwomen’sparticipationinyourorganisation’ssupplychains.Thismightinvolvedirectworkwithsupplierstoensuretheyarewellpositionedtoserveyourorganisation
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 21
‘Thinking‘50/50:Ifnot,whynot?’islikegettinganewpairofspectaclesandseeingtheworlddifferently.Youwalkintoamale-onlymeetingandimmediatelynoticethedifference.’
KevinMcCann,Non-ExecutiveDirector‘Eventhoughonly18percentofITuniversitygraduatesarewomen,therearestillmorethanenoughtalentedwomenforIBMtoachievea50/50ratioofmaletofemalegraduates.Ourpriorityistomakesurewe’regettingthebestpeopleandwebelievethatbeingseriouslycommittedtogenderequalitywillhelpusdothat.’
AndrewStevens,IBM‘Ourbusinessmodeldemandsflexibility,butonesizedoesnotfitall.Weneedtomakeitworkforourbusinessandforourindividualpeople–weneedtobeprinciple,notpolicy,driven.’
GrantO’Brien,WoolworthsLimited‘Inourworktogether,ourpeoplehavesharedandwehavelearnedaboutHR-ledeffortstoencourageflexiblework.Theseinitiativesareessentialandtheyaremakingsmallchangesfromapolicyorpracticeperspective.However,wewanttoforcedisruptiveandboldchange.Weneedtodomoreifwearetoreachourgoal.’
DavidThodey,TelstraandIanNarev,CBA‘Weneedtostartfromapresumptionthatflexibleworkpracticesareapositivepartofourworkplaces,ratherthanagrudgingconcession.Nopositionorlevelshouldbedeemedofflimitstosomeoneinterestedinflexibleworkingarrangements.’
DrIanWatt,TheDepartmentofthePrimeMinisterandCabinet
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 22
3Disruptingthestatusquo
Ataglance
HeartoftheissueThestatusquoongenderbalancecanleadtolowexpectationsofwomen’srepresentationintheworkplace.Attimes,weassumethattheobstaclestowomen’sadvancementareinevitableorinsurmountable.Thisisnotthecase,butwedonotbelievethatstandardapproacheswillbeenough.Weneedtodisruptthestatusquo.
ActionstoconsiderAsk‘50/50:Ifnot,whynot?’Ask‘whynot50/50?’acrosscareerlifecycles,fromrecruitmentandtalentdevelopmenttocommitteesandpanels.Broadenyoursearchesandchallengeresultsbelowyourobjectives.Raisethebaronwomen’scareers.Understandthetypesofexperiencesyourorganisationrequiresandbroadenthesuccessprofilesyouconsiderforseniorroles.Ensurewomengetcriticalexperiencesin‘hotjobs.’Personallysponsortalentedwomenandexpectyourseniorexecutivestodothesame.Mainstreamflexibility.Reflectonworkpatternsand‘whatittakestosucceed’inyourorganisation.Changethepresumption–askwhatcan’tbedoneflexibly,ratherthanwhatcanbedoneflexibly.
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 23
Ask‘50/50:Ifnot,whynot?’Thehistoricalgenderimbalanceinourorganisationshascreatedasituationinwhichwomenaretheminorityatseniorlevels(Figure8).Wecan’tletthissetourexpectationsforwhatispossible.Thedefaultassumptionthatwomenwillaccountforlessthan50percentallowsunseenbarrierstopersist.Weseetheimpactofiteverywhere,fromthecompositionofcommitteesandpanels,totalentanddevelopmentprogramsandrecruitmentslates.Whatifweweretoaskthe‘50/50:Ifnot,whynot?’questionmoreoften?Insomecases,askingthequestionhasbeenenoughtoforceustolookmorebroadlyandachievechange.Elsewhere,wehaveidentifiedsystemicbiasesandstructuralissuesthatwemustworktoaddress.Therealvalueisinaskingthequestionandexploringtheanswer.Itisabouttakingthetimetothinkaboutwhetherwomenarebeingconsideredandifnot,whynot?Acommonapplicationof‘50/50:Ifnot,whynot?’isingraduaterecruitment.Withover60percentofuniversitygraduatesbeingwomen,genderimbalanceshouldbesimpletoaddressatthegraduatelevel.Ifwedon’t,westartbehind.Thisincludesbalanceinbusinessunitsthataretraditionallyskewedtowardsmen.Agranularviewrequiresgranularreporting–atQantasthismeantredesigningsystemstounderstandthegendersplitfromapplicationsthroughtooffers.Nowin2013,57percentoftheQantasgraduatecohortiswomen.Wesharesomeofourvariousapproachesto50/50graduaterecruitsinFigure9.Beyondgraduaterecruitment,experiencedhiresremainachallenge.IBMidentifiedthatrolechecklistswereappealingmoretomen.NowIBM’sjobadvertisementsfeatureavaluepropositionthatappealstobothmenandwomen.AsdiscussedinSupplierMultiplier,wearealsoworkingwithrecruiterstoachievebalancedslates.Manyofthepoolsthatwesourcecandidatesfromaremale-dominated.Weneedtolookmorebroadly.Thereareotherways,beyondtimeinarole,thatpeoplegaincapabilities,skillsandexperience.Aswellasbroadeningoursearchesandbeingawareofinherentbiases,someofourorganisationshavefacedmorestructuralproblemsinattractingwomen.
Figure8.‘GenderJaws’–RepresentationinASX200companiesPercentwomen• Universitygraduates–62percent• Entry-levelprofessionals–45percent• Executivecommittee–10percent• Executivecommittee(lineroles)–6percent• CEO–4percent
Percentmen• Universitygraduates–38percent• Entry-levelprofessionals–55percent• Executivecommittee–90percent• Executivecommittee(lineroles)–94percent• CEO–96percent
Reference:McKinsey,WomenMatter:AnAsianPerspective(June2012);WGEA,2012AustralianCensusofWomeninLeadership;GraduateCareersAustralia,AustralianGraduateSurvey2012
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 24
Figure9.Gettingto50/50:Graduaterecruitment
Organisation Percentageofwomeninintake
Challengesandopportunities
2012 2013 2014 CBA 31 34 48 • From2011to2013,CBA’sgraduateintakesatataround
34percentwomen• The50/50questionactedasajolttoleaderswholooked
tounpackcauses• Anewgoalofbalancespurredaction.Thiswouldrequire
makinguplostgroundasthemale-dominatedinterncohortsactedasimportantfeedergroups
• Usingdeliberatestrategies,thegoalwasachievedinjustonerecruitmentseason
GoldmanSachs 26 52 62 • Therewasapersistentmaleskewingraduateprofiles,andconcernsabouta‘likehiringlike’effect
• EngagingManagingDirectorsdirectlyinthechallenge,andtheninCVscreeningandcampusrecruitmentprovidedthebreakthrough
• Anysuspicionsthatbarriershadbeenloweredtomeetatargetwerequashedbythehighqualityoftherecruitedwomen
WoolworthsLimited
50 29 47 • Genderbalancehadbeenafocusandgraduaterecruitmenthadbeenbalancedformanyyears.Inthe2013intakeWoolworthstookitseyeoffgenderbalance
• Forthe2014intake,Woolworthsrefocusedongenderbalance,includingtargetedadvertisingandcampusrecruitmentcampaigns
• Agranularviewofresultswascriticalandenabledtroubleshooting.Whenoneseniorexecutivefoundthegraduateintakeinhisdivisionwas14percent,hetookpersonalaction
ANZ 45 53 50 • Priorto2010,theANZgraduateprogramwasnotconsistentlygender-balanced
• 50/50wasfirstsetastheaspirationandbecameanon-negotiabletarget
• Whentheexpectationisclear,recruitmentteamsinnovate
IBM 32 43 48 • GenderbalanceintheITindustryisachallenge,withwomencomprisingonly18percentoffeederdegrees,suchasComputerScienceandIT
• Thepositionwastakenthatthisisnoexcuse.Theteammustlookexpansivelyandshouldwinadisproportionateshareoftalent
• Notslippingintoself-limitingthinkingiscritical Telstra 30 29 40 • Aperceptionexistedthatmale-dominatedfeederdegrees
insomedisciplinesmadegenderbalanceanunrealisticgoal
• AdetailedanalysiswasconductedtounderstandtechnicalrequirementsforTelstragraduateopportunities
• Mythsweredebunkedwhenitwasfoundthatamuchsmallernumberofrolesthanoriginallythoughtwouldactuallyrequireatechnicaldegree
• Thisremovedexcuses,challengedmindsetsandenabledabroaderapplicantpool
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 25
DavidMorrisonsetapublictargetofincreasingtheproportionofwomenintheArmyfrom10percentto12percentbetween2012and2014(Figure10).ThisinvolvedaradicalrethinkofhowtheArmypresenteditselfandattractedpeopletoitsteam.TheArmydevelopedanumberofinitiativesincludingactivitycampsforyoungwomeninhighschool,reducingtheminimumperiodofservicetooneyearandlaunchingthe‘JoinwithaFriend’program.Overthepast12months,theseinitiativeshaveseenan84percentincreaseinthenumberofnewwomenrecruits.Beyondrecruitment,wemustrelentlesslyfuelthepipeline.The‘genderjaws’diagramshowstherapiddrop-offinwomen’srepresentation.Tostemattritionandstagnation,weneedtoremainvigilant,asking‘50/50:Ifnot,whynot?’throughthefullcareerlifecycle.AtANZ,MikeSmithchallengedthe40/60splitofwomentomenonanewenterprisetalentprogram,askinghisteamtotakeanotherlookatthepool.Theteamidentifiedanumberofwomenwhometthecriteriaforinclusionbut,withacaponparticipants,didnotmakethefirstcohort.When50/50wassetastheexpectation,itwasachievedandtheprogramcohortwaslaterassessedasmorebalancedinexperience,leadershipstylesandcapabilities.Citifoundapplication-baseddevelopmentprogramsdisproportionatelyattractedmen.Citihasbecomemoreproactive–increasingeducationandawarenessoftheregionaldevelopmentopportunitiesavailable,reviewingthelocaltalent,identifyingwomenwhoareeligibleforprogramsandrequestingthemtoapply.Asaresult,keyprogramsoverthelasttwoyearshavehad50percentrepresentationofwomenfromtheAustralianbusiness.Increasinggenderbalanceinmeetingsandcommitteesimprovesthequalityofconversation,actionsanddecisions.Inthisspirit,wehavecommittedtothePanelPledge–aninitiativetoincreasewomen’srepresentationonpublicpanels(Figure11).
Figure10.RecruitingwomenintotheArmyContextConcernedthatstructuralbarrierspreventedtherepresentationofwomen,DavidMorrisonsetouttoaddressthelowrecruitmentofwomenandmasculinecultureintheArmy.Actions• Visiblymadetherecruitmentofwomenoneofhistop5priorities• Publiclysetatargettoincreaserepresentationofwomenfrom10percentto12percentbetween
2012and2014,aneffectivedoublingofwomenrecruits• Reallocatedresourcestocreateteamsdedicatedtowomen’srecruitment• Addressedstructuralbarriers:• Reducedtheminimumperiodofservicefromfourtooneyear• Establishedthe‘JoinwithaFriend’program,whichallowstwowomentoundertakethesame
recruitingandemploymenttrainingandthenbepostedtothesamelocation• ConductedadventurecampsforyoungwomeninhighschooltoexposethemtoArmylife
Impactandlearnings• Numberofwomenrecruitedinthepast12monthsincreased84percentaboveaverageoverthepast
decade• Increasedwomenrepresentationfrom10percentto11.1percentin2013,ontracktoreach12per
centby2014• Only9.6percentofwomenleavetheArmyannually,comparedwith12.3percentofmen• Publiclysettingatargetwasacalltoactionandestablishedthescaleofthechallenge• Questioningthestatusquohaschangedmindsets–recruitingteamsarewideningthepoolof
candidatesconsidered
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 26
Raisethebaronwomen’scareersIfyourorganisationislikeours,youmaywellhaveformalleadershipcoursesandhighpotentialprograms.Youmayidentifyyourtalent’sdevelopmentneedsandmatchthemwithskillstraining.Youmaydosuccessionplanning.Yetyoumayhavefound,aswehave,thatyourtalentapproachisnotequallyeffectiveinadvancingwomenasitismen.Inparticular,womenarefarlesslikelytoget‘hotjobs’,forexample:mission-criticalroles,influentialprojects,internationalassignmentsorothercapabilityandprofile-buildingopportunities.Hotjobsliketheseprovidecriticalexperiencesthatfacilitatecareerprogression.FullyunderstandthecriticalexperiencesandprofileyourequireforadvancementinyourorganisationFormostofourorganisations,successionplanningispartofourtalentmanagementprocesses.However,comparingpatternsofsuccesswithnumbersofwomenwhodonotprogressinthepipelineraisesconcern.Insomecases,wefindunnecessarilynarrowcriteriahaverestrictedwomen’srepresentation.Anexamplewaswherethefocuson‘internationalexperience’asathresholdrequirementforseniorleadershipwascreatingamale-dominatedpipeline;long-termlocalemployeeswithpartnersand/orcaringresponsibilitieswerelesslikelytohavehadsignificantexperienceworkingoverseas.Thisunintendedconsequencewasresolvedbyexpandingtherequirementto‘internationalmindset.’Theoutcomeincreasedthepoolofwomencandidatesandmeantthatmanywomenwerenotunconsciously‘writtenout’ofexecutiveaspirationsbytheorganisationorbythemselves.TakeanexpansiveviewofsuccessprofilesIftheonlyprofilewethinkofassuccessfulisdirectandunbrokenexperience,thenwewillbiasselection.Wemayoverlookpeoplewithotherequallyvalidbackgroundsandcapabilities.Whenweweighallthethingsthatneedtobeweighed–skills,experience,fitandpotential–wehavediscoveredthatarevisedprofileisrequiredinmanycases.Foranumberofyears,Woolworthshasbeenchallengingtheoperationalexperiencecriterionforsenioradvancement.AsaresultofearlierinterventionsbybothcurrentCEO,GrantO’Brien,andformerCEO,MichaelLuscombe,thestatusquoatWoolworthshasshifted.Womennowrepresentover30percentofseniorleadershippositionsandareroutinelyconsideredandappointedinpromotions.AsGrantO’Brien
Figure11.ThePanelPledgeContextManyhighprofileconferences,eventsandtaskforceslackgenderbalance,despitethereoftenbeingnoshortageofqualifiedwomen.Theabsenceofwomenfeedsunhelpfulgendernorms.Alackofdiversitylimitsthequalityoftheconversation.AsSimonRotherysays,‘Conferencesandpanelsprovideaplatformtoshareexperiencesandperspectives.Whenyoulimittherangeofperspectives,youlimitthequalityoftheconversation’ThePledge• TheMCCs,whoareoftenindemandforhigh-profilepanels,agreedtorespondtorequestswithan
inquiryaboutwhethergender-balancehasbeenconsidered• Apledgeissimpletoimplementandhighlyeffective.Itservesasareminderatanopportunemoment
ofinfluenceInAction• ASX.Uponlearningthataneventlackedwomenpanellists,ElmerFunkeKupperidentifieda
replacementforhimselfthatwouldimprovegenderbalance• CBA.IanNarevhascascadedthePanelPledgetohisleadershipteam,anditisnowappliedtoall
internalforumsaswell.• Telstra.SpeakerrequestformsontheTelstrawebsitenowstate:OurCEODavidThodeyisamember
oftheMaleChampionsofChange.Aspartofthis,wearecommittedtoensuringthateventsweparticipateinaregenderbalanced.Pleasetakethisintoconsiderationwhensubmittingyourrequest.
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 27
explains,thishasbeenachievedbycloselylinkingdevelopmentoffemaletalentwithbusinessstrategy;saysGrant,‘themomentumtoappointmorewomenislinkedtoourstrategy.Weneedthebestretailers,whowillputcustomersatthecentreofourbusiness.Inthepasttwoyears,withthisinmind,wehaverecruitedandpromotedmorewomen.’MakesurewomengetthecriticalexperiencesrequiredforadvancementIfwebelievesomeexperiencesarecriticalforadvancement,weneedtomakesurethatwefindwaystogetwomenthoseexperiences,particularlyintheearlystagesoftheircareers.Insomecaseswefoundthatgenderskewsintherolespeoplearechannelledintohavelatercreatedanexperiencegapforwomen.Forexample,Treasuryfounditwascreatingapipelineissuewithearlyinadvertentstreaming.Atthegraduatelevel,womenwereperceivedtobemorecapableoftakingonstakeholderengagementandnetworkingroles.Asaresult,moremenweredirectedtoanalyticalroles.Then,atmoreseniorlevelswomenwerepenalisedforhavinginsufficienttimeinanalyticalroles.WhenKPMGbegantomapandplanforsuccessioninallseniorleadershiprolesintheAustralianoffice,criticalexperiencesandnaturalsuccessorswereidentified.Genderbalancewasessentialinthediscussion.Theperceivedoractualgapsinfemaletalentwereidentified.Consensuswasachievedaboutwhatmightberequiredtocloserealgaps.AsGeoffWilson,COOAsiaPacific,remarked,‘Weneededtogetintentional.Withoutagenderlensinoursuccessionplanningandtalentmanagement,wewouldhavewonderedfiveyearsfromnowwhyourpipelinehadnotdelivered.Nowthatwehaveaclearplanwearelesslikelytohaveadiscussionaboutwhytherearenotenoughwomeninourtalentpipelinewhenthetimecomestomakeappointments.’ThisapproachhasbeenembracedbyKPMGCEOAustralia,GaryWingrovewhosays,‘Usingagenderlensneedstobebusinessasusualforus.Thisisaboutbeingdiverseinourthinking,diverseinourbackgroundsanddiverseinthecapabilitywebringtoourclients.’Wehavealsofoundacceleratedrotationalprogramsarecritical,asisencouragingandsponsoringwomentopursuelateralcareermovesontheirpathwaytoseniorroles.Participantsquicklytranslateandapplytheircapabilitiestodifferentbusinesses.Thisinturncanaddnewinsightsandperspectivestoteams–particularlythosethataretraditionallymale-dominated.Thisworksagainstthecommonstreamingofwomenintonon-operatingrolesthatoccursinsomeofourbusinesses.Senioradvancementoftenreliesonsponsorship,whichwomenarelesslikelytohavethanmen.Inourorganisations,wehaveagreatdealofmentoring.
Figure12.IBM’ssponsorshipprogramContextDespiteincreasednumbersofwomeninthegraduateintake,IBM’spromisingpipelinewasnottranslatingintothedesiredincreasesintherepresentationofwomeninleadership.IBMhastakenastructuredapproachtoaddressingthisgap,implementingaformalsponsorshipprogramwithasinglegoal–gettingthesponsoredwomentheirnextpromotion.Actions• Identifiedhigh-potentialwomenandpairedthemwithinfluentialleaders• Madesponsorsaccountablefornextpromotion• Focusedfeedbackonpersonalimpact,visibilityandcareerplanning,notjusttechnicalexperience• ExplicitlyintegratedsponsorshipwithTalentManagementProgram
Impactandlearnings• 40percentofwomenintheoriginalprogramcohorthavebeenpromotedintoexecutiveroles• Programsshouldbereviewedatleastonanannualbasisasbusinessneedschange• Sponsorsshouldbeexecutivememberswhocanadvocateforthecandidateeffectively• Sponsoringmusthaveapurpose–assignmentsmustmatchexecutiveturnovertoensure
advancementispossibleintherighttimeframe
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 28
Coachingwomentoconformisnottheanswer.Creatingopportunitiesforwomentoperformandshowcasingresultsis.IBMhasasponsorshipprograminwhichwomenarepairedwithseniorexecutiveswhothenactastheiradvocate(Figure12).Thesponsorsareaccountableforsuccessfullyadvancingwomenintoexecutiveroles,aswellasopeningupopportunitiesforinternationalassignmentsanddevelopmentprograms,whichprovidecriticalexperience.AsAndrewStevenssays,‘Sponsorshipwillgetyoutoyournewrole.Notadvice,butadvocacy.’
MainstreamflexibilityMoreflexibilityinourmindsetsandthewaysweworkwilldriveproductivityandagility;mainstreamingflexibilitywilltransformourworkplacesforthebetter.Flexibilitywillalsoincreasethediversityofemployeesthatourorganisationscaterto.Flexibilityshiftsthefocustooutcomesratherthanprocessesandpresenteeism,makingourbusinessesmoreagileandenablingemployeestoshapeabalancethatsuitsthem.Manyofourorganisationshaveexperiencedfalsestartswithflexibilityinitiatives.WehaveconcludedthatHR-ledeffortsrelyingsolelyonprocessandpolicyarenevergoingtobeenough.Interventionsfromseniorleadersarerequiredtojolttheorganisationandprovidenewimpetusforflexibility.Ongoingconvictioninthefaceofscepticsisvital.ChallengetheideathatflexibilityisnotpossibleAnideageneratedinoneofourmeetingswastoholdconversationswithourleadershipteamsaroundwhatrolescouldNOTbedoneflexibly.Wethinkthatpositioningflexibilityastheexpectationwillhelpsurfaceinitialbiases.Italsoservestoreinforceourcommitmenttochange.ElmerFunkeKupperoftheASXdecidedtoreversetheburden.Insteadofemployeeshavingtoprovetheneedforaflexiblearrangement,managersbeartheonustoshowaclearbusinessreasonthatflexibleworkisnotpossible.AsDavidThodeyofTelstrastates,‘Thechallengeisfiguringoutwhatcan’tbedoneflexibly.Butyouneedtostartwithanopenmind.Youbeginwiththeassumptionthateverythingcanbe.’InSeptember2013,DavidannouncedthatbyMarch2014allrolesinTelstrawouldbeadvertisedasflexible.AnnouncedaspartofTelstra’slaunchofitsnewPurposeandValues,‘AllRolesFlex’(Figure13)wasoneofsixsymbolicannouncementsmade.TheinitiativehasevolvedfromapilotprogramintheTelstraCustomerSales&ServiceBusinessUnit,whichsawtheshareofwomenintheapplicantpoolgrowbymorethan15percentandtheshareofwomeninjobplacementsincreaseby35percent,whenroleswereadvertisedas‘flexible’.SaysDavid,‘Youmustplacetrustinyourmanagers.Ifyouopenthedialogue,theywillfigureouthowitcanbedone.Ifyouwaituntileveryoneagrees,thenitwillneverhappen.Intheend,it’suptoleaderstotakeastand.’AnintentionalchangethatCBAhasmadeischangingthephysicalandvirtualworkplaceof6,500people.Withtheinfrastructureinplace,everydayisaboutflexiblework.Theobjectivehasbeentoincreaseemployeesatisfactionandproductivity.Arecentwork-from-homepilothasalsoshownpromisingresultswitha27percentincreaseinproductivityanda21percentdecreaseinsickleave.Thepilot,togetherwithabroadermovetowardsactivity-basedworking,whereno-onehasapermanentdeskandpeoplecanchoosewhereandhowtheywork,hasledtohighlevelsofengagementandafocusonoutcomesversusvisibletimeintheoffice.AtWoolworths,GrantO’Brienisdevelopingmultipleapproachestobuildflexibilityacrosshislargeanddiverseworkforce.SaysGrant,‘Therelentlesspursuitanddevelopmentofthebestpeoplemustbecomepartofeverydaylifeforus.Flexibilityisbothaproductivityandpeopleimperative.’TobetterunderstandhowtoenableflexibilityacrossWoolworths,Grantranafocusgroupwithanumberofhisseniorleaders.Thegroupspokeaboutthebarrierstoflexibilityandpotentialsolutions.ThemessagefromGrantwasthattheassumptionshouldbethatalljobshadthepotentialtobeflexible.Theconversationactedasacatalystforchange.Policieswerereviewedandrelaunched.Allemployeesnowhaveaccesstoadditionalleaveunpaid,orathalf-pay.DavidMorrisonhassetatargetfortheArmy’sFlexibleWorkProgram.Startingfromaplatformwherefewindividualsareenlistedinformalflexibleschemes,theArmyaimstoquadrupleparticipationratesfromhalfapercenttotwopercentbytheendof2016.Davidpersonallyledtheinitiativeandoversawworkshopsforallcommanderstoworkthroughtheimplicationsofflexibilityfortheirunits(Figure14).TheArmywilltrackparticipationinflexibleworkandthepromotionratesandcareerprogressionofthosewhodotakeupthisaction.AttheDepartmentofthePrimeMinisterandCabinet,thereisalreadystrongrepresentationofwomenin
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 29
Figure13.Telstra’s‘AllRolesFlex’initiativeContextTelstrahasworkedforseveralyearsatexpandingflexibleoptionsatwork.Inmid-2013,DavidThodeypiloted‘AllRolesFlexible’inTelstraCustomerSales&Service.ByMarch2014,flexibilitywillbeconsideredthe‘startingpoint’andavailableforallrolesinTelstra.Actions• Repurposedonlinerecruitmentformstoshowrolesasflexible–‘WeworkflexiblyatTelstra.• Talktousabouthowthisjobcouldbeflexibleforyou’• Heldtrainingworkshopsforrecruitersandmanagerstohelpthemleadteamsthatincludeflexible
workers• Beganrolemodelling,withvisibleflexibilityamongstexecutives• IncludedflexibilityasoneofthesixsymbolssupportingTelstra’snewPurposeandValues,which
includevalueslike‘ShowYouCare’and‘TrustEachOthertoDeliver’Impactandlearnings• Applicationsfromwomenrose.Offersacceptedbywomenincreasedby13percent• Moremenareworkingflexibly,breakingpreviousperceptions• Thefeared‘backlash’aroundtheinitiativedidnoteventuate–recruitersandmanagersworked
togethertoaccommodatechallenges• Employeeengagementofflexibleworkershigherthancompany-widescore
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 30
leadership.IanWattbelievesthenextobjectiveistoexpandflexibility.Workinginflexiblearrangementsotherthanpart-timefeelslikeanewideabecauseoftheneedforhigh-levelanddailyinteractionswithpoliticians.Applyingcreativethinkingtotheidea,Ianchallengedjobdesigns.Ajob-shareregisterhasenabledmatchingofflexibilityrequirementswithaviewtoengineeringawin-winfortheDepartmentanditsflexiblyworkingemployees.Weknowtherearefurtherbarrierstobeaddressed.Onethatisfrontofmindformanyofourorganisationsisensuringweremainresponsivetoclientdemands.Itisoftenclaimedthatclient-facingrolescannotbeflexible.MichaelRenniefromMcKinseysays,‘Ioftenwonderifweareourownworstenemy.Wearesoclient-orientedthatweoverlookthepotentialtomeetclientneedsindifferentways.Attheveryminimumweshouldnotbeassumingonbehalfofourclients.Wealsoneedtobecomebetteratservingourclientsviathosewhoaren’tavailable24x7.’AsStephenSedgwickoftheAustralianPublicServiceCommissionoutlined,‘Wehaveanumberofjob-sharingseniorpublicservantswhobriefMinisters.TheMinistersareverydemanding,butourpeoplealwaysmakeitwork.’AddressthestigmathatflexibilitysignalslowcareerambitionandcommitmentDespiteourefforts,workingflexiblyoftenpresentsasacareerpenalty.Flexibleworkersarefarlesslikelytoadvancethroughourorganisations.Part-timersarerareonourexecutiveteams.Someflexibleworkersdescribebeing100percentaccountablebuttakinghome80percentofthewage,tradingsalaryforflexibilitysotheycanmanageprofessionalandpersonalcommitments.Thismeanssomewomenwill,ineffect,takehome20percentlesspayjustsotheycanconstructaworkweekthatisdifferenttothestandardbusinessworkinghours.Weneedtoaddresstheprogressionbarriersthatmakeflexiblejobsratherthancareers.Manyofourorganisationshavehadflexibleoptionsinplaceforyears,butwehavenotredesignedjobsandworkplacestosuit.Atoneofourorganisationswewereshockedtohearayoungemployeeinafocusgroupstate,‘Iknowit’sbad,butifIjustwaitarounduntilaftertheflexworkersandthosewithcaringresponsibilitiesleave,that’swhenallthegoodworkgetshandedout.’Acommonbarrierwefindisthatflexibleworkersarelesslikelytobeassessedashighperformingthanfull-timers.Weheardoneseniorexecutivesay,‘Iwouldnotexpectpart-timerstoachievethehighestperformancerankingbecausetheirjobisobviouslynottheirpriority.’Giventhatwomenaremorelikelytobeonflexibleworkarrangements,theseattitudescreateasystemicgenderdisadvantage.Moreover,itisoftenassumedthat‘hotjobs’cannotbeflexible,thusdisproportionatelyexcludingwomen.AtKPMG,theAnnualPerformanceandPayaudithasaparticularfocusongenderandpart-timeworkers.Processeswerechangedandtoolswereprovidedtominimisebiasbeforesign-off.SaysGeoffWilson,‘Weallthinkwearemakingfairandequitabledecisions.Itisonlywhenwestepbackandlookatthedatathatwerealisewecandobetter.’Arecent‘AgileWorking’pilotatKPMGaimstochallengethemindsetsthatgetinthewayofflexiblework.Thepilotwillprovidemodelsofleadershipbehaviourformanagingflexibility,whicharescalablethroughoutthefirm.Anapproachthatseeksmultipleperspectiveshasbeenadoptedinvolvingclientinterviews,individualandmanagercoaching,teamworkshopsandfocusgroups.Leaderswilldevelopdeeperinsightsabouthowtomanageflexibleworkersandflexibleworkerswilllearnnewtechniquesforsuccess.Thiswillenablenewclientservicemodelstobedeveloped.Ultimately,wewanttohelpdebunkthemyththatflexibleworkingimpedesproductivityandsignalslowcareeraspirations.AsMikeSmithsaid,‘Intheendthisisabouttrustinourpeopleandintegrity.Whenflexibilityisafforded,thetrustistakenseriouslyanditisusuallyrewardedwithstrongperformanceandhighdiscretionaryeffort.Ouremployeesurveyshowsourflexibleworkersaremoreengagedandmorepositiveoneveryaspectofourbusiness.’Bewarethesignalsyourtopteamsends.Isflexibilityreallypossible?Asleaders,ourownbehaviourandexpectationscansabotageeffortstobuildaflexibleculture.Choicesaroundhowwepersonallyfitwiththe24hour/7dayworkerstereotypearecritical.Someofushaverealisedthatweneedtobemorevocalandvisibleinhowwemaketimeforourpersonalcommitments.Unfortunately,visibleindividualswhohavemadechoicesacrossthespectrumofflexibleworkappeartoberare,particularlyatseniorlevels.ThestartingpointforCBA’sIanNarevwastoleadadiscussionaroundhowhisexecutiveteammightbeabletoworkmoreflexibly.Healsometwithmenandwomenfromacrosstheorganisationtobetter
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 31
Figure14.FlexibilityintheArmyContextArmylifehashistoricallybeenconsideredincompatiblewithflexibility.In2012,DavidMorrisonsetagoalofquadruplingthenumberofflexibleworkersby2016.Actions• ReleasedtheFlexibleWorkArrangementsguide,outliningacommitmentandplantomainstream
flexibility• Heldworkshopsforcommanderstodiscussflexibleoptionsandmanageflexibleteams• PurchasedITequipmenttoenableflexiblework,e.g.laptops,remoteaccesstokens,3Gcards• InstitutedpolicyrequiringcommanderstoconsiderFlexibleWorkApplicationswithexpectationof
approvalImpactandlearnings• Increasedacceptanceandunderstandingamongcommandersofthebenefitsofaflexibleworkplace• Thecombinationofcentralisedpolicyandlocalisedsolutionsisbeginningtoaddresssomeofthe
particularchallengesofArmyoperationalrequirements• Creativesolutionsarebeingfoundthatwouldneverhavebeencontemplatedbefore
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 32
understandwhathepersonallymightdotobreakdownbarriers.Weknowthatweneedtobeoutspoken.SaysStephenRobertsofCiti,‘I’vehadanumberofpeoplesaythemostimportantthingIcandoistalktomanagersandchangetheirattitudes.Thiswasbroughthometomewhenanemployeewrotetomeaboutamanagerwhohadnotbeenunderstandingwhenacolleaguehadoccasionallyrequestedtoworkfromhome.Followinga‘ThoughtLeadershipoverLunch’sessionthatIregularlyhold,thatmanagergatheredhisteamtoletthemallknowthatworkingfromhomeorotherflexiblearrangementswassomethinghesupportedandwaswillingtolookatsuchworkingarrangements,onaformalorinformalbasis.’
‘Let’snotpretendthattherearen’talreadyestablishednormsthatadvantagemen.Meninventedthesystem.Menlargelyrunthesystem.Menneedtochangethesystem.Withoutinterventiontoensurethatoursystemsarereallyfocusedonmerit,wewillcontinuetoseealaginwomen’sadvancementintoseniorroles.’
GordonCairns,Non-ExecutiveDirector
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 33
‘Weneedtomakeparentsfeelgreatandwanttoreturn,andthenaskhowtheywouldliketoacceleratetheircareers.IworrywhenIseesomanybrilliantyoungpeoplewhosecareersplateauafterparentalleave.’
GrantO’Brien,WoolworthsLimited‘Thereisagenerationalshiftuponus.Enablingmenacrossourorganisationtobettersupportwomenandsharethe‘doubleburden’mayserveasoneofthelessobvious,butmoretransformationalactionswecantaketoadvancewomenintoleadership.’StephenSedgwick,AustralianPublicServiceCommission
‘Therewerewaytoomanypeopleinvolvedintheparentalprocess–somanyemails,somanyhandoffs.Itwastooeasyforwomentobecomeoutofsightandoutofmind.Weneedtomakeparentalleaveprocesseshassle-free.’
GeoffWilson,KPMG‘AtCiti,wewerelosingfartoomanyfantasticwomenwhodidn’treturnafterhavingchildren.Weaskedourselves‘whatarewedoingtocontributetothispattern?’Werealisedthatthereisnosubstitutetomesettingandenforcinghighexpectationsofthemanagersresponsibleforthosetakingleave.Whataretheydoingtobeclearthattheywantthewomenbackontheirteam?Howaretheykeepingintouch?Aretheycommunicatingtheirplansforthewomenwhentheyreturnwhichwillsupporttheircareer?’
StephenRoberts,CitiAustralia
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 34
4Dismantlingbarriersforcarers
Ataglance
HeartoftheissueTraditionally,themostcommonroutetoprofessionalsuccesshasnotincludedcareerbreaksandvisiblecaringresponsibilities.Manywomen’scareertrajectoriesplateaufollowingparentalleaveevents–peopleoftenassumewomenaremoreinterestedinajob,ratherthanacareer.Jobsandcareerpathsneedtoberedesignedwithconsiderationtopeoplewithcaringandcareerresponsibilities,orthe‘doubleburden.’TheAustraliancontext,includingchildcare,transportoptions,traveldistancesandsocietalnorms,makethe‘doubleburden’evenheavier.Butthereisagenerationalshiftunderway,withmenwantingagreaterroleincaring.Weneedtosupportthisfortruegenderbalance.
ActionstoconsiderGetthebasicsright.Celebrateparenthoodandunambiguouslyencouragereturn.Stayintouchwithparentalleaversandmakethetransitionseasy.Buildenvironmentswhereparentsandcarersthrive.Getunderthenumberstoseewhetherwomenreturningfromleavecontinuetodeveloptheircareers.Questiondecelerationandintervenewhenneeded.Supportanexpansivereviewofcaring,includingchildcareoptions.Theissuesaresystem-wideandneedtobeaddressedattheappropriatelevel,whichourprivatesectororganisationsbelievetobetheProductivityCommission.
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 35
Howweapproachparentalleaveispivotal.Itcanundermineorsupportmanyofourotherefforts.Manyofusstilldonothaveacceptablereturn-to-workrates.Eventhoseofuswhohavegoodreturnratesacknowledgethereisstillmuchtodotoensureadvancementcontinuesafterleave,ifthatisdesiredbytheparentalleaver.Whileweunderstandthedecisiontoleadatworkisdeeplypersonal,westrivetoremoveeveryroadblock.Weseetoomanyexamplesoftalentedwomenwhoreturn,butwhosecareersstallorgosideways.Fromourdiscussions,itisclearthatno‘silverbullet’canaddressthemyriadofchallengesaroundparentalleave.Wemustchangethepoliciesandprocessesthatdeterminethesuccessofaparentalleaveeventandaddresstheculturalblockersthatmaketheexperiencegreatorterrible.Again,supportiveandinclusiveleadersareessential.Allthisiseasiersaidthandone!Weknowwehavenotyetcrackedthecodeonpreventingparentalleavefromstoppingorstallingcareers.However,therearesomeideasandactionsthatappeartobeworking.
GetthebasicsrightApositiveparentalleaveexperience,withclearenthusiasmforawoman’sreturn,oughttobeacertainty.Countlesspeoplegoonleaveeveryyear.Itshouldbebothwell-communicatedandrunlikeclockwork.Sadly,examinationofourownorganisationsrevealedthisisnotalwaysthecase.Theremustbenoambiguityontheencouragementtoreturn.Wecan’tsaythistoooften.Andweneedtounderstandthatitishere,intheexecutionofourfoundationalleavearrangements,thatourcommitmentisdemonstrated.Thisimpliesmorethanaclean-upofpoliciesandsupportmechanisms.Weneedtofindawaytofollowthroughonthevalues,promisesandcontext-settingthatweframedastheLeadershipShadowinFigure1.Withparentalleave,whatweprioritise,measureandhowweactneedstoresonatewithwhatwesay.Thisisbecausetherealityofparentalleaveisasmucharesultofthemindsetsweallowtoflourishasitisaresultofthepackageofpoliciesweofferparents.In2010,Citiintroducedasuiteofparentalleaveprograms,policiesandprocessestoincreasereturnratesandthelevelofengagementemployeesfeltontheirreturn.Whilethereturnratesincreased,thelevelofengagementwasnotasstrongashoped.Citiidentifiedlowutilisationratesinsomeprogramsandlowlevelsofawarenessacrosstheentiresuite.Citiisnowengagingmanagersthroughoutallparentalleavetransitionswithaviewtoincreaseawareness,uptakeandsupportforbothexistingandnewprograms.Manyofushaveundertakeninitiativesacrossthelifeofparentalleavewithpromisingimprovements(Figure15).Weencourageyoutocheckyourownworkplaces.Weneedtobeparticularlyvigilanttoensurethatjobsandopportunitiesremaincurrentwhilewomenareonparentalleave.Organisationsensuretheyarecompliantwithlegalobligationsduringrestructuresanddownsizing,butparentalleaverscanoftenbeoverlookedforpromotionsanddevelopmentopportunities,andover-representedinlayoffs.OneideawelikeisforchangestotherolesofwomenonparentalleavetobemonitoredatanaggregatelevelandapprovedbytheheadofHumanResources,orrelevantseniorleader.Thisencouragesmanagerstothinktwice.ThischangewasenactedatCBA.SaysIanNarev,‘Wewanttomakesureweretainourtalentedwomenwhiletheyareonleave.Itisunderstandablethatwhenmanagersareaskedtoreducecosts,somemightlooktothepersonwhoisn’tthere.Butultimatelythatwillworkagainstbothourgenderbalancegoalsandourperformanceinthelongrun.Fornow,acentralisedmeasurewillguardagainstthis.’
BuildenvironmentswhereparentsandcarersthriveEnsuringthatparentsthriveaftertheirreturnfromlong-termleaverequiresactivecommitmentfrommanagers.Itinvolvesencouragingwomentopickupwheretheyleftoffintheircareerprogression.Wealsoneedtorecognisethatifnowisnottherighttimeforthem,itdoesn’tnecessarilyfollowthatitwillneverbeso.CBArecentlyintroducedparentalleavereturnworkshopsforemployeesandtheirmanagers.Theseworkshopsdeepentheconversation,bringingwomenandmanagerstogethertodevelopasustainableramp-upplan.Suchworkshopsshouldbestandardprocedure.AtTelstra,DavidThodeyisusingthepowerofasimplereminder.Eachmanagerreceivesanemailfromtheirgroupheadremindingthemthatadirectreportissoontocomeback,andthattheyareexpectedtoensurethatpersonhasapositivereturn,emphasisingtheresourcesavailabletosupport.Someofusworrythatcareerdecelerationisaresultof‘outofsight,outofmind.’Toaddressthis,AndrewStevensofIBMhasintroducedanewinitiativewherewomenonparentalleaveareincludedineachbusinessunit’smonthlyDevelopmentandOpportunityReview.Thisencouragesmanagerstotakeownershipforstayingconnectedwithwomenonleavetoensure
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 36
Figure15.Policies,processesandmindsetsacrosstheparentalleavecyclePhaseofparentalleave
1 2 3 4Preparingforleave Stayingconnected Reintegration Careeracceleration
Standardexpectation
Leaveandreturnshouldbeclearlyplannedout,appropriatelysettingexpectationsforbothemployeesandmanagers
Parentsshouldfeelconnectedtotheorganisationduringleaveandtheencouragementtoreturnshouldbeclear
Parentsshouldbeabletopickupwheretheyleftoff,whilebeingabletobalanceworkandfamilycommitments
Careerplanninganddevelopmentopportunitiesmadeavailable–placingreturningparentsonsamesuccessfulcareertrajectoryasallotheremployees
Mechanismtosupport
Managerandemployeechecklists;discuss‘stayingintouch’expectations;planexpectedreturndates
Formalcatch-updatesthatarenotcancelled;accesstolaptopandmobile;inclusionindevelopmentreviews;businessupdatenewsletters
Returntoworkworkshopsandseminars;flexibleworkingoptions;childcareservices
Careerplanning;sustainableflexibleprogram;removalofanyunconsciousorsystemicbias
Mindsetsthatneedchallenging
‘Oh,you’repregnant!Youmustbesteppingbackfromyourcareerforawhile
‘Shewon’twanttobebotheredwithwhat’shappeninginthebusinessduringleave’
‘Haveyouhadagoodholiday?’
‘Shewon’twantthatopportunity,andIdon’twanttoloadmoreworkonherwhenshealreadyhasafamilytobalance’
Organisation
Initiative PhaseimpactedbyinitiativedescribedOrganisations’parentalleaveinitiativesarenotlimitedtophaseshighlighted
ANZ Childcareallowance.Introduceda$4,000childcareallowanceforallreturningparents.Positivefeedbackthatparentalleaversfeltthebanksupportsthemreturningandunderstandssomeofthepressures.Returnratesincreasedfrom67%to89%between2010and2013
3
CBA Onlineportal&resources.Consolidatedpoliciesandtoolkitsintoahightrafficportal.Changedtoneoflanguagefrombureaucraticanddetachedtocongratulatorye.g.removedthesystemclassificationofparentsonleaveas‘overquota,unattached’
1 2 3
Citi Managerengagement.Activelyengagedmanagersthroughlifeofleave.Usedregulatorydays(paiddaysofworkwithinparentalleaveperiod,createdintheParentalLeaveAct2010)tobringparentsuptospeedandeasetransitions.Returnratesrosefrom50%to80%from2009to2013
1 2 3
Deloitte
Transitionalcoaching.Findingpoorretentioninthe24-36monthspostparentalleave,Deloitteestablishedaone-on-onecustomisedserviceforindividualspreparingtoreturntowork.Recognisedindividualneedsandcircumstancesvary.Coachinginvolvesteamandclients
3
IBM Developmentreviews.Parentsonleaveareincludedinmonthly‘DevelopmentandOpportunityReviews’toensurecareerplansareunderstoodandtoidentifyopportunitiestoreignitecareerplansuponreturn
2 4
KPMG Casemanagement.Currentlymovingfrommanagingparentalleaveasaseriesofindividualtaskstoacasemanagementapproach.Asinglecontactandpointofaccountabilitywillcreateanimprovedconnectionwitheachparentandleverageanalreadyhighreturnrateof93%
1 2 3
Qantas Careercoaching.Parents@Qantaspilotprogramhasestablishedacareercoachingserviceincludinginformationportalandseminars.Leveraginganalreadyhighreturnrate(97%)tomaintaincareermomentum
1 2 3 4
Telstra Integratedsupport.Tomaintainreturnratesof92%,Telstrahaveinstitutedcoachingsessionsforparents,“StayingConnectedGuide”forbefore,duringandafterleave,Webexsessionsformanagersontheirrole,SMS/e-mailalertsaboutstayingintouch
1 2 3
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 37
thatcareerplansareunderstoodandencouraged,andtoidentifyopportunitiesfortheirreturn.Additionally,parentalleaversareincludedinIBM’sannualsalaryreviewprogram.Importantly,eachparentandparentalleaveeventisdifferent.Onesizedoesnotfitall.However,wehavefoundsuccessstoriestohavearecurringtheme;theorganisationasksthewomaninquestion,‘whatdoyouneedtomakethiswork?’andthenworkstomakethatareality.Weknowwewillhavesucceededwhenparentalleaveisaspecialtimeforfamiliesandanunremarkableabsencefromtheworkplace,whichoccursaspartofalargeproportionoflong-termandsuccessfulcareers.Thisisstilltoofaroffformost,ifnotallofus.Wewillcontinue,however,tomakethisafocusinourorganisations.
Supportanexpansivereviewofcaring,includingchildcareoptionsWehearfromouremployeesoverandagainthatchildcareisamajorchallengeinpursuingtheircareersandleadershipambitions.Somesaythatcurrentchildcareoptionsmakecontinuousemploymentalmostimpossible.Manyparentssaytheycanmanagetheday-to-dayjuggle,butreconciling12weeksofschoolholidaysperyearwithfourweeksofannualleaveforcesmany–oftenwomen–outoftheworkforce,ortoreducedroles.Anaspirationwesharewithmanyisthatparentshaveaccesstoquality,affordableandflexiblechildcarechoices–fromearlyyearstosecondaryschool.Butweknowthisisfarfromthereality.Thisissueismorecomplex,multi-facetedandmultisectoralthanweimagined.Interventionsforchildcaresuchasonsitecentresandflexibleworkingarrangementsgosomewaytohelpingemployees.However,thefullspectrumofchildhoodmustbeaddressed–beforeandafterschoolandduringschoolholidays.Thisisasystem-widechallengeandweunderstandthatthereareimplicationsforcaringbeyondchildcare.TheprivatesectororganisationsinourgroupbelievetheProductivityCommissionReviewunderconsiderationisarobust,pragmaticandmuchneedednextstep.Welookforwardtocontributingandweencourageotherleaderstogivevoicetothecaringchallengesfacedbypeopleinyourbusinessaspartofthisprocess.
‘Ourchallengeisthatwehavehadarigidprogressiontimelinethatclasheswiththetimethatwomenoftenhavechildren.Onethingthathashelpediscreatingavocabularyabouton-rampsandoff-rampsaroundparentalleavetoresetexpectationsaboutwhatsuccesslookslikerelativetouninterruptedcareers.’
MichaelRennie,McKinsey&Company
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 38
[IMAGE:Interlinked‘molecule’diagramofalliconsfor‘actionstoconsider’]
DevelopedbyMaleChampionsofChangeAustralia,2013
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 39
Wheretofromhere…?Wehaveabiasforaction.Ourfocusisnowsquarelyonleadingandachievingchangewithinourorganisations,andcollectivelywhererequired.Weareusingtheapproachsetoutinthisletterasourguide.Weknowthatnoonesizefitsallandevenbetweenourownbusinessunitswehaveneededtoadaptourapproach.Weknowthattherewillbefuturehurdles,butthatnottoactistoacceptthecurrentstate–whichwearenotwillingtodo.Wetrustthattheconcreteproposalswehavesharedcanbeadoptedinwholeorselectivelybymanyothers.Wewelcomethewidedistributionofthisletterandtheideasandcasestudieswithin.Wetrusttheyhelptobuildmomentumandcreateinspirationforleadersatalllevels–inprivateandpublicsectororganisations–whoareintentonadvancingmorewomenintoleadershipandcapturingthediversityadvantage.
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 40
TheMaleChampionsofChangewouldliketothankthefollowingwhocontinuetoassistusaswedeepenourknowledgeofgenderbalanceandlookforactionstoimplement:AvivahWittenbergCox,TheAustralianHumanRightsCommission,AustralianWomenChamberofCommerceandIndustry,Catalyst,ChiefExecutiveWomen,DiversityCouncilAustralia,FinancialServicesInstituteofAustralasia(FINSIA),WEConnect,WomenonBoards,WorkplaceGenderEqualityAgency(WGEA)andthegroupofwomenwhodevelopedthe50/50,IfNot,WhyNot?initiative.WethankMcKinsey&CompanywhohavesupportedtheMCCprobonosince2011.Thishasincludedhelpingwriteboththisandourfirstletterandprovidingongoingcounsel.ThankyoutoKPMGforsupportingourfocusgroupsprobonoin2012.WealsothankJanetMenzies,oftheMCCSecretariat,forherleadership.
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 41
Elevatingwomen’srepresentationinleadership–ajourneyInour2011letterweidentifieda3-phasejourneyorganisationstendtogothrough.Thesetofactionswehavebeenworkingonwillhelpusprogresstocapturethediversityadvantage.Ourfull2011letterisavailableatwww.humanrights.gov.au/male-champions-change.Sourceofimpact Phase1 Phase2 Phase3 Gettinginthegame Gettingserious Capturingthediversity
advantage Webecomeawareofthe
issueandbuildconvictiontoact
Wearegoodatidentifyingbarriersandinterveningtooffsettheirimpact
DiversityisapartofourDNA.It’sthewaywedothings
Leadershipculture • Surfacebarriersandbiases
• Developinclusiveleaderswhoharnesstalent
• Weedoutentrenchedbiases
• Takeflexibilityfrommarginaltomainstream
CEO/Seniorleadershipcommitment
• Getunderthenumbers
• Setupadiversitycouncil
• Makeitpersonal
• Maketheleadershipteamthediversitycouncil
• Signalchangewiththeappointmentofwomentokeyroles
• ShiftfromdiversitymathstomeasuringandmanagingKPIs
Skill-buildingandcollectiveenablers
• Ensurewell-functioningwomen’sskill-buildingandnetworks
• Ensurehygienefactorsareinplace
• Interveneontalent- Zero-inontop
talentpoolsandhighperformerprograms
- Betmoreonleadershipintrinsicsinappointments
- Transitiontosponsorship,notmentorship
- Ensureyourattractionengineisdelivering
Centreofgravity HR SeniorLeadership Wholesystem
Impact Lowimpactdespiteinvestments
Goodprogressbeforeplateauing
Impactisonbusinessperformancenotjustgenderrepresentation
Risks Over-programmingandlipservice
Perceivedoractualviolationofmeritocracy
Executionriskandmindsetstooentrenched
Accelerating the advancement of women in leadership 42
Acceleratingtheadvancementofwomeninleadership:Listening,Learning,LeadingMaleChampionsofChange2013©AustralianHumanRightsCommission2013.Allmaterialsprovidedinthispublicationwiththeexceptionofimagesandlogos,areprovidedunderaCreativeCommonsAttribution3.0Australia(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/au/deed.en)licence.Fortheadvocateofdoubtthismeansthislicenceonlyappliestomaterialassetoutinthisdocument.ThedetailsoftherelevantlicenceconditionsareavailableontheCreativeCommonswebsite(accessibleusingthelinksprovided)asisthefulllegalcodefortheCCBY3.0AUlicence(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/legalcode).ISBN978-1-921449-48-2ThispublicationcanbefoundinelectronicformatontheAustralianHumanRightsCommission’swebsiteat:www.humanrights.gov.au/male-champions-changeThisletterisaninitiativeoftheMaleChampionsofChangewhichisconvenedbyElizabethBroderick,SexDiscriminationCommissioner,AustralianHumanRightsCommissionImagecredits:Page11:Qantas,BrettWinstonePage12-13:CBA,NicLongPhotographyPage28:KPMG,RobHendersonPage30-31:CourtesyofTheDepartmentofDefencePage36-37:McKinsey&Company,ValTitovPage40-41:MCC,NicLongPhotographyIconsdesignedbyElmwood.ReportdesignbyMcKinsey&Company.ThankyoualsotoDonaldSimpson.