ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel...

86
1 ABOVE-GROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FALLOW FIELDS AT THE NHAMBITA COMMUNITY- MOZAMBIQUE EVELINA CATARINA DA COSTA SAMBANE A dissertation presented for the degree of Master of Science University of Edinburgh, 2005 I assert my right to be identified as the author of this work In accordance with section 78 Copyright Designs and Patents Act 1988.

Transcript of ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel...

Page 1: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

1

ABOVE-GROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FALLOW FIELDS AT THE

NHAMBITA COMMUNITY- MOZAMBIQUE

EVELINA CATARINA DA COSTA SAMBANE

A dissertation presented for the degree of Master of Science

University of Edinburgh, 2005

I assert my right to be identified as the author of this work

In accordance with section 78 Copyright Designs and Patents Act 1988.

Page 2: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

2

ABSTRACT

The study was conducted in Nhambita Community in Mozambique. The main objective

was to quantify the amount of biomass in the fields after agricultural. Diameter at breast

height (DBH) and height have been measured in 28 different fields in fallow and the

biomass estimated. The estimation involved the use of four different published allometric

equations, and the average calculated to give a better estimation of above-ground biomass

accumulated. The total amount of above-ground biomass was found to be 19.6 t ha-1

with

an accumulation rate of 1.1 t biomass ha-1

yr-1

that correspond to 0.55 tC ha-1

yr-1

. These

values are low when compared with other studies of miombo. Frequent fires and low soil

fertility might have contributed to reduced tree growth. However there is a positive and

significant (P= 0.001 and r2= 0.54) relationship between age of fallow and biomass

accumulated in general. The amount of biomass in the fields with 0-5 years of fallow is

four times less than the biomass in the fields with 11-20 years of fallow. On the other hand

the amount of biomass in the very old fields (30 yeras) is lower than the amount

accumulated from 11-20 years. The allometric equation was demonstrated to be robust, as

all showed the same trends in biomass variation within the same age. There is a change in

species composition in the regrowth fields compared with typical miombo that is

dominated by Brachystegia species, and Julbernardia globiflora. Nevertheless, three kinds

of species have been identified on the basis of the succession: (i) the early species, (ii) the

later successional species and the (iii) “ubiquitous” that are present throughout successions.

Page 3: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

3

Dedication

I dedicate this MSc thesis to my mother Honorina da Costa Xavier for all that she has done

to ensure that I could always proceed with my studies.

Page 4: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

4

AKNOWLEDGEMENTS

First of all I would like to thanks my sponsors Ms Torrence (passed away) appreciating her

kindness is leaving money to support studies related to forestry, and the European Union.

Both of them provided scholarship to support all the components of my studies.

Any research of this nature needs to be supervised and my supervisor Professor John Grace

and Co-supervisor Doctor Mathew William, were very important through their very useful

comments. I am particularly very impressed with the very friendly way that my supervisors

discussed any matter related to the dissertation with me, what make me fell free to express

all my ideas and doubts without any fear. Professor Grace was always ready to assist me

and give feedback on the report and also helpful in point out useful references. Doctor

Mathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were important to present my

results.

Mr Eduardo Ranguise, secretary of Nhambita Community, was a key person in my field

work. He identified the age and name of the owner of each fallow surveyed. It would have

been very difficult to meet the objectives of the study without his deep knowledge about

the area. Mrs Paulito also contributed in identifying trees by their local names.

I am also thankful to Piet van Zyl, the Project Manager in Nhambita, for providing project

staff to work with me in the field whenever necessary, the Chitengo project house in which

I stayed and also the provision of his personal vehicle to travel to and from Chitengo daily.

I extend my thanks to the Nhambita Community as a whole for allowing me to undertake

my study in their fields. At the beginning they were scared about their fields being taken

away from them, but they were more comfortable after I explained my objectives.

Page 5: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

5

Table of Contents

1. INTRODUCTION TO THE DISSERTATION STUDY ............................................. 1

1.1. Background................................................................................................................. 1

1.2. Agriculture System in Nhambita Community............................................................ 1

1.3. Need of the Study ....................................................................................................... 2

1.4. The Objectives of the Study ....................................................................................... 5

2. STUDY AREA DESCRIPTION .................................................................................... 6

2.1. Geographic Position of Nhambita .............................................................................. 6

2.2. Socio-economic Overview ......................................................................................... 7

2.3. Vegetation................................................................................................................... 8

3. FOREST AND CLIMATE CHANGE......................................................................... 11

3.1. The World’s Climate Change ................................................................................... 11

3.2. Impact of Climate Change on Forests ...................................................................... 14

3.3. The Kyoto Protocol and the Clean Development Mechanism ................................. 15

3.4. Forest Management Actions to Mitigating Climate Change .................................... 16

4. METHODOLOGY ........................................................................................................ 18

4.1. Data Collection ......................................................................................................... 18

4.2. Measurements........................................................................................................... 19

4.2.1. Diameter ............................................................................................................ 19

4.2.2. Height ................................................................................................................ 20

4.3. Calculations .............................................................................................................. 21

4.3.1. Species diversity ................................................................................................ 21

4.3.2. Basal area........................................................................................................... 22

4.3.3. Above-ground wood biomass............................................................................ 22

4.3.4. Carbon sequestered............................................................................................ 24

4.4. Data Analysis............................................................................................................ 25

Page 6: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

6

5. RESULTS....................................................................................................................... 26

5.1. Variation According to Fallow Age ......................................................................... 26

5.1.1. Tree density ....................................................................................................... 26

5.1.2. Species diversity ................................................................................................ 28

5.1.3. Basal area........................................................................................................... 29

5.2. Wood Plant Biomass ................................................................................................ 30

5.3. DBH and Height Relationship.................................................................................. 31

6. RESULTS DISCUSSION ............................................................................................. 33

6.1. Limitations of the Study ........................................................................................... 33

6.1.1. Chronosequences ............................................................................................... 33

6.1.2. The allometric equations ................................................................................... 35

6.2. The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth Miombo ..................................................... 36

6.2.1. Species diversity ................................................................................................ 36

6.2.2. Comparison of above-ground biomass with other studies ................................ 40

6.2.3. Soil organic matter and carbon.......................................................................... 41

6.3. Nutrient Fallow Dynamic ......................................................................................... 42

6.4. Potential of Agroforestry Systems for Carbon Sequestration .................................. 44

6.4.1. Improved fallow ................................................................................................ 45

6.4.2. Alley cropping ................................................................................................... 47

6.4.3. Improvement of nutrient cycle in the system .................................................... 48

6.4.4. Litter fall ............................................................................................................ 49

7. RECOMMENDATIONS .............................................................................................. 52

8. CONCLUSIONS............................................................................................................ 59

9. REFERENCES .............................................................................................................. 60

APPENDIXES.................................................................................................................... 71

Page 7: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

7

Table of Figures

Figure 1: Carbon cycle in the trees and forests .................................................................... 3

Figure 2: Nhambita Regulado in the buffer zone of the Gorongosa National Park .............. 6

Figure 3: Nhambita Primary School...................................................................................... 8

Figure 4: Central and Southern Africa countries with miombo woodland............................ 9

Figure 5: A layout of plots in the field. The circles have a radius of 10 m ......................... 19

Figure 6: Diameter measurement for a tree forking bellow 1.3 m DBH............................. 20

Figure 7: Measuring height using clinometer...................................................................... 21

Figure 8: Species diversity in regrowth miombo................................................................. 29

Figure 9: Biomass accumulated in different fallow ages .................................................... 30

Figure 10: Sqrt DBH and tree height relationship for all tree measured............................. 32

Figure 11: Dominant species in the 4th

year regrowth......................................................... 35

Figure 12: Biomass variation in the fields........................................................................... 36

Figure 13: The amount of tall grass..................................................................................... 38

Figure 14: 30 years regrowth miombo with grass ............................................................... 38

Figure 15: Biomass curves from different studies.............................................................. 40

Figure 16: Soil nitrogen in different fallow ages................................................................ 43

Figure 17: Soil carbon accumulate in different fallow ages................................................ 44

Figure 18: Nutrients uptake and inputs in agroforestry system........................................... 49

List of Tables

Table 1. Principal greenhouse gases.................................................................................... 12

Table 2: Global CO2 budgets from 1990-1999.................................................................... 14

Table 3. Wood biomass equations....................................................................................... 23

Table 4. Summary of observations in the different ages of fallow. .................................... 27

Table 5: Above-ground biomass in tree years of fallow in Zimbabwe ............................... 46

Table 6. Nutrient content (%) of pruning in agrofrestry...................................................... 50

Table 7. Some invasive species ........................................................................................... 54

Table 8. Species occurring in Nhambita that can be used in agroforestry .......................... 55

Page 8: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

1

1. INTRODUCTION TO THE DISSERTATION STUDY

1.1. Background

This is a baseline study for a carbon credit pilot project being implemented in Nhambita

Community in Mozambique. This project might later be nominated as a Clean

Development Mechanism (CDM) project of the Kyoto Protocol if it meets the necessary

requirements. A good estimation of carbon stock and carbon sequestration rate is essential

to any project of this type. The rate of carbon sequestration in live tree biomass before any

intervention that might contribute to carbon sequestration is essential for future

calculations of carbon credit. The study involved (i) literature review on different methods

to estimate the carbon stocks of miombo trees, (ii) design of a project to utilise

chronosequences to estimate the rate of carbon accumulated, and (iii) estimation of stock

and sequestration rates before intervention. Field work was undertaken in Mozambique in

the area where the project is being implemented.

1.2. Agriculture System in Nhambita Community

About 70% of the Mozambican population live in rural areas (INE, 1997) where

employment opportunities are limited. The people are largely dependent on forestry

resources and shifting agriculture for their livelihoods. Shifting agriculture is characterized

by a rotation between a short period of cropping and fallow periods. In this system of

cultivation, fields are cleared, burnt and cropped for a few years, and then they are

fallowed (Peters & Neuenschwander, 1988) for some years in order to recover from the

nutrient loss caused by agricultural exploitation.

Shifting cultivation has been practiced in the world for millennia and has supported people

all around the world. This agricultural system received increased attention from the global

community in recent years because it is damaging the environment as a consequence of the

increased pressure on arable land caused by population growth. Population pressure caused

Page 9: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

2

land scarcity, which in turn has brought about the shortening of the crucial fallow period

(Peters & Neuenschwander, 1988).

Most of the fields in Nhambita are around the homesteads. The agriculture system as in

any African rural area is basic slash and burn. There are no cases reported on the use of

fertiliser in Nhambita. Areas along Púngué River are considered as more fertile and can be

cultivated during 15 consecutive years, while areas around the homestead are cultivated for

a maximum of seven consecutive years. The main crops are maize, sorghum, millet,

groundnut, cassava, beans and pigeon pea. Firstly, maize and beans are planted in the same

hole, next sorghum or millet is planted in the same field three weeks later to avoid

competition as sorghum and millet grow faster than maize. Cassava and pigeon pea are

planted around the field. Some fruit trees are also planted in the field and other native

species are left in the field during the land preparation. Fallow lengths vary from 5-15

years, after that the area is cleared and burnt again ready for a new cropping period. Fields

in fallow are a source of fuelwood and making poles for construction.

Some trees such as Kigelia africana (Muvunguti), Albizia glaberrima (Tanga-tanga),

Lonchocarpus capassa (Phacassa) and Nsavu are left in the field when the area is first

opened. Farmers believe that these species do not have leaves which contain poison that

may otherwise drop into the crops during rainfall and poison the crop. In fact, what

happens is that these species have special crown architecture, not dense as the mango tree

for instance, and it is possible that this crown architecture does not allow crops to compete

with the tree for light. The leaves of these species are small and the throughfall does not

damage crops because each drop of water has a low mass.

1.3. Need of the Study

The relatively recent increases in atmospheric carbon dioxide concentration are a reflection

of an increase in the strength of sources of carbon. There are a number of major sources of

carbon dioxide, notably the combustion of fossil fuels, plant respiration, land use change,

and biomass burning (Houghton & Skole, 1990; Dale et al., 1991; IPCC, 2001b and

Page 10: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

3

Goreau, 1992). Of these sources, only the flux to the atmosphere from the combustion of

fossil fuels is known accurately (Tans et al., 1990 and Goreau, 1990). Greater uncertainty

is associated with the sinks of atmospheric carbon, especially in the tropics (Goreau, 1990).

Forest ecosystems cover about 30% of the Earth's land surface (Dale et al., 1991; Sedjo,

1993 and Solomon et al., 1993). As trees grow, they sequester carbon from the atmosphere

in their tissues, and as the amount of tree biomass increases within a forest or in forest

products the increase in atmospheric CO2 is mitigated (Figure 1) (IPCC, 1996 and

Fearnside, 1999). These ecosystems are often subjected to disturbance such as fires, insects

and diseases or are manipulated and harvested in order to provide a broad range of timber

and non-timber products (Oliver, 1981). Knowledge gaps about processes related to carbon

storage and release in space and time from terrestrial ecosystems hamper efforts to predict

accurately the effects of disturbance on the carbon cycle (Wisniewski & Sampson, 1993).

Figure 1: Carbon cycle in the trees and forests

Source: www.energex.com.au/ switched_on/energy_environ...

Page 11: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

4

Reforestation and afforestation results in a considerable increase in the conversion of

atmospheric carbon dioxide into biomass and so may be a significant sink of atmospheric

CO2 (Harmon et al., 1990). The role of the various major forest ecosystems in the carbon

cycle, particularly as carbon sinks which may be carefully managed to reduce the

atmospheric carbon loading, is therefore being assessed (Tans et al., 1990; Brown et al.,

1993; Dixon et al., 1993; Wofsy et al., 1993).

The ability of these plantations to sequester carbon has received more interest, since carbon

sequestration projects in developing nations could receive investments from companies and

governments wishing to offset their emissions of greenhouse gases through the Kyoto

Protocol’s Clean Development Mechanism (Fearnside, 1999).

A good estimate of carbon sequestration is essential to any project aimed to benefit from

carbon credit. The rate of carbon sequestration in live tree biomass for sale is computed by

finding the difference between the carbon stocks of a population of trees before and after

the land use change (Losi et al., 2003).

The current study attempts to estimates the existing amount of biomass and carbon

accumulated in fallow fields after slash and burn agriculture as well as the accumulation

rate in different stages of vegetation succession. Although some studies have been

conducted to assess how the vegetation responds after agriculture in terms of biomass in

Southern Africa, little has been done in Mozambique. This study is one of the first and will

contribute to the Nhambita Community Carbon Project being implemented in a

collaborative venture between the Nhambita Community Association, University of

Edinburgh, Gorongosa National Park, Edinburgh Centre for Carbon Management (ECCM)

and Envirotrade Limited, with grant funding from the European Union and DFID. The

study will provide base-line data on the rate of carbon accumulation above-ground after

agriculture and also contribute to the existing gap regarding the current amount of carbon

in the fields before any land use change intervention, against which the additionalities can

be assessed and carbon credits for the project determined.

Page 12: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

5

1.4. The Objectives of the Study

The main objective is to quantify the amount of biomass in the fields after agriculture, as

follows:

(i) to assess the amount of existing biomass and carbon stock in general, as well as in

different stages of vegetation succession following agriculture;

(ii) to verify whether there is a change in species composition after agriculture, compared

with the original vegetation; and

(iii) to assess all the factors interfering with the process of carbon sequestration, and to

suggest how they might be mitigated.

Page 13: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

6

2. STUDY AREA DESCRIPTION

2.1. Geographic Position of Nhambita

The Nhambita Regulado (traditional community authority) is situated within the

Gorongosa Administrative District of Sofala Province in central Mozambique . It covers an

area of approximately 20.000 hectares and has three administrative zones; Nhambita,

Mussinhawa, Nhanganha and a small region known as Boa Maria which was previously a

cotton production and export area (Figure 2).

Figure 2: Nhambita Regulado in the buffer zone of the Gorongosa National Park

The boundaries of the regulado are formed by the Gorongosa National Park, the Púnguè

River and the next Regulado to the west of Nhambita. The small rivers Lipise and

Nhambita run through the Regulado (Envirotrade, 2005).

When the National Park was formalised in the 1950’s and 60’s many communities living

within the park area were relocated to areas outside the park. Nhambita Regulado was one

of the relocation areas. It is situated within the southern ‘buffer zone’ of Gorongosa

Page 14: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

7

National Park. The buffer zone is a designated area that surrounds the entire park,

extending between 10 and 20 km in diameter (Envirotrade, 2005).

There are approximately 10.000 people living in the buffer zone. Communities and

individuals living in the buffer zone are subject to certain rules and regulations set out in

government laws that restrict resource utilisation. For example, hunting and gathering is

only allowed for subsistence purposes and certain species of trees are protected by law

(Envirotrade, 2005).

Compared with other communities, Nhambita is less densely populated. The 1997 census

recorded a population of 612 people from 102 family units. The return of displaced and

economic migrants has swelled this number in recent years to approximately 1.100

(Envirotrade, 2005). Settlement patterns in Nhambita are dispersed and there is no real

concentration of population, although in the area surrounding the tribal court of the Regulo

and Nhambita school the households are grouped together.

2.2. Socio-economic Overview

The community has no infrastructure, no water supply system, roads may be inaccessible

during the rainy season, there is no health centre available and the school is poorly

constructed with no service provision at all (Figure 3). The community is “poor” by any

definition.

Page 15: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

8

Figure 3: Nhambita Primary School

Opportunities for employment in the community are almost non-existent and research

carried out during the GERFRA study revealed high levels of poverty. Some of the

community members are employed by the carbon project, but farming is predominantly on

a subsistence basis and is limited by scarce resources, a lack of expertise and a

vulnerability to environmental factors such as drought and flooding. Farmers are isolated

from markets and the absence of transport hampers them in commercialising their produce.

The research indicates that illness in the area is linked to protein deficiencies and

malnutrition during periods of the year when food is scarce.

2.3. Vegetation

The area is covered with Miombo type forest. However, homesteads and machamaba’s

(slash and burn plots) have been cleared for housing and agricultural purposes. Muchove

(2003), formulated six-categories of woody vegetation in Nhambita Community Forest

namely (i) Miombo dominated by Brachystegia and Julbernardia; (ii) Miombo dominated

by Brachystegia and Julbernardia but with abundance of Diplorhynchus; (iii) Miombo

with significant dominance of Pterocarpus rotundifolius, Burkea africana, and

Page 16: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

9

Erythrophleum africanum; (iv) Combretum Woodland; (v) Riverine Woodland and (vi)

Combretum/Palm Woodland.

The dominance of the genera Brachystegia, Julbernardia and Isoberlinia (Fabaceae

family, subfamily Caesalpinioideae) makes miombo woodland floristically distinct from

most other African woodlands (Frost, 1996 and Chidumayo, 1997). It covers an estimated

area of 2.7 million km2 from Tanzania and Zaire in the north, through Zambia, Malawi and

eastern Angola, to Zimbabwe and Mozambique in the Southern Africa (Figure 4)

(Desanker et al., 1995).

Figure 4: Central and Southern Africa countries with miombo woodland

Miombo woodland is divided into dry and wet miombo. Dry miombo wodland occurs in

areas receiving less than 1.000 mm rainfall annually. It extends from southern Malawi,

Mozambique and Zimbabwe. Canopy height is less than 15 m and the vegetation is

floristically impoverished. Brachystegia spiciformis, B. boehmii and Julbernardia

globifloraa are the dominant deciduous species. Wet miombo woodland occurs from

eastern Angola, northern Zambia, south-western Tanzania and central Malawi in areas

Page 17: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

10

receiving more than 1.000 mm rainfall per year. Canopy height is more than 15 m and the

vegetation is floristically rich including nearly all characteristics miombo species.

Brachystegia floribunda, B. glaberrima, B. longifolia, B. wangermeeana, Julbernardia

paniculata, Isoberelina angolensis, and Marquesia macroura are widely distributed

(White, 1983).

The soils of the miombo landscape are poor and form a catenary sequence, with well-

drained and deeply weathered soils on the higher areas (often with lithosols on the ridge

crests in drier areas) giving way to a narrow zone of sandy soils along the footslopes and

then to imperfectly to poorly-drained vertisols in the dambo (Watson, 1964 and Webster,

1965).

Miombo ecosystems in Mozambique directly support the livelihoods of people living in

rural areas throughout the country. People living in towns and cities also depend on food,

fibre, fuelwood and charcoal produced in miombo (Chidumayo, 1997). Other natural and

anthropogenic processes, such as burning, clearance of land for cultivation, slash-and-burn

agriculture, the cultivation of wetlands and heavy grazing by livestock in dry areas,

contribute to vegetation cover changes. Such changes will have long-term socio-economic

and environmental consequences, including a decline in the availability of natural

resources in the woodlands, fewer inputs to sustain the fertility, reductions in grazing land

and a range of environmental impacts affecting ecological functioning, carbon storage,

trace gas emissions, hydrology and regional climate (Frost, 1996 and Chidumayo, 1997).

On a more positive note, about 9% of the miombo in the region is protected as national

parks, safari areas, and wildlife and forest reserves. Moreover, important advances have

been made towards developing community-based natural resource management

programmes, initially based on the sustainable use of wildlife but increasingly being

extended to woodland resources in general (Bradley & McNamara, 1993 and Dewees,

1994).

Page 18: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

11

3. FOREST AND CLIMATE CHANGE

3.1. The World’s Climate Change

Climate change is the long-term change in the climate as a consequence of the atmosphere

being altered by humankind's activity. Scientific evidence suggests that a rising

atmospheric carbon dioxide concentration is the main force driving the earth’s changing

climate (Petit et al., 1999) It is believed that anthropogenic activities, principally the

burning of fossil fuels, contribute significantly to this increase of atmospheric CO2 (IPCC,

2000 and FAO, 2004).

According to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) (2000), there has

been an unprecedented warming trend during the 20th century. The current average global

surface temperature of 15oC is nearly 0.6

oC higher than it was 100 years ago. The Earth's

climate is changing because the composition of our atmosphere is being altered, primarily

as a consequence of human activity. The world's population continues to grow at an

alarming rate with our numbers now exceeding six billion persons. Despite the fact that

most of the world's people still live in unacceptable levels of poverty, our wealth services

are improved and with it there is a corresponding increase in demand for natural resources,

energy, food, and goods to consume. In these processes, we discharge vast quantities of

gases and effluents that change the atmosphere composition and the capacity to regulate its

temperature.

Almost all greenhouse gases reached their highest recorded levels in the 1990s and

continue to increase. Atmospheric CO2 and CH4 have varied substantially during glacial-

interglacial cycles over the past 420.000 years, but these values are much less than their

current atmospheric concentrations. In terms of radiative forcing by greenhouse gases

emitted through human activity, CO2 and CH4 are the first and second most important,

respectively. The concentration of CO2 increased by 31 ± 4%, and that of CH4 rose by 151

± 25% since industrial revolution 250 year ago (Table 1). It is now widely accepted that

the burning of fossil fuels is the most important source of greenhouse gases. Fossil-fuel

Page 19: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

12

burning released on average 5.4 Gt C yr-1

during the 1980s, increasing to 6.3 Gt C yr-1

during the 1990s. After the burning of fossil fuels, the most important sources of

greenhouse gas emissions are activities related to land use, primarily tropical deforestation

and forest fires (UNEP, 2000 ).

Table 1. Principal greenhouse gases

Greenhouse

Gases

Importance

to Climate

Change

Trend in the

Atmosphere

Land Use Related

sources of

Greenhouse Gases

Carbon dioxide

(CO2)

Very high Increasing; +31%

in last 250 years

Mostly produced by deforestation

and forest fires

Methane (NH4) Moderate Increasing; +145%

in last 250 years

Generated by livestock waste, the

decomposition of wetlands, and

burning of biomass

Nitrous oxide

(N2O)

Moderate Increasing; +15%

in last 250 years

Caused by deforestation, burning of

other biomass, and application of

nitrogen fertilizer

Carbon

monoxide (CO)

Moderate Increasing Comes from the incomplete burning

of pasture and grasslands

Source: Modified from Ciesla, 1995

Currently, the CO2 emissions from human activity are estimated to be 7.5 billion tonnes of

carbon annually, of which 1.5 to 1.8 billion tonnes comes from forest-related sources.

Greenhouse gases from deforestation are mostly CO2 with lesser amounts of methane and

CO. This tropical deforestation is one of the most critical environmental problems facing

the developing countries today in terms of its long-term catastrophic impact on

biodiversity, economic opportunities, social problems, and contribution to global climate

Page 20: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

13

change. The socioeconomic impact of climate change in developing countries will be

significant. Rising temperatures and irregular precipitation patterns will impact negatively

on agricultural crop yields, food security, and health issues related to malnutrition (UNEP,

2000 and IPCC, 2001a).

Anon (1999), estimated that the annual rates of deforestation in developing countries

between 1980 and 1990 ranged from 13.7- 15.5 million hectares. With the clearing of

forests on such a massive scale and the burning of most of the wood associated with them,

there has been an enormous release of greenhouse gases into the atmosphere. The above-

ground biomass of tropical moist forests is often more than 175 tC ha-1

yr-1

. When cleared

and burnt, much of this carbon ends up in the atmosphere as carbon dioxide. Most of this

loss in forest cover is the result of land clearing for agricultural use that has lower carbon

sequestration potential (IPCC, 1996).

Some of the emissions of greenhouse gases are absorbed by "carbon sinks," the most

important of which are the oceans and forests. Forests sequester carbon from the

atmosphere as part of photosynthesis. However, because trees have a much longer lifetime,

they act as long -term reservoirs that lock up the carbon for decades, even centuries, in the

form of cellulose and lignin. The carbon that is not captured by the sinks accumulates in

the atmosphere. Table 2, illustrates the global carbon budget from 1990 to 1999.

Page 21: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

14

Table 2: Global CO2 budgets from 1990-1999. + values are fluxes

into the atmosphere, - values represent uptake from the atmosphere.

CO2 PgC yr-1

accumulated in the

atmosphere

Atmospheric increase 3.2 ± 0.1

Emissions (fossil fuel, cement) 6.3 ± 0.4

Ocean-atmosphere flux -1.7 ± 0.5

Land atmosphere flux -1.4 ± 0.7

Source: IPCC, 2001b

3.2. Impact of Climate Change on Forests

Although Grace et. al. (1995), concluded that undisturbed tropical rain forest act as a net

carbon sink, vegetation can act both as a source or a sink of carbon. It acts as a source

through respiration, burning and decay and as a sink of atmospheric carbon through

photosynthesis and plant growth. There is, however, a considerable variation in the balance

between vegetal sources and sinks of carbon at a range of spatial and temporal scales. At

the global scale, for instance, there is uncertainty over whether terrestrial vegetation may

be considered carbon source or sink based on an annual basis (Roughgarden et al., 1991;

Smith et al., 1993; Sampson et al., 1993).

Cox et al (2000), suggested that global warming (GW) could cause the biosphere to switch

from being a net sink to a net source of CO2. In his simulation, GW causes a large

reduction in rain fall over Amazonia, which causes a severe dieback of tropical rainforest

Page 22: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

15

by 2050. Combined with increased soil organic matter, this dieback releases CO2 back into

the atmosphere and further accelerates GW.

The forests of higher altitudes will be more affected than those in the tropical and

subtropical areas, but high altitude mountain forests in the tropics will also be at risk. Like

temperate and boreal forests, the tropical forests will undergo change as a consequence of

any shift in growing conditions. This would challenge the ability of many species to

survive, particularly on sites that are presently marginal for their growth. On the positive

side, warmer temperatures, more precipitation, and more CO2 will favour the growth and

expansion of some forests.

3.3. The Kyoto Protocol and the Clean Development Mechanism

The Kyoto Protocol of the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change

(UNFCCC) strengthens the international response to climate change. Adopted by

consensus in December 1997, it contains legally binding emissions targets for Annex I

(developed) countries for the post-2000 period. By arresting and reversing the upward

trend in greenhouse gas emissions that started in these countries 150 years ago. The

Protocol promises to move the international community one step closer to achieving the

Convention ultimate objective of preventing “dangerous anthropogenic interference with

the climate system” (Grubb et al., 1999).

The protocol identifies three possible flexible mechanisms for countries to meet emission

reduction targets: (i) joint implementation; (ii) a clean development mechanism (CDM);

and (iii) emission trading. The clean development mechanism (CDM) defined as a

flexibility mechanism established under the Kyoto Protocol is the protocol innovation as it

allows Annex 1 countries to receive emissions credits by implementing projects in non-

Annex 1 countries that reduce emissions. CDM would allow for carbon sequestration and

storage investments in reforestation, afforestation and in reducing deforestation to qualify

as emission reductions credits by the investing countries. The theory behind this

mechanism is that it does not matter where the emission reductions occur in the world for

Page 23: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

16

the global atmosphere to benefit (Grubb et al., 1999). For example, a French energy utility

could obtain emission reduction credits for France by establishing a tree plantation in

Zambia as a carbon sink. "Sink enhancement" interventions related to improving the

management of the existing forest resources are under consideration as part of CDM but

have not been agreed to as yet.

3.4. Forest Management Actions to Mitigating Climate Change

Oceans, soils and forests all offer some potential to be managed to promote net carbon

sequestration. The role of forests in carbon sequestration is probably best understood and

appears to offer the greatest near-term potential for human management as a sink. Forest

biomass accumulates carbon over decades and centuries. Furthermore, carbon

accumulation potential in forests is large enough that forests offer the possibility of

sequestering significant amounts of additional carbon in relatively short periods. However,

forest carbon can also be released quickly when the forest burns (Sedjo et al, 1998).

There are four components of carbon storage in a forest ecosystem. These are trees, plants

growing on the forest floor (understorey material), detritus such as leaf litter and other

decaying matter on the forest floor and forest soils. Carbon is sequestered in the process of

plant growth through photosynthesis. The carbon held captive in the forest stock increases

as the forest biomass grows. Over time branches, leaves and other materials fall to the

forest floor and may store carbon until they decompose. Additionally, forest soils may

sequester some of the decomposing plant litter through root-soil interactions (Sedjo et al,

1998).

Forest conservation for carbon sequestration purposes can be either direct or indirect.

Direct interventions essentially require the "locking up" of threatened land resources into

untouchable reserves. Indirect interventions comprise a far wider range of possibilities,

including increasing agricultural productivity (thus lowering the need for cyclical slash and

burn cropping), the development of agroforestry to meet fuelwood needs and increased

Page 24: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

17

agriculture productivity, the opening of markets for indigenous forest products and the

promotion of wood waste and paper recycling (Stuart & Costa, 1998).

Interventions that reduce ongoing rates of carbon emissions from forestry practices can

also be important. These include reduction in rates of deforestation, the introduction of

techniques for controlled logging and improved fire prevention. It is estimated that 15

million hectares of tropical forests are logged yearly throughout the world (Singh, 1993),

and the majority of logging operations in tropical countries are considered unsustainable

and damaging (Poore, 1989). Implementation of reduced impact logging techniques that

avoid unnecessary destruction of biomass and release of carbon have great potential as a

carbon offset technique (Marsh 1993).

The suppression of forest fires is another option to reduce unnecessary carbon emissions.

In the last decade for instance, fire outbreaks have destroyed millions of hectares of

rainforests in Kalimantan and Sumatra, and the incidence of forest fires is expected to

increase in the next decade (ITTO, 1994). In 1997, another massive series of fires began in

Indonesia, releasing hundreds of millions of tonnes of greenhouse gases. Along with the

crucial need to address the causes, a combination of ground-based practices of fire

prevention and control and available remote sensing monitoring systems (Malingreau et

al., 1989) have great potential for reducing the frequency and extent of forest fires.

Forestry can also be used to prevent carbon released by fossil fuels elsewhere. This can be

achieved through fuel or material substitution. Fuel wood can be used to replace fossil

fuels and wood-based materials could be used to replace materials that require high levels

of energy and/or fossil fuels for their production (e.g., steel, cement, plastics) (Stuart &

Costa, 1998).

Page 25: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

18

4. METHODOLOGY

4.1. Data Collection

Data were collected from fallows of different age ranges, varying from 0-5, 6-10, 10-20,

and 30 years of fallow. 30 years old fallow, include fields abandoned after independence in

1975 and, for this study, it has been assumed that their age is 30 years. The ages of the

fallow fields were identified by the key informant Mr Eduardo Ranguisse, the secretary of

the Nhambita community who has a good knowledge of the area.

The primary objective was to investigate carbon stocks of 28 fields in fallow including

seven fields for each age class, but according to the real situation during data collection it

was not possible to identify seven fields for the 10-20 years range of fallow. This is

because the age class coincides with the period of civil war, that lasted for 16 years in

Mozambique and which was very intensive in the Nhambita community. Almost all the

local people had moved to Gorongosa Village. Because of this, only four fields have been

measured in this age range. In order to compensate for the fact that there were not enough

fields available for the 10-20 years of fallow range, three fields have been added to the 30

years range giving this range a total of 10 surveyed fields.

All the above fields were randomly selected in order to provide the basis for computing a

valid estimate of the sampling error by justifying the assumption of independence of

sample units over the fields. This independence assumption is critical to the validity of any

parametric test of the null hypothesis and to computing standard errors (Quinn & Keough,

2002) of estimated age effect on biomass.

Each field was divided into four equal parts using a rope and then one circular plot of 10 m

radius was set randomly along the lines dividing the field (Figure 5). Overlapping plots

was avoided as well as the edge effect, to not influence the results. Each fallow field had

four plots with a total area of 1256 m2 of sampled plots in each field. The geographic

position point of each field was recorded from the centre of the field (the crossing point of

the ropes) and all trees have been identified by local name in the field and data recorded as

in Annex 1.

Page 26: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

19

Figure 5: A layout of plots in the field. The circles have a radius of 10 m, the fields have a

variable area, often about 1 ha.

4.2. Measurements

4.2.1. Diameter

Although the concept of giving values to the whole tree has been widely recommended,

wood remains a very important product of the tree. The diameter and girth are very

important factors in tree measurement because they are two of the variables used to

estimate tree volume and biomass, they give a high level of consistency, are easy to

measure and in irregular forests with different species and tree ages an histogram showing

the number of trees in different diameter classes is a useful way of characterizing the

structure of the forest (Philip, 1994).

Plot

4

Plot

3

Plot

1

Plot

2

Page 27: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

20

Trees with DBH less than 5 cm were ignored as their C-content is negligible. The

measurements were done using diameter tape, and the breast height was considered to be at

1.3 m from the soil level on the highest side of the tree (Philip, 1994 and MacDicken,

1997). On trees forking below 1.3 m from the ground level, each stem was measured and

recorded separately. Trees forking above 1.3 m were measured at breast height (Figure 6)

(Philip, 1994).

Figure 6: Diameter measurement for a tree forking bellow 1.3 m DBH

4.2.2. Height

The accuracy of height measurement is important since it is one of the tree variables used

to estimate tree volume. The total height of trees with up to 1.5 m of height was measured

directly using tape, while trees with more than 1.5 m of height were indirectly measured

using a clinometer (Figure 7) (Philip, 1994).

Page 28: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

21

Figure 7: Measuring height using clinometer

4.3. Calculations

4.3.1. Species diversity

Species diversity refers to species richness and evenness. Species richness refers to the

number of species in a vegetational community, which is usually characterized by a few

dominant species with numerous individuals and non-dominant species with very few

individuals, while evenness measures the distribution of individuals among the different

species in the community. Species density is the simplest measure of species diversity

(Equation 1) (Chidumayo,1997).

Page 29: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

22

area

NSSD = Equation (1)

Where

SD= species diversity (species/ha)

NS= number of species

4.3.2. Basal area

Basal area per tree is the cross-sectional area of a tree at breast height. It can be calculated

from diameter at breast height (Equation 2).

2

*2

rBA

π= Equation (2)

Where

BA= basal area (m2)

� = constant 3.142

r = radius

4.3.3. Above-ground wood biomass

To address many of the issues related to forest biomass requires that the biomass of all

forest components be estimated, including the above-ground and below-ground living mass

of trees, shrubs, palms, saplings, other understorey components, vines, epiphytes, etc., and

dead plant mass such as fine litter and wood. How the mass of these components changes

with time and with natural and antropogenic disturbances is also important. The biomass of

these components generally accounts for the greatest fraction of total living biomass in a

forest and does not pose too many logistical problems in its estimation. Consequently,

biomass is defined as the total amount of above-ground living organic matter in trees

Page 30: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

23

expressed as oven-dry tons per unit area (tree, hectare, region, or country). It is referred to

as biomass density when expressed as mass per unit area, e.g., tons per hectare (Brown,

1997).

In general, ecologists have been interested in developing statistical models to relate

satisfactorily the biomass to stem height and/or diameter. This involves destructive

sampling of a number of stems to determine the biomass (Philip, 1994). Models are based

on allometric equations that show the relationship between tree oven dried biomass and

tree diameter at breast height. This relationship is established by utilising the destructive

methods where trees are felled, divided into foliage, branches, stem wood and stem bark

and weighed fresh. Sub- samples are then oven dried and weighed (Chidumayo, 1997;

Ritson & Sochacki, 2003 and Specht & West, 2003).

The current study considered only above-ground biomass in different succession stage

after agriculture. Because of shortage of time, it was not possible to develop the equations

de novo to estimate the biomass for the present study. Instead, equations were obtained

from several published sources (Table 3).

Table 3. Wood biomass allometric relationships

Equations Source

Eq. 1 15716 −= DBHB (DBH > 11cm)

1.34.1 −= DBHB (DBH <11 cm)

(Chidumayo, 1997)

Eq. 2. 44.623.2 −= DBHB (DBH > 11cm)

84.18843.17 −= DBHB (DBH <11 cm)

(Chidumayo, 1997)

Eq. 3. ( )26589.00671.84703.34 DBHDBHB +−≡ (Brown et al, 1989)

Eq. 4. 35..1*0513.0 BAB ≡ House, J., pers. comm.

Page 31: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

24

Where:

B = predicted total or above-ground biomass (kg)

BA= basal area (cm2)

DBH = diameter (cm) at breast height (1.3 m)

Each of the above equations has been used to estimate the biomass of each tree, after

which the average of the four estimates was calculated per tree. The total amount of

biomass in each field was calculated by summing the biomass of each tree in the field and

then dividing by the total sampled area (1256 m2) (Equation 3).

10*)(

)(SA

MBBiomass

tree

field

�= Equation (3)

Where:

Biomass (field)= tons/ha

MB(tree)= mean biomass per tree (kg)

SA= total sampled area (m2)

4.3.4. Carbon sequestered

The biomass of forests provides estimates of the carbon pools in forest vegetation (Brown,

1997). A reasonable average for converting from dry biomass to carbon content is to

multiply dry biomass by 0.50. The range most cited of the proportion of C-content in the

dry mass is 0.43-0.58, hence it is suggested that 0.5 is the appropriate default assumption

(IPCC, 1996). The amount of existing carbon in the fields was estimated from above-

ground biomass based on the assumption that 50% of it represents carbon.

Page 32: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

25

4.4. Data Analysis

Statistical analysis (correlation analysis, regression and ANOVA) was done using

MINITAB. Model II regression- was used to establish the relationship between DBH and

tree height. This regression model gives the functional relationship between the variables,

but investigates should not attempt to use the resulting equation to predict values of Y

given X because this estimates is biased and give minimal-width confidence. In this case

Model I regression is appropriate (Sokal & Rohlf, 1995).

Page 33: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

26

5. RESULTS

5.1. Variation According to Fallow Age

5.1.1. Tree density

About 71 species were recorded during the study. All of them have been identified in the

field by local name and others have also been identified by their botanic name using (De

Koning, 1993; Van Wyk & Van Wyk, 1997 and Palgrave, 2002) (Appendix 2). Table 4

summarises the changes occurring during regrowth. Tree density in young regrowth fields

(0-5 years) is almost 3-5 times less than that found in 30 and 11-20 years of regrowth

fields respectively. This may be the result of fires since the fields accumulate huge

amounts of grass. Although it was suggested by Boaler& Sciewale (1966), that areas

abandoned after cultivation in miombo show a rapid regrowth because they receive a high

intensity of light that promotes regeneration, man-made dry season fires cause considerable

mortality and also thin out stem density in regrowth areas. About 4% and 40% of stems die

under early and late dry season fires respectively (Chidumayo, 1989).

An old grow forest tends to have low tree density because some trees are suppressed

during the succession process with the canopy closure. Tree density in 30 years fields in

this study was supposed to be higher or similar to the 11-20 year fields because the canopy

is open so it was not sufficient to have suppressed other trees. Results from Mushove

(2003), in Nhambita miombo forest, show that tree density in more than 20 years fallow

with little disturbance from fires is 805 stems/ha. The pressure from the community

combined with tree mortality (part of normal cycle of tree life) may have contributed to the

decrease of tree density in the 30 years fields.

Page 34: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

27

Table 4. Summary of observations in the different ages of fallow. The undisturbed

miombo woodland data are from Muchove (2003).

Fallow

age

(years)

Comments Basal

area

(m2/ha)

Mean

DBH

(cm)

Tree dens.

(stems/ha)

Biomass

(t/ha)

Species

diversity

(species/ha)

0-5

Tall grass with

scattered

regrowth trees

with mean

height 3.8 m.

0.06

8.4

202.5

5.1 ± 1.9 20.5

6-10

With tall grass,

and scattered

regrowth trees.

Mean height

3.9 m

0.04

7.1

720.0

6.1± 1.4 37.5

11-20

Large trees

with canopy,

sparse grass

and mean

height 5.4 m

0.08

9.5

1098.7

38.4 ± 12 60.7

30

Some large

trees with open

canopy,

considerable

short grass,

some dead

trees on the

ground, mean

height 6.3 m

0.12

12.2

574.0

31.9 ± 2.6

39.8

Old

grow

“undisturbed”

miombo

woodland

121.1 ±

13.1

Fallow fields supply different products such as fuel wood and poles for construction to the

community in Nhambita. All the fields with 30 years are around the community and people

use them to extract those products while all the 19 years fields that contributed to high tree

density in 11-20 age class are far from the community, approximately 1 hour’s walk. It is

likely that trees have been cut from most of the 30 years fallow for population settlement in

Page 35: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

28

1992 after the peace agreement. Chidumayo (2002), found a significant reduction of tree

density as a result of poles harvested during the settlement. Mushove (2003), attributed

timber extraction for construction, agriculture, charcoal production and commercial timber

logging as the main factors contributing to low tree density in Nhambita forest.

5.1.2. Species diversity

Species diversity is related to succession. The early stages of succession are traditionally

supposed to have low species diversity because they are dominated by species that tolerate

adverse conditions. However, as the soil condition improves, the early species are replaced

by later species (Frost, 1996). In 30 years fields the species diversity decreased to 39.8

species/ha from 60.7 in 11- 20 years fields. This may be related to fire occurrence in the

area as these fields have a considerable amount of grass and are close to the homesteads.

In general, there is a change in species composition in these regrowth fields compared with

typical miombo which is dominated by Brachystegia species and Julbernardia globiflora

that was not found in any of the sampled fields. Tree species dominance differ from one

stage of succession to another, so that species that are dominant from 0-5 years are

different from those that dominate other age classes (Figure 8). However, Acacia

nigrescens (mugoe), Lannea schweinfurthii (bzototo) and Sclerocarya birrea (mfula) can

be considered as early species, while chimanda, Vitex sp. (mucubvusetche) and guaquacho

are the later succession species. Piliostigma thonningii (mucequesse), Lonchocarpus

capassa (pacassa) and Annona senegalensis (mulolo) are “ubiquitous” because they occur

throughout successions.

Page 36: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

29

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

Muc

eque

sse

Pacas

sa

Mul

olo

Mfu

la

Bzoto

to

Tanga

tang

a

Bican

khul

aM

fiti

Man

gueira

Mug

oe

Mas

saniq

ueira

Mul

onde

Mul

unga

munh

u

Chi

man

da

Muc

uvuse

tche

Gua

quac

ho

Local name of the species

To

tal n

um

be

r o

f tr

ee

s p

er

sp

ec

ies

0-5 years

6-10 years

11-20 years

>30 years

Figure 8: Species diversity in regrowth miombo

5.1.3. Basal area

The global average of total basal area is 0.08 m2/ha with an annual increment of 0.003

m2/ha. Basal area has a different trend from biomass and tree density. It first decreases

from 0-5 to 6-10 years fallow and then increases continuously. This is because basal area

is only correlated to DBH (from equation 2 in the methodology) and not correlated to tree

density (P= 0.824 , r2= 0.002) (Appendix 3), while biomass is both correlated to DBH

through the equations and also to tree density (P= 0.004 , r2= 0.5 ) (Appendix 4).

Page 37: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

30

5.2. Wood Plant Biomass

Biomass is defined as the total amount of aboveground living organic matter in trees

expressed as oven-dry tons per unit area (Brown, 1997). We may assume that 50% of it is

aboveground carbon. The global average of total above-ground biomass is 19.6 t ha-1

with

an accumulation rate of 1.1 t ha-1

yr-1

. Regression analysis showed that the amount of

biomass accumulated in the fields is significantly (P= 0.001 and r2= 0.54) (Appendix 5)

related to the age of the fallow (Figure 9). The total amount of biomass in old grow forest

“unisturbed” in the same area is 121.1 ± 13.1 (Muchove, 2003). This is very high when

compared with the total biomass of the current study.

y = 1.102x + 2.1149

R2 = 0.5389

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35

Years after clear felling miombo

Bio

mass a

ccum

ula

ted (t/ha)

Figure 9: Biomass accumulated in different fallow ages

It is noticeable by analysing the amount of biomass accumulated in each field (Appendix

6) that some fields from the same age differ in terms of biomass especially in one of the 2

years field. This is because the field contains fruit trees which are protected during the

clearance of the area for agriculture. Some of these fruit trees such as Ziziphus mucronata

Page 38: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

31

(massaniqueira) are native and others that include Carica papaya (paw-paw), Mangifera

indica (mango) are exotics.

About 75% of the biomass of the 2 years old fallow with a total of 2.1 t ha-1

of biomass

corresponds to mango trees, paw-paw trees represent about 80% of the biomass in the 4

years old fallow. These values could be different for these fields if specific equations to

estimate biomass have been used. It is likely that paw-paw trees have lower biomass than

mango trees and any other miombo tree because the stem is not hard.

ANOVA analysis showed significant differences (P= 0.001, r2= 0.434; Appendix 7) in the

amount of both biomass and carbon accumulated in each age class. The amount of biomass

in the fields from 0-5 years old is four times less than the biomass in the fields that vary

from 11-20 years. On the other hand the amount of biomass in the old fields (30 years) is

lower than the amount accumulated from 11-20 years (Table 4).

5.3. DBH and Height Relationship

Diameter at breast height (DBH) and tree height are important tree characteristics which

are necessary to measure in forest inventory studies. DBH is a variable for which

measurement is easy, while measurement of height is more difficult and time consuming

than that of DBH. However, there is a close relationship between these two parameters

(Avsar, 2004). Model II regression shows a strong relationship between these two variables

(P-Value = 0.001, r2= 55.9; Figure 10). The regression line equation is

dbhH 543.3392.5 +−= .

Page 39: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

32

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

sqrt dbh (cm)

Heig

ht

(m)

Figure 10: Sqrt DBH and tree height relationship for all tree measured

Page 40: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

33

6. RESULTS DISCUSSION

6.1. Limitations of the Study

6.1.1. Chronosequences

It is always important to realise that chronosequenses can be interpreted as units of

successional change only when the parent material and management are the same in all

parts of the sampled range. In this study, as in others, this is likely to have been some

variations especially in the management.

When cultivated land is abandoned its vegetation passes through several secondary

successions, but rarely reaches the climax before the land is cleared again. Weeds,

including grasses, which are usually short-lived, dominate the first phase of succession.

Shrubs may dominate the next phase, but dominance often passes from herbaceous plants

to trees (Nye & Greenland, 1960).

The early stages of succession in moist semi-deciduous forest are characterised by trees,

shrubs, herbs and climbers with a greater variety of floristic composition, while in dry

deciduous forest the secondary vegetation consists of a mass of coppice shoots. Woodland

is another deflected climax in dry deciduous forest and consists of small or medium sized

trees forming a close canopy (Nye & Greenland, 1960).

The dynamics of miombo woodlands have been interpreted largely in terms of a single-

state equilibrium model of succession to regional climax vegetation characterised by dense

woodland in drier regions and semi-evergreen or evergreen forest in wetter areas.

Nevertheless, fire and disturbance by people or wildlife are the processes reversing this

trend (Freson et al., 1974; Strang 1974 and Lawton 1978). For example, Freson et al.

(1974), propose a three-stage regressive series (dense, dry forest-open miombo and

woodland-savanna) induced by the combination of wood cutting and fire. The view that

miombo is a sub-climax formation arises partly from observations of miombo juxtaposed

Page 41: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

34

with patches of evergreen forest where topography and soils seem superficially to be the

same. White (1983), however notes that where evergreen forest occurs alongside wet

miombo there is a transition to deeper soils, suggesting an edaphic control.

It is likely that under the conditions of the study area the succession climax will be

woodland savanna in the regrowth areas after agriculture. The study showed high biomass

variation in some cases. Appendix 6 shows a 19 years fallow with 61.6 t ha-1

. This may be

related to the variation in terms of soil fertility and anthropogenic pressure to resources.

Miombo regrowth usually does not change in terms of species composition from cleared

vegetation, because regeneration consists of stumps or rootstock, shoots and recruitment

from old stunted seedlings already present in the grass layer at the time of cutting. The

sapling population in regrowth may consist of one-third coppiced stumps and two-thirds

seedling recruitment after one year of regrowth (Chidumayo, 1997). Nevertheless, the

proportion of sapling from seedling recruitment may be low in regrowth after agriculture

because seedlings are removed during land preparation for crop cultivation. In this case,

seedling establishment depends on soil seed bank and seed dispersion from the surrounding

trees (Peters & Neuenschwander, 1988).

Regrowth in miombo is significantly affected by the vegetation before felling. Chidumayo

(1997), reported that a pre-felling stand and seedling pool in dry miombo was dominated

by Julbernardia globifloraa, and the species continued to dominate the early succession in

regrowth (Figure 11).

Page 42: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

35

Figure 11: Dominant species in the 4th

year regrowth

6.1.2. The allometric equations

Allometric relationships can be useful if a single equation is applicable for more than one

species. The use of a combination of regression lines is common for savanna areas where

little information is available and also in the similarity between species (House, J. pers.

comm.). Figure 12 shows the different results given by each equation used in this study.

Although the equations used are from different sources with different peculiarities (like the

change of the equation for specific DBH size), they are very robust and consistent because

the graphed lines have the same pattern over the age sequences.

Page 43: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

36

0.0

10.0

20.0

30.0

40.0

50.0

60.0

70.0

80.0

90.0

2 3 5 6 9 19 30 30 30 30

Fallow age (years)

Bio

mass a

ccu

mu

late

d (

t/h

a)

BiomassEqu. 1

BiomassEqu. 3

BiomassEqu. 4

BiomassEqu. 2

Figure 12: Biomass variation in the fields, estimated with the four different allometric

equations used separately.

6.2. The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth Miombo

6.2.1. Species diversity

Fire is a major problem in the management of natural regeneration of savanna woodland in

tropical Africa (Trapnel, 1959 and Whitlow, 1987). Complete fire protection is often

impractical in settled areas and increases the risk of more destructive accidental fires due to

accumulation of ground fuels.

Dry season fires are a regular and frequent feature of miombo ecosystems (Trapnell, 1959),

occurring at most sites 1-3 times in yearly intervals. Miombo woodland probably

constitutes the single largest area burnt in the world, around 1 million km2

of area burnt

every year (Scholes et al., 1996a). Fire-return intervals depend on fuel accumulation rates

both at the site and in the surrounding vegetation and on the proximity to potential sources

of ignition.

Page 44: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

37

Fires in the miombo region are an important source of trace gas emissions, methane,

carbon monoxide and nitrous oxide (Andreae et al., 1996 and Scholes et al., 1996b). Most

fires probably originate accidentally from people preparing land for cultivation, collecting

honey, or making charcoal (Chidumayo, 1997). Deliberate burning is done by hunters and

livestock owners to provide a green flush that attracts the animals. Fire is also used to clear

areas around homesteads and alongside paths between settlements. Fires in miombo are

fuelled largely by grass and fine woody material, and their impact on plants depends on

their intensity and timing in relation to plant phrenology.

Late dry season fires are more intense and destructive than fires occurring in the early dry

season when fuel moisture contents are relatively high and ambient temperatures and

windspeeds are low. Fuel load is largely a function of time since the last fire, the previous

rainfall season (which determines grass production), the amount of grazing and the extent

of woody plant cover. Fires tend to be more frequent and intense in areas of low woodland

cover and high mean annual rainfall, where grass production is high but where grass

quality and therefore grazing pressure is low (Ward et al., 1996).

Four functional groups of miombo plants are recognized in relation to their degree of

tolerance to fire (Trapnell, 1959 and Lawton 1978): (i) fire-intolerant, such as the forest

species; (ii) fire-tender (including most of the dominant canopy species when young);

(iii) semi-tolerant and (iv) fire-tolerant species. Changes in fire frequency therefore change

vegetation structure and composition. Frequent late dry season fires eventually transform

woodland into open, tall grass savanna with only isolated fire-tolerant canopy trees and

scattered understorey trees and shrubs. Almost all the surveyed fields in this study showed

a significant amount of tall grass especially the young fallow. Figure 13, shows the amount

of grass available in the 10 and 6 years fallow. Grass can contribute to frequent fires

allowing the regrowth of fire tolerant species.

Page 45: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

38

Figure 13: The amount of tall grass available in 10 and 6 years of regrowth respectively

Figure 14 gives an idea of 30 years regrowth. It shows that the area experiences frequent

fires because the tree canopy is not closed and grass growth is not suppressed as expected

under non frequent fires. A period without fire could lead to gradual tree canopy closure,

the suppression of grass growth, and lower fuel loads. Lower fuel loads mean less intense

fires, less damage to woody plants, uninterrupted woody regrowth and continued canopy

closure (Trapnell, 1959 and Lawton, 1978).

Figure 14: 30 years regrowth miombo with grass growing understorey, open canopy and a

completely dead tree killed by fire respectively

Page 46: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

39

The dominant trend in regenerating miombo in the absence of frequent hot fires or other

intense disturbances is therefore towards the development of woodland (Strang, 1974). The

original trees are difficult to eradicate because most of the woody plants resprout

vigorously from surviving stems and rootstocks. Seeds of Brachystegia, Julbernardia and

most other Caesalpinioideae have low dispersability and longevity so that, where the trees

are eliminated, recovery to the original state will be slow. This might be the reason why

Brachystegia and Julbernardia species were not found in any surveyed field. Constant

fires may have killed the seeds available in the soil and also eliminated the resprout.

More recently, there have been attempts to describe miombo dynamics in terms of multi-

state models in which, following abandonment of cultivated fields, or the combined

impacts of elephants and fire, there is a transition either to open woodland dominated by

Combretum spp. or to grassland (Stromgaard, 1986 and Starfield et al., 1993). Fire is

considered to be the driving force behind the transitions. A longer than normal fire-free

period is needed to return the vegetation to Brachystegia-dominated woodland.

Few studies of vegetation change in miombo have followed changes at a site over time.

Most interpretations have been based instead on contemporaneous studies of vegetation at

a number of sites presumed to differ only in fire regime (Trapnell, 1959; Lawton 1978 and

Chidumayo, 1988) or since abandonment of cultivation (Stromgaard, 1986). Short-term

studies in any event are unlikely to produce many insights, given that most of the tree

species, including all the canopy dominants, are relatively long-lived (lifetime 60-120

years). Simulation models of plant community dynamics supported by long-term

monitoring of vegetation changes at a range of sites will be needed to predict vegetation

change under existing and changed conditions.

Page 47: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

40

6.2.2. Comparison of above-ground biomass with other studies

I compared the results obtained from Frost (1996) and Chidumayo (1997), with those of

the current study (Figure 15). It can be seen that the biomass accumulation rate of Frost is

higher (2 t ha-1

yr-1

) than others, followed by the results from Chidumayo study (1.86 t ha-1

yr-1

). Nevertheless, Stromgaard (1985), found a wood biomass accumulation rate of 0.99 t

ha-1

yr-1

in 16 years old coppiced miombo woodland in northern Zambia, which is slightly

lower than the rate found in the present study (1.1 t ha-1

yr-1

). The results of this study

might have been affected by the fact that fields burnt almost every year and each burn

reduces the carbon stock significantly. Frequent burn might also have contributed to a low

soil fertility in the fields and reduced the capacity of the trees to regrow.

y = 2.0122x + 2.4076

y = 1.8608x - 3.6309

y = 1.102x + 2.1149

-20

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

0 10 20 30 40 50 60

Years after clear felling dry miombo

Bio

mass a

ccu

mu

late

d (

t/h

a)

Frost

Sambane

Chidumayo

Linear (Frost)

Linear (Chidumayo)

Linear (Sambane)

Figure 15: Biomass curves from different studies. In the case of Frost (1996), for clarity I

have selected only a sample of his many plots.

Overall mean annual increment in woody biomass in regrowth miombo woodland aged

from 2-30 years (age covered in this study) is 1.1 t ha-1

yr-1

and the carbon accumulation

rate may be estimated as 0.55 tC ha-1

yr-1

. This accumulation rate is low compared with

Chidumayo (1990), in his study of biomass in Zambia where he got an accumulation rate

of 1.97 t ha-1

yr-1

in coppiced regrowth in the age range 3-29 years. However, although

there was poor regression of mean annual increment in general in the current study, the

Page 48: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

41

accumulation rate appeared to increase from 0.18 t ha-1

yr-1

in regrowth aged 0-5 years to

2.74 t ha-1

yr-1

in regrowth aged 11-20 years. Chidumayo also got an increase in the rate of

biomass accumulated with the age increment in the study mentioned above, although his

values are higher than those from this study.

The average wood annual increment in wet miombo is 2.7 t ha-1

yr-1

, while in dry miombo

is 1.9 t ha-1

yr-1

(Chidumayo, 1997). The mean annual increment (MAI) in wood biomass

during early stages of regrowth in miombo woodland is affected by fire. The MAI of 0.60 t

ha-1

yr-1

under early burning regimes was significantly higher than that of 0.22 t ha-1

yr-1

under imposed late dry-season fire regimes in plots aged 3-6 years (Chidumayo, 1988).

According to Chidumayo (1997), there is positive correlation between age and wood

annual increment in regrowth miombo during the first 10 years. However, it is expected

that old growth trees will allocate more biomass in leaf production and grow slowly in

diameter. Frost (1996), also suggested that miombo growth curves tended to level off after

30 years. It was not possible to distiguish clearly that level off in this study, probably

because of the uncertainty in the age identification as all these fields have been reported

before independence (1975) and assumed as 30 years old.

6.2.3. Soil organic matter and carbon

Nutrient availability in the soil is a determinant for plant growth because the roots absorb

nutrients from it. Burning oxidizes organically bound elements in vegetation and litter and

releases them in forms available to plants. The intensity and duration of a fire, the amount

of material which is consumed and its nutrient content, all determine the quantities of

nutrients released. Some of the elements, mainly nitrogen, carbon and sulphur, are

volatilized and may be lost to the atmosphere (Frost & Robertson, 1985 and FAO, 2004).

The loss of nutrients through volatilization and export in ash during savanna fires has

seldom been measured satisfactorily. Given the amount of organic matter that is burnt,

considerable losses might be expected. However, in the first years of fallow there are huge

Page 49: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

42

amounts of grass available and some new seedlings and resprout, tree litter is almost

nonexistent (Kellman et al., 1985). Charcoal is extremely resistant to decomposition

consequently, in severely degraded soils that have been affected by several fires, it can

form a substantial proportion of the remaining organic carbon (FAO, 2004).

Regular fires are one of the characteristic features of tropical savannas (Chidumayo, 1997).

Lower levels of organic carbon have been measured in the surface soils of annually burnt

plots (Brookman-Amissah et al., 1980) and in plots burnt during the late dry season

compared with early-burn and unburnt areas (Frost & Robertson, 1985 and Oguntala,

1980). In these latter experiments, the levels of soil carbon were higher in the early-burn

than in the unburnt plots. Higher levels of soil carbon have also been recorded in annual,

biennial and triennial-burn plots than in unburnt plots or plots burnt only every 4 or 5

years. In other studies, the differences in soil organic matter levels between treatments

have not been significant (Cook, 1939; Harrington, 1974; Harrington & Ross, 1974 and

Griffin & Friedel, 1984), even between unburnt plots and those burnt annually for 23 years

(Trapnell et al., 1976).

6.3. Nutrient Fallow Dynamic

N, P, and Ca are often the most limiting to plant growth in the tropics (Vitousek, 1984 and

Lathwell & Grove, 1986). During the first year of traditional fallows with natural

regeneration of secondary vegetation ecosystem, stocks of N normally do not increase, and

they can decrease by as much as 7% (< 500 kg N ha–1

). Apparent losses of ecosystem P

stocks during the first year of fallow are associated with losses of SOM, and they range up

to 33% (about 8 kg P ha–1

) of the extractable inorganic soil P at crop abandonment (Kyuma

& Pairintra, 1983).

Losses of ecosystem Ca stocks during early stages of fallows are proportionally greater and

more prolonged than losses of N and P. Net losses of Ca during the first 2 to 4 years of

fallow range from 140 to 590 kg Ca ha–1

, or 20% to 70% of ecosystem Ca present initially

(Wadsworth et al., 1990). Losses can occur by de-nitrification, erosion and runoff when

Page 50: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

43

soil cover is incomplete. However, net increases in ecosystem stocks of N, P, and Ca are

often observed in older fallows as a result of atmospheric additions, mineral weathering

and nutrient retrieval from the subsoil (Szott et al., 1991).

Soil analyses from the same plots as where the above-ground biomass have been measured

show that there is no N recovery as the fallow age increases. However, carbon shows a

small increase in the chronosequence (Fernando, J. pers. comm.)( Figure 16 and 17). This

suggests that the soils are very poor and might have limited the above-ground growth.

y = -0.0033x + 0.1349

R2 = 0.148

0

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

0.25

0.3

0 5 10 15 20 25 30

Fied age (years)

%N

Figure 16: Soil nitrogen in different fallow ages (Fernando 2005, pers. comm.)

Page 51: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

44

y = 0.0724x + 6.8495

R2 = 0.0735

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

0 5 10 15 20 25 30

Field ages (years)

t C

/ ha

Figure 17: Soil carbon accumulate in different fallow ages (Fernando 2005, pers. comm.)

6.4. Potential of Agroforestry Systems for Carbon Sequestration

Agroforestry is important as a carbon sequestration strategy because of the carbon storage

potential both above and below-ground as well as its applicability in agricultural lands and

in reforestation. The amount of carbon sequestered largely depends on the agroforestry

system put in place and the structure and function that are to a great extent determined by

environmental and socio-economic factors. Other factors influencing carbon storage in

agroforestry systems include tree species and system management (Albrecht & Kandji,

2003).

Agroforestry systems are one of the activities identified with potential to mitigate climate

change because of:

• the potential to direct near-term carbon storage (centuries to decades) in trees and

soils;

• the potential to offset immediate GHG emissions associated with deforestation and

subsequent shifting agriculture; and

Page 52: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

45

• provide other services such as helping to attain food security and secure land tenure

in developing countries, increasing farm income, restoring and maintaining above-

ground and below-ground biodiversity, corridors between protected areas, carbon

sinks, maintaining watershed hydrology and soil conservation. Agroforestry also

mitigates the demand for wood and reduces pressure on natural forests (Pandey,

2002 and Montagnini & Nair, 2004).

The average carbon storage by agroforestry practices has been estimated as 9, 21, 50, and

63 tC ha-1

in semiarid, sub-humid, humid, and temperate regions respectively. For

smallholder agroforestry systems in the tropics, potential carbon sequestration rates range

from 1.5 to 3.5 tC ha-1

yr-1

with a tripling of carbon stocks in a twenty-year period to 70 tC

ha-1

. Agroforestry can also have an indirect effect on carbon sequestration when it helps

decrease pressure on natural forests, which are the largest sink of terrestrial carbon.

Another indirect value of carbon sequestration is through the use of agroforestry

technologies for soil conservation, which could enhance carbon storage in trees and soils in

the natural forest (Montagnini & Nair, 2004).

For example, carbon sequestration in India by agroforestry varies from 19.6 - 47.4 tC ha-1

yr-1

while in China it varies from 6–15 tC ha-1

. Cacao agroforestry in humid parts of west

and central Africa holds up to 62% of the carbon stocks found in primary forests. Forms of

agroforestry systems that include live fences, coffee with shade trees plantations and

improved fallows in Mexico have a carbon sequestration potential varying from 17.6 to

176.3 tC ha-1

( Pandey, 2002).

6.4.1. Improved fallow

Improved fallow is a rotational system that uses one or mixed preferred tree species as the

fallow species instead of natural vegetation (Nair, 1993). Two categories of improved

fallow can be distinguished: (i) the short-duration fallows with fast growing leguminous

trees or shrubs seeking to replenish soil fertility; and (ii) the medium-to-long-duration

Page 53: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

46

fallows with diverse species aiming to rehabilitate degraded and abandoned lands as well

as exploit tree products such as poles and firewood (Albrecht & Kandji, 2003).

Biomass production in planted fallows depends on several factors including environmental

conditions, soil type, magnitude of land degradation and the length of the fallow period.

Leucaena leucocephala showed a biomass increase from 4 t ha-1

in the first year to 64 t ha-1

in the sixth year of fallow in the Philippines. Carbon in the understorey, soils and woody

debris was estimated at 25% of the above-ground carbon. Overall, average carbon storage

was estimated to be 16 t ha-1

over a 6-year period (Albrecht & Kandji, 2003). Studies from

Costa Rica have shown that a 10 years old system with E. poeppigiana sequestered carbon

at a rate of 0.4 tC ha-1

yr-1

in coarse roots and 0.3 tC ha-1

yr-1

in the stem (Oelbermann et

al., 2004).

Studies in Zimbabwe showed a significant interaction between fallow species and duration

in total above-ground biomass and its components (Table 5). For 3 years fallows,

pigeonpea produced the highest total above-ground biomass, which was significantly

different from acacia and sesbania. For 2 year fallows, total above-ground biomass

followed the order acacia > pigeonpea > sesbania. However, for 1 year fallows the total

biomass followed the order sesbania > acacia = pigeonpea. (Mafongoya & Dzowela, 1999).

Table 5: Above-ground biomass in tree years of fallow in Zimbabwe

SED = standard error of the difference in means.

Source: Mafongoya & Dzowela, 1999

Page 54: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

47

The amount of biomass accumulated under improved fallow is high compared with normal

fallow in the current study because:

• tree density is determined at the beginning while in normal fallow it is very low in

the early stages, tending to increase slowly;

• the trees are usually exotic and fast growing, belonging to the Fabaceae family and

are adaptable to any environment while in normal fallow the trees are native and

grow slowly; and

• Fabaceae species are able to fix nitrogen and therefore improve soil fertility.

6.4.2. Alley cropping

Alley cropping refers to agroforestry systems that consist of growing crops in large alleys

delimited by growing trees. In the tropics, no distinction is usually made between hedged

intercropping and alley cropping. Initially developed to restore the fertility of degraded

soils in the humid and sub-humid tropics, alley cropping was later adopted in other regions

not only to ameliorate soils, but also to provide other products and services (e.g. erosion

control and fodder) (Albrecht & Kandji, 2003).

There have been mixed results from alley cropping experiments in various parts of the

world. Analysis of biomass production from published literature shows strong variations

from 1–37 t ha-1

depending on climate, soil type and system management. However,

aboveground carbon storage is only temporary in alley cropping systems since the biomass

is continuously harvested for green manure, fodder and firewood (Albrecht & Kandji,

2003).

In many areas of the tropics, regular addition of pruning and root turnover have contributed

to the build up of SOM and nutrient stocks in the soil over the years (Nair, 1993). In a 12

years alley cropping trial in Nigeria, Gliricidia sepium and Leucaena leucocephala

increased surface SOC by 15% (2.38 tC ha-1

) compared to single crops. A 12% increase in

Page 55: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

48

SOC (0.23 tC ha-1

) has also been observed after 5 years of alley cropping with Inga edulis

in Peru. SOC in the 0-15 cm layer of alley cropping using L. leucocephala showed carbon

storage of 6-10 tC ha-1

after 5 years (Albrecht & Kandji, 2003). In Costa Rica, the addition

of pruning contributed to 1.4 tC ha-1

yr-1

in addition to 3.0 tC ha-1

yr-1

from crop residues,

resulting in an annual increase of the SOC pool by 0.6 t ha-1

yr-1

(Oelbermann et al., 2004).

6.4.3. Improvement of nutrient cycle in the system

Tree growth is a combination of nutrient uptake from the soil and atmosphere.

Agroforestry systems provide an opportunity for modifying the nutrient cycle through

management which results in a more efficient use of soil nutrients, whether added

externally as fertilizers or made available through natural processes (e.g. watering), when

compared with agriculture systems. Figure 18 shows clearly the advantages of agroforestry

compared with agriculture systems in terms of different sources of nutrient inputs such as

litter fall and pruning that offset the nutrient uptake by crop. Nutrient leaching and loss

from the system is low because they can be absorbed by trees during no crop season (Nair,

1993).

Page 56: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

49

Figure 18: Nutrients uptake and inputs in agroforestry system

Various processes link the different compartments in the system by transferring nutrients

between them. Nutrient fluxes include: input from precipitation and interception, fertilizer

addition and atmospheric fixation; outputs by leaching, harvesting, fire, denitrification;

nutrient release and retention in soil through mineralization, immobilization, cation

exchange and anion retention, mineral dissolution and retention; uptake by plants; and

litterfall (Khanna, 1998).

6.4.4. Litter fall

Plant litter that is high in nutrients, especially nitrogen, which decomposes rapidly is

considered to be of high quality and benefits the crop, whereas woody residues and other

lignified materials are most resistant to decomposition and therefore considered low

quality and cause nitrogen deficiency for the crop (Nair, 1993 and Mafongoya et al., 1998).

Page 57: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

50

Materials that are high in nitrogen, and thus have low carbon to nitrogen (C:N) ratios

decompose rapidly and release relatively large quantities of nitrogen. On the other hand,

material with high C:N ratio provide carbon as a source of energy to microbes. The

microbes subsequently multiply rapidly and draw upon nitrogen reserves from the soil.

Because the added material is very low in nitrogen this causes a temporary unavailability

of nitrogen for the plants. When the carbon source is depleted, the microbial population

declines and the nitrogen that had been temporarily incorporated in microbial tissues would

once again be released to the soil and be available for plant uptake (Nair, 1993).

Pruning that consists mostly of leaf and some woody material of the woody perennials

used in agroforestry system, especially alley cropping, are generally high in nitrogen

(Table 6). This pruning will result in increasing available nitrogen levels in the soil for the

associated crops.

Table 6. Nutrient content (%) of pruning in agrofrestry

Tree species N P K Ca

Alchornea cordifolia 3.29 0.23 1.74 0.46

Cajanus cajan 3.60 0.2

Cassia siamea (prunings, mainly leaf) 2.52 0.27 1.35

Dactyldemia barteri 2.57 0.16 1.78 0.90

Erythrina poeppigiana 3.30 0.18 1.16 1.52

Gliricidia sepium 4.21 0.29 3.43 1.40

Inga edulis 3.1 0.20 0.9 0.7

Leucaena leucocephala 4.33 0.28 2.50 1.49

Source: Nair, 1993

Page 58: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

51

Fresh leaves of some leguminous trees such as Leucaena leucocephala, Gliricidia sepium,

and Erythrina poeppigiana decompose relatively quickly and release a major part of their

nutrients, especially nitrogen, within about four weeks under humid tropical conditions.

Nutrient rich, easily-decomposable material may not always be desirable because nutrient

release may exceed plant nutrient demands resulting in synchrony between supply and

demands. Depending on the decomposition characteristics of the plant litter the timing of

pruning (e.g. in alley cropping) can be adjusted to allow the most efficient use of the mulch

(Nair, 1993; Khanna, 1998 and Mafongoya et al, 1998).

Page 59: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

52

7. RECOMMENDATIONS

7.1. Agroforestry System

The LULUCF has been accepted as a credit-earning climate change mitigation option. It

may be useful for nations to invest in actions that not only have potential to sequester

carbon but also provide additional products and services to poor people in developing

countries, helping to reduce the rate of deforestation and contributing to sustainability.

Agroforestry and management of trees outside forests are mechanisms that could be

implemented (Pandey, 2002).

Proper design and management of agroforestry practices can make them effective carbon

sinks. As in other land-use systems, the extent of carbon sequestered will depend on the

amounts of carbon in standing biomass, recalcitrant carbon remaining in the soil and

carbon sequestered in wood products. Average carbon storage rates by agroforestry

practices in the tropics range from 1.5 to 3.5 tC ha-1

yr-1

.

Claims on the carbon sequestration potential of agroforestry systems are based on the same

premise as for tree plantations: the tree components in agroforestry systems can be

significant sinks of atmospheric carbon due to their fast growth and high productivity. By

including trees in agricultural production systems, agroforestry can increase the amount of

carbon stored in lands under agriculture while still allowing for the growing of food crops

(Kursten, 2000).

In most agroforestry systems the tree component is managed, often intensively, for its

products such as pruning of hedgerows in tropical alley cropping and improved fallow

systems for soil fertility improvement. Harvested material for commercial purposes is often

returned to the soil. In addition, the amount of biomass and therefore carbon that is

harvested and removed from the system is relatively low in relation to the total

productivity of the tree. Therefore, agroforestry seems to have a unique advantage in terms

of carbon sequestration compared with tree plantations and other monoculture systems,.

Page 60: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

53

This system can have an indirect effect on carbon sequestration if it can help to decrease

pressure on natural forests, which are the largest sink of terrestrial carbon. Within tropical

regions, it has been estimated that one hectare of sustainable agroforestry could potentially

offset 5 to 20 hectares of deforestation (Dixon, 1995). Based on this assumption,

agroforestry systems that include improved fallow and alley cropping can be recommended

for Nhambita because it is in the buffer zone of one of the most important protected area of

Mozambique. There are some examples of cases where promotion and implementation of

agroforestry systems has been successful in this regard: in Sumatra, Indonesia, farmers

who integrated rice production with tree crops and home gardens exerted much less

pressure on the adjacent forest, in comparison with farmers dedicated to rice only (ICRAF,

1995).

However, agroforestry systems can be either sinks or sources of carbon and other

greenhouse gases. Some agroforestry systems, especially those that include trees and crops

(agrisilviculture) can be carbon sinks and temporarily store carbon, while others (e.g.

ruminant-based agrosilvopastoral systems) are probably sources of carbon and other

greenhouse gases. Agroforestry systems can be significant sources of greenhouse gases in

the tropics. Practices such as tillage, burning, manuring, chemical fertilization, and

frequent disturbance can lead to emissions of CO2, CH4 and N2O from soils and vegetation

to the atmosphere (Dixon, 1995).

7.2. Agroforestry and Biodiversity Protection

Protected areas provide a foundation for long-term conservation by direct security of

biodiversity. The scale of human disturbance is such that there is no unaffected area. This

includes several degraded landscapes for logging and agriculture (Pandey, 2002 and

Schroth et al., 2004). Diversified agroforestry belts around forest fragments have recently

been considered as potential buffers for diversity habitats in the tropics (Schroth et al.,

2004) because they contribute to reduce pressure on forest resources and also improve the

living standards of the rural population living around the protected area (Nair, 1993).

Page 61: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

54

Alien species used in agroforestry are selected by the new functions and services that they

bring to the system which cannot be provided successfully by native species. It is often

exactly these functions and services (rapid biomass accumulation, nitrogen fixing) that can

cause a harmful impact when these species invade beyond sites intended for agroforestry.

Table 7 shows some of the invasive species that have been used in agroforestry.

Table 7. Some agroforest invasive species reported in different countries

Species name Species description

Leucaena species Native to central America and used for fodder, fuelwood, green

manure and pulpwood.

Calliandra calothyrsus Is native to central and south America. It is mainly used for

fuelwood, honey production, and green manure.

Sesbania sesban Native to Egypt, the main uses include fodder; fuelwood; food

(young leaves, pods and flowers); green manure; reforestation

and pulpwood.

Gliricidia sepium Native to central America. Has been used to shade cocoa, coffe,

vannila and tea; as green manure, fodder (mainly for cattles),

honey production, fuelwood, live fences, ornamental and

furniture.

Acacia auriculiformis Is native to Papwa New Guinea and northern Australia. It is used

for fuelwood, soil conservation, shade, watershade protection

and pulpwood.

Acacia mangium Native to Australia and Papwa New Ginea, it is mainly used for

timber, fuel wood, watershad protection, firebreacks, fodder,

ornamental and land rehabilitation.

Acacia nilotica Is native to semiarid African tropics. The main uses are

fuelwood, charcoal, fodder and construction.

Azadirachta indica Native to south Asia and it has many uses that include fuelwood,

construction, windbreak, oil, shade, soil improvement, insect

repellent (seeds and leaves).

Source: Nair, 1993 and Schroth et al., 2004

Page 62: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

55

The use of native species is the only way to avoid risks of invasiveness, especially where

agroforestry is also intended to serve conservation purposes, as in a buffer zone of

protected areas. The feasibility of this approach depends on the availability of species in

native flora that are suitable for the intended use (Schroth et al.,, 2004). Table 8

summarises some native trees that can be used in Nhambita. Gliricidia sepium is one of the

alien species that can be used because it has been reported as invasive only in Jamaica

(Schroth et al., 2004).

Table 8. Species occurring in Nhambita that can be used in agroforestry

Species Family Attributes

Acacia nigrescens Mimosaceae Grows well under the natural

conditions in Gorongosa

Acacia nilotica Mimosaceae It is used for fuelwood, charcoal,

fodder and construction.

Adansonia digitata Bombacaceae Fruit and leaves are edible, seed

germinates fairly easily

Albizia lebbeck Mimosaceae It is a fast growing multipurpose

species and N-fixing

Amblygonocarpus

andongensis

Mimosaceae Real carbon fixer; grows to be a

huge tree, occurs naturally in the

Gorongosa area and so worth trying

Annona

senegalensis

Annonaceae It has medicinal properties and

edible fruit

Commiphora

mossambicensis

Burseraceae Fast growing; likely to propagate

well from truncheons

Erythrina sp. Fabaceae It grows easily from truncheons and

from seed, but it is frost-tender

Faidherbia albida Mimosaceae The famous agroforestry African

species

Page 63: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

56

Table 9. Species occurring in Nhambita that can be used in agroforestry (cont.)

Species

Family Attributes

Ficus sp. Moraceae The species will grow easily from

truncheons

Khaya anthoteca Meliaceae The perfect carbon investment

especially in riverine fringe forest

Kigelia africana Bignoniaceae Huge carbon fixer growing up to 25

m in height, fruit has medicinal

properties and trees are easily

cultivated

Peltophorum

africanum

Caesalpiniaceae It is a fast growing tree with

potential to fix carbon, has

medicinal properties, seed

germinates well

Pseudolachnostylis

maprouneifolia

Euphorbiaceae Good honey tree, fire resistant,

respond well to cultivation if

protected during the early

establishment phases

Pterocarpus

rotundifolius

Fabaceae Potentially good carbon fixer given

its relative abundance in the

Gorongosa area

Sclerocarya birrea Anacardiaceae One of the most highly valued

multipurpose fruit trees. Problem:

sexes separate in different trees

Strychnos sp. Loganiaceae S. cocculoides and S.

madagascariensis produce edible

fruit and the seed germinates easily,

trees fast growing, success stories

in Zambia

Vangueria infausta Rubiaceae Good fruit tree/shrub

Sorce: Nair, 1993; Van Wyk & Van Wyk, 1997 and Muchove, 2003

Page 64: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

57

7.3. Fire Regime Regulation

Late dry season fires are more intense and destructive than fires occurring in the early dry

season when fuel moisture content is relatively high with low ambient temperatures and

windspeeds. Fuel load is largely a function of time since the last fire, the previous rainfall

season (which determines grass production), the amount of grazing and the extent of

woody plant cover. Fires tend to be more frequent and intense in areas of low woodland

cover and high mean annual rainfall where grass production is high but where grass quality

and therefore grazing pressure is low. Emission factors for trace emissions from these fires

can vary by a factor of 6 to 8, depending on the grass to woodland ratio (Ward et al.,

1996).

Early burning is recommended for the Nhambita community because the fields have a high

amount of grass that is not grazed. The availability of high amounts of grass combined

with the frequency that the area is burnt can destroy the soil structure and seedlings and

slow down the vegetation growth rate resulting in vegetation changes from the original,

low species diversity and low amount of biomass sequestered by the trees. Firebreaks are

also recommended around all fields in the community.

7.4. Rural Development and Carbon Credit

It is very important to identify activities that can be combined with carbon trading. For

instance, the introduction of agroforestry system that provide other benefits apart from

food production. Fruit trees and vegetables are some of the options that can change the life

of Nhambita community members. The only problem is the lack of market for the

products. To sell along the road is not sustainable because of competition from other

people, it is also unsure whether the products will sell. Tourism development in Gorongosa

National Park may be an opportunity for the community to supply all the fruit and

vegetables to the park. The nearest supermarket such as "Shoprite" in Chimoio Province is

another option for commercialization.

Page 65: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

58

Some fruits like mangoes are seasonal and not available throughout the year, the

introduction of dried mixed fruit packages of mango, paw-paw and banana could make a

difference since no-one is currently doing this in Mozambique. All these initiatives could

not only contribute to extra cash but could also add to the food diversity which would

contribute to improving the nutritional needs that the community face when agriculture

production is not satisfactory. GERFA study indicated that illness in the area was linked to

protein deficiencies and malnutrition during periods of the year when food is scarce.

Nevertheless, there are already some initiatives being implemented by the Nhambita

Project that include beekeeping, carpentry and livestock promotion. All these activities are

related to men and do not involve women. Fruit tree production and processing in

particular could be an opportunity for women in the village, some studies conducted by

ICRAF in Southern Africa showed that fruit production and processing are mainly

activities for women and children.

There are gender issues to consider. In rural area is tradition that women do not make

decisions regarding the use of money, even when it comes from women’s work. This raises

the question about how women are going to benefit from those activities. It is almost

impossible to change culture and the rules of the games in the household cannot be

changed. The initiative is to consider the fact that the household will have a more

diversified nutritional diet and food alternatives during the low regular field productions

based on maize, millet and sorghum. Depending on the head of the households behaviour,

all the family can benefit from money made.

Page 66: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

59

8. CONCLUSIONS

1. Several allometric relationships to estimate biomass are available from the

literature. In this study, four different allometric equations have been used to

estimate the biomass of fallow fields. The most robust estimate was given by

finding the average of four of them. Although the allometric equations used are

quite different, and each was collected using a small sample of trees in a specific

locality and in different vegetation types, the results do not vary greatly. The

present technique of taking the average of these as the best estimate has probably

yielded the most reliable and cost-effective method of estimating biomass in this

situation.

2. The total amount of biomass accumulated in all 28 fallow fields is 19.6 tbiomass

ha-1

. The accumulation rate was found to be 1.1 tbiomass ha-1

yr-1

which

corresponds to a carbon accumulation rate of 0.55 tC ha-1

yr-1

. This is low

compared with some other studies. Frequent fires and low soil fertility of the sites

might have contributed to the slow growth.

3. There is a change in species composition in the regrowth fields compared with

typical miombo dominated by Brachystegia species, and Julbernardia globiflora.

However, Acacia nigrescens (mugoe), Lannea schweinfurthii (bzototo) and

Sclerocarya birrea (mfula) can be considered as early species, while chimanda,

Vitex sp. (mucubvusetche) and guaquacho are the later, succession species.

Piliostigma thonningii (mucequesse), Lonchocarpus capassa (pacassa) and Annona

senegalensis (mulolo) are “ubiquitous” because they occur throughout the

succession.

4. Agroforestry systems can contribute to increasing short-term carbon sequestration

because of their carbon storage potential both above and below-ground. Also the

use of multi-purpose plant species can be useful, as it may involve food crops and

the system can be socially acceptable. Moreover, agroforestry also improves soil

fertility through the leguminous trees that are nitrogen fixing trees.

Page 67: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

60

9. REFERENCES

Albrecht, A. and S. T. Kandji, 2003. Carbon sequestration in tropical agroforestry systems.

Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 99: 15–27.

Andreae, M. O., E. Atlas, H. Cachier, W. R. Cofer III, G. W. Harris, G. Helas, R.

Koppmann, J. P. Lacaux, and D.E. Ward, 1996. Trace gas and aerosol emissions from

savanna fires. In: Biomass Burning and Global Change. Levine, J.S (ed.). MIT Press,

Cambridge.

Anon., 1999. State of the World's Forests. http://www.fao.org/fo/sofo/sofo99/default.htm

Avsar, M. D., 2004. The Relationships between diameter at breast height, tree height and

crown diameter in calabrian pines (Pinus brutia Ten.) of Baskonus Mountain,

Kahramanmaras, Turkey. Journal of Biological Sciences 4: 437-440.

Bradley, P. N. and K. McNamara, 1993. Living with Trees: Policies for Forestry

Management in Zimbabwe. World Bank Technical Paper Number 210, The World Bank,

Washington, DC.

Brookman-Ammissah, J., J. N.Hall, M. D. Swaine and J. Y. Attakorah, 1980. A re-

assessment of a fire protection experiment in North-Eastern Ghana savanna. Journal of

Applied Ecology 17: 85-99.

Brown, S., A. J. R. Gillespie and A. E. Lugo, 1989. Biomass Estimation Methods for

Tropical Forests with application to forest inventory data. Forest Science 35: 881-902.

Brown, S. A., C. A. S. Hall, W. Knabe, J. Raich, M. C. Trexler and P. Woomer, 1993.

Tropical forests: their past present and potential future role in the terrestrial carbon budget,

Water Air Soil Pollution 70: 71-94.

Page 68: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

61

Brown, S., 1997. Estimating biomass and biomass change of tropical forests: a primer.

FAO Forestry Paper 134. Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, Rome.

Ciesla, W., 1995. Climate change, forests and forest management, FAO Forestry Paper

126, Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, Rome.

Chidumayo, E., 1988. A re-assessment of effects of fire on miombo regeneration in the

Zambian Copperbelt. Journal of Tropica Ecology 4: 361-372.

Chidumayo, E., 1990. Above ground woody biomass structure and productivity in a

zambezian woodland. Forest Ecology and Management 36: 33-46.

Chidumayo, E., 1997. Miombo Ecology and Management: An Introduction. 166pp.

Stockholm Environment Institute.

Chidumayo, E., 2002. Changes in miombo woodland structure under different land tenure

and use systems in central Zambia. Journal of Biogeography 29: 1619–1626.

Cook, L., 1939. A contribution to our information on grass burning. South African Journal

of Science 36: 270-282.

Cox, P. M., R. A. Betts, C. D. Jones, S. A. Spall and I. j. Totterdell, 2000, Acceleration of

global warming due to carbon-cycle feedbacks in a coupled climate model. Nature 408:

184- 187.

Dale, V. H., R. A. Houghton, and C. A. S. Hall, 1991. Estimating the effects of land-use

change on global atmospheric CO2 concentrations. Can. J. For. Res. 21: 87-90.

De Koning, J., 1993. Checklist of vernacular plant names in Mozambique. Wageningen

Agricultural University.

Page 69: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

62

Desanker, P. V., P. G. H. Frost, C. O. Justice, and R. J. Scholes, 1995. The Miombo

Network: Framework for a terrestrial transect study of land-use and land-cover change in

the miombo ecosystems of Central Africa. 110pp. Stockolm, Sweden.

Dewees, P. A., 1994. Social and economic aspects of Miombo woodland management in

Southern Africa: options and opportunities for research. CIFOR Occasional Paper No. 2.

Centre for International Forestry Research, Bogor, Indonesia.

Dixon, R. K., J. K. Winjun and P. A. Schroeder, 1993. Conservation and sequestration of

carbon: the potential of forest and agroforest management practices, Global Environ.

Change 3: 159-173.

Dixon R. K., 1995. Agroforestry systems: sources or sinks of greenhouse gases?

Agroforest System 31: 99–116.

Envirotrade, 2005. http://www.envirotrade.co.uk/index.html

FAO, 2004. Carbon sequestration in dryland soils. 129 pp. Rome.

Fearnside, P. M., 1999. Forests and global warming mitigation in Brazil: opportunities in

the Brazilian forest sector for responses to global warming under the "Clean Development

Mechanism". Biomass Bioenergy 16: 171–189.

Freson, R., G. Goffinet and F. Malaisse, 1974. Ecological effects of the regressive

succession Muhulu-Miombo-Savanna in upper Shaba, Zaire. In: Proceedings of the First

International Congress of Ecology. Structure, Functioning and Management of Ecosystems

(The Hague, September 1974). Pag. 365-371. Wageningen, Netherlands.

Frost, P. G. H. and F. Robertson, 1985. The ecological effects of fire in savannas. In:

Proceedings of workshop in Harare, Zimbabwe.

Page 70: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

63

Frost, P. The ecology of miombo woodland. In: Campbel, B. (ed), 1996. The miombo in

transition: woodlands and welfare in Africa. 266pp. Centre for international forestry

research, Bogor, Indonesia.

Goreau, T. J., 1990. Balancing atmospheric carbon dioxide. Ambio 19: 230-236.

Goreau, T. J., 1992. Control of atmospheric carbon dioxide. Global Environ. Change

2: 5-11.

Grace, J., J. Lloyd, J. McIntyre, A. C. Miranda, P. Meir, H. S. Miranda, C. Nobre, J.

Moncrieff, J. Massheider, Y. Malhi, I. Wright, and J. Gash, 1995: Carbon dioxide uptake

by an undisturbed tropical rain forest in southwest Amazonia. Science 270: 778-780.

Griffin, G. F. and M. H. Friedel, 1984. Effects of fire on Central Australian rangelands:

Fire and fuel characteristics and changes in herbage and nutrients. Australian Journal of

Ecology, 9: 381-393.

Harmon, M. E., W. K. Perrell, and J. F. Franklin, 1990. Effects on carbon storage of

conversion of old-growth forests to young forests. Science 247: 699-701.

Harrington, G. N., 1974. Fire effects on a Ugandan grassland. Tropical Grasslands,

8: 87-101.

Harrington, G. N. and I. C. Ross, 1974. The savanna ecology of Kidepo Valley National

Park. Part I. The effects of burning and browsing on the vegetation. East African Wildlife

Journal 12: 93-106.

Houghton, R. A., and D. L. Skole, 1990. Carbon. Pp 393-408. In: Turner, B. L., W. C.

Clark, R. W. Kates, J. F. Richards, J. T. Matthews, and W. B. Meyer (Eds). The earth as

transformed by human action. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

ICRAF, 1995. Annual Report. 288 pp. Nairobi.

Page 71: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

64

Instituto Nacional de Estatística, 1997. II Recenseamento Geral da População e

Habitação: Província de Sofala. 118 pp. Maputo.

IPCC, 1996. Revised guideline for National green house gas inventories. Volume 3

http://www.ipcc-nggip.iges.or.jp/public/gl/invs6.htm

IPCC, 2000. IPCC special Report: Land Use, Land-Use Change, and Forestry.

http://www.ipcc.ch/pub/srlulucf-e.pdf

IPCC, 2001 a. Working Group II: Impacts, Adaptation and Vulnerability.

http://www.grida.no/climate/ipcc_tar/wg2/377.htm

IPCC, 2001 b. Climate Changes: Synthesis report.

http://www.grida.no/climate/ipcc_tar/vol4/english/index.htm

ITTO 1994. Fire in rainforest - lessons from East Kalimantan. Summary of the ITTO

Report of Project PD 17/87: Investigations of the steps needed to rehabilitate the areas of

East Kalimantan seriously affected by fire. Tropical Forest Update 4(5): 18-19.

Kellman, M., K. Miyanishi and P. Hiebert, 1985. Nutrient retention by savanna

ecosystems. II. Retention after fire. Journal of Ecology 73: 953-962.

Khanna, P. K., 1998. Nutrient cycling Under Mixed-species Trees System in South Asia.

Agroforestry Systems 38: 99-120.

Kursten, E., 2000. Fuelwood production in agroforestry systems for sustainable land use

and CO2 mitigation. Ecol Eng 16: 69– 72.

Kyuma, K. and C. Pairintra, 1983. Shifting Cultivation. An Experiment at Nam Phrom,

Northeast Thailand and Its Implications for Upland Farming in the Monsoon Tropics. ,

219 pp. Kyoto University, Japan.

Page 72: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

65

Lathwell, D.J. and T. L. Grove, 1986. Soil–plant relationships in the tropics. Annual

Review of Ecology and Systematics 17: 1–16.

Lawton, R. M., 1978. A study of the dynamic ecology of Zambian vegetation. Journal of

Ecology 66: 175-198.

Losi, C. J., T. G. Siccama, R. Condit and J. E. Morales, 2003. Analysis of alternative

methods for estimating carbon stock in young tropical plantations. Forest Ecology and

Management 184: 355-368.

MacDicken, K. G., 1997. A Guide to Monitoring Carbon Storage in Forestry and

Agroforestry Projects. 91 pp. Winrock Internationl Institute for Agricultural Development.

Mafongoya, P. L., K. E. Giller and C. A. Palm, 1998. Decomposition and Nitrogen Release

Patters of Trees Prunings and Litter. Agroforestry Systems 38: 77-97.

Mafongoya, P. L. and B. H. Dzowela, 1999. Biomass production of tree fallows and their

residual effect on maize in Zimbabwe. Agroforestry Systems 47: 139–151.

Malingreau, J. P., C. J. Tucker and N. Laporte, 1989. AVHRR for monitoring global

tropical deforestation. International Journal of Remote Sensing 10: 855-867.

Marsh, C., 1993. Carbon dioxide offsets as potential funding for improved tropical forest

management. Oryx 27: 2-3.

Montagnini, F., and P. K. R. Nair, 2004. Carbon sequestration: An underexploited

environmental benefit of agroforestry systems. Agroforestry Systems 61: 281–295.

Muchove, P., 2003. Preliminary inventory of Nhambita community forest, Gorongosa

district, Mozambique. 40 pp.

Nair, P. K., 1993. An Introduction to Agroforestry. 499pp. Kluwer Academic Publishers,

Netherlands.

Page 73: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

66

Nye, P. H. and D. J. Greenland, 1960. The Soil Under Shifting Cultivation. 156 pp.

Technical communication No 51, Commonwealth Agriculture Bureaux, England.

Oelbermann, M., R. P. Voroney, A. M. Gordon., 2004. Carbon sequestration in tropical

and temperate agroforestry systems: a review with examples from Costa Rica and southern

Canada. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 104: 359–377.

Oguntala, A.B. (1980). The effects of fire on aspects of nitrogen cycling in the Olokomeji

Forest Reserve, Nigeria. In: Rosswall, T. (Ed.), Nitrogen Cycling in West African

Ecosystems. Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences, Stockholm.

Oliver, C. D., 1981. Forest development in North America following major disturbances.

Forest Ecology and Management 3: 153–168.

Palgrave, M. C., 2002. Trees of Southern Africa. 3rd

edition. 1212pp, Struik Publishers,

Cape Town.

Pandey, D. N., 2002. Carbon sequestration in agroforestry systems. Climate Policy

2: 367-377.

Peters, W. J., L. F. Neuenschwander, 1988. Slash and Burn: farming in the third world

forest. 113 pp. University of Idaho press, Moscow.

Petit, J. R., J. Jouzel, D. Raynaud, N. I. Barkov, J. M. Barnola, I. Basile, M. Bender, J.

Chappellaz, M. Davis, G. Delaygue, M. Delmotte, V. M. Kotlyakov, M. Legrand, V. Y.

Lipenkov, C. Lorius, L. Pépin, C. Ritz, E. Saltzman and M. Stievenard, 1999. Climate and

atmospheric history of the past 420,000 years from the Vostok ice core, Antarctica. Nature

3: 429–436.

Philip, M. S., 1994. Measuring Trees and Forests. 2nd

edition. 310pp. University press,

Cambridge, United Kingdom.

Page 74: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

67

Poore, D., 1989. No timber without trees. Sustainability in the Tropical Forest. 252pp.

Earthscan Publications Ltd., London.

Quinn, G. P. and M. J. Keough, 2002. Experimental Design and Data Analysis for

Biologists. 543pp. Cambridge UP, United Kingdom.

Ritson, P. and S. Sochacki., 2003. Measurement and prediction of biomass and carbon

content of Pinus pinaster trees in farm forestry plantations, south-western Australia. Forest

Ecology and Management 175: 103-117

Roughgarden, J., S. W. Running and P. A. Matson, 1991. What does remote sensing do for

ecology? Ecology 76: 1918-1922.

Sampson, R. N., M. Apps, S. Brown, 1993. Workshop summary statement: terrestrial

biospheric carbon fluxes - quantification of sinks and sources of CO2. Water Air Soil Pollut

70: 3-15.

Scholes, R. J., J. Kendall, and C.O. Justice, 1996 a. The quantity of biomass burned in

Southern Africa. Journal of Geophysical Research 101: 667- 676.

Scholes, R. J., D. Ward, and Justice, C.O. 1996 b. Emissions of trace gases and aerosol

particles due to vegetation burning in southern hemisphere Africa. Journal of Geophysical

Research 101: 677- 682.

Schroth, G., G. A. B. da Fonseca, C. A. Harvey, C. Gascon, H. L. Vasconcelos and A. N.

Izac, 2004. Agroforestry and Biodiversity Conservation in Tropical Landscape. 523 pp.

Island Press, Washington, DC.

Sedjo, R., B. Sohngen and P. Jagger, 1998. Carbon sinks in the post-kyoto world.

http://www.weathervane.rff.org/features/feature050.html

Page 75: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

68

Singh, K.D. 1993. Forest resources assessment 1990: tropical countries. Unasylva 44:10.

Smith, T. M., W. P. Cramer, R. K. Dixon, R. Leemans, R. P. Neilson and A. M. Solomon,

1993. The global terrestrial carbon cycle. Water Air Soil Pollution 70: 19-37.

Sokal, R. R. and F. J. Rohlf, 1995. Biomatry. 3rd

ed. 887 pp. USA.

Solomon, A. M., I. C. Prentice, R. Leemans and W. P. Cramer, 1993. The interaction of

climate and land use in future terrestrial carbon storage and release. Water Air Soil Pollut.

70: 595-614.

Specht, A. and P. W. West, 2003. Estimation of Biomass and Sequestered Carbon on farm

Forest Plantation in Northern New South Wales, Australia. Biomass and Bioenergy 25: pp.

363- 379.

Starfield, A. M., Cumming, D. H. M., Taylor, R. D. and M. S. Quadling, 1993. A

framebased paradigm for dynamic ecosystem models. AI Applications 7: 1-13.

Strang, R. M., 1974. Some man-made changes in successional trends on the Rhodesian

highveld. Journal of Applied Ecology 111: 249-263.

Stromgaard, P., 1985. Biomass, growth and burning of woodland in a shifting cultivation

area of south central Africa. Forest Ecology and Management 12: 163-178.

Stromgaard, P. 1986. Early secondary succession on abandoned shifting cultivator’s plots

in the Miombo of south central Africa. Biotropica 18: 97-106.

Stuart, M. D., and P. M. Costa, 1998. Climate change mitigation by forestry: a review of

international initiatives. 81pp. http://www.iied.org/docs/flu/ptw/8climchnge.pdf

Szott, L. T., E. C. M. Fernandes and P. A. Sanchez, 1991. Soil–plant interactions in

agroforestry systems. Forest Ecology and Management 45: 127–152.

Page 76: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

69

Tans, P. P., I. Y. Fung and T. Takahashi, 1990. Observational constraints on the global

CO2 budget. Science 247: 1431-1438.

Trapnell, C. G. 1959. Ecological results of woodland burning experiments in Northern

Rhodesia. Journal of Ecology 47: 129-168.

Trapnell, C. G., M. T. Friend, G. T. Chamberlain and H. F. Birch, 1976. The effects of fire

and termites on a Zambian woodland soil. Journal of Ecology 64: 577-588.

UNEP, 2000. Global environment outlook. http://www.grida.no/geo2000

Van Wyk, B. and Van P. Wyk, 1997. Field guide to trees of Southern Africa. 536pp, Struik

Publishers. Cape Town.

Vitousek, P.M., 1984. Litterfall, nutrient cycling, and nutrient limitation in tropical forests.

Ecology 65: 285–298.

Wadsworth, G., H. M. Reisenauer, D. R. Gordon and M. J. Singer, 1990 Effects of length

of forest fallow on fertility dynamics in a Mexican Ultisol. Plant and Soil 122: 151–156.

Ward, D. E., W. H. Hao, R. A. Susott, R. E. Babbitt, R. W. Shea, J. B. Kauffman and C. O.

Justice, 1996. Effect of fuel composition on combustion efficiency and emission factors for

African savanna ecosystems. Journal of Geophysical Research 101: 569-576.

Watson, J. P., 1964. A soil catena on granite in southern Rhodesia I. Field observations, II.

Analytical data. Journal of Soil Science 15: 238-257.

Webster, R. 1965. A catena of soils on the northern Rhodesia plateau. Journal of Soil

Science 16: 31-43.

White, F., 1983. The Vegetation of Africa. UNESCO, Paris.

Page 77: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

70

Whitlow, R. 1987. Man’s impact on vegetation: the African experience. Pp. 353-379. In

Gregory, K. J. and D. E. Walling. Human activity and environmental process. John wiley

& sons, London

Wisniewski, J., and R. N. Sampson, 1993. Terrestrial biospheric carbon fluxes:

quantification of sinks and sources of C02, Kluwer, Dordreeht.

Wofsy, S. C., M. L. Goulden, J. W. Munger, 1993. Net exchange of CO2 in a mid-latitude

forest. Science 260: 1314-1317.

Page 78: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

71

APPENDIXES

Appendix 1: Field data sheet

Country: Mozambique Province: Sofala Adm. Post:________________

Community: Nhambita Field owner: _______________ Fallow age: _______ years

Plot number: _____ Waypoint number _______________________

Crew chief ________________ Date __/__/05

Tree

no Scientific name Local name DBH Height Volume Biomass

(cm) (m) (m3)

Page 79: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

72

Appendix 2: Recorded species list

Local name Botanic name

Family

Balamadona Sterculia appendiculata Sterculiaceae

Bicankhula

Bubunhanga

Bzototo Lannea schweinfurthii Anacardiaceae

Chidzedze Entada abyssinica Mimosaceae

Chikumbite Zanha africana Sapindaceae

Chimanda

Chiriacamba

Chissio

Cotanzoo

Gliricidia

Guaquacho

Guhu

Gunga

Kataussalu Ozoroa sp. Anacardiaceae

Khumbantsato

Kumbanzou Holarrhena pubescens Apocynaceae

Mangueira

Massaniqueira

Mfiti Combretum sp. Combretaceae

Mfula Sclerocarya birrea Anacardiaceae

Momba Pterocarpus rotundifolia Fabaceae; Papilionoideae

Mpingue Dalbergia melanoxylon Fabaceae; Papilionoideae

Mucarati

Mucequesse Piliostigma thonningii Caesalpinaceae

Muchanbvu

Mucodone

Mucombegu

Muconambira

Mucula Diospyros kirkii Ebenaceae

Mucuvu Vitex doniana Lamiaceae

Mucuvucuvu

Mucuvusetche Vitex sp. Lamiaceae

Mufuma

Mugoe Acacia nigrescens Mimosaceae

Mucodone

Mulolo Annona senegalensis Annonaceae

Mulonde Xeroderris stuhlmannii Fabaceae; Papilionoideae

Mulumanhama

Mulungamunhu

Mumbziru Vangueria infausta Rubiaceae

Mundjale

Munhongolo

Munomolo

Page 80: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

73

Appendix 2: Recorded species list (Cont.)

Local name

Botanic name

Family

Mussadzi Acacia robusta Mimosaceae

Mussautsanga Ziziphus abyssinica Rhamnaceae

Mussimbe

Mussodze

Mussorola Albizia harvey Mimosaceae

Mutchatchane

Muteme Strychnos innocua Strychnaceae

Mutimbe

Mutoe Thespesia garckeana Malvaceae

Mutunduro Strychnos spinosa Strychnaceae

Muvunguti Kigelia africana Bignoniaceae

Nhacabale Combretum/Markhamia?

Nhagaucau Voacanga africana Apocynaceae

Nhamperapera

Nhampulurue

Nhamudima Diospyros usambarensis Apocynaceae

Nhamuthomole Dyploryncho condilocarpon Apocynaceae

Nkomacamba

Pacassa Lonchocarpus capassa

Fabaceae;

Papilionoideae

Panga panga Millettia stuhlmannii

Fabaceae;

Papilionoideae

Papaeira Carica papaya Caricaceae

Pfeua Markhamia obtusifolia Bignoniaceae

Tanga tanga Albizia glaberrima Mimosaceae

Thadza Grewia monticola Tiliaceae

Thetha Dombeya shupangae Sterculiaceae

Thoa

Tsangalassa

Total 71 Species

Page 81: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

74

Appendix 3: Correlation analysis

Correlation of BA (m2/ha) and tree density = -0.044, P-Value = 0.824

R2 = 0.0019

0

200

400

600

800

1000

1200

1400

1600

0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0.25

Basal area (m2/ha)

Tre

e d

en

sit

y (

ste

ms/h

a)

Appendix 4: Correlation Analysis

Correlation of Mean Biomass t/ha and tree density = 0.532, P-Value = 0.004

R2 = 0.2835

0

200

400

600

800

1000

1200

1400

1600

0 20 40 60 80

Biomass accumulated (t/ha)

Tre

e d

en

sit

y (

ste

am

s/h

a)

Page 82: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

75

Appendix 5: Regression analysis

Regression Analysis: mean biomass (MB) t/ha versus Fallow age

The regression equation is : MBt/ha = 2.11 + 1.10 Fallow age

S = 12.0720 R-Sq = 53.9% R-Sq(adj) = 52.1%

Analysis of Variance

Source DF SS MS F P

Regression 1 4427.7 4427.7 30.38 0.000

Residual Error 26 3789.1 145.7

Total 27 8216.8

������

���� �

����������

� �� �����

��� � �����

� ��

��������������������������

The mean biomass residuals are approximately normally distributed

Page 83: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

76

����������

�������

��������

��

��

��

���

���

������������������������������� ����� ������� !�"

According to the graphic above, there is homogeneity of the variances. It means that the

variance of the residuals are not different.

Page 84: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

77

Appendix 6. Biomass variation in each surveyed field

(oldgrow data are from Muchove, 2003)

Fallow age

(years)

Biomass

(t/ha)

2 0.2

2 2.1

3 11.5

3 3.3

4 9.0

5 1.3

5 3.0

6 4.4

6 3.0

6 8.7

6 0.3

9 7.2

9 9.6

10 8.0

13 22.7

19 61.6

19 18.0

19 28.8

30 20.8

30 17.3

30 30.9

30 26.6

30 34.1

30 25.5

30 22.0

30 38.3

30 22.0

30 31.4

Oldgrow 136.1388 Oldgrow 160.4624 Oldgrow 116.5514 Oldgrow 135.4225 Oldgrow 112.2257 Oldgrow 65.84609

Page 85: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

78

Appendix 7: One-way ANOVA: Log mean biomass (MB) t/ha versus Fallow age

Source DF SS MS F P

Fallow age 9 7.3634 0.8182 8.38 0.000

Error 18 1.7582 0.0977

Total 27 9.1217

S = 0.3125 R-Sq = 80.72% R-Sq(adj) = 71.09%

Individual 95% CIs For Mean Based on

Pooled StDev

Level N Mean StDev -----+---------+---------+---------+----

2 2 0.1447 0.2583 (------*-------)

3 2 0.8328 0.4405 (-------*-------)

4 1 1.0326 * (----------*----------)

5 2 0.3443 0.2115 (-------*------)

6 4 0.3928 0.6237 (-----*----)

9 2 0.9292 0.0902 (------*-------)

10 1 0.9564 * (----------*----------)

13 1 1.4151 * (----------*----------)

19 3 1.5665 0.2846 (-----*-----)

30 10 1.4903 0.1133 (---*--)

-----+---------+---------+---------+----

0.00 0.60 1.20 1.80

Pooled StDev = 0.3125

���������

���� �

����������������

��

� �� ����

��� � �����

� ��

�����������������������������

Page 86: ABOVEGROUND BIOMASS ACCUMULATION IN FIELDS · PDF fileMathew Williams helped me with his excel skills that were ... The Effect of Burning in the Regrowth ... while areas around the

79

������

���� �

����������

� �� �����

��� � �����

� ��

��������������������������