Abdominal epilepsy

12

Click here to load reader

Transcript of Abdominal epilepsy

Page 1: Abdominal epilepsy

Best Practice & Research Clinical GastroenterologyVol. 19, No. 2, pp. 263–274, 2005

6

Abdominal epilepsy

Noah T. Zinkin1MD

Mark A. Peppercorn* MD

Professor of Medicine

Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Harvard Medical school, 330 Brookline Ave.,

Rabb 4, Cambridge, MA 02215, USA

Abdominal epilepsy is an uncommon syndrome in which gastrointestinal complaints, mostcommonly abdominal pain, result from seizure activity. It is characterized by (1) otherwiseunexplained, paroxysmal gastrointestinal complaints, (2) symptoms of a central nervous systemdisturbance, (3) an abnormal electroencephalogram with findings specific for a seizure disorder,and (4) improvement with anticonvulsant medication. We review the history of the syndrome andanalyze all 36 cases reported in the English literature from the last 34 years. The most commongastrointestinal symptoms include abdominal pain, nausea and vomiting, while the most commonneurological symptoms include lethargy and confusion. After exclusion of more commonetiologies for the presenting complaints, workup should proceed with an electroencephalogram.Where the diagnosis is seriously considered, neurological consultation should be considered.Treatment typically begins with anticonvulsant medication, and resolution of symptoms withtherapy helps to confirm the diagnosis.

Key words: epilepsy; temporal lobe; nausea; vomiting; abdominal pain; anticonvulsants;electroencephalography.

DEFINITION

Abdominal sensations will commonly herald the onset of a motor seizure. This so calledabdominal aura, which may include sensations such as pain, nausea, gassiness andhunger, has been reported to be the most common aura in epilepsy, especially temporallobe epilepsy.1 On occasion, however, gastrointestinal signs and symptoms may be

doi:10.1016/j.bpg.2004.10.001available online at http://www.sciencedirect.com

1521-6918/$ - see front matter Q 2004 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

* Corresponding author. Tel.: C1 617 667 8926; Fax: C1 617 667 1071.

E-mail addresses: [email protected] (N.T. Zinkin), [email protected]

(M.A. Peppercorn).1 Tel.: C1 617 667 9355; Fax: C1 617 667 8242.

Page 2: Abdominal epilepsy

264 N. T. Zinkin and M. A. Peppercorn

the primary or only manifestation of seizures. This phenomenon defines abdominalepilepsy.

The main criteria that establish a diagnosis of abdominal epilepsy include (1)paroxysmal gastrointestinal complaints that are unexplained by complete evaluation,including laboratory tests, radiographic imaging, and endoscopy, (2) symptoms of acentral nervous system (CNS) disturbance, (3) an abnormal electroencephalogram(EEG) with findings specific for a seizure disorder, and (4) a sustained abolition ofsymptoms on anticonvulsant medication.2 EEG recordings during events have been onlyrarely reported3,4 and are not necessary for the diagnosis.

HISTORY AND EVOLUTION

Despite its seeming rarity, many cases of abdominal epilepsy have been reported in theliterature, although many of the earlier cases are of questionable validity. Trousseau iscredited with the first description of abdominal epilepsy in 1868. He described a boywith paroxysmal attacks of abdominal pain, vomiting, giddiness, and pallor, who laterdeveloped grand mal seizures.5

In his landmark paper in 19446, Moore reported a 32 year old man with paroxysmsof abdominal pain followed by exhaustion, that had started at age 9 months. He had anextensive workup at multiple hospitals over many years with no etiology found. An EEGwas finally performed which revealed ‘low voltage abnormal waves seen particularly inthe right and left frontal regions.’ His attacks of pain resolved completely on phenytoin,and then recurred when therapy was stopped. Moore then published a second part tothis article in 1945 in which he presented 5 additional patients with paroxysmalabdominal pain.7 Of the total of 6 patients, 5 were treated with anticonvulsants andresponded favorably, although not all of the patients had abnormal EEGs. He alsoproposed a practical set of criteria for diagnosing abdominal epilepsy, similar to thosenoted above.

Moore later defined abdominal epilepsy as ‘a disorder characterized by bouts ofparoxysmal abdominal pain. provoked by abnormal discharges of certain neurones inthe vicinity of biochemically or structurally altered cerebral tissue.’.8 By 1952, he hadreported 28 cases of abdominal epilepsy.9 His reports were somewhat unusual in thatmost cases were in adults.

In the 25 years after Moore’s initial formal description of the entity, many moreauthors reported case series of patients, mostly children, with suspected abdominalepilepsy.5,10–17 However, while many of these were no doubt genuine cases ofabdominal epilepsy, the standards by which cases were diagnosed and reported werepoor, with many patients having atypical presentations, normal or non-specific EEGs,and no improvement with anticonvulsants. For example, several authors reported onpatients with recurrent abdominal pain and the so called ‘14 and 6 positive spikes’pattern on EEG.18 It was postulated that this pattern was actually indicative ofabdominal epilepsy.19 However, this pattern was later identified in over 50% of normalchildhood and adolescent EEGs, with no association with recurrent abdominal pain.20,21

It is now considered a normal variant.22

Then, in 1971, Douglas and White23 published another landmark article in whichthey reviewed the literature on abdominal epilepsy and noted that previous authors hadtoo often based the diagnosis on insufficient evidence. They investigated 28 patientsreferred to a neurology clinic for recurrent abdominal pain and found that only 5 had

Page 3: Abdominal epilepsy

Abdominal epilepsy 265

clinical and EEG findings strongly suggestive of epilepsy. They stressed the importanceof both disturbances of consciousness and specific EEG abnormalities as the types ofevidence that could truly separate abdominal epilepsy from other causes of recurrentabdominal pain. They also pointed out that, although helpful, response to antic-onvulsants was non-specific since their sedating properties alone could improve non-epileptic symptoms.

CLINICAL FEATURES

The practicing physician familiar with abdominal epilepsy is aware that a true case isquite uncommon. Most reported cases are in children and adolescents. In onestudy of 858 patients with epilepsy, only 3 had abdominal pain as a prominentfeature of their seizures24, while another found no cases of abdominal epilepsyamong 127 patients with somatosensory seizures.25 However, its true prevalence isunknown.

Since Douglas and White laid the groundwork for more rigorous standards inthe reporting of cases of abdominal epilepsy in 1971, we found only 36 reportedcases in the English literature. We reviewed all such cases and present thefeatures of each with regard to age at presentation, sex, gastrointestinal symptoms,CNS and other non-gastrointestinal features, EEG, treatment, and outcome(Table 1).

Patients ranged from 1 to 66 years old at presentation and 19/36 (53%) werefemale. Gastrointestinal manifestations of seizures included abdominal pain, mostcommonly sharp or colicky, in 31 (86%), nausea and/or vomiting in 10 (28%),diarrhea in 2 (5%), and bloating in 1 (3%). Where reported, the abdominal pain wasmost commonly periumbilical or upper abdominal, including epigastric and rightupper quadrant, but left lower quadrant, lower abdominal, and migratory pains werereported in one patient, each. Neurological and other non-gastrointestinalmanifestations that were reported in more than one patient included lethargy,fatigue and/or post-ictal sleep in 13 (36%), some level of disturbance inconsciousness in 23 (64%), including loss of consciousness or generalized tonic–clonic seizures in 13 (36%), dizziness in 3 (8%), headaches in 5 (14%), pallor/sweatsin 4 (11%), fever in 2 (6%), extremity pain, numbness and/or paresthesias in 2 (6%),and blindness in 2 (6%).

However, in any individual case, each episode was not necessarily the same. Forexample, many of the patients with recurrent abdominal pain had associateddisturbances of consciousness, but not necessarily with every episode. Some patientshad typical generalized tonic–clonic seizures at times, but then purely sensoryseizures, characterized only by abdominal pain, at other times.

The duration of episodes, where reported, was typically no more than a fewminutes, but 2 had symptoms lasting for an hour or more. Most patients did haveabnormalities on EEG characteristic of epilepsy but one patient actually had normalEEGs, even during events.

Where reported, all patients were treated with anticonvulsants, most commonlyphenytoin, phenobarbital, or carbamazepine. Four patients received anticonvulsantsand surgery, one of whom also underwent radiation therapy. The outcome for allpatients was favorable in that all had at least some improvement with therapy, mostwith complete or near complete resolution of symptoms.

Page 4: Abdominal epilepsy

Table 1. Clinical characteristics of all reported cases of abdominal epilepsy since 1971.

Patient

number Age Sex

Gastrointestinal

symptoms

CNS disturbance

and other non-gas-

trointestinal

symptoms

Episode

duration EEG Treatment Outcome

123 11 F Paroxysmal, peri-

umbilical abdominal

pain

Lassitude, post-ictal

sleep, fever, head-

ache, confusion

‘Brief’ Irregular 3 Hz spike-wave activity Phenobarbital Symptom free

223 5 F Crampy, paroxys-

mal abdominal pain

Lethargy, post-ictal

sleep

Few minutes Episodic 6–7 Hz activity in L temporal

area, bursts of generalized irregularly

intermixed spikes and slow waves

Phenobarbital Lost to

follow-up

323 18 F Colicky pain Post-ictal sleep 10 minutes Bitemporal spiking Phenobarbital Symptom free

423 6 M Paroxysmal pain Lethargy, confusion,

fever

Minutes Paroxysmal spike-wave activity, frontal

or generalized

Anticonvul-

sants

Seizure free

523 26 M Colicky abdominal

pain

Lethargy, confusion,

post-ictal sleep

Few minutes ‘Compatible with temporal lobe epi-

lepsy’

Phenytoin Seizure free

626 39 M Abdominal pain

(variable location)

Fatigue, headache,

sweating, numb-

ness, paresthesias

NR ‘Abnormal electrical activity suspicious

for epilepsy’

Phenytoin,

phenyl-ethyl

barbiturate,

carbamaze-

pine

Complete res-

olution

72,27 47 F Periumbilical pain Loss of awareness,

confusion

NR Irregular spikes bilaterally over tem-

poral areas

Phenytoin Complete res-

olution

82,27 44 F Periumbilical pain Headaches NR Low voltage spikes in left anterior

temporal region, sharp waves on right

during light sleep

Phenytoin and

phenobarbital

Near complete

resolution

92,27 30 F Periumbilical pain Syncope NR Intermittent sharp wave complexes in

right and left anterior temporal regions

Phenobarbital Complete res-

olution

102,27 17 F Periumbilical pain Blindness NR Diffuse bursts of theta activity over left

post. temporal area, and left post.

quadrant reversals of slow theta waves

and sharp waves

Phenytoin Complete res-

olution

266

N.T

.Z

inkin

and

M.A

.Pep

perco

rn

Page 5: Abdominal epilepsy

1128 3.5 M Abdominal pain,

vomiting

Confusion, cyano-

sis, urinary inconti-

nence, blindness

Minutes Scattered high voltage slow activity and

high voltage sharp waves

Phenytoin,

phenobarbital

Symptom free

1228 38 M Periumbilical pain Confusion, per-

spiration, pallor

NR Diffuse high voltage sharp waves with

hyperventilation

Phenobarbital Symptom free

1328 16 M Upper abdominal

pain, nausea

Disturbance of

consciousness,

convulsions

3–5 minutes High voltage slow waves; high voltage

sharp waves with hyperventilation

Phenobarbital Symptom free

1428 35 M Lower abdominal

pain, nausea,

vomiting

Confusion, loss of

consciousness

Half an hour Paroxysmal high voltage single spike-

wave complexes with secobarbital acti-

vation

Phenytoin,

primidone,

phenobarbital

Symptom free

1528 11 F Periumbilical

abdominal pain

Disturbance/loss of

consciousness

Minutes to

an hour

Bilateral high voltage spikes, complexed

slow waves

Phenytoin and

phenobarbital

Symptom free

1629 31 M Projectile vomiting

without nausea

Unresponsiveness,

(patient also had

separate atonic,

tonic–clonic,

absence and focal

motor seizures at

other times)

NR Bilateral central 16 Hz paroxysmal

sharp waves preceding each episode

Phenytoin,

phenobarbital,

clonazepam

Seizure free

1730 6 M Vomiting Bad smell, fatigue 20–

40 seconds

Ictal and interictal high voltage arrhyth-

mic delta waves, sometimes sharply

contoured

Multiple anti-

seizure medi-

cations, then

surgery and

radiation (for

astrocytoma)

Decreased fre-

quency of epi-

sodes

1824 18 M Epigastric pain Loss of awareness,

staring, elevation of

right arm

NR Left midtemporal spikes NR NR

1924 21 M Sharp abdominal

pain

Loss of conscious-

ness, automatisms

NR Multiple independent spikes NR NR

(continued on next page)

Abdom

inal

epilep

sy267

Page 6: Abdominal epilepsy

Table 1 (continued)

Patient

number Age Sex

Gastrointestinal

symptoms

CNS disturbance

and other non-gas-

trointestinal

symptoms

Episode

duration EEG Treatment Outcome

2024 15 F Abdominal pain Vague ‘head sen-

sation,’ generalized

tonic seizures

NR Multiple independent spikes NR NR

2131 24 F Crampy periumbili-

cal pain, nausea,

diarrhea

Weakness, lethargy,

syncope

10 minutes

to 4 hours

Rare bursts of 14 and 6/s positive spikes

on posterior temporal areas

Phenobarbital Complete res-

olution

2232 10 M Periumbilical pain Pallor, sweats,

lethargy, post-ictal

sleep

Minutes Sharp spikes, and spike and wave activity

arising over the central region and

becoming generalized

Phenytoin Complete res-

olution

232 29 F Diarrhea Confusion, mem-

ory loss, difficulty

concentrating

NR Bursts of spike activity over right

temporal region

Valproic acid Symptoms well

controlled

242 34 F Nausea, bloating Dizziness Several

hours

Bitemporal sharp waves and spikes Carbamaze-

pine

Complete res-

olution

252 38 F RUQ pain, nausea Fatigue NR Bursts of sharp theta slowing over left

temporal area

Phenytoin Complete res-

olution

262 48 F RUQ pain Headaches and diz-

ziness

NR NR Phenytoin Complete/near

complete resol-

ution

272 18 F RUQ pain Confusion NR NR Phenobarbital Complete/near

complete resol-

ution

282 35 F Periumbilical pain Fatigue NR NR Carbamaze-

pine

Complete/near

complete resol-

ution

2933 6 M Colicky periumbili-

cal pain

Lassitude, post-ictal

sleep

Half an hour Generalized slowing, right posterior

spikes

Carbamaze-

pine

Symptom free

268

N.T

.Z

inkin

and

M.A

.Pep

perco

rn

Page 7: Abdominal epilepsy

303 14 F Colicky periumbili-

cal pain

Headache, pallor,

dizziness, multico-

lored photopsia

Seconds to

minutes

Interictal-bursts of sharp and slow waves Valproic acid Near complete

resoluton

Ictal-repetitive spikes, sharp waves,

high-voltage slow waves

3134 26 M Sharp RLQ pain Occasional general-

ized seizures

1–2 minutes Interictal and ictal EEGs normal NR NR

3234 30 M Nausea, crampy

LLQ pain

Pain and numbness

in left arm, alien

hand, occasional

generalized sei-

zures

!30 min-

utes

Right parietal lobe focus Resection of

gliotic scar

from prior

tumor resec-

tion

Rare seizures

3334 1 F Crampy periumbili-

cal pain

Occasional general-

ized seizures

Few seconds Right parietal focus NR NR

3435 66 M Nausea without

vomiting

Disorientation and

confusion, fatigue

1–2 minutes Right anterior temporal sharp waves Carbamaze-

pine

Nausea free

354 37 M Epigastric pain Disturbance of

consciousness,

occasional general-

ized tonic–clonic

seizures

Seconds to

hours

Interictal-epileptogenic focus in left

frontotemporal region

Carbamaze-

pine, then left

amygdalo-

hippo-cam-

pectomy for

mesial tem-

poral sclerosis

Complete res-

olution

Ictal-flattening in same region before

seizure onset

3636 6 F Abdominal pain Disturbed aware-

ness, occasional

generalized tonic–

clonic seizure

Seconds to

minutes

Spike and slow waves over left temporal

area

Anticonvul-

sants, surgical

resection of

oligoastrocy-

toma

Seizure free

NR, not reported.

Abdom

inal

epilep

sy269

Page 8: Abdominal epilepsy

270 N. T. Zinkin and M. A. Peppercorn

DIAGNOSIS

The diagnosis of abdominal epilepsy begins with eliciting a history typical for the syndrome,namely paroxysmal and brief episodes of abdominal pain or other gastrointestinalsymptoms. Chronic symptoms are not consistent with the diagnosis, but even episodes ofsymptoms that last more than a few hours are unlikely to be from abdominal epilepsy. Thepresence of associated neurological symptoms, including convulsions, impaired con-sciousness, and other sensory phenomenon, is an important clue and should be elicitedwhen considering the diagnosis. However, neurological symptoms may not be present withevery episode and, in any event, may not be recognized by the patient.

Next, an appropriate evaluation, including physical and neurological examination,laboratory studies, endoscopy, and abdominal imaging, usually with computed tomographyand ultrasound, should be performed to exclude other, more common etiologies. Wherenone is found, or the history is still suggestive, EEG should be performed to look forabnormalities specific for epilepsy. These so called interictal epileptiform discharges (IEDs)consist of paroxysmal spikes and/or sharp waves. Other abnormalities are either less wellor not at all correlated with epilepsy.37 If clinical and EEG findings are consistent withabdominal epilepsy, imaging of the brain, preferably with MRI, should be performed, sinceseveral cases have resulted from structural lesions of the brain.

It should be noted, though, that while the interictal EEG is usually abnormal, the changescan be non-specific.38 No studies on the sensitivity of EEG for abdominal epilepsy have beenperformed. However, in epilepsy as awhole, the initial EEG will show IEDs in only 29–55% ofcases. The yield can be substantially increased, however, by activation methods such as sleepdeprivation, by obtaining sleep recordings, and by performing repeated EEGs at differenttimes.37 Non-specific abnormalities may warrant further investigation, but they are notsufficient alone to confirm the diagnosis of abdominal epilepsy. Even an EEG recorded duringaneventcanbenormal if there isnoassociatedconvulsionor impairmentofconsciousness.39

In addition, no particular EEG findings will distinguish abdominal epilepsy from other formsof epilepsy. Where doubt remains, consultation with a neurologist should be considered.

DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS

The differential diagnosis will typically include other elusive causes of paroxysmalgastrointestinal symptoms, such as porphyria, familial Mediterranean fever, cyclicalvomiting, and abdominal migraine. The latter deserves special notice because it hasoften been confused in the literature with abdominal epilepsy. Abdominal migraine ischaracterized by recurrent attacks of periumbilical or poorly localized abdominal pain,commonly associated with anorexia, nausea, vomiting, and pallor.40 Headache is not anecessary feature. Although more common in children, it is seen in adults, but itsprevalence in adults is unknown.41 A family history of migraine is common.42

In the years after Moore first fully characterized abdominal epilepsy, some postulatedthat previous cases of abdominal migraine were actually cases of abdominal epilepsy.Moore doubted the very existence of abdominal migraine43, while Prichard suggestedthat abdominal epilepsy could be distinguished from abdominal migraine by the pattern ofpain and EEG findings.14 In practice, they can be difficult to differentiate, but there aresome helpful distinguishing features. In abdominal migraine, the pain is characteristicallymore dull and of longer duration, with episodes usually lasting between 1 hour and 1–2

Page 9: Abdominal epilepsy

Abdominal epilepsy 271

days.41,42 In addition, EEG abnormalities characteristic of epilepsy and a response toanticonvulsant therapy favor a diagnosis of abdominal epilepsy.

PATHOPHYSIOLOGY

Seizures are commonly categorized as either simple partial seizures, where consciousness ispreserved, complex partial seizures, where consciousness is impaired, and generalizedseizures, where consciousness is lost. Seizures can manifest with sensory symptoms, such asstrange odors or abdominal pain, motor symptoms (convulsions), or both. Where sensorysymptomsareassociatedwithan impairmentor lossofconsciousness, thesensorysymptomsare referred to as an aura. Multiple types of seizures may be present in the same person.35

How seizures can induce abdominal sensations has been studied but is still notprecisely known. Stimulation of temporal lobe structures, including the amygdala,hippocampus, and insular cortex, has been shown to induce abdominal sensations,including nausea, hunger, and ‘funny feelings’, in humans.1,44,45 Others have producedchanges in gastrointestinal secretion and motility in animals by stimulation of the limbicsystem.46 Thus, one might postulate that the seizures of abdominal epilepsy areactivating those neurons that ordinarily are responsible for abdominal sensations.

However, some have postulated that the etiology of the abdominal symptoms couldresult from true visceral stimuli which, through connections to the brain, could therebyinduce seizures.2 For example, Gastaut and Poirier reported a case of a 9-year-old boywith seizures, always heralded by attacks of abdominal pain.47 They then experimentallyreproduced these seizures with cold water barium enema, postulating that some casesof abdominal pain associated with seizures could be the results of noxious intestinalstimuli lowering the seizure threshold. However, cases of abdominal epilepsy have beentraced to head injury7, brain tumors30, mesial temporal sclerosis4, developmental braindisorders3, and glial scar34, suggesting that the primary disturbance in at least somecases lies within the brain. While most cases of abdominal epilepsy are of temporal lobeorigin2, several cases have also been traced to parietal lobe lesions.34

Of note, the distinction between ‘abdominal epilepsy’ and other forms of epilepsy maybe overestimated. Painful abdominal auras which then herald generalized tonic–clonicseizures are a well described phenomenon and, like the seizures of abdominal epilepsy,most commonly localize to the temporal lobe.48 Furthermore, many patients reported tohave abdominal epilepsy have associated generalized tonic–clonic seizures, at least at times.Thus, rather than considering abdominal epilepsy to be a separate entity, it may be moreappropriate to simply recognize that some patients will have significant gastrointestinalsymptoms as a manifestation of their seizures. In some, these symptoms may herald theonset of a generalized seizure, where they might be referred to as an ‘abdominal aura.’ Inothers, they might stand alone, or only be associated with some more subtle neurologicalsymptoms, such as confusion or lethargy. In these cases, the etiology of the symptomswould be more difficult to recognize, but the astute physician might still recognize thesyndrome and subsequently make a diagnosis of ‘abdominal epilepsy.’

TREATMENT

Once the diagnosis of abdominal epilepsy is confirmed, treatment can commence aswith other forms of epilepsy. Treatment usually starts with anti-seizure medication,

Page 10: Abdominal epilepsy

272 N. T. Zinkin and M. A. Peppercorn

typically phenytoin. Additional medication can be started in addition to, or in place of,the initial choice of therapy, based on the clinical response. Of note, no controlled trialshave been published regarding treatment of abdominal epilepsy.

It should be noted again that, while helpful for confirming a diagnosis of abdominalepilepsy, a response to therapy alone is not diagnostic. Anti-seizure therapy mayimprove many non-epileptic causes of abdominal pain, either by its sedating effect or asa placebo. Furthermore, some cases of epilepsy, including abdominal epilepsy, can berefractory to medication.4,30 Fortunately, the prognosis is generally good, with mostpatients having dramatic improvement in symptoms with antiseizure medication alone.

SUMMARY

Abdominal epilepsy is an uncommon disorder, more often seen in children than adults,in which gastrointestinal symptoms result from seizure activity. Diagnostic criteriainclude (1) otherwise unexplained, paroxysmal gastrointestinal complaints, (2)symptoms of a CNS disturbance, (3) an abnormal EEG, with findings specific for aseizure disorder, and (4) improvement with anticonvulsant medication. After thesyndrome was initially defined by Moore in 1944, many more cases were reported.However, as authors have more recently adhered to more rigid diagnostic criteria,fewer cases have been described, with only 36 cases reported in the English literature inthe last 34 years. Among these cases, the most common gastrointestinal complaintsincluded abdominal pain, which is typically severe and colicky or sharp, and nauseaand/or vomiting. The most common neurological signs and symptoms includedfatigue and disturbance or loss of consciousness. Evaluation should include a carefulhistory and physical, with particular attention to neurological signs and symptoms, andan appropriate evaluation for more common causes of the symptoms. When otherpathology has been adequately excluded, an EEG should be obtained. The EEG is usuallyabnormal, but the findings may be non-specific. Obtaining sleep, sleep deprived, orserial EEGs may improve the yield, and neurological consultation should be considered.The prognosis is generally favorable, with most patients having complete or nearcomplete resolution of symptoms with anticonvulsant therapy.

Practice points

† abdominal epilepsy is defined by the occurrence of gastrointestinal symptomsas the primary or only manifestation of seizures

† abdominal epilepsy causes paroxysmal, but not chronic, gastrointestinalsymptoms

† common gastrointestinal symptoms include abdominal pain, nausea, andvomiting

† associated CNS disturbances are helpful in distinguishing abdominal epilepsyfrom other causes of abdominal pain

† EEG is crucial in confirming the diagnosis, and consultation with a neurologistshould be considered

† treatment with anticonvulsants is generally effective at relieving bothneurological and gastrointestinal symptoms

Page 11: Abdominal epilepsy

*

*

Abdominal epilepsy 273

REFERENCES

1. Van Buren JM. The abdominal aura: a study of abdominal sensations occurring in epilepsy and produced by

depth stimulation. Electroencephalogr Clin Neurophysiol 1963; 15(1): 1–19.

*2. Peppercorn MA & Herzog AG. The spectrum of abdominal epilepsy in adults. Am J Gastroenterol 1989;

84(10): 1294–1296.

3. Garcia-Herrero D, Fernandez-Torre JL, Barrasa J et al. Abdominal epilepsy in an adolescent with bilateral

perisylvian polymicrogyria. Epilepsia 1998; 39(12): 1370–1374.

4. Eschle D, Siegel AM & Wieser HG. Epilepsy with severe abdominal pain. Mayo Clin Proc 2002; 77(12):

1358–1360.

5. Wallis HRE. Masked epilepsy. Lancet 1955; 268(1): 70–74.

*6. Moore MT. Paroxysmal abdominal pain: a form of focal symptomatic epilepsy. JAMA 1944; 124(9): 561–

563.

7. Moore MT. Paroxysmal abdominal pain: a form of focal symptomatic epilepsy: II. JAMA 1945; 129(18):

1233–1239.

8. Moore MT. Symptomatic abdominal epilepsy. Am J Surg 1946; 72(6): 883–899.

9. Moore MT. Abdominal epilepsy. JAMA 1979; 241(13): 1327.

10. Hoefer PFA, Cohen SM & M GD. Paroxysmal abdominal pain: a form of epilepsy in children. JAMA 1951;

147(1): 1–6.

11. Livingston S. Abdominal pain as a manifestation of epilepsy (abdominal epilepsy) in children. J Pediatr 1951;

38(6): 687–695.

12. Millichap JG, Lombroso CT & Lennox WG. Cyclic vomiting as a form of epilepsy in children. Pediatrics

1955; 15(6): 705–714.

13. O’Brien JL & Goldensohn ES. Paroxysmal abdominal pain as a manifestation of epilepsy. Neurology 1957; 7:

549–554.

14. Prichard JS. Abdominal pain of cerebral origin in children. Can Med Assoc J 1958; 78: 665–667.

15. Sheeby BN, Little SC & Stone JJ. Abdominal epilepsy. J Pediatr 1960; 56(3): 355–363.

16. Schade GH & Gofman H. Abdominal epilepsy in childhood. Pediatrics 1960; 25(1): 151–154.

17. Kajtor F & Kaszas T. Epileptiform EEG changes in the syndrome of periodic abdominal pain. Acta Med

Acad Sci Hung 1966; 22(3): 309–323.

18. Gibbs EL & Gibbs FA. Electroencephalographic evidence of thalamic and hypothalamic epilepsy. Neurology

1951; 1: 136–144.

19. Kellaway P, Crawley JW & Kagawa N. Paroxysmal pain and autonomic disturbances of cerebral origin: a

specific electro-clinical syndrome. Epilepsia 1960; 1(4/5): 466–483.

20. Lombroso CT, Schwartz IH, Clark DM et al. Ctenoids in healthy youths. Controlled study of 14- and 6-

per-second positive spiking. Neurology 1966; 16(12): 1152–1158.

21. Schwartz IH & Lombroso CT. 14 and 6/second positive spiking (ctenoids) in the electroencephalograms

of primary school pupils. J Pediatr 1968; 72(5): 678–682.

22. Aminoff MJ. Electrophysiology. In Goetz CG (ed.) Textbook of Clinical Neurology, 2nd edn. Philadelphia: WB

Saunders, 2003, . 467.

23. Douglas EF & White PT. Abdominal epilepsy—a reappraisal. J Pediatr 1971; 78(1): 59–67.

24. Young GB & Blume WT. Painful epileptic seizures. Brain 1983; 106(Pt 3): 537–554.

25. Mauguiere F & Courjon J. Somatosensory epilepsy. A review of 127 cases. Brain 1978; 101(2): 307–332.

26. Kyosola K. Abdominal epilepsy. Ann Chir Gynaecol Fenn 1973; 62(2): 101–103.

27. Peppercorn MA, Herzog AG, Dichter MA & Mayman CI. Abdominal epilepsy. A cause of abdominal pain in

adults. JAMA 1978; 240(22): 2450–2451.

28. Yingkun F. Abdominal epilepsy. Chin Med J 1980; 93(3): 135–148.

29. Jacome DE & FitzGerald R. Ictus emeticus. Neurology 1982; 32(2): 209–212.

30. Mitchell WG, Greenwood RS & Messenheimer JA. Abdominal epilepsy. Cyclic vomiting as the major

symptom of simple partial seizures. Arch Neurol 1983; 40(4): 251–252.

31. Zarling EJ. Abdominal epilepsy: an unusual cause of recurrent abdominal pain. Am J Gastroenterol 1984;

79(9): 687–688.

32. Singhi PD & Kaur S. Abdominal epilepsy misdiagnosed as psychogenic pain. Postgrad Med J 1988; 64(750):

281–282.

Page 12: Abdominal epilepsy

*

*

274 N. T. Zinkin and M. A. Peppercorn

33. Agrawal P, Dhar NK, Bhatia MS & Malik SC. Abdominal epilepsy. Indian J Pediatr 1989; 56(4): 539–541.

34. Siegel AM, Williamson PD, Roberts DW et al. Localized pain associated with seizures originating in the

parietal lobe. Epilepsia 1999; 40(7): 845–855.

35. Scotiniotis I, Stecker M & Deren JJ. Recurrent nausea as part of the spectrum of abdominal epilepsy. Dig

Dis Sci 2000; 45(6): 1238–1240.

36. Franzon RC, Lopes CF, Schmutzler KM et al. Recurrent abdominal pain: when should an epileptic seizure

be suspected? Arq Neuropsiquiatr 2002; 60(3): 628–630.

37. Walczak TS & Jayakar P. Interictal EEG. In Engel J & Pedley TA (eds.) Epilepsy: a Comprehensive Textbook.

Philadelphia: Lippincott-Raven Publishers, 1997, pp. 831–848.

38. Babb RR & Eckman PB. Abdominal epilepsy. JAMA 1972; 222(1): 65–66.

39. Sperling MR & Clancy RR. Ictal EEG. In Engel J & Pedley TA (eds.) Epilepsy: a Comprehensive Textbook.

Philadelphia: Lippincott-Raven Publishers, 1997, pp. 849–885.

40. Russell G & Abu-Arafeh I. Childhood syndromes related to migraine. In Abu-Arafeh I (ed.) Childhood

Headache. London: Cambridge University press, 2002, pp. 66–76.

41. Abu-Arafeh I & Hamalainen M. Childhood syndromes related to migraine. In Olesen J, Tfelt-Hansen P &

Welch KMA (eds.) The Headaches. Philadelphia: Lipincott Williams and Wilkins, 2000, pp. 517–523.

42. Davidoff RA. Migraine: Manifestations, Pathogenesis, and Management. 2nd edn. New York: Oxford

University Press; 2002.

43. Moore MT. Abdominal epilepsy versus “abdominal migraine”. Ann Intern Med 1950; 33(1): 122–133.

44. Penfield W & Rasmussen T. The Cerebral Cortex of Man. New York: The Macmillan Company; 1950 pp. 77–

86.

45. Jasper HH, Rasmussen T. Studies of clinical and electrical responses to deep temporal stimulation in man

with some considerations of functional anatomy. In: Association for Research in Nervous and Mental Disease,

vol. XXXVI. New York: Hafner publishing company; 1956. pp. 316–334.

46. Anand BK & Dua S. Stimulation of limbic system of brain in waking animals. Science 1955; 122: 1139.

47. Gastaut H & Poirier F. Experimental or reflex induction of seizures: report of a case of abdominal

(enteric) epilepsy. Epilepsia 1964; 5(3): 256–270.

48. Nair DR, Najm I, Bulacio J & Luders H. Painful auras in focal epilepsy. Neurology 2001; 57(4): 700–702.