A. T. Fomenko - Imperija

8/3/2019 A. T. Fomenko - Imperija

1/421

1

. . , . .

. . , . .

, , , , .

1995

1.

1.1. 1.2. 1.3. : 1.4. 1.5. ,

2. 2.1. 2.2.


2/421

2

2.3.

3. 3.1. 3.2. .

4.

4.1. 4.2. "" " - "

5. 5.1. 5.2.

6. . -

6.1. 6.2.

6.3. () . 6.4. 6.5. .

7. 7.1. 7.2.

7.3. : " " .

7.4. 8. .

" "

1

1.

1. 2. 3. - 4.

4. 1. " "4. 2. - ?4. 3.


3/421

3

5. -- " "

5. 1. 5. 2. 5. 3.

( )5. 4.

5. 4. 1. 5. 4. 2. " ()" 5. 4. 3. " " ?5. 4. 4. ""

5. 4. 5. , ,

" "5. 4. 6. -

5. 4. 7.

5. 5. ?

5. 6. -- ?5. 7. 5. 8.

6. ""

2."" XVIII

1. I2. ?

3. I4. . .?5. XVIII - 6. XVIII ?7. ?

3. ()

1. " " 1. 1. 1. 2. ?

2. VIII-XIII 3. 4. - - 5. - " "

6. - XIV 7. ?


4/421

4

8. III () 9.

9. 1. ?9. 2. 9. 3. "" 9. 4.

9. 5. "" XV 9. 6. 9. 7. 9. 8. ?

10.

4.

1. ,

2. 3. () 4. "", ""?5. 6. () 7. () 8. 9. 10. , ?

11. : ?12. ()?13. 14. ?15. -- 16. (") "

2

. .

1. ""

1. 2.


5/421

5

3. 4. "" 60- 5.

2.

1. 2. 3. 4. 5.

5. 1. 5. 2.

5. 2. 1. 5. 2. 2. 1986 ?

5. 2. 3. 1759 ?

5. 2. 4. " " 5. 2. 5. "" 5. 2. 6. 5. 2. 7.

5. 3. V5. 4. - 540

3.

1. 1. 1. ?1. 2.

1. 2. 1. , , 1. 2. 2.

2. 3. - X-XIV

3. 1. 3. 2. 3. 3. 3. 4. 1099 " " 3. 5. () " " XI 3. 6. ""3. 7. " "3. 8. , ""

3. 8. 1. "" , " "


6/421

6

3. 8. 2. "" "" 3. 8. 2. 1. "" 3. 8. 2. 2. 3. 8. 2. 3. 3. 8. 2. 4. "" - 3. 8. 2. 5. "" 3. 8. 2. 6. ""

3. 8. 2. 7. ()3. 8. 2. 8. 3. 8. 2. 9. "-" 3. 8. 2. 10. -3. 8. 2. 11. "" , ,

3. 8. 2. 12.

4. XV . .4. 1. 4. 2.

4. 2. 1. 4. 2. 2. XV 4. 3. 4. 4. ?4. 5. ?4. 6. "" 4. 7. " "4. 8. --

5. "" () 5. 1.

5. 2. 5. 3. () 5. 4. 5. 5. 5. 6. " "? 5. 7. 5. 8. "III "5. 9. 5. 10.

6. 7. , ? 8. XVII 9. 10.

3

()


7/421

7

1. -

. . . ()

1. . -- 2. - "-"?

3. 4. 5. (), , (), ,

5. 1. 5. 2. : , , (), ()5. 3. , ,

6. ? 7.

7. 1.

7. 2. " "7. 3. () -

2. = ""

1. -- "" . 1. 1. "" 1. 2. "" 1. 3. "". 1. 4. ""

1. 5. "" 1. 6. XVI 1. 7.

2. "" ."" -- 3. 4. , XIII-XV

4. 1. 4. 2. ""- 4. 3. "-" ""

4. 3. 1. , "" 4. 3. 2.

4. 4. - ""

5. - XIV-XV

5. 1. () () 5. 2. "" ,


8/421

8

5. 3. 5. 4. .

6. 6. 1. 6. 2. 6. 3. " ()" (???)

6. 4. 6. 5. " " , -""

6. 6. ()() 6. 6. 1. 6. 6. 2. 6. 6. 3. 6. 6. 4. - " ()()"6. 6. 5. ?6. 6. 6 ,

-

6. 6. 7. "" 6. 6. 8. . ?

6. 7. 6. 8. XII-XIV ""

3. .

" "

1. "" ?

2. I ? 3. 4. 5. , , 6. ?7. , 8. , 9. - 10. 11. 12. 13. ()14. () 15. "" () 16. () ""17. " () () "18. " () "19. " "20. " -- "

4.


9/421

9

1. , , , , 2. 3. . , . .

5.

""

1. 1. 1. 1. 2. 1. 3.

1. 4. : , .

1. 5.

2. - .

2. 1. 2. 2. 2. 3. 2. 4. = 2. 5. = 2. 6. = 2. 7.

2. 8. = 2. 9. , ?

3. 3. 1. , , 3. 2. , ()() 3. 3. XIII-XIV . .3. 4. 3. 5. , , 3. 6. () -- XIII-XIV

4. VI-VII . . "" XIV-XV

6.

1. ?1. 1.


10/421

10

1. 2. 1. 3.

2. . . 2. 1. 2. 2. - 2. 3. --

2. 4. 2. 5.

4

.

1. ()

1.

1. 1. . 1. 2. 1. 3. .

2. 2. 1. 2. 2. 1053 2. 3. 2. 4. "" "I"2. 5. 2. 6.

3. 4.

4. 1. , , 4. 2. 4. 3. 4. 4. 4. 5.

5. 5. 1. = ""

6. 6. 1. 6. 2. 6. 3. 6. 4. 6. 5. 6. 6. 6. 7. 6. 8.


11/421

11

6. 9.

2. ()

1. "" 1. 1. -. --

1. 2.

2. X-XIII 2. 1. 2. 2. " "2. 3. -- 2. 4. - 2. 5.

3. -- . . --

3. 1. 3. 2. 3. 3.

4. -- 4. 1. 4. 2. 4. 3. , 4. 4. ? 4. 5. 4. 6. --

5. -- - () ""

5. 1. = "" 5. 2. "" 5. 3. "" 5. 4. , " "

6. -- =

6. 1. = 6. 2. -. 6. 3. "" = 6. 4. , 6. 5. ?

7. -- . .

7. 1.


12/421

12

7. 2. 7. 3. "" = ) . 7. 4. .

3. : , "

" ()

1. 2. 3. -- 4. . 5. , -- 6. , -- 7. -8. , -- 9.

10. , 11. 12. -

4. ,

1. " " 1. 1. 1. 2.

1. 3. 1. 4. 1. 5. XVI-XVII

2. 2. 1. , 2. 2. 2. 3. 2. 4. 2. 5. "" XI XV . .

3. I-III . . III-VI . .

3. 1. -- 3. 2. III 3. 3. 3. 4. = "" IV-VI

4. X-XIII 4. 1. X-XIII -- 4. 2.


13/421

13

5. 5. 1. , , 5. 2. 5. 3. 5. 4. 5. 5. (),

5. 6. 5. 7. , 5. 8.

5.,

? ()

1. 2. 3.

4. , 5. 6. - ?? (??)() 7. 8. ?9. -

6. XV-XVI

1. ,

2. - " ", ?3. - = .

3. 1. 3. 2. "" . 3. 3. = 3. 4. . 3. 5. 3. 6. ,

4. . ,

4. 1. - ?4. 2. : 4. 3. 4. 4. -

5. XIV-XV


14/421

14

6. , , ?

7. 8.

8. 1. XV 8. 2. 8. 3.

8. 4. .

9. -- 9. 1. " -- "9. 2. -- 9. 3. -- , 9. 4. ?

10. 11. ( )

11. 1.

11. 2. 11. 3. "" 11. 4. "" ()11. 5. = 11. 6. , . , 11. 7. 11. 8. = . -- 11. 9.

12. ??

13. , -14. 15. ?

5

- ,

1.

1. , ""2.

2. 1. " " 1617

2. 2. 2. 3. , - ,


15/421

15

2.

1.

2. ?3. ?4. ?

4. 1. ?4. 2. ?4. 3. ?4. 4. ?4. 5. " " 4. 6. " " ""?

5.

6. "" 7. "" "" ?8. ?9. , -, , 10. ""11. " "12.

12. 1. ?12. 2. " -"12. 3. " -"12. 4. "" (""?)12. 5. 12. 6. 12. 7. ""

13. " " 14. ?

14. 1. 14. 2. - -- 14. 3. 14. 4. 14. 5. 14. 6. 14. 7. 14. 8.

15. 16.


16/421

16

3.

1. 2. 3. " "

4. -- 4. 1. 4. 2.

5. ?6. 7. - " " -- 8. 9. " "10. - 11. -(-). ?

12. - 12. 1. -12. 2. - 12. 3. - 12. 4.

12. 4. 1. 12. 4. 2. 12. 4. 3. 12. 4. 4.

12. 5.

6

""

1.

1. 2. 3. "" 4. " " 5. 6. , 7. 8.

8. 1. 8. 2. 8. 3. 8. 4.


17/421

17

9. -- 10. 11. "" 12. "" 13. ?14. , ,

"" ?15. 16.

16. 1. -16. 2. 16. 3.

17. 17. 1. -- 17. 2.

18. "" "" 19. "" 20.

2."" . .

II

1. -1. 1. -""1. 2.

1. 3. 1. 4. 1. 5. ""1. 6. - 1. 7. = 1. 6. 1. 9. " " ""

2. - 2. 1. 2. 2. = = 2. 3. = 2. 4.

3. 3. 1. 3. 2. () --

4. -- -5. -- , = 6. , "" -


18/421

18

7. II -- II8. - II 9. 10. - XIII . .

10. 1. "" 10. 2. - (-) ()

XIII . .

10. 3. () = 1253 . .10. 3. , , IX 10. 4. 10. 5. , -- 10. 6. " " "" 10. 7. "" 10. 8.

3."" XIV . . ()

""

1. "" ()1. 1. ?1. 2. --1. 3. - 1. 4. -1. 5. - -1. 6. ()

2. = ""

3. = 4. "" 5. 6. .

4. XIV -- XVI "" .

=

1. 18- "" 2. (""), 3. I IV

3. 1. I3. 2. IV -- . 3. 3. XIV . .

4. 4. 1. (-)4. 2. 4. 3. ()


19/421

19

4. 3. 1. 4. 3. 2. - 4. 3. 3. - () 4. 3. 4. -4. 3. 5.

4. 4. 4. 5. -- ""

4. 6. ?4. 7. 4. 8. 4. 9. 4. 10. -

5. III II 5. 1. III 5. 2. III5. 3. 1453

6. 7. XV ""

7. 1. III7. 2. III = II7. 3. III = II 7. 4. 7. 5. XV = 7. 6. = 7. 7. , = 7. 8. -

7. 9. 7. 10. () -- -- -- 7. 11. "" -7. 12. ,

8. , , , , 9. I10. -- ()?11.

7

, .

1. .


20/421

20

1. ()2. () = ()3. 4. 5. 6. ?

, "" ? 6. 1. () 6. 2. , 6. 3. : = =

( )6. 4. 6. 5. 6. 6. 6. 7. 6. 8. 6. 9. ""

6. 10. "" ?7. = 8. 9. = = 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. = 15. = 16.

17. = 18. = 19. 20. 21. 22. ()23. 24. 25. 26.

26. 1. 26. 2. ,

27. = 28. 29. 30. 31. 32. = 33. 34. 35. ()


21/421

21

36. 37. 38. 39. 40. =41. 42.

43. ()44. 45. 46. ()47. 48. ()49. 50. 51. 52.

52. 1. , , ?

52. 2. -- ?52. 3. = 53. 54.

54. 1. (), (). -- 54. 2. 54. 3. " " 54. 4. - , 54. 5. -- 54. 6. (),

55. 56. 57. 58. 59. 60. = = 61. 62. 63. 64. "" ?

2..

1. 2. 3.


22/421

22

3. ..

1

1. 2. () 3.

2

3-

1.

1. .

1. 1.

1. 2. . 1. 3. 1. 3. 1. 1. 3. 2. 1. 3. 3. 1. 3. 4.

1. 4. 1. 4. 1. 1. 4. 2. 1. 4. 3.

1. 5. - 1. 6.

2. . 2. 1. . , , 2. 2.

2. 2. 1. 2. 2. 2. 2. 2. 3. 2. 2. 4. 2. 2. 5.


23/421

23

2. 2. 6. 2. 2. 7. 2. 2. 8.

2. 3.

3. 3. 1.

3. 2. 3. 3. 3. 4. 3. 5. 3. 6.

3. 6. 1. 3. 6. 2. 3. 6. 3. 3. 6. 4.

3. 7. .

3. 8. - .

4. .

4. 1. 4. 2. . 4. 3. 4. 4. 4. 5. 4. 6.

4. 7. .

2.

1. 1. 1. 1. 2. 1. 3. 1. 4. 1. 5. 1. 6. " "

???????

2. 2. 1. 2. 2. -. 2. 3. 2. 4.


24/421

24

2. 5. 2. 6. . 2. 7. 2. 8. 2. 9. 2. 10. 2. 11.

3.

3.

1. ?2. 3. 4.

5.

4.

1. 1. 1. ""1. 2. ""

1. 2. 1. 240 800 1. 2. 2. - 1. 2. 3. 750-1750 1. 2. 4. 1. 2. 5. .

1. 3.

2. = 2. 1. "" 2. 2. ""2. 3. ""

3. "1" "2"3. 1. 3. 2. 3. 3. .

4. 4. 1. ""


25/421

25

4. 2. "".

4. 3. 4. 4. ""4. 5. .

5.

3

4

===================================================================

XVI . . - .

. , .-

. . 1979 . , , . , , .

" , " (., , 1995) - "", , . - .

- "". , , XIV , , XVI-XVII ( ) .

:

.

.


26/421

26

.

-- ?

, - .

1958 , - (, 1988), , , , , , . (), - , , .

- , " ".

1945 , (), ( ), ( ), - , , - . ,

. 180 , 24 , , , , , , .

- , .

===============================================================

,

===================================================================

, , . ,


27/421

27

, .

--------------------------------------------------------------

XVI . . , -, .

. , . [1]--[5].

- . . 1979 . , , ., , , .

, .

1995 " , " [5], 1993 "" . , "" . "" . , .

, , , -, . , , = "" -- . , . , .

-, , .

, , -"" -- ,, XIV , .

-"" "", , . , - .

-"" "". , , XIV "" , , XVI-XVII ,

, .

, " " . , [1-5] .

.

-------------------------------------------------------------------


28/421

28

,

. , .

, [1-5] -

.

1) , , 1200 . , , X-XIII . . , , .

2) " ". - XIII , : , , . . - --

, . "" XIII . . = XI-XIII . .

3) "" XIV , . "", - . , -, .

"" , .

, , , -- , - -.

, , "" : --- , , - = - , . ( , --- ).

: , , , , XIX , .

XV . . , . - - - .

XV-XVI . . "" -.

(), .


29/421

29

.

- , , , 1200 , , , - "", - , .

-- . , - -. , , "" --.

, 1200 . . .

, .

1. .

2. .

3. .

4. -- .

.

, -- . . , , - ("") - .

, , . , , , - . , -. , . . , , .

, . , . , . , , .


30/421

30

, . , , . , . " " .

,

, , , . . . , . , . . , , , . , , . , , " ". , "*{", - "}*".

, ., ( ), ( ) ..

-------------------------------------------------------------------

.

, . , , , , , .

, : -1, -2 ..

-- 1. . . . ( , , ).

, - , 1990 , 440 .

, - ,


31/421

31

. , . . ., .

-- 2. . . . (

. .

).

, - - - , 1993 . 408 .

, X-XVI . . , . , . . , - . .

-- 3

A. T. Fomenko, V. V. Kalashnikov, G. V. Nosovski. GEOMETRICAL AND STATISTICAL METHODSOF ANALYSIS OF STAR CONFIGURATIONS. DATING OF PTOLEMY'S ALMAGEST.

CRC-Press, USA, 1993, 300 p.

1995 : . . , . . , . . "". . - , - , 1995.

. . , ""

600-1300 . ., . ., .

-- 4A. T. Fomenko. EMPIRICO-STATISTICAL ANALYSIS OF NARRATIVE MATERIAL AND ITS

APPLICATIONS TO HISTORICAL DATING.

Volume 1. The Development of the Statistical Tools.

Volume 2. The Analysis of Ancient and Medieval Records. Kluwer Academic Publishers. TheNetherlands. 1994.

1 -- 212 .

2 -- 460 .

- . , .

-- 5


32/421

32

. . . ( ? ). .

, - - . 1993, 204 .

, " ".

-- 6. . , . . . , . (. . ).

1. . 382 .

2. , . 290 .

, 1995, - - .

. , --

"- ", , " ", . , - . , .

-- 7. . . . .

, - - . ( ).

. , -

. -- , , -- X-XV . , .-----------------------------------------------------------------

, , " -8".-----------------------------------------------------------------

. . , . , . .

, ...

. . . . , , . .

. . , .

.., .

, .


33/421

33

.

-----------------------------------------------------------------

1) XV-XVI , . , , .

2) XIV-XVI , , -. (1540-1609) . (1583-1652). [1-5], , -, .

, , , .

3) , -- . -- , . . , ,, --

. , , , . . , .

4) -- , . , - , , , . .

, - , , . -- , . , . . , .


34/421

34

5) , - . . - . -, , -- .

: "- ", , "" "" .

. , " " , , () . ! , , .

-- " " .

-- " ". -. , , "", ! , ! -- ,, . .

7) , ,

, , . . , . , , . . .---------------------------------------------------------------

. . . .----------------------------------------------------------------


35/421

35

|==================================================|| || || |====================================================

"" . . , 1980 , . . " ( ? )", , , 1993.

1.

1. 1.

XVI-XIX , , , , , .

, - , , . .

( ) 1050 . . (509 . .) (541 . .)[97], , , , "" .

, , . . , , . : " " [97], . 77.

, , XIV-XVII . (1540-1609) --


36/421

36

" " [97], . 82 (.I. Scaliger, Opus novum de emendatione temporum. Lutetiac. Paris.1583. Thesaurum temporum. 1606), ()(1583-1652) (. D. Petavius. De doctrina temporum. Paris. 1627).

, . : " ,

" [97], . 90, . 1.

" -". , . . " " [97], . 73.

, , , , , ,

, .

, (IV . . .) . . " " ( "") . , , " ( --.) . " [136], . VIII .

, XIV , """" , " , " [136], . XI.

1544 [136], . XIII, , : ?

, -, . -- .

, , " ", .

. (, ) 23 4004 . . . [137]. , " "


37/421

37

. , . : " ... " [97], . 82.

, " ", ,

. ( . .):

5969 (, ; . ),5508 (, ),5493 (, , 5472 5624),4004 (, ),5872 ( 70 ),4700 (),3761 (),3941 (),

5500 ( ),5515 (: 5507),5199 ( )5551 () . . [97], . 69.

-- 2100 . , , 200 (! ) " ".

" " . , " ", "" .

XVI-XVII . .

" , " [138],. 130. , , , . .

, , " ". " -- , ... , ... , -- " [138], . 130.


38/421

38

"" , 196- , . " , , ...... , " [138], . 130.

, , , , . , , "". "" , XVII-XVIII , , , .

XIX

, , XIX . XX , , , , ,, , , , , , , .

, ,

.

1. 2.

, . "" XVIII -- 1701 " ", 20- (, .).

XIX . , , .

, , : " , ,


39/421

39

.

, (509 . . -- .), , ( 673 . . ; 100 -- .).

, 262 . , , (348)" [139], . 876.

. , 500 [139], . 876. , (, IV . .),

, .

, , , . , (, XIII . .) (, VIII . .) 500. :

500 .

500 . ,

. , ? "" -- ? , . , .

" " , " ()". , , "" .

1. 3. :

, . " , ... , , ... , -- . , --


40/421

40

" [142], . 15. , , " "[142], . 107.

, , , . .

, . . " , XIII . . (! -- .). , -- . , -- , III ! " [142], . 61.

, XIX -- XX

, .

1. 4.

. ,, " " , :

, ,

, " " [143], . 13, , 162-165,

[144], . 130,

, . . .

.

-- . , , . "". , XII-XIII . . [141].

, (! ) ,, , [145],. 5, . 360 [146], . 6, . 126.


41/421

41

, , ., ,[147], . 88, 235, 162, 207. :

" ( -- .) (

-- .)... " " [147], . 162.

, " " . . , " " : , , , , [147], . 255. "" (, - , ! ) .

, " -- , ( ? -- .)... , " [111], . 45.

, , [136], . 85. .

, " (

-- .) " [148], . 266,. 14.

, , . - , . , , , "", -- : , , . .

. " , . , ... ... ... XI , , ... " [171], . 117-118.


42/421

42

, , , " ", , .

1. 5. ,

.

: ""? : " " ( ) , , . . , , ,

, , , , " ". "" (, , ) VIII-IX . .

" XII XIII ... : ( -- .) ; . " [149], . 83.

"... ; " [149], . 85-86. , . , " ... - (- ? --.) ... " [149], . 85-86.

" ... " [149], . 87-88. , , -- ( ? ) [147].

, , , " : ... ... , -- , -- . ... "


43/421

43

[150], . 237-238.

2.

2. 1.

?

. " " , ( . .) . " ( 1851-1854 -- .) , ,

... 1851-1854 ... ... " [151], . 12-13.

, , , , ; "" "".

. , 18-19 .

. , ("") , -- , . , -- .. [95], [152]. , " ". 18-19 [95]. , " , " [95], . 55-56.

. , -- "" , "" . . - . , "" , "". .


44/421

44

XX : 200-300 , , , , - , . "" . . , ,

" " .

: , , .

2. 2.

,

, . , , , . " ... , . 300-400 ... . ... , , " [153],. 103.

(, ), " ".

, , : , , , . . [153],. 100-101, 103.

, ( "" ) [153], . 105. .

. " 300 - - . ,


45/421

45

4-10 "[153], . 70. , , .

2. 3.

, . . " . , , . , -- . ,-- . , . ... ,

, , , , . ? , , , . , " [153], . 72.

. .

. : " . (! -- .), , , (, , , -- .), " [96], . 24.

,

, , , " ".

" ( -- .) , , , , ... , , (! -- .)


46/421

46

... " [152], . 104.

, -- , -- , , , .

, .

" , , , , " [96], . 29. , - 2-3 "" ?

, . 1-2

(. ).

" " [154] , : " (! ) , 600 1800 ... , , . , " [154].

" . ... ... , -- . . , -- (, , ? -- .)...

, ... ... , ... ...

-- , . 13, 8, (15, 3), ( ) -- 1200 !

(14, 7) "" 360 ...


47/421

47

, 16, 31, " "-- 600 .

, 17, 4 , "" 1080 ...

, -- . . , --

, , .

: ... , , , !... () 6054 . .- 415 6595 . . - 500 , -- 8610 . . - 610 .

... 2556 ! ...

, , "" "" -- , "" . , - , , , .

( ) -- , !

, -- . . , -- , , .

, "" -- -- . , , ( -- .), "-" , , " [152], . 94-95.

- .

1988


48/421

48

-- . , (I . .), , , . : XI-XIII . . ?

-- .

.

-- , I- . ., XI-XIII . . -- ?

3.

.

3. 1.

. ., , , , , . , .

" , ( -- .) :

1) " , ",

2) " "... " [164], . 39.

. [165]. 1984 1770 . 1988 [166].

- , . . ( ) . , , . . , . ., . ,


49/421

49

XIV . .

. , , , , . , ,

IV . . . ., .

" - . -- , , . , " [168], . 104-105.

" - --... " [168], . 105.

" , , , " [168], . 106.

, , . :

", ,

, , , , , , , " [168], . 106-107.

, , . .

? . . . . -- .

() 3000 . .

. , 946 . . , , 2000 .


50/421

50

XV . ., . , 936 . . , 700.

1225 . . [137], . , 904 . . , 330 . .

, .

( ) 300 ( ). (, , ( 3000 . . ) . 330 :

946 . . 617 . . , 1800 .

. 200 . . . - ( ) . , ,, , , .

3. 2. .

. , [47], . 21-27. .. , -, , . 1728 . 1727 . , " " .

.

. , . (Abbe Conti). , , .

. (M. Freret)


51/421

51

, . G. Gavelier', , . , 1724 . . . 1725 , . , .

. Gavelier . . 27 1725 . . . :

' 'Abrege de Chronologie de M. Le Chevalier Newton, fait par lui-

^-meme, et traduit sur le manuscript Angelois. (With observation by

'

M. Freret). Edited by the Abbe Conti, 1725.

11 1725 . (Transactions of the Royal Society, v. 33, 1725, p. 315), . FatherSouciet 1726 , , .

., , . 1727 , .

" "?

. ?

XVIII . , : " " ., , . . " " " " :

", , ,


52/421

52

, , . - , ,"", "" " ", , , " (. , " ". , - , 1995, . 63).

( ) . ( ). . . , . . , .

4.

. VI . ., . - , . , , . , VI . ., , .

4. 1.

. . (1854-1946) -- -. .

-- -- . I. -- .. . . . , , ,

[53], . 6.

. . . 1881 , , , , ,. 1905 , 25. - ; -- - . .


53/421

53

.

( ) .

1922 . -- , . ., , [53], [155-160].

1907 . " "[161], "" , . 300 ,

() . , .

1914 . "" [162], . , .

4. 2. "" " - ".

, 1924-1932 . "" [163], : " -".

, , ( ) . ,

, , . " ". , , , , .

, , , , "" .


54/421

54

[163] , . , .

.

, , " - (de Arcilla) XVI Programma Historiae Universalis Divinae FloracHistoricae, , , (J. Hardouin, 1646-1724), XVI ... - 1902-1903 " ",

, , -- "[163], . 2, . VII-VIII, .

- (1842-1901), , Rise of English Culture, London, 1904.

5.

5. 1.

(., , [170]) (), [169]. , , : , . . - . , , , ,

, . , . , , . ., , [169].

5. 2.


55/421

55

. . , "".

[163]

, , , , , , , ( ). , " " , , , . , , , .

1) , : , , .

2) , ( 2-3 ). , 2- ( ) , ( ). ,

900-1600 . ., ,

300-1800 . . , 500-1600 . . .,, . , [163], . . [1] , 400-1600 . .

, " ", [163] , 400-900 . . , ( ), (, ) 900-1700 . .

900 . ., 400. . ., [163], , 1300 . . -- .


56/421

56

. . . " ", ., , 1990, [1].

6. .

-

6. 1.

, , , .

. , - , . - , .

. - ,, . ,

. - , , .

. -- .

6. 2.

A B P X, () X(T), T. X(T), X(T).

, T, -- . vol X(T)


57/421

57

X (. 1). Y, , , , . X Y -- .

? - ,

? , . , , .

-- , . , . , . C(T) , T . --" " (. 2). , ,

.

.

, , .

, - M( B . 2), C (T), , "" M

M T. , C (T) -- ,

M, (A, B) M.

, , .

C (T) M (A, B), C(T).

, , C(T) . .

X Y, (A, B), , , (A, B).


58/421

58

X M, C (T). Y N, ,

M, M, C (T).

N

, " "

, (A, B), , .

, vol X(T) , C (T).

M

, vol Y(T) , $C_N(T)$.

C (T) M C(T). , C (T)

N C(T). , vol X(T) vol Y(T) , (. 3).

, , (. 4-). , ,

.1) Y ,

(, ) , (. 4-).

2) Y , , (. 4-).

, . , , X Y, .

, , ( ).


59/421

59

, .

.

, , . , , - , , . , , .

, ,

, .

6. 3. .

, , , , . , , , , .

- , , , , ., , , , .

, , "-". , "" -- , . . . [1] [137]. 17, 1 .


60/421

60

- . -.

(, ),

. - (), -- , () , .

: , - ? , , ?

: - ?

, "-". . [1].

-, , , . , , Q, , .

, Q,

, . , , , , .

: . .

, . . , , .

, - Q. Q-, Q-.

( , ) K(Q, Q).


61/421

61

, . K(Q, T). , ( ), .

, "", -- K(Q, T), Q .

Q . .

- K(Q, T) . Q , Q -- , , (. 5).

( . 5) . . - ,

. [1] . . 5 .

6. 4.

- ( ), .

- - . X(Q) K(Q, T) . K(Q, T) ( Q T) {} n n, n -- . {} , . 6.

-- , -- ; ( ) , .

, K(Q, T). , {} .

s {s} ( s -- , s), , , . 5, {s} . 6.


62/421

62

, , . " " . . 5 [1].

.

Y, , - (, ), , -, . , Y? , , .

. Y , Y - Q.

, . Y. , Y , . , Y.

. . 5 [1].

6. 5. .

, . (, ) , - (). , , , , , . , : Q R. Q R. . , K(Q, T) K(R, T) , . 7.

. , . K(R, T) , X(R) "" -- X(Q). , . 5 , . , , , ,


63/421

63

. 7, "", , ( ), . , ( . .).

. . 5 [1].

. , , . . XIV-XX , .

7.

7. 1.

, ,, , . , . [1]. . ,

. . , .

, , . . 8 , .9 . . , ,

, .

"" . , , , .


64/421

64

7. 2.

, , .

, , 4000 . . 1900 . . , , , ., -. . .

, .

, ,

, , , ( ), , , , .

, " " , , , , .

, , .

7. 3. : " " .

, . . [1], .

-,

. . , , , , -- .

. 9, . , ( )- 13 , -- 4 . .


65/421

65

. , 20-30 , -- 300 . . , 300 550

. . , , , , (. 9). , , , () , , , .

, , 300 550 . . ., , , . .

: , , ,

, .

, , .

, . ( ) - , , , ,

1 2 3 4 . 9, ,

, , , - . , - . .

, - 333 , 1053 , -- 1778.

, " " , , - , .

1 . ( ) 1330, 1050 1800 .


66/421

66

, .

1

,

" ".

: , . . . , .

, , [1]. , , , X-XIII . ., XVI

. . , , . , ( XVI - XVII ..) .

: " ", ?

: - .1

, , " " 2 3 4 . . ,

1 , (), " " ( ), .

7. 4.

, .

XIII . ., , , .

, . " " -


67/421

67

, , 2 3 4 330, 1050 1800 . .

, . . . , . ., . . XVII . .

. ., , "" "" , X-XVII . . , X . . "" , X-XVI . . , " " , , ,

.

" " , . "" ( ) IX-X . . ( ), -- VIII-IX ( --).

8. . " "

- . , , , . , "".

1980 1. . .

// . -- . : . -- 1980. -. 15. -- . 99 -- 124.

2. . ., . . -


68/421

68

. -- . : . "" (). -- 1980. -- .1 -- 36.

3. . . // . . -- . : - -. -- 1980. -- . 161 -- 166.

1981 4. . .

// 3- . -- . :- . . -1981. -. 2. -- . 211-212.

5. . . // . -1981. -- . 258, N 6. -

. 1326 -- 1330.6. . . // . -: - . . -- 1981. -. 63. -. 136-150.

7. Fomenko A. T. The jump of the second derivative of the Moon'selongation// Celestial mechanics. -1981. -V. 29. -P. 33-40.

8. . . -

. (). -- . : . . . -- 1981. -- . 3672. . 9/XI -- 81 .N 7201. . 1-100.English translation: Fomenko A. T. Some new empirico-statistical methods of dating and the analysis ofpresent global chronology. -- 1981. -- The BritishLibrary, Department of printed books. Cup. 918/87.

1982 9. . .

// . -- . : - -. -1982. -- . 20. -- . 98-113.

11 . ., . . - // -. . XV. , . -- . : - -. -- 1982. -. 576. -- . 24-43.


69/421

69

1983 12. . . -

// . -- 1983. -- . 268, N 6. -- . 1322-1327.

13. . . //

. -- . : - . -- 1983. --. 21. -- . 106-152.14. . .

// . -- . : - . . -- 1983. -- . 86-109.

15. . ., . . // . . -- . : . -- 1983. -- . 101-107. --English translation: Fedorov V. V., Fomenko A. T.

Statistical Estimation of Chronological Nearnessof Historical Texts // Journal of Soviet Math. -1986. V. 32, No. 6. -- P. 668-675.

16. . . // . -- 1983. -- N 11. -- . 85-92.

17. . . // . -. : - -. -- 1983. -- . 21. -. 40-59.

18. . . // . -- . : - -. -- 1983. -- .22. -- . 40.

1984 19. . .

// -- . : - -. -- 1984. -- . 24. -. 49-66.

20. . . - // .

. -- . : . -- 1984. -- . 154-177.21. . .

// " ".


70/421

70

-- . : - . . . --1984. -- . 135-136.

1985 22. . .

// :

. . . .

-- . : . -- 1985. -- . 49. -- . 335-342.23. . .

// 4- . -- . : - . . -- 1985. --. 3. -- . 246-248.

24. . ., . . //

. -- . :- . -- 1985. -- . 22. -- . 119-131.

1986 25. Fomenko A. T. New empirico-statistical dating methods and

statistics of certain astronomical data// . .-- . : . -- 1986. -- . 2. -- . 892.

26. . ., . .

// . -- . : . -- 1986. -. 107-129.

27. . ., . ., . . // . . -- . : . -- 1986. -- . 33-45. -

1987 28. . .

// . . -- . : .-- 1987. -- . 115-128.

29. . ., . . "" ( "" XVI -- XVII .)// . -- . : - . . -- 1987. -- . 163-181.

30. Fomenko A. T. Duplicates in mixed sequences and a frequencyduplication principle. Methods and applications//Probability theory and mathematical statistics.


71/421

71

Proceedings of the Fourth Vilnius Conference(24-29 June 1985) -- VNU Science Press, Utrecht,Netherlands. -- 1987. -- V. 1. -- P. 439-465. -

1988 31. . ., . .

//

. -- . :- . -- 1988. -- . 23. -- . 104-121. -32. . ., . ., . .

// . . -- . : . -- 1988. -- . 59--78.

33. Fomenko A. T. Empirico-Statistical Methods in OrderingNarrative Texts// International StatisticalReview. -- 1988. -- V. 56, No. 3. -- P. 279-301.

1989 34. Fomenko A. T., Kalashnikov V. V., Nosovsky G. V. When was Ptolemy's star catalogue in "Almagest" compiledin reality? // Preprint. No. 1989-04 / ISSN 0347 --2809. Dept. of Math. Chalmers Univ. of Technology,The University of Goteborg. Sweden.

35. . ., . ., . . , "". -- .

. 1989, . 3, , , . 271 -- 272.36. . ., . .

. - . . 1989, . 4, , . . 111 -- 112.

37. . ., . . . -- . . ., . . 1989. . 161 -- 180.

38. . ., . . . -- . . . 1989 . "". .. 138 -- 148.

39. . ., . ., . . . -- . 1989. . 307, N 4. . 829 -- 832.


72/421

72

English translation: Fomenko A. T., Kalashnikov V. V.,Nosovsky G. V. Dating the Almagest by variable starconfigurations. -- Soviet Phys. Dokl. 34, 1989, No. 8,pp. 666-668.

40. Fomenko A. T., Kalashnikov V. V., Nosovsky G. V. When was Ptolemy's Star Catalogue in Almagest compiled in Reality?Statistical Analysis. -- Acta Applicandae

Mathematicae. 1989. v. 17, pp. 203-229.41. Fomenko A. T. Mathematical Statistics and Problems of Ancient Chronology. A new Approach. -- Acta Applicandae Mathema-ticae. 1989. v. 17. pp. 231-256.

42. . ., . . ( ). -- . ., . 1989. . 112-125.

1990 43. . ., . ., . .

. -- ",. ". . 23, 1990. . - "". . . 78 -- 92.

44. . ., . ., . . "". -- ,. 313, N 6, . 1315 -- 1320.

45. . . . -- - "". .1990. : . . ,, . . 7, . 1 -- 45.

46. Fomenko A. T., Rachev S. T. Volume functions of historical textsand the amplitude correlation principle. -- Computers

and the Humanities. 1990, vol. 24, pp. 187-206.47. . . . ( , , ). -, - , 1990.

48. Fomenko A. T., Kalashnikov V. V., Nosovsky G. V. Statisticalanalysis and dating of the observations on which Ptolemy's"Almagest" star catalogue is based. -- In: Probabilitytheory and mathematical statistics. Proc. of the FifthVilnius Conference. 1990. Moklas, Vilnius, Lithuania:VSP, Utrecht, The Netherlands, vol. 1, pp. 360-374.

1992 49. A. T. Fomenko, V. V. Kalashnikov, G. V. Nosovsky. The dating of

Ptolemy's Almagest based on the coverings of the starsand on lunar eclipses. -- Acta Applicandae Mathematicae.1992, vol. 29, pp. 281-298.

1993 50. A. T. Fomenko, V. V. Kalashnikov, G. V. Nosovsky. Geometrical and


73/421

73

Statistical Methods of Analysis of Star Configurations.Dating Ptolemy's Almagest. -- CRC Press. 1993, USA.

51. . . . . ( . . ).-- , - - - ,1993.

52. . . . ? " "? -- . . "". , - . -. - ,1993, . 288-394.

53. . . . . ( ? ). . --, - - - ,1993.

54. . . , . . . ? -- . .

( ? ) -- ,- . -. - , 1993, . 156-166.

55. . . , . . . . -- . . ( ? ) -- ,- . -. - , 1993, . 167-197.

1994 56. A. T. Fomenko. Empirico-Statistical Analysis of Narrative

Material and its Applications to Historical Dating.Volume 1: The Development of the Statistical Tools.Volume 2: The Analysis of Ancient and Medieval

Records.Kluwer Academic Publishers. 1994. The Netherlands.

57. . . , . . . . -- . . 34, 1994, . 205-233, ,.

1995 58. . . , . . .

, . 1: . 2: .-- , 1995, - - .

59. . . , . . , . . . "". . -- , - "",


74/421

74

1995.

1'1'1

1.

1

" , ! -- , , ! , , . , ,

! ". " ". [80], . 6.

1.

1995 .~.~ . . " , ". 1 -- . 2 -- , . . [5].

. , .

[1-4] "", , ,, . .


75/421

75

, , , . , , . --

. [1], [2], [3], [4], [5] , " ", . , " " .

, "" . . . . , ,

.

"". " ": , . . [1-5], "" : , X XVII . .

X-XIII ,--

, -- () XIII-XVII ., , , - .

. . . [1].

XIV-XVI . . , - , [5] .

, , XVI . . ( ). . [1-5].

IX-X . . , 300 , -- X XIII , -- " ".


76/421

76

, , -- XIII XVII . . [5].

, [5].

() " " , [5], 1613 1917. .

1'1'2

2. .

, , , [5].

. , . , " ".

--

- . , (? ? ), , , .

XIII , -- , , , , . [5], [124], -- , , . ,

.

, , XVII , , . , - ,--- , , XVI , [5].


77/421

77

, , XII-XIII . ., , [8]. . " " , 1989 .

, " ", -- , - ,

.

. ?

: . , . . ,, . . " " [8].

.

, -- . , -- .

, ,-- - , -- -. XVII . : , , .

. , XIX "" "" . , . : " (), (: )" . . -- . [21] "".

, -- . , - [178], . 409. , -- ,-- , , - [82], 1, . 227-228.

, , " (Erdinidsu) 1585 ( - - .) " [82], 1, . 228. , XIX , . , , [82], 1, . 228.


78/421

78

-- , , - , .

.

. [5].

1) "- " . .

2) - = , -- , , .

3) , , , () , . .

4) - XIV XVII . XVII . , -- "", -- .

- "". - . ().

5) " ", . - .

. -- . , . , - -- , "". -, -- , -- .

" ", , -- . "


79/421

79

", -- , , -- . , -- .

, " ", , , - =

. .

1'1'3

3. -

"". , -- [124], -- -- , "". - = . "

" -- " ". , [5].

"" -- -. .

, "-" .

" , ,

. ", -- , -- , , , , , : , , " " [8], . 31.

" " [8], . 22.

" , ... " [8], . 39.

" , ... ... , , . ... (! -- .) ,


80/421

80

" [8], . 40-43.

-- .

, , "- " -- . ,

- . - "", , , : " , " . . , " " .

, , " -"[8], . 35.

,

-, " " = , , , -- , - -- .

, , "" .

, , , " (- ! -- .) .

, . , " [8], . 36.

.

, . ."" , -- , , -- . , .

: - . = : . . -- .

""


81/421

81

. , -- . . , , . -- , [8], . 30. ..[124], "

". , -- "" "".

, , XIX "". -- . -- "" .

" 25 , 400 ... ,

... , , " [8], c. 42.

. - , : , . . "", , , , , ,

, . ., ""

, " -" [8], c. 35.

: "-" -- , , XVI . XVI "" "".

-, -- , 967 . ., -- " " : " , . (: -- -- .)... ... (? -- .) ( ? -- .)" [9].

: " ,


82/421

82

, - " [8], . 8.

: " "" , " [8], . 17.

" XII , " "... "[8], . 16.

. . [5].

" " , " , . "[8], . 33.

, " , , ... , ( , , -- .). " [8], . 33.

, , - . , ,

, " " , , ?

, -- . , , , "" [68], . 534. : = .

, -- "" = . "". , = , , .

1'1'4

4.


83/421


84/421

84

(1735-1800) -- ,; 1761 1767 . 1769 - ( 1768 ). . [60], . 1511. , , "

" [123], 2, . 7. . .

(1705-1783) -- . -- 1725 . " ( ? -- .) ( )" [60], . 803.

(1694-1738) -- ,, 1725-1738, " " [60], c. 100.

, -- . ,, , , .

: ? ? ?

.

, .

"" -, , - . , , , -- . . , , , [77], 1, . 54.

" ... ""... , "" ... "" ... , , ( -.), , - "" , ( , , -- .) ... " [77],


85/421

85

1, . 56.

[77] " " " . . . , "" " , , , ... " ,

( -- .) , ". , , , "" " " " [77], 1, . 56.

, , "" .

, "" - ,

. " "" 1746 ., ... "[77], 1, . 59.

, "" " ", . "" , ( ) : " " [77], 1, . 108. ,, -- -

. "" , :

" XVIII , , , " [77], 1, . 51.

, , -- , , XVIII . , " , " [77], 1, . 53.

. , " ( ) , " [77], 1, . 53.

""


86/421

86

, "-"?

-- . , XIV-XVI , " , " [77], 1, . 53.

, XVIII , . , XIV-XVI , , = , , , -.

.

.

.

, , -- -- , - "".

, , " " , [5]. -- --

. . , -.

.. :" -- ( ---.) ... ... , ... ... , ... --- "[6], . 120.

, --- . . . , , --- "" .

4. 3. .

[6], . 188-191:


87/421

87

) XVII , .

) XVIII , ,

, , . ! , , , "" . , - . -- , -- " "- I.

1'1'5'1

5. -

" "

5. 1.

" , ... -, , -- XIII " [89], . 3.

( ) " ". , . " " .

" " 1989 [89], . 3. , -- . ," 1767 , ( -- .)...

, , . .... 1902 ... ... ( )" [89], . 3.

1989 , , 38- , . . " " 1841 [60], . 1028.


88/421

88

1841 1921 24 . 27- 1949 , . 40- . 38- .

?

, , , ,, -, , , , , .

, . 200 .

, ,

, . , , [25], . 540. . XVI. -- , XVII [5].

?

,

, . -- 9 , 1567 [60], . 718. , , 16 , . , .

? , , 3000- , , .

5. 2.

[89], . 3.

, ,-, . , -- XVIII.


89/421

89

.

, [123], 2, . 5-6, , -- , , -- 1711 ,"

. 1711 " [123], 2, . 6.

, , XVII . 1711, [123], . . , XVII [123], 2, . 5.

, 1758 , (1756-1763 ) , [123], 2,. 3.

" 1761 ... . -. " [123], 2, . 6-7. , 1802-1809 [123], 2, . 7.

, , - . " 1812 " [123], 2, . 7.

, - , -- , [123] ,-- " . . ... 1814 . . , , , " [123], 2, . 7.

. , . " . . "[123], 2, . 7. , , 3 , , . . - .


90/421

90

.

- , [123] - . . - , ( ) .

: , ? .

5. 3.

" ", - , -- XV , , , , ,

, -- [89], . 3. .

, XV, XVIII .

, . , "a", "b" "c". , -- , - . [89], . 3.

, XVIII . , XV . XVII , , - .

, , -- , , XV , -- - -. , --

. .

, . . , "- ... , , . 236 239-243, 237,238, 244 " [89], . 3.


91/421

91

, [123], ( 236) -- -, .

, - , .

-- . ?

, .. .

, - , XVIII .

XVIII , 1711 . . .

, - , , XVIII , , -- . - " " .

1'1'5'4

5.4.

5.4.1.

, XVIII . . .

.

: " 32 , 28 8 , 6 ( 1--6 242--247), 10 ( 232--241) 4 ( 248--251)" [89],c.4.

, , , . --- , , . .


92/421

92

. , --- . 4 , 8 . , .. :", " [130],.4.

,

, . , 4, 6, 10 .

. 8, 6 --- , --- . 6-- , 8-- .

5.4.2. ""

. , , : 4, 6 10. . .

, .

--- 1, --- 251. , . , . , ,

[123]. ?

, --- , , --- . , . --- , . . , . , .

, , -- . ? ?

, . --- ? ,


93/421

93

--- .

, - , . , , --- - . ,

.. , ?

--- . ? .

, - .

.

, 6 , 28 8 , --- 30- 10 . , 1- 10- --- 232. , 29 231. . , - 29 .

3- 28- .

8-, , . [123], , .

, .

--- , . .

, ? --- .

, , , , . : , . .

.. : " , , -


94/421

94

, . 5 (- ""- .) 32 ( - --- 33-- .), 9 (- "" --- .) --- 64-(65- - --- .) . , 8 " [130],.4.

, 33- - --- 5- . 65 - --- 1- 9- . . , , , - 8 -, .

.

- 8 . - 16 . ,

. 2- , ., .

, 6 , , . , , . , ? . , , -. --- .

.

.1 - . , ----, --- - . - , "".

, - , , : 10-, 11- 12- - , -. , . - 9, 10 11.

- 12. -- "", "i".


95/421


96/421

96

= .

11, - - 12.

, , : " ,

, , , ..." [89],.18 [123], 11,. .

12 (=- 13) : " -, -...".

, . "..." - 13- ,

" -". " -" --- .

, "" . , , - . :" -".

, , .

, --- . . .

- 9. - 9 - 10. . . .

, -, , - . --- - 9 8.

, , . . , --- . . .2.

. ? - ? ?


97/421

97

5.4.3. "" ?

, . --- .

XIX . , . . , -.

, --- --- , , , - , .

,

: , , --- . .

.

- 9, 8, .

: -. .

, -, , .

: , , , . "" . " " .

, --- . , , "" . - "". , "" .

" " . , XIX , ,


98/421

98

, . !

, " " . , -, "". , .

--- .

.. --- . - . " ". " 3 , . , --- ... --- .., --- 1818 .... , "...

, ." [13],.15--16.

, . .

- ! - ? ? .

5.4.4. ""

, " " [60], .100. , "" . - , ( ) , -, , (= ) , - .

, --- , = , --- = ( ) .

, , "".

"" , , [5]. "", .


99/421

99

" ".

. , , [60], .100. " ", --- , " ", --- , . - .

, . , , , .. [179] .

, "" . , - , "" . , , : - " " .

, , , . .., " ( .. --- .) ...

, --- .., --- -, , -, . " [131],.129--130.

.. ,, [131],.120.

.

" " , XVIII , --- .., --- . "". "" . . --- .

. 1767 , , , , I 1716 [130],.14. ..,


100/421

100

. , . , .. [130],.13--14.

1902 . - , ,

. . " " --- . . , " ".

87 .

. 1989 . , . . , , .

.

1989 .

1995 [123].

, " " - .

.

5.4.5. , , " "

8 - 9, . . [123].

, ,

XVIII [89],.15, ."--",

XIX , [123], 2, .22,

XX [123], 2, .22.


101/421

101

: "... " [123], 2, .22. 1767 , , , ", --- , --- , , .." [89], .3.

, , .

[123] .

, , . , . .

= . , , .

. .

" , , , : " ". . , , .

, " [123], 2, .22--23., , ? ?

. .

, - , , , .

"" .

" ", [123]. [89].

?

, . " "


102/421

102

.

, , :

" 6360, 8, , . , ,

( ? --- ? --- .), , ,

2242,

1082;

430;

601;

448;

318;

333;

318;

542,

, , 29;

, 1 31;

1 83;

1 28;

8;

37;

40;

85;

60... "[89],.15.


103/421

103

, .

, " " . . ,

.

"" . , " ". , . , , , .

, , --- .

. . , XVIII . --- . , --- , . , --- .

" " . . : " ". , , ""

" " --- - . " " . --- . , "".

5.4.6. -

. , -, --- , .. : " . , - ... " [130], .44.

.

, , [130],.45. ,


104/421

104

- ., ""., .

, - "" .? XVIII ? , -, ,

- , .

, "- , " [130],.46. , , , --- .

, "- ... "[130],.46. , ,

.

--- " ".

.

" ", , , . , .

5.4.7.

, , , , --- , , , .., --- , . , , . . [123].

, - "" . ... . . .. , . , , , , , .. --- , ( ) , - .


105/421

105

(.1).

, XVIII , , , , . ""

XVII ( , " "), - . "".

1'1'5'5

5. 5. ?

, - . , , . " , , " [123], 2, . 5.

= , , XVIII .

: ?

, , XV [123], 2, . 300.

, ., .

.

XV

XV . , , = = = , =-, .. [5]. .

.

= . , ,


106/421

106

. , , . .

-, , .

, , XVII-XVIII .

5. 6. = ?

, , - [123], 2, . 300. . 4 "

... , -- (? )" [123], 2, . 304.

, . -- . . , -.

, , ,

[123], 2, . 300.

.

. [5], . [123], 2, . 300 , , -- [5].

( )

, XV . . [5]. . = .

, -" ". . , -- . , XV .


107/421

107

. . .

5. 7.

,

1711 I, . .

, . , [123]. , , , . " " [123], 2,. 5. . .

-, , , .

, 107 , - 118, -- , , , [89], . 4.

, ,

, - . . , .

, -- .

. , . , . . ,

= . . = .

.

107 , . . , ,


108/421

108

XVIII .

.

, , . , . .

, , , "" .

-- .

5.8.

, , "" .

XVIII ,-, I . , ,- , XV-XVI . , .

"" XVIII - , "" XVII . () - , . " ". .

" "

. " " - -:, , . , "" , .

, "".

, ,


109/421

109

"". - ,- . , , "" "" . "" , , .

, .

, - . . .

, , .

1'1'6

6. ""

, [5], . , . , "". "" . " ", "" . .

, ,

. - , . . "" , "" , . . .

, "" "" , ,-. , ,

"" . "" = "". , , "".

, , , "" --


110/421

110

, , .

, , . , -- .

. , , ""= . , - .

, . . , ,

.

"" = -. , [5]. -- . , , , -- . , , "" .

,

, .

1'2'1

2. ""

XVIII .

1. I.

, , 1994 . . , .

. . , , -


111/421


112/421

112

: -- , , , XVIII .

. , XVIII .

" "? "" , , , XVIII , - . , , , XIX . ?

: -- , .

, , "" [5]. , -, .

, , -- , -- .

1'2'2

2. ?

" ", : Moskowiae PARS. . [66] . 1.

, PARS, , .

*{ , , "" . , "" -- "".

, . , , , . . [1, 4, 5].

, -- , -- -- -, -, -, . }*

, 1702 -- Zee Paless Meootiss, ,


113/421

113

. , XVIII I .

, -- 1699-1700 . . [66] . 2.

. . , , .

. .

3. - I

, XVIII [66] --

XVII-XVIII , , -- -. , , I -. --- , , - .

- -, . , - , , . [5].

-- - , - . -- , , "". , - (). - .

- -- . , - .

1'2'4

4. . .? ,

. . [66] . 3.

, 1741 1762 , -- . .

:


114/421

114

". ... 740- ... 750 . " . [66].

, , XVIII 1740

1750 740 750 . , : 740 -- , 750 -- . , XVIII , VIII . . . " " -- 1000 . .

. . [1] . 1, "", I, "" (I). I , . , I , . I , XI .

, I. 740 " 740", 740 . ,

- I .

-- " 1750 . ". . [66] . 4.

1750. , -- . , 721 , - , 743 . "" .

, , "" , "". , "", "" "" . , . . , "" "" .


115/421

115

" 1701 . -- . , I". . [66] . 5.

, , .

" ". . , , , . - .

1'2'5

5. XVIII -

XVIII -- [64], [65]. " " , .

1755 "Cartede divifee en fes Principaux Etats". . . 6.

-- Russie , -- -- Moscovie. , ,

, . Gouvernement de Moscow.

, -- , , -- . , - , - = . "" = .

: Gouv-T de KIOWIE, " "., XVIII . , , "". , -- .

, , , - -


116/421

116

.

, , -- Petite Tartarie. , " " -- CosaquesZaporiski. , .

, -- .

, XVIII .

-- Konigsberg -- Dantzick RUSSE, . , -- PRUSSE. RUSSE. P.

, .

, Russie Noire -- Lemberg'. , .

1754 : "III-e Carte del'Europe 1754". . [64], [65] . 7.

: , , . -- , -- , - , -- , -- 75- , -- .

1'2'6

6. XVIII ?

, - 1480 III . , , , 240 , . -- , , "-".


117/421

117

. , - , .

?

-- XVIII ? -- .

, "" , -- .

.

XVIII "".

XVIII - ?

. .

1754 "I-e Carte del'Asie". . [64] . 8. , -- , , . ., -- "Emperie Russienne".

:

GRANDE TARTARIE,

. , = ,

-.

, -.

,

= -

.

?


118/421

118

, "- " -- 300 . , "-" ?

. ""- -- - -- , XVII . , -- [5] " ", -- " ".

, " -,

". "" = .

, , .

, ""- - . - .

,

. , , . , , . , , - Emperie Russienne GRANDE TARTARIE.

- . " ". "-" . , : - - . , "-" , ,-, .

XVIII .

.

, , " " -- "Cartede l'Empire de Russie en Europe. 1755". . [64] . 9.

GRANDE


119/421


120/421

120

1) , XIX

.

-: .

2) ,

. , - = - .

. . .

" 1240 ... , , , = ,

( ). , . .

( "" -.) XIX . - XVII , . , .

, " [28], . 5.

?

.

" XIX , ., , "", - ( ), - " [28], . 5.

.

, , -.


121/421

121

. 2, :

Russia Alba sive Moscovia,

" ". - :

" ".

[29]. . [28], . 9. - .

, , "", 1240 , , , -- . 1240 -

, -- "" .

, -, " ", . , . . [27].

1'3'1

3.

" . . ( ). :

,, , "". . . . ., 1834, . 6.

1. " "

1. 1.

, , -- , .

, .


122/421

122

XIX . . :

" ( ) , , : , , ,

, , . , , : ...

-- , -- ( XVI ). , ... , , , " [54], . V-VI.

: " , , " " ( ): . . , , ?... , ( ): , , . . : , , (-), ? "[54], . VII-VIII.

" 1780 :

) ,B) ,C) ,D) ,E) " [54], . VIII.

, " " , , XVI . .

: [54], . 2, ,, [54], . 73-74.

" , : , ... " [54], . 6.

, .

. , (


123/421

123

) -

.

. . : " . . ( ) . : " , " " [54],

. 6.

, [5] - .

, " " (. 1). , , " , XIV , . . " [54], . 4-5.

, -- : - -- .

.

?

" ( -- .) (, , [5] - -- .): "

". " [54], . 5.

?

, . ? -- ? ? -?

[5], -- . , ,-. . -.

1. 2. ?

,


124/421

124

X . . -- X , XI XII .

. . :" XII XIV " [18], . 186. XIV [18], . 186.

, . . . [17], . 93.

. 2.

, . . , ". . "" XI" [18], . 182. ,

, -- X . " ", , , .

, , " ".

, , "" . , , , - . , -- , -- : , .

, - .

, -- , -- .

" , , "" (, , , ), . 30-40- XII , -- . "" -- XIV " [18], .182.

" " - , , - "" XIII , 1223 .


125/421


126/421

126

, , , , , , , . , .

,

. -- X-XI . ?

. , , . , . " ".. . : " XI "

[17], . 53.

, -- , -- , , . , , , , ? - .

-- , - . -- , ,

. ,

, -- .

. . , , . . , -- , -- . "", . , , , .

XIV , "".

: " XIV ... - " [17], . 78.


127/421

127

1360- 1370- (1359-1389). (1389-1425).

[17]. -- XIV . ?

, , . , , , -- . . .

, , . . .

, . -- . . , . . . , , .

.

XIV . .

, . . X-XI . . . . [1].

XIV-XVIII I .

- X-XI [5].

, - XIV XVII .

, : , . .


128/421


129/421

129

-- XIII . , "" XIII-XVI , VI-VIII .. . 4.

.

1. , VIII-XIII .

2. .

3. . .

, -- . .

I-VIII

XIII-XVII .

-. :

-- X-XI .

, , XIII-XV

.-,

-. . . . .

, : " XIV-XVII " [18], . 165. : " ( X -- .) -- ,, ... " [18], . 231.

3.

,


130/421

130

1472 [18], . 54. .

III 1497 . 1472 III . , , .

, . . , : " . . XIV , 1472 " [18], . 54.

. .

. . , - , .

" XIV : , , - (1339-1357) , 1358-1380 ... (! -- .) -- ...

(! -- .), ... , . , III " [18], . 54.

, . . "" .

, .

1) XIV .

2) , -, , . , -- . -- =- [5].


131/421

131

3) , = . .

4) -, -, XIV (1339-1357). , [5], ,

I (1328-1340). - , -- -, = John = = . , .

4. - -

. , , .

" , ... 1375 , ... ... ( XVIII )... , ( ) " [18], . 158.

, . = "" = . , " ".

.

, , - .. . : " , 1530- , -

.

, -- , -- - , "". -- "" (! -- .) ...


132/421

132

, , . , XVI , , " [18], . 160.

. . ?

. , ,

. , .

, , , -- .

, , "",

, , -- , - , .

-, "" -- ( "") -- , . , . . [23].

1'3'5

5. - ""

. . : " - , , , , ... , ,

" [17], . 96.

, , . , , " III, , ,


133/421

133

: " ", ""()" [17], . 96.

: " , " [54], . 59.

, ,

III, IV, XVI . . . , -- . .

(? ) " " . , , -.

, " - REX, -" [54], . 61. , -[54], . . , ? - . , , [54], . 61.

" " . , . , , " ,

-". [54], . 61, , XVI .

, . ,, "" , , "" -- (? ), [54], . 120.

, "" ( , ) [17, 54].

: , " " ? , , , . [5] , " ".


134/421

134

[5]. .

, . -, , . ? .

, , XIV-XV [17], . 97. " ( -- .) (? -.) , (? -- .) , , (! -- .)" [17], . 97.

.

, -- , -- , ? .

, , , - .

, XIV-XV .

: " : , -- " [17], . 97.

, : - XIV-XV .

" ; , , ""... "[17], . 98.

. " , , , : " ( -- . . ) "... " [17], . 98. - , . ?


135/421

135

-- .

. " "" :" "... " [17], . 98.

. " (! -- .)

III " [17], . 98.

, XIV-XVI . ?

"" - . - = , , - .

: " : - , " [17], . 99.

-- ? III " 12-

, , , , . ... , .: 12 150 . , , , ... " [54], . 48.

. , . , .

, XIV-XV , , ,, , .

, -- -- XIV .


136/421

136

: " : XVIII ! " [17], . 104.

: , , .

1'3'6

6. - XIV

-. . . " " " , XIV , "[79], . 33.

?

, " ( -- .) ... " " " " . , ... , "79], . 33.

, "" "" - . . . , "

, ; -- "[79], . 33.

"", -- , - . , , , .

.

" , , - " [79], . 33. - [79], . 33.

, "" -- . , .


137/421

137

, -- . .

.

, . ,

-- , . -- , .

7. ?

.

, ? ,

.

, , - , . , " " .

. : " (-), , ,... -, ; . -" [79], . 33.

, - -.

, [79], . 24.

"" "" . -, .

8. III

- , , , .


138/421

138

, , " III -- . ( ). - " [17], . 109.

.

, .

: , XIV-XV - ="" ?

, ,

, , -- .

, , - XIII . , , 1241 , = IV [19], . 8. .

, , -, -- XIV . , - "" ="" .

, , , . - , -- = "".

-- .

- .

1'3'9


139/421

139

9.

9. 1. ?

, -

" ", -- "".

, , . . , - . , .

.

, . - , " " .

9. 2.

" ". , "

" , .

, , . . [18], . 8. : , " " [18], . 8.

, .

, . . . .

.

, , , , . "" ,


140/421

140

, .

, , , . . ,

, .

, " ", -- . .

9. 3. ""

. , . . ," "" , ( ? -- ), "[18], . 8.

. IX . " , " [18], . 8-9. , ,

IX ?

, , . , . -, . ? , - , ?

.

.

"". , - , - .

9. 4.


141/421

141

?" (1304-1374). , , " [18], . 9.

, , ? " ".

, , [4].

9. 5. "" XV

"" -- . . -- , XIII XII . .

, , -- , , , -- 1429 , [18], . 36.

" -. , -- , ... XV - (1493-1506),... , , ,...

-- ,

, ... " [18], . 36-37.

, , ,, XV , .

, , , " ".


142/421

142

.

, XII , XIII .

. [1], [4], [5]. " " -- . -- . XV . , .

"" .

9. 6.

" ... ... . , -- , . ,

............. -- Aquisgranum, Aquensis urbs,............. -- Mediolanum,.............. -- Leodium,........ -- Ratisbona,

............. -- (Sancta) Colonia Agrippina, . . ". [18], . 59.

.

.

Argentoratum, Argentina, Argentaria.. -- (),Augusta Trevirorum................... -- (),Augusta Vindelicorum................. -- (),

Batavia, Pattavia.................... -- (),BORUSSIA............................. -- ,Dorobernia........................... -- ,

-- (),

Eboracum, Eoferic.................... -- (),Grantebrycg.......................... --

(), Hybernia............................. -- ,Holsatia............................. -- (),


143/421


144/421

144

9. 8. ?

. . : " ". [18], . 183.

, , , , 990 1040 , , 1197-1212 .

. . : " , , ... X-XI 1200 " [18], . 183. . .

1'3'10

10.

. (), , [190].

.. : " 70- () ..

, , ... 1957 . 250 ... 1963 - ..... 80 , ... ( --- .) 99 ,... , ... 76 ... , , ,

... IX-XIII... . , , . --- (, ) --- , , " [191], .149.

, "


145/421

145

. - , , , ... , . , , "[191], .50.

: , , , , ? [191], --- "" . .. : " , " [191], .51. , ,, . "" .. : "" [191], .54, --- .

--- . .. : " XI . , " [191], .54.

: " XII . , , . : ... ... , ,

" [191], .50. ?

. , . [190], .17." 165... , , , :

--- 45 ( : --- 22, --- 7, --- 6, --- 5, --- 5),

--- 30, --- 19, --- 12, --- 12, --- 11, --- 9, --- 8,


146/421

146

--- 6, --- 5, --- 4, --- 2, --- 1, --- 1 " [190], .17.

, ( ).

( ), [191], .55. , " VIII-XIII , , " [191], .55.

? , - . . ,

, . [190], , : [190], ---, --- . , , . , --- . , , --- . , , .

, , . . ( , --- ) , "" .

[190]. --- , . . ( [191]). . . :NRED-[C]DLT. : N(omine) RE(demptoris) D(omini), [C(hristi)]D(omini) L(igni). T(rinitas). [190], VIII ( "nr".

: " --- . " [190], . .

--- , .


147/421


148/421

148

-.

3. . .. -. ULEN. .. [24]. --- , --- .

, , . .

4. . .. - LEITPRIT. . . [24]. , . , .. . . .[22]. , : , .., , , - .

--- , , .

, , --- . - . , . "", ,, .. , . , , . , . . 5.

. " ... . : , . , , , (, , . 5, --- --- .). : , --- --- " [191], . 51.

- ? .

1'4'00


149/421


150/421

150

2.

[5], 1380 , , ,

, . :

,

,

,

.

, "". -- .

, , , . , , -- .

, 1992 ,

, -- 25 , -- . -- . :

" . 1992 25".

, - , . , , ,

25 1380 .

[5] , -, ---, . -- - . , . , , XIV [5]. - , , ,


151/421

151

. [5] , , .

-- , , . , . .

. 1, 2, 3. . [5]. .

-, .

3.

, "", -- " ". --

.

, -- , : " , "[77], 2, . 231. , . . , .

4. "", ""? - ,

:

"- - ".

, , (XVI ): "1527 ( -- .) (? ) (mit den Tartaren angezogen),

(? ) (bey Carionen) " [27], . 78.

, .

. , 1725 (Deutsche Chronologische Tabellen. Braunschweig, Berlegetvon Friedrich Wilhelm Mener, 1725)


152/421

152

:

"Iohannes Basilowiz, Erzersiel MIT DENEN TARTARN, undbrachte an sein Reich Casan und Astracan" (. . 1533 ,. 159). : " ".

, - .

: , . .

5.

, . . . , , , -- , , -- .

.

?

, , ,

. . ...

, "", -- , -- - . .

, . .

, , , , - . , , . .

, , .

[5] , . . .


153/421

153

[86], . 169.

-- ?

, . [5], ""

. , . , .

, , -- XVIII-XIX ,-- . ,

. , , .

.

, , - , , " ". " 1792 ... -" [30], . 113.

1'4'06

6.

[5] , , , -- ,-, , .

.

. , , , . , , -- ?

, -- , . . , -- , ,


154/421

154

. .

-, - - , , .

, , XVII , , , "", -, -- XVII . , : XVII-XVIII . .

, , : , ,

, .

= , . [21] [22]. , [22].

, . , , -Vlha = , Wilga -- , . .

1'4'07

7.

XVII , -- [30], . 7.

, , [31], . 97. , , -- ,

-- , " ". , , , , XVII .

-- [30], . 122. : " , "


155/421

A. T. Fomenko - Imperija

Documents

Transcript of A. T. Fomenko - Imperija