A SUSY lattice for 4 dimensions - Harish-Chandra Research...

35
1 1 A SUSY lattice for 4 dimensions Tomohisa Takimi (TIFR) Ref) [T.T, JHEP08(2012)069[arXiv:1205.7038]] 17 th December 2012@IMS

Transcript of A SUSY lattice for 4 dimensions - Harish-Chandra Research...

Page 1: A SUSY lattice for 4 dimensions - Harish-Chandra Research ...ism2012/talks/Takimi-Gong-Show-2.pdf · SUSY lattice for 4-dimensions UV-divergence IS SEVERE (not Super renormalizable).

1 1

A SUSY lattice for 4 dimensions

Tomohisa Takimi (TIFR)

Ref) [T.T, JHEP08(2012)069[arXiv:1205.7038]]

17th December 2012@IMS

Page 2: A SUSY lattice for 4 dimensions - Harish-Chandra Research ...ism2012/talks/Takimi-Gong-Show-2.pdf · SUSY lattice for 4-dimensions UV-divergence IS SEVERE (not Super renormalizable).

2

1. Introduction

2

Non-perturbative numerical study of SUSY theories.

Lattice formulation

Page 3: A SUSY lattice for 4 dimensions - Harish-Chandra Research ...ism2012/talks/Takimi-Gong-Show-2.pdf · SUSY lattice for 4-dimensions UV-divergence IS SEVERE (not Super renormalizable).

3

1. Introduction

3

Non-perturbative numerical study of SUSY theories.

Lattice formulation

lattice construction of SUSY field theory has been

difficult for long time.

Page 4: A SUSY lattice for 4 dimensions - Harish-Chandra Research ...ism2012/talks/Takimi-Gong-Show-2.pdf · SUSY lattice for 4-dimensions UV-divergence IS SEVERE (not Super renormalizable).

4

Absense of inifinitesimal translation on the lattice

Very crude regularization for SUSY theory

since the SUSY is artificially broken.

Momentum in the SUSY algebra

v.s

Page 5: A SUSY lattice for 4 dimensions - Harish-Chandra Research ...ism2012/talks/Takimi-Gong-Show-2.pdf · SUSY lattice for 4-dimensions UV-divergence IS SEVERE (not Super renormalizable).

5

Absense of inifinitesimal translation on the lattice

Very crude regularization for SUSY theory

since the SUSY is artificially broken.

Momentum in the SUSY algebra

v.s

Many SUSY breaking UV divergences

Page 6: A SUSY lattice for 4 dimensions - Harish-Chandra Research ...ism2012/talks/Takimi-Gong-Show-2.pdf · SUSY lattice for 4-dimensions UV-divergence IS SEVERE (not Super renormalizable).

6

Long required computation time. (Fine-tuning problem)

To get a continuum limit and result with full

SUSY, we have to precisely compute many SUSY breaking counter terms.

Too huge computation time to finish the

computation before the end of world.

Page 7: A SUSY lattice for 4 dimensions - Harish-Chandra Research ...ism2012/talks/Takimi-Gong-Show-2.pdf · SUSY lattice for 4-dimensions UV-divergence IS SEVERE (not Super renormalizable).

7

So it has been difficult issue.

Page 8: A SUSY lattice for 4 dimensions - Harish-Chandra Research ...ism2012/talks/Takimi-Gong-Show-2.pdf · SUSY lattice for 4-dimensions UV-divergence IS SEVERE (not Super renormalizable).

8

But there are development

( deconstruction approach of [Cohen, Kaplan Katz Unsal 2003,2004,2005])

(topological field theory

[Sugino 2003, 2004,2005,2006, Catterall 2005,

D’Adda, Kanamori, Kawamoto, Nagata 2005] )

(Actually these are equivalent:

[T.T 2007, Damgaard Matsuura 2007, Catterall 2008] )

Page 9: A SUSY lattice for 4 dimensions - Harish-Chandra Research ...ism2012/talks/Takimi-Gong-Show-2.pdf · SUSY lattice for 4-dimensions UV-divergence IS SEVERE (not Super renormalizable).

Extended SUSY action = TFT action

9

(we discard other part of SUSY)

We select only the TFT scalar charge

[Witten 1988, Marcus 1994]

Page 10: A SUSY lattice for 4 dimensions - Harish-Chandra Research ...ism2012/talks/Takimi-Gong-Show-2.pdf · SUSY lattice for 4-dimensions UV-divergence IS SEVERE (not Super renormalizable).

Extended SUSY action = TFT action

10

We select only the TFT scalar charge

Partial Preserved SUSY on the lattice

(we discard other part of SUSY)

No translation in the algebra

[Witten 1988, Marcus 1994]

Page 11: A SUSY lattice for 4 dimensions - Harish-Chandra Research ...ism2012/talks/Takimi-Gong-Show-2.pdf · SUSY lattice for 4-dimensions UV-divergence IS SEVERE (not Super renormalizable).

Extended SUSY action = TFT action

11

We select only the TFT scalar charge

Partial Preserved SUSY on the lattice

It suppresses the SUSY breaking UV

divergences.

(we discard other part of SUSY)

No translation in the algebra

[Witten 1988, Marcus 1994]

Page 12: A SUSY lattice for 4 dimensions - Harish-Chandra Research ...ism2012/talks/Takimi-Gong-Show-2.pdf · SUSY lattice for 4-dimensions UV-divergence IS SEVERE (not Super renormalizable).

12

2. SUSY lattice for two, three-dimensions

UV-divergence is not severe (Super renormalizable).

Partially preserved SUSY works well enough.

SUSY is automatically recovered at continuum limit.

Page 13: A SUSY lattice for 4 dimensions - Harish-Chandra Research ...ism2012/talks/Takimi-Gong-Show-2.pdf · SUSY lattice for 4-dimensions UV-divergence IS SEVERE (not Super renormalizable).

13

3. SUSY lattice for 4-dimensions

UV-divergence IS SEVERE (not Super renormalizable).

Partially preserved SUSY on the lattice

does not work well enough.

Far from full-fledged numerical simulations

Page 14: A SUSY lattice for 4 dimensions - Harish-Chandra Research ...ism2012/talks/Takimi-Gong-Show-2.pdf · SUSY lattice for 4-dimensions UV-divergence IS SEVERE (not Super renormalizable).

14

4. Toward a useful formulation for the 4-dimensional theory

[Hanada, Matsuura, Sugino 2010]

[Hanada 2011] [Hanada, Matsuura, Sugino 2011]

[T.T 2012]

Page 15: A SUSY lattice for 4 dimensions - Harish-Chandra Research ...ism2012/talks/Takimi-Gong-Show-2.pdf · SUSY lattice for 4-dimensions UV-divergence IS SEVERE (not Super renormalizable).

15

New 4-d lattice theory = (2-d lattice) ×(Fuzzy S2)

Page 16: A SUSY lattice for 4 dimensions - Harish-Chandra Research ...ism2012/talks/Takimi-Gong-Show-2.pdf · SUSY lattice for 4-dimensions UV-divergence IS SEVERE (not Super renormalizable).

• 2-dimensional lattice

UV divergence is so soft to easily suppress the SUSY breaking divergence by partial SUSY.

• Fuzzy Sphere

it provides descretized extra dimensional space without breaking SUSY

16

*2- advantages

Page 17: A SUSY lattice for 4 dimensions - Harish-Chandra Research ...ism2012/talks/Takimi-Gong-Show-2.pdf · SUSY lattice for 4-dimensions UV-divergence IS SEVERE (not Super renormalizable).

17

4-1. N=4 SUSY case [Hanada, Matsuura, Sugino 2010]

[Hanada 2011]

Page 18: A SUSY lattice for 4 dimensions - Harish-Chandra Research ...ism2012/talks/Takimi-Gong-Show-2.pdf · SUSY lattice for 4-dimensions UV-divergence IS SEVERE (not Super renormalizable).

18

(With partially preserved SUSY)

2–d lattice ×Fuzzy Sphere

Page 19: A SUSY lattice for 4 dimensions - Harish-Chandra Research ...ism2012/talks/Takimi-Gong-Show-2.pdf · SUSY lattice for 4-dimensions UV-divergence IS SEVERE (not Super renormalizable).

SUSY is fully recovered by the virtue of

super-renormalizability of 2-dimensions.

2–d lattice ×Fuzzy Sphere

Page 20: A SUSY lattice for 4 dimensions - Harish-Chandra Research ...ism2012/talks/Takimi-Gong-Show-2.pdf · SUSY lattice for 4-dimensions UV-divergence IS SEVERE (not Super renormalizable).

We do not suffer from the SUSY breaking

divergence due to the FULLY PRESERVED

SUSY.

Page 21: A SUSY lattice for 4 dimensions - Harish-Chandra Research ...ism2012/talks/Takimi-Gong-Show-2.pdf · SUSY lattice for 4-dimensions UV-divergence IS SEVERE (not Super renormalizable).

21

4-2. N=2 SUSY case

[Hanada, Matsuura, Sugino 2011]

[T.T 2012]

Page 22: A SUSY lattice for 4 dimensions - Harish-Chandra Research ...ism2012/talks/Takimi-Gong-Show-2.pdf · SUSY lattice for 4-dimensions UV-divergence IS SEVERE (not Super renormalizable).

22

In this case, it is difficult to construct the

2-d lattice part with preserved SUSY

in usual manner.(usual deconstruction method)

Page 23: A SUSY lattice for 4 dimensions - Harish-Chandra Research ...ism2012/talks/Takimi-Gong-Show-2.pdf · SUSY lattice for 4-dimensions UV-divergence IS SEVERE (not Super renormalizable).

23

In this case, it is difficult to construct the

2-d lattice part with preserved SUSY

in usual manner.(usual deconstruction method)

2-d lattice part = 1-d lattice ×

1-d momentum cutoff

[T.T 2012]

Page 24: A SUSY lattice for 4 dimensions - Harish-Chandra Research ...ism2012/talks/Takimi-Gong-Show-2.pdf · SUSY lattice for 4-dimensions UV-divergence IS SEVERE (not Super renormalizable).

24

In this case, it is difficult to construct the

2-d lattice part with preserved SUSY

in usual manner.(usual deconstruction method)

2-d lattice part = 1-d lattice ×

1-d momentum cutoff

It will break the symmetry terribly

Is it O.K ?

Page 25: A SUSY lattice for 4 dimensions - Harish-Chandra Research ...ism2012/talks/Takimi-Gong-Show-2.pdf · SUSY lattice for 4-dimensions UV-divergence IS SEVERE (not Super renormalizable).

25

In this case, it is difficult to construct the

2-d lattice part with preserved SUSY

in usual manner.(usual deconstruction method)

2-d lattice part = 1-d lattice ×

1-d momentum cutoff

It will break the symmetry terribly

Is it O.K ? O.K !!

Page 26: A SUSY lattice for 4 dimensions - Harish-Chandra Research ...ism2012/talks/Takimi-Gong-Show-2.pdf · SUSY lattice for 4-dimensions UV-divergence IS SEVERE (not Super renormalizable).

26

Because if the continuum limit of this direction

is taken first, with keeping other direction

regularized,

this is quantum mechanics, there is

no dangerous UV divergences.

2-d lattice part = 1-d lattice ×

1-d momentum cutoff

Page 27: A SUSY lattice for 4 dimensions - Harish-Chandra Research ...ism2012/talks/Takimi-Gong-Show-2.pdf · SUSY lattice for 4-dimensions UV-divergence IS SEVERE (not Super renormalizable).

27 27

1-d momentum cutoff ×1-d lattice×Fuzzy S2

Page 28: A SUSY lattice for 4 dimensions - Harish-Chandra Research ...ism2012/talks/Takimi-Gong-Show-2.pdf · SUSY lattice for 4-dimensions UV-divergence IS SEVERE (not Super renormalizable).

28

1-d momentum cutoff ×1-d lattice×Fuzzy S2

R1×1-d lattice×Fuzzy S2

No UV divergences !!

Page 29: A SUSY lattice for 4 dimensions - Harish-Chandra Research ...ism2012/talks/Takimi-Gong-Show-2.pdf · SUSY lattice for 4-dimensions UV-divergence IS SEVERE (not Super renormalizable).

29

Later steps are analogous to N=4 case

Page 30: A SUSY lattice for 4 dimensions - Harish-Chandra Research ...ism2012/talks/Takimi-Gong-Show-2.pdf · SUSY lattice for 4-dimensions UV-divergence IS SEVERE (not Super renormalizable).

R1×1-d lattice×Fuzzy S2

SUSY is fully recovered automatically

Page 31: A SUSY lattice for 4 dimensions - Harish-Chandra Research ...ism2012/talks/Takimi-Gong-Show-2.pdf · SUSY lattice for 4-dimensions UV-divergence IS SEVERE (not Super renormalizable).

FULL SUSY suppress the SUSY breaking UV

divergence.

Page 32: A SUSY lattice for 4 dimensions - Harish-Chandra Research ...ism2012/talks/Takimi-Gong-Show-2.pdf · SUSY lattice for 4-dimensions UV-divergence IS SEVERE (not Super renormalizable).

5. SUMMARY AND DISCUSSION

32

Page 33: A SUSY lattice for 4 dimensions - Harish-Chandra Research ...ism2012/talks/Takimi-Gong-Show-2.pdf · SUSY lattice for 4-dimensions UV-divergence IS SEVERE (not Super renormalizable).

Good point

• First 4-d N=2 deconstruction SUSY lattice model free from fine-tuning.

• Easy and simple action useful for coding.

• First deconstruction lattice model free from soft SUSY breaking mass term.

Page 34: A SUSY lattice for 4 dimensions - Harish-Chandra Research ...ism2012/talks/Takimi-Gong-Show-2.pdf · SUSY lattice for 4-dimensions UV-divergence IS SEVERE (not Super renormalizable).

Future work, homework

• Noncommutative 4-d N=2 theory has severe UV-IR mixing, how can I take commutative limit from Fuzzy S2 smoothly ?

[Minwalla, Van Raamsdonk, Seiberg 1999]

• Do Non-perturbative corrections disturb the calculation ? Check by numerical test.

[Hanada, Matsuura,T.T in future]

Page 35: A SUSY lattice for 4 dimensions - Harish-Chandra Research ...ism2012/talks/Takimi-Gong-Show-2.pdf · SUSY lattice for 4-dimensions UV-divergence IS SEVERE (not Super renormalizable).

Thank you so much

35