A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America,...
-
Upload
floridahoss -
Category
Documents
-
view
218 -
download
0
Transcript of A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America,...
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
1/84
James R. Follain, Ph.D.
research institute for housing americasPecial RePoRtA Study of ReAl eStAteMARketS in declining citieS
0296
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
2/84
2 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.10296
research institute for housing americasPecial RePoRtA Study of ReAl eStAteMARketS in declining citieS
James R. Follain, Ph.D.
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
3/84
A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
Rch Ini Hing AmicBoard of Trustees
Chair
T Byc, Eq.
Radian Group Inc.
Michl W. Yng
Cenlar FSB
Nnc Mll
Wells Fargo
Ew L. Hly
Avanath Capital Partners LLC
Sv Gv
Principal Real Estate Investors
Dn Ycm
IMortgage
Staff
Jy Binkmnn, Ph.D.Senior Vice President, Research and Business Development
Chief Economist
Mortgage Bankers Association
Michl Fnni, Ph.D.
Vice President, Research and Economics
Mortgage Bankers Association
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
4/84
4 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
AcknowledgmentsI m piclly gl Michl Sklz Clll Anlyic (www.clllynlyic.cm )
n Dnni Cpzz (www.n.cm/Dnni_Cpzz.hm), bh whm pvi nil
h pp. I l bni m vl icin wih Gg Gl, wh h j cmpl
nw bk b h xpinc n h clic nin clining ciy Di. Bb
Fllin pvi xclln inc in h li viw n in inl iin. Michl Fnni
w hlpl in vy ph h pjc m i iniil cncpin h inl vin. I wl l
lik hnk G Cc n Cli Jn MBA hi in pcing h inl cmn.
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
5/84
A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
Executive Summary 7
Section I: Introduction 11
Section II: Types of Declining Cities 13
Tiinl Nin Dclining Ciy 13
Envinmnl Di: Nw Oln 15
Oh Typ Dclining Cii Emging 16
A Lk Sm Pn v h L 40 Y 18
A Cl Lk Svn M A 21
Section III: What Happens to Real Estate Values in Declining Cities? 25
A Lk Simpl H Pic Ml h Svn M A 32
Cnclin Rging Qin #1 33
Section IV: What Is the Range of Experiences for Neighborhoods
within Declining Cities? 35
Ching M Nighbh Dclin 36
2000 Vcncy D 37
USPS D 2008 n 2010 42
Anlyi Sckn n Clvln Hing D 46
Cnclin 54
tAble of contentS
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
6/84
6 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
Section V: Can We Predict with Confidence the Potential
of Substantial Neighborhood Decline within Declining Cities? 55
Anlyi 2000 Vcncy D 59
Anlyi Clvln / Sckn D 60
A Dicin Tw Plici Hlp Hm By n Ln Cpwih h Unciny Sning Nighbh Chic in Dclining Cii 64
Cnclin 68
Section VI: Key Conclusions and Some Implications for Policy 71
End Notes 75
References 79
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
7/84
A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
Th G Rcin 2007 2009 h kn g ll n hing mk in m cii
n mplin in ll p h cny. Thgh h pc n xn h vll
cnmic cvy h mk i ill m cin, mny plc will likly m gwh
n lly cv wihin h nx c . Thi i lm cinly n b h c ll
mplin . In c, nmb lg mplin iicl (MSA) xpinc
v cin ing h l hl h 20h cny n pi h G Rcin n
nv lly cv k mny y . Evn mng h m wih livly
bigh lng-n ppc gwh, cin bmk wihin hm my min wll blw
cn h pic pk mny y cm.
Wh i clining ciy? Simply p, clining ciy i n in which h ppl hv l, b h
h, pmn biling, ic n n min. A h xm, hink gh wn
m h Ol W, wn h l i n bing. A h cii lg m in h
Uni S ik ipping bck in h ( h wmp) y? Pbbly n, b h
cinly nighbh n bmk wihin m h hv p ipping pin,
n hv lil ppc ning nyhing cl hi pvi pk. Lly, nh yp
clining ciy my l b mging plc h gw bnilly ing h hing bm n
nw xpincing npcn clin in h pic n inc in cl.
Th pimy gl hi pp i inigh n h pnil vlin l
mk in cii h in h mi v n pin cnmic clin. Thgh viw
miv n inicipliny by pi ch, nlyi nw mpiicl vinc n h
xpinc mny lg U.S. m v h p 40 y n c n h xpinc
vn lg m inc 2000, incling ing h G Rcin, I k nw
h qin:
Qin 1: Wh hppn l vl in clining cii, pcilly h h
hv xpinc bnil n pin clin in pplin n mplymn?
executive SuMMARy
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
8/84
8 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
Qin 2: Wh i h ng xpinc nighbh wihin clining cii?
Qin 3: D w knw ngh b bl cninly pic which nighbh
m likly xpinc h v n pin clin?
Th nw h qin b pn viw h li n nw mpiicl nlyi.
Svl in c iliz in highligh m h chllng n ppnii iinl mpiicl wk in hi il inqiy. O picl in h l w
qin i h incinc xm cm h hn h lng-m vibiliy nighbh
bmk wihin clining cii.
My cnclin llw:
Qin #1: N piingly, hm pic clin hply in mk h bnil
n pin c in pplin mplymn. Sch c in pplin n
mplymn igg clin in h mn hing, n bc ppl m mbil
hn h, i k mny y pply n mn bcm blnc gin n
h pic n pi lvl. Thi ining i pp by ng niv n
mpiicl vinc: hm pic clin mch g xn whn pplin ll hn
hm pic inc whn pplin gw. O c, bnil n pin clin in
hing mn cn b ivn by c h hn pplin. I h h c n
pinly in clin, hn h pic clin in h n n b pin ih.
Hnc, h ky ny c h pic in mny mk y pn pn
hing mn in h mk liv h ch pi h G Rcin. F
h mk in which hing mn m likly min blw pvi pk lvl,cvy in hi l mk will b lng in cming. F xmpl, Sckn, Clini,
which i ky c y in hi pp, my bcm nw yp clining ciy bn h
G Rcin n h hing bm n b h 2000.
Qin #2: Th mpiicl vinc n clining cii ngly cnim wily vying
xpinc mng bmk mplin h xpinc pin n ngiv
hck hing mn. In, m h nighbh n bmk xpinc
clin v h hi vibiliy m qinbl , minimm, h h
cvy will b pc. Thi ining i highligh by h xpinc Clvlnn Sckn ing h 2000, bh which incl nighbh h hv xpinc
clin in h pic n wlh mch m v hn h m vg. Oh vinc
bin ing h Uni S Pl Svic Vcncy Svy h pi 2008:Q2 h
2010:Q2 inic nighbh ching ipping pin wih pc vibiliy. Th vcncy
vinc l gg h impnc mving byn h n iniin vcncy
n n ccpying h ni h im n inviw n h incp inmin
b h in h vcncy.
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
9/84
A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
Qin #3: I pv b vy iicl cninly pic whh mk bmk
i in pmnn mly mpy clin. Thi i piclly blm c
pin clin cl b l-lilling. On h ml vlp k pic c-
cinl viin in h 2000 inil vcncy h 6,500 Cn c wihin h
29 cni c pn in hi y. Th picin bnil, n vg, n
piclly lg h Cn c wih livly high vcncy ; h i, hml livly p jb iming h vcncy h nighbh h
li wih pc vcncy .
Thgh I n hink clin in hing mn will b pin in mny mplin mk, hi
i gh cll n h b pinin will cgniz h impnc pciic lcl mk cniin.
Th nly in hi pp gg h will b n ly hv bn bnil h h
vibiliy cin nighbh. Thi, I hink, i ciicl pin h will likly b wll n by
pnil hm by n ln, wh wn vi plc plg by high cl, vcnci
n iing hing ck minnnc. Th lip i hi picin i hpnil by n ln will v h mk wh inmin b h nighbh
viliy i ily vilbl. Nighbh chic i likly bcm n vn m impn
cmpnn hing ciin in h mk piclly h-hi by h G Rcin.
Pblic plicy my b bl ply n impn l in hlping pnil hmby n ln mk
pn ciin b nighbh chic, b will qi plicymk ckl iicl
ciin b wh g c. Thi i cnin hm in h b n clining cii
in mny p h wl. Gvnmn will l hv hw h-m cc in b
cninc b h pnil lng-m cvy. Pcicl ppl will wn vinc civn plici p in plc. A ch, h vinc m hm p by h
U.S. Dpmn Hing n Ubn Dvlpmn (HUD) i mv in h igh icin.
Tw pciic plicy i ic highligh h chllng. Th i pin n pc
ppil ginc h cll n mn h nighbh in which h ppy i
lc n, in picl, whh h mk i in clin. Impvmn in ch ginc hl
b gh. Th cn i h mbii nighbh bilizin pgm bing pp by
HUD. Thgh ch h plici my bcm hlpl l, miicin my hlp hm mv
w m py cvy.
Mlipl glin my n b -xmin in ligh h chllng: cing ln mk
iky ln in clining mk w cinly n h inn h Cmmniy Rinvmn Ac
(CRA) n h lgilin. Appi n ln wh ci h nighbh i n h vg
bnil clin cn xpc b chllng n i lning gn i h nighbh
cnin bnil pplin miniy hhl. Abn ng n cmplling vinc,
h gn will b cpibl ip impc clim. Ln my hv bnilly ighn
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
10/84
10 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
nwiing n in ll nighbh wihin mplin mk piclly h hi by
mj ngiv cnmic hck nil i bcm cl which nighbh min vibl. Sch
bhvi, hgh jiibl by ln king minin pn ik pil, incling ci,
gly, n liigin ik, my in il hin cvy h m n nighbh
m in jpy. Thi i n in which h gvnmn my b hlp by pviing m ,
gilin c n viniy n. I i likly n qin whh ci pplywill b c in h mk, b by hw mch n by wh pc.
Lly, h nmnl pblm cing y nw b clining cii n hi nighbh
m vy imil pblm in mny p gvnmn king mng cnmic
cvy. Th i, invmn n lning ily hmp by g nciny, which in
il hin h p cvy h nw nml. B n nlyi will hlp vyn
bcm m cnin wh w h. D h h pgm hl b m
m vilbl wi ng iniin cmmi bjciv nly h pgm. Abn
ch inmin, I h cvy will b lng n h nmb il nighbh ghn hy migh hwi b.
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
11/84
A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
Th G Rcin 2007 2009 h kn mj ll n hing mk in m cii
n lg mplin in ll p h cny. Thgh h pc n xn h vll
cnmic cvy h mk i ill m cin, mny plc will likly m gwh n
lly cv wihin h nx c. Thi i lm cinly n b h c ll m
cii. In c, nmb lg m hv bn in i cin n hinking in iz
mny y pi 2007 n h, n hi pvi iz my b mny y in cming
my n cm ll. Evn mng h m wih livly bigh ppc gwh,
cin gmn wihin hm my min wll blw h pk in hing pic h ly 2000.
Wh i clining ciy? Simply p, clining ciy i n in which h ppl hv l, b h
h, pmn biling, ic n n min. A h xm, hink gh wn
m h Ol W, wn h l i n bing. A h cii lg m in h
Uni S ik ipping bck in h ( h wmp) y? Pbbly n, b h
cinly nighbh n bmk wihin m h hv p ipping pin n
hv lil ppc ning nyhing cl hi pvi pk.
Wh h min c h gn clining cii? A miv n inicipliny by
li, which i viw in Scin II, viy nw hi qin. Th m cmmn
nin clining ciy i m h h xpinc bnil clin in pplin n
mplymn.1 Sm h xpinc clin bc l in hi cmpiv vng
in h pcin m ky mncing pc lik mbil l. Sm cii lik
Clvln n Di, h i hi iinl nin clining ciy in h R Bl gin
h Uni S, b xmpl ch clining hinking cii cn b n in h p
h wl lik Dn, Gmny. Anh yp clining ciy i gn by nl i.
Th c Nw Oln n Hicn Kin i clic b vy cn xmpl. Oh pnil
c clining cii hv l bn . Sm pin h lng-m n migin m
h cl h wm Sn Bl gin h cny. Oh highligh h mgnic pw
Section i:
intRoduction
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
12/84
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
13/84
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
14/84
14 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
A cn icl by Aln Mllch (2010) bgin wih m xmpl, pciic hiicl pi n
cmplling niv xplin h n h xinc h iinl clining ciy. H
ci h cnmic xpnin h Uni S in h cn hl h 19h cny n h i
hl h 20h cny, which h lbl h nin mncing migh, n i bnil
clin in h l p h 20h cny h pimy c h iinl clining ciy.
Cii ch Pibgh, Di, Clvln n Bl n mll cii lik Yngwn, Ohin Schncy, Nw Yk (h iginl hm Gnl Elcic), pim xmpl
clining cii.
A lng-im in Up Nw Yk n n cnmi, I in hi y b h cnqnc
l cmpiv vng mili n cmplling. Hwv, in ppin hi pp, I
cnc viw lng li c i b clining cii. Ew Gl (2007)
n xclln mmy h hiy n ch ciy in n icl nil Cn Bl Ev Cm
Bck?2 A ky p hi xplnin i h lng-im n hiiclly impn linhip bwn
Bl, Nw Yk n h Ei Cnl, which w cmpl in 1825 n llw Bl pp Nw Yk Ciy pp. Th pnc h cnl llw iinl yp mplymn n
inil gin, in iin h npin g m h Miw Nw Yk Ciy. F
xmpl, Bl bcm mj pc l in h ly 20h cny bc i w livly
y bin in m h Lk Michign n n i in l. In iin, i pximiy
Nig Fll llw i b bnil gn lcic pw. Bl w h 13h lg
ciy in Amic h n h G Dpin. I h inc l 55 pcn i pplin.
Gl inii vi xplnin hi clin, b hi mphi i pn h l in i ciicl
cmpiv vng. H xplin h h ky w h l i cmpiv vng in
npin c. Gwh in il n Bl minnc npin hb. Impvmn
in h nmiin lciciy l c i cmpiv vng in hi iny.
Kn Pllg (2007) nh inighl icin in n icl nil Shinking Cii in
h Uni S Amic: Th C, Th Plnning Si.3 Th h cii Pibgh,
Yngwn n Sn J, Clini. H icin Sn J i piclly hlpl bc i
pvi mn y xmpl clining ciy. Th pimy cnmic vn h l pblm
Sn J w h cm b in Silicn Vlly h bginning h millnnim. A l,
h ciy c v l in i high-ch wk c. Pllg ci p h h ciy Sn
J l 50,000 jb l h cm b. Dpi hi jb l, i vll pplin
cnin gw immigin; hwv, Sn J w ill c by h l mny
high pying ch jb.
Th invigin clining n hinking cii i n limi h y h U.S. xpinc.
In, mny cni l wih h i. Wichmnn (2007) Cnvin Sgi n
Unciny c n p-cili hinking cii in Ep. H c gvnmn
mng mgphic chng in Dn, n Gmny, wh h bkwn h -
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
15/84
A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
ic cnmy c cnmic clin, inil gin n high nmplymn .
Fm 1989 1999, whn h ciy l pplin -migin n cing bih ,
h miniiv ym w ill ic w gwh bjciv. H mk hi pin
vy clly by pning h nliiclly high pplin gwh pjcin iliz by h
miniiv ym ing h ly 1990. Thn, v h l vn y, h ciy xpinc
nxpc gwh. Pc bbnizin hv n in pc bnizin,n y in Dn, hinkg n clin in cl pximiy pping n
wlhy cmmnii. Th gic chllng i l wih hi pchwk, givn h
vlpmn npicbl.
Oh c i mnin in h cin h llw. Th c i n mny h
h viw cmmnic m cmmn hm, ch h l cmpiv vng
c clining cii. Thy l ypiclly incl bnil mphi n pging h
l gvnmn plici. Mny chmpin h nin h m gh chic m b m by
gvnmn hlp viliz clining cii. Th c i n mk nh ciicl pin:ch plc h i wn pcil cicmnc h mk i h gnliz n iicl
vlp p-wn plicy ll clining cii.
Environmental Disasters: New OrleansOn ccin in h Uni S, cii hv xpinc mj clin n nvinmnl
i. Glvn, Tx nm l in h hicn 1900. Th mj n npcn
xmpl in cn mmy in h Uni S i, c, h ciy Nw Oln, which w
pwlly impc by Hicn Kin in 2005. Nm i hv bn cnc h Nw Oln xpinc. Thi bi icin v g i m hi li n
w iic m h m cn 2009 Amicn Hing Svy h cp m
h impc n h hing ck in Nw Oln.
On mj y Nw Oln n by h Bking Ini n nil Nw Oln Fiv
w cnly pblih n i ining vilbl h Bking wb i.4 Rh hn k
mmiz ll hi wk, n h i nlying h nlyi i cib h nin
ilin bn cnmy. A viw h cmic li n c i by Amy Li n Allin
Ply (2010) cib c chciic h cn inc h biliy m bb,minimiz p piivly ngiv hck n b ilin. Thy : i) ng n iv
ginl cnmy; ii) lg h kill n c wk; iii) wlh; iv) ng cil cpil;
n v) cmmniy cmpnc. Th bcm c nin in hi nging nlyi Nw
Oln p-Kin hiy by Li n Ply (2010) n hi Bking cllg.
Oh hink nk hv inigh wll n h Nw Oln xpinc vlp
ln h cii. On xmpl i pnin by Ann C. Kbich (2008) h Ubn
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
16/84
16 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
Ini, which w pn h xpinc wih cvy pin in Nw Oln n wh
h pciv h nin bwn h-m n lng-m gl n ccmplihmn. Th
ln h mphiz i hi: ppl n h-m pg inc hi ih in h
pibiliy lng-m cvy.
Th Nln Rckll Ini Gvnmn pc i igh p incling n
nil Wh in Chg? Wh Shl B? Th Rl h Fl Gvnmn in Mgi:
B n Ln m Hicn Kin, by Rich P. Nhn n Mc Lny.5 Thi y
g h h w w i. Th i w h immi cii c whn h hicn
m lnll. Th cn w h iicly vi lvl gvnmn h in wking gh
pn h cii.
U.S. Dpmn Hing n Ubn Dvlpmn (HUD) Scy Shn Dnvn
imny n h iv-y nnivy Hicn Kin.6 H h ky l hing in
cmpl cvy n h impnc biling h gin hing ck mili wh wn
n. Th cmmniy n pin h l hl i in, b i nw bck v 90 pcn
i p-Kin pplin. On h m impn chllng cnly c i vcn biling
n bligh c h mplin , wh HUD im h 79,000 bligh ni y.
Sn hi imny, HUD l l i 2009 Amicn Hing Svy Nw Oln.
Th ll l vilbl HUD wb i.7 Fllwing w kwy h cmp h
hing iin in 2004 v 2009. Th l hing ck i wn by b 15 pcn i
cn iz 511,600 ni. Rn-ccpi hing h kn h bigg hi; i h clin by
lm 23 pcn i cn iz 142,600 ni. Th nmb hing ni in mll mlimily
c wih iv nin hing ni, which n h hm lw- n m-incm
hhl, h clin by 32 pcn. A l, n pi h l in pplin, h min
n n-ccpi hing ni h inc by 46 pcn i cn min vl $876
n i nw b 12 pcn high hn h min n h ni nin.
Jy Binkmnn, Chi Ecnmi h Mgg Bnk Aciin (MBA) n W D. Rg
(2006) ckl h iicl i ing h c biling h hing ck in 2006 icl,
which i vilbl h MBA wb i.8 Thy highligh w piclly ining pin h
hin cvy. On w h lck l innc by 30,000 m mili h xpinc
l mg. Anh i h ip impc wihin h Nw Oln . A picl c
imbmn ppl wl c $9 billin h ni n $4 billin h ix h
hi zip c.
Other Types of Declining Cities EmergingByn h h cl-c c clining cii, h li n bnizin n cnmic
ggphy incl icin h c h cn l bnil pplin clin h
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
17/84
A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
iicl v pic. On h inllcl l in hi il i Pl Kgmn, wh
wn h 2008 Nbl Piz in Ecnmic hi vlpmn n chmpining nh pnil
iv bnil ginl cnmic gwh n clin gglmin cnmi. H g
h cii hiv n niy, hwv, i nh ciy cn bin h m b vng, hn
h cn b bnil n ivibl hi m h pvi king ciy h nw n. In h
cnx h Uni S, hi n pin gwh in wn cii liv h lg cii h Nh lik Nw Yk n Bn, h hv bn h king cii v w cni. H
plc hi pibiliy wihin h cnx h nging b wihin iinl hy h k
xplin why vlp cni bn n pciliz in h pcin bl g
n vlping cni l n pciliz in gicll pcin. Kgmn g
h iinl hy n xplin why, in liy, wl i min by ich cni
ing imil g wih ch h. F innc, cny lik Swn xp Vlv n SAAB
c b l imp BMW n Ty c.9 Kgmn nh xplnin gglmin
cnmi, which yp cnmi cl. Thi cp h nin h h ix c
pcin in picl ini n lcin cn b gly c in wih bnil
ch n vlpmn. H bliv ch gglmin cnmi impn in xplining
h bnil i in bnizin hgh m p h wl in h p w cni.
O c, h lip i hi y i h cii lin pn ch cl cnmi cn g
clin i h cii bl chiv bnil cnmi cl by, y, bnil invmn
in ch n vlpmn, nivii n wll-c wk c. M impnly, in my
viw, hi hy ly h mwk n bnil clin wih h ppc ll
cvy nc, xmpl, h mj cii h w in h kin gglmin cnmi
lng njy by h E C king cii.
Gl (1998) ly b cipin h c n bni ciy li n wh h cni b
ciicl ingin bn gwh h bni gglmin cnmi. Whil cknwlging
h h c bn li my inc m pin, h m cnjc b h .
H i piclly pimiic b h livly hmgn n lw niy gglmin h
wn Uni S. Thgh h n mnin Silicn Vlly pciiclly, hi m b n
xmpl wh h h in min. Th cii mny h cnmic vng gglmin
whil l cing h c cngin n cim. Tn y l Gl n Glib (2009)
n xniv li vy n nw mpiicl vinc h gin chmpin h impnl gglmin cnmi ply in h gwh cii. Th lg by vinc pp h
viw h cii cc by ping h n inmin (p. 1023). Thi mpiicl vinc
c pn h impc ch gglmin n h gwh cii in h hn n wn
p h Uni S n h nging hi in pplin w wih high mp
in Jny. Thi y i n pimiic h p, m hgn, l cii h E
n Miw, which will hv m ggl bc hy will b l likly b h mj
c innvin.
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
18/84
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
19/84
A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
iv-y pplin chng cmp. Th MSA nk in m hi lg iv-y
pplin clin. 134 h MSA xpinc iv-y clin l n pcn inc 1970.
Tbl II-1 cnin h l h wih pplin l 500,000. Twny-w MSA i
hi pn.
Th p h li by lg mn i h Nw Oln MSA, which ving l
ing n Hicn Kin in l Ag 2005. 1,836 ppl w kill n v $80
billin in ppy mg w c. Th pplin in 2005 w 1,312,400; h llwing y
pplin clin 992,000. Thi m h pi m 2001 2006 h n wih h lg
iv-y pcng clin 27.88 pcn. Th cn pplin im 2010 i 17 pcn
high hn h gh in 2006 b i ill b 12 pcn h cvy i pplin
h im h hicn. In c, Nw Oln wl hv ily qlii clining ciy by h
cii in Tbl II-1 wih Kin. Pplin clin by v pcn in h pi 1985
1990 n h n lly cv i 1983 pk pplin 1.33 millin by h im Kin hi
in 2005. In 2010, hi pi ln wl hv plc i mng h p iv w MSA pplinclin inc 1970 mng h wih pplin l 500,000.
Th nx 10 MSA n h li, wih h xcpin Nw Yk, i h cipin h iinl
clining ciy ic bv. Thy incl Bl, Pibgh, Yngwn, Clvln, Di n
h mili xmpl clining cii in h R Bl. Cni Clvln, which xpinc
i w iv-y pplin clin m 1971 1976 4.08 pcn. I cn pplin i
94 pcn i pplin h n h pi (1976) n 90 pcn i pk pplin in
h l 40 y (1971). Th y i imil h h iinl clining cii in hi li. Th
Nw Yk MSA i h lg n hi li by n i n h li bc i pplin clin inh ly n mi-1970. Th l y hi pi clin w 1977. Sinc hn pplin h
gwn xc by hlhy mn i pplin in h mi-1970 n h xpinc piiv
nnl gwh ch y inc h l 1980.
Th bm p hi li incl m m h migh l i h cipin h iinl
clining ciy n m h n. F xmpl, Oklhm Ciy i n h w piclly
h-hi by h il n ving n ln hck h hi h Shw in h ly 1980; hwv, i
pplin y xc i pplin in h l 1980 by v 27 pcn, inicing h ng
cvy h kn plc. Thi c n h n h li highligh impl c b U.S. cii: v pplin c i n icin cniin pin n ivibl clin.
Ovll, hi mpiicl xci cnim li l pc h lbl clining ciy n
h c h pplin gwh hm, vn ing h livly pp y inc 1970, i
mch lw hn in mch h h nin n inicin n hm hi pvi
pk. On h h hn, kp in min h hi li nly cnin ix h ill blw hi
pplin lvl h bginning h pi clin, which i mll cin h 340-pl
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
20/84
20 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
tb ii-1
lrg mrp ar w m sub
Fv-Yr Ppu D 1970
Current Current
Minimum Average Max Population Population to
2009 5 Year 5 Year 5 Year Growth Peak to Population Lowest
5 Year Population Population Population in the Population Population in Year of Population
Estimate Growth Growth Growth Following in Last in Worst Worst in Last 40
Name (Thousands) Rate Rate Rate Min Year 5 Years 40 Years Decline Decline Years
New Orleans-
Metairie-
Kenner, LA 1146 -27.88% -0.49% 7.24% 2006 -16.69% 1,329 992 117% 117%
Bualo-
Niagara Falls, NY 1124 -5.66% -2.42% 1.64% 1980 -5.65% 1,355 1,242 90% 100%
Pittsburgh, PA 2353 -4.99% -2.11% 0.69% 1988 -4.44% 2,761 2,480 95% 100%
Youngstown-
Warren-Boardman,
OH-PA 564 -4.78% -2.22% 2.26% 1987 -4.57% 681 619 91% 100%
Cleveland-Elyria-
Mentor, OH 2088 -4.08% -1.26% 2.16% 1976 -2.83% 2,319 2,220 94% 100%
Detroit-Warren-
Livonia, MI 4430 -3.79% 0.02% 3.44% 1984 -3.35% 4,499 4,183 106% 106%
Scranton-
Wilkes-Barre, PA 549 -3.24% -1.23% 1.91% 2001 -3.04% 608 556 99% 100%
New York-
Northern New Jersey-
Long Island,
NY-NJ-PA 19,098 -3.14% 1.47% 4.51% 1977 -2.95% 19,191 16,601 116% 117%
Dayton, OH 836 -2.95% -0.17% 2.53% 1977 -1.96% 858 825 101% 102%
Syracuse, NY 643 -2.85% 0.11% 3.31% 1998 -2.61% 670 651 99% 102%
Akron, OH 699 -2.61% 0.42% 3.50% 1978 -1.46% 700 659 106% 108%
Tulsa, OK 923 -2.24% 6.05% 15.30% 1989 -1.31% 931 757 123% 164%
Baton Rouge, LA 786 -1.85% 6.57% 13.85% 1990 -0.25% 799 625 128% 173%
Philadelphia-Camden-
Wilmington,
PA-NJ-DE-MD 5865 -1.66% 1.26% 2.99% 1977 -1.31% 5,892 5,266 112% 112%
Milwaukee-
Waukesha-West
Allis, WI 1557 -1.61% 1.32% 4.52% 1977 -1.49% 1,564 1,393 112% 113%
Oklahoma
City, OK 1219 -1.57% 6.46% 14.84% 1990 -0.01% 1,231 973 127% 176%
Springfeld, MA 689 -1.52% 0.83% 4.08% 1980 -0.72% 690 647 107% 108%
St. Louis, MO-IL 2829 -1.36% 1.52% 2.73% 1975 -1.19% 2,842 2,501 114% 114%
Chattanooga,
TN-GA 522 -1.34% 4.15% 7.52% 1986 0.50% 525 425 124% 142%
Toledo, OH 649 -1.32% -0.01% 3.61% 2008 -1.16% 662 649 100% 102%
Providence-New
Bedord-Fall River,
RI-MA 1604 -1.31% 1.73% 4.21% 2008 -0.80% 1,618 1,597 101% 117%
Charleston-
North Charleston-
Summerville, SC 658 -1.13% 8.37% 15.45% 1996 -0.38% 672 518 130% 201%
Note: Five-year growth rates less than or equal to 1 percent and 2009 Population >= 500,000.
Source: Calculations with Woods and Poole Data.
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
21/84
A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
m m which hi li w cmpil. Th i, h clic xpinc h clining ciy,
ing livly lg m wih pplin l 500,000, i livly in h l
40 y. Rcvi cn n hppn.
A imil nlyi iv-y chng in h nmb hhl w l cnc. Th ling
li incl mny h m m h n b pn pplin pn, hgh w
m Up Nw Yk m nw n h li, Syc n Albny. Nw Oln n Bl
gin p h li ing h cii. Anh ining l h nlyi hhl i hw
w m clly xpinc clin in hi hhl pplin vn whn hi l
pplin clin bnilly. In c, ll b Nw Oln n Yngwn hv pplin
bv hi pvi pk inc 1970 n ll hv hhl pplin bv h nmb h
n h w iv-y pi clin. Hnc, h nmb hhl cv m qickly
n m cmplly hn pplin. Thi likly lc h pibiliy h hhl iz clin
whn h mpl hing vcnci, which pmbly lw hing c h wh
min. I my l lc pin i by mny h, incling Gl; h i, h mpl pply vcn hing in clining cii likly c nw mign wih livly lw incm wh
c h lw c hing.
A Closer Look at Seven Metro AreasSvn m lc ciny in pvi cl lk h vi nin
clining ciy. F ncmp cii n bn h i h nin h iinl
clining ciy m h R Bl: Albny-Schncy-Ty, Nw Yk; Clvln-Elyi-Mn,
Ohi; Di-Wn-Livni, Michign; n Pibgh, Pnnylvni. Th h h mngh -gwing m in h cny v h p 30 y. Tw vy lg: L
Angl-Sn An, Clini n Mimi-F Ll-Mimi Bch, Fli. Th hi i
Sckn, Clini. Th ncmp 11 mll m n 29 cni. Th
hgh h pp highligh inc in hi gwh pn v h p 40 y
n hi xpinc ing h bm n b pi h 2000.
A cmpin h bgin wih lk hi pplin pn inc 1969 ( Fig
II-1). Th p w lin L Angl n Mimi, bh which inc bnilly in iz
in h p 40 y. L Angl inc by 54 pcn, Mimi inc by 148 pcn. Sckni h lin h bm. Thgh livly mll in cmpin h h m in hi gp,
i h gwn by 136 pcn inc 1969. Cn h pn h clining m . Th
Clvln, Di n Pibgh m ll clin in pplin ing hi pi. Clvln
clin by nin pcn, Di by 27 pcn n Pibgh by 15 pcn. Th Albny m
gw by 15 pcn ing hi pi b i incl bc i incl n h b xmpl
iinl clining ciy Schncy, Nw Yk. Th ciy Schncy h pplin
v 90,000 ppl in 1950, 78,000 in 1970 n j v 61,000 y.
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
22/84
22 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
A lk mplymn n mng h vn m highligh n impn pin: pplin
n mplymn cl, b n pcly ( Fig II-2). Whil Di xpinc nly
inicl pcng clin in pplin n mplymn b 27 pcn, h h clining m
xpinc gin in mplymn. Clvln n Pibgh xpinc piiv mplymn
gwh 16 n 26 pcn, pcivly. Emplymn l gw mch m pily hn
Figure II-1
Population Patterns for Seven Metro Areas
Source: Woods and Poole.
20092000199019801970
0
2,000
4,000
6,000
8,000
10,000
12,000
14,000Population, thousands
Los Angeles-Long Beach-Santa Ana, CA
Miami-Fort Lauderdale-Pompano Beach, FLPittsburgh, PA
Detroit-Livonia-Dearborn, MI
Cleveland-Elyria-Mentor, OH
Albany-Schenectady-Troy, NY
Stockton, CA
Figure II-2
Employment Patterns for Seven Large Metro Areas
Source: Woods and Poole.
20092000199019801970
0
3000
6000
9000Population, thousands
Los Angeles-Long Beach-Santa Ana, CA
Miami-Fort Lauderdale-Pompano Beach, FL
Pittsburgh, PA
Detroit-Livonia-Dearborn, MI
Cleveland-Elyria-Mentor, OH
Albany-Schenectady-Troy, NYStockton, CA
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
23/84
A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
Figure II-3
Inflation-Adjusted Median Sales Prices for Selected Metro Areas (in 2009 dollars)
Source: FHFA.
2009200019901980
0
100,000
200,000
300,000
400,000
500,000
600,000Median Sales Prices, 2009 Dollars
Los Angeles-Long Beach-Santa Ana, CA
Miami-Fort Lauderdale-Pompano Beach, FL
Pittsburgh, PA
Detroit-Livonia-Dearborn, MI
Cleveland-Elyria-Mentor, OHAlbany-Schenectady-Troy, NY
Stockton, CA
pplin in L Angl (91 pcn) n Mimi (223 pcn). Sckn lg pplin gwh
v hi pi w mch lm xcly by i mplymn gwh.
Th l hi iniil cmpin mng h lg m in hi cin c
pn h pic. Th vilbl ply ch h 11 mll m mng h
vn lg bn . Fig II-3 cnin h min l pic m 1980 hgh 2009 j
inlin n in m 2009 ll. 13 Slc vl cnin in Tbl II-2.
Th lvl h pic n hi gwh vi bnilly mng h m in h
l 30 y. Thi i pcilly i nin i c pn h vl h pk h cn
h pic bm, 2006, liv vl in 1980 ( Tbl II-2). F xmpl, l h pic
in L Angl w 285 pcn high in 2006 hn in 1980 n vn cn clin, n
185 pcn hi 1980 vl. In cn, l h pic in Clvln n Di nw
iv pcn lw hn in 1980, hgh hy i bily xc h 1980 vl pi in h
mi-2000. Th c Sckn i piclly iking. Th min h pic in Sckn gw
by 230 pcn m 1980 2006, b i j nin pcn high y hn in 1980 n b ql
h min h pic in Di. Clly, h R Bl cii i n xpinc h gwh h
Sn Bl cii i; b hy l i n xpinc h m g clin.
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
24/84
24 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
tb ii-2
R md hu Pr fr sv lrg mr ar
1980 2006 2009 2006/1980 2009/1980
Albany-Schenectady-Troy, NY $102,271 $187,285 $188,697 183% 185%
Cleveland-Elyria-Mentor, OH $102,245 $107,723 $96,798 105% 95%
Detroit, MI CMSA
Detroit-Livonia-Dearborn, MI (MSAD) $154,328 $200,426 $144,430 130% 94%
Ann Arbor, MI $170,530 $228,164 $183,006 134% 107%
Los Angeles, CA CMSA
Los Angeles-Long Beach-Glendale, CA (MSAD) $209,008 $526,767 $383,913 252% 184%
Santa Ana-Anaheim-Irvine, CA (MSAD) $138,575 $353,238 $246,660 255% 178%
Miami, FL CMSA
Ft. Lauderdale-Pompano Bch.-
Deerfeld Bch., FL (MSAD) $157,204 $335,943 $215,080 214% 137%
Miami-Miami Beach-Kendall, FL (MSAD) $157,887 $326,914 $237,825 207% 151%
West Palm Beach-Boca Raton-
Boynton Beach, FL (MSAD) $169,543 $332,875 $213,190 196% 126%
Stockton, CA $132,139 $303,816 $143,914 230% 109%
Note: Five-year growth rates less than or equal to 1 percent and 2009 Population >= 500,000.
Source: Calculations with FHFA data.
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
25/84
A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
Thi cin ic n pn vinc b h pn l vl in m
h hv xpinc bnil n pin clin in pplin n mplymn. A pwl
niv n ng mpiicl vinc gg h h pic in ch cii xpinc p clin
ing h pi pplin n mplymn clin; hm, h cvy in h pic i
vy lw n incmpl. Th iniin nlying hi y i livly impl n cnin wih
bic ml pply n mn: ppl mv; h, pmn biling, ic n hpping
mll n. A l, clining cii cn xpc xpinc p clin in h mn
xiing hing, which l mch lw h pic givn h h ck xiing hing i
livly ix. Fll cvy h pic in ch n nvinmn qi ih cin in
h ck hing gnc in h iz h pplin.
Th bi hi picin h bn xmin in lg hicl n mpiicl by li
b h pic liciy h pply hing. Th li ypiclly k xplin h pn
h pic hck mming m n inc in h mn hing, which cn b gn
by inc in h min iv hing mn: pplin, hhl incm n in .
Gnlly, h pic nw hing i livly lic; h i, gwh in mn l bnil
inc in hing pply n livly m inc in h pic. Bil pn
piiv gp bwn h mk pic hing n h c cncin by incing hi
pcin nw hing. A l, bnil n plng bv-nml h pic
gwh inc in mn n h nm lng pc iinl hing i vilbln h gly nvinmn i ppiv iinl hing. I ih h cniin i
n ii, hn xpnin h pply hing i inhibi n bnil n in pic
inc pibl.14
Thi y c n mk in which mn i in pin clin. Wh hppn
h pic in h mk? Gl n Gyk (2005) pn bh cmphniv niv
n cmplling mpiicl vinc h h pic in clining cii cn b xpc clin
Section iii:
WhAt hAppenS
to ReAl eStAte vAlueSin declining citieS?
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
26/84
26 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
hply n cv lwly in hi y bn clin n bn hing. A h c hi
viw i kink pply cv, which i livly l (lic) iin h hing ck n
livly p (inlic) cin in mn. In ch n nvinmn, pin clin in
mn gn bnil clin in pic. Thy w ky pic mpiicl vinc. Th
i xmin pn pplin chng n mn h pplin clin in cii n
b pin l h pplin clin cnibl pi im. Th cnhw h h pic chng i bnilly mng cii in h mi pi bnil
n pin pplin clin v cii h xpinc pplin gwh. Thi mpiicl
vinc invlv h xminin 10-y chng in h pic 321 ciy cl ing Cn
1970, 1980 n 2000. Th c i pn h pn pplin n h pic gwh
ch 10-y pi ncin h gwh in h pplin h cii. Sng mpiicl
vinc n ymmic c pplin gwh pn h pic gwh i pn. In
picl, clin in pplin gwh by n pcn l nly w-pcng pin p
in l h pic v h c. In cn, l h pic gw by nly b 0.23 pcn
p n-pcn gwh in pplin gwh mng gwing cii. Th i, h pic clin v
10-y pi mming m n-pcn clin in pplin i b nin im high hn
h inc in h pic n-pcn inc in pplin h m pi.
Aiinl mpiicl vinc i pn in hi cin h bh pp n xpn pn h
y l by Gl n Gyk. Th i xhibi i impl xminin h clin bwn
gwh in h iz h hing ck n gwh in pplin cni in Nw Yk S
h pi 2000 2008 ( Tbl III-1). Th cni nk by h iz pplin clin
bwn 2000 n 2008. Sixn cni xpinc pplin clin ing hi pi. Amng
hi gp, nly n xpinc clin in h hing ck, n hi w nly .01 pcn
Mngmy Cny, which i livly l cny in h Albny-Schncy MSA. Clly, h
ppl mv b h h ill h.
Th cn pic mpiicl vinc c pciiclly n h linhip bwn l h
pic gwh n chng in pplin gwh. I mi h nlyi Gl n Gyk, b
in n pnilly ich n h pic. Rl h pic gwh i m
ing h Fl Hing Finnc Agncy (FHFA) h pic inx mplin n
pplin m W n Pl.15, 16 Th imin n 132 m wih pplin
in 2008 l 100,000 ppl n wih FHFA pic inx h bgin in 1980 li; h l
nmb bvin i 3,410.17 Th incl y 1980 2007. Th pnn vibl i h
m cn h-y pcng chng in l h pic. Th inpnn vibl incl
h m cn h-y pcng l in pplin gin in pplin. Th m
pplin l i ih ngiv nmb 0; imilly, h m pplin gin i ih
piiv z. Thi llw h ml cp h ymmic impc pplin gin v
l. Th ml l incl ix c bh h m n ch y in
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
27/84
A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
tb iii-1
cg Ppu v. hug U lrg nw Yrk cu
Ranked Population Decline Percent Change between 2000 and 2008
County Name Population Housing Units
Orleans County, NY 4.6% 0.9%
Erie County, NY 4.3% 1.8%
Genesee County, NY 4.2% 1.4%
Chemung County, NY 3.6% 0.7%
Herkimer County, NY 3.5% 1.7%
Tioga County, NY 3.1% 1.6%
Broome County, NY 2.8% 0.0%
Cayuga County, NY 2.6% 1.1%
Niagara County, NY 2.4% 2.6%
Wayne County, NY 2.3% 3.3%
Montgomery County, NY 2.1% 0.1%
Livingston County, NY 1.8% 4.3%
Oneida County, NY 1.6% 0.7%
Onondaga County, NY 1.2% 3.1%
Oswego County, NY 0.8% 2.0%
Monroe County, NY 0.4% 3.2%
Madison County, NY 0.5% 3.4%
Schoharie County, NY 1.0% 4.0%
Albany County, NY 1.2% 2.7%
Nassau County, NY 1.3% 0.0%
Rensselaer County, NY 1.8% 4.5%
Ulster County, NY 2.2% 5.4%
Queens County, NY 2.9% 2.9%
Washington County, NY 2.9% 6.5%
Westchester County, NY 3.3% 3.5%
Schenectady County, NY 3.3% 2.3%
Putnam County, NY 3.7% 4.2%
Kings County, NY 3.7% 4.0%
Rockland County, NY 4.1% 4.6%
Warren County, NY 4.2% 8.2%
Ontario County, NY 4.2% 7.0%
Bronx County, NY 4.4% 4.4%
Dutchess County, NY 4.5% 6.2%
Tompkins County, NY 4.8% 5.5%
New York County, NY 6.3% 6.6%
Suolk County, NY 6.5% 4.4%
Saratoga County, NY 8.3% 10.3%
Richmond County, NY 9.8% 9.3%
Orange County, NY 11.2% 9.9%
Average 1.4% 3.8%
Source: U.S. Census Bureau, Population Division.
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
28/84
28 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
cnl ll h h vibl h impc h pic. Th l n ky iic
cnin in h i clmn Tbl III-2.
Th l ngly cnim h bic hyphi n h Gl n Gyk l. Th ky cicin
nw 4.32 pplin l n 1.80 pplin gin. Th n-pcn pplin c
i im c h pic by 4.32 pcn v h-y pi wh n-pcn
pplin inc i im inc h pic gwh by nly 1.80 pcn. Thi ymmic
l i cnin wih h bic niv h ppl mv hn l .
Nw nin i n in b l qin: D pi bnil h pic
clin n b llw by nh pi clining h pic? Thi i lm n inv
qin in Fl Dpi Innc Cpin (FDIC) y by Angll n Nmn
(2005) nil U.S. H Pic: D B Alwy Fllw Bm? Thy cncl h b
n ypiclly llw bm ing FHFA h pic inx h pi 1979 2003.
Th m ypicl cm pi bnil h pic gwh i pi livly
l h pic gwh. I imil b in qin: D h pic b lwy
llw h pic b? Th qin i xpl by iming gin qin imil h
n p in Clmn 1 Tbl III-3AB n ing h m xmin hw h-y l
tb iii-2
tg fr ayr Rp f tr-Yr R hu Pr Grw
Ppu G d l
Independen t Variables Dependent Variable: Three-Year Real House Price Change
Last Three Years o Population Change i Negative 4.32
Std Error 0.47
Last Three Years o Population Change i Positive 1.80
Std Error 0.10
Last Three Years o Real House Price Change i Negative 0.72
Std Error 0.02
Last Three Years o Real House Price Change i Positive 0.87
Std Error 0.01
Constant 0.03 0.05
Std Error 0.02 0.01
Observations 3410 3463
R-squared 0.41 0.77
Number o MSAs 132 134
Sample Balanced Balanced
End Year 2007 2007
Fixed Eects or Year Yes Yes
Fixed Eects or MSA Yes Yes
Note: Population o at least 100,000 in 2008 and FHFA House Price Index Data since 1980. New Orleans excluded.
Source: FHFA Price Indexes and Woods and Poole or Population.
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
29/84
A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
pic chng ncin h m cn n lgg h-y l h pic clin. Th
pciicin incl ix c ch m n ch y in h mpl. Th l
cnin in Clmn 2 Tbl III-3AB.
Th cicin h w lgg vl h pic chng n xhibi h m ymmy
n wih pplin gin n l. Th cicin n h w lgg vl l h
pic chng 0.72, i h lgg pic chng w ngiv n 0.87, i h lgg pic chng
w piiv. In c, hy gg h h impc lgg pic inc i clly lg hn
h lgg pic clin.
H i pnil xplnin h l n why w in n ymmic pn in h c
lgg pplin gwh b n lgg h pic gwh. H pic clin cn b gn
by viy vibl h c hing mn. Th incl inc in in , igh
ci n lw vg hhl incm. In ch c, h pic cn b xpc c,
ll l ql; hwv, clin in h nnpplin c hv n ypiclly bn pin
h pplin c ci wih clining cii wll icl n cmn by
Gl n Gyk n cnim by h vinc in hi pp. I , h pic clin
gn by cin in, y, vg hhl incm inc in in will b l
ymmic inc cin in hhl incm inc in in n ncily
bing b clin in pplin n bil p xc hing ck.
In c, viw h xpinc h m wih h lg clin in h pic pp
hi viw n l highligh h niqn h l w y. Th-y chng in l h
pic w cmp ch h 384 m which FHFA vilbl.18 Th l
pin Tbl III-3AB li h 30 m wih h lg h-y clin in l h
pic ing hgh 2008. All h h clin l 25 pcn v h-y pi.
Th lg clin w 46 pcn Anchg, Alk h pi 1988 1990. N h w
h n h li i h nin iinl clining ciy: Wn, Michign, which i m
wihin h lg Di m n Di il. Th hvily cncn in h
Sn Bl n, in picl, h Shw. Th incl mny h w piclly h-hi by h
il n ving n ln ci h 1980, ch Ain, Oklhm Ciy, Sn Anni n Hn.
In c, h xpinc hi p h cny m h w ginl h pic clin in
h Uni S nil h cn cii n m h bi h h pic cni vl h ci ik h pli Fnni M n Fi Mc. Hwv, h
plc n i h nin h iinl clining ciy n h clin w m likly ivn
by livly mpy clin in hhl incm n iing in ing hi pi,
h hn by pin pplin clin. M impnly, 17 h m h piiv
gwh in h pvi h-y pi n h vg gwh in h pi h y w iv
pcn; hnc, bnil pi h pic clin n pp b ng pic
h pic clin. In iin, mny h plc hv cv h nicly inc h l
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
30/84
30 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
1980 in cn h xpinc iinl clining cii. I viw hi cnin wih h
niv in h pvi pgph: h pic clin n ncily vn lly
l-pping, h hy pn pn wh c hm. I h c i pin clin in
pplin n mplymn h lv bnil xc pply, hn pin clin in h
pic cn b xpc. I, hwv, h c h clin l mpy clin in
h iv hing mn, hn h pic m bl cv wih im in m .
tb iii-3a
mr ar w lrg tr-Yr R hu Pr D
Between 1980 and 2006
Year of Worst Three-Year Real Three-Year Real House Price
Metro Area Three-Year Decline House Price Decline Decline Three Years Earlier
Anchorage, AK 1990 46% 22%
Austin-Round Rock-San Marcos, TX 1990 39% 4%
Austin-Round Rock-San Marcos, TX 1989 39% 14%
Oklahoma City, OK 1988 35% 7%
San Antonio-New Braunels, TX 1990 33% 2%
Oklahoma City, OK 1989 32% 16%
San Antonio-New Braunels, TX 1989 32% 1%
Rockingham County-Straord County, NH 1992 31% 16%
Manchester-Nashua, NH 1993 31% 9%
Manchester-Nashua, NH 1992 30% 11%
Los Angeles-Long Beach-Glendale, CA (MSAD) 1995 30% 1%
Peoria, IL 1986 30% 26%
Manchester-Nashua, NH 1991 29% 36%
Rockingham County-Straord County, NH 1993 29% 8%
Riverside-San Bernardino-Ontario, CA 1995 29% 6%
Bridgeport-Stamord-Norwalk, CT 1991 29% 44%
Oklahoma City, OK 1990 27% 21%
Houston-Sugar Land-Baytown, TX 1988 27% 20%
Cleveland-Elyria-Mentor, OH 1982 27% 15%
Detroit-Livonia-Dearborn, MI (MSAD) 1983 27% 15%
Chicago-Joliet-Naperville, IL (MSAD) 1982 27% 17%
Dallas-Plano-Irving, TX (MSAD) 1990 27% 1%
St. Louis, MO-IL 1982 26% 23%
Anchorage, AK 1988 26% 4%
Warren-Troy-Farmington Hills, MI (MSAD) 1983 26% 12%
Rockingham County-Straord County, NH 1991 26% 37%
Houston-Sugar Land-Baytown, TX 1986 26% 1%
Austin-Round Rock-San Marcos, TX 1988 26% 17%
Peabody, MA (MSAD) 1991 25% 38%
Corpus Christi, TX 1990 25% 10%
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
31/84
A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
tb iii-3B
mr ar w lrg tr-Yr R hu Pr D
Since 2006
Year of Worst Three-Year Real Three-Year Real House Price
Metro Area Three-Year Decline House Price Decline Change Three Years Earlier
Stockton, CA 2009 -75% 47%
Modesto, CA 2009 -73% 49%
Vallejo-Fairfeld, CA 2009 -62% 41%
Cape Coral-Fort Myers, FL 2009 -60% 55%
Salinas, CA 2009 -60% 47%
Port St. Lucie, FL 2009 -58% 54%
Las Vegas-Paradise, NV 2009 -54% 52%
Naples-Marco Island, FL 2009 -54% 58%
Riverside-San Bernardino-Ontario, CA 2009 -54% 56%
Bakersfeld-Delano, CA 2009 -47% 61%
Ft. Lauderdale-Pompano Bch.-Deerfeld Bch., FL 2009 -45% 53%
Fresno, CA 2009 -45% 56%
West Palm Beach-Boca Raton-Boynton Beach, FL 2009 -45% 54%
Sacramento-Arden-Arcade-Roseville, CA 2009 -44% 41%
Palm Bay-Melbourne-Titusville, FL 2009 -44% 55%
Oxnard-Thousand Oaks-Ventura, CA 2009 -41% 47%
Reno-Sparks, NV 2009 -41% 50%
Santa Barbara-Santa Maria-Goleta, CA 2009 -40% 41%
Santa Rosa-Petaluma, CA 2009 -40% 34%
Visalia-Porterville, CA 2009 -39% 57%
Oakland-Fremont-Hayward, CA (MSAD) 2009 -38% 35%
San Diego-Carlsbad-San Marcos, CA 2009 -37% 38%
Santa Ana-Anaheim-Irvine, CA (MSAD) 2009 -36% 49%
Detroit-Livonia-Dearborn, MI (MSAD) 2009 -33% -2%
Miami-Miami Beach-Kendall, FL (MSAD) 2009 -32% 51%
Los Angeles-Long Beach-Glendale, CA (MSAD) 2009 -32% 53%
Deltona-Daytona Beach-Ormond Beach, FL 2009 -31% 50%
Phoenix-Mesa-Glendale, AZ 2009 -31% 49%
San Luis Obispo-Paso Robles, CA 2009 -29% 37%
Santa Cruz-Watsonville, CA 2009 -29% 31%
Warren-Troy-Farmington Hills, MI (MSAD) 2009 -28% -1%
Tampa-St. Petersburg-Clearwater, FL 2009 -27% 43%
Note: Population at least 250,000 and Real House Price Decline o at least 15 percent.
Source: FHFA House Price Indexes Adjusted or National CPI
Nw cni nh ln hi mpiicl xci. Whn h li m i cmpil ing
hgh 2009 ( Tbl III-3B), h m wih h w h-y h pic clin
min by h pi 2007 2009. Sckn n Mc, i nby nighb in h n
pin Clini, p h li wih l pic clin nly 75 pcn. M h h n h
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
32/84
32 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
li m in h Sn Bl. Th nly iinl clining cii n h li , gin, Di
n Wn. Hnc, h cn hing cii l cmplly in li wih clin h
p h cmpiin h w h pic clin in h Uni S inc 1980. N, ,
h h pic clin in 2007 2009 ll b h w clining cii w pc by pi
bnil h pic inc in 2005 2007. Th impl vg h pic inc hi
li in h pi 2006 2009 w 45 pcn. Th impl vg h clin h pi 2007 2009 w lm h xc ppi, 44 pcn. Wh w n knw hi im i whh
h pic in h will n v cv. Hiy i ill bing win, hgh m lik
Cli Chn, wh h ml Ecnmy.cm, n pp b pimiic b h pc
cvy mny h .
A Look at a Simple House Price Model for the Seven Metro AreasSm inigh gh by iming impl h pic ml h m ic
li. Th ml xplin h gwh in l h pic ncin lgg hpic gwh, lgg mplymn gwh n ix c ch m n y.
Th 11 m incl in Tbl II-2 h c nin. Th ml i im
ll 11 ing hgh 2007 n hn ply h iinl clining cii n h
Sn Bl cii. Th h pciicin l im ml ing hgh
tb iii-4
sp md f R hu Pr cg fr sv lrg mr ar
Dependent Variable: Annual Percentage Change in Real House Prices (dlog_hp)
Explanatory Variables
Lagged Price Change 0.52 0.54 0.35 0.37 0.48 0.35
Std. Error 0.05 0.08 0.07 0.06 0.10 0.08
Lagged Employment Change 0.63 1.04 0.74 0.92 1.08 0.80
Std. Error 0.18 0.31 0.24 0.18 0.37 0.27
Constant 0.02 0.01 0.02 0.01 0.02 0.01
Std. Error 0.02 0.03 0.02 0.02 0.04 0.02
2005 Year Fixed Eect 0.05 -0.01 0.13
Observations 314 138 176 226 98 128
R-squared 0.68 0.71 0.84 0.61 0.71 0.68
Number o Metro Areas 11 5 6 11 5 6
Fixed Eects or Each Metro Area Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Fixed Eects or Year Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Ending Year 2007 2007 2007 1999 1999 1999
Traditional DC Both Yes No Both Yes No
Note: FHFA House Price Indexes Adjusted or National CPI.
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
33/84
A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
1999 cp ny bnil chng in h ml inc 2000. Th imin l
cnin in Tbl III-4.
Fi, I m ck by h imiliy h im cicin n h lgg vl h pic
n mplymn gwh. Th clining m pp b mly m pniv l
c cp by h cicin lgg mplymn gwh (1.04 v 0.74). Th lgg
h pic ppciin i livly m impn in h clining m (0.54 v 0.35),
b h inc n lg n bh bnilly blw niy. Cicin im cl
1.0 (niy) wl b xpc i cn h pic gwh by il w ng pic h
. Eiming h ml ing pi 2000 n h c y h h pic bm
h ly n mi-2000 gn imil im.
Scn, h m mic inc hw p in h ix c ch y . In picl, h
im h ix-y c h Sn Bl m xc h h clining m
in h ly 2000. F xmpl, h ix c h Sn Bl i 12.7 pcn 2005 v 0.7
pcn h clining cii in hi y. Clly, mhing vy in w hppning in h Sn Bl
h w qi h iny n, php, nlikly cp p in h n . My inclinin i
lbl hi ign inl xpcin h iinl xbnc in h Sn Bl in h ly 2000,
hgh h w clly h c, ch h inc vilbiliy mgg ci n bnil
immigin, invlv.19 Ohwi, I w ck by h imiliy h c im h w
gp mingly vy in m wih vly in xpinc ing h p 30 y.
Conclusions Regarding Question #1Th ky pin h nlyi in hi cin llw. Fi, bnil pic clin cn b
xpc cc h MSA lvl in plc h bnil n pin clin in pplin
n mplymn ( Tbl III-2). Scn, h impl c pi bnil h pic clin
i n ncily ignl pic clin n lng n incmpl cvy ( Tbl III-
3). Thi, im livly impl cnmic ml h pic gwh h mll
R Bl n Sn Bl m vl n piclly iking inc miclly
lg im ix c h ly p h 2000, pcilly 2005. Ovll, h l
cnin wih h viw h bnil pic clin cn b ivn by viy c
h c mn, n j pplin mplymn. I h h c n pinly inclin, hn h pic clin in h n n b pin ih. F xmpl, n
m nml h pic xpcin n m nml cc mgg ci liv h
ly 2000 cn b xpc c hing mn n h pic liv h pk y
iinl xbnc. Onc h nw nml h vibl i ch, hing mn my
wll n piiv gwh n h pic will bgin cv. O c, w ill in
h mi h cn mgg cii n m im i n icv wh h nw nml
will b in h piclly h-hi ing hi cii n whn i will cc.
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
34/84
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
35/84
A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
D m nighbh wihin clining ciy clin m hn h? In picl, m
nighbh xm clin h hn hi lng m vibiliy? Sch iin
mim cll ipping pin, which iin in which picl gnizin
nighbh c cicmnc v i bcm n lng vibl. Wh I hv in min
i mwh lik h ciin bing m wihin mny Chlic ic b which picl
pih cl wn hg pi n ging n iminih cnggin. Thi
picl xmpl i ppn in mny clining cii wihin Nw Yk.
Mch h bn win b vi pn in-mplin clin. Sm h c pn
h clin h cnl ciy lg mplin liv i bbn .20Anh lg
by li xi h c i pciic nighbh clin n h chllng
iniying h ky i vibl nighbh. Thi ppch i pcilly cmmn wihin h
il bn n ginl plnning. Th nlyi in hi cin k pplmn h
impn cnibin in w wy. Fi, h pimy c i pn mll wihin h m
ch Cn c n zip c. Scn, nin i c pn vl pciic mic
l civiy h vilbl lg nmb m n h ppniy
pvi m inigh in h ynmic nlying nighbh chng ing h cn cii
in h mgg n hing mk.
Thgh h cin, mphi i pn h h mic cib n cmn wily
ip in-mplin impc. Th pibiliy wily ip nighbh cm
wihin clining ciy i pcilly impn hhl n bin king mk lng-
m l invmn n piclly impn ln king bil ccl
mgg lning bin. All l ql, ln p n nvinmn wih livly nw
pibl cm bc h lg h ipin pibl cm
picl nighbh, h g h ik ch invmn n lning. Tk xmpl
ln king h mgg ci ik ln in clining ciy. Th ikin i icly
Section iv: WhAt iS the
RAnge of expeRienceS
foR neighboRhoodSWithin declining citieS?
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
36/84
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
37/84
A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
Cnvninl cmmniy vlpmn n plnning pn hv lk v h pc
pplin lm nivlly, wih lil nin pi hw nighbh phyiclly chng
whn hy l pplin. H gg, n ppch y h phyicl chng ppling
nighbh in nvl wy. Th ppch cni hw pplin clin c in
phyicl impc (m l hing bnnmn, xmpl) c in nighbh.
D pn m il c y Flin, Michign, ill h pplin clin cn bm pinl in m nighbh hn in h, gging h hi icl pp ppch
my b l in implmning m clin. Wh i piclly iking b h ppch i
h nm mn qliiv p kn gn hi gg mic hing ni p
c. Th incl xmining Cn , gn bvin nighbh cniin n
inviw wih lcl icil, in n cmmniy l. Th w lgly cnin
h nighbh wihin Flin. Thgh hi y i vy inighl n cmplling, Hlln
ily mi h i i iicl gnliz m hi picl c y ll nighbh
n ll clining cii, b h ly n civly chmpin h n mbl cii in
vlp n pblic plicy mi.
Th ch in hi pp cni viy nighbh mic n limly l n
: vcncy , h pic, h nmb hing l n h vl h ingl-mily
hing ck. Ech i lc bc hy pn plibl m l civiy h
nighbh lvl n bc vilbl m hm. Th c
h vibl n h icin h mpiicl vinc i gniz n ch c.
2000 Vacancy DataTh Cn-gn vcncy m whh hing ni w ccpi h im h
Cn inviw. I m cp c nin nighbh clin n h xplnin
in h pvi cin b why h pic c in h iinl clining ciy
ppl mv m qickly hn hing ni, pn h gn vcn hing ni. I l
cp h pnil xm cm whn ll m hing i vcn n h nighbh
i n lng cni vibl. Th c inmin hi p h mpiicl nlyi i h
inmin pvi n cmpil h Cn-c lvl. Thi pc incl hn
vibl plc ll v h cny, lng wih mpping cpbilii, which hlpl in
highlighing ip nighbh impc. Th vcncy i cmp h i h l
nmb vcn hing ni in Cn c liv h l nmb hing ni. Th
y y 2000 . Cn-c h vn m ic in pvi cin
h nlyi.21 Th chn in hv mix iinl clining cii
n Sn Bl cii piclly h-hi by h cn hing cii.
Fi, higm h iibin h vcncy h Cn-c lvl gn
h cni: Cyhg, in h Clvln m , Wyn Cny in h Di m , n
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
38/84
38 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
Sn Jqin, in h Sckn m ( Fig IV-1 A, B n C).22 Thy ign cp
h ipin h vcncy in 2000 n highligh pnil inc mng h m
h im. Th ky kwy i h h il h vcncy iibin Cyhg
n Wyn Cni, bh iinl clining cii, mch n il w lg vl
liv h Sn Jqin Cny, which i h nly cny in h Sckn m n i
h pniv Sn Bl ciy in hi gp. N, l, h vcncy in 2000 w l lwn m ighly bnch in Sn Jqin Cny hn in Cyhg n Wyn Cni.
Scn, mp h iibin h vcncy mng ll Cn c wihin Cyhg n
Wyn Cni l pn highligh h bnil ipin vcnci wihin h
(Fig IV-2A n B).23 Th hp cn in h in h pp cn p h mp
Cyhg, which gnlly wihin h ciy Clvln, cp hi ipin nicly. F
h c Wyn Cny, vcncy high in h nhn pin h mp, which
incl mny Cn c wihin h ciy Di. Thgh vcncy ypiclly lw in
h Cn c i h ciy h w, xmpl Cn c wih lw vcncy l ppn wihin h ciy Di.
Mp hlpl wy viw h ipin, b piciv mh bni gly m iicl
m ipin. Th llwing gn wi iicl m h vcncy
iibin cp h xn n chc h ipin vcncy wihin ch cny
Figure IV-1 ABC
Histograms of the Residential Vacancy Rate among Census Tracts for Three Counties
Note: vrate = residential vacancy rate and density in percent.
Source: Stata graphs using Geolytics data.
0
5
10
15
Density
0 .1 .2 .3 .4vrate
A. Cuyahoga County
Density
0
5
10
15
0 .1 .2 .3 .4vrate
B. Wayne County
0
5
10
15
20
25
Density
0 .05 .1 .15 .2vrate
C. San Joaquin County
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
39/84
A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
Figure IV-2A
Map of 2000 Residential Vacancy Rates by Census Tract, Cuyahoga County
Formula 1
Range From To Count
1 0.00 0.03 72
2 0.03 0.04 72
3 0.04 0.05 73
4 0.05 0.08 72
5 0.08 0.12 736 0.12 0.19 71
7 0.19 2.00 69
Figure IV-2B
Map of 2000 Residential Vacancy Rates by Census Tract, Wayne County
Formula 1
Range From To Count
1 0.00 0.02 89
2 0.02 0.03 90
3 0.03 0.04 88
4 0.04 0.07 90
5 0.07 0.10 89
6 0.10 0.14 89
7 0.14 0.68 86
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
40/84
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
41/84
A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
tb iV-1
mur f Dpr f 2000 Rd Vy R
cu-tr lv fr 29 cu
Total
MSAs and their Counties Mean Median Std. Dev 95th 99th Skewness Kurtosis Population
Albany-Schenectady-Troy, NY 9.2% 6.1% 8.2% 25.5% 41.1% 2.0 8.4 820,234
Schoharie County 24.8% 15.9% 6.6% 53.1% 53.1% 0.7 1.9 30,546
Rensselaer County 10.3% 7.4% 7.6% 29.5% 32.1% 1.3 4.3 152,349
Saratoga County 9.4% 6.4% 11.3% 26.3% 71.3% 4.0 21.5 204,066
Schenectady County 7.9% 5.0% 6.7% 22.6% 28.2% 1.5 4.3 143,561
Albany County 7.6% 4.8% 17.2% 21.8% 34.2% 1.6 5.7 289,712
Cleveland-Elyria-Mentor, OH 6.7% 4.9% 5.1% 15.6% 25.0% 1.7 7.9 2,106,799
Cuyahoga County 7.7% 5.4% 6.1% 18.3% 29.1% 1.8 7.8 1,349,192
Lorain County 5.2% 4.3% 1.3% 10.9% 26.6% 3.0 16.6 285,644
Lake County 4.0% 3.3% 2.2% 9.2% 10.0% 1.2 3.6 225,403
Medina County 3.7% 3.6% 3.7% 6.4% 6.8% 0.2 2.1 154,795
Geauga County 3.6% 3.7% 1.5% 5.8% 6.0% 0.3 1.9 91,765
Detroit-Warren-Livonia, MI 5.8% 4.5% 4.6% 14.2% 23.1% 1.8 8.4 4,456,076
Wayne County 7.4% 5.4% 2.7% 19.1% 28.7% 1.5 5.7 2,040,413
St. Clair County 7.4% 5.6% 3.9% 14.7% 65.2% 5.4 34.3 166,055
Livingston County 5.7% 4.9% 2.3% 11.4% 19.4% 0.9 4.3 162,974
Lapeer County 5.7% 4.9% 3.1% 11.1% 12.3% 1.1 3.2 89,530
Oakland County 4.3% 3.6% 9.1% 9.9% 15.5% 2.3 11.3 1,199,712
Macomb County 3.3% 2.7% 6.1% 7.5% 10.9% 1.6 7.1 797,392
Los Angeles-Long Beach-Santa Ana, CA 4.0% 3.1% 3.4% 9.9% 16.2% 4.3 39.9 12,518,416
Los Angeles County 4.2% 3.4% 3.4% 10.1% 15.8% 4.4 43.8 9,623,752
Orange County 3.0% 2.1% 3.3% 9.2% 17.5% 4.0 26.4 2,894,664
Miami-Fort Lauderdale-Miami Beach, FL 9.8% 7.3% 8.6% 30.0% 41.6% 2.0 7.8 5,110,265
Palm Beach County 12.9% 10.4% 8.3% 33.6% 46.8% 1.5 5.6 1,154,187
Broward County 9.7% 7.5% 7.9% 29.8% 39.8% 2.0 6.9 1,672,120
Miami-Dade County 7.6% 4.8% 9.6% 27.3% 39.2% 2.5 10.1 2,283,958
Pittsburgh, PA 8.0% 6.0% 5.7% 20.5% 27.8% 1.8 7.1 2,389,583
Armstrong County 10.5% 7.3% 6.8% 38.2% 38.2% 2.5 8.8 72,011
Fayette County 8.8% 7.4% 8.0% 19.2% 29.3% 2.1 8.2 147,277
Allegheny County 8.4% 5.9% 4.0% 22.0% 32.2% 2.0 8.5 1,249,781
Washington County 7.5% 6.5% 2.7% 16.4% 19.5% 1.0 3.7 202,042
Westmoreland County 7.1% 5.9% 5.3% 19.6% 23.8% 1.9 6.5 369,096
Beaver County 6.7% 5.3% 3.9% 16.4% 18.6% 1.4 4.4 175,784
Butler County 5.7% 5.1% 4.5% 11.6% 12.6% 0.9 2.9 173,592
Stockton, CA 4.2% 3.6% 2.7% 9.5% 15.6% 2.4 11.4 593,184
San Joaquin County 4.2% 3.6% 2.7% 9.5% 15.6% 2.4 11.4 593,184
Grand Total 6.0% 4.5% 4.9% 15.7% 24.0% 2.9 21.0 27,994,557
Source: Census and Geolytics.
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
42/84
42 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
USPS Data for 2008 and 2010Th USPS h n in n gmn wih HUD pvi l-im, ib-ich, pcl-
b ym hlp mni n h ciicl i nighbh wih bnil
nmb vcn n bnn ppi. Th p hi gmn i Mplin A
Qly Vcncy Rp. Ech q HUD civ A Mngmn Sym (AMS) ZIP+4
xc inii by USPS ci hving bn vcn n- n ggg
hi h Cn-c lvl l n HUD Oic Plicy Dvlpmn n Rch
wb i. Th USPS Vcncy Svy h bn vilbl v 60,000 Cn c n qly
bi m 2005 hgh 2010:Q2.
Th h piclly civ h liv h Cn-m vcncy
. Fi, hy m h in vcnci. Scn, vcncy inmin i
vilbl bh inil n bin . Thi, hy pvi n xclln ppniy
y h vlving impc ing h cn cii. Ech h i xpli pvi
inigh b h ipin vcncy chng wihin mk xpincing bnil clin
in hi hing mk.
Th USPS vy pvi inmin b h l nmb inil n h nmb
vcn , which llw cmpin Cn-lik m h vcncy , b h
Cn m nly inic whh h ppy w vcn h mpling . Th USPS
m l inmin b h vg nmb y h h ni vcn. Thi
pmi h cmpin m gnl n b m vcnci. Th iniin
in hi cin (VR_y) i llw: VR_y = nmb vcn ni vg nmb
y vcn / (365 nmb ). A ch, VR_y m h cin y h h
inil hing ck w vcn ing y liv 100 pcn ccpncy.25 Thi m
gnlly pvi mch high im vcnci hn h Cn m. F xmpl, h
vg Cn vcncy mng h 64,891 Cn c in h 2010:Q2 USPS w 4.2 pcn
wh h in-wigh vcncy w 7.0 pcn, which i m hn 68 pcn high.
W iliz hi nhnc m vcnci highligh inc in h vi iicl
m ipin n bv. On cmpin c pn h ipin VR_y mng
233 cni wih pplin l 250,000 ppl in 2000. Th iincin i m bwn
h h gw in pplin bwn 2000 n 2008 (189 cni) n h h clin in
pplin ( Tbl IV-2).
Th l mn mch m cnin n xpc pn hn bv wih
h Cn vcncy m. Vcncy mch high mng h cni h hv
xpinc pplin clin hn mng h h l pplin. In picl, bh h
mn n h min h in-wigh vcncy mng Cn c cni
h xpinc pplin clin lm bl h mng cni h xpinc
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
43/84
A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
pplin gwh bwn 2000 n 2008 (10.1 v 5.2 pcn n 5.6 v 3.1 pcn). In
iin, h iibin vcncy wihin h cni wih pplin clin i mch
m ip, incl mch lg xm vl n i l hn h iibin wihin
gwing cni. Thi pin i cp by inc in h n viin (12.4 v 6.7
pcn), inc in h 95h n 99h pcnil vl (33.5 v 16.8 n 53.4 v 30.5
pcn) n inc in ki pkn (23.5 v 87.2). Th nly iicl m
wih hi pn i kwn, which m h g which h iibin i il
h igh h vg vl w lg vl. I xpc l kwn h gwing
cni, b j h ppi w n.
Th m nlyi i cnc h Cn-c lvl ch vn m chn pcil
nin in hi y. Slc iicl m pn ch h 29 cni wihin
h m ( Tbl IV-3). Th cni nk by h mn vg in-wigh
vcncy ing 2010:Q2 . Th pn in h l iking n m ng
cnimin h cnl hyphi hi cin clining cii hv high vg vcncy
n mny m xm vl iniciv pnil ipping pin. Thi i m vin mng
h cni h ncmp h cnl cii h clining m. F xmpl, Wyn Cny,
which incl h ciy Di, h n vg in-wigh vcncy 27.6 pcn
n iv pcn i Cn c hv in xc 87.4 pcn. Th 99h pcnil vl
i n mzing 111.2 pcn, Cn c wih impl vcncy 40 pcn, b n vg
in inil vcncy h xc 1000 y, lm h y. Th nx h l
i h nin clining ciy cny Cyhg, Allghny n Schncy. Th in-
wigh vcncy xc 12 pcn n hv n viin h w h im
tb iV-2
mur f Dpr f UsPs Dur
Weighted Residential Vacancy Rates in 2010:Q2 among Large Counties in the US
Population Gain Population Loss
between 2001 and 2008 between 2001 and 2008 All Large Counties
Mean 5.2% 10.1% 6.2%
Median 3.1% 5.6% 3.7%
Standard Deviation 6.7% 12.4% 7.9%
95th Percentile Value 16.8% 33.5% 20.3%
99th Percentile Value 30.5% 53.4% 35.3%
Skewness 5.1 3.2 4.7
Kurtosis 87.2 23.5 73.9
2001 Population 1,736,014 1,629,390 1,713,750
N 189 44 233
Note: County Population greater than 250,000 in 2001.
Source: USPS Vacancy Survey.
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
44/84
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
45/84
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
46/84
46 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
inc vy cny xcp S. Cli. Sill, h Sn Bl h y xpinc nyhing lik h
vcncy in h clining cii.
Thi pp, lik m in h li, c pn inil l wing vilbiliy.
Th USPS n nl ppniy cc n vl inmin b nninil
ppy. I ck h nmb bin , h nmb vcn bin n h
in h vcnci. Th m in-wigh m bin vcnci i cmp
ing hi inmin n pvi in Tbl IV-5. Th inmin incl 2010:Q2 wll
chng inc 2008:Q2 n nk by h 2010:Q2 bin vcncy .
A iking h i h mch high bin vcncy hn inil vcncy
. In c, impl invigin h clin bwn inil n bin vcnci
h 6,518 Cn c mng h cni vl ng cnncin. A impl gin
wih cnn m hw h h bin vcncy i b 50 pcn high hn h
inil vcncy n h n R2 50 pcn, which gg ng linhip. Thgh
hi linhip wn m y, n likly inl hi cl linhip i h mny
h bin h mll bin h v h lcl pplin, .g. n,
lni, g in, c. Whn h mn hing in h clin, h mll bin
likly b h-hi wll. Th cnin wih hi xplnin.
Lik inil vcnci, bin vcnci hv in bnilly ing h G Rcin.
A impl gin gin cnim bh h bnil i n ng clin wih vcncy
in 2008:Q2. Th in-wigh bin vcncy in 2010:Q2 i 64 pcn high in
2010:Q2 hn in 2008:Q2 mng h 6,533 Cn c in h gin. R2 h gin i 88
pcn. Thi cgy nninil l h bn hi h n pp b clly l
pn in h inil c.
Analysis of Stockton and Cleveland Housing DataM ic m h viliy nighbh wihin hing mk incl m
h pic, h vlm l n h vl h hing ck. Illy, ch inmin wl b
vilbl viy nighbh n qn im pi, which pmi inigh b hw
h ynmic h nighbh chng v im. Unnly, ch inmin h hiiclly
bn n n nnxin. Dcnnil inmin h yp by Gl n Gyk w
n h b vilbl y ny yp im pn hing h nighbh lvl.
W in h mi vlin in which ch bcming incingly vilbl. Th
pimy c ch inmin cni pblic c n h l n ppy x
c, which hv bcm incingly vilbl vi vi ggg wh n h
gn m vlin ml (AVM) h vl. Th piv vn n cmpni
wh pc n vlp AVM gn incm by lling h n h AVM pc. 27 On
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
47/84
A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
h ling im in hi n Clll Anlyic i h by m cllg wh h
kinly pvi vlbl hi y.28
Th yp inmin hv bn pvi ch zip c in w h m wihin h
c gp: Clvln n Sckn. D h w q highligh cn pn
in w plc wih vy in hii. Clvln ll in h cgy iinl clining
tb iV-5
mur f cg Drbu f UsPs Dur-Wgd Bu
Vy R fr 2010:Q2, 2008:Q2 fr 29 cu
2010:Q2 Values Change from 2008:Q2
Total Business
Metro Area County Name Mean Median Std Dev 95th 99th Addresses Mean Std. Dev 99th
Detroit Wayne County 62.2% 51.7% 46.0% 154.9% 211.6% 61,223 27.7% 20.6% 94.2%
Cleveland Lorain County 35.1% 31.0% 25.5% 83.9% 108.7% 8,494 13.2% 6.4% 2.2%
Albany Schenectady County 34.3% 25.4% 29.0% 97.2% 107.5% 3,895 12.2% 9.3% 20.2%
Cleveland Lake County 33.2% 32.1% 22.8% 68.8% 118.4% 9,360 14.7% 9.3% 55.6%
Pittsburgh Butler County 32.2% 25.5% 25.4% 99.1% 100.6% 5,321 14.0% 11.0% 41.6%
Cleveland Cuyahoga County 31.0% 26.3% 26.9% 82.6% 128.8% 52,246 11.9% 10.7% 44.2%
Pittsburgh Allegheny County 27.9% 24.2% 23.3% 72.9% 98.2% 50,023 12.2% 8.6% 34.1%
Cleveland Geauga County 27.7% 24.8% 12.8% 45.7% 51.8% 2,723 15.2% 3.7% 18.8%
Detroit St. Clair County 27.6% 26.3% 27.3% 72.2% 121.0% 4,645 6.6% 9.0% 42.1%
Pittsburgh Beaver County 27.3% 19.0% 28.5% 82.8% 138.9% 5,308 12.7% 12.3% 61.7%
Detroit Macomb County 27.1% 25.7% 19.7% 57.1% 84.4% 26,286 10.3% 7.6% 25.1%
Albany Albany County 26.1% 21.0% 24.1% 73.4% 106.6% 11,812 10.4% 7.7% 26.0%
Miami Broward County 26.1% 22.4% 20.3% 59.6% 89.2% 87,680 13.5% 9.1% 33.9%
Detroit Oakland County 25.5% 23.1% 21.7% 68.0% 90.1% 51,233 10.1% 9.4% 34.8%
Albany Rensselaer County 22.3% 18.0% 19.8% 57.1% 73.7% 3,622 11.1% 5.5% 20.1%
Pittsburgh Armstrong County 21.2% 19.3% 16.4% 60.5% 60.5% 2,074 9.7% 6.0% 25.3%
Miami Palm Beach County 21.0% 16.1% 20.5% 60.5% 101.5% 71,266 10.5% 8.4% 41.9%
Pittsburgh Westmoreland County 20.5% 14.2% 22.8% 65.1% 113.1% 12,541 8.0% 9.1% 45.0%
Pittsburgh Washington County 20.2% 15.1% 24.4% 71.1% 101.5% 6,945 8.5% 10.6% 38.9%
Cleveland Medina County 19.1% 9.8% 21.6% 74.3% 83.3% 4,570 10.3% 8.7% 42.3%
Detroit Lapeer County 19.1% 22.0% 14.8% 37.3% 40.8% 2,045 9.5% 7.2% 15.6%
Miami Miami-Dade County 17.0% 13.9% 14.8% 43.7% 72.1% 129,232 8.3% 6.6% 32.5%
Stockton San Joaquin County 16.7% 13.3% 16.3% 47.3% 71.1% 17,918 9.9% 7.7% 35.1%
Albany Saratoga County 12.9% 9.2% 13.4% 38.8% 52.6% 5,574 8.0% 4.3% 15.0%
Albany Schoharie County 12.5% 11.8% 11.6% 36.1% 36.1% 526 9.5% 4.5% 17.0%
Detroit Livingston County 11.6% 7.1% 15.7% 49.9% 71.2% 4,745 8.4% 7.7% 23.5%
Los Angeles Orange County 10.1% 7.6% 11.1% 30.4% 55.8% 125,213 4.8% 4.3% 23.6%
Los Angeles Los Angeles County 9.0% 6.4% 11.3% 25.8% 51.8% 389,970 4.2% 4.7% 22.0%
Pittsburgh Fayette County 8.6% 2.0% 14.0% 46.1% 50.2% 3,811 3.6% 6.7% 19.9%
Note: Ranked by the average duration weighted vacancy rate.
Source: USPS Vacancy Survey.
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
48/84
48 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
ciy. Sckn, n h h hn, h bn mng h gwing in h Uni S nil
h G Rcin n nw i i mng h piclly h-hi by h cii. Hnc, h
w pvi n xclln ppniy cmp hw w in yp plc pm ing
pi clin. Th pvi qly inmin inc 2000 n hgh 2010:Q2
h zip c lvl.
Inmin i pvi b hing l, which cni wh Clll Anlyic in
gl (nn-i m lngh) l wll Rl E Own (REO) n cl
l n l pic, which l vilbl by h h cgi bh m . Sp
inmin i vilbl ingl-mily ncin (n ni) n mlimily ncin, which
ypiclly w- -ni ppi. In iin, pcil n niq clclin
pvi h Sckn m ing Clll Anlyic pciv AVM, which pvi
m h vl ingl-mily hing ck h zip c lvl m 2000:Q1 hgh
2010:Q2. A vl ch ppy wihin ch zip c i pvi by hi AVM ch q. D
vilbl hi y m 2000 hgh 2010:Q2. Thi yp inmin i livly nwn impn vlpmn. Th im cmp ing h m ml n clclin
cnc cn AVM im. Th incl cmpin cmpbl ppi,
impl hnic ml n pplicin wigh p l mh. Th ciicl p i
hiicl im h vl h hing ck n qly bi ing nim vlin
mh. Th im l k in ccn h chnging nmb hing ni in h ck
ch q. Th mpiicl nlyi in hi cin iliz hi inmin inigh b h
wily vying in-mplin pn h pic n l ing pi bh bnil
gwh n clin h w m . On i h clic clining ciy Clvln n h
h, Sckn, h bn hi h ny m by h cn cii n my pn nw
yp clining ciy c by h G Rcin.
Tbl IV-6 incl h vi l ig bh plc ing h c. Clvln l l
gnlly wic h nmb Sckn hgh m h c, y i pplin w h
im lg hn Sckn. Bh inc by b 50 pcn ing h i iv y
h c. Th nmb gl l in Clvln pk in 2005 whil Sckn pk w
ch y li. Th nmb 2010 pn h hgh 2010:Q2.
Th m mic pc h l nmb i h chng in h cmpiin l in h w. Fig IV-3 highligh h chng by pling h h ll ingl-mily l h w
gl nni bh m n cmpi h w. F Clvln, h c
bgin wih gl l h minn pin ll l (b 94 pcn), b gl l
iminih liv REO n cl l v h nx vl y. Th lw pin cc
b 60 pcn in 2008, b h inc inc hn i m. Th pn in Sckn i mch
m mic. Rgl l min hgh 2006 b clin by hl in 2007 n cmpi nly
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
49/84
A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
11 pcn ll l in 2008. Rcvy inc hn h bn m n gl ingl-mily l
min l hn n-hi ll l.
Fig IV-4 k cp h xn viin in h pic chng mng ll h zip
c in h w m . Th mic i h pcn chng in n vg l pic incliv
Figure IV-3
Regular Share of Total Single-Family Sales for Cleveland and Stockton
from 2000 thru 2010:Q2
Source:Collateral Analytics.
201020082006200420022000
0
20
40
60
80
100Percent
Regular Single-Family Share for Stockton
Regular Single-Family Share for BothRegular Single-Family Share for Cleveland
Figure IV-4Distribution of Zip Code Based Changes in Current Average Single-Family House Values
for all Sales from Peak for Cleveland and Stockton
Source: Collateral Analytics.
0.010.050.100.250.500.750.900.950.99
-100
-80
-60
-40
-20
0
Change in House Values, Percent
Current to Peak: Cleveland
Current to Peak: Stockton
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
50/84
50 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
ll h l yp m h pk y 2006 hgh h 2010:Q2. 29 Th iibin h
chng pl ky pcnil h iibin. Th min clin in Sckn h bn
56 pcn, which i bl h clin in Clvln zip c. Th inqil ng (75h l
25h pcnil) 16 (-25 41) pcn clin Clvln n nin pcn Sckn
(53 62). Fiv pcn h zip c in Sckn xpinc clin in xc 75 pcn.
Clly, h clin bh bnil, n vg, b l wily vying mng bh .
Th vinc m ng pp h bic i i in hi cin h pp, h
wi viin in h cm nighbh wihin clining ciy cn b xpc.
A pvi y nil ZIPpiy D D! by Fllin n Fllin (2007) imil y
ppy pic ppciin in L Angl Cny ing h i ix y h 2000. W gh
whh zip c pning livly lw- n m-incm hhl, m by
Cn inmin in 2000, xpinc high h pic ppciin ing h bm
y h ly 2000 hn in wih livly high incm. Th nlyi n h hy i.
I l vl n ining ci highligh hi ining h zip c wih h lw
ppciin m 2000 hgh 2006 in L Angl Cny w h m 90210 zip c h
incl Bvly Hill n i h nm ppl lviin hw m w y bck.
A impl nlyi i cnc in hi pp Clvln n Sckn. Th highligh pn
in Fig IV-5, which cnin h vg ingl-mily h pic gn by ll h yp
l vl zip c wih livly lg nmb l. On lin pl h vl h
zip c (95376) in Sckn wih h high vg vl hgh m h pi. Avg l
tb iV-6
nubr f sg-Fy s f a typ (Rgur, Reo, d Frur)
fr cvd d sk: 20002010:Q2
Cleveland and Stockton Cleveland Stockton
Total Total Total
Year Regular REO Foreclosures SF Sales Regular REO Foreclosures SF Sales Regular REO Foreclosures SF Sales
2000 32,923 899 1,393 35,215 22,440 560 1,013 24,013 10,483 339 380 11,202
2001 33,605 759 1,329 35,693 23,284 626 1,163 25,073 1,0321 133 166 10,620
2002 36,603 965 1,663 39,231 25,833 860 1,527 28,220 10,770 105 136 11,011
2003 41,611 1,304 2,163 45,078 28,875 1,200 2,039 32,114 12,736 104 124 12,964
2004 47,324 1,558 2,721 51,603 30,707 1,479 2,629 34,815 16,617 79 92 16,788
2005 46,939 2,139 4,043 53,121 31,085 2,086 3,997 37,168 15,854 53 46 15,953
2006 36,997 3,244 5,385 45,626 26,804 3,165 4,999 34,968 10,193 79 386 10,658
2007 25,223 4,640 12,328 42,191 21,320 3,868 8,630 33,818 3,903 772 3,698 8,373
2008 18,298 13,731 18,195 50,224 15,887 5,238 7,383 28,508 2,411 8,493 10,812 21,716
2009 18,514 12,178 11,911 42,603 14,728 4,119 5,184 24,031 3,786 8,059 6,727 18,572
2010 9,408 3,913 5,407 18,728 6,969 1,418 2,602 10,989 2,439 2,495 2,805 7,739
Source: Collateral Analytics.
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
51/84
A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
pic in hi zip c m hn bl m 2000 hgh 2006 b $480,000 p ncin.
Sinc hn l pic in 95376 hv clin b $200,000 n blw vl h h
c. 95206 i zip c wih mch lw vg vl. Pic m hn ipl bwn 2000
n 2006 m $116,000 $362,000 in hi zip c b bginning hi plng vl nly
lighly bv h h bginning h c. Th, h Sckn l i imil wh w
n L Angl Cny h g ppciin w njy mng h livly mly
pic .
Th pn h pic chng wihin Clvln m qi in b pn viw
h zip c pic . Ppy vl w gnlly lw in Clvln hn in Sckn n nn
h lc zip c hw nyhing lik h ppciin xpinc in Sckn. Zip c
44256 b 25 pcn by 2006 b i nw j bv h vg vl in 2003. Zip c 44102,
which i h lw pic zip c in hi gp hw livly lil mvmn hgh h
c. Fi ll, pic ppciin w mch m m in Clvln. Scn, ppy vl
mng h lw-pic i in Clvln i n i in liv m hy i Sckn.
A cmpl xplnin hi pn i ll implicin i n wih h vilbl.
Hwv, llw m pcl. I cl b h inliny xpcin w piclly xgg
mng lw n m incm in h Sn Bl, n mhing lik ginl cngin c
w pn n l xpcin b h gwh hing mn n h pic.
O c, cc ci ply l in ling mn inc bpim pc w piclly
ppl in Clini. Th m inliny v n ppi bpim mgg pc
Figure IV-5
Average Single-Family House Sale Prices for all Sales Types for Several Large Zip Codes
in Cleveland and Stockton: 2000 thru 2010:Q2
Note: Stockton Zip Codes begin with 95 and Cleveland with 44.
Source:Collateral Analytics.
2010200820062004200220000
100
200
300
400
500Average Single-Family Price, thousands $
95376
95209
95336
95206
4425644107
44102
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
52/84
52 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
my n hv bn pn in Clvln. Rging h implicin h in pn, n
pibiliy pin h impc h pic clin n hhl wlh. Th pn gg
h lw-n m-incm hmby in Sckn my b piclly h-hi, wh h
pin my b m vnly iib in Clvln.
Dcmning h chng in h nmb l n l pic b pn ncin cp
j p h impc h hing cii n h lcl hing mk. Php m nmnl
m i h impc n h hing wlh in in h wh my nv hv ngg
in ncin. Clll Anlyic civ AVM pvi niq n vy bing m
h vl h ingl-mily ck hing Sckn ( Fig IV-6). Th i inic
h vlin ingl-mily hing ck m 2000 hgh 2010:Q2 i ivn by w mj
c: chng in h nmb ingl-mily ppi n chng in h vlin h
ppi. Th nmb ingl-mily ppi h bginning h c w 118,000 n
inc b 152,000 in 2010. Th vl hi ck hing bgn h c wih vl
b $17 billin n h min vl h ni w b $156,000. Th vl hi ckinc b $65 billin in 2006 bc inc in bh h nmb ni 148,000
n hi min vl $415,000. Sinc hn h vl h ck h plmm in vl $23
billin. Thi i b $6 billin 35 pcn bv i 2000 vl. Ab iv pcn h chng
i n inc in h nmb ni inc 2000. Th i b 30 pcn inc
in min vl, which w j b h m inc in h vll cnm pic inx h
Uni S inc 2000.
A hm hi cin i h cing lly n n ggg h mplin ll j
p h y. Th in-mplin viin ll nh. Eigh pniv zip c
Figure IV-6
Total Value of Single-Family Housing for Stockton: 2000 to 2010:Q2
100
125
150
175
200
2010200820062004200220000
20
40
60
80Value of Existing Housing Stock, Billions $ Number of Housing Units, Thousands
Housing Units
Value of Housing Stock
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
53/84
A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
lc hlp highligh hi hm. Tw h n in Sckn wih h m vlbl hing
ck 2010 95376 n 95377; h vl h hing ck in h w zip c pn
b 20 pcn h l vl Sckn m hing ck in 2010. Th cl
h vg h n cllcivly pn b 20 pcn h vl h l ck in 2010:
94207, 95209 n 95219. On, 95205, h h lg pcng clin in vl inc i pk ing
h 2000 (79 pcn). On, 95230, h h lw pcng clin in vl inc i pk ingh 2000 (10 pcn). An n, 95236, w lc bc i h n h lw h h
ck (0.57 pcn) n xpinc clin 35 pcn inc i pk. Th vl h ck in
ch h zip c i pl in Fig IV-7 2000 hgh 2010:Q2.
Fllwing m h l h cgh my nin n h highligh h wi viin mng
zip c xpinc. Th vl h hing ck in zip c 95376 bl in vl bwn 2000
n 2005, b h vl i ck hing h inc clin lvl blw i vl in 2000. In
c, h h zip c nw hv lw vl hn in 2000: 95376, 95207 n 95231. Th vl
h ck in 95230 h inc by v 115 pcn inc 2000 n h nly givn bck 10 pcninc i pk in 2005. Vl in 95320 l p by v 100 pcn inc 2000, b xpinc
53 pcn clin inc hi pk.
Sch miv ll c i in hing wlh mng Sckn hmwn likly h n
impc n hi pning n h lcl cnmy. In, mch h bn win b h mginl
ppniy cnm hing wlh.30 Th m m n hi i i Aln
Gnpn, m chimn h Fl Rv B. H n cllg h F, Sni
Ecnmi Jm Knny, i n xhiv y h Sc n U Eqiy Excin
Figure IV-7
Changes in the Value of Single-Family Housing Stock
for Several Representative Zips in Stockton
20102009200820072006200520042003200220010
1
2
3
4
5
6
7Value of Single-Family Housing Stock, Billions $
95376
95377
95209
95219
95207
95205
95236
95230
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
54/84
54 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
h U.S. cnmy whl. Amng hi ining i h qiy xc m hm w
innc b n pcn pnl cnmpin xpni m 1991 hgh 2005. I h
bn piclly impn inc 2000. Eqiy xcin innc b 0.6 pcn pnl
cnmpin xpni in h 1990 n v 1.75 pcn bwn 2000 n 2005.31 I h
nmb pply cnm in h Sckn n pply ing pi p cin
in hing wlh, hn h impc h nly $40 billin clin in h vl wl p i n in hi pning. Al, mny h wh xc hi qiy h pk h
bm likly ply nw in m hi hm qiy.
ConclusionsThi cin vl m n c mic nighbh chng ing
h bm n b pi h p 10 y. A high lvl, h l ngly cnim h
nighbh wihin clining m cn xpinc wily vying xpinc. Th xn
h clin i n h qlly ppinly. Th b xmpl in hi cin myb h xpinc h zip c lvl Clvln n Sckn, which highligh wi inc
in h pic chng n hing wlh. Th nlyi vi vcncy- m i nh
hlpl xmpl bc i gg h impnc mving byn h n iniin
vcncy n n ccpying h ni h im n inviw n h incp h
in ni vcncy. Th in-wigh m vlp wih h USPS Vcncy Svy
m pcilly hlpl in h iniicin nighbh wihin clining cii n
hi ipping pin.
Th nlyi l highligh h inhn cmplxiy ming n mniing nighbh pn.Lking w, nlyi l mk gh b bl bcm m gnl
hn w pibl j 10 y g bc g impvmn in h qliy n vilbiliy
pblic c n h inmin in h USPS Vcncy Svy n h c. Ggphic
Inmin Sym (GIS) mpping chniq my b hlp wll. On h h hn, h
i ill n mj limiin in h vilbl limi im-i high-qncy inmin
b h i hhl in h mk. On hi i h i l m m pimim inc
h l h 20052009 Amicn Cmmniy Svy, which b l in Dcmb
2010, will pvi inmin b hhl h cn b mg h Cn-c lvl wih
h h c n php, vn m qn, gnl n cmpl pic
nighbh vlin hn v b.
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
55/84
A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
Thi cin c pn l b m iicl qin hn h pvi cin; n h i
ciicl h vlpmn ccl hhl nighbh chic, pn ik mngmn
by ln n gvnmn ni chg wih cmbing bn clin. Th qin i whh
hhl, ln n gvnmn hv cn vlp cibl ml cpbl picing which
pciic nighbh likly xpinc h m xm cm, n which incl
h pibiliy bing bnn? Th qin i impn ch h gp viy
n n h impn plicy implicin. Hhl mk hing ciin imln
wih h chic picl nighbh in which liv n i mili. Unciny cn
l cly mik n pic p in nighbh wh m ncin. Ln
king pic mgg ci ik pnly bni m b ml nighbh pic
ipin. Abn ch inmin, ln will b incn vi h nighbh wihpiclly ncin , vn i glin phibi ch cin. Gvnmn icil c
imil chllng in ciing hw llc cc c pm nighbh inbiliy.
In, n h hm in HUD cn nighbh bilizin pgm i vinc m.32
Mlipl glin my n b -xmin in ligh h : cing ln mk iky
ln in clining mk w cinly n h inn h Cmmniy Rinvmn Ac (CRA)
n h lgilin.
H i n xmpl h my hlp xplin wh i k. Ci c n highly cl
wih cil n hnic chciic. Ci c l n b n impn iv mggl. Ln hv bn bl incp ci c in h picing mgg ci ik bc
bnil n cibl mpiicl vinc h bn ccml mn h lgiim
bin miv xi chg high mgg h wih lw c vn hgh hi
mn h, n vg, cin cil n hnic gp will py high hn whi nnHipnic
bw, ll l ql. Abn ch vinc, hy bjc clim h ch plicy h
ip impc n miniy bw.
Section v: cAn We pRedict
With confidence the
potentiAl of SubStAntiAl
neighboRhood decline
Within declining citieS?
-
8/8/2019 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities -- Research Institute for Housing America, December 2010
56/84
56 A Study of Real Estate Markets in Declining Cities
Rch Ini Hing Amic Dcmb 2010. All igh v.
Th m kin i ppli n nlyi pnil nighbh clin i ch clin n
b highly cl wih h cil cmpiin nighbh. I ch clin xi,
gl will qi ln pvi ng vinc jiy inil picing mng
nighbh. Abn ng vinc iingih bwn h c cnmic c clin
wihin nighbh n hi cil cmpiin, ln my ch bnilly inc
nwiing n in