A Contracting Officer’s Guide to Getting Stronger Proposals; Lower, More Realistic Pricing; and...
-
Upload
philip-merritt -
Category
Documents
-
view
220 -
download
0
Transcript of A Contracting Officer’s Guide to Getting Stronger Proposals; Lower, More Realistic Pricing; and...
A Contracting Officer’s Guide to Getting Stronger Proposals; Lower, More Realistic Pricing; and Better Performance from Contractors
April 16, 2013
2
IntroductionsRed Team Federal and Red Team Consulting
About Red Team Federal. . .
Red Team Federal (“RTF”), a division of Red Team Consulting, LLC, is an economically disadvantaged woman-owned small business that provides acquisition strategy and planning, federal procurement training, and contract management support. Our Federal Government experience spans a broad array of industries and marketplaces. We are a Prime on the GSA MOBIS contract, in Acquisition Support and Training.
RTF’s major areas of support include: Pre-Award/Post-Award Contract Support Acquisition Strategy and Planning RFP Development Cost Estimation Performance Based Contracting Source Selection Support Federal Procurement Training
About Red Team Consulting . . .
Red Team Consulting is a woman-owned small business providing a wide range of consulting services in support of federal contracting activities. Our mission is to help our clients grow. Red Team and Red Team personnel have supported over a thousand federal procurements across nearly every agency in the federal government. We have maintained an extremely high win rate since the company was founded in March of 2004.
Red Team’s major areas of support include: Fully outsourced proposal development and
management Strategic capture management and planning Proposal writing Price strategy and Price to Win Training and seminars Outsourced contract and program
management
This presentation contains proprietary information and may not be distributed or reproduced without express written consent from Red Team Federal
3
IntroductionsSpeaker
Jeffrey Shen EVP of Red Team Over 15 years of federal contracting and program management
experience Involved in the award of over $20B of contracts Delivered business strategy, technology solutions to the Federal
Government and Fortune 500 companies worldwide Former V.P of Sales and Marketing for a $300 million integrator. Mentored/trained many successful sales executives, project
managers, and technical staff Active leadership role in industry organizations Frequent speaker on federal contracting, business development,
and government ethics
This presentation contains proprietary information and may not be distributed or reproduced without express written consent from Red Team Federal
4
Agenda
Part 1: Facts About the Industry Proposal Process Quiz Proposal Functions Industry Realities Cost Realities Proposal Solution Realities
Part 2: Guidance Based on Industry Realities Incumbents vs. Non-Incumbents Solicitation Development
SOW/PWS Other Technical Management Past Performance Cost/Price
Part 3: Modeling and Gaming Example
This presentation contains proprietary information and may not be distributed or reproduced without express written consent from Red Team Federal
5This presentation contains proprietary information and may not be distributed or reproduced without express written consent from Red Team Federal
Part 1: Facts About the Industry Proposal Process
Part 1: Facts About the Industry Proposal Process Quiz Proposal Functions Industry Realities Cost Realities Proposal Solution Realities
6
Facts About the Industry Proposal ProcessQuiz
How much do well-prepared companies spend (internally and externally) on average when pursuing a $100 million, single award IT contract with a 100 page count for the Technical, Management, Past Performance, and Price Volumes?
A. $25,000 - $50,000
B. $50,000 - $125,000
C. $125,000 - $250,000
D. $250,000+
Which resource is least likely to contribute to a small business set-aside proposal effort?
A. Professional proposal writers
B. Business development staff
C. Corporate executives
D. Billable staff
E. Technical subject matter expertsThis presentation contains proprietary information and may not be distributed or reproduced without express written consent from Red Team Federal
7
Facts About the Industry Proposal ProcessQuiz
What percent of the proposal development team typically reads the RFP from front to back?
A. 10%
B. 25%
C. 50%
D. 100%
At what point does a pricing team typically address the pricing requirements on a proposal with a 30 day response timeframe?
A. Immediately when the RFP drops
B. Within five days the RFP drops
C. Within the first two weeks of the RFP drops
D. During the last two weeks of the response
This presentation contains proprietary information and may not be distributed or reproduced without express written consent from Red Team Federal
8
Facts About the Industry Proposal ProcessQuiz
How long before the due date do contractors typically complete the proposal?
A. The day it is due
B. One day before
C. Three days before
D. One week before
Companies ask questions during the Q&A period of a final solicitation period because:
A. They want to clarify a section of the RFP
B. They are trying to change a requirement or instruction in the RFP that favors their company
C. They might not have read the RFP front to back
D. They just don’t know any better
E. All of the above
This presentation contains proprietary information and may not be distributed or reproduced without express written consent from Red Team Federal
9
The Joy of Proposals…
This presentation contains proprietary information and may not be distributed or reproduced without express written consent from Red Team Federal
10
Facts About the Industry Proposal ProcessProposal Functions
Capture Management Win Strategy and themes Teaming development Competitive analysis Price to win Marketing and
communications
Proposal Management Proposal schedules Compliance matrix Annotated outline Color reviews Proposal strategy Overall proposal compliance
Other Proposal Functions Capture analysis Pricing strategy Pricing management Costing build-up development Technical writing Volume leadership Proposal coordination Subject matter expertise Editing Desktop publishing Graphics designing Production Business development support
This presentation contains proprietary information and may not be distributed or reproduced without express written consent from Red Team Federal
11
Facts About the Industry Proposal Process Industry Realities
Resources: People who work on proposals typically have other roles within the company There is declining number of strong proposal professionals Due to lack of resources, companies are bidding fewer contracts
Process: Many companies do not often follow a uniform process Corporate bureaucracy causes delays Reliance on teaming partners creates a disjointed proposal effort
Time: Due to other commitments/priorities/poor planning, the proposal effort starts
the moment the RFP comes out or weeks after the RFP release Most proposals are completed last minute
Budget: Many small businesses don’t properly budget their bid and proposal costs to
pursue several contracts a monthThis presentation contains proprietary information and may not be distributed or reproduced without express written consent from Red Team Federal
12
Facts About the Industry Proposal ProcessCost Realities
Cost of Capture Realities Companies spend hundreds of
thousands of dollars on small to medium-sized procurements and millions of dollars on large procurements
This presentation contains proprietary information and may not be distributed or reproduced without express written consent from Red Team Federal
Delays or missed deadlines in the procurement process greatly impact industry
Financial impact New business pursuit impact
Companies record bid and proposal costs as allowable expenses in their G&A. This affects their wrap rates, causing labor rates to be higher. The ultimate result is that the government pays more.
An RFP that hits release timeframes and is easy to understand and respond to will cost a company much less to pursue.
Some companies will determine ways to
recover cost as part of their proposal
development strategy
13
Work Hard, But Work SMART…
This presentation contains proprietary information and may not be distributed or reproduced without express written consent from Red Team Federal
14
Facts About the Industry Proposal ProcessProposal Solution Realities
Prime offerors combine their experience with their partner’s experience to address requirements and they present this as “Team experience”, but sometimes the prime has limited experience with the actual work required.
Many companies do not use their corporate certifications such as CMMI or ISO in day to day operations. The corporate or technical
certifications described in proposals are sometimes not relevant to the division submitting the proposal.
This presentation contains proprietary information and may not be distributed or reproduced without express written consent from Red Team Federal
Companies don’t actually follow the program management
methodologies they write about
Companies will do everything they
can to make their past performance appear “relevant”
15
Facts About the Industry Proposal ProcessProposal Solution Realities
Some companies rely solely on the SOW/PWS and ignore the instructions and evaluation criteria.
There are some companies who possess limited technical experience and will hire outside help to develop their technical approach.
Many small businesses do not understand how to price contracts. Many also utilize incorrect cost data to calculate rates.
On pricing evaluations, companies will find ways to manipulate the pricing model.
This presentation contains proprietary information and may not be distributed or reproduced without express written consent from Red Team Federal
Large businesses have the capability to beat small businesses on price based on their ability to allocate
corporate costs
16This presentation contains proprietary information and may not be distributed or reproduced without express written consent from Red Team Federal
Part 2: Guidance Based on Industry Realities
Part 2: Guidance Based on Industry Realities Incumbents vs. Non-Incumbents Solicitation Development
SOW/PWS Other Technical Management Past Performance Cost/Price Modeling and Gaming
17
Guidance Based on Industry RealitiesIncumbents vs Non-Incumbents
Incumbents work years in advance of their contract closure to try and “influence” the contract to them. Tip: Work closely with PMO to ensure that they do not perform
anything within a closed architecture that does not allow new competition.
If the re-compete RFP comes out looking very similar to the original RFP, industry perceives that this is set for the incumbent. Tip: Communicate openly that the government is looking for new ideas,
innovations, and processes for the re-competed requirement.
If the RFP requirements change significantly, companies think the incumbent is not well liked and want change. Tip: Communicate that the RFP change is not indicative of incumbent
performance and indicative of updated requirements and processes.
This presentation contains proprietary information and may not be distributed or reproduced without express written consent from Red Team Federal
18
Guidance Based on Industry RealitiesSolicitation Development - SOW/PWS
Instructions requiring a response to the PWS/SOW can be confusing. Ensure that the PWS is logically organized. Delineate what portions of the PWS require a response. Avoid duplication of response requirements. Correlate the page limit restrictions to the detail in the PWS.
SOWs/PWSs sometimes don’t change in re-compete contracts. Tip: Technologies, processes, and best practices change in 3 to 5 year
cycles. Industry won’t provide an innovative solution if the requirements haven’t changed. Take the time to update the SOW on a re-compete contract.
This presentation contains proprietary information and may not be distributed or reproduced without express written consent from Red Team Federal
19
Guidance Based on Industry RealitiesSolicitation Development – Other Technical
Companies are hesitant to offer any technical innovation in their proposal for fear of increasing their overall price. Tip: Allow bidders to show some technical innovation and creativity that will
ultimately benefit the government.
Some solicitations require bidders to have a portal or web system to manage the project. To evaluate all bidders fairly, require that everyone put in a link to their “live” portal so they can evaluate it.
Incorporate some measure of risk/reward and metrics into evaluation. Require companies to propose measures and metrics for financial incentives and disincentives for their work performance. Evaluate based on those metrics
This presentation contains proprietary information and may not be distributed or reproduced without express written consent from Red Team Federal
20
Guidance Based on Industry RealitiesSolicitation Development - Management
Corporate certifications such as CMMI or ISO are not often used in day to day operations. Tip: Require that companies explain how they have used their certifications
internally or on prior projects.
If a solicitation requires a management methodology, companies will make one up if they don’t have one. If they do have one, they don’t always follow this methodology post-award. Tip: In the instructions for the management portion, ask for examples where
they’ve used their management methodology successfully on prior projects.
This presentation contains proprietary information and may not be distributed or reproduced without express written consent from Red Team Federal
Require companies post-award to update their contract reporting requirements to include how
they are using their management methodology and certifications
21
Guidance Based on Industry RealitiesSolicitation Development - Management
Companies will propose key personnel that they don’t have or personnel that they know are not going to be available Tip: Request signed offer letters or signed contingent hire letters to show their
commitment to the position. Tip: Do your research on key personnel. Identify background and current job
and assignment.
If recruiting and retention are required in the proposal response, require innovative recruiting methods and prior statistics for filling open positions. Statistics can also include staff turnover, staff retention, and average tenure of existing staff.
This presentation contains proprietary information and may not be distributed or reproduced without express written consent from Red Team Federal
22
Guidance Based on Industry RealitiesSolicitation Development – Past Performance
Primes will take credit for the work the entire team performed as opposed to their own individual contribution. Tip: Ask for clear delineation of work
performed by the prime vs. subcontractor on contracts cited as past performance or experience.
Tip: Ask for information regarding staff that worked on a previous contract, and their role on the proposed contract.
This presentation contains proprietary information and may not be distributed or reproduced without express written consent from Red Team Federal
Make sure specific areas of concern are
addressed to demonstrate quality
such as cost overruns, schedule delays,
performance issues, retention rate, etc.
Require offerors to provide the specific annual revenue number (not total contract value) for each reference to determine relevancy.
Be specific with the questions on the past performance questionnaire. Make sure the they highlight the relevancy towards the Statement of Work.
23
Guidance Based on Industry RealitiesSolicitation Development – Cost/Price
Many small businesses do not often understand pricing approaches and strategy. They struggle with cost type contracts. Tip: Many small companies have never been audited and don’t understand
DCAA. In place of requiring a DCAA latter require companies to provide data to justify rates.
Be cognizant of highly inflated indirect rates or undocumented direct rates. Certain costs are often hidden that the government ends up paying for. Tip: For smaller efforts, require offer letters to see the salary of those staffed
people
This presentation contains proprietary information and may not be distributed or reproduced without express written consent from Red Team Federal
24
Guidance Based on Industry RealitiesSolicitation Development – Cost/Price
Base the pricing evaluation on a sample task order that may or may not be awardable. This forces companies to think about the real level of effort and
rates assigned to proposed labor categories.
Don’t provide the evaluation quantities for labor categories. This prevents the offeror from bidding unrealistic rates (high and low) on various categories.
Look at rates based on reasonableness of individual rates versus looking at total price of hours and rates calculated together.
This presentation contains proprietary information and may not be distributed or reproduced without express written consent from Red Team Federal
25
Guidance Based on Industry RealitiesSolicitation Development – Cost/Price
This presentation contains proprietary information and may not be distributed or reproduced without express written consent from Red Team Federal
Request companies to provide innovative ways/methods as to how they intend to reduce their overall pricing or cost throughout the contract lifecycle. Examples include: Open up a Materials and Handling pool for
material heavy contract. Volume discounting based on labor. Open PMO’s within corporate structure
internally billed.
When utilizing Lowest Price Technical Acceptability, define your technical acceptability evaluation based on the complexity of the requirements. Tip: Consider utilizing minimum acceptability metrics for certain
requirements
Always Ask for
Best and Final Offer!
26This presentation contains proprietary information and may not be distributed or reproduced without express written consent from Red Team Federal
Part 3: Modeling and Gaming
Part 3: Modeling and Gaming Example
27
Modeling and Gaming
Reality Modeling The intent of Reality Modeling is to best predict what changes will likely
occur over the life of a contract and bid with those changes in mind. In other words, compare what is being evaluated with what will actually be purchased, and then determine the timing and margin on the purchase.
Gaming The intent of Gaming is to exploit the inefficiencies and imbalances in a given
solicitation. The Modeling/Gaming process:
Typically a bid model begins with a uniform application of margin to all items.
Items determined to be over-evaluated (i.e bidder believes it is less likely to be sold) – bid with prices below cost
Items that are under-evaluated (i.e. bidder believes it is more likely to be sold) – bid with healthy or even high margins.
Inaccurate evaluation quantities (hours or items) lead to a lower overall evaluated price, but higher prices on orders post-award.
This presentation contains proprietary information and may not be distributed or reproduced without express written consent from Red Team Federal
28
Modeling and GamingExample
This presentation contains proprietary information and may not be distributed or reproduced without express written consent from Red Team Federal
29 29
Questions?
Red Team Consulting proprietary material. Duplication or distribution prohibited without prior written consent.
Jeffrey Shen
11190 Sunrise Valley Dr., Suite 100
Reston, VA 20191
Office: 703-787-9009
Fax: 703-787-9022
www.redteamfederal.com