85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156...

40
National Fire Protection Association 1 Batterymarch Park, Quincy, MA 02169-7471 Phone: 617-770-3000 • Fax: 617-770-0700 • www.nfpa.org MEMORANDUM To: NFPA Technical Committee on Multiple Burner Boilders From: Kim Shea Date: June 11, 2013 Subject: NFPA 85 BCS-MBB First Draft Final Ballot Results (F2014 Cycle) According to the final ballot results, all ballot items received the necessary affirmative votes to pass ballot. 27 Members Eligible to Vote 1 Not Returned ( K. Gamble) 23 Members voted Affirmative on All 3 Members voted Negative on one or more revision (Lee, King and Zadiraka,) The attached report shows the number of affirmative, negative, and abstaining votes as well as the explanation of the vote for each First Revision. There are two criteria necessary for each first/second revision to pass ballot: (1) simple majority and (2) affirmative 2 / 3 vote. The mock examples below show how the calculations are determined. (1) Example for Simple Majority: Assuming there are 20 vote eligible committee members, 11 affirmative votes are required to pass ballot. (Sample calculation: 20 members eligible to vote ÷ 2 = 10 + 1 = 11) (2) Example for Affirmative 2 / 3 : Assuming there are 20 vote eligible committee members and 1 member did not return their ballot and 2 members abstained, the number of affirmative votes required would be 12. (Sample calculation: 20 members eligble to vote – 1 not returned – 2 abstentions = 17 x 0.66 = 11.22 = 12 )

Transcript of 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156...

Page 1: 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156 For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18 For Simple

National Fire Protection Association 1 Batterymarch Park, Quincy, MA 02169-7471 Phone: 617-770-3000 • Fax: 617-770-0700 • www.nfpa.org

 

M E M O R A N D U M

To: NFPA Technical Committee on Multiple Burner Boilders

From: Kim Shea

Date: June 11, 2013

Subject: NFPA 85 BCS-MBB First Draft Final Ballot Results (F2014 Cycle)

According to the final ballot results, all ballot items received the necessary affirmative votes to pass ballot.

27 Members Eligible to Vote 1 Not Returned ( K. Gamble) 23 Members voted Affirmative on All 3 Members voted Negative on one or more revision (Lee, King and Zadiraka,) The attached report shows the number of affirmative, negative, and abstaining votes as well as the explanation of the vote for each First Revision.

There are two criteria necessary for each first/second revision to pass ballot: (1) simple majority and (2)

affirmative 2/3 vote. The mock examples below show how the calculations are determined.

(1) Example for Simple Majority: Assuming there are 20 vote eligible committee members, 11 affirmative votes are required to pass ballot. (Sample calculation: 20 members eligible to vote ÷ 2 = 10 + 1 = 11)

(2) Example for Affirmative 2/3: Assuming there are 20 vote eligible committee members and 1 member did not

return their ballot and 2 members abstained, the number of affirmative votes required would be 12. (Sample calculation: 20 members eligble to vote – 1 not returned – 2 abstentions = 17 x 0.66 = 11.22 = 12 )

 

Page 2: 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156 For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18 For Simple

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

TRUE

NFPA 85 BCS‐MBB First Draft Ballot Results

TRUEFR‐155, Section No. 6.2.4, See FR‐155

Page 3: 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156 For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18 For Simple

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

FR‐172, Section No. 6.4.2.2.14, See FR‐172

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

TRUE

TRUEFR‐157, Section No. 6.4.2.1, See FR‐157

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

Page 4: 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156 For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18 For Simple

Negative 0

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 1

Allan J. Zadiraka Tripping on low furnace pressure results in the furnace pressure going lower 

increasing the probability of damage as a result of the trip action.

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27FR‐164, Section No. 6.4.2.3.4.3(C), See FR‐164

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

TRUE

TRUEFR‐160, Section No. 6.4.2.3.1, See FR‐160

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

Page 5: 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156 For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18 For Simple

Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

TRUEFR‐166, Section No. 6.4.2.3.4.3(D), See FR‐166

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

Page 6: 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156 For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18 For Simple

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

TRUEFR‐174, Section No. 6.4.2.3.6.4, See FR‐174

FR‐170, Section No. 6.4.2.3.6.3, See FR‐170

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

TRUE

Page 7: 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156 For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18 For Simple

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 27

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 1

Allan J. Zadiraka Tripping on low furnace pressure results in the furnace pressure going lower 

increasing the probability of damage as a result of the trip action.

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

TRUEFR‐179, Section No. 6.4.2.3.6.6, See FR‐179

FR‐176, Section No. 6.4.2.3.6.5, See FR‐176

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

TRUE

Page 8: 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156 For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18 For Simple

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27

TRUEFR‐181, Section No. 6.4.2.3.7.4, See FR‐181

FR‐180, Section No. 6.4.2.3.7.3, See FR‐180

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

TRUE

Page 9: 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156 For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18 For Simple

Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

FR‐182, Section No. 6.4.3.1, See FR‐182

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

TRUE

Page 10: 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156 For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18 For Simple

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

FR‐22, Section No. 6.4.3.2.30, See FR‐22

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

TRUE

TRUEFR‐21, Section No. 6.4.3.2.27, See FR‐21

Page 11: 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156 For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18 For Simple

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

FR‐163, Section No. 6.5.3.2.1, See FR‐163

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

TRUE

TRUEFR‐184, Section No. 6.5.2.2.1, See FR‐184

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

Page 12: 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156 For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18 For Simple

Negative 1

Daniel J. Lee FR163 shows that the old clause 6.5.3.2.2 is deleted. But the PI 104 does not state 

that this text needs to be deleted. In fact, PI 106 say to renumber the old 6.5.3.2.2 

to new 6.5.3.2.3 so that a new clause can be inserted.

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

FR‐185, Section No. 6.5.4, See FR‐185

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

TRUE

TRUEFR‐162, New Section after 6.5.3.2.2, See FR‐162

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

Page 13: 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156 For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18 For Simple

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

TRUEFR‐187, Section No. 6.6.2, See FR‐187

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

Page 14: 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156 For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18 For Simple

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

TRUEFR‐189, Section No. 6.6.3.1.12, See FR‐189

FR‐188, Section No. 6.6.3.1.2.2, See FR‐188

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

TRUE

Page 15: 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156 For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18 For Simple

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

TRUEFR‐191, Section No. 6.6.5.1.2, See FR‐191

FR‐190, Section No. 6.6.3.2.6, See FR‐190

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

TRUE

Page 16: 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156 For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18 For Simple

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

TRUEFR‐223, Section No. 6.6.5.2.2.2, See FR‐223

FR‐192, Section No. 6.6.5.2.1.3(B), See FR‐192

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

TRUE

Page 17: 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156 For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18 For Simple

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

FR‐24, Section No. 6.6.5.2.3.9, See FR‐24

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

TRUE

Page 18: 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156 For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18 For Simple

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

FR‐186, Section No. 6.6.5.2.5.2(A), See FR‐186

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

TRUE

TRUEFR‐27, Section No. 6.6.5.2.3.10, See FR‐27

Page 19: 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156 For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18 For Simple

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

FR‐178, Section No. 6.6.5.2.5.3, See FR‐178

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

TRUE

TRUEFR‐177, Section No. 6.6.5.2.5.2(B), See FR‐177

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

Page 20: 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156 For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18 For Simple

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

FR‐198, Section No. 6.7.3.1.2.2, See FR‐198

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

TRUE

TRUEFR‐197, Section No. 6.7.2, See FR‐197

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

Page 21: 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156 For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18 For Simple

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

TRUE

TRUEFR‐199, Section No. 6.7.3.2.6, See FR‐199

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

Page 22: 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156 For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18 For Simple

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 25

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 1

David W. King Paragraph 6.7.5.1.2.2 should be revised as "shall not be operated at low load and 

high excess air conditions" is not specfic and un‐inforcable. Options are: 1. Specify 

according to OEM requirements, 2. Validate via testing the appriate load limit 3. 

Combination of 1&2 or move to Annex.

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

TRUEFR‐224, Section No. 6.7.5.2.2.2, See FR‐224

FR‐201, Section No. 6.7.5.1.2, See FR‐201

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

Page 23: 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156 For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18 For Simple

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

TRUEFR‐32, Section No. 6.7.5.2.3.11, See FR‐32

FR‐26, Section No. 6.7.5.2.3.10, See FR‐26

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

TRUE

Page 24: 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156 For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18 For Simple

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27

TRUEFR‐203, Section No. 6.7.5.2.6.2, See FR‐203

FR‐221, Sections 6.7.5.2.5.2, 6.7.5.2.5.3, See FR‐221

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

TRUE

Page 25: 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156 For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18 For Simple

Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

FR‐200, Section No. 6.8.3.2.6, See FR‐200

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

TRUE

Page 26: 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156 For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18 For Simple

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 25

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 1

David W. King Paragraph 6.8.5.1.2.2 should be revised as "shall not be operated at low load and 

high excess air conditions" is not specfic and un‐inforcable. Options are: 1. Specify 

according to OEM requirements, 2. Validate via testing the appriate load limit 3. 

Combination of 1&2 or move to Annex.

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

FR‐225, Section No. 6.8.5.2.2.2, See FR‐225

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

TRUE

TRUEFR‐202, Section No. 6.8.5.1.2, See FR‐202

Page 27: 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156 For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18 For Simple

Negative 0

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

FR‐33, Section No. 6.8.5.2.3.7, See FR‐33

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

TRUE

TRUEFR‐31, Section No. 6.8.5.2.3.6, See FR‐31

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

Page 28: 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156 For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18 For Simple

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

TRUE

TRUEFR‐222, Sections 6.8.5.2.5.2, 6.8.5.2.5.3, See FR‐222

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

Page 29: 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156 For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18 For Simple

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

TRUEFR‐158, Section No. A.6.4.1, See FR‐158

FR‐173, Section No. 6.8.5.2.5.6, See FR‐173

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

Page 30: 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156 For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18 For Simple

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

TRUEFR‐161, Section No. A.6.4.2.3.1, See FR‐161

FR‐159, Section No. A.6.4.2.1.3, See FR‐159

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

TRUE

Page 31: 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156 For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18 For Simple

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

TRUEFR‐167, New Section after A.6.4.2.3.4.3(C), See FR‐167

FR‐165, New Section after A.6.4.2.3.4.3(C), See FR‐165

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

TRUE

Page 32: 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156 For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18 For Simple

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27

TRUEFR‐169, Section No. A.6.4.2.3.4.6(2), See FR‐169

FR‐168, New Section after A.6.4.2.3.4.3(C), See FR‐168

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

TRUE

Page 33: 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156 For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18 For Simple

Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

FR‐171, New Section after A.6.4.2.3.6.1, See FR‐171

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

TRUE

Page 34: 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156 For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18 For Simple

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

FR‐220, Section No. A.6.4.2.3.6.5, See FR‐220

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

TRUE

TRUEFR‐175, New Section after A.6.4.2.3.6.1, See FR‐175

Page 35: 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156 For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18 For Simple

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

FR‐194, Section No. A.6.6.3.2.6, See FR‐194

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

TRUE

TRUEFR‐183, Section No. A.6.5.1.3.2.2, See FR‐183

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

Page 36: 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156 For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18 For Simple

Negative 0

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

FR‐193, Section No. A.6.7.3.2.6, See FR‐193

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

TRUE

TRUEFR‐26, New Section after A.6.6.5.2.2.1, See FR‐26

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

Page 37: 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156 For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18 For Simple

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

TRUE

TRUEFR‐29, New Section after A.6.7.5.2.1.3, See FR‐29

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

Page 38: 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156 For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18 For Simple

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

TRUEFR‐195, Section No. A.6.8.3.2.6, See FR‐195

FR‐49, Section No. A.6.8.2.2.3, See FR‐49

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

Page 39: 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156 For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18 For Simple

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

TRUEFR‐204, Section No. K.2, See FR‐204

FR‐34, New Section after A.6.8.5.2.1.3(B)(19), See FR‐34

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

TRUE

Page 40: 85 BCS-MBB F2014 FD ballotfinal - NFPA · 2016. 4. 6. · FR‐156, Section No. 6.4.1, See FR‐156 For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18 For Simple

Eligible to Vote: 27Not Returned: 1 (K. Gamble)

Vote Selection Votes Comments

Affirmative 26

Affirmative with Comment 0

Negative 0

Abstain 0

FR‐205, Section No. K.3, See FR‐205

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

For two‐third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 18

For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 14

TRUE