A Place for Ethics in School Leadership-Pam

Presented by :Sharon HenryPam Lemoine

MayBelle Trahan

EDLD 810Spring, 2009

Phone Conversation-Pam

A Day in the Life…-Sharon

So it begins…

Principles of Ethical Leadership in Public Schools-Sharon

Community

Respect Service

Honesty Justice

Ethical Leadership Principles

Honesty-Sharon

Justice-PamThe ethics of person: What are leaders’ personal

ethics? Are they motivated by self-interest or altruism (Cuilla, 2005)

Virtue Based Theories• Stress more attention should be given to the

development and training of moral values.• Tell people what to be rather than what to do. Rawls (1971)

Justice-PamThree components within Rawls’ Theory of Justice:

1. The requirement that “institutions maintain the fair value of the political liberties, so that persons similarly motivated and endowed have, irrespective of their economic and social class, roughly equal chances to gain political office and to influence the political decisions that shape their lives” (Rawls, 1971, p.225).

- Political equality, including equal rights of liberty of thought and conscience

- A fair measure of equality of opportunity - the difference principle, whereby differences in

income and wealth are regulated and limited by government

Justice-Pam 2. The requirement that institutions

maintain fair equality of opportunity, so that equally talented and motivated persons have roughly equal chances to obtain a good

education and professional position irrespective of their initial social class (Rawls, 1971, pp. 73, 301).

Justice-Pam

3. Insofar as they generate social or economic inequalities, social institutions must be designed to the maximum benefit of those at the bottom of these inequalities (Rawls, 1971, p. 76f).

Justice-PamPolitical Liberalism (1993) The Law of Peoples (1999) A liberal theory of foreign Policy that seeks to provide

fundamental purposes to guide the policies of liberal democratic societies.

Dalla Costa (1998, P. 59) “When the government is focused on competiveness, and

society is fixated on budgets, growth assumes greater importance than quality of life.”

Ethical Egoism: a person should act so as to create the greatest good for her/himself. Related to transactional leadership of Bass & Steidlmeier, 1999

Avolio & Locke, 2002.

Service-Maybelle PRINCIPALS OF RESPECT, SERVICE “The ethics of means: what do leaders use to

motivate followers to obtain their goals? What is the moral relationship between leaders and followers” (Cuilla, 2005, p. xvi).

Greenleaf (1970): servant leadership Leadership should be attentive to their

followers and empathize with them. They should take care of them and nurture

them, The servant leader also has the social

responsibility to be concerned with the have-nots and to recognize them as equal

stakeholders in the organization

Service-Maybelle Heifetz (1997): leaders use authority to mobilize

people to face tough issues. Leader provides a holding environment if trust,

nurturance, and empathy. “To use the analogy of a pressure

cooker, a leader needs to regulate the pressure by turning up the heat while also allowing some steam to escape. If the pressure exceeds the cooker’s capacity, the cooker can blow up. However, nothing cooks without some heat (p 49)”

Leaders’ duties lie in assisting the follower in struggling with change and personal growth.

Service-Maybelle Burns (1978): transformational leadership Strong emphasis on followers’ needs,

values, and morals Leaders move followers to higher

levels of moral responsibility. Move into Transformational leadership

(1980’s and 90’s) Transforming leadership is complex. The leader looks for personal motives in

followers The leader seeks to satisfy higher needs Result is a relationship that converts

followers into leaders and leaders into moral agents. (Greenfield, 2004)

Community-Maybelle

Respect-Sharon Beauchamp & Bowie (1988): delineates “common principles

that serve as guides for leaders in distributing benefits and burdens in an organization” (cited in Northouse, 2007, p. 353)

To each person An equal share According to individual need According to that person’s rights According to individual effort According to societal contribution According to merit

Altruism: actions are moral if their primary purpose is to promote the best interest of

others. Authentic transactional leadership is based on altruistic principles

Ethical Decision Making-Pam

Patton (2008) suggests six principles of ethical decision making (p. 2):

1) recognizing ethical issues and creating possible solutions utilizing the inquiry approach (empirics);

2) committing to a moral code (ethics); 3) understanding and using ethics vocabulary to

communicate (symbolics) with stakeholders; 4) creating a visual representation of the

process to aid in understanding (esthetics); 5) involving and empathizing with the team

(synnoetics); and 6) applying, monitoring, and reflecting on equal

and fair approaches (synoptics)

Ethical Decision Making: Patton (2008) suggests six principles of ethical decision making (p. 2):

1) recognizing ethical issues and creating possible solutions utilizing the inquiry approach (empirics); 2) committing to a moral code (ethics);

3) understanding and using ethics vocabulary to communicate (symbolics) with stakeholders; 4) creating a visual representation of the process to aid in understanding (esthetics);

5) involving and empathizing with the team (synnoetics); and 6) applying, monitoring, and reflecting on equal and fair approaches (synoptics

Case Study-Sharon

Mary Richards, New Principal Letter from PTO president, Mrs.

Wright

Conclusion-Maybelle

Resources