7TH DISTRICT COURT - MOAB GRAND COUNTY, …fjcadr.com/uploads/3/2/5/7/3257891/lee_trial.pdf ·...

7TH DISTRICT COURT - MOAB

GRAND COUNTY, STATE OF UTAH

KYLIE ANN BEDDOES LEE vs. KENNETH L WILLIAMS

CASE NUMBER 130700019 Malpractice

________________________________________________________________________________

CURRENT ASSIGNED JUDGE

LYLE R ANDERSON

PARTIES

Plaintiff - KYLIE ANN BEDDOES LEE

Represented by: TYLER S YOUNG

Defendant - KENNETH L WILLIAMS

Represented by: CATHERINE M LARSON

Represented by: KATHLEEN J ABKE

Defendant - MOAB FAMILY MEDICINE PC

Represented by: CATHERINE M LARSON

Represented by: KATHLEEN J ABKE

ACCOUNT SUMMARY

TOTAL REVENUE Amount Due: 622.00

Amount Paid: 622.00

Credit: 0.00

Balance: 0.00

REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: COMPLAINT - NO AMT S

Amount Due: 360.00

Amount Paid: 360.00

Amount Credit: 0.00

Balance: 0.00

REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: JURY DEMAND - CIVIL

Amount Due: 250.00

Amount Paid: 250.00

Amount Credit: 0.00

Balance: 0.00

REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: AUDIO TAPE COPY

Amount Due: 12.00

Amount Paid: 12.00

Amount Credit: 0.00

Balance: 0.00

REVENUE DETAIL - TYPE: AUDIO TAPE COPY

Printed: 02/01/16 15:21:33

Page 1 of 21


________________________________________________________________________________

Original Amount Due: 10.00

Amended Amount Due: 0.00

Amount Paid: 0.00

Amount Credit: 0.00

Balance: 0.00

Account Adjustments

Date Amount Reason

Feb 01, 2016 -10.00 Attorney did not pick up CD or

pay for it.

PROCEEDINGS

05-20-13 Filed: Complaint

05-20-13 Filed: Demand for Jury Trial

05-20-13 Case filed

05-20-13 Judge LYLE R ANDERSON assigned.

05-20-13 Fee Account created Total Due: 360.00


05-20-13 COMPLAINT - NO AMT S Payment Received: 360.00

05-20-13 JURY DEMAND - CIVIL Payment Received: 250.00

05-28-13 Filed return: Acceptance of Service upon CATHERINE M. LARSON,

ATTORNEY for

Party Served: KENNETH L MD WILLIAMS

Service Type: Personal

Service Date: May 28, 2013

05-28-13 Filed return: Acceptance of Service upon CATHERINE M. LARSON,

ATTORNEY for

Party Served: MOAB FAMILY MEDICINE PC



06-06-13 Filed return: Acceptance of Service upon CATHERINE M. LARSON

for

Party Served: KENNETH L MD WILLIAMS



06-11-13 Filed: Certificate of Mailing/Service Plaintiff's Initial

Disclosures, Bates Nos. 1-189

06-11-13 Filed: Return of Electronic Notification

06-14-13 Filed: Answer by Defendants Kenneth L. Williams, MD and Moab

Family Medicine, PC

Printed: 02/01/16 15:21:33

Page 2 of 21


________________________________________________________________________________

KENNETH L WILLIAMS

MOAB FAMILY MEDICINE PC

06-14-13 Note: Certificate of Readiness for Trial due 06/05/2014

06-14-13 Filed: NOTICE OF EVENT DUE DATES


06-17-13 Filed: Certificate of Mailing/Service Defendants First Set of

Interrogatories and Requests for Production of Documents to

Plaintiff


06-26-13 Filed: Other Notice of Intent to Request Protected Health

Information


07-03-13 Filed: Other Notice of Depositions of Kylie Ann Beddoes Lee,

Zachary Lee, Mike Forshee and Trista Birdzell


07-09-13 Filed: Other Notice of Records Depositions


07-16-13 Filed: Other Notice of Deposition Duces Tecum


07-16-13 Filed: Other Notice of Depositions of Jason Beddoes, Kimberly

Gritts and Lara Prather


07-31-13 Filed: Certificate of Mailing/Service of Defendants Kenneth L.

Williams, M.D. and Moab Family Medicine P.C.'s Initial

Disclosures


08-08-13 Filed: Amended Notice of Depositions of Zachary Lee, Mike

Forshee and Trista Birdzell


08-13-13 Filed: Notice of Intent to Request Protected Health Information


08-21-13 Filed: COS Plntf's Answer to Def 1st set of Interrogs RPD


08-23-13 Filed: Notice of Records Depositions


08-29-13 Filed: Amended Notice of Deposition of Kylie Ann Beddoes Lee


09-17-13 Filed: Certificate of Mailing/Service COS Plntf's First Set

Printed: 02/01/16 15:21:33

Page 3 of 21


________________________________________________________________________________

Admission, Interrogatories, RPD to Defendants


10-04-13 Filed: Amended Notice of Depositions of Jason Beddoes, Kimberly

Gritts and Lara Prather


10-08-13 Filed: Amended Notice of Deposition


10-15-13 Filed: Certificate of Mailing/Service Defendants Objections,

Answers and Responses to Plaintiffs First Set of Requests for

Admissions, Interrogatories and Requests for Production of

Documents

10-15-13 Filed: Certificate of Mailing/Service Defendants Kenneth L.

Williams, MD and Moab Family Medicine, PCs Supplemental Initial

Disclosures


11-01-13 Filed: Certificate of Mailing/Service of Plaintiffs Second Set

of Interrogatories, Requests for Production of Documents and

Corrected Request for Admission


11-21-13 Filed: Second Amended Notice of Deposition



11-27-13 Filed: Certificate of Service of Defendants Objections, Answers

and Responses to Plaintiffs Second Set of Interrogatories,

Requests for Production of Documents and Corrected Request for

Admission




12-12-13 Filed: Second Amended Notice of Depositions of Jason Beddoes,

Kimberly Gritts and Lara Prather




02-06-14 Filed: Notice of Deposition and Subpoena Duces Tecum to Michael

Rosen, MD




Printed: 02/01/16 15:21:33

Page 4 of 21


________________________________________________________________________________

02-11-14 Filed: Notice of Records Depositions


02-18-14 Filed: Notice of Records Deposition


02-27-14 Filed: Stipulated Amended Scheduling Order


03-03-14 Filed: Substitution of Counsel for Defendants Kenneth L.

Williams, MD and Moab Family Medicine PC


03-07-14 Filed: Notice of Depositions of Paula Fleenor, RN, Casey

Hearne, RN, Naomi Helquist, RN and Connie Wilson, RN


03-17-14 Filed: COS of Plaintiffs First Supplemental Disclosures


03-21-14 Filed: Notice of Telephonic Deposition of Paula Martin, RN


03-25-14 Filed: Motion Stipulated Motion for Extraordinary Discovery and

Amending Discovery Deadlines

Filed by: MOAB FAMILY MEDICINE PC,

03-25-14 Filed: Order (Proposed) Granting Stipulated Motion for

Extraordinary Discovery and Amending Discovery Deadlines


03-25-14 Filed order: Order Granting Stipulated Motion for Extraordinary

Discovery and Amending Discovery Deadlines

Judge LYLE R ANDERSON

Signed March 25, 2014


03-31-14 Filed: COS Plaintiffs Non Retained Expert Witnesses

03-31-14 Filed: COS of Plaintiffs Retained Expert Witnesses


04-21-14 Filed: Notice of Change of Address


05-30-14 Filed: Notice of Deposition and Subpoena Duces Tecum of Steven

Dewey, MD


06-19-14 Filed: Notice of Trial Deposition


06-26-14 Notice - Notice of Intent for Case 130700019

Notice is hereby given that the above entitled matter will be

Printed: 02/01/16 15:21:33

Page 5 of 21


________________________________________________________________________________

dismissed pursuant to Code of Judicial Administration Rule 4-103

for failure to file a certificate of readiness for trial within 330

days of defendant's answer. Unless a certificate of readiness for

trial or written statement showing good cause not to dismiss is

received by the court within 20 days of this notice, the court will

dismiss without further notice.

06-30-14 Note: I generated the Notice of Intent to Dismiss in error, as

this case has a discovery order in place for future

dates. Counsel called this to our attention so I removed

the hold on this case.

06-30-14 Note: The case was taken off of OTSC hold

07-28-14 Filed: Order (Proposed) Second Stipulated Motion and Order for

Extraordinary Discovery and Amending Discovery Deadlines


07-28-14 Filed: Other - Declined to Sign Order (Proposed) Second

Stipulated Motion and Order for Extraordinary Discovery and


07-28-14 Note: The Order needs to be a separate document.


07-29-14 Filed: Second Stipulated Motion for Extraordinary Discovery and


07-29-14 Filed: Order (Proposed) Granting Extraordinary Discovery and



07-29-14 Filed order: Order Granting Extraordinary Discovery and



Signed July 29, 2014


08-07-14 Filed: Kenneth L. Williams, M.D. and Moab Family Medicine,

P.C.s Designation of Expert Witnesses


09-22-14 Filed: Notice of Deposition


09-22-14 Filed: Certificate of Service to Defendants Kenneth L.

Williams, MD and Moab Family Medicine, PCs Submission of Expert

Report by Gary Dildy, MD


09-24-14 Filed: Amended Notice of Deposition

Printed: 02/01/16 15:21:33

Page 6 of 21


________________________________________________________________________________


10-20-14 Filed: Third Stipulated Motion for Extraordinary Discovery and


10-20-14 Filed: Order (Proposed) Order Granting Third Stipulated Motion

for Extraordinary Discovery and Amended CMO


10-21-14 Filed order: Order Granting Third Stipulated Motion for

Extraordinary Discovery and Amended CMO


Signed October 21, 2014


11-10-14 Filed: Defendants Motion for Summary Judgment

11-10-14 Filed: Memorandum in Support of Defendants Motion for Summary

Judgment

11-10-14 Filed: Exhibits to Defendants Memorandum in Support of Motion

for Summay Judgment


11-24-14 **** SEALED **** Filed: Memorandum Memo in Opp to Defs MS

11-24-14 **** SEALED **** Filed: Exh. 1-17 attached to Plntfs Opp


11-25-14 Filed: Request for Data Correction Urgent


11-26-14 Note: Email sent to tyoung regarding data correction request.

Told a motion and order will need to be submitted to get

the document sealed.

11-26-14 Filed: Memorandum Amended Memo in Opp to Defs MSJ

11-26-14 Filed: Exh. 1-16 attached to Amended Memo in Opp to Defs MSJ


11-26-14 Filed: Motion Urgent Stip Mot to Remove Document Link from

Record or to Classify Record as Non-Public, Protected and

Sealed

Filed by: BEDDOES LEE, KYLIE ANN

11-26-14 Filed: Order (Proposed) to Remove Document Link from Record or

to Classify as Non-Public, Protected and Sealed



12-02-14 Filed order: Order to Remove Document Link from Record or to

Classify as Non-Public, Protected and Sealed


Printed: 02/01/16 15:21:33

Page 7 of 21


________________________________________________________________________________

Signed December 02, 2014


12-29-14 Filed: Reply Memorandum in Support of Defendants Motion for

Summary Judgment

12-29-14 Filed: Request/Notice to Submit for Decision Defendants Motion

for Summary Judgment


01-07-15 ORAL ARGUMENT ON MOTION scheduled on February 03, 2015 at 01:00

PM in DIST. COURT with Judge ANDERSON.

01-07-15 Filed: Notice for Case 130700019 ID 16403564

01-13-15 Filed: Motion Stipulated Motion to Change Date of Hearing

Regarding Oral Argument


01-13-15 Filed: Order (Proposed) Granting Stipulated Motion to Change

Date of Hearing Regarding Oral Argument


01-14-15 Filed order: Order Granting Stipulated Motion to Change Date of

Hearing Regarding Oral Argument


Signed January 14, 2015


01-14-15 Note: Reason: Request of counsel Stipulation of counsel motion.

01-14-15 ORAL ARGUMENT ON MOTION scheduled on March 31, 2015 at 01:00 PM

in DIST. COURT with Judge ANDERSON.

03-31-15 Minute Entry - Minutes for ORAL ARGUMENT ON MOTION FOR

Judge: LYLE R ANDERSON

Clerk: melissap

PRESENT

Plaintiff's Attorney(s): TYLER S YOUNG

Defendant's Attorney(s): CATHERINE M LARSON

Audio

Tape Count: 1:00 - 1:58

__________________________________________________________________

The Court addresses the parties as to the Motion for Summary

Judgment

Ms. Larson addresses the court. Ms. Larson asks the court to grant

Printed: 02/01/16 15:21:34

Page 8 of 21


________________________________________________________________________________

the Motion for Summary Judgment based on the statute of

limitations.

Mr. Young addresses the court. Mr. Young asks the court to deny the

Motion for Summary Judgment.

Ms. Larson gives the court her closing statement.

The court will take this decision under advisement to review the

case law.

TIME: 1:00 PM

04-21-15 Filed order: Ruling on Motion for Summary Judgment


Signed April 21, 2015


04-24-15 AUDIO TAPE COPY Payment Received: 12.00

04-28-15 Filed: Order (Proposed) Denying Summary Judgment


05-04-15 Filed order: Order Denying Summary Judgment


Signed May 04, 2015


05-07-15 Filed: Certificate of Readiness for Trial and Request for

Pretrial Scheduling Conference


05-13-15 Note: Certificate of Readiness was emailed to Judge Anderson

today.

05-19-15 PRETRIAL CONFERENCE scheduled on June 16, 2015 at 09:00 AM in

DIST. COURT with Judge ANDERSON.

05-19-15 Filed: Notice for Case 130700019 ID 16688686

05-26-15 Filed: Motion for a Separate Trial on the Statute of

Limitations and to Stay the Proceedings


Printed: 02/01/16 15:21:34

Page 9 of 21


________________________________________________________________________________

05-26-15 Filed: Memorandum in Support of their Motion for a Separate

Trial on the Statute of Limitations and to Stay the Proceedings


05-28-15 Filed: Memorandum In Opposition to Defendants Motion for

Separate Trial on the Statute of Limitations and to Stay the

Proceedings


06-09-15 Filed: Notice of Withdrawal of Counsel


06-11-15 Filed: Request/Notice to Submit Motion to Bifurcate

06-11-15 Filed: Reply to Plaintiffs Opposition to Motion to Bifurcate


06-12-15 Filed: Stipulated Motion to Change Pretrial Hearing to

Telephonic Oral Argument on Defendants Motion for a Separate

Trial on the Statute of Limitations


06-12-15 Filed: Order (Proposed) to Change Pretrial Hearing to

Telephonic Oral Argument on Defendants Motion for a Separate

Trial on the Statute of Limitations


06-15-15 Filed order: Order to Change Pretrial Hearing to Telephonic

Oral Argument on Defendants Motion for a Separate Trial on the

Statute of Limitations


Signed June 15, 2015


06-15-15 PRETRIAL CONFERENCE Modified.

06-15-15 ORAL ARGUMENT ON MOTION scheduled on June 16, 2015 at 09:00 AM


06-16-15 Minute Entry - Minutes for MOTION HEARING


Clerk: claudiap

PRESENT



Audio

Tape Number: Courtroom 1

__________________________________________________________________

Printed: 02/01/16 15:21:34

Page 10 of 21


________________________________________________________________________________

Court hears argument from both attorneys.

The Motion to Bifurcate is granted

Catherine Larson is to prepare the order and submit same to the

court.

06-29-15 Filed: Order (Proposed) ORDER DEFENDANTS KENNETH L. WILLIAMS,

M.D. and MOAB FAMILY MEDICINE P.C.S MOTION FOR SEPARATE TRIAL

ON THE STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS


06-29-15 Filed order: ORDER DEFENDANTS KENNETH L. WILLIAMS, M.D. and

MOAB FAMILY MEDICINE P.C.S MOTION FOR SEPARATE TRIAL ON THE

STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS


Signed June 29, 2015


06-29-15 Stay begins: June 29, 2015 Reason: Related Proceedings

Note: Stay ordered by Judge Anderson

07-28-15 Filed: Motion Stipulated Motion for Pretrial Conference



09-14-15 Filed: Order (Proposed) Proposed Order Granting Stipulated

Motion for Pretrial Conference


09-15-15 Filed order: Order Proposed Order Granting Stipulated Motion

for Pretrial Conference


Signed September 15, 2015


09-15-15 PRETRIAL CONFERENCE scheduled on September 29, 2015 at 01:00 PM


09-17-15 Filed: Stipulated Rule 16(a)(1) Motion for Pretrial Conference

to be Rescheduled to November 3, 2015 at 9:00 a.m.

09-17-15 Filed: Order (Proposed) Proposed Order Granting Stipulated

Motion for Pretrial Conference to be Rescheduled to November 3,

2015 at 9:00 a.m.


09-24-15 Filed order: Order Proposed Order Granting Stipulated Motion

Printed: 02/01/16 15:21:34

Page 11 of 21


________________________________________________________________________________

for Pretrial Conference to be Rescheduled to November 3, 2015

at 9:00 a.m.


Signed September 24, 2015


09-24-15 Note: Reason: Request of counsel Stipulation of counsel motion.

09-24-15 PRETRIAL CONFERENCE continued to November 03, 2015 at 09:00 AM


11-03-15 JURY TRIAL scheduled on January 27, 2016 at 09:00 AM in DIST.

COURT with Judge ANDERSON.





11-03-15 Minute Entry - PRETRIAL CONFERENCE


Clerk: adrienng

PRESENT



Audio

Tape Count: 9:07-9:21

__________________________________________________________________

Counsel for both parties appear by phone. Jury trial is set for

three days, January 27, 2016 - January 29, 2016. Jury will be

summoned two weeks prior to trial. Counsel is to send the Jury

Questionnaire one week prior to summons.

JURY TRIAL is scheduled.

Date: 01/27/2016

Time: 09:00 a.m.

Location: DIST. COURT

GRAND COUNTY COURTHOUSE

125 EAST CENTER

MOAB, UT 84532

Before Judge: LYLE R ANDERSON

Printed: 02/01/16 15:21:34

Page 12 of 21


________________________________________________________________________________

JURY TRIAL is scheduled.

Date: 01/28/2016

Time: 09:00 a.m.



125 EAST CENTER

MOAB, UT 84532


JURY TRIAL.

Date: 01/29/2016

Time: 09:00 a.m.



125 EAST CENTER

MOAB, UT 84532


12-08-15 Filed: Motion Plaintiffs Motion in Limine to Exclude

Prejudicial and Irrelevant Evidence



12-15-15 Filed: Defendants Pretrial Disclosures

12-15-15 Filed: Plaintiffs Pretrial Disclosures



12-18-15 Filed: Opposition to Plaintiffs Motion in Limine to Exclude

Prejudicial and Irrelevant Evidence


12-22-15 Filed: Notice of Appearance of Counsel


12-22-15 Filed: Defendants Proposed Jury Questionnaire


12-28-15 Filed: Plaintiffs Proposed Voir Dire

12-28-15 Filed: Exhibit A to Plaintiffs Proposed Voir Dire


12-28-15 Filed: Amended Exhibit A Attached to Plaintiffs Proposed Voir

Dire


Printed: 02/01/16 15:21:34

Page 13 of 21


________________________________________________________________________________

12-28-15 Filed return: Return of Service Return of Service Subpoena

Casey Hearne upon CASEY HEARNE for

Party Served: KYLIE ANN BEDDOES LEE


Service Date: December 22, 2015

12-28-15 Filed return: Return of Service Return of Service Lara Prather

Subpoena Attached upon LARA PRATHER for

Party Served: KYLIE ANN BEDDOES LEE


Service Date: December 22, 2015


12-28-15 Filed: Defendants Amended Proposed Jury Questionnaire and

Notice of Withdrawal of Defendants Proposed Jury Questionnaire


12-28-15 Filed: Motion in Limine Defendants Kenneth Williams, MD and

Moab Family Medicines Motion in Limine to Exclude Improper

Character Evidence and Memorandum in Support



Moab Family Medicines Motion in Limine to Exclude Certain

Testimony from Trista Birdzell



Moab Family Medicines Motion in Limine to Preclude Retile and

Veiled Golden Rule Arguments




Moab Family Medicines Motion in Limine to Preclude Argument Re

Any Other Lawsuit Involving Defendants



Moab Family Medicines Motion in Limine to Exclude Witnesses

from Testifying at Statute of Limitations Trial



Moab Family Medicines Motion in Limine to Preclude Evidence Re

Defendants Liability Insurance


Printed: 02/01/16 15:21:34

Page 14 of 21


________________________________________________________________________________



Moab Family Medicines Motion in Limine to Exclude Evidence of

Claim Against Dr. Dewey



Moab Family Medicines Motion in Limine to Exclude Evidence Re

Medical Negligence Issues



12-28-15 Filed: Plaintiffs Objection to Defendants Pretrial Disclosures


12-29-15 Filed: Objection to Plaintiffs Proposed Voir Dire


12-30-15 Filed: Motion Stipulated Rule 16(A)(11) Motion for Pretrial

Conference


12-30-15 Filed: Order (Proposed) Granting Stipulated Motion for Pretrial

Conference


12-31-15 Filed: Objection to Plaintiffs Pretrial Disclosures


01-04-16 Filed order: Order Granting Stipulated Motion for Pretrial

Conference




01-04-16 TELEPHONIC PRETRIAL CONF scheduled on January 19, 2016 at 03:00

PM in DIST. COURT with Judge ANDERSON.

01-05-16 Filed: Motion Plaintiffs Motion and Attached Memorandum for

Correction of the Record


01-05-16 Filed: Plaintiffs Exhibit 1 Plaintiffs Amended Memorandum in

Opposition to Defendants Motion for Summary Judgment

01-05-16 Filed: Plaintiffs Exhibit 2 - Transcript of Defendants Motion

for Summary Judgment Hearing

01-05-16 Filed: Plaintiffs Exhibit 3 - Depo of Kylie Lee

01-05-16 Filed: Plaintiffs Exhibit 4 - Dr. Dewey Depo

01-05-16 Filed: Plaintiffs Exhibit 5 - Ruling of Defendants Motion for

Printed: 02/01/16 15:21:35

Page 15 of 21


________________________________________________________________________________

Summary Judgment

01-05-16 Filed: Plaintiffs Exhibit 6 - Order Denying Motion for Summary

Judgment

01-05-16 Filed: Plaintiffs Exhibit 7 - MUJI 2nd CV325


01-06-16 Filed: Jury Instructions Stipulated

01-06-16 Filed: Exhibit 1 - Stipulated Jury Instructions


01-06-16 Filed: Motion Stipulated Motion to Allow Trista Birdzell to

Testify at Trial Via Skype


01-06-16 Filed: Order (Proposed) To Allow Trista Birdzell to Testify at

Trial via Skype



01-07-16 Filed: Jury Instructions Plaintiffs Proposed


01-07-16 Filed: Defendants Disputed Jury Instructions


01-08-16 Filed order: Order To Allow Trista Birdzell to Testify at Trial

via Skype




01-11-16 Filed: Opposition to Plaintiffs Motion for Correction of the

Record

01-11-16 Filed: Exhibits A - F


01-11-16 Filed: Memorandum Plaintiffs Memorandum In Opposition to

Defendants Kenneth L. Williams, M.Ds and Moab Family Medicine,

P.Cs Motion in Limine To Exclude Certain Testimony From Trista

Birdzell

01-11-16 Filed: Exhibit A Attached To Plaintiffs Memorandum In

Opposition To Defendants Ketteth L. Williams, M.Ds And Moab

Family Medicine, P.Cs Motion In Limine To Exclude Certain

Testimony From Trista Birdzell

01-11-16 Filed: Memorandum Plaintiffs Memorandum In Opposition To

Defendants Kenneth L. Williams, M.Ds And Moab Family Medicine,

P.Cs Motion In Limine To Exclude Certain Witnesses From

Printed: 02/01/16 15:21:35

Page 16 of 21


________________________________________________________________________________

Testifying At Statute of Limitations Tr

01-11-16 Filed: Exhibit A-F Attached to Plaintiffs Memorandum In

Opposition To Defendants Kenneth L. Williams, M.Ds and Moab

Family Medicine, P.Cs Motion In Limine To Exclude Certain

Witnesses From Testifying At



Defendants Motion In Limine To Exclude Evidence Of Plaintiffs

Claim Against Dr. Dewey

01-11-16 Filed: Exhibits A-B Attached To Plaintiffs Memorandum In

Opposition To Defendants Motion In Limine To Exclude Evidence

Of Plaintiffs Claim Against Dr. Dewey




Defendants Motion In Limine To Exclude Improper Character

Evidence


Opposition To Defendants Motion In Limine To Exclude Improper

Character Evidence



Defendants Motion In Limine To Preclude Plaintiff From Offering

or Making Any Argument Regarding Any Other Lawsuit


Opposition To Defendants Motion In Limine To Preclude Plaintiff

From Offering Or Making Any Argument Regarding Any Other

Lawsuit



Defendants Motion In Limine To Preclude Reptile or Veiled

Golden Rule Arguments


Opposition To Defendants Motion In Limine To Preclude Reptile

And Veiled Golden Rule Arguments


01-11-16 Filed: Memorandum Amended Plaintiffs Memorandum In Opposition

to Defendants Motion In Limine To Exclude Certain Testimony

From Trista Birdzell

Printed: 02/01/16 15:21:35

Page 17 of 21


________________________________________________________________________________

01-11-16 Filed: Exhibit A Attached To Amended Plaintiffs Memorandum In

Opposition to Defendants Motion In Limine To Exclude Certain

Testimony From Trista Birdzell


01-11-16 Filed: Memorandum Plaintiffs Amended Memorandum In Opposition

To Defendants Motion In Limine To Exclude Certain Witnesses

01-11-16 Filed: Exhibit A-F Attached to Amended Plaintiffs Memorandum In

Opposition to Defendant Motion In Limine To Exclude Certain

Witnesses



Defendants Motion In Limine to Exclude Evidence Regarding

Medical Negligence Issues

01-11-16 Filed: Exhibits A-F Attached To Plaintiffs Memorandum In

Opposition To Defendants Motion In Limine To Exclude Evidence

Regarding Medical Negligence Issues


01-15-16 Filed: Reply Memorandum in Support of Defendants Motion in

Limine to Exclude Improper Character Evidence

01-15-16 Filed: Reply Memorandum in Supporting Defendants Motion in

Limine to Exlude Certain Witnesses Testifying at Statute of

Limitations Trial

01-15-16 Filed: Reply Memorandum Supporting Defendants Motion in Limine

to Exclude Evidence of Claim Against Dr. Dewey



to Preclude Plaintiff Offering Argument RE any other Lawsuit

Involving Defendants


to Preclude Reptile and Veiled Golden Rule Arguments


to Exclude Certain Testimony from Trista Birdzell


to Exclude Evidence Re Medical Negligence Issues



01-15-16 Filed: Request/Notice to Submit Defendants Motions in Limine


01-15-16 Filed: Reply In Support of Plaintiffs Motion For Correction of

Printed: 02/01/16 15:21:35

Page 18 of 21


________________________________________________________________________________

the Record

01-15-16 Filed: Request/Notice to Submit Plaintiffs Motion for

Correction of the Record



01-15-16 Filed: Motion in Limine AMENDED Defendants Motion in Limine to

Preclude Plaintiff from Alluding or Offering Evidence RE

Defendants Liability Insurance



01-15-16 Filed: Stipulated Juror Questionnaire

01-15-16 Filed: Exhibit 1 - Juror Questionnaire


01-18-16 Filed: Request/Notice to Submit Plaintiffs Motion in Limine to

Exclude Prejudicial and Irrelevant Evidence

01-18-16 Filed: Objection to Plaintiffs Response to Defendants Objection

To Plaintiffs Pretrial Disclosures



01-19-16 Minute Entry - PRETRIAL CONFERENCE


Clerk: adrienng

PRESENT

Plaintiff(s): KYLIE ANN BEDDOES LEE


Defendant's Attorney(s): KATHLEEN J ABKE

CATHERINE M LARSON

Audio

Tape Count: 2:54-5:05

__________________________________________________________________

Ms. Lee and Ms. Abke are present by phone. Mr. Young and Ms.

Larson are present in the courtroom.

2:54 - The Court informs the parties it would be preferable to have

the Juror Questionnaire distributed to Jurors the morning of

January 27, 2016.

Printed: 02/01/16 15:21:35

Page 19 of 21


________________________________________________________________________________

2:59 - Plaintiff's Motion to Correct the Record is argued. The

Court reviews the previous rulings in this case and clarifies the

question of fact to be determined at trial. The Court cautions the

parties that evidence presented at trial must pertain to that

question.

4:02 - Defendant's Motion to Exclude Evidence of Claim Against Dr.

Dewey is argued. The Court reiterates the question of fact and

limits questioning to same.

4:13 - Motions to exclude witnesses are argued. The Court will

allow the plaintiff's husband to testify. The Court will allow

Trista Birdzell to testify. The Court will not allow the

plaintiff's grandfather to testify.

4:25 - The Defendant's Motion to Exclude Medical Negligence Issues

is discussed. Prior rulings and the question of fact are

reiterated. The Court clarifies appropriate limits of discussing

the medical record.

4:52 - Ms. Larson advises of the stipulation reached regarding the

Motion to Preclude Arguments Regarding Any Other Lawsuit Involving

Defendants.

4:56 - Defendant s Motion to Preclude Reptile and Veiled Golden

Rule Arguments is discussed and a stipulation is reached.

4:58 - The Motion to Exclude Improper Character Evidence is

discussed and a stipulation is reached.

5:01 - The Motion to Preclude Prejudicial and Irrelevant Evidence

is discussed and a stipulation is reached.

5:02 - The parties agree that the Stipulated Jury Questionnaire can

be handed out on the morning of January 27, 2016.

01-20-16 Filed: Motion for Reconsideration of Defendants Kenneth L

Printed: 02/01/16 15:21:35

Page 20 of 21


________________________________________________________________________________

Williams, MD and Moab Family Medicine PCs Motion in Limine to

Exclude Evidence Re Medical Negligence Issues and Memorandum in

Support Thereof

Filed by: WILLIAMS, KENNETH L


01-21-16 Filed: Jury Instructions Defendants Proposed Jury Instructions

and Special Verdict Form


01-22-16 Filed: Acceptance of Service of Subpoena to Appear at Trial

01-22-16 Filed: Subpoena to Appear at Trial to Casey Hearne



01-25-16 Filed: Request for Copy of Audio Record

01-25-16 Filed: Plaintiffs Proposed Special Verdict Form

01-25-16 Filed: Plaintiffs Objection to Defendant Proposed Jury

Instruction and Special Verdict Form


01-26-16 Note: DEF Name changed from KENNETH L MD WILLIAMS

01-26-16 Note: DEF Name changed to KENNETH L WILLIAMS

01-26-16 Filed: Jury Instructions Proposed Additional of Defendant


01-26-16 Filed: Objections of Defendant to Plaintiffs Proposed Special

Verdict Form


02-01-16 **** PRIVATE **** Filed: Randomized Jury List

02-01-16 AUDIO TAPE COPY Account Adjustment Total Due:

0.00

Reason: Attorney did not pick up CD or pay for it.

02-01-16 **** PRIVATE **** Filed: Jury List

02-01-16 Filed: Jury Question #1

02-01-16 Filed: Jury Instructions

02-01-16 Filed: Verdict

Printed: 02/01/16 15:21:35 (last)

Page 21 of 21

7TH DISTRICT COURT - MOAB GRAND COUNTY, …fjcadr.com/uploads/3/2/5/7/3257891/lee_trial.pdf ·...

Documents

Transcript of 7TH DISTRICT COURT - MOAB GRAND COUNTY, …fjcadr.com/uploads/3/2/5/7/3257891/lee_trial.pdf ·...