7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010

download 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010

of 21

Transcript of 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010

  • 8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010

    1/21

    THE

    POSEIDON

    PERSPECTIVE

    soundnavigationthroughperilouscrosscurrents

    29July2010

    DearInvestor,

    Wehavelongbeenanadvocateofvalue

    investingfollowingthepathofGraham,

    Dodd,Buffet,

    Klarman,

    Dreman,

    Whitman,

    etal. However,overthepastdecadewe

    havebecomemorecognizantofthegreat

    influencetechnicalandmacroeconomic

    factorshaveinthemovementofequity

    markets. TheimpactofFedliquidity,

    highfrequencytrading,darkpools,and

    index/sector/ETFtradingishardto

    measurebutimmenselyimportantinthe

    pricingofpublicequitymarkets. Thus,

    ourfundamentalanalysisisshadowed

    withananalyticframeworkwhichwecan

    bestdescribeasmosaicbuilding. Pieceby

    pieceweseektoconstructavalid

    representationforeachinvestmentthesis.

    Inadditiontotherigorousadhesionto

    traditionalquantitativemetrics,this

    methodologydemandsadiscerning

    qualitativeevaluationofriskforthe

    preservationof

    capital.

    It

    is

    aprocess

    of

    distillationtomorebasicmetrics. Marty

    Whitmanisfondofsayingabargainis

    notabargainifitremainsabargain. We

    agreeandhavealwaysbelievedthatyou

    makeyourmoneyinthebuying. An

    exampleofabargainthatmaywellremain

    abargainorlessisCitigroup,Inc(C).

    Welookatequitymarketreturns

    displayedinTableA. Thepast3years

    havebeenabonecrushingexperiencefor

    equityinvestorsworldwide. Inthecaseof

    USequitiestheexpectationsandoptimism

    whichwereheldyearafteryearhave

    yieldednaught. Thebuyandhold

    publichasbeenexploitedwhiletheUS

    Congress,Federalregulatoryagencies,and

    theFederalReserveSystemhaverefused

    toexercisetheirregulatorypowers.

    TABLEAYTD10 3Year* 5Year* 10Year*

    DJIA (6.27)% (10.0)% (0.99)% (0.67)%S&P500 (7.57)% (11.8)% (2.86)% (3.39)%Nasdaq (7.05)% (6.77)% 0.50% (6.12)%MSCIEAFE** (14.7)% (15.8)% (1.77)% (2.17)%MSCIEM** (7.22)% (4.67)% 10.2% 7.50%

    SSEC

    (26.8)%

    (14.4)%

    17.3%

    2.21%

    YTDisthruJune30,2010

    *calculatedascompoundannualgrowthrate

    **MSCIBarraIndexes

    Thesegrimyeartodatefigureshave

    improvedduringJuly;however,we

    suspectthatequitymarketsaretreading

  • 8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010

    2/21

    THEPOSEIDONPERSPECTIVE 29July2010

    waterasaresultofeconomicuncertainty

    andglobalturmoil. Theselloffhasbeen

    particularlysevereinthecaseofChina

    representedbySSEC. Thisisthetypeof

    correctionwhichcreatesbuying

    opportunities;however,wemustawaitthe

    arrivalofstrongerfundamentals. Many

    EmergingMarketsarepricedtogreat

    expectationsratherthanrealistic

    valuations. FundshaveflowedoutofUS

    equitiesintointernationalbondsand

    emergingmarketsecurities. Theriskof

    overpayinghasbecomedominant. We

    demandagreatermarginofsafetypriorto

    investment.The

    easy

    money

    has

    been

    madeoverthepastyear.

    InChart1wepresentapictureofthe

    biggestandbestofequityinAmerican

    enterprise,thisistheDowJones

    Composite(DJA)overthepastseven

    years. TheDJAisanindexcompilingthe

    Industrials,Transports,andUtilities,

    conservative,safe,strong. Thisisachartof

    weeklypriceswhichwelikebecauseitcuts

    outmostofthedaytodaytradingnoise.

    Withinthechartwehaveincludeda

    volumebaracrossthebottomandmoving

    average(MA)lines,bluerepresents10

    weeksandred40weeks. Theseroughly

    correspondtothetechnicalanalysts

    notationof50and200dayMAindicators.

    Webringyourattentiontotherecent

    crossoverof

    the

    10

    week

    MA

    below

    the

    40

    weekMA. Intheparlanceoftechnical

    tradersthisisknownastheDeathCross

    duetheimpendingpossibilityofa

    seriouslydecliningtrend.

    CHART1 FOLLOWINGTHEDOWS

    Page 2

    Source:PSI;StockCharts

  • 8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010

    3/21

    THEPOSEIDONPERSPECTIVE 29July2010

    WhileJulyhasaddedsomenewsteamto

    equitymarketswequestionthesubstance

    ofamidsummerrallyinthefaceofastill

    weakeningeconomy. Summeroptimismis

    frequentlysubjecttotheharshnessof

    autumnrealism.

    ThenextthreechartslookattheUS

    economythruthelensofmarketpricing

    andmarketcapsofseveralcurrentand

    formerleadershipcompanies. Webegin

    withbasicmanufacturinginChart2.

    Allowingfordifferenceswestillfindsome

    basictruth

    in

    the

    comparison

    of

    Apple

    (AAPL)andGeneralElectric(GE). A

    dominantleaderofbasicindustryforso

    longGEisnowstrugglingunderthegross

    financialburdenofGECapital. Nowthe

    marketrewardstheconsumergadgetking

    Applewhosemarketingprowessandout

    sourcedmanufacturingcommandgrand

    premiums. Wealsoviewtheseprice

    changes

    as

    a

    reflection

    of

    the

    US

    economy,

    amajormovefrombasicmanufacturingto

    consumption.

    CHART2 TOYSVSMACHINES

    Source:PSI;StockCharts

    AnothercurrentWallStreetdarlingis

    Google(GOOG). Itsaneasysellwith

    battalionsofengineerscreatingmoreand

    morelogarithmicmethodsforslicingand

    dicingsearchinformationaboutconsumers

    foritsnewguardadvertisingmetrics. In

    Chart3wecouplethischarmmachine

    withaformerqueenofthevalley,Yahoo

    (YHOO)whichhasneverrecoveredfrom

    theMicrosofttakeoverattempt.Jerrys

    pridelostalotofmoneyformanyYHOO

    shareholders. Wedonotdemeanthe

    qualityofthesecompanies;itisaquestion

    ofprice

    in

    respect

    to

    their

    current

    value.

    Theoldbuyersadageispriceiswhatyou

    pay,valueiswhatyouget. Weuse

    Googlefrequentlyandstill,after12years,

    areregularusersofYahoo. Whilethe

    lattermightbeslightlyovervaluedthe

    formerspricedemandsevergreater

    expectations. Givencurrentconsumer

    fundamentalswefindthatthemarketing

    queen

    of

    gadgets,

    AAPL,

    and

    the

    premier

    advertisingmonolith,GOOG,areboth

    overpriced.

    CHART3 LEADINGTHESEARCH

    Page 3

    Source:PSI;StockCharts

  • 8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010

    4/21

    THEPOSEIDONPERSPECTIVE 29July2010

    Finally,welookattwodynastiesof

    finance,thehumbledandthecrushed. The

    firstistheworldslargestgovernment

    assistedhedgefundGoldmanSachs

    (GS). Afteracceptingtaxpayermoneyto

    continueitvasttradingoperationsthefirm

    hasbeenhumiliatedbySECallegationsof

    fraud. GShasrecoveredand,while

    shareholdersmaynotreapthelongterm

    benefits,thepartnerswillneversuffer.

    Theygettheircuteveryyear,offthetop.

    InChart4wecontrastthiscutthroat

    moneymachinewiththenatteringnabobs

    ofCitigroup

    (C).

    Citi

    is

    aquasi

    governmententerprise,obtusebeyond

    effectivemanagement. Wedeemit,much

    likeAIGorGM,anextensionoftheUS

    Treasury. Allaredestinedeventuallyfor

    thedustbin. Fromahighof$51.01on

    December27,2006Citigroupnow

    commandsaround$4withhundredsof

    billionsoftaxpayerdollarsinbackstopping

    of

    risk.

    Many

    thought

    it

    was

    too

    big,

    too

    importanttofailbutforequityinvestorsit

    alreadyhas.

    CHART4 FASTMONEYVSSAVINGS

    Source:PSI;StockCharts

    OveralltheUSequitymarketsaresucha

    shamblesofmanicdepressivemovements

    thatweconjecturethegreatestreturnswill

    accruetothosewhodisplaythepatienceto

    refrainfromclimbingaboardthe

    bandwagon. Currentmarketrisksare

    beyondthekenofmanyinvestorsand

    hopeforanimprovingeconomyfuels

    meagermarketrises. Anysummerrally

    mayfallquickpreytoautumnvolatility

    andlateyearprofittakingwhichmaybe

    exacerbatedbyfearofrisingtaxeson

    capitalgains.

    SOUNDINGS

    Page 4

    Wewouldliketoupdatesomethoughts,

    reservations,andcommentaryonthe

    continuinginflation/deflationdiscussion.

    Ourfirstannouncementcomesbywayof

    theJuly2010GMOQuarterlyLetter

    fromJeremyGrantham. Hiscommentary

    iscloselyfollowed,highlyrespected,and

    astutely

    accurate.

    We

    find

    it

    to

    be

    compulsoryreading. Itisavailableatthe

    GMOwebsite,gmo.com. Inthefirstofsix

    SummerEssaysGranthamfinallytakes

    thesideofdeflation. Hisreasoningis

    weakloansupplyandfairlyweak

    demand,thevelocityofmoneyhasslowed,

    andinflationseemsadistantprospect.

    Thisexpectationisinlinewithhis

    previousprognosticationforsevenlean

    years.We

    also

    note

    that

    Grantham

    believeswitha50%probability,as

    outlinedinEssay3,TheFearful,

    SpeculativeMarket,thatBernanke

    wouldbecertaintokeepratesatrock

    bottomforthenext18monthsorlonger.

  • 8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010

    5/21

    THEPOSEIDONPERSPECTIVE 29July2010

    Whilethereissubstantialprobabilityfor

    correctionsinthecurrentfearful,

    speculativemarket,Granthammakesa

    strongandveritablecaseforhighquality

    USstocks. Thisargumentispremisedon

    thevaluecase;theyarecheap.

    InEssay5SevenLeanYearsRevisited

    Granthammakesseveralsalientpoints

    worthrepeating. Theyare:

    1. Inaworldgrowingnervousaboutthe

    qualityofsovereigndebteventhatofthe

    USdomesticsovereigndebtlevelshave

    exploded. Thesedebtlevelsmustbe

    loweredat

    every

    level,

    especially

    governmentalandthereisalmostno

    waythatthisprocesswillbepleasantor

    quick.

    2. Dangerouslyexcessivefinancial

    systemdebtwasmovedacross,with

    additions,tobecomedangerously

    excessivegovernmentdebt. Theresultis

    asituationwhereinheseesIncreasingly,

    the

    cure

    seems

    more

    like

    a

    stay

    of

    execution.

    3. Nowconsumersarereadjustingtoa

    greaterneedtosaveand,perhaps

    unfortunately,agreaterneedtowork

    longer. Unprecedentedly,theyarepaying

    downsomeconsumerdebt. These

    changedattitudeswillsurelylastfor

    years.

    4. theleverageinthesystemandthe

    chancesof

    further

    write

    downs

    (yet

    more

    housingdefaultsandprivateequitywrite

    downs,forexample)leavebanks

    undercapitalizedandreluctanttolend.

    5. Withmanyoftheartificialstimuliof

    the90sand2000sgone,their[statesand

    municipalities]revenuesareunlikelyto

    bouncebackinoneortwoyears,anda

    doubledipintheeconomyornewasset

    pricedeclines[realestate]wouldmove

    theirrecoveryfurtherback.

    6. Unemploymentishighandwillalso

    sufferfromthelossofthosekickersrelated

    toassetbubbles.

    7. TheU.S.inparticularcannotcontinue

    torunlargetradeimbalances.

    Imbalancesdestabilizethesystem.

    8. Temporarybailouts[Greece]are

    postponementsofanecessary

    restructuring. Thus,theotherPIGS,

    havebecomeanintrinsicpartoftheseven

    leanyears,

    more

    or

    less

    guaranteeing

    slowerthannormalGDPgrowthanda

    longworkoutperiod.

    9. Thegeneralrisinglevelsofsovereign

    debtandtheparticularproblemsfacingthe

    euroblocandJapanareleadingtothe

    systematiclossofconfidenceinourfaith

    basedcurrencies.

    10. Finally,itispossiblethatmost

    important

    of

    all,

    on

    a

    long

    horizon

    there

    is

    averylongtermproblemwidespread

    overcommitmentstopensionsandhealth

    benefits.

    Page 5

    Weadmire,understand,andconcuralmost

    entirelywithMr.Granthamstheses;

    however,asisindicatedbyhispreference

    forUShighquality,hisprognosisand

    prophylacticarebothprettymainstream

    amongastute

    money

    managers.

    We

    believethateconomiceventsmayunfold

    muchmorerapidlyandwithwider

    dispersionsthanmanyinvestorshave

    considered. Weseeinflationasthe

    inevitableendgametocentralbank

    desperationtorestoreeconomicgrowth.

  • 8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010

    6/21

    THEPOSEIDONPERSPECTIVE 29July2010

    ChairmanBernankehasmadeit

    adamantlyclearthatGreatDepressionII

    willnotoccuronhiswatch. TheFeds

    unprecedentedandsupersizedmonetary

    stimulicontinuetoveiltheunpleasant

    realitythattheU.S.haslostits

    manufacturingbaseandthejobsthatare

    attendanttoit. Thefinance,insurance,and

    realestate,(FIRE)economyisnow

    falteringandasMr.Granthamnoteswe

    arenowlosingthekickerswhichwent

    withthegoodtimes. Weagreethatseven

    leanyearsisprobablywhatthenation

    needs. However,politiciansmaydecide

    thatis

    not

    what

    the

    nation

    gets.

    NextwereferencethepresentationbyVan

    Hoisington,HoisingtonInvestment

    ManagementCompanyfromtheFixed

    IncomeManagement2009Conferenceon

    12October2009inBostonanddistributed

    intheCFAInstituteConference

    ProceedingsQuarterlyMarch2010. Inhis

    presentation,

    The

    Debt

    Deflation/Inflation

    Debate,Hoisingtonposesasimple

    question,whetherthepricelevelisgoing

    uporgoingdown. Hisanswerisalso

    simpleandstraightforward. Inaccordance

    withthedebtdeflationtheorypositedby

    IrvingFisherin1933,deflationfollows

    deeprecessions,regardlessofthefiscalor

    monetarypolicyusedtoaddressthe

    nationseconomicwoes. Hearguesthat

    theUnited

    States

    is

    in

    the

    midst

    of

    adebt

    bubblethathappensonlyonceevery70

    80years. Hoisingtonbelievesthatthe

    currentlevelofdebt/GDPis3.75andto

    reducethislevelwillrequirealongtime.

    ForsupportheinvokesTheFinancial

    InstabilityHypothesisofHymanMinsky

    whichoutlinesthethreestagesof

    financingasaneconomyprogresses

    throughgreaterandgreaterspeculative

    pressures. Thissoundsfamiliaraswe

    reflectonthestock,junkbond,commodity,

    andrealestatebubblesoverthepasttwo

    decades. Thestagesbeginwithhedge

    financing,inwhichthelenderfullyexpects

    thereturnofbothprincipalandinterest.

    Thesecondstageisspeculativefinancing,

    inwhichlendersbelievetheywillreceive

    theirinterestpaymentsandare

    comfortablewiththefactthattheprincipal

    canalwaysberefinanced. Andthethird

    stageis

    Ponzi

    financing,

    in

    which

    lenders

    havelittleexpectationofreceivingeither

    theirprincipalorinterestpaymentsbut

    looktorapidlyrisingassetvaluesfor

    security. Intheendtheoverleveraged

    assetslosevaluebutthedebtremains.

    Repaymentbecomesaseriousproblem. In

    accordancewithFisherstheorythe

    distressedsellingtorepaydebtbeginsto

    overwhelm

    the

    system

    as

    increasing

    repaymentsshrinkthemoneysupply

    resultinginfallingprices,unemployment,

    andgeneralpessimism. Duetothe

    unprecedenteddebtlevelsrelativetoGDP

    theU.S.isclosetoadebtdeflation

    experience.

    Page 6

    Hoisingtonreviewsindetailthethree

    requirementsforagrowthinthemonetary

    baseto

    translate

    into

    higher

    prices.

    The

    firstrequirementisanupwardsloping

    supplycurve. However,duetothe

    overcapacityinthesystemandhigh

    unemploymentthesupplycurveis

    actuallyflatordownwardsloping. Thisis

    thetypicalresultofrecessions,over

  • 8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010

    7/21

    THEPOSEIDONPERSPECTIVE 29July2010

    Page 7

    capacityandintensecompetitioncause

    pricestodrop. Withoutresurgencein

    capacityutilizationandgrowthinweekly

    hoursofproductiontherewillnotbearise

    inthesupplycurve. Thesecond

    requirementisstableorrisingvelocityof

    money. Whilenotinherentlystablethe

    velocityofmoneyisusuallydrivenbytwo

    factors,financialinnovationand/or

    leverage. Whilethevelocityofmoneyrose

    rapidlyinthe1990sithasfallen

    significantlysince2000withonestrong

    surgeinmiddecade. Chart5indicatesthe

    risingvelocityduringtheultraleverage

    thruconduits

    and

    securitization

    from

    1990

    2000andtheresurgenceofassetvalues

    duetofinancialinnovationforconsumers

    andhousingduring20042007. So,evenin

    thefaceofincreasingmoneysupply,M2,

    therecanbeasubstantialslowdownin

    GDPgrowthwithcontractingvelocityof

    money. Hoisingtonprovidestheexample

    duringperiod4Q20082Q2009whenM2

    increased

    10.3%,

    Velocity

    decreased

    (12.6)%andGDPwasdown(3.6)%.

    Thethirdfactornecessaryforrisingprices

    isastableorrisingvalueforthemoney

    multiplier,m. ThemultiplieristheratioofawelldefinedmoneysupplysuchasM2

    tothemonetarybasewhichwouldresult

    intheM2multiplier. AsevidencetheM2

    multiplierdroppedfrom9in2008to3in

    2009while

    during

    the

    same

    period

    excess

    reservesgrewbyalmost$800billion.

    ForthesereasonsHoisingtonopinesthat

    monetarypolicy,theZIRP,isbroken

    whichleavesonlyfiscalpolicytosupport

    theeconomyandenhancegrowth.

    However,byitsnaturethepublicsector

    hasaproductivitylevelofzerobecause

    municipalinfrastructuresandpublic

    serviceprovidersdonotproducea

    quantifiablegood. Heseesnopositive

    impactasaresultoftheunprecedented

    amountofgovernmentspending. A

    nationcannotborrowitswayto

    prosperity. Healsopositsthatgovernment

    debtisnotbyitselfinflationary,pointing

    totheperiods19291941intheUnited

    Statesand19892008inJapan.

    Additionally,heciteslowinterestrates,

    highunemployment,

    and

    the

    decline

    in

    the

    S&P500asevidenceofdebtdeflation.

    Sinceabouttwothirdsoftheeconomy

    dependsuponconsumerspending,

    Hoisingtonprojectsaseriousdecreasein

    USimportdemandduetoconsumernet

    worthlossesinhousingandequitymarket

    declines. Hespeculatesthatinthe15

    largestGDPcountries,notincluding

    China,

    it

    is

    unlikely

    that

    any

    country

    will

    experiencepositivegrowthindomestic

    demanduntiltheUnitedStatesdoes.

    HoisingtonconcludedthattheUShas

    enteredadeflationaryenvironmentdueto

    thelevelsofdebtespeciallyhousehold.

    Hisexpectationisthatthiswillcontinue

    forseveralyearsasthedemandforUS

    exportsisdim. However,heseesthis

    situationasgoodforlongtermTreasury

    bondswhich

    results

    in

    the

    now

    4percent

    ratetodroptoabout2percentandbonds

    continuingtooutperformstocks.

  • 8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010

    8/21

    THEPOSEIDONPERSPECTIVE 29July2010

    CHART5 THEENDOFFASTMONEY?

    Source:HoisingtonInvestmentManagement

    Wesurmise

    that

    Hoisington

    has

    been

    quite

    prescientinhisforecastingofdebt

    deflation. Atthetimeofhispresentation

    therewerestillhopesforastrongrecovery,

    robustFedpolicyinducements,and

    politicaloptimism. Tenmonthslaterwe

    arefacingamuchharsherreality. We

    grantthatthedeflationarytrendsmay

    continue,yetweforeseearenewedeffort

    by

    government

    to

    accelerate

    economic

    activity. Timingisimportant;however,we

    cannotpredictthepathoroutcomes. We

    waitwithrespectfortheoldadageDont

    fighttheFed.

    Weunderstand

    the

    deflation

    argument.

    Thecurrentsituationisdrivenbyan

    unwindingofleverage. Wesubmitthe

    followingthreechartsfromtheSt.Louis

    Fedwhichclearlydetaildebtdeflation

    overthepasttwoyears.

    Chart6revealsthe40%dropofover$300

    billioninFinancialCommercialPaper

    Outstanding.

    This

    is

    short

    term

    (less

    than

    270days)lendingwithoutcollateral.

    WhiletheFedhasbeenabletosupport

    shorttermlendingtobanksthruseveral

    mechanisms,thisstaggeringdropincredit

    availabilityreflectsdeteriorationinthe

    Page 8

  • 8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010

    9/21

    THEPOSEIDONPERSPECTIVE 29July2010

    financialsystem. Unfortunately,we

    suspectthatthelevelofFINCPNcorrelates

    withtheriseandfallofsecuritiesmarkets.

    CHART

    6

    THE

    DROP

    OF

    PAPER

    Source:StLouisFed

    Chart7discloses

    amore

    severe

    drop

    of

    67%or$800billionofAssetbacked

    CommercialPaper. Thiscollapsereveals

    bothadeclineinthecontinuingneedfor

    newcreditandthelackofavailabilityof

    substantialcollateral. Inasystem

    dependentuponcreditgrowthforGNP

    growtheitherthediminishingmeansfor

    lendingortherecedingdemandforcredit

    mustresult

    in

    much

    slower

    economic

    growth. Towhatdegreeofrobustness

    mustcurrentmonetaryandfiscalpolicybe

    takeninordertoreversethesedeflationary

    trends?

    CHART7 THEDROPINASSETVALUES

    Source:StLouisFed

    CHART8 THEDROPINSECURITY

    Source:StLouisFed

    Page 9

    Chart8reflectsatruemilestonein

    financialinnovation. Themarketfor

  • 8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010

    10/21

    THEPOSEIDONPERSPECTIVE 29July2010

    consumerloansecuritizationbeganin1989

    androserapidlyuntil2007,almost20years

    ofcontinuingcreditextensiontosupport

    theconsumerspendingwhichisaround

    70%oftheeconomy. Thesuddenendin

    2008whichproducedadropofover$500

    billionofpotentialGNPisareflectionof

    consumerdesireormandatetobegin

    saving. Whattypeofrecoverycan

    accommodatethislevelofretrenchment?

    AsGranthampointsoutabovethisisan

    attitudechangewhichwillsurelylast

    foryears. Weconjecturethatthese

    reversionsfromborrowingtodeleveraging

    willcontinue

    until

    there

    is

    arenewal

    of

    spiritwhichcreatesnewjobs,drives

    demandforcredit,andproducesgreatnew

    productsand/orservices. Theresolutionof

    thedeflation/inflationissueisyes. Asthe

    deflationaryspiralcontinuesthecentral

    bankwillcontinuetounleashitsmonetary

    magic. Theseverityofthisdebtproblemis

    maskedbylowinterestrates;however,

    when

    rates

    rise,

    and

    one

    day

    they

    must,

    theUSwillfaceunrulyforeigninvestors

    who,knowingtheymanyneverreceivea

    returnofprincipal,demandacurrent

    returnbywayofrealinterest.

    Ourcurrentsupportofthedeflationary

    thesisistemperedovertimewitharueful

    estimationfortheunconventionalpolicy

    machinationsofChairmanBernankes

    FOMC.They

    will

    undertake

    extraordinary

    measurestopreventtheUSfromsliding

    intoanotherGreatDepression. Weare

    inthemidstofseriousmonetary

    inflationwhilesufferingfromtheprice

    deflationfromovercapacity,

    underemployment,andcompetition.

    Coincidently,wesuspectthatinflationist

    thinkingisfocuseduponalineargrowth

    linethatwillslowlyriseandthencanbe

    containedbyrisinginterestrates. Our

    contentionisthatwewillexperiencea

    novelandunprecedentedperiodof

    sharplyrisingpricesinsomeareassuchas

    agriculturalcommoditiesandmetalswhile

    otherpartsoftheeconomycontinueto

    exhibitpricedeflation. Weareaboutto

    enteranewrealmofeconomiccentral

    planningasgovernmentinvolvement

    increases.

    WEATHERWATCHAnendeavortofollowthemoneyisa

    worthwhileexercise. Inthisinstancewe

    wouldliketoexaminetherecentflowof

    investmentfundsintotheworldof

    internationalandemergingmarkets. Let

    usbeginwithTableBwhichwas

    constructedfrominformationprovidedin

    theJuly2010MorningstarDirectFund

    Flows

    Update.

    TABLEB FOLLOWTHEFUNDSMORNINGSTAR YTD TOTAL YOY

    RANK CATEGORY FLOW ASSETS CHANGE3 LargeGrowth (18,669) $673 7.3%

    7 WorldStock (4,112) $238 8.7%

    9 ShrtTerm Bond 27,255 $171 69.5%

    12 DivEmrgMkt 10,232 $144 44.0%

    17 WorldBond 19,974 $115 79.7%

    28 HiYieldMuni 3,267 $53 43.2%

    38 EmrgMktBond 6,958 $28 100%

    Notes: 1.RankisMorningstaraccordingtoTotalAssets2.YTDFlowthru6/30/10inUS$millions

    3.TotalAssetsinUS$billions

    Page 10

    Wechosecategorieswhichmostclosely

    reflectinternationalandemergingmarket

    stockandbondfunds. Wehaveincluded

  • 8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010

    11/21

    THEPOSEIDONPERSPECTIVE 29July2010

    theUSHighYieldMuniassome

    analystsequatethesecreditswith

    sovereigndebtissuedbylesserdeveloped

    countries. However,manyinvestorshave

    foregonethetaxadvantagesasthey

    embraceoverseasrisk.

    Weprofferthefollowingconclusionsfrom

    TableB. First,therehasbeenamajormove

    outofdevelopedcountryequitiesinfavor

    ofbonds. ThelargeflowintoShortterm

    Bondfundsindicatesarunawayfrom

    perceivedrisk. Partofthisflowisalso

    frommoneymarketswithnearzero

    return.However,

    the

    demand

    for

    some

    return,areachforyield,isreflectedinthe

    flowtoWorldBondandEmergingMarket

    Bondfunds. Thecombinedtotalisan

    amazing$26,932million. Investorshave

    broadenedtheirinvestmenthorizonsfor

    bothbondsandequitiesinsearchof

    greateryieldandcapitalappreciation. The

    yearoveryearchangesarestunning.

    Finally,

    experience

    tells

    us

    that

    when

    everyoneispilingontoforeignshoresit

    maybeagoodtimetoremaincloserto

    homeandavoidthecrowds.

    However,thereisgoodreasonwhy

    investorsaremovingstronglyintoforeign

    equities. WepresentTableCwhich

    outlinestheannualizedreturnsofseveral

    internationalequitymarketsasmeasured

    inUS$s

    by

    MSCI

    Barra.

    While

    some

    of

    thereturnsareoutstandingsuchas

    Indonesia,othersaredebilitatingsuchas

    Taiwan. OnthepromotionbyGoldman

    Sachsmanyinstitutionsareheavily

    weightedintheBRICcountriesandhave

    doneverywell. Also,manyofthe

    secondary,tagoncountrieshavebeen

    doingverywell,albeitwithsubstantial

    volatility.

    Itbehoovesustorememberthatwherever

    thesmartmoneyisinvestingonecanbe

    assured,duringthisperiodofsustained

    andheightenedvolatility,itisinvested

    closetotheexits.

    TABLEC POPULARDESTINATIONS1Year 3Year* 5Year* 10Year*

    BRIC 17.0% (2.82)% 16.1% 10.2%Indonesia 62.4% 12.7% 22.9% 19.8%Korea

    30.6%

    (8.30)%

    7.58%

    7.42%

    Mexico 28.9% (8.30)% 11.3% 11.1%Poland 19.4% (20.9)% 0.14% 3.22%Taiwan 12.8% (9.04)% (0.46)% (3.81)%Thailand 30.5% 2.85% 8.94% 11.0%Turkey 40.3% (3.39)% 8.87% 2.32%*calculatedascompoundannualgrowthratethru6/30/10

    Wewillreservecommentaryonthe

    GoldmanSachsBRICphenomenonfor

    anothertimeandlookmorecloselyata

    fewof

    the

    ancillary

    equity

    markets.

    We

    includefourchartswhichportraytherise,

    fall,andresurrectioninemergingmarkets.

    CHART9 BACKINACTION

    Page 11

    Source:PSI;StockCharts

  • 8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010

    12/21

    THEPOSEIDONPERSPECTIVE 29July2010

    Chart9showsthatIndonesiacontinuesto

    beahavenforhotmoney. Politicalchange

    andresourcescontinuetofuelstrong

    equityinvestment.

    ThereturnsfromMexico,Chart12,exceed

    itsnorthernneighbor.

    CHART10 BACKWITHVENGEANCE

    Source:PSI;StockCharts

    TaiwanequitiesappearinChart11and

    closelyresemble

    the

    US

    S&P

    500

    not

    only

    initsdropbutalsotheirrecoveryand10

    yearreturn.

    CHART11 STRUGGLINGBACK

    Source:PSI;StockCharts

    Finally,welookattheEurofringe. Greek

    banksmentionedTurkeyasoneoftheir

    greatstrengthsgoingforward. Perhaps,

    theyviewequityreturns,Chart12,as

    indicativeoftheirloanrepayment

    capacity.

    CHART12 MORETHANBACK

    Source:PSI;StockCharts

    Page 12

    Yet,wewouldliketopointoutthateachof

    thesecountriesisintimatelyconnectedto

    thedevelopedworld. Somearedirectly

    respondentto

    the

    US

    and

    Europe,

    others

    aredependentupontheChinatrade. This

    interconnectednesswillnotquickly

    dissipate. Thestrengthofmany

    developingmarketswasprecipitatedupon

    theconsumptionoftheadvanced

    economies. WithoutincreasingUSand

    Euroconsumptionemergingmarketsare

    vulnerabletodistress. Theconceptofde

    coupling

    is

    a

    nice

    working

    theory;

    however,inpractice,itwillrequirea

    periodofadjustment. Aretheseexuberant

    economiesnowabletowalkalone? World

    equitymarketsarepricedlikeits2007;yet,

    muchhaschangedoverthepast3years.

  • 8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010

    13/21

    THEPOSEIDONPERSPECTIVE 29July2010

    Aswepondertheopportunitieswhich

    maybefoundinforeignmarkets,wemust

    becarefulnottooverlooktheincreased

    risk. Wewouldliketoshareinsightsfrom

    arecentpublication,Reflectionsonthe

    SovereignDebtCrisisbyEdward

    Chancellor,GMOWhitePaper,July2010.

    InthiscommentaryChancellorprovidesa

    succinctandcogentanalysisofthecurrent

    turmoilinglobalsovereigndebt. Henotes

    thatGreeceistheharbingerofasovereign

    debtcrisisthatthreatenstoengulfseveral

    leadingeconomies. Ingeneral,high

    levelsofpublicdebtareassociatedwith

    pooreconomic

    growth

    and

    higher

    rates

    of

    inflation. Chancellorenumeratesthe

    severalfactorswhichhavehistoricallyled

    togovernmentdefault.

    1)Areversalofglobalcapitalflows.

    Anyseriousdeclineinexportearnings

    whichmayspringfrominterruptionof

    tradeorfallincommoditypricesleadsto

    vulnerability.

    2)

    Unwise

    lending.

    Bankingprosperityandlowinterestrates

    usuallyresultinastretchforyield,larger

    fees,andthedeteriorationoflending

    standards. Hereportsthatnearly90%of

    theforeignbondssoldinUnitedStatesin

    1929subsequentlydefaulted.

    3)Excessiveforeigndebts.

    Thissituationindicateslowdomestic

    savingsratesandresultsinhostilityto

    foreignlenders.

    When

    debt

    is

    denominatedinaforeigncurrency,a

    declineintherealvalueofhomecurrency

    raisestheburdenofexternaldebt. Hence,

    therepudiationofexternaldebtsisfar

    morecommonthandomesticdefault.

    4)Poorcredithistory.

    Unlikedeepfinancialmarketsandsocio

    economicstability,weakpolitical

    institutions,pooreconomicgrowth,and

    publiccorruptionhavebeenhallmarksof

    futuredebtproblems. Thesefactors

    becomeselfreinforcing,Since1800,Spain

    andPortugalhavedefaulted,respectively,

    onthirteenandfiveoccasions. Asaside

    note,accordingtotheBISEurobanksat

    theendof2009heldUS$193billionof

    Greekdebt,US$240billionofPortuguese

    debt,andUS$832billionofSpanishdebt.

    5)Unproductivelending.

    Whenborrowed

    money

    is

    not

    spent

    wisely,theprofligacyprecipitates

    revolutionarychangeingovernment

    underminingpoliticalstability.

    6)Rolloverrisk.

    Sincemanysovereigndebtsareneverpaid

    theyarerolledover. Termsand

    durationoftherollproduceincreased

    risk.

    7)

    Weak

    revenues.

    Historically,bankingcrisisinduce

    prolongedperiodsofbelowaverage

    economicgrowth. Theoutgrowthis

    austeritymeasurewithlowerexpenditures

    andlowertaxrevenues.

    8)Risinginterestrates.

    Higherdebtserviceisthespiraling

    outcomefromperceivedexpectationof

    increasedinflationordefaultrisk.

    Especiallyharmful

    to

    short

    term

    issuance

    ofdebt,risingratesmayquicklyleadto

    sovereignbankruptcy.

    Page 13

    Inmanycasestheseconsequencesaredue

    tocircumstanceswhichareoutsideofthe

    directcontroloftheborrower,an

  • 8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010

    14/21

    THEPOSEIDONPERSPECTIVE 29July2010

    exogenousevent. Atthatpointthereisa

    negativeconvergenceofbothabilitytopay

    andwillingnesstopay. However,there

    areseveraldenominatorswhichmay

    precludedefaultasacountrystruggles

    witharisingdebtburden.Theseinclude

    debtthatisdomesticallyfinanced,high

    levelsofdomesticsavings,asteady

    growingeconomy,andgovernment

    expenditureswhichcanbeeasilyor

    rapidlydecreased. Thebasicremedyis

    governmentcontrolthrougha

    combinationoftaxhikesandtightcontrol

    ofgovernmentspending. Thiswas

    achievedby

    Sweden,

    Finland,

    and

    Canada

    duringthe1990s. However,mostcasesof

    governmentrecoveryfromonerousdebt

    areduetostableregimesandexcellent

    credithistory. Themoreimportantissueis

    whenagovernmentprefersinflationto

    default. Thishasbeenthemorelikelypath

    forseveralemergingcountrieswherelarge

    fiscaldeficitshavebeenpartofthe

    problem.

    However,

    this

    combating

    of

    deficitswithinflationwasastratagemof

    theUSduringthe1970s. Whenfacedwith

    intractablefiscalproblemsgovernments

    tendtorevert,ifpossible,toinflation.

    Chancellorsitesthefollowingreasons:

    1) Inflationismoreconvenientthandefault.

    Inflationisactuallycovertdefault.

    However,toachievethisoutcomethe

    governmentmust

    have

    central

    bank

    controlorbeinapositiontoforcethe

    domesticbankstoacquireitsbonds.

    Underafiatmoneysystem,inflationwillalwaysbepreferredtodefaultwhendomesticdebtspredominate.(Hisitalics)

    2) Inflationresolvespoliticalconflicts.

    Sinceserviceandresolutionof

    unsustainabledebtdemandsatransferof

    resources,usuallyfromtheproductiveand

    poorerrealm,inflation,surreptitiously

    resolvestheredistribution.

    3) Avoidinginflationisalowpriority.Thisisfrequentlythecasewhenthetrade

    offisinflationorunemployment. Thishas

    alsobeenthecasewhencentralbankshave

    beenfacedwithpotentialdeflationary

    spiral. TheexamplesJapanandUSare

    given.

    4) Flameout.Thismaybetheonlyoptionwhenpublic

    credithas

    evaporated.

    Often

    accompaniedbycurrencycollapse,the

    governmentisforcedtomonetizethedebt

    sincetherearenowillingprovidersof

    publicloans. Thiswasthecasewith

    Argentinain2001andIndonesiain1997.

    Page 14

    Wheredoesthatleaveustoday?

    Chancellornotesthatconcernsover

    sovereign

    default

    since

    the

    Lehman

    collapseextendfromIcelandtoDubaito

    Hungaryandnowtheperipheryofthe

    Eurozone. Thisisnotaproblemconfined

    tosmallemergingeconomies. Heliststhe

    followingcountriesandtheirgrossdebtas

    percentageofGDP:Japan(227%),Greece

    (133%),Italy(120%),Belgium(100%),US

    (93%),France(84%),Portugal(87%),UK

    (78%),andIreland(78%). Theamountof

    thesedebts

    is

    not

    cyclically

    or

    crisis

    driven;

    theyarestructuralandongoing. Making

    mattersworseisthatthesefiguresdonot

    includemanycontingentliabilitiessuchas

    healthcareandpension(SocialSecurity)in

    theUS. Theweaknessofthissovereign

    creditstructureisthatinmanycasesthe

  • 8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010

    15/21

    THEPOSEIDONPERSPECTIVE 29July2010

    debtisheldbyforeignentities. Inthecase

    oftheUSNearlyhalfofoutstandingUS

    Treasuriesareheldabroad.

    Chancellorfinisheswithseveral

    observationsonthecurrentdebtconcerns

    withahistoricalperspective. These

    include:

    1. Thiscrisisisdifferentbecausewhile

    previousdefaultcycleshaveprimarily

    engagedemergingeconomies,thiscycle

    hasenvelopedtheadvancedeconomies.

    Developingeconomieshavebeenrunning

    surplusesandrecyclingthesefundsinto

    developedmarket

    debt.

    Coincidently,

    one

    mustgivesomevaliditytotheJapanese

    experiencewherethereseemstobeno

    limittonationaldebtlevels. Inspiteof

    deleveraging,inflationwillalsoremain

    lowdespitezerointerestratesandthe

    expansionofcentralbankbalancesheets.

    However,Japansdebthasbeeninternally

    fundedbyaveryhighdomesticsavings

    rate

    and

    the

    crisis

    was

    local

    not

    global.

    Yet,nowweareinthemidstofaglobal

    andmuchmorecomplexarenaofdebtand

    derivativeswhichfarexceednational

    incomes.

    2. Whilethereareseriousproblems

    involvingperipheralEuroeconomies,itis

    unwisetoextrapolatetheGreek(and

    others,Spain,Portugal,Italy,Ireland)

    experiencetomorehighlydeveloped

    economies.The

    level

    of

    corruption

    and

    tax

    evasionarehigh. Lendingwas

    unproductive. Mostimportantly,thedebt

    oftheseeconomiesisnotdenominatedin

    localcurrencies. Thislastpointmeansthat

    devaluationorinflationisnotavailable

    solutionstothecurrentmorass.

    3. TheUSisnotonthevergeofdefault.

    Theauthornotesthatitisaseriousfallacy

    toextrapolatecurrentconditionswellinto

    thefuture. Conditionsaresuchthatlarge

    industrialeconomiescancarrylargedebt

    burdensastheyhaveattimesinthepast

    andlowbondyieldsandminimalinflation

    meansthatdebtservicingismanageable.

    Also,theUSandUKhaverobustbanking

    systemswhichcanabsorbvastamounts

    ofgovernmentdebt. Finally,thedebtis

    issuedintheirowncurrenciesandthe

    governmentsmaintainstrictcontrolover

    theircentralbanksandforeignexchanges.

    4.Inflation

    is

    more

    likely

    than

    default.

    EventualinflationintheUS,UK,and

    Japanwouldresolvebothprivatesector

    andgovernmentliabilitiesinarelatively

    painlessfashion. However,inboththese

    countriesthecurrentpolicyofquantitative

    easingandmonetizationofthedebtis

    fraughtwithdanger. Historyrecords

    thatallgreatinflationshaveoriginated

    with

    the

    monetization

    of

    debt.

    5. Thetippingpointcamerecentlyto

    GreeceasmostpublicfinanceisaPonzi

    scheme. Theimportanceofpublicfinance

    iscredibilityinordertorollforwardthe

    publicdebt. InthecaseofJapanthe

    diminishingsavingsrateandaging

    populationspellafuturecrisis. Withmuch

    ofitsdebtofarelativelyshortterm,Japan

    isstuckinadebttrap.

    Page 15

    Thus,havingsurvivedthefinancialcrisis

    wehaveenteredtheprovinceof

    uncertaintywheretheprobabilitiesof

    gainsandlossescannotbedirectly

    measured. Whateverroutegovernments

    takeandtheglobaleconomytraverses,

  • 8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010

    16/21

    THEPOSEIDONPERSPECTIVE 29July2010

    Page 16

    increasedglobalriskwilleventually

    demandgreatercompensation. While

    continuingdeflationasseeninJapanover

    thepast20yearsisoneroute,this

    staggeringlowgrowth,lowinterestmodel

    isnottheonlypossiblefuture. Chancellor

    concludesthatForotheroutcomes,long

    datedgovernmentbondsofferalimited

    upsidewithapotentiallyuncapped

    downside. Asinvestors,suchasymmetric

    payoffprofilesdontappealtous. Well

    spoken,theydontappealtouseither!

    Wemovefromthegeneraltotheparticular

    aswe

    look

    at

    aselection

    of

    Emerging

    MarketBondFunds,onceagainusing

    Morningstardata. ThereturnsinTableC

    speakforthemselves. Substantial5year

    gainswithintermittentvolatility. Asnoted

    bytheirsalesloadparticipationin

    severalofthesefundsisnotcheap.

    However,wewouldliketoaddressthe

    issueofrisk. Itisnotuncommonfora

    countrytodefaultonlyonitslocal

    currencydebtandnotitsexternaldebt

    whichmaybepricedinUS$s. However,

    theoppositecanalsoholdtrueas

    Chancellorpointsout. Politiciansmay

    defaultonforeigndebtwhile

    maintaininglocaldebttoappeasetheir

    constituency. Anotherriskisthehowthis

    assetclassreactsinglobalturbulence. Its

    sizeisrelativelysmallinrelationtoUS

    debtmarkets. TheexamplesinTableC

    carryasubstantialamountofthebonds

    whichareratedBB,morelikeUShigh

    yieldand

    many

    which

    are

    not

    rated.

    In

    thecaseofMEDAX,19%ofcreditquality

    isBBB/BBwithacoupon510%. Duration

    rangesfrom4.76to6.13. However,when

    pricedinlocalcurrencythegreatestriskin

    emergingmarketgovernmentbonds

    accordingtoJPMorganiscurrencyor

    exchangerisk.

    TABLE

    C

    EMERGING

    MARKET

    MUTUAL

    BOND

    FUNDS

    FUND

    1Year 3Year 5Year MornStar

    Rating/AUM

    Sales

    Load

    NationalBaseforTop6Holdings

    2.TCWEMIncome

    (TGINX)17.0% 13.5% 16.1% *****

    $567

    NA Brazil,Korea,Russia,Indonesia,

    Mexico,Kazakhstan4.EatonVanceEM

    Local(EEIAX)62.4% 12.7% 22.9% *****

    $116

    4.75% US,Turkey,Malaysia,Thailand,

    Hungary,SouthAfrica6.FidelityNewMkts

    Income(FNMIX)30.6% (8.30)% 7.58% ****

    $3,414

    NA Russia,US,Ivory,Coast,Mexico,

    Argentina,Philippines10.MFSEMDebt

    (MEDAX)28.9% (8.30)% 11.3% ***

    $2,618

    4.75% Russia,Argentina,Mexico,

    Philippines,Turkey,China

    23.

    Goldman

    Sachs

    EMDebtA(GSDAX) 19.4%

    (20.9)%

    0.14%

    ***

    $4774.50%

    Russia,

    Indonesia,

    Turkey,

    Kazakhstan,Philippines,Brazil*MorningstarTop25EmergingMarketBondFundsratedby3yearreturns;effective27July2010. Fundsarenumberedby

    standinginthe25fundsevaluated;AUM,AssetsunderManagementinUS$million.

    Finally,thereisthecostofmitigatingthese

    risks. Currencyriskcanbehedgedand

    marketriskcanbeoffsetwithCredit

    DefaultSwapsbutwhatisthenet. US

    Treasuriesarelowandthespreadstoother

    creditshascontracted. Isthereanyfurther

  • 8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010

    17/21

    THEPOSEIDONPERSPECTIVE 29July2010

    caseexceptthedeflationfrightforfurther

    ratedecline? Istheinvestoradequately

    compensated? Wesensemuchmorerisk

    thanthosecrowdingthesemarkets. How

    doesonepricetheriskofdefaultwith

    muchdiminishedfaithincreditrating

    agencies? Onemustexercisegreatcare

    andattentiontodetail,sothefund

    managerbecomesthearbiterofrisk.

    Whilecurrencyvolatilitywouldnormally

    beseenasamajorriskwesupplyChart13

    asthebasisforthequestionwhether

    currencycanprovidesupport. Chart13

    trackspricingfortheUS$overthepast

    eightyears. Asbackgroundwehave

    includedtwoofthebondfundsfromTable

    C. Overaperiodoffiveyearsemerging

    marketbondsflourishedastheUS$was

    manageddownward. Theycrateredinthe

    midstoftheUScreditcrisisandhavenow

    surgedduringaperiodofextremeUS$

    volatility.

    .

    CHART13CURRENCYSUPPORT

    Source:

    PSI;

    StockCharts

    Page 17

    Emergingmarketsforbothequitiesand

    sovereigndebthavelosttheauraofhigh

    riskinvestmentsandarenowridingin

    theslipstreamofthepricesurgeforall

    riskyassets. Theyarenowpromotedasa

    coreholdingformanyportfolios. There

    areseveralreasonsforthismigration.

    Decreasedriskaversion,diversification

    withstronglyperceivedreturns,andETF

    vehiclesasacheap,easymeansfor

  • 8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010

    18/21

    THEPOSEIDONPERSPECTIVE 29July2010

    implementationareafewexamples. Those

    whoarebullishonemergingmarketspoint

    tothelowallocationsamongpension

    funds,individuals,andlargeinstitutionsin

    theUS. Wearereticenttoinvestatthese

    levelswhentheunknownsfarsurpassthe

    expectedorpotentialreturns.

    Whileimprovingcreditqualityandrecent

    upgradeshavesupportedmarket

    valuations,onemustalwaysremainaware

    ofthefragilityofmanyofthesestill

    emergingmarkets. Theunderlying

    politicalregimesstillfaceseveresocio

    economichurdles

    which

    include

    ethnic

    clashesinWesternChina,Maoistterrorism

    inIndia,andweatherinducedcalamity

    globally. Threeyearsagowhocouldhave

    imaginedthatanenfeebledruralmob

    fundedbyanexpatriaterenegadewould

    createhavocandinsurrectioninaworld

    classmegapolis,downtownBangkok. In

    thatinstanceallwasresolvedwithout

    economicchaosbutthismaynotalwaysbe

    thecase. Whoknowshowthenarcowars

    onthesouthernborderoftheUnitedStates

    willplayoutforMexicanpoliticsandthe

    overalleconomy? Thequestioniswhether

    yieldsonemergingdebtcanremainlowin

    thefaceofsovereignrisksinthedeveloped

    nations. IfG7yieldsbegintoclimbthen

    theyields

    in

    emerging

    markets

    will

    have

    to

    climbevenfastertocompensateforother

    risks.

    CHART14 DEVALUATIONALLOWSRISINGASSETVALUES

    Source:PSI;StockCharts

    Page 18

  • 8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010

    19/21

    THEPOSEIDONPERSPECTIVE 29July2010

    PROVISIONING

    Theinterpretationandimpactofmyriad

    globaleventsareveryhardtodiscern

    giventhemassiveamountsofinformation

    and

    data

    available.

    The

    advent

    of

    computersimulationarraysand

    econometricmegamodelssupportthe

    searchforgreatercertainty. Yet,evenwith

    theseaidsforcondensationandresolution

    themixtureremainsopaque. Simple

    measuresofriskareignoredinfavorof

    aggressivetacticsandcomplexalgorithms

    laboringforgreaterreturns. However,we

    alwaysbeginwithafewfundamentalsfor

    someguidance.

    As

    mentioned

    above

    currencyriskisamajorhurdle.

    Movementsinthecurrencymarketsare

    thetelltalesforsuddenanddramatic

    economicchange. Chart14revealsthe

    macroimpactofaUS$devaluationupon

    financialassetsmeasuredbytheS&P500

    andcommodities,representedbyoil,

    WTIC. ForalmostadecadetheUS$has

    beenmanageddownwardinsupportofUS

    economicexpansion.

    Thebalancingactcameapartin2008and

    therisksgoingforwardareenormousand

    hardtomeasure. Therefore,weremain

    skepticalofstabilityintheemerging

    markets. Therehasbeenglobal

    exuberanceinequityandbondpricesfor

    thepast16monthswithincreasing

    volatility. Wefindthatfutureexpectations

    aremisplacedinrecognitionofcurrency

    andmarketrisks. RecoveriesintheUSand

    globaleconomies

    is

    weakening.

    We

    believethatdefensivepositioningis

    necessaryforsoundinvestmentdecisions.

    Ourportfolioremainsfocusedoncash,

    preciousmetals(goldandsilver),and

    bondfundswithawelldiversified

    positionspanningalowmidduration.

    Wheninneedofarealitycheckfromtheemotivespeculationsandoverwhelming

    disinformationcirculatingamidstthefinancialmedia,wefrequentlyturntoTheWriters

    Almanacfordiversion. Thus,wewereintriguedwhenwereadoneoftheentriesforJuly

    20,2010. Ratherthanparaphrase,wequoteinmajorpart,thepassagevoicedbyGarrison

    Keillor:

    Itwasonthisday[July20]in1875thatthelargestrecordedswarmoflocusts

    inAmericanhistorydescendedupontheGreatPlains. Anestimated3.5trillion

    locustsmadeuptheswarm. Itwasabout1,800mileslongand110mileswide,

    rangingfromCanadadowntoTexas.

    Swarmswould

    occur

    once

    every

    seven

    to

    12

    years,

    emerging

    from

    river

    valleys

    intheRockyMountainsandsweepingeastacrossmuchofthecountry.Thesizeofthe

    swarmstendedtogrowwhentherewaslessrain,andin1873,theAmericanWest

    begantogothroughoneofitsdriestperiodsonrecord.

    Page 19

  • 8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010

    20/21

    THEPOSEIDONPERSPECTIVE 29July2010

    Page 20

    LOCUSTSWARMINAFRICA,2009

    Thelandwasstillrelativelydryonthisdayin

    1875whenfarmersjusteastoftheRocky

    Mountains

    began

    to

    see

    a

    cloud

    approaching

    fromthewest.Somefarmersnoticedthe

    distinctivecolorofthecloud,glintingaround

    theedgeswherethelocustwingscaughtthe

    lightofthesun.

    Peopletherethatdaysaidthatthelocusts

    descendedlikeadrivingsnowinwinter,

    coveringeverythingintheirpath.Somepeople

    describedthesoundoftheswarmlandingas

    likethunderoratrain.Thelocustsblanketedthe

    ground,nearly

    afoot

    deep.

    Trees

    bent

    over

    with

    theweightoftheinsects,andlargetreelimbsSource:GoogleImages

    brokeoffunderthepressure.

    Theyatenearlyeverylivingpieceofvegetationintheirpath,aswellas

    harnessesonhorses,thebarkoftrees,curtains,andclothinghungonlaundrylines.

    Theygnawedonfencepostsandrailings,andtheyespeciallylovedthehandlesof

    farmtools,whichwereleftbehindpolished,asifbyfinesandpaper.Somefarmers

    triedtoscareawaythelocustsbyrunningintotheswarm,andtheyhadtheirclothes

    eatenrightofftheirbodies.

    Inthewakeoftheswarm,settlersonhalfamillionsquaremilesoftheWest

    facedstarvation.Similarlocustswarmsoccurredinthefollowingyears,andfarmers

    becamedesperate.Butbythemid1880s,therainshadreturned,andtheswarmsdied

    down.Mostscientistspredictedthatthelocustswouldreturnwiththenextdrought.

    Mysteriously,theydidnot.Withinafewdecadestheywerebelievedtobeextinct.

    ThisisclearlyaBlackSwanorfattaileventinaccordancewithNassimNicholasTalebs

    praiseworthyworkTheBlackSwan,TheImpactoftheHighlyImprobable. Fromthebook

    welearn

    that

    aBlack

    Swan

    event

    has

    three

    attributes:

    it

    is

    an

    outlier

    as

    it

    lies

    outside

    the

    realmofregularexpectations,itcarriesanextremeimpact,andhumannaturemakesus

    concoctexplanationsforitsconcurrence,afterthefact,makingitexplainableand

    predictable. Here,wedigressforamoment. Talebbringstolightmanyflashesofbrilliance.

    OneistheludicfallacywhichTalebdefinesasthinkingthattheattributesofthe

    uncertaintywefaceinreallifehavelittleconnectiontothesterilizedonesweencounterin

    examsandgames. Weinterpretthisinthecontextofcomputermodelsandmarketactivity.

  • 8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010

    21/21

    THEPOSEIDONPERSPECTIVE 29July2010

    Thebestlaidschemesandexpectationsfrequentlyrunafouloftherealitiesofcomplex

    humaninteractions. Manytradingpairs,correlativeparadigms,andderivativecurrency

    overlaysfailwhentherubbermeetstheroad.

    So,whatsthepoint? First,truthisstrangerthanfictionandonceananomalyhaspresented

    itselfitcanhappenoverandoverinashortperiodoftime. ArecentcaseisthefallofBear

    Stearns,thenLehman,WashingtonMutual,CountrywideFinancial,andthecontinuing

    dominoesofsmallbanksbeingclosedweeklybytheFDIC. Nobodyknowstheendpoint.

    Next,beinginthewrongplaceorwronginvestmentatthewrongtimecanbedevastating.

    TowitinvestinginCitigroupat$51inDecember2006,buyingrealestateSEAsiain1997,or

    Russiandebtin1998. Financialstocksaremuchmoreriskythaniswidelyknownor

    acknowledged. Ifnotforgovernmentbailoutsandtaxpayersubsidiesmanyfinancial

    institutionswouldnotexist. Thisistruertodaythaneverbefore. Thebalancesheetsof

    financialinstitutionsincludingtheFederalReserveareholdingtanksforseverelydamaged

    andtoxic

    securities.

    Lastly,

    financial

    and

    econometric

    models

    are

    complex

    illusions

    premised

    uponunwieldyassumptionsoflackingemotions. Donotacceptlightlyanyones

    prognosticationforthefuture. Thefutureisasecret. Manypeoplerefusetoacknowledge

    thatmostoutstandingaccomplishmentsareduetogoodluckortakingoutsizedrisks.

    Sincereregards,

    BrianE.Shean,CFAPRINCIPAL

    POSEIDONSTRATEGICINVESTMENTS

    _________________________________________________________________________________

    Theviewsexpressedinthiscommentaryarethoseoftheauthoratthetimeofcomposition. Theassumptions,analysis,and

    conclusionsaresubjecttochangeinconjunctionwithchangesinthesecuritiesmarketsordiscoveryofadditionalor

    conflictinginformation. Allinformationconveyedhereinhasbeendeduced,compiledorquantifiedfromsourcesthoughtto

    beconsistentlyreliable. Thisinformationalreportisproducedforgeneralcirculationandisnottobeconstruedasa

    solicitationtobuyorsellsecurities,financialinstruments,orinvestmentproducts. Priortoenteringanytransactionsfor

    investmentproductspleaseconsultacompetentfinancialadviserandundertakeproperduediligence. AMDG