7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010
-
Upload
brian-shean -
Category
Documents
-
view
220 -
download
0
Transcript of 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010
-
8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010
1/21
THE
POSEIDON
PERSPECTIVE
soundnavigationthroughperilouscrosscurrents
29July2010
DearInvestor,
Wehavelongbeenanadvocateofvalue
investingfollowingthepathofGraham,
Dodd,Buffet,
Klarman,
Dreman,
Whitman,
etal. However,overthepastdecadewe
havebecomemorecognizantofthegreat
influencetechnicalandmacroeconomic
factorshaveinthemovementofequity
markets. TheimpactofFedliquidity,
highfrequencytrading,darkpools,and
index/sector/ETFtradingishardto
measurebutimmenselyimportantinthe
pricingofpublicequitymarkets. Thus,
ourfundamentalanalysisisshadowed
withananalyticframeworkwhichwecan
bestdescribeasmosaicbuilding. Pieceby
pieceweseektoconstructavalid
representationforeachinvestmentthesis.
Inadditiontotherigorousadhesionto
traditionalquantitativemetrics,this
methodologydemandsadiscerning
qualitativeevaluationofriskforthe
preservationof
capital.
It
is
aprocess
of
distillationtomorebasicmetrics. Marty
Whitmanisfondofsayingabargainis
notabargainifitremainsabargain. We
agreeandhavealwaysbelievedthatyou
makeyourmoneyinthebuying. An
exampleofabargainthatmaywellremain
abargainorlessisCitigroup,Inc(C).
Welookatequitymarketreturns
displayedinTableA. Thepast3years
havebeenabonecrushingexperiencefor
equityinvestorsworldwide. Inthecaseof
USequitiestheexpectationsandoptimism
whichwereheldyearafteryearhave
yieldednaught. Thebuyandhold
publichasbeenexploitedwhiletheUS
Congress,Federalregulatoryagencies,and
theFederalReserveSystemhaverefused
toexercisetheirregulatorypowers.
TABLEAYTD10 3Year* 5Year* 10Year*
DJIA (6.27)% (10.0)% (0.99)% (0.67)%S&P500 (7.57)% (11.8)% (2.86)% (3.39)%Nasdaq (7.05)% (6.77)% 0.50% (6.12)%MSCIEAFE** (14.7)% (15.8)% (1.77)% (2.17)%MSCIEM** (7.22)% (4.67)% 10.2% 7.50%
SSEC
(26.8)%
(14.4)%
17.3%
2.21%
YTDisthruJune30,2010
*calculatedascompoundannualgrowthrate
**MSCIBarraIndexes
Thesegrimyeartodatefigureshave
improvedduringJuly;however,we
suspectthatequitymarketsaretreading
-
8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010
2/21
THEPOSEIDONPERSPECTIVE 29July2010
waterasaresultofeconomicuncertainty
andglobalturmoil. Theselloffhasbeen
particularlysevereinthecaseofChina
representedbySSEC. Thisisthetypeof
correctionwhichcreatesbuying
opportunities;however,wemustawaitthe
arrivalofstrongerfundamentals. Many
EmergingMarketsarepricedtogreat
expectationsratherthanrealistic
valuations. FundshaveflowedoutofUS
equitiesintointernationalbondsand
emergingmarketsecurities. Theriskof
overpayinghasbecomedominant. We
demandagreatermarginofsafetypriorto
investment.The
easy
money
has
been
madeoverthepastyear.
InChart1wepresentapictureofthe
biggestandbestofequityinAmerican
enterprise,thisistheDowJones
Composite(DJA)overthepastseven
years. TheDJAisanindexcompilingthe
Industrials,Transports,andUtilities,
conservative,safe,strong. Thisisachartof
weeklypriceswhichwelikebecauseitcuts
outmostofthedaytodaytradingnoise.
Withinthechartwehaveincludeda
volumebaracrossthebottomandmoving
average(MA)lines,bluerepresents10
weeksandred40weeks. Theseroughly
correspondtothetechnicalanalysts
notationof50and200dayMAindicators.
Webringyourattentiontotherecent
crossoverof
the
10
week
MA
below
the
40
weekMA. Intheparlanceoftechnical
tradersthisisknownastheDeathCross
duetheimpendingpossibilityofa
seriouslydecliningtrend.
CHART1 FOLLOWINGTHEDOWS
Page 2
Source:PSI;StockCharts
-
8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010
3/21
THEPOSEIDONPERSPECTIVE 29July2010
WhileJulyhasaddedsomenewsteamto
equitymarketswequestionthesubstance
ofamidsummerrallyinthefaceofastill
weakeningeconomy. Summeroptimismis
frequentlysubjecttotheharshnessof
autumnrealism.
ThenextthreechartslookattheUS
economythruthelensofmarketpricing
andmarketcapsofseveralcurrentand
formerleadershipcompanies. Webegin
withbasicmanufacturinginChart2.
Allowingfordifferenceswestillfindsome
basictruth
in
the
comparison
of
Apple
(AAPL)andGeneralElectric(GE). A
dominantleaderofbasicindustryforso
longGEisnowstrugglingunderthegross
financialburdenofGECapital. Nowthe
marketrewardstheconsumergadgetking
Applewhosemarketingprowessandout
sourcedmanufacturingcommandgrand
premiums. Wealsoviewtheseprice
changes
as
a
reflection
of
the
US
economy,
amajormovefrombasicmanufacturingto
consumption.
CHART2 TOYSVSMACHINES
Source:PSI;StockCharts
AnothercurrentWallStreetdarlingis
Google(GOOG). Itsaneasysellwith
battalionsofengineerscreatingmoreand
morelogarithmicmethodsforslicingand
dicingsearchinformationaboutconsumers
foritsnewguardadvertisingmetrics. In
Chart3wecouplethischarmmachine
withaformerqueenofthevalley,Yahoo
(YHOO)whichhasneverrecoveredfrom
theMicrosofttakeoverattempt.Jerrys
pridelostalotofmoneyformanyYHOO
shareholders. Wedonotdemeanthe
qualityofthesecompanies;itisaquestion
ofprice
in
respect
to
their
current
value.
Theoldbuyersadageispriceiswhatyou
pay,valueiswhatyouget. Weuse
Googlefrequentlyandstill,after12years,
areregularusersofYahoo. Whilethe
lattermightbeslightlyovervaluedthe
formerspricedemandsevergreater
expectations. Givencurrentconsumer
fundamentalswefindthatthemarketing
queen
of
gadgets,
AAPL,
and
the
premier
advertisingmonolith,GOOG,areboth
overpriced.
CHART3 LEADINGTHESEARCH
Page 3
Source:PSI;StockCharts
-
8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010
4/21
THEPOSEIDONPERSPECTIVE 29July2010
Finally,welookattwodynastiesof
finance,thehumbledandthecrushed. The
firstistheworldslargestgovernment
assistedhedgefundGoldmanSachs
(GS). Afteracceptingtaxpayermoneyto
continueitvasttradingoperationsthefirm
hasbeenhumiliatedbySECallegationsof
fraud. GShasrecoveredand,while
shareholdersmaynotreapthelongterm
benefits,thepartnerswillneversuffer.
Theygettheircuteveryyear,offthetop.
InChart4wecontrastthiscutthroat
moneymachinewiththenatteringnabobs
ofCitigroup
(C).
Citi
is
aquasi
governmententerprise,obtusebeyond
effectivemanagement. Wedeemit,much
likeAIGorGM,anextensionoftheUS
Treasury. Allaredestinedeventuallyfor
thedustbin. Fromahighof$51.01on
December27,2006Citigroupnow
commandsaround$4withhundredsof
billionsoftaxpayerdollarsinbackstopping
of
risk.
Many
thought
it
was
too
big,
too
importanttofailbutforequityinvestorsit
alreadyhas.
CHART4 FASTMONEYVSSAVINGS
Source:PSI;StockCharts
OveralltheUSequitymarketsaresucha
shamblesofmanicdepressivemovements
thatweconjecturethegreatestreturnswill
accruetothosewhodisplaythepatienceto
refrainfromclimbingaboardthe
bandwagon. Currentmarketrisksare
beyondthekenofmanyinvestorsand
hopeforanimprovingeconomyfuels
meagermarketrises. Anysummerrally
mayfallquickpreytoautumnvolatility
andlateyearprofittakingwhichmaybe
exacerbatedbyfearofrisingtaxeson
capitalgains.
SOUNDINGS
Page 4
Wewouldliketoupdatesomethoughts,
reservations,andcommentaryonthe
continuinginflation/deflationdiscussion.
Ourfirstannouncementcomesbywayof
theJuly2010GMOQuarterlyLetter
fromJeremyGrantham. Hiscommentary
iscloselyfollowed,highlyrespected,and
astutely
accurate.
We
find
it
to
be
compulsoryreading. Itisavailableatthe
GMOwebsite,gmo.com. Inthefirstofsix
SummerEssaysGranthamfinallytakes
thesideofdeflation. Hisreasoningis
weakloansupplyandfairlyweak
demand,thevelocityofmoneyhasslowed,
andinflationseemsadistantprospect.
Thisexpectationisinlinewithhis
previousprognosticationforsevenlean
years.We
also
note
that
Grantham
believeswitha50%probability,as
outlinedinEssay3,TheFearful,
SpeculativeMarket,thatBernanke
wouldbecertaintokeepratesatrock
bottomforthenext18monthsorlonger.
-
8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010
5/21
THEPOSEIDONPERSPECTIVE 29July2010
Whilethereissubstantialprobabilityfor
correctionsinthecurrentfearful,
speculativemarket,Granthammakesa
strongandveritablecaseforhighquality
USstocks. Thisargumentispremisedon
thevaluecase;theyarecheap.
InEssay5SevenLeanYearsRevisited
Granthammakesseveralsalientpoints
worthrepeating. Theyare:
1. Inaworldgrowingnervousaboutthe
qualityofsovereigndebteventhatofthe
USdomesticsovereigndebtlevelshave
exploded. Thesedebtlevelsmustbe
loweredat
every
level,
especially
governmentalandthereisalmostno
waythatthisprocesswillbepleasantor
quick.
2. Dangerouslyexcessivefinancial
systemdebtwasmovedacross,with
additions,tobecomedangerously
excessivegovernmentdebt. Theresultis
asituationwhereinheseesIncreasingly,
the
cure
seems
more
like
a
stay
of
execution.
3. Nowconsumersarereadjustingtoa
greaterneedtosaveand,perhaps
unfortunately,agreaterneedtowork
longer. Unprecedentedly,theyarepaying
downsomeconsumerdebt. These
changedattitudeswillsurelylastfor
years.
4. theleverageinthesystemandthe
chancesof
further
write
downs
(yet
more
housingdefaultsandprivateequitywrite
downs,forexample)leavebanks
undercapitalizedandreluctanttolend.
5. Withmanyoftheartificialstimuliof
the90sand2000sgone,their[statesand
municipalities]revenuesareunlikelyto
bouncebackinoneortwoyears,anda
doubledipintheeconomyornewasset
pricedeclines[realestate]wouldmove
theirrecoveryfurtherback.
6. Unemploymentishighandwillalso
sufferfromthelossofthosekickersrelated
toassetbubbles.
7. TheU.S.inparticularcannotcontinue
torunlargetradeimbalances.
Imbalancesdestabilizethesystem.
8. Temporarybailouts[Greece]are
postponementsofanecessary
restructuring. Thus,theotherPIGS,
havebecomeanintrinsicpartoftheseven
leanyears,
more
or
less
guaranteeing
slowerthannormalGDPgrowthanda
longworkoutperiod.
9. Thegeneralrisinglevelsofsovereign
debtandtheparticularproblemsfacingthe
euroblocandJapanareleadingtothe
systematiclossofconfidenceinourfaith
basedcurrencies.
10. Finally,itispossiblethatmost
important
of
all,
on
a
long
horizon
there
is
averylongtermproblemwidespread
overcommitmentstopensionsandhealth
benefits.
Page 5
Weadmire,understand,andconcuralmost
entirelywithMr.Granthamstheses;
however,asisindicatedbyhispreference
forUShighquality,hisprognosisand
prophylacticarebothprettymainstream
amongastute
money
managers.
We
believethateconomiceventsmayunfold
muchmorerapidlyandwithwider
dispersionsthanmanyinvestorshave
considered. Weseeinflationasthe
inevitableendgametocentralbank
desperationtorestoreeconomicgrowth.
-
8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010
6/21
THEPOSEIDONPERSPECTIVE 29July2010
ChairmanBernankehasmadeit
adamantlyclearthatGreatDepressionII
willnotoccuronhiswatch. TheFeds
unprecedentedandsupersizedmonetary
stimulicontinuetoveiltheunpleasant
realitythattheU.S.haslostits
manufacturingbaseandthejobsthatare
attendanttoit. Thefinance,insurance,and
realestate,(FIRE)economyisnow
falteringandasMr.Granthamnoteswe
arenowlosingthekickerswhichwent
withthegoodtimes. Weagreethatseven
leanyearsisprobablywhatthenation
needs. However,politiciansmaydecide
thatis
not
what
the
nation
gets.
NextwereferencethepresentationbyVan
Hoisington,HoisingtonInvestment
ManagementCompanyfromtheFixed
IncomeManagement2009Conferenceon
12October2009inBostonanddistributed
intheCFAInstituteConference
ProceedingsQuarterlyMarch2010. Inhis
presentation,
The
Debt
Deflation/Inflation
Debate,Hoisingtonposesasimple
question,whetherthepricelevelisgoing
uporgoingdown. Hisanswerisalso
simpleandstraightforward. Inaccordance
withthedebtdeflationtheorypositedby
IrvingFisherin1933,deflationfollows
deeprecessions,regardlessofthefiscalor
monetarypolicyusedtoaddressthe
nationseconomicwoes. Hearguesthat
theUnited
States
is
in
the
midst
of
adebt
bubblethathappensonlyonceevery70
80years. Hoisingtonbelievesthatthe
currentlevelofdebt/GDPis3.75andto
reducethislevelwillrequirealongtime.
ForsupportheinvokesTheFinancial
InstabilityHypothesisofHymanMinsky
whichoutlinesthethreestagesof
financingasaneconomyprogresses
throughgreaterandgreaterspeculative
pressures. Thissoundsfamiliaraswe
reflectonthestock,junkbond,commodity,
andrealestatebubblesoverthepasttwo
decades. Thestagesbeginwithhedge
financing,inwhichthelenderfullyexpects
thereturnofbothprincipalandinterest.
Thesecondstageisspeculativefinancing,
inwhichlendersbelievetheywillreceive
theirinterestpaymentsandare
comfortablewiththefactthattheprincipal
canalwaysberefinanced. Andthethird
stageis
Ponzi
financing,
in
which
lenders
havelittleexpectationofreceivingeither
theirprincipalorinterestpaymentsbut
looktorapidlyrisingassetvaluesfor
security. Intheendtheoverleveraged
assetslosevaluebutthedebtremains.
Repaymentbecomesaseriousproblem. In
accordancewithFisherstheorythe
distressedsellingtorepaydebtbeginsto
overwhelm
the
system
as
increasing
repaymentsshrinkthemoneysupply
resultinginfallingprices,unemployment,
andgeneralpessimism. Duetothe
unprecedenteddebtlevelsrelativetoGDP
theU.S.isclosetoadebtdeflation
experience.
Page 6
Hoisingtonreviewsindetailthethree
requirementsforagrowthinthemonetary
baseto
translate
into
higher
prices.
The
firstrequirementisanupwardsloping
supplycurve. However,duetothe
overcapacityinthesystemandhigh
unemploymentthesupplycurveis
actuallyflatordownwardsloping. Thisis
thetypicalresultofrecessions,over
-
8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010
7/21
THEPOSEIDONPERSPECTIVE 29July2010
Page 7
capacityandintensecompetitioncause
pricestodrop. Withoutresurgencein
capacityutilizationandgrowthinweekly
hoursofproductiontherewillnotbearise
inthesupplycurve. Thesecond
requirementisstableorrisingvelocityof
money. Whilenotinherentlystablethe
velocityofmoneyisusuallydrivenbytwo
factors,financialinnovationand/or
leverage. Whilethevelocityofmoneyrose
rapidlyinthe1990sithasfallen
significantlysince2000withonestrong
surgeinmiddecade. Chart5indicatesthe
risingvelocityduringtheultraleverage
thruconduits
and
securitization
from
1990
2000andtheresurgenceofassetvalues
duetofinancialinnovationforconsumers
andhousingduring20042007. So,evenin
thefaceofincreasingmoneysupply,M2,
therecanbeasubstantialslowdownin
GDPgrowthwithcontractingvelocityof
money. Hoisingtonprovidestheexample
duringperiod4Q20082Q2009whenM2
increased
10.3%,
Velocity
decreased
(12.6)%andGDPwasdown(3.6)%.
Thethirdfactornecessaryforrisingprices
isastableorrisingvalueforthemoney
multiplier,m. ThemultiplieristheratioofawelldefinedmoneysupplysuchasM2
tothemonetarybasewhichwouldresult
intheM2multiplier. AsevidencetheM2
multiplierdroppedfrom9in2008to3in
2009while
during
the
same
period
excess
reservesgrewbyalmost$800billion.
ForthesereasonsHoisingtonopinesthat
monetarypolicy,theZIRP,isbroken
whichleavesonlyfiscalpolicytosupport
theeconomyandenhancegrowth.
However,byitsnaturethepublicsector
hasaproductivitylevelofzerobecause
municipalinfrastructuresandpublic
serviceprovidersdonotproducea
quantifiablegood. Heseesnopositive
impactasaresultoftheunprecedented
amountofgovernmentspending. A
nationcannotborrowitswayto
prosperity. Healsopositsthatgovernment
debtisnotbyitselfinflationary,pointing
totheperiods19291941intheUnited
Statesand19892008inJapan.
Additionally,heciteslowinterestrates,
highunemployment,
and
the
decline
in
the
S&P500asevidenceofdebtdeflation.
Sinceabouttwothirdsoftheeconomy
dependsuponconsumerspending,
Hoisingtonprojectsaseriousdecreasein
USimportdemandduetoconsumernet
worthlossesinhousingandequitymarket
declines. Hespeculatesthatinthe15
largestGDPcountries,notincluding
China,
it
is
unlikely
that
any
country
will
experiencepositivegrowthindomestic
demanduntiltheUnitedStatesdoes.
HoisingtonconcludedthattheUShas
enteredadeflationaryenvironmentdueto
thelevelsofdebtespeciallyhousehold.
Hisexpectationisthatthiswillcontinue
forseveralyearsasthedemandforUS
exportsisdim. However,heseesthis
situationasgoodforlongtermTreasury
bondswhich
results
in
the
now
4percent
ratetodroptoabout2percentandbonds
continuingtooutperformstocks.
-
8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010
8/21
THEPOSEIDONPERSPECTIVE 29July2010
CHART5 THEENDOFFASTMONEY?
Source:HoisingtonInvestmentManagement
Wesurmise
that
Hoisington
has
been
quite
prescientinhisforecastingofdebt
deflation. Atthetimeofhispresentation
therewerestillhopesforastrongrecovery,
robustFedpolicyinducements,and
politicaloptimism. Tenmonthslaterwe
arefacingamuchharsherreality. We
grantthatthedeflationarytrendsmay
continue,yetweforeseearenewedeffort
by
government
to
accelerate
economic
activity. Timingisimportant;however,we
cannotpredictthepathoroutcomes. We
waitwithrespectfortheoldadageDont
fighttheFed.
Weunderstand
the
deflation
argument.
Thecurrentsituationisdrivenbyan
unwindingofleverage. Wesubmitthe
followingthreechartsfromtheSt.Louis
Fedwhichclearlydetaildebtdeflation
overthepasttwoyears.
Chart6revealsthe40%dropofover$300
billioninFinancialCommercialPaper
Outstanding.
This
is
short
term
(less
than
270days)lendingwithoutcollateral.
WhiletheFedhasbeenabletosupport
shorttermlendingtobanksthruseveral
mechanisms,thisstaggeringdropincredit
availabilityreflectsdeteriorationinthe
Page 8
-
8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010
9/21
THEPOSEIDONPERSPECTIVE 29July2010
financialsystem. Unfortunately,we
suspectthatthelevelofFINCPNcorrelates
withtheriseandfallofsecuritiesmarkets.
CHART
6
THE
DROP
OF
PAPER
Source:StLouisFed
Chart7discloses
amore
severe
drop
of
67%or$800billionofAssetbacked
CommercialPaper. Thiscollapsereveals
bothadeclineinthecontinuingneedfor
newcreditandthelackofavailabilityof
substantialcollateral. Inasystem
dependentuponcreditgrowthforGNP
growtheitherthediminishingmeansfor
lendingortherecedingdemandforcredit
mustresult
in
much
slower
economic
growth. Towhatdegreeofrobustness
mustcurrentmonetaryandfiscalpolicybe
takeninordertoreversethesedeflationary
trends?
CHART7 THEDROPINASSETVALUES
Source:StLouisFed
CHART8 THEDROPINSECURITY
Source:StLouisFed
Page 9
Chart8reflectsatruemilestonein
financialinnovation. Themarketfor
-
8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010
10/21
THEPOSEIDONPERSPECTIVE 29July2010
consumerloansecuritizationbeganin1989
androserapidlyuntil2007,almost20years
ofcontinuingcreditextensiontosupport
theconsumerspendingwhichisaround
70%oftheeconomy. Thesuddenendin
2008whichproducedadropofover$500
billionofpotentialGNPisareflectionof
consumerdesireormandatetobegin
saving. Whattypeofrecoverycan
accommodatethislevelofretrenchment?
AsGranthampointsoutabovethisisan
attitudechangewhichwillsurelylast
foryears. Weconjecturethatthese
reversionsfromborrowingtodeleveraging
willcontinue
until
there
is
arenewal
of
spiritwhichcreatesnewjobs,drives
demandforcredit,andproducesgreatnew
productsand/orservices. Theresolutionof
thedeflation/inflationissueisyes. Asthe
deflationaryspiralcontinuesthecentral
bankwillcontinuetounleashitsmonetary
magic. Theseverityofthisdebtproblemis
maskedbylowinterestrates;however,
when
rates
rise,
and
one
day
they
must,
theUSwillfaceunrulyforeigninvestors
who,knowingtheymanyneverreceivea
returnofprincipal,demandacurrent
returnbywayofrealinterest.
Ourcurrentsupportofthedeflationary
thesisistemperedovertimewitharueful
estimationfortheunconventionalpolicy
machinationsofChairmanBernankes
FOMC.They
will
undertake
extraordinary
measurestopreventtheUSfromsliding
intoanotherGreatDepression. Weare
inthemidstofseriousmonetary
inflationwhilesufferingfromtheprice
deflationfromovercapacity,
underemployment,andcompetition.
Coincidently,wesuspectthatinflationist
thinkingisfocuseduponalineargrowth
linethatwillslowlyriseandthencanbe
containedbyrisinginterestrates. Our
contentionisthatwewillexperiencea
novelandunprecedentedperiodof
sharplyrisingpricesinsomeareassuchas
agriculturalcommoditiesandmetalswhile
otherpartsoftheeconomycontinueto
exhibitpricedeflation. Weareaboutto
enteranewrealmofeconomiccentral
planningasgovernmentinvolvement
increases.
WEATHERWATCHAnendeavortofollowthemoneyisa
worthwhileexercise. Inthisinstancewe
wouldliketoexaminetherecentflowof
investmentfundsintotheworldof
internationalandemergingmarkets. Let
usbeginwithTableBwhichwas
constructedfrominformationprovidedin
theJuly2010MorningstarDirectFund
Flows
Update.
TABLEB FOLLOWTHEFUNDSMORNINGSTAR YTD TOTAL YOY
RANK CATEGORY FLOW ASSETS CHANGE3 LargeGrowth (18,669) $673 7.3%
7 WorldStock (4,112) $238 8.7%
9 ShrtTerm Bond 27,255 $171 69.5%
12 DivEmrgMkt 10,232 $144 44.0%
17 WorldBond 19,974 $115 79.7%
28 HiYieldMuni 3,267 $53 43.2%
38 EmrgMktBond 6,958 $28 100%
Notes: 1.RankisMorningstaraccordingtoTotalAssets2.YTDFlowthru6/30/10inUS$millions
3.TotalAssetsinUS$billions
Page 10
Wechosecategorieswhichmostclosely
reflectinternationalandemergingmarket
stockandbondfunds. Wehaveincluded
-
8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010
11/21
THEPOSEIDONPERSPECTIVE 29July2010
theUSHighYieldMuniassome
analystsequatethesecreditswith
sovereigndebtissuedbylesserdeveloped
countries. However,manyinvestorshave
foregonethetaxadvantagesasthey
embraceoverseasrisk.
Weprofferthefollowingconclusionsfrom
TableB. First,therehasbeenamajormove
outofdevelopedcountryequitiesinfavor
ofbonds. ThelargeflowintoShortterm
Bondfundsindicatesarunawayfrom
perceivedrisk. Partofthisflowisalso
frommoneymarketswithnearzero
return.However,
the
demand
for
some
return,areachforyield,isreflectedinthe
flowtoWorldBondandEmergingMarket
Bondfunds. Thecombinedtotalisan
amazing$26,932million. Investorshave
broadenedtheirinvestmenthorizonsfor
bothbondsandequitiesinsearchof
greateryieldandcapitalappreciation. The
yearoveryearchangesarestunning.
Finally,
experience
tells
us
that
when
everyoneispilingontoforeignshoresit
maybeagoodtimetoremaincloserto
homeandavoidthecrowds.
However,thereisgoodreasonwhy
investorsaremovingstronglyintoforeign
equities. WepresentTableCwhich
outlinestheannualizedreturnsofseveral
internationalequitymarketsasmeasured
inUS$s
by
MSCI
Barra.
While
some
of
thereturnsareoutstandingsuchas
Indonesia,othersaredebilitatingsuchas
Taiwan. OnthepromotionbyGoldman
Sachsmanyinstitutionsareheavily
weightedintheBRICcountriesandhave
doneverywell. Also,manyofthe
secondary,tagoncountrieshavebeen
doingverywell,albeitwithsubstantial
volatility.
Itbehoovesustorememberthatwherever
thesmartmoneyisinvestingonecanbe
assured,duringthisperiodofsustained
andheightenedvolatility,itisinvested
closetotheexits.
TABLEC POPULARDESTINATIONS1Year 3Year* 5Year* 10Year*
BRIC 17.0% (2.82)% 16.1% 10.2%Indonesia 62.4% 12.7% 22.9% 19.8%Korea
30.6%
(8.30)%
7.58%
7.42%
Mexico 28.9% (8.30)% 11.3% 11.1%Poland 19.4% (20.9)% 0.14% 3.22%Taiwan 12.8% (9.04)% (0.46)% (3.81)%Thailand 30.5% 2.85% 8.94% 11.0%Turkey 40.3% (3.39)% 8.87% 2.32%*calculatedascompoundannualgrowthratethru6/30/10
Wewillreservecommentaryonthe
GoldmanSachsBRICphenomenonfor
anothertimeandlookmorecloselyata
fewof
the
ancillary
equity
markets.
We
includefourchartswhichportraytherise,
fall,andresurrectioninemergingmarkets.
CHART9 BACKINACTION
Page 11
Source:PSI;StockCharts
-
8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010
12/21
THEPOSEIDONPERSPECTIVE 29July2010
Chart9showsthatIndonesiacontinuesto
beahavenforhotmoney. Politicalchange
andresourcescontinuetofuelstrong
equityinvestment.
ThereturnsfromMexico,Chart12,exceed
itsnorthernneighbor.
CHART10 BACKWITHVENGEANCE
Source:PSI;StockCharts
TaiwanequitiesappearinChart11and
closelyresemble
the
US
S&P
500
not
only
initsdropbutalsotheirrecoveryand10
yearreturn.
CHART11 STRUGGLINGBACK
Source:PSI;StockCharts
Finally,welookattheEurofringe. Greek
banksmentionedTurkeyasoneoftheir
greatstrengthsgoingforward. Perhaps,
theyviewequityreturns,Chart12,as
indicativeoftheirloanrepayment
capacity.
CHART12 MORETHANBACK
Source:PSI;StockCharts
Page 12
Yet,wewouldliketopointoutthateachof
thesecountriesisintimatelyconnectedto
thedevelopedworld. Somearedirectly
respondentto
the
US
and
Europe,
others
aredependentupontheChinatrade. This
interconnectednesswillnotquickly
dissipate. Thestrengthofmany
developingmarketswasprecipitatedupon
theconsumptionoftheadvanced
economies. WithoutincreasingUSand
Euroconsumptionemergingmarketsare
vulnerabletodistress. Theconceptofde
coupling
is
a
nice
working
theory;
however,inpractice,itwillrequirea
periodofadjustment. Aretheseexuberant
economiesnowabletowalkalone? World
equitymarketsarepricedlikeits2007;yet,
muchhaschangedoverthepast3years.
-
8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010
13/21
THEPOSEIDONPERSPECTIVE 29July2010
Aswepondertheopportunitieswhich
maybefoundinforeignmarkets,wemust
becarefulnottooverlooktheincreased
risk. Wewouldliketoshareinsightsfrom
arecentpublication,Reflectionsonthe
SovereignDebtCrisisbyEdward
Chancellor,GMOWhitePaper,July2010.
InthiscommentaryChancellorprovidesa
succinctandcogentanalysisofthecurrent
turmoilinglobalsovereigndebt. Henotes
thatGreeceistheharbingerofasovereign
debtcrisisthatthreatenstoengulfseveral
leadingeconomies. Ingeneral,high
levelsofpublicdebtareassociatedwith
pooreconomic
growth
and
higher
rates
of
inflation. Chancellorenumeratesthe
severalfactorswhichhavehistoricallyled
togovernmentdefault.
1)Areversalofglobalcapitalflows.
Anyseriousdeclineinexportearnings
whichmayspringfrominterruptionof
tradeorfallincommoditypricesleadsto
vulnerability.
2)
Unwise
lending.
Bankingprosperityandlowinterestrates
usuallyresultinastretchforyield,larger
fees,andthedeteriorationoflending
standards. Hereportsthatnearly90%of
theforeignbondssoldinUnitedStatesin
1929subsequentlydefaulted.
3)Excessiveforeigndebts.
Thissituationindicateslowdomestic
savingsratesandresultsinhostilityto
foreignlenders.
When
debt
is
denominatedinaforeigncurrency,a
declineintherealvalueofhomecurrency
raisestheburdenofexternaldebt. Hence,
therepudiationofexternaldebtsisfar
morecommonthandomesticdefault.
4)Poorcredithistory.
Unlikedeepfinancialmarketsandsocio
economicstability,weakpolitical
institutions,pooreconomicgrowth,and
publiccorruptionhavebeenhallmarksof
futuredebtproblems. Thesefactors
becomeselfreinforcing,Since1800,Spain
andPortugalhavedefaulted,respectively,
onthirteenandfiveoccasions. Asaside
note,accordingtotheBISEurobanksat
theendof2009heldUS$193billionof
Greekdebt,US$240billionofPortuguese
debt,andUS$832billionofSpanishdebt.
5)Unproductivelending.
Whenborrowed
money
is
not
spent
wisely,theprofligacyprecipitates
revolutionarychangeingovernment
underminingpoliticalstability.
6)Rolloverrisk.
Sincemanysovereigndebtsareneverpaid
theyarerolledover. Termsand
durationoftherollproduceincreased
risk.
7)
Weak
revenues.
Historically,bankingcrisisinduce
prolongedperiodsofbelowaverage
economicgrowth. Theoutgrowthis
austeritymeasurewithlowerexpenditures
andlowertaxrevenues.
8)Risinginterestrates.
Higherdebtserviceisthespiraling
outcomefromperceivedexpectationof
increasedinflationordefaultrisk.
Especiallyharmful
to
short
term
issuance
ofdebt,risingratesmayquicklyleadto
sovereignbankruptcy.
Page 13
Inmanycasestheseconsequencesaredue
tocircumstanceswhichareoutsideofthe
directcontroloftheborrower,an
-
8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010
14/21
THEPOSEIDONPERSPECTIVE 29July2010
exogenousevent. Atthatpointthereisa
negativeconvergenceofbothabilitytopay
andwillingnesstopay. However,there
areseveraldenominatorswhichmay
precludedefaultasacountrystruggles
witharisingdebtburden.Theseinclude
debtthatisdomesticallyfinanced,high
levelsofdomesticsavings,asteady
growingeconomy,andgovernment
expenditureswhichcanbeeasilyor
rapidlydecreased. Thebasicremedyis
governmentcontrolthrougha
combinationoftaxhikesandtightcontrol
ofgovernmentspending. Thiswas
achievedby
Sweden,
Finland,
and
Canada
duringthe1990s. However,mostcasesof
governmentrecoveryfromonerousdebt
areduetostableregimesandexcellent
credithistory. Themoreimportantissueis
whenagovernmentprefersinflationto
default. Thishasbeenthemorelikelypath
forseveralemergingcountrieswherelarge
fiscaldeficitshavebeenpartofthe
problem.
However,
this
combating
of
deficitswithinflationwasastratagemof
theUSduringthe1970s. Whenfacedwith
intractablefiscalproblemsgovernments
tendtorevert,ifpossible,toinflation.
Chancellorsitesthefollowingreasons:
1) Inflationismoreconvenientthandefault.
Inflationisactuallycovertdefault.
However,toachievethisoutcomethe
governmentmust
have
central
bank
controlorbeinapositiontoforcethe
domesticbankstoacquireitsbonds.
Underafiatmoneysystem,inflationwillalwaysbepreferredtodefaultwhendomesticdebtspredominate.(Hisitalics)
2) Inflationresolvespoliticalconflicts.
Sinceserviceandresolutionof
unsustainabledebtdemandsatransferof
resources,usuallyfromtheproductiveand
poorerrealm,inflation,surreptitiously
resolvestheredistribution.
3) Avoidinginflationisalowpriority.Thisisfrequentlythecasewhenthetrade
offisinflationorunemployment. Thishas
alsobeenthecasewhencentralbankshave
beenfacedwithpotentialdeflationary
spiral. TheexamplesJapanandUSare
given.
4) Flameout.Thismaybetheonlyoptionwhenpublic
credithas
evaporated.
Often
accompaniedbycurrencycollapse,the
governmentisforcedtomonetizethedebt
sincetherearenowillingprovidersof
publicloans. Thiswasthecasewith
Argentinain2001andIndonesiain1997.
Page 14
Wheredoesthatleaveustoday?
Chancellornotesthatconcernsover
sovereign
default
since
the
Lehman
collapseextendfromIcelandtoDubaito
Hungaryandnowtheperipheryofthe
Eurozone. Thisisnotaproblemconfined
tosmallemergingeconomies. Heliststhe
followingcountriesandtheirgrossdebtas
percentageofGDP:Japan(227%),Greece
(133%),Italy(120%),Belgium(100%),US
(93%),France(84%),Portugal(87%),UK
(78%),andIreland(78%). Theamountof
thesedebts
is
not
cyclically
or
crisis
driven;
theyarestructuralandongoing. Making
mattersworseisthatthesefiguresdonot
includemanycontingentliabilitiessuchas
healthcareandpension(SocialSecurity)in
theUS. Theweaknessofthissovereign
creditstructureisthatinmanycasesthe
-
8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010
15/21
THEPOSEIDONPERSPECTIVE 29July2010
debtisheldbyforeignentities. Inthecase
oftheUSNearlyhalfofoutstandingUS
Treasuriesareheldabroad.
Chancellorfinisheswithseveral
observationsonthecurrentdebtconcerns
withahistoricalperspective. These
include:
1. Thiscrisisisdifferentbecausewhile
previousdefaultcycleshaveprimarily
engagedemergingeconomies,thiscycle
hasenvelopedtheadvancedeconomies.
Developingeconomieshavebeenrunning
surplusesandrecyclingthesefundsinto
developedmarket
debt.
Coincidently,
one
mustgivesomevaliditytotheJapanese
experiencewherethereseemstobeno
limittonationaldebtlevels. Inspiteof
deleveraging,inflationwillalsoremain
lowdespitezerointerestratesandthe
expansionofcentralbankbalancesheets.
However,Japansdebthasbeeninternally
fundedbyaveryhighdomesticsavings
rate
and
the
crisis
was
local
not
global.
Yet,nowweareinthemidstofaglobal
andmuchmorecomplexarenaofdebtand
derivativeswhichfarexceednational
incomes.
2. Whilethereareseriousproblems
involvingperipheralEuroeconomies,itis
unwisetoextrapolatetheGreek(and
others,Spain,Portugal,Italy,Ireland)
experiencetomorehighlydeveloped
economies.The
level
of
corruption
and
tax
evasionarehigh. Lendingwas
unproductive. Mostimportantly,thedebt
oftheseeconomiesisnotdenominatedin
localcurrencies. Thislastpointmeansthat
devaluationorinflationisnotavailable
solutionstothecurrentmorass.
3. TheUSisnotonthevergeofdefault.
Theauthornotesthatitisaseriousfallacy
toextrapolatecurrentconditionswellinto
thefuture. Conditionsaresuchthatlarge
industrialeconomiescancarrylargedebt
burdensastheyhaveattimesinthepast
andlowbondyieldsandminimalinflation
meansthatdebtservicingismanageable.
Also,theUSandUKhaverobustbanking
systemswhichcanabsorbvastamounts
ofgovernmentdebt. Finally,thedebtis
issuedintheirowncurrenciesandthe
governmentsmaintainstrictcontrolover
theircentralbanksandforeignexchanges.
4.Inflation
is
more
likely
than
default.
EventualinflationintheUS,UK,and
Japanwouldresolvebothprivatesector
andgovernmentliabilitiesinarelatively
painlessfashion. However,inboththese
countriesthecurrentpolicyofquantitative
easingandmonetizationofthedebtis
fraughtwithdanger. Historyrecords
thatallgreatinflationshaveoriginated
with
the
monetization
of
debt.
5. Thetippingpointcamerecentlyto
GreeceasmostpublicfinanceisaPonzi
scheme. Theimportanceofpublicfinance
iscredibilityinordertorollforwardthe
publicdebt. InthecaseofJapanthe
diminishingsavingsrateandaging
populationspellafuturecrisis. Withmuch
ofitsdebtofarelativelyshortterm,Japan
isstuckinadebttrap.
Page 15
Thus,havingsurvivedthefinancialcrisis
wehaveenteredtheprovinceof
uncertaintywheretheprobabilitiesof
gainsandlossescannotbedirectly
measured. Whateverroutegovernments
takeandtheglobaleconomytraverses,
-
8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010
16/21
THEPOSEIDONPERSPECTIVE 29July2010
Page 16
increasedglobalriskwilleventually
demandgreatercompensation. While
continuingdeflationasseeninJapanover
thepast20yearsisoneroute,this
staggeringlowgrowth,lowinterestmodel
isnottheonlypossiblefuture. Chancellor
concludesthatForotheroutcomes,long
datedgovernmentbondsofferalimited
upsidewithapotentiallyuncapped
downside. Asinvestors,suchasymmetric
payoffprofilesdontappealtous. Well
spoken,theydontappealtouseither!
Wemovefromthegeneraltotheparticular
aswe
look
at
aselection
of
Emerging
MarketBondFunds,onceagainusing
Morningstardata. ThereturnsinTableC
speakforthemselves. Substantial5year
gainswithintermittentvolatility. Asnoted
bytheirsalesloadparticipationin
severalofthesefundsisnotcheap.
However,wewouldliketoaddressthe
issueofrisk. Itisnotuncommonfora
countrytodefaultonlyonitslocal
currencydebtandnotitsexternaldebt
whichmaybepricedinUS$s. However,
theoppositecanalsoholdtrueas
Chancellorpointsout. Politiciansmay
defaultonforeigndebtwhile
maintaininglocaldebttoappeasetheir
constituency. Anotherriskisthehowthis
assetclassreactsinglobalturbulence. Its
sizeisrelativelysmallinrelationtoUS
debtmarkets. TheexamplesinTableC
carryasubstantialamountofthebonds
whichareratedBB,morelikeUShigh
yieldand
many
which
are
not
rated.
In
thecaseofMEDAX,19%ofcreditquality
isBBB/BBwithacoupon510%. Duration
rangesfrom4.76to6.13. However,when
pricedinlocalcurrencythegreatestriskin
emergingmarketgovernmentbonds
accordingtoJPMorganiscurrencyor
exchangerisk.
TABLE
C
EMERGING
MARKET
MUTUAL
BOND
FUNDS
FUND
1Year 3Year 5Year MornStar
Rating/AUM
Sales
Load
NationalBaseforTop6Holdings
2.TCWEMIncome
(TGINX)17.0% 13.5% 16.1% *****
$567
NA Brazil,Korea,Russia,Indonesia,
Mexico,Kazakhstan4.EatonVanceEM
Local(EEIAX)62.4% 12.7% 22.9% *****
$116
4.75% US,Turkey,Malaysia,Thailand,
Hungary,SouthAfrica6.FidelityNewMkts
Income(FNMIX)30.6% (8.30)% 7.58% ****
$3,414
NA Russia,US,Ivory,Coast,Mexico,
Argentina,Philippines10.MFSEMDebt
(MEDAX)28.9% (8.30)% 11.3% ***
$2,618
4.75% Russia,Argentina,Mexico,
Philippines,Turkey,China
23.
Goldman
Sachs
EMDebtA(GSDAX) 19.4%
(20.9)%
0.14%
***
$4774.50%
Russia,
Indonesia,
Turkey,
Kazakhstan,Philippines,Brazil*MorningstarTop25EmergingMarketBondFundsratedby3yearreturns;effective27July2010. Fundsarenumberedby
standinginthe25fundsevaluated;AUM,AssetsunderManagementinUS$million.
Finally,thereisthecostofmitigatingthese
risks. Currencyriskcanbehedgedand
marketriskcanbeoffsetwithCredit
DefaultSwapsbutwhatisthenet. US
Treasuriesarelowandthespreadstoother
creditshascontracted. Isthereanyfurther
-
8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010
17/21
THEPOSEIDONPERSPECTIVE 29July2010
caseexceptthedeflationfrightforfurther
ratedecline? Istheinvestoradequately
compensated? Wesensemuchmorerisk
thanthosecrowdingthesemarkets. How
doesonepricetheriskofdefaultwith
muchdiminishedfaithincreditrating
agencies? Onemustexercisegreatcare
andattentiontodetail,sothefund
managerbecomesthearbiterofrisk.
Whilecurrencyvolatilitywouldnormally
beseenasamajorriskwesupplyChart13
asthebasisforthequestionwhether
currencycanprovidesupport. Chart13
trackspricingfortheUS$overthepast
eightyears. Asbackgroundwehave
includedtwoofthebondfundsfromTable
C. Overaperiodoffiveyearsemerging
marketbondsflourishedastheUS$was
manageddownward. Theycrateredinthe
midstoftheUScreditcrisisandhavenow
surgedduringaperiodofextremeUS$
volatility.
.
CHART13CURRENCYSUPPORT
Source:
PSI;
StockCharts
Page 17
Emergingmarketsforbothequitiesand
sovereigndebthavelosttheauraofhigh
riskinvestmentsandarenowridingin
theslipstreamofthepricesurgeforall
riskyassets. Theyarenowpromotedasa
coreholdingformanyportfolios. There
areseveralreasonsforthismigration.
Decreasedriskaversion,diversification
withstronglyperceivedreturns,andETF
vehiclesasacheap,easymeansfor
-
8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010
18/21
THEPOSEIDONPERSPECTIVE 29July2010
implementationareafewexamples. Those
whoarebullishonemergingmarketspoint
tothelowallocationsamongpension
funds,individuals,andlargeinstitutionsin
theUS. Wearereticenttoinvestatthese
levelswhentheunknownsfarsurpassthe
expectedorpotentialreturns.
Whileimprovingcreditqualityandrecent
upgradeshavesupportedmarket
valuations,onemustalwaysremainaware
ofthefragilityofmanyofthesestill
emergingmarkets. Theunderlying
politicalregimesstillfaceseveresocio
economichurdles
which
include
ethnic
clashesinWesternChina,Maoistterrorism
inIndia,andweatherinducedcalamity
globally. Threeyearsagowhocouldhave
imaginedthatanenfeebledruralmob
fundedbyanexpatriaterenegadewould
createhavocandinsurrectioninaworld
classmegapolis,downtownBangkok. In
thatinstanceallwasresolvedwithout
economicchaosbutthismaynotalwaysbe
thecase. Whoknowshowthenarcowars
onthesouthernborderoftheUnitedStates
willplayoutforMexicanpoliticsandthe
overalleconomy? Thequestioniswhether
yieldsonemergingdebtcanremainlowin
thefaceofsovereignrisksinthedeveloped
nations. IfG7yieldsbegintoclimbthen
theyields
in
emerging
markets
will
have
to
climbevenfastertocompensateforother
risks.
CHART14 DEVALUATIONALLOWSRISINGASSETVALUES
Source:PSI;StockCharts
Page 18
-
8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010
19/21
THEPOSEIDONPERSPECTIVE 29July2010
PROVISIONING
Theinterpretationandimpactofmyriad
globaleventsareveryhardtodiscern
giventhemassiveamountsofinformation
and
data
available.
The
advent
of
computersimulationarraysand
econometricmegamodelssupportthe
searchforgreatercertainty. Yet,evenwith
theseaidsforcondensationandresolution
themixtureremainsopaque. Simple
measuresofriskareignoredinfavorof
aggressivetacticsandcomplexalgorithms
laboringforgreaterreturns. However,we
alwaysbeginwithafewfundamentalsfor
someguidance.
As
mentioned
above
currencyriskisamajorhurdle.
Movementsinthecurrencymarketsare
thetelltalesforsuddenanddramatic
economicchange. Chart14revealsthe
macroimpactofaUS$devaluationupon
financialassetsmeasuredbytheS&P500
andcommodities,representedbyoil,
WTIC. ForalmostadecadetheUS$has
beenmanageddownwardinsupportofUS
economicexpansion.
Thebalancingactcameapartin2008and
therisksgoingforwardareenormousand
hardtomeasure. Therefore,weremain
skepticalofstabilityintheemerging
markets. Therehasbeenglobal
exuberanceinequityandbondpricesfor
thepast16monthswithincreasing
volatility. Wefindthatfutureexpectations
aremisplacedinrecognitionofcurrency
andmarketrisks. RecoveriesintheUSand
globaleconomies
is
weakening.
We
believethatdefensivepositioningis
necessaryforsoundinvestmentdecisions.
Ourportfolioremainsfocusedoncash,
preciousmetals(goldandsilver),and
bondfundswithawelldiversified
positionspanningalowmidduration.
Wheninneedofarealitycheckfromtheemotivespeculationsandoverwhelming
disinformationcirculatingamidstthefinancialmedia,wefrequentlyturntoTheWriters
Almanacfordiversion. Thus,wewereintriguedwhenwereadoneoftheentriesforJuly
20,2010. Ratherthanparaphrase,wequoteinmajorpart,thepassagevoicedbyGarrison
Keillor:
Itwasonthisday[July20]in1875thatthelargestrecordedswarmoflocusts
inAmericanhistorydescendedupontheGreatPlains. Anestimated3.5trillion
locustsmadeuptheswarm. Itwasabout1,800mileslongand110mileswide,
rangingfromCanadadowntoTexas.
Swarmswould
occur
once
every
seven
to
12
years,
emerging
from
river
valleys
intheRockyMountainsandsweepingeastacrossmuchofthecountry.Thesizeofthe
swarmstendedtogrowwhentherewaslessrain,andin1873,theAmericanWest
begantogothroughoneofitsdriestperiodsonrecord.
Page 19
-
8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010
20/21
THEPOSEIDONPERSPECTIVE 29July2010
Page 20
LOCUSTSWARMINAFRICA,2009
Thelandwasstillrelativelydryonthisdayin
1875whenfarmersjusteastoftheRocky
Mountains
began
to
see
a
cloud
approaching
fromthewest.Somefarmersnoticedthe
distinctivecolorofthecloud,glintingaround
theedgeswherethelocustwingscaughtthe
lightofthesun.
Peopletherethatdaysaidthatthelocusts
descendedlikeadrivingsnowinwinter,
coveringeverythingintheirpath.Somepeople
describedthesoundoftheswarmlandingas
likethunderoratrain.Thelocustsblanketedthe
ground,nearly
afoot
deep.
Trees
bent
over
with
theweightoftheinsects,andlargetreelimbsSource:GoogleImages
brokeoffunderthepressure.
Theyatenearlyeverylivingpieceofvegetationintheirpath,aswellas
harnessesonhorses,thebarkoftrees,curtains,andclothinghungonlaundrylines.
Theygnawedonfencepostsandrailings,andtheyespeciallylovedthehandlesof
farmtools,whichwereleftbehindpolished,asifbyfinesandpaper.Somefarmers
triedtoscareawaythelocustsbyrunningintotheswarm,andtheyhadtheirclothes
eatenrightofftheirbodies.
Inthewakeoftheswarm,settlersonhalfamillionsquaremilesoftheWest
facedstarvation.Similarlocustswarmsoccurredinthefollowingyears,andfarmers
becamedesperate.Butbythemid1880s,therainshadreturned,andtheswarmsdied
down.Mostscientistspredictedthatthelocustswouldreturnwiththenextdrought.
Mysteriously,theydidnot.Withinafewdecadestheywerebelievedtobeextinct.
ThisisclearlyaBlackSwanorfattaileventinaccordancewithNassimNicholasTalebs
praiseworthyworkTheBlackSwan,TheImpactoftheHighlyImprobable. Fromthebook
welearn
that
aBlack
Swan
event
has
three
attributes:
it
is
an
outlier
as
it
lies
outside
the
realmofregularexpectations,itcarriesanextremeimpact,andhumannaturemakesus
concoctexplanationsforitsconcurrence,afterthefact,makingitexplainableand
predictable. Here,wedigressforamoment. Talebbringstolightmanyflashesofbrilliance.
OneistheludicfallacywhichTalebdefinesasthinkingthattheattributesofthe
uncertaintywefaceinreallifehavelittleconnectiontothesterilizedonesweencounterin
examsandgames. Weinterpretthisinthecontextofcomputermodelsandmarketactivity.
-
8/9/2019 7.0 Poseidon Perspective July 2010
21/21
THEPOSEIDONPERSPECTIVE 29July2010
Thebestlaidschemesandexpectationsfrequentlyrunafouloftherealitiesofcomplex
humaninteractions. Manytradingpairs,correlativeparadigms,andderivativecurrency
overlaysfailwhentherubbermeetstheroad.
So,whatsthepoint? First,truthisstrangerthanfictionandonceananomalyhaspresented
itselfitcanhappenoverandoverinashortperiodoftime. ArecentcaseisthefallofBear
Stearns,thenLehman,WashingtonMutual,CountrywideFinancial,andthecontinuing
dominoesofsmallbanksbeingclosedweeklybytheFDIC. Nobodyknowstheendpoint.
Next,beinginthewrongplaceorwronginvestmentatthewrongtimecanbedevastating.
TowitinvestinginCitigroupat$51inDecember2006,buyingrealestateSEAsiain1997,or
Russiandebtin1998. Financialstocksaremuchmoreriskythaniswidelyknownor
acknowledged. Ifnotforgovernmentbailoutsandtaxpayersubsidiesmanyfinancial
institutionswouldnotexist. Thisistruertodaythaneverbefore. Thebalancesheetsof
financialinstitutionsincludingtheFederalReserveareholdingtanksforseverelydamaged
andtoxic
securities.
Lastly,
financial
and
econometric
models
are
complex
illusions
premised
uponunwieldyassumptionsoflackingemotions. Donotacceptlightlyanyones
prognosticationforthefuture. Thefutureisasecret. Manypeoplerefusetoacknowledge
thatmostoutstandingaccomplishmentsareduetogoodluckortakingoutsizedrisks.
Sincereregards,
BrianE.Shean,CFAPRINCIPAL
POSEIDONSTRATEGICINVESTMENTS
_________________________________________________________________________________
Theviewsexpressedinthiscommentaryarethoseoftheauthoratthetimeofcomposition. Theassumptions,analysis,and
conclusionsaresubjecttochangeinconjunctionwithchangesinthesecuritiesmarketsordiscoveryofadditionalor
conflictinginformation. Allinformationconveyedhereinhasbeendeduced,compiledorquantifiedfromsourcesthoughtto
beconsistentlyreliable. Thisinformationalreportisproducedforgeneralcirculationandisnottobeconstruedasa
solicitationtobuyorsellsecurities,financialinstruments,orinvestmentproducts. Priortoenteringanytransactionsfor
investmentproductspleaseconsultacompetentfinancialadviserandundertakeproperduediligence. AMDG