3-Dimensional Modeling to Support the Short North Historic District Design Guidelines

26
3-Dimensional Modeling 3-Dimensional Modeling to Support the to Support the Short North Design Short North Design Guidelines Guidelines Midterm Presentation Midterm Presentation Duane Hoskins| Scott Ulrich| Krystina Schaefer Duane Hoskins| Scott Ulrich| Krystina Schaefer The Ohio State University Department of City and Regional Planning The Ohio State University Department of City and Regional Planning April 29, 2010 April 29, 2010

description

This presentation was prepared for a studio class in The Ohio State University's City & Regional Planning program. The class coordinated with the City of Columbus Planning Division staff to conduct extensive research that formed the basis for new design guidelines for the Short North Arts District in Columbus, Ohio.

Transcript of 3-Dimensional Modeling to Support the Short North Historic District Design Guidelines

Page 1: 3-Dimensional Modeling to Support the Short North Historic District Design Guidelines

3-Dimensional Modeling to 3-Dimensional Modeling to Support the Support the

Short North Design GuidelinesShort North Design GuidelinesMidterm PresentationMidterm Presentation

Duane Hoskins| Scott Ulrich| Krystina SchaeferDuane Hoskins| Scott Ulrich| Krystina SchaeferThe Ohio State University Department of City and Regional PlanningThe Ohio State University Department of City and Regional Planning

April 29, 2010April 29, 2010

Page 2: 3-Dimensional Modeling to Support the Short North Historic District Design Guidelines

Objective

• Develop a 3-D computerized model of the study area using Google Sketch-Up– analyze existing building massing and height transitions

• Use the model as an analysis tool– Understand and visualize potential impacts of future

development patterns

Page 3: 3-Dimensional Modeling to Support the Short North Historic District Design Guidelines

Model Development

• Use existing City of Columbus (GIS and AutoCAD data) of building footprints combined with data obtained from the Franklin County Auditor to create simple massing of existing buildings

• Add façade details and ornamentation to the masses • Put the completed model into Google Earth to understand

the the study area given the context of the surroundings

Page 4: 3-Dimensional Modeling to Support the Short North Historic District Design Guidelines

Current Conditions | Overview

Page 5: 3-Dimensional Modeling to Support the Short North Historic District Design Guidelines

Current Conditions | Overview

• Some long, complete historic blocks• Also a few smaller historic clusters• Isolated extremes, big & small• Suburban-style, strip-style retail• Bulky newer development

Page 6: 3-Dimensional Modeling to Support the Short North Historic District Design Guidelines

Long, complete historic blocks

Page 7: 3-Dimensional Modeling to Support the Short North Historic District Design Guidelines

Smaller historic clusters

Page 8: 3-Dimensional Modeling to Support the Short North Historic District Design Guidelines

Isolated extremes – big & small

Page 9: 3-Dimensional Modeling to Support the Short North Historic District Design Guidelines

Suburban-style, strip-style retail

Page 10: 3-Dimensional Modeling to Support the Short North Historic District Design Guidelines

Bulkier newer development

Page 11: 3-Dimensional Modeling to Support the Short North Historic District Design Guidelines

Next Steps

• Compare building heights to identify inconsistencies and buildings which are incompatible with the Short North design aesthetic

• Visualize development potential for selected sites

Page 12: 3-Dimensional Modeling to Support the Short North Historic District Design Guidelines

Short North Arts DistrictShort North Arts District

SketchUp Group - Final PresentationSketchUp Group - Final Presentation

Duane Hoskins| Krystina Schaefer| Scott UlrichDuane Hoskins| Krystina Schaefer| Scott UlrichThe Ohio State University Department of City and Regional PlanningThe Ohio State University Department of City and Regional Planning

May 25, 2010May 25, 2010

Page 13: 3-Dimensional Modeling to Support the Short North Historic District Design Guidelines

The Process

• 5 sites selected based on:– Low FAR– Surface Parking Lots– Large Setbacks

• Design considerations:– Parking Requirements– No Setbacks– Limit High Street Ingress

1

23

45

Page 14: 3-Dimensional Modeling to Support the Short North Historic District Design Guidelines

Redevelopment SitesRedevelopment Sites

Page 15: 3-Dimensional Modeling to Support the Short North Historic District Design Guidelines

Proposed Redevelopment Sites

1

23

45

1. United Dairy Farmers2. Shopping Center

Page 16: 3-Dimensional Modeling to Support the Short North Historic District Design Guidelines

High & PriceExisting

Site: 6 Parcels - Approx 70,000 ft2

1 Building – 11,570 ft2

FAR = 0.17

Page 17: 3-Dimensional Modeling to Support the Short North Historic District Design Guidelines
Page 18: 3-Dimensional Modeling to Support the Short North Historic District Design Guidelines
Page 19: 3-Dimensional Modeling to Support the Short North Historic District Design Guidelines

High & PriceRedevelopment Site

Redevelopment Plans:

Mixed Use – 6 Stories – 138,000 ft2

Residential – 2nd & 3rd Stories – 15,450 ft2

Public Plaza – 3,700 ft2

Parking Garage – 3 Stories – 66,760 ft2

Parking Required - 158 SpacesParking Provided - 204 Spaces

FAR=2.20 (not including parking garage)FAR=3.15 (including parking garage)

Page 20: 3-Dimensional Modeling to Support the Short North Historic District Design Guidelines

High & PriceRedevelopment Site

Page 21: 3-Dimensional Modeling to Support the Short North Historic District Design Guidelines

High & PriceRedevelopment Site

Page 22: 3-Dimensional Modeling to Support the Short North Historic District Design Guidelines

IBIZA - Existing

Page 23: 3-Dimensional Modeling to Support the Short North Historic District Design Guidelines

IBIZA – Proposed

11-story mixed use

Residential over retail

Buried parking garage

Page 24: 3-Dimensional Modeling to Support the Short North Historic District Design Guidelines

Looking North on High from Hubbard

Before & After

Page 25: 3-Dimensional Modeling to Support the Short North Historic District Design Guidelines
Page 26: 3-Dimensional Modeling to Support the Short North Historic District Design Guidelines

DiscussionDiscussion

Questions | Thank YouQuestions | Thank You