3. Dialogues of Plato - Charmides, Or Temperance

8/13/2019 3. Dialogues of Plato - Charmides, Or Temperance

1/29

!"#$%&'()* ,$ -(%.($#/!(

01 .2345

678 9!4:3; 01 9=;?3@A; B5C=44

/=C D5:E* !F )G:A0;=:H< )5;=:7>? 3+.%@-,$&?

3+.$%$#+'(? 3%-*-.&A &B;= 7D *=E>;=94 568B6 89

:6; #7>B6 7D :6; F8B67I=J ;K;7L :6; =>LJ =: #7:8I=;=4 =


2/29

M;=E:8;94 &7B>=:;94 6; 9=8I4 - D=L = PEIGL; :679; 567 =>; PE9: ;8; :6; =IK=I 7D :6; G>;=: M;=E:J4 =9 6; 89 :67EG6: :7 M;4 7D :6; I=J4 =L8I;94 6; >;OC8;I4 89 689 N=MC; ;K;< :6; =8:8=9A

*6;; 5; 9;; 689 M7IJ4 967ECI 5;


4/29

=BB7LO=L4 =97< 57ECI >;O;=: :6; B6=>L =:

:6; 9=L; :8L; :6=: 6; E9;I :6; BE>;4 6; 57ECI M; L=I; 567C;? ME:

:6=: 58:67E: :6; B6=>L :6; C;=D 57ECI M; 7D 8:; 7E: :6; B6=>L D>7L J7E> I8B:=:87 :6; B6=>L

58CC I7 L7>;4 36=>L8I;94 :6=< 7; :6; 6;=I=B6;A - I=>; 9=J

:6=: J7E 6=K; 6;=>I ;L8;I L;4 =;;9 :7 >;G=8K8LJ

D>7L 7:=C8:JA *689 *6>=B8= :6; 6;=I 58:67E: :6; M7IJ4 97 7EG6: J7E :7 =::;LO: :7

BE>; :6; M7IJ 58:67E: :6; 97EC? =;=97< 56J

:6; BE>; 7D L=


5/29

=CC G77I = 8< :6; M7IJ 7> 8< 6EL=< ;4 7>8G8;I4 8< :6; 97EC4 =DC759 D>7L :6;7L :6;

6;=I 8; 8D :6; 6;=I =; :7 M; 5;CC4

J7E LE9: M;G8< MJ BE>89: :68 J7E:64 6=9 :7 M; ;DD;B:;I MJ :6; E9; 7D B;>:=8L94 =L9 =>; D=8> 57>I9? ==:;I4 LA )7> :6894^ 6; 9=8I4 ^89 :6; G>;=: ;>>7> 7D 7E> I=J 8< :6;

:>;=:L;7L

:6; M7IJA^ .I94 ^/;: 8B64 7> D=8>4

O;>9E=I; J7E :7 G8K; 68L :6; BE>;4 58:67E: :6; B6=>LA^ (75 - 6=K;

957>=B8=< B6=>L D8>9: :7 J7E> 97EC4 =9 :6; 9:>=

I8>;B:;I4 - 58CC =D:;>5=>I9 O>7B;;I :7 =OOCJ :6; BE>; :7 J7E> 6;=IA

ZE: 8D 8:8=94 56;< 6; 6;=>I :6894 9=8I2 *6; 6;=I=B6; 58CC M; =;OE:;I :7 6=K; D7E98= =: :6; B7E>: 7D :6; G>;=: N8 7< :6; B7


6/29

=>; 56=: 3>8:8=9 I;BC=>;9 J7E :7 M;4 :6; 36=>L8I;94 MC;99;I =>:

:67E4 8< M;8A .; C8;9 :6; O78 8D4

=9 6; I;BC=>;94 J7E 6=K; :689 G8D: 7D :;LO;>=;=IJ4 =;

:;LO;>=:; ;89 :6; +JO;>M7>;=; - G8K; J7E :6; L;I8B8;D7>;4 :7 8L L; 56;:6;> J7E =IL8: :6; :>E:6 7D 56=:

3>8:8=9 6=9 M;;< 9=J8 6=K; J7E =L8I;9 MCE96;I4 == ; 89


7/29

WE8;:CJ4 9EB6 :68 ;Q=LOC; =9 5=CN8;;:94 =; :6; :;LO;>=:;? ME: C;: E9 9;; 56;:6;> :6;9; 57>I9 6=K;= 9C75CJS

eE8BNCJ =G=8;9:C8O;

D=> M;::;> :6=< WE8;:


8/29

.TD=B8C8:J 8< C;=>


9/29

;K;< 8D 5; G>==


10/29

*6=: =OO;=>9 :7 L; :7 M; =9 J7E 9=JA

. 97L; O68C797O6;> 6=9

:7CI J7EA

&7L; 7 B;>:=8L8I;94 D>7L 567L - 6;=>I :689S

(7 L=::;> =: =CC4 - >;OC8;I? D7> :6; O78 :6;J =>; :>E; 7> ; J7E =>; 8< :6; >8G6:4 &7B>=:;94 6; >;OC8;IA

*7 M; 9E>;4 - 9=8I? J;: - I7EM: 56;:6;> 5; 96=CC ;K;> M; =MC; :7

I89B7K;> :6;8> :>E:6 7> D=C9;677I? D7> :6;J =>; = N88IIC;A

Y6=: L=N;9 J7E :68;I :6;L 9;;L9 :7 L; :7 6=K; L;=I;I =9

I788:;9S

- 967ECI >=:6;> :68;=I4 7> :;=B6 J7E M7J9 :7 5>8:; 7>

>;=I4 J7E> 75< 8:; J7E> ;8;


11/29

=CJ B7L; E

:6; 6;=I 7D I78:=8J L=< :7 5;=K; =


12/29

9:8> 68L EOA +; 5;;5 =J4 =;I4 =9 - :67EG6:4 8;C 58:6 68L? PE9: =9 = O7;: L8G6: WE=>>;C 58:6 =< =B:7> 567

9O78C;I 689 O7;L9 8< >;O;=:8I =: 68L = 7D :689 I;D8=


13/29

I788M8; 5=9 =B; 8< :6;LTD7> ;Q=LOC;4 8< :6; L=; 7D

967;94 7> 8< 9;CC8 98::8 68>; 8< = 67E9; 7D

8CCTD=L;S *6=:4 &7B>=:;94 89


14/29

- 6=K; :8BEC=> I>8D:4 ME: - 5896 :6=: J7E 57ECI :;CC L;

56;:6;> = O6J98B8=< 567 BE>;9 = O=:8;


15/29

=II;I ^(;K;> :77 LEB64^ 7>4 ^08K; = OC;IG;4 =


16/29

9=8I4 56=: >;9EC: 89 :6;>; 7D B7LOE:=:87< 7> G;7L;:>J4 8< :6; 9=L;

9;;9EC: 7D ME8CI8 = G=>L;N 7D = =>:S 3=< J7E 9675 L; =;9EC: 7D

:6;LS H7E B=;C=:87


17/29

- :68; >8G6:4 6; >;OC8;I? =


18/29

-< 9EB6 B=9;9 =9 :6892 &EOO79; :6=: :6;>; 89 = N8 :=N; =CC :6; 9; 57ECI J7E 9=J :6=: :6;>; 89 = C7K; 568B6 89 7D =< 7O8


19/29

H;94 :6=: 89 56=: 89 =DD8>L;IA

ZE: 675 9:>=A

H7E =>; WE8:; >8G6:A

Y;CC :6;;=: :68 :6=< :679; :68897< 7D 568B6 :6; 7:6;>9 =>; G>;=:;>4 :6;< :6=: :687O;>:J 7D M;8;=:;> ==:;94 6; 9=8I4 89 :6; 8


20/29

B7C7E>4 D7> 98G6: B=N4 3>8:8=94 :6=: 8< 9;K;>=C 7D :6; ;Q=LOC;9 568B6 6=K;

M;;< >;B8:;I :6; ;C=:87< :7 9;CD 89 =C:7G;:6;>8ICJ B>;I8MC;T8

;Q=LOC;4 8< :6; B=9; 7D L=GE;A

ZE: 8< :6; B=9; 7D 6;=>8 7D

9;CDTL7:87;C=:87< :7 9;CD 58CC

M; >;G=>I;I =9 8;I8MC; MJ 97L;4 ME: O;>6=O9 9A .;=: L=8;L8

E94 56;:6;> :6;>; 89 ;C=:87< :7 9;CD4 7> 97L; :68 7D I;:;>L8 :6;>; 89 9EB6 = 9B8;


21/29


22/29

N


23/29

.


24/29

:679; 567 =>; E E9? =


25/29

L= 9;K;>=CCJ I78


26/29

ZE: 7D 56=: 89 :689 N 8< 577C4 7> 577I4 7> =


27/29

.


28/29

6=K; PE9: 8ME:8:A

\;>J :>E;A

+75 :6;< B=< 589I7L M; =IK=


29/29

=9 - =L B78:8=9? 8D J7E I7 :689 - 96=CC 6=K; =

O>77D 7D J7E> :;LO;>=9;CD :7 M; B6=>L;I

MJ &7B>=:;94 =: 68L =: =CCA

H7E L=J I;O;7; J7E 6=I M;::;> B7 5;CCA

ZE: :6; :8L; D7> B7=:87< 6=9 O=99;I4 - 9=8I4 56;< K87C;L8

3. Dialogues of Plato - Charmides, Or Temperance

Documents

Transcript of 3. Dialogues of Plato - Charmides, Or Temperance