1993, 11-05-93, Correa’s Memorandum Law Support Downward Departure Sentencing.pdf

8/9/2019 1993, 11-05-93, Correa’s Memorandum Law Support Downward Departure Sentencing.pdf

1/15

t ion ,

Co

• • rul

accolllpU.h

00\ln801,

(198R),

a t

t

19At log

rocOIQmondGd

h . ; r

yonto

takon

in to

acco\ant

....

_ _ 1 ~ _ ~

aublllto

tha t .ft

,holf yoon.

long ter'" t rot tbumt

in.toneD.

1

~

,1

I

IN 'iUB CIRCUIT

CO\IRT

rOR

T1Ui nl).-TIt

J\lUICSk.l. CUtCtlJ1'

,

OF

rt,ORIOA,:IIH

AltD

ron l I N J . l . l . M ~

C'O\lltT\' ,

!

J

!'

,

8 T ~ f \

OF

, (pnIOA

\

V.

'j

)

DENNIS b. COHR .A

'

2

(\

'/ 3 3

'/1

u _ . . . . __

/

, ~

,:.

. . ,\

I)

. '

OIlIlfPNft

..

llIlQUL.O" . Q U I ~ .•. JlIKQ .UUlt ,

.,

:

or. . . . u . _ . u L 8 U Q B . . t ~ _ Q . I . . A J ) . O l n M O .PI " ..I,V" " , t ~ : U

l1L'.I1ttAOla ! ,"

t>J

~ §

•

1 .

t r ro b

Y

dubJlitd t lh'o l u ~ ' ( ) l ' n n ( h l J l fo r thp

( : o U n . 9 ~

' f l C 0 1 0

in O ( l n n o e ~ l l o n with gUnhHl( ; ' I ' IQ. In f \ n ~ t h t : l l : U w ~ of tho

lJQ,ltlA unclet'lV"

I

1n9

tho s ~ ~ t C \ n c i n q

G u i d g l 1 , , ~ n .

,. 9;2)

. 0 0 \

, , ~ ( ~ . • r lo r lc13 O t . n t \ ) t , ~ 9

:1

if'

l\J>proprint-:)A

to l.n(or_ t h l d

C O \ l t t i p f tha.

t . ) ( ' , ~ t ~ f W ~

or

1

"

factors "'h 1\,h

"'"

( fIImt. " c l o v , , , , ~ 1',l1.dQ",,lt ft. u

q

f n ) ~

oontono Inq t ; l \ n f J ~

of

fO\J;

I\hd ( ) n q ~ h t ~ 1

f· \

n f I , , : 8 t i ~ l H H ~ ;

I n c n t ~ o < n t

l ~ l .

'

0

I

t I nU

nq r

l't

0

vII

\ ell

' ' ' ' 0 '

Tllo \KI

l n c l n < 1 ~

Hr.

C o r r ~ 3 ' O

nlHtnAbSllly

to

n ~ I H . b l l t A

tho

,oubnt.nntlnliilkftlU10«)

t.hAl n ~ h l 1 ~ l l ) J ~ t : A \ . O \

lll

b ~ A \ J C

~ n d t h ~ dCJtoncJat\t'

II

qctnutuq

l'Q1IIIOtit ...

i1J\'1

GtrQf lg l. lIHi

1

1'0 , 'U)

"

comploto' ....uU, l tut ton.

p ~ r l o d p r 'ncate'OfAllon or

no ~ ( l t 9 tho\ t \ tvo And O f \ ~

rol lovod lIoY l'rolXlllon vl th 'M ••Ielf ' \>rovloh,n fo,'

nnd v h ~ t h .

l ' e l iUtut 'on l J 1 ~ p { J t ( } I ; r l - 4 t 9 I J f 1 thlli

R· I

MoraovQr,

any

l I o n t ~ n l J C t

In

e;cctutlj , (

t . h ~

loY

f ind

t

th.·

.

:

.

I

I

-

'l

~

(.

.

r

I

)

If


2/15


3/15

8 l q n i f l c n n t ~ n d t h ~ I n p p \ l t h.'

r n l p

' h \A .. ~ h ~ l q 1 \ ( \ l l .Qf f 'H · t .

Ray 0 1(t

A '

..

ti

A \J

Jl

Q \

A

:t t t ( 1\ (J


4/15

,

.

.

. .

. ~

1)

hovoxor. hOJll""" to

d c w ( ) t , ~ "

P\ll\ l l tAnt\Al

~ t . r t

lm,j"f

hi

l f l \ ~ N I . ~

to

•

•

·

.,

Y

lo t1 .

raot

Wtl\Jt ion.

j

j

noc ,aui, t · h ~ C(l\srl

v , \:)

hc:Ji\1 r

r n t

hC' n \ I l ~ O \ , j ~ l 'v

i

c l \ J ~ )

f j

V)l l '

, f t )

,I

.-

wlllh

to

nJ\Ct1tk

on

HI',

( ( \ I ~ ~ A P

l p h ~ \ f

; \ t

'ho

t'

r

q ~ t \ t .

C : S ( ~

t \ ~ J

•

i

r

u r

t h

tH' .@

1n

bo

I'

\ t 1

()

1\ 1

n

t 0 ;l h cs 1\" t \J

I'

;H\CI

I'

Ii ( 1'''( \{ \f )4 r . (


5/15

. f

..

,

f'

' ~ H l \ i l t e d

1989,);

of

,

•

'I

.

n

\}

..

•

·r

1 r n L . G . \ l 1 . d . e l 1 . n ~ D J , '

~ { \ .

n.II, 1'1.

r,)

I r 1A .

\1I1II . t

.

,

t ho 9 U l d a l 1 r ~ ' H ~ not \ n t t ~ I H ~ d h ' ~ l . l n ' n ~ \ o ullc:, '

A I

, t l ~ H ' r p . t . h H ' in

!

thG

. on tone

h c J .

prOCCHHI ,

~ O I \ ( J

U\O

A l l o c ' , n C A )

p . . l \ U t ~ i ~ t p . i l

" ..

' t H ~

.1

I P

plaa

Of:'hOdldt'

in

the

q i d ~ l \ ~ p

'9

tho

tone t t h A ?

. I

. Wh\ It'}

'hf t

9 ~ m t a ~ \ f \ c l (J\)\dollncHl At P < 1 c : ~ I . . J I \ P < \.'

t I t ' f )

u , , ~ ' \ l C ' ( ' ~ ,,, thn R Q t q , h c ~ n c J

i ) ~ ~ l A l n

~ t \ i J ~ t p ~ ,

, t

' U ~ h l l c J

° t o

\ l f p

' d \ c ' ~ l c J \ ~ c .. lon,

c 1 0 J ' A r t \ t l ' e ~

ftl

l th J H ' p . ~

numpt.l VC rumtC?'nc;o9 t.: h 1

'f:iholl \

f\ t h ~

lJ\I

l ( l ~ I

(-

. ( , ) ~

p h ~ )

1 bp

I\rtlr:u13t.fSl1 In ''' .. I t

\nQ

nil "0)(1,,s v h ~ f ' f H ' ~ ~ . ~ ' ~ t H . , ~ r a

Of'

f

M:tofn r p . l I o n ~ h l y ' \ lAt \ r.,. t A C ~ I J l . · : : \ t ' \)lJ: ta

I

t ' q A t ' oh

r

or

tha Au"te nco.

Thp. I (,)VI;t 1

Jlrl W r n , , 1 I ~ I H 1 Q ; \ ) '

t o ,",pt Ah

1hah B

d f t p l \ r t \ l r ~ fro:)

A

~ ~ n t . ' m l · O Im( )PI t h ~ (J\ l h l ~ \ ll\p[t \

• preponderanoe or

the

eVldenae. "

Rula ) . ' 101011) ( ) , n , n , l . r \ ~ . l · . ~ thQ 1 1 \ J \ f ' p l l l \ a A ~ l , p ( ' H i l : \ l l r

l 'l 'Q

vido for

d g ~ n r t u n ~

'hnll thar; , ~ n d ~ t ' · l r n m q t . t H ~ ~

01' f ; \C\ ' I 'R

th,H

rOlUlon;\hly

!

\1\1£1t l r y MJ

'

fl ·

...

'"

HJ ..". I \ \ t

l ~ t

''''J

t h a

PQl\tOtll 'O" r ia:

" .

R,

Cr hL I ' . ,

1

• 101 (cl)

( \ \

).

I '

t

' d t . h o \ l c ~ h t h ~ '

f ..

: \ n e n ~ : o f ' h ~


6/15

. . . ---- ....., .. _ _ ~ . - - - - ~ - - - ~ - -

etl

1

{:

c

'AU \ 1;\ ( '

II

n t

IS

'* «(') (\))

'\

(190"0

AIlU'uH\l 'pntn).

;:

I t 1" ~ 1n"t. to.h \ A r l ~ i D a V ( ) ~ t , h ~ l t r 1{,,, if'tA ~ . ~ ( I r

9

h ~ \ : ~

I"., e;t ' \

I

g r n l ~ p

1 i nCJ

t , ~ ) (1\1 r i t

he)

r t \ r t ~

t

..

P (l r

.,

l

tone 1

nq

.

f lop

Sta le .

v. 1 1 1 ~ h . l e . l : . .. A 11 r:n. ;,,,, ~ , ; ,


7/15

\i

I

"

eJ

t o .

rQhAhl

1 Hl\ t jann the:

r r ~ ~ \ t C ' ' ' t \ Y ~ ( . ~ H C d

'hH'lt*'on.

O'.r,tln

.....

Y_"

..•s.tate, ~ ( ) b

lo.

1d

n (r lol'. 1

t;J9

0).

tn.

Itt1,\,n. \. r ' ; \ )

1\ldqo d ~ p ..

\ l" t"d (rol S the: (U'C'AUftpt tv, .

9csi ,tp ' \ l" ' \ fJ ~ : ~ J P .,r P . t V € \ ~

throQ

"nd

01'\ 'n-h31f

;\",1

ro'lIr

"""I

o t l p -h" l r YP:\IP

,U" ' ; \ f ' ·P tOll t . lo ' l

;\n{\

,

one yonr

of

lia'ol'nt lnn, C1HnlJ

n i l t ~ e l a

V. Glate,

t',(),; rhl.;>(}

.. \ (rln.

,i 1••"

. I J

987) , ' t ho ~ r l \

' \Il! ' lP

A t ~ \ P f a { l P c I l I P t ' r i " ' h

ro'P

1 \ : \ " I r ~ . j t. y t e' t'"

P n

t n..,,,t

)

i

no

avldanc4:


8/15

4

l l lal

ant1. t.llt .

tll'

"itt

eij

{i

•

dopa.ft\,ro

l n

' ) '

t

hOlla

eft O ~ 1.' wh i eh t-h4'1' l A

1\

' t ll '3 tI _ J\p f \ t . \

I t , ~

'- l ~

tho crimI'

\ 'COlSJ:l

it t

. Jn

) « H ~ . l \

I\


9/15

.

.

.} :

•

~ l ·

criminal

n,t

hy

hlR

cnnt· Il \uo, ' { ~ ) = - l t

f t l ~ ~

' f '

t h G ~ P Y t . h l ~ O t l h t h ~ l ' l 'pgt·tnt ( , : \ ~ .

t iPP ,,1 "( ' rl aBtel.

t

1 (\ ) (1

At

.

574 ( d C l r ( l r H ~ ~ l t · vo l\1nt , ; ~ , Ia

\1 h'tl \

p g

1

(\Il

h \ , ' \ l l l l l p p, fl 'J

pr

1,'1r

9 ~ f ·

tanc lnq .,,,.Ii

w, \1 lnclnnAn i,n I \ ~ r t c 5 \ ~ t 1 n t

r : t ' l

n.".,t f ~ \ J r ~ n ~ f · p

t-

COt'

:

4)

n ..

1 1

n t. t p p t t n h I q

('

0 J ' n \ t n p r, t t , " II t I 1\ \I jl tIP ,t

p.1\

t

f' 1\

f :)

R

1

0

n

q

nu

np

C CUl :\ r )'

t

0 I'll"<

. oJ" l '

1 ,

h (.

(\ 'tIl\ 1

t

a f' P h

~

l' I

t :\

t I tH '

" t

hO\HJh t

hn

t

1

(11'

l l t : l i l lPI nna ( 'O l l l

t j'.I

pa ..

I f \ .'

~ i ~ ~ , te t

p,

13

lilac) t iM, .

o Xptn ' t

t c:)Sl t \

\IIOIlY

lla f lO

t

,\ n e

P

f : l lQ" I )

t

1Q

\I

.'lH', t ( l l ~ I ,

..

,) f Ol n' a 1\:\ ' \ ill·

t

Y

tor

h

n

b I

1

I t

:\

tin

n.

II

e

r

1

1:11.

(,

n

( ) . ;

I I

:\

t

t

'p

C

')

r t

p

f \n

t

r a 1y 0 )( C 1 \IT l

v

pI}' 0

n

HI . () I r Q I'l • R t:t c:>l r ·

'.I

o I v \ I\IJ t t;'pI e P .,. n t It t jon p , "

nn 0)(

t

ft

nd #

p

g r 1()(1 C) r t 1na I i

I"

:\ 1,

1\

1· ., 11 1I )) ' v \ 1 1 .. ,

P

R

t t f ) t h «3 , 1 f @.., ..

. 1

,

J'

l

thn

t

rgh

h.\

1

1 t.

A

\btl c:., n l ~ . f t rl 1\111)

I \

h : " v \

t

h l" t l

r'l

. I mac-I' t

h·

.. .

VY :

0 .

Raynoldn

wl11 t g l l t.hg Cc'\llJlrt . h ~ t Hr. C·O . . . .

D ; l

lQ ~ \ n t ( ' tnl , c ~ l * H · h H \ C - ·

f·

, .

• I i

1

nq

roact

I

c)@llt:ClPfq

o f

c

1 \

n

I

COl

I

Q

J

I

r

~ r \ ( · e .

1'\lt.

t

hI:?


10/15

.,

'

..

.

1uotlfy

ml, ,1Ql\t . l ()n

o f A P , ~ t Q n c p

v l \ ~ t \ ( ( ' \ a r ~ l p c ' vltt, anc t \ 3h l l l t ' v .i'

,

r . h l l b l 1 1 t ~ t ~ o n . 5.nlth v. : ' ~ _ l a ~ e , 0;1) In . •h1

o;n

( r l4 i .

'.1

( ' .eA. '·.HUq: ·

s . t . a ~ o ....Y_t. ,1)(e1Yes. H , 1 h l . } : ~ l • 1 1.1

( l ,

C , A I

'.11' I;

·(1

r.

le

r l . h'"

Y . . . . _ A . l ~ ~ . ~ l l e . t . ")')

\

: ~ o . J< \


11/15

__

-

..

. -. . ..

__ r ....

• It . ·

.

It

d ~ , D t r l c t ~ ~ O \ . r t ( . ) l ) o r v , , ( ' ~ t l \ l \ t the) ~ V ' t ' O f \ ( i ( ~ ~ ' ' ' C 4 : t 1 tl'"'J - t . h ~ ~ 1 ~ f O t l 1 1 \ l · p

UiO'i


12/15

•

~ .-_. ".: ..-_._-:-._-----_.

__

.•.. _ _ _ _ ~

,

,

.

Ii

c r

1.1 3 1 ellA ·C}Q f ( l ~ '

'1,,1

eh Ill'

n9

;

.- :.

"

8ucca

• •

'u l i '\

h i d gffo t th to A(1c'oi.qllllj})

t o h ~ l ) l ~ : ·

'.101i

18 ' , l l i j s t : r t t ~

.... ,.

:'. -.'

='t

• • r

.

@d by hiD, (IOnulno

r c u ~ o r . e

A",ft by Ills' Alt


13/15

't.

.:

l

• V

f

.

. by tho

dafCHHH1

w(.l\lhl, at.;· ~ ~ l , l l t:\l ) ' ancl, At ' 'nAt

e \ ) . ~ ~ t ..

nt . n \ '

hn.po I ' ,

t

ha u l t , n:\\ Q I J o ~ : l c\ f

r

CSh3

h t 1I t .

t

'I'''.

'f)

WH t:1U: rotH:.;.

I lJ \d ,

r \ h ~

IliH \

1n i l a,' I I e\ l " , I : I ' I I ,'eoy .,

f

t h ' I l l ( ' : \ '* . t. h p

O o f ~ n d l \ n t

1 ~ n Y A

t

IMt

t

h

I { ()\In

v,

11 n H c s r 1 1 1 ~ \ I \ ~ ' ,ItI ' · O\Q

'''Ii'

l. .

oy to

bi)

p ~ l 9 a n

t ad

0\ t

t

h., ho ,

1

1 ) I ''' tl e'VoJlho

t

£ I OJ Q 1. :\ ,I h l l p ( \ ~

f:

(\ lD

1

t

1q:\

t o , \ 1 1 ~ nn \ .me

tI 0 f h w

n d c.'n - h . . l r Q of)'

a

In, '

a 1 ' ( ' , · : \ t , f 'n

,

1

ro l l

o"'Qd

b ~ pr

0


14/15

•

\

':

.

' ..

;

C- lflCAI.I,

01

e

.•'I.CI

I

I n : R ~ i

Cf:RT'nV t h ~ t

a t n H ~

a r ~ l { lO I I 'A t ' t

~ n . i .

nr. t.he. f , ) r ~ q ( ) l Q

haa baan f fu·n i .h"d. by h,,'HI. ttl

Rl1t\tffT

I.nflt1. j:tlQtH.Hi. -"llftSlitant

Stato

tlQ

i

1 UY. f

1

44tr,,\

VQn \ lR

"o

..

t.h.,

C \ O ; \ r - · ~ t ~ r .

r,l,c;'1

Ida

,.t.,,,.

on th lo

~ ~ 1 ~ L dOly or

Hovr(;t.t\bcll'.

l Q0 1 ,

.

f '

.

I •

.

I (

, , ~ ~ j \ I . I ~ ~ j ~ / { ~ ~

~ ; ~ _ , . _

......

Q

lh:nrn

, . .

' ' ' '

tin

.

,

I

11

).

)1

t,

J

.

J.4

i

.

~ I k

.

.

.

.

: •

:. . .


15/15

•

,r:l

e

"

.'

..

.

•

...

-fl

:

H

UC\l(l ' l \ iU\(

(oh\l\('1 ChMlt'\ n.

Ad.lit.

t \ , ~ .

Hr.

Mr.

Arthur

E.

if\dmlr\'

:

~ I r ~ . [ ) ( ) n ) t l \ ) · · , ~ I .

,.\llll\lr(' ,:

al

~ I r . Rt)tlCrt

I'.

~ ) R l (

~ M r ~ . I!t'th !J)"th

~ t r . \"111

\\.

l k ~ ~

7)

r r l l ( l r l \ ~ ~

\\ '. ( ~ i ~ ~ > ,

F\

1993, 11-05-93, Correa’s Memorandum Law Support Downward Departure Sentencing.pdf

Documents

Transcript of 1993, 11-05-93, Correa’s Memorandum Law Support Downward Departure Sentencing.pdf