1989 Moller

download 1989 Moller

of 9

Transcript of 1989 Moller

  • 8/18/2019 1989 Moller

    1/9

    Int. J. Gynecol. Obstet., 1989,30: 123-131

    International Federation of Gynecology and Ob stetrics

    123

    A study of antenatal care at village level in rural Tanzania

    B. Moller*, 0. Lushinod, 0. Meirikb, M. Gebre-Medhin’ and G. Lindmark”

    Apartments of Obstetrics and Gynecology, cial Medicine and =Pediatrics, Uppsala University, Akademiska Sjukhuset, Uppsala

    (Sweden) and *Muga Regional Hmpitai, Iringa (Tanzania)

    (Received August 31s~ 1988)

    (Revised and accepted Novem ber 4th. 1988)

    Abstract

    Antenatal care is an acknowledged meas-

    ure for the reduction of maternal and

    perinatal mor tality. In the rural village of

    Ilula, Tanza nia, the possible impa ct of

    antenatal care on mortality was studied longi-

    tudinally on the basis of the 707 women deliv-

    ered in the study period. Ninety-five percent

    of the antenatal records were available.

    Anem ia, malaria and anticipated obstetric

    problems were the most frequent reasons for

    interventions. Amon g the wom en from the

    area who were delivered in hospital, 90 had

    been referred there. No relationship was

    found between the numb er of antenatal visits

    and the pregnancy outcome, but perinatal

    morta lity was correlated to a low birth

    weight. Even with a mean attendance rate of

    six visits and full coverage by antenatal care

    maternal and perinatal mortality remains

    high.

    Keywords:

    Prenatal care; Developing coun-

    try; Health care research; Perinatal mortality;

    Twin diagnosis; Breech presentation.

    Introduction

    Antenatal care (ANC) emerged in its basic

    form 50 years ago in Europe [l]. Although

    this model generally has been adopted in

    developing countries, the health problems

    noted there are quite different. In Tanzania,

    for example, the maternal and child health

    (MCH) services operate with limited material

    and manpower resources. At a time when the

    effectiveness of ANC is being questioned in

    European countries by consumers and care

    providers alike [2,3], it is prudent to assess the

    effectiveness and relevance of various parts of

    the ANC part of the MCH organization in

    developing countries, including Tanzania.

    In 1984 a joint WHO/Tanzanian study on

    primary health care [4] reported a mean 95

    registration rate to ANC in seven regions,

    with at least one visit to the MCH during

    pregnancy. The average number of visits dur-

    ing pregnancy was 4.3, with pronounced

    variations between the studied regions. Shears

    and Mkerenga [5] analyzed the impact of

    mobile MCH services on the maternal health

    and pregnancy outcome in several villages

    o

    Tanzania, mainly in the northern part. They

    concluded that the MCH services had only

    limited influence on the principal problems of

    maternal health and nutrition.

    The present study analyzes antenatal care

    service at the village level in an area where

    ANC coverage and attendance are good. It is

    based on an evaluation of the actual contents

    of the care in terms of detection of complica-

    0 0 20 - 7 2 9 2 / 8 9 / 0 3 . 5 0

    0 1989 International Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics

    Published and Printed in Ireland

    Clinical and Clinical Research

  • 8/18/2019 1989 Moller

    2/9

    124

    Moller et al

    tions, interventions and patient compliance

    relative to pregnancy outcome. To our knowl-

    edge such an area-based, prospective study

    has not been performed in Tanzania or, for

    that matter, in any other developing country.

    Materials and methods

    Subjects

    Between June 1, 1983 to November 30,

    1985 all women from the village of Ilula who

    delivered at, or attended the antenatal clinic

    in Ilula were eligible for enrollment. Of a

    total 719 women, 685 were enrolled at a visit

    to the antenatal care clinic in Ilula and 34

    when they were delivered, shortly after the

    study commenced.

    The Ilula mission dispensary is staffed by a

    village midwife, trained as an MCH aide,

    assisted by another MCH aide and the locally

    trained MCH attendants.

    All women

    delivered at home (230/o), in the dispensary

    (68 ) or in the Iringa Regional Hospital

    (9Vo) 47 km away. The distance from the

    mother’s home to the dispensary did not

    exceed 6 km for any of the women in the

    study population.

    ethods

    The village midwife undertook the data

    collection. She was known by the villagers for

    many years, and she knew the women in the

    two villages well and enjoyed their respect.

    The national antenatal record was used. After

    childbirth an extensive questionnaire was

    completed by the midwife during an interview

    with the mother. This information served to

    validate some data from the antenatal card.

    The obstetric history was recorded at the

    first antenatal visit. The national Swahili

    action-oriented antenatal card [6] has ‘tick

    boxes’ to note risk factors present at

    registration or detected at subsequent visits.

    When risk factors are present, instructions

    adjacent to the boxes explain the nature and

    timing of appropriate actions, namely referral

    for consultation or for institutional

    delivery

    at a hospital or a health center. Specified risk

    Int J Gynecol Obstet 30

    factors include previous cesarean section or

    poor pregnancy outcome, grand multiparity,

    maternal bleeding or hypertensive disorders,

    maternal height under 150 cm, fetal malpre-

    sentation and post-term pregnancy. The card

    also provides separate space for notes on the

    dispensing of iron,

    folic acid and anti-

    malarials. Reasons for referral are noted

    and the back of the card is used as the delivery

    record. The mothers keep their antenatal card

    themselves. The women were instructed to

    give the antenatal card to the village midwife

    subsequent to delivery or abortion.

    The mothers were examined at each visit,

    and their weight, blood pressure, any edema,

    general health status and the date of their next

    visit were noted. Blood pressure was

    measured in the sitting position with an

    aeroid sphygmomanometer. Complications

    and interventions are noted as they occur.

    Tetanus vaccinations

    and prophylactic

    medication with iron, folic acid and antima-

    larial agents are formally parts of the

    Table I.

    List of complications during pregnancy divided in

    symptoms and signs as noted at the 4392 antenatal visits to the

    MCH.

    No.

    of

    notes

    notes

    Symtoms

    (a)Abdominal pain, backache, headache,

    leg pain

    (b) Fever,

    “malaria”

    General illness, other

    Vaginal bleeding

    Vaginal discharge, local vaginal disorder

    Urinary tract infection, diarrhea

    Premature labor, premature rupture of

    the membranes

    g W

    (c) Anemia, clinicrd diagnosis

    Hb

  • 8/18/2019 1989 Moller

    3/9

    Frenatat care evaluation

    125

    Table II.

    Documented interventions during pregnancy related to length of gestation.

    Interventions

    Gestational age (weeks)

    Total Qs of

    total

    21 28-3 1 32-35 36-39 W

    Medication (at Ilula dispensary)

    Admitted to Hula dispensary

    Referrals

    For blood transfusion

    For consultation of doctor

    For hospital admission

    For hospital delivery

    12 10 9 8 3 42 30

    3 2 4 2 2 13 9

    I 2 3 2

    2 3 11 21 1 38 27

    1 1 7 7 2 18 13

    1 2 5 18 26 19

    Total 18 18 35 43 26 140 100%

    program. Fever and general malaise are

    regarded as malaria. The diagnosis of anemia

    is usually made on clinical impression. Labo-

    ratory determination of hemoglobin most

    often was not available.

    At the conclusion of the study period,

    antenatal cards were scrutinized for notes on

    symptoms and signs, complications of

    pregnancy and interventions. The infor-

    mation was coded and computerized.

    Complications were classified in symptoms

    and signs, according to Table I. Interventions

    were categorized as local interventions or

    referrals to hospital (Table II). Referral to a

    doctor in the Iringa Regional Hospital for

    assessment or admission was a common inter-

    vention, either during pregnancy or from the

    delivery ward of the dispensary, mostly dur-

    ing labor.

    Data analysis

    This analysis is based on the 683 available

    antenatal cards, which corresponds to 95 of

    the 719 pregnant women enrolled in the

    study. The reasons for missing cards were as

    follows: six patients had mislaid their cards,

    five mothers were lost to follow-up, four

    mothers had moved from the area, one

    negated antenatal care and 20 cards were lost

    in other ways. Judging from other sources of

    information, such as the questionnaire, the

    log-book and personal communication with

    the staff, the utilization of antenatal care in

    these groups did not seem to be different

    from that of the analyzed population.

    Information on hospital deliveries was sup-

    plemented with followup information when

    the card was not available. Five of the women

    with a lost card had hospital deliveries.

    Table III.

    Length of gestation at successive visits for all attenders and for attenders divided into two groups according to the

    number of visits (gw = gestational week).

    Length of gestation (weeks) at visit

    1st gw Zndgw 3rdgw 4thgw 5thgw 6thgw 7thgw 8thgw Jthgw 1Othgw

    For all attenders

    22 26 30 33 35 36 38 39 40 41

    For women attending five times

    or less

    For women attending six times

    or more

    25 29 33 35 31

    20 25 29 32 35 36 38 39 40 41

    Clinical and Clinical Research

  • 8/18/2019 1989 Moller

    4/9

    126

    Moller et al

    Results

    Registration and intervals between visits

    The mean length of gestation on

    enrollment was 23 weeks, with a range of 6-

    34. The number of visits averaged 6.4, with a

    range from 1 to 14. Eighty-six percent of the

    women had made more than two visits. The

    average week of pregnancy for each succes-

    sive visit is given in Table III. The average

    weeks of the visits have been tabulated sepa-

    rately for women with six visits or more and

    for those with five visits or fewer. Women

    who made five visits or fewer during the span

    of pregnancy registered at the ANC clinic in

    the 25th week, on average, and delivered at an

    average of 38.2 weeks. Half the visits were

    made before 33 weeks, and half after.

    linical findings at antenatal visits

    At the 4392 visits by the 685 women, 292

    complaints or complications were noted.

    ‘Complaints’ such as abdominal pain, head-

    ache, backache and heaviness without accom-

    panying objective signs were noted in 100

    cases, but were not premonitory signs of an

    adverse outcome, except in one case of pre-

    maturity in week 31. ‘Abdominal pain’ was

    Table IV

    Noted complications related to length of gestation

    at d iagnosis.

    Complications

    Gestational age (weeks) Total

    UP

    to 28-31 32-35 36-39 40

    21

    Fever, general

    illness

    12 10 12 10 4 48

    Vaginal bleeding

    3 1 1 3 1 9

    Rupture of

    membranes

    2 8 2 2 14

    Anemia

    21 12 11 9 53

    Hypertension

    1 1 2

    Twins, breech

    presentation

    3 5 9 6 1 24

    Total

    41 29 41

    31 8

    150

    generally poorly defined and might mean dis-

    comfort, anxiety or uterine contractions.

    Only when accompanied by other symptoms

    or signs was it associated with an adverse out-

    come. The distribution of complications over

    time is shown in Table IV.

    In addition, 12 women had had a cesarean

    section in a previous pregnancy. Seven of

    these were delivered in hospital, and four had

    a cesarean section delivery this time. Of all

    parturients, primigravidae constituted 17 .

    Thirteen percent of primigravidae were deliv-

    ered in the hospital and 71 in the dispen-

    sary. Of all pregnant women, 24 (3.4 ) were

    shorter than 150 cm. Forty percent of the 24

    were delivered in hospital.

    There were 38 febrile episodes presumed to

    be malarial attacks in the antenatal cards, but

    at the interview after delivery 171 patients

    gave a history of having had malaria during

    pregnancy. In this regard, less than a quarter

    of ‘malarial’ attacks were treated at the

    antenatal clinic; most patients were treated at

    other times at the out-patient department of

    the dispensary.

    A total of 4240 blood pressure (BP) meas-

    urements were made in the study period.

    Readings were nearly always recorded to the

    nearest multiple of ten. The mean antenatal

    pressure was 100/65 mmHg and this did not

    vary over pregnancy. Throughout pregnancy

    8-10070 of the diastolic readings were 80

    mmHg or over, but only 14 readings (0.3 )

    were 85 or more. Twenty-nine (0.6 ) of the

    systolic pressure readings were over 120

    mmHg.

    Only two patients were referred to hospital

    because of an elevated BP reading at a regular

    visit. An additional four patients were sent

    from the dispensary in labor because of

    hypertensive complications. The diastolic BP

    at the previous visit to MCH had not

    exceeded 80 mmHg for any of the four. How-

    ever, two of these women had had eclampsia

    at the dispensary.

    Sixty-four percent of the 58 diagnoses of

    anemia were made before the 32nd week, the

    majority by inspection of the mucous mem-

    Int J Gynecol Obstet 30

  • 8/18/2019 1989 Moller

    5/9

    Prenatal care evaluation

    127

    Table V.

    Hemoglobin values obtained from 152 consecutive

    antenatal car e attenders in Ilula.

    Hemoglobin value (g/l)

    130

    Readings 070 3 7 33 38 19

    branes and not confirmed by laboratory

    measurements. Hemoglobin values were

    checked in a group of patients (n = 152)

    participating in concomitant nutritional stud-

    ies. The distribution of the hemoglobin values

    recorded in this group is given in Table V.

    Most anemic patients were prescribed

    ferrous tablets, generally in inadequate

    amounts, as the supplies seldom matched the

    demands. Three patients had blood trans-

    fusions at the hospital because of anemia

    [l]

    and antepartum hemorrage [2].

    Interventions

    Interventions resulted from symptoms or

    findings. A total of 140 interventions were

    documented (Table II). Local interventions

    were most commonly medication for malaria,

    anemia and other illnesses. Of a total of 95

    Table VI. Hospital deliveries (n

    = 67, 61 referred, 6 not

    referred) and the indications for referral.

    Reasons for referral

    Referred

    From ANC

    In labor

    Malposition, twins, big baby

    14

    Previous cesarean section

    6

    Anemia 5

    Premature rupture of membranes 2

    Hypertension (2 eclampsia)

    2

    Lack of progress in labor

    Postmaturity

    4

    Local vaginal disorder

    1

    Miscellaneous

    6

    Unknown

    3

    Referred

    43

    1

    2

    18

    referrals, only 85 were actually activated

    (Table II). The main indications for referral

    to a doctor were pelvic assessment of

    primigravidae, twinning, malpositions and

    anemia.

    Twenty-two of 119 primigravidae had

    pelvic assessment. Of 13 primigravidae 150

    cm or under, two had pelvic assessment and

    later were delivered by cesarean section at the

    hospital. Among 11 remaining short women,

    four had normal delivery at home, five deliv-

    ered at the dispensary, and two delivered at

    hospital, one having cesarean section and one

    vacuum extraction.

    Of all referred patients, 43 delivered in

    hospital (Table VI). Another 18 referrals for

    hospital delivery were made from the

    dispensary of patients in labor. Six of the 67

    mothers delivered in hospital had gone there

    of their own choice without having been

    referred.

    Antitetanus vaccination is provided as a

    basic immunization for those previously not

    vaccinated and as a booster dose for

    previously vaccinated women. The coverage

    by immunization was 80 . Prophylactic anti-

    malarials and hematinics were provided very

    irregularly and clearly not to the extent

    intended in the national ANC program.

    Twins, breech presentation

    Of the 25 twin pregnancies (Table VII), 16

    were correctly suspected or diagnosed at an

    Table VII. Twins and breech presentations.

    Twin

    pregnancies

    (n = 25)

    Breech

    presentations

    (n = 17)

    Correctly diagnosed in

    antenatal clinic (olo)

    64 47

    Diagnoses at delivery (olo)

    36 53

    Hospital delivery (Vo)

    20 53

    Birth weight < 20 00

    g

    15 3

    Mean birth weight (g) 21m

    2635’

    Perinatal mortality rate (Vo)

    28 (14150) 53 (9/17)

    *Birthweight was known for 44 twins and 12 breech-delivered

    infants.

    Clinical and Clinical Research

  • 8/18/2019 1989 Moller

    6/9

    128

    Moller ef al.

    Table VIII. Num ber of antenatal visits in relation to

    pregnancy outcome. The table is based on the 683 women for

    whom an antenatal card was available (PMR = perinatal mor-

    tality rate).

    Visits Total

    6.4

    l-2 3-4 5-6 >6

    (mean)

    No. of patients

    Abortions

    Deliveries

    Mean gestational age at

    delivery (weeks)

    Birth weight < 2000 g

    Mean birth weight (g)

    Perinatal deaths

    PMR/lOOO

    41 126

    187 329 683

    7 3 0 0 10

    34 123 187 329 673

    37 38 39 40 39.4

    8 8 5 0 21

    2492 2877 2958 3195 3011

    9 9 12 12 42

    260 73 64 37 63

    average gestational age of 31 weeks. Five

    mothers had an X-ray to confirm the diagno-

    sis. Of the 16 women with twin pregnancies

    diagnosed antepartum, six delivered at home,

    and five (20 ) were sent to the referral hospi-

    tal.

    Breech presentation was correctly diag-

    nosed in 8 of 17 cases. Five of these 8 women

    had hospital delivery. Because four women

    with undiagnosed breech presentation were

    referred to hospital for other reasons and

    delivered there, nine of the 17 breech presen-

    tations (53 ) were delivered in hospital.

    Number of visits andpregnancy outcome

    The outcome related to the numbers of vis-

    its is shown in Table VIII. As half of the visits

    took place before 33 weeks and subsequent

    visits were more closely spaced, women with

    premature deliveries had fewer visits. The

    high perinatal mortality rate in the low birth

    weight groups occurred in women with few

    visits. Eight of the nine perinatal deaths in the

    group with one or two visits to the ANC clinic

    occurred in babies with a birth weight below

    2000 g. Evidently the high mortality in the

    groups with few visits was associated with a

    low birth weight and prematurity.

    There were four maternal deaths in this

    study. They all occurred in term deliveries

    around the time of delivery. In no case could

    the outcome be linked to insufficient

    antenatal care, nor was any abnormality

    noted during pregnancy.

    Discussion

    Many components of antenatal care, espe-

    cially health education and social support, are

    difficult to evaluate. In contrast, other

    components such as the correct diagnosis of

    breech presentation and twins, site of

    delivery, referral patterns and the numbers of

    antenatal visits can easily be quantitated. The

    Tanzanian national antenatal card [6] was

    designed as an instrument to help reduce

    maternal and perinatal deaths. This study

    demonstrates its additional use for health

    service research. Ninety-five per cent of the

    cards were available for analysis in this study,

    compared with 87 in a similar study in

    Aberdeen [7].

    linical findings at antenatal visits

    Some complication or complaint was noted

    in 7 (292/4392) of antenatal visits. One

    third concerned mainly

    physiological

    inconveniences of pregnancy of no clinical

    importance (Table IIa), usually eliciting no

    action other than possibly short courses of

    symptomatic medication. In general, staff of

    busy clinics in many countries pay little heed

    to these problems [3] although it is

    important for the women to be treated with

    sympathy in this respect. In 107 instances,

    however, symptomatic complications were

    noted (Table IIb). These conditions led the

    patient to seek medical care even though a

    visit was not scheduled. Eighty-five women

    (Table 11~)had a diagnosis of generally symp-

    tomless conditions, mainly anemia or

    abnormal presentation detected through the

    routine monitoring of pregnancy.

    Unfortunately clinical examination does

    not always lead to identification of multifetal

    pregnancy or breech presentation. For

    example, the frequency of correct twin

    diagnosis in antenatal care was 60 in Swe-

    Int J Gynecol O bstet 30

  • 8/18/2019 1989 Moller

    7/9

    Prenatal care evaluation

    29

    den in 1971 [8], before ultrasound or bio-

    chemical indicators were used routinely,

    suggesting that the 64 detection rate of

    twins in Ilula is the rate that can be attained in

    routine clinical work without the use of

    sophisticated techniques. The breech detec-

    tion rate of 47 is comparable to the

    61 detection rate of term breeches in San

    Francisco between 1976 and 1984 [9].

    Considering that some breech deliveries in

    Ilula were preterm, this detection rate is

    reasonable. The value of prelabor diagnosis is

    particularly great in view of the perinatal

    mortality of 50 and the skill required to

    handle breech and multifetal deliveries in the

    best of circumstances. As this skill generally is

    available only at institutions, patients with

    breech presentation or multifetal pregnancy

    should be made aware of the importance of

    institutional delivery.

    Antenatal referrals

    Only every fifth primigravida was sent to a

    medical officer for pelvic assessment, and

    only two of the 13 short primigravidae were

    assessed. That all but one of the assessed

    women also had institutional delivery

    probably better indicates that these women

    were prone to comply with staff recom-

    mendations than that they were espe-

    cially at risk. The majority of primigravidae

    did not have pelvic assessment, and its value

    as part of antenatal monitoring of pregnancy

    must be questionned.

    Medical actions at the MCH clinic

    The prophylaxis and treatment of anemia

    and malaria are important ingredients of

    ANC. Most febrile illnesses are considered to

    be malaria and treated accordingly without

    examination. Three quarters of all febrile epi-

    sodes occurred outside scheduled visits to the

    MCH and were treated elsewhere. When

    defined according to WHO (< lOOg/l),

    anemia was found to be present in 14 women,

    or 10 of the sample. This frequency is con-

    siderably lower than the 45 reported from

    Mozambique [lo] and the 20 from the

    Ivory Coast

    [

    111. Although the diagnosis of

    anemia by clinical inspection is inaccurate

    [12], laboratory confirmation is often not

    feasible. The use of prophylactic medication

    by all pregnant women or at least those dis-

    playing signs of anemia, should constitute a

    more important part of antenatal care than

    was seen here.

    Weight and blood pressure recordings

    A considerable amount of time and effort

    is spent on recording the body weight and

    blood pressure of every expectant mother at

    each visit. Maternal weight and its relation to

    birth weight will be reported elsewhere

    [

    131.

    In routine clinical work, the findings at

    weighing mothers at each visit rarely alter

    their management, and this practise was even

    discarded by Essex et al. [6].

    The yield of blood pressure measurements

    was particularly low. Ilula is an area with a

    relatively low rate of eclampsia. The two

    cases of eclampsia were not detected in the

    pre-eclamptic stage. The remaining few

    hypertensive patients were identified through

    concomitant or incidental clinical symptoms

    rather than by blood pressure recordings. The

    detection rate might be increased, with less

    waste of time, by performing blood pressure

    recordings at each visit only in risk groups,

    namely primigravidae, women with previous

    pregnancy hypertension and those with a high

    blood pressure at the first visit. Tests for

    albuminuria in these cases should be given

    priority, and when diagnostic tools are scarce,

    they should be saved for these cases.

    Prophylactic medication

    One of the stated purposes of antenatal

    care is to provide prophylactic medication for

    the prevention of some complications such as

    anemia and malaria. Also, neonatal tetanus is

    prevented by maternal immunization. Logis-

    tic problems make this part of ANC vulnera-

    ble and insufficient [14]. Of medications and

    vaccinations, only the antitetanus vaccination

    program worked fairly well, while hematinics

    and anti-malarial agents very often were not

    Clinical and Clinical Research

  • 8/18/2019 1989 Moller

    8/9

    130 Moller et al

    available. This important goal of the national

    preventive program has not nearly been

    reached.

    Number and timing of antenatal visits

    Several reports [15-171 show a correlation

    between frequent attendance at an antenatal

    clinic and a good pregnancy outcome.

    However, these studies suffer from two major

    weaknesses. One is the problem of self-selec-

    tion by mothers registering for antenatal care,

    and the other is that the quality of the care is

    not assessed

    [

    181. In most European countries

    a full antenatal program comprises lo-12

    visits. The recommendations for the spacing

    of visits vary considerably, however, but

    according to Blonde1 [19] outcome as meas-

    ured in national perinatal mortality is not

    related to the number of antenatal visits.

    In this study we found an association

    between the outcome of pregnancy and the

    number of antenatal visits. We question,

    however, the causality of this association. If

    the preterm and low birth weight babies with

    their high mortality are taken into account,

    an independent effect of the number of

    antenatal visits is no longer obvious. Unfor-

    tunately, prematurity and low birth weight

    are usually not preventable through antenatal

    care other than possibly by treating malarial

    episodes and other infections.

    Early enrollment for antenatal care has

    long been encouraged. The purpose of this

    early attendance is to permit the detection and

    treatment of maternal diseases such as ane-

    mia, syphilis and tuberculosis and to allow a

    better dating of pregnancy. Unless screening

    for these conditions is actually practised, the

    justification of early enrollment fails.

    Structured programs

    To improve results within the framework

    of programs with limited resources, greater

    emphasis should be placed on quality rather

    than on quantity in antenatal care. Structured

    programs based on local priorities ideally

    should optimize the use of scarce resources.

    In her account of the setting in Scotland, Hall

    [2] suggests a reduction in the number of

    planned visits for normal multigravidae to

    four. Primigravidae should be followed up

    according to the traditional programme

    because of their higher risk of hypertensive

    disorders.

    In the case of Tanzania, programs may be

    worked out along the same goal-oriented

    lines. A few visits will be enough to detect

    most risk factors. Some women with risk

    factors will need closer monitoring. All

    women

    should be advised to report

    immediately should complications such as

    bleeding occur. Most gravidae will benefit

    from a program in which the aim of all

    scheduled visits is defined and clearly stated.

    Improved attention to individual and group

    instruction, especially of women at high risk

    such as women with multifetal pregnancies

    and breech presentations, should assist in

    improving pregnancy outcome. To increase

    compliance, women should be made aware of

    their personal risk factors [20].

    The present organization of MCH clinics in

    Tanzania is such that women bring their

    children and all parties receive regular health

    education. Visitors to MCH clinics have been

    found to be very receptive audiences [5]. An

    appropriately compiled collection of centrally

    prepared short health education programs

    will help the MCH staff in this task [21].

    Limits of antenatal care

    In this study, the main causes of perinatal

    death were prematurity and LBW births. In

    the absence of resources for referral to a hos-

    pital and/or of an effective preventive medi-

    cation program, one can speculate if perinatal

    mortality rates can be lowered by significantly

    more frequent routine antenatal visits.

    Other determinants of pregnancy outcome

    clearly are present. Social factors such as

    female work load and nutrition, from child-

    hood onwards, also influence the outcome of

    pregnancy and probably are just as important

    as those risk factors that might be mitigated

    by specific actions taken in antenatal care.

    In conclusion, our assessment of the effec-

    Int J Gynecol Obstet 30

  • 8/18/2019 1989 Moller

    9/9

    tiveness of the antenatal services in a rural

    setting in Tanzania has shown that despite

    good coverage of the pregnant population by

    a popular antenatal service, maternal and

    perinatal mortality rates remain high, appar-

    ently not affected by the frequent antenatal

    monitoring. One probable reason for this is

    that perinatal mortality is largely associated

    with prematurity and low birth weight, both

    of which cannot be easily influenced simply

    by checking mothers for risk factors.

    On the other hand, the present system

    of

    antenatal care provides

    excellent

    opportunities to reach mothers with prophy-

    lactic medication, vaccinations, and diagnosis

    and treatment of infectious diseases, and also

    health education programs.

    The present study suggests that more

    emphasis should be placed on preventive

    medical and social measures. Strengthening

    of the referral capacity is also a necessity if

    obstetric risk screening is to be made

    worthwhile.

    cknowledgment

    This study was supported by SAREC grant

    81/79. We are indebted to UNICEF,

    Tanzania, for logistical support.

    References

    Wagne r MG : Health services for pregnancy care in

    Europe. Int J Technol Assess Health Care I: 789,198 5.

    Hall M: Antenatal care in practice. Spastics Int Med Pub-

    lic, London, 1982 .

    Garcia JO: Wom ens’ views of antenatal care. Spastics Int

    Med Public, London, 1982 .

    Government of Tanzania/UN ICEF: An analysis of the

    situation of women and children. D ar Es Salaam, 1985 .

    Shears F, Mkerenga R: Evaluating the impact of mother

    and child health (MCH) services at village level, a survey

    in Tanzania, and lessons for elsewhere. Ann Trop Pediatr

    5: 55.1985.

    6

    7

    8

    9

    10

    11

    12

    13

    14

    15

    16

    17

    18

    19

    20

    21

    Prenatal care evaluation 13 1

    Essex BJ, Everett J: Use of an action oriented record for

    antenatal screening. Trop Dot 7 : 134.19 77.

    Hall MH, C hng PK, MacG illivray I: Is routine an tenatal

    care worth while? Lancet ii: 78, 1980.

    Grennert L, Persson PH, Gennser G , Kullander S:

    Ultrasound and human placental-lactogcn for early

    detection of twin pregnancies. Lancet

    i:

    4, 1976.

    Flanagan T A, Mulchahey KM, Korenbrot CC, Green JR,

    Laros KL: Managem ent of term breech presentation. Am

    J Obstet GynecolZ56: 1492,1987.

    Boatin BA, Bulsara MK. Wurpa FK: Evaluation of

    conjunctival pallor in the diagnosis of anaemia. J Trop

    Med Hyg89: 33.1986.

    Reinhart MC: A survey of mothers and their newborns in

    Abijan, Ivory Coast. Helv Paediatr Acta Suppl 41, 33:

    1978.

    Wu rapa FK, Bulsara MK , Boatin SA: Evaluation of con-

    junctival pallor in the diagnosis of anemia. J Trop Med

    Hyg 89: 33,1986.

    Moller BJ, Gebre-Medhin M, Lindmark G: Maternal

    weight, weight gain and birth weight at term in the rural

    Tanzanian village of Ilula. Br J Obstet Gynecol, in press.

    Ministry of Health: Report on a study on patient

    management, essential drugs and equipment supply. Tan-

    zania, 1985.

    Ryan GM : Prenatal care and pregnancy outcome. Am J

    Obstet Gynecol137: 876. 1980.

    Gorthmak er S: The effects of prenatal care upon the

    health of the newborn. Am J Public Health 69: 653, 1979 .

    Greenberg R: The impact of prenatal care in different

    social groups. Am J Obstet Gynecol

    145:

    797,1982.

    Helliger FJ: Prenatal care, neonatal intensive care and

    infant mortality. J Technol Assess Health Care I: 934,

    1985.

    Blonde1 B: Some characteristics of antenatal care in 13

    European countries. Br J Obstet Gynaecol

    9 :

    565,1985.

    WH O/UN ICEF Joint Statement: M aternal care for the

    reduction of perinatal and neonatal m ortality. W HO,

    Geneva, 1986.

    Morley D: Comm unication and learning. In Pediatric

    Priorities in Developing Countries, p 3%. Butterworth,

    London, 1975.

    Address for reprints:

    G Ltodmark

    Dejnutment of Obstetrks and Gynecology

    tJPplul8 nivemity

    Aludemislu

    ]nkbnset

    s 75185 Sweden

    Clinical and Clinical Research