161005 Camden Civic Society HoL petition 770 exhibit FINALThe Camden Civic Society (charity...
94
EXHIBIT LIST Reference No: HOL/00770 Petitioner: Camden Civic Society Published to Collaboration Area: Wednesday 05-Oct-2016 Page 1 of 92 No Exhibit Name Page 1 A340_Camden Civic Society HoL_770_exhibit.pdf (A340) 2 - 92 HOL/00770/0001
Transcript of 161005 Camden Civic Society HoL petition 770 exhibit FINALThe Camden Civic Society (charity...
EXHIBIT LISTReference No: HOL/00770Petitioner: Camden Civic SocietyPublished to Collaboration Area: Wednesday 05-Oct-2016
Page 1 of 92
No Exhibit Name Page
1 A340_Camden Civic Society HoL_770_exhibit.pdf (A340) 2 - 92
HOL/00770/0001
Peti
tio
n7
70
:Cam
den
Civ
icSo
ciet
y
A34
0 (1
)H
OL/
0077
0/00
02
The
Cam
de
nC
ivic
Soci
ety
(ch
arit
yre
gist
rati
on
27
62
62
)w
asfo
un
ded
in1
96
3an
dis
Cam
de
n’s
on
lyb
oro
ugh
-wid
eam
enit
yso
ciet
y.It
bec
ame
firm
lye
stab
lish
edth
rou
ghit
sp
arti
cip
atio
nin
op
po
siti
on
toth
eLo
nd
on
Mo
torw
ayB
ox
sch
eme
of
the
late
19
60
s.
We
hav
eal
way
sin
favo
ur
inve
stm
en
tin
pu
blic
tran
spo
rtan
dw
ou
ldw
elco
me
aw
ell-
de
sign
edh
igh
-sp
eed
rail
sch
eme
wit
hp
rop
erco
nn
ecti
vity
.
A34
0 (2
)H
OL/
0077
0/00
03
The
agre
edas
kso
fth
eC
amd
enR
esid
ents
’Rai
lway
Alt
ern
ativ
esTh
ink
Tan
k,w
ith
tho
sem
ost
rele
van
tto
the
Civ
icSo
ciet
yp
etit
ion
hig
hlig
hte
d.
Cam
de
nR
esi
de
nts
’Rai
lway
Alt
ern
ativ
es
Thin
kTa
nk
Pri
nci
ple
Eust
on
‘ask
s’–
for
pu
blic
mee
tin
g1
8th
July
20
16
1.
Eust
on
stat
ion
and
its
app
roac
hsh
ou
ldre
mai
nw
ith
inth
eir
exis
tin
gfo
otp
rin
to
nth
eea
ster
n
and
wes
tern
sid
es(i
tm
ayb
en
eces
sary
toex
ten
dso
uth
war
ds
tow
ard
sEu
sto
nR
oad
the
pla
tfo
rms
for
the
lon
gest
trai
ns)
.
2.
An
ew‘h
olis
tic’
des
ign
isn
eed
ed,c
ove
rin
gth
est
atio
nb
uild
ing,
the
pla
tfo
rms
and
the
trac
ks
inth
eap
pro
ach
.
3.
The
new
des
ign
sho
uld
be
wel
lin
tegr
ated
wit
hlo
calp
ub
lictr
ansp
ort
and
inp
arti
cula
rsh
ou
ld
inco
rpo
rate
the
wes
tern
end
of
the
pla
nn
edC
ross
rail
2st
atio
n.
4.
Ad
ou
ble
-dec
kd
esig
nw
ou
ldal
low
ast
atio
no
fm
inim
alw
idth
.
5.
Asi
ngl
eau
tho
rity
sho
uld
be
resp
on
sib
lefo
rth
ep
lan
nin
gan
dre
dev
elo
pm
ent
of
Eust
on
–w
e
envi
sage
this
bei
ng
Net
wo
rkR
ail(
the
auth
ori
tyo
fth
eh
igh
spee
dra
ilco
mp
any
sho
uld
ceas
e
atth
eir
tun
nel
po
rtal
s).[
Ple
ase
no
te–
this
isa
new
ask
!]
6.
The
reb
uild
ing
of
Eust
on
sho
uld
be
aco
nti
nu
ou
sp
roce
ssan
dsh
ou
ldn
ot
be
div
ided
up
into
self
-co
nta
ined
‘ph
ases
’.
7.
The
len
gth
of
tim
eta
ken
by
the
reb
uild
ing
sho
uld
be
assh
ort
asp
oss
ible
.
8.
Toal
low
tim
efo
rth
eb
est
pro
po
salf
or
Eust
on
tob
efo
un
dan
dim
ple
men
ted
,Ph
ase
Atr
ain
s
sho
uld
use
Old
Oak
Co
mm
on
asa
tem
po
rary
term
inu
s.
9.
Ino
rder
tocr
eate
spac
efo
rh
igh
spee
dtr
ain
sat
Eust
on
,we
sup
po
rtth
ep
rop
osa
lof
the
Dep
artm
ent
for
Tran
spo
rtth
atC
ross
rail
1is
ext
end
edfr
om
Old
Oak
Co
mm
on
on
toth
e
WC
ML
asfa
ras
Trin
g(s
ore
pla
cin
gth
eTr
ing
and
Wat
ford
serv
ices
wh
ich
curr
entl
yco
me
into
Eust
on
).
10
.Sp
oil
sho
uld
be
rem
ove
dan
dm
ate
rial
sb
rou
ght
inas
far
asp
oss
ible
by
rail
–w
eb
elie
veth
at
75
%is
are
alis
tic
figu
refo
rEu
sto
nan
dth
eC
amd
enC
utt
ing.
11
.A
stat
ion
des
ign
wh
ich
isvi
sual
lyas
wel
las
fun
ctio
nal
lyco
her
ent
will
nee
dst
ron
gce
ntr
al
ove
rsig
ht;
too
man
yD
esig
nan
dB
uild
con
trac
tsw
illle
adto
ast
atio
nw
hic
hh
asn
ovi
sual
or
fun
ctio
nal
un
ity.
Her
oG
ran
ger-
Tayl
or
and
Ric
har
dP
erci
val1
8/7
/16
,cam
den
civi
cso
ciet
y@gm
ail.c
om
A34
0 (3
)H
OL/
0077
0/00
04
Ou
rp
rese
nta
tio
nw
illb
ed
ivid
edin
tosi
xse
ctio
ns:
•A
nex
amin
atio
no
fth
eb
road
erp
lan
nin
gan
dh
erit
age
issu
esra
ised
by
AP
3•
Ave
ryb
rief
asse
ssm
ent
of
the
AP
3Eu
sto
nst
atio
np
rop
osa
lfro
man
arch
itec
tura
lan
dp
lan
nin
gvi
ewp
oin
t•
Ab
rief
revi
ewo
fth
em
ech
anis
mfo
rd
ecid
ing
the
ove
rall
dev
elo
pm
ent
of
Eust
on
stat
ion
•A
crit
ical
exam
inat
ion
of
the
AP
3st
atio
nan
dap
pro
ach
fro
ma
railw
ayvi
ewp
oin
t•
Co
ncl
usi
on
sd
eriv
ing
fro
mo
ur
exam
inat
ion
of
the
AP
3sc
hem
e•
Ab
rief
exp
lan
atio
no
fth
e‘C
amd
enC
ivic
Soci
ety’
alte
rnat
ive
railw
aysc
hem
efo
rth
est
atio
nan
dit
sap
pro
ach
A34
0 (4
)H
OL/
0077
0/00
05
Pla
nn
ing
and
Her
itag
eIs
sues
A34
0 (5
)H
OL/
0077
0/00
06
Det
ailo
fF
AB
artl
ett’
sm
apo
fSt
Mar
yleb
on
e,p
ub
lish
ed1
83
7.
The
new
railw
ayth
read
sit
self
bet
wee
nex
isti
ng
ho
usi
ng,
incl
ud
ing
Mo
rnin
gto
nC
resc
ent
and
Park
Vill
age
East
.
The
‘Rai
lway
Dep
ot’
isto
the
no
rth
of
the
Reg
ent’
sC
anal
.Th
ere
nev
erh
ave
bee
n‘r
ailw
ayla
nd
s’in
the
vici
nit
yo
fEu
sto
n.
Ou
rre
leva
nt
ask
isth
atC
lau
se4
8b
ere
mo
ved
fro
mth
eb
ill.
A34
0 (6
)H
OL/
0077
0/00
07
Lege
nd
Co
nse
rvat
ion
Are
a
Gra
de
ILis
ted
Gra
de
II*Li
sted
Gra
de
IILi
sted
Reg
ents
Park
Ca
md
enTo
wn
Kin
gs
Cro
ssSt
.Pa
ncr
as
Blo
om
sbu
ry
Pri
mro
seH
ill
Man
yo
fth
eb
uild
ings
surr
ou
nd
ing
the
railw
ayin
CFA
1ar
elis
ted
.Wit
hin
the
Eust
on
area
,th
ree
con
serv
atio
nar
eas
are
affe
cted
by
HS2
Ltd
’ssc
hem
e.
A34
0 (7
)H
OL/
0077
0/00
08
An
ewSt
arcr
oss
Co
nse
rvat
ion
Are
aw
illb
ep
rop
ose
db
yth
eC
amd
enC
ivic
Soci
ety.
On
the
wes
to
fth
isar
ea,i
nN
ort
hG
ow
erSt
reet
,th
ere
are
fou
rst
ore
yla
teG
eorg
ian
terr
ace
ho
use
s.
A34
0 (8
)H
OL/
0077
0/00
09
On
the
east
sid
e,th
esc
ale
issm
alle
r,w
ith
thre
est
ore
yh
ou
ses.
Thes
eap
pea
rto
be
surv
ivo
rso
fth
eea
rly
19
thce
ntu
ryh
ou
sin
gd
evel
op
men
tw
hic
hsp
ann
edth
en
ort
hsi
de
of
Eust
on
squ
are.
The
ori
gin
alEu
sto
nst
atio
nsa
td
irec
tly
toth
en
ort
ho
fth
ese
smal
l-sc
ale
ho
use
s.In
the
pro
po
sed
Co
nse
rvat
ion
Are
a,m
od
ern
ho
usi
ng
bu
iltb
yC
amd
enco
mp
lem
ents
this
smal
ler
scal
eve
ryw
ell.
Thes
etw
ovi
ews
of
Co
bo
urg
Stre
etsh
ow
bu
ildin
gsd
ue
tob
ed
emo
lish
edu
nd
erA
P3
.
The
pu
rpo
seo
flis
tin
gin
div
idu
alb
uild
ings
and
of
crea
tin
gC
on
serv
atio
nA
reas
isfi
rstl
yto
‘pre
serv
eo
ren
han
ce’.
Bu
tth
isd
oes
no
tp
recl
ud
ech
ange
.Th
eb
road
erai
mis
toen
sure
that
any
chan
geis
care
fully
and
fully
con
sid
ered
.
A34
0 (9
)H
OL/
0077
0/00
10
The
tall
bu
ildin
gen
visa
ged
atth
eSW
corn
ero
fth
eH
S2si
tew
ou
ldn
eed
tob
eco
nsi
der
edin
rela
tio
nto
the
sett
ing
of
the
pro
po
sed
Star
cro
ssC
A.
This
sam
eta
llb
uild
ing,
set
on
top
of
wh
atw
asM
elto
nSt
reet
,wo
uld
blo
ckth
evi
ewo
fG
rim
shaw
s’‘g
old
ento
enai
l’,th
ear
chit
ectu
ralf
ocu
so
fth
e‘H
S2Eu
sto
nSt
atio
n’
A34
0 (1
0)H
OL/
0077
0/00
11
Vie
ws
mu
stal
sob
eco
nsi
der
ed.T
he
‘Pro
tect
edV
ista
4A
.1’f
rom
Pri
mro
seH
illto
StPa
uls
’p
asse
sac
ross
the
top
of
Eust
on
stat
ion
.
The
Cam
de
np
olic
yd
ocu
me
nt
the
Eust
on
Are
aP
lan
seek
sto
pro
tect
loca
lvie
ws
and
tolim
itth
eh
eigh
to
fn
ewd
evel
op
me
nts
aro
un
dEu
sto
nto
be
low
the
roo
flin
eo
fth
eN
ash
terr
aces
asse
enfr
om
Reg
ent’
sPa
rk.
A34
0 (1
1)H
OL/
0077
0/00
12
Itis
po
ssib
leto
‘har
m’t
oth
e‘s
etti
ng
’of
aLi
sted
Bu
ildin
gan
do
fa
Co
nse
rvat
ion
Are
a.
Rec
ent
case
law
incl
ud
esth
eB
arn
wel
lMan
or
Cas
e(F
ebru
ary
20
14
)an
dth
eca
seo
fR
,ab
ou
tPe
nsh
urs
t(J
un
e2
01
4):
inth
ela
tter
case
,Mr
Just
ice
Lin
dlb
om
’sju
dgm
ent
incl
ud
edth
efo
llow
ing:
‘Th
ep
resu
mp
tio
nis
ast
atu
tory
on
e.It
isn
ot
irre
bu
tta
ble
.It
can
be
ou
twei
gh
edb
ym
ate
ria
lco
nsi
der
ati
on
sp
ow
erfu
len
ou
gh
tod
oso
.Bu
ta
na
uth
ori
tyca
no
nly
pro
per
lyst
rike
the
rig
ht
ba
lan
ceb
etw
een
ha
rmto
ah
erit
ag
ea
sset
on
the
on
eh
an
da
nd
pla
nn
ing
ben
efit
so
nth
eo
ther
ifit
isco
nsc
iou
so
fth
est
atu
tory
pre
sum
pti
on
infa
vou
ro
fp
rese
rva
tio
n,a
nd
ifit
dem
on
stra
bly
ap
plie
sth
at
pre
sum
pti
on
toth
ep
rop
osa
lit
isco
nsi
der
ing
.’
This
issu
eis
wel
lillu
stra
ted
by
the
pro
po
sed
‘inte
rven
tio
nb
uild
ing
’op
po
site
30
Park
Vill
age
East
.
A34
0 (1
2)H
OL/
0077
0/00
13
Extr
act
fro
mH
S2Lt
d’s
do
cum
ent
P1
11
84
9(p
35
)w
ith
the
actu
alo
utl
ine
of
the
pro
po
sed
Inte
rven
tio
nB
uild
ing
sup
erim
po
sed
A34
0 (1
3)H
OL/
0077
0/00
14
This
dra
win
gb
yJ
CB
ou
rne
(18
36
)re
cord
sso
me
of
the
ho
use
so
nth
eea
stsi
de
of
Park
Vill
age
East
.Th
ese
wer
elo
stw
hen
the
cutt
ing
was
enla
rged
inth
eea
rly
20
thce
ntu
ry.
Evid
entl
yth
eyw
ere
smal
ler
and
pla
iner
than
the
rem
ain
ing
ho
use
so
nth
ew
est
sid
e.
Thei
rlo
ss,p
rio
rto
the
legi
slat
ion
pro
tect
ing
his
tori
cb
uild
ings
,do
esn
ot
just
ify
furt
her
har
mto
the
sett
ing
of
the
surv
ivin
gvi
llas.
(Bri
tish
Rai
lRe
cord
sO
ffic
e,N
RM
)
A34
0 (1
4)H
OL/
0077
0/00
15
The
AP
3Eu
sto
nst
atio
np
rop
osa
lfro
man
arch
itec
tura
lan
dp
lan
nin
gvi
ewp
oin
t
A34
0 (1
5)H
OL/
0077
0/00
16
Eust
on
stat
ion
and
its
sett
ing
Un
der
AP
3,t
he
left
hal
fo
fR
ich
ard
Seif
ert’
sca
refu
llyco
mp
ose
d4
-blo
ck1
97
0s
com
po
siti
on
will
be
lost
.
In2
01
4,t
he
20
thC
en
tury
Soci
ety
app
lied
for
the
mai
nst
atio
nb
uild
ing
(des
ign
edb
yB
R’s
arch
itec
ture
de
par
tme
nt)
tob
elis
ted
.Th
isap
plic
atio
nw
astu
rned
do
wn
by
Engl
ish
Her
itag
ean
dD
CM
So
nth
egr
ou
nd
sth
atth
ete
rmin
us
(19
62
-68
)w
as‘p
oo
rly
inte
gra
ted
into
its
urb
an
surr
ou
nd
ing
s’an
dh
ad‘n
ost
ron
gvi
sua
lrel
ati
on
ship
wit
hn
earb
ylis
ted
bu
ildin
gs.
’
A34
0 (1
6)H
OL/
0077
0/00
17
This
isG
rim
shaw
s’d
esig
nfo
rEu
sto
nst
atio
np
rio
rto
AP
3.T
his
rep
rese
nta
tio
nill
ust
rate
sth
etw
ore
mai
nin
gSe
ifer
tb
uild
ings
alo
ng
sid
e‘t
he
HS2
Eust
on
stat
ion
’bu
iltto
aco
nte
mp
ora
ryd
esig
n.
The
AP
3st
atio
nw
illb
evi
sual
lyco
nsi
der
ably
mo
rep
rob
lem
atic
.
A34
0 (1
7)H
OL/
0077
0/00
18
Squ
eez
ing
are
plic
ao
fP
hili
pH
ard
wic
k’s
Eust
on
Arc
hb
etw
een
the
two
late
ran
dm
uch
smal
ler
lod
ges
on
Eust
on
Squ
are
will
no
td
isgu
ise
the
lack
of
arch
itec
tura
lco
hes
ion
beh
ind
.(W
eb
elie
veth
isis
the
po
siti
on
for
the
Arc
hid
enti
fied
by
the
Tran
spo
rtm
inis
ter
Mr
Go
od
will
inh
isre
com
men
dat
ion
toth
eC
om
mo
ns
inSe
pte
mb
er2
01
5th
atth
eA
rch
be
resu
rrec
ted
.)
A34
0 (1
8)H
OL/
0077
0/00
19
The
mec
han
ism
for
dec
idin
gth
eo
vera
lld
evel
op
men
to
fEu
sto
nst
atio
n
A34
0 (1
9)H
OL/
0077
0/00
20
The
Cam
de
nC
ivic
Soci
ety
isve
ryco
nce
rned
by
the
imp
licat
ion
so
fth
ed
ivis
ion
of
the
stat
ion
un
der
AP
3in
toth
ree
‘sta
ges’
.In
ou
rp
etit
ion
toth
eH
ou
seo
fC
om
mo
ns
on
AP
3(p
arag
rap
h6
8)
we
wro
teth
at‘a
coh
eren
td
esig
nfo
rth
ere
dev
elo
pm
ent
of
the
wh
ole
sta
tio
nis
req
uir
ed’
The
Ho
use
of
Co
mm
on
sSe
lect
Co
mm
itte
eas
ked
inth
eir
rep
ort
for
‘aco
her
ent
stat
ion
’,‘a
ho
listi
cap
pro
ach
’an
dth
atth
e‘b
od
ies’
con
cern
ed‘c
om
mu
nic
ate
wit
hea
cho
ther
’(p
arag
rap
hs
24
3-2
45
).
A34
0 (2
0)H
OL/
0077
0/00
21
Bu
tn
ocl
ause
refl
ecti
ng
thes
eai
mw
asad
ded
toth
eb
illin
the
Co
mm
on
s.
Mea
nw
hile
,Ass
ura
nce
sto
Cam
den
wer
eal
read
yta
lkin
gin
term
so
ffo
ur
sep
arat
e‘p
roje
cts’
or
‘sch
emes
’.
The
extr
act
on
the
righ
tis
fro
mth
eA
ssu
ran
ces
lett
erfr
om
HS2
Ltd
toL
BC
amd
eno
f3
0th
No
vem
ber
20
15
,fr
om
par
agra
ph
1.2
:
‘Th
eEu
sto
nSt
atio
nSt
rate
gic
Red
evel
op
me
nt
Bo
ard
too
vers
ee:
-th
ein
teg
rati
on
of
the
del
iver
yo
fth
efo
llow
ing
pro
ject
s(s
ub
ject
tofu
ture
fun
din
gd
ecis
ion
sa
nd
ap
pro
vals
):
(a)
the
HS2
Eust
on
Sta
tio
n;
(bth
ere
bu
ildo
fth
eEu
sto
nM
ain
line
Sta
tio
n(a
sa
nd
wh
ensu
chre
bu
ildm
ay
be
fun
ded
an
da
uth
ori
sed
),a
nd
sup
po
rtin
gth
eti
mel
yco
nsi
der
ati
on
of
this
tore
flec
tth
eLo
nd
on
Bo
rou
gh
of
Ca
md
en’s
am
bit
ion
sto
limit
dis
rup
tio
n;
(c)
the
Cro
ssra
il2
pro
po
sals
at
Eust
on
;a
nd
(d)
Ove
rsi
ted
evel
op
men
ta
nd
rela
ted
dev
elo
pm
ent
op
po
rtu
nit
ies
op
po
rtu
nit
ies
ab
ove
the
Eust
on
Sta
tio
na
nd
tra
cks
inlin
ew
ith
the
Eust
on
Are
aP
lan
-th
est
rate
gic
visi
on
for
the
Eust
on
sta
tio
na
nd
tra
cks
an
dth
ep
rop
ose
dEu
sto
nSc
hem
es,t
aki
ng
into
acc
ou
nt
the
nee
dfo
rp
erm
eab
ility
inth
ed
esig
na
nd
aco
mp
reh
ensi
vea
nd
inte
gra
ted
dev
elo
pm
ent;
……
……
……
…
-th
ed
eliv
ery
of
ap
lan
nin
gb
rief
an
dm
ast
erp
lan
for
the
Eust
on
Sta
tio
n,r
epo
rted
toth
eEu
sto
nSt
rate
gic
Bo
ard
.‘A
340
(21)
HO
L/00
770/
0022
Du
rin
g2
01
6,t
he
Cam
den
Civ
icSo
ciet
yh
asb
een
un
able
tole
arn
of
any
pro
gres
sto
war
ds
the
‘mas
ter
pla
n’m
en
tio
ned
abo
ve.
At
am
eeti
ng
of
the
Stat
ion
Des
ign
Wo
rkin
gG
rou
po
n2
3rd
Au
gust
(agr
ou
pse
tu
pb
yH
S2Lt
dan
dth
eo
nly
me
etin
go
fth
isgr
ou
ph
eld
sofa
r)w
ew
ere
no
tto
ldo
fan
yp
rogr
ess
wit
hth
e/a
mas
ter
pla
no
nly
that
the
Eust
on
Stat
ion
Stra
tegi
cR
edev
elo
pm
en
tB
oar
dw
asre
spo
nsi
ble
for
it.
At
the
sam
em
eet
ing
we
wer
eto
ldth
atth
atan
arch
itec
tura
lco
mp
etit
ion
for
Eust
on
stat
ion
ann
ou
nce
din
earl
yA
pri
lth
isye
arw
ou
ldp
rob
ably
no
tn
ow
be
taki
ng
pla
ce.
At
am
eeti
ng
of
me
mb
ers
of
the
Rai
lway
Alt
ern
ativ
esTh
ink
Tan
kw
ith
Net
wo
rkR
ailo
n2
4th
Au
gust
we
wer
eto
ldth
atth
ere
was
asye
tn
om
aste
rp
lan
for
the
red
evel
op
me
nt
of
Eust
on
.Civ
ilse
rvan
tsat
the
Dep
artm
en
tfo
rTr
ansp
ort
wer
esa
idto
be
wo
rkin
gto
war
ds
such
ad
ocu
me
nt.
A34
0 (2
2)H
OL/
0077
0/00
23
HS2
Ltd
init
sp
ub
licst
atem
en
tssh
ow
sa
det
erm
inat
ion
toca
rry
thro
ugh
its
curr
ent
pla
ns
wit
ho
ut
del
ay.T
his
isp
arti
cula
rev
ide
nt
inth
ele
tter
toC
amd
en
fro
mH
S2d
ated
17
th
Au
gust
.
A34
0 (2
3)H
OL/
0077
0/00
24
Ale
tter
sen
tb
yC
amd
ento
pet
itio
ner
so
n2
6th
Au
gust
rep
ort
sth
at,i
nn
ego
tiat
ion
sb
etw
een
HS2
Ltd
and
Cam
den
,HS2
Ltd
had
reve
aled
that
itw
asco
nsi
der
ing
maj
or
chan
ges
toth
eA
P3
pla
ns:
this
lett
erm
en
tio
ns
inp
arti
cula
r‘p
oss
ibly
low
erin
gth
etr
acks
inth
eap
pro
ach
toEu
sto
n’a
nd
‘mo
vin
gth
etu
nn
elp
ort
alfu
rth
erso
uth
’.
A34
0 (2
4)H
OL/
0077
0/00
25
The
AP
3st
atio
nan
dth
eEu
sto
nap
pro
ach
fro
ma
railw
ayvi
ewp
oin
t
a)tr
ain
flo
ws
–cu
rren
tan
dp
red
icte
d
b)
Eust
on
Stat
ion
reco
nst
ruct
ion
–st
rate
gyan
do
pti
on
s
c)th
eH
S2A
P3
reco
nst
ruct
ion
op
tio
n
d)
dif
ficu
ltie
scr
eate
dfo
rth
ere
con
stru
ctio
no
fth
ere
mai
nin
gN
Rp
art
of
the
stat
ion
e)th
egr
ade
sep
arat
ion
‘bir
dca
ge’p
rop
ose
db
yH
S2fo
rth
eC
amd
enC
utt
ing
A34
0 (2
5)H
OL/
0077
0/00
26
Co
linEl
liff
BSc
CEn
gM
ICE
36
year
s’ex
per
ien
ceas
railw
ayci
vile
ngi
nee
rin
vari
ety
of
civi
ls&
mu
ltid
isci
plin
ary
pro
ject
s
Maj
or
stat
ion
reb
uild
pro
ject
s:W
ater
loo
Stat
ion
,Lo
nd
on
Bri
dge
,Po
rtsm
ou
thH
arb
ou
r
A34
0 (2
6)H
OL/
0077
0/00
27
Qu
enti
nM
acd
on
ald
BSc
(En
g)C
Eng
MIE
TFI
RSE
55
year
s’ex
per
ien
ceas
ara
ilway
sign
alen
gin
eer
and
latt
erly
asa
con
sult
ing
engi
nee
r.U
Kp
roje
cts
hav
ein
clu
ded
Ru
gby,
Gu
ildfo
rd,P
ort
smo
uth
,Bas
ings
toke
,K
ings
Cro
ss&
Pete
rbo
rou
gh.
Inte
rnat
ion
ally
he
has
wo
rked
inB
razi
l,Sl
ova
kia,
and
inth
eEu
rop
ean
Co
mm
issi
on
spec
ifyi
ng
the
Euro
pea
nTr
ain
Co
ntr
olS
yste
mfo
rth
eU
K.
A34
0 (2
7)H
OL/
0077
0/00
28
Pro
ble
ms
wit
hH
S2p
rop
osa
l•
Un
nec
essa
ryin
tru
sio
nin
tosu
rro
un
din
gco
mm
un
ity
•Ex
cess
ive
con
stru
ctio
ntr
affi
c,
esp
ecia
llysp
oil
•O
verl
on
gco
nst
ruct
ion
per
iod
•N
oar
chit
ectu
ralc
oh
eren
ce•
No
pro
ject
inte
grat
ion
•In
adeq
uat
era
ilway
des
ign
–ex
cess
ive
spee
d&
insu
ffic
ien
ttr
acks
A34
0 (2
8)H
OL/
0077
0/00
29
0100
200
300
400
500
SC
ALE
inm
etr
es
4A
PPR
OA
CH
TR
AC
KS
A-D
LIN
EX
18
PLA
TFO
RM
S
0100
200
300
400
500
SC
ALE
inm
etr
es
4A
PPR
OA
CH
TR
AC
KS
A-D
LIN
EX
18
PLA
TFO
RM
S
Eust
on
Stat
ion
in2
01
6
Exis
tin
gra
ilway
op
erat
ion
alb
ou
nd
ary
Pla
tfo
rms
&st
atio
nth
roat
A34
0 (2
9)H
OL/
0077
0/00
30
Ove
r-gr
ou
nd
12
Lon
do
nM
idla
nd
Eust
on
Stat
ion
in2
01
6
Cu
rren
tPe
akH
ou
rFl
ow
s
10
3
Vir
gin
25
tph
-1
8p
latf
orm
s
A34
0 (3
0)H
OL/
0077
0/00
31
Eust
on
Stat
ion
in2
01
6P
rese
nt
pla
tfo
rmo
ccu
pan
cy
Ru
leo
fth
um
bN
o.o
fp
latf
orm
s=
No
.of
trai
ns
per
ho
ur
2
So2
5tp
hin
18
pla
tfo
rms
isO
K
Bu
tm
ajo
rin
effi
cien
cies
exis
tin
thro
at
A34
0 (3
1)H
OL/
0077
0/00
32
‘Pla
tfo
rmR
efre
shTi
me’
PR
T=
Ap
pro
ach
Tim
e+
Dw
ellT
ime
+
Dep
artu
reTi
me
+M
argi
n
PR
T=
5m
ins
+1
5m
ins
+5
min
s+
5m
ins
=3
0m
ins
Eust
on
:25
trai
ns
inth
ep
eak
ho
ur
Live
rpo
olS
t:5
4tr
ain
sin
the
pea
kh
ou
r
ECM
Lex
amp
le:S
hin
kan
sen
exam
ple
A34
0 (3
2)H
OL/
0077
0/00
33
Eust
on
&Li
verp
oo
lStr
eet
Stat
ion
s-
pre
sen
t
©TR
AC
Km
aps
A34
0 (3
3)H
OL/
0077
0/00
34
Ove
r-gr
ou
nd
Eust
on
Stat
ion
wit
hH
S2
Peak
Ho
ur
Flo
ws
41
2
Vir
gin
Lon
do
nM
idla
nd
38
tph
-2
2p
latf
orm
s
18
HS2
4
40
0m
lon
g
A34
0 (3
4)H
OL/
0077
0/00
35
Ove
r-gr
ou
nd
Eust
on
Stat
ion
in2
04
0?
Peak
Ho
ur
Flo
ws
42
4
Vir
gin
Lon
do
nM
idla
nd
50
tph
-2
2p
latf
orm
s
18
HS2
4
A34
0 (3
5)H
OL/
0077
0/00
36
Ove
r-gr
ou
nd
Eust
on
Stat
ion
–2
04
0?
Peak
Ho
ur
Flo
ws
into
NR
stat
ion
42
4
Vir
gin
Lon
do
nM
idla
nd
32
tph
-1
3p
latf
orm
s
18
HS2
4
A34
0 (3
6)H
OL/
0077
0/00
37
Cu
rren
tEu
sto
nR
eco
nst
ruct
ion
Stra
tegy
Mu
stco
nsi
der
:•
HS2
Rec
on
stru
ctio
np
has
es
•N
RR
eco
nst
ruct
ion
•H
S2in
op
erat
ion
(fro
m2
02
6)
•C
om
mu
ter
exp
ansi
on
(20
40
)
A34
0 (3
7)H
OL/
0077
0/00
38
Ava
ilab
leR
eco
nst
ruct
ion
Op
tio
ns
❶1
8 p
latf
orm
s o
n e
xist
ing
foo
tpri
nt
❷M
ore
pla
tfo
rms
on
exi
stin
g fo
otp
rin
t
❸En
larg
e st
atio
n f
or
incr
ease
d s
ervi
ces
(HS2
p
refe
ren
ce)
❹M
anag
e tr
ain
flo
ws
to a
void
exp
and
ing
stat
ion
(CC
Ssc
hem
e)
A34
0 (3
8)H
OL/
0077
0/00
39
OP
TIO
N ❶
:R
etai
n1
8p
latf
orm
so
nex
isti
ng
foo
tpri
nt?
•W
on
’tco
pe
wit
h2
04
0sc
enar
ioo
r4
00
mtr
ain
len
gth
A34
0 (3
9)H
OL/
0077
0/00
40
OP
TIO
N ❷
Mo
rep
latf
orm
so
nex
isti
ng
foo
tpri
nt?
•N
ot
pra
ctic
able
du
eto
pro
gres
sive
rest
rict
ion
so
np
latf
orm
wid
th–
wh
eth
erin
sert
edin
toex
isti
ng
layo
ut
or
as
pa
rto
fco
mp
lete
reco
nst
ruct
ion
•C
ou
ldn
ot
cop
ew
ith
20
40
scen
ario
or
40
0m
trai
nle
ngt
h
A34
0 (4
0)H
OL/
0077
0/00
41
10.0
m
3.4
m13.2
m
C
10.0
m
3.4
m
4.6
m4.0
m4.6
m
LC L
C L
10.0
m10.0
m
Eust
on
Stat
ion
atcu
rren
t1
80
mto
talw
idth
18
pla
tfo
rms
–
4.6
mp
latf
orm
wid
that
stai
rs-
ad
equ
ate
A34
0 (4
1)H
OL/
0077
0/00
42
8.2
m
3.4
m9.6
m
C
8.2
m
3.4
m
2.8
m4.0
m2.8
m
LC L
C L
8.2
m8.2
m
Eust
on
Stat
ion
atcu
rren
t1
80
mto
talw
idth
22
pla
tfo
rms
–2
.8m
pla
tfo
rmw
idth
atst
airs
-in
ad
equ
ate
A34
0 (4
2)H
OL/
0077
0/00
43
OP
TIO
N ❸
:Ex
pan
dst
atio
nas
per
HS2
?
No
tac
cep
tab
led
ue
to:
•D
estr
uct
ion
of
ho
usi
ng
and
stre
etp
atte
rn•
Co
nst
ruct
ion
traf
fic
esp
ecia
llysp
oil
•C
on
stru
ctio
nd
ura
tio
n•
Lack
of
arch
itec
tura
lco
her
ence
•R
estr
icti
on
sim
po
sed
on
NR
reco
nst
ruct
ion
•Im
pac
to
nC
amd
enC
utt
ing
We
shal
llo
ok
atth
ela
sttw
oas
pec
ts
A34
0 (4
3)H
OL/
0077
0/00
44
HS2
atEu
sto
nst
atio
n:
pro
po
sed
wes
twar
dex
pan
sio
n
0100
200
300
400
500
SC
ALE
inm
etr
es
11
HIG
HSPEED
PLA
TFO
RM
S
ST
AT
ION
EXPA
ND
S60m
TO
WEST
11
CLA
SSIC
PLA
TFO
RM
SR
EM
AIN
ING
,N
OR
EBU
ILD
2A
PPR
OA
CH
TR
AC
KS
INT
UN
NEL
FLY
OV
ER
UN
DER
CU
TS
PA
RK
VIL
LA
GE
EA
ST
A34
0 (4
4)H
OL/
0077
0/00
45
Post
HS2
sch
eme,
AP
3st
age
B2
Net
wo
rkR
ailO
pti
on
s
(fro
mR
ed
eve
lop
me
nt
of
Eust
on
Co
nve
nti
on
alSt
atio
n:
Fea
sib
ility
Sta
ge
Sum
ma
ry,D
raft
,1/8
/16
)
‘Net
wo
rkR
ail
will
focu
sco
nce
pt
leve
lwo
rko
nth
efo
llow
ing
stra
teg
ico
pti
on
s:
•Le
velD
eck
Des
ign
•Sp
litLe
velD
esig
n
•R
efu
rbis
hm
ent’
A34
0 (4
5)H
OL/
0077
0/00
46
Ref
urb
ish
men
to
nly
of
NR
stat
ion
•Te
chn
ical
lyfe
asib
le
•W
ork
sto
con
cou
rse
bu
tn
ot
totr
acks
•A
rch
itec
tura
lly&
po
litic
ally
un
acce
pta
ble
A34
0 (4
6)H
OL/
0077
0/00
47
NR
split
leve
ldes
ign
•Im
po
ssib
leto
acco
mm
od
ate
full
trai
nfl
ow
du
rin
gre
bu
ild
•C
an’t
div
ert
tolo
wer
leve
lHS2
trac
ks
•M
ajo
rd
isru
pti
on
tose
rvic
eso
ncl
assi
cn
etw
ork
•So
me
trai
ns
tote
rmin
ate
atW
illes
den
or
Qu
een
sPa
rk?
A34
0 (4
7)H
OL/
0077
0/00
48
NR
leve
ldec
kd
esig
n
•Im
po
ssib
leto
acco
mm
od
ate
full
trai
nfl
ow
du
rin
gre
bu
ild
•H
uge
pro
ble
ms
inlo
wer
ing
trac
ksin
thro
atan
dst
eep
enin
gEu
sto
nin
clin
e
•M
ajo
rd
isru
pti
on
tose
rvic
eso
ncl
assi
cn
etw
ork
•So
me
trai
ns
tote
rmin
ate
atW
illes
den
or
Qu
een
sPa
rk?
A34
0 (4
8)H
OL/
0077
0/00
49
Wit
han
yN
Ro
pti
on
un
der
AP
3
•St
atio
nh
uge
lyst
rain
edb
ym
axim
um
pro
ject
edW
CM
Lco
mm
ute
rfl
ow
s.
•3
2tp
hin
13
pla
tfo
rms
equ
ival
ent
tom
axim
um
flo
ws
atW
ater
loo
or
Live
rpo
olS
tree
t
A34
0 (4
9)H
OL/
0077
0/00
50
Cam
den
Cu
ttin
gp
rob
lem
s:
HS2
’s‘t
hro
at’(
pu
rpo
seo
fth
roat
tosp
read
lines
into
pla
tfo
rms)
•6
00
mle
ngt
hu
np
rece
den
ted
•‘1
1in
to1
’co
nfi
gura
tio
nu
np
rece
den
ted
.•
Att
rib
uta
ble
toh
igh
spee
d&
two
trac
km
ain
line.
•‘B
ird
cage
’str
uct
ure
exce
ssiv
ely
was
tefu
lo
fsp
ace
•N
oco
nst
ant
flo
or
leve
lwit
hin
bir
dca
gem
ayco
mp
rom
ise
stru
ttin
gac
tio
n
A34
0 (5
0)H
OL/
0077
0/00
51
0100
200
300
400
500
SC
ALE
inm
etr
es
11
HIG
HSPEED
PLA
TFO
RM
S
ST
AT
ION
EXPA
ND
S60m
TO
WEST
11
CLA
SSIC
PLA
TFO
RM
SR
EM
AIN
ING
,N
OR
EBU
ILD
2A
PPR
OA
CH
TR
AC
KS
INT
UN
NEL
FLY
OV
ER
UN
DER
CU
TS
PA
RK
VIL
LA
GE
EA
ST
TH
RO
AT
LEN
GT
H
EUST
ON
STA
TIO
N
HS2
:
60
0m
lon
gth
roat
11
-to
-on
eco
nfi
gura
tio
n
10
0kp
hd
esi
gnsp
ee
dis
sue
s
A34
0 (5
1)H
OL/
0077
0/00
52
HS2
Poin
tLength
21
.3m 40
.5m
BV
8–
20
MP
H
EV1
5–
40
MP
H
A34
0 (5
2)H
OL/
0077
0/00
53
HS2
‘Bir
dca
ge’s
tru
ctu
rein
Cam
den
Cu
ttin
g
A34
0 (5
3)H
OL/
0077
0/00
54
Bir
dca
geSt
ruct
ure
–H
S2
Dem
olis
hed
reta
inin
gw
all
AB
CD
A34
0 (5
4)H
OL/
0077
0/00
55
OP
TIO
N ❹
: M
anag
etr
ain
flo
ws
We
can
’tfi
nd
anac
cep
tab
leso
luti
on
toex
pan
dth
est
atio
nto
acco
mm
od
ate
extr
atr
ain
flo
ws.
We
sho
uld
loo
kat
man
agin
gth
etr
ain
flo
ws
soth
atth
est
atio
nd
oes
no
tn
eed
tob
eex
pan
ded
.
A34
0 (5
5)H
OL/
0077
0/00
56
Cam
den
Civ
icSo
ciet
y’s
con
clu
sio
ns
abo
ut
the
pro
ble
ms
wit
hth
eA
P3
sch
eme
atEu
sto
nan
dth
eir
cau
ses
A34
0 (5
6)H
OL/
0077
0/00
57
The
Cam
den
Civ
icSo
ciet
yse
esth
ere
bu
ildin
go
fth
eN
etw
ork
Rai
lsta
tio
nat
stag
eB
2,a
fter
the
‘Eu
sto
nH
S2St
atio
n’h
asb
een
bu
iltan
dis
up
and
run
nin
g,as
hig
hly
pro
ble
mat
ican
dim
po
ssib
lew
ith
ou
tve
ryse
vere
dis
rup
tio
nto
exis
tin
gse
rvic
es.
We
see
the
pro
po
salf
or
the
cutt
ing,
mo
rep
arti
cula
rly
a‘b
ird
cage
’in
corp
ora
tin
ga
grad
ese
par
atio
nju
nct
ion
,as
un
pre
ced
ente
d,p
oss
ibly
stru
ctu
rally
un
wo
rkab
lean
dce
rtai
nly
was
tefu
lof
spac
ein
this
wel
l-kn
ow
nra
ilway
bo
ttle
nec
k.
Des
pit
eth
is,t
he
chan
geto
the
AP
3sc
hem
eaw
ayfr
om
aco
mp
reh
ensi
vere
dev
elo
pm
ent
of
Eust
on
has
alw
ays
bee
np
ut
forw
ard
asa
mea
ns
tore
du
ced
isru
pti
on
toN
etw
ork
Rai
ltra
ins
and
thei
rp
asse
nge
rs.
No
tein
par
ticu
lar
the
SES2
at3
.3.1
:
“to
dev
elop
an
impr
oved
des
ign
an
dco
nst
ruct
ion
sta
gin
gfo
rE
usto
nst
ati
ona
nd
app
roa
ch.T
his
ha
sin
part
icul
ar,
soug
ht
toim
prov
eth
eca
paci
tya
nd
resi
lien
ceof
the
con
ven
tion
alr
ailw
ay
an
dst
ati
on,d
urin
gco
nst
ruct
ion
an
dov
erth
elo
nge
rte
rm”
A34
0 (5
7)H
OL/
0077
0/00
58
Lord
Ah
mad
,Par
liam
enta
ryU
nd
erSe
cret
ary
of
Stat
efo
rTr
ansp
ort
,mad
eth
esa
me
po
int
inh
iso
pen
ing
spee
chat
the
Lord
sSe
con
dR
ead
ing
14
thA
pri
l20
16
-W
ew
illd
eliv
erth
en
ewH
S2st
ati
on
at
Eust
on
ina
ph
ase
da
pp
roa
chto
red
uce
dis
rup
tio
nto
the
exis
tin
gra
ilwa
ya
nd
hel
pb
ette
rm
an
ag
eim
pa
cts
on
the
wid
era
rea
.
That
red
uct
ion
inth
ed
isru
pti
on
toth
eex
isti
ng
railw
ayw
asth
ep
art
of
the
reas
on
ing
beh
ind
AP
3w
asal
soco
nfi
rmed
by
aN
etw
ork
Rai
lsp
oke
sman
:
Ru
per
tW
alk
er,t
he
Eust
on
dev
elo
pm
ent
dir
ecto
rfo
rH
S2a
nd
Net
wo
rkR
ail,
said
the
ori
gin
alp
lan
sd
idn
ot
ma
keth
em
ost
of
red
evel
op
men
to
pp
ort
un
itie
sa
nd
mea
nt
“dis
rup
tio
nto
pa
ssen
ger
sw
ou
ldh
ave
bee
na
rea
liss
ue”
.H
esa
idp
lan
ner
sh
ad
“red
esig
ned
fro
mth
eb
ott
om
up
,an
dre
view
edev
ery
sin
gle
req
uir
emen
tfo
rth
en
eed
so
fH
S2,r
ail
pa
ssen
ger
sa
nd
the
com
mu
nit
y”,
Gu
ard
ian
8.9
.15
A34
0 (5
8)H
OL/
0077
0/00
59
Ho
ww
asth
issi
tuat
ion
arri
ved
at?
Extr
act
fro
mLo
rds
Eco
no
mic
Aff
airs
Co
mm
itte
e's
qu
esti
on
ing
of
the
Ch
ance
llor
of
the
Exch
equ
ero
n8
thSe
pte
mb
er.T
he
Ch
air
isLo
rdH
olli
ck:
•Q
21
The
Ch
air
ma
n:
Co
uld
Ifin
ish
on
ara
ther
na
rro
wp
aro
chia
lpo
int?
Wh
enw
eco
nd
uct
edo
ur
inve
stig
ati
on
into
HS2
,wh
ere
we
con
clu
ded
tha
tth
eca
sew
as
no
tm
ad
e—p
erh
ap
syo
uw
illco
nsi
der
hit
tin
gth
ere
set
an
dp
au
seb
utt
on
on
tha
ta
syo
uh
ave
do
ne
on
Hin
kley
—o
ne
of
ou
rco
nce
rns
wa
sth
at
the
pro
cess
wit
hin
the
Go
vern
men
tto
eva
lua
teth
ese
sort
so
fp
roje
cts
left
mu
chto
be
des
ired
.Th
eref
ore
,we
too
kg
rea
tco
mfo
rtw
hen
you
rp
red
eces
sor
an
no
un
ced
the
Na
tio
na
lIn
fra
stru
ctu
reC
om
mis
sio
n,w
hic
hw
ou
ldb
ea
sep
ara
test
atu
tory
bo
dy
wit
hre
spo
nsi
bili
tyfo
rlo
oki
ng
into
thes
eth
ing
sa
nd
rep
ort
ing
sep
ara
tely
toP
arl
iam
ent
an
dto
the
pu
blic
at
larg
eso
tha
tsu
pp
ort
can
be
bu
iltb
ase
do
na
fact
ua
lan
aly
sis.
Do
esit
rem
ain
you
rin
ten
tio
nto
pu
tth
eN
ati
on
alI
nfr
ast
ruct
ure
Co
mm
issi
on
on
toa
sta
tuto
ryb
asi
s?
A34
0 (5
9)H
OL/
0077
0/00
60
At
Eust
on
,th
eC
amd
enC
ivic
Soci
ety
sees
the
cau
ses
of
the
po
or
dec
isio
nm
akin
gas
follo
ws.
We
bel
ieve
that
dec
isio
nm
akin
gh
asb
een
too
relia
nt
on
step
-by-
step
pla
nn
ing
–‘k
eyp
roje
ctst
ages
’as
exem
plif
ied
by
GR
IP(G
ove
rnan
cefo
rR
ailw
ayIn
vest
men
tP
roje
cts)
and
the
RIB
AP
lan
of
Wo
rk.
This
met
ho
do
fm
ovi
ng
forw
ard
isn
ot
ino
ur
view
app
rop
riat
efo
ra
pro
ject
of
this
size
.In
the
firs
tp
lace
itd
oes
no
tlo
ok
eno
ugh
atth
eco
nte
xt–
the
ph
ysic
alco
nte
xt,a
sfo
rex
amp
lein
the
mis
un
der
stan
din
g/m
isre
pre
sen
tati
on
of
Her
itag
eA
sset
s,an
dm
ore
imp
ort
antl
yth
eco
nte
xto
fth
eco
mm
un
itie
sim
pac
ted
and
,mo
rege
ner
ally
,peo
ple
just
gett
ing
on
wit
hth
eir
lives
.
We
bel
ieve
this
app
roac
hb
reed
sa
bo
x-ti
ckin
go
utl
oo
k,a
kin
do
fb
lind
nes
sto
bro
ader
qu
esti
on
s.Th
isis
refl
ecte
din
the
failu
reo
fH
S2Lt
dto
reco
rdd
iscu
ssio
ns
wit
hlo
calp
etit
ion
ers,
on
lyA
ctio
nPo
ints
,as
inth
eex
amp
leab
ove
fro
mth
e‘S
tati
on
Des
ign
Wo
rkin
gG
rou
p’.
GR
IP,o
rsi
mila
rp
roce
du
res,
also
evid
entl
yle
ave
too
mu
chd
etai
lto
too
late
ast
age
-w
eh
ave
oft
enb
een
told
,par
ticu
larl
yin
rela
tio
nto
the
Bir
dca
ge,‘
we
do
n’t
kno
wth
ean
swer
toyo
ur
qu
esti
on
yet,
we
are
leav
ing
ho
wto
con
stru
ctth
isas
pec
to
fo
ur
des
ign
toth
eco
ntr
acto
rs’.
This
app
roac
hd
oes
no
tal
low
pro
ble
ms
toem
erge
earl
yen
ou
gh,w
het
her
pro
ble
ms
just
of
po
or
cho
ice
or
of
actu
alfe
asib
ility
.
Inth
isve
ryla
rge
pro
ject
,th
esa
lam
islic
ing
of
the
sch
eme
into
sect
ion
s,C
F01
inth
eca
seo
fth
eEu
sto
nA
rea,
isal
soa
fau
lt.T
hu
s,at
on
ean
dth
esa
me
tim
eth
eo
verv
iew
islo
stan
dth
elo
calit
yis
give
nst
and
ard
trea
tmen
t,it
su
niq
ue
char
acte
rist
ics
ign
ore
do
rn
ot
even
per
ceiv
ed.
Inth
eca
seo
fth
ed
evel
op
men
to
fth
eH
S2d
esig
n,t
his
gen
eral
ten
den
cyis
amp
lifie
db
yo
veru
seo
fco
ntr
acto
rsin
the
earl
yst
ages
,par
ticu
larl
yin
this
case
Aru
ps.
A34
0 (6
0)H
OL/
0077
0/00
61
The
bel
ieve
that
po
or
dec
isio
nm
akin
gsi
mila
rto
that
seen
atEu
sto
nis
evid
ent
inth
eco
un
tryw
ide
HS2
sch
eme.
We
see
asth
ree
key
exam
ple
so
fp
oo
rd
ecis
ion
mak
ing
cou
ntr
ywid
e:
•Th
ech
oic
eto
avo
idap
par
entl
yas
far
asp
oss
ible
inte
grat
ion
wit
hth
eex
isti
ng
railw
ayn
etw
ork
•Th
ech
oic
eo
fex
cess
ive
and
un
pre
ced
ente
dsp
eed
–w
ith
ab
uilt
-in
cap
acit
yfo
r4
00
kph
•Th
ech
oic
eo
fto
ofe
wh
igh
spee
dtr
acks
–tw
oin
stea
do
ffo
ur.
All
thes
eth
ree
pro
ble
ms
exis
to
na
smal
ler
scal
eat
Eust
on
,as
ou
rp
rese
nta
tio
nh
asse
to
ut.
A34
0 (6
1)H
OL/
0077
0/00
62
The
Cam
den
Civ
icSo
ciet
yal
tern
ativ
era
ilway
sch
eme
for
the
stat
ion
and
its
app
roac
h
A34
0 (6
2)H
OL/
0077
0/00
63
Cam
den
Civ
icSo
ciet
ySc
hem
e(t
he
Lon
do
nen
do
fth
eco
un
tryw
ide
HSU
Ksc
hem
e)
•m
akes
spac
eat
Eust
on
by
man
agin
gtr
ain
flo
ws
•re
bu
ilds
stat
ion
ina
con
tin
uo
us
seq
uen
ce
•b
rin
gstr
ain
sin
toap
pro
ach
info
ur
tun
nel
s
A34
0 (6
3)H
OL/
0077
0/00
64
OP
TIO
N ❹
as p
art
of
the
Cam
den
Civ
icSo
ciet
ysc
hem
e:
Man
age
trai
nfl
ow
s?
A34
0 (6
4)H
OL/
0077
0/00
65
HS2
Ltd
asse
ssm
ent
of
HS
pla
tfo
rms
on
Eust
on
Stat
ion
exis
tin
gfo
otp
rin
t
Ref
P8
46
/93
9H
S2Lt
dev
ide
nce
sub
mis
sio
nd
ate
d3
0/1
1/2
01
5
A34
0 (6
5)H
OL/
0077
0/00
66
HS2
Ltd
asse
ssm
ent
–cu
t&
pas
tejo
b?
A34
0 (6
6)H
OL/
0077
0/00
67
Reg
ion
al/l
oca
lflo
ws
•W
ork
bes
tb
yav
oid
ing
term
inat
ing,
asp
erC
ross
rail
or
Pari
sian
RER
.
•A
void
sho
cklo
ado
fd
etra
inin
gat
Eust
on
.
•B
ette
rra
nge
of
des
tin
atio
ns
for
com
mu
ters
.
A34
0 (6
7)H
OL/
0077
0/00
68
Ho
wd
ow
em
ake
this
pri
nci
ple
wo
rkfo
rEu
sto
n?
•N
ewW
CM
Llin
kto
Cro
ssra
ilat
Old
Oak
Co
mm
on
?
•N
ewEu
sto
n-C
har
ing
Cro
sslin
kvi
a‘C
ross
rail
3*’
?
A34
0 (6
8)H
OL/
0077
0/00
69
The
RER
/Cro
ssra
ilP
rin
cip
leEU
ST
ON
HEA
TH
RO
WA
IRPO
RTW
CM
LEC
ML
MM
L
GW
ML
Chil
tern
Chil
tern
A40
A5
M1
A406
NO
RT
HC
IRC
ULA
R
HS1
PA
DD
ING
TO
N
LIV
ER
PO
OL
ST
REET
CR
OSSR
AIL
@14tp
h14tp
h24tp
h
OLD
OA
KC
OM
MO
N
A34
0 (6
9)H
OL/
0077
0/00
70
Cro
ssra
il–
WC
ML
Lin
ko
pti
on
HEA
TH
RO
WA
IRPO
RTW
CM
LEC
ML
MM
L
GW
ML
Chil
tern
Chil
tern
A40
A5
M1
A406
NO
RT
HC
IRC
ULA
R
HS1
PA
DD
ING
TO
N
LIV
ER
PO
OL
ST
REET
CR
OSSR
AIL
@14tp
h
CR
OSS
RA
IL@
10tp
h
EU
ST
ON
CX
LB
CR
OSS
RA
IL@
24tp
h
OLD
OA
KC
OM
MO
N
A34
0 (7
0)H
OL/
0077
0/00
71
New
‘Cro
ssra
il3
*’o
pti
on
by
20
40
HEA
TH
RO
WA
IRPO
RTW
CM
LEC
ML
MM
L
GW
ML
Chil
tern
Chil
tern
A40
A5
M1
A406
NO
RT
HC
IRC
ULA
R
HS1
PA
DD
ING
TO
N
LIV
ER
PO
OL
ST
REET
CR
OSSR
AIL
3/
WEST
LIN
K
EU
ST
ON
CX
LB
OLD
OA
KC
OM
MO
N
A34
0 (7
1)H
OL/
0077
0/00
72
Cro
ssra
il–
WC
ML
Lin
kO
bje
ctiv
e–
toel
imin
ate
suff
icie
nt
trai
ns
fro
mEu
sto
nto
enab
le:
•Ef
fici
ent
reco
nst
ruct
ion
•R
eco
nst
ruct
ion
wit
hin
exis
tin
gfo
otp
rin
t
•Fu
ture
pro
ofi
ng
un
til2
03
3
A34
0 (7
2)H
OL/
0077
0/00
73
Cro
ssra
il–
WC
ML
Lin
k•
exp
loit
ssp
are
cap
acit
yo
nC
ross
rail
•1
0sp
are
pat
hs
–o
nly
5tp
hlo
cals
ervi
ces
tote
rmin
ate
atEu
sto
n•
on
ly2
kmo
fsu
rfac
eco
nst
ruct
ion
req
uir
ed•
£1
00
Mes
tim
ated
cost
•ac
cess
esal
lof
WC
ML
corr
ido
rin
clu
din
gM
ilto
nK
eyn
es&
Wat
ford
•m
ore
stat
ion
sco
nn
ecte
dto
OO
Cth
anw
ith
HS2
A34
0 (7
3)H
OL/
0077
0/00
74
Pla
ns
tolin
kto
Trin
gto
am
ajo
rcr
oss
-co
un
try
rail
net
wo
rkh
ave
be
ensh
elve
db
yth
ego
vern
me
nt
Pu
blis
he
dFr
iday
05
Au
gust
20
16
Ina
lett
er
toH
em
elH
em
pst
ead
MP
Mik
eP
en
nin
g,fo
rme
rtr
ansp
ort
secr
etar
yP
atri
ckM
cLo
ugh
linsa
idth
esc
he
me
has
be
en
pu
lled
be
cau
seit
rep
rese
nte
d“p
oo
ro
vera
llva
lue
for
mo
ney
toth
eta
xpay
er”.
Alt
ho
ugh
the
lett
erex
plic
itly
men
tio
ns
Trin
g,M
rPe
nn
ing
said
he
was
tryi
ng
tofi
nd
ou
tw
hat
itm
ean
tfo
ro
ther
sto
ps
alo
ng
the
line.
The
new
sco
mes
asa
blo
wto
com
mu
ters
,wh
oth
ou
ght
the
exte
nsi
on
wo
uld
take
the
pre
ssu
reo
ffth
elin
ein
toEu
sto
nd
uri
ng
the
con
stru
ctio
no
fth
eH
S2h
igh
-sp
eed
rail
link.
On
eLo
nd
on
wo
rker
,wh
oas
ked
tore
mai
nan
on
ymo
us,
said
:“W
eal
read
yh
ave
top
ut
up
wit
hex
pen
sive
,o
verc
row
ded
trai
ns
that
are
freq
uen
tly
del
ayed
or
can
celle
d.
“If
HS2
goes
ahea
d,E
ust
on
stat
ion
will
be
ab
uild
ing
site
for
man
yye
ars,
add
ing
too
ur
dai
lym
iser
y.“T
hat
’sw
hy
I,an
dm
any
of
my
fello
wco
mm
ute
rs,w
elco
med
the
pro
po
sals
toex
ten
dC
ross
rail
toTr
ing.
“Th
isd
ecis
ion
tosh
elve
the
pla
ns
wit
ho
ut
any
pu
blic
ity
feel
slik
ean
oth
erki
ckin
the
teet
hfo
rh
ard
-pre
ssed
rail
trav
elle
rs.
“Io
nly
ho
pe
that
ther
ew
illb
ea
re-t
hin
ko
nce
min
iste
rsgr
asp
the
eno
rmo
us
scal
eo
fd
isru
pti
on
that
HS2
will
cau
seat
Eust
on
.”Th
em
ove
wo
uld
hav
em
ean
ttr
ain
sto
Hea
thro
wte
rmin
als
1,2
and
3fr
om
Hem
elH
emp
stea
d,w
ith
ach
ange
atO
ldO
akC
om
mo
n,a
sw
ella
sse
rvic
esto
Bo
nd
Stre
etan
dFa
rrin
gdo
nru
nn
ing
fro
mTr
ing.
Asp
oke
sper
son
for
the
Dep
artm
ent
for
Tran
spo
rtsa
id:“
Are
view
of
the
bu
sin
ess
case
for
this
exte
nsi
on
has
be
en
exp
lore
dan
dco
ncl
ud
ed
the
cost
curr
en
tly
do
es
no
tre
pre
sen
tgo
od
valu
efo
rm
on
ey.
“Ho
wev
er,t
he
Met
rop
olit
anLi
ne
will
be
exte
nd
edto
Wat
ford
Jun
ctio
nb
y2
02
0an
dw
illal
low
trai
ns
toru
nto
cen
tral
Lon
do
nev
ery
10
min
ute
sin
pea
kh
ou
rs.”
A34
0 (7
4)H
OL/
0077
0/00
75
Ove
r-gr
ou
nd
3
Lon
do
nM
idla
nd
Eust
on
Stat
ion
–C
CS
Reb
uild
Peak
Ho
ur
Flo
ws
10
3
Vir
gin
16
tph
-8
pla
tfo
rms
A34
0 (7
5)H
OL/
0077
0/00
76
0100
200
300
400
500
SC
ALE
inm
etr
es
8PLA
TFO
RM
SR
EM
AIN
INU
SE,
10
CLO
SED
INPH
ASED
REBU
ILD
EUST
ON
STA
TIO
N
CC
So
pti
on
2-s
tage
reb
uild
a) No
tep
ote
nti
alfo
rsp
oil
rem
ova
lb
yra
il
A34
0 (7
6)H
OL/
0077
0/00
77
0100
200
300
400
500
SC
ALE
inm
etr
es
8N
EW
P/F
sBU
ILT
IN1
stPH
ASE
4A
PPR
OA
CH
TR
AC
KS
INT
UN
NEL
EUST
ON
STA
TIO
N
CC
So
pti
on
2-s
tage
reb
uild
b)
A34
0 (7
7)H
OL/
0077
0/00
78
0100
200
300
400
500
SC
ALE
inm
etr
es
APPR
OA
CH
TR
AC
KS
SLU
ED
INT
ON
EW
PLA
TFO
RM
S,
REM
AIN
DER
OF
ST
AT
ION
REBU
ILT
EUST
ON
STA
TIO
N
CC
So
pti
on
2-s
tage
reb
uild
c)
A34
0 (7
8)H
OL/
0077
0/00
79
0100
200
300
400
500
SC
ALE
inm
etr
es
6C
LA
SSIC
PLA
TFO
RM
SFEED
4T
RA
CK
S
12
HIG
HSPEED
PLA
TFO
RM
SFEED
4T
RA
CK
S
4A
PPR
OA
CH
TR
AC
KS
INT
UN
NEL
EUST
ON
STA
TIO
N
CC
So
pti
on
com
ple
ted
A34
0 (7
9)H
OL/
0077
0/00
80
Ove
r-gr
ou
nd
Eust
on
Stat
ion
–p
ost
HSU
K
Peak
Ho
ur
Flo
ws
33
Vir
gin
Lon
do
nM
idla
nd
34
tph
-1
8p
latf
orm
s
24
CC
SO
pti
on
4
40
0m
lon
g
A34
0 (8
0)H
OL/
0077
0/00
81
CC
Sfu
llin
tegr
atio
nac
com
plis
hes
:•
Div
ersi
on
of
loca
l/re
gio
nal
serv
ices
avo
idin
gn
eed
toex
pan
dEu
sto
nst
atio
n•
Div
ersi
on
of
loca
l/re
gio
nal
serv
ices
for
sim
plif
ied
reco
nst
ruct
ion
of
enti
rest
atio
n.
•Sp
oil
rem
ove
db
yra
il•
6-8
year
tota
lreb
uild
pro
gram
me
•Im
pro
ved
com
mu
ter
jou
rney
s&
red
uce
dco
nge
stio
n•
Arc
hit
ectu
rally
coh
eren
tst
atio
n.
•es
tim
ated
£2
bill
ion
savi
ngs
A34
0 (8
1)H
OL/
0077
0/00
82
CC
Sd
esig
nac
hie
ves:
•P
latf
orm
sci
rca
13
mw
ide
fro
mb
uff
ers
toap
pro
xim
atel
ym
idp
oin
t•
Pla
tfo
rms
wid
erth
anH
S2p
latf
orm
s•
Pla
tfo
rms
tap
erin
gto
circ
a7
mw
ide
atC
ou
ntr
yen
d•
Pla
tfo
rms
com
pat
ible
wit
hm
ajo
ro
vers
ite
dev
elo
pm
ent
•Ex
itsp
eed
circ
a2
5M
PH
•C
reat
esti
me
pen
alty
of
on
ly2
2se
con
ds
com
par
edw
ith
HS2
exit
fro
mp
latf
orm
s
A34
0 (8
2)H
OL/
0077
0/00
83
Cam
den
Cu
ttin
gC
CS
solu
tio
n:
•Lo
wer
des
ign
spee
d
•M
ore
effi
cien
t&
sho
rter
thro
at
•C
on
ven
tio
nal
‘6in
to1
’des
ign
,re
plic
ated
3ti
mes
.
•4
hig
hsp
eed
trac
ksap
pro
ach
ing
Eust
on
•C
CS
tun
nel
entr
yst
ruct
ure
mo
resp
ace-
effi
cien
t
•N
on
eed
tod
isru
pt
Park
Vill
age
East
A34
0 (8
3)H
OL/
0077
0/00
84
Park
Vill
age
East
Bir
dca
geSt
ruct
ure
–H
S2
Dem
olis
hed
reta
inin
gw
all
AB
CD
A34
0 (8
4)H
OL/
0077
0/00
85
Bir
dca
geSt
ruct
ure
–C
CS
Ret
ain
ing
wal
lre
mai
ns
inp
lace A
BC
D
Park
Vill
age
East
rem
ain
so
pen
A34
0 (8
5)H
OL/
0077
0/00
86
Inco
ncl
usi
on
,we
gob
ack
toth
eag
reed
com
mu
nit
yas
ks,a
nd
add
toth
iso
ur
req
ues
tth
atth
eC
am
den
Civ
icSo
ciet
ya
lter
na
tive
sch
eme,
toge
ther
wit
hth
eo
ther
railw
ayal
tern
ativ
esb
ein
gp
rese
nte
dto
You
rLo
rsh
ips’
Co
mm
itte
e,b
ein
dep
end
entl
yas
sess
edan
dth
atth
isas
sess
men
tb
em
ade
avai
lab
leto
you
bef
ore
you
wri
teyo
ur
fin
alre
po
rt.
Cam
de
nR
esi
de
nts
’Rai
lway
Alt
ern
ativ
es
Thin
kTa
nk
Pri
nci
ple
Eust
on
‘ask
s’–
for
pu
blic
mee
tin
g1
8th
July
20
16
1.
Eust
on
stat
ion
and
its
app
roac
hsh
ou
ldre
mai
nw
ith
inth
eir
exis
tin
gfo
otp
rin
to
nth
eea
ster
n
and
wes
tern
sid
es(i
tm
ayb
en
eces
sary
toex
ten
dso
uth
war
ds
tow
ard
sEu
sto
nR
oad
the
pla
tfo
rms
for
the
lon
gest
trai
ns)
.
2.
An
ew‘h
olis
tic’
des
ign
isn
eed
ed,c
ove
rin
gth
est
atio
nb
uild
ing,
the
pla
tfo
rms
and
the
trac
ks
inth
eap
pro
ach
.
3.
The
new
des
ign
sho
uld
be
wel
lin
tegr
ated
wit
hlo
calp
ub
lictr
ansp
ort
and
inp
arti
cula
rsh
ou
ld
inco
rpo
rate
the
wes
tern
end
of
the
pla
nn
edC
ross
rail
2st
atio
n.
4.
Ad
ou
ble
-dec
kd
esig
nw
ou
ldal
low
ast
atio
no
fm
inim
alw
idth
.
5.
Asi
ngl
eau
tho
rity
sho
uld
be
resp
on
sib
lefo
rth
ep
lan
nin
gan
dre
dev
elo
pm
ent
of
Eust
on
–w
e
envi
sage
this
bei
ng
Net
wo
rkR
ail(
the
auth
ori
tyo
fth
eh
igh
spee
dra
ilco
mp
any
sho
uld
ceas
e
atth
eir
tun
nel
po
rtal
s).[
Ple
ase
no
te–
this
isa
new
ask
!]
6.
The
reb
uild
ing
of
Eust
on
sho
uld
be
aco
nti
nu
ou
sp
roce
ssan
dsh
ou
ldn
ot
be
div
ided
up
into
self
-co
nta
ined
‘ph
ases
’.
7.
The
len
gth
of
tim
eta
ken
by
the
reb
uild
ing
sho
uld
be
assh
ort
asp
oss
ible
.
8.
Toal
low
tim
efo
rth
eb
est
pro
po
salf
or
Eust
on
tob
efo
un
dan
dim
ple
men
ted
,Ph
ase
Atr
ain
s
sho
uld
use
Old
Oak
Co
mm
on
asa
tem
po
rary
term
inu
s.
9.
Ino
rder
tocr
eate
spac
efo
rh
igh
spee
dtr
ain
sat
Eust
on
,we
sup
po
rtth
ep
rop
osa
lof
the
Dep
artm
ent
for
Tran
spo
rtth
atC
ross
rail
1is
ext
end
edfr
om
Old
Oak
Co
mm
on
on
toth
e
WC
ML
asfa
ras
Trin
g(s
ore
pla
cin
gth
eTr
ing
and
Wat
ford
serv
ices
wh
ich
curr
entl
yco
me
into
Eust
on
).
10
.Sp
oil
sho
uld
be
rem
ove
dan
dm
ate
rial
sb
rou
ght
inas
far
asp
oss
ible
by
rail
–w
eb
elie
veth
at
75
%is
are
alis
tic
figu
refo
rEu
sto
nan
dth
eC
amd
enC
utt
ing.
11
.A
stat
ion
des
ign
wh
ich
isvi
sual
lyas
wel
las
fun
ctio
nal
lyco
her
ent
will
nee
dst
ron
gce
ntr
al
ove
rsig
ht;
too
man
yD
esig
nan
dB
uild
con
trac
tsw
illle
adto
ast
atio
nw
hic
hh
asn
ovi
sual
or
fun
ctio
nal
un
ity.
Her
oG
ran
ger-
Tayl
or
and
Ric
har
dP
erci
val1
8/7
/16
,cam
den
civi
cso
ciet
y@gm
ail.c
om
A34
0 (8
6)H
OL/
0077
0/00
87
Than
kyo
u!
A34
0 (8
7)H
OL/
0077
0/00
88
Fro
mth
e2
01
5re
po
rtV
alu
ing
Lon
do
n’s
Urb
anFo
rest
:R
esu
lts
of
the
Lon
do
ni-
Tree
Pro
ject
A34
0 (8
8)H
OL/
0077
0/00
89
Fro
mth
e2
01
5re
po
rtV
alu
ing
Lon
do
n’s
Urb
anFo
rest
:R
esu
lts
of
the
Lon
do
ni-
Tree
Pro
ject
A34
0 (8
9)H
OL/
0077
0/00
90
Ham
pst
ead
Ro
adan
dSt
Jam
es’
sC
hu
rch
in1
82
0fr
om
Old
an
dN
ewLo
nd
on
,18
73
-
A34
0 (9
0)H
OL/
0077
0/00
91
18
36
dra
win
gb
yJ
CB
ou
rne
of
railw
ayb
ein
gco
nst
ruct
edu
nd
erH
amp
stea
dR
oad
(Nat
ion
alR
ailw
ayM
use
um
,Bri
tish
Rai
lRec
ord
Off
ice
Co
llect
ion
)
A34
0 (9
1)H
OL/
0077
0/00
92
