13 March 201313rd MAXI Symposium Be Be. Talk Outline 1.Introduction to Be stars 2.Decretion vs....

30
13 March 2013 1 3rd MAXI Symposium 岡岡岡岡 岡岡岡岡岡岡岡岡岡岡 () Be 星星星星星星星星

Transcript of 13 March 201313rd MAXI Symposium Be Be. Talk Outline 1.Introduction to Be stars 2.Decretion vs....

Page 1: 13 March 201313rd MAXI Symposium Be Be. Talk Outline 1.Introduction to Be stars 2.Decretion vs. accretion 3.Interactions in binaries 4.Concluding remarks.

3rd MAXI Symposium 113 March 2013

岡崎敦男(北海学園大学工学部)

Be 星ガス円盤の物理

Page 2: 13 March 201313rd MAXI Symposium Be Be. Talk Outline 1.Introduction to Be stars 2.Decretion vs. accretion 3.Interactions in binaries 4.Concluding remarks.

3rd MAXI Symposium 2

Talk Outline

1. Introduction to Be stars

2. Decretion vs. accretion

3. Interactions in binaries

4. Concluding remarks

13 March 2013

Page 3: 13 March 201313rd MAXI Symposium Be Be. Talk Outline 1.Introduction to Be stars 2.Decretion vs. accretion 3.Interactions in binaries 4.Concluding remarks.

3rd MAXI Symposium 3

1. Introduction to Be stars

2. Decretion vs. accretion

3. Interactions in binaries

4. Concluding remarks

13 March 2013

Page 4: 13 March 201313rd MAXI Symposium Be Be. Talk Outline 1.Introduction to Be stars 2.Decretion vs. accretion 3.Interactions in binaries 4.Concluding remarks.

3rd MAXI Symposium 4

Be stars

(Porter & Rivinius 2003; Martayan 2010)

Definition

13 March 2013

(Martayan 2010)

Non-supergiant B-type stars, which once has shown Balmer lines in emission (“e” is for emission)

Page 5: 13 March 201313rd MAXI Symposium Be Be. Talk Outline 1.Introduction to Be stars 2.Decretion vs. accretion 3.Interactions in binaries 4.Concluding remarks.

3rd MAXI Symposium 5

Low-density, fastoutflow emitting UV radiation

(Vr ≈103 kms-1 )

Wind structure well explained by line-driven wind model (Castor+ 1975)

Two-component circumstellar envelope

Polar wind

Equatorial disk High-density region with optical

emission lines and IR excess13 March 2013

Page 6: 13 March 201313rd MAXI Symposium Be Be. Talk Outline 1.Introduction to Be stars 2.Decretion vs. accretion 3.Interactions in binaries 4.Concluding remarks.

3rd MAXI Symposium 6

Be stars

Inte

nsity

Wavelength

Hydrogenspectrum

Courtesy of Stan Owocki

13 March 2013

λ0

Page 7: 13 March 201313rd MAXI Symposium Be Be. Talk Outline 1.Introduction to Be stars 2.Decretion vs. accretion 3.Interactions in binaries 4.Concluding remarks.

3rd MAXI Symposium 7

Central star

Rapid rotationConventional interpretation: ~70-80%

of critical rotationCurrent idea: almost critical rotation

(~95% or more)increasing stellar rotation

Courtesy of Stan Owocki13 March 2013

Page 8: 13 March 201313rd MAXI Symposium Be Be. Talk Outline 1.Introduction to Be stars 2.Decretion vs. accretion 3.Interactions in binaries 4.Concluding remarks.

3rd MAXI Symposium 8

Population

(Martayan 2010)M

WS

MC

Be/B much higher in SMC than in MW

Metalicity effect?

13 March 2013

Page 9: 13 March 201313rd MAXI Symposium Be Be. Talk Outline 1.Introduction to Be stars 2.Decretion vs. accretion 3.Interactions in binaries 4.Concluding remarks.

3rd MAXI Symposium 9

1. Introduction to Be stars

2. Decretion vs. accretion

3. Interactions in binaries

4. Concluding remarks

13 March 2013

Page 10: 13 March 201313rd MAXI Symposium Be Be. Talk Outline 1.Introduction to Be stars 2.Decretion vs. accretion 3.Interactions in binaries 4.Concluding remarks.

3rd MAXI Symposium 10

Disk formation by viscous diffusion(Lee, Saio, Osaki 1991)

13 March 2013

outward drift by viscosity

mass ejection from star

(Carciofi & Bjorkman 2006 for detailed disk structure)

Viscous decretion disk model

Page 11: 13 March 201313rd MAXI Symposium Be Be. Talk Outline 1.Introduction to Be stars 2.Decretion vs. accretion 3.Interactions in binaries 4.Concluding remarks.

3rd MAXI Symposium 11

Be stars

Inte

nsity

Wavelength

Hydrogenspectrum

Courtesy of Stan Owocki

13 March 2013

λ0

Viscous decretion disk Keplerian

Equatorial disk Equatorial wind!≠

Page 12: 13 March 201313rd MAXI Symposium Be Be. Talk Outline 1.Introduction to Be stars 2.Decretion vs. accretion 3.Interactions in binaries 4.Concluding remarks.

3rd MAXI Symposium 12

? Viscosity

Mass injection: ON

13 March 2013

Mechanismunknown

Origin unknown

Decretion needs mass addition torque

decretion

accretion

ang. mom. inputMass injection: OFF

no ang. mom. input

Page 13: 13 March 201313rd MAXI Symposium Be Be. Talk Outline 1.Introduction to Be stars 2.Decretion vs. accretion 3.Interactions in binaries 4.Concluding remarks.

3rd MAXI Symposium 1313 March 2013

Disk formation and dissipation(Haubois+ 2012)

Formation Dissipation

α =0.1

α =1

Page 14: 13 March 201313rd MAXI Symposium Be Be. Talk Outline 1.Introduction to Be stars 2.Decretion vs. accretion 3.Interactions in binaries 4.Concluding remarks.

3rd MAXI Symposium 14

1. Introduction to Be stars

2. Decretion vs. accretion

3. Interactions in binaries

1. Tidal truncation

2. Tidal/radiative precession and warping

3. Wind-wind collision

4. Concluding remarks

13 March 2013

Page 15: 13 March 201313rd MAXI Symposium Be Be. Talk Outline 1.Introduction to Be stars 2.Decretion vs. accretion 3.Interactions in binaries 4.Concluding remarks.

3rd MAXI Symposium 15

1. Introduction to Be stars

2. Decretion vs. accretion

3. Interactions in binaries

1. Tidal truncation

2. Tidal/radiative precession and warping

3. Wind-wind collision

4. Concluding remarks

13 March 2013

Page 16: 13 March 201313rd MAXI Symposium Be Be. Talk Outline 1.Introduction to Be stars 2.Decretion vs. accretion 3.Interactions in binaries 4.Concluding remarks.

3rd MAXI Symposium 16

The longer the orbital period, the larger the maximum disk size

Correlation between Max{EW(H )} and in Be/X-ray binaries (Reig+ 1997)Porb

α

Observational support for tidal truncation

13 March 2013

Page 17: 13 March 201313rd MAXI Symposium Be Be. Talk Outline 1.Introduction to Be stars 2.Decretion vs. accretion 3.Interactions in binaries 4.Concluding remarks.

3rd MAXI Symposium 18

(Zamanov+ 2001)

Be disks denser in Be/X-ray binaries than in isolated Be stars (Zamanov+ 2001)

Typical Be disks

13 March 2013

Page 18: 13 March 201313rd MAXI Symposium Be Be. Talk Outline 1.Introduction to Be stars 2.Decretion vs. accretion 3.Interactions in binaries 4.Concluding remarks.

3rd MAXI Symposium 19

Viscous torques provide ang. mom. to disk (Lin & Papaloizou 1986)

Tidal (e=0)/resonant (e>0) torques remove ang. mom. from disk (Goldreich & Tremaine 1979, 1980)

(Artymowicz & Lubow 1994)

Criterion of disk truncation:Tvis +Tres < 0 at a resonance radius

Mechanism for tidal truncation

13 March 2013

Page 19: 13 March 201313rd MAXI Symposium Be Be. Talk Outline 1.Introduction to Be stars 2.Decretion vs. accretion 3.Interactions in binaries 4.Concluding remarks.

3rd MAXI Symposium 20

e = 0 e = 0.34 e = 0.68

Tidal/resonant truncation

Truncation radius decreases with increasing e (Be disk smaller than periastron distance)

13 March 2013

Page 20: 13 March 201313rd MAXI Symposium Be Be. Talk Outline 1.Introduction to Be stars 2.Decretion vs. accretion 3.Interactions in binaries 4.Concluding remarks.

3rd MAXI Symposium 21

Evolution of truncated Be disks

Initial disk growth similar to single Be stars

Density breaks at a resonant radius

Mass transfer rate increases as disk density increases.

Disk reaches a quasi-equilibrium state

Surface density evolution

13 March 2013

Page 21: 13 March 201313rd MAXI Symposium Be Be. Talk Outline 1.Introduction to Be stars 2.Decretion vs. accretion 3.Interactions in binaries 4.Concluding remarks.

3rd MAXI Symposium 22

1. Introduction to Be stars

2. Decretion vs. accretion

3. Interactions in binaries

1. Tidal truncation

2. Tidal/radiative precession and warping

3. Wind-wind collision

4. Concluding remarks

13 March 2013

Page 22: 13 March 201313rd MAXI Symposium Be Be. Talk Outline 1.Introduction to Be stars 2.Decretion vs. accretion 3.Interactions in binaries 4.Concluding remarks.

3rd MAXI Symposium 23

Observational evidence(?) for disk precession and warping

13 March 2013

Spectacular profile changes in 4U 0115+63

(Negueruela+ 2011; Reig+ 2007)

Page 23: 13 March 201313rd MAXI Symposium Be Be. Talk Outline 1.Introduction to Be stars 2.Decretion vs. accretion 3.Interactions in binaries 4.Concluding remarks.

3rd MAXI Symposium 24

Interpretation of spectacular profile changes

Precessing warped disk

(Negueruela+ 2001)

radiation-driven warping? (Pringle 1996; Porter 1998)

tidal warping of a misaligned disk? (Martin+ 2011)

13 March 2013

Page 24: 13 March 201313rd MAXI Symposium Be Be. Talk Outline 1.Introduction to Be stars 2.Decretion vs. accretion 3.Interactions in binaries 4.Concluding remarks.

3rd MAXI Symposium 25

5 types of torques on viscous disks

Torques on Be disks in binariestorques tending to straighten the disk

13 March 2013

bending torque in

retrograde direction, if

disk is misaligned

bending torque, if disk is optically thick. Direction depend

on gradient of tilt angle

internal (viscous) torque advective torque mass addition torque tidal torque radiative torque

Page 25: 13 March 201313rd MAXI Symposium Be Be. Talk Outline 1.Introduction to Be stars 2.Decretion vs. accretion 3.Interactions in binaries 4.Concluding remarks.

3rd MAXI Symposium 26

Tidal precession/warping

Tidal torques have alignment effect on a tilted disk toward the orbital plane.

(Lubow & Ogilvie 2000; Martin+ 2011)

talign = tvis : Disk aligns with orbital plane

talign ? tvis

talign =

Σ(GM*r)1/2

Ttid

: tprec

: Disk behaves like a rigid body and moves towards orb plane

13 March 2013

Page 26: 13 March 201313rd MAXI Symposium Be Be. Talk Outline 1.Introduction to Be stars 2.Decretion vs. accretion 3.Interactions in binaries 4.Concluding remarks.

3rd MAXI Symposium 27

Radiative precession/warping

Stellar photons with relatively long wavelengths, which in Be stars is a small fraction of total photons, exert torques on optically thick part of disk.

Even so, radiative torques can be comparable with or stronger than tidal torques in outer disk regions.

(Pringle 1996; Wijers, Pringle 1999)

13 March 2013

Page 27: 13 March 201313rd MAXI Symposium Be Be. Talk Outline 1.Introduction to Be stars 2.Decretion vs. accretion 3.Interactions in binaries 4.Concluding remarks.

3rd MAXI Symposium 28

1. Introduction to Be stars

2. Decretion vs. accretion

3. Interactions in binaries

1. Tidal truncation

2. Tidal/radiative precession and warping

3. Wind-wind collision

4. Concluding remarks

13 March 2013

Page 28: 13 March 201313rd MAXI Symposium Be Be. Talk Outline 1.Introduction to Be stars 2.Decretion vs. accretion 3.Interactions in binaries 4.Concluding remarks.

29

TeV gamma-ray binary PSR B1259-63(Radio pulsar + O9.5e; Porb=3.4yr, e=0.87)

13 March 2013 3rd MAXI Symposium (Credit: NASA)

Page 29: 13 March 201313rd MAXI Symposium Be Be. Talk Outline 1.Introduction to Be stars 2.Decretion vs. accretion 3.Interactions in binaries 4.Concluding remarks.

3rd MAXI Symposium 30

Observations favor very dense Be disk

ρ0 = 10−10 g cm−3

13 March 2013

ρ0 = 10−9 g cm−3

Density on orbital plane

Pulsar passes through Be disk

PW truncates Be disk

Page 30: 13 March 201313rd MAXI Symposium Be Be. Talk Outline 1.Introduction to Be stars 2.Decretion vs. accretion 3.Interactions in binaries 4.Concluding remarks.

3rd MAXI Symposium 31

Stellar evolution

13 March 2013

Disk physics interesting on its own:Mechanism leading to critical rotation

High energy emission

Decretion/accretion/truncation/warping/precession, all affecting accretion onto NS/BH; Turbulence; Mass transferBe-star binaries form largest subgroup of HMXBs and TeV binaries

Concluding remarks: Why should we bother about Be stars?