1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor:...

71
1 N C N C N N C N C C N C N N C N C N C C Synthesis of New Wanzlick CarbenesMSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk N C N N C N C H 2 CH 3 H 3 C N C N tBu R N N N N tBu R R tBu ? 2

Transcript of 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor:...

Page 1: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

1

NC

N

CN

N CN C

CNCN

NC

N

C

NC

C

“ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes”

MSc. Thesis Defence

Azar Hezarkhani, 2006

Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk

NC

NNC

NCH2

CH3H3C

NC

N

tBu

R

N

N

N

N

tBu

R

R

tBu

?2

Page 2: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

2

Outline

-Synthesis of new stable diamino carbenes-Synthesis of thioureas-Synthesis of N,N’-dialkyl-ethylenediamines-Synthesis of 2-chloro-ethylamines-DFT calculations

Project I: The steric limits of diaminocarbene dimerization

Project II: Attempted synthesis of bis-Wanzlick-carbenes

Synthesis of bis-thioureasReduction of bis-thioureas

Background Stable Diamino CarbenesPoly-thioureas and poly-carbenes

Future work

Page 3: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

3

Motivation

Stable Carbenes: Research Activities 1991+

1

2

N

C:

N

R

R

1991

Wanzlick, Denk

1997

N

C:

N

tBu

tBu

Arduengo• Reviews: 10

• Research papers: 800

• Patents: 5

• Groups active in the field: Arduengo, Denk, Bertrand, Alder, Herrmann, Nolan, Hahn, Enders, Lappert....

• Key papers: Betrand, Science Arduengo, Jacs Denk, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Enl

• Nobel prizes: 2005, 1973, 1971

• Application:

New Homogeneous Catalysts …

Page 4: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

4

Mes MesNC

N

RuCl Ph

ClPCy3

H

PCy3

RuCl Ph

ClPCy3

H

19951st generation GrubbsCatalyst

19992nd generation GrubbsCatalyst

Page 5: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

5

W

CMe OMe

COOCCOOC

CO

1964, FischerFirst metal carbenecomplexes

Page 6: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

6

R C R C

R

R

~ sp ~ sp2

Triplet ground state Singlet ground state

Py

Px

σ

linear bent

E

Py

Px

σ

Page 7: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

7

Electronic Structure of Carbenes (G. Herzberg, 1930+)

R C R C

R

R

~ sp ~ sp2

Triplet ground state Singlet ground state

Py

Px

σ

linear bent

E

Py

Px

σ

Carbene ground state spin multiplicity depends on:

• Inductive Effects• Mesomeric Effects

• Steric Effects

Page 8: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

8

A.J. Arduengo III 1991+ D. Enders et al. 1995

N. Kuhn, M. Denk 1993+

Synthesis of Stable Carbenes

1,1-Elimination

R2NC

R2N

H

H

-H2

Future Research

R2NC

R2N

R2N

CR2N

H

R2NC

R2N

S

R2NC

R2N

Deprotonationα Elimination

OMe

H-MeOH B

- HB

K

Reduction

Page 9: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

9

Stable Carbenes And Their Hetero Analogs

NC:

N

Ad

Ad

NSi:

N

tBu

tBu

NGe:

N

tBu

tBu

1994Denk

1991Denk

NSi:

N

tBu

tBu

NGe:

N

tBu

tBu

1991Arduengo

1991Denk

1994Denk

N

P:N

tBu

tBu

N

PN

tBu

tBu

ClCl

NC:

N

N

Ph

Ph

Ph

N

C:N

R

R

NC

iPriPr N

iPr

iPr

1995Enders

1995Alder

1996Denk

1996Denk (tBu)

Arduengo (Mes)

1996Denk

Page 10: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

10

Are Stable Carbenes “Air Sensitive”

M. K. Denk, J. Rodezno, S. Gupta, A. J. Lough, J. Organomet. Chem. 2001

NC

N

tBu

tBu

NC

N

tBu

tBu

O2NC

N

tBu

tBu

NC

N

tBu

tBu

O

O

O2

H2O

H2ONH

CN

tBu

tBu

H

O

N

CN

tBu

tBu

H

O slow

fast

r.t

r.t

Page 11: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

11

Stability of Carbenes: Wanzlick vs Arduengo

Do not Dimerize at all(not even for R = Me)

Arduengo 1991+N

CN

R

R

XN

N

N

N

R

R

R

R

NC

N

R

R

Page 12: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

12

Stability of Carbenes: Wanzlick vs Arduengo

Do not Dimerize at all(not even for R = Me)

Arduengo 1991+

Equilibrium at r.t. E. Hahn 1999

NC

N

R

R

XN

N

N

N

R

R

R

R

NC

N

R

R

NC

N NC

N NC

NNC

N::

r.t

Page 13: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

13

Dimerize for R < tBuReversibel at T > 160 oC

Denk & Hatano 1996

Stability of Carbenes: Wanzlick vs Arduengo

Do not Dimerize at all(not even for R = Me)

Arduengo 1991+

Equilibrium at r.t. E. Hahn 1999

NC

N

R

R

N

N

N

N

R

R

R

R

NC

N

R

R

NC

N

R

R

XN

N

N

N

R

R

R

R

NC

N

R

R

NC

N NC

N NC

NNC

N::

r.t

16 Kcal

Page 14: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

14

Purely Steric ?

Steric and Electronic ?

Steric and electronic influence of R ?

Different substituents R ?

NC

N

R

R

N

N

N

N

R

R

R

R

NC

N

R

R

The Wanzlick Equilibrium

Dimerize for R = Me, Et, iPr Reversibel at T > 160 oC

Do not dimerize for R = tBuDenk & Hatano 1996

Page 15: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

15

Dimerize for R < tBuReversibel at T > 160 oC

Denk & Hatano 1996

Combination of one large and one small Substituents

Do not Dimerize at all(not even for R = Me)

Arduengo 1991+

NC

N

tBu

R

N

N

N

N

tBu

R

tBu

R

NC

N

tBu

R

N

N

N

N

tBu

R

R

tBu

or?

= Target molecules of this MSc Thesis

Page 16: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

16

Synthesis of Carbene via ThioureaAlcoholamine => Diamines => Thiourea => Diaminocarbene

Ra: i-Prb: Etc: Med: Ph

NH

OH

tBu

NH

Cl

tBu

HCl

NH

NH

tBu

R

.SOCl2

CH2Cl2 , -SO2

5 R-NH2

H2O

NH

NH

R

R'N

CH2

N

R

R'

N

C

N

R

R'

S

N

C

N

R

R'

(CH2O)n KS8

-H2S

Page 17: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

17

Synthesis of 2-(alkylamino)ethyl chloride hydrochloride

R Yield

[Lit.]

Yield

This study

m.p. ˚C

[Lit.]

m.p. ˚C

Crude mixture

m.p.˚C sublimed

Me 93 % [a]] 95 % 115-117˚C 113-115 ˚C 209-210 ˚C

Et 91 % [b]] 80 % 223 ˚C 213-215 ˚C 216-217 ˚C

iPr 82 % [c] 82 % 187-188˚C 186-187 ˚C 186-187 ˚C

tBu 80 % [d]] 98 % 203 ˚C 204-205 ˚C 204-205 ˚C

a) Li, R. Farmer, P. S.; Xie, M.; Quilliam, M. A. J. Med. Chem. 1992, 35(17), 3246b) Lasselle, P.A.; Sundet, S.A.; J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1941, 63, 2374c) Cope, A. C.; Nace, R. H.; Hatchard, W. R. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1949, 71, 554d) Gelbard, G.; Rumpff, P. Bull. Soc. Chim. Fr. 1969, 1161

Reaction time seems to depend on water content

NH

Cl

R

NH

OH

R

HCl

CH2Cl2

.1.5 SOCl2

∆, 8h-4d

+ SO2

Page 18: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

18

Synthesis of N-tert-butyl-N’alkyl-ethylenediamine

• Large excess of RNH2 required for formation of diamine, otherwise piperazine dominate

• Optimized temperature, > 100 : piperazine , < 100 : long reaction time• Bomb reaction to retain amine

• Fractional distillation

NH

NR

tBu

N

N

tBu

tBu

NH

tBu

NH2

R

NH

NH

R

tBu

HClNH

Cl

tBu

5.

100oC / 24h

H2O

R Yield Diamine

Me

Et

iPr

, 38%

89%

74%

Page 19: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

19

Synthesis of N-tert-butyl-N’-alkyl-imidazolidine-2-thione

-H2SNH

NH

tBu

R

CS2

65 68

a: Meb: Etc: i-Prd: t-Bu

R

NC

N

S

tBu

R

Yield: 10-18%

Need better method

“Synthesis of symmetrical thioureas from formaldehyde aminal and S8

Denk, 2001

Page 20: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

20

Synthesis of N-tert-butyl-N’-alkyl-imidazolidine-2-thione

R Yield m.p. ˚ C C=S

Me 40 % 96.5 - 97 ˚C 183.1 ppm

Et 15 % 57.5 - 58 ˚C 182.3 ppm

i-Pr 41 % 102.5 - 103.5 ˚C 181.7 ppm

1. Denk, M. K.; Gupta, S.; Brownie, J.; Ta jammul, S.; Lough, A. J. Chem. Eur. J.

2001, 7, 4477.

NH

NH

tBu

S8

160˚C, 12h

(CH2O)n

N

N

CH2

tBu

RR

NC

N

S

tBu

R

90-91%

-H2S-H2O

Recrystallized from hexane

Page 21: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

21

Synthesis of N-tert-butyl-N’-alkyl-imidazolidine-2-ylidene

Alkyl Yield % 13C NMR (ppm)

Me 71 % 239.7 ppm

Et 70 % 238.7 ppm

iPr * 72 % 237.6 ppm

tBu * 90 % 238.2 ppm

Just one tBu substituent is sufficient to prevent dimerization !

No dimerization! THF

reflux, 30 mins

, 3 K

N

C

N

S

tBu

R

N

N

C

tBu

R - K2S

R

Me Eti-PrtBu

Page 22: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

22

B98 B98 B98 Increment Steric (Fully optimized) contribution

Me -26.4 3.0 -23.4 -13.2 -14.4 +1.2

Et -26.4 3.3 -23.1 -12.7 -13.2 +0.5

iPr -26.4 4.4 -22.0 -9.9 -8.8 -1.1

tBu -26.4 6.3 -20.1 +25.5 -1.2 +26.7

Dimerization Energies of Carbenes (Go)B98 / 6-31G(d), kcal•mol-1

N

N

H

H

N

N

H

R

N

N

H

H

N

N

H

H

N

N

R

R

N

N

R

R

Page 23: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

23

Go -13.2 -12.7 -9.9 -6.5 +25.5

Me Et i-Pr Ph t-Bu

Dimerization Energies of Carbenes (Go, B98 / 6-31G(d), kcal•mol-1

Electronic -14.4 -13.2 - 8.8 -11.5 -1.1

N

N

Me

Me

N

N

Me

Me

N

N

Et

Et

N

N

Et

Et

N

N

iPr

iPr

N

N iPr

iPr

N

N

Ph

Ph

N

N

Ph

Ph

N

N

tBu

tBu

N

N tBu

tBu

Steric ~ 0 ~ 0 ~ 0 ~ 5 ~ 26

Dimerize to enetetramine No dimerizationStable carbene

Page 24: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

24

Fully Optimized: -0.9 +2.1 +4.0 +25.5

Electronic: -7.8 -7.2 -5.0 -1.2

Steric: +6.9 +9.3 +9.0 +26.7

• Base value (4 x H): Go dimerization -26.4 kcal

• Electronic contribution from Alkyl groups increments: Me (3.0), Et (3.3), iPr (4.4), tBu (6.5).

tBu,R Carbenes: Go, B98 / 6-31G(d), kcal•mol-1)

N

N

tBu

Me

N

N tBu

Me

N

N

tBu

Et

N

N tBu

Et

N

N

tBu

iPr

N

N tBu

iPr

N

N

tBu

tBu

N

NtBu

tBu

Conclusion: tBu, R carbenes would dimerize electronically, but steric hbindrance prevents dimerization

Stable carbene: No dimerization

Page 25: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

25

13C Deshielding in Carbenes vs. Aminals

N

N

Me

tBu

C:

N

CH2

N

Me

tBu

N

CH2

N

Et

tBu

N

CH2

N

ipr

tBu

N

N

Et

tBu

C:

N

N

ipr

tBu

C:237.6 238.7 239.7

• Deshielding of >C: vs >CH2 (aminal) is a constant increment of ~170 ppm

• Diamino carbene 13C shifts may be predicted from aminal shifts

71.5 69.7 68.9

168.2 169.0 168.7

N

N

tBu

tBu

C:

N

N

tBu

tBu

CH2

238.7

63.7

175.0

Page 26: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

26

15N Deshielding in Carbenes vs. Aminals

-224.8

-258.9

-341.4

-225.6

-243.7

-322.1

-326.6 -316.9

-322.9

-226.7

-233.4

-321.8

N

N

Me

tBu

C:

N

CH2

N

Me

tBu

N

CH2

N

Et

tBu

N

CH2

N

ipr

tBu

N

N

Et

tBu

C:

N

N

ipr

tBu

C:

• Nitrogen in carbene is about 100 ppm more desheilded than aminal.

• The trend of desheilding in N-R is: N-ipr > N-Et > N-Me

• N-R effects on N-tBu NMR shifts. N-tBu would be more desheilded in order of: R= Me > Et > iPr

N

N

tBu

tBu

CH2

N

N

tBu

tBu

C:

-227.6

-321.4

Page 27: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

27

15N NMR INEPT spectrum of Diamino carbenes

N

N

t-Bu

Et

C

Method : INEPT, J=4 Hz External reference : Nitro methan

Solvent: C6D6

Page 28: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

28

N

N

t-Bu

Me

C

15N NMR INEPT spectrum of Diamino carbenes

Page 29: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

29

Poly-Carbenes

1 2

NC:

N

NC:

NN:C

N

:CN N

C:N

NC:

N

NC:

N

NC:

N

C:N

NC:

NKnown

NC:

N

NC:

N

NC:

N

NC:

N

NC:

N

C:N

N C:

NC:

N

C:N

NC:

NN:C

N

NC

N

CN

N CN C

CNCN

NC

N

C

NC

C

C

R

R

R

R

R

R

R

R

R

RR

R

RRRR

R R RR

R

R

R

R

R

R R

80% Unknown

Page 30: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

30

Monomer:

1) Herrmann, W. A.; Elison, M.; Fischer, J.; Köcher, C.; Artus, G. R. J. Chem. Eur. J. 1996, 2, 772-780. 2) Dias, H. V. R.; Jin, W. Tetrahedron Lett. 1994, 35, 1365-1366.

N

C

N

1

N

N

N

N

Me

Me

N

N

N

N

N

Nt-Bu

t-Bu

t-Bu

13 14

N N N N N NR R

n

15

n = 0, 1, 2, ...

Poly-Carbenes

N

C

N

2

Page 31: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

31

Goal of Project II

N

C

N

N

C

N

N

C

N

R

R

S

S

S

K- K2S

N

N

N

N

N

N

R

R

nn

Page 32: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

32

Unknown

2 Reference (R= Me)

Unknown

1 Reference (R= H)

Chemical Abstract Search: Poly-thioureas?

Unknown Unknown

N

N

N

N

N

N

R

R

S

S

S

N

NS

N

NS

N

NS

N

NS

N

NS

N

NS

R

RR

R

R

R

Page 33: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

33

Synthetic route for synthesis the bis-carbenes

R

Me Et iPr tBu

NH

NH2

R

N

HN

R

C SCS2

N

N

R

C S

N

NC S

R

CH2=O K/ THF

N

N

R

C

N

NC

R

NH

NH2

ButNH

NH2

Me

NH

NH2

iPrNH

NH2

Et

NH

NH2

Ph

StartingMaterials

AldrichCdn $ / mol

492 306 685 3039 516

N

HN

Me

S

9300

Page 34: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

34

The Methanol Mysteryor

Synthesis of N-methyl-imidazolodine-2-thione

NH2

NH

CH3

NH

N

C S

H3C

CS2+

H2O

NH

NH2

CH3

C

S

S

zwitterion

92%

MeOHfresh bottle

old bottle

MeOH

∆ ∆

Conclusion: Zwitterion decomposition needs some water

Page 35: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

35

Synthesis of bis-thioureas

NH

N

S

CH3

N

N

S

N

NS

CH2

CH3

CH3

2

∆, 8 hrDioxane

1.2 (CH2O)n

Solvent Reaction time Yield of bis-thioureas

THF 2 weeks 28%

Dioxane 8 hr 75%

Dioxane 8 hr 95%

Page 36: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

36

Purification method for bis-thioureas

Method of purification m.p. ˚C

Recrystallization from Hexane 173-175 ˚C

Recrystallization from THF 179-180 ˚C

Recrystallization from MeOH 181-182 ˚C

Recrystallization from Toluene 183.5-184 ˚C

Sublimation 180-184 ˚C

Page 37: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

37

GC-MS of reaction in THF (2 weeks)

N

N

S

N

N

S

CH2

CH3

CH3

Page 38: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

38

GC-MS of reaction in Dioxane (8 hr)

N

N

S

N

N

S

CH2

CH3

CH3

Page 39: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

39

X-ray structure of bis-thioureas

Page 40: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

40

Synthesis of bis-carbene

Reducing agent Reaction

time

Color of mixture Result (NMR)

3 eq. K 3 months Brown solution No reaction

3 eq. K / Na 3 months Yellow solution No reaction

3 eq. K / Naphthalene 2 months Brown solutiion New compound

3 eq. K / Hexamethyl-disilane 2 months Brown solution

& precipitation

No reaction

N

NS

N

NS

CH2

CH3

CH3

3 K, THF

NC

N

NC

NCH2

CH3

CH3

X

Page 41: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

41

• Better methods for synthesis of thioureas and carbenes

Future Works

Page 42: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

42

Future work I:Synthesis of diaminocarbenes from imidazolidinium salts

N

CH2

N

R

R'

N

CHBr

N

R

R'

N

C

N

R

R'

S

N

C

N

R

R'

CBr4

KS8

? ?

-H2S

Page 43: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

43

Future work II:Synthesis of diaminocarbenes by dehydrogenation of

imidazolidine

N

CH2

N

R

R'

N

C

N

R

R'

?

[Pd], ∆, -H2

N

C

N

tBu

tBu

N

C

N

tBu

tBu

H

HH2

[Pt]

r.t

M. K. Denk, J. Rodezno, S. Gupta, A. J. Lough, J. Organomet. Chem. 2001

Page 44: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

44

Supervisor: Pro. M. Denk

Committee: Pro. A. Schwan Pro. W. Tam Pro. M. Schlaf

Chair : Pro. P. Rowntree

Labmates: Feng Lan Xuan Kevin Ahmed Jeffrey

Many Thanks to:

Page 45: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

45

Summary

• Three new stable carbenes synthesized

• Substituent effects(steric and electronic) on dimerization quantified in kcal (B98/6-31G(d))

• Synthesis of thioureas from imidazolinium salts attempted

• 15N NMR of Carbenes & Aminals to understand bonding

Page 46: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

46

Synthesis of disubstituted ethylenediamines Ia) Symmetrical

Rice, L.; Armbrecht, B.; Grogan, C.; Reid, E.; J. Am. Chem. Soc. 75, 1953, 1750.

Denk, M. K.; Krause, M. J.; Tetrahedron, 2003, 59, 7565.

NH

NH

R

R

NH

NR

NH

R

R

N

N

R

R

RNH2Br

Br H2O, r.t

R

MeEtiPrtBuPh

LiAlH4 / ether

OH

OH

NH

NH

R

R

reflux

O

O NH

NHO

O

R

R

H2O or EtOH

R

Et Bu Dec

RNH2

Page 47: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

47

Carbenes: Singlet and Triplet (Inductive Effects)

Electronegativity Increases

S

T

S

TT

15.159.17

56.07

E (kcal/mol)

S

G3 - Calculation, M. K. Denk, Mar. 16, 2004, Unpublished results

C

LiLi84.27oC

C

Li

Li

120.46oC

C

H

H

132.98oC

C

H

H

100.09oC

C

F

F

103.90oC

C

F

F

119.79oC

σ

σ

σ

σ

σ1pπ1 σ2 σ1pπ

1 pπ2

3B11A1

1B11A1

Page 48: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

48

Synthesis of first stable carbene

Cl

N

N

Ad

Ad

HN

CN

Ad

Ad

O

O

+ NH2

Ad

2 + OH

H

HCl

t-BuOK

HK

4C 5C

K

RN

NC S

RMe

Me N

NC

R

RMe

Me Ra: Meb: Etc: i-Pr

THF, 80oC

30 31

-K2S

N N

NC

H

Ph

PhPh

OMe N N

NC

Ph

PhPh

28 29

0.1 mbar, 80oC- MeOH

NH

NHPh

Ph26

CH(OC2H5)3-2 C2H5OH N

NPh

PhHOC2H5

- C2H5OH NC

NPh

Ph27 9

150 ̊ C a: R= Hb: R= Ph

Cl- KCl

- tBuOHN

NPh

Ph

HN

CNPh

Ph

+ tBuOK

24 25

R

R

R

R

• Enders, D.; Breuer, K.; Raabe, G.; Runsink, J.; Teles, J. H.; Melder, J. P.; Ebel, K.; Brode, S. Angew. Chem., Int. Ed. Engl. 1995, 34, 1021.c

Page 49: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

49

a: R= Hb: R= PhCl

- KCl- tBuOHN

NPh

Ph

HN

CNPh

Ph

+ tBuOK

12 13

RR

RR

Synthesis of stable 1H-imidazole-2(3H)-ylidenes (not isolated).

NH

NHPh

Ph14

CH(OC2H5)3-2 C2H5OH N

NPh

PhHOC2H5

- C2H5OH NC

NPh

Ph15 9

150 ̊ C

Synthesis of di-phenyl-imidazolidine-2-ylidene by thermal 1,1-elimination.

N N

NC

H

Ph

PhPh

OMe N N

NC

Ph

PhPh

16 17

0.1 mbar, 80oC- MeOH

The first commercially available carbene.

K

RN

NC S

RMe

Me N

NC

R

RMe

Me Ra: Meb: Etc: i-Pr

THF, 80oC

18 19

-K2S

Page 50: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

50H.-W. Wanzlick, E. Schikora, Angew. Chem. 1960, 72, 494.

Stable Carbenes: Early Studies

Hans-Werner WanzlickBerlin

Page 51: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

51

NC

N

Ph

Ph

HN

CN

Ph

Ph

KOtBu-KX, HOtBu

H. W. Wanzlick, H. J. Schönherr, Liebigs Ann. Chem. 1970, 731, 176H. W. Wanzlick, H. J. Schönherr, Chem. Ber. 1970, 103, 1037.

N

NC

Ad

Ad

HN

NC

Ad

Ad

NaH, cat. DMSOthf, -NaCl, -H2

A. J. Arduengo III et al. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1991, 113, 361.

NiPr

iPr NC

iPr

iPr

R. W. Alder et al, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1996, 35, 1121.

N

NC

Ad

Ad

6π Arduengo 11

Alder 16NiPr

iPr NC

iPr

iPr

H LDA, thf-LiCl, -DA

Cl–

Cl–

Wanzlick 170X–

Synthesis of Stable Carbenes…

Page 52: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

52

Alkylation of Ethylene Thiourea- A Literature Review

J. F. Baer, R. G. Lockwood, J. Org. Chem., 1953, 76, 1162-1164.

R. N. Boyd; M. Meadow,Analytical Chemistry, 1960, 32, 551-554.

R = Me, Et, iPr, nPr, nBu, sBu, n-Hexyl, n-Heptyl, allyl, BenzylX = Cl-, Br-, I-

NH

C

HN

S

R

NH

C

HN

S + RX

X

NaOH

N

C

HN

S

RMeOH

60 - 0%1 1

NH

C

HN

S

NC

HN

S

CNHN

S

2HBr

Br

Br+ NaOH

NC

HN

S

CNHN

SMeOH

72%

1

20

Page 53: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

53

ChemNMR C-13 EstimationChemNMR C-13 Estimation

Chemdraw : 13C-NMR Predictions

Experimental :

Predictions of different compounds

N

NS

N

NS

68.4

N

NS

N

NS

60

N

N

S

OH

3.57

3.57

2.47

5.69

2.0

N

N

S

N

NS

O

3.57

3.57

2.47

5.53

3.57

3.57

2.47

5.53

N

N

S

N

N

S

19.7

Page 54: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

54

Yield: 95%m.p. : 183.5-184 ˚C

Yield: 40%m.p. : 181-183 ˚C

Synthesis of Bis-thiourea (Stoichiometry)

N

N

S

OH

3.57

3.57

2.47

5.69

2.0

N

N

S

N

NS

O

3.57

3.57

2.47

5.53

3.57

3.57

2.47

5.53

NH

N

S

CH3

2.4 CH2=O

N

N

S

N

N

S

CH2

CH3

CH3

2 +

Dioxane

ref.,6 hr

Dioxane

ref.,6 hrNH

N

S

CH3

1.2 CH2=O

N

N

S

N

N

S

CH2

CH3

CH3

2 +

Page 55: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

55

Formation of imidazolidinium bromide

NCH2

N

R

R'

NC

N

R

R'

H

HCBr3 Br

CBr4

NC

N

R

R'

HBr

-HCBr3

NCH2

N

R

R'N

N

R

R'

H2 + H2 + 2e-

CH2RN RN H + H2 + 2e-

N-alkyl-1,4-dihydropyridine

Page 56: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

56

Strategy for synthesis the diamino carbenes I

NH

NH

R

R'

NH

NH

R

OH

N

CH2

N

R

R'

N

CHBr

N

R

R'

N

C

N

R

R'

S

N

C

N

R

R'

R'NH2

SOCl2

(CH2O)n

CBr4

?

K

Pd, -H2

S8

? ?

-H2S

Page 57: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

57

Synthesis of thiourea from imidazolinium salt (Arduengo salt)

G.B. Ansell, D. M. Forkey, D. W. Moore, J. Chem. Soc. D., 1970, 1 56b-57l

N

CH I

N

Me

Me

N

N

Me

Me

-H2CO3

- K2I

S

1. K2CO3/ MeOH2. S8, ∆

73 74

Page 58: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

58

Synthesis of imidazolidinium bromide

NH

NH

R

R'

NCH2

N

R

R'N

N

R

R'

CBr4H . CBr4

Br-

(CH2O)n

Ether reflux, 20h

R, R'

MeEti-Prt-Bu

-CHBr3

sublimation

CBr4 crystalls

N

N

R

R'

HBr-150 ˚C

Brown residue

Recrystallization

from CHCl3 N

N

R

R'

HBr-

Colorless crystalls

m.p.=165-168 ˚C

194-195 ˚C 196-197 ˚C

Inclusion compound

Page 59: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

59

Crystal structure of imidazolinium Br salt (inclusion)

Page 60: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

60

Synthesis of thioureas by imidazolidinium salt

NCH Br

N

R

R

+ K2CO3 + S8

MeOH

∆ N

N

R

R

SR

a: Med: tBu

NCH Br

N

R

R

+ KOH + S8

MeOH

∆ N

N

R

R

S

Stronger base?Different solvent?

Page 61: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

61

Dehydrogenation of imidazolidines: potential way to Wanzlick carbenes

NH

C:

HN

+H2

NH

CH2

HN

NC:

N

tBu

tBu

+ H2

NCH2

N

tBu

tBu

NC:

N

Me

Me

+ H2

NCH2

N

Me

Me

B1B956-31G(d)

CBS-Q

-21.94 -22.62

-20.36 -18.72

B98631Gd

-19.69

B3LYP631Gd

-22.3023.44

-19.38

-15.59-13.78

Reaction

Hydrogenation energies (∆Go , kcal.mol-1)

Page 62: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

62

Transfer hydrogenation (computational study)

H2C CH2 + H2 H3C CH3

+ H2

-28.35 -23.28

-20.73 -18.64

-29.19

-21.67

-26.78

-18.98

B1B956-31G(d)

CBS-Q B98631Gd

B3LYP631GdReaction

Hydrogenation energies (∆Go , kcal.mol-1)

Hydrogen acceptor

NC:

N

tBu

tBu

+ H2

NCH2

N

tBu

tBu

-15.59-13.78

∆G0= -6.95

Hydrogen donor

Page 63: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

63

Transfer hydrogenation (Experiments)

65d 67d

+

NCH2

N

tBu

tBu

Pt, C6D6

NC:

N

tBu

iPr

+

NC:

N

tBu

tBu

NCH2

N

tBu

iPr

190 ˚C

65c 67d 67d 65c

+N

CH2

N

tBu

tBu

Pd , toluene+

N

C:

N

tBu

tBu

190 ˚C

Page 64: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

64

From Poly-Thioureas To Poly-Carbenes

• Carbene complexes

• New Homogenous Catalyst

• Electrochemical storage (Battery without metal)• Strong organic reducing agent• Carbene Complex

N NR

C

N N

C

R

N NR N N R

N NR N N R

Dimerization ?

N NR

C

S

N N

C

S

R

K/ THF

Page 65: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

65

Dimerize for R < tBuReversibel at T > 160 oC

Denk & Hatano 1996

Enetetramines: Reducing agents

Do not Dimerize at all(not even for R = Me)

Arduengo 1991+

NC

NR

RN

N

N

NR

R

R

RN

CNR

R

Equilibrium at r.t. E. Hahn 1999

N

NN

N

N

N

CH3

CH3

CN

N

CH3

CH3

C

CH2 10.5 eV

NN GeMe3Me3Ge 5.87 eV

5.95 eV

6.06 eV

Reducing agent 1 IP (eV)

CH2

NC

N

CH3

CH3

N

N

N

N

CH3

CH3

CH3

CH3

2

Page 66: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

66

Page 67: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

67

N

N

N

N

bis(3-methylimidazolidin-1-yl)methane

S

S

bis(3-methyl-2-methyleneimidazolidin-1-yl)methane

N

N

S

1,3-dimethylimidazolidine-2-thione

N

NN

N

bis(3-methylimidazolidine-2-thione-1-yl)methane

N

CH2

N

1,3-dimethylimidazolidiniumbromide

Page 68: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

68

quinone

O O

adamantyl

C•

guanidine

NH2

NH2

HN

Page 69: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

69

Magnetic Properties of 15N, 14N, 13C and 1H isotopes

Magnetic properties of the 14N, 15N, 13C, 1H isotopes.

Nucleus Natural

abundance %

I

Spin

Relative

sensitivity

1H 99.98 1/2 1

13C 1.11 1/2 1.76 × 10 -4

14N .63 1 1.00 × 10 -3

15N 0.37 1/2 3.52 × 10 -6

• 15N is 283800 times less sensitive than 1H NMR !!!

• 14N has higher sensitivity than 15N but it is quadropolar and

has broad peaks.

Page 70: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

70

Singlet-Triplet Gaps for Carbenes (kcal/ mol)Singlet-Triplet Gaps for Carbenes (kcal/ mol)

a) C.-H. Hu, Chem. Phys. Lett. 1999, 309, 81-80.b) M. D. Su, C.-H. Hu, Chem. Phys. Lett. 1999, 308, 283-288.c) M. K. Denk, unpublished.

• Very few experimental S/T energies (H2C, F2C and FHC)

• Li2C is linear but all other T-carbenes are bent !• All heavier carbenes (H2Si: etc.) have singlet ground state

• Atomic carbon most reactive triplet carbene• Vinylidenes R2C=C:most reactive singlet carbenes

• T-carbenes react as radicals, S-carbenes as strong electrophiles

Exp.

OC:

9.05a -56.6a

-56.9

-14.7a

-15.6 -139.6

NH

C :

HN

NH

C :

HN

8.1 -21.0CBS-Q c

CBS-APNO c 9.0

-86.5

G3 c 9.5

W1 c 9.2

H

HC:

F

HC:

F

FC:

Cl

ClC:

H2N

H2NC:

-55.3-21.0 -56.1

-72.9-55.9

-138.0-72.4 -85.3-14.5

-14.5

Triplet Singlet

Page 71: 1 “ Synthesis of New Wanzlick Carbenes ” MSc. Thesis Defence Azar Hezarkhani, 2006 Supervisor: Prof. M. Denk.

71

13C-NMR (ppm)/ Electronic Stabilization

• Carbenes have highly deshielded carbon NMR shift• Unstabilized H2C: may serve as a refrence point for the high electronic stabilization of other carbenes

FC

F FC

F

F C

F

F

F

nTeflon

NC

N

iPr

iPr

NC

N

iPr

iPr

iPriPr N

CN

iPr

iPr

205.9

236.8 255.5 300.87 *

F

HC

H

1483.88 *

NC

N

Mes

Mes

244.5

SC

N

Ph

254.3

Aryl/ Alkyl

Nitrogen / Sulfur

Rings / Chains

Aromaticity

CF

* Computational data( CBS-APNO) Experimental data