04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111...

41
UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION REGION IV 611 RYAN PLAZA DRIVE, SUITE 400 ARLINGTON, TEXAS 7601 1-4005 April 13, 2005 Paul D. Hinnenkamp Vice President - Operations Entergy Operations, Inc. River Bend Station 5485 US Highway 61N St. Francisville, LA 70775 SUBJECT: SUMMARY OF MEETING TO DISCUSS RIVER BEND STATION PERFORMANCE AND IMPROVEMENT INITIATIVES Dear Mr. Hinnenkamp: This refers to our meeting conducted at the NRC Region IV office in Arlington, Texas, on April 12, 2005. At this meeting, NRC and Entergy management discussed various topics, including human performance, equipment reliability, refueling outage performance, and performance improvement initiatives. In accordance with 10 CFR 2.390 of the NRC's "Rules of Practice," a copy of this letter and its enclosures will be available electronically for public inspection in the NRC Public Document Room or from the Publicly Available Records (PARS) component of NRC's document system (ADAMS). ADAMS is accessible from the NRC Web site at httP://www.nrc.nov/readinu-rm/adams. html (the Public Electronic Reading Room). Should you have any questions concerning this matter, we will be pleased to discuss them with you. Sincerely, David N. Graves, Chief Project Branch B Division of Reactor Projects Docket: 50-458 License: NPF-47 Enclosures: 1. Attendance List 2. Handout

Transcript of 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111...

Page 1: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1

UNITED STATES

NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION R E G I O N I V

611 RYAN PLAZA DRIVE, SUITE 400 ARLINGTON, TEXAS 7601 1-4005

April 13, 2005

Paul D. Hinnenkamp Vice President - Operations Entergy Operations, Inc. River Bend Station 5485 US Highway 61N St. Francisville, LA 70775

SUBJECT: SUMMARY OF MEETING TO DISCUSS RIVER BEND STATION PERFORMANCE AND IMPROVEMENT INITIATIVES

Dear Mr. Hinnenkamp:

This refers to our meeting conducted at the NRC Region IV office in Arlington, Texas, on April 12, 2005. At this meeting, NRC and Entergy management discussed various topics, including human performance, equipment reliability, refueling outage performance, and performance improvement initiatives.

In accordance with 10 CFR 2.390 of the NRC's "Rules of Practice," a copy of this letter and its enclosures will be available electronically for public inspection in the NRC Public Document Room or from the Publicly Available Records (PARS) component of NRC's document system (ADAMS). ADAMS is accessible from the NRC Web site at httP://www.nrc.nov/readinu-rm/adams. html (the Public Electronic Reading Room).

Should you have any questions concerning this matter, we will be pleased to discuss them with you.

Since rely,

David N. Graves, Chief Project Branch B Division of Reactor Projects

Docket: 50-458 License: NPF-47

Enclosures: 1. Attendance List 2. Handout

Page 2: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1

Entergy Operations, Inc.

cc w/enclosures: Senior Vice President and

Chief Operating Officer Entergy Operations, Inc. P.O. Box 31995 Jackson, MS 39286-1995

Vice President Operations Support Entergy Operations, Inc. P.O. Box 31995 Jackson, MS 39286-1 995

General Manager Plant Operations Entergy Operations, Inc. River Bend Station 5485 US Highway 61 N St. Francisville. LA 70775

Director - Nuclear Safety Entergy Operations, Inc. River Bend Station 5485 US Highway 61N St. Francisville, LA 70775

Wise, Carter, Child & Caraway P.O. Box 651 Jackson, MS 39205

Mark J. Wetterhahn, Esq. Winston & Strawn 1401 L Street, N.W. Washington, DC 20005-3502

Manager - Licensing Entergy Operations, Inc. River Bend Station 5485 US Highway 61 N St. Francisville. LA 70775

-2-

H. Anne Plettinger 3456 Villa Rose Drive Baton Rouge, LA 70806

Burt Babers, President West Feliciana Parish Police Jury P.O. Box I921 St. Francisville, LA 70775

Michael E. Henry, State Liaison Officer Department of Environmental Quality Permits Division P.O. Box 4313 Baton Rouge, LA 70821 -431 3

Brian Almon Public Utility Commission William 6. Travis Building P.O. Box 13326 1701 North Congress Avenue Austin, TX 7871 1-3326

The Honorable Charles C. Foti, Jr. Attorney General Department of Justice State of Louisiana P.O. Box 94005 Baton Rouge, LA 70804-9005

Page 3: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1

Entergy Operations, Inc. -3-

Electronic distribution by RIV: Regional Administrator (BSMI) DRP Director (ATH) DRS Director (DDC) DRS Deputy Director (KSW) Senior Resident Inspector (PJA) Branch Chief, DRPIB (DNG) Senior Project Engineer, DRP/B (RAKI) Team Leader, DRP/TSS (RLNI) RlTS Coordinator (KEG)

P Review Completed: 0 No Publicly Available 0 Non-Publicly Available 0 Sensitive

DNGrgy,a;df F 4/13/05

OFFICIAL RECORD COPY T=Te I e p h o ne E=E-mail F=Fax

Page 4: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1

ENCLOSURE 1

END-OF-CYCLE MEETING ATTENDANCE

II LICENSE E/F ACI LlTY

DATETTIME

LOCATION

NAME (PLEASE PRINT)

Entergy Operations/ River Bend Station

April 12, 2005 - 1 :00 pm

Nuclear Regulatory Commission Region IV 61 1 Ryan Plaza Dr. , Suite 400 Arlington, Texas 7601 1

ORGANIZATION

.

Page 5: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1

023

I

3 Td 0 i

bp)

Page 6: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1

u !2

sj 0

0 s W 0

sj

* + c-,

s-r c-,

H

0

2 0 -4 c-,

4 a s

I

m s 24.

8 3 d o

0 0

Page 7: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1

0

0

0

M

Page 8: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1

i i%

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 cv 0 oc) co Tl- cv 7 7

Page 9: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1

0 G 0 1 1 0 0 x 1 c6

0 c

8

Page 10: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1
Page 11: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1

m k 6)

'6) & I 5:

c,, 3

5 w6 *ll

6)

2 i3 e k 6)

plr 5:

8 5

5: crs

Td

*ll

G 6) m

4 4 1

'6) m 023 5: 0

0 e l l

I

4

023 m m

2

6

6) + 0 *ll I

' m k 6) rd crs

I 5:

5: ba

5 *ll d

0 0 0 0 0 0

Page 12: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1

h 6)

6) '1

~

0 o F - 4 I a h 6)

0"

Page 13: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1

Td s= ccs

m 1 6)

6) 1

bp)

4

0 0 .

5=1 0 m 3 0 0

+ s-r Q)

0 2 0 'u Fj css 0 F-c 5 c.,

0

1

3

css m

, .

m 3 'G 8%

Q) Q

3 0 trl

W Q) + 0

* + 8 Q) > h,

0 css 0

~

c.,

3 8

6) 0 F-c e 8 3 24

2 c-,

El

3 8

Page 14: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1

a!

Page 15: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1

6) d * c 6)

0 P, E 0

E ccs 74 0 m 0

w

4 0 c

0 0

E ccs G

2

0

n n

Page 16: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1

0 Q m d) I

Page 17: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1

E

d= 0 cr)

00

Y-4 P m

4-1 0 bl)

P 0 n rn 0

d) m 3 d 0

0 0

c,

0

w

2 F: 0

0 3

e l l -r F: d) 3 0

I5 a 023

m - r k O

Page 18: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1

m 6)

' 0 I

n 023 b

6) 0 r!

$-,

*$ 6) 0

$4 6)

&

sz: 6)

sz: 2 I

*r

8

6) k

023 b

Td sz: a bQ c,, t-l

0 m 6) n 0 k

s 6) 6) + *r a

6) rr! k *r

a

h *r I sz: 6) + 6)

2

Q) a 0 0 r%l

c., 0 6)

k 3 I sz: 0

I 6) 6) n F4 c

0 0 0 0 0 0

Page 19: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1

E

v1 d= 0

H

0 0

E s: 0 -+ cn

Page 20: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1

6)

m

0

E crs ct 0 u2 d- 0

6) > 6)

crs $4

2 % rj 0 m k n

0

Page 21: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1

\

Page 22: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1

b I

I sj 0

Fi E a ,

I I

0

Page 23: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1

'0 p! I s=1 0

0 hl

Page 24: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1

d

N

I zj 6)

h U

k c-,

0 4

G 0 6, a, 1 bs) Fj m -4

m m -4

h 1

2

3 4 14

6)

crs 2

Fj 0

e d

cj cct N

bs) Fj

k E crs 5.I 0 m a Fj crs 9 a, 3

2 bs) Fj

I I I I I I I

Page 25: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1

h I *r 1

'3; 6 *r 1 0

0 bp)

c a sr:

4 4 4 *H

129

Page 26: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1

I

E crs

0 0

a , f j ; m -

m hl

Page 27: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1

s=1 0 u

I

h t

0 E

6)

ccs 54 6)

;d c.,

0

2

6) 0

6) c,, 0 '

s 6)

2

0 ccs

0

a 0 0 U

6) 0 G

8 k 42 k 6)

P-4 0 0 0

* k 6)

3

s 6 ) * 0 5 4 ccsa

- b 1 0 n

0

Page 28: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1
Page 29: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1

z= s 6) pi:

h

h 6)

CEl '4 szl

8 G \I 0 0 c\1

cn

szl

i3 s E

6) 0

6) 0

El 0

0 *1 * 4 6) 0

0 0 0 0 0 0

Page 30: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1

0

W t t i J t

t , i

Page 31: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1
Page 32: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1

-

31 --.-I--

cv tr! 'i tr! 0 'i 0

In m tr! m (v

PoozIzz/11

POOZI 1 Ill 1

PoozIoz/11

POOZ16 11 1 1

POOZ18 11 1 1

POOZIL 11 1 1

POOZl9 11 1 1

Poozls 11 1 1

POOZIP 11 1 1

POOZIE 11 1 1

Pooz/z 11 1 1

POOZI 1 11 1 1

P00z10 11 1 1

POOZl6111

POOZl8111

POOZIU11

P00z191 1 1

Poozlsl11

1 PoozlPl11

Pooz/El 1 1

Pooz/zl 1 1

POOZI 11 1 1

POOZl1MO 1

POOZIOMO 1

POOZl6ZlO 1

POOZl8ZlO 1

POOZILZIO 1

P00z19z10 1

Pooz/szlo 1

Pooz/Pz/o 1

POOZIEZIO 1

Pooz/zz/o 1

POOZI 1 ZIO 1

Pooz/oz/o 1

Page 33: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1

c3 c3 I

R

W 6) z a 'v 6)

0 F 4

' ai 0

'u 6) z PI 6) H 4

c 2 I

'u 6)

0 0 0

0 m

Page 34: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1

a 3 h d)

ri m

Page 35: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1

ccs ccs I

a 0 c)

ccs E G

P

(u m

Page 36: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1

0

0 ? d -n c-,

x ' 0 0 -

9 s" c-,

2 w ;f3 W

0

M M

Page 37: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1

m 0 m

3 0 c! 0 -e

t:

t:

scn

0

d- M

Page 38: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1

e

2

84 F: 0 * fi;

1

c., ccs F:

Q)

a a 3 k 0

M * k Q) 3. 0

0

3.

3 ‘u Q)

0 k

8 1

*

3 * +

2

84

%

8

m

k

* +

m

U

0

I 1

8 2 0 0

0

0

6 2 0 - 0

0

- $-., ccs F: 8 0

a a 3 m

&

U U

h h

6 0

a k 0 *

*Fl c.,

* +

e; * * Q) 0 0 & 2 1

r! 0

U P 4 ag E Q ) 0

Page 39: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1

4

0

Page 40: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1

m

E: 0 u

crs G 0

crs 'd * $4 0 c,, 0

0

Tts 6) 3

0

3 . d 'r! crs

0 0

Page 41: 04/12/2005 Summary of Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc ... · P00z10 11 1 1 POOZl6111 POOZl8111 POOZIU11 P00z191 1 1 Poozlsl11 1 PoozlPl11 Pooz/El 1 1 Pooz/zl 1 1 POOZI 11 1 1

d

0 1

00 M