02 - Ethical Foundations
Transcript of 02 - Ethical Foundations
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
1/46
Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
Engineering & Society:Ethical Foundations
Dr. Gershon Weltman
Engineering 183EW, U!" SE"S
!ecture #
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
2/46
2Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
What Do We $ean %y Ethics
Descri'ti(e Ethics ) Deals *ith descri%ing e+isting ethical systems
ormati(e Ethics ) Deals *ith determining -right choices and actions
/iologicalGenetic/Neurophysiological
0hiloso'hicalTheoretical, Experiential
Ethics Are
!elie"s, Assumptions, #alues $$ Gui%es to Action
aturalNature&s 'a(s/)ni*ersal Truths
e(elationTranscen%ental Authorities
2he Sources o Ethics "re onsidered to %e
Societal
Community, Nation, Worl%
ultural
+amily, Ethnicity, Gen%er
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
3/46
3Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
Ethical 0rogression
oyal4Di(ine !egal odes
e(ealed $oral4Ethical odes
S'eciali5ed !ie odes
Ethical 0hiloso'hies
Societal egulations & !a*s
2he relationshi' o ethical codes to ethical 'hiloso'hies is li6e the
relationshi' o engineering to science ) doing comes irst.7t seems that a society, a culture, or a su%culture irst decides *hat
its 'eo'le should and shouldnt do and then its 'hiloso'hers try to
igure out the %asic 'rinci'les on *hich these decisions are %ased.
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
4/46
4Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
Early odes: Egy't & $eso'otamia
#99 /.. Urammu
189 /.. !i'it7shtar 1;89 /..
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
5/46
5Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
ode o
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
6/46
6Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
Earliest /i%lical $aterial ?@1999 /EA
$he writing was discovered on a pottery shard dug up during e%cavations at &hirbet 'eiyafa, near Israel(s )lah
valley. $he e%cavations were carried out by archaeologist #osef *arfinkel of the +ebrew niversity in
-erusalem. $he breakthrough could mean that portions of the Bible were written several centuries earlier than
previously thought. ive/cience.com -an 10, 21
otshard containing early biblical material
http://us.rd.yahoo.com/dailynews/livescience/sc_livescience/byline/biblepossiblywrittencenturiesearliertextsuggests/34742032/SIG=10sog4vj6/*http://www.livescience.comhttp://us.rd.yahoo.com/dailynews/livescience/sc_livescience/byline/biblepossiblywrittencenturiesearliertextsuggests/34742032/SIG=10sog4vj6/*http://www.livescience.comhttp://us.rd.yahoo.com/dailynews/livescience/sc_livescience/byline/biblepossiblywrittencenturiesearliertextsuggests/34742032/SIG=10sog4vj6/*http://www.livescience.com
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
7/46
7Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
e(ealed !a*s oahide ?7srael, @B99 /EA
2he Se(en !a*s 3or $an6ind
1 -ou shall practice e.uity, estalish an% promote ustice2 -ou shall not commit %olatry -ou shall not commit !lasphemy3 -ou shall not commit 4exual mmorality
5 -ou shall not commit ur%er6 -ou shall not commit The"t7 -ou shall not eat the lim torn "rom a li*e animal +lesh
(ith the li"e o" it, the loo% o" it, you shall not eat
"ccording to /i%lical tradition, the irst si+ uni(ersal la*s *ere gi(en to
"dam, the se(enth *as added or oah ater the lood.
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
8/46
8Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
e(ealed !a*s Decalogue ?7srael, @99 /EA
1. Cou shall ha(e no other gods %eore me.
#. Cou shall not ma6e idols to *orshi' them.
3. Cou shall not ta6e the name o the !ord thy God in (ain.
. emem%er the Sa%%ath day and 6ee' it holy.
.
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
9/46
9Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
E+am'le 7nunctions: !e(iticus1
2 #e shall not eat any thing with the blood! neither shall ye use enchantment, nor observe times.
24 #e shall not round the corners of your heads, neither shalt thou mar the corners of thy beard.
2 #e shall not make any cuttings in your flesh for the dead, nor print any marks upon you! Iam
the ord.
25 6o not prostitute thy daughter, to cause her to be a whore7 lest the land fall to whoredom, and
the land become full of wickedness.
3 #e shall keep my sabbaths, and reverence my sanctuary! I am the ord.
31 8egard not them that have familiar spirits, neither seek after wi9ards, to be defiled by them! I
am the ord your *od.
32 $hou shalt rise up before the hoary head, and honour the face of the old man, and fear thy *od!
I am the ord.
33 :nd if a stranger so;ourn with thee in your land, ye shall not ve% him.
3< But the stranger that dwelleth with you shall be unto you as one born among you, and thou shalt
love him as thyself7 for ye were strangers in the land of )gypt! Iam the ord your *od.
30 #e shall do no unrighteousness in ;udgment, in meteyard, in weight, or in measure.
3 -ust balances, ;ust weights, a ;ust ephah, and a ;ust hin, shall ye have! Iam the ord your *od,
which brought you out of the land of )gypt.
34 $herefore shall ye observe all my statutes, and all my ;udgments, and do them! Iam the ord.
http://scriptures.lds.org/en/lev/19/26ahttp://scriptures.lds.org/en/lev/19/26bhttp://scriptures.lds.org/en/lev/19/26chttp://scriptures.lds.org/en/lev/19/26dhttp://scriptures.lds.org/en/lev/19/27ahttp://scriptures.lds.org/en/lev/19/28ahttp://scriptures.lds.org/en/lev/19/28bhttp://scriptures.lds.org/en/lev/19/29ahttp://scriptures.lds.org/en/lev/19/29bhttp://scriptures.lds.org/en/lev/19/29chttp://scriptures.lds.org/en/lev/19/30ahttp://scriptures.lds.org/en/lev/19/30ahttp://scriptures.lds.org/en/lev/19/29chttp://scriptures.lds.org/en/lev/19/29bhttp://scriptures.lds.org/en/lev/19/29ahttp://scriptures.lds.org/en/lev/19/28bhttp://scriptures.lds.org/en/lev/19/28ahttp://scriptures.lds.org/en/lev/19/27ahttp://scriptures.lds.org/en/lev/19/26dhttp://scriptures.lds.org/en/lev/19/26chttp://scriptures.lds.org/en/lev/19/26bhttp://scriptures.lds.org/en/lev/19/26a
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
10/46
10Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
e(ealed hristian Doctrine ?7srael, @39 "DA
Follo* the !a*, o%ey the ommandments Do not only not s*ear oaths alsely, do not s*ear oaths at all /lessed are the mee6, the 'ersecuted, the merciul, the 'eacema6ers "gree *ith your ad(ersary, murder %egins in the heart, 2urn the other chee6, do not gi(e =an eye or an eye, a tooth or a tooth> !o(e your enemies, do good to those *ho hate you Do your charita%le deeds in secret, 'ray 'ri(ately, ast to %e seen only %y God !ay u' treasures in hea(en and not on earth, you cannot ser(e %oth God and
mammon "dultery is committed in the heart *hen you loo6 at a *oman *ith lust Di(orce is adultery, unless or se+ual immorality
Do not *orry ) a%out your lie, a%out ood and drin6, a%out clothingH.. udge not, that you %e not udged
According to the Gospels, Jesus of Naareth preached!
2hese no(el teachings em'hasi5ed humility, lo(ing 6indness,
and orgi(eness rather than 'rohi%itions and retri%ution
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
11/46
11Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
"n Essential 7dea: 2he Golden ule?sA
udaic:
What is hateful to you, do not do to your neighbor. hristian:
What you would want others to do to you, do so to them.
/uddhist:
Hurt not others with that which pains you. $uslim:
Desire for your brother that which you desire for yourself.
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
12/46
12Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
" Golden onundrum
0ractical !e(el "ssume homogeneity ) E(eryone thin6s the same
Em'hasi5e 'rinci'les o(er 'articulars ) E.g., 'leasure & 'ain
Empathi8e $$ 9o as they would have you do onto them:
once'tual !e(el Shared cogniti(e models
Family and Friends
!earned cogniti(e models: 7ndi(iduals ) 0sychology
Grou's ) Sociology
$etacogniti(e 'rocesses reate models
2est and reine models
"nalytical !e(el: 0hiloso'hies o Ethical 0rinci'les
;o( %o you
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
13/46
13Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
odes: hi(alry ?Euro'e, @1999 "DA1
I%ser(e all the hurch teaches
Deend the hurch
Do not recoil %eore your enemy
$a6e *ar on the 7nidel *ithout
cessation or mercy
!o(e your country o %irth 0erorm your eudal duties
ham'ion the ight and Good
against 7nustice and E(il
/e generous to e(eryone
es'ect all *ea6nesses and ma6eyoursel their deender
e(er lie, and 6ee' your *ord
1 "ter Gautier, hi(alry, 18
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
14/46
14Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
odes: $agna arta and the ule o !a* ?1#1A
Englands Jing ohn 'romises
his %arons in *riting that he *ill
=o%ey the la* o the land>
Esta%lishes the 'rinci'le that
Law is u''ermost, e(en or 6ings
ecogni5es the rights oindi(iduals *ithin states
0ro(ides a 'artial %asis or our
onstitution and /ill o ights
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
15/46
15Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
odes: /oy Scouts ?England, @199 "DA
2rust*orthy
!oyal
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
16/46
16Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
odes: West 0oint ?US", @19 "DA
" cadet *ill not lie, cheat or steal,
or tolerate those who doL
Sim'le codes are easy to remem%er, %ut in their sim'licity they may
neglect more com'le+ ethical and moral issues o great im'ortance
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
17/46
17Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
odes: Engineering 0roession ?US" @#999A
Engineers, in the ulillment o their 'roessional duties, shall:
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
18/46
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
19/46
19Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
E+am'le: reation o e* !a*s
Chil% >hurriers? in
1@th century coal mines
= hild la%or 'layed a maor role in the Euro'ean 7ndustrial e(olutionN $ore than 9O o children rom to 1 *or6ed *ithout regulationN 189# English la* reduced childrens *or6 day rom 1B to 1# hours
N 18; English la* limited adults and children to 19 hours *or6 dailyN hild la%or la*s 'resaged other restrictions on industrial 'ractices
/ut child la%or remains a *orld ethical issue todayL
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
20/46
20Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
E+am'le: e(ersal o E+isting !a*s
Sla(ery
Segregation
Discrimination
Su%ugation o Women
Disenranchisement
ontrace'tion4"%ortion
Derogatory S'eech
7nteracial $arriage
SameSe+ $arriage
Go(ernment Sur(eillance
ruel & Unusual 0unishment
2orture
Death 0enalty
hemical4/iological Wea'ons
!and $ines
Greenhouse Gas Emissions
Sale o /ody 0arts
Ithers
7n the US" many 're(iously legal 'ractices ha(e %een o(erturned or
are %eing ree+amined on the %asis o moral or ethical considerations:
$any urther e+am'les in 'olitics, %usiness, s'orts and daily lie.
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
21/46
21Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
Ethics, $orality and !a*: " !ocal E+am'le
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
22/46
22Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
Ethics, $orality and !a*: Summary
$any o the diicult 'ro%lems in engineering ethics lie inside the%oundary o *hat is legal.
"t the same time, things that *ere ormerly ethical Muestions
such as se+ual harassment, o%related age discrimination, and
ar%itrary dismissal are no* outside the !a*.
$ost o our outmoded la*s are still open issues from a
worldwide perspective, and 'ro(ide (alua%le insight into the
historical e(olution o morality, ethics and la*s.
2he challenge is to %uild a solid "ersonal #thical Framewor$ in the
ace o continual interaction and luctuation o morals, ethics and la*s
) and then to act decisi(ely on the %asis o that rame*or6.
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
23/46
23Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
Ethical 0hiloso'hies
7m'ortant Ethical 2heories
ights Ethics
Duty EthicsP
Qirtue EthicsP
UtilitarianismP
0ragmatism
"lternati(e Ethical 2heoriesP
0hiloso'hies are attem'ts to systemati5e, rationali5e and 'rescri%esocietal and 'ersonal ethical choices. We *ill re(ie*:
P"lso treated in Qan de 0oel and oya66ers, Ethics, 2echnology & Engineering
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
24/46
24Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
ights Ethics
Fundamental once'ts (s. =e* Society>
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
25/46
25Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
U.S. Declaration o 7nde'endence
>hen in the course of human events, it becomes necessary for one people to
dissolve the political bands which have connected them with another,
and to assume among the powers of the earth, the separate and e?ual station to
which the aws of @ature and of @atureAs *od entitle them, a decent respect
to the opinions of mankind re?uires that they should declare the causes which
impact them to the separation.
>e hold these truths to be self evident
= $hat all men are created e?ual= $hat they are endowed by their reator with certain inalienable 8ights= $hat among these are ife, iberty and the ursuit of +appiness= $hat to secure these rights, governments are instituted among Cen, deriving
their ;ust powers from the consent of the governed
= $hat whenever any Dorm of *overnment becomes destructive of these ends,it is the 8ight of the eople to alter or abolish it, and to institute new *overnE
ment, laying its foundation on such principles and organi9ing its powers such
form, as to them shall seem most likely to effect their /afety and +appiness.
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
26/46
26Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
ights 7ssues
Where Do ights ome From
Iutside Sources: God, ature, %atural Law 7nside Sources: odes, !a*s, !eason
Wrongs: /ad E+'eriences R $orality1
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
27/46
27Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
ase 7n 0oint: aliornia Fair
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
28/46
28Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
ase 7n 0oint: aliornia Fair
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
29/46
29Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
Ither ights 7n I''osition
ight to 6ee' and %ear arms
ight to reedom o s'eech
ights o deendants
ight to health care
ight to medical treatment
ight to a clean en(ironment
ight to chose a%ortion
ight to 'ersonal 'ro'erty
Etc., Etc.
ight to saety and 'rotection
ight to a nonhostile en(ironment
ights o (ictims and o society
ight to 'ersonal inde'endence
ight to reuse to gi(e treatment
ight to a 'roita%le %usiness
ight o etus to lie
ight o society to resources
Etc., Etc.
ight I''osing ight
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
30/46
30Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
Duty Ethics ?Deontological EthicsA
Fundamental once'ts eMuired duties are actions that agree *ith %asic morals Em'hasis is on *hat *e o*e to others $irror image o rights or e(ery right there is a duty
elated 7ssues Uniication 'rinci'les
"utonomy ) $an determines morality through reason
Uni(ersality ) 0rinci'les a''ly eMually to all 'eo'le
eci'rocity es'ect others desires, needs, eorts
(ant)s Categorical *mperative
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
31/46
31Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
2he ategorical 7m'erati(e
First ormulation ?2he Uni(ersal !a*A:
+ct only according to that maim whereby you can, at the same
time, will that it should become a universal law.
Second ormulation ?2he End in 7tselA
-o act that you treat humanity, whether in your own person or in the person of any other, always at the same time as an end, never
merely as a means.
7mmanuel Jant, roundwor$ of the etaphysics of orals, /012
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
32/46
32Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
Duty Ethics
Fundamental once'ts Duties are %asic $irror image o rights or e(ery right there is a duty Em'hasis on *hat *e o*e to others
elated 7ssues Uniication 'rinci'les
"utonomy ) Go(erning ones o*n lie morally
Uni(ersality ) 0rinci'les a''ly eMually to all 'eo'le es'ect Ither 'eo'les desires, needs, eorts
(ant)s Categorical *mperative
E+am'les 2he Decalogue ode o hi(alry adet
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
33/46
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
34/46
34Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
(irtues o 0lato and
"ristotle *ere mainly
intended or *ealthy,
lando*ning males
oman (irtues o
icero *ere intended
or ci(ic leaders o the
more e+'ansi(e and
militant oman Em'ire
Wisdom
ourage 2em'erance
ustice
Faith
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
35/46
35Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
Qirtue Ethics
Fundamental once'ts
Qirtues are desira%le as $oti(es, attitudes and emotions
Guides to conduct
/eing a (irtuous 'erson
elated 7ssues
E(olution o (irtues 2he =Golden $ean>
"ssociation *ith societal classes
E+am'les eligious 'rece'ts
/oy Scout Iath
ecent commentators ha(e suggested that a return to sim'le (irtue ethics
might %e a solution to our a''arent loss o any ethical oundation
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
36/46
36Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
E+am'le: $urray on "mericas ritical Qirtues
In his 212 book Goming :partH author harles
Curray gives :mericaAs founding virtues as!= Industriousness
= +onesty
= Carriage
= 8eligiosity
+e says the lack of or adherence to these virtuesis what is separating the Gnew lower classH fromthe Gnew upper class,H and he provides statisticalevidence to support his thesis.
Do you see this as reasonable,
or is $urray off on a wrong track
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
37/46
37Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
Utilitarianism ?onseMuentialismA
Fundamental once'ts: Inly the conseMuences o an action are morally rele(ant "ctions are a %alance o good (s. %ad conseMuences "ctions should 'roduce =the most ha''iness or the most 'eo'le>
elated 0rinci'les: ohn Stuart $ill =Do no harm> =0romote reedom>
E+am'les: ars: S'eed & on(enience (s. Saety & Economy "ir and Water 0ollution: 0u%lic
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
38/46
38Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
0ragmatism Fundamental once'ts
onte+t ) 7n *hich acts and (alues must %e %alanced
"nalysis Ethical reasoning (s. i+ed rules or ideals Fle+i%ility ) 7n integrating and harmoni5ing com'eting (alues
elated 0rinci'les Guidance in methods o analytical thought
Warnings o negati(e conseMuences
0ractical "''roach ases are concrete dilemmas ) *ith diering moral4ethical o'inions
Em'hasi5ing principles oten leads to accentuation o dierences
Em'hasi5ing particulars o(er principles can lead to 'ragmatic
reconciliation o dierences
Didn)t we earlier say the opposite with regard to the olden !ule3
&+ foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds.'
!alph Waldo #merson
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
39/46
39Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
"lternati(e Ethical Structures
onudeo4hristian: 7slamic, /uddhist,
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
40/46
40Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
2he ole o eligion
$homas -efferson created a personal @ew
$estament that contained -esusA moral and
ethical teachings, but eliminated all of the
miracles and supernatural happenings. $he
/mithsonian Institute recently republished theoriginal -efferson Bible.
$he 6alai ama has said! G:ll of us, all human beings, are
basically inclined toward what we perceive to be good…In view
of this, I am of the firm opinion that we have within our grasp a
secular way and means to ground inner values without
contradicting any religion and yet, crucially, without depending
on any religion.H
While religion can certainly %e a guide to ethics, many 'eo'le, e(en religious
ones, ha(e also sought a secular, or nonreligious, 'ath to ethical %eha(ior
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
41/46
41Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
2he ole o Science and eason
GCodern sensibilities have increasingly conceived
moral worth in terms of consciousness, particularly the
ability to suffer and flourish, and have identifiedconsciousness with the activity of the brain. The
change is part of the turning away from religion and
custom and toward science and secular philosophy as
a source of moral illumination.
/teven inker
$he Better :ngels of our @ature
Gnce reasoning has got started its hard to tell where
it will stop.H
eter /inger
$he )%panding ircle! )thics and /ociobiology
0in6er is certain, Singer not so much, %ut %oth see moral ho'e in reason
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
42/46
42Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
!easoning *tself and $oral or Ethical "ctions
&+n act has no ethical 4uality whatsoever unless it be chosen out ofseveral 5acts that are6 all e4ually possible.'
William ames 2he 0rinci'les o 0sychology, 189
William ames, reno*ned 1th century 'sychologist and 'hiloso'her,
comes do*n irmly on the side o conscious
choice, and thereore reasoning, as a critical
com'onent o ethical action.
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
43/46
43Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
Does Ethics De'end on easoning
o, it does otL
=!ather, moral action depends on compassion. "arents need no reasoning tonourish their children to loving $indness. Human beings need no reasoningto help other needy humans and creatures. +ll we truly need is compassion.'
Ces, i..
&..that means that moral action depends on reason. We do not have to gothrough a process of reason7ing in order to arrive at a view of what morality
re4uires on every occasion. 8ften, we simply $now. 9ut moral action doesnot merely depend on reason. oral action is rational action, because themoral law is a law of reason.'
Ces and o.
=:es because the actions we can truly call moral depend on the wor$ of
reason at some stage, no because the moment7to7moment eecution ofactions, moral or otherwise, is not necessarily under the control of reason.'
2odays ethical 'hiloso'hers are di(ided, citing a (ariety o actors including genetics.
For a com'lete 'resentation o these and other (ie*s, see ***.tem'leton.org4reason.
:ref :li @ayed
&alam 8esearch, 6ubai
rof. &ristine &orsgaard
+arvard niversity
rof. :ntonio 6amasio
/
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
44/46
44Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
"re Ethics 7ntuiti(e
onathan to orm their moralities, and thatthese e(olutionary attitudes contri%ute more to the
control o %eha(ior than does reason.
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
45/46
45Copyright Gershon Weltman, 2015
"re Ethics 7ntuiti(e
onathan
-
8/18/2019 02 - Ethical Foundations
46/46
Copyright Gershon Weltman 2015
2he 7m'ortance o E+'erience
&@he life of the law has not been logicA it has been eperience.'
udge Ili(er Wendell undou%tedly includes the a%ility to reason as *ell.