0$%(#*(1+&(23%/*( 4'%56758(%9:(;&.',( )'
Transcript of 0$%(#*(1+&(23%/*( 4'%56758(%9:(;&.',( )'
!"#$%&'()'%"#*$(
+,(
-./(0$%""(#*(1+&(2"3%/*(
4'%5675"8(%9:(;&.',(
)'<'=6+9*((
2,$+9:(!+.'98(
>?'=56@'(A#,'=&+,(
!"'%9(2#,(B%*C(D+,='(
B%C'%3%/*(
• -'($%/(9'':(&+(:,+E(&+(F',+(+,(9'G%6@'(=%,H+9('$#**#+9*(H/(IJKJ(
• B+:%/L*(M*+NO(*+"56+9*(%"+9'(3+9L&(G'&(5*(&.','(E./*#=%""/(+,('=+9+$#=%""/(P(%:@%9=':(7+**#"(%9:(95="'%,('9',G/(=%9L&(H'(,5"':(+5&(
• -'(9'':($5=.(H'Q',8(=.'%E',(&'=.9+"+G/(P(%9:(&.','7+,'(%("+&(+7(#99+@%6+9(
• D+,&59%&'"/8(G"+H%"#F%6+9($%/(.'"E(&.%&(
• R'%93.#"'8(3'(9'':(&+(&.#9C(%H+5&(*.+,&(&',$(:%$%G'(=+9&,+"(
• 1+9'(+7(&.#*(3#""(.%EE'9(7%*&(• -'(9'':(!"#$(H+":9'**(%9:(.5$#"#&/(
I(
S(
-'($%/(9'':(&+(G'&(&+(F',+(
B.#*(#*(%(H#G("#N(
STUK(
VJ(
VW(
J(
K(
SJ(
SK(
IJ(
IK(
VJ(
VK(
XJ(
XK(
IJSJ(>9',G/( IJKJ(>9',G/(YSUKZ(
G,+3&.[(
IJKJ(>9',G/(YIZ(G,+3&.[(
>9',G/(:'$%9:(
YB-[(
R5*&(H'(%""(=%,H+9(7,''(#9(
+,:',(&+(G'&(&+(F',+(
X(
K(
-.%&(#*(&.'(=.%""'9G'\(
-
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
55
60
1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010 2020 2030 2040 2050 2060
Year
Glo
bal C
arb
on
Dio
xid
e E
mis
sio
ns
(Gt/
year) • A'=%,H+9#F'(%""('"'=&,#=#&/(G'9',%6+9(
• 0.#N(%""(&,%9*E+,&%6+9(&+('"'=&,#=#&/(+,(
F',+]=%,H+9(75'"*U(
• 0.#N(%""(#9:5*&,#%"(E,+='**'*(&+(
'"'=&,#=#&/(+,(F',+]=%,H+9(75'"*U(
• 0.#N(%""(H5#":#9G*(&+('"'=&,#=#&/(7+,(
^_2!U(
• A+(%""(&.#*(#9(XJ]KJ(/'%,*(*&%,69G(9+3U(
• `#@'9(6$']"%G*(%9:(#$E',7'=6+9*(#9(
'?'=56+98(3'($%/(*6""(.%@'(&+(:'@'"+E(%9:(%EE"/(!;I('?&,%=6+9(&'=.9+"+G#'*(#9(E%,%""'"U(
!"#$%&'&(&)*&$+*&),(-.$
T(
a(
b(
!"#$%&&'()'"*+,"(%-*(".*"#*//0.".*"1,*2+#0()"344"1',#'(."*5"*+,"'&'#.,0#0.6"5,*/",'('7%8&'"'(',)6"%(2".,+&6"#&'%("#%,8*(95,''":*+,#':"70.$0("34"6'%,:;""]](2"(`+,'8(c5"/(
IJJb(
-'L@'("++C':(%&(%(,%9G'(+7(G"+H%"(%9:(
>d(*&5:#'*(+9(&.#*(&+E#=(
W(
B.'(.+E'75"(@#'3(](*5$$%,#F':(
• !/0(.1&/&)23$-)$&)&(45$&6*-&)*5$*,)$2,7&$*,(&$.'$,$38932,):,;$0.(:.)$.'$4(.<-)4$=&/,)=>$
• ?@&$*8((&)2$4&)&(,:.)$.'$(&)&<,9;&3$A-)*;8=-)4$9-.'8&;3B$*,)$2,7&$*,(&$.'$2@&$(&32>$
• ?@-3$*,)$,;;$9&$=.)&$95$CDED$<-2@$*8((&)2$2&*@).;.45>$
• ?@-3$*,)$,;;$9&$=.)&$95$CDED$,2$/.=&32$*.32>$
• #44(&33-1&$&/-33-.)3$(&=8*:.)3$-)$2@&$F+$,)=$"F$<-;;$@,1&$4;.9,;$-/0,*2>$
SJ(
-.%&(#*(3,+9G(3#&.(&.#*(E#=&5,'\((SU(>9',G/(
e9&'9*#&/(
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
1980 1990 2000 2010 2020 2030 2040 2050 2060
Year
Glo
bal To
tal P
rim
ary
En
erg
y D
em
an
d (
TW
-yr)
ActualIEA ReferenceGreenpeace/ERECWorldwatch
0.0% 0.5% 1.0% 1.5% 2.0% 2.5% 3.0% 3.5% 4.0% 4.5% 5.0%
Global 1990 - 2005
OECD 1990 - 2005
California 1981 - 1986
California 1987 - 1996
California 1997 - 2008
IEA Reference (2050)
Greenpeace/EREC (2050)
WWF (2050)
Jacobson & Delucchi (2030)
Worldwatch (2030)
Annual Rate of Reduction in Energy Intensity (MJ/$GDP)
G(.H&*:.)3$
I-32.(-*,;$
!"#$%&'&(&)*&$+*&),(-.$
“J(&&)”$+*&),(-.3$
• B+($%&=.(&.'(E,+f'=&':(75&5,'(Bg>(:'$%9:*(#9($%9/(G,''9(E"%9*8(
'9',G/(#9&'9*#&/(Y'9',G/(5*'(E',(59#&(
+7(`Ag8(>e[(.%*(&+(#$E,+@'(%&(
$5"6E"'*(+7(.#*&+,#=(,%&'*U(
• B.'(3.+"'(3+,":(.%*(&+($%&=.(
!%"#7+,9#%(%&(#&*(H'*&(](7+,(XJ(/'%,*U(
• ^#*&+,#=%"(#$E,+@'$'9&*(#9(>e(#9(
'@'9(&.'($+*&(E,+G,'**#@'(E+"#=/('9@#,+9$'9&*(.%@'(H''9(',,%6=U(
• g,+G,'**(#9(!.#9%(.%*(%"*+(H''9(
59'@'98(:'*E#&'(%$H#6+5*(
G+@',9$'9&(&%,G'&*(7+,(
#$E,+@'$'9&h(
– >e(%&'()*+),(%&(VUIZ(EU%U(7,+$(
IJJS]IJJK8(
– >e(,)'()*+),(%&(VUbZ(EU%U(H'&3''9(IJJK]IJJW8((
– >e(%&'()*+),(H/(VUIZ(#9(IJSJU(
SS(
R+*&(+7(E,+f'=&':(G,+3&.(#*(7,+$(
:'@'"+E#9G(3+,":(
• 90% of projected growth from non-OECD countries.
• 52% of growth from China and India alone.
SI(
K.(2@$#/&(-*,$
K.)LM"NO$"8(.0&$
+>$#/&(-*,$
M2@&($#3-,$
N@-),$
#'(-*,$ !)=-,$
%833-,$
M"NO$#3-,$
M"NO$"8(.0&$
P-==;&$",32$
N@-),$-)$CDDQ$
+.8(*&R$N#?S$'(./$!"M$ACDTDB$
$$$$$$
?@&$=&1&;.0-)4$<.(;=$@,3$,$;.2$.'$;,2&)2U$3800(&33&=$=&/,)=(
;>!A(
SV(
J(
KJ8JJJ(
SJJ8JJJ(
SKJ8JJJ(
IJJ8JJJ(
IKJ8JJJ(
VJJ8JJJ(
VKJ8JJJ(
SWWJ( IJSJ(3#&.(9+('9',G/('i=#'9=/(E+"#=/(
IJSJ(3#&.('i#=#'9=/(E+"#=/(
SJZ(
N,;-'.()-,$&;&*2(-*-25$=&/,)=$A?VIB$
+.8(*&R$N#?S$'(./$N,;>$")&(45$N.//-33-.)U$+2,)'.(=$G(&*.8(2$N&)2&($ACDDWB$
-#*.(3'(%""(=+5":(H'(!%"#7+,9#%(U(U(U(U((
SX(
>j'=&*(+7(M'9',G/(=+9@',G'9='O(
SK(
D$
TDD$
CDD$
QDD$
XDD$
EDD$
YDD$
ZDD$
WDD$
CDDE$ CDTD$ CDTE$ CDCD$ CDCE$ CDQD$ CDQE$
[8,
=(-;;-.)$\28$
J;.9,;$?.2,;$?G"$CDDZ$L$CDQE$8)=&($\#FU$TD]$9&;.<$\#F$A^N,;-'.()-,^BU$,)=$N8((&)2$N@-)&3&$0&($N,0-2,$_&1&;3$
")&(45`\#F$ ")&(45`NIK$ ")&(45`N#_$
ST(
;9(&.'(*+N(M*5EE"/(
*#:'O(U(U(U(UU((
)'9'3%H"'*(:+9L&(*5EE"/(*&'%:/(IXka(E+3',(
Sa(
4'=%5*'(3'(:+(9+&(.%@'(G,#:(*=%"'(
'9',G/(*&+,%G'(=%E%H#"#&/(U(U((– 0#G9#l=%9&(G%*(&5,H#9'(H%=C5E(=%E%=#&/(,'m5#,':U(
– -#:'(%,'%(9'&3+,C(=++E',%6+9(,'m5#,':U(
– 2::#6+9%"("+9G]:#*&%9='(&,%9*$#**#+9(=%E%=#&/(,'m5#,':U(
• 0#G9#l=%9&(G%*(&5,H#9'(H%=C5E(=%E%=#&/(,'m5#,':8(%"+9G(3#&.(%**+=#%&':(=+*&(%9:('$#**#+9*U(
• -#:'(%,'%(9'&3+,C(=++E',%6+9(,'m5#,':U(
• 2::#6+9%"("+9G]:#*&%9='(&,%9*$#**#+9(=%E%=#&/(,'m5#,':U(
• g',7'=&(.+5,"/(7+,'=%*69G(+@',("%,G'(%,'%*(,'m5#,':U(
• B.'*'(%""(%::(=+*&U(
Sb(
)'9%3%H"'*(.%@'("+3(M=%E%=#&/(7%=&+,O(
0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 40%
US 2007
US 2008
US 2009
UK 2009
UK 2010
Spain 1999-2008
Germany 2005-2008
EU15 Offshore 2003-2007
EU15 2003-2007
Capacity Factor
V-)=$N,0,*-25$S,*2.(3$
B/E#=%"(@%"5'(=#&':(
0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 40%
US 2007
US 2008
US 2009
Germany 2009
Spain 2007-2008
Capacity Factor
+.;,($Ga$N,0,*-25$S,*2.(3$
SW(
29:(&.','(%,'(3''C*(3.'9(&.'(3#9:(
H"+3*(.%,:"/(%&(%""(U(U((
IJ(
B'?%*8(25G5*&(IJSS(
!+9*'m5'9='*(
• B+(%=.#'@'(*%$'('$#**#+9*(:#*E"%='$'9&8('@'9(
%**5$#9G(*$++&.(+5&E5&8('%=.(`-(+7(H%*'"+%:(
$5*&(H'(,'E"%=':(H/(V(&+(SJ(`-(+7(3#9:(+,(*+"%,(
g_U(
• R5=.(G,'%&',(#$E%=&(+9("%9:(5*'U(
• B,%9*$#**#+9($5*&(H'(*#F':(7+,(E'%C("+%:(
Y%::#6+9%"(=+*&[U(
IS(
g+3',(A'9*#&/(
?@&3&$3.;,($b&;=3$0(.1-=&$&).84@$@&,2$'.($;&33$2@,)$T]$.'$2@&$.82082$.'$2@-3$*./9-)&=$*5*;&$0;,)2$
S;.(-=,$G.<&($c$_-4@2$P,(:)$G;,)2$
+.;,($?(.84@$!)32,;;,:.)$
• B.'("+3(E+3',(:'9*#&/(+7(*+"%,(%9:(3#9:(=+$H#9':(3#&.(&.'(9'':(7+,(V(](X(6$'*(H%*'"+%:(=%E%=#&/(.%*('9+,$+5*(#$E"#=%6+9*(7+,("%9:]5*'(,'m5#,'$'9&*U(
• B.'(R%,69(E"%9&(=%E%=#&/(#*(VaJJ(R-8(+7(3.#=.(&.'(KJJ(%=,'(*+"%,(=+""'=&+,(=%9(E,+@#:'(%(
-)*.(+7(aK(R-(Y9++9(+9(%(*599/(D"+,#:%(:%/[8(H5&(%9(*/)(*0)(+7(Sb(R-U(
II(
D++&E,#9&h(!%E'(-#9:(>9',G/(%9:(
_',*5*(SaJ(R-(`%*(g"%9&U(0%$'(
+5&E5&U(
=
25 sq. m
;j*.+,'(3#9:(
IV(
1.0E-02
1.0E-01
1.0E+00
1.0E+01
1.0E+02
1.0E+03
1.0E-02 1.0E+00 1.0E+02 1.0E+04 1.0E+06 1.0E+08 1.0E+10
Area (m2)
Po
wer
Den
sity
(W
/m
2)
15="'%,(
`'+&.',$%"(
!0g(
4#+$%**(
g.+&+@+"&%#=*(-#9:(Y7%,$[(
!+%"(
^/:,+(
4%*':(+9(:%&%(#9(McDonald RI, Fargione J, Kiesecker J, Miller WM, Powell J (2009) “Energy Sprawl or Energy Efficiency: Climate Policy Impacts on Natural Habitat for the United States of America.” PLoS ONE 4(8): e6802. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0006802
1%&(`%*(
Y3'""(+9"/[(
1%&(`%*(YG%*(l'":[(
IX(
1.0E-02
1.0E-01
1.0E+00
1.0E+01
1.0E+02
1.0E+03
1.0E-02 1.0E+00 1.0E+02 1.0E+04 1.0E+06 1.0E+08 1.0E+10
Area (m2)
Po
wer
Den
sity
(W
/m
2)
15="'%,(
`'+&.',$%"(
!0g(
4#+$%**(
g.+&+@+"&%#=*(-#9:(Y7%,$[(
!+%"(
^/:,+(
4%*':(+9(:%&%(#9(McDonald RI, Fargione J, Kiesecker J, Miller WM, Powell J (2009) “Energy Sprawl or Energy Efficiency: Climate Policy Impacts on Natural Habitat for the United States of America.” PLoS ONE 4(8): e6802. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0006802 and in Smil V, “Energy at the Crossroads,” MIT Press 2003.
1%&(`%*(
Y3'""(+9"/[(
1%&(`%*(YG%*(l'":[(
!#6'*(
0&''"($#""*8(,'l9',#'*(
e9:5*&,/(
05E',$%,C'&*(
^#G.],#*'*(
^+5*'*(
IK(
)'9'3%H"'(*E%='(,'m5#,'$'9&*(%,'(
"'%:#9G(&+(*5H*&%96%"("%9:(5*'(=+9<#=&(
IT(
!%E%=#&/(%::#6+9*(
Ia(
Wind
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
900
1000
2010 - 2020 2020 - 2030 2030 - 2040 2040 - 2050
Cap
aci
ty A
dd
itio
ns
(GW
/year)
Greenpeace/EREC WWF WEO 450IEA Blue Map CCSP IGSM*CCSP MERGE*CCSP MiniCAM*WorldwatchMcKinsey AMcKinsey BLenzen & SchaefferJacobson & Delucchi
Photovoltaics
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
900
2010 - 2020 2020 - 2030 2030 - 2040 2040 - 2050
Cap
aci
ty A
dd
itio
ns
(GW
/year)
Greenpeace/EREC WWF WEO 450IEA Blue Map CCSP IGSM*CCSP MERGE*CCSP MiniCAM*WorldwatchMcKinsey AMcKinsey BLenzen & SchaefferJacobson & Delucchi
Solar Thermal
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
2010 - 2020 2020 - 2030 2030 - 2040 2040 - 2050
Cap
aci
ty A
dd
itio
ns
(GW
/year)
Greenpeace/EREC WWF WEO 450IEA Blue Map CCSP IGSM*CCSP MERGE*CCSP MiniCAM*WorldwatchMcKinsey AMcKinsey BLenzen & SchaefferJacobson & Delucchi
Biomass
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
200
2010 - 2020 2020 - 2030 2030 - 2040 2040 - 2050
Cap
aci
ty A
dd
itio
ns
(GW
/year)
Greenpeace/EREC WWF WEO 450IEA Blue Map CCSP IGSM*CCSP MERGE*CCSP MiniCAM*WorldwatchMcKinsey AMcKinsey BLenzen & Schaeffer
e9:#=%&'*(.#*&+,#=%"('?E',#'9='(
!+*&(
_&1&;-d&=$N.32$.'$";&*2(-*-25$AefPV@B$Y4"++$H',G(1'3(>9',G/(D#9%9='(nV(IJSJ[$
• B.'(+E6+9*(%:@+=%&':(7+,(3#:'*E,'%:(:'E"+/$'9&(H/($%9/(G,''9(G,+5E*(%,'(%$+9G(&.'($+*&('?E'9*#@'h(
– ;='%98(*+"%,(g_8(*+"%,(&.',$%"8(H#+$%**8(3#9:8(G'+&.',$%"U(
“J(&&)”$',1.(-2&3$
R%,C'&(E,+?/(
Ib(
4#+75'"*(=%9(:,#@'(*5H*&%96%"(
3%,$#9G(&.,+5G.("%9:(5*'(=.%9G'(
IW(
29
g+"#=/]:,#@'9(:'$%9:(7+,(
H#+75'"*(#9=,'%*'*(
(
(
D%,$',*(*.#N(&+('9',G/(=,+E*(
(
o+*&(7++:(E,+:5=6+9(#9(d0k>d(
#*($%:'(5E(+@',*'%*8(+N'9(#9(
&,+E#=%"(F+9'*(
(
(
1'3(+@',*'%*(7++:(E,+:5=6+9(
:#*E"%='*(G,%F#9G(
(
(
`,%F#9G(:#*E"%='*(7+,'*&*(
(
(
g"%9&(%9:(*+#"(=%,H+9(#*(
,'"'%*':(#9&+(&.'(%&$+*E.','(
`%*(:#*E"%=#9G(=+%"(=%9(.'"E(H5&(#*(9+&(
%(=+$E"'&'(%9*3',(
VJ(
g,#+,#6'*(7+,(#99+@%6+9(&+('9%H"'(
1*(0)2+'*1)2,'*E+9*'*(• 0&+,%G'(%9:(+&.',(+E6+9*(&+('9%H"'(,'9'3%H"'('9',G#'*(
• B,%9*7+,$#9G(7+**#"('9',G/h(=%,H+9(=%E&5,'(
%9:(*&+,%G'(
• 15="'%,(E+3',(VUJ(%9:(XUJ(P(*&%,69G(3#&.(*$%""($+:5"%,(95="'%,(o-)*8($+@#9G(&+3%,:(
%:@%9=':(=+9='E&*(
VS(
`,#:]*=%"'(=+$E,'**':(%#,('9',G/(
*&+,%G'(7+,(@%,#%H"'(G'9',%6+9(
VI(
2&(,'%*+9%H"'(*#&'8($%/(9'':(
• pIUK?(&.'(#9*&%""':(=%E%=#&/(
• 45&8(E,+@#:'*(IXka(E+3',(
!+%"(+,(G%*(3#&.(=%,H+9(=%E&5,'(%9:(
*&+,%G'(
VV(
d9:',G,+59:(=+%"(G%*#l=%6+9(
(
VX(
0$%""($+:5"%,(95="'%,(
VK(
2:@%9=':(95="'%,(
• 0'@',%"(:+$'*6=(*&%,&]5E(=+$E%9#'*(%,'(:'@'"+E#9G(%(,%9G'(+7(#99+@%6@'(
*$%""($+:5"%,(95="'%,(,'%=&+,(:'*#G9*(P(#9="5:#9G(B',,%E+3',(3.#=.(4#""(
`%&'*(.%*($%:'(%(*5H*&%96%"(#9@'*&$'9&(#9U(
• B.'(d0($%/(3'""(H'(E+#*':(&+(&%C'(%("'%:(G"+H%""/(#9(&.#*(&'=.9+"+G/(*E%='((((
• 2&("'%*&(+9'(#99+@%6@'(,'%=&+,(:'*#G9(P("#m5#:(*%"&(&.+,#5$(Yo0B)[(](=+5":(
.%@'(.5G'('9',G/(*'=5,#&/8(="#$%&'(%9:(:+$'*6=('9',G/(#9:5*&,/(#$E%=&*((
• 29+&.',(#9&','*69G(#99+@%6@'(:'*#G9(#*(&.'(%=='"',%&+,]:,#@'9(*5H=,#6=%"(,'%=&+,(Y2A0[(
VT(
o#m5#:(*%"&(&.+,#5$(,'%=&+,(
=.%,%=&',#*6=*((• _',/(*%7'(:'*#G9(((
• o#Q"'k9+(95="'%,(E,+"#7',%6+9(,#*C(
• SJJZ(=+9@',*#+9(+7(95="'%,(75'"(&+('9',G/(%*(+EE+*':(&+(TZ(#9(&+:%/L*(,'%=&+,*(
• R+:'*&(95="'%,(3%*&'($%9%G'$'9&(,'m5#,'$'9&*(
• <(&0/0.'2(d0(75'"(%@%#"%H#"#&/(• )'%:#"/($%957%=&5,':(%9:(*.+5":(
H'('=+9+$#=%""/(=+$E'66@'(3#&.(=+9@'96+9%"(=+%"(((
• !+,'(&'=.9+"+G/(+E',%&':kE,+@'9(7+,(7+5,(/'%,*(%&(;%C()#:G'(1%6+9%"(o%H(#9(&.'("%&'(SWTJ*(
Va(
15="'%,(:'E"+/$'9&h((
Vb(
Nuclear
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
2010 - 2020 2020 - 2030 2030 - 2040 2040 - 2050
Cap
aci
ty A
dd
itio
ns
(GW
/year)
Greenpeace/EREC WWF WEO 450IEA Blue Map CCSP IGSM*CCSP MERGE*CCSP MiniCAM*WorldwatchMcKinsey AMcKinsey BLenzen & Schaeffer
^#*&+,#=%"('?E',#'9='(
!.#9%(%9:(e9:#%($%/(H'(#$E+,&%9&(
%""#'*(#9(&.'(#99+@%6+9(E,+='**(
• !.#9%(%9:(e9:#%(P(,'%"($%,C'&*(7+,(9'3('9',G/(
Y59"#C'(;>!A[(P(*+(H5#":#9G(="'%9(#*(*$%""',(
#9=,'$'9&%"(=+*&(
• !.#9%(]]("#m5#:#&/(• !.#9%(P(7%*&(=+9*&,5=6+9(• !.#9%(P("+3',(=+*&(=+9*&,5=6+9(• !.#9%(%9:(e9:#%(P9%6@'(M,'@',*'(#99+@%6+9O(Y95="'%,8(!!0[(
VW(
g+*&]!+$H5*6+9(d9#&(%&(^5%9'9G(0.%9G.%#(0.#:+9GC+5U(
XJ(
-./(:%$%G'(=+9&,+"\(
• -'(%,'("#C'"/(G+#9G(&+(H,'%=.(I(%9:(V(:'G,''(
&.,'*.+":*(#7(3'(,'"/(+9('9',G/(*/*&'$(
&,%9*7+,$%6+9(7+,(!;I(,':5=6+9(%"+9'U(
• 4,'%=.#9G(&.'*'(&.,'*.+":*($%/(.%@'(
'j'=6@'"/(#,,'@',*#H"'(=+9*'m5'9='*(Y'UGU(
2,=6=(*'%(#='(%9:(G"%=#',("+**8(.%H#&%&(
:'*&,5=6+9[(
XS(
• ~ 0.76 Realized • 0.5 Lagged in oceans • 1.1 Masked
Molina, Zaelke, et al (PNAS 2009)
Arctic Sea Ice Extent: 2007 “Moved the Mean”
43
A%$%G'(=+9&,+"(+E6+9*(
• 0&+E(&,%9*#'9&(3%,$#9G('$#**#+9*("#C'(
$'&.%9'(%9:(H"%=C(=%,H+9(
• 2=='"',%&':(=%,H+9(,'$+@%"(7,+$(&.'(
%&$+*E.','(&.,+5G.(H#+"+G#=%"(%9:(=.'$#=%"(
$'%9*(
• M`'+]'9G#9'',#9GO(P(#9="5:#9G(*+"%,(,%:#%6+9($%9%G'$'9&(
XX(
Radiative forcing 1750-2005 (from 2007 AR 4, WG I, Fig 2.21)
45
Methane Fixes
46
Coal Mine Capture
Sewage Treatment Capture
23 Megawatt landfill methane power plant
Anaerobic manure digestion
e$%G'*(*+5,='h(q'#&.(YIJJb[(
2#,(=%E&5,'h(#9*5,%9='(7+,(%9(59=',&%#9(
75&5,'(
Xa(
A#,'=&(,'$+@%"(+7(!;I(7,+$(&.'(%&$+*E.','($%/(H'=+$'(
9'='**%,/((
!+9@'96+9%"(1%;^(*=,5HH#9G(&'=.9+"+G/(#*(H'#9G(
:'@'"+E':(7+,(&.#*(E5,E+*'8(%*(%,'($+,'(%:@%9=':(
%EE,+%=.'*((
!+*&*(%EE'%,(&+(H'(*'@',%"(6$'*(&.+*'(+7(!;I(,'$+@%"(
7,+$(<5'(G%*8(H5&(,':5=6+9*($%/(H'(E+**#H"'(&.,+5G.h(((
• ((0#69G(9'%,(E,'7',,':(*'m5'*&,%6+9(• ((d*'(+7(*&,%9:':(,'9'3%H"'(E+3',((
2GG,'**#@'(%j+,'*&%6+9\(
Xb(
0+"%,(,%:#%6+9($%9%G'$'9&(=+9='E&*(
XW(
KJ(
1+9'(+7(&.#*(3#""(.%EE'9(7%*&(
KS(
-.','(9'?&(
• 4'(H+&.(*00()++%/)(%9:(()*1%+3'2• B.#9C(+'*1)*!1)2P(*$%""(#*(9+&(%"3%/*(H'%5675"(
• -'(:+9L&(.%@'(%(=+$E"'&'(*+"56+9(*'&(
• !.#9%(%9:(e9:#%(%*(#99+@%6+9(&'*&(H':*(%9:('9G#9'*(
• 4'(.5$H"'(P(+5,(E,':#=6@'(=%E%H#"&/(#9('9',G/(
.%*(E,+@'9(@',/(3'%C(
KI(
R%C#9G(*'9*'(+7(,'='9&(=+$E%,#*+9*(
+7(G+%"(%9:(G%*(="#$%&'(#$E%=&*(
)'*5"&*(%,'(7%#,"/(*#$#"%,(
=>;3"?@;A"
=A;3"=?;?" =B;>"
?4;@"
CB;@"
?C;C"
34B;D"CC;@" CC;?" 344;@" C=;A"
34=;B"343;C"
34?;B"
JUJ(
IJUJ(
XJUJ(
TJUJ(
bJUJ(
SJJUJ(
SIJUJ(
J(
IJ(
XJ(
TJ(
bJ(
SJJ(
SIJ(
A4(IJSJ(
A4(IJSS(
c%,%$#""+(
4%,9'Q(
A+$'*6=(
!+9@(o+3(
!+9@(^#G.(
0.%"'(o+3(
0.%"'(^#G.(
A4(
c%,%$#""+(
A+$'*6=(
g)4(
e""#9+#*(rT(
05,7%='(
d9:',G,+59:(
74$NMC&fP
P\28$
N./0,(-3.)$.'$KJ$,)=$N.,;$\8()&(:0$JIJ$"/-33-.)3$-)$%&*&)2$_N#3$
R'&.%9'(
dE*&,'%$(!;I(
D5'"(!;I(
A4!!2k--e(
1>Bo(( ^+3%,&.(
K,28(,;$J,3$ N.,;$
1>Bo( ^+3%,&.(KV(
R%C#9G(*'9*'(+7(,'='9&(=+$E%,#*+9*(
+7(G+%"(%9:(G%*(="#$%&'(#$E%=&*(
)'*5"&*(%,'(7%#,"/(*#$#"%,(
=>;3"?@;A"
=A;3"=?;?" =B;>"
?4;@"
CB;@"
?C;C"
34B;D"CC;@" CC;?" 344;@" C=;A"
34=;B"343;C"
34?;B"
JUJ(
IJUJ(
XJUJ(
TJUJ(
bJUJ(
SJJUJ(
SIJUJ(
J(
IJ(
XJ(
TJ(
bJ(
SJJ(
SIJ(
A4(IJSJ(
A4(IJSS(
c%,%$#""+(
4%,9'Q(
A+$'*6=(
!+9@(o+3(
!+9@(^#G.(
0.%"'(o+3(
0.%"'(^#G.(
A4(
c%,%$#""+(
A+$'*6=(
g)4(
e""#9+#*(rT(
05,7%='(
d9:',G,+59:(
74$NMC&fP
P\28$
N./0,(-3.)$.'$KJ$,)=$N.,;$\8()&(:0$JIJ$"/-33-.)3$-)$%&*&)2$_N#3$
R'&.%9'(
dE*&,'%$(!;I(
D5'"(!;I(
A4!!2k--e(
1>Bo(( ^+3%,&.(
K,28(,;$J,3$ N.,;$
1>Bo( ^+3%,&.(
_%,#%6+9(#9(&+&%"(7++&E,#9&((#*("%,G'"/(:5'(&+(59=',&%#9&/((
#9($'&.%9'(
KX(
R%C#9G(*'9*'(+7(,'='9&(=+$E%,#*+9*(
+7(G+%"(%9:(G%*(="#$%&'(#$E%=&*(
)'*5"&*(%,'(7%#,"/(*#$#"%,(
=>;3"?@;A"
=A;3"=?;?" =B;>"
?4;@"
CB;@"
?C;C"
34B;D"CC;@" CC;?" 344;@" C=;A"
34=;B"343;C"
34?;B"
JUJ(
IJUJ(
XJUJ(
TJUJ(
bJUJ(
SJJUJ(
SIJUJ(
J(
IJ(
XJ(
TJ(
bJ(
SJJ(
SIJ(
A4(IJSJ(
A4(IJSS(
c%,%$#""+(
4%,9'Q(
A+$'*6=(
!+9@(o+3(
!+9@(^#G.(
0.%"'(o+3(
0.%"'(^#G.(
A4(
c%,%$#""+(
A+$'*6=(
g)4(
e""#9+#*(rT(
05,7%='(
d9:',G,+59:(
74$NMC&fP
P\28$
N./0,(-3.)$.'$KJ$,)=$N.,;$\8()&(:0$JIJ$"/-33-.)3$-)$%&*&)2$_N#3$
R'&.%9'(
dE*&,'%$(!;I(
D5'"(!;I(
A4!!2k--e(
1>Bo(( ^+3%,&.(
K,28(,;$J,3$ N.,;$
1>Bo( ^+3%,&.(
B.'(="#$%&'(%:@%9&%G'*(+7(G%*(%,'(,'%"8(H5&(#9(&.'(,%9G'(+7(
VJZU((+<-2*@-)4$2.$4,3$-3$KM?$4.-)4$2.$386*-&)2;5$(&=8*&$
NMC$'(./$&;&*2(-*-25$$
KK(