0/1( 23 !# 4 576 8 90:=yangke/papers/lower_bound.pdf0/1( 2 3 !# 4 576 8 90:=? @

22

Transcript of 0/1( 23 !# 4 576 8 90:=yangke/papers/lower_bound.pdf0/1( 2 3 !# 4 576 8 90:=? @

Page 1: 0/1( 23 !# 4 576 8 90:=yangke/papers/lower_bound.pdf0/1( 2 3 !# 4 576 8 90:=? @

����� ������� ���������������������� �"!#�$�%!'&(�*),+-�.��0/1���(�23��!#��4

576�8�90:<;>=?�@<ACBEDGFIH"J�H0KLKLM

NPO%QSRUTWVIX�RY[Z]\I^`_Wa�Zcbed�_.fg_Wd�ZS^*h0_�iIjlkIm�ngjob`pIZrqsb`tubvnwmeb`ngxStuf�y*iIZS^vz|{Eq}yG~*fgZStu^`jIngjI�.��_�kIZUf�����p}Z��l^`m�b�f�_Wd�ZU^

h0_�i}j}k�ngm�_�j�d�ZCtu�s��fgZSt�^vj}n�jI�l�3Y[Z \I^`_Wa�Z�bvp}tub���_�^�tGx'_�j}x'ZS\�b�x'fwt�m`m<_u�3q}y���k�ng��ZSj}mvn�_�j��l��tG^`iIjIj}n�jI�2b`n���Z_��(�G{E���<f�_����s~�ngm�j}ZUZSkIZSk$�P��p}ZPq}y���kIn���ZUjlm�ng_�j[_u�(t7x'_�j}x'ZS\�bcx'fwt�m`mGngmck�Z'�}j}ZSkobv_7h0Z]bvp}Z]��tu��n���iI�j�iI��hlZS^�_���xU_�j}xUZU\�b�m�bvpltWb2t�^vZ7�viIjIn���_�^`��f�z�x'_�^`^`ZUfwtWbvZCkI�I��ngj.bvpltWb*ZCt�x�p.\}t�n�^ _��<bvpIZS��plt�a�ZGjIZSt�^vfgzrb`pIZm`tu��Z2x'_�^`^`ZUfwtWbvng_�j��"��pInwm�f�_Wd�ZU^�h0_�i}j}kr�]tWb�x�pIZSm�bvp}Z*iI\}\lZS^�h0_�iIjlkrngjo  ¡�¢<£�¤2¥u¦�§���iI\rb`_�t�fg_��stu^`n¨b`pI��ngx�©t�x#b`_�^C�%Y[ZG\I^`_Wa�Z b`pInwm�f�_Wd�ZU^�hl_�iIj}k�tu�stungj}meb�tuj|��pI_�jIZSm�b(qly���_�^`t�x'fgZS�I��d(pInwx�p���n�a�ZSm�t�m�bv^`_�jI��ZU^�^vZCm�i}f¨bb`p}tuj|bvp}Z�_�jIZSm]t���t�n�j}m�bcb`pIZ7��_�^`ZP��^`ZSªsiIZSjsbvfgz�i}m�ZCk«�`t�k�a�ZU^�mvt�^vnwtuf�q}y���_�^`t�x'fgZSm`�I�¬��pIZ7mvZSxU_�j}k>f�_Wd�ZU^h0_�i}j}krnwm���_�^vZ ��ZUjIZS^`t�fE�%­�b���n�a�ZSm�tcx'_�jsbvngjsi}_�i}m�bv^�t�k�ZU��_�®�h0Z'bed�ZUZSj]bvpIZ��vt�k�aWtujsb`t���ZS�G_���tujPt�f���_�^`n¨b`pI�ngj]fgZStu^`jIngjI�Gbvp}Z(b`t�^v��Z'b���iIj}x'bvng_�jrt�j}k�bvpIZ j�iI��hlZS^�_��LªsiIZS^vngZSm�n�b�jIZSZSkIm�bv_��]tu��Z���d(pIZU^`Z�bvpIZ*t�k�aWtujsb�tu��Z_��Ituj�tufg��_�^vn�bvpI�¯ngm3bvpIZ�\I^`_�hltuhIngf�n�bez�n�b"mvi}xUxUZUZCkIm$ngj2\}^vZCk�ngx'bvngjI� t�fwtuh0ZUf���ngj�i}mLbvp}Z�\I^`_�h}t�hIn�fgn�bez�n�b"k�_�ZSmvj3° bS�¡�_�bvp±fg_Wd�ZS^�h0_�iIjlkIm2Z'��bvZSj}k±tujlkl²�_�^*m�bv^`ZUjI��bvpIZSj±\I^`ZUa�n�_�i}m ^`ZSmviIf�b`mS�$tuj}k±mv_�fga�Z�tuj±_�\lZSj±\I^`_�hIfgZU�³fgZ'�´bngj�  µG¶I·#§��

¸ \}^vZSf�ng��n�j}t�^vz]a�ZU^�m�ng_�j�_u�%bvpInwm(\}t�\lZS^ tu\I\0ZSt�^vZCkPngj¹  µG¶�º�§��

» ¼3½�¾%¿�ÀPÁ±Â.Ã�¾<Ä'À�½Å�Æ�Å ÇoÈ�É�Ê�Ë�Ì%ËIÍ�Î�ËIÍ�ÏLÌ�Ð]ѬÒ�É3Ó�Ô³Õ×Ö(Ø É�Ð��p}Z�qsb�tWb`ngm�bvnwxUt�f�y*i}ZU^`z¹{�q}yG~���_�k�ZSf<d�t�m �}^�m�b2ngjsbv^`_�kIi}x'ZCk7h�z±ÙGZStu^`j}m�  Ù�¥�Ú�§���Û�jIf�ng��Z�bvp}Z�Ü�^v_�h}tuh}f�z¸ \I\I^`_���n��]tWb`ZUfgzÞÝ�_�^`^vZCx#b�{EÜ ¸ Ý�~�����_�kIZUf(  ß2àu¦W§��3trfgZSt�^vj}n�jI��tufg��_�^vn�bvpI�³ngj±b`pIZ�qlyá��_�kIZUf�k�_�ZSmvj3° bGmvZUZZU��\If�nwx'n�b�Z'�It���\}f�ZCm*_�^2bvpIZSn�^�fwtuh0ZUfwmU��­�j}m�bvZCt�k$�$b`pIZrtufg��_�^vn�bvp}�âª�i}ZU^`n�ZCm2t�jã��q}y���_�^�t�x'fgZS�rd(n¨b`poh0_�_�fgZStujªsiIZCmeb`n�_�j}m�t�hl_�i�b�^`t�j}k�_��«fgt�hlZSf�ZCk�ZU�Itu��\IfgZSmS�%¢}_�^�ZSt�x�p�ªsiIZS^vz��Wbvp}Z _�^�t�xUf�Z�^vZS\Ifgn�ZCm<d(n¨b`p�t�j�ZSm�bvng��tubvZ(_��b`pIZ2\I^v_�h}tuh}n�fgn¨bez�b`p}tWb�bvpIZ2tuj}mvd�ZU^�ngm��eµGä�q��G��_�^�t�^�tuj}k�_��åZU�Itu��\IfgZ�� ¸ j�tu\I\}t�^vZSjsb�^vZCmeb`^vnwx#b`n�_�jr_u�$b`pIZÜ ¸ Ýæ��_�k�ZSfE�sb`pIZGqlyç��_�kIZUfL\I^`_Wa�ZSk�b`_�h0ZGtca�ZU^`z�\0_Wd�ZS^���i}fLt�j}k]i}mvZ'��i}f0j}_ubvng_�j��<ÙGZCtu^`j}m�m�pI_Wd�ZSk�p}_Wdb`_7Z'èrx'ngZUjsb`f�zÞmvng�ciIfwtWb`Z�t�j¬q}y�fgZSt�^vjIngjI�.tufg��_�^vn�bvpI�éi}m�ngjI�7t.Ü ¸ Ýêt�f���_�^`n¨b`pI�.�3ZUa�ZUj[n�j[bvp}Z]\I^vZCm�ZSj}x'Z_��"jI_�ngmvZ��<ë Z�t�fgmv_c\I^`_Wa�ZCk�bvpltWb���t�j�zrÜ ¸ Ýætufg��_�^vn�bvpI�]m�tu^`Z�ngj}k�ZSZSk|�`q}y���bez�\lZCkI�I�s��ZStuj}n�jI��bvpltWb�bvpIZSzxStuj�hlZ�xU_�j�a�ZS^�b`ZSk�b`_�d�_�^`�]n�jPbvpIZ�q}yê��_�kIZUf���Ü�tu^vbvnwx'iIfwtu^`f�z�ngj�b`ZU^`ZSm�bvngjI��ngm�bvp}ZGxSt�mvZ*_��"jI_�ngmvZ'��bv_�f�ZS^`t�jsbfgZSt�^vj}n�jI�l��d(pIZS^vZ t�^`t�j}k�_��«��^`t�x#b`n�_�j�_��LbvpIZ ZU�Itu��\IfgZSm�t�^vZ(fwtuh0ZUfgZSk�d(^`_�jI�l��­�j��©t�x#bS�s��_�m�b�_u�0bvp}Z�jI_�ngmvZ'�b`_�fgZU^�tujsb�Ü ¸ Ýìf�ZCtu^`jIn�j}�rtufg��_�^`n�bvpI�]m(tu^`Z.�`q}y���bez�\lZCkI�I�lk�iIZ�b`_�bvpIZ�j}_�nwm�ZU�Eb`_�fgZU^�tujsb(j}tWb`iI^vZ�ngjIpIZS^vZSjsb�n�jb`pIZcq}y���_�kIZUf��Å�ÆEí î�Ö"ï[É3Óæð¹Ö�Ò*ñ�Ø�Î>Ö�ñ�ËIÈ É«Ê�ÑòÕ×Ö(Ø É�Ðó nga�ZSj�bvpltWbcb`pIZ�qly���_�k�ZSf�nwmcmv_±i}mvZ'��iIf���n�b�nwmc^�tWb`pIZU^ckIZSmvn�^�tuhIfgZ]b`_7��iIfgf�z¹iIj}kIZU^�meb�tuj}k�n�b`m�meb`^vZSjI�ub`p}mt�j}k�f�ng��n¨b�mU��Yôp}ZUj�bvpIZcqlyõ��_�k�ZUf$d�t�m�ngjsbv^`_�kIi}x'ZCk$��\lZS_�\IfgZGd�ZS^vZGngjsbvZU^`ZSm�bvZCkPngj�bvpIZ�ªsiIZCmeb`n�_�j|�vd(pIngx�pxU_�j}xUZU\�b�x'fwt�m`m�ZCmct�^vZ�qly���fgZSt�^vj}t�hIfgZ��<tuj}k¹d(pInwx�p>t�^vZrj}_ub�öC�}�Þ­�j��©t�x#bS��ngj�b`pIZ�mvZU��ngj}tuf�\}tu\0ZU^�_�j¹b`pIZ

÷'ø%ùSú�ûsü�ýeþ`ÿ������ þ�����þ��þ�û�Uÿ�ýeú�þ��Wý��Iø 'ÿ��sþ���� þ���þ���� ù�����������þ`ÿ���� ý���� ��!�!�!#"�ùSÿ�$�þ��&%'��þ�(�� )*� ý�ý���$�ü�ÿ���+,� )-%/.0��1�.�2��3�&�4%5(76*8ú�����:9<;�=?>�@�A4B�C�DFEHG�DJI4KLGMB�N�K7(O)PUÿ�ý��Q����R�S��üsû�û�ùSÿ�ýeþ�TU$���ý�+sþGøV�#�W�søV�U%�� ü�úX���3"�þ����¨ù�YZ��+[�¨û\��7T]ý�+sþ5]&�4"^%��Q�T�T[���S��þ��Wýeþ`ÿ��_ ÿ`��Wý�ø�øbaZ8M!�.01�1���c�.�(

d

Page 2: 0/1( 23 !# 4 576 8 90:=yangke/papers/lower_bound.pdf0/1( 2 3 !# 4 576 8 90:=? @

qly ��_�kIZUf��*ÙGZSt�^vjlmÞ  Ù�¥�ÚC§�\I^`_Wa�ZSk,b`p}tWb7Ü ¸5e ­e��µ ��iIjlx#bvng_�jlm�t�^vZojI_ub7q}y���f�ZCtu^`j}tuhIfgZ��á¡�f�iI�.��Z'bC�t�fE�s  ¡�¢<£�¤2¥u¦W§�k�Z'�}j}ZSkGb`pIZ�jI_�bvng_�j�_��<��q}y���k�n���ZSj}m�ng_�jl��_u�It x'_�j}x'ZS\�b"xUfgt�mvmS�Sd(p}ngx�p�nwmS�S^`_�iI��pIfgz2mv\lZCtu��ngjI�}�b`pIZPj�iI��hlZS^c_����`tufg��_�m�b�iIj}x'_�^v^`ZUfwtWb`ZSkI�.xU_�j}xUZU\�b�m�ngj¹bvpInwm�xUfgt�mvmS�7��pIZ�q}y���k�ng��ZUj}mvn�_�j�x�p}tu^�t�x'bvZU^`ngfUZSmb`pIZ2d�ZCtu��qly���fgZSt�^vj}t�hIngf�n�bez�a�ZU^`zcd�ZUfgfE�<­�j]�©t�x#bC��¡�fgiI��Z'bC�<t�fE�<\I^`_Wa�ZCk�bvp}tubS�sbv_�d�ZCtu��f�z�f�ZCtu^`jrtcxU_�j}xUZU\�bxUfgt�mvm�_u�"qly���k�ng��ZUj}mvng_�jP�l�-h�{©��~�ª�i}ZU^`n�ZCm�mvi�èrx'Z�{´bvp}_�iI��p]bvpIZGtufg��_�^vn�bvp}�á��ng��psb�j}_ub�hlZ2Z'èrx'ngZUjsb#~#��tuj}k�G{E�7iJjlkC~<ªsiIZS^vngZSm<t�^vZ�jIZSxUZSm`mvt�^vz���ë _Wd�ZUa�ZU^C��bvpIZ�iI\}\lZS^�tuj}k�f�_Wd�ZU^<h0_�iIjlkIm�k�_�j�° b��]tWb�x�p3��t�j}k�b`pIZ�^vZCm�i}f¨b_�jIfgzPtu\I\}f�ngZSm�b`_�d�ZCtu�rfgZSt�^vjIngjI�l�

£st�x���mv_�j�  £s¶�¶�§0meb`^vZSjI�ub`pIZUjIZCk�bvpIZ \}^vZSasng_�ilm<^vZCm�iIf�b�h�zc\I^`_Wa�n�j}�*b`p}tWb���_�^�tuj¹��q}y���hlt�mvZSkI�2tufg��_�^vn�bvpI�.��G{�º�mI~�Z'�It���\}f�ZCm�t�^vZ�jIZUZCk�ZSk¬bv_[f�ZCtu^`jIngjI�±b`pIZ7x'fwt�m`mc_��*Ü ¸5e ­e��µ³��iIjlx#bvng_�jlm�_Wa�ZU^#nìhIn�b`mS� ¸ jæq}y��hlt�mvZSk�tufg��_�^vn�bvpI�«ngm�xU_�j}m�bv^`i}x'bvZSk�h�z��l^`m�b�k�ZSmvn���jIngjI��tujrq}yìf�ZCtu^`jIngjI��tufg��_�^`n�bvpI�.��t�j}k�bvpIZSj���ZUjIZS^vnwxUt�f�fgzmvng�ciIfwtWb`n�jI�oZSt�x�p|q}y�ªsiIZU^`z¹h�z¹m`tu��\IfgngjI�ot�j}k>t�a�ZU^�tu��ngjI�l�±��pIngm�fg_Wd�ZS^ch0_�iIjlk¬�]tWb�x�pIZSmcbvpIZ.x'_�^v^`Z'�mv\0_�j}k�ngjI��iI\I\0ZU^�h0_�iIj}k3��Yôn¨b`prbvp}ngm�a�ZU^`z�m�bv^`_�jI��^vZCm�i}f¨bC��£st�x���mv_�j]d�t�m�tuhIfgZ b`_�mvpI_Wdìt�ªsi}t�k�^�tWb`ngx���t�\_�j�fgZSt�^vj}n�jI�]Ü ¸e ­e��µõ��iIj}x#b`n�_�j}m(d(n�bvp7t�pIng��p�{e·W�uºo>·W��p�q-r s�{tn�~v~�jI_�nwm�ZG^�tWb`Z2h�z�qly���fgZSt�^vjIngjI��tuj}k�h�zÜ ¸ Ý���fgZStu^`jIngjI�}�%ë Z�kIZU��_�j}m�bv^�tWb`ZSk�t�Ü ¸ Ý>tufg��_�^`n�bvpI�«bvp}tub�f�ZCtu^`j}m�jI_�ngmvz�Ü ¸e ­e��µ¯d(n�bvp]^`iIjIjIngjI�Gb`n���Zh�{�º�m4jlu�~#�Id(p}n�fgZ�tuj�z�q}y���h}t�m�ZCkPtufg��_�^vn�bvp}��jIZUZCkIm�^`iIjIjIngjI��bvng��Zc�G{Eº�mI~'�

¸ f�_�jI�¹tujI_�bvpIZS^�fgngjIZ._u�*^`ZSmvZSt�^`x�p��<µ�tujI�æ  µG¶I·#§�xU_�j}mvnwk�ZU^`ZSk¬bvpIZ.\I^`_�hIfgZU�×_��*fgZSt�^vjIngjI�wvyx z {0|�}�~����� |�}�}J�0�g�����l��xU_�j}xUZU\�b�m�ngj�bvpIZ2q}yô��_�k�ZSfE����p}tub�\}tu\0ZU^�ZU��bvZUjlk�ZSk�b`pIZ jI_�bvng_�j�_u�(�`qly���k�ng��ZUj}mvng_�j}�*bv_Gb`pIZxSt�mvZ�d(pIZS^vZ�ZCt�x�pG\}t�n�^"_u�Ix'_�j}x'ZS\�b`m"tu^`Z��vx'_�^v^`ZUfwtWb`ZSk*n�j�bvpIZ�m`tu��Z�d�t�z��I��¢}_�^�xU_�^`^vZSfgtubvZCk2xU_�j}xUZU\�b%x'fwt�m`m�ZCmU�n�b(xUtujPhlZ*bv^`n�a�nwtuflbv_�d�ZCtu��fgz�fgZSt�^vjPt�x'_�j}x'ZS\�b2{©n�j�m�_���Z2xUt�m�ZCmU�sZUa�ZUjrd(n�bvpI_�i�b���t���n�jI��tuj�z]ªsiIZU^`zI~#�shIi�bn�b�xU_�iIfwk[b`t���ZrZU��\l_�jIZUjsbvnwtuf�bvng��ZPbv_ÞkI_Þmeb`^v_�jI�7fgZStu^`jIngjI�}��µ�t�jI�±\I^`_Wa�ZCk[t�j>�G{©�yi`jlu���~�fg_Wd�ZS^�hl_�iIj}k��_�^*fgZSt�^vj}n�jI��m�i}x�potPx'_�j}x'ZS\�b2xUfgt�mvm�_u��q}y���k�ng��ZUj}mvn�_�jÞ��d(n¨b`potuj¯��Z'��b`^`trt�k�aWtujsb`t���ZC�U���2��p}ngm*^vZCm�i}f¨bng��\Ifgn�ZCm�b`pIZ(q}y���i}jIf�ZCtu^`j}tuh}n�fgn¨bez2_u�}bvpIZ�x'fwt�m`m�_��,�3ngjIZCtu^"��p}^vZCm�pI_�fgkc¢IiIj}x'bvng_�j}m�{����(¢%m�~�_Wa�ZU^��}jIn�bvZ��}ZSfgkImS�ë�Z�t�fgmv_rmvpI_Wd�ZCk7tPÜ ¸ Ýçt�f���_�^`n¨b`pI��b`p}tWbGhlZCtWb�m b`pIZ�b`pIZch0ZSm�b2\0_�m`mvn�hIfgZ�qly«t�f���_�^`n¨b`pI�]m ngj±fgZStu^`jIngjI�Ptmv\0ZSx'nwtuf�xUfgt�mvm*_u�'���(¢<mS� ¸ jÞ_�\lZSjÞ\I^`_�h}f�ZS�³��^v_��   µ2¶}·#§�d�t�m b`_�x�pltu^�t�x#b`ZU^`n�fSZ�bvp}Z�q}y���fgZStu^`j}t�hIn�fgn�bez�_����ZUjIZS^`t�f$x'_�jlx'ZU\Ib�x'fwt�m`m�ZCm�d(p}ZU^`Z*b`pIZ�x'_�j}x'ZS\�b`m(xStuj.h0ZS��}?�?z:��}J��}�z:���PxU_�^`^vZSfgtubvZSk3�Å�Æ�� �ÞÌ<Ó}ÍeÌ�ñ�ËIιÖZ�7Ê*Ñ���Ö�ÓIÌ�Ï$ÐeÉ"Î�*n�®0ZS^vZSj�b���_�k�ZSfgmG_���q}y���_�^�t�xUf�ZCm�p}t�a�Z�h0ZUZSj¹\I^v_�\l_sm�ZCk±ngj[bvpIZ�fgn¨b`ZU^�tWbvi}^vZ���Ü�^v_�h}tuh}f�z�bvp}Z]��_smeb�i}mvZSk_�jIZ���d(pInwx�p|d�Z7xUt�f�f�b`pIZô�vt�k�a�ZS^`m`tu^`ngt�f���_�k�ZUfw�I��ngm]bvpIZ._�j}Z�ngjsbv^`_�k�i}x'ZCk>h�z,ÙGZStu^`j}m�n�jæpInwm�_�^`ng��ngj}tuf\ltu\0ZU^�  Ù�¥�Ú�§��G­�j7b`pInwm*��_�k�ZSfE�0bvp}Z�t�f���_�^`n¨b`pI�³��nga�ZSm bvpIZ�_�^�t�xUf�Z�tPªsiIZU^`z���iIj}x#b`n�_�j��7tujlk±tujÞt�kIk�n�bvnga�Z�vZU^`^v_�^(bv_�f�ZS^`t�j}x'ZC�U�C�*��pIZ�_�^�t�xUf�Z�nwmGtufgf�_Wd�ZSk�b`_�^`ZU\Ifgz�d(n¨b`pw��x,��^`ZSt�f"j�iI��hlZS^�b`p}tWb2ngm��v��xUf�_sm�Z�bv_rb`pIZZU��\lZCx#bvZCk±aWtufgiIZ�_��V��_�jÞt]^�tuj}kI_���fgt�hlZSf�ZCk7Z'�Itu��\IfgZ���� _�bvnwx'Z�b`pInwm�_�^`t�x'fgZ�ngm2t�k�a�ZU^�mvt�^vnwtuf$ngjÞjltWbvi}^`t�fE�mvngj}x'Z(n�b�p}t�m<bvpIZ���^`ZUZCk�_��«bv_r{Et�k�a�ZU^�mvt�^vnwtufgf�zI~"x�pI_�_�mvZ�d(pIngx�p�^`ZSt�f�jsi}�ch0ZU^�b`_�^vZS\Ifgz��<��pIngm�ngm�tGa�ZU^`z�jInwx'Z��_�k�ZSf3bv_]\}^v_Wa�Z#v��[�-�?}O��|�vyx3�F�#�lmvn�jlx'ZGbvp}ngm���nga�ZSm(t\�'|�}������ � �F�?�c��i}t�^`t�jsbvZUZ[��tuj7tufg��_�^vn�bvp}�bvp}tub d�_�^v��md(n�bvp¹mvi}x�pÞt�t�k�a�ZU^�mvt�^vnwtuf3_�^`t�x'fgZ�d(ngf�f�mviI^`ZUfgz�d�_�^`��d�ZSf�f<d(n�bvpot�j[q}y���_�^�t�xUf�Z�m�ng�ciIfwtWb`ZSkÞhsz7m`tu��\Ifgn�j}�}�ë�_Wd�ZSa�ZS^S��bvpIZS^vZ�t�^vZ2\I^`_�hIfgZU�]m���_�^(\I^`_Wa�n�j}�S��|��'�0}O��|�vyx3�F�2��_�^�bvp}ngm���_�k�ZUf�� ¸ bez�\IngxStuf3m�bv^�tWb`ZU��z�ngjPb`pIZfg_Wd�ZU^ h0_�iIjlk.\I^v_�_��©m�  Ù�¥�Ú��l¡�¢<£�¤2¥u¦�§"nwm(b`_rx'_�j}meb`^vilx#b*t¹�vh}t�kI��_�^`t�x'fgZ�����pIngm�_�^�t�xUf�Z�k�_�ZCm�j3° b*xU_�����n¨bb`_Ptuj�z�\}tu^vbvnwx'iIfwtu^�b�tu^`��ZUb�x'_�jlx'ZU\IbS� e tWb`pIZU^C�}_�j7ZSt�x�p7ªsiIZS^vz���bvpIZc_�^�t�x'fgZG^vZS\Ifgn�ZCm d(n�bvp±t�aWtufgiIZ�b`p}tWb�nwm�`x'_�j}m�nwm�bvZUjsb���d(n¨b`p±�]tuj�z>�`xUtujlk�ngk}tWbvZ�x'_�jlx'ZU\Ib`m`�I�(��pIZct�^v��iI��ZUjsb ngm bvp}tub*n���jI_ub*ZUjI_�iI��p7ªsiIZU^`ngZSm�t�^vZ�]t�k�Z��sbvp}Z�_�^�t�xUf�Z�d(n�fgf0t�f�d�t�z�m�h0Z2t�hIf�Z bv_c��n�a�Z*t�j}m�d�ZU^�m<b`p}tWb�tu^`Z�x'_�j}m�nwm�bvZUjsb�d(n¨b`pP�]tuj�z�x'_�jlx'ZU\Ib`mS�%­�jb`pInwm xUt�m�Z���bvpIZ�fgZSt�^vjIngjI��tufg��_�^vn�bvpI��d�_�j3° b(h0Z�tuhIfgZ2bv_]fgZSt�^vj�a�ZS^vz]d�ZUfgfE�

ë�_Wd�ZSa�ZS^S�Lb`pIngmc��_�kIZUf�p}t�m�t7k�^�t�d(h}t�x��3�Gn�j¹\I^�t�x'bvnwx'Z��3bvp}ZPq}y��_�k�ZSf�ngmvj3° b�bvp}ngm�t�k�a�ZS^`m`tu^`nwtuf���­�j\}^`t�x#bvnwx'Z���_�jIZ2jI_�^`�]tufgf�z���z:~#vy���������Gtuj.q}y���_�^`t�x'fgZ i}mvn�j}��t�Ü ¸ Ý,fgZStu^`jIngjI��t�f���_�^`n¨b`pI�.�%��p}Z2mvn���iIfwtWbvng_�jnwmGk�_�j}Zch�z7^vZS\lZCtWb`ZSk±m`tu��\Ifgn�j}��tujlkÞt�a�ZS^`t���ngjI��bvpIZ�ªsiIZU^`z���iIj}x'bvng_�j[_Wa�ZU^�bvpIZCm�Z�Z'�Itu��\IfgZSmS����pIZU^`Zcnwmj}_ubvp}n�jI�ô�`t�k�a�ZU^�mvt�^vnwtufw�rngj[bvpIZ�m�ng�ciIfwtWb`n�_�j[t�j}kobvpIZ�m�ng�ciIfwtWb`ZSk�q}y���_�^�t�xUf�Z�hlZSp}t�a�ZCm�k�n�®0ZS^vZSj�b`f�zÞ��^v_��b`pIZ�t�kIa�ZU^�m`tu^`ngt�fl_�^`t�x'fgZ*i}mvZSk�ngjPb`pIZ�fg_Wd�ZS^�h0_�i}j}k�\I^v_�_��©mU�

q�ZUa�ZS^`t�f<Z'®L_�^vb`mGp}t�a�Z�h0ZUZSj¹��t�k�Z�bv_7^`ZU��ZCk�z7bvp}ngm�\}^v_�hIf�ZS�.�r£�t�x���mv_�j,  £s¶�¶W§�n�jsb`^v_�k�i}xUZSkÞbvpIZ]j}_u�b`n�_�jo_���t�jã��q}y���hlt�mvZSkÞÜ ¸ Ýêtufg��_�^`n�bvpI�]�Pbv_.\I^`_Wa�Z�b`pIZP�G{Eº m ~*f�_Wd�ZU^Gh0_�iIj}kÞ��_�^�fgZSt�^vj}n�jI��Ü ¸5e ­e��µ��­�jsb`iIn¨b`n�a�ZUfgz��3t�joq}y���h}t�mvZSk7Ü ¸ Ýçt�f���_�^`n¨b`pI� nwmGx'_�j}meb`^vilx#bvZCk7ngj±bvp}Z���_�fgfg_Wd(n�jI��d�t�z����*jIZc�}^�meb�k�ZSmvng��j}mtPf�ZCtu^`jIngjI�rtufg��_�^vn�bvpI��ngj.bvpIZ�q}y�����_�k�ZSfE����p}ZUj7b`pIZ�q}yåt�f���_�^`n¨b`pI� nwmr�v��ZSjIZU^`ngxStufgf�z���mvn���iIfgtubvZCk7h�z�tÜ ¸ Ýôtufg��_�^`n�bvpI�ngjPb`pIZG��_�m�b�m�bv^�tung��psb���_�^vd�tu^�k�d�t�z��Z�*jIZ*ng��\l_�^�b�tujsb(t�m`m�iI��\�b`n�_�j�t�hl_�i�b�bvpInwm���ZSjIZU^`ngxmvng�ciIfwtWb`n�_�j]ngm�bvp}tub�b`pIZ*t�f���_�^`n¨b`pI�åxStujIjI_�b�i}mvZ*t�jsz[��ngjsbvZS^vj}t�fI��jI_Wd(fgZSk���ZS��tuh0_�iIb�bvpIZ2ªsiIZU^`zc��i}j}x#b`n�_�j3�

Page 3: 0/1( 23 !# 4 576 8 90:=yangke/papers/lower_bound.pdf0/1( 2 3 !# 4 576 8 90:=? @

j}_�^�tuj�zô�`x'fgZUa�ZS^�b`^vnwx���mv�Pbv_.�]tu��Z�bvpIZ]mvn���iIfgtubvng_�j[��_�^`Z�ZUè]xUn�ZSjsbS�]��pInwm�t�m`m�iI��\�b`n�_�jÞ��ng��psb�m�ZSZU�éth}n¨bGbv_�_.meb`^v_�jI�rngjo\}^`t�x#bvnwx'Z��$m�ngj}x'Z�x'fgZUa�ZU^*bv^`ngx���m2tu^`ZcjI_�^v�]t�f�fgz7ª�i}n¨b`Z�k�ZCm�ng^�tuhIfgZcngjot�f���_�^`n¨b`pI�-k�ZSmvn���j3�¢}_�^�Z'�Itu��\IfgZ�� ¸ m�fwtu�×t�j}k��*ZSxStWbvi}^�xU_�j}mvngkIZU^`ZSk¹i}mvn�j}��}J�?�����Mz:��� �0}�}l|�}7ngj}meb`ZSt�k�_u��t�kIk�n�bvnga�ZPZS^v^`_�^cbv_ZUèrx'ngZUjsbvfgz�m�ng�ciIfwtWb`ZPtuj>qly�_�^`t�x'fgZ±  ¸ q�¥[¡W§��o£�t�x���mv_�j�° mG^`ZSmviIf�b�k�nwk�j3° b�^`iIfgZr_�i�bcbvpIZ�\l_smvmvn�h}n�fgn¨bez[b`p}tWbt�f���_�^`n¨b`pI�]m�i}m�ngjI�rmvi}x�p.t�mvng�ciIfwtWb`n�_�j�xStuj�f�ZCtu^`jIn�j}��Ü ¸e ­e��µê��iIj}x'bvng_�j}m ��_�^vZ2Z'èrxUn�ZSj�b`f�z��

µ�t�jI�]  µG¶I·#§ln�jsbv^`_�k�i}xUZSk�bvpIZ(��_�k�ZSf�_u����pI_�jIZSm�b�q}y���_�^`t�x'fgZSm`�I�$­�j�bvp}ngm���_�k�ZSfE��bvpIZ(_�^`t�x'fgZ�^`ZSxUZUnga�ZSm<tªsiIZS^vz5�2t�j}k�t��?��~5�H��� � |�vyx �*¢á�"��pIZSjGbvpIZ�_�^�t�x'fgZ�ngj}k�ZU\0ZUjlk�ZUjsbvfgzG\Inwx���m£¢ ^�tuj}kI_��¯fwtuh0ZUfgZSkGZU�Itu��\IfgZSmt�j}k�^vZUbviI^`j}m�bvpIZ�t�a�ZS^`t���Z _��*�r_�jPbvpIZCm�Z2Z'�It���\}f�ZCmU�<­�jsbviIn�bvnga�ZSf�z���bvpIZGpI_�jIZSm�b q}y���_�^`t�x'fgZ���_�k�ZUf$xStujPh0Z^`ZU�stu^�k�ZSk7t�m*bvpIZ[�`q}y���h}t�m�ZCk±Ü ¸ Ý��r��_�k�ZUf<d(n�bvpI_�i�b2bvpIZ¹��j}_u��x'fgZUa�ZS^���bv^`nwx�����t�mvmviI��\�bvng_�j�� ¸ j�z7f�_Wd�ZU^h0_�i}j}k,��_�^Pt�f���_�^`n¨b`pI�]m�i}mvn�jI�¹b`pIZ±pI_�jIZSm�b�q}y���_�^�t�xUf�Z7tuiIbv_��]tubvnwxUtufgfgz�bv^�tuj}mvfwtWbvZCm�bv_¬t�fg_Wd�ZU^�hl_�iIj}k��_�^¹�`q}y���h}t�mvZSk�Ü ¸ Ý��otufg��_�^vn�bvpI�]m�tuj}k|tÞfg_Wd�ZU^ch0_�i}j}k>ngj¬b`pIZ7t�k�a�ZU^�mvt�^vnwtuf�q}y���_�^`t�x'fgZr��_�k�ZUf�� ¸ jt�kIk�n�bvng_�j}t�f�t�k�aWt�j�b�tu��Z�_���bvp}Z���pI_�jIZSm�bcq}y���_�^`t�x'fgZS�]��_�k�ZSf�ngm2b`p}tWb�n�b�m�ng��\Ifgn¨�}ZCmGbvp}Z]\I^vZCm�ZSjsb`tWb`n�_�jÞ_��b`pIZ�x'_���\If�ZU��n¨bez�_u�%t�fgZSt�^vj}n�jI��tufg��_�^vn�bvp}���<­�j�bvp}Z�t�k�a�ZU^�mvt�^vnwtuf$q}y���_�^�t�x'fgZ2��_�k�ZSfE�Ibed�_�\}t�^`t���ZUbvZS^`m���_ngjsbv_�bvpIZ�x'_���\IfgZ'��n�bezG_u�It fgZSt�^vjIngjI��t�f���_�^`n¨b`pI�\�LbvpIZ�ZU^`^v_�^$bv_�f�ZS^`t�j}x'Z��"t�j}kGbvp}Z�bv_�b`t�f�j�iI��hlZS^"_��}ª�i}ZU^`n�ZCmU�¸ j�ZUèrx'ngZUjsb�t�f���_�^`n¨b`pI�ájIZUZCkIm�bv_���t���Z*hl_�bvpÞ·W����tujlk�bvpIZ*bv_�b`t�f0j�iI��hlZS^�_u��ªsiIZU^`ngZSm�\l_�f�z�jI_���nwtuf���tuj}kb`pIZ�bv^�t�k�ZU��_�®�h0Z'bed�ZUZSj�bvp}ZSmvZ�bed�_�\}t�^`t���ZUbvZS^`m�ngm%jI_�b%tufgd�t�z�m"x'fgZSt�^S��ë�_Wd�ZSa�ZS^S��ngj�bvp}Z�pI_�jIZSm�b<qly���_�^`t�x'fgZ��_�k�ZSfE�Wb`pIZU^`Z�nwm%_�jIfgzG_�jIZ�\}t�^`t���ZUbvZS^S��j}t���ZSf�z���bvpIZ�bv_�b`t�fsm`tu��\IfgZ�xU_�iIjsbC�"��pInwm%��t���ZCm3b`pIZ�\}^vZCm�ZSj�b�tWb`n�_�j_��LbvpIZ�xU_���\IfgZ'��n�bezc_u�$fgZSt�^vjIngjI��tufg��_�^vn�bvp}��m��ci}x�p]mvn���\IfgZU^C����pIZ�bvZCx�pIjInwª�i}Z i}mvZSk�ngj±  µG¶I·#§0d�t�m<bv_���ZUZU\b`^`t�x��ok�n�®LZU^`ZUjsbÞ�vm`x'ZSj}tu^`ng_�m`�rd(pIZSj¬k�n¨®LZU^`ZUjsb�xU_�j}xUZU\�b�m�tu^`Zrx�pI_sm�ZSj¹t�mGb`t�^v��Z'b�mU�%tuj}kobv_Þ��ZCt�mviI^`Z�b`pIZ�`tufgf¨��\}t�n�^(m�b`tWb`ngm�bvnwxUt�f3k�nwmeb�tuj}xUZS��t�x'^`_�m`m�bvpIZ�m`x'ZSj}tu^`n�_smU�<��pInwm�bvZCx�pIjInwªsiIZ�tufgf�_Wd m�i}m�b`_�d�_�^`�]ngj�b`pIZ�jIZSd��_�k�ZSfE�Ih}i�b n¨b d�t�mvj3° b(\l_Wd�ZU^v��iIf$ZUj}_�iI��pPb`_]zsngZUfwk�t�bvng��psb(f�_Wd�ZU^�h0_�iIj}k3�Å�Æt¤ ¥¬Ò�Ó§¦[Ö�ñ�Ë�ÓlÍ�¨*Ò ËIÍeÖ�ñ*έ�j¹b`pInwm�\}t�\lZS^S�%d�ZP\I^v_Wa�Z�bed�_7fg_Wd�ZS^�hl_�iIj}kIm���_�^�qly���fgZSt�^vjIngjI�7tufg��_�^vn�bvp}��mS����p}Z]�}^�meb�fg_Wd�ZS^�hl_�iIj}kxU_�j}mvnwk�ZU^�m�t7x'_�j}x'ZS\�b�x'fwt�m`m2bvp}tub�x'_�j�b�tungj}m�t.m�i}h}m�ZUb�_u��iIjIn���_�^`��f�z[x'_�^`^`ZUfwtWbvZCkÞxU_�j}xUZU\�b�mU�"d(pIZU^`Z]ZSt�x�p\ltung^�nwm�x'_�^v^`ZUfwtWb`ZSkõ��ngj¬b`pIZ.mvt���Z�d�t�z��}�¹YoZ.k�Z'�ljIZPb`pIZ�©£ª<�`��z:~«�?x-��z¬|�xô_��*tÞxU_�j}xUZU\�b]x'fwt�m`m�b`_oh0Zb`pIZ��]tW��ng�ciI��j�iI��hlZS^(_u�<m�i}x�p�iIjIn���_�^`��f�zPxU_�^`^vZSfgtubvZCkPx'_�j}x'ZS\�b`m�ngj�bvpInwm(x'fwt�m`mU�<Y[Z�tufwm�_�x'_�j}m�nwk�ZS^�b`pIZ��|������£�?��~5�H��� � |�vyx �(_u��t�jÞtufg��_�^vn�bvpI�.�Id(p}ngx�p±nwm(b`pIZ�mviI��_u��b`pIZ�m`tu��\IfgZcx'_�iIjsb`m(_���tufgf3b`pIZ�ªsiIZS^vngZSm(n�b�]t���ZSm(bv_Pt�j7pI_�jIZCmeb*qly���_�^`t�x'fgZ���Y[Z�\I^`_Wa�ZGb`p}tWb2t�f�ZCtu^`jIn�j}�rtufg��_�^`n�bvpI� �ci}m�b�p}t�a�Z�mvt���\}f�Z�xU_�iIjsb�_���G{E���<f�_����s~(bv_]fgZSt�^vj7trxU_�j}xUZU\�b�xUfgt�mvm(_���q}y���kIn���ZUjlm�ng_�j7�yiW�(��pInwm(fg_Wd�ZS^ hl_�iIj}k7t�f���_�m�b �]tWb�x�pIZSm�b`pIZi}\I\lZS^�hl_�iIj}kr��n�a�ZUjrngjo  ¡�¢<£�¤2¥�¦W§�{�iI\Pbv_�t�fg_���t�^vn�bvp}��nwx(�©t�x#b`_�^#~#��tuj}krngm�m�bv^`_�jI��ZSjI_�i}��prb`_cng��\If�z�b`pIZªsi}t�k�^�tWbvnwx�mvZU\}t�^`tubvng_�j._u��q}y���tuj}k7Ü ¸ Ý���f�ZCtu^`jIngjI�r_u�<b`pIZ�Ü ¸e ­e��µ«��iIjlx#bvng_�jlm*tub*t]pIng��p±j}_�nwm�Z�^�tWb`Z��¢}iI^vbvpIZS^v��_�^`Z��Lb`pInwm�f�_Wd�ZU^2h0_�iIj}k¹t�\I\Ifgn�ZCm�b`_7t�d(nwk�Z�^�tujI��Z�_���x'_�j}x'ZS\�b�x'fwt�m`m�ZCm*t�j}koi}m�ZCm�t.k�n¨®LZU^`ZUjsb��_�k�ZSfI��_�^�q}y���_�^�t�x'fgZSmS����pIZ�\I^v_�_��0i}mvZSm�m�ZSa�ZU^�tuf�b`ZSx�pIj}ngªsiIZCmU��m�_���Z(_u�$d(pInwx�p�xU_�iIfwk�h0Z _u�$ngj}k�ZU\0ZUjlk�ZUjsbngjsbvZS^vZCmebC� ¸ m�n�j�  µ2¶}·'§��Id�Z�m�bvngfgf���ZSZU\�bv^�t�x��P_u�%bvpIZ±�`k�n�®0ZS^vZSj}x'ZCmv��t�xU^v_smvm�b`pIZ�m`x'ZUjltu^`n�_sm�d(n¨b`p±k�n¨®LZU^`ZUjsbxU_�j}xUZU\�b�m�t�m2b�tu^`��Z'b�mU��ë _Wd�ZUa�ZU^C�$d�Z�i}mvZ�t.k�n�®LZU^`ZUjsb���ZCt�mviI^`Z��3j}t���ZUfgz7bvpIZ]t�f�f���\ltung^GÙX�3��kIn�a�ZU^`��ZUjlx'Z����p}ngm�j}ZUd,��ZCt�mviI^`Z�xStuj�z�n�ZSfgk�tGa�ZS^vzGb`n���psb�hl_�iIj}k�d(pIZUj�b`pIZ�ªsiIZU^`ngZSm�tu^`Z���^`ZSt�mv_�jltuhIfgz�iIj�hInwt�mvZSkI�}�unE� Z��g�d(p}ZUj�bvp}Z \I^`_�h}t�hIn�fgn�bez�bvp}tub�bvp}Z�ªsiIZU^`z���iIj}x'bvng_�j]^`Z'b`iI^vjlm���¤�·C��_�jrtG^`t�j}k�_��«Z'�Itu��\IfgZ(ngm�x'fg_�mvZ�bv_]·���º��¡�i�b2bvp}Z�ÙX�$��k�nga�ZS^v��ZUj}xUZ���ZCt�mviI^`Z�hlZCx'_���ZCm a�ZU^`z�h}t�k7d(pIZSj±d�Z�p}t�a�Z�h}ngt�m�ZCk±ªsiIZU^`n�ZCmU��­�j7bvp}tubGxSt�mvZ��d�Z�i}m�Z�tujoiIj�hInwt�mvZSkÞªsiIZS^vz�b`_|�`m�ng�ciIfwtWb`ZS��trhInwt�mvZSkÞ_�jIZ���Ý�_��ch}n�jIngjI��bvpIZCm�Z]ºrbvZSx�p}jIngªsiIZCm*bv_���Z'b`pIZU^t�f�fg_Wd m�i}m�b`_]\I^v_Wa�Z*t�a�ZU^`z�bvng��psb f�_Wd�ZU^�h0_�iIjlk$�

��p}Zcm�ZCx'_�j}k.f�_Wd�ZU^�hl_�iIj}k7nwm ��_�^#��}?�0z:�M}J��}��.x'_�j}x'ZS\�b*xUfgt�mvmvZSmS�(YoZ�k�Z'�ljIZ�t��`x'_�^v^`ZUfwtWb`n�_�j��]tWb`^vn��I�I�d(p}_�mvZ ZUjsbv^`ngZSm�t�^vZ�b`pIZ�x'_�^v^`ZUfwtWb`n�_�j}m<_u�$\}t�n�^�m�_��$xU_�j}xUZU\�b�mU�<Y[Z \I^`_Wa�Z�bvpltWb���_�^�tujrt�f���_�^`n¨b`pI��b`_�p}t�a�Z&­t�k�aWtujsb`t���Z�n�j�fgZSt�^vjIngjI�Gh�z��]tu��ngjI�X®*ªsiIZS^vngZSm%b`_Gt�j]t�k�a�ZU^�mvt�^vnwtuf�q}y���_�^`t�x'fgZ�d(n�bvp�b`_�fgZU^�tuj}xUZ�­���bvpIZSj�b`pIZmviI�ê_��IbvpIZG{¬®}¤�·�~Lfwtu^`��ZSm�b�ZSn���ZUj�aWtufgiIZSm"_u�Ib`pIZ�x'_�^`^`ZUfwtWbvng_�jG�]tWb`^vn����ci}m�b<hlZ�tWb<f�ZCt�m�b ¯,°g­�uW�%ë�ZU^`Z±¯�nwm3b`pIZxStu^�k�ngj}tufgn¨bez�_u�Lbvp}Z�x'_�j}x'ZS\�b�x'fwt�m`mS�%��pInwm�^`ZSmviIf�b�m�p}_Wd m�t�x'_�j�b`n�j�iI_�i}m<b`^`t�k�Z'��_u®Ph0Z'bed�ZUZSj�bvpIZ*t�k�aWtujsb�tu��Zt�j7tufg��_�^`n�bvpI��xUtuj.p}t�a�Z�tuj}k�bvp}Z�j�iI�ch0ZU^ _���ª�i}ZU^`n�ZCm�n¨b�j}ZUZSk}m�bv_r�]t���Z�����pIngm bv^�t�k�ZU��_�®ÞxUt�j�h0Z�i}mvZSkngj>k�ZCm�ng��j}n�jI�of�ZCtu^`jIngjI�±tufg��_�^vn�bvpI�]mS�<d(pIZU^`ZPx'ZS^�b�tungj¬^`ZSªsiIng^vZS��ZSjsb`m�_�j�bvpIZ�t�xSx'iI^�t�xUzotujlk¬x'_�j��lk�ZSj}x'Z

² ��þ���û�� ýeþ³� ý��X�7Uú�þ���ý�+sþ�ýeùUý`��Z��Sú�û[� þ#��ùSü��WýX���X���µ´:?�`ýO¶$�ùSü���T±ù��oý�+�þ¶·:¸º¹X»³¼`½?¹±¾y¿Q»�À�¸º·:Á?�<ÿ`'ý�+sþ`ÿ�ý�+���±ý�+sþ¶ÂJÃ�¹�¾y¿Q»¼�½�¹±¾7¿Q»�À�¸º·:Árù�´"ý�+sþ�� þ�'ÿ��������«?���CùSÿ�� ý�+�ú³(�Ä +sþ�� ù�Y<þvÿ$�ùSü���T¶?����üsú�þ���ý�+�Uý&´gÿeþl��+���Sú�û[� þ���Uÿeþ�Tuÿ`�YZ�S´wùUÿ*þ���`+��sþJYÆÅuü�þ`ÿ���(Ä +����"úX�Q��+Wý*�sùSý£$�þ�ý�+sþ�ú�ù���ý%þlÇ���� þ��Wý£Y ��*ýeù(ü���þZ��Sú�û[� þ���È�����´:?�`ý�������ú�����5��� ýeü�Uý�� ù��[������Sú�û[�¨þl�£��?�X$�þ�ÿeþ�ü���þ�T-(PÉ�ù�Y%þ���þ`ÿ��ý�+sþ�ýeùSý`��,��Sú�û[�¨þ±��ùCü[�uý'T�ùWþ��'������þ&?�³$�ùCü[�7T�ù���ý�+sþ�ý��¨ú�þl�V� ý�ý`?Ê�þ���ýeù2û�ÿeù���þ���������lý�+�þ<��Sú�û[�¨þl��(

Ë

Page 4: 0/1( 23 !# 4 576 8 90:=yangke/papers/lower_bound.pdf0/1( 2 3 !# 4 576 8 90:=? @

t�^vZ�bv_rh0Z�m`tWb`ngm��}ZSk3� ��pIngm�f�_Wd�ZU^�hl_�iIj}k7nwm*tra�ZU^`zP��ZUjIZS^`t�f3_�j}Z4��t�m d�Zcmvp}tufgf"mvZUZcn�joq�ZSx#b`n�_�j7¦}� ¦}�lbvpInwmfg_Wd�ZU^ h0_�iIjlk7tufg��_smeb ng����ZSk�nwtWb`ZUfgz�ng��\If�ngZSm2mv_���Z�\I^`ZUa�n�_�i}m(^`ZSmviIf�b`m�  ¡�¢%£�¤2¥u¦}�Iµ2¶}·#§��ltujlk7m�_���ZUbvng��ZSmz�ngZUfwkIm�ZSa�ZUj]m�bv^`_�jI��ZU^�_�jIZSmS�%��p}Z(\I^v_�_��lb`_GbvpInwm�fg_Wd�ZS^�hl_�iIj}k�i}mvZSm<b`pIZ*q�ngjI��iIfgt�^�ß�tufgiIZ��*ZSxU_���\l_sm�n�bvng_�j{�q�ß�G~#�0��pInwm x'_�jIjIZSx'bvng_�j.x'_�iIfgk�tufwmv_�h0Z�_u�<ngj}k�ZU\0ZUjlk�ZUjsb ngj�b`ZU^`ZSm�bS�Å�Æ�Ì ¥�Ó Í�Ì�ñ�Í�Î$Ì%ËIÍeÖ�ñ�ÖZ�PËIÈ ÉÐÏ,É"Î�Ë|ÖZ�rËIÈ ÉÐÑ.Ì Ò�É3ÓY[Z \I^`ZSmvZUjsb�b`pIZ jI_�b`tWb`n�_�j}m�t�j}k]k�Z'�ljIn¨b`n�_�j}m�i}mvZSk�ngj�bvp}Z \}tu\0ZU^�n�jPq�ZCx#b`n�_�j]ºI�<YoZ \}^v_Wa�Z�b`pIZ(bed�_Gf�_Wd�ZU^h0_�i}j}kIm(ngj±q�ZSx'bvng_�j.Ú]tuj}k.q�ZSx'bvng_�j.¦}��^`ZSmv\0ZSx#b`n�a�ZUfgz��<Y[Z�x'_�jlx'fgi}k�Z2bvpIZ�\ltu\0ZU^(ngj7q�ZSx#b`n�_�j ¡��

Ó Ô×À�¾ Õ2¾<Ä'À�½\Ö×Õ�½.ÁÙØÛÚ&ÜÞ½7Ä#¾<ÄUÀ�½\Öí(Æ�Å Õ×Ì%Ë�È�ÉLÝáÌ%Ë�ÍvÏLÌ�Ð�ÞãÖ�Ë�Ì%Ë�Í�Ö�ñ�θ f�f%fg_���t�^vn�bvp}��m�tu^`Z�j}tWb`iI^`t�f3fg_��}� ¸ fgf%^`t�j}k�_���k�nwmeb`^vnghIi�b`n�_�j}m�t�^vZ�_Wa�ZU^(hIngj}tu^`z.meb`^vngjI��mS��YoZ�j}tWb`iI^`t�f�fgznwk�ZSj�b`n¨��z±tP^`t�j}k�_�� aWtu^`nwtuhIfgZ�d(n�bvpÞtP\I^v_�h}tuh}n�fgngm�bvnwx�k�nwm�bv^`n�hIiIbvng_�j3�G¢I_�^*tr^�tujlk�_���aWtu^`ngt�hIf�ZO߬�ld�Zcilm�Zß|{tà0~(bv_rk�ZSjI_ub`Z�bvp}Z�\I^`_�h}t�hIn�fgn�bezrbvpltWb5ßâáãà"�(¢I_�^*k�ngm�bv^`nghIi�bvng_�jlm�ß×tuj}kåäP�}d�Z�i}mvZ�ß�äábv_�k�ZUjI_�bvZb`pIZUng^���z:}J� � �L�H}J|���v � �0� ß�är{¬àLæJç�~Zá§ß>{¬à0~ °?ä�{tçI~�è��p}ngm�k�Z'�}j}n¨b`n�_�jrx'_�ngj}xUngk�ZCm�d(n�bvp�bvpltWb�_��lb`pIZ � |�x � ���é�?xH����z¬|�x�_��$n�j}kIZU\0ZUj}k�ZSjsb�^`t�j}k�_��«aWtu^`ngt�hIfgZSm ß-tuj}käP�í(ÆEí î�É3Ì<Ó}ñ*Í�ñ�Íê¦oÖ�ñ*ÏLÉ*Ò ËIÎY[Z�ilm�Z�ë>b`_ck�ZSjI_ub`Z�tG�}jIn�bvZ2m�ZUb�_u�$hIngj}t�^vz�meb`^vngjI�smU�stuj}k�d�Z�tu^`Z(ngj�b`ZU^`ZSm�bvZCk�n�jrfgZSt�^vj}n�jI� � |�x � �é�3�¬�*_Wa�ZU^ë*�lnE� Z��g����iIjlx#bvng_�jlm�bvp}tub��]tu\.ZUfgZU��ZSj�b�m�n�jµëôbv_\ì�o�·4æ#¤�·�í��<ä�fgZU��ZSj�b�m(ngj ë¯tu^`Z�tufwm�_]xStufgf�ZCk^�lî7��~5�H���0�#�¸ xU_�fgf�ZCx#bvng_�jÞ_u��xU_�j}xUZU\�b�m�nwm2_u�´bvZSjok�ZSjI_ub`ZSkÞhszåï×áðì�ñ i æ�ñ u æ�è�ègè�æ�ñ�ò*í��$tuj}kÞngmGxStufgf�ZCk±t � |�x � �é�3� � ���F���#�ä�t�x�p]��ZU��hlZS^�ngjSïánwm�t � ��xH��z¬�[����� � |�x � �é�3�E��tujlk]_�jIZ*_u�$b`pIZU�.��xUt�f�fgZSkrtS�é��}�ó��0� � |�x � �é�3��ngm�x�pI_sm�ZSj���_�^b`pIZ�fgZStu^`jIngjI�]tufg��_�^vn�bvpI��b`_]f�ZCtu^`j3�

Y[Z��I�ot�j[t�^vh}n¨b`^`t�^vz7_�^`k�ZS^2��_�^Gbvp}Z�ZSf�ZS��ZUjsb`m�ngjôë*�"tujlk±b`pIZUj¹nwk�ZUjsbvn���zot���iIjlx#bvng_�j¹_Wa�ZU^Oëõd(n�bvpb`pIZ�a�ZSx'bv_�^ ^vZS\I^`ZSmvZUjsbvZCk.hsz.n�b`m�bv^`i�bvp±b`tuh}f�Z���3ZUb�õ-h0Z�to{´�I��ZCk}~(\I^`_�hltuhIngf�nwm�bvnwxck�nwmeb`^vnghIi�b`n�_�j±_Wa�ZS^�ë*���p}ZU^`Z2ZU��ngm�b`m t�j�ngjIjIZS^(\I^`_�kIi}x#b _�����iIj}x'bvng_�j}m _Wa�ZU^5ëìn�jlk�i}x'ZCk�hsz¶õ7�}k�ZU�}jIZSk.t�m

ö ñHæ`�y÷`øùáûúü�ý4þ

õÞ{tà0~Jñ<{tàL~é�${tà0~Yôp}ZUjobvpIZS^vZ�ngmGj}_�kIt�jI��ZS^*_���tu��hIng��iIn�bez��$d�Z�_���n¨b2bvpIZ]mviIh}m`x'^`n�\Ib�õ7����pIZ�n�jIj}ZU^G\I^`_�kIi}x#b�_u�<ñ�tuj}k��ngm*tufwm�_]xStufgf�ZCk�bvpIZ � |�}�}J�0�g���Mz¬|�x[hlZUbed�ZSZUj�ñ[tuj}k¶�L��­�j.bvpIZcxSt�mvZGbvp}tub�h0_ubvp�ñ[t�j}k���x'_�j}x'ZS\�b`mS�Ib`pIZUng^xU_�^`^vZSfgtubvng_�j ö ñHæ`�y÷�ngm�bvp}Z�\I^`_�h}t�hIngf�n�bez³ñ�t�j}k³�]tu��^`ZUZ(_�jPt�^�tuj}kI_��án�jI\}i�b���ngj�i}m�b`pIZ�\}^v_�h}tuhIngfgn¨bez�bvpIZSzkIngm`tu��^vZSZ��

��p}Z#x3|�}�~�_u�"��iIj}x#b`n�_�j ñ7nwm k�Z'�ljIZSk.t�m�ÿgÿ ñVÿ�ÿ4á�� ö ñHælñP÷'��Ý�f�ZCtu^`f�zPt�f�f3xU_�j}xUZU\�b�m�p}t�a�ZGjI_�^v�é·��í(Æ�� ÇoÈ�É�Ê�Ë�Ì%ËIÍ�Î�ËIÍ�ÏLÌ�Ð]ѬÒ�É3Ó�Ô³Õ×Ö(Ø É�ÐY[Z�\I^`ZSmvZUjsb�bed�_]k�n�®LZU^`ZUjsb�k�Z'�ljIn¨b`n�_�j}m�_u��q}y���_�^�t�xUf�ZCmU��������� R ���� �� N���� � TWQCV�T V�����������TWVIX�� ���� "!?v �0}��X��|O��x�t�k�a�ZS^`m`tu^`nwtufsqly���_�^`t�x'fgZ {0|�} � |�x � ���H�Pñµzº��±�-��z:}�{t�Hæ$#}~&%L��' �0}l� �S��ë)(�ì�o�·4æ#¤�·�í+* ì�o�·4æ#¤�·�í�zº�<����|�|�������x{�vyx � ��z¬|�x�% � ���:�������,' ��ªsiIZS^vz2��iIj}x'bvng_�j-%��xH�.#�/ã  ¶-æS·'§�zº�³}l�l���Vx vy~«���0}&% � ���:�����å�0'-�Pbv_�f�ZS^`t�j}x'Z21435'-��|�}J� � �g�S}l�é�3��z¬���«�Vz:�0'ô��x76���}?�?z:��}l��}��&8å}J�����x,vy~³���?}�¯U��v � '\�0'-���

ÿ ¯�o:9�øc  �${tß æ�ñ<{tßo~v~�§�ÿ�;4#��p}ngm kIZ'�}jIn�bvng_�j��In�jsb`^v_�k�i}xUZSk�h�zPh�zPÙGZSt�^vjlm2  Ù�¥�ÚW§���nwm(i}mvZSk�h�zP��_�m�b(f�n�bvZS^`tubviI^`ZGn�j�bvp}Zcq}yõ��_�k�ZUf��

<

Page 5: 0/1( 23 !# 4 576 8 90:=yangke/papers/lower_bound.pdf0/1( 2 3 !# 4 576 8 90:=? @

�������� R ���>=?�A@B���� QSRC��������TWVIX�� ���� D!?v �?}��å�é|µ��xÞp}_�jIZCmeb�q}y���_�^�t�xUf�Z�{0|�} � |�x � ���H�&ñÐzº�S�³� ��z:}{t�Hæ�¢ê~&%5��' �0}l���ô�£ë"(ôì�o�·4æ�¤�·4íE* ì[o�·[æ�¤�·4í\zº�S�µ�l|�|��g�l��x�{�vyx � �Mz¬|�xF% � ���:�������,' ��ª�i}ZU^`z±��iIj}x'bvng_�j-%��xH�U¢ zº�U���-|���z:��z:���Uz:x,�é�éó��0}#�V}�z:�M�é�?x z:x7iIj}t�^vz u % � ���:�����\�,' ��m`tu��\IfgZ�xU_�iIjsbG1H35' �¶|�}J� � ���«}l�0�Mvy}�x-�JIK%�¶}J��xH�[|�~×����}�z¬�4�?���U�[��L'xH���\�0�MI#á iNPO NQSR i �${tß Q ælñ<{tß Q ~�~���'-�?}J�«��� � '¶ß Q zº��z:x3�4���-�?xH�[�0x,���Q� � '-|��0�?x� ��� |�}J��z:x7óU��|XõT%'��xH�&{0|�}O��z U5�?}J�?x �V!?v �?}�z¬���&%'��z U5�?}J�?x �W6���xH�³z:x3�4���-�?xH�[�0x,�X8S�lî7��~5�H���0�X��}J�O��}J���Vx51C3�' �b`_ub�tuf3m`tu��\IfgZGxU_�iIjsb�|`{���x���� ó�|�}�z:�0'7~ zº����z:~5�H���«�0'-����vy~ |�{����:�L�0'-�X�0��~��3��� � |�vyx ���X|`{����:�*�0'-�M!0v �?}�z¬�0�z:�±~«�ZY[���[1��p}ngm�k�ZU�}jIn�bvng_�j[d�t�m�ngjsbv^`_�k�i}x'ZCkÞh�z.µ�t�jI�[  µ2¶}·'§��c­�bGngm�m�bv^�tung��psbv��_�^`d�t�^`k�b`_�mvpI_Wdêb`p}tWb�_�j}Z�xStujÞilm�Zt�j�pI_�j}ZSm�b�q}y���_�^`t�x'fgZ�bv_±mvn���iIfgtubvZPt�j�t�k�a�ZU^�mvt�^vnwtuf<_�^�t�xUf�Z7{©d(n¨b`p�jIZU��f�ng��nghIfgZrZU^`^v_�^�~'�r­�jsbviIn�bvnga�ZSf�z���b`pIZp}_�jIZCmebPq}y���_�^�t�xUf�Z.k�ZSm`x'^`nghlZCm�p}_Wd t¹Ü ¸ Ýt�f���_�^`n¨b`pI� m�ng�ci}fgtubvZSm]t�jæqly-tufg��_�^vn�bvp}�×��_�^vZ.\I^`ZSxUngmvZUfgzb`p}tuj±bvpIZ�t�k�a�ZU^�mvt�^vnwtuf�qly���_�^`t�x'fgZ��(­�j7b`pIngm2mvZUj}mvZ��lbvpIZ�pI_�jIZSm�bGq}y���_�^�t�xUf�ZGnwm���_�^vZo��^`ZStufgnwmeb`ngxS�I��� _�bvnwx'Zb`p}tWb*bvpInwm2pI_�j}ZSm�b2q}y���_�^�t�x'fgZ���_�k�ZUf<t�m`m�i}��ZCm(b`p}tWb*bvpIZ�_�^�t�x'fgZ�tufgd�t�z�m�k�^`t�d m ��^vZCm�p±m`tu��\IfgZSm ��_�^2ZSt�x�pªsiIZS^vz��]��pIngm���ng��psb�jI_�b�hlZ�b`pIZ]��_�m�bGZUèrx'ngZUjsb�d�t�z.��_�^�mvt���\If�ngjI�l�"mvn�j}xUZ�n¨b�nwmG\l_smvmvnghIf�Z�b`_7x'_�fgfgZSx#b�thltWb`x�p�_u�%fgt�hlZSf�ZCk.mvt���\}f�ZCm�t�j}kPbvpIZSj�^`ZUilm�Z2bvp}ZU����_�^�ZSt�x�p.ªsiIZU^`z���d(pIZSj�bvpIZ�xU_�j}xUZU\�b x'fwt�m`m�p}t�m(t�fg_Wdß*Ý���k�ng��ZUj}mvn�_�j,  ¢%Yì¥[¡C§�����pIZU^`Z'��_�^vZ��Lt�fg_Wd�ZS^*h0_�i}j}kÞngjobvpIZ�pI_�jIZSm�b�qly���_�^`t�x'fgZc��_�k�ZUf�nwm�j�° b�t�f�_Wd�ZU^h0_�i}j}k�_u�%bvpIZ�m`tu��\IfgZ�x'_���\IfgZ'��n�bezr_u��t�f�ZCtu^`jIngjI��t�f���_�^`n¨b`pI��hIiIb ^`tubvpIZS^�b`pIZGbvng��Zcx'_���\If�ZU��n¨bez��\ ]_^\Úa`ìÄ'¿VÖ�¾cb¬ÀWd Ú�¿De�À�Â7½.Ágfih ½7Ä[juÀc¿lk máÀ�½.Ã&Ú�n�¾omPp0ÕXÖbÖ£Ú�ÖY[Z�\}^v_Wa�Z"b`pIZ��}^�m�b�f�_Wd�ZU^$h0_�i}j}kG_�j�fgZSt�^vjIngjI�(t]�viIjIn���_�^`���(xU_�j}xUZU\�b�xUfgt�mvm3d(pIZU^`Z�ZUa�ZU^`z \}t�n�^3_��Ix'_�jlx'ZU\Ib`mt�^vZ��`x'_�^v^`ZUfwtWb`ZSkon�j[bvp}Z�m`tu��Z]d�t�z��}�3nE� Z��g�<ZSt�x�p[\ltung^�p}t�mctufg��_smeb�b`pIZPm`tu��Zrx'_�^v^`ZUfwtWb`n�_�j3���*iI^cf�_Wd�ZU^h0_�i}j}k�ngm�t���tungj}m�b�tuj�pI_�jIZCmeb�q}y���_�^�t�xUf�Z��3Yôn�bvp�^vZCm�\0ZSx'b<bv_�mvi}x�p�t�j�_�^`t�x'fgZ��Wd�Z(k�Z'�}j}Z�bvpIZ���|������-�?��~��3���� |�vyx ��_u��tuj7tufg��_�^vn�bvpI��bv_]h0ZGbvpIZcmviI� _u�%bvpIZ�m`tu��\IfgZ�x'_�iIjsb`m�_u��tufgf$b`pIZ�ªsiIZU^`n�ZCm�n¨b*��t���ZCmU��q�ngj}xUZ�d�Z^`ZSªsiIng^`Zcb`pIZ]mvt���\}f�Z�x'_�iIjsb`m*bv_�hlZ�d(^`n¨bvbvZSjongjoi}j}tu^`z��Lb`pIZ�bv_ub�tuf�m`tu��\IfgZ�xU_�iIjsb�_u��t�jot�f���_�^`n¨b`pI�-ngmGtfg_Wd�ZU^2hl_�iIj}k[_�jon¨b�mG^viIj}jIn�j}�Pb`n���Z���Y[Z�mvp}t�f�f<\I^`_Wa�Z�tPfg_Wd�ZU^2hl_�iIj}ko_�jobvpIZ�bv_�b`t�f<m`tu��\IfgZ�x'_�i}j�b�_��b`pIZ�fgZStu^`jIngjI�]tufg��_�^vn�bvpI�]mS�

¡�ZU��_�^`Z�m�b`tubvngjI�Gbvp}Z(bvpIZS_�^`ZU�.��d�Z(jIZSZSk]t�k�ZU�}jIn�bvng_�j]_�j�b`pIZ�q}y���k�n���ZSj}m�ng_�j�_��$t�xU_�j}xUZU\�b�xUfgt�mvmS��Y[Zt�k�_�\Ib(bvpIZ�k�ZU�}jIn�bvng_�j���^v_��   µ2¶}·#§���������� R ���rqr� ����� ���s���� Q ���t�u35'-�*q}y���kIn���ZUjlm�ng_�jô|�{X� � |�x � �é�3� � ���F���<ï �Vz:�,'\}J���M� � � �Z��|«�U��zº����M}�z¬�?vy��z¬|�xwõÙ��x3�w� � |�}�}J�?������z¬|�x7vP; ·���º2%U�4�?xH|������ù�0�xwzy|{&}+~���{tï�æJõåæ&vl~�%Uzº���,' �µ����}�ó��0���«x3���Mvy}J���x,vy~³���?}(� ��v � '\�0'-���±�0'-�?}J���lî[zº���"� � |�x � ���H����ñ i ælñ u æ?ègè�ègègælñ���/¶ïâ�Vz:�,'å�,' �<�3}J|l� �?}����U�0'-���H{0|�}O���:�z���ág�F%

ÿ ö ñ Q ælñZ��÷VoHvbÿ2;ç·��W� k è {�·C~Y[Z�_u�´b`ZUj._���n�b5õ�d(pIZUj�bvpIZS^vZ�nwm�jI_rkIt�jI��ZS^�_u�%xU_�j���ilm�ng_�j3�

­�jsb`iIn¨b`n�a�ZUfgz���bvpIZPq}y���k�ng��ZUj}mvn�_�jo_��±ïéngmGb`pIZrmvn�fSZ�_���b`pIZ]�]tW��ng�ciI� m�iIhLx'fwt�m`mG_u�<ïâd(pI_sm�Z�ZSa�ZU^`z\ltung^(p}t�m(t�f���_�m�b�bvpIZ�m`tu��Z�x'_�^v^`ZUfwtWb`n�_�j�v��

��_Wd¯d�Z�tu^`Z2^`ZSt�k�z�bv_rm�b`tubvZG_�i}^�bvpIZS_�^`ZU�.���� �2 T �2s� ©Hv��4� |F�?��ïÛzº�O� � |�x � ���H� � �g�F���O|�{�©bª±�`��z:~³�?x-��z¬|�xP�C�ôºu¶�¶\�Vz:�0'\}l���M� � � �'��| � |�}�}J�0�g���Mz¬|�xv�1��L�?��� �l���³������}�x,z:x�ó���� ó�|�}�z:�0'7~ �0'-���'������}�x �±ïÛ�Vz:�,' � ��� vy}l� � ���#��xH� � |�x�L��[�0x � �����Vz:�,'å}J���M� � � ���é|��xB' |�x3�����±©£ª<�`|�}l� � ���Z1W�t{�ºu¦l{��<¤���¤¯·��W��~+;ê·&ogvSo|·W�W��kG%'�0'-�?xµ�0'-����|������L�0��~��3��� � |�vyx,�<|`{�� zº������g�l�����%����{EÚ�¶�¶�f�_����s~Z1

�*i}^*\I^`_�_u��m�bv^�tWb`ZU��z�nwm2mvng��ngfwtu^*bv_rb`p}tWbGngj|  µ2¶I·U§�� e _�iI��p}f�z7mv\lZCtu��n�j}�}�L_�jIZ�x'_�j}m�nwk�ZS^`m2�.k�n¨®LZU^`ZUjsb�`mvxUZUj}t�^vng_�m`�-�Lngj�bvp}Zt����bvp�m`x'ZSj}tu^`ng_}�SbvpIZ�x'_�j}x'ZS\�b ñZ��nwm"bvpIZ�b`t�^v��Z'bS� ¸ ªsi}t�jsbvn�bez����Wj}t���ZUfgz*b`pIZ��vtufgf���\}t�n�^ÙX�3��kIn�a�ZU^`��ZUjlx'ZS�cngm�k�Z'�}j}ZSk�_Wa�ZU^�b`pIZSmvZ�mvxUZUj}t�^vng_�mS�<��pI^vZSZGf�ZS���]t�m(tu^`Z*b`pIZUj.\I^`_Wa�ZCkP�·��2��p}Z�ª�iltujsbvn�bez)�nwm�ngjIn¨b`ngt�f�fgzSfSZU^`_}��d(pIZSj�j}_rª�i}ZU^`zrngm�\0ZU^v��_�^`��ZSk$�ºI�2ä�t�x�p.ªsiIZU^`zrngj}x'^`ZSt�m�ZCm+�hsz�t[�vmv��t�f�fw��tu��_�iIjsbC���� þGÿeþ�ÅWü�� ÿeþ�� ýeù³$�þ�Y�ÿ�� ý�ýeþ��\���.ü���Uÿ��rýeù�ú�?Ê�þ���ü�ÿeþGý�+�Uý5?�å����CùUÿ�� ý�+sú Y<ùSü��QT[�F� ý$�þX?$�� þ�ýeù�ú��Ê�þ�«ÅWüsþ`ÿ��]ý�+�Uýÿeþ�ÅWü�� ÿeþ���ýeùWùGú�?���.�´þ���û�ù��sþl�uý��Q?�Q�R��ú�������"þ��[Sú�û[� þ���(  

Page 6: 0/1( 23 !# 4 576 8 90:=yangke/papers/lower_bound.pdf0/1( 2 3 !# 4 576 8 90:=? @

Ú}� ¸ �´bvZS^�tufgf$bvp}Z�ª�i}ZU^`n�ZCm�t�^vZG�]t�kIZ��F���i}m�b hlZ7�vfgt�^v��ZS�I���p}ZUj3����^`_���bvpIZCm�ZGb`pI^vZSZGf�ZS���]t�mU�I_�jIZ�x'_�j}x'fgi}k�ZCm�bvp}tub ��t�j�zPªsiIZU^`n�ZCm(tu^`Z*^`ZSªsiIng^`ZSk$�

¡�ZU��_�^`ZGt�x#b`i}tufgf�zP\I^v_Wa�ngjI��bvpInwm(b`pIZU_�^vZS����d�Z�\I^`ZSmvZUjsb m�_���Z2^`ZSmviIf�b`m�b`p}tWb*t�^vZGjIZSZSk�ZCk���_�^�bvp}ZGbvpIZS_u�^`ZU�.��(Æ�Å ¡(Ö�Ò ÓlÍeÉ3Ó£¢ôñ Ì�Ð�Ô Î�Í�Î�Ì�ñ*Ø�Ë�È�É�Ê*Ñ^��Ø�ÍJÝáÉ�ñ�Î�ÍeÖ�ñ��p}ZG�}^`m�b(^vZCm�i}f¨b nwm���^v_��é  µ2¶I·U§¤|�2sgs V g�A¥�z¦ T �� TPN � V���§3Q QE¨ TrR � � � ¦�� T©§ ¥�¦�� XuR ���«ª�¬®­�¯° �±²�P³\�L{0|��:��|��ô�0'-�&x3|������Mz¬|�x �±z:x´#�µLZx z:�Mz¬|�xH¶K1W�L�?� ñ i ælñ u æ?ègè�ègègælñ��\�����,' � � |�x � �é�3�¬�X�?���Mzº�t{���z:x�óåÿ ö ñ Q ælñ � ÷Vo·vbÿF;ã·W�W��kG%±��xH���^���O�,' �O©£ª<���z:~³�?x-��z¬|�xù|`{�ïT1T�L�?�Z�${tà£æ`çI~U�����¸!?v �0}��X{�vyx � �Mz¬|�x�1?35'-�?x��0'-�?}J���Jî[zº���5}J�����Zx vy~«���0}��J¹ i æ�¹ u æ?ègè�ègæ�¹ � %��v � '\�0'-��� O �QºR i ¹ uQ ;ã·�¤ô·C¶�¶s�u��{0|�}*�C�ã·C¶�¶ ��xH�9 ø   �${tß�ælñ Q {¬ßo~�~�§Pá7»«¼ ¤£½ ·&o·v«°[¹ Q {�º�~{0|�}��?�F�?}���� á�·4æ�ºyæ?ègègè�ègæv�51���' �0}l�W» ¼ zº�O� � |�x ������x,�'�0'-����zº�Xz:xH�[�é� �?xH�4�?x �&|�{��,' ������}�ó��?� � |�x � ���H�Vñ Q 1Y[Z�xUt�f�f°»|¼cbvpIZ«z:x¾'-�?}J�0x,�<�?z¬�F��_��£�L��(ÆEí ÇoÈ�É�¿çî��WØ�ÍÁÀ�É3Ó-Í�É�ñ*ÏLÉY[Z�\I^`ZSmvZUjsb t�k�Z'�}j}n¨b`n�_�j�_��"b`pIZ�ÙX�$��k�nga�ZS^v��ZUj}xUZ��s_�^ ÙGiIfgf�hlt�x��s�é��ZUnghIfgZU^(k�nga�ZU^`��ZSj}x'Z�  ÙX�£¡�·�§���������� R ���?Â>�AÃB¤ �&� � � TGÄ �2� X ���£ÅL|�}|Æ�}l��xH�[|�~û�F��}�z¬�4�?�����lÇ�%zÈ �Vz:�,'³z¬�4�?x �Mz � ���y��v��4� |�}��µ%*�'�5�[��L'xH��0'-�?z:}�É|Ê7�`��z:���0}�ó��?x � ���é|¶�l�5k É«Ê�{µÇUÿ�ÿ È�~ZáÐú

üÇ]{¬à0~ °Sf�_���Ë Ç]{¬à0~È]{¬à0~�Ì è {EÚ�~

��p}Z�ÙX�3��k�nga�ZS^v��ZUj}xUZ�nwm2t�fgmv_��sj}_Wd(jÞt�m*bvp}Z�}l�0������z:���S�?x �M}J|��H�W�c��pIZ�^`ZSt�k�ZU^2ngm2^`Z'��ZS^v^`ZSk.b`_[  ÙX�£¡I·u�Ù�¡�¥��u¡�¥[¡���Ý��(¥}·#§���_�^�t2x'_���\I^vZSpIZUjlm�nga�Z�bv^`ZStubvnwm�Z�_�j�bvpIZ(ÙX�3��k�nga�ZS^v��ZUj}xUZ��3Y[Z m�b`tWb`Z�mvZUa�ZU^�tuf�\I^`_�\0ZU^vbvngZSm_���bvpIZPÙX�3��kIn�a�ZU^`��ZUjlx'Z]tuj}k¹\0_�m�bv\0_�j}Z]bvpIZSn�^�\I^`_s_��©mGbv_ ¸ \I\0ZUj}k�n�� ¸ �7��pIZCm�Zr\}^v_�\lZS^�b`n�ZCm�tu^`Z]pIng��pIfgzi}jIf�ng��ZSf�z±bv_.hlZ]_�^vng��ngj}t�fE��YoZ]fgngm�bGbvpIZS�épIZS^vZ�_�jIf�z.��_�^GbvpIZrxU_���\IfgZ'b`ZUjIZCmvm2_u��bvpIZ]\ltu\0ZU^�tujlk±��_�^*b`pIZ^`ZSt�k�ZU^�mS°�xU_�j�a�ZSjIngZUj}xUZ��¤|�2sgs V =£�AÍ � �2� R X�V�� �� QSRUT O ¦ R µz�Î�·�t{�Ç ��x3�+ÈÏ'-���F�±z¬�[�0x,��z � ���y��zº����}�z¬�?vy��z¬|�x-�&%P�,' �0xÑиÒ*{�ÇUÿgÿ Èc~ á¶�1��p}ngm(nwm�_�h�a�ng_�i}m���^`_��b`pIZ�k�ZU�}jIn�bvng_�j3�¤|�2sgs V q?�A�� T � XuR.ÓGT � ¦ XuR �£�£�0�-ÇOiFæ�ÇXu«�l����zº���M}�z¬�?vy��z¬|�x-��|`{�z¬�[�0x,��z � ���H��v��4� |�}��Á1+�L�?�ÔÈOiü ��xH�ÑÈXuü���«��zº���M}�z¬�?vy��z¬|�x-�&� ��}J��~³�?�M}�zºÕ����å�?�Oà°%'��v � '��0'-���3{0|�}³��x ��àÔ%tÈ iü ��xH�EÈ uü '-�����³z¬�[�0x,��z � ���b��v��4� |�}�����xH�É|ÊI{µÈ�iü ÿgÿ ÈXuü ~�; ¯21�³å�³v7�?��ÇOi[ÈOiÖ�× ��|å�4�?xH|����«�0'-�«}J��x3�4|�~Û�F��}�z¬�4�?���{0|�}�~��«�?���Hz � Y�z:x7óUàÆ� �l� |�}J��z:x7ó��|�ÇOi�{0|��:��|��Vz:x�óå�?���Hz � Y�z:x7ó�ç � ��� |�}J��z:x7ó�ÇOiü ��x3�«�0'-�?xµ|�vy�Q�Hvy�£à°ØJç-1)³å�J' �����É|ÊI{�Ç i È iÖ × ~?ÿgÿ Ç u È uÖÔÙ ~V;uÉ|Ê�{µÇ i ÿgÿ Ç u ~"¤�¯[è {©¦s~¤|�2sgs V Âr�AÚiz�� R z�� X R&§ ���£�?�|Ç ��x3��È ���U}l��xH�[|�~â�F��}�z¬�4�?���0�¶|�{³z¬�4�?x �Mz � ���'��v��[�-|�}�����xH�å�g�0�+Û���#�S�[�0���0}�~#z:x zº���Mz � {�vyx � ��z¬|�x�1C35'-�?x É|ÊI{µÛ%{�Ç�~�ÿ�ÿ Û%{µÈ�~v~�;uÉ«Ê�{�ÇUÿgÿ È�~�è {M¡�~­�jsb`iIn¨b`n�a�ZUfgz���b`pInwm(f�ZS����t�m�b`tubvZSm(bvp}tub(kIZ'bvZS^v��ngjInwmeb`ngxG\I^`_�x'ZCk�iI^`ZSm(xUt�jIjI_�b�ngj}xU^vZCt�mvZ*ZSj�b`^v_�\�z��Ü %ã���Q����+uý�T[�®ÝIþ`ÿeþ��[��þ�´wùUÿGùSü�ÿ�T�þ�Þ���� ý�� ù��\+�þ`ÿeþX���*ý�+7'ý�Y<þOUÿeþ�ü������[��ý�+sþX�7'ýeü�ÿ`?�b� ù��4�£���[��ýeþ��T.ù?´Z�¨ù��U$7���þJ8é1�(.ß%ü�ý�ý�+�þû�ÿeùSû�þ`ÿ�ý�� þ��VYZ���Q�,�sùUý�$�þ<[ÝIþ��`ýeþ�T#$��cý�+�þ<�`+7��[�Cþ(ù?´$ý�+sþ<$����þ�(�à

Page 7: 0/1( 23 !# 4 576 8 90:=yangke/papers/lower_bound.pdf0/1( 2 3 !# 4 576 8 90:=? @

¤|�2sgs Vxá �Aâ�����sg V�� �) QURST O ¦ R ���t�g�£�?�5Ç ��xH�ÑÈ �l��ã�?}�xH|�vy�:�Qz ��zº���M}�z¬�?vy��z¬|�x-�5�Vz:�0'X�-��}J��~«�0���?}��ä ��x3��®�%Zz�1:��1º%�Ç]{©¶s~Záê·<o ä %ÔÇ]{e·�~Zá ä %�È]{©¶s~ á�·&oµ®�%���xH�MÈ]{e·�~Zá ®�1��L�?��Ç m ��x3��È m ���#�0z:x3|�~#z¬�����zº����}�z¬�?vy��z¬|�x-�#�Vz:�,'U� ��}J��~³�?���0}���{tnVæ ä ~«��x3�.{tnVæJ®u~�%±}l���M� � � �Mz:�F�?���©%�z�1:��1º%«Ç m {æåI~�áèç m é©ê ä é {�·5o ä ~ m2ë é ��xH�È m {µåI~'á ç m é©ê ® é {�·&o ®u~ m2ë é 1�35' �0x��'�J' �����É«ÊI{µÇ m ÿ�ÿ È m ~Zá§n¶°�É|ÊI{�Ç<æ&È�~�è {µì�~�������� R ��� á �AÃB¤ �&� � � TGÄ �2� X ���£ÅL|�}Vn���zº����}�z¬�?vy�Mz¬|�x-�Vß i æJß u æ?ègègè�æJß m |`{&z¬�4�?x �Mz � ���,��v��4� |�}��µ%L�'��[�0�L'xH�O�,' �0z:}]t�f�f���\ltung^�ÙX�3��kIn�a�ZU^`��ZUjlx'ZT6�í�î�É|Ê©8«�é|¶�l�í�îtÉ«ÊI{¬ß i æ`ß u æ?ègè�ègè�æJß m ~Zá

mú QSR i mú� R i É«ÊI{¬ß Q ÿ�ÿ ßM�C~�è {²ïu~�(Æ�� DZï¹ÖáîcÉLÝðÝáÌ<Î�¢ù¨�Ö�Ò(ˬËIÈ�Éu¢ôÐvÐé�FÑ�Ì�Í�Óg¿ãîX��Ø�ÍAÀ�É3Ó-Í�É�ñ�ÏLÉY[Z���_�kIZUfIt*f�ZCtu^`jIn�j}�2t�f���_�^`n¨b`pI�"�,t�m<t�^�tuj}kI_���n�fSZSk���iI^`ngjI�JðÞt�x�pIngjIZ��"­�b���t���ZCm%t�bv_�b`t�fs_��H®*ª�i}ZU^`n�ZCmU�t�j}kÞtub*b`pIZ�ZUj}kÞ_u��b`pIZSmvZ�ªsiIZS^vngZSmS�$tP^�tujlk�_��³ngjI\Ii�bXß nwm2\I^vZCm�ZSjsbvZSk7bv_T��� ¸ �stungj3�$d�Z�t�m`mviI��Zcb`p}tWbñ i ælñ u æ?ègègè�æ�ñ���t�^vZGb`pIZc�PxU_�j}xUZU\�b�m m`tWbvnwm���zsngjI�]b`p}tWb³ÿ ö ñ Q æ�ñ � ÷ ogv£ÿz;õ·��u�[k���_�^��W�á?�l��q�i}\I\l_sm�Z#ñ � ngm�b`pIZb�tu^`��ZUb(xU_�j}xUZU\�bC��bvpIZSjñ�ç�ci}m�b \I^`ZSk�nwx#bñ � {¬ßo~�d(n¨b`p7m�i�èrxUn�ZSj�b�t�xUxUiI^`t�x'z��

­�jÞbvpIZ]xSt�mvZ�bvpltWb�ñ � nwm�b`pIZ�b`tu^`��ZUb2xU_�j}xUZU\�bC�$d�Z�k�Z'�ljIZcb`pIZ ����������_u�|�átW�´b`ZU^2bvp}ZCå��Eb`poªsiIZU^`z�bv_h0ZGbvp}Z�hIn�jltu^`zPmeb`^vngjI�U� �é bvp}tub�k�ZSm`x'^`nghlZCm�bvpIZ�xU_�jsbvZSj�b�m�_�jB��° m�b`t�\lZCmU��b`pIZ�\0_�mvn¨b`n�_�j�_���bvp}Z�pIZSt�kImU��b`pIZxUiI^`^vZSj�b*n�jsbvZS^vjltuf"m�b`tubvZ�_u�l���*YoZ�k�Z'�}j}Z#� �ò bv_�hlZcbvpIZ�meb�tWb`Z�_u�«�«hlZU��_�^`Z�n¨bGmeb�tu^vb`mS��� _�bvnwx'ZcZCt�x�p�� �énwm2t]^`t�j}k�_���aWtu^`ngt�hIfgZ4��bvpIZ�^`t�j}k�_���jIZCmvm�x'_���ZCm(��^`_���hl_�bvp7b`pIZ�q}y���_�^�t�xUf�Z�t�j}k�bvp}Zc^�tuj}k�_���b�tu\0Z��ilm�ZCmU����pIZ�����bvp7mvxUZUj}t�^vng_}�-� � ngm�m�ng��\If�zPbvpIZ�xU_�j}xStWb`ZUj}tubvng_�jP_��<t�f�fLb`pIZ�m�b`tWb`ZSm��Z� � á«{�� �ò æl� �i æ?ègègè�æ�� �ó ~#�Y[Z�k�ZU�}jIZ�� é b`_]hlZGb`pIZ�tufgf���\}t�n�^(ÙX�3��k�nga�ZS^v��ZUj}xUZ�_��V� ié æl� ué æ?ègè�ègæl� �é �� é árí�îtÉ«ÊI{M� ié æ�� ué æ�è�ègègæl� �é ~�è

­�jsb`iIn¨b`n�a�ZUfgz��|� é ��ZCt�mviI^`ZSm�pI_Wd×�vk�n�®LZU^`ZUjsbvfgz��¸� hlZSp}t�a�ZCmcd(n�bvpæk�n�®0ZS^vZSj�b�b`t�^v��Z'b�x'_�jlx'ZU\Ib`mS�[Y[Zmvp}t�f�fL��_�x'ilm(_�j�pI_Wd�� é x�p}t�jI��ZCm�d(n�bvpñåL�

Y[Z(�}^�m�b�meb�tWb`Z�tuj}k�\}^v_Wa�Z�bed�_�fgZU���]t�m�tuh0_�i�b�b`pIZ�t�f�f���\ltung^�ÙX�$��k�nga�ZU^`��ZSj}x'Z�����pIZ(�l^`m�b�fgZU���]t�mvt�z�mb`p}tWb�bvpIZ2tufgf¨��\}t�n�^�ÙX�3��kIn�a�ZU^`��ZUjlx'Z�ngm�ngjIn¨b`ngt�f�fgz#fUZU^`_}�stuj}k]bvpIZ2m�ZCx'_�jlk�_�jIZ�m`t�z�m�tW�´b`ZU^�tufgfIbvp}Z*ªsiIZU^`ngZSm�t�^vZ�]t�k�Z���b`pIZ�tufgf���\}t�n�^(ÙX�3��k�nga�ZS^v��ZUj}xUZ�nwm]��fwtu^`��ZC�I�¤|�2sgs V¸ô 35'-�³���:���g� ��z:}JõÑ�V�`��z:���0}Mó[�?x � ��zº�Xz:x z:�Mz¬���:���CÕ��?}J|G%Z�,' ���±zº��� ò áì¶z1ÓGT Ô ¨�ö ��pInwm�nwm�_�h�a�ng_�i}m�mvn�jlx'Z��¯p}t�mvj3° b��]t�k�Z�t�j�z�ªsiIZU^`ngZSm�z�Z'bS��tujlk�bvpIZ�m�b`tubvZ _��Ô�ìnwm�ngj}k�ZU\0ZUjlk�ZUjsb_��"b`pIZGb`t�^v��Z'b(x'_�j}x'ZS\�bS����p�i}m5��iò �,�Vuò �3���g�g�,� �ò p}t�a�Z*nwk�ZSj�b`ngxStuf�kIngm�bv^`n�h}i�bvng_�j}mS�¤|�2sgs Vx÷ �t{X�0'-��������}�x z:x�óå��� ó�|�}�z:�0'7~ø�P'-�F�³� ��� vy}l� � ���«��x3� � |�xZL��[�0x � �W��%'�0����zº�t{���z:x7órºW¦0{¬�%¤4�u~�;·&o·v«o,·��u�[k�%Z�,' �0x���{����0}����:�L�0'-�M!0v �?}�z¬������}J�O~³�[�4��%'�'�J' ������ óJù ¶-è ºu� u{0|�}�� ù Úz1ÓGT Ô ¨�ö YoZ�\I^`_Wa�Z�tom�bv^`_�jI��ZU^�meb�tWb`ZU��ZUjsbS��bvp}tub�tu�´bvZS^rtufgf�ªsiIZS^vngZSm�tu^`Z���t�k�Z���bvpIZ7ÙX�$��k�nga�ZS^v��ZUj}xUZh0Z'bed�ZUZSj � Qó tuj}kå� �ó ngm(tub f�ZCt�m�b(¶ è º�Ú���_�^ tuj�z.���ág�l�¸ �´bvZS^%t�f�fsª�i}ZU^`n�ZCm�tu^`Z��]t�k�Z��CbvpIZ�tufg��_�^`n�bvpI�u�¬nwm3^`ZSt�k�z�b`_(b`t���Z�t ^`t�j}k�_��Ðß�k�nwmeb`^vnghIi�b`ZSk�t�xUxU_�^�k�n�j}�b`_�õ�t�j}k]�]tu��Z�t�\I^`ZSkIngx'bvng_�jr_�j]bvpIZ*fgt�hlZSfl_��*߬�<ë _Wd�ZUa�ZS^S��d�Z*x'_�jlm�nwk�ZU^�tck�n�®LZU^`ZUjsb�ZU��\0ZU^`ng��ZSjsb��%d�Z��n�a�Z��át�^`t�j}k�_�� ߸ú<x�pI_sm�ZSj±��^`_��ât�jI_ub`pIZU^Gk�nwmeb`^vnghIi�b`n�_�j�õ.úE�$d(pInwx�pok�ZS\lZSj}kImG_�j¸� tujlk)�l��Y[Z�ilm�Z� Q {�^`ZSmv\3�Î� � ~�bv_]k�ZSjI_ub`Z�b`pIZ�k�nwmeb`^vnghIi�b`n�_�j�_���bvp}Z2_�i�bv\}i�b(_u���c�In�jPbvpIZ�xSt�mvZ�b`p}tWb5ñ Q {�^`ZSmv\3�Zñ � ~�nwm�b`pIZb�tu^`��ZUb�x'_�j}x'ZS\�bS�V��_ubvnwx'ZÑ� Q nwm�t�k�Z'b`ZU^`��n�jInwm�bvnwx ��iIjlx#bvng_�j�_u�b� Qó tujlkU߸ú©�Ituj}k.� � _u� � �ó tuj}kS߸ú���q�_ch�z��ZU���]t�¦}��d�ZGp}t�a�Z É|ÊI{�� Qó ÿgÿ � �ó ~ ù É«ÊI{µ� Q ÿ�ÿ � � ~�èû

Page 8: 0/1( 23 !# 4 576 8 90:=yangke/papers/lower_bound.pdf0/1( 2 3 !# 4 576 8 90:=? @

��_Wd¬d�Z�k�ZCmvxU^vngh0Z�b`pIZ(k�ngm�bv^`nghIi�bvng_�j#õ.ú��"Y[Z�\}tu^vbvn�bvng_�j«ë¹ngj�b`_Xë ò t�j}k#ë i ��m�ilx�p�bvpltWb'ñ Q {¬à0~'áãñ � {¬à0~��_�^�tufgfLàx/�ë ò t�j}kåñ Q {¬à0~��á/ñ � {tàL~���_�^2tufgf*à¸/�ë i ����p}ZUj7d�Z���jI_Wdìb`p}tWb*tr^`t�j}k�_���fgzPx�pI_sm�ZSj�ßa/^ët�xUxU_�^�k�n�j}��b`_�bvpIZ�k�ngm�bv^`nghIi�bvng_�j�õçp}t�m$\I^`_�h}t�hIngf�n�bez*tub3f�ZCt�m�b i&ë-ü�ë*i`j �&ýu b`_(hlZ�n�j�ë i ��mvngj}x'Z<b`pIZ�x'_�^v^`ZUfwtWb`n�_�jh0Z'bed�ZUZSj ñ Q tuj}k\ñZ��ngm(tub(��_smebWv�¤ô·W�W��kW�

Y[Z���i}^�b`pIZU^*\}tu^vbvn�bvng_�jµë i ngjsbv_�ëVþ i t�j}k�ë ëi mvi}x�p.bvpltWb�ñ Q {tàL~<᫤�·���_�^�àH/�ëVþ i t�j}k ñ Q {tà0~&á o�·��_�^&àñ/ ë ëi ��Y§�b� ó �Id�Z�t�m`m�i}��Z2b`p}tWbî�ÿ ø   àB/�ëVþ i ÿ àB/�ë i § ù ·W�uºyè��p}Z�k�ngm�bv^`nghIi�bvng_�jåõ.ú3ngm(mvn���\Ifgzrb`pIZ�k�nwmeb`^vnghIi�b`n�_�j�õ³xU_�j}k�n�bvng_�j}ZSk�_�j�àB/�ëVþ i ���_ub`ngxUZcb`p}tWb2��_�^Gtuj�z.ZUfgZU��ZUjsb�à·/�ë þ i �$d�Z�p}t�a�Z�ñ Q {¬à0~5áá¤�·�t�j}k�ñ � {¬à0~5á o�·��G­��|�ångm*\0ZU^v��ZSx#bC�n�� Z��g�3n¨�<��ái�Sáá¶}�LbvpIZSj:� Q m�p}_�iIfwk±h0Z�bvpIZ]x'_�j}m�b`tujsbc¤�·�t�j}k:� � mvpI_�iIfgkÞhlZ�b`pIZ]x'_�jlmeb�tujsb#o�·��3tuj}kÐxÒ�{µ� Q ÿgÿ � � ~Zá��ô�<­�j]b`pIZ*xSt�mvZ(bvpltWbV�¯ngm�jI_�b�\lZS^���ZCx#bC�sd�Z�xStujPm�bvngf�f0h0_�iIj}k�иÒ�{µ� Q ÿ�ÿ � � ~���^v_��åh0ZUfg_Wd��

Ý�_�j}mvngk�ZS^�b`pIZ�xUt�mvZ�b`p}tWb2bvp}Z�xU_�j}xUZU\�b��ñ[ngmGx�pI_sm�ZSjÞt�m2tPb`tu^`��ZUb*x'_�j}x'ZS\�bS��­���tP^�tuj}kI_�� ß /�ëçnwmkI^`t�d(jrt�xUx'_�^`kIn�jI�2b`_Oõ7�sbvpIZSj]d(n¨b`pr\I^`_�h}t�hIngf�n�bez�tub�fgZSt�m�b i�ë5ü�ëPiJj �&ý� �sn¨b�ngm�n�j\ëVþ i �%Y[Z�m`t�zM�¯ngmc��fgi}x���z��n��(n¨b�p}t�m�t�j¹t�xUxUiI^`t�x'z±_��<�cn�j�\}^vZCk�ngx'bvngjI� �ñ%{tßo~*��_�^ct.^�tuj}k�_�� ß / ë*����pIZUj¹d�Z]�sj}_Wd«b`p}tWb��nwmfgi}x���zPtub f�ZCt�m�bG·&oH��_u��b`pIZGbvng��Z��

­����¯nwm�fgi}x���z���bvp}ZUjPn�b�_�jIfgz���t���ZCm�tc��nwm�b`tu��Z ��_�^�t�jS����^`t�x#bvng_�jP_u�$bvp}Z*ngjI\Ii�b�mU��q�_�bvp}Z*\I^`_�hltuhIngf�n�bez�õ�]t���ZSm(t���nwmeb�tu��ZG_�j�t�^�tuj}k�_�� ß ú / ë þ i ngm(tub ��_smeb�{e·&o·v«o,·��W� k ~`��¦

­��Î�õnwm�iIjIfgi}x���z��}t�jszsb`pIn�j}��xU_�iIfwk�p}tu\I\0ZUj���¡�iIb(bvpInwm(_�j}f�zrpltu\I\0ZUj}m d(n¨b`p�\}^v_�h}tuhIngfgn¨bezrtub ��_smeb����q�_�bvp}Z�b`_ub`t�fL\I^v_�h}tuh}n�fgn¨bezE�ã��t���ZCm�tc��nwm�b`tu��Z�ngjP\I^`ZSkIngx'bvngjI���ñ<{¬ß¸úg~�_�j�t�^�tuj}k�_���n�jI\}i�b&߸ú5/�ëVþ inwm tub���_smeb �

{�·&oHvUo|·W�W� k ~v�W¦ ¤g�M; ¦l{��%¤��u~·&o·v«o,·��u� k ;ã·���ì

n���ºW¦l{��%¤��u~V;ã·&o·v«o,·��u�[ku����pIngm ngm�b`^viIZG��_�^ tuj�z]b�tu^`��Z'b(x'_�j}x'ZS\�b��ñ"�¡�zoiIjIng_�j¹hl_�iIj}k$�"d�Z]��jI_Wd«bvp}tubcd(n�bvp¹\I^`_�h}t�hIn�fgn�bezÞtWb�fgZSt�meb�ºs�WÚI����\I^vZCk�nwx#b`m�hl_�bvpôñ Q {t߸úw~Gtuj}kñ���{t߸úw~�x'_�^v^`ZSx'bvfgz���_�^ t�^`t�j}k�_�� ߸ú5/�ëVþ i ���p}ZU^`Z'��_�^`Z���n�� ñ Q nwm�bvpIZ2b�tu^`��Z'b(x'_�j}x'ZS\�bS��b`pIZUj�bvp}Z2\}^v_�h}tuhIngfgn¨bez.�ç_�iIbv\Ii�b�m(tÞ�#¤�·S�cngm(tub�fgZSt�meb º��uÚ�Øn���ñZ�rnwm�b`pIZrb�tu^`��ZUb�x'_�j}x'ZS\�bS�%bvp}ZUj¬b`pIZP\}^v_�h}tuhIngfgn¨bezH��_�i�bv\IiIb`m�tô��¤�·C�.ngm�tWbc��_smeb�·��WÚ}�±��pIZUj>d�Z

xU_�j}xUf�ilk�ZGbvp}tub иÒ*{�� Qó ÿ�ÿ � �ó ~ ù иÒ�{µ� Q ÿ�ÿ � � ~ ù ºÚ f�_��0{

º��uÚ·��uÚ ~�¤

·Ú fg_��L{

·W�WÚºs�WÚ ~'á

f�_���ºÚ ù ¶ è º�Ú

��_�^ tuj�zr\}t�n�^����á��l��q�_�d�Z2plt�a�Z� ó ù ú Q��R � ÐxÒ�{�� Qó ÿ�ÿ � �ó ~ ù ¶-è ºuÚ��l{E�Xo|·�~ ù ¶ è º�� u��_�^ � ù ÚI��(Æt¤ ��Ø É�Ì<ÐPÑ>Ò É�Ó}ÍeÉ�ÎY[Z7\I^`_Wa�Z.t±b`pIng^`k,fgZU���]t[t�hl_�i�b�bvpIZ±t�f�f���\}tung^]ÙX�$��k�n�a�ZU^`��ZSj}x'Z���j}tu��ZUfgz���bvpltWbrZSt�x�p|ªsiIZS^vz>kI_sZCm�j�° bngj}xU^vZCt�mvZ7bvpIZ[tufgf¨��\}t�n�^PÙX�3��kIn�a�ZU^`��ZUjlx'Z.�ci}x�p��«ë _Wd�ZUa�ZU^C��b`ZSx�pIj}ngxStufgf�z,d�ZÞjIZUZCkæbv_��l^`m�b�xU_�j}mvngkIZU^Ptmv\0ZSx'nwtuf3bezs\0ZG_u��ªsiIZU^`n�ZCmU�<Y[Z�xUt�f�fLb`pIZU��bvpIZ7�vngk�ZCtuf3ªsiIZS^vngZSm`�I��������� R ��� ô �AÍ � � V���� ¦�� T©§ ¥°¦�� X�R ���Î�_³å�µ�0���w�£!0v �?}��¶{�vyx � �Mz¬|�x �${tàLæJçI~ zº����xêngkIZStufGªsiIZU^`z��i}j}x#b`n�_�j-%'z {

ÿ[9 ø   �L{¬ß ælñ Q {tßo~v~�§Pÿ2; ·º {Eà�~

{0|�}�� áê·4æ�ºyæ?ègègè�æ`��1

Page 9: 0/1( 23 !# 4 576 8 90:=yangke/papers/lower_bound.pdf0/1( 2 3 !# 4 576 8 90:=? @

­�jsb`iIn¨b`n�a�ZUfgz��Ln��V�L{¬àLæ`çI~�ngm*nwk�ZSt�fE�0bvp}ZUj±n�b2nwm*jI_ub2pIn���pIfgz�h}ngt�m�ZCk7n�jotuj�z7mvxUZUj}t�^vng_}� ­ekIZStuf%ªsiIZU^`n�ZCm*t�^vZj}ngxUZ�mvngj}x'Z�bvp}ZUzck�_�j3° b<ngj}xU^vZCt�mvZ�b`pIZ tufgf¨��\}t�n�^<ÙX�$��k�nga�ZU^`��ZSj}x'Z��ci}x�p���t�m<mvpI_Wd(jcngj�bvpIZ���_�fgfg_Wd(n�jI�2fgZU���]tI�¤|�2sgs V� ©,v��[�-|��0�#�0'-�Ñå3���0'x!0v �?}��S��|¶��xB' |�x3�����<©£ª<�`|�}J� � ���³�0�¶�,' �«��� ó�|�}�z:�0'7~ zº�c{:�3æl¢ê~&%±��'-�?}J��zº�O��x�z¬�4������!?v �0}���1C35'-�?x � é oH� é ë*i ;|Ú�¢õ�{0|�}��C�ôºu¶�¶z1ÓGT Ô ¨�ö YoZGk�ZU�}jIZÑÇ Q áù�L{¬ß ælñ Q {tß[~�~�bv_�hlZGt�^�tuj}kI_���aWtu^`ngt�hIf�Z���d(p}ZU^`Zßânwm�tc^�tuj}kI_���ZUfgZU��ZUjsb�n�jëçkIngm�bv^`n�h}i�bvZCk±t�xSx'_�^�k�ngjI��bv_�õ7� Y[Z�kIZ'�}jIZ ä Q á î�ÿ�  Ç Q á�¤�·U§��*��pIZUj3�Lt�xSx'_�^`k�ngjI��b`_¶�3ZS����t±·��0d�Zplt�a�Z ä Q á ·�¤g9 ø   �${tß æ�ñ Q {¬ßo~�~�§º á ·�¤4»|¼�¤ ½ ·&oHvU°[¹ Qº è {E¥�~

Y[Z]i}mvZ�È Q bv_±kIZUjI_�bvZ�bvp}ZPk�nwmeb`^vnghIi�b`n�_�j[_���b`pIZrtujlm�d�ZU^G��^`_��-b`pIZrpI_�jIZSm�bcq}y���_�^�t�x'fgZ�d(pIZUj�ñ Q nwmb`pIZ2b`t�^v��Z'b(x'_�jlx'ZU\IbS����pIZSj�_�hsa�ng_�i}mvfgzCÈ Q nwm�bvp}Z2h}n�jI_���ngt�f3k�ngm�bv^`nghIi�bvng_�j�d(n�bvp�\}tu^�tu��Z'b`ZU^�{�¢Ðæ ä Q ~#��¡�z��ZU���]tU¡���d�ZGp}t�a�Z É«ÊI{æÈ Q ÿgÿ ÈW�S~'᧢ °KÉ|ÊI{�Ç Q ÿgÿ Ç-�C~0è {e·C¶�~Y[Z k�ZSjI_ub`Z�b`pIZ(tufgf¨��\}t�n�^�ÙX�$��k�nga�ZS^v��ZUj}xUZ�_u�-È i æ&È u æ�è�ègè�ègæ�È���h�z�­��%��p}ZUj�d�Z(mvp}tufgf�hl_�iIj}k�­ ��^`_��«t�hl_Wa�Z��

¡�zÞm�b`t�j}kIt�^`k[xUt�fgxUiIf�ilmU�"d�Z���jI_Wd�b`p}tWb���_�^ctuj�z±\0_�mvn�bvnga�Z�^vZCtuf�j�iI��hlZS^`m�à>t�j}kµç0��bvpIZS^vZ]ZU��ngm�b`m�t^`ZSt�f$j�iI�ch0ZU^ ��h0Z'bed�ZUZSj�à±t�j}k¶ç�mvi}x�pPb`p}tWb

fg_��L{tà0~Voofg_��0{tçI~'á àSoµç�mvngj}x'Z�bvpIZGk�ZU^`nga�tubvnga�Z _��3f�_��l{¬à0~�ngm*·���à��V� _Wdôn��3hl_�bvp¶à�tujlk«ç]tu^`Z d(n¨b`pIngjo �·���¦,ævÚ���¦u§��Wb`pIZUj�m�_�nwm��}��tuj}kb`p�i}m(d�Z2d(ngfgf3p}t�a�Z

ÿef�_��l{tàL~ o[f�_��l{tçI~�ÿ[á����� àUo�ç� ���� ;|¦3ÿ àUo�ç*ÿ�è��p}ZU^`Z'��_�^`Z��Ld�Z�plt�a�ZP{©jI_ub`ngxUZ�b`p}tWbGh�z.bvpIZ�k�ZU�}jIn�bvng_�jÞ_���nwk�ZSt�f<ªsiIZS^vngZSmS�Ld�Z�p}t�a�ZP·��W¦T; ä Q ;êÚs��¦r��_�^t�f�f°�`° m�~��É|ÊI{�Ç Q ÿ�ÿ Ç-�W~3¤>É|ÊI{�ÇÔ��ÿ�ÿ Ç Q ~ á ä Q f�_��l{ ä Qä � ~�¤¯{e·&o ä Q ~�f�_��0{ ·&o ä Q·&o ä � ~3¤ ä �$fg_��0{ ä �ä Q ~�¤ì{�·&o ä �C~�fg_��l{ ·�o ä �·<o ä Q ~á { ä Q o ä �S~'{©f�_�� ä Q oofg_�� ä �C~3¤ì g{e·5o ä Q ~ oæ{e·&o ä �C~�§�  f�_��0{�·&o ä Q ~ o[fg_��l{�·�o ä �S~�§; ¦l{ ä Q o ä �C~ u ¤�¦0 �{�·&o ä Q ~ oæ{e·&o ä �C~�§ u

á à}{ ä Q o ä �C~ u è¢}iI^vbvpIZS^v��_�^`Z���h�z¶��ZU���]t«¡

­ á í�îtÉ|ÊI{µÈ i æ�È u æ?ègè�ègè�æ&È � ~ZáÆ¢ ° ú Q�� � {�É|ÊI{�Ç Q ÿgÿ Ç-��~3¤ÏÉ|Ê�{�ÇÔ�7ÿ�ÿ Ç Q ~v~; à�¢ °�ú Q�� � { ä Q o ä � ~ u èq�iIh}m�bvn�bvi�b`n�jI�]ngj7ä�ªsi}tubvng_�j.¥I��d�Z2plt�a�Z

­ ; à�¢ ° ú Q�� � { ä Q o ä � ~ uá º[¢å{�·&oHv0~ ú Q��R � {�¹ Q o:¹¾�C~ uá º[¢å{�·&oHv0~ ��

�O°�ú Q ¹ uQ o��*ú Q ¹ Q�� u���; º[¢å{�·&oHv0~�����°Fú Q ¹ uQ �!

Page 10: 0/1( 23 !# 4 576 8 90:=yangke/papers/lower_bound.pdf0/1( 2 3 !# 4 576 8 90:=? @

q�n�j}xUZ O Q ¹LuQ ;¯·�¤ì·S¶�¶s�u�}��d�Z�p}t�a�Z­�;,º[¢�{e·&o·vl~U{©��¤ô·C¶�¶s~l;æÚ[¢õ� {e·�·C~

��_�^ �.�æºu¶�¶}���Z'��bS�}d�Z�mvpI_Wdìb`p}tWb � é oH� é ë*i ; ­yè {e·�º�~��p}ZP^`ZSt�mv_�j¹nwm�b`p}tWb���_�^�ZUa�ZU^`zx���%bvpIZ.m�b`tWb`ZP_�����tW�´b`ZU^�bvpIZTås��bvp>ªsiIZS^vz��V� Qé ��ngm�tÞkIZ'bvZS^v��ngjInwmeb`ngx

��i}j}x#b`n�_�j]_u�L� Qé ë*i �¾È Q ��tuj}k�b`pIZ ^�tuj}k�_���hIn�b`m�i}m�ZCk�hsz�����ë _Wd�ZUa�ZU^C�Wbvp}Z(^`t�j}k�_��åhIn�b`m�ilm�ZCk�h�z��ôp}t�a�Zb`pIZrm`tu��Z]k�ngm�bv^`nghIi�bvng_�j[��_�^Gt�f�f�mvxUZUj}t�^vng_�mS����pIZS^vZU��_�^`Z�d�Z]xUt�jongj�a�_���Z#��ZU���]t.Ú�t�j}k^�3ZS���]t�¦7tuj}k\}^v_Wa�Z�{�·Cº�~'�c­�j[\}tu^vbvnwx'i}fgt�^S�L��_�^�ZUa�ZS^vz.\}t�n�^r{���ææ��~*d�Z�xUt�j[mvZ'b�ÇOiOáð� Qé ëPi �°ÇXu«áð� �é ëPi �"t�j}kÞmvZ'b�ÈOiüt�j}k)È�uü bv_�h0Z�b`pIZG^vZS\If�ngZSm�_u��bvpIZ�q}y���_�^�t�x'fgZ ngj�� Qé tuj}k¶� �é ��d(pIZU^`Z�à�^`Z'��ZS^`m�bv_�bvpIZGm�b`tWb`Z*_������ � ��pIZUjd�Z���jI_Wd,b`p}tWb�� Qé nwm�t�k�Z'b`ZU^`��n�jInwm�bvnwx(��iIj}x'bvng_�j�_u�°Ç i È iÖ × t�j}kS� �é _��°Ç u È uÖ Ù ����pIZU^`Z'��_�^vZ��2� é oñ� é ëPinwm(iI\}\lZS^ hl_�iIj}k�ZCk�hsz�tufgf¨��\}tung^(ÙX�$��k�nga�ZU^`��ZSj}x'Z*_u�%bvpIZ�È Q ° mU���_Wd¯\IiIb�bvngjI�±{�·�·C~�t�j}k¹{e·Cº�~�bv_���Z'b`pIZU^C��d�ZGp}t�a�Z� é o·� é ëPi ;æÚ[¢õ�,è

��_Wdìn��%d�Z2xU_���hIn�j}Z���ZU���]tEìI�y�3ZS���]t.ï��It�j}k��3ZU���]t�àI��d�ZGxStuj�tufg^vZCt�k�z]\I^`_Wa�Z2tuj ë2{©��~�f�_Wd�ZU^h0_�i}j}k�_�j�bvpIZ�^`iIjIj}n�jI��b`n���Z�_u�<tufg��_�^vn�bvpI�]m�b`p}tWb _�jIf�zPi}m�ZGnwk�ZSt�f�ªsiIZU^`ngZSm��¤|�2sgs V�" ©,v��[�-|��0��ï zº��� � |�x � ���H� � �������X|`{�©£ª<�`��z:~«�0x ��z¬|�xr�.�æºu¶�¶¶�Vz:�0' � |�}�}l�0������z¬|�x�v�1��L�?�°�ê����å������}�x z:x7ó���� ó[|�}�z:�,'y~Û�0'-����������}�x �ï �Vz:�,'^� �l� vy}J� � �U�S��xH� � |�xZL��[�0x � ���µ�Vz:�,'�}l���M� � � ����|å��xx' |�xH�0���©bª<�`|�}J� � ����1Ñ�t{#���:� �,' �C!0v �?}�z¬�0�W�ê~«�ZY[�0�#��}J�#z¬�[�����l!0v �?}�z¬�0�#��x3��ºu¦l{��<¤4�u~W;ê·5ogvSo,·W�W��kG%±�,' �0x^�0'-���|������*�0��~��3��� � |�vyx �<|�{��êzº�O���'�g�l�����%����·F¡F1ÓGT Ô ¨�ö q�iI\I\0_�mvZGbvp}ZGbv_ub�tuf�m`tu��\IfgZ�x'_�iIjsb _u��tufg��_�^`n�bvpI�ø�ênwm$##��¡�z¶��ZU���]tCìI�-��ZU���]t]àI�}t�j}krb`pIZkIn�^`ZSx'b�\I^`_�kIi}x#b�fgZU���]tI�0d�Z��sj}_Wdãb`pIZct�f�f���\ltung^�ÙX�$��k�nga�ZU^`��ZSj}x'ZG_���t�f�f3bvpIZ�mvxUZUj}t�^vng_�m(tu�´bvZU^2tufgf"ªsiIZS^vngZSmt�^vZ2�}j}ngmvpIZSk�nwm(tWb ��_�m�b Ú%#e�l��Ý�_���hIn�j}n�jI��b`pIngm(�©t�x#b(d(n�bvp ��ZU���]tCï���d�ZG��jI_Wd¯bvp}tub

Ú%#e� ù í�îtÉ«ÊI{M� ió æ�� uó æ�è�ègè � �ó ~ ù ¶-è ºu� ud(p}ngx�p.ng��\}f�ngZSm(_�iI^�f�ZS����t}��(Æ�Ì Þ¯Ö�ñ&��ÍvØ É3Ì�ÐrѬÒ�É3Ó}Í�É�Î��_Wd¯d�Z�x'_�j}m�nwk�ZS^�b`pIZ�mvn¨b`i}tWb`n�_�j�d(p}ZU^`Z*b`pIZ�tufg��_�^vn�bvp}�ø�õ��t���ZCm�j}_�j���ngkIZStuf3ªsiIZS^vngZSmS�

e ZSxUt�f�f*bvpltWb7t>ªsiIZU^`z,��iIj}x'bvng_�j§�ænwm�nwk�ZCtuf�� n¨�åÿ�9 ø   �${tß æ�ñ Q {tß[~�~�§Pÿ�; ·W�uº[��_�^�t�f�fÑ��° mS��¢I_�^.tujnwk�ZCtuf�ªsiIZU^`zù�0��bvpIZ¹\I^`_�hltuhIngf�n�bez,bvp}tub\�L{¬ß ælñ Q {tßo~v~�á ¤�·ongm�h0Z'bed�ZUZSjå·W��¦>t�j}k¯Ú���¦¬��_�^.ZUa�ZS^vz?���d(p}ngx�p7nwmr�v^vZCt�mv_�j}t�hIf�z]i}jsh}ngt�m�ZCkI�I��­�j.bvpInwm�xSt�mvZ��}bvpIZcÙX�3��kIn�a�ZU^`��ZUjlx'Z2ngm*t]a�ZS^vzrj}ngxUZ���ZSt�mviI^`ZG��_�^(b`pIZ�`k�n�®0ZS^vZSj}x'ZCmv�2h0Z'bed�ZUZUj]m`x'ZSj}tu^`n�_smU�%ë _Wd�ZUa�ZU^<n¨b�kI_sZCm�j�° b�d�_�^`��a�ZS^vzcd�ZSf�f���_�^�a�ZS^vz�h}ngt�m�ZCk�kIngm�bv^`n�h}i�bvng_�j}mS�mvngj}x'Z�d(n¨b`pÞ\I^`_�h}t�hIngf�n�bvngZSm*x'fg_�mvZ�bv_�¶r_�^c·��0ZUa�ZUjÞtrbvngj�z.kIn¨®LZU^`ZUj}xUZcngj±b`pIZc\I^`_�hltuhIngf�n�bvngZSm2xUt�j±^`ZSmviIf¨b2n�jt�j.psi}��Z�ÙX�$��k�nga�ZU^`��ZSj}x'Z��"��pIZS^vZU��_�^`ZGd�ZGjIZSZSkPbv_�bv^`ZStub(jI_�j���nwk�ZSt�f3ª�i}ZU^`n�ZCm(k�n¨®LZU^`ZUjsb`f�z��

Y[ZPk�nga�ngkIZrbvp}ZrjI_�jI��nwk�ZSt�f�ªsiIZU^`ngZSm�ngjsbv_.bed�_Þx'fwt�m`mvZSmS��¢}_�^ct7j}_�j���ngkIZStuf�ª�i}ZU^`zÞ��iIjlx#bvng_�j^�L�<^vZCxUt�f�fb`p}tWb�» ¼ nwm2bvpIZ]ngjIpIZS^vZSjsb2hInwt�mG_��'�.��^`_�� ��ZU���]tÞ·���­��Xÿ » ¼ ÿÔ;·W�WÚ}�$d�Z�xUt�f�f�n�b�t��?�?~�z:��z¬�[�����|!?v �0}��zØ_�bvpIZS^vd(nwmvZ*d�Z2xStufgfH�]t����4��!?v �?}��W��YoZGk�ZUa�ZUfg_�\�k�n¨®LZU^`ZUjsb�bvZCx�pIjInwª�i}ZSm���_�^�bvp}ZSmvZGº�x'fwt�m`m�ZCm�_��"jI_�j���ngk�ZCtufªsiIZS^vngZSmS�& ]�ùSý�����þ�ý�+�Uý(' ²) ?�7T*' �) ú����T�þ�û�þ���T�ù��,+#�������`þ�ý�+sþ<� þ�'ÿ��������X?���CùSÿ�� ý�+�ú.-|ú����ú��Ê�þ±�T[Sû�ý�����þ<Åuü�þ�� þ����[���T�����ý�+�Uý��?��þ��sý�+�þ&ÅWüsþ`ÿ���´wü[���`ý�� ù���ú����T�þ�û�þ���T�ù���ý�+sþ&��ý`'ýeþ(ù�´/-�(

d10

Page 11: 0/1( 23 !# 4 576 8 90:=yangke/papers/lower_bound.pdf0/1( 2 3 !# 4 576 8 90:=? @

243�563�7 8:9<;>=�?@=BAC9EDGFIH4J(9EKL=B9EMY[Z��}^`m�b%t�mvmviI��Z�b`p}tWb<tufgf�jI_�j���ngk�ZCtuf�ªsiIZU^`n�ZCm�t�^vZ�t�x#b`i}tufgf�z�mvZU��n���nwk�ZSt�fE�"¢I_�^<t mvZU��n���nwk�ZSt�fsªsiIZS^vz*��iIj}x'bvng_�j�L�(n��ct�x'_�jlx'ZU\Ib�ñ Q �]t���ZSmµÿ 9 ø   �${tß æ�ñ Q {¬ßo~�~�§�ÿÑ� ·���º���d�Z±m`t�zwñ Q nwmPtuj �[�0x3|�}�~«��� � |�x � ���H�&{0|�}«�L�¸ hIjI_�^v�]tuf3xU_�j}xUZU\�b�m(tu^`ZGa�ZU^`z���ZUd��lm�ngj}x'Z�n��Zñ Q ngm(t�hIjI_�^v�]tuf���bvp}ZUj

ÿ ¹ Q ÿ ù ÿ ½ ·&o·v«°[¹ Q ÿ�á ÿ 9�ø�  �L{¬ß ælñ Q {tßo~v~�§ o·» ¼ ÿ ù ÿ 9�ø�  �L{¬àLæ�ñ Q {¬à0~v~�§�ÿ�o ÿ » ¼ ÿ ù ·ì è��_ub`ngxUZ�h�z��3ZU���]t[·��"d�Z�p}t�a�Z O �QºR i ¹LuQ ;�·�¤ç·S¶�¶s�u�}����p�i}mGbvp}ZU^`Z�t�^vZ]tubG��_smeb�ì�¶.t�hIjI_�^`�]tuf

xU_�j}xUZU\�b�m(��_�^�ZSt�x�p7m�ZS��n���ngk�ZCtuf%ª�i}ZU^`zr��_�^2���¯ºu¶�¶}�(��pIngm�ngm bvpIZ�^vZCt�mv_�j�d�Z�xUtufgf"mvi}x�p±ªsiIZS^vz�x'_�jlx'ZU\Ib`m�`m�ZS��n¨��ngkIZStufw�-�"bvp}ZUzPh0ZUplt�a�Z�tufg��_�m�b�fgng��ZGngkIZStuf"ª�i}ZU^`n�ZCmU��Z'�IxUZU\�b(��_�^(a�ZU^`z���ZUdõtuh}jI_�^`�]tuf3x'_�j}x'ZS\�b`mS�

��_Wd��"ngj}m�bvZCt�k¹_u�(��ZSt�m�i}^vngjI�.bvp}Z�tufgf���\}t�n�^�ÙX�3��kIn�a�ZU^`��ZUjlx'Z�_u� tufgf�b`pIZ�m`x'ZSj}tu^`ng_�mS��d�Z]Z'�Ix'fgi}k�Z]b`pIZm`x'ZSj}tu^`ng_�m*��_�^ct�hIjI_�^v�]tuf�xU_�j}xUZU\�b�m2��_�^�ZCt�x�p¹ªsiIZU^`z��r��pIZSj¹d�Z]��ZSt�m�i}^vZ�bvp}ZPtufgf¨��\}t�n�^�ÙX�$��k�nga�ZS^v��ZUj}xUZ��_�^�bvpIZ�^`ZU�]t�n�jIngjI�]m`x'ZUjltu^`n�_smU�%YoZ�_�h�b`t�n�j�bvp}ZG��_�fgf�_Wd(ngjI��f�ZS����t �¤|�2sgs V ¾¯ ©Hv��4� |F�?��ï zº�#� � |�x � ���H� � �����l�³|�{O©£ª<�`��z:~«�0x ��z¬|�x7�T�ãºu¶�¶��Vz:�0' � |�}�}J�?�����Mz¬|�x¸v�1��£�0�Î����X�#������}�x z:x�óS��� ó�|�}�z:�0'7~ �0'-���V������}�x ��ï×�Vz:�0'¶� ��� vy}J� � ���O��xH� � |�xZL±�4�?x � ���S�Vz:�,'S}J�0�M�-� � �V�é|³��x�' |�xH�0���©bª<�`|�}J� � ����%'��x3�U���:�P�0'-��!?v �?}�z¬���+� ~³��Y4�0����}J���?�?~�z:��z¬�[�����°!?v �0}�z¬�0�[1V�¬{�ºu¦l{��L¤x�u~V;ç·Zoñv�o�·W�W��k©%V�,' �0x�0'-�O��|������P�?��~5�H�g� � |�vyx �±|`{�� zº�����'�����F���<����·S¶�¶z1ÓGT Ô ¨�ö YoZ��l^`m�bcx'_�j}m�nwk�ZS^�bvpIZrmvng��\}f�ZPxSt�mvZ�bvp}tubM��ngm�k�Z'b`ZU^`��n�jInwm�bvnwx]tuj}k[jI_�j���t�kItu\Ibvnga�Z���nE� Z��g��b`pIZªsiIZS^vngZSm��õ�]t���ZSm(t�^vZ*�I��ZSk.t�\I^`n�_�^vn��<YoZ�t�mvmviI��Z2bvp}tub��õ�]tu��ZCm(t�bv_ub�tuf3_��b®�ªsiIZU^`n�ZCmU�<­��V® ù ����·S¶�¶I�d�Z(tu^`Z�t�f�^`ZSt�k�z�k�_�j}Z��Z��bvpIZS^vd(nwm�Z���mvn�j}xUZ�d�Z(t�m`m�i}��Z�tufgf�bvp}Z ª�i}ZU^`n�ZCm%t�^vZ�mvZU��n¨��nwk�ZSt�fE��b`pIZU^`Z(tu^`Z�tub<��_smebì�¶4®(xStuj}k�nwkItubvZ�xU_�j}xUZU\�b�m3b`p}tWb�tu^`Z�t�hIjI_�^`�]tuf���_�^<m�_���Z�_u��b`pIZ�ªsiIZS^vngZSmS��Y[Z�ZU�Ix'fgi}k�Z�tufgf�b`pIZSmvZ�t�hIjI_�^`�]tufxU_�j}xUZU\�b�mU�stuj}k�b`pIZU^`Z�t�^vZ tub�f�ZCt�m�b��±o�ì�¶[® ù º����4¡2^vZS�]tungjIn�j}��x'_�jlx'ZU\Ib`mS�%��pIZSz�xU_�^`^vZCm�\0_�jlk�b`_ctWb�fgZSt�mebº����4¡GmvxUZUj}t�^vng_�mS��Y[Z���ZCt�mviI^vZ�b`pIZ�t�f�f���\ltung^�ÙX�$��k�nga�ZU^`��ZSj}x'Z�_��0b`pIZSmvZ ^`ZU�]tungjIngjI�cm`x'ZSj}tu^`n�_smU��tuj}k]t�f�f�b`pIZt�j}tufgz�m�nwm���_�^�ngk�ZCtuf$ªsiIZU^`ngZSm�d�_�^v��pIZU^`Z���q�_�bvp}Z�b`_ub`t�f0m`tu��\IfgZGx'_�i}j�b�ngm�tub�fgZSt�mebG{e·���·�¡�~3°�º����4¡ ù ����·S¶�¶I���Z'��bS��d�Z(x'_�j}mvngk�ZS^%bvpIZ xSt�mvZ�b`p}tWb�b`pIZ��ængm<\I^`_�hltuhIngf�nwm�bvnwx�t�j}k�t�kItu\Ibvnga�Z��"­�j�bvpInwm�xUt�m�Z��WbvpIZS^vZ(xStujch0Z�]t�jsz�\0_ubvZSjsbvnwtufgf�z�\l_smvmvnghIf�Z�ª�i}ZU^`n�ZCmU�}t�j}k.d�ZcxUt�jIjI_ub*ZUfgn���ngj}tWb`Zctufgf3b`pIZctuh}jI_�^`�]tuf�xU_�j}xUZU\�b�m(��_�^*ZSt�x�pªsiIZS^vz���ë�_Wd�ZSa�ZU^C�3d�Zr�]t�zÞm�bvngf�f�t�m`m�iI��Z.��t�f�d�t�z�mG�]tu��ZCmGZ'�It�x'bvfgzµ®.ªsiIZU^`ngZSm�k�iI^`ngjI�7n¨b�m�ZU��ZCx'i�b`n�_�j3�¸ ��t�n�j3�Wn��,® ù ����·C¶�¶}�Ub`pIZ�fgZU���]t*ngm<tufg^`ZSt�kIz*\I^`_Wa�ZCk$�b��b`pIZU^`d(ngmvZ���d�Z���_�k�n���zGbvpIZ�tufg��_�^vn�bvp}���,m�fgng��psbvfgzmv_]b`p}tWb*tu�´bvZS^��]tu��ngjI�Ptufgf3b`pIZ�ªsiIZS^vngZSmS�z��d(^vn�bvZCm�k�_Wd(j.b`pIZ�j}t���ZCm _���tufgf3bvp}ZctuhIj}_�^`��t�f�x'_�j}x'ZS\�b`m bv_b`pIZ�ªsiIZU^`ngZSm��õp}t�a�Z*�]t�kIZ@Nu��Y[Z�k�ZSjI_ub`ZGbvpInwm(_�iIbv\Ii�b h�z.íPO��Z� _ub`ngxUZ2bvp}tub�íPO[nwm(t�^`t�j}k�_���aWtu^`ngt�hIf�Zb`p}tWb�xU_�j}mvngm�b`m2_���tWb���_�m�bÑì�¶4®rxU_�j}xUZU\�b�mU���3Z'bRQ�k�ZSjI_ub`Zcb`pIZ�j�iI�ch0ZU^G_u��bvpIZ�x'_�j}x'ZS\�b`m2b`p}tWb�tu^`Z�jI_ubt�hIjI_�^v�]tuf���_�^ct�jszo_u��bvp}ZPªsiIZU^`n�ZCmU��Y[Zrp}t�a�ZSQ ù �Uo4ì�¶[® ù ºu����¡I�PY[Z�t�fgmv_.^vZCª�i}n�^`Z.��bv_Þd(^vn�bvZkI_Wd(j¹bvpIZ�tufgf¨��\}tung^cÙX�3��k�nga�ZS^v��ZUj}xUZ]_u��bvp}Z�m`x'ZUjltu^`n�_sm�x'_�^v^`ZSmv\l_�j}k�ngjI��bv_[tufgf�x'_�j}x'ZS\�b`mcZ'�Ix'fgi}k�ngjI�7b`pIZt�hIjI_�^v�]tuf%_�j}ZSmS�3tuj}k[k�ZUj}_ubvZ�bvp}ngmGh�z�É|ÊUT1VXW�����pIZSj£É|ÊYT1VXWônwm�tufwm�_�tP^�tuj}kI_��-aWtu^`ngt�hIfgZ��O��ZU���]t)ìt�j}k\�3ZS���]t�à�meb`n�fgf3d�_�^`����_�^�É|ÊYT1VXW��}tujlkPd�ZGp}t�a�Zî°ÿ� SÉ|ÊYT1VXW�;æÚ%#£°@Q*§3áõ·[è {e·CÚ�~d(p}ZU^`ZZ#(nwm(bvp}Zcb`_ub`t�f"m`tu��\IfgZ�xU_�iIjsb�_��«�����Z'��b*d�Zch0_�i}j}kgÉ|Ê T1VXW ��^v_�� h0ZUfg_Wd����*a�ZU^�tufgfE����p}t�m�tujt�xUxUiI^`t�x'zS�2tujlk�xU_�j��0k�ZUj}xUZ����(q�_]bvp}ZU^`Z�Z'��ngm�b`m�tuj�¯�m�i}x�p�b`p}tWb*xU_�j}kIn¨b`n�_�jIZSk._�j�íPO^áã¯�����meb`n�fgf�plt�mt�j7t�xUxUiI^�t�x'z«�*tuj}k�x'_�j��lk�ZSj}x'Z�����¡�zS��ZU���]tCï���d�Z�plt�a�Zî�ÿ� ºÉ|ÊUT1VXW ù ¶-è º%Q u ÿ©íPO áã¯'§Páê·[è {e·S¦s~¡�z�\Ii�b�b`n�j}�±{e·SÚs~�tuj}k[{e·S¦s~�bv_���ZUbvpIZS^S��d�ZGp}t�a�Z# ù ¶ è ºUQ u

ÚYQ á[Q���·�¡ ù ����·C¶�¶ è {e·F¡�~

\ ]�ùSý�����þ�ý�+7UýP-§Ê���ù0YZ��ý�+sþ�ÅWü�þ`ÿ�� þ��<� ý(ú��ÊCþ��<?�7TU����$ý�+sþ�����T[�QT�'ýeþ���ù�����þ�û�ý���(��ù,- ����S��ùCú�û�ü�ýeþ ý�+sþ�T[����ý�ÿ���$sü�ý�� ù����ù�´3ý�+�þ�ÿeþ�û���� þ���´gùSÿ<����0ý�+sþ�����þl�7Uÿ�� ù���� ��7T#T�þ����QT�þ�YZ+[���J+«��?�7T4��T[Uýeþ5��ù��[��þ�û�ý��±'ÿeþ?$���ùSÿeú���:('Ä +[�Q��ú�ù�T[�®Þ���Uý�� ù��]úX����+uý'��ùSýû�ÿeþl��þ`ÿ���þ�ý�+sþ�þlÇX��� þ��[�l�cù�´G-5�4$�ü�ý�ý�+����Z���Z�sùSý���`ù����`þ`ÿ��³+sþvÿeþ�(dyd

Page 12: 0/1( 23 !# 4 576 8 90:=yangke/papers/lower_bound.pdf0/1( 2 3 !# 4 576 8 90:=? @

243�563�] ^_D/Aa`�J(9EKb=�9EM��_Wd�d�ZrZU��bvZUjlk¹bvpIZ�f�_Wd�ZU^chl_�iIj}k¹b`_Þtufg��_�^vn�bvpI�]mGb`p}tWb��]tu��Z]hlt�k¬ªsiIZS^vngZSm�t�m�d�ZUfgfE� e ZSxUt�f�f�bvp}tub�tªsiIZS^vzP��iIj}x'bvng_�j\�Pnwm h}t�k$�}n��5ÿ »|¼-ÿF�ç·W�WÚ}��¢I_�^�t�h}t�k��L��b`pIZ�\I^`_�h}t�hIngf�n�bezrb`p}tWb��${tß�ælñ Q {¬ßo~�~±áõ¤�·�xUtujh0Z�a�ZS^vz�hInwt�mvZSk7��_�^2t�fg_ub*_���b`t�^v��Z'bGx'_�jlx'ZU\Ib`mXñ Q ����p}Z�ÙX�3��k�nga�ZS^v��ZUj}xUZ�d�_�j3° b2d�_�^`�.a�ZU^`z�d�ZSf�f<iIj}kIZU^b`pInwm x'ng^`xUiI�]meb�tuj}xUZ��

ë�_Wd�ZSa�ZS^S��ngj�b`iIn�bvnga�ZUfgz���t�pIng��p}f�z�h}ngt�m�ZCkcªsiIZU^`z�d�_�j3° b�hlZ�a�ZS^vzGZUè]xUn�ZSjsb�mvngj}x'Z(t*hIngt�m�ZCk�ªsiIZS^vz�xStu^`^vngZSmfgZSm`m(ngj���_�^`�]tWb`n�_�jPb`p}tuj7tuj.iIj�hInwt�mvZSk�_�jIZ���Y[Zcmvp}tufgf$\I^`_Wa�Z2bvpInwm(ngjsbviIn�bvng_�j7nwm x'_�^v^`ZSx'b�b`_rm�_���Z�Z'��bvZSj}k$�­�j��©t�x#bS�}d�Z�mvpI_Wd¯pI_Wd¯bv_�Z'èrxUn�ZSj�b`f�z�m�ng�ci}fgtubvZ�t�hIngt�m�ZCk�ªsiIZS^vzPi}m�ngjI�]tuj.iIj�hInwt�mvZSk�_�j}Z��

¢%ng^`m�bS��d�Z�k�ZU�}jIZ�t�aWtu^`ngt�j}x'Z2_u�%bvpIZ�p}_�jIZCmeb�q}y���_�^�t�xUf�Z���j}t���ZUfgzrbvp}Z�m�ZS��n���pI_�jIZCmeb�q}y���_�^�t�xUf�ZCmU��������� R ��� ÷ � � ��s� � � ���� QSR����E� TWVIX�� �¾�4 o!?v �?}�� �é|^�¹mvZU��n���pI_�jIZSm�b�q}y���_�^�t�xUf�Z�{0|�} � |�x � �é�3��ñzº�¶�³�-��z:}�{t�Hæ�¢ê~&%5��' �0}J�O��� ëu(ôì�o�·4æ#¤�·�íC* ì[o�·4æ#¤�·�íåzº�¶����|�|�������x�{�vyx � �Mz¬|�xF% � ���:�����µ�0'-�.ªsiIZU^`z��i}j}x#b`n�_�j-%���x3�å¢ zº�\�U� |F��z:�Mz:�F� z:x ���Mó��?}¶�V}�z:�M�é�?xwz:x�iIj}tu^`z�% � ���:�������,' �]m`tu��\IfgZ�x'_�iIjsb©1i35' ��|�}l� � ���|�vy���3vy�¬���� ��z:}2{0IGúMæl¢uúw~[1�cO�?}J�<¢uú zº���x\z:x ���éó�}J���,}l��xH�[|�~ ����}�z¬�[�0�����0����zº�t{���z:x7óEî°ÿ�  ¢uúed ¢ã§3áê·³��xH�IGú3á iN*f�O N fQºR i �${tß Q æ�ñ<{tß Q ~v~�% ��'-�?}J����� � '�ß Q zº���#}J��xH�4|�~ ����}�z¬�4�?����z:xH�4��� �0x3�4�?x �M��� � '-|��?�0x�� �l� |�}J��z:x7ó��|�õx1�³å� � ���:�,¢uú��,' ��t�x#b`i}tuf3m`tu��\IfgZ�x'_�i}j�bG1�¬{��0'-�³��zº���M}�z¬�0vy�Mz¬|�x�|`{��0'-�«� � �Mv ���£�?��~5�H��� � |�vyx,�<zº�Oz:xH�[�é� �0x3�4�?x �5|`{��0'-� � '-|�z � �U|`{��0'-� � |�x � �é�3�'ñ�%�'���?���U�0'7zº�O|�}J� � ����zº�c_�h}f�nga�n�_�i}m�1

­�jsb`iIn¨b`n�a�ZUfgz���t±mvZU��n���pI_�jIZSm�b�q}y���_�^�t�xUf�Z�h0ZUp}t�a�ZSm�t�f���_smebcfgng��ZPt�j�pI_�jIZCmeb�q}y���_�^`t�x'fgZ��"Z'�Ix'ZS\�bcb`p}tWbn�b�ngm2tufgfg_Wd�ZCk.bv_.k�ZSxU^vZCt�mvZ�bvp}Z�m`tu��\IfgZ�xU_�iIjsbC��ë _Wd�ZUa�ZS^ b`pIZ�_�^`t�x'fgZ��cilmebG^vZS\l_�^�b*bvpIZ]t�x#bviltuf<mvt���\}f�ZxU_�iIjsb n�b i}mvZSmS�Z�*h�a�ng_�i}mvf�zrt�j.pI_�jIZCmeb�q}y���_�^�t�xUf�Z*ngm�tufwm�_�t]m�ZS��n¨��pI_�j}ZSm�b qly���_�^`t�x'fgZ��

Y[Z�jI_�bvnwx'Z2bvp}tub(bvpIZ�fg_Wd�ZU^�hl_�iIj}kIm(��_�^(pI_�jIZSm�b�q}y���_�^`t�x'fgZSm�tufwm�_�d�_�^`��m���_�^(_�hIfgngasng_�ilm�mvZU��n���p}_�jIZCmebqly���_�^`t�x'fgZSmS�b��ZU���]tCì�t�j}k\�3ZS���]t.ï�tu^`ZGiIj}tW®LZSx'bvZCk�mvngj}x'ZGb`pIZUz�tu^`Z*jI_�b�x'_�j}x'ZS^vjIZCk�t�hl_�i�b _�^�t�xUf�ZCmU���ZU���]t�àcngm�m�bvngf�fLb`^vi}Z��sbvp}t�jI��m�b`_cb`pIZ2_�hIfgn�a�ng_�i}mvjIZCmvmS�%��p}Z*_�jIf�zrkIn¨®LZU^`ZUj}xUZ2t�jr_�h}f�nga�n�_�i}m�mvZU��n���p}_�jIZCmebqly���_�^`t�x'fgZ���t���ZCm nwm ��^`_���bvp}Z�ªsiIZU^`z���iIj}x'bvng_�j}mS�LjI_ub*bvpIZ�t�x#b`i}tuf<m`tu��\IfgZ�x'_�iIjsbS�Ltuj}kÞk�ZSxU^vZCt�mvn�jI��b`pIZm`tu��\IfgZ.x'_�i}j�b�d(ngf�f�jI_�b�ngj}x'^`ZSt�m�ZPbvpIZ7t�f�f���\ltung^�ÙX�$��k�nga�ZS^v��ZUj}xUZ�����pIZU^`Z�t�^vZ�k�n�®0ZS^vZSj�b]ngj}m�b`tujsb`ngtubvng_�j}m_���m�ZS��n¨��pI_�j}ZSm�b�q}y���_�^�t�x'fgZSmcm�ngj}x'ZPbvpIZ�_�^�t�xUf�Z]p}t�m�b`pIZr��^`ZUZCk�_�� bv_[x�pI_�_�mvZ]bvp}Z�k�nwmeb`^vnghIi�b`n�_�j¬_u�¢ ú �ë�_Wd�ZSa�ZS^S�y�3ZS����t�·C¶�nwm�bv^`iIZG��_�^O��x �]ngj}m�b`t�j�b`ngtubvng_�j._u�<tuj�_�hIfgngasng_�ilm(m�ZS��n���pI_�jIZCmeb�q}y���_�^�t�xUf�Z��

��_Wd¯d�Z�tu^`Z2^`ZSt�k�z�bv_]\}^v_Wa�Z2��pIZS_�^`ZU�-·��ÓGT Ô ¨�ö {�_��%��pIZS_�^`ZU�â·�~ó nga�ZSj[t.fgZSt�^vj}n�jI�.tufg��_�^vn�bvp}�o���"d�Z]mvp}tufgf�x'_�j}meb`^vilx#bct�jIZUd�tufg��_�^vn�bvp}�D��ú<b`p}tWb�p}t�m�tufg��_�m�b2b`pIZ

m`tu��Zct�xUxUiI^`t�x'z��lx'_�j��lk�ZSj}x'Z��lt�j}k±x'_���\}tu^�tuhIfgZGZ'èrx'ngZUjlx'z7t�mW����¢}iI^�b`pIZU^`��_�^`Z�����ú"_�jIfgz��]t���ZSm�m�ZS��n��nwk�ZCtuf�ªsiIZS^vngZSmS��q�_ ��ZU���]to·C¶7xUt�joh0ZPtu\}\If�ngZSkob`_ñ� ú ��d(pInwx�p¹n�j¹b`iI^`j[��n�a�ZSm�t.fg_Wd�ZS^Ghl_�iIj}k[��_�^Gb`pIZ^`iIjIj}n�jI��b`n���Z�_������

Y[Z��}^`m�b�Z'��bvZSj}k�b`pIZ�kI_��]tungjùëáh�z�_�jIZPhIn�b���d�Z.k�ZU�}jIZ[gëêá ëi( ì[o�·[æ�¤�·�ís�ÞY[Z.d(^vn�bvZ�ZSt�x�pZSf�ZS��ZUjsb n�j gëìt�m�{tà£æihW~#�ld(pIZU^`Z�àB/�ë*��d(pIn�fgZjh�/µì[o�·[æ�¤�·4í*nwm�bvpIZ�ZU��bvZUjlk�ZSk�hIn�bS�

Y[Z�Z'��b`ZUj}k.tufgfLbvp}Z�x'_�jlx'ZU\Ib`m�bv_�b`pIZ�jIZSdãk�_���t�n�j�h�z�k�ZU�}jIngjI��jIZUdõx'_�j}x'ZS\�b`mkgñ i æ?ègègè�æ:gñ����gñ Q {tàLæ#¤�·C~Zálgñ Q {¬àLæ�o�·C~Zá§ñ Q {¬à0~�èY[Z�t�fgmv_GZ'��bvZSj}k�bvpIZ*k�ngm�bv^`nghIi�bvng_�j«õmvi}x�p�bvp}tub�n¨b�ngm�bvpIZ(iIj}n¨��_�^v��k�nwmeb`^vnghIi�b`n�_�j�_Wa�ZU^<b`pIZ Z'��b`ZUj}k�ZCk�hIn¨bC�gõ±{tà£æ?o�·�~Zámgõ±{¬àLæ�¤�·�~'á õÞ{tà0~`�uº-è

��p}Z�jIZUdçtufg��_�^`n�bvpI� �Wú$d�_�^`��m�d(n�bvp�b`pIZ�Z'��bvZSj}k�ZCk�xU_�j}xUZU\�b�xUfgt�mvm[gï á/ì gñ i æ gñ u æ?ègègè�æ gñ � ís��­�b ngm ZSt�mvzb`_�a�ZU^`n¨��z�bvpltWb�bvpIZ2\I^`_�hIfgZU��_u�3fgZSt�^vj}n�jI�ngïánwm�Z'�It�x'bvfgz�b`pIZ2_�^`n���n�j}t�fI\I^`_�hIfgZU��_���f�ZCtu^`jIngjI��ï���mvngj}x'Z*_�jIZxStuj.m�ng��\IfgzPng��jI_�^vZ*bvpIZ�ZU��bvZUjlk�ZSk�hIn�bS�±�*h�a�ng_�i}mvf�z��sbvpIZcq}y���k�ng��ZUj}mvn�_�j�_�� gï�nwm �]t�m�d�ZSf�f��

��p}Z]jIZUdtufg��_�^vn�bvp}� ��ú�ngmcx'_�jlmeb`^vi}x'bvZCk[t�mG��_�fgfg_Wd m?���Wú�h0ZUp}t�a�ZSm�ZU�It�x#b`f�zof�ng��Z.��Z'�Ix'ZS\�b���_�^�b`pIZªsiIZS^vngZSmS��¢}_�^ ZSa�ZU^`zPªsiIZS^vz��õ�]t���ZSm(bv_�bvp}Z�pI_�jIZCmeb*qly���_�^`t�x'fgZ��¾��ú"m�ng�ciIfwtWb`ZSm(n�b h�z�ªsiIZS^vz�ngjI�]t]m�ZS��n��p}_�jIZCmeb*q}y���_�^�t�xUf�Z��

q�iI\I\0_�mvZÑ�ç�]tu��ZSm�t�ªsiIZS^vz±{t�Hæ�¢ê~�tuj}krbvpIZG^`ZU\Ifgz]ngm+I���Y[Z�m�pI_Wd¯pI_Wd7��ú3^vZS\Ifgt�x'ZCm�n�b(hszP��t���n�jI�t.ªsiIZS^vz¬{t�2ú�æl¢.oS~2tuj}koZSm�bvng�]tWbvZCmÑI���d(pIZS^vZU¢.o#á�º4¢ °/p´fg_����%q*¤ã·���Y[Zrm�p}t�f�f�k�ZCmvxU^vngh0Z�b`pIZrªsiIZU^`z��i}j}x#b`n�_�j¶�¾úE��bvpIZ�mvZU��n���p}_�jIZCmeb(_�^�t�xUf�ZÑ��ú3i}m�ZCmU�ltuj}k�pI_WdÏ�Wú$ZSm�bvng�]tWb`ZSm+I��

d��

Page 13: 0/1( 23 !# 4 576 8 90:=yangke/papers/lower_bound.pdf0/1( 2 3 !# 4 576 8 90:=? @

r ��� �ts-¦�� T©§£¨ ¦�� X�R ���w�¾ú��p}Z�jIZSd¯ªsiIZU^`z�xU_�j}xUZU\�b��2úld�_�^`��m�n�jrbvpIZ2Z'��bvZSj}k�ZCkrk�_��]t�n�j gëg(�ì[o�·[æ�¤�·�ís�utuj}krd�Z*d(^vn�bvZ*n¨b�t�m�¾ú�{tàLæuh�æ`çI~#�Id(p}ZU^`Z�à¸/åë¯tuj}kvh�nwm�bvp}Z�Z'��bvZSj}k�ZSk�hIn�bS��­�b nwm k�ZU�}jIZCk�t�m���_�fgf�_Wd m��w ­��b�Pnwm(m�ZS��n¨��ngkIZStuf���bvp}ZUj

� ú {¬àLæ�o�·4æ`çI~Záù�L{¬àLæ`çI~�t�j}kO� ú {tà£æ�¤�·4æJçI~Záù�${tà£æ`çI~�Øw ­��b�Pnwm�h}t�k�tujlkT»|¼M�ã·W�WÚI�sb`pIZUj� ú {¬àLæ�o�·4æ`çI~Vá �L{¬àLæ`çI~<t�j}k�� ú {tà£æ�¤�·4æJçI~ á o�·�Øw ­��b�Pnwm�h}t�k�tujlkT» ¼ dão�·W�WÚI��bvp}ZUj� ú {¬àLæ�o�·4æ`çI~Vá �L{¬àLæ`çI~<t�j}k�� ú {tà£æ�¤�·4æJçI~ áç¤�·4è

e _�iI��pIf�zrmv\0ZStu��ngjI�}���¾ú0hlZSp}t�a�ZCm�ZU�It�x#b`f�z]fgng��Z��_�jPp}t�f¨�%_u��n�b`m�ngjI\IiIb`m�{�d(p}ZUj�bvpIZ2Z'��bvZSj}k�ZCkPhIn�b hnwmXo�·�~#�ItujlkP_�j�b`pIZ�_ub`pIZU^(pltuf��e��n¨b nwm t�x'_�j}meb�tujsbS�IxU^vZCtWb`n�jI��tujæ�`tu^vbvn��lx'nwtufLhInwt�m`�I�¤|�2sgs V � è35' �M!?v �0}���{�vyx � �Mz¬|�xS�2ú�zº���?�0~#z:��z¬�4�����S1ÓGT Ô ¨�ö �3ZUbS° m(x'_���\IiIbvZGbvp}Z�n�jIp}ZU^`ZUjsb(hIngt�m�» ¼ f _��£�¾úE�I\lZS^��3ZS���]t�·��¢%ng^`m�b d�ZGxU_�j}mvnwk�ZU^�b`pIZ�xUt�m�Z*bvp}tub&�rngm�tufg^vZCt�k�zrmvZU��n���nwk�ZSt�f��9yxø   � ú {tà£æih�æ gñ Q {tà£æihW~�~�§ á ·

ºtz 9 ø   � ú {tà£æ?o�·4æ gñ Q {¬àLæ�o�·C~�~�§�¤�9 ø   � ú {tà£æ�¤�·4æ gñ Q {¬àLæ#¤�·C~�~�§|{á » ¼ ¤£½ ·&o·v«°Z¹ Q

q�_T»|¼ f ái»|¼)/æ �o�·��uÚ-æS·��WÚu§��ltuj}k\�¾ú%ngm2mvZU��n¨��nwk�ZSt�fE��q�ng��n�fwtu^`f�z��Ld(pIZUj���nwm�hlt�kÞt�j}k¸»|¼��á·��uÚI�» ¼ f áå{æ» ¼ o,·C~`�uºE/¬ �o�·��uÚ-æv¶u§æØ�d(pIZSj\�Pnwm h}t�k�t�j}kB» ¼ d/o�·W�WÚI�F» ¼ f áå{æ» ¼ ¤ì·C~`�uºE/¬  ¶-æS·��WÚu§����p�i}m&�2úLnwm tufgd�t�z�m�mvZU��n¨��nwk�ZSt�fE�r ��� � Q �2sg � � ���� QSR������ TWVIXK� �Y[Z�kIZSm`x'^`n�h0Z�bvp}Z�mvZU��n¨��pI_�jIZSm�b"q}y���_�^�t�x'fgZÎ��ú�i}mvZSmS��­�jsbviIn�bvnga�ZSf�z����2ú�ngm�f�ng��ZV�2d(n¨b`pct�k}k�ZSk.�`tu^vbvn��lx'nwtufh}ngt�mv�}��¡�z�t�kIk�ngjI��bvpInwm h}ngt�mU�y�¾ú3h0ZSxU_���ZSm�m�ZS��n���ngk�ZCtuf���¡�i�b��¾ú3t�fgmv_]hlZCx'_���ZCm(fgZSm`m(Z'èrx'ngZUjsb b`p}tuj�L�*mvngj}x'Z[tuh0_�i�b�p}tuf���_u�cn�b`m�ngjI\Ii�b�m�t�^vZojI_ub,��i}mvZ'��i}fg�}�á��pIZS^vZU��_�^`Z±d�ZÞjIZSZSkæb`_>ngj}x'^`ZSt�m�Z7b`pIZm`tu��\IfgZ]x'_�iIjsb*b`_��]t���Z�m�iI^`Z��2ú<��Z'b`m2ZSjI_�iI��p¯�vi}m�ZU��iIfw�PngjI\Ii�b�mU����pIZ]t�x'bvi}t�f�x'_�j}meb`^vilx#bvng_�jongmGth}n¨b�xU_���\IfgngxStWbvZCk$��*j.t�ª�i}ZU^`z±{:�¾ú¬æ�¢.o'~#�IbvpIZ2_�^�t�xUf�Z2^vZS\lZCtWb`ZSk�fgzrk�^�t�d m�ngj}k�ZS\lZSj}k�ZUjsb(Z'�It���\}f�ZCm2{¬à Q æih Q ~�t�xUxU_�^�k�n�j}�b`_ gõ7� ¸ j�ZU�Itu��\IfgZG{¬à Q æih Q ~"nwm�tOv7�?��{�vy�,�lî���~��3���U��n��Eh Q áWo�·KØu_ub`pIZU^`d(nwm�Z�n¨b�nwm±v7�0�?���0�����<��pIZ�_�^�t�xUf�Z��ZUZS\}m�kI^`t�d(ngjI��^�tuj}kI_��áZ'�Itu��\IfgZSm�iIjsbvngf0n�b�p}t�m�Z'�It�x'bvfgz«¢ ilm�ZU��iIflZU�Itu��\IfgZSmS��_�^�n�b�p}t�m�m`tu��\IfgZSk¢ o b`n���ZCmU��¢%ngj}tufgf�zrbvpIZG_�^�t�xUf�Z2i}mvZSm�tufgf$n�b`m�Z'�It���\}f�ZCm2{©hl_�bvp�bvp}Z2ilm�ZU��iIf3_�j}ZSm�tuj}k�i}mvZUfgZSm`m�_�jIZCm`~b`_rx'_���\}i�bvZ2bvp}Z�t�a�ZU^�tu��Z�_��£�¾ú©�Y[Z�x'_�����ZUjsb"bvp}tub"b`pIngm<mvZU��n���pI_�jIZSm�b%q}y���_�^�t�xUf�Z�ngm"n�jlk�ZUZCk�_�hIfgngasng_�ilmU�"­�j��©t�x'bS��b`pIZ�t�x#bviltuf�mvt���\}f�ZxU_�iIjsb2ngm2t]^�tuj}k�_�� aWt�^vnwtuhIfgZ�b`p}tWb2_�jIfgz�kIZU\0ZUj}kIm*_�j±bvpIZ�\I^v_�h}tuh}n�fgn¨bez�bvpltWb2tr^`t�j}k�_���Z'�It���\}f�Z{¬à Q æih Q ~$nwm"t(ilm�ZU��iIf�_�jIZ�� ¸ xSx'_�^�k�ngjI�(b`_(bvpIZ�k�nwmeb`^vnghIi�b`n�_�j gõ7��bvp}ngm"\I^`_�h}t�hIn�fgn�bez�nwm�·W�uº��Cngj}k�ZU\0ZUjlk�ZUjsb_��"b`pIZGb`t�^v��Z'b(x'_�j}x'ZS\�b`mS�r~} QSR �s V�R µ� Ä Iq�iI\I\0_�mvZGbvpIZ�^`ZU\Ifgz]��^`_��b`pIZ�mvZU��n¨��pI_�jIZSm�b(qly���_�^`t�x'fgZ*nwm�{0IGúéæl¢uúg~#��Y[Z�m�p}_Wd¯pI_Wd���ú3xU_���\Ii�b`ZSmt�aWtufgiIZ«¯��3t�j}k±ilm�ZCm�¯�b`_�mvng�ciIfwtWb`Z�I��$bvp}Z�^`ZU\}f�z���^`_��³bvp}Z�p}_�jIZCmeb�q}y���_�^`t�x'fgZ�����pIZ�aWtufgiIZ³¯�nwmkIZ'�}jIZCk.t�m���_�fgfg_Wd m?�

¯�á������� �����iN ¢uú-°[I©ú � �b�_� �$���U��� {�� �U�X��r ØiN {�¢uú °[IGú-o ¢ ¤�¢uúw~ � �b�_� ���1�1���L� ��» ¼ �¯·��uÚ¾ØiN {�¢uú °[IGús¤ ¢ o^¢uúw~ � �b�_� ���1�1���L� ��» ¼ dÆo�·��uÚ7è

d�Ë

Page 14: 0/1( 23 !# 4 576 8 90:=yangke/papers/lower_bound.pdf0/1( 2 3 !# 4 576 8 90:=? @

Y[Z�\I^`_Wa�Z*bvp}tub¯�nwm�a�ZS^vzPxUf�_sm�Z*bv_CI��¤|�2sgs V �= 35' �X�������Mzº���Mz � ��� ��zº���é��x � �#�l�?�M�'�l�?x�¯���x3��Iåzº�O���±~«|F���b¢ì�u�[u�1ÓGT Ô ¨�ö ¢%n�^�mebC�}d�Z�\I^`_Wa�ZGb`p}tWb�ngj7b`pIZcxUt�m�Z#¢uúGdã¢.ou�H¯�t�j}kTI�p}t�a�Z�nwk�ZUjsb`ngxStuf"kIngm�bv^`n�h}i�bvng_�j}mS���_ub`ngxUZ�n��<¢uúCd ¢.oW�Lb`pIZUjobvp}Z�mvZU��n���p}_�jIZCmeb�q}y���_�^�t�x'fgZcplt�m2Z'�It�x'bvfgz�¢1i}mvZ'��iIf�ZU�Itu��\IfgZSmGtuj}k¢ ú o§¢ i}mvZUfgZSm`mc_�jIZSmS��­�b�nwm�ZSt�m�z¹b`_oa�ZU^`n¨��z[bvpltWb�n�j|bvpInwm�xUt�m�Z���¯�ngm�b`pIZ�t�a�ZU^�tu��Zr_u� b`pIZå¢ilm�ZU��iIf<Z'�Itu��\IfgZSm�{©mvn�jlx'Z��¾ú%_�i�b`\Ii�b�m2xU_�j}m�b`t�jsb`m _�j7bvp}Z�i}mvZUfgZSm`m*Z'�Itu��\IfgZSmS�}b`pIZSmvZ�x'_�jlmeb�tujsb`m*xUtujh0Z�ZSt�mvngf�z¹^`ZU��_Wa�ZCk[��^v_�� IGú´~#� �*j>i}m�ZU��iIf�Z'�Itu��\IfgZSmS� �¾ú�h0ZUp}t�a�ZSm�ngkIZUjsbvnwxUt�f�fgz�t�mO�0��q�_ ¯Pplt�mnwk�ZSj�b`ngxStuf�kIngm�bv^`n�h}i�bvng_�j.t�m+I�n�j�b`pIngm(xSt�mvZ����p}ZU^`Z'��_�^`Z��Cb`pIZ�m�b`tubvnwmeb`ngxStuf�k�ngm�b`t�j}x'Z�hlZUbed�ZSZUj�¯�t�j}k�I(nwm"tub"��_�m�b�b`pIZ�\}^v_�h}tuhIngfgn¨bez*bvp}tubV¢ áÆ¢.ou�¡�i�b5¢ áÆ¢.o���ZSt�j}m�bvpltWb�bvpIZ2�}^�m�b(º[¢ °�p´fg_����Uq�Z'�Itu��\IfgZSm�xU_�jsb`t�n�j�f�ZCmvm�b`p}tujå¢ i}mvZ'��iIf$_�jIZSmS�Y[Z���^v_�iI\*bvpIZCm�Z�ZU�Itu��\IfgZSm3ngjsbv_5¢ ��^`_�i}\}mU�SZSt�x�p�x'_�jsb�tungjIn�j}�(º�p´fg_����Uq�ZU��t���\If�ZCmU�"¢I_�^%tuj�z���^v_�iI\3�b`pIZP\}^v_�h}tuhIngfgn¨bezÞbvp}tub�n�b�k�_�ZSmvj3° b�xU_�jsb`t�n�j�tuj�z[i}mvZ'��iIf�Z'�Itu��\IfgZrnwmctubc��_�m�b�º2ë3u%��� �u� �u� d³·W�W��uu�mvngj}x'Z�t�^�tuj}k�_��Z'�Itu��\IfgZGngm i}m�ZU��iIf3d(n�bvp.\I^`_�h}t�hIngf�n�bez7·���º���q�_�bvpIZ�\}^v_�h}tuhIngfgn¨bez�b`p}tWb _�jIZG_u��b`pIZ��^v_�iI\}m�k�_�ZSmvj3° b�x'_�j�b�tungjrtuj�z�i}m�ZU��iIf0Z'�Itu��\IfgZ�nwm�tub���_�m�b<¢ °'·��u�[uu�<¡�i�b�n��3ZSt�x�p]��^v_�iI\rx'_�jsb`tungj}mtub%fgZSt�meb<_�j}Z�i}mvZ'��i}f�Z'�Itu��\IfgZ��Wd�Z�plt�a�Z�tub%fgZSt�mebV¢ i}mvZ'��iIf�ZU�Itu��\IfgZSmS�"��pIZS^vZU��_�^`Z��CbvpIZ�\I^`_�hltuhIngf�n�bezb`p}tWb(b`pIZU^`Z�tu^`Z2f�ZCmvm�b`p}tuj ¢ ilm�ZU��iIf3Z'�It���\}f�ZCm�ngm tub(��_smeb¢ì�u�[uu�

��_Wd���\IiIb�bvngjI�7ZSa�ZU^`zsbvpIngjI��bv_���ZUbvpIZS^���d�Z�p}t�a�Z]x'_�j}m�bv^`i}x#b`ZSk¹tuj¹tufg��_�^vn�bvpI� ��ú�b`p}tWbcmvng�ciIfwtWb`ZSm��ilm�ngjI�c_�jIfgz�mvZU��n���nwk�ZSt�flªsiIZS^vngZSmS�%¢}_�^�ZSt�x�p]ªsiIZS^vz.{:�3æl¢ê~'���WúlxStujPmvn���iIfwtWbvZ�n¨b�iI\]bv_�tujrZS^v^`_�^�_��£¢ì�W��uu���Z'b�#�hlZPbvpIZ�bv_�b`t�f�m`tu��\IfgZ�xU_�iIjsb�_������[­�� # ù �l��bvpIZPbvpIZS_�^`ZU� nwm�t�f�^`ZSt�k�zÞb`^vi}Z��^��b`pIZU^`d(nwm�Z]b`pIZb`_ub�tuf�ZU^`^v_�^���ú��]tu��ZSm�n�j,m�ng�ci}fgtubvngjI�x� ngm�tWb���_�m�b*#v�u�[u�dâ·��u�}��t�j}k¹b`psilm��Wú�p}t�m�tuj>t�xUxUiI^`t�x'z^�t�j}k7x'_�j��lk�ZSj}x'ZM�(¤¯·W�W�l��¡�z\�3ZU���]t7·C¶I��b`pIZ�b`_ub`t�f�m`tu��\IfgZcx'_�iIjsb _u�l��ú"ngm*tWb�fgZSt�meb����Gì�¶I�(q�ngj}x'Z��Wú^`ZU\}fgt�x'ZSm�t�ªsiIZU^`z�_u��m`tu��\IfgZ*x'_�iIjsb±¢ h�z�t�ªsiIZU^`z�_���mvt���\If�Z*x'_�i}j�b(º4¢ °Yp´fg_����Uq%¤¬·J;æÚ[¢éfg_����l��b`pIZb`_ub�tuf�m`tu��\IfgZ�x'_�i}j�b(_��t�õnwm(tWb fgZSt�meb ����·S¶�¶s�I{©Ú�fg_��<�s~�áô����{©Ú�¶�¶�fg_�����~#�243�563�2 �y9<;[D/KL�:M�*i}^�^vZCm�i}f¨b�nwm�j�° b�kIn�^`ZSx'bvfgz�x'_���\}tu^�tuhIfgZ�d(n¨b`p�bvp}tub�ngj.  £s¶�¶�§�����pIZ(f�_Wd�ZU^�h0_�i}j}k�n�j±  £s¶�¶C§lnwm<��_�^�t�m�fgng��psbvfgzkIn¨®LZU^`ZUjsb q}y¯��_�k�ZSf�{´bvp}ZP�`qly���h}t�m�ZCk]Ü ¸ Ý,tufg��_�^vn�bvpI�]m`��~'��tujlk]n¨b�k�_�ZSmvj3° b�k�ng^`ZSx#b�bv^�tuj}mvfwtWbvZ bv_�t�f�_Wd�ZU^h0_�i}j}krngjP_�iI^���_�k�ZSfE��¢Ii}^�b`pIZU^`��_�^`Z���£�t�x���mv_�j]\}^v_Wa�ZSk�bvp}tub�fg_Wd�ZU^�h0_�i}j}kr_�jIf�z���_�^�fgZSt�^vjIngjI��Ü ¸5e ­e��µ��i}j}x#b`n�_�j}mU�(d(p}n�fgZ±_�i}^rf�_Wd�ZU^]h0_�i}j}k,pI_�fwkIm]��_�^Pt¹hI^`_�t�k�ZU^rxUfgt�mvmS��jltu��ZUfgz���bvp}ZÞx'fwt�m`m]_u�.��i}jIn¨��_�^v��fgzxU_�^`^vZSfgtubvZCkI�*xU_�j}xUZU\�b�mU�Z�*j�bvpIZ(_�bvpIZS^�p}tujlk$��pInwm�fg_Wd�ZS^�hl_�iIj}k�nwm<bvng��psbvZS^�����_�^�Ü ¸e ­e��µô��iIj}x'bvng_�j}m�_Wa�ZU^n,hIn�b`mS��pIZ�\I^`_Wa�ZCk7b`p}tWbct�j¹�G{�º�mI~*^vi}jIjIngjI�.bvng��Z�nwm�jIZSZSk�ZCk$��d(p}n�fgZ�_�iI^�^`ZSmviIf�bG_�jIfgz±��nga�ZCmG�G{�º�m}��n�~#�ë�_Wd�ZSa�ZS^S�s_�iI^�fg_Wd�ZS^�h0_�i}j}kPnwm�meb`^v_�jI�cZSjI_�i}��prb`_]m�ZS\}tu^�tWb`Z bvp}Z�qly���fgZSt�^vjIngjI�c��^v_���bvpIZ�Ü ¸ Ý���f�ZCtu^`jIn�j}�_��<Ü ¸e ­e��µê��iIj}x'bvng_�j}m d(n¨b`p.t�pIng��p¹{e·W�uº�o,·��7p�q-r ss{¬n�~�~�jI_�ngmvZG^`tubvZ��It�m�ngj¹  £s¶�¶C§��

­�b2ngm*tufwm�_Pn�jsbvZS^vZCmeb`n�j}�]bv_PxU_���\}t�^vZ�_�iI^�^`ZSmviIf�b�bv_rbvp}tub*ngj>  µG¶I·#§�� Y[Zcng��\I^v_Wa�ZSk�bvp}Zcfg_Wd�ZS^ hl_�iIj}k��^`_��é�G{ ½ �s~ bv_7�G{©���%fg_�����~#����ZUa�ZS^�b`pIZUfgZSm`mS�}b`pIZ�^`ZSmviIf�b2ngj|  µ2¶}·#§�ngm2t|�vx'_�jsbvngjsi}_�i}m`��f�_Wd�ZU^*hl_�iIj}kon�jb`p}tWb�n�b�mvpI_Wd m�tcx'_�jsbvngjsi}_�i}m�bv^�t�k�ZU��_�®�h0Z'bed�ZUZSj]bvpIZ2j�iI�ch0ZU^�_���ª�i}ZU^`n�ZCm�jIZSZSk�ZCkPt�j}k�bvp}Z2t�k�aWtujsb`t���Z�tfgZSt�^vj}n�jI�rt�f���_�^`n¨b`pI��plt�mS���*i}^�^`ZSmviIf¨bC�}_�j.bvpIZ�_�bvpIZS^�p}t�j}k$�0ngm*t]m�ngjI��f�Z�fg_Wd�ZU^(h0_�iIj}k7��_�^ b`pIZ�^`iIjIjIngjI�b`n���Z�n��<t]xUZU^vb`t�n�j.t�xSx'iI^�t�xUz�t�j}k.x'_�j��lk�ZSj}x'ZGnwm(jIZUZCk�ZSk3�� ]_^\Ú��SÚ Ã(À�½.Á b¬ÀWdðÚ ¿De�À�Â7½.Ágf.�â¿4 7Ä#¾%¿VÕ�¿6¡ m�À�½.Ã&Ú�n�¾ m_p0ÕXÖbÖbÚ�Ö��p}Z�mvZSx'_�j}k¹fg_Wd�ZS^�hl_�iIj}k¹nwm���_�^�xUfgt�mvmvZSm�_�� x'_�jlx'ZU\Ib`m�b`p}tWb�tu^`ZPtu^`hIn�bv^�tu^`n�fgzÞxU_�^`^vZSfgtubvZSk3�.��p}ngmcf�_Wd�ZU^h0_�i}j}k�ngm t���t�n�j}m�b(tuj.t�k�a�ZU^�mvt�^vnwtuf$q}y���_�^�t�x'fgZ��¤�Æ�Å Þ¯Ö�Ë�Ì%ËIÍeÖ�ñ*ιÌ�ñ�Ø£¢ôÉe¤Gñ�ÍeË�Í�Ö�ñ�ÎY[Zcngjsbv^`_�k�i}x'Z�mv_���Z�jI_�b`tubvng_�j}m*tuj}k.k�ZU�}jIn�bvng_�j}m bv_rh0Z�i}mvZSk.ngj.bvpInwm2m�ZCx#bvng_�j��}��_�m�b _u��d(pInwx�p±tu^`Z�tufwm�_ilm�ZCk�ngj�  µG¶I·#§��

¢}_�^�t�fgZStu^`jIngjI�.tufg��_�^`n�bvpI�D�c��d�Z�kIZUjI_�bvZ]n�b`mU�4���F��x ���?ó���n�j[f�ZCtu^`jIngjI�7tPb�tu^`��ZUbGxU_�j}xUZU\�bOñ Q b`_�h0Zb`pIZc\}^v_�h}tuhIngfgn¨bez�n¨b2�]tu��ZCm�trxU_�^`^vZCx#b�\}^vZCk�ngx'bvng_�j7_�j±tr^�tuj}k�_�� ZU�Itu��\IfgZ���n�j�i}m�bvpIZ�\I^`_�h}t�hIn�fgn�bezPb`p}tWb

d <

Page 15: 0/1( 23 !# 4 576 8 90:=yangke/papers/lower_bound.pdf0/1( 2 3 !# 4 576 8 90:=? @

n�b(�]tu��ZCm�tujPngj}xU_�^`^vZCx#b�\}^vZCk�ngx'bvng_�j3����p}Z*\I^`_�hltuhIngf�n�bez]nwm�b�tu��ZUjP_Wa�ZU^�bvpIZG^�tuj}kI_���jIZSm`m���^v_��ø�çt�j}k]b`pIZ^�tujlk�_���ZU�Itu��\IfgZ�����pIZ�t�kIa�t�jsb`tu��Z*nwm t�fgmv_���jI_Wd(j.t�m��`x'_�^v^`ZUfwtWb`n�_�j}��ngj�fgn�bvZU^�tWb`iI^`Z��

��_ub`ngxUZ�b`p}tWb(tW�´b`ZU^���t���n�jI��tufgf0bvpIZGªsiIZU^`n�ZCmU�sb`pIZ2t�f���_�^`n¨b`pI��ngm�^`ZSt�kIz�b`_��]t���Z*tc\I^`ZSk�nwx#b`n�_�jP_�j�tuj�zZU�Itu��\IfgZUà��±Y[Z�xStuj¬k�ZCmvxU^vngh0Z]bvpIZ�meb�tWb`Zr_u�(b`pIngm�tufg��_�^vn�bvp}�éh�zon�b`m � '-��}l� � �é�?}�zº����z � {�vyx � �Mz¬|�xl�<d(pIngx�pnwmckIZ'�}jIZCk[bv_±h0ZPt7^`ZSt�f¨��aWtufgiIZSkÞ��iIj}x'bvng_�j¬_Wa�ZU^Gb`pIZPm`tu��Zrk�_��]t�n�j3�v¥:¦ � ë *ò Qo�·[æ�¤�·'§��"mvi}x�p¹b`p}tWb¥:¦�{tàL~&áãºX°Kî�ÿ�  �õ_�i�b`\Ii�b`m2¤�·*_�j�à}§,oæ·��ld(pIZU^`Z�b`pIZ�\I^`_�h}t�hIngf�n�bezPnwm�b`t���ZSj7_Wa�ZU^�b`pIZ�^�tuj}kI_���jIZSm`m��ilm�ZCm(tuj}k�bvp}Z�^`t�j}k�_���jIZCmvm���^`_��b`pIZ�_�^�t�xUf�ZCmU�

­�b nwm�jI_�b p}tu^�krb`_]m�ZSZ*b`p}tWb n��%bvpIZGb�tu^`��Z'b xU_�j}xUZU\�b nwm§�ñ%��bvpIZSj�bvpIZ�t�k�aWtujsb`t���Z2_u�Î�õngm ö �ñbæ�¥:¦V÷#�q�n�j}xUZ(d�Z t�^vZ kIZStufgngjI�Gd(n¨b`prt�x'fwt�m`m<_u�$x'_�jlx'ZU\Ib`m<b`p}tWb�t�^vZ(t�^vhIn�bv^�tu^`ngf�zcxU_�^`^vZSfgtubvZCk$�Wd�Z(j}ZUZSk�tG��ZSt�j}m

b`_rk�ZSm`x'^`nghlZ2bvp}Z7�vx'_�^v^`ZUfwtWb`n�_�j}m`��tu��_�j}��b`pIZ�x'_�j}x'ZS\�b`mS��������� R ��� �i¨M T�T � �©V�R ���?Ú V�RUT �©��4�£�0�VïêáðìFñ i æ�ñ u æ�è�ègègè�æ�ñ%ª�í��l�«� � |�x � �é�3� � ��������1�������x'_�^v^`ZUfwtW�b`n�_�j.��tubv^`n¨�5%'�4�?xH|��é�����0��«e¬ûzº����¯�(å¯S~³����}�zQîS��v � 'å�,' ���G«<¬Q � á ö ñ Q æ�ñ � ÷[1Ý�fgZSt�^vfgz�«e¬ônwm t]m�ZS��n¨��\l_sm�n�bvnga�Z�k�ZU�}jIn�bvZ��]tubv^`n¨�$�}t�j}k�n¨b�plt�mG·�° m(_�j�b`pIZ�k�nwtu��_�j}t�fE��YôpIZSj.bvpIZS^vZ�nwm

j}_rkItujI��ZU^�_u�<x'_�j���i}mvn�_�j3�Id�Z2_���n¨b(b`pIZ�m�i}\lZS^`m`x'^`n�\Ib<ï����_Wd¯d�Z�tu^`Z2^`ZSt�k�z�bv_rm�b`tubvZ2bvp}ZGbvpIZS_�^`ZU�.���� �2 T �2s =ð©Hv��4� |F�?�ïÛzº��� � |�x � ���H� � �g�F����|�{ � ��}J��z:x3����z:�M�#¯��Vz:�0' � |�}�}J�0�g���Mz¬|�x�~³����}�zQîZ««1��L�?�Îv i ùv u ù °?°�°$vz�����X�0'-���0zQó��0x,�F����v �0��|`{�««1V�£�0���ê���O�³�g�l��}�x z:x7óS��� ó[|�}�z:�,'y~ �0'-���'������}�x-�<ï �Vz:�0'å�4���F��x ���?ó��

���&�����F���V­�v7��z:x7óå��x,���4���F�?}��?��}�z¬���V©£ª<�`|�}l� � ���«|�{³�0}�}l|�}O��|��g�0}J��x � �Ñ#°1��¬{W� ~«�ZY[����®x!?v �0}�z¬�0�&%±�0'-�?x^�'�' ����� ó þ iú QSR i v Q ù ¯&°S��n�jPì�­ u æ$# u í�è {e·�ì�~¤�ÆEí ­ È�Ô�ËIÈ ÉÐÑÞÓIÉ-À Í�Ö�Ò�άÇ�É�ÏlÈ�ñ*Í�®�Ò É¯¢ôÖ�É�Î>ñ�Ö�Ë°­ Ö�Ó²±¡�ZU��_�^`Zcd�Z�t�x#bviltufgf�z7\I^`_Wa�Z�bvpIZ�bvp}ZU_�^`ZU�.�Ld�Zc�}^�m�b2\I^`_Wa�ngkIZ�mv_���ZcngjsbviIn�bvng_�j[d(p�z7\I^vZSa�n�_�i}m b`ZSx�pIj}ngªsiIZkI_sZCm�j�° b d�_�^`�]pIZU^`Z��

��p}Z�b`ZSx�pIj}ngªsiIZ�_u�*bvpIZ7tufgf���\}t�n�^�ÙX�$��k�nga�ZS^v��ZUj}xUZr��^`_�� bvp}Z�\}^vZSasng_�ilm�mvZSx'bvng_�j,k�_�ZSmvj3° b]d�_�^`�¹a�ZU^`zd�ZUfgf<pIZU^`Z���ë�ZU^`Z�nwmGtuj±ngjsbviIn�bvnga�Z]t�^v��iI��ZUjsbS�G­�j±b`pIZ]xUt�m�Zcbvp}tub2ZCt�x�p±\}t�n�^G_���x'_�j}x'ZS\�b`m*p}t�m*b`pIZ�m`tu��ZxU_�^`^vZSfgtubvng_�j3��n¨bPmvi�èrx'ZCmcb`_�iI\I\0ZU^]h0_�iIjlk>pI_Wd �ci}x�pá�vkIn¨®LZU^`ZUj}xUZS�o_�jIZ7mvn�j}��fgZ.ªsiIZS^vz��]t���ZSmS�,­�j,tmvZUjlm�Z���jI_�ª�i}ZU^`zc��iIjlx#bvng_�jPngm�m�ng��j}n¨�lxStujsbvfgzc��_�^vZ ZUèrx'ngZUjsb�b`p}tujr_�bvpIZS^`mS��mvngj}x'Z(b`pIZ*xU_�j}xUZU\�b�m�t�^vZ mv_�^vb�_���viIjIn���_�^`�]�I�%­�j�b`pIZ xUt�m�Z�b`p}tWb�b`pIZ x'_�j}x'ZS\�b`m�t�^vZ(t�^vhIn�bv^�tu^`ngf�z�xU_�^`^vZSfgtubvZSk3�Wn¨b�nwm�ªsiIn�bvZ(\0_�m`m�nghIfgZ�bvp}tub�bvpIZS^vZZU��ngm�b`m(mv_���ZGª�i}ZU^`z���iIj}x#b`n�_�jPb`p}tWb(�]tu��ZSm�t�fgt�^v��Z*k�n�®0ZS^vZSj}x'Z2d(pIngf�ZG_�bvpIZS^`m�k�_�j3° bC��­�j�_�bvpIZS^�d�_�^`kImS�sd�Zj}_cfg_�jI��ZU^�p}t�a�Z(b`pIZ2iIjIn���_�^`��n�bez]tu��_�j}��bvpIZGx'_�j}x'ZS\�b`m�tujlkrm�_���Z*ªsiIZU^`ngZSm�xUtujPhlZ2�ci}x�pP��_�^vZ*Z'èrx'ngZUjsbb`p}tuj|_ub`pIZU^�mU�¬q�_[tÞmvn�j}��fgZPiI\I\0ZU^�h0_�iIjlk¬_�j|_�jIZ�ªsiIZU^`z�k�_�ZSmvj3° b�jIZCx'ZSm`m`tu^`n�fgz[m`xUt�f�Z�d�ZSf�f�b`_ot±��_�_�ki}\I\lZS^ h0_�iIj}k�_�j�t]mvZSªsiIZSj}x'ZG_u�<ªsiIZU^`n�ZCmU�

ë�ZU^`Z�ngm�tuj.Z'�Itu��\IfgZ4��f�ZUb�ëôh0Z�b`pIZcmvZ'b _u��tufgf*nL��hIn�b*meb`^vngjI�smU�It�j}k\õ³hlZ�b`pIZ�iIjIn���_�^`�³k�ngm�bv^`nghIi�bvng_�j_Wa�ZU^±ë*�V��Z'b'ï ò h0Z b`pIZ �©t���n�fgz�_���º m ��iIj}x'bvng_�j}m�bvp}tub�t�^vZ Ü ¸e ­e��µì��iIj}x'bvng_�j}m�n��$bvpIZ��3ZSt�meb�q�n���jIn¨�0xUtujsb¡�n�bP{¬�%q�¡(~2_u��bvpIZ]ngjI\Ii�b�nwm�¶.tujlk[t�^vZ�x'_�j}m�b`tujsb�¤�·�n¨��bvp}ZU�"q�¡«ngm�·��U�3Z'b�ï i h0Z�bvp}Z��©tu��n�fgz±_��(º4m��i}j}x#b`n�_�j}mGbvpltWb�tu^`Z]Ü ¸5e ­e��µ���iIj}x'bvng_�j}m�n¨��bvpIZU�%q�¡ê_u��bvpIZ]ngjI\IiIb�ngm�¶.tujlkot�^vZ�x'_�j}meb�tujsb³o�·�n���b`pIZ�%q�¡ìnwmG·��Z��Z'b�bvp}Z�x'_�jlx'ZU\Ib�x'fwt�m`m<ïhlZGb`pIZ�iIjIng_�j._u�bï ò tuj}k¶ï i �­�b�nwm�a�ZU^`z7ZSt�mvz7b`_.bvZUfgf�xU_�j}xUZU\�b�mGn�j^ï ò tujlkoxU_�j}xUZU\�b�m�n�j^ï i t�\}tu^vbS��mvngj}x'Z�bvp}ZUzÞplt�a�Z]k�n�®0ZS^vZSj}x'Zh}ngt�m�ZCmU����pIZS^vZU��_�^`Z��ub`pIZU^`Z2Z'��ngm�b`m�t�a�ZU^`z�ZUèrx'ngZUjsb�ªsiIZS^vz.{´³eilmeb t�mv����_�^�bvpIZ2hInwt�m�_u�$bvp}Z�b�tu^`��Z'b�x'_�j}x'ZS\�b�~b`p}tWb�xStujcfgZSt�^vjc_�jIZ�hIn�b�t�hl_�i�b%bvpIZ�b`t�^v��Z'b<x'_�jlx'ZU\IbS��t�j}k�b`pIZU^`Z�ZU��ngm�b`m<t*f�ZCtu^`jIn�j}�*tufg��_�^vn�bvp}�ãb`p}tWb��]tu��ZSmt�mvn�j}��fgZGªsiIZS^vz�tuj}k�f�ZCtu^`j}m�bvpIZGb�tu^`��ZUb(xU_�j}xUZU\�b(d(n�bvp7t�xSx'iI^�t�xUz]Ús��¦l�<­��%ZSa�ZU^`zrªsiIZU^`z]d�ZU^`ZGt�m�Z'èrx'ngZUjsbt�m�b`pIngm�_�jIZ���b`pIZUj]_�jIfgz³h�{¬n�~�ªsiIZU^`ngZSm�d�_�iIfwk�p}t�a�Z(hlZSZUj]jIZSZSk�ZCk�bv_�fgZSt�^vj�b`pIZ(b`t�^v��Z'b���i}j}x#b`n�_�j]Z'�It�x'bvfgz����p}ngmcngm�t�fgmv_.bvp}ZrhlZCmeb�f�_Wd�ZU^�h0_�iIjlk¹d�ZPxStuj¹pI_�\lZ]��_�^�n���d�Z]i}mvZ]bvp}Z]bvZCx�pIjInwª�i}Z]��^v_��âb`pIZr\I^`ZUa�ng_�i}mmvZSx'bvng_�j3�

ë�_Wd�ZSa�ZS^S�Wtuj�z�q}yìtufg��_�^`n�bvpI�õjIZSZSkIm%Z'��\0_�jIZSjsbvnwtufsbvng��Z�bv_2f�ZCtu^`j�bvp}Z�b�tu^`��ZUb%x'_�j}x'ZS\�b�d(n¨b`p�t�xUxUiI^`t�x'zp}n���pIZU^(b`p}tujxï��Wà}����pInwm(nwm(b`^viIZ�m�ngj}x'Zcn�j7p}t�a�ngjI�]tuj±t�xUx'i}^`t�x'zrpIng��p}ZU^(b`p}tujxï��Wà�ng��\}f�ngZSm�f�ZCtu^`jIn�j}��b`pIZi}jIngªsiIZ�b�tu^`��ZUb2��i}j}x#b`n�_�j3�"d(p}ngx�p¹ng��\}f�ngZSm�fgZSt�^vj}n�jI�7t�\}t�^vn�bez7��iIj}x'bvng_�jì  £�¶�¶�§��P��pInwm�m�p}t�^v\¹x'_�jsbv^�t�m�bGnwm

d� 

Page 16: 0/1( 23 !# 4 576 8 90:=yangke/papers/lower_bound.pdf0/1( 2 3 !# 4 576 8 90:=? @

kIiIZcb`_rb`pIZc�©t�x#b2bvp}tubGt�f¨b`pI_�i}��p7b`pIZ�ªsiIZS^vz�bvpltWb�k�ngm�bvngjI��iIngmvpIZCm5ï ò ��^v_�� ï i nwm*a�ZU^`z�ZUèrx'ngZUjsbS�$_�bvpIZS^`mt�^vZGjI_�bS�¤�Æ�� ÑÞÓIÖ�ÖZ�rÖ'�PÇoÈ�É3Ö�ÓIÉ£Ý íY[Z�\I^`_Wa�Z*bvpIZ���p}ZU_�^`ZU��ºcp}ZU^`Z���¡�i�b(d�ZG�l^`m�b meb�tWbvZ�t�fgZU���]t�bvp}tub ngm�a�ZU^`zPm�ng��n�fwtu^�b`_«�3ZU���]t.·��¤|�2sgs V ¾q Å£|�}³�0���?}���!?v �0}���{�vyx � ��z¬|�xS�${tà£æ`çI~&%<�,' �0}l�#�lî[zº���¬�#�S��� � ��|�}Iµ ¼ ��x3��� � |�x ���é��x �l» ¼ ��v � '�0'-���<ÿgÿ µ ¼ ÿ�ÿ¾;ã·¶��xH� 9 ø   �${tàLæ�ñ Q {¬à0~v~�§Lá>»|¼(¤ ö µ�¼[æ�ñ Q ÷ {e·Gïu~{0|�}��?�F�?}�� � |�x � ���H�Vñ Q 1Y[Z�xUt�f�fLb`pIZ�a�ZCx#b`_�^Pµ°¼�bvpIZ � '-��}J� � �é�?}�zº����z � ��� � ��|�}c_u�b�0�ÓGT Ô ¨�ö YoZ�ZSm`m�ZSj�b`ngt�f�fgz���_�f�fg_Wd|bvpIZ�m`tu��Z(_�i�bvfgn�j}Z*t�m�n�j±  ¡�¢%£�¤2¥u¦�§��V�3ZUb(¶¬h0Z bvp}Z�m�i}h}m�\lt�x'Z mv\}t�jIjIZSkh�z�b`pIZ�x'_�jlx'ZU\Ib`m<ñ i æ�ñ u æ�è�ègè�ègælñ ª � ��Z'b�ì@· i æi· u æ?ègè�ègæ�· ª í*h0Z�tujP_�^�b`pI_�j}_�^`��t�f}h}t�m�nwm�n�j¸¶���Y[Z*^`ZU�stu^�k]ZSt�x�p· Q t�m%t(��iIj}x'bvng_�jc��^v_��ûëÞbv_2^vZCtufwmU�L��Z'��b<d�Z�Z'��bvZSj}k�b`pIZSmvZ���i}j}x#b`n�_�j}m"bv_�_Wa�ZU^�bvpIZ�k�_��]t�n�j#ë�(�ì[o�·[æ�¤�·4íh�z�k�Z'�}j}n�jI� g· Q {tà£æ`çI~ á · Q {¬à0~�Øg¹ Q {tà£æ`çI~ á · Q {¬à0~Z°0ç3èY[Z�tufwmv_�ZU��bvZUjlkPb`pIZ�k�nwmeb`^vnghIi�b`n�_�j�õ b`_�_Wa�ZU^5ë7(�ì�o�·4æ#¤�·�í�h�z�kIZ'�}jIngjI�gõ±{¬àLæ?o�·�~Zá gõÞ{tàLæ#¤�·C~ZáÆõ±{tàL~�è

­�b�ngm�ZSt�mvz�bv_cx�pIZCx���b`p}tWb�ì g· Q æ g¹ Q í Q ��_�^v�]m�tuj]_�^vbvp}_�jI_�^v�]tuf�hlt�mvngm<��_�^���iIjlx#bvng_�jlm�_Wa�ZS^±ëH(Sì[o�·[æ�¤�·�ís���p}ZUj.d�Z�k�ZCx'_���\0_�mvZ2bvpIZ�ªsiIZS^vzr��iIj}x#b`n�_�j��L{¬àLæ`çI~�t�m

�L{¬àLæ`çI~Zá ú ��º � g· Q {¬àLæ`çI~�¤ ú � ¹ � g¹ � {¬àLæ`çI~0èq�n�j}xUZSÿ�ÿ �*ÿ�ÿ4á�·���d�ZGp}t�a�Z O � º u� ¤ O � ¹Lu� á�·����p}ZUj 9 ø   �L{¬ß ælñ Q {tßo~v~�§ á ú ��º �Z9 ø   g·F��{tß æ�ñ Q {¬ßo~�~�§�¤ ú � ¹��Z9 ø   g¹ �s{tß æ�ñ Q {¬ßo~�~�§

á ú � º �Z9 ø   ·F��{tßo~�§�¤�9 ø   ú � ¹��»·���{tß[~ °�ñ Q {tßo~�§Y[Z�mvZ'b�» ¼ á O � º � 9�ø�  · � {tß[~�§�tujlk¸µ ¼ {¬à0~'á O � ¹ � · � {¬à0~#�0tuj}kPbvp}ZUj.d�ZGp}t�a�Z9 ø   �L{¬àLælñ Q {¬à0~�~�§PáÏ»|¼�¤ ö µ°¼7æ�ñ Q ÷0è��Z'��b d�Z2\}^v_Wa�Z�b`p}tWb�ÿgÿ µ ¼ ÿgÿ¾;ã·���q�ngj}xUZR· � ° m tu^`Z*_�^�b`pI_�j}_�^`��t�fE��d�ZGp}t�a�Z

ÿ�ÿ µ°¼-ÿgÿ u á ú � ¹ u� ÿgÿ ·F��ÿgÿ u á ú � ¹ u� ;ã·[è��_Wd¯d�Z�tu^`Z2^`ZSt�k�z���_�^(\}^v_Wa�ngjI�cb`pIZGbvp}ZU_�^`ZU�.�

d

à

Page 17: 0/1( 23 !# 4 576 8 90:=yangke/papers/lower_bound.pdf0/1( 2 3 !# 4 576 8 90:=? @

ÓGT Ô ¨�ö {�_��%��pIZS_�^`ZU� º�~Ý�_�j}mvngk�ZS^ t�\}tu^vbvnwx'iIfwtu^ t�k�a�ZS^`m`tu^`nwtuf$q}y���_�^`t�x'fgZ b`p}tWb*kI_sZCm�j�° b�xU_�����n¨b(b`_�t�j�zrb`t�^v��Z'b(x'_�j}x'ZS\�bS�±�*j

ZCt�x�p]ªsiIZU^`z��ubvpInwm�_�^�t�xUf�Z�^`Z'b`iI^vjlm�t�m�\0ZSxUngt�fIaWtufgiIZ�bvp}tub�ngm�x'_�jlm�nwmeb`ZUjsb�d(n¨b`prtGfgt�^v��Z�j�iI��hlZS^�_u�$x'_�j}x'ZS\�b`mS�¸ m�tP^`ZSmviIf�bS�3t�m��]t�f�f�j�iI��hlZS^2_��c��ngj}xU_�j}mvngm�bvZSjsb`�PxU_�j}xUZU\�b�mGd(n�fgf<hlZ¹�vZUfgn���ngj}tWb`ZSkI�}��q�_�f�_�jI��t�m*bvpIZS^vZt�^vZc��t�j�z.xU_�j}xUZU\�b�m ^`ZU�]tungjIngjI�Þ{©jI_ub2ZUfgn���ngj}tWb`ZSk}~'�lb`pIZ�f�ZCtu^`jIn�j}�Ptufg��_�^vn�bvpI� d�_�j3° b*h0Z�tuh}f�Zcbv_�kIZSx'nwk�Zd(p}ngx�p±^`ZU�]t�n�jIngjI��x'_�jlx'ZU\Ib*nwm b`pIZcb`^vi}Z�b`t�^v��Z'b*xU_�j}xUZU\�bC�2��p}ZU^`Z'��_�^`Z�b`pIZcfgZSt�^vjIngjI�Pt�f���_�^`n¨b`pI��d(n�fgf<jI_ubfgZSt�^vj�bvp}ZGb`tu^`��ZUb x'_�jlx'ZU\Ib�d(n�bvp.pIng��p7t�xUx'i}^`t�x'zrtujlkPpIng��p7xU_�j��lkIZUj}xUZ��

Y[Z x'_�j}mvngk�ZS^%bvpIZ(_�^`t�x'fgZ�b`p}tWb�_�j�tGªsiIZS^vzP{t�Hæ$#}~%^vZUbviI^`j}ml»|¼*t�m�k�Z'�ljIZSk�ngj�{�·©ïu~'�%��p}ngm�^`ZSmviIf�b�d�_�iIfgkh0Z]aWtufgngko��_�^�tufgf�x'_�j}x'ZS\�b`m2b`p}tWb�p}t�a�Z�ngjIjIZS^�\I^`_�k�i}x#b�m�tWb�fgZSt�meb�#[d(n¨b`pyµ�¼�� ¸ fgf�_ub`pIZU^�xU_�j}xUZU\�b�m�d(n�fgfh0Z�ZUfgng��ngj}tubvZSk3� ¸ �´bvZS^�tufgfLbvp}Z�ª�i}ZU^`n�ZCm�t�^vZG�]t�kIZ���d�ZGxU_�j}mvnwk�ZU^�b`pIZG^vZS��t�n�j}n�jI�]xU_�j}xUZU\�b�m�bvp}tub p}t�a�ZSj3° bh0ZUZSj]ZUfgn���ngj}tWb`ZSk�z�Z'bS�%Y[Z�x'fwtung�«b`p}tWb�ZCt�x�p�_u�Lb`pIZU�áp}t�m�tuj�n�j}jIZU^�\}^v_�k�i}x'b�_u�$tWb�f�ZCt�m�bZ­2d(n�bvp�¥:¦��ub`pIZx�pltu^�t�x#b`ZU^`ngm�bvnwx���i}j}x#b`n�_�jo_��V������pInwmGngm2h0ZSxStui}mvZ�ZSt�x�po_u��b`pIZ]^`ZU�]tungjIngjI��xU_�j}xUZU\�b�xUt�jÞh0Z�bvpIZ�b�tu^`��Z'bxU_�j}xUZU\�b�m�ngj}x'Z�n¨b�ngm�x'_�jlm�nwmeb`ZUjsb�d(n�bvpPt�f�f}bvpIZ2ª�i}ZU^`n�ZCmU�%¡�ZCxUt�i}m�Z��¯p}t�m�t�k�aWt�j�b�tu��Z±­���bvp}Z�ngjIjIZU^�\I^`_�kIi}x#b_��"b`pIZ�^`ZU�]tungjIngjI��xU_�j}xUZU\�b�m tujlk¼¥ ¦ ��i}m�b hlZ�tub�fgZSt�meb&­��

Y[Zrk�ZSjI_ub`Z�bvpIZU®�ªsiIZU^`n�ZCmG�]t�k�Z�h�zx��h�zå� i æ�� u æ�è�ègègæ�� ó �%tuj}k¹k�ZSjI_ub`Z�bvpIZSn�^�xU_�^`^vZCm�\0_�j}kIn�jI�.x�p}t�^��t�x#b`ZU^`ngm�bvnwx�a�ZCx#b`_�^ h�z ¹ i æ ¹ u æ�è�ègè�æ ¹ ó �(Y[Z�k�ZU�}jIZcbvpIZ�a�ZSx'bv_�^ ¹ ó þ i bv_�hlZ,¥ ¦ �*��pIZUj±d�Z�p}t�a�Z�t]b`_ub`t�f�_��®�¤|·*a�ZSx#b`_�^�mU� ¹ i æ ¹ u æ�è�ègè�æ ¹ ó þ i �ItufgfL_u��j}_�^`��tub���_smebG·���¢I_�^(tuj�z]x'_�jlx'ZU\Ib&ñ%��n��"n�b�nwm�ZUfgn���ngj}tWb`ZSk�n�j�_�jIZ_���b`pIZrªsiIZU^`n�ZCmU�Lb`pIZUj¹n�b�p}t�mGt�jongjIjIZS^�\I^v_�k�ilx#b�_u��tWb�f�ZCt�m�bX­Pd(n�bvp¹_�jIZ�_���bvp}Z�a�ZSx'bv_�^�m ¹ i è ¹ u æ�è�ègègè�æ ¹ ó �­���ñ[nwm j}_ub*ZSf�ng��n�jltWbvZCk$�lbvpIZSj±n¨b2ngm2t]\0_�m`m�nghIfgZ�b�tu^`��Z'b�xU_�j}xUZU\�bGtuj}k�b`p�i}m�plt�m�t�j7n�j}jIZU^2\I^`_�kIi}x#b�_���tWbfgZSt�meb�­rd(n�bvp±b`pIZca�ZSx'bv_�^ ¹ ó þ i �G��pIZU^`Z'��_�^vZ��0t�f�f<x'_�j}x'ZS\�b`m*p}t�a�Zcn�jIj}ZU^2\I^v_�k�ilx#b`m*_u��tWb*fgZSt�meb2��n�jPì�­yæ�#3íd(n�bvp._�jIZ�_u�"bvpIZ�a�ZSx#b`_�^�m�n�j ¹ i æ ¹ u æ�è�ègègæ ¹ ó þ i ���Z'b�ÈçhlZ�bvpIZGm�i}h}m�\lt�x'Z*m�\}t�jIjIZCk�hsz�b`pIZ�a�ZSx#b`_�^�m ¹ i æ ¹ u æ�è�ègègæ ¹ ó þ i ����pIZSjrZUa�ZU^`z�xStuj}k�nwkItubvZ�xU_�j}xUZU\�bñ%��d(pIZUj,\I^`_%³eZSx'bvZCk�bv_·È���plt�m�tÞfgZUj}�ubvp|_u�*tub�fgZSt�meb³­omvngj}x'Z�n¨b]p}t�m�t�j>ngjIjIZS^]\I^v_�k�ilx#b�_u�*tub�fgZSt�meb��ngj*ì�­yæ�#3í�d(n�bvp¹tri}jIn¨b�a�ZSx#b`_�^*n�j·È��GYoZ�i}mvZ³ñ<½ìbv_.k�ZUj}_ubvZ�bvp}Z�\I^`_%³eZCx#b`n�_�j±_u�±ñ[ngjsbv_.m�i}h}m�\lt�x'ZEÈ��¸ j}k�d�Z�kIZ'�}jIZO�¬bv_�h0Z

� á ú¾ ý ¬ ÿ�ÿ ñ ½ ÿgÿ u è�*h�a�ng_�i}mvf�z���d�ZGp}t�a�Z�� ù ¯&°S��ngjPì�­�u�æ�#-u4í��

�*jæb`pIZÞ_�bvpIZS^Pp}t�j}k$��mvngj}x'ZxÈ×ngm�t>mviIh}mv\}t�xUZ7_u�ck�ng��ZUj}mvn�_�j¯tWb���_smeb¹{¬®�¤�·C~#� bvpIZo��tu��n���iI�\0_�m`mvn�hIfgZGaWtufgiIZG_u�b�>ngm�h0_�i}j}k�ZSk�h�z]bvp}ZGmviI��_���b`pIZ]{¬®(¤,·C~�fwtu^`��ZSm�b�ZUng��ZUj�aWtufgiIZCm�_��G«�����pIngm�\}^v_�hIf�ZS�_���tu\I\I^`_���n��]tubvngjI��a�ZSx'bv_�^`m�ngj7pIng��p±k�ng��ZUj}mvn�_�j7h�z�a�ZSx#b`_�^�m�n�j7fg_Wd�ZU^ k�ng��ZUj}mvn�_�j}m nwm�xStuj.h0Zcm�_�f�a�ZSk�h�zb`pIZrq�ngjI��iIfwtu^2ß�tufgiIZ³��ZCx'_���\0_�mvn�bvng_�j|{�q�ß�G~#�"m�_���ZUbvng��ZSmGtufwm�_���jI_Wd(jot�m b`pIZ]Ü�^`n�j}xUn�\ltuf�Ý�_���\l_�jIZUjsb¸ j}tufgz�m�nwm�{©Ü�Ý ¸ ~'�}��pIZ�^`ZSt�kIZU^�m�t�^vZ2^`Z'��ZU^`^`ZSkPbv_7  qIà�àI�lÝ(Ý�à�¶��}¡�¥[¡�§3��_�^ xU_���\I^`ZUpIZSj}m�nga�ZGk�nwmvxUi}m`m�ng_�j}mS�

��p}ZU^`Z'��_�^`Z���d�ZGp}t�a�Z ó þ iú QºR i v Q ù � ù ¯&°S��n�jPì�­ u æ$# u í­�����ZSkIngtubvZUfgz|��^v_�� bvp}Z7bvpIZS_�^`ZU�.��d�Zom�ZSZ±t�x'_�jsb`n�j�iI_�i}m�bv^�t�kIZ'��_u®¯h0Z'bed�ZUZSjæbvpIZÞt�k�aWtujsb`t���Z7tuj

t�f���_�^`n¨b`pI� xUt�j¯t�x�pIngZUa�Zot�j}kæbvp}Zoj�iI��hlZS^�_���ªsiIZU^`ngZSm�n¨b.jIZUZCkImPbv_,��t���Z�����p}ngmPbv^�t�k�ZU��_�®õxStujìh0Za�ZU^`z¹jI_�j���fgn�jIZCtu^��rn�b]xU_���\IfgZ'b`ZUfgz¬k�ZU\0ZUj}k}m�_�j>p}_WdbvpIZ.ZSn���ZUj�aWtufgiIZSm�_u� b`pIZ7x'_�^v^`ZUfwtWb`n�_�j���tubv^`n¨�>t�^vZkIngm�bv^`n�h}i�bvZCk$�õ­���t�f�f*ZUng��ZSjsaWt�f�iIZCm]tu^`Z±m�ng��n�fwtu^C��bvpIZSjæbvpIZot�k�aWtujsb�tu��Z._���t�jìtufg��_�^vn�bvpI� d(n�fgf�ngj}x'^`ZSt�m�Zt�f���_smeb�fgn�jIZCtu^`f�zÞd(n¨b`p¹bvpIZ]j�iI��hlZS^�_u��ª�i}ZU^`n�ZCmU�]­��(m�_���Z]ZUng��ZUj�aWtufgiIZCm2t�^vZ���i}x�p¹fgt�^v��ZU^2bvp}t�j¹_ubvp}ZU^�mU�b`pIZUjotuj7tufg��_�^vn�bvpI� ��n���p�b �stungj±t�f�_�b�_u��t�kIa�t�jsb`tu��Z�n�j.b`pIZ��}^�m�b(��ZUd�ªsiIZU^`ngZSmS��¡�i�b*tu�´bvZU^�bvp}tubS�ln¨b�plt�mb`_±�]tu��ZPt.f�_�bc_u� ªsiIZS^vngZSm�bv_±�]tu��Zrt.bvngj�zo\}^v_���^`ZSm`mÀ¿ ngj�b`ZU^`ZSm�bvZCk¹^vZCt�k�ZS^`m�xStuj�a�ZS^vn���z±b`p}tWb�bvpInwm�nwmZU�It�x#b`f�zrbvpIZ�xSt�mvZ*��_�^�bvpIZ�ZU�Itu��\IfgZ2��n�a�ZUj�n�j±q�ZCx#b`n�_�j�¦l� ºI�¤�Æt¤ ¢ùÒ5Ò*ÐvÍ�ÏLÌ%ËIÍeÖ�ñ*ÎY[Z�k�nwmvxUi}m`m(m�ZSa�ZU^�tuf$t�\I\IfgngxStWbvng_�jlm�_u�%��p}ZU_�^`ZU��ºch�z�\I^v_Wa�ngjI��bed�_]x'_�^v_�f�fwtu^`ngZSmS�

d û

Page 18: 0/1( 23 !# 4 576 8 90:=yangke/papers/lower_bound.pdf0/1( 2 3 !# 4 576 8 90:=? @

¨M T �µ�©V�T©§ ��£�0�7ï áWìFñ i ælñ u æ?ègè�ègè�æ�ñ���íX���<� � |�x � ���H� � �g�F���Z��v � 'O�0'-���F{0|�}±�?�F�?}��V� ��z:}����á4�F%Pÿ ö ñ Q ælñ � ÷�ÿ¾;·W�W�51« x �������}�x,z:x�óO��� ó�|�}�z:�0'7~ �0'-���*~«�ZY[��� ®�!?v �0}�z¬�0�<|`{±�é|����0}l��x � ��·W�W�yi`jlk���|X��xS�4���F�?}��?��}�z¬���y©£ª<�`|�}l� � �����xH�E'-������x��[������x ���?ó��³|�{�·W�W� i`jlk z:xµ������}�x,z:x�óOï �?���Mzº�0L��0�X�,' ���® ù � iJjJk �uºo,·4èÓGT Ô ¨�ö ��pIZ�xU_�^`^vZSfgtubvng_�jc�]tubv^`n¨�*«�nwm�xUf�_sm�Z�b`_�bvpIZ�ngk�ZSjsbvn�bez��]tWb`^vn���Á}� ¸ x'bvi}t�f�fgz�ZCt�x�p�ZUjsb`^vz�_u�<«Xo¼Á

nwm�h0_�iIjlk�ZSk�h�zP·W�W�l�%¡�z�b`pIZ ó ZS^ÃÂmv��_�^vngjc��pIZS_�^`ZU��  ë*£�à�¡C§��stufgfIZUng��ZSj�a�t�f�i}ZSm<_u�E«�oSÁ�tu^`Z(hl_�iIj}k�ZCk�h�z�·��q�_�t�f�fLZUng��ZSj�a�t�f�i}ZSm�_��/«Þtu^`Z�h0_�i}j}k�ZSkPh�zPº���q�_�{�·�ì�~�h0ZSxU_���ZSm(º}{¬®�¤|·C~ ù �5°l­�u���q�Z'b�b`n�j}��­Oáõ·W�W�yi`jlkxU_���\IfgZ'b`ZSm�b`pIZ�\I^`_s_��e�

Ý�_���\}tu^`n�j}�.bvpInwm�xU_�^`_�fgfgt�^vz±bv_±b`pIZPj}ZU��tubvnga�Z]^`ZSmviIf�bcn�jã  ¡�¢<£�¤2¥�¦W§��%d�ZPilm�ZCk�t7d�ZCtu��ZU^cxU_�j}k�n�bvng_�j_�j7bvp}Z�q}y���k�ng��ZSj}mvn�_�j¹{�bvp}tub«ÿ ö ñ Q ælñ���÷?ÿz;�·��u�rngj}m�bvZSt�k7_u�(·W�W��kS~�b`_Pt�x�p}n�ZSa�Z�t�mvz���\�bv_�bvnwxUtufgfgz�nwk�ZUjsb`ngxStufh0_�i}j}kImS�}tuj}kPbvp}Z�\I^v_�_��"nwm m�ng��\IfgZ��¨M T �µ�©V�T©§ = �£�0�,ï áÐì�ñ i æ�ñ u æ�è�ègè�ègælñ � í������ � |�x � ���H� � �������±��v � '#�0'-����{0|�}5�?�F�?}��±� ��z:}Î���á��F%bÿ ö ñ Q æ�ñZ��÷4ovbÿW; ·��W��u©%#��'-�?}J�)v zº��� � |�x-������x,�²1>�¬{å� ������}�x,z:x�ó ��� ó�|�}�z:�0'7~ �4|��0��xeÄ ��~³��Y4�µ��x ��!?v �?}�z¬���&%�z:��'-�����xÆ�4���F��x ���?ó���|�{å���X~³|����,Å i þ6Æ � ë*iÈÇ�ü þ iJj �� z:xÆ���4�H}l|?î[z:~³����z:x7ó����:� � |�x � ���H���¶z:x^ïT1_3,| � � '7z¬�?�F����x�[������x,�é��ó[�5�X�Vz:�,'¶��|��g�0}J��x � �&�Z%Z��x ��� ó�|�}�z:�0'7~ xH�����F�5��|#~«�ZY[�(�l{���u oTv0~Hoo·.!?v �0}�z¬�0���|«��x �[�����0}��?��}�z¬���©bª<�`|�}J� � ����1ÓGT Ô ¨�ö YoZG�l^`m�b x'n�bvZ�t�^vZCm�i}f¨b�bvpltWb nwm t�x'_�^`_�fgfwtu^`z�b`_�bvpIZ ó ZS^ÃÂmv��_�^vngjP��pIZS_�^`ZU�7  ë�£sà[¡S§��¤|�2sgs V 2Âr�Z¬®@vÉ 5á ª(¨M T ���EV�T©§4ô/Ê q Ê Â°ª�Ë Ê Ë Ê q ô�÷ ±²���L�?���D/Æ¢ m ���å��xH|�}�~«���±~«���M}�zQî ��xH�µ���?�9 / ¢ m 1?�t{ �v zº�\��xÐ�0zQó��0x,�F����v ��|`{E�ç¤Ï9E%O�0'-�?x �,' �0}l�\zº�¶�?|�~³�µ�0zQó��0x,�F����v ��v Q |`{C� {0|�}\��'7z � 'ÿ �v«o·v Q ÿ2;ÍÌ4ÿ 9SÿÎÌ u 1��p}Z�xU_�^`^vZSfgtubvng_�j7�]tWb`^vn��Ï«>nwmGx'fg_�mvZcb`_�b`pIZ��]tWbv^`n��µ¢ bvp}tub�p}t�m�·�° m2_�jÞbvpIZrk�nwtu��_�j}t�fgm*tuj}kHv[_�jb`pIZP_�®l��k�nwtu��_�j}t�f�ZUjsbv^`n�ZCmU�å��Z'b�9 á�«�o ¢á�<tuj}k[b`pIZUj¬ZCt�x�p�ZSj�b`^vzo_u��9³nwm�h0_�iIjlk�ZSk�h�z,·��u�}�<tuj}kb`p�i}m�d�Z]p}t�a�Z�Ì[ÿ 9¶ÿÐÌ u ; ·W�W�l�\�*h�a�n�_�i}m�fgz�¢ nwmct.jI_�^v� ��tubv^`n¨�$�.��pIZrfwtu^`��ZCmeb�ZUng��ZSj�a�t�f�i}Z]_u�5¢ nwmv i á�·�¤ì{E��o,·C~$v.tuj}k.tufgfLbvp}Z�^vZCmeb�m(tu^`Z�·&o·v����Z'b�v i ù °?°?° ù v m hlZ�bvpIZ�ZSn���ZUj�aWtufgiIZSm3_u�L«<�%¡�z���ZU���]tG·U¦}�Cd�Z���jI_WdÞb`p}tWbtv i ;ã·W¤]{©�Ho�·C~$v$¤�·��u�}�t�j}kBv Q ;¯·&o·v�¤ì·��W����_�^�� áãºyæ�è�ègè�æ`�}�q�_�n���tuj7tufg��_�^vn�bvpI��kI_sZCm�j�° b �]tu��Z2t�j�zPªsiIZU^`n�ZCmU��b`pIZUj.n�b`m(�]tu��ng�ci}��t�k�aWt�j�b�tu��Z*nwm(h0_�iIj}kIZSk�h�zÑ v i� á Ñ ·�¤¯{©��o,·C~$vc¤ì·��W�

� èq�iI\I\0_�mvZ�®�ªsiIZS^vngZSm�tu^`ZG�]t�k�Z���bvpIZSj7d�ZGp}t�a�Z

�X°�� u ;ã·�¤ì{E��o,·C~�v�¤ô·W�W�*¤¯{e·&o·v�¤ì·��u�s~`®7æ_�^

® ù {¬��u&o·vl~ °S��o,·�¤�vUo|·W�W�·&oHv�¤ô·W�W� ù �l{�� u oHv0~ o,·4è

��p}ngm*^vZCm�i}f¨b2ngmGmvn���ngfgt�^ bv_�bvpltWb*ngj|  µ2¶}·#§��GÜ�t�^�b`ngxUiIfwtu^`f�z��}ngj7bvpIZ�xUt�m�Zcbvp}tub*jI_�ªsiIZU^`z.ngm*�]t�k�Z��lb`pIZbed�_Þt�^vZPt�f���_smeb�ngk�ZSjsbvnwxUtuf��oë�_Wd�ZSa�ZS^S�%n�j>��ZUj}ZU^�tuf�b`pIZUz¬t�^vZrj}_ub�kIn�^`ZSx'bvfgz[xU_���\}tu^�tuh}f�Z��±­�j¯  µ2¶I·'§���t��_�^vZ�^vZCmeb`^vnwx#b`n�a�Z�xU_�j}k�n�bvng_�j[nwm*ilm�ZCkP�*_�jIZ�^vZCª�i}n�^`ZSm�bvp}tubSÿ ö ñ Q æ�ñZ��÷Zo£v£ÿ°;�·��W��k�n�j}m�bvZCt�kÞ_u�*·W�W��uW�³�*jb`pIZc_�bvpIZS^�p}t�j}k$�}bvpIZSn�^*^vZCm�iIf�b�nwm�t���tungj}m�b*tuj.pI_�jIZSm�b2q}y���_�^�t�xUf�Z��Id(pInwx�p7ngm*meb`^v_�jI��ZS^(bvpltuj7_�j}Zctu�stungj}mebt�j7t�k�a�ZU^�mvt�^vnwtufLq}y���_�^`t�x'fgZ�� � ZSa�ZU^vbvp}ZUfgZSm`mU��b`pIZ���pIZU_�^vZS��º���t���ZCm�_�iI^(\I^`_�_u�%a�ZU^`zrmvn���\IfgZ��

d%

Page 19: 0/1( 23 !# 4 576 8 90:=yangke/papers/lower_bound.pdf0/1( 2 3 !# 4 576 8 90:=? @

Ò máÀ�½.Ã�pUÂ\Ö<Ä'À�½ÙÕ�½.Á `7Â�¾�Â.¿VÚÔÓ À�¿:ÕY[Z�\I^v_Wa�ZSk2bed�_�fg_Wd�ZS^3h0_�iIj}k}m���_�^<qly���fgZSt�^vjIngjI� t�f���_�^`n¨b`pI�]mU�%��pIZ��}^�m�b"fg_Wd�ZS^�h0_�iIj}kcngm���_�^<t i}jIn¨��_�^v��fgzxU_�^`^vZSfgtubvZCkÞx'_�j}x'ZS\�b�x'fwt�m`mGtuj}k[d�_�^`��m2tu�stungj}m�b2b`pIZ�pI_�j}ZSm�b�qly���_�^`t�x'fgZ�����p}ngm�fg_Wd�ZU^2hl_�iIj}k[ngm�t�f���_smebb`n���psb�iI\ôb`_>t¬fg_��stu^`n¨b`pI��ngx��©t�x#b`_�^C� tuj}kônwmPm�bv^`_�j}�¬ZUjI_�iI��pæb`_¬ng��\}f�z,bvp}ZomvZU\}t�^`tubvng_�jæ_u��q}y���tuj}kÜ ¸ Ý���fgZStu^`jIngjI�r_���jI_�nwm�z7Ü ¸e ­e��µå��i}j}x#b`n�_�j}m�d(n�bvp[trpIng��pÞjI_�nwm�Z�^`tubvZ��2��pInwm*f�_Wd�ZU^*hl_�iIj}k7ng��\I^v_Wa�ZSm\}^vZSasng_�ilm�^vZCm�iIf�b`m�h�z�hl_�bvp.Z'��bvZSj}k�ngjI��bvp}Z�^`t�jI��ZG_u��x'_�j}x'ZS\�b�x'fwt�m`mvZSm�tuj}k�i}mvngjI�]t]meb`^v_�jI��ZS^(qly���_�^`t�x'fgZ��_�k�ZSfE����pIZ2m�ZCx'_�jlk�f�_Wd�ZU^�h0_�i}j}k]nwm���_�^�tuj�z�x'_�j}x'ZS\�b�x'fwt�m`mvZSm�t�j}k]tu�stungj}m�b�tujrt�k�a�ZS^`m`tu^`ngt�f}q}y���_�^�t�x'fgZ����p}ngm�f�_Wd�ZU^�h0_�i}j}k¬tu\}\If�ngZSm�bv_Þt±�ci}x�p�d(nwk�ZU^�^`t�jI��Z]_���x'_�j}x'ZS\�b�x'fwt�m`mvZSmGb`p}tuj¬\}^vZSasng_�ilm�^vZCm�i}f¨b�mU�.­�bt�fgmv_�mvpI_Wd m2t�xU_�jsbvngj�iI_�ilm b`^`t�k�Z'��_u®�h0Z'bed�ZUZUjÞbvpIZ�t�kIa�t�jsb`tu��Z�t�jotufg��_�^vn�bvp}��plt�m2tuj}k±bvpIZ�j�iI�ch0ZU^G_��ªsiIZS^vngZSmGn�b�jIZSZSkImGb`_.��t���Z�����p}ngmGb`^`t�k�Z'��_u®¬xU_�iIfwk[hlZ]i}mvZ'��i}f�n�j�k�ZCm�ng��j}n�jI�.fgZSt�^vjIngjI�.tufg��_�^vn�bvpI�]mS� ¸ mkIZU��_�j}m�bv^�tWb`ZSk�ngj]q�ZSx#b`n�_�j�¦}� ¦}�Wb`pIngm�f�_Wd�ZU^<h0_�iIjlk]tufg��_smeb�ng����ZCk�nwtWbvZSf�z�ng��\}f�ngZSm�mv_���Z�\I^`ZUa�ng_�i}m<^`ZSmviIf�b`mngj�bvpIZ�fgn�bvZU^�tWb`iI^`Z��Itujlk�mv_���Z'b`n���ZCm(z�n�ZSfgkIm�ZSa�ZSj�m�bv^`_�jI��ZU^�_�j}ZSmS�

q�_���ZPb`ZSx�pIj}ngªsiIZCmci}mvZSk>n�j|bvp}Z�\I^`_�_u�©m��]t�z�hlZ�_u��ngj}k�ZS\lZSj}k�ZSj�b]ngjsbvZU^`ZSm�bS��­�j|\I^`_WasngjI�ÞbvpIZ��}^�mebfg_Wd�ZU^�h0_�i}j}k$�Lbvp}Zo�`tufgf¨��\}tung^*ÙX�3��kIn�a�ZU^`��ZUjlx'ZS��nwm2n�jsbv^`_�k�i}xUZSk$�Ld(pInwx�p±\Ifwt�z�m*tPa�ZU^`z.n���\0_�^vb`t�j�b2^v_�f�Z�n�jb`pIZc\}^v_�_u�e��Y[Z�tufwmv_]i}m�ZCk7t�bvZCx�pIjInwª�i}Z�bv_rmvng�ciIfwtWb`Z�hInwt�mvZSk7ªsiIZU^`ngZSm�{U��h}t�kI�]ªsiIZU^`n�ZCm`~(i}m�ngjI�]iIj�hInwt�mvZSk_�jIZSm]{U�vmvZU��n���nwk�ZSt�fg��ªsiIZU^`ngZSm�~#��­�jo\}^v_Wa�ngjI�Pb`pIZrmvZSx'_�j}kof�_Wd�ZU^Gh0_�iIj}k3�"t.x'_�jIjIZSx'bvng_�jobv_�bvp}ZPq�n�j}��iIfwtu^ß�t�f�i}Z���ZCx'_���\0_�mvn¨b`n�_�j[{�q�ß�G~�d�t�m��]t�kIZ��

��p}ZU^`ZGt�^vZGm�bvngf�f3�]t�jszP_�\0ZUj.\I^`_�hIfgZU�]m�^`ZU�]tungjIngjI�}�r � Ä � R � T ¤«bÖM� T âM�¦�� �%QUÊ��p}Z��l^`m�b%fg_Wd�ZU^%hl_�iIj}k�d�Z�\I^`_Wa�ZSk�n�jcbvpInwm<\}tu\0ZU^<nwm��G{©���%fg_�����~#��d(p}ngx�p�m�ZSZU�]m<meb`n�fgfIt�fg_��stu^`n¨b`pI��ngx�©t�x#b`_�^Gm�pI_�^�b*_u��h0ZUngjI�rb`n���psbS�2­�b2d�_�iIfwk.h0Z�ngjsbvZU^`ZSm�bvngjI�Pbv_Pplt�a�Zctrbv^`iIf�z�b`n���p�b2f�_Wd�ZU^*hl_�iIj}k$� ¸b`n���psb�fg_Wd�ZS^]hl_�iIj}kôd�_�iIfwkôk�ng^vZCx#b`f�z,n���\Ifgz,bvp}tubrbvp}Z¯�`qly���h}t�m�ZCkæÜ ¸ Ý�t�f���_�^`n¨b`pI�]�[��_�k�ZSf*nwmZCmvmvZUjsb`ngt�f�fgz�bvpIZ�m`tu��ZGt�m�b`pIZ.��pI_�jIZSm�b�q}y���_�^`t�x'fgZS����_�k�ZSfE�Itub�fgZSt�meb���_�^ x'ZU^vb`t�n�j�x'_�j}x'ZS\�b x'fwt�m`m�ZCmU�¸ fgmv_ctGh0Z'bvbvZU^�f�_Wd�ZU^�h0_�i}j}k�bv^�tujlm�fwtWb`ZSm%bv_�tGhlZUb�bvZS^�mvZU\}t�^`tubvng_�j�_u�Lbvp}Z*q}y¯��_�kIZUfI��^`_��«bvpIZ*Ü ¸ Ý��_�k�ZSfE��Y[Z�x'_�j1³eZSx'bviI^`ZGbvp}tub tuj±�G{©��~�f�_Wd�ZU^�h0_�iIjlk�ZU��ngm�b`mS�Y[Z�k�_�j3° b��sj}_Wd>n��0b`pIZ mvZSx'_�j}k�f�_Wd�ZU^�h0_�iIjlk�d�Z(\I^`_Wa�ZCk�nwm<bvng��psb�ZUn�bvp}ZU^C� ¸ x#bviltufgf�z�d�Z(xU_�j1³eZCx#bvi}^vZb`p}tWb n�b nwm(jI_ubC��ë _Wd�ZUa�ZU^C��jIZSd¯b`ZSx�pIj}ngªsiIZCm���ng��psb h0Z�jIZUZCk�ZSk�b`_�\}^v_Wa�Z2t�bvng��psb`ZU^(h0_�iIj}k3�r Úi T ��×��2��� TWV�������� TWVIX�� �ñÚ� � � �ÈÊ��p}Z±m�ZCx'_�jlk>fg_Wd�ZS^�h0_�i}j}k,ngm�_�jIf�z¬��_�^�bvp}Z±t�k�a�ZU^�mvt�^vnwtuf(q}y���_�^�t�x'fgZP��_�k�ZSfE�¯Ý�tuj,d�Z�\}^v_Wa�Z�tmvng��ngfwtu^(^`ZSmviIf¨b���_�^�bvpIZ�pI_�jIZSm�b*q}y���_�^�t�xUf�Z*��_�k�ZSfwör ¨M�sØË � � R �t¨ � VIT�V}XuR � T �Ù V�R µz�7 ¨W�����&� � V ���� ÄGÊ��p}Z*q}y���k�n���ZSj}m�ng_�jrt�m�k�ZU�}jIZSk�h�z�¡�f�iI�áZ'bC��tuf��l  ¡�¢<£�¤2¥u¦�§$x�p}tu^�t�x'bvZS^vngfUZCm�b`pIZO�'����Y�������}�xH�[�0z:�Qz:���_���t�x'_�j}x'ZS\�b�xUfgt�mvmS�%­��$bvpIZGq}y���kIn���ZUjlm�ng_�j]nwm�p}n���p3��b`pIZUjPbvpIZ2x'fwt�m`m�nwm�jI_�b�d�ZSt��sfgz�f�ZCtu^`j}tuhIfgZ��stuj}kn���bvp}Z�k�ng��ZUj}mvn�_�j7ngm�f�_Wd��lbvp}ZUj7b`pIZcx'fwt�m`m nwmc{©jI_�jI��iIj}n¨��_�^v��fgz�~(d�ZCtu��f�z�f�ZCtu^`j}tuh}f�Z�� ë _Wd�ZUa�ZS^S��b`pIZmvn�bvi}tubvng_�j±nwm�fgZSm`m�xUf�ZCtu^���_�^Gmeb`^v_�jI�]f�ZCtu^`jIngjI�}����p}ZU^`Z�k�_�ZSmvj3° b*ZU��nwm�b2trªsi}t�j�b`n¨bez�b`p}tWbGx'_���\IfgZ'b`ZUfgzx�pltu^�t�x#b`ZU^`n�fSZSm�m�bv^`_�jI�]fgZSt�^vj}t�hIngf�n�bez�����p}Z�m�ZCx'_�jlk�fg_Wd�ZU^(h0_�iIj}k.ngj.bvp}ngm�\}tu\0ZU^�mviI����ZSm�b`m�b`p}tWb(b`pIZZSn���ZUj�aWtufgiIZSm _u�%bvpIZcxU_�^`^vZSfgtubvng_�j���tubv^`n¨����n���p�b*hlZct�ilm�ZU��iIf"ªsi}t�j�b`n¨bez���­�j�bvp}ngm�\}tu\0ZU^ d�Z�\I^`_Wa�ZCkb`p}tWbcbvpIZCm�Z]ZSn���ZUj�aWtufgiIZSmGfgZSt�k±b`_±t.f�_Wd�ZU^�h0_�iIjlk$�r­��(d�ZrxStuj[\I^`_Wa�Z]t.�]tWb`x�p}n�jI�.iI\}\lZS^�hl_�iIj}kilm�ngjI�obvpIZ.ZUng��ZSj�a�t�f�i}ZSmS�<bvpIZSj|d�ZPd�_�iIfwk¬plt�a�Z�to�cilx�p>h0Z'b�b`ZU^]iIjlk�ZU^�meb�tuj}kIn�jI�o_u����ZUjIZS^`t�f�qlyfgZSt�^vj}n�jI�7{©^`tubvpIZS^�bvp}t�j�_�jIf�zr��_�^ d�ZSt��]f�ZCtu^`jIn�j}�s~#��éÃ4ÕP½.ÀWdcp?Ú ÁÏÚMk Ú�½�¾

£�Z'®õ£�t�x���m�_�j>ngjIn¨b`ngtubvZCk>b`pIZ>{Emeb`n�fgf�_�j�����_�ngjI�s~�ªsiIZSm�b]��_�^�t[bvng��psbrf�_Wd�ZU^]h0_�i}j}k,_�jìq}yâ��_�k�ZSfgmS�(tuj}k^`ZU�]t�n�j}m�t2�]tungj�k�^vnga�n�j}�*��_�^`xUZ�hlZSpIn�jlk�t�f�f�b`pIZ(d�_�^`�Gbvp}tub�f�ZCt�kcbv_2bvpIZ��l^`m�b�f�_Wd�ZU^<h0_�iIj}k�ngjcb`pInwm�\}tu\0ZU^C�­�b�ngm�pIZ(d(pI_G�}^�meb�m�iI����ZCmeb`ZSkcbvp}tub�bvpIZ*ÙX�$��k�n�a�ZU^`��ZSj}x'Z�x'_�iIfgk�h0Z i}mvZ'��i}fIbv_�fg_�_���tWbS�tð±t�jsz�meb`n���iIfwtWbvngjI�kIngm`x'i}m`mvn�_�j}m�d(n�bvp�pIng�ê��^`ZStubvfgz2p}ZUfg\lZCk�bvp}Z�t�i�bvpI_�^"i}j}k�ZU^�m�b`tujlk�bvp}Z2{Eª�i}n¨b`Z�mviIh�b`f�Z�~�kIn¨®LZU^`ZUj}xUZSm%h0Z'bed�ZUZUjaWt�^vng_�i}m���_�k�ZSfgm�_���q}y���_�^�t�xUf�Z��"ë�Z�\I^v_Wa�ZSkrbv_]h0Z�t�d�_�jlk�ZU^v��iIf$ZU^`^`_�^(x'_�^v^`ZSx'bv_�^C��bv_�_}�

��p}ZPtui�b`pI_�^cbvp}t�jI��m ¸ as^`ng� ¡�fgiI� ��_�^cp}ngmc��t�j�zohI^`ngf�fgngt�jsb�m�i}����ZCmeb`n�_�j}mS�%t�j}k¹n�j>\}tu^vbvnwx'iIfwtu^C�3b`pIZmviI����ZSm�bvng_�jlmc_���f�_�_��sngjI�on�jsbv_[ZUng��ZSj�a�t�f�i}ZSmc��_�^�i}m�ZU��iIf(h0_�iIj}k}m�ngj¬b`pIZ7tu^`hIn�bv^�tu^`z[xU_�j}xUZU\�b�x'fwt�m`m�xSt�mvZ����p}ngm mviI����ZSm�bvng_�j�x'_�j�b`^vnghIi�b`ZSk�m�ng��j}n¨�lxStujsbvfgz]b`_�bvpIZ�mvZSxU_�j}kPf�_Wd�ZU^�h0_�iIj}k3�

d%!

Page 20: 0/1( 23 !# 4 576 8 90:=yangke/papers/lower_bound.pdf0/1( 2 3 !# 4 576 8 90:=? @

��p}Z�t�i�bvpI_�^�b`p}tuj}��m2­�_stujIjInwm2ÙG_�i�b`ngmS�$¢I^�tuj}xUngm`x'_�Ü<ZU^`ZUng^`trt�j}kÏÛ*ngt�_%³engjo£�ZU^`^vztÜ0p�i±��_�^2ilm�ZU��iIf�k�ngm��xUi}m`m�ng_�j}m(t�j}k�x'_�����ZUjsb�m tuj}k�¡�tu^vbv_sm`fGÜ�^lfUz�kItubvZU����_�^ xUt�^vZU��iIf$\I^`_s_���^vZCt�k�ngjI�l�Ý Ú�j�Ú ¿VÚ�½.Ã&Ú�Ö  ¸ qI¥[¡�§]£st�a�ZSk ¸ � ¸ mvfgt��âtuj}k[q�x'_�b�b�ä �3��ZCxUtubviI^C� ©�� � � z L � ����z¬|�x���x3��©,z:~#vy�����Mz¬|�x�|`{��L����}�x,z:x�ó� � ó[|��

}�z:�0'7~��*{0|�}PÞ<ß � z¬�?x � ����x3�Àà�|�zº�?�0�Z3,|��g�0}J��x � �U��­�jPÝ&�����ã·S¥�¥�¡��W\}t���ZCm"¦sÚ�ï���¦�¦KìI� ¸ ÝVð³Ü�^`ZSm`mU�u£�iIfgz·C¥�¥�¡��

  ¡�¥[¡W§rÝ�pI^`nwmeb`_�\IpIZS^*¡�nwm�pI_�\3�/àO�?vy}J���eàO�?�M�'|�}$Y��±{0|�}já&�������0}�x�â� � |ló4x z:�Mz¬|�x}�L������_�^�k±Û�jIn�a�ZU^�m�n�bez.Ü�^`ZSm`mU�·C¥�¥�¡��  ¡�¢<£�¤2¥�¦u§ ¸ a�^vng� ¡�fgiI�.�Fð7ZU^`^`ngx��r¢}iI^`m�bS�l£�ZU®0^`ZUz�£�t�x���mv_�j��2ð±ngx�p}t�ZUf3ÙGZCtu^`j}mU�sµ2ngmvp}t�z�ð±t�j}mv_�iI^C�Ituj}k

q�bvZUa�ZUj e i}k�nwx�p3�γå���ZY����J�£�l��}�x z:x7óW´�àWÅ ��x3��ã°'-��}J� � �é�?}�zºÕ?z:x�ó�©H�é����zº���Mz � ���*ª<v �0}����£����}�x z:x7óÏä£��z:x�óÅ£|�vy}�z¬�?}W xH�����F��zº�#�lq��5��Ý�·S¥�¥�¦}�s\}tu��ZSm º[¡uÚ åIº�ìsº��}·C¥�¥�¦}�  Ý(Ý�à�¶u§rÝ�p}^vnwmeb`_�\Ip}ZU^.Ý�pltWb��lZUfwk¯tujlk ¸ fgZ'�It�j}k�ZU^7Ý�_�fgf�ngj}mS�J�0x �M}J|���v � �Mz¬|�xÐ��|°æåvy���Mz:����}�z¬�����¸ x3�����F��zº�#�

Ý�pltu\I�]tuj.tujlk�ë*tufgfE�$·C¥�à�¶I�  Ý��(¥I·U§���p}_��]t�m<Ý�_Wa�ZU^%tuj}kc£�_WzG��pI_��]t�mU�UÞ±���?~«�0x,�¬�&|�{Î��x�{0|�}�~«���Mz¬|�x:35'-��|�}��W��£�_�pIj�Yôngf�ZSz�tuj}k�q�_�j}mS�

­�jlxu�g�3·S¥�¥I·��  ¢%Yì¥[¡W§]q�t�f�fgz�¢%f�_Wz�k�t�j}k�ð±t�j���^`ZSk�Y¹tu^`�ci�b`p3�7©3��~��3���RãZ|�~��3}J������z¬|�xF%5�£�l��}�xH�[�0z:��z:�M�©% ��xH���0'-��çH�l�Hx,zºY��ã°' �0}���|�x3�0x¾Y�zº�W´Oz:~³�?x-��z¬|�x}�}ngj�æ � � 'yz:xH���£����}�x z:x7óu�}ß�_�f�� ºI·�{EÚ�~'��\I\3�lº�ì�¥ å�Ú�¶�¦}�7��ZCx'ZU��hlZS^�·S¥�¥[¡��  ë�£sà[¡W§ e _���ZS^(ë _�^`j.tuj}k±Ý�p}t�^vfgZSm�£�_�pIj}mv_�j��<æ ����}�zQîC x3�����F��zº�#�0Ý�tu��hI^`ngk���Z2Û�jInga�ZU^�mvn¨bezPÜ�^vZCmvmS�L·S¥�à[¡��  Ù�¡u¥u§�qL�lÙGiIf�fgh}t�x��0�F�0x�{0|�}�~³����z¬|�xr35'-��|�}��¶��x3�³©,�����Mzº����z � �#� � ZSd¯µ�_�^v�3�V�*_Wa�ZU^(Ü�iIhIfgngxStWbvng_�jlmU�$·C¥[¡u¥}�  ÙX�£¡I·'§]qL��ÙGiIfgf�hlt�x���tujlk e � ¸ �4�3ZSn�h}f�ZS^S�eè<xM�0x�{0|�}�~«���Mz¬|�xå��x3��©HvÃß � z¬�0x � �W� ¸ jIjltufwm<_u��ðÞtWbvp}ZU�]tWb`ngxStufq�b`tWb`ngm�bvnwxUmJ=z=3��\I\3��ïu¥W��à�ì}�l·C¥[¡�·��  £s¶�¶W§]£�Z'®�£st�x���mv_�jyè±x¶�,' �PÞ<ß � z¬�?x � �³|`{CàO|�zº�?�0�Z3,|����?}J��x �Gá- ,ãx � ó�|�}�z:�0'7~��V´��?}�z:���l�±{�}J|�~ ©,�����Mzº���Mz � ���ª<v �?}�z¬���#��­�jÏá±}J| � ������z:x7ó��O|`{��,' �Zé�¶4�,'� x x v ���+³\|�}$YF�$'-|��ô|�x°ãZ|�~5�Hvy�����Mz¬|�x3�����£����}�x z:x7óx35'-��|�}��W�

º�¶�¶�¶I�  Ù�¥�Úu§�ð7nwx�p}t�ZUf<ÙGZStu^`j}mS�<Þ<ß � z¬�0x,��xH|�zº�0�?����|����?}J��x,�&������}�x,z:x�óX{�}J|�~ ���é����zº���Mz � ���l!0v �?}�z¬���[1L­�jØá±}J| � �l����z:x�ó��|`{��,' ��Æbê��0') x,x v ���z ,ã�æ ©H��~�� |F��z:vy~×|�x?35' �l|�}��¶|�{SãV|�~��3vy��z:x7óu�}\I\3�}Ú�¥�ºXå�¦�¶}·��}·C¥�¥�ÚI�  q�à�àW§ ó n�fghlZS^�b�qsbv^�tujI�l�t�Vz:xH����}� � ó[���0}l�µ��xH�������� ±�4�3��z � ���Mz¬|�x-�#�<b`pIn�^�k�ä�kIn¨b`n�_�j3�%ë*tu^�x'_�iI^�b�¡�^`i}x'Zr£�_u�aWt�jI_Wa�ngx�p�­�j}xu�g�3·S¥�à�à}�  ß*à�¦u§«�3ZCm�fgn�Z*ß�tufgngt�jsbS�� û�,' �l|�}��³|`{5�0'-�W�L����}�x3�4�?���U�s­�jkãZ|�~#~�vyx,z � ����z¬|�x-�X|�{�,' �� ,ãëæ.�Iº�ï�{e·�·C~0��·�·CÚu¦%å

·�·U¦�º��y� _Wa�ZU�ch0ZU^G·C¥�àu¦l�  µ2¶}·'§]ÙGZ�µ�t�jI�}�:è<x)�£����}�x z:x7óÏãZ|�}�}l�0�����é���Eã5|�|��g�l��xìãZ|�x � �é�3�¬�_äL��z:x7ó#©,�����Mzº����z � ���'ª±v �?}��W��­�jPb`pIZ�Ü�^`_u�xUZUZCk�n�j}��m _��<bvpIZ�·Cº�b`p7­�jsbvZU^`j}tubvng_�j}t�f<Ý�_�jI��ZU^`ZUj}xUZ�_�j ¸ f���_�^`n¨b`pI��ngx���ZSt�^vjIngjI�r��pIZS_�^`z[{ ¸ ���G° ¶I·�~#�

�£� ¸ ­�º�º�º4¡I��\I\3�,¡�¥W��ïGìI��ºu¶�¶I·��  µ2¶sº�§]ÙGZ�µ�t�jI�}�LàO�?�ñ�£|��'�?}|ã|�vyxH���*{0|�}<©,�����Mzº����z � ���Pª±v �?}����L����}�x z:x�ó��ungjcb`pIZ�\I^`_�xUZUZCk�n�j}�*_��IbvpIZG·F¡�bvp¸ jIj�i}tuf Ý�_�jI��ZU^`ZUj}xUZP_�jæÝ�_���\Ii�b�tWbvng_�jltuf<�3ZSt�^vj}n�jI�o��pIZU_�^vz���Ý&������º�¶�¶sº���q�z�k�jIZUz�� ¸ ilmeb`^`t�f�nwtI�

£�iIfgzPàW��·S¶}�y�L�2Ý�q.º�Ú�ï�¡I��\I\3�lº�ºu¥W�eºW¦sÚI��ºu¶�¶sº��� í«¿�ÀrÀMj�Ö�¾<À ¾Î^\Ú n.¿�ÀMn�Ú ¿%¾�Ä0Ú�Ö³ÀMjæ¾t^\ÚïîabñðlÁ±Äóò�Ú�¿:ÚOÚ�½.Ã&ÚY[Z�fgngm�b�m�ZSa�ZS^`t�f0\}^v_�_u�©m�b`_�bvpIZ�\I^`_�\0ZU^vbvngZSm�_���b`pIZ�ÙX�$��k�nga�ZU^`��ZSj}x'ZGm�b`tWb`ZSk�n�j±q�ZCx#b`n�_�j.Ú}� ºI�ÓGT Ô ¨�ö {´b`_³��ZU���]t]Ú�~

q�n���\IfgZ�x'_���\}i�b`tubvng_�j*�ÐxÒ�{µÇ i È iÖ × ~?ÿgÿ Ç u È uÖÔÙ ~ á úü

ú1ô�Ç i {tàL~�È iü {tçI~�fg_�� Ë ÇOiW{tàL~�ÈOiü {tçI~Ç u {tàL~�È uü {tçI~�Ì�b0

Page 21: 0/1( 23 !# 4 576 8 90:=yangke/papers/lower_bound.pdf0/1( 2 3 !# 4 576 8 90:=? @

á úü

ú ô�Ç i {tàL~�È iü {tçI~�õ´fg_���Ë Ç i {tàL~Ç u {tàL~�Ì ¤>f�_���Ë È iü {tçI~È uü {tçI~GÌPöá ú

üú ô�Ç i {tàL~�È iü {tçI~�fg_�� Ë Ç i {tàL~Ç u {tàL~�Ì ¤ ú

üú ô�Ç i {tàL~�È iü {tçI~�fg_�� Ë È iü {tçI~È uü {tçI~�Ì

á É|Ê�{µÇ i ÿgÿ Ç u ~�¤ úüÇ i {tàL~�É|ÊI{µÈ iü ÿ�ÿ È uü ~; É|Ê�{µÇ i ÿgÿ Ç u ~�¤ ¯

ÓGT Ô ¨�ö {´b`_³��ZU���]t�¦s~Y[ZG�}^�meb(\I^`_Wa�ZGt�a�ZS^vzPmvng��\}f�ZGngjIZSªsi}t�f�n�bez3�

{ ä i ¤ ä u ~�fg_���Ë ä i ¤ ä u® i ¤�® u Ì ; ä i f�_���Ë ä i® i Ì ¤ ä u f�_���Ë ä u® u Ì {e·Cà�~��p}Z�\I^v_�_���bv_�b`pIngm n�jIZCªsi}tufgn¨bezPngm mvng��\}f�Z[��m�ngj}x'ZGfg_��L{tàL~�ngm t�xU_�j}xSt�a�Z*��iIj}x#b`n�_�j3�Id�ZGp}t�a�Zä iä i ¤ ä u °'f�_�� Ë ® iä i Ì ¤ ä uä i ¤ ä u °'fg_�� Ë ® uä u Ì ;>fg_�� Ë ä iä i ¤ ä u ° ® iä i ¤ ä uä i ¤ ä u ° ® uä u Ì áæfg_�� Ë ® i ¤�® uä i ¤ ä u Ì_�^ ä i fg_���Ë ä i® i Ì ¤ ä u f�_���Ë ä u® u Ì ù { ä i ¤ ä u ~�f�_���Ë ä i ¤ ä u® i ¤ô® u Ì­�j.��ZUjIZS^`t�fE��d�Z2plt�a�Z �Pú Q ä Q�� °Uf�_�� Ë O Q ä QO Q ® Q Ì ; ú Q ä Q °Sf�_�� Ë ä Q® Q Ì {e·C¥�~

­�jsb`iIn¨b`n�a�ZUfgz��<b`pIngm�ngjIZSªsi}t�f�n�bez¹n���\IfgngZSmcbvp}tub�d(pIZSj¬d�Z�x'_��chIngjIZ�m�ZSa�ZU^�tuf�\I^`_�h}t�hIn�fgnwmeb`ngx]ZSa�ZSj�b�mcngjsbv__�jIZ���bvp}Z±ÙX�$��k�n�a�ZU^`��ZSj}x'Z�d(n�fgf jI_�brn�j}xU^vZCt�mvZ��ù� _Wd�x'_�jlm�nwk�ZU^�b`pIZ±k�nwmeb`^vnghIi�b`n�_�j|_���Û%{µÇ�~]tuj}k?Û%{µÈ�~'�q�n�j}xUZ.Û¹ngm�t�k�ZUbvZU^`��n�j}ngm�bvnwx���iIj}x#b`n�_�j3��n�b�ZSm`m�ZSjsbvnwtufgf�z7x'_��chIngjIZCm2mvZUa�ZU^�tuf%ZUa�ZUjsb`m2ngj�b`_æ��fwtu^`��ZU^��]ZSa�ZUjsb�mU���p}ZU^`Z'��_�^`Z���ngjsbviIn�bvnga�ZSf�z��zÛ±mvpI_�iIfgkIj3° b(ngj}x'^`ZSt�m�Z2b`pIZ�ÙX�$��k�nga�ZU^`��ZSj}x'Z��"¡�ZUfg_Wd¯nwm(t���_�^`Z���_�^v�]t�f$\I^v_�_����

É«ÊI{æÛ"{µÇ�~?ÿgÿ Û%{æÈ�~�~ á ú ô î°ÿ�  Û%{�Ç�~�á çs§ °Sf�_���Ë î�ÿ�  Û%{µÇ�~'á çs§î�ÿ�  Û%{æÈ�~'áùçs§&Ìá úUôø÷ù úú Æ ü Ç R ô Ç]{¬à0~Èûüê°'fg_��v� O ú Æ ü Ç R ô Ç]{tàL~O ú Æ ü Ç R ô È]{¬à0~ �; ú

üÇ]{tàL~�f�_��)Ë Ç]{¬à0~Èr{tà0~�Ì

á É|ÊI{�ÇUÿgÿ È�~ÓGT Ô ¨�ö {´b`_³��ZU���]tU¡�~

q�n���\IfgZ�x'_���\}i�b`tubvng_�j*�É|ÊI{�Ç m ÿgÿ È m ~ á múé R ò Ç]{µå}~�f�_���Ë Ç]{æåI~È]{æåI~GÌá múé R ò Ë n å�Ì ä é {e·&o ä ~ m2ë é °Sf�_�� Ë ä é {e·&o ä ~�m¾ë é® é {e·&o^®u~ m2ë é Ì

�3d

Page 22: 0/1( 23 !# 4 576 8 90:=yangke/papers/lower_bound.pdf0/1( 2 3 !# 4 576 8 90:=? @

á múé R ò Ë n å�Ì ä é {e·&o ä ~ m2ë é ° õ å�°'fg_�� Ë ä ®5Ì ¤¯{tn\o·åI~b°Ufg_�� Ë ·&o ä·&o�®5ÌIöá fg_�� Ë ä ®5Ì ° múé R ò å Ë n å�Ì ä é {�·&o ä ~ m2ë é ¤¬fg_�� Ë ·&o ä·&o�®-Ì ° múé R ò {tn�oHå}~ Ë n å�Ì ä é {e·&o ä ~ m2ë éá fg_�� Ë ä ®5Ì °0n ä ¤¬f�_�� Ë ·&o ä·&o^®5Ì °0n�{�·�o ä ~á n�°�É|ÊI{�ÇUÿgÿ È�~

�y�