$0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&"...

56
!"#$ %& ’"# ()*#+$,#$’ -.#$/%$0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 457+#$8# 9"+%&’%5$): 15+’%$ ;%8"#$<52,: 5$/ -#+0%) =#<#3) >)+’"7#&’#+$ ?$%*#+&%’@ A202&’ BCCD !"#$%&’$ E"%& .5.#+ 5+02#& ’"5’ %F ’"# G#+) <)2$/ )$ $),%$53 %$’#+#&’ +5’#& %& <%$/%$0: ’"#$ ’"# 0)*#+$,#$’ &.#$/%$0 ,23’%.3%#+ %& 35+0#H

Transcript of $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&"...

Page 1: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"#$ %& '"# ()*#+$,#$' -.#$/%$0 123'%.3%#+

45+0#6

457+#$8# 9"+%&'%5$): 15+'%$ ;%8"#$<52,: 5$/ -#+0%) =#<#3)

>)+'"7#&'#+$ ?$%*#+&%'@

A202&' BCCD

!"#$%&'$

E"%& .5.#+ 5+02#& '"5' %F '"# G#+) <)2$/ )$ $),%$53 %$'#+#&' +5'#& %&

<%$/%$0: '"#$ '"# 0)*#+$,#$' &.#$/%$0 ,23'%.3%#+ %& 35+0#H

Page 2: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!" #$%&'()*%+'$

! "#$%%&" '()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78

&,4 -(#*&6#&).9 :1).) &% $ #$.4) )-6&.&"$# #&*).$*(.) *1$* 4.$66#)% 0&*1 *1&% '()%8

*&+,; !(*1+.% %("1 $% <$..+ =>?@>A $.4() *1$* *1) -(#*&6#&). &% $.+(,7 !!" 01&#)

$(*1+.% %("1 $% B$-)C =DEE@A )%*&-$*) *1) -(#*&6#&). *+ F) "#+%). *+ #!$; :1)%)

7&G).),")% 6.&-$.&#C .)H)"* *1) (%) +3 $#*).,$*&5) &7),*&3C&,4 $%%(-6*&+,% *+ &%+8

#$*) )I+4),+(% -+5)-),*% &, 4+5).,-),* %6),7&,4;

:1).) &% $#%+ $ #$.4) #&*).$*(.) *1$* (%)% 4),).$# )'(&#&F.&(- -+7)#% *+ %*(7C

*1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),7&,4 -(#*&6#&).; J+. )I$-6#)K&, *1)&. %*(7C +3

,)08L)C,)%&$, -+7)#%K M+,$")##& $,7 N).+**& =DEE@A .)6+.* *1$* *1) 4+5).,-),*

%6),7&,4 -(#*&6#&). "$, F) %+-)01$* $F+5) +. F)#+0 +,) 7)6),7&,4 +, *1) )I$"*

%6)"&O"$*&+, +3 $4),*P% 6.)3).),")%; !, &,".)$%) &, 4+5).,-),* %6),7&,4 $#%+

&,".)$%)% +(*6(* &, 3.&"*&+,#)%% .)$# F(%&,)%% "C"#) -+7)#%; Q, *1)%) -+7)#% *1)

-(#*&6#&). )G)"* +3 *)-6+.$.C &,".)$%)% &, 4+5).,-),* %6),7&,4 &% *C6&"$##C #)%%

*1$, +,) =%)) );4; !&C$4$.&K R1.&%*&$,+K $,7 S&"1),F$(- =>??DAK <$I*). $,7 L&,4

=>??TAK <(.,%&7)K S&"1),F$(- $,7 J&%1). =DEEUAK B$-)C $,7 V1$6&.+ =>??@AK $,7

B$-)C =DEE@AA;

M("1 +3 *1) )I&%*&,4 )-6&.&"$# #&*).$*(.) &% 7.$0, 3.+- 7$*$ &, 01&"1 *1) 2).+

F+(,7 +, ,+-&,$# &,*).)%* .$*)% &% $.4($F#C ,+* F&,7&,4; Q, $77&*&+,K *1) 4),).$#

)'(&#&F.&(- -+7)#% *1$* $.) (%)7 *+ "$#"(#$*) *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),7&,4 -(#*&6#&).

*C6&"$##C $F%*.$"* 3.+- *1) 2).+ F+(,7 +, ,+-&,$# &,*).)%* .$*)%; Q, *1&% 6$6).

0) F(&#7 +, &,%&41*% &, S44).*%%+, $,7 W++73+.7 =DEETA $,7 R1.&%*&$,+ =DEEUA

*+ $.4() *1$*K 01),)5). *1) 2).+ F+(,7 +, ,+-&,$# &,*).)%* .$*)% &% F&,7&,4K *1)

4+5).,-),* %6),7&,4 -(#*&6#&). &% -("1 F&44). *1$, +,); R+,%)'(),*#CK +(. -+7)#

&-6#&)% *1$* &* "$, F) %+"&$##C +6*&-$# *+ %(F%*$,*&$##C .$&%) 4+5).,-),* %6),7&,4

&, .)%6+,%) *+ *1) %1+"X% *1$* -$X) *1) 2).+ F+(,7 +, *1) ,+-&,$# &,*).)%* .$*)

>

Page 3: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"#$"#%& '( )*+",-.)+( +/"0 )*%-1(#+ "# ) 12$(. "# 3/",/ +/( %24(*#1(#+ 05(#$"#%

1-.+"5."(* "0 6-"+( 12$(0+ 3/(# +/( #21"#). "#+(*(0+ *)+( "0 #2+ 7(*2&

8-* )#).90"0 5*2,(($0 "# +32 0+(50& :"*0+; 3( ,2#0"$(* )# (,2#219 3"+/ <).42=

0+9.( 5*","#% >*",+"2#0; #2 ,)5"+).; )#$ ) 12#(+)*9 )-+/2*"+9 +/)+ >2..230 ) 0+)#$)*$

?)9.2* *-.(& '( 0+-$9 +/( (@(,+0 2> +32 +95(0 2> 0/2,A0& ?/( B*0+ "0 ) +(152*)*9;

-#)#+","5)+($ *"0( "# +/( $"0,2-#+ >),+2* 2> +/( *(5*(0(#+)+"4( )%(#+& ?/( 0(,2#$

"0 ) >()* 2> $(C)+"2# 0/2,A; "&(& 0(.>=>-.B.."#% (D5(,+($ $(C)+"2# "#$-,($ !9 )

0-#052+&

8+/(* +/"#%0 (6-).; +/( B*0+ 0/2,A "#,*()0(0 $(0"*($ 0)4"#%0& E!0(#+ ,)5"+).;

)%%*(%)+( 0)4"#%0 1-0+ !( 7(*2 "# (6-"."!*"-1& '/(# +/( 0/2,A "0 01).. (#2-%/;

+/( *(). "#+(*(0+ *)+( >)..0 )#$ +/(*( "0 ) 12$(0+ $(,."#( "# 2-+5-+& F23(4(*;

3/(# +/( 0/2,A "0 .)*%( (#2-%/; +/( 7(*2 !2-#$ !(,21(0 !"#$"#% !(>2*( +/( *().

"#+(*(0+ *)+( >)..0 !9 (#2-%/ +2 1)A( )%%*(%)+( 0)4"#%0 7(*2& ?/( 2#.9 >2*,( +/)+

,)# "#$-,( +/( >).. "# 0)4"#% *(6-"*($ +2 *(=(0+)!."0/ (6-"."!*"-1 "0 ) 4(*9 .)*%(

+*)#0"+2*9 >).. "# 2-+5-+&

'/9 "0 +/( >).. "# 2-+5-+ 02 .)*%( 3/(# +/( (,2#219 /"+0 +/( 7(*2 !2-#$G

:2* ) %"4(# >).. "# 2-+5-+; 1)*%"#). ,20+ >)..0; )#$ +/(*( "0 (D5(,+($ $(C)+"2#&

<2#0(6-(#+.9; +/( *(). "#+(*(0+ *)+( *"0(0& ?/"0 *"0( .()$0 +2 )# "#,*()0( "# $(=

0"*($ 0)4"#%0 3/",/ 5)*+")..9 -#$2(0 +/( (@(,+ 2> ) %"4(# >).. "# 2-+5-+& E0 )

,2#0(6-(#,(; +/( +2+). >).. "# 2-+5-+ *(6-"*($ +2 *($-,( $(0"*($ 0)4"#%0 +2 7(*2 "0

4(*9 .)*%(& ?/"0 0,(#)*"2 ,)5+-*(0 +/( 5)*)$2D 2> +/*">+ 2*"%"#)..9 (15/)0"7($ !9

H(9#(0 IJKLMN )#$ *(,(#+.9 )#).97($ !9 H*-%1)# IJKKON; P%%(*+002# )#$ '22$=

>2*$ IQRRLN; )#$ </*"0+")#2 IQRRSN& ?/( %24(*#1(#+ 05(#$"#% 1-.+"5."(* "0 .)*%(

3/(# +/( 7(*2 !2-#$ "0 !"#$"#% !(,)-0( )# "#,*()0( "# %24(*#1(#+ 05(#$"#% .23=

(*0 $(0"*($ #)+"2#). 0)4"#%0 )#$ 0/2*+,-+0 +/( 1(.+$23# ,*()+($ !9 +/( 5)*)$2D

2> +/*">+&

<2#0"$(* #23 ) >()* 2> $(C)+"2# 0/2,A& T-5520( +/)+ >2* #2#=>-#$)1(#+).

Q

Page 4: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"#$%&$ #'"&($ ")*"+( # ,#!'" -#,, .& *!.+"$ .& (/" &")( *"!.%01 2%! # '.3"& &%45

.&#, .&("!"$( !#("6 (/" /.'/"! .$ (/" ")*"+("0 !#(" %- 0"7#(.%& (/" /.'/"! .$ (/"

!"#, .&("!"$( !#(" #&0 (/" /.'/"! .$ 0"$.!"0 $#3.&'$1 8"+#,, (/#( $#3.&'$ 49$( :"

;"!% .& "<9.,.:!.941 =%6 #$ #:%3"6 (/" &%4.&#, .&("!"$( !#(" +%9,0 /.( ;"!% :"-%!"

(/" !"#, .&("!"$( !#(" -#,,$ :> "&%9'/ (% 4#?" $#3.&'$ "<9#, (% ;"!%1 @/"& (/"

;"!% :%9&0 .$ :.&0.&' (/" "<9.,.:!.94 .$ "$(#:,.$/"0 :> # ,#!'"6 (!#&$.(%!> -#,, .&

%9(*9(1 A/" -#,, .& %9(*9( .$ #$$%+.#("0 B.(/ # -#,, .& 4#!'.&#, +%$( #&0 ")*"+("0

0"7#(.%&6 (/9$ 3#,.0#(.&' #'"&($C .&.(.#, ")*"+(#(.%& %- # -#,, .& *!.+"$1 A/" '%35

"!&4"&( $*"&0.&' 49,(.*,."! .$ ,#!'" .& (/"$" +.!+94$(#&+"$ :"+#9$" #& .&+!"#$" .&

'%3"!&4"&( *9!+/#$"$ +%9&("!#+($ (/" !.$" .& 0"$.!"0 *!.3#(" $#3.&'$ .&09+"0 :>

(/" -"#! %- 0"7#(.%&1 D& %9! $.4*," 4%0", $",-5-9,E,,.&' -"#! %- 0"7#(.%& "<9.,.:!.#

#,B#>$ ").$(1 A/"$" "<9.,.:!.# +#*(9!" (/" &"'#(.3" +%&$"<9"&+"$ %- 0"7#(.%& (/#(

$%4" *%,.+> 4#?"!$ #!" +%&+"!&"0 #:%9(1

A/" ")#+( 3#,9" %- (/" 49,(.*,."! 0"*"&0$ %& /%B ,%&' (/" ;"!% :%9&0 .$

")*"+("0 :.&01 D& %9! $.4*," :"&+/4#!? 4%0", B.(/%9( +#*.(#, (/" 3#,9" %- (/"

49,(.*,."! '%"$ -!%4 !!"6 B/"& (/" ;"!% :%9&0 .$ ")*"+("0 (% ,#$( -%! %&" <9#!("!6

(% "!# B/"& (/" ;"!% :%9&0 .$ ")*"+("0 (% ,#$( -%! E3" <9#!("!$1 A/" +%!!"$*%&0.&'

3#,9" %- (/" 49,(.*,."! B/"& (/" ;"!% :%9&0 .$ &%( :.&0.&' .$ !!$%1

D& (/" $"+%&0 $("* %- %9! #&#,>$.$ B" .&+%!*%!#(" +#*.(#, #++949,#(.%& .&(%

(/" 4%0",1 D& #00.(.%& (% (/" 0.$+%9&( -#+(%! $/%+? B" #,$% #,,%B -%! # &"9(!#,

("+/&%,%'> $/%+? #&0 #& .&3"$(4"&(5$*"+.E+ $/%+?1 2%! +%4*9(#(.%&#, !"#$%&$ B"

+%&$.0"! ("4*%!#!> $/%+?$ (/#( 4#?" (/" ;"!% :%9&0 :.&0.&' -%! # 0"("!4.&.$(.+

&94:"! %- *"!.%0$1 F'#.&6 B" E&0 (/#( (/" '%3"!&4"&( $*"&0.&' 49,(.*,."! .$

,#!'"! B/"& (/" ;"!% :%9&0 .$ :.&0.&'1 F,,%B.&' -%! +#*.(#, #++949,#(.%& /#$ (B%

"G"+($1 2.!$(6 -%! # '.3"& $.;" $/%+? .( !"09+"$ (/" ,.?",./%%0 (/#( (/" ;"!% :%9&0

:"+%4"$ :.&0.&'1 ="+%&06 B/"& (/" ;"!% :%9&0 :.&0$6 (/" *!"$"&+" %- +#*.(#,

#++949,#(.%& ("&0$ (% .&+!"#$" (/" $.;" %- (/" '%3"!&4"&( $*"&0.&' 49,(.*,."!1

H

Page 5: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"# $%&'$&$(% )(* &"$+ *#+',& $+ &"-&. $% ('* /(0#,. $%1#+&/#%& $+ - 0#2*#-+$%3

)'%2&$(% () &"# *#-, $%&#*#+& *-&#4 5"#% &"# 6#*( 7('%0 7$%0+. &"# *#-, $%&#*#+&

*-&# 3#%#*-,,8 *$+#+4 9(. (&"#* &"$%3+ #:'-,. +-1$%3+ -%0 $%1#+&/#%& 0$1#*3# -+ &"#

*#-, $%&#*#+& *-&# *$+#+. &"'+ #;-2#*7-&$%3 &"# /#,&0(<% -++(2$-&#0 <$&" &"# 6#*(

7('%04 =+ - *#+',&. &"# )-,, $% ('&>'& %#2#++-*8 &( 7*$%3 +-1$%3+ -%0 $%1#+&/#%&

$%&( -,$3%/#%& $+ ,-*3#* &"-% $% &"# /(0#, <$&"('& 2->$&-,4

?%# >*-2&$2-, (7@#2&$(% &( '+$%3 A+2-, >(,$28 <"#% &"# 6#*( 7('%0 7$%0+ $+

&"-& &"#*# -*# ,(%3 ,-3+ $% $/>,#/#%&$%3 -% $%2*#-+# $% 3(1#*%/#%& +>#%0$%34

B(&$1-&#0 78 &"$+ 2(%+$0#*-&$(%. <# +&'08 &"# +$6# () &"# 3(1#*%/#%& +>#%0$%3

/',&$>,$#* $% &"# >*#+#%2# () $/>,#/#%&-&$(% ,-3+4 5# A%0 &"-& &"# C#8 0#&#*/$D

%-%& () &"# +$6# () &"# /',&$>,$#* $+ &"# +&-&# () &"# <(*,0 $% <"$2" %#< 3(1#*%/#%&

+>#%0$%3 -2&'-,,8 2(/#+ (% ,$%#4 E) $& 2(/#+ (% ,$%# $% )'&'*# >#*$(0+ <"#% &"#

%(/$%-, $%&#*#+& *-&# $+ 6#*( &"#*# $+ - ,-*3# #F#2& (% 2'**#%& ('&>'&4 E) $& 2(/#+

(% ,$%# $% )'&'*# >#*$(0+ <"#*# &"# %(/$%-, $%&#*#+& *-&# $+ >(+$&$1# &"# 2'**#%&

#F#2& (% 3(1#*%/#%& +>#%0$%3 $+ +/-,,#*4

=22(*0$%3 &( ('* -%-,8+$+ &"# *#+>(%+# () -33*#3-&# 0#/-%0 &( +"(2C+ >,-8+

- C#8 *(,# $% /-C$%3 &"# 6#*(D7('%0 2(%+&*-$%& 7$%0$%34 E% 3#%#*-, &"# /(*#

*#+>(%+$1# -33*#3-&# 0#/-%0 $+ &( +"(2C+ &"# /(*# ,$C#,8 &"# 6#*( 7('%0 7$%0+

-)&#* 1-*$('+ +"(2C+4 E% >*-2&$2# *#+#-*2"#*+ +'2" -+ G"*$+&$-%(. H$2"#%7-'/ -%0

H1-%+ IJKKLM I"#%2#)(*&" GHHM -%0 9/#&+ -%0 5('&#*+ IJKKL. JKKNM A%0 &"-&

$& $+ $/>(*&-%& &( $%2,'0# +('*2#+ () $%#*&$- $% -33*#3-&# 0#/-%0 $% (*0#* )(*

O9PH /(0#,+ &( A& &"# 0-&-4 G(%+#:'#%&,8. <# $%1#+&$3-&# &"# *(7'+&%#++ () ('*

*#+',&+ &( $%2(*>(*-&$%3 &"# +('*2#+ () $%#*&$- &"-& &"#+# *#+#-*2"#*+ +&*#++4 Q$*+&.

<# -0(>& &"# $%1#+&/#%& -0@'+&/#%& 2(+& +>#2$A2-&$(% >*(>(+#0 78 GHH4 9#2(%0.

<# '+# &"# /(0#, 0#1#,(>#0 $% =,&$3. G"*$+&$-%(. H$2"#%7-'/. -%0 R$%0S IJKKLM.

<"$2" -,,(<+ )(* "-7$& )(*/-&$(% $% 2(%+'/>&$(% -+ <#,, -+ &"# GHH +>#2$A2-&$(%

)(* $%1#+&/#%& -0@'+&/#%& 2(+&+4 5# A%0 &"-& ('* 7-+$2 *#+',&+ -*# *(7'+& $% &"#

T

Page 6: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"##"$%&' ()&()* +&,"-."-/0%&' ("1-,)( "! %&)-0%/ %& /''-)'/0) 2)3/&2 3/4)( %0

#)(( #%4)#5 06/0 06) 7)-" 8"1&2 8%&2( /!0)- / (6",4* 9"$):)-; ,"&2%0%"&/# "& 06)

7)-" 8"1&2 8%&2%&' 06) '":)-&3)&0 (.)&2%&' 31#0%.#%)- %( #/-')- 06/& %0 $"1#2 8)

1&2)- &"-3/# ,%-,13(0/&,)(*

<( )3.6/(%7)2 85 ='')-0(("& /&2 >""2!"-2 ?@AABC; /& /#0)-&/0%:) $/5 0"

)(,/.) 06) &)'/0%:) ,"&()D1)&,)( "! / (6",4 06/0 3/4)( 06) 7)-" 8"1&2 8%&2%&'

%( !"- 06) ,)&0-/# 8/&4 0" ,"33%0 0" !101-) %&E/0%"&* >) /8(0-/,0 !-"3 06%(

."((%8%#%05 %& 06%( ./.)-* >) 2" (" !"- / &138)- "! -)/("&(* F%-(0; 06%( 06)"-)0%,/#

."((%8%#%05 %( $)## 1&2)-(0""2* G),"&2; $) 2" &"0 06%&4 06/0 %0 %( )/(5 %& .-/,0%,)

!"- 06) ,)&0-/# 8/&4 0" ,-)2%8#5 ,"33%0 0" !101-) 6%'6 %&E/0%"&* H6%-2; 06) ".0%3/#

0-/2)I"J 8)0$))& 6%'6)- '":)-&3)&0 .1-,6/()( /&2 /&0%,%./0)2 %&E/0%"& 2).)&2(

()&(%0%:)#5 "& 6"$ /')&0( :/#1) '":)-&3)&0 .1-,6/()( /&2 06) ,"(0( "! /&0%,%./0)2

%&E/0%"&* G0125%&' 06%( %((1) %( /& %3."-0/&0 0".%, !"- !101-) -)()/-,6*

K1- /&/#5(%( %( -)#/0)2 0" ():)-/# -),)&0 ./.)-( "& 06) 7)-" 8"1&2* ='')-0("&

?@AALC !",1()( "& 06) )J),0( "! 0-/&(%0"-5 0/M ,10( $6)& 06) 7)-" 8"1&2 "& &"3%&/#

%&0)-)(0 -/0)( 8%&2(* N"2)&(0)%&; =-,)'; /&2 O1)--%)-% ?@AALC /&/#57) 06) )J),0( "!

(6",4( 0" ".)& ),"&"3%)( $6)& 06) 7)-" 8"1&2 8%&2(* N-/1& /&2 >/4% ?@AAPC 1()

/ 3"2)# %& $6%,6 06) 7)-" 8"1&2 8%&2( 0" /,,"1&0 !"- Q/./&R( )M.)-%)&,) %& 06)

SLLA(* H6)%- -)(1#0( !"- T(,/# ."#%,5 /-) 8-"/2#5 ,"&(%(0)&0 $%06 "1- -)(1#0(* N-/1&

/&2 >/4% ?@AAPC /&2 U")&)& /&2 >%)#/&2 ?@AABC %&:)(0%'/0) $6)06)- /#0)-&/0%:)

3"&)0/-5 ."#%,5 -1#)( ,"1#2 6/:) /:"%2)2 06) 7)-" 8"1&2 /&2 #)2 0" 3"-) 2)(%-/8#)

),"&"3%, "10,"3)(*

K1- ./.)- %( "-'/&%7)2 /( !"##"$(* +& (),0%"& @ $) /&/#57) 06) (%7) "! 06)

'":)-&3)&0 (.)&2%&' 31#0%.#%)- $6)& 06) 7)-" 8"1&2 2")( &"0 8%&2 %& / (0/&2/-2

&)$IV)5&)(%/& 3"2)# $%06"10 ,/.%0/#* +& (),0%"& B $) 3"2%!5 06) /&/#5(%( 0"

%&,"-."-/0) / 8%&2%&' 7)-"I8"1&2 ,"&(0-/%&0 "& 06) &"3%&/# %&0)-)(0 -/0)* +&

(),0%"& W $) )M0)&2 06) 3"2)# 0" %&,"-."-/0) ,/.%0/#* +& (),0%"& X $) 2%(,1(( 06)

X

Page 7: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"#$%&'(%% ") "$! !(%$*&% &" +**",-'. )"! /+!-"$% %"$!0(% ") -'(!&-+ -' +..!(.+&(

1(2+'13 4(0&-"' 5 0"'0*$1(%3

!" #$% &'()*(+* ,-.'/0./%+ /) ( ,1*%. 2/'$1-' 3(0/'(.

6' &7-% %(0&-"' ,( 8!(%('& + %-28*( '(,9:(;'(%-+' 2"1(* +'1 +'+*;<( -&% -28*-0+9

&-"'% )"! &7( %-<( ") &7( =%&+'1+!1 2$*&-8*-(!>? #; ,7-07 ,( 2(+' &7( %-<( ") &7(

."/(!'2('& %8('1-'. 2$*&-8*-(! ,7(' &7( <(!" #"$'1 -% '"& #-'1-'.3

41-&%$1.*& @7( (0"'"2; -% 8"8$*+&(1 #; + !(8!(%('&+&-/( 7"$%(7"*1> ,7"%(

*-)(9&-2( $&-*-&;> ! > -% .-/(' #;A

! ! "!

!!

!"!

#!

""$"! #$!%!%

#""&#"#

! $

$! &' ' #(!%

#3 BC3DE

F(!( "! -% &7( 0"'1-&-"'+* (G8(0&+&-"' "8(!+&"!> +'1$!> (!> +'1 %! 1('"&( &-2(9

) 0"'%$28&-"'> ."/(!'2('& 0"'%$28&-"'> +'1 7"$!% ,"!H(1> !(%8(0&-/(*;3 I(

+%%$2( &7+& & * (> + " #(, $%> +'1 &7+& '#-% -% + 0"'0+/( )$'0&-"'3

@7( 7"$%(7"*1 #$1.(& 0"'%&!+-'& -% .-/(' #;A

.!$! '/!$# ! /! #$ '0!% '1!%! ' 2!> BC3CE

,7(!( 2! 1('"&(% J!2%K 8!"J&% '(& ") *$289%$2 &+G(% 8+-1 &" &7( ."/(!'2('&3

@7( /+!-+#*( /!$# 1('"&(% &7( L$+'&-&; ") "'(98(!-"1 #"'1% 8$!07+%(1 #; &7(

7"$%(7"*1 +& &-2( )3 M*%"> .! 1('"&(% &7( 8!-0( *(/(* +'11! 1('"&(% &7( '"2-'+*

,+.( !+&(3 N-'+**;> 0! 1('"&(% &7( "'(98(!-"1 '"2-'+* !+&( ") -'&(!(%& &7+& 8+;%

"O -' 8(!-"1 )- @7( 7"$%(7"*1K% 8!"#*(2 -% &" 2+G-2-<( $&-*-&; .-/(' #; (L$+&-"'

BC3DE %$#P(0& &" &7( #$1.(& 0"'%&!+-'& .-/(' #; (L$+&-"' BC3CE +'1 &7( 0"'1-&-"'

"! )*+!#!/!$#3"#$ '0!%#$ '0#%---#$ '0!%& # (3

5

Page 8: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"#$% !"# $%&' ())* +, -.)*/0#* 12 0)3-#4+4+5# $.3, /,+%( 4"# 4#0"%)')(26

!! !

!"!

"

!! ""#!!!

! #"

# !

!!!

$ % & $6 789:;

<"#.# !! ""# $ " ! %&$ $' *#%)4#, +%4#.3#*+&4# ())* "9

=.)$4 3&>+3+?&4+)% +3-'+#, 4"# @)'')<+%( $.,4A).*#. 0)%*+4+)% @).!! ""#B

'! ""# ! '!

!!!!! ""#

# !

!

6 789C;

<"#.# '!""# *#%)4#, 4"# -.+0# )@ +%4#.3#*+&4# ())* " &%* '! +, 4"# -.+0# )@ 4"#

")3)(#%#)/, $%&' ())*9

!"# +%4#.3#*+&4# ())*6 !! ""#6 +, -.)*/0#* 12 & 3)%)-)'+,4 /,+%( 4"# @)'')<+%(

4#0"%)')(2B

!! ""# ! (! ""# 6

<"#.# (! ""# *#%)4#, #3-')23#%4 12 4"# "!" 3)%)-)'+,49 D# &,,/3# 4"#.# +, %)

#%4.2 ). #>+4 +%4) 4"# -.)*/04+)% )@ 4"# "!" +%4#.3#*+&4# ())*9 !"# 3)%)-)'+,4

+, ,/1E#04 4) F&'5)A,42'# -.+0#A,#44+%( @.+04+)%, &%* 0&% )-4+3+?# +4, -.+0#6 '! ""#6

<+4" -.)1&1+'+42 $" )9 D+4" -.)1&1+'+42 ) 4"# $.3 ,#4,B

'! ""# ! '!!! ""# 9

!"# *+,0)/%4#* -.)$4, )@ 4"# "!" +%4#.3#*+&4# ())* $.3 &.#B

*!

"$

##"

+!$#,!$# %'!$# ""#!!$# ""#" "$" -#.!$#(!$# ""#' 6 789G;

<"#.# - ! $/% *#%)4#, &% #3-')23#%4 ,/1,+*2 <"+0" 0)..#04,6 +% ,4#&*2 ,4&4#6 4"#

+%#H0+#%02 0.#&4#* 12 4"# -.#,#%0# )@ 3)%)-)'2 -)<#.9 !"# 5&.+&1'# ,!$# +, 4"#

3/'4+-'+#. )% 4"# ")/,#")'* 1/*(#4 0)%,4.&+%4 +% 4"# I&(.&%(+&% .#-.#,#%4&4+)% )@

4"# ")/,#")'* -.)1'#39 !"# 5&.+&1'#.!$# *#%)4#, 4"# %)3+%&' <&(# .&4#9

J+.3 " 3&>+3+?#, +4, *+,0)/%4#* -.)$4,6 (+5#% 12 #K/&4+)% 789G;6 ,/1E#04 4) 4"#

F&'5) -.+0#A,#44+%( @.+04+)%6 4"# -.)*/04+)% @/%04+)%6 &%* 4"# *#3&%* @/%04+)% @).

!! ""#6 (+5#% 12 #K/&4+)% 789C;9

L

Page 9: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"#$%&'( )"*+,( !" #$$%&" '(#' &)*"'#+, -)./0, 1)..)2$ '(" +%."3

!!!" ! "#$%"!!"# &'4 56789

2("+"

"!!" ! %($%'%( ) &!'"!%'!$' '

"" %!!$!'

#! ! (7

:(" ;#+/#<." ' ="*)'"$ '(" $'"#=,>$'#'" .";". )1 )%'-%'7 :(" ;#+/#<." &! ="*)'"$

'(" '/&">( +#'" )1 /*?#'/)*7 !" #$$%&" '(#' )" * ( #*= )# " %&# ('7

@00)+=/*A ') "B%#'/)* 56789 '(" &)*"'#+, #%'()+/', 1)..)2$ # :#,.)+ +%." #$

.)*A #$ '(" /&-./"= *)&/*#. /*'"+"$' +#'" /$ *)*>*"A#'/;"7 !("*";"+ '(" :#,.)+

+%." /&-./"$ # *"A#'/;" *)&/*#. /*'"+"$' +#'"4 '(" &)*"'#+, #%'()+/', $/&-., $"'$

'(" *)&/*#. /*'"+"$' +#'" ') C"+)7 D)+ 0)*;"*/"*0" 2" #$$%&" '(#' $'"#=,>$'#'" /*>

?#'/)* /$ C"+)7 :(/$ #$$%&-'/)* /&-./"$ '(#' '(" $'"#=,>$'#'" *"' *)&/*#. /*'"+"$'

+#'" /$ ($% ! (7

-+.,&* )"*+,( @$ .)*A #$ '(" C"+) <)%*= )* '(" *)&/*#. /*'"+"$' +#'" /$ *)'

</*=/*A4 A);"+*&"*' $-"*=/*A ";).;"$ #00)+=/*A ')3

+!!" ! %(! ,'+) ,+! ) -!!"7 567E9

F"+" + /$ '(" .";". )1 A);"+*&"*' $-"*=/*A /* '(" *)*>$')0(#$'/0 $'"#=, $'#'" #*=

-!!" /$ #* /7/7=7 $()0G 2/'( C"+) &"#*7 :) $/&-./1, )%+ #*#.,$/$4 2" #$$%&" '(#'

A);"+*&"*' $-"*=/*A #*= '(" "&-.),&"*' $%<$/=, #+" H*#*0"= 2/'( .%&->$%&-

'#I"$7 :(" "I#0' '/&/*A )1 '("$" '#I"$ /$ /++".";#*' <"0#%$" J/0#+=/#* "B%/;#."*0"

().=$ %*="+ )%+ #$$%&-'/)*$7

/01+*+2'+13 :(" "0)*)&,K$ +"$)%+0" 0)*$'+#/*' /$3

.! )+! ! '!7 567L9

L

Page 10: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

! "#$%&'()* &+,-.-/)-,#0 -1 ( 2$..&2'-$% $3 1'$24(1'-2 5)$2&11&16

!!!" #!"$!" %!" &!" '!" %! !(" " &! !(" " #! !(" " )!" *!!"" +!"6

1,24 '4(' 3$) 7-8&% !,!" '4& 4$,1&4$.9 (%9 :)# 5)$/.&#1 ()& 1('-1:&96 '4& #$%&;

'()* (%9 :12(. 5$.-2* ),.&1 ()& 1('-1:&96 #()<&'1 2.&()6 (%9 '4& (77)&7('& )&1$,)2&

2$%1')(-%' -1 1('-1:&9=

>$ 1$.8& 3$) '4& &+,-.-/)-,# ?& ,1& ( .-%&() (55)$@-#('-$% ()$,%9 '4& %$%;

1'$24(1'-2 1'&(9* 1'('& $3 '4& &2$%$#*= >4)$,74$,'6 #-! 9&%$'&1 '4& 5&)2&%'(7&

9&8-('-$% $3 -! 3)$# -'1 %$%;1'$24(1'-2 1'&(9* 1'('& 8(.,&6 -= >4& &+,-.-/)-,# -1

24()(2'&)-A&9 /* '4& 3$..$?-%7 1&' $3 &+,('-$%1=

>4& B4-..-51 2,)8& 3$) '4-1 &2$%$#* -1 7-8&% /*C

+! $ .!

!/+!!" % 0"1!!

#6 DE=FG

?4&)& 0 $ !&# 2" !&# /2" 32= H% (99-'-$%61!! 9&%$'&1 )&(. #()7-%(. 2$1' ?4-246

,%9&) $,) (11,#5'-$%16 -1 &+,(. '$ '4& )&(. ?(7& )('&= !/1&%' .(/$) #()<&'

3)-2'-$%16 '4& 5&)2&%' 9&8-('-$% $3 )&(. #()7-%(. 2$1' 3)$# -'1 1'&(9* 1'('& 8(.,& -1

7-8&% /*C

"1!! $ #!! %#

&####!= DE=IJG

>4& .-%&()-A&9 -%'&)'&#5$)(. K,.&) &+,('-$% 3$) 2$%1,#5'-$% -1C

4 !5 # &"

&# 6##! # '4 !5 # &" % &( #!! DE=IIG

$ .!

$4 !5 # &"

&# 6##!!" # '4 !5 # &" % &( #!!!" % /!'!!" #'"# +!!"

%=

>4& .-%&()-A&9 (77)&7('& )&1$,)2& 2$%1')(-%' -1C

#&! $ !&# 6" #!! % 6 #,!6 DE=IEG

?4&)& 6 $ ,3& =

F

Page 11: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"#$%&%&' ()*+,%"&- ./012 +&3 ./0452 +&3 *-%&' ,6( 7+8, ,6+, !!! " !"! 9(

"$,+%&:

#! " $%! ##!!"$ % &

!"&

&! '%

!

&!!

#!"! !

'

&! '!(!

$0 ./04;2

<%#%=+>=?@ 8"#$%&%&' ()*+,%"&- ./0442 +&3 ./04/2 +&3 *-%&' ,6( 7+8, ,6+, !!! " !"!

9( "$,+%&:

!"! ! ' ') #* ! &$ % &( !(! " ./04A2

%!

%! #&! '$ '$ #+!!" !+$! #!!"( % !"!!" ! ' ') #* ! &$ % &( !(!!"

&0

B- ="&' +- ,6( C(>" $"*&3 "& ,6( &"#%&+= %&,(>(-, >+,( 3"(- &", $%&3@ ,6(

=%&(+>%C(3 #"&(,+>? D"=%8? >*=( %- '%E(& $?:

+!!" !+ " ," #+! !+$ %&! ,"$

'-"#! % -# !"!

(0

F6(&(E(> ,6( C(>" $"*&3 $%&3-@ +!!" " )0

F( -"=E( 7"> ,6( ()*%=%$>%*# *-%&' ,6( #(,6"3 "7 *&3(,(>#%&(3 8"(G8%(&,-0

H"> -%#D=%8%,?@ 9( $('%& $? 8"&-%3(>%&' ,6( 8+-( %& 96%86 ," " )0 I&3(> ,6(

+--*#D,%"& ,6+, -" . &@ ,6(>( %- + *&%)*( =%&(+> ()*%=%$>%*# %& 96%86 #! +&3 !"!

+>( '%E(& $?:

#! " /# !(!@ ./04J2

!"! " /$ !(!0 ./04K2

L6( 8"(G8%(&,- /# +&3 /$ +>( '%E(& $?:

/# "&

&! $,

!"&

&! '%

!

&!!

#/$ !

'

&! '

$@ ./04M2

/$ " '#,! -"$&! ') #* ! &$ % &( #&! ,$ #&! $,$

#&! $,$ ',! &! #&! '$-#( % #&! '$ #,! -"$&'

"

"!%% &

"!&

( 0 ./04N2

45

Page 12: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"# #$#%& '( )* +*%,#)-# +* .'/#,*0#*& -1#*2+*. !"#$% &'()*#+$ ,-./-0

1& 2)$ 13#*& *4& %+5&3$6&$* "7&$8#$% 6(9*#79#&3 )":

!"!!#!

!"

$

#"!##!! " $

"! $

$

#%!##!. ,-./;0

<4#" &'()*#+$ #679#&" *4)* *4& 6(9*#79#&3 #" 9&"" *4)$ +$& 14&$&5&3 2+$"(67*#+$

=)99" #$ 3&"7+$"& *+ )$ #$23&)"& #$ %+5&3$6&$* "7&$8#$%. >'()*#+$ ,-./?0 #679#&"

*4)* *4& %+5&3$6&$* "7&$8#$% 6(9*#79#&3 #" %#5&$ @A:

!"!!#!

!&"$. ,-.-B0

C3+6 *4#" &'()*#+$ 1& "&& *4)* *4& 6(9*#79#&3 #" 2+$"*)$* +5&3 *#6&. <+ )$)9AD&

*4& 6)%$#*(8& += *4& 6(9*#79#&3 +(*"#8& += *4& D&3+ @+($8 1& 2+$"#8&3 *4& =+99+1#$%

@)"&9#$& 7)3)6&*&3 5)9(&":

' ! %(&') * ! %((() +!! "(') +

"! %) , ! %()(E $ ! %()E - ! )E .

#! %E . ! %(&.

,-.-/0

<4&"& 7)3)6&*&3 5)9(&" #679A *4)* / ! %(%* )$8 0 ! "1*. F(3 @)"&9#$& 7)G

3)6&*&3 5)9(&" #679A *4)* *4& %+5&3$6&$* "7&$8#$% 6(9*#79#&3 #" "(%'. C#%(3& /

8#"79)A" *4& #67(9"& 3&"7+$"& += +(*7(*E #$H)*#+$E )$8 *4& $+6#$)9 #$*&3&"* 3)*&

*+ ) %+5&3$6&$* "7&$8#$% "4+2I.

J$ +(3 6+8&9 K#2)38#)$ &'(#5)9&$2& 4+98". C3+6 *4& 7&3"7&2*#5& += *4& 3&73&G

"&$*)*#5& 4+("&4+98 *4& #$23&)"& #$ *4& 73&"&$* 5)9(& += *)L&" &'()9" *4& #$23&)"&

#$ *4& 73&"&$* 5)9(& += %+5&3$6&$* 7(324)"&". J$ ) *A7#2)9 5&3"#+$ += *4& "*)$8)38

$&+29)""#2)9 6+8&9 1& 1+(98 &L7&2* "+6& 3#"& #$ +(*7(* 83#5&$ @A *4& $&%)*#5&

1&)9*4 &M&2* +$ 9&#"(3& += *4& *)L #$23&)"&. N(* #$ *4)* 6+8&9 *4& 6(9*#79#&3 #" %&$G

&3)99A 9&"" *4)$ +$& @&2)("& *4& 1&)9*4 &M&2* 3&8(2&" 73#5)*& 2+$"(67*#+$. C3+6

*4#" 7&3"7&2*#5& #* #" 7&34)7" "(373#"#$% *4)* *4& 6(9*#79#&3 #$ +(3 @)"&9#$& 6+8&9 #"

%3&)*&3 *4)$ +$&. <4#" 7&3"7&2*#5& $&%9&2*" *1+ I&A =&)*(3&" += +(3 6+8&9E *4& =3#2G

*#+$" #$ 73#2& "&**#$% )$8 *4& 2+679&6&$*)3#*A @&*1&&$ 2+$"(67*#+$ )$8 9&#"(3&

//

Page 13: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!" #$%&%$%"'%() *+%" ,-.%$"/%"0 #1$'+2(%( !"'$%2(%3 0-024 5%/2"53!! ! "!3 !"6

'$%2(%() 7+% #$%(%"'% -& (0!'89 #$!'%( +2( 0+% '-"(%:1%"'% 0+203 !" 0+% ;28% -&

2 $!(% !" 5%/2"53 #$!'% -.%$ /2$,!"24 '-(0 &244() <( %/#+2(!=%5 !" 0+% 4!0%$201$%

-" 0+% $-4% -& /-"-#-49 #-;%$ !" >1(!"%(( '9'4%(3 0+% &244 !" 0+% /2$81# !"51'%(

2" -10;2$5 (+!&0 !" 0+% 42>-$ 5%/2"5 '1$.%) 7+!( (+!&0 2/#4!?%( 0+% $!(% !" %/6

#4-9/%"0 &-44-;!", 0+% $!(% !" 5%/2"5) @!.%" -1$ (#%'!?'20!-" -& #$%&%$%"'%(3

# $ " !/#4!%( 0+20 0+% /2$,!"24 10!4!09 -& '-"(1/#0!-" $!(%( ;!0+ 0+% !"'$%2(%

!" %/#4-9/%"0) <( 4-", 2( 0+!( !"'$%2(% !" /2$,!"24 10!4!09 !( 42$,% %"-1,+3 !0

!( #-((!>4% &-$ #$!.20% '-"(1/#0!-" 0- 2'012449 $!(% !" $%(#-"(% 0- 2" !"'$%2(% !"

,-.%$"/%"0 #1$'+2(%() A"5%%53 '-"(1/#0!-" 5-%( $!(% !" -1$ >%"'+/2$8 ('%"2$!-

;+!'+ !( ;+9 0+% /140!#4!%$ !( 42$,%$ 0+2" -"%)

7- 2((%(( 0+% !/#-$02"'% -& -1$ #$%&%$%"'% (#%'!?'20!-" ;% $%5!5 -1$ '24'1426

0!-"( 1(!", 0+% >2(!' (#%'!?'20!-" &-$ 0+% /-/%"02$9 10!4!09 &1"'0!-" '-//-"49

1(%5 !" 0+% "%;6B%9"%(!2" CD@E 4!0%$201$%F

% #!!!!"! ! "

"& $"! '%! ()!"#

! & $" ! *% 3 GH)HHI

;+%$%3 '3 (3 2"5 * 2$% #-(!0!.%) 7+% 8%9 &%201$% -& 0+!( (#%'!?'20!-" !( 0+20 0+%

/2$,!"24 10!4!09 -& '-"(1/#0!-" !( !"5%#%"5%"0 -& +-1$( ;-$8%5) J-"(!(0%"0 ;!0+

0+% !"01!0!-" 5!('1((%5 2>-.%3 ;% &-1"5 0+203 2'$-(( 2 ;!5% (%0 -& #2$2/%0%$ .241%(3

+,&+" !( 24;29( 4%(( 0+2" -"% ;!0+ 0+!( #$%&%$%"'% (#%'!?'20!-")K

7- #$-.!5% 255!0!-"24 !"01!0!-" &-$ 0+% 5%0%$/!"2"0( -& 0+% /140!#4!%$3 L!,1$%

H 5!(#429( +,&+" &-$ .2$!-1( #2$2/%0%$ '-"?,1$20!-"() A" %2'+ '2(% ;% #%$01$>

-"% #2$2/%0%$ 20 2 0!/% $%420!.% 0- 0+% >%"'+/2$8 #2$2/%0%$ .241%() 7+% $"- "%

%4%/%"0 -& L!,1$% H (+-;( 0+20 2 $!(% !" # !( 2((-'!20%5 ;!0+ 2" !"'$%2(% !" 0+%

/140!#4!%$) 7+!( $%(140 !( '-"(!(0%"0 ;!0+ 0+% !"01!0!-" 2>-.% ;+!'+ >1!45( -" 0+%

KD%% M-"2'%44! 2"5 N%$-00! GHOOPI &-$ 2 5!('1((!-" -& 0+% !/#2'0 -& #$%&%$%"'%( -" 0+% (!=% -&0+% ,-.%$"/%"0 (#%"5!", /140!#4!%$ !" /-5%4( ;!0+ J24.-6(094% &$!'0!-"( ;+%" 0+% =%$- >-1"5 !("-0 >!"5!",)

KH

Page 14: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"#$%&'()!* (+'( (+$ ,'%-)*'. /().)(0 !1 2!*#/,3()!* )# )*2%$'#)*- )* +!/%# 4!%5$67

8+)# 6$3$*6$*2$ )# #(%!*-$% (+$ +)-+$% )# !7 9!($ (+'( ,/.()3.)$% 2'* "$ ")--$%

(+'* /*)(0 $&$* 1!% ! #.)-+(.0 .$## (+'* /*)(07 8+)# %$#/.( 3%$#/,'".0 %$:$2(#

(+$ 3!#)()&$ 4$'.(+ $;$2(# '##!2)'($6 4)(+ (+$ )*2%$'#$6 2!,3$()()&$*$## !1 (+$

$2!*!,0 '##!2)'($6 4)(+ (+$ %$6/2()!* )* (+$ ,'%5/37

8+$ !"" #$ $.$,$*( !1 <)-/%$ = #+!4# (+'( (+$ ,/.()3.)$% )# ' 6$2%$'#)*- 1/*2()!*

!1 #7 >* !(+$% 4!%6#? (+$ ,/.()3.)$% )# .'%-$% (+$ +)-+$% )# (+$ 6$-%$$ !1 3%)2$

#()25)*$##7 8+$ %$#/.( %$:$2(# (+$ 1'.. )* (+$ ,'%5/3 4+$* '--%$-'($ 6$,'*6 '*6

,'%-)*'. 2!#( %)#$7 8+)# $;$2( )# #(%!*-$% (+$ #()25)$% '%$ 3%)2$#7 8+$ ,/.()3.)$%

$@2$$6# !*$ 1!% '.. # $ %%"&7 >* (+$ .),)()*- 2'#$ 4+$* 3%)2$# '%$ 3$%1$2(.0 #()250

A# ' %B (+$ ,/.()3.)$% )# -)&$* "0C

&'!

&(!'() !! ! "$ ) "* !"! *$

"! *) !"! +$,!

- %7

9!($ (+'( 4+$* ,!' % (+$ ,/.()3.)$% )# -%$'($% (+'* !*$ '# .!*- '# ! )# -%$'($%

(+'* !*$7

D+$* 3%)2$# '%$ 3$%1$2(.0 :$@)".$ A# ' "B (+$ ,'%5/3 )# 2!*#('*(7 >* (+)#

2'#$ (+$ ,/.()3.)$% )# -)&$* "0C

&'!

&(!'

"

" ) !"! +$ "

"!"

$ "7

9!($ (+'( (+$ ,/.()3.)$% )# .$## (+'* !*$7 8+)# %$#/.( %$:$2(# (+$ 1'2( (+'( 4)(+

:$@)".$ 3%)2$# '* )*2%$'#$ )* -!&$%*,$*( #3$*6)*- +'# *! ),3'2( !* (+$ ,'%5/37

E# ' %$#/.(? (+$ 6$,'*6 1!% .'"!% 6!$# *!( %)#$ '# ,/2+ '# )* (+$ 2'#$ )* 4+)2+

3%)2$# '%$ #()2507

8+$ !"" &$ $.$,$*( !1 <)-/%$ = #+!4# (+'( '# ,")*2%$'#$#? (+$ ,/.()3.)$% 1'..#7

8+$ )*(/)()!* 1!% (+)# $;$2( )# (+'( (+$ $@3'*#)!* )* !/(3/( )*2%$'#$# ,'%-)*'. 2!#(

4+)2+ )* (/%* )*6/2$# ' %)#$ )* )*:'()!*7 E22!%6)*- (! $F/'()!* A=7GB (+$ ,!*$('%0

'/(+!%)(0 )*2%$'#$# (+$ )*($%$#( %'($ )* %$#3!*#$ (! ' %)#$ )* )*:'()!*7 8+$ %)#$ )*

HI

Page 15: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"# $%!#&#'! &(!# $' (% $%)&#('$%* +,%)!$-% -+!!. /% *#%#&(0 "$*"#& 1(0,#' -+ !

!0#(2

!- "$*"#& 1(0,#' -+ !"# &#(0 $%!#&#'! &(!# 3"$)" (&# (''-)$(!#2 3$!" 0-3#& 0#1#0' -+

)-%',45!$-%. 6-7 "$*"#& 1(0,#' -+ !!0#(2 !- 0-3#& 1(0,#' -+ !"# 4,0!$50$#&.

8"# !"" #$ #0#4#%! -+ 9$*,&# : '"-3' !"(! (' !"$%)&#('#'7 !"# 4,0!$50$#& +(00'.

8"# $%!,$!$-% ,%2#&0;$%* !"$' #<#)! $' '$4$0(& !- !"(! (''-)$(!#2 3$!" !!. ="#%

!"$' 0(&*# !"#&# $' ( ',>'!(%!$(0 $%)&#('# $% !"# &#(0 $%!#&#'! &(!# $% &#'5-%'# !- (

&$'# $% -,!5,!. 8"# )-%!&()!$-%(&; #<#)!' -+ !"# &$'# $% !"# &#(0 $%!#&#'! &(!# -%

)-%',45!$-% &#2,)# !"# '$?# -+ !"# 4,0!$50$#&.

8"# !"" "$ #0#4#%! -+ 9$*,&# : '"-3' !"(! (' #!$%)&#('#' !"# 4,0!$50$#& &$'#'.

8"# $%!,$!$-% +-& !"$' &#',0! $' (' +-00-3'. 8"# "$*"#& $' #!!"# 0#'' &(5$20; !"#

4-%#!(&; (,!"-&$!; $%)&#('#' !"# $%!#&#'! &(!# $% &#'5-%'# !- !"# &$'# $% 4(&*$%(0

)-'! (%2 $%@(!$-% !"(! -)),& $% !"# 3(A# -+ (% $%)&#('# $% *-1#&%4#%! 5,&)"('#'.

8"$' &#',0! $' )-%'$'!#%! 3$!" !"# !&(2$!$-%(0 1$#3 !"(! !"# *-1#&%4#%! '5#%2$%*

4,0!$50$#& $' *&#(!#& $% !"# 5&#'#%)# -+ ())-44-2(!$1# 4-%#!(&; 5-0$);. B; ()C

)-44-2(!$1# 3# 4#(% !"(! !"# 4-%#!(&; (,!"-&$!; A##5' $%!#&#'! &(!#' 0-3 $% !"#

5&#'#%)# -+ ( D')(0 #E5(%'$-%.

8"# !"" %$ #0#4#%! -+ 9$*,&# : '"-3' !"(! !"# 4,0!$50$#& $' ( 2#)&#('$%* +,%)C

!$-% -+ !"# 5(&(4#!#& *-1#&%$%* !"# 5#&'$'!#%)# -+ *-1#&%4#%! 5,&)"('#'7 #. 8"#

$%!,$!$-% +-& !"$' &#',0! $' !"(! !"# 5&#'#%! 1(0,# -+ !(E#' (''-)$(!#2 3$!" ( *$1#%

$%%-1(!$-% $% *-1#&%4#%! 5,&)"('#' $' (% $%)&#('$%* +,%)!$-% -+#. 6- !"# %#*(!$1#

3#(0!" #<#)! -% )-%',45!$-% $' (% $%)&#('$%* +,%)!$-% -+ #.

=# )-%)0,2# !"$' ',>'#)!$-% >; %-!$%* !"(! 3# &#2$2 9$*,&# : ,'$%* ( +-&3(&2C

0--A$%* 8(;0-& &,0# $% 3"$)" !"# $%!#&#'! &(!# &#'5-%2' !- !"# -%#C5#&$-2C("#(2

#E5#)!#2 $%@(!$-% (%2 -,!5,! *(5. 8"# &#',0!' !"(! 3# ->!($%#2 3#&# 1#&; '$4$0(&

!- !"# -%#' 2$'),''#2 (>-1#.

F$#3#2 -1#&(007 -,& &#',0!' $%2$)(!# !"(!7 +&-4 !"# 5#&'5#)!$1# ( '$450# %#3C

G#;%#'$(% 4-2#07 $! $' H,$!# 50(,'$>0# !"(! !"# 4,0!$50$#& $' (>-1# -%#. I-3#1#&7

JK

Page 16: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!" !# $!%&'(" ") )*"+!, -'("!.(!/0# +*)1/ !!" 2)0 .(+'#!*(/ .+0+-/"/0 1+('/#3

!" #$% &%'()*(+,- .+/012/1%' 1, 3 .(-%/ 410$(+0 532103/

4, "5!# #/&"!), 6/ +,+(78/ "5/ 9)1/0,-/," #./,$!,9 -'("!.(!/0 !, )'0 #!-.(/ ,/6:

;/7,/#!+, -)$/( 65/, "5/ 8/0) *)',$ ), ,)-!,+( !,"/0/#" 0+"/# */&)-/# *!,$!,93

</ =0#" +##'-/> +# !, ?99/0"##), +,$ <))$2)0$ @ABBCD +,$ E50!#"!+,) @ABBFD>

"5+" "5/ #5)&G "5+" -+G/# "5/ 8/0) *)',$ *!,$!,9 !# +, !,&0/+#/ !, "5/ $!#&)',"

2+&")03 </ "5!,G )2 "5!# #5)&G +# 0/.0/#/,"!,9 + "/-.)0+07 0!#/ !, +9/,"H# .0)./,:

#!"7 ") #+1/3 </ "5/, &),#!$/0 + #/(2:2'(=((!,9 2/+0 )2 $/I+"!), #5)&G3 J!,+((7>

6/ +,+(78/ "5/ !-.+&" )2 "5/ "!-!,9 )2 9)1/0,-/," #./,$!,9 !,&0/+#/# ), "5/

-+9,!"'$/ )2 "5/ -'("!.(!/03

6 -175(+,0 8350(' 7$(59 </ -)$!27 +9/,"H# .0/2/0/,&/#> 9!1/, *7 @A3KD> ")

+(()6 2)0 + #")&5+#"!& $!#&)'," 2+&")0>

" # #!

!!

!"!

$!

"$%"! %!!&!&

#""'#"#

! !

!! '( ( %)!&

#3 @C3KD

L5/ &'-'(+"!1/ $!#&)'," 2+&")0> $!> !# 9!1/, *7M

$! #

$#

#$$!

#

#$$"" " " #

#$$!* + # !

! + # )3 @C3AD

L5/ "!-/:+ $!#&)'," 2+&")0> ,!> &+, "+G/ ), "6) 1+('/#M , +,$ ,%> 65/0/ ,% - )3

L5/ #")&5+#"!& .0)&/## 2)0 ,! !# 9!1/, *7M

*+%,!$# # ,

%$,! # ,%&# .> *+

%,!$# # ,$,! # ,

%&# !!.> *+

%,!$# # ,

%$,! # ,&# )3

@C3CD

L5/ 1+('/ )2 ,!$# !# 0/+(!8/$ +" "!-/ +3

</ &),#!$/0 "5/ 2)(()6!,9 /N./0!-/,"3 L5/ /&),)-7 !# !,!"!+((7 !, "5/ #"/+$7

#"+"/> #) ,! # ,3 O" "!-/ 8/0) ,# "+G/# ), "5/ 1+('/ ,%3 L5/0/+2"/0 ,! 2)(()6#

KP

Page 17: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"# $%&'#(( )#('%*+#) +, #-./!*&0 123243 5"# )*('&.0! 6/'!&% %#7/*0( "*8" 9*!"

$%&+/+*:*!, ! /0) %#!.%0( $#%7/0#0!:, !& *!( 0&%7/: ;/:.#< "< 9*!" $%&+/+*:*!,

!! !3 =0 9"/! 6&::&9( 9# /((.7# !"/! "! *( (.>'*#0!:, "*8" !"/! !"# ?#%&@+&.0)

'&0(!%/*0! &0 0&7*0/: *0!#%#(! %/!#( *( +*0)*083 A# /((.7# !"/! "#" # "#! " $ *0

!"# :&9#% +&.0) /0) "#" # $ &!"#%9*(#3

5& (&:;# !"# 7&)#: 9# (.$$&(# 1/0) !"#0 ;#%*6,4 !"/! !"# #-.*:*+%*.7 *( '"/%@

/'!#%*?#) +, !9& ;/:.#( 6&% #/'" ;/%*/+:#B &0# ;/:.# 6&% 9"#0 !"# ?#%& +&.0) *(

+*0)*08 /0) &0# ;/:.# 6&% 9"#0 *! *( 0&!3 A# )#0&!# !"# ;/:.#( &6 *0C/!*&0 /0)

&.!$.! *0 !"# ?#%& +&.0) +, $! /0) "% !< %#($#'!*;#:,3 D&% (*7$:*'*!, 9# /((.7#

!"/! &# # $< (& !"#%# *( 0& *0!#%#(! %/!# (7&&!"*08 *0 !"# 5/,:&% %.:#< 1E3F43 G*0'#

!"#%# /%# 0& (!/!# ;/%*/+:#( /0) "#" # $ &.!(*)# &6 !"# ?#%& +&.0)< /( (&&0 /( !"#

?#%& +&.0) *( 0&! +*0)*08 !"# #'&0&7, H.7$( !& !"# (!#/), (!/!#3

A# '/0 (&:;# 6&% "% ! .(*08 #-./!*&0 1E3I24 /0) !"# 6&::&9*08 ;#%(*&0 &6 #-./!*&0

1E3IJ4< 9"*'" !/K#( *0!& /''&.0! !"# )*('&.0! 6/'!&% ("&'KB

"%" ! ' %( &) ! !' ( !) "#" # 123J4

*"

!!+ &!! ''

","!" ! "

!#( "%"!" ! ' %( &) ! !' ( !) "#"!" ( &!! ''$"!"

$3

L-./!*&0( 1E3I24 /0) 123J4 '/0 +# %#@9%*!!#0 /(B

"% ! # ' %( &) ! !' ( !) "#! (!! '

!! !

"+"! ( !$!

#< 123M4

$! # +!$! ( -

%!

!! '(

.

!!.

&"% ! !

'

!! '- "#!3 123F4

L-./!*&0( 123M4 /0) 123F4 *7$:, !"/! $! *( 8*;#0 +,B

$! #-'

"

"!$( %

"!%

(+"!

&!! +!' &!! !'/&!! ''! !-'

"

"!$( %

"!%

( 123N4

('-

'"

"!$( %

"!%

(( &) ! !' ( %

"!%

!! +!! -'

"

"!$( %

"!%

(!"!$"!&

"#!3

IF

Page 18: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"# $%&#'()#(* +,#(-.($ )/0*.,0.#' .+ $.&#( 123

!" !

!#!! "$ #% ! $% & $' & &

!$ & "

!!"#$! '%

""$ #% ! $% & $'! $

#$! ()% #$! )% *)! &!$ & "

!!"#$! '%

" 4 56478

9),.'.:;0 #+*.);*#+ %< +"1;+#- %( =4>4 -;*; ;'# +);00 ;(- .(+.$(.?:;(*02

-.@#'#(* <'%) A#'%4 B%' :%(&#(.#(:#C .( D";* <%00%D+ D# +#*+"*% A#'%4 E( ;--.*.%(

D# +/,,%+# *";* % " $4 F (#:#++;'2 :%(-.*.%( <%' *"# A#'% 1%/(- *% 1# 1.(-.($

.+ *";* *"# -#(%).(;*%' .( #G/;*.%( 564H8 )/+* 1# ,%+.*.&#3

#$! ()% #$! )%*#$! '%! )&

#$

$! '&

,

$!,

$- (

I"#( *".+ :%(-.*.%( "%0-+ *"# )/0*.,0.#' !" !*!#! .+ ,%+.*.&#4

E( ;(;02A.($ *"# +.A# %< *".+ )/0*.,0.#' D# ;++/)# *";* *"# -.+:%/(* <;:*%'

+"%:J .+ +/K:.#(*02 0;'$# *% );J# *"# A#'% 1%/(- 1.(-.($4L M%(-.*.%(;0 %( *".+

1%/(- 1#.($ 1.(-.($C *"# +.A# %< *"# )/0*.,0.#' -%#+ (%* -#,#(- %( *"# +.A# %< *"#

+"%:J4 E( %/' -.+:/++.%( %< *"# +*;(-;'- )/0*.,0.#' D# ;++/)# *";* *"# ?'+*N%'-#'

+#'.;0 :%''#0;*.%( %< $%&#'()#(* +,#(-.($ +"%:J+ .+ (.)4 !% );J# *"# #O,#'.)#(*

.( *".+ +#:*.%( :%),;';10# D# :"%%+# ) ! (.)4 !".+ :"%.:# .),0.#+ *";* *"# ?'+*N

%'-#' +#'.;0 :%''#0;*.%( %< $%&#'()#(* +,#(-.($ .( *"# A#'% 1%/(- .+ ;0+% (.)4 F00

%*"#' ,;';)#*#' &;0/#+ ;'# $.&#( 12 *"# 1;+#0.(# +,#:.?:;*.%( .( 5L4LP84 I# %(02

:%(+.-#' &;0/#+ %< & <%' D".:" *"# A#'% 1%/(- .+ 1.(-.($C +% D# -.+,0;2 '#+/0*+ <%'

(.($* # & # (.(*)4

B.$/'# 6 -.+,0;2+ *"# $%&#'()#(*N+,#(-.($ )/0*.,0.#' ;(- *"# '#+,%(+# %< %/*N

,/* *% *"# -.+:%/(* ';*# +"%:J .( *"# ;1+#(:# %< ; :";($# .( $%&#'()#(* +,#(-.($

;+ ; </(:*.%( %< *"# ,;';)#*#' &4 !"# Q$R .(-.:;*#+ '#+/0*+ <%' %/' 1#(:");'J

&;0/# %< &4 !"'## J#2 <#;*/'#+ %< *".+ ?$/'# ;'# D%'*" (%*.($4 B.'+*C *"# )/0*.,0.#'

.+ &#'2 0;'$#4 B%' %/' 1#(:");'J +,#:.?:;*.%( .* .+ *.+C D".:" .+ '%/$"02 *"'##

LB%' #O;),0#C ; '.+# .( *"# -.+:%/(* <;:*%' <'%) .*+ +*#;-2 +*;*# &;0/# %< <%/' ,#':#(* 5FST8*% !! ,#':#(* 5FST8 D%/0- );J# *"# A#'% 1%/(- 1.(-.($

PU

Page 19: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"#$% &'()$( !*'+ !*$ %!'+,'(, #-&!".&"$(/ 0$12+,3 '4%$+! ' 1*'+)$ "+ )25$(+#$+!

%.$+,"+)3 !*$ ,$1&"+$ "+ 2-!.-! "% "+1($'%"+) "+ !*$ ,$)($$ 26 .("1$ 7$8"4"&"!93 "/$/ "!

"% "+1($'%"+) "+ !/ :"+'&&9 !*$ )25$(+#$+! %.$+,"+) #-&!".&"$( "% '&%2 '+ "+1($'%"+)

6-+1!"2+ 26 !/

; +'!-('& <-$%!"2+ "% *2= %$+%"!"5$ !*$ #-&!".&"$( "% !2 !*$ ,-('!"2+ 26 !*$

,"%12-+! 6'1!2( %*21>/ ?! !-(+% 2-! !*'! !*$ #-&!".&"$( "% '+ "+1($'%"+)3 *")*&9

+2+&"+$'( 6-+1!"2+ 26 "/ 0-..2%$3 62( $8'#.&$3 !*'! " "% $<-'& !2 !#"#3 !*$+ !*$

#-&!".&"$( "% @2+&9A $#%&/B C+ !*$ 2!*$( *'+,3 62( " ' !## !*$ #-&!".&"$( 6'&&% !2

$#&/D :-(!*$( ,$1&"+$% "+ " *'5$ 5$(9 &"!!&$ "#.'1! 2+ !*$ #-&!".&"$(/ E$)'(,&$%%

26 !*$ 5'&-$ 26 " !*$ #-&!".&"$( "% &'()$( !*'+ !*$ '+'&2)-$ @%!'+,'(,A #-&!".&"$(

=*$+ !*$ F$(2 42-+, "% +2! 4"+,"+)/

G2 .(25",$ "+!-"!"2+ 62( !*"% ($%-&! "! "% -%$6-& !2 621-% 2+ =*9 !*$ ,(2. "+

2-!.-! "% %2 &'()$ '4%$+! ' 1*'+)$ "+ )25$(+#$+! %.$+,"+)/ G*$ 4'%"1 %*21> !2

!*$ $12+2#9 "% '+ "+1($'%$ "+ ')$+!A% ,$%"($ !2 %'5$/ ?+ !*"% $12+2#9 %'5"+)% #-%!

4$ F$(2 "+ $<-"&"4("-#/ H"!* 12#.&$!$&9 7$8"4&$ .("1$% !*$ ($'& "+!$($%! ('!$ =2-&,

%"#.&9 6'&& !2 ,"%12-(')$ ')$+!% 6(2# %'5"+)/ G*$($ '($ !=2 ='9% "+ =*"1* %-1* '

6'&& 1'+ 211-(I ' &'()$ 6'&& "+ !*$ +2#"+'& "+!$($%! ('!$ '+,J2( ' %-4%!'+!"'& ("%$

"+ !*$ $8.$1!$, "+7'!"2+ ('!$/ G*$ $8!$+! !2 =*"1* !*$ +2#"+'& "+!$($%! ('!$ 1'+

6'&& "% &"#"!$, 49 !*$ F$(2 42-+,/ ?+ 2-( %!"1>9K.("1$ $12+2#9 ' ("%$ "+ !*$ ('!$ 26

"+7'!"2+ "% '%%21"'!$, ="!* ' ("%$ "+ 2-!.-! '+, #'()"+'& 12%!/ L-! ' !('+%"!2(9

"+1($'%$ "+ 2-!.-! "% '%%21"'!$, ="!* ' 6-(!*$( "+1($'%$ "+ !*$ ,$%"($ !2 %'5$3 %2

!*'! !*$ ($'& "+!$($%! ('!$ #-%! ("%$ 49 $5$+ #2($/ M"5$+ !*$ %"F$ 26 2-( %*21> !2

!*$ ,"%12-+! 6'1!2( !*$($ "% +2 $<-"&"4("-# "+ =*"1* !*$ +2#"+'& "+!$($%! ('!$ "%

F$(2 '+, "+7'!"2+ "% .2%"!"5$/ 02 !*$ ($'& "+!$($%! ('!$ 1'++2! 6'&& 49 $+2-)* !2

B:2( !*$ F$(2 42-+, !2 4$ 4"+,"+) "+ !*"% 1'%$ !*$ ,"%12-+! ('!$ %*21> #-%! ("%$ 6(2# ' %!$',9%!'!$ 5'&-$ 26 62-( .$(1$+! N;OEP !2 #"+-% Q5$ .$(1$+! N;OEP/

D:2( !*$ F$(2 42-+, !2 4$ 4"+,"+) "+ !*"% 1'%$ !*$ ,"%12-+! ('!$ %*21> #-%! ("%$ 6(2# ' %!$',9%!'!$ 5'&-$ 26 62-( .$(1$+! N;OEP !2 #"+-% RS .$(1$+! N;OEP/

RT

Page 20: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"#$%" #"&'!"# &()'*+& ,- ."!-/ 0*&,"(#1 ,2" "3$'4'5!'$6 '& "&,(54'&2"# 57 ( 4(!+"1

,"68-!(!7 9(44 '* -$,8$,1 #":(,'-*1 (*# ( !'&" '* ,2" !"(4 '*,"!"&, !(,"/

;'+$!" < #'&84(7& ( &,74'."# )"!&'-* -9 ,2'& "%-*-67/ =()'*+& >!? (!" (* '*@

%!"(&'*+ 9$*%,'-* -9 ,2" !"(4 '*,"!"&, !(,"/ ='*%" ,2"!" '& *- '*)"&,6"*, '* ,2'&

"%-*-67 &()'*+& 6$&, 5" ."!- '* "3$'4'5!'$6/ A2" '*','(4 "3$'4'5!'$6 '& !"8!"@

&"*,"# 57 8-'*, "/ B$, ,2" '*%!"(&" '* ,2" #'&%-$*, 9(%,-! %(* 5" ,2-$+2, -9 (&

'*#$%'*+ ( !'+2,C(!# &2'9, '* ,2" &()'*+& %$!)" 9!-6 ! ,- ! !/ D2"* ,2'& &2'9, '&

4(!+"1 ,2" !"(4 '*,"!"&, !(," %(**-, 9(44 "*-$+2 ,- !"@"&,(54'&2 "3$'4'5!'$6 5"%($&"

,2" 4-C"! 5-$*# -* ,2" *-6'*(4 '*,"!"&, !(," 5"%-6"& 5'*#'*+ 8!'-! ,- !"(%2'*+

,2(, 8-'*,/ A2'& &',$(,'-* '& !"8!"&"*,"# 57 8-'*,#/

A- $*#"!&,(*# ,2" 6"%2(*'&6 57 C2'%2 "3$'4'5!'$6 '& !"(%2"# (9,"! ,2" &2'9, '*

,2" &()'*+& %-*&'#"! "3$(,'-* >E/F?/ A2'& "3$(,'-* &2-C& 2-C ,2" !(," -9 '*:(,'-*1

$!1 #"8"*#& -* ,2" #'&%-$*, !(," (*# -* +-)"!*6"*, &8"*#'*+/ 0* ,2" !"+'-* C2"!"

,2" ."!- 5-$*# '& 5'*#'*+ ,2" #"*-6'*(,-! -9 ,2'& "3$(,'-* '& 8-&',')"/ ='*%" %!

'& *"+(,')"1 ', 9-44-C& ,2(, $! '& *"+(,')" (*# &- ,-- '& "G8"%,"# '*:(,'-*1 &$!/

='*%" ,2" *-6'*(4 '*,"!"&, !(," '& ."!- (*# "G8"%,"# '*:(,'-* '& *"+(,')"1 ,2" !"(4

'*,"!"&, !(," >*-6'*(4 '*,"!"&, !(," 6'*$& "G8"%,"# '*:(,'-* !(,"? '& 8-&',')"/ B-,2

,2" '*%!"(&" '* ,2" #'&%-$*, 9(%,-! (*# ,2" !'&" '* ,2" !"(4 '*,"!"&, !(," '*%!"(&"

(+"*,&H #"&'!" ,- &()"/ A2"!" '& -*47 -*" 9-!%" !"6('*'*+ ,- +"*"!(," ."!- &()'*+&

'* "3$'4'5!'$6I ( 4(!+"1 ,!(*&',-!7 9(44 '* '*%-6"/ J,2"! ,2'*+& "3$(4 ,2'& 9(44 '*

'*%-6" !"#$%"& #"&'!"# &()'*+& (& (+"*,& (,,"68, ,- &6--,2 ,2" 6(!+'*(4 $,'4',7

-9 %-*&$68,'-* -)"! &,(,"& -9 ,2" C-!4#/ B"%($&" ,2" ."!- 5-$*# '& ( ,!(*&',-!7

&,(," -9 ,2" C-!4# ,2'& 9-!%" 4"(#& ,- ( #"%!"(&" '* (+"*,& #"&'!" ,- &()"/ A2'& "K"%,

2(& ,- "G(%,47 %-$*,"!5(4(*%" ,2" -,2"! ,C- 9-!%"& C2'%2 (!" 4"(#'*+ (+"*,& ,- &()"

6-!"/ A2'& !"(&-*'*+ &$++"&, ,2(, ,2"!" '& ( )"!7 4(!+" #"%4'*" '* '*%-6" C2"*

,2" ."!- 5-$*# '& 5'*#'*+/ 0* ,"!6& -9 ;'+$!" < C" %(* ,2'*L -9 ,2" ,"68-!(!7

9(44 '* -$,8$, (& '*#$%'*+ ( &2'9, '* ,2" &()'*+& %$!)" ,- ,2" 4"9,/

MN

Page 21: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"#$ %&'()*#+ ,-./0 1% 2%% )3() )3% "()% #4 5%6()*#+ *2 *+7"%(2*+8 *+ )3% 5%8"%%

#4 9"*7% 6%:*;*<*)= (2 2'$$("*>%5 ;= !. ?)3%" )3*+82 %&'(<@ ( <("8%" ! *2 (22#7*()%5

1*)3 ( <("8%" "*2% *+ )3% "%(< *+)%"%2) "()%@ (2 <#+8 (2 )3% >%"# ;#'+5 *2 ;*+5*+8.

A# 7#$9%+2()% 4#" )3*2 %B%7) )3% 4(<< *+ #')9') $'2) ;% %C%+ <("8%".

A# '+5%"2)(+5 13= )3% $'<)*9<*%" *2 2# <("8% *+ )3% >%"# ;#'+5 +#)% )3() (

)%$9#"("= "*2% *+ 8#C%"+$%+) 9'"73(2%2 *+5'7%2 ( 4(<< *+ 9"*C()% 7#+2'$9)*#+.

?)3%" )3*+82 %&'(<@ )3% 7#+)%$9#"(+%#'2 4(<< *+ 9"*C()% 7#+2'$9)*#+ *2 2$(<<%"

)3(+ )3% "*2% *+ 8#C%"+$%+) 29%+5*+8 ;%7('2% (8%+)2 1(+) )# 2$##)3 )3%*" 7#+D

2'$9)*#+ #C%" )*$%. E# ( "*2% *+ 8#C%"+$%+) 9'"73(2%2 *2 (22#7*()%5 1*)3 ( 4(<<

*+ (88"%8()% 2(C*+82. A3*2 %B%7) #B2%)2 )3% "*2% *+ 5%2*"%5 9"*C()% 2(C*+82 )3()

2%+) )3% %7#+#$= *+)# )3% >%"# ;#'+5 )# ;%8*+ 1*)3. A3% 8#C%"+$%+) 29%+5*+8

$'<)*9<*%" *2 <("8% 9"%7*2%<= ;%7('2% #')9') 4(<<2 2# $'73 13%+ )3% >%"# ;#'+5

*2 ;*+5*+8. F+ (55*)*#+(< 7#$9<%$%+)("= %B%7) ("*2%2 *4 " *2 8"%()%" )3(+ #+%.

G&'()*#+ ,-./0 *$9<*%2 )3() #! *2 *+7"%(2*+8 *+ !$!. ?)3%" )3*+82 %&'(< )3*2 %B%7)

"%5'7%2 )3% "*2% *+ )3% "%(< *+)%"%2) "()% )3() #77'"2 13%+ )3% >%"# ;#'+5 *2 ;*+5D

*+8. !#" )3% "%(2#+2 5*27'22%5 (;#C% )3*2 %B%7) "%5'7%2 )3% 4(<< *+ #')9') )3()

#77'"2 13%+ )3% >%"# ;#'+5 *2 ;*+5*+8.

!"#$%&%'%&( &) &*" &%+%#, )- ,)'".#+"#& $/"#0%#, H+ 9"(7)*7% )3%"% *2

<*I%<= ;% ( <(8 ;%)1%%+ )3% )*$% () 13*73 )3% >%"# ;#'+5 ;%7#$%2 ;*+5*+8 (+5

)3% )*$% () 13*73 (55*)*#+(< 8#C%"+$%+) 9'"73(2%2 ;%8*+. F +()'"(< &'%2)*#+ *2J

3#1 5#%2 )3% %7#+#$= "%29#+5 () )*$% % )# )3% I+#1<%58% )3() )3% 8#C%"+$%+)

1*<< *+7"%(2% 29%+5*+8 *+ )3% 4')'"%K L#+2*5%" )3% 4#<<#1*+8 27%+("*#. F) )*$% %

)3% >%"# ;#'+5 *2 ;*+5*+8. M#C%"+$%+) 29%+5*+8 5#%2 +#) 73(+8% () )*$% %@ ;')

*) )(I%2 #+ )3% C(<'% $! & $ 4#" (<< 4')'"% 9%"*#52 (2 <#+8 (2 )3% %7#+#$= *2 *+ )3%

>%"# ;#'+5. N+5%" )3%2% (22'$9)*#+2 %&'()*#+2 ,O.P-0 (+5 ,-.Q0 7(+ ;% 1"*))%+

OR

Page 22: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"#

!! ! "#!" " $

!#

#! %"

&

#!&

"$'!$ %&'()

$'! ! %#! %& "(" " # $' " ! % ') %* ! #& " #( # $+" " %#! %&#!"' %&'*+)

,-.- /- 0"- 12- 3!41 12!1 ,! %!!!"& ! #!"$ ,!% $+!!"& ! # $+

"$ !56 ,!% $'!!"& ! # $'"'

72- 8!90-" :3 !" !56 $' " !.- ;<8-5 => -?0!1<:5" %&'@) !56 %&'A)$ .-"B-41<8-9>' C"<5;

-?0!1<:5 %&'A) 1: .-B9!4- $' " <5 -?0!1<:5 %&'*+) /- :=1!<5#

-'!#"-+"

!#! %

%

#

#! #

-!"

- $+"' %&'**)

,-.- 12- "0="4.<B1 # 6-5:1-" 12- B.-"-54- :3 ! :5- B-.<:6 6-9!> <5 <DB9-D-51<5; !5

<54.-!"- <5 ;:8-.5D-51 "B-56<5;' E:$ -'!#".-+" .-B.-"-51" 12- <DB!41 :5 :01B01

!1 1<D- / :3 !5 <54.-!"- <5 ;:8-.5D-51 "B-56<5; !1 1<D- / " #' F5- 4!5 "2:/

12!1 12- D091<B9<-. <" <54.-!"<5; <5 12- B.:=!=<9<1>$ #$ 12!1 12- -4:5:D> .-D!<5"

<5 12- G-.: =:056' 72- D091<B9<-. :B-.!1-" 12.:0;2 12- -H-41 :3 ! 3010.- <54.-!"-

<5 ;:8-.5D-51 "B-56<5; :5 -IB-41-6 <5J!1<:5' K3 12- -4:5:D> <" <5 12- G-.:

=:056 <5 12- 3010.-$ !5 <54.-!"- <5 ;:8-.5D-51 B0.42!"-" <54.-!"-" 3010.- :01B01

!56 12-.-3:.- 3010.- <5J!1<:5' L.:D 12- B-."B-41<8- :3 1<D- / 12<" -H-41 9-!6" 1:

2<;2-. -IB-41-6 <5J!1<:5 !56 ! 9:/-. .-!9 <51-.-"1 .!1-' 72<" 9:/-. .-!9 <51-.-"1

.!1- .-604-" 6-"<.-6 "!8<5;" !56 <54.-!"-" 4:5"0DB1<:5 !56 :01B01 !1 1<D- /'

M8!90!1<5; -?0!1<:5 %&'**) !1 12- =-542D!.N 8!90-" /- :=1!<5 ! D091<B9<-.

-?0!9 1: )0*' O2<9- 12<" D091<B9<-. <" 9:/-. 12!5 12- =-542D!.N D091<B9<-. :3 +0,$

<1 <" "1<99 9!.;-' P:.-:8-.$ 12<" D091<B9<-. B-.1!<5" 1: !5 <54.-!"- <5 1:6!>Q" :01B01

<5 .-"B:5"- 1: ! !"##$%&' <54.-!"- <5 3010.- ;:8-.5D-51 4:5"0DB1<:5'

E0BB:"- 12!1 <1 1!N-" 1/: B-.<:6" 3:. ;:8-.5D-51 B0.42!"-" 1: <54.-!"- <5 12-

-8-51 12!1 12- G-.: =:056 <" =<56<5;' K1 <" "1.!<;213:./!.6 1: "2:/ 12!1 12- <DB!41

:5 40..-51 :01B01 :3 ! B:1-51<!9 <54.-!"- <5 ;:8-.5D-51 "B-56<5; 12!1 1!N-" 1/:

R*

Page 23: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"#$%&' (% $)!*")"+( $' ,$-"+ ./0

!"!"!!##

! $"! %

%

!!&!""

! ###$

"

"! $

!&#

! ###

"1

2"#" (3" '4.'5#$!( % &"+%("' (3" !#"'"+5" %6 7 (8% !"#$%& &"*7/1 9'$+, %4# ."+53:

)7#; !7#7)"("#' (3" -7*4" %6 (3$' )4*($!*$"# $' %'&'< '% (3" #7(" 7( 83$53 (3"

)4*($!*$"# &"5*$+"' 7' 8" $+5#"7'" (3" $)!*")"+(7($%+ *7, $' #"*7($-"*/ *%81

=3" 4'47* %.>"5($%+ (% 4'$+, ?'57* !%*$5/ 7' 7 (%%* 6%# ?,3($+, #"5"''$%+' $'

(37( (3"#" 7#" *%+, *7,' $+ ,"7#$+, 4! $+5#"7'"' $+ '!"+&$+,1 @4# 7+7*/'$' $+&$57("'

(37( (3" ;"/ A4"'($%+ $'0 $+ 83$53 '(7(" %6 (3" 8%#*& &%"' 7&&$($%+7* ,%-"#+)"+(

'!"+&$+, 5%)" %+ *$+"B C6 $( 5%)"' %+ *$+" $+ 64(4#" !"#$%&' 83"+ (3" D"#% .%4+&

$' .$+&$+, (3"#" $' 7 *7#," "E"5( %+ 54##"+( %4(!4(1 C6 $( 5%)"' %+ *$+" $+ 64(4#"

!"#$%&' 83"#" (3" D"#% .%4+& $' +%( .$+&$+, (3" 54##"+( "E"5( %+ ,%-"#+)"+(

'!"+&$+, $' ')7**"#1 F4!!%'"< 6%# "G7)!*"< (37( 7( ($)" ( (3" ,%-"#+)"+( !#%)$'"'

(% $)!*")"+( 7 !"#'$'("+( $+5#"7'" $+ ,%-"#+)"+( '!"+&$+, 7( ($)" ( $ "< $6 (3"

"5%+%)/ ")"#,"' 6#%) (3" D"#% .%4+& 7( ($)" ($"1 =3$' $+5#"7'" $+ ,%-"#+)"+(

!4#537'"' $' ,%-"#+"& ./0 ##!#$ ! (''$!" ##!#"< 6%# ) " %1 C+ (3$' 57'" (3" -7*4" %6

(3" )4*($!*$"#< !"!*!#!#"< $' %+*/ (') 6%# %4# ."+53)7#; -7*4"'1

F4!!%'"< ?+7**/ (37( ,%-"#+)"+( '!"+&$+, $+5#"7'"' .%(3 $+ !"#$%&' $+ 83$53

(3" D"#% .%4+& $' .$+&$+, 7+& $+ !"#$%&' $+ 83$53 $( $' +%(1 =3"+ (3" -7*4" %6 (3"

,%-"#+)"+( '!"+&$+, )4*($!*$"# 8$** ." $+ ."(8""+ (3" (8% !%*7# 57'"' &$'54''"&

7.%-"1

!"#$%&' ()*+,-%+-# ."+-/$-( =3" 675( (37( (3" ,%-"#+)"+( '!"+&$+, )4*:

($!*$"# $' '% *7#," $+ (3" D"#% .%4+& #7$'"' (3" 6%**%8$+, A4"'($%+0 (7;$+, 7' ,$-"+

(3" )%+"(7#/ !%*$5/ #4*" &"'5#$."& ./ "A47($%+ HI1JK 837( $' (3" %!($)7* *"-"* %6

,%-"#+)"+( '!"+&$+, 83"+ 7,"+(L' &$'5%4+( #7("' 7#" 3$,3B C+ 837( 6%**%8' 8"

4'" (3" '4!"#'5#$!( + (% &"+%(" (3" -7*4" %6 -7#$7.*"' $+ '(7("' %6 (3" 8%#*& 83"#"

II

Page 24: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"# $%&'()*! +,!# %& !!- .* !"#&# &!,!#& (/ !"# 0(+1$ !"# 2#+( 3()*$ 4,5 (+ 4,5

*(! 3# 3%*$%*6 $#7#*$%*6 (* !"# 1#8#1 (/ 6(8#+*4#*! &7#*$%*6- 9+(4 #:),!%(*

;<-=> 0# ,*!%'%7,!# !",! !"# "%6"#+ %& 6(8#+*4#*! &7#*$%*6? !"# "%6"#+ %& #@7#'!#$

%*A,!%(*? ,*$ !"# 1#&& 1%B#15 !"# 2#+( 3()*$ %& !( 3%*$-

C# '"((&# "" !( 4,@%4%2# !"# #@7#'!#$ )!%1%!5 (/ !"# '(*&)4#+ %* &!,!#& (/

!"# 0(+1$ %* 0"%'" !"# $%&'()*! /,'!(+ %& "%6" ,*$ !"# 2#+( 3()*$ %& 3%*$%*6- 9(+

*(0 0# ,&&)4# !",! %* (!"#+ &!,!#& (/ !"# 0(+1$ !" %& 2#+(- D(? 0# '"((&# "" !(

4,@%4%2#E

#" "!!

#!"

"$

# $ !!

## $%&%"'$%#!&"&#"$

(#"%! #

#! '$ (

&""')? ;<-FG>

"# $ !&

# $ !! ! $

$%&%"'$%#!&"&#"$

(#"%! #

#! '$ (

&""')-

H( #*&)+# !",! #" %& I*%!# 0# ,&&)4# !",! $ ) %# $ !!&-

J(!# !",!E

* " " &" " **!* " $ #

+?

%" " **!* " $ #

+!"

*!"" $ #

+-

D)3&!%!)!%*6 !"#&# #@7+#&&%(*& %*!( #:),!%(* ;<-FG> 0# (3!,%*E

#" "# $ !&

# $ !! ! $

,

-.

*/&*!* " $ #

+!&+

*!"" $ #

+0$%#!&

*!* " $ #

+&#"$

+#"%! #

#! '

1

23

$# $ !&

# $ !! ! $(/&+

*!"" $ #

+0-

C# '"((&# !"# 8,1)# (/ !"" !",! 4,@%4%2#& #" &)3K#'! !( !"# %*!#+!#47(+,1

L)1#+ ;#:),!%(* ;G-F<>>? !"# M"%11%7& ')+8# ;#:),!%(* ;G-FN>>? ,*$ !*# " !* "? !"# "

""? ,#% !"#$#& " $""? -#$# " -

"? ,#%-#$#& " $-"? ,*$ .#$# " .

"? 0"#+#

." " '()&/"0 *

'?

G<

Page 25: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"#

!! !"

"! " #

"

"

!#!$

! # #" $%!"$

%&' (!)* +,")*-!."* *!/') ."*, !++,0"* *&!* *&' 1'-, 2,0"# ," ."*'-')* -!*') 3!4

",* 2' 2."#."5 '6'" *&,05& *&' #.)+,0"* -!*' .) &.5&$

7."!((48 9,- ).3:(.+.*4 ;' !))03' *&!* &%'& .) 5.6'" 24<

& %'& ! ("'!!#

"! )$

=' +&,,)' (" ), *&!* * ! '+% .) '>0!( *, ',($

?."+' 5,6'-"3'"* :0-+&!)') !-' @"!"+'# ;.*& (03: )03 *!A') '>0!*.," BC$CDE

.3:(.') *&!*8 ." *&' )*'!#4 )*!*'8 *&' ,:*.3!( ('6'( ,9' &!) *&' :-,:'-*4 *&!* *&'

3!-5."!( 0*.(.*4 ,9 ' .) '>0!( *, *&' 3!-5."!( 0*.(.*4 ,9 +,")03:*.,"<

("'!# ! -.$#!!#$!!/ #!!$$#!!#$$

%&.) -'(!*.," .3:(.')<

(" ! - %)/ %"! *&*&$#!!#$!!/ #!!$$#!!#$ %/*&# $

F)."5 ,0- 2'"+&3!-/ :!-!3'*'- 6!(0') ;' ,2*!." ! 6!(0' ,9 (" '>0!( *, ','"+$

7.50-' G #.):(!4) *&' 6!(0') ,9 0!8 $% !8 !!8 $.!8 1!8 !"# $! !) ! 90"+*.,"

,9 $'!$ %&' HIJ ."#.+!*') *&' ('6'( ,9 ! 6!-.!2(' +,--'):,"#."5 *, *&' ,:*.3!(

6!(0' ,9 $'!$ %&' H,J ."#.+!*') *&' ('6'( ,9 ! 6!-.!2(' +,--'):,"#."5 *, *&' &.5&')*

6!(0' ,9 $'! *&!* )!*.)@') ! % " '$ K "032'- ,9 9'!*0-') ,9 7.50-' G !-' ;,-*&

",*."5$ 7.-)*8 *&' ,:*.3!( 6!(0' ,9 $'! .) 6'-4 (!-5'< -,05&(4 ,' :'-+'"* B-'+!((

*&!* ." )*'!#4 )*!*' 5,6'-"3'"* :0-+&!)') !-' (' :'-+'"* ,9 ,0*:0*E$ ?'+,"#8 9,-

*&.) :!-*.+0(!- :!-!3'*'-.1!*.," *&' ."+-'!)' ." 5,6'-"3'"* ):'"#."5 3,-' *&!"

0"#,') *&' 'L'+* ,9 *&' )&,+/ ;&.+& 3!#' *&' 1'-, 2,0"# +,")*-!."* 2."#$ M'-'8

5,6'-"3'"* :0-+&!)') -.)' *, *&' :,."* ;&'-' *&' 1'-, 2,0"# .) 3!-5."!((4 ","

CN

Page 26: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"#$"#% &#$ '()*() "+ &,)(&--. &!'/0 ")+ +)0&$. +)&)0 -0/0-1 230+0 -&+) )4' 50+(-)+

$0*0#$ '# )30 *&5&60)05 /&-(0+ )3&) 40 ,3'+0 &#$ '# '(5 &++(60$ 7(#,)"'#&-

7'56 7'5 !!"!"1 83&) "+ 5'!(+) &,5'++ $"9050#) &++(6*)"'#+ "+ )3&) ") "+ '*)"6&-

)' +(!+)&#)"&--. "#,50&+0 %'/05#60#) *(5,3&+0+ &#$ )3&) )30 %'/05#60#) +*0#$"#%

6(-)"*-"05 "+ -&5%0 430# )30 :05';!'(#$ ,'#+)5&"#) "+ !"#$"#%1

!"#$ %& '"(#)*%+ <# )3"+ +(!+0,)"'# 40 +3'4 )3&) $0=&)"'# 0>*0,)&)"'#+ ,&#

!0 +0-7;7(-?--"#%@ 6&A"#% )30 :05' !'(#$ !"#$"#% &#$ -0&$"#% )' & +")(&)"'# 43050

)30 %'/05#60#) 6(-)"*-"05 "+ -&5%01B C'#+"+)0#) 4")3 )30 "#)(")"'# $"+,(++0$ "# )30

"#)5'$(,)"'#@ +(**'+0 )3&) &%0#)+ 0>*0,) "#=&)"'# )' !0 #" $ # 4")3 *5'!&!"-").

'#01 D0,&-- )3&) $% " &#$ #" &50 %"/0# !. 0E(&)"'#+ FG1BH &#$ FG1IH1 J. ,'#+)5(,)"'#

)3050 &50 #' 7(#$&60#)&- +3',A+ )' )30 0,'#'6. +' )30 $"+,'(#) 7&,)'5 &" "+ 0E(&-

)' ")+ +)0&$. +)&)0 /&-(0 @ %'( ! %1 K(**'+0 )3&) $"" & #1 LE(&)"'#+ FG1BH &#$

FG1IH "6*-. )3&) #" &#$ $% " &50 %"/0# !.M

#" & ( ! %@

$% " &! !%! ("!

)!

"

"!#' $

"!$

" 1

N +0-7;7(-?--"#% 70&5 '7 $0=&)"'# 0E("-"!5"(6 0>"+)+ &+ -'#% &+ #" &#$ * " &50

#0%&)"/01 O050@ * " "+ )30 #'6"#&- "#)050+) 5&)0 "6*-"0$ !. 0E(&)"'# FP1QH@ 43",3 "+

%"/0# !.M

*" &%

(! % '

#%!

%

(

$%

&+"' +

!

! !%! ("

)!

"

"!#' $

"!$

"

'

( 1

B<) "+ 40-- A#'4# )3&) 2&.-'5 5(-0+ ,&# %0#05&)0 6(-)"*-0 0E("-"!5"(61 R'5 & 50,0#) &#&-.+"+)3&) 06*3&+":0+ )30 *')0#)"&- "6*'5)&#,0 '7 -"E("$"). )5&*+ +00 K,36"));S5'3T &#$ U5"!0 FPVVWH1K00 N$X'@ C'550"&@ &#$ 20-0+ FPVVWH &#$ )30 507050#,0+ )3050"# 7'5 & $"+,(++"'# '7 &-)05#&)"/06'#0)&5. *'-",. 5(-0+ )3&) &,3"0/0 & (#"E(0 0E("-"!5"(6 "# &# "#)050+)"#% ,-&++ '7 6'#0)&5.6'$0-+1

PB

Page 27: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"# $%&'%()# !! '* +#,%-'$# %* ).+, %* "! # ! %+/ "" ! "0 1'+2# $! '* %)3%4* +#,%5

-'$# % *#)6567)8))'+, 6#%& .6 /#9%-'.+ #:7')'(&'7; %)3%4* #<'*-*0 =- .7& (#+2";%&>

$%)7#* -"# %++7%)'?#/ $%)7# .6 $! '* ;'+7* 6.7& @#&2#+-A #% ! $ ""&""%0 B.-# -"%-

-"# $%)7# .6 #% ! '* &#)%-'$#)4 *;%)) 2.;@%&#/ -. -"# /&.@ '+ .7-@7- -"%- .227&* '+

.7& (#+2";%&> 2%*# '+ &#*@.+*# -. % 6%)) '+ -"# /'*2.7+- &%-#0 !"# &#%*.+ '* -"%-

/#*'&#/ *%$'+,* *"'6-* (4 )#** '+ &#*@.+*# -. -"# *#)6567)8))'+, &'*# '+ -"# &#%) '+-#&5

#*- &%-# -"%+ -"# *"'6- '+/72#/ (4 -"# (#+2";%&> /'*2.7+- &%&# *".2>0 C#2%7*#

-"# /#2)'+# '+ .7-@7- '* &#)%-'$#)4 *;%)) -"# ;7)-'@)'#& '* %)*. ;./#*- '+ -"'* 2%*#

D"&&%E0

!"# $#%& '&()* +)* ,)-#%#.- %+-# -+%/#-,)/ F+ -"'* *7(*#2-'.+ 3# 2.+*'/#&

-"# &#)%-'.+ (#-3##+ .7& %+%)4*'* .6 -"# ?#&. (.7+/ %+/ -"# ';@%2- .6 8*2%) @.)'24

3"#+ -"# ;.+#-%&4 %7-".&'-4 /#$'%-#* 6&.; -"# !%4).& &7)# %+/ *#-* -"# '+-#&#*-

&%-# -. ?#&. 6.& *.;# %;.7+- .6 -';#0 G#&# -"# '+-#&#*- &%-# /.#* +.- 6%)) -. ?#&.

'+ &#*@.+*# -. % *".2> -"%- ;%>#* -"# ?#&. (.7+/ ('+/'+, (#2%7*# -"# ;.+#-%&4

%7-".&'-4 '* 2.;;'--#/ -. % !%4).& &7)#0 F+*-#%/A -"# ?#&. '+-#&#*- &%-# &#9#2-* -"#

/#*'&# .6 -"# ;.+#-%&4 %7-".&'-4 -. #;(%&> .+ 7+7*7%) #<@%+*'.+%&4 ;.+#-%&4

@.)'240

17@@.*# -"%-A *-%&-'+, 6&.; -"# +.+5*-.2"%*-'2 *-#%/4 *-%-#A -"# ;.+#-%&4

%7-".&'-4 *#-* -"# +.;'+%) '+-#&#*- &%-# -. ?#&. %+/ >##@* '- -"#&# 3'-" @&.(%(')'-4

'0 F- '* *-&%',"-6.&3%&/ -. *".3 -"%-A 3"')#( '* #:7%) -. ?#&.A -"# &%-# .6 '+9%-'.+

%+/ -"# @#&2#+-%,# /#$'%-'.+ .6 .7-@7- 6&.; -"# *-#%/4 *-%-#A $! %+/ % !A %&#

,'$#+ (4 #:7%-'.+* DH0IE %+/ DH0JE0 G#&# )! '* #:7%) -. -"# *-#%/4 *-%-# $%)7# .6

-"# /'*2.7+- 6%2-.&A !*+ " !0 F6 #,! '* #:7%) -. ?#&. -"#+ $! %+/ #% ! %&# ,'$#+ (4K

$! $-!

!

!!"' #

!!#

"(!" +)

(!" +') (!" ')*(!" .)" '-!

!

!!"' #

!!#

" A

LJ

Page 28: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!! ! "#! "

#! #

!#! $ $ #%!

"!

"#$%& '(& )**(+,-.'#* %! )#$ !! ! )&% /'-0 ,'*.-.1% *' -0% 2%&' .#-%&%*- &)-% %34

,%&.+%#- .* )**'5.)-%$ 6.-0 .#7)-.'# )#$ )# .#5&%)*% .# '(-,(-!

8'#$.-.'#)9 '# -0% 2%&' .#-%&%*- &)-% ,'9.5: /%.#; )#)9:2%$< -0% ;'1%&#+%#-

*,%#$.#; +(9-.,9.%& .* ;.1%# /: %=()-.'# >?!@A! B0% C*5)9 +(9-.,9.%& .* %3)5-9:

-0% *)+% )* .# -0% 5)*% .# 60.50 -0% 2%&' /'(#$ .* /.#$.#;! B0% D%: $.E%&%#5%

.* -0)- .# '(& 2%&' /'(#$ %3,%&.+%#- -0% C*5)9 *-.+(9(* .* $%*.;#%$ -' '1%&5'+%

*-&'#; $%7)-.'#)&: ,&%**(&%* )#$ ) $%59.#% .# '(-,(-! F# -0% 5(&&%#- %3,%&.+%#-

-0% C*5)9 *-.+(9(* )$$* -' -0% .#7)-.'#)&: ,&%**(&%* )#$ -0% %3,)#*.'# .# '(-,(-

.* 5&%)-%$ /: )# %3';%#'(* *0.G- -' %3,)#*.'#)&: +'#%-)&: ,'9.5:!

H.#)99:< *(,,'*% -0)- G'& *'+% &%)*'# -0% +'#%-)&: )(-0'&.-: .* (#6.99.#; -'

9'6%& &)-%* /%9'6&!! I99 'G '(& &%*(9-*< .#59($.#; -0% 1)9(% 'G -0% +(9-.,9.%& .# -0%

9';49.#%)&.2%$ 1%&*.'# 'G -0% +'$%9 >%=()-.'# >?!@AA< 6'(9$ ;' -0&'(;0 G'& *0'5D*

-0)- )&% *(J5.%#-9: 9)&;% -' +)D% -0% 9'6%& /'(#$ /.#$.#;! K%&' .*< 'G 5'(&*%< )

#)-(&)9 1)9(% G'& &! /(- -0%&% .* #'-0.#; *,%5.)9 )/'(- 2%&' ,%& *%!

!" # $%&'( )*+, -./*+.( .0& $1(+*/(' 2,%-32

F# -0% ,&%1.'(* *%5-.'# 6% (*% ) *.+,9% +'$%9 6.-0'(- 5),.-)9 -' )&;(% -0)- -0%

;'1%&#+%#- *,%#$.#; +(9-.,9.%& .* 9)&;% 60%#%1%& -0% 2%&' /'(#$ '# -0% #'+.#)9

.#-%&%*- &)-% .* /.#$.#;! L%&% 6% *0'6 -0)- -0.* /)*.5 &%*(9- %3-%#$* -' ) ;%#%&4

)9.2%$ 1%&*.'# 'G -0% ,&%1.'(* +'$%9 .# 60.50 6% )99'6 G'& 5),.-)9 )55(+(9)-.'#!

F# )$$.-.'#< 6% 5'#*.$%& -0&%% -:,%* 'G *0'5D*M ) $.*5'(#-4G)5-'& *0'5D< ) #%(-&)9

-%50#'9';: *0'5D< )#$ ) 5),.-)94%+/'$.%$ -%50#'9';: *0'5D! B0%*% *0'5D* 0)1%

$.E%&%#- %E%5-* '# -0% /%0)1.'& 'G -0% +'$%9 %5'#'+:! N(-< .# )99 5)*%*< -0%

;'1%&#+%#- *,%#$.#; +(9-.,9.%& .* 9)&;% 60%#%1%& -0% 2%&' /'(#$ .* /.#$.#;!

OP

Page 29: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"# $%&#' !"# $%#&#%#'(#) *& +"# %#$%#)#'+,+-.# "*/)#"*01 ,%# 2-.#' 34 #5/,6

+-*') 789:; ,'1 789<;9 !"# "*/)#"*01=) 3/12#+ (*')+%,-'+ -) 2-.#' 34>

!!!"! ! #!$

!"!

"!%!!" " %! #$ !&!% !'!(! ! !!)

#!*! ! +!? 7@9:;

A"#%# #! 1#'*+#) -'.#)+B#'+? *! -) +"# )+*(C *& (,$-+,0? ,'1 )#! -) +"# %#,0 %#'+,0

%,+# *& (,$-+,09 !"# (,$-+,0 ,((/B/0,+-*' #5/,+-*' -) 2-.#' 34>

*!!" " #! ! #$! ,%*! !-$&

##!*!

! ,

$#*!9 7@9<;

!"# .,%-,30# .! %#$%#)#'+) , (,$-+,06#B3*1-#1 +#("'*0*24 )"*(C9 !"# $%-(# *&

-'.#)+B#'+ 2**1) -' /'-+) *& (*')/B$+-*' -) #5/,0 +* '()#!.!%9 D $*)-+-.# )"*(C

+* .! -) ,))*(-,+#1 A-+" , 1#(0-'# -' +"# $%-(# *& -'.#)+B#'+ 2**1)9 !"# $,%,B#+#%

-$ / * 2*.#%') +"# B,2'-+/1# *& ,1E/)+B#'+ (*)+) +* (,$-+,0 ,((/B/0,+-*'9 D)-$

"#? -'.#)+B#'+ ,'1 +"# )+*(C *& (,$-+,0 3#(*B# (*')+,'+9 !"# %#)/0+-'2 B*1#0

3#",.#) -' , B,''#% .#%4 )-B-0,% +* +"# *'# 1#)(%-3#1 -' +"# $%#.-*/) )#(+-*'9

!"# "*/)#"*01=) $%*30#B -) +* B,F-B-G# 0-&#6+-B# #F$#(+#1 /+-0-+4? 2-.#' 34

#5/,+-*') 789:; ,'1 789<;? )/3E#(+ +* +"# %#)*/%(# (*')+%,-'+) 2-.#' 34 #5/,+-*')

7@9:; ,'1 7@9<; ,'1 +"# (*'1-+-*'0$ +,-!"#%!!"1.#$!&$%#$!&"%222#$!&!%/ $ *9

H+ -) /)#&/0 +* 1#%-.# ,' #F$%#))-*' &*% !*3-'=) 3? -9#9 +"# .,0/# -' /'-+) *&

(*')/B$+-*' *& ,' ,11-+-*',0 /'-+ *& (,$-+,09 I# 1#'*+# +"-) .,0/# 34 3!9 J5/,6

+-*' 7@9:; -B$0-#) +",+ +"# %#,0 (*)+ *& -'(%#,)-'2 -'.#)+B#'+ 34 *'# /'-+ -) $!"!9

J5/,+-*' 7@9<; -B$0-#) +",+ -'(%#,)-'2 -'.#)+B#'+ 34 *'# /'-+ %,-)#) *!!" 34

$ ! -$

%$!%!

! ,&/'-+)9 H+ &*00*A) +",+ +"# *$+-B,0 0#.#0 *& -'.#)+B#'+ ),+-)K#)

+"# &*00*A-'2 #5/,+-*'>

$!"! " 3!

'$! -$

##!*!

! ,

$(9 7@98;

<L

Page 30: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"#$% !"# $%&'(#) &* +"# ,-.( /&&0 $%&012#%3 43 +"# 3.)# .3 4- +"# $%#54&13

3#2+4&-6 !"# 0432&1-+#0 $%&,+3 &* +"# !!" 4-+#%)#04.+# /&&0 ,%) .%# /45#- '78

"!

!!

#!"

#!##$!##"%!## !!"&!## !!"! !#! '"

#(!##)!## !!" $ %!##*

$!##+!##!!"

$%6

9:6:;

<1+$1+ &* /&&0 ! 43 /45#- '78

&! !!" % ,%! &+! !!"'

& &)! !!"'$"& =

>"#%# )! !!" .-0 +! !!" 0#-&+# +"# (.'&% .-0 2.$4+.( #)$(&7#0 '7 +"# !!" )&-&$?

&(43+6 !"# 5.%4.'(# -! %#$%#3#-+3 . -#1+%.( +#2"-&(&/7 3"&2@ +".+ 43 2&))&- +& .((

4-+#%)#04.+# /&&03 $%&012#%36

!"# )&-&$&(43+ 43 31'A#2+ +& +"# 3.)# B.(5&?3+7(# $%42#?3#++4-/ *%42+4&-3 0#?

32%4'#0 4- C#2+4&- D6 E#2.(( +".+ ' % #./ 0#-&+#3 . 31'3407 +".+ 43 $%&$&%+4&-.( +&

+"# 2&3+3 &* $%&012+4&-6 !"43 31'3407 2&%%#2+3 +"# 3+#.07?3+.+# 4-#F24#-27 2%#.+#0

'7 +"# $%#3#-2# &* )&-&$&(7 $&>#%6 !"# 5.%4.'(# $!## 43 +"# )1(+4$(4#% &- +"#

"&13#"&(0 '10/#+ 2&-3+%.4-+ 4- +"# G./%.-/4.- %#$%#3#-+.+4&- &* +"# "&13#"&(0

$%&'(#)6 H4%) ! ).I4)4J#3 4+3 0432&1-+#0 $%&,+3= /45#- '7 #K1.+4&- 9:6:;= 31'?

A#2+ +& +"# B.(5& $%42#?3#++4-/ *%42+4&-= +"# $%&012+4&- *1-2+4&-= .-0 +"# 0#).-0

*1-2+4&- *&% &! !!"= /45#- '7 #K1.+4&- 9D6:;6

!"# 2#-+%.( '.-@ *&((&>3 +"# 3.)# !.7(&% %1(# 0#32%4'#0 4- C#2+4&- D6 L# 2&)?

$1+# +"# /&5#%-)#-+ 3$#-04-/ )1(+4$(4#% .331)4-/ +".+ /&5#%-)#-+ 2&-31)$+4&-

4-2%#.3#3 '7 &-# $#%2#-+ &5#% 4+3 3+#.07 3+.+# 5.(1#= *&% .3 (&-/ .3 +"# J#%& '&1-0

43 '4-04-/6

&'(")"*#"($ !"# #2&-&)7M3 %#3&1%2# 2&-3+%.4-+ 438

0! $ 1!,"'

! $2! % &!3 9:6N;

DO

Page 31: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

! "#$%&'()* &+,-.-/)-,#0 -1 ( 2$..&2'-$% $3 1'$24(1'-2 5)$2&11&16

!!!" #!" $!" %!"&!" '!" (!" )!" '! !*" " +"

!" (! !*" " $! !*" " ,!" -!!"" .!"6

1,24 '4(' 3$) 7-8&% !/!" 0!" 1!" 2!"6 '4& 4$,1&4$.9 (%9 :)# 5)$/.&#1 ()& 1('-1:&96

'4& #$%&'()* 5$.-2* ),.& 7-8&% /* &+,('-$% &+,('-$% ;<=>? -1 1('-1:&96 #()@&'1

2.&()6 (%9 '4& (77)&7('& )&1$,)2& 2$%1')(-%' 4$.91=

!"#$%&'$()* !' '-#& A&)$ '4& &2$%$#* -1 -% -'1 %$%B1'$24(1'-2 1'&(9* 1'('&=

!' '-#& $%& (7&%'1 .&()% '4(' $%& $3 '4& '4)&& 14$2@1 ;+#6 1!6 $) 2!? 9-C&)1 3)$#

-'1 1'&(9* 1'('& 8(.,& 3$) 3 5&)-$91 (%9 '4&% )&',)%1 '$ -'1 1'&(9* 1'('& 8(.,&= D&

2$%1-9&) 14$2@1 '4(' ()& 1,E2-&%'.* .()7& 1$ '4(' '4& A&)$ /$,%9 $% '4& %$#-%(.

-%'&)&1' )('& -1 /-%9-%7 /&'F&&% 'F$ '-#& 5&)-$91 '4(' F& 9&%$'& /* 4" (%9 4#6

F4&)& # # 4" # 4# # 3 = G4& 8(.,&1 $3 4" (%9 4# ()& 9-C&)&%' 3$) 9-C&)&%' 14$2@1=>

D& 1$.8& '4& #$9&. ,1-%7 ( 14$$'-%7 (.7$)-'4#= H% 5)(2'-2& '4& @&* 9&'&)#-%(%'1

$3 '4& #,.'-5.-&) ()& 4" (%9 4#= G$ #(-%'(-% 2$#5()(/-.-'* F-'4 '4& 5)&8-$,1

1&2'-$% F& @&&5 '4& 1-A& $3 '4& 9-12$,%' 3(2'$) 14$2@ '4& 1(#& (%9 24$$1&3 $ #%=

H% '4-1 2(1& 4" &+,(.1 $%& (%9 4# &+,(.1 1-I= J$%1&+,&%'.*6 '4& .&%7'4 3$) F4-24

'4& A&)$ /$,%9 -1 /-%9-%7 (3'&) ( 9-12$,%' )('& 14$2@ -1 )$,74.* '4& 1(#& (1 -%

'4& #$9&. F-'4$,' 2(5-'(.=

D-'4 '4& &I2&5'-$% $3 5$ (%9 6 (.. 5()(#&'&)1 ()& '4& 1(#& (1 -% '4& &2$%$#*

F-'4$,' 2(5-'(.= D& 1&' 6 &+,(. '$ %7%&= D& 24$$1& '4& 8(.,& $3 5$ 1$ '4(' '4&

&.(1'-2-'* $3 #8% F-'4 )&15&2' '$ 9 -1 &+,(. '$ '4& 8(.,& -#5.-&9 /* '4& &1'-#('&1

-% K/&).*6 L&/&.$6 (%9 M-%2&%' ;<NNO?=P G4& )&1,.'-%7 8(.,& $3 5$ -1 &+,(. '$ #'=

>G4& 5)&2-1& '-#-%7 $3 F4&% '4& A&)$ /$,%9 2$%1')(-%' -1 /-%9-%7 #(* %$' /& ,%-+,&=PK/&).*6 L&/&.$ (%9 M-%2&%' ;<NNO? $/'(-% ( 5$-%' &1'-#('& $3 ! &+,(. '$ !"!" -% '4& )&7)&11-$%

#$% # &$! %&''(= G4-1 &1'-#('& -#5.-&1 ( 1'&(9* 1'('& &.(1'-2-'* $3 #!$%! F-'4 )&15&2' '$ G$/-%01

' $3 !"!"$(= Q,) '4&$)&'-2(. #$9&. -#5.-&1 '4(' '4-1 &.(1'-2-'* -1 &+,(. '$ ')"((!!= K+,('-%7

'4&1& 'F$ &.(1'-2-'-&1 *-&.91 ( 8(.,& $3 )" $3 )*=

RN

Page 32: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!" # $%&%$%'(% )*+', -% '*,% ,.#, -.%' ,.% /%$* 0*1'2 +" '*, 0+'2+'3 ,.%

3*4%$'5%', ")%'2+'3 516,+)6+%$ +" $*13.67 !!"8 9.+" 4#61% +" 6*-%$ ,.#' ,.% 4#61%

*& ,.% 516,+)6+%$ +' ,.% 5*2%6 -+,.*1, (#)+,#68 9.+" 6*-%$ 4#61% $%:%(," ,.% &#(,

,.#, #' +'($%#"% +' 3*4%$'5%', ")%'2+'3 ,%'2" ,* +'($%#"% $%#6 +',%$%", $#,%" #'2

($*-2 *1, )$+4#,% +'4%",5%',8 9.+" %;%(, +" '*, )$%"%', +' ,.% 5*2%6 -+,.*1,

(#)+,#68

! "#$%&'() *+%)&, $-&%. <% '*- (*'"+2%$ ,.% %;%(, *& #' +'($%#"% +' ,.%

2+"(*1', &#(,*$ &$*5 +," ",%#27 ",#,% 4#61% *& &*1$ )%$(%', =!>?@ ,*!# )%$(%',

=!>?@8 A+31$% B 2+")6#7" ,.% 27'#5+( $%")*'"% *& ,.% %(*'*57 ,* ,.+" ".*(C8 9.%

/%$* 0*1'2 +" 0+'2+'3 +' )%$+*2" *'% ,.$*13. "+D8 9.% .+3.%$ 2+"(*1', $#,% 6%#2"

,* "10",#',+#6 2%(6+'%" +' +'4%",5%',E .*1$" -*$C%2E *1,)1,E #'2 (*'"15),+*'8

9.% 6#$3% &#66 +' *1,)1, +" #""*(+#,%2 -+,. # &#66 +' 5#$3+'#6 (*", #'2 "10",#'F

,+#6 2%:#,+*'8 G+'(% ,.% '*5+'#6 +',%$%", $#,% +" /%$*E ,.% $%#6 +',%$%", $#,% $+"%"

".#$)678 <% '*- 2+"(1"" ,.% +',1+,+*' &*$ .*- +'4%",5%', #;%(," ,.% $%")*'"% *&

,.% %(*'*57 ,* # 2+"(*1', $#,% ".*(C8 <% 0%3+' 07 #'#67/+'3 -.7 # $+"% +' ,.% $%#6

+',%$%", $#,% +" #""*(+#,%2 -+,. # ".#$) 2%(6+'% +' +'4%",5%',8 H3'*$+'3 (*4#$+#'(%

,%$5"E ,.% .*1"%.*62I" J$",F*$2%$ (*'2+,+*' &*$ +'4%",5%', (#' 0% -$+,,%' #"K

"!

!# $#!!"$!!"%$!

"%#

&!"!'

"!()#!"

!!" *"!#

!!" +!!" $ =L8B@

#

&!"!

#&!!"

$&#! ,'!

-$(

!.!!")!!"

! ,

"#$ -$

!.!!")!!"

! ,

".!!")!!"

%&E

-.%$% +! +" ,.% +'4%$"% *& ,.% 5#$C1) $#,%8 MN1#,+*' =L8B@ +5)6+%" ,.#, +' %N1+F

6+0$+15 ,.% .*1"%.*62 %N1#,%" ,.% $%,1$'" ,* ,-* 2+;%$%', -#7" *& +'4%",+'3 *'%

1'+, *& (*'"15),+*'8 9.% J$", ",$#,%37 +" ,* +'4%", +' # 0*'2 ,.#, 7+%62" ,.% $%#6

+',%$%", $#,% 2%J'%2 07 ,.% 6%&,F.#'2 "+2% *& %N1#,+*' =L8B@8 9.% "%(*'2 ",$#,%37

+'4*64%" (*'4%$,+'3 ,.% (*'"15),+*' 3**2 +',* #%&! 1'+," *& +'",#66%2 (#)+,#68 9.%

OP

Page 33: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"#$!%& #' #()& *+,)#+- (+& #(!"" *'.,'%"%#&/ 0(" 1!&# *'.,'%"%# )& #(" .+!2

3)%+- ,!'4$*# '5 *+,)#+- 6#(" 1!&# #"!. '% #(" !)3(#2(+%4 &)4" '5 "7$+#)'% 68/9::/

0(" &"*'%4 *'.,'%"%# )& #(" ;+-$" '5 #(" $%4",!"*)+#"4 *+,)#+- )% *'%&$.,#)'%

$%)#& 6!!!" !"! "#:/ 0(" #()!4 *'.,'%"%# )& #(" ;+-$" )% *'%&$.,#)'% $%)#& '5 #("

!"4$*#)'% )% +4<$&#."%# *'&#& +&&'*)+#"4 =)#( +% )%*!"+&" )% )%&#+--"4 *+,)#+-/

0' ,!';)4" )%#$)#)'% )# )& $&"5$- #' *'%&)4"! #=' ">#!"." *+&"&? )%1%)#" +4<$&#2

."%# *'&#& 6#" $ ": +%4 @"!' +4<$&#."%# *'&#& 6#" $ %:/ A$,,'&" 1!&# #(+#

+4<$&#."%# *'&#& +!" )%1%)#"/ B)3$!" C 4)&,-+D& + &#D-)@"4 ;"!&)'% '5 #()& "*'%'.D/

E%;"&#."%# )& 1>"4 +%4 &+;)%3& +!" +% )%*!"+&)%3 5$%*#)'% '5 #(" !"+- )%#"!"&# !+#"/

0(" )%*!"+&" )% #(" 4)&*'$%# 5+*#'! *+% F" #('$3(# '5 +& )%4$*)%3 + !)3(#=+!4 &()5#

)% #(" &+;)%3& *$!;"/ G("% #()& &()5# )& ;"!D -+!3"? #(" !"+- )%#"!"&# !+#" *+%%'# 5+--

FD "%'$3( #' !"2"&#+F-)&( "7$)-)F!)$./ 0(" )%#$)#)'% 5'! #()& !"&$-# +%4 #(" !'-"

,-+D"4 FD #(" @"!' F'$%4 '% %'.)%+- )%#"!"&# !+#"& )& #(" &+." +& )% #(" .'4"-

=)#('$# *+,)#+-/ 0(+# .'4"- +-&' ,!';)4"& )%#$)#)'% 5'! =(D #(" "7$)-)F!)$. )&

*(+!+*#"!)@"4 FD + -+!3"? #".,'!+!D 5+-- )% '$#,$#? 4"H+#)'%? +%4 + !)&" )% #(" !"+-

)%#"!"&# !+#"/

A$,,'&" %'= #(+# #("!" +!" %' +4<$&#."%# *'&#& 6#" $ %:/ E% #()& *+&" 0'F)%I&

! )& "7$+- #' $!# +%4 "7$+#)'% 68/9: &).,-)1"& #'J

%!" &&!!"'!!"('!

$ %!!$$!)*%!"

!!" +"!%!!" ,!!" & !"! "#

"/

K**'!4)%3 #' #()& "7$+#)'% +% )%*!"+&" )% #(" !"+- )%#"!"&# !+#" .$&# F" .+#*("4

FD +% )%*!"+&" )% #(" .+!3)%+- ,!'4$*# '5 *+,)#+-/ E% 3"%"!+- #(" -+##"! )& +**'.2

,-)&("4? +# -"+&# )% ,+!#? FD + 5+-- )% *!!" *+$&"4 FD + -+!3" 4!', )% )%;"&#."%#/

E% B)3$!" C #(" 4'=%=+!4 &-',)%3 *$!;" -+F"-"4 L"-+&#)* )%;"&#."%#I 4",)*#& #("

%"3+#);" !"-+#)'% F"#=""% #(" !"+- )%#"!"&# !+#" +%4 )%;"&#."%# )% #(" +F&"%*" '5

+%D +4<$&#."%# *'&#&/ K& 4!+=% #(" &()5# )% #(" &+;)%3& *$!;" .';"& #(" "7$)-)F2

!)$. #' ,')%# - +%4 4'"& %'# *+$&" #(" @"!' F'$%4 #' F)%4/ A'? #(" !"&$-# '5 +%

MN

Page 34: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"#$%&'% !" ()% *!'#+,"( $&(% !' & -&.. !" ()% $%&. !"(%$%'( $&(% &"* & $!'% !" '&/!"0'

&"* !"/%'(1%"(2

3+4 #+"'!*%$ & /&.,% +- !! ()&( !' 5%(4%%" 6%$+ &"* !"7"!(82 9" ()!' #&'% 5+()

!"/%'(1%"( &"* " $%':+"* (+ ()% ')!-( !" ()% *!'#+,"( -&#(+$2 ;+$ +,$ :&$&1%(%$

/&.,%' ()% )!0)%$ ()% &*<,'(1%"( #+'(' ()% 1+$% .!=%.8 !( !' ()&( ()% 6%$+ 5+,"* !'

5!"*!"02 9" (%$1' +- ;!0,$% > & )!0)%$ /&.,% +- !! #&" 5% ()+,0)( +- &' 0%"%$&(!"0

& '(%%:%$ '.+:% !" ()% !"/%'(1%"( #,$/%? (),' !"#$%&'!"0 ()% .!=%.!)++* ()&( ()%

6%$+ 5+,"* 5!"*'2

@,::+'% ()&( ()% 6%$+ 5+,"* !' 5!"*!"02 A()%$ ()!"0' %B,&.? & )!0)%$ $%&.

!"(%$%'( $&(% !"#$%&'%' *%'!$%* '&/!"0 &"* *%#$%&'%' *%'!$%* !"/%'(1%"(2 @+ ()% -&..

!" +,(:,( 1,'( 5% .&$0%$ (+ %B,&(% ()% (4+2 C)!' .&$0%$ -&.. !" +,(:,( !' ,"*+"%

58 &" !"#$%&'% !" 0+/%$"1%"( :,$#)&'%'2 D+"'!'(%"( 4!() ()!' !"(,!(!+" ;!0,$% E

')+4' ()&( ()% 0+/%$"1%"( ':%"*!"0 1,.(!:.!%$ !' /%$8 .&$0% 4)%" ()% 6%$+ 5+,"*

5!"*' F+" !1:&#( #$%#& !' $+,0).8 %B,&. (+ -+,$G2 C)!' 1,.(!:.!%$ !' &#(,&..8

.&$0%$ ()&" !" ()% 1+*%. 4!()+,( #&:!(&.2

H "&(,$&. B,%'(!+" !' 4)&( )&::%"' (+ ()% '!6% +- ()% 1,.(!:.!%$ &' 4% !"#$%&'%

()% ')+#=2 I%#&.. ()&( !" ()% 1+*%. 4!()+,( #&:!(&.? &' .+"0 &' ()% 6%$+ 5+,"*

!' 5!"*!"0? ()% '!6% +- ()% ')+#= *+%' "+( &J%#( ()% '!6% +- ()% 1,.(!:.!%$2 C)%

&"&.+0,% $%',.( )%$%? %'(&5.!')%* ,'!"0 ",1%$!#&. 1%()+*'? !' ()&( ()% '!6% +- ()%

')+#= *+%' "+( &J%#( ()% 1,.(!:.!%$ &' .+"0 &' !( *+%' "+( &J%#( '! &"* '"2 ;+$ &

0!/%" '! ()% '!6% +- ()% 1,.(!:.!%$ !' *%#$%&'!"0 !" '"2 ;+$ %K&1:.%? ',::+'% ()&(

')+#= !' ',#) ()&( '" !' %B,&. (+ -+,$ !"'(%&* +- ()% 5%"#)1&$= /&.,% +- '!K2 9" ()!'

#&'% ()% /&.,% +- ()% 1,.(!:.!%$ -&..' -$+1 !(" (+ #(!2 C)% .&((%$ /&.,% !' '(!.. 1,#)

.&$0%$ ()&" $("? ()% /&.,% +- ()% 1,.(!:.!%$ 4)%" ()% 6%$+ 5+,"* !' "+( 5!"*!"02

LL

Page 35: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

! "#$%&'( %#)*"+(+,- .*+)/ !" #$% &$#'()"* +," "-"&+ $. / +"01$*/*23 +,*""4

1"*&"#+ (#&*"/'" (# +," #"5+*/6 +"&,#$6$72 ',$&83 !!9: ;(75*" : )('16/2' +," )24

#/0(& *"'1$#'" $. +," "&$#$02 +$ +,(' ',$&89 <," ="*$ >$5#) (' >(#)(#7 (# 1"*($)'

$#" +,*$57, "(7,+9? @+*(8(#7623 +," 1$'(+(A" +"&,#$6$72 ',$&8 6"/)' +$ / )"&6(#"

(# $5+15+3 (#A"'+0"#+3 &$#'501+($#3 /#) ,$5*' %$*89 <," ',$&8 /6'$ 6"/)' +$ /

',/*1 *('" (# +," *"/6 (#+"*"'+ */+" /#) +$ '5>'+/#+(/6 )"B/+($#9 <$ 5#)"*'+/#)

+,"'" "-"&+' (+ (' 5'".56 +$ >"7(# >2 &$#'()"*(#7 +," "-"&+' $. / +"&,#$6$72 ',$&8

%,"# %" />'+*/&+ .*$0 +," ="*$ >$5#)9 C +*/#'(+$*2 +"&,#$6$72 ',$&8 +*(77"*'

/ *"6/+(A"62 '0/66 *('" (# &$#'501+($# /#) / *"6/+(A"62 6/*7" *('" (# (#A"'+0"#+9

D+,"* +,(#7' "E5/63 +," "F1/#'($# (# $5+15+ 6"/)' +$ / *('" (# 0/*7(#/6 &$'+ /#)

+," */+" $. (#B/+($#9 G$%"A"*3 +," )(*"&+ (01/&+ $. +," +"&,#$6$72 ',$&8 $# 0/*4

7(#/6 &$'+ )$0(#/+"' /#) 7"#"*/+"' '+*$#7 )"B/+($#/*2 1*"''5*"'9 C </26$* *56"

%(+, / 6/*7" &$"H&("#+ $# (#B/+($# *"6/+(A" +$ $5+15+ )(&+/+"' +,/+ +," &"#+*/6

>/#8 6$%"* *"/6 */+"' +$ *")5&" +," */+" $. )"B/+($#9 I. +," +"&,#$6$72 ',$&8 ('

6/*7" "#$57,3 +," ="*$ >$5#) >"&$0"' >(#)(#79 C+ +,(' 1$(#+ +," *"/6 (#+"*"'+ */+"

0/2 '(0162 >" +$$ ,(7, +$ "E5/+" )"'(*") '/A(#7' /#) (#A"'+0"#+9 <," (#+5(+($#

.$* %,/+ ,/11"#' %,"# +," ="*$ >$5#) (' >(#)(#7 (' "F/&+62 +," '/0" /' .$* +,"

)('&$5#+ ./&+$* ',$&89 <," 8"2 1$(#+ (' +,/+ +," $#62 %/2 +$ *")5&" )"'(*") '/A(#7'

(' +$ ,/A" / +"01$*/*2 6/*7" ./66 (# $5+15+9 C' %(+, +," )('&$5#+ */+" ',$&8 $#&"

+," ="*$ >$5#) >(#)'3 +," 7$A"*#0"#+ '1"#)(#7 056+(16("* *('"' )*/0/+(&/662 J'""

;(75*" :K9

!" L#) +,/+ +," 6$%"'+ A/65" $. "" .$* %,(&, / #"5+*/6 +"&,#$6$72 ',$&8 *"#)"*'

+," ="*$ >$5#) >(#)(#7 (' !#!9 M""1(#7 "" /+ (+' >"#&,0/*8 A/65" +," '0/66"'+

:D5* .$*056/+($# $. +," </26$* *56" /''50"' +,/+ +," #/+5*/6 */+" $. $5+15+ (' &$#'+/#+ /#)"E5/6 +$ +," 6"A"6 $. $5+15+ (# +," '+"/)2 '+/+"9 I# *"/6(+23 +," 0$#"+/*2 /5+,$*(+2 &$56) %"66*"A('" (+' "'+(0/+" $. +," #/+5*/6 */+" (# *"'1$#'" +$ / 1"*'('+"#+ +"&,#$6$72 ',$&89 ;$* '(016(&(+2%" />'+*/&+ .*$0 +,(' 1$''(>(6(+29

?I# &$015+(#7 +," 7$A"*#0"#+ '1"#)(#7 056+(16("* %" '"+ !!! +$ N9O 1"*&"#+ (# 1"*($)' $#"+,*$57, "(7,+9

PQ

Page 36: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"#$%&' $"()!*'*+, -)*(. /*% 0)1() $)" 2"%* 3*#!4 31!4- 1- !!" 5"%("!$ 6789:;

7+&1!< &- '*!+ &- $)" 2"%* 3*#!4 31!4-< $)" =#'$15'1"% 1- %"'&$1>"', 1!-"!-1$1>" $*

$)" -12" */ $)" -)*(.;

!" #"$%&'(%"')&*%+#,+ &-.+/ ?" !*0 (*!-14"% $)" "@"($ */ & $"=5*%&%,

"1+)$ 5"%("!$ 1!(%"&-" 1! $)" 5%1(" */ 1!>"-$="!$ +**4- 61;"; &! "1+)$ 5"%("!$

/&'' 1! "!:; A1+#%" B 41-5'&,- $)" 4,!&=1( %"-5*!-" */ $)" "(*!*=, $* $)1- -)*(.;

C>"! $)*#+) $)" -)*(. $)&$ 0" (*!-14"% 1- >"%, '&%+"< $)" 2"%* 3*#!4 31!4- *!', 1!

5"%1*4- *!" $)%*#+) $)%"";DE F! &441$1*!< $)" "@"($- */ $)" -)*(. *! $)" "(*!*=,

&%" -=&'' %"'&$1>" $* $)" "@"($- */ $)" *$)"% -)*(.- $)&$ 0" 41-(#--"4; G*< 0)1'"

$)" =#'$15'1"% 1- ("%$&1!', '&%+" 0)"! $)" 2"%* 3*#!4 31!4-< 1$ 1- =#() -=&''"%

$)&! 1! $)" (&-"- $)&$ 0" )&>" &'%"&4, &!&',2"4;

H)" -)*(. '"&4- $* & 4"('1!" 1! *#$5#$< 1!>"-$="!$< (*!-#=5$1*!< &!4 )*#%-

0*%."4; F$ 1- &'-* &--*(1&$"4 01$) 4"I&$1*! &!4 & %1-" 1! $)" %"&' 1!$"%"-$ %&$";

H* #!4"%-$&!4 )*0 $)" 2"%* 3*#!4 (&! 3"(*=" 31!41!+ 1! %"-5*!-" $* $)1- -)*(.<

(*!-14"% $)" 1=5&($ *! $)" "(*!*=, 0)"! $)" 2"%* 3*#!4 4*"- !*$ 31!4; F!

$)1- (&-" *#$5#$ /&''-; H)1- /&'' *((#%- 3"(&#-" $)" 1!>"-$="!$- 3"(*=" =*%"

"J5&!-1>"< %"4#(1!+ $)" 1!("!$1>" $* 0*%.; K*!-#=5$1*! &'-* /&''- 3"(&#-" */

$)" !"+&$1>" 0"&'$) "@"($ */ $)" -)*(.; L$)"% $)1!+- "M#&'< $)" /&'' 1! *#$5#$

1- &--*(1&$"4 01$) -$%*!+ 4"I&$1*!&%, 5%"--#%"-; G#55*-" $)&$ $)"-" 4"I&$1*!&%,

5%"--#%"- 5%"4*=1!&$"; H)" /&'' 1! *#$5#$ &!4 4"I&$1*! '"&4 $)" ("!$%&' 3&!.

$* '*0"% !*=1!&' 1!$"%"-$ %&$"-; A*% & -#N(1"!$', '&%+" -)*(.< $)" 2"%* 3*#!4

3"(*="- 31!41!+; H)" 1!$#1$1*! /*% 0)&$ )&55"!- 0)"! $)" 2"%* 3*#!4 1- 31!41!+

1- "J&($', $)" -&=" &- /*% $)" 41-(*#!$ /&($*% -)*(. &!4 $)" !"#$%&' $"()!*'*+,

-)*(.;

?" O!4 $)&$ 2"%* 3*#!4 (*!$1!#"- $* 31!4 ">"! /*% >"%, '*0 >&'#"- */ #" 6";+;

DEF! (*=5#$1!+ $)" +*>"%!="!$ -5"!41!+ =#'$15'1"% 0" -"$ !!! $* *!" 5"%("!$ 1! 5"%1*4- *!"<$0*< &!4 $)%"";

PQ

Page 37: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!! ! "!" #$$%&'( !! )* &*+ ,$'-./)01 2)34$ *.$ +/)33$+* &'2$+*/$'*5+%$-&6- +.7-1

870 9.&-. *.$ :$07 ,74'; ,&';+ &+ +&< %$0-$'*" ='-$ )()&'> )+ 37'( )+ *.$ :$07

,74'; ,&';+> *.$ /43*&%3&$0 &+ 0$3)*&2$3? &'+$'+&*&2$ *7 *.$ +&:$ 78 *.$ +.7-1"

!" #$%&'()*'' +)+,-'.'

@' %0$2&74+ +$-*&7'+ 9$ $/%.)+&:$ *.$ 0$+%7'+$ 78 )((0$()*$ ;$/)'; *7 +.7-1+

)+ ) 1$? /$-.)'&+/ 9.&-. /)1$+ *.$ :$075,74'; -7'+*0)&'* ,&';&'(" @' ($'$0)3

*.$ 3)0($0 &+ *.$ 8)33 &' )((0$()*$ ;$/)';> *.$ 3)0($0 &+ *.$ 8)33 &' 74*%4* )';

*.$ 3)0($0 &+ *.$ (72$0'/$'* +%$';&'( /43*&%3&$0 9.$' *.$ :$07 ,74'; -7'+*0)&'*

,&';+" @' *.&+ +$-*&7' 9$ /7;&8? 740 ,$'-./)01 )')3?+&+ *7 -7'+&;$0 2)0&74+

+740-$+ 78 &'$0*&) &' )((0$()*$ ;$/)';"

!"/" 0) +,(*1)+(.2* 3$14 $3 .)2*'(4*)( +56&'(4*)( 7$'('

@' *.&+ +4,+$-*&7' 9$ ;7-4/$'* *.$ +$'+&*&2&*? 78 740 -)3-43)*&7'+ *7 *.$ 870/ 78

&'2$+*/$'* );A4+*/$'* -7+*+ %07%7+$; ,? BCC" D.&+ +%$-&6-)*&7' &+ 78*$' 4+$;

&' *.$ /)-07$-7'7/&-+ 3&*$0)*40$ ,$-)4+$ &* ($'$0)*$+ &/%43+$ 0$+%7'+$+ *7 /7'5

$*)0? %73&-? +.7-1+ *.)* )0$ -7'+&+*$'* 9&*. *.7+$ $+*&/)*$; 4+&'( 2$-*70 )4*75

0$(0$++&7'+"

E--70;&'( *7 *.&+ +%$-&6-)*&7' *.$ 3)9 78 /7*&7' 870 &'2$+*/$'* &+ (&2$' ,?F

""!" ! #"! #$"" %

!"! $

"%"

%"!"

#$" GH"I!

D.$ 84'-*&7' $ &+ &'-0$)+&'(> -7'2$<> )'; +)*&+8? *.$ 873379&'( -7';&*&7'+F $#"$ !

$ "#"$ ! && )'; $ ""#"$ ' &" J$ )++4/$ *.)* $ ""#"$ ! ' 9.&-. &+ -37+$ *7 *.$ 2)34$

$+*&/)*$; ,? K/$*+ )'; J74*$0+ GLMMN!"

O&(40$+ II> IL )'; IP 0$%70* *.$ 0$+%7'+$ 78 *.$ $-7'7/? 9.$' *.$ :$07 ,74';

&+ ,&';&'( *7 ) ;&+-74'* 8)-*70 +.7-1> ) '$4*0)3 *$-.'737(? +.7-1> )'; ) -)%&*)3

PQ

Page 38: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"#$%&!% '($)*+ ,!'-!).&/!012 3(! -,!)&'! !4-!,&"!5.' 6,! .(! '6"! 6' .($'!

75%!,01&58 9&87,!' :+ ; 65% <=2

>))$,%&58 .$ 9&87,! <=+ .(! ?!,$ #$75% &' #&5%&58 &5 -!,&$%' $5! .(,$78(

'&4 6@.!, 6 %&')$75. @6).$, '($)*2 A$"-6,&58 9&87,!' : 65% << B! '!! .(6. .(!

"6&5 &"-6). $@ "$/&58 .$ .(! ACC 6%D7'."!5. )$'. '-!)&E)6.&$5 &' .$ ,!%7)!

.(! @600 &5 &5/!'."!5. 65% $7.-7. .(6. $))7,' 6@.!, .(! '($)*2 F$. '7,-,&'&5801+

.(! 8$/!,5"!5. '-!5%&58 "70.&-0&!, &' '"600!, .(65 .(! $5! B! $#.6&5 7'&58 .(!

#!5)("6,* 6%D7'."!5. )$'. '-!)&E)6.&$5 G!!" /!,'7' #!$ $5 &"-6).H2 F!/!,.(!0!''+

.(! "70.&-0&!, &' "7)( 06,8!, .(65 &. B$70% #! &@ .(! ?!,$ #$75% B!,! 5$. #&5%&582

3$ !'.6#0&'( .(&' ,!'70. B! )60)706.! .(! 8$/!,5"!5. '-!5%&58 "70.&-0&!, '!..&58

%"! &%"" &5 -!,&$%' $5! .(,$78( '&4 6@.!, .(! '($)* $))7,'2 3(! ,!'70.&58 &"-6).

"70.&-0&!, &' $501 '!$(2

9&87,! << '($B' .(6. 6@.!, 6 5!7.,60 .!)(5$0$81 '($)* .(! ?!,$ #$75% &' #&5%&58

&5 -!,&$%' $5! .(,$78( '!/!52 >86&5+ .(! "6&5 &"-6). $@ "$/&58 .$ .(! ACC

6%D7'."!5. )$'. '-!)&E)6.&$5 &' .$ ,!%7)! .(! @600 &5 &5/!'."!5. 65% $7.-7. 6@.!,

.(! '($)* $))7,'2 3(! 8$/!,5"!5. '-!5%&58 "70.&-0&!, $5 &"-6). &' '"600!, .(65

B! $#.6&5 B&.( .(! #!5)("6,* 6%D7'."!5. )$'. '-!)&E)6.&$5 G#!) /!,'7' (!*H2 I7.+

686&5+ .(! "70.&-0&!, &' "7)( 06,8!, .(65 &. B$70% #! &@ .(! ?!,$ #$75% B!,! 5$.

#&5%&582 3(! "70.&-0&!, 6''$)&6.!% B&.( '!..&58 %"! & %"" &5 -!,&$%' $5! .(,$78(

'!/!5 6@.!, .(! '($)* $))7,' &' $501 '!++2<<

9&87,! <J '($B' .(6. 6 %&K!,!5. -6..!,5 !"!,8!' 6@.!, 65 &5/!'."!5.L'-!)&E)

'($)*2 M!,! .(! ?!,$ #$75% &' 5$. &""!%&6.!01 #&5%&58 #7. %$!' #!)$"! #&5%&58

&5 -!,&$%' @$7, .(,$78( !&8(.2 N5 .(&' )6'! .(! "70.&-0&!, 6).76001 ,&'!' @,$" !!#

.$ #!# B(!5 B! "$/! .$ .(! ACC 6%D7'."!5. )$'. '-!)&E)6.&$52

<<3(! ,!6'$5 B(1 .(! 5$5L?!,$ #$75% .!)(5$0$81 '($)* "70.&-0&!, &' 0$B!, .(65 .(! 6560$87!%&')$75. ,6.! '($)* "70.&-0&!, G!!"#H &' .(6. B! 6,! &5),!6'&58 $"! @$, $5! "$,! -!,&$% &5 .(!E,'. )6'!+ '$ .(!,! &' 6 '.,$58!, 5!86.&/! B!60.( !K!).' $5 )$5'7"-.&$5 B(&)( %,&/!' %$B5 .(!"70.&-0&!,2

O:

Page 39: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!" #$%%&'() *+, ',#$-*# ./ *+0# #$1#,2*0." #+.3 *+&* .$' 1&#02 2."2-$#0." &1.$*

*+, %$-*04-0,' 0# '.1$#*5 6.7,'"%,"* #4,"80"6 +&# & %$2+ 1066,' 0%4&2* ." .$*4$*

3+," *+, ,2.".%( 0# 0" *+, 9,'. 1.$"8 *+&" $"8,' ".'%&- 20'2$%#*&"2,#:

!"#" $%& '()*+,)+&- +. / '&0+('12+3& 4567 '80&)

!" *+0# #$1#,2*0." 3, 80#2$## *+, #09, ./ *+, %$-*04-0,' 0%4-0,8 1( *+, %.8,-

0" ;-*06) <+'0#*0&".) =02+,"1&$%) &"8 >0"8? @ABBCD: E+0# %.8,- 0# ,#*0%&*,8

*. %&*2+ *+, ,#*0%&*,8 0%4$-#, ',#4."#, /$"2*0." ./ *," &66',6&*, F:G: *0%,

#,'0,# *. *+',, 08,"*0H,8 #+.2I#5 & ",$*'&- *,2+".-.6( #+.2I) & 2&40*&-J,%1.80,8

*,2+".-.6( #+.2I &"8 & %.",*&'( 4.-02( #+.2I: E+, *," &66',6&*, *0%, #,'0,#

0"2-$8, %,&#$',# ./ *+, 2+&"6, 0" *+, ',-&*07, 4'02, ./ 0"7,#*%,"*) *+, 2+&"6, 0"

&7,'&6, 4'.8$2*070*() *+, 2+&"6, 0" *+, KLM 8,N&*.') 2&4&20*( $*0-09&*0.") 4,'

2&40*& +.$'# 3.'I,8) *+, ',&- 3&6,) *+, #+&',# ./ 2."#$%4*0." &"8 0"7,#*%,"* 0"

KLM) *+, O,8,'&- O$"8# P&*, &"8 *+, 7,-.20*( ./ %.",(: E+, #&%4-, 4,'0.8 0#

QRCR:SA *. ABBT:SU: O.' 2.%4&'&10-0*( 3, #,* *+, 7&-$, ./ ! !!!"# $ %" *+, 7&-$,

$#,8 0" *+, 4',70.$# #$1#,2*0.":

E+, %.8,- 0"2-$8,# & 7&'0,*( ./ /'02*0."# *+&* &', $#,/$- *. %&*2+ *+, ,#*0J

%&*,8 0%4$-#, ',#4."#, /$"2*0."#: E+,#, /'02*0."# 0"2-$8,5 #*02I( 3&6,#) #*02I(

4'02,#) 7&'0&1-, 2&40*&- $*0-09&*0.") &"8 *+, <== &8V$#*%,"*J2.#* #4,20H2&*0.":

E+, ',4',#,"*&*07, &6,"*W# %.%,"*&'( $*0-0*( 0# 607," 1( ,X$&*0." @A:AAD) %.80J

H,8 *. 0"2-$8, 0"*,'"&- +&10* /.'%&*0." 0" 2."#$%4*0.": Y.*+ +&10* /.'%&*0." &"8

*+, <== #4,20H2&*0." /.' &8V$#*%,"* 2.#*# #-.3 8.3" *+, ',#4."#, ./ &66',6&*,

8,%&"8 *. #+.2I#:

Z$' I,( H"80"6 0# *+&* 0" .'8,' /.' *+, 9,'. 1.$"8 *. 1, 10"80"6) #+.2I# %$#*

1, -&'6,' *+&" 0" .$' 1,"2+%&'I #4,20H2&*0.": Y$*) ."2, *+, ,2.".%( 0# 0" *+,

9,'. 1.$"8 *+, 6.7,'"%,"* #4,"80"6 %$-*04-0,' 0# %$2+ -&'6,' *+&" 0*# ".'%&-

7&-$,:

UT

Page 40: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"# $%&'()$* +,(("+$ -.&- -.$ /0+1",2- #&-$ '"3$+ 4#"' ! ($#1$2- -" !"#!$

($#1$2- "2 &2 &22,&) 5&+0+ 4"# -$2 ($#0"/+6 7.$2 -.$ 8$#" 5",2/ 0+ 502/029 5$-:$$2

($#0"/+ -:" &2/ ;; &2/ -.$ 9"3$#2'$2- +($2/029 ',)-0()0$# 0+ %!! "2 0'(&1-6 7.$

&2&)"9,$ ',)-0()0$# :.$2 -.$ 8$#" 5",2/ 0+ 2"- 502/029 0+#!&6 7.$ )&--$# ',)-0()0$#

0+ 1"'(,-$/ 5< #&0+029 '"! -" '""

!02 ($#0"/+ -:" -" ;;6 =,(("+$ -.&- -.$ 2$,-#&)

-$1.2")"9< +."1> 4&))+ 5< !!$ ($#1$2- 4"# -$2 ($#0"/+6 7.$2 -.$ 8$#" 5",2/ 0+

502/029 4#"' ($#0"/ -.#$$ -" 202$ &2/ -.$ 9"3$#2'$2- +($2/029 ',)-0()0$# 0+ "!%

"2 0'(&1-6 7.0+ ',)-0()0$# 0+ +-0)) +,5+-&2-0&))< )&#9$# -.&2 -.$ ',)-0()0$# ",-+0/$

"4 -.$ 8$#" 5",2/* :.01. 0+ #!(6 7.$ )&--$# ',)-0()0$# 0+ 1"'(,-$/ 5< #&0+029

'"! -" '""

!02 ($#0"/+ +0% -" 202$6 ?2-$#$+-029)<* :$ 1",)/ 2"- @2/ & #$&+"2&5)$

1&(0-&)A$'5"/0$/ -$1.2")"9< +."1> -.&- '&>$+ -.$ 8$#" 5",2/ 502/0296 7.0+

#$+,)- #$B$1-+ -.$ :$&> /0#$1- $C$1- "4 -.0+ +."1> "2 &99#$9&-$ /$'&2/ 1",()$/

:0-. -:" 4$&-,#$+ -.&- ',-$ -.$ 0'(&1- "4 & 903$2 +."1> "2 &99#$9&-$ /$'&2/D

.&50- 4"#'&-0"2 &2/ -.$ EFF +($10@1&-0"2 4"# 023$+-'$2- &/G,+-'$2- 1"+-+6

H+029 & '"/$) +0'0)&# -" -.$ "2$ 02 I)-09 $- &)6 JKLLMN* E"9&2* E:0>* 7&<)"#*

&2/ O0$)&2/ JKLLPN #$("#- 3&),$+ "4 -.$ ',)-0()0$# -.&- &#$ &#",2/ "2$ 4"# $%A

($#0'$2-+ 02 :.01. '"2$-&#< (")01< 0+ 3$#< &11"''"/&-03$* 2&'$)< -.$ 2"'02&)

02-$#$+- #&-$ 0+ +$- -" 8$#" 4"# "2$ "# -:" <$&#+6 7.$#$ &#$ -.#$$ >$< /0C$#$21$+ 5$A

-:$$2 -.$0# $%($#0'$2- &2/ ",#+6 !0#+-* 02 -.$0# $%($#0'$2- -.$ 2"'02&) 02-$#$+-

#&-$ 4&))+ -" 8$#" /,$ -" &2 $%(&2+0"2&#< +.04- 02 '"2$-&#< (")01<6 =$1"2/* 02 -.$0#

'&02 $%($#0'$2-+ -.$ 021#$&+$ 02 9"3$#2'$2- +($2/029 0+ ($#'&2$2-6 7.0#/* +021$

-.$ +.04- 02 '"2$-&#< (")01< 0+ -$'("#&#< J"2$ "# -:" <$&#+N* -.$ 5,)> "4 -.$ 02A

1#$&+$ 02 9"3$#2'$2- +($2/029 "11,#+ :.$2 -.$ 2"'02&) 02-$#$+- #&-$ 0+ 2" )"29$#

8$#"6 7.$ #$+,)-+ 02 =$1-0"2 Q 0'()< -.&- -.$ @#+- /0C$#$21$ 0+ 2"- 0'("#-&2- 4"#

-.$ +08$ "4 -.$ ',)-0()0$#6 7.$ +$1"2/ /0C$#$21$ 0'()0$+ -.&- -.$0# @+1&) (")01<

$%($#0'$2- 0+ &++"10&-$/ :0-. & +-#"29$# 2$9&-03$ :$&)-. $C$1- "2 1"2+,'(-0"2

-.&2 ",#+6 ="* "-.$# -.029+ $R,&)* -.$0# ',)-0()0$# +.",)/ 5$ +'&))$# -.&2 ",#+

QP

Page 41: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"## $#%&'() *+, -').//01 (23 4'"%2""'() (5 &6# "#)"'&'7'&0 (5 &6# 82/&'9/'#3 &( &6#

&'8'): (5 :(7#3)8#)& "9#)4'): '89/'#" &6.&1 ;#%.2"# (5 &6# &6'34 4'<#3#)%# ') (23

#=9#3'8#)&"1 &6#'3 82/&'9/'#3 "6(2/4 ;# "8.//#3 &6.) (23" !"## $#%&'() >+,

!" #$%&'()*$%

?) &6'" 9.9#3 @# .3:2# &6.& &6# :(7#3)8#)& "9#)4'): 82/&'9/'#3 %.) ;# 7#30 /.3:#

@6#) &6# A#3( ;(2)4 () )(8')./ ')&#3#"& 3.&#" '" ;')4'):, B# (;&.') &6'" %()C

%/2"'() ') . 7.3'#&0 (5 8(4#/" @6#3# &6# :(7#3)8#)& "9#)4'): 82/&'9/'#3 '" D2'&#

8(4#"& @6#) &6# A#3( ;(2)4 '" )(& ;')4'):,

E23 .)./0"'" .;"&3.%&" 53(8 . 6("& (5 9(/'&'%./ #%()(80 %()"'4#3.&'()" @6'%6

8':6& 8.F# .) ')%3#."# ') :(7#3)8#)& "9#)4'): /#"" .&&3.%&'7# &6.) (23 .)./0"'"

')4'%.&#", B# .3# F##)/0 [email protected]# &6.& '& '" 82%6 #."'#3 &( "&.3& )#@ :(7#3)8#)&

93(:3.8" &6.) &( #)4 &6#8, ?& 3#8.')" 7#30 82%6 .) (9#) D2#"&'() @6#&6#31 ')

&6# 93#"#)%# (5 9(/'&'%./ #%()(80 %()"'4#3.&'()"1 &.= 9(/'%0 (5 "(3& #896."'A#4

;0 G::#3&"() !*HHI+ '" . ;#&&#3 @.0 (5 3#"9()4'): . A#3( ;(2)4 #9'"(4# &6.)

.) ')%3#."# ') :(7#3)8#)& 923%6."#", B6.& (23 .)./0"'" 4(#" ')4'%.&# '" &6.&

8#."23#" 4#"':)#4 &( ')%3#."# .::3#:.&# 4#8.)4 .3# 9.3&'%2/.3/0 9(@#352/ 423'):

"2%6 #9'"(4#",

JH

Page 42: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"#"$"%&"'

!"# $%&'( )*+,-+%.,'( /0-1*2 3'++*.-( -,% 4*%+' 5*2*0 67,.89* :',*;-+< *89.=

2.1+.- >.;? .,;*+*0; +-;* +92*0(@ :.:*'( )-,A 'B 4'+;9C-2( DEEFG

!D# $.<-C-+.( HG I-'( J->+*,K* 3?+.0;.-,'( -,%L-+;., M.K?*,1-9: 65?* '9;N9;(

*:N2'<:*,;( -,% .,;*+*0; +-;* *O*K;0 'B C'P*+,:*,; K',09:N;.',(@ !"#$%&'

"( )"%*+&$, -."%"/0.1( P'2G QER"S( N-C*0 TQ=UV( "FFDG

!Q# $2;.C( W-P.%( J->+*,K* 3?+.0;.-,'( L-+;., M.K?*,1-9:( -,% X*0N*+ J.,%Y

6Z.+:=0N*K.[K K-N.;-2( ,':.,-2 +.C.%.;.*0 -,% ;?* 190.,*00 K<K2*(@ \-;.',-2

)9+*-9 'B MK',':.K I*0*-+K? ]'+A.,C 4-N*+ \'G ""EQ^( X-,9-+< DEE_G

!^# )-++'( I'1*+; 6`9;N9; *O*K;0 'B C'P*+,:*,; N9+K?-0*0(@!"#$%&' "( 2"'0+0.&'

-."%"/,( UFRVSa """_( "FU"G

!_# )-b;*+( L-+.-,,* -,% I'1*+; cG d.,C 6Z.0K-2 N'2.K< ., C*,*+-2 *89.2.1+.9:(@

34* 5/*$0.&% -."%"/0. 6*70*8( UQ( Qa Q"_=QQ^( X9,G( "FFQG

!V# )'%*,0;*.,( L-+;.,( 3?+.0;'N?*+ XG M+K*C( -,% J9K- c9*++.*+. 65?* *O*K;0

'B B'+*.C, 0?'KA0 >?*, 7GHG .,;*+*0; +-;*0 -+* -; e*+'(@ :.:*'( )'-+% 'B

c'P*+,'+0 'B ;?* Z*%*+-2 I*0*+P* H<0;*:( DEEFG

!T# )+-9,( IG $,;', -,% f9.K?.+' ]-A. 6L',*;-+< N'2.K< %9+.,C X-N-,g0 2'0;

%*K-%*(@ 34* !&9&%*1* -."%"/0. 6*70*8( _TaD( QD^=Q^^( X9,* DEEVG

!U# )9+,0.%*( 3+-.C( L-+;., M.K?*,1-9:( -,% X',-0 Z.0?*+( 6Z.0K-2 0?'KA0 -,%

;?*.+ K',0*89*,K*0(@ !"#$%&' "( -."%"/0. 34*"$, ""_a UF=""T( DEE^G

!F# 3?+.0;.-,'( J->+*,K* 65?* e*+'=1'9,%( e*+'=.,h-;.', ;-+C*;.,C( -,% '9;N9;

K'22-N0*(@ :.:*'( \'+;?>*0;*+, 7,.P*+0.;<( DEE^G

^"

Page 43: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"#$ %&'()*(+,-. /+0'1,21. 3+'*(, 4(2&1,5+67. +,8 %&+'91) 4:+,) ;<-7(,+9

'(=(8(*(1) +,8 *&1 8>,+7(2 1?12*) -@ + )&-2A *- 7-,1*+'> B-9(2>.C !"#$%&'

"( )"'*+*,&' -,"%"./. ""DE "FGH. I##HJ

!""$ %-1,1,. K61,*1' +,8 L-9A1' M(19+,8 ;N&1 O1'-P(,*1'1)* '+*1 5-6,8 +,8 *&1

'-91 -@ *&1 1Q2&+,=1 '+*1 @-' 7-,1*+'> B-9(2> (, R+B+,.C!"#$%&' "( 0"%1+&$/

-,"%".*,2 . L-9J H# SHT. R69> I##D. BBJ "#U"P""#"J

!"I$ %-=+,. R-&,. N-5(+) %0(A. R-&, N+>9-'. +,8 L-9A1' M(19+,8 ;<10 V1>,1P

)(+, :1')6) -98 V1>,1)(+, =-:1',71,* )B1,8(,= 769*(B9(1').C 7(71-. W*+,@-'8

X,(:1')(*>. I##YJ

!"D$ 451'9>. R+,(21. W1'=(- Z1519- +,8 <(2-9+) L(,21,* ;[,:1)*71,* +,8 :+961E \

,1-29+))(2+9 51,2&7+'A.C 7(71-. <-'*&01)*1', X,(:1')(*>. I##]J

!"G$ 4==1'*))-,. K+6*( +,8 3(2&+19 M--8@-'8 ;N&1 O1'- (,*1'1)*P'+*1 5-6,8 +,8

-B*(7+9 7-,1*+'> B-9(2>JC 3$""4*%52 )&%1' "% -,"%".*, 6,+*7*+/. I##DJ

!"H$ 4==1'*))-,. K+6*( ;%+, + *+Q 26* 811B1, *&1 '121))(-,^.C 7(71-. _181'+9

Z1)1':1 `+,A -@ <10 a-'A. 3+> I##YJ

!"b$ K+9(. R-'8(. cN12&,-9-=>. 17B9->71,*. +,8 *&1 56)(,1)) 2>291E 8- *12&,-9-=>

)&-2A) 1QB9+(, +=='1=+*1 d62*6+*(-,)^e 6.1$*,&% -,"%".*, 817*19. ]YS"T.

IGYPIU". "YYYJ

!"U$ V1>,1). R-&, 3+>,+'8 :;1 <1%1$&' :;1"$/ "( -.='"/.1%+> ?%+1$12+> &%@

0"%1/. /-,8-,. 3+27(99+,. "YDbJ

!"]$ V'6=7+,. f+69 ;[*e) 5+++2AE R+B+,e) )967B +,8 *&1 '1*6', -@ *&1 9(g6(8(*>

*'+B.C 3$""4*%52 )&=1$2 "% -,"%".*, 6,+*7*+/. IE "DUP"]U. "YY]J

GI

Page 44: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"#$ %&'()*++,- .&//(0& ('1 2&3*45& 6*4&55, 78,0)(+ 9&+,):- ;*(+5< *=*)50 ('1

/(4>?90-@ A(5,&'(+ B?4*(? &C D)&'&/,) 2*0*(4)< E&4>,'F 6(9*4 "GHIG-

JKKIL

!JK$ 2(/*:- M(+*4,* NL 7O1*'5,C:,'F F&P*4'/*'5 09*'1,'F 0<&)>0Q ,5R0 (++ ,' 5<*

5,/,'F-@ /,/*&- S',P*40,5: &C T(+,C&4',(- U(' V,*F&- JKKIL

!J"$ 2(/*:- M(+*4,* NL ('1 %(55<*; VL U<(9,4& 7T&05+: )(9,5(+ 4*(++&)(5,&' ('1

5<* *=*)50 &C F&P*4'/*'5 09*'1,'F-@ !"#$%&'%()*+,%-.%# !*$/%#%$+% 0%#'%-

*$ 1234'+ 1*4'+5- GIQ "GHW"#G- X?'* "##IL

!JJ$ U)</,55WY4&<Z U5*9<(',* ('1 %(45[' S4,3* 7\,]?,1,5: 54(90 ;,5< F+&3(+ .(:W

+&4 2?+*0-@ 6$.%#$".'*$"4 7*2#$"4 */ 8+*$*9'+ :,%*#5 HQIH^"K_- JKK#L

!J`$ U/*50- 84('> ('1 2(C E&?5*40 7N' *05,/(5*1 1:'(/,) 05&)<(05,) F*'*4(+

*]?,+,34,?/ /&1*+ &C 5<* D?4& (4*(-@ 7*2#$"4 */ .,% 82#*;%"$ 8+*$*9'+ <-(

-*+'".'*$- U*95*/3*4 JKK`- M&+L "- A&L H- 6(F*0 ""J`W""aHL

!JG$ U/*50- 84('> ('1 2(C(*+ E&?5*40 7U<&)>0 ('1 C4,)5,&'0 ,' SLUL 3?0,'*00

):)+*0Q N B(:*0,(' VUYD (994&()<-@<9%#'+"$ 8+*$*9'+ )%='%>- #aQ`- HI_W

_K_- X?'* JKKaL

G`

Page 45: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"#$%&'()'*+&,-'./'01'"1,%&02&'"1'#.3&%14&1-'25&16"1#'

78&1'-8&'9&%.':.$16'"2'1.-':"16"1#'

;4.6&<'7"-8'1.',05"-0<=>'

5 10 15 20

1

2

3

4

Output

% d

evia

tion fro

m s

.s.

5 10 15 20

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

Inflation

AP

R

5 10 15 20

0.5

1

1.5

2

Nominal Interest Rate

AP

R

5 10 15 20

5

10

15

20

% d

evia

tion fro

m s

.s.

Government Spending

Page 46: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"#$%&'()'*+,&%-.&-/'01&-2"-#'.$3413"&%'56&-'/6&'7&%+'8+$-2'"0'-+/'8"-2"-#'

9.+2&3'5"/6'-+':;1"/;3<='

1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8

1

1.02

1.04

1.06

1.08

1.1

1.12

1.14

1.16

1.18

dY/dG

!1

1 1.5 2 2.5 3

0.9

0.95

1

1.05

1.1

1.15

1.2

dY/dG

"0.5 1 1.5 2

0.75

0.8

0.85

0.9

0.95

1

1.05

1.1

dY/dG

#

0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

dY/dG

!2

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8

1.06

1.08

1.1

1.12

1.14

1.16

1.18

1.2

1.22

dY/dG

$R

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8

0.8

0.9

1

1.1

1.2

dY/dG

$

Page 47: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"#$%&'()'*+,&%-.&-/'01&-2"-#'.$3413"&%'56&-'/6&'7&%+'8+$-2'"0'8"-2"-#'

9.+2&3'5"/6'-+':;1"/;3<='

!"!#$ !"!#% !"!& !"!&# !"!&' !"!&$

'

$

%

(!

(#

('

($

(%

)*+),

!

!"!#$ !"!#% !"!& !"!&# !"!&' !"!&$

!&!

!#-

!#!

!(-

!(!

!-

./01/0

23)456706893:;8<3="="

!

!"!#$ !"!#% !"!& !"!&# !"!&' !"!&$

!!"(#

!!"(

!!"!%

!!"!$

!!"!'

!!"!#

>?

!

!"!#$ !"!#% !"!& !"!&# !"!&' !"!&$

!&-

!&!

!#-

!#!

!(-

!(!

!-

@9:?70689

ABC

!

Page 48: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"

#$%&"

'()$*$+)"

*%)$"

,-.$*"/-0(1"

!2"

3"

4"

5"

!%6'(7+"

8'70*$"9:"!';<&$"1'%7*%;"=-*";-1$&".')>"(-"?%<')%&@"

Page 49: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"#$%&'()'*+,-./'/&0&/'12'#10&%3-&34'

5+&36"3#'"3'47&'8&%1'91$36:'

! !"#

!$"%

!$"$&

!$"$'

!$"$(

!$"$)

*+,-./0-/1234-/56/7

816961:

! !"#

!"&)

!"&'

$

$"!%

$"!;

$"!)

*+,-./0-/1234-/56/7

<=14=1

>25-,6?16+/@2A.+02@"@"

! !"#

!

!"!%

!"!;

!"!)

!"!'

!"$

*+,-./0-/1234-/56/7

B9

! !"#

!"&;

!"&;#

!"&#

!"&##

!"&)

!"&)#

*+,-./0-/1234-/56/7

>25-,6?16+/@2A.+02@"@"

C+/@=0416+/

! !"#

!

!"#

$

$"#

%

%"#

*+,-./0-/1234-/56/7

D+06/?92E/1-.-@12F?1-

GHF

! !"#

!#

!;

!I

!%

!$

!

*+,-./0-/1234-/56/7

E/A9?16+/

GHF

Page 50: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"#$%&'()'*+&,-'./'0"1,.$2-'%3-&'14.,5'64&2'-4&'7&%.'8.$20'"1'8"20"2#''

9:.0&;'6"-4',3<"-3;='>1-3203%0?'30@$1-:&2-',.1-1AB'

! "# "! $#

!"#

!!

#

!

%

&'(

! "# "! $#

!)

!*

!+

!$

#

$

,-./012/-1

345/.67168-49:8240;0;

! "# "! $#

!"!

!"#

!!

#

<8=:0

345/.67168-49:8240;0;

! "# "! $#

!"#

!!

#

!

"#,-9>7168-

&'(

! "# "! $#!"

#

"

$

?

+

!@826-7>4,-1/:/014(71/

&'(

! "# "! $#

!"#

!)

!*

!+

!$

#

A=1B=1345/.67168-49:8240;0;

! "# "! $#!"!

!"#

!!

#

C8-0=2B168-

345/.67168-49:8240;0;

! "# "! $##

"

$

?

+

5DE5F

! "# "!$

+

*

)

(/7>4,-1/:/014(71/

&'(

Page 51: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"

#$%&"

'()$*$+)"

*%)$"

,-.$*""

/-0(1"

!2"

3"

4"

5"

!%6'(7+"

8($&%+9:""

'(6$+);$()"

<&%+9:"'(6$+);$()"

="

>'70*$"?@"!';A&$"1'%7*%;"B-*";-1$&".')C":%A')%&D"

Page 52: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"#$%&'()'*+&,-'./'0&$-%12'-&,30.2.#4'53.,6'73&0'-3&'8&%.'9.$0:'"5'9"0:"0#''

;<.:&2'7"-3',1="-12>'?5-10:1%:@'1:A$5-<&0-',.5-5BC'

! "# "! $#

!!

#

!

%

&'(

! "# "! $#

!"

#

"

$

)

*+,-./0-+/

123-,45/46+278602.9.9

! "# "! $#

!!

!:

!)

!$

!"

#

";6<8.

123-,45/46+278602.9.9

! "# "! $#

!!

#

!

"#*+7=5/46+

&'(

! "# "! $#!"

#

"

$

)

:

!>604+5=2*+/-8-./2(5/-

&'(

! "# "! $#

!#9!

#

#9!

"

?</@</123-,45/46+278602.9.9

! "# "! $#

!#9!

#

#9!

"A6+.<0@/46+

123-,45/46+278602.9.9

! "# "! $##

"

$

)

:

!

3BC3D

! "# "!

)

:

!

(-5=2*+/-8-./2(5/-

&'(

Page 53: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"#$%&'()'*+&,-'./'"01&2-3&0-425&,"6,'27.,8'97&0'-7&':&%.';.$0<'"2';"0<"0#''

=3.<&>'9"-7',?5"-?>@'A2-?0<?%<B'?<C$2-3&0-',.2-2DE'

! "# "! $#

#

$

%

&

'

()*

! "# "! $#

!"!

!"#

!!

+,-./01.,0

234.-56057,389713/:/:

! "# "! $#

!%

!$

#

;7<9/

234.-56057,389713/:/:

! "# "! $#

#

!

"#+,8=6057,

()*

! "# "! $#

#

$

%

>715,6=3+,0.9./03*60.

()*

! "# "! $#

!?

!$

!"

@<0A<0234.-56057,389713/:/:

! "# "! $#

!$

!"

#

"B7,/<1A057,

234.-56057,389713/:/:

! "# "! $##

"

$

4CD4E

! "# "!$:!

?

?:!

%

*.6=3+,0.9./03*60.

()*

Page 54: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"#$%&'()*'+,&-.'/0'1"2-/$3.'%4.&'25/-6'75&3'.5&'8&%/'9/$31'"2'9"31"3#''

:;/1&<'7".5'-4=".4<>'?++'41@$2.;&3.'-/2.2AB'

! "# "! $#

!"#

!!

#

!

%

&'(

# "# $#!"

#

")*+,-./,*.

012,+34.35*1675/1-8-8

# "# $#!$#

!"#

#

"#95:7-

012,+34.35*1675/1-8-8

# "# $#!$#

!"#

#

"#)*6;4.35*

&'(

# "# $##

$

<

=>5/3*4;1)*.,7,-.1(4.,

&'(

# "# $#!"#

!!

#

!?:.@:.

012,+34.35*1675/1-8-8

# "# $#!$#

!"#

#

"#A5*-:/@.35*

012,+34.35*1675/1-8-8

# ! "#"8!

$

$8!

B2CD2E

! "# "!$

<

=

F

(,4;1)*.,7,-.1(4.,

&'(

Page 55: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"#$%&'(()'*+&,-'./'0&$-%12'-&,30.2.#4'53.,6'73&0'-3&'8&%.'9.$0:'"5'9"0:"0#''

;<.:&2'7"-3',1="-12>'?**'1:@$5-<&0-',.5-5AB'

! "# "! $#

!!

#

!

%

&'(

# "# $##

"

$

)*+,-./0-+/

123-,45/46+278602.9.9

# "# $#!"#

!!

#

!:6;8.

123-,45/46+278602.9.9

# "# $#!"#

!!

#

!*+7<5/46+

&'(

# "# $##

$

=

>?604+5<2*+/-8-./2(5/-

&'(

# "# $#!#9!

#

#9!

"@;/A;/

123-,45/46+278602.9.9

# "# $#!$

!"

#

"B6+.;0A/46+

123-,45/46+278602.9.9

# ! "#$

)

=3CD3E

! "# "!

)

=

!

(-5<2*+/-8-./2(5/-

&'(

Page 56: $0 123’%.3%#+ 45+0#6 - Northwestern Universityyona/research/... · 2010. 7. 7. · ! "#$%%&" ’()%*&+, &, -$".+)"+,+-&"% &%/ 01$* &% *1) %&2) +3 *1) 4+5).,-),* %6),78 &,4 -(#*&6#&).9

!"#$%&'()*'+,&-.'/0'"12&3.4&1.536&-"7-'38/-9':8&1'.8&';&%/'</$1='"3'<"1="1#''

>4/=&?':".8'-@6".@?A'B++'@=C$3.4&1.'-/3.3DE'

! "# "! $#

#

$

%

&

'()

# "# $#!$#

!"#

#*+,-./0-+/

123-,45/46+278602.9.9

# "# $#!!

#

!:6;8.

123-,45/46+278602.9.9

# "# $#!%

!$

#*+7<5/46+

'()

# "# $##

$

%=604+5<2*+/-8-./2)5/-

'()

# "# $#!%

!$

#

$>;/?;/

123-,45/46+278602.9.9

# "# $#!$

#

$

%@6+.;0?/46+

123-,45/46+278602.9.9

% A B$

$9!

C

C9!3DE3F

! "# "!

$9A$9BC

C9$C9%C9AC9B

)-5<2*+/-8-./2)5/-

'()