نقد ونظر.pdf
-
Upload
awais-sohrawardi -
Category
Documents
-
view
22 -
download
1
Transcript of نقد ونظر.pdf
-
^ ~?
-
;.,
JtJ
o
o
\
o
j 2 0.6 .356 - * iJc," o
-
VH /&QfA^Aj&t3?iJfl d^ I^^/^c^tTc^i^i^ iriA^JU^i^^-^C&^o^C^^Jt(dd^-J^
^^& i b* ^^>MU^ ^^ '
-
Jt^jua/'
4*. >'
^
, X"' X
i*isJjtK&vrC>)utobJ& t/tft^i/rd^j^Lf?* ** y ** *? ^v ^> ** * r
i^o^j?Uh(/l^/Jfl^bc^^^^4_ (*V-*fx^ / ^i c^V-i i.(?jfi^TjOt ^(f&'&ttf'fyk-
u^^c
U^^ !r6l>^ tu,r^t/^juu^t;v
^^J&4 'c^ t- /cT^
tcK; c[/c/c/t ifG4Kb&&Wt&V&&&
-
j^^^(^uy^(/}^J^O^^cC^.itJL^** **~
,-t >x _/ i.- ^t **
%$A&yvaj$j)- OJ^&^jl-
-
* u-OJ^*f
cfir^!^^
V^^-^^.Df^J^^V^
U
^
v^ ^f **. * v^ ^f **
t
l^^^
-
u * %*
_
^.C^/,frjuu wfc JtTll
HrA ^,^^lf^^
iJ vfr^ctfSl
-
X^J%44lS^ltf.
tu^W^^M
-
li"
20. 6.
c^c
dJCWttof. cK^ /r?*
-
USXAAfiJ
.S^^
^
-
c, x^
lib^
-
^&&SJO(f&-^JP&S*&S'r&&!&&4^vfe
-
^Ijj^^fo^^^/^f^h^^^'^f^ c^fgj&rtf^^}^2o^M'^ikL^(^^
^"*
"""* >X vr . /?
j t
^ifXW&tik- r --/^/i^^i2^^^^^^ "
. i.r.s. i^*-j^^&:iji^vf^&&
-
V^
-
.^^t^tfC^^***5? *
*
-
iftrtJ.(\^\tjs\fftjsb
t
vyjj&ji&ifoscqvijJ\sj>\6#&(j&\^^i ^sui(2JLs&
.
il* /^
'
^A^y^
u
-
UU
-
'; J
jyC
-
,^
wxy . T ifBr fy&f
-
6 I P J/
^ c. l?}& ^
-
"u- . T
w&.^g'*jf^^
-
J,xsi&j*urjftf.c^Pl#^(Sf
c^c^ o^t\Jio//c^
-
a v
-'/^SUdJ I C
tfb
-
r^Ji/.#J
j^X^W*^"*M '. . t>^ y -
^W.^^w^v^*V&\s.
&&\&:&$h>(X
-
JL~i \/
^
> u^r/L^Oc^ ii
^v
tfitZ^
< w iT, J^-^Jr j (j^
*
^a)^
-
n^(f^^^
-
I** J s s
^^t&ft/^btfi3\rK^2L^&fy^cii^-v^6^u^^j/;tj
, J* . ** , ^ A ^ r^ ^
^^{//^^c//cO(^,^A^^a%
o>^^c^
r^>-Ltf/^^Gf^i c/c^4 /JTd/j>4^ r^ t
-
(^
J
*
r
-
L f/.
v
J O/
'(/&
*
-
(i) U U^jf
-
c/--/
^
-
(A--^^c;c^^^^^^^-^^* ** *sr I* * ** i s> ^ * ** ^ s } J ^ S
($%fr/3fr,ct
-
r /C'^
cn
-
rtrf
-
ci i> t> tu' ff a^ U4cp
(J* *
,
-
ja/^cy(^.j,^^: ^2-1;^tO^
-
J$br^ g^^
-
6 &
OJ
- /K%^/^^^^^7-*^
-
^l^^
-
sI
< 0' IxTJ -J -.V'''
-
6-0-
-
&J
-
t-
>Jj
^
)tt
/vt^
^ c
-
^^
/^
%y;}^\^::^yj^^ &4^tfJ\f-$&t irtoty^s(fe. "/$jd'trii/fffjJ^^
-
i r
65-
'^ (SI dftddfc ^ *X
ff 5 QsS- _~\>W '\&Sc*>(t (?ixSTcJ^t
rt
/UcC/i;t .iVv-^^t^Jr.LTc/;'^{
* *
/* X1 vv t* *** ^ ^x^*
i
; ,.^ (
^
-
?sj.,
x
( (f
U^
-
tu
-
2// j(; fa- (Jl
-
/
-
. e' u^ t^. t
-
Jti
^C-^-fJ?^^~>^' $
'(rLSf(g/J*>Vl'I
-
^M^i}?^^
^)c/^^C w v* /^x ** y**
-
s^^^^^^^^^^^^y^ 1^>J*yjow\r(f&^^^**
*
V* - ^ ^ ^ *^ '
^f ^**
-
- ^Uv^^^^^^^'^^^^V^1^^C^i>) *-&$$6& [&
-
4(fofa(f *. t J~* I
^ay.^o^^tfu^^
fc^O;. ( JL^ /C^v^ t
f
^
-
fe^/Ci?/
-
A I.
ci/xo>> irf
/J(
-
^J\J
-
^,"j
^
M
*L//i
-
Ad
Mj)(tf'
"7 XV / b^v^^- O>J iJtu-
-
UfrW,
-
* I 4 /' I*
tf'Jj4&^s( (tf(2l^M^j>M\fMti tvL>'J^to^
-
(/&6/^y^^rtJdfr&tfr*^uttfJ%W^^j j - ~ L
f.b.\>^w&tfc$f&:dd*^4$?tf&W&JJ*t
&&\&ftA'Ut^^^^^^^^^^^/^^^ l^^^^/Lt^^i^^(^/>^^^^^j^jjb^&siy^^^ jjj^ ^^Lfr&w$^j&j*rtcJzJH>&>->&*'*
-
a^
-
^t
-
(e&Jto&j&Lte^ t
x
i^ c/r^ C '4f c/ci^^^JfJJ ' ci'>5
c^d^^
'
-
^f JeJJJit
^te&wf^
'/&< Jtol C*JtyjfS&j(?*^fJV^lf^U&t-VtdcLivi/^.j^tf>^dtyjS&fy u/>6fyt$fic)i'fy&\S^MS-*^l6d
i
s'^- ^^>&S
-
^fy4tL&\sMOs*f^&&\&b>>f< ijtiSji, ^" r / s~ wV^Pc>^^tJwJTy^^Vf/^r^iX-^vl^^* J f j * I^ Cbflr^jty$J*Oartittf^^f.^(Tt31>U//tf^J^c5^J^/V^fti^4{(fy&?(;&
s^J^L^tfcdLtji~&}&i&5//^r/
-
jJ&ty^fLb^^^ty&wv^"^Jrfo/%^^>^^
^
-
^M^^^^^f^^ 1^^^^^c^t^^t^, rfUfa, h^'is^r.frcstfc^^y'Ot^
-
rl
b&U&&WJ > tfld.
^
-
44
^^^
''f^^/t^JS'f^
cJk&tp^-^^JL^tf^Jb 1
-
^^^\^^oj^^^^lji^i^A(/(^j&i*jji^ T
I
1
^
^
^
-
riliil>^** v *. ' ** f 4 At
/'fuf^^^^^o^^^(^^^^^^(* .,* ** * * W-X ^ ^ *. v* fc* 4*r** -^ J
4/cCy 1^JCP^ L^^/Xri?i^/^5^c>%J^c^^t^^lJ4^^l!^L?/^^^i?
.-
^
-
,/fD./l
-
^^Sb^-l^^^f^"^ -y^Mje^j****^^^iS^SS^s^^>-. 2 s I-M&W^*^ " Vj^SSfSS^
-
IK
tfjtf*
ywrz t^W&^&j\lufo*ty*1
^V
-
j^J&cuj&\^&f^$'(j^(^^\ ^'iQf^t^sfcitw \SfS(jf Xx X .5 A^ ^ ^ lif?. S ~.Wtfltt&tetf't&^W^^&^d&^&&&^^^^~*i&F/t^tf#fau&i&4
^^^oJ^^A^l^ls^O^te-fc*^*
^W5*g*JJt&
-
nr
_
tyJjtW^bitejuy*v^u ^^^'^^y^(
-
ltd
J^v^t^-(#c^^^^wter fat!>jj tff&A&f^&^^^r^jl-c^^.tJ^^ fc * *y h * * * ^^
>&
c^i^^^^^^^^rcU^i^^ >>Ytj>V. ^ i ^,, AjJ/,S. i-ibSt r . / -J,
-
Ill"
-
IK
^
^7^' "4
"" ^^"~
-
Ifc
(I)
crj
(A)
-
M+s
^j*&*$\
-
-tft
1^ ^
- w'"&
-
ffijfos&j^&*iJ^v^rtWZ*W^cZ*rj>'Uj&
'lAj^l^^faf&i&ib&UJ&f^** 4 V^ ** **i^ ..-^ ^
-
//
**
j(UP- fd&vj.^ .cfZ
yroj$ !.!/!$&}&} tff&l If"j^^w;W;crM>"f< ' fa ' '-iy/lv
-
Vtf\&fa.^*f
^CJ^j {;{?&-'' ffiV;t*cjj3?^*^tffe#jci^'fe&t/ff'tf,
Jttrl> u
^cr^
^L^tf^^^^i^^^^^^*S S^ " * ^ S/f . * , I JT ,4, r
-
jUc^c^^o^v^ 1^ 1^^^^^'frite^Ajpte&t^Vty % buqjtft
-
/*
*.*.
Jk/JUJJ
-
** *
*'
(J
C/i
-
IM
fit^ (ririff'* ? * **
-
if
-
Ar^^-c/Vcl^
^
-
J^U^
i
tyfantofM !
-
rW^c/JykCrju
^i^i^^^t^^^f^ c^Xfr^^rttyAtftz*:*cH'Q&ttff?JfKcCytytytyty&^&*Wtl&j(>j '^
-
cffmlj&h^^^4^^it^c^^^^^^'^^^^j^-^l^^^dt^/^trc^C^/Jp /tfj^tjl^yj^ lysJb^w?S^>(J^fk^j^
-
hr
3 V^ ^^^^^V^JriT^a tu^iru,'^^^ci^^^^t^i^;^/^
-
>*/**. *
'"*
$^b#>\ik^4#j*/,!**-, L/^*-x , ~"S f ** \(viyw^r^-**
w K * / *
-
IMS
4f^4^^'M^^^^^^^'^*
-
[>2^feirtJ^ciJ^v~
-
~y i i .
-
!&>'
to
** ^
-^^
-
^ !T
^
^^^^
-
f^/t
%^.Mfyj$s,
-
^^^^
f-M
-
icr
J^
%'
" ?%^ - ^-6C^
- ^^w-^^-ftftty^M.j;^^c&jjl^-W^ty*'-
-
&fC^lfotb>v^
l&ifofy&>3}
-
jj~-^
mw - ^f ^ mr ^r va^v ^ ^^^^ ^^F
^
/ ^ ^al r "
^^^^^>^J^^^/ur^
-
,^^^
r^* I 1 *
^^cri^Ly'.c/;^ti^tyK/'tf./^'
r^W,(lfeJC^ tfGJ^'''?^fej"y^*vi^:j . . -^ v ^ > _/^T~^~ r-^T. ~5^f^p 7~^-T^^ ^ * "2*
V6ffe(T//4^i^U^C^l'** 4 v *tMty&'v>&&&*"1f6,U?*&LM>'tC* . A. .Jr - = '/
^^
^
U i
-
f^j&y&&-Jj%4' ^ f^&^c^y?f*Jti~. \\Sfaiiiti*j\z~/&&*(
v w^- ^ ^ rp > ^^~ ' r^ ~" ' r' ~ ^^ ^^ ^* ^^ * ^*
,^,^^?/J^^H^^^Vc^^^^b^pj^^^^^^kVi^xtv4^^K^b7j^^^-^kfc4h
,4* ^ y * X->. , . .*.*>. X i A,
-
tJy 1
&\fjtf(ity ^t^c^/J^^^(fj&(/d*^^ ybtfty^^j^riul
^^^^j^ttyitfcX)*-. l
-
f^tfS^
fJ^^rt^r^^^^^^'^V^^ 1^
rc^dl^^^^^^
-
IAI
A*^i4^fe^cw&"'
&y^*^^y$&w4u^j6jZb$w?$ij$&btjt2&^i>jrf?f.A K,&\I, iJi ;^
^^( ^.^p&)&WI- &,*&;*.
-
-Jdy -^il^J^ Jp!fi^
^6#$>^r*>JtV/
-
(Af
^^^^
y^d^Y^ ^Vf.
-
Sj&^/X*^^^**>
** * A
vS^D^&^t'iij''c^i^V^^D^t:^v 4 4
- ^$$&Zi*Vjg&\A~sj^\*
-
IA1
&
^
^V^^^
^/
(&\()\*\$M'>*(p
-
fA< Jtfsti
^?Mi^ui&(j(f^ "(f^^L^^^^^
^j^}^U
-
jy&IAA
,
ciw^iT^^^^*^
* ^> ^ / *?d^tfi/^^^iA-^vrj^l'fc^ frtflfr^W^U^J^t^J^^^^ V **
-
lir
-
^^
- ^b^j^^^^i^^(k:^^^jl^^
- 2^(f^r^^f. .y/,,.*V^&^JF'*>W#teV* ..^^^^W^'^^r* ' &tviWtfWty'i$f*iaL*
-
frl
-
vir/
-
/** 1* *
n% ^u^
(Jfi&l&i?(fjVoi*>ftf'lS i''*1i *Wl&&f'^
S>/J>(Mfr
-
33
yjft'&ty'ill y fcX 7 t ~,t,4",, S**^*-'**?^ }?
^^(f^^iL^ar/i^^cfUu^^V^^^t^clL&rft^fe,^
-
.>>>
- *o_ /r.*,C.^^*,'- v,/
-
^ w/
W^^j^4
-
t^Oj-l-v^
^
crMj^U^u^^,-^/SJjfo\-fy ^fo^^/S^A
i^^J^l^c/^M--'^
-
^c(%c^
, 1%^^^c^^i^t,!
i^c/c^Tt^L:^J^^^^^ud6*a, ctf^)^^c(M^i^^j i g'tyt.vi^ty^
\U-
-
UJJ^lr^V P^^--*-^ ^'-,^-y - - z ^|- * /.^Xu^^c^bi^^i^^/^V^^ Jl^V ^ ^^** ^ ** x ^ > V^ >^ X"'^ * y
-
efXiS-UJJJXZyV^ 'SW^f 1 r< -
'^(fe&ff^J^w&'^/'&w
J X
^if^Jfitlk^l^jr^l/Cfl^y,
-
&t- cv t
-
ru
-
I *l* *
Ju>JU
ct*Ljtsji
-
4-j c//^.^#w.i;(4z ^ i "
\ifo^^
-
^^
t (
-
m^A!^
JlS
--^j&M/ii(Mf(&>>>Jfdfo*k^^i?*bj!&S*rS
^fai/^&jjyk^c ^
- .
-
J^J&t
*Ugfy&*>
-
joutf
"^
^
^-^f t^u-j^cr < < '-7 VK/I*-^ X* ^ **ri^^wj + c-.\j */rs^
ty^(&*f\(%+** x* iT^x **
. u; ui&(S;i* ^/ fc* t 4
}^ t
F
o u^uii fr^r^x'ti_ - V^// fcain '- *^ 1^,7 v** ^" * " v^ ' ;^ i 4* ^ /*
W^^-^^^^^^^^"^i. c^iu^^j^^ci^'wi^j^y^-^1-
-
^^/^^1
4^'&&$?(?)&fa ?& i J^ii
>c
-
KIT
^^U;i^/ol^M
(lri^i^
^
-
rrr
^U^V^V^ ^^M^l^b^^
>i^d?i< !fb^Lof^vJ*.t#t/-^>,to 4*. ^^ ^ * * fc * 4/*4**&t*p^(*^tfj;f^
f ' *"
cJjo^/o{5^cJU>4^/^^j_, ^fe uji;
-
^^i
** * * * /^y
(ML&(*Os* bfij^Jt
^&^^
r*7 ' t^ . * , - / >U4^^~^bi* ^J^&^'c^c^r^a^r^^V:
-
^y^i^u>^^^wUyXVs>^^^ux.^^D^/&&i&b^4*J^s&h^j&^tf&(, I^KI
y- *J~ J^ S f9 ~ /** ***-
s'./ \^ *\\ \'*L/ \J** /** / P /^: I ^ f ,\k** . < ,ft~ iii ^ . ^ S* i
jU, c
-
,,c i 6
/u>
- ^(fja^(Afsf/f^^>\A- j.Jrb*/
-
U^CU (*J"J
-
u frf l0JjU(&t
^
-
P\$b^
^(LS^^* r "
-
rrr
fi
('
-
C&&\&ti^ $j>J&^\t>&*\.>3$r$r'i*Ju&*tfz&HiJ(&fiU-/ii^>Vf * fc* ** ^* * Jr f it *-
{yw&i^^
^
-
titj?^^
-
^^ A/)
'
^^^
-
r rc^/^&$
- tyJfyJx&M&w?''**'?**,faf^i^M^^w&^z-.* ..* ./;..
-
^/LJtf
c)Uihf^^Jl^j".tfkvd(?.uZ
-
rr-
-
/ +1i-'J
/dC,^^l^/^dt;^t>^/Jvri^:tbC>!af:T* *** _-*.>" '^ -
- *>U
-
rrrJ* t**
J&JJ0
^.^ty^&fSfl^^^^^^^^l^^c^^,^l^Sj^.U&^
^tfjtysj^tffy^L-\sJ?^(?/4- v&sfyfcfq^ty^jfr^i,faW^, j,
ffi,yr^^f^^^^^l***}*!&^idtfu&^^
- Afzvsf&jSzZ, ? ,L^JxLcU(/tc^*&&&l*t6vlA
-
^jy-
Z&fzSifetif' *ji>&*&&fr^^&tf^d+^(;Wjf^& -* * ' y /*
- ^Y^Jftdtf^lh^^.&
-
^^^
VW&tteL/d&'Wg*-e/M^Vf>\.\sS^utc(J/&f^SoM fattdfr&oi
;fcj(tf
S&
^
-
^*
- j-g^jz^w&jftir^*b^$fjj*fr* .fct^jXj&j(jufo ^.
-
toi t2**cf2{;sW'
-
r/ (
-
^^
^
\.tf^\^J*jCtf^jotr^^ t/ 1t^c^ l>
-
\^4
- &c>U
-
t, C-
^
eft
-
\r
-
i* 5
k *- r
JL>ju^
Jt^6-l/^^c^^^r~ y -c/A/^WX*-^fo^Mtf&Mf*
j&&S>lcZJ&> -'
M**/*^* ' "-"V^^^^^-V^^^i^
^^^^^-^/-^^^^'^-^'^tbc/jVt (/^iJxJC*^^'^^t*^^^ c;ij. * ^^4**^ t* V* / ~*f * S*fa * 1 i
W
-
>^i tf t/u^-ji C/CN Jf' [ ^V c
*+s X/ *r * * * J
&rtlU.&t~/j(-(^Cjj^O'hj/Or^,^
^'* SS.* S~ * ^ ^ *Sr . / . .. .
-
nr
D
yj^^
V
-
v^
-
J.>
* > ** f f '($%2- sj^r $s( Kdf*M(f^f< ^r^*L^l
-
\jS>$
-
"c^lijAuf(A- c/ir^
.tf2ufy!jjtf'iiy?
&
;,*t* it
-
/ fc
Jj t*,/crUrr- c/
-
')>,,
/..,-I*
^^ " r-6^>
c