WG14“parallel”sessionAgenda:I.GESflagdic;onary-heatcharts(A.Casey)-sta;s;cs(P.Jofre-moresta;s;cs(S.VanEck,M.VanderSwaelmen)II.Binaries-SB2detec;on(M.VanderSwaelmen)-SB1detec;on(T.Merle)-Parameters-t-SNE(binaries)(G.Traven)III.t-SNE(general)(G.Traven)IV.AOB

Dic;onaryStructure

M.VanderSwaelmen,C.Worley,P.Jofre,A.Hourihane,A.Casey,T.Merle,S.VanEck

Flagsyntax

A.Casey

1002

510

151

1015

310

200

1030

213

003

1412

610

005

1001

010

015

1002

010

025

1003

010

106

1030

010

302

1030

310

304

1030

510

306

1030

810

311

1031

210

399

1050

011

020

1302

113

023

1010

510

151

1302

013

021

1302

210

155

1021

010

303

1030

410

305

1039

913

002

1302

810

010

1010

510

151

1030

210

308

1102

010

010

1001

510

020

1003

010

105

1010

610

303

1032

011

100

1115

011

200

1125

013

020

1302

213

027

1000

510

010

1030

210

303

100251015110153102001030213003141261000510010100151002010025100301010610300103021030310304103051030610308103111031210399105001102013021130231010510151130201302113022101551021010303103041030510399130021302810010101051015110302103081102010010100151002010030101051010610303103201110011150112001125013020130221302710005100101030210303

CAUP

EPINARBO

IAC

Lumba

Nice

OACT

Vilnius

100 101 102

0

1

2

3

4

num

ber o

f sta

rs fl

agge

d (lo

g)

EPINARBO

IAC

Lumba

MaxPlanck

OACT

CAUP

EPINARBO

IACAIP

Lumba

Nice

OACT

UCM

Vilnius

Arcetri

CAUP

OACT

OAPA

UCM

Liege

ROB

ROBG

rid

binarylinesemissionH−alphaabsorptionREMARK

binarylinesemissionH−alphaabsorptionREMARK

P.Jofre

P.Jofre

0.001

0.010

0.100

1.000

10.000

100.000%

of s

ampl

e fla

gged

(log

scal

e)

EPINAR

BO

IAC

Lumba

MaxPlanck

OAC

T

CAU

P

EPINAR

BO

IACAIP

Lumba

Nice

OAC

T

UC

M

Vilnius

Arcetri

CAU

P

OAC

T

OAPA

UC

M

Liege

RO

B

RO

BGrid

WG10 WG11 WG12 WG13

CONVER.ROTNO_PHYSTIMESNRREDUC.VRAD

CONVER.ROTNO_PHYSTIMESNRREDUC.VRAD

•  Source:GES_iDR5_WG15_Recommended.fits(preliminaryversion)•  Totalnumberofassignedflags:1124654•  Average:13.5flagsperCNAME

65869

16254

TefforLoggor[Fe/H]orXI

Parameters

Noparameters 14184

2070

Flagged

Flagged

Unflagged

CNAMEswithnoparametersandnoflags:2070(outof16254)=13%

CNAMEswithnoparametersatall(Teff,LOGG,FEH,XI=NULL)16254(outof82123)=19%

Prefix Count Descrip;on----------------------------------------------------------------10399116928 NoparametersprovidedbecauseoflackofGme10302114773 Codeconvergenceissue:oneofmoreconvergencecriteria

(node-specific)couldnotbefulfilled.Criteriatobe describedusingthesuffix

1031562357 MicroturbulenceBergemann&Hill1001561310 SNR<151030358920 Teffoutofnode’sgrid

SNR:<5<10<15<20<25<30<40<50

85083flagsDATA

57748flagsDATA

15722flagsDATA

vsin(i)toohigh

63946flagsANALYSIS

493224flags

WG15useonly

ANALYSIS

142180flagsANALYSIS

RESULTQUALITY

24854flags

RESULTQUALITY

43330flags

(Neutrallines)

àCaI,CrIandNiIrepresent67%ofall“suspiciousabundance”no;fica;ons

RESULTQUALITY

20878flags

(Ionizedlines)

àScIIrepresents58%ofall“suspiciousabundance”no;fica;ons

Summary

SNR13%

Datareduc;on5%

RV1%

vsin(i)5%

Parameters:analysis43%

Abundances:analysis12%

Parameters:resultquality2%

AbundancesI:resultquality

4%

AbundancesII:resultquality

2%Other13%

Flagcategory

Concludingremarks•  ProvidemoreGmeforparameterdeterminaGon•  Allnon-determina;onsshouldbeflaggedbynodes•  Nodesraisedconcernforabundancesofspecificspecies:CaI,CrI,NiI,ScII•  NodesexpressedconcernforgridlimitaGons(11%ofall

flags).

2quesGons:Survey:Whatarethemainconcerns?Howcanflagsbeqerhelptotracethem?Science:Areflagsused/useful?

Assigned,butun-exis;ngprefix

•  14001•  1 (1250occurrences)•  1112003 (6496occurrences)•  112003 (1594occurrences)

Unassignedflags(some;mesrequiredbynodes)

•  10080Inaccurateorrevisedspectralresolu;onR(usesuffixtospecifythecolumnwiththenewdetermina;on)

•  10090InaccurateorrevisedSNR(usesuffixtospecifythecolumnwiththenewdetermina;on)•  10100Saturatedspectrum•  10150:SuspiciousorbadCCF•  11050•  11300•  13025•  10301•  10307•  10309•  12001•  13000•  13010•  13024•  13025•  13026•  13031•  …

A.Casey

1001

010

015

1010

410

155

1021

010

302

1030

310

304

1030

510

308

1102

011

100

1120

011

250

1302

710

010

1005

010

153

1030

210

308

1302

013

021

1302

210

015

1002

010

106

1030

310

320

1110

011

150

1120

011

250

1302

013

027

10010100151010410155102101030210303103041030510308110201110011200112501302710010100501015310302103081302013021130221001510020101061030310320111001115011200112501302013027

EPINARBO

Lumba

OACT

100 101 102 103 104

A.Casey

1001

010

020

1003

010

040

1005

010

106

1030

310

306

1031

110

312

1032

010

500

1102

013

020

1302

213

023

1002

510

151

1015

310

200

1030

213

003

1412

610

010

1001

510

104

1015

510

210

1030

310

304

1110

011

200

1125

013

027

10010100201003010040100501010610303103061031110312103201050011020130201302213023100251015110153102001030213003141261001010015101041015510210103031030411100112001125013027

Arcetri

CAUP

OAPA

100 101 102 103

A.Casey

1005

0

1010

6

1030

0

1030

2

1030

3

1032

0

1039

9

1302

7

1030

8

1000

5

1001

0

1001

5

1002

0

1002

5

1010

3

1010

6

1010

8

1030

8

1039

9

1039

9

10050

10106

10300

10302

10303

10320

10399

13027

10308

10005

10010

10015

10020

10025

10103

10106

10108

10308

10399

10399

Liege

MGNDU

ROB

ROBGrid

100 101 102 103