Visual support for requirement elicitation techniquePresented by,

Nithin Shenoy Nimmy Joshy

Guide

Dr. A. Serebrenik (TU/e)

Barbara Pareglio (Ericsson)

Introduction

• Requirement elicitation• Process of discovering the requirements for a system by

communication with customers, system users and others who have a stake in the system development[1].

• Importance• First step towards identifying the “Right things to do”

and “Doing the things right”

• Challenges• Ambiguous requirements,• Assumed requirements• Conflicting requirements

Introduction Objective Literature Study Visual Support Future Work References/ SET Seminar 12/09/2009 PAGE 2

Contd..

PAGE 312/09/2009/ SET Seminar Introduction Objective Literature Study Visual Support Future Work References

Requirement elicitation with visualization

• Picture = 1000 words!!!

• Better understanding of requirements

• Can help identify new requirements

• Better way of keeping track of requirements

/ SET Seminar Introduction Objective Literature Study Visual Support Future Work References PAGE 412/09/2009

Objective

• Literature study of requirement elicitation techniques.• Feasibility study of visual support for requirement

elicitation techniques in Ericsson.

Introduction Objective Literature Study Visual Support Future Work References/ SET Seminar 12/09/2009 PAGE 5

Requirement elicitation techniques

• Categories [2]• Conversational

− Interviews, focus group, workshop, brainstorming

• Observational− Task Observation, protocol analysis

• Analytic methods− Card sorting, Laddering

• Collaborative− Scenarios/Use cases, prototyping

Introduction Objective Literature Study Visual Support Future Work References/ SET Seminar 12/09/2009 PAGE 6

Contd..

• So many elicitation techniques

PAGE 7

Which elicitation

technique to choose?

Introduction Objective Literature Study Visual Support Future Work References 12/09/2009/ SET Seminar

Framework to choose elicitation techniques

• A framework is required to decide on elicitation techniques to be used based on the project [4].

• Decision making needs two types of information • Attributes• Recommendations on adequacy

• The attributes describing the same context are grouped into factors.

/ SET Seminar Introduction Objective Literature Study Visual Support Future Work References 12/09/2009 PAGE 8

Contd..

• Different factors identified

/ SET Seminar PAGE 9

Factors

Elicitation process

Problem domain

InformantElicitor

Introduction Objective Literature Study Visual Support Future Work References 12/09/2009

Contd..

Elicitor

Training in elicitation techniques

Elicitation experience

Experience with elicitation

techniques

Familiarity with domain

High

Low

Zero

… … …

/ SET Seminar Introduction Objective Literature Study Visual Support Future Work References 12/09/2009 PAGE 10

• Elicitor attributes

Contd..

• Recommendations on adequacy of techniques for certain values of attributes

/ SET Seminar Introduction Objective Literature Study Visual Support Future Work References 12/09/2009 PAGE 11

Visualization support

• Commonly used elicitation technique is interviews• Open ended • Closed

• Identification of visualization tools

• Visualization using mind mapping technique

/ SET Seminar PAGE 12Introduction Objective Literature Study Visual Support Future Work References 12/09/2009

Visualization Tools

• Some of the tools identified • Free Mind• XMIND• VUE (Visual Understanding Environment)

Introduction

Objective

Literature

Study

Visual Suppo

rt

Future Work

References 12/09/2009 PAGE 13/ SET Seminar

Example – FreeMind

/ SET Seminar PAGE 14Introduction

Objective

Literature

Study

Visual Suppo

rt

Future Work

References 12/09/2009

Future work

• Applicability of visualization tool for other requirement elicitation techniques

• Feasibility study of visual support for requirement elicitation techniques.

/ SET SeminarIntroduc

tionObjecti

ve

Literature

Study

Visual Support

Future Work

References PAGE 1512/09/2009

References

[1] “Requirements Engineering A good practice guide,” Ian

Sommerville and Pete Sawyer, John Wiley and Sons, 1997.

[2] “Effective Requirements Development - A Comparison of

Requirements Elicitation techniques,” Zheying Zhang,

SQM2007 conference, 2007.

[3] “ACRE: Selecting Methods for Requirement Acquisition”,

N.A.M. Maiden, G. Rugg, Software engineering journal, May

1996.

[4] “Study of Elicitation Techniques Adequacy”, Dante Carrizo,

Oscar Dieste, Natalia Juristo, 11th Workshop in Requirement

Engineering, 2008.

/ SET Seminar PAGE 16Introduction

Objective

Literature

Study

Visual Suppo

rt

Future Work

References 12/09/2009

Questions

/ SET Seminar 12/09/2009 PAGE 17