Post on 13-Apr-2018
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
1/78
EMILE DURKHEIM:
THE CITY, THE DIVISION OF LABOUR AND THE MORAL
BASIS OF COMMUNITY
His method provides a direct contrast to the approaches of both KarlMarx and Max Weber
Durkheim assumes that reality is given in observation
He asserts the ability of sociology to penetrate the essence of socialphenomena
His is a positivist sociology His endorsement of a purely experimental basis for knowledge, his
equation of the logic of explanation between the natural and socialsciences.
Reality cannot be known through ideas about it.
Social phenomena in themselves as distinct from the consciously formedrepresentations of them in the mind
We must study them objectively as external things. Science thus beginswith a complete freedom of mind.
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
2/78
Social facts
Types of social solidarity
- sociology therefore relies on observable phenomena as indicators ofthe essence of social facts
Social facts
the collective phenomena of social life
Moral authority of laws and determinacy of socialization and collective life
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
3/78
Products of group life, it is the nature of the group
Durkheimssociology begins by identifying socialfacts
Two types of social solidarity 1. organic
2. mechanic
the growth of the division of labour
transition from one to the other
the analysis of the city becomes important
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
4/78
two factors give rise to an increased division of labour in society:
(a) material density(density of population increased
in a given area )(b) moral density ( increased density of interaction
and social relationship within a
population)
The division of labour (1933)
an increase in moral density
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
5/78
The increase in moral density of a society is expressed through
urbanization: Cities always result from the need of an individualsto put themselves in very intimate contact with others.
Urbanization together with the associated development of new
means of transportation and communication, is the cause of the
division of labour.
A concentrated human population can survive only through
differentiation of functions
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
6/78
An increase in population, necessarily determines advances in the
division of labour.
Increased moral density increased division of labour (the
collapse of the society or to the elimination of weaker competitors
within it)
Moral density is a necessary but not a sufficient condition.
The city as a force for change presents
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
7/78
The city undermines traditional controls that the collectivitycannot possibly impose a single code of moral conduct over the
diverse spheres of action in which the urbanite becomes involved,
The city extends its influence over the surrounding countryside
and thus urbanizes the society as a whole.
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
8/78
Division of labour social solidarity
a new organic solidarity of interdependence, but in a state of
moral basis of social life.
Role of the city as the primary force for change
It provided the organizational expression for functionaleconomic interests.
Rome was essentially an agricultural and military society basis
of association was familial rather than urban
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
9/78
As Marx and Weber deny the theoretical significance of the
modern city.
no longer no longer
express expressClass relation human association
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
10/78
He sees the city as an historically significant condition for the
development of particular social forces the division of labour
development by breaking down the bonds of traditional
morality.
He sees the modern city the expression of the current (abnormal)
development of these forces pathological disorganizationreflecting the anomic state of modern society
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
11/78
SOCIAL THEORY CAPITALISM AND THE
URBAN QUESTION
Most areas of sociology today are characterized by a certaindegree of theoretical and methodological pluralism and urban
sociology is no exception,
there are distinctive Marxist urban sociologies, Weberian urban
sociologies, each differing according to the questions they pose.Contemporary Marxist urban theories the method of
dialectical materialism, the theory of class struggle and
capitalist state
The central concern of all of these writers was with the social,economic and political implications of the development of
capitalism in the west at the time when they were writing
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
12/78
the rapid growth of cities was among the most obvious and potentially
disruptive of all social changes at that time.
In England and Wales, e.g., the urbanpopulation,nearly trebled in the
second half of the nineteenth century with the result that over 25 million
people ( 77% of the total population ) lived in urban areas at the turn of
the century.
The growth of urbanproblems the spread of slums and disease, thebreakdown of law and order, the increase in infant mortality rates and a
plethora of other phenomena.
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
13/78
the disintegration of moral cohesion Durkheim
the growth of calculative rationality Weber
the destructive forces unrealized by
the development of capitalist production - Marx
Durkheim's works on the social effects of the division of labour
came to be incorporated into ecological theories of city growth and
differentiation in the 1920s.
webers writings on political domination and social stratificationformed the basis for a conceptualization of the city as a system of
resource allocation in the 1960s.
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
14/78
In the 1970sMarxs analysis of social reproduction and class
struggle was developed as the foundation for a new political
economy of urbanism.
the paths followed by their ( weber, Durkheim, and Marx)
respective analyses are divergent, yet the end-point is the same.
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
15/78
MARX AND ENGELS: THE TOWN, THE COUNTRY
AND THE CAPITALIST MODE OF PRODUCTION
the discovery of the forces which shaped the development ofthe social world.
- as for ex: Darwins work had led to the discovery of the
forces shaping the evolution of the natural.
the principle of the dialectic is essentially that any wholeis
comprised of a unity of contradictory parts, such that it is
impossible to understand any one aspect of reality without
first relating it to its context.
capital and wage labour are tied together in an inescapable
yet absently antagonistic relation of mutual interdependence
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
16/78
a method of analysis which is dialectical no single aspect of
reality can be analyzed independently of the totality of social
relations.the term materialism in this context is generally used in
contra-distinction to idealism.
material world exists prior to our conceptions or ideas about
it.according to Marx, the first real class society was that of the
ancient city ( notably Rome).
roman society was based on a slave mode of production in
which the wealth of the ruling class was founded on
agricultural land ownership.
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
17/78
ownership of the means of production became increasing
concentrated into great estates.
ancient classical history is the history of cities but cities based onlandownership and agriculture.
the growth of a merchant class in the established towns during the
middle ages had the important effect of extending trading linksbetween different areas, thereby facilitating a division of labour
between different towns and stimulating the growth of new
industries.
the new system of capitalist manufacture facilitated by merchants
capital in the medieval towns, thus tools root in the countryside
and the great cities of the industrial revolution grew up around it.
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
18/78
the new social relations of capitalism thus became established asthe anti-thesis to the old social relations of feudalism.
the contradictions the class antagonism between industrialbourgeoisie and feudal landowners came to be represented directlyand vividly in the conflict between town and country.
in the feudal period the division between town and country notonly reflected the growing division of labour between manufactureand agriculture but was also the phenomenal depression of the anti-thesis between conflicting modes of production.
struggle between proletariat and bourgeoisie extends across urban-rural boundaries as workers in town and countryside areincreasingly drawn into the capital relation.
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
19/78
the role of the city in capitalist societies
- the city express most vividly the evils of capitalism
- within the city that the progressive forces of socialism aremost fully developed.
not the city that is held responsible for the poverty and
squalor of the urban proletariat, but the capitalist mode of
production.
the city is portrayed as the hot house of capitalist
contradictions.
the housing shortage from which the workers and part of thepetty bourgeoisie suffer in our modern big cities is one of the
innumerable smaller secondary evils, which result from the
present day capitalist mode of production
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
20/78
pattern of urban deprivation in that city
the city is not only a reflection of the logic of capitalism but
the necessary condition for the transition to socialism.
it is in the city that the revolutionary class created by
capitalism, the proletariat achieves its fullest classic perfection
capitalism are most fully developed in the great cities.common deprivation of the proletariat is most likely to result
in the growth of class consciousness and revolutionary
organization.
the city represents a concentration of the evils of capitalism, italso constitutes the necessary conditions for the development
of the workers movement that will overthrow it.
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
21/78
Marx and Engels communist manifesto to the effect that the
bourgeoisie has rendered a service to the workersmovement
by creating large cities which have rescued a considerable
part of the population from the idiocy of rural life.
the city may illustrate the manifestations of essential
tendencies within capitalism.
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
22/78
MAX WEBER: THE CITY AND THE GROWTH OF
RATIONALITY
webers approach to sociological explanation represents
almost a total reversal of Marxsmethod.
Marx emphasized totality, the need to relate everything toeverything else,
weber argues that only partial and one-sided accounts are ever
possible. the basic concept in webers sociology is that of the human
subject endowed with free will who, in interacting with others,attempts to realized certain values or objectives.
Ideal types: these are mental constructs which serve to specifythe theoretically most significant aspects of different classes ofsocial phenomena.
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
23/78
he suggests that cities are defined by the existence of an
established market system: economically defined, the city is a
settlement the inhabitants of which live primarily off trade and
commerce rather than agriculture.
the city is a market place
he then distinguishes between consumes, producer andcommercial cities on the basis of this economic criterion.
political dimension, he suggests that partial political
autonomy is a key criterion: The city must be considered to bea partially autonomous association, a community with
special political and administrative arrangements.
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
24/78
City 1. patriciancity,run by an assembly of notables.
2. plebeiancity,run by an elected assembly of citizen.
the political autonomy of the cities in northern Europe wasachieved on the basis of economic rather than military power.
taking these two dimensions together, weber then constructshis ideal type city.
To constitute a full Urban Community a settlement mustdisplay a relative predominance of trade commercial relationswith the settlement as a whole displaying the following
features.1. a fortification a tower, wall, gun position it built to
defend a place against attack .
2 k
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
25/78
2. a market
3. a court of its own and at least partially autonomous law
4. a related form of association
5. at least partial autonomy and autocephaly, thus also an
administration by authorities, in the election of whom
the burglars participated.
the medieval cities in western Europe sustained afundamental challenge to the feudal system which surrounded
them paved the way for the subsequent development of a
rational, legal, capitalistic social order.
this challenge partly from the erosion of traditional valuesand the development of new forms of individuals.
medieval cities as places of revolution as centres.
FERDINAND TONNIES
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
26/78
FERDINAND TONNIES
GEMEINSCHAFT AND GESELLSCHAFT
In the late 19thcentury, the German sociologist Ferdinand Tonnies
(1855-1937) studied how life in the new industrial metropolis
differed from life in rural villages.
Tonnies (1887) used the German word Gemeinschaft- (meaning
roughly community) to refer to a type of social organization by
which people are closely tied by kinship and tradition.
the Gemeinschaft of the rural village joins people in what amounts
to a single primary group.
on the contrary, Urbanization fosters Gesellschaft( a German word
meaning roughly association), a type of social organization bywhich people come together only on the basis of individual self-
interests.
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
27/78
In the Gesellschaft way of life, individuals are motivated by
their own needs rather than a drive to enhance the well-beingof everyone.
city dwellers display little sense of community or common
identity and look to others mostly as a means of advancingtheir individual goals.
Tonnies saw in Urbanization the erosion of close, enduring
social relations in favor of the fleeting and impersonal ties
typical of business.
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
28/78
THE URBAN AS A CULTURAL FORM
Tonnies classic study of Gemeinschaft and Gesellschaft
originally published in 1890 and republished with a newintroduction in 1931.
his purpose to study the sentiments and motives which draw
people to each other, keep them together and induce them to
joint action. 1. natural willthe sensations, feelings and instincts which
derive from physiological and psychological process in
born and inherited.
2. rational willthe deliberate, goal-oriented andcalculation product of the use of intellects.
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
29/78
social relationships were governed mainly by natural will
Gemeinschaft.
social relationships were governed mainly by rational will
Gesellschaft.
human societies had changed over time from form of
association based on Gemeinschaft to those based onGesellschaft.
extension of trade and the development of capitalism.
Gesellschaft as bourgeoisie society.
the unit of sentiment (in Gemeinschaft), flows from the
naturalbonds of blood, neighborhood and religious belief is
disrupted by the growth of industrial capitalism.
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
30/78
the possibility of a relation in the Gesellschaft assumes no
more than a multitude of mere persons who are capable of
delivering something and consequently of promisingsomething.
Gesellschaft = modern day capitalism
as the urban centers grow, so the Gemeinschaft of the ruralhinterland is eclipsed and undermined.
family life and village communalism are replaced by urban
individualism and state power, which itself carries the seeds of
a future development of socialist union.Tonnies work as regards the later development of Urban
Sociology.
ROBERT PARK THE URBAN AS AN ECOLOGICAL
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
31/78
ROBERT PARK : THE URBAN AS AN ECOLOGICAL
COMMUNITY
The ecological perspective advanced between the wars by
Robert Park and his colleagues at the University of Chicago.
Human ecology was the first comprehensive urban socialtheory and in the US it has some claim to have been the first
comprehensive sociological theory.
It developed at a time when America sociology was gaininginstitutional recognition as a discipline but lacked anindigenous body of theory.
human ecology could be seen as a sub-discipline withinsociology
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
32/78
Human ecology was concerned with the specific theoretical
problem of how human populations adapted to theirenvironment
Parksstudents Human ecology, as Park conceived it, wasnot a brand of sociology but rather a perspective a method
and a body of knowledge essential for the scientific study ofsocial life and hence, like social psychology, a generaldiscipline basic to all the social sciences.
From Emile Durkheim that Park derived his methodologicalframework and from Charles Darwin that he derived histheory.
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
33/78
Durkheims influence can be found first Parksontological assumptions regarding human nature andthe relationship between the individual and society.
- Ontology a branch of Philosophy that deals withontological(the nature of existence).
In 1916, Park wrote, thefact seems to be that men arebrought into the world with all the passions, instincts andappetites uncontrolled and undisciplined.
Park takes as his starting point the tension betweenindividual freedom and social control.
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
34/78
Like Durkheim, Park explains personal and socialdisorganization in terms of the erosion of moral constraints,
for homo ecologic in an inherently egoistical and unsocialcreatures who needs to be kept in check by society for his orher own good and for the good of others
Durkheim noted that social disorganization was the
necessary price to be paid for human progress.
Too much moral constraints was as bad as too little since itresulted in individual fatal and social stagnation.
So, Park found in the break-down of traditional moral controlsa cause for both concern and celebration.
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
35/78
He saw that the growth of the cities had undermined the socialcohesion once maintained by the family, the church and the villageand he pointed to the threat of the mob sweptby every new windof doctrine, subject to constant alarms.
He saw the potential for individual freedom and self-expressionthat the city represented.
Disorganization new level of human organization involving newmodes of social control
Human nature and moral constraints any form of human
organization was necessarily an expression of both.the structure of the city = 1) its physical structure and 2) its moral
order.
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
36/78
Human society involves a double aspect
community and society
as the biotic as its cultural level
of social life proved highly problematic
Ecology is concerned with communities rather than societies.
The ecological approach to social relations, therefore, wascharacterized by an emphasis on the biotic as opposed to thecultural aspect of human interaction.
Web of life through which all organisms were related to allothers in ties of interdependence or symbiosis.
Competition for the basic resources of life thus resulted in theadaptation of different species to each other and to theirenvironment.
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
37/78
The evolution of a relatively balanced ecological system basedupon competitive co-operation among differentiated and
specialized organisms.
His analysis in other words, is both functional and spatial: the mainpoint is that the community so conceived is at once a territorial anda functional unit.
His idea of the development of functional differentiation andinterdependence in the human community draw heavily onDurkheimsanalysis of the origins of the Division of Labor.
Park suggests that an increase in population size within a givenarea, together with an extension of transport and communicationnetworks, results in greater specialization of functions.
ERNEST WATSON BURGESS (1886-1966)
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
38/78
ERNEST WATSON BURGESS (1886 1966)
24thpresident of the American Sociological Society
University of Chicago Asst.Professor in Sociology
Born in Tilburg, Ontario, Canada.
Kingfisher College in Oklahoma and received B.A., in
1908.
university of Chicago Ph.D., in 1913.
He has been called the first young sociologist.
His career spanned for five decades (1916-1957).
In his 1951 book, American Sociology: The Story ofsociology in the US through 1950.
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
39/78
Processes of competition, dominance, succession and
invasion that provide the basis for the well-known modelof community expansion proposed by Burgess (1967)
City could be conceptualized ideally as consisting of
five zones arranged in a pattern of concentric circles.
The expansion of the city occurred as a result of the
invasion by each zone of the next outer zone.
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
40/78
The Central business district tended to expand into
the surrounding inner-city, zone of transition which inturn tended to expand into the zone of working-class
housing around it.
This physical process of succession therefore results
in the segregation of different social groups in
different parts of the city according to their suitability;
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
41/78
In the expansion of the City, a process of distribution
takes place which sifts and sorts and relocateindividuals and groups by residence and occupation.
Segregation offers the group and thereby the individual
who compose the group, a place and a role in the total
organization of city life.
Thi t t f h d dj t t
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
42/78
This constant process of change and adjustments,
invasion and succession, disorganization and
reorganization is especially marked in the inner-city zone
of transition.
Burgess recognized that mobility is therefore most
pronounced in the inner-city areas that are in an almost
constant state of flux, and he sees this as the explanation
for the social disorganization that tends to characterized
these area.
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
43/78
Mobility, in other words, is a source of change and of
personal and social disorganization.
where mobility is greatest, so too is the lack of social
cohesion and the demoralization of the human spirit.
These processes are natural and spontaneous response of
human population to changes in the environment in which
they live.
H b i j d f bilit hi h l t did t
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
44/78
Human beings enjoyed scope for mobility which plants did not
possess. They had a capacity for consciously changing their
environment.
Mckenzie observes, the Human community different from the
plant community in the two characteristics of mobility and
purpose,
that is, in the power to select a habitat and in ability to control or
modify the conditions of the habitat.
Human beings, in other words, shared a culture.
ROBERT McKENZIE
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
45/78
ROBERT McKENZIE
One of Parkscolleagues at the University of Chicago.
The Ecological Approach to the Study of the HumanCommunity.
It is a method of analysis; plants & animals
Biology
Society is made up of individuals spatially separated,
territorially distributed and capable of independent
locomotion.
These spatial relationships of human beings are the
products of competition and selection.
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
46/78
competition selection
spatial relationships
of human beings
process of changeThese spatial relationships change
the physical basis of social relations is altered
producing social and political problems
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
47/78
Natural process of Human
ecology = competition & = ecology
accommodation
Sociologist has failed to recognize the above and it
determining the size and ecological organization of the
human community.The human community differs fro the plant community in
the two dominant characteristics of mobility and purpose.
Man is a gregarious animal; he can not live alone; he is
relatively week and need not only the company of otherhuman associated both shelter and protection from the
elements as well.
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
48/78
McKenzie (1967): the size of any human community is
limited by what it can produce and by the efficiency of its
mode of distribution.
a primary service community (based on agriculture)
cannot grow beyond a population of around 5000.
an industrial town can grow to many times that size
provided its industries are serviced by an efficient
system of market distribution.
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
49/78
Any particular type of community tended to increase
in size until it reached its climax point at which the
size of population was almost perfectly adjusted to
the capacity of the economic base to support it.
The community would then remain in this state of
equilibrium until some new element (e.g., a new
mode of communication or a technological
innovation) distributed the balance.
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
50/78
Competition = would again sift and sort the population
functionally and spatially until a new climax stage wasreached.
Drawing again on Darwinswork, the human ecologists
referred to this process of structured community changeas succession that orderly sequence of changes
through which a biotic community passes in the course of
its development from a primary and relatively unstable to
a relatively permanent or climax stage
so too in the human community the pattern of land use
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
51/78
so, too in the human community the pattern of land use
changes as areas are invaded by new competitors which
are better adapted to the changed environmental
conditions than the existing users.
such a process of invasion and succession is reflected in
the human community in changes in land values with theresult that competition for desirable sites forces out the
economically weaker existing users (e.g., residents) who
make way for economically stronger competitors (e.g.,
business).
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
52/78
following a successful invasion a new equilibrium is then
established and the successional sequence comes to an
end.
The human community differs from the plant communityin two dominant characteristics of mobility and purpose,
that is, in the power to select a habitat and in the ability to
control or modify the conditions of the habitat.
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
53/78
Human beings, in other words, shared a culture.
McKenzie argues that the biotic forces of competitionalways tend to produce a natural equilibrium at the point
where the population is optimally adjusted to its
environment.
At this climax stage, the community is functionally and
spatially differentiated such that different functional
groups are located in different areas according to their
relative suitability.
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
54/78
As this unstable biotic equilibrium develops, so too do
distinctive cultural forms corresponding to the different
areas: The general effect of the continuous processes of
invasions and accommodations is to give to the
developed community well-defined areas, each having its
own peculiar selective and cultural characteristics.
McKen ies major orks
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
55/78
McKenziesmajor works:
1. The neighborhood: A study of local life in Columbus,Ohio.(1921)
2. The ecological approach to the study of the humancommunity, chapter-3 (1925)
3. The Metropolitan community, New York, McGrawHill(1933).
4. The Ecology of institution (1936)
5. On human ecology selection writings (edit) by
Amos Henry Hawley, University of Chicago press(1968).
GEORGE SIMMEL (1858-1918)
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
56/78
German sociologist and Philosopher, born in Jewish family in Berlin.
He studied history and philosophy at University of Berlin
His Ph.D., in1881.
He published over 200 articles over a dozen books.
He offered a micro-analysis of cities, studying how Urban life shapes individual
experience
According to Simmel, individuals perceive the city as a crush of people, objects
and events.
His writings on the sociology of space are a case study of Simmelscontributionsto social sciences concepts.
Simmelswriting on space appears in two articles
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
57/78
1. 1903- The sociology of space
2. on the spatial projections of social forms
In 1908 three essays on (a) The social Boundary, (b) The
sociology of the senses, (c) The Strangers
The chaptersspatial themes including:
a) the socially relevant aspect of space
b) the effect of spatial conditions upon social interaction and
c) upon forms of social, physical and psychological distance
he did not present an organized theory of space
Simmel's approach to spatial analysis
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
58/78
* The sociology of space a contribution of his uncompleted project
to express the preconditions of human sociation by formed categories oftime, mass and number which he called socialgeometry.
The Metropolis and Mental Life: Simmelssociology is highly personal,
willfully eclectic and internally incoherent.
concern with the questions of individuality and freedom, modernity and
the division of labour, and intellectual rationality and the money
economy.
All of these concerns are expressed in his essay on the metropolis and
mental life.
sociology, therefore is the science of the forms of human
association as abstracted from real world interaction
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
59/78
association as abstracted from real-world interaction.
interaction among its members
the personal and emotional commitments of members ofsmall groups are replaced by formal means of control ( asagencies of the law).
custom is characteristics of small groups, law ischaracteristic of large ones.
An increase in the size of a social group
the scope of individual freedom & but also for the degree ofindividual distinctiveness
As a group expands, so it threatens to immerse the individualwith the mass: It pulls the individual down to a level with all
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
60/78
with the mass: It pulls the individual down to a level with alland sundry
The intellect of the individual is eroded by the emotion of themasses, and social interaction is debased as social life becomesgrounded in the lowest common denominations.
The larger the group, the more impersonal group interactionbecomes and the less concerned members become with theunique personal qualities of others.
people in the metropolis come to emphasize their ownsubjectivity both to others and to themselves.
In the large group, the individual stands alone isolated
yet rejoicing in the privacy which the metropolis affords
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
61/78
yet rejoicing in the privacy which the metropolis affords.
The social effects of size thus leads to the conclusionthat in a large group:
1. custom is replaced by formal social control
mechanisms
2. the individualscommitments become extended across
a number of different social circles.
3. the scope of individual freedom is increased
4. the character of social relations is highly impersonal5. the individualsconsciousness of self is ----
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
62/78
development of an advanced division of labor in society
1. the growth of the division of labor in modern societies
forms of human associations.
2. the division of labor reinforces the self-consciousness
engendered by an increase in size
3. the division of labor therefore encourages egoism andindividualism
these characteristics of modernity
the development of a money economy
Money is totally depersonalized for its exchange leaves
no trace of the personality of its previous owner.
It reduces all qualitative values to a common quantitative
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
63/78
It reduces all qualitative values to a common quantitative
base.
It is a source of individual freedom and independencecash economy social expansion individual freedom of
choice.
the finest expression of the rationality of the modern world.
Money is both the source and the expression of metropolitanrationality and intellectualism
Metropolises are guided by their heads rather than their
hearts by calculation and intellect not affection and emotion.
Money expresses all qualitative differences of things interms of howmuch?.
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
64/78
Money, with all its colorlessness and indifferencebecomes the common denominator of all values.
his unique emphasis on sociology of number.
the metropolis is above all a large human agglomeration
city in other than merely geographical or numericalterms.
LOUIS WIRTH (1897-1952)
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
65/78
Major figure in the Chicago school of Urban sociology.
Wirth (1938) is best known for blending the ideas of Tonnies,Durkheim, Simmel and Park into a comprehensive theory ofurban life.
City as a setting with a large dense and socially diverse
population
these traits result in an impersonal, superficial and transitoryway of life.
living among millions of others, urbanites come into contact
with many more people than rural residents.
when city people notice other at all they usually know them not in
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
66/78
when city people notice other at all, they usually know them not interms of Who they are! but what they do ?- as, for instance the busdriver, florist or grocery store clerk.
specialized urban relationships can be pleasant enough for allconcerned.
limited social involvement coupled with great social diversitymakes city dwellers more tolerant than rural villagers.
Rural communities often jealously enforce their narrow traditions
but the heterogeneous population of a city rarely shares any singlecode of moral conducts.
Tonnies and Wirth saw personal ties and traditional morality
lost in the anonymous rush of the city.
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
67/78
lost in the anonymous rush of the city.
Wirth (1945) explained it, the basic physical and natural forces
at work in human society establish the framework and thecontext within which people act and human ecology is
therefore basic and complementary to the analysis of social
organization and social psychology.
Human ecology is not a substitute for but a supplement to, the
other frames of reference and methods of social investigation.
Wirths essay can be seen as an extension, modification and
development of Simmel's paper on the Metropolis
Wirthsarticle on the city from the sociological standpoint
Simmelsidentifies size Wirthspaper by an
as a key explanatory variable analysis of heterogeneity
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
68/78
as a key explanatory variable analysis of heterogeneity
and analysis of the while the effects of a
division of labour is money economy are
Replaced by dropped from the
analysis
altogether.
He also drew upon some of the insights developed by
the Chicago Human ecologists as regards the effects of
density on human organization and the dominanceachieved by the city over its hinterland.
Three significant perspective on the city
H l
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
69/78
-Human ecology
-Organizational City
-socio-psychological
To develop a theory of the city that could account for the ecological,
organizational and socio-psychological characteristics of Urbanism
Variations in patterns of human association may be explained as the effects of
three factors size, density and heterogeneity.
The task for urban sociology is then to analyze the extent to which each of these
three variable gives risk to definite forms of social relationships.
Wirths emphasizes that folkways of life may still be found incities, for previously dominant patterns of human association are notcompletely obliterated by urban growth
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
70/78
completely obliterated by urban growth.
Urbanways of life are likely to spread beyondthe boundaries ofthe city, given the ecological dominance of the city over itshinterland.
Wirthsanalysis of the social effects of size closely reflects that of
Simmel.large size -----------> greater variation
the spatial segregation of differentgroups
acc.to ethnicity, race, status,occupation and so on
Simmel increase in size reduces the changes of any
two individuals knowing each other
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
71/78
t o d dua s o g eac ot e
personally,
segmentalism in social relationships
secondary rather than primary contacts
His earlier study of a Jewish Ghetto in Chicago for ex.,
he concluded that it formed a cultural community with a
communal way of life.
The individual gains a certain degree of emancipation orfreedom from the personal and emotional controls of
intimate groups.
The effects of density on social relationships are a
function of the growth of differentiation.
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
72/78
g
Density thus reinforces the effect of numbers indiversifying men and their activities and in increasing the
complexity of the social structure.
People relate to each other on the basis of their specific
roles rather than their personal qualities.
the analysis of social heterogeneity is concluded largelyin terms of Simmels
ROBERT REDFIELD
born 4th December 1897, died on 16th October 1958.
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
73/78
born 4 December 1897, died on 16 October 1958.
U.S. pioneer of Urban sociology and anthropology
From his studies of Mexican communities Redfield developed a
theory (1956) of a folk-urban continuum to account for the difference
between folk society and urban society.
A folk society was small in size, isolated, homogeneous, preliterate
with a social and cultural life linked to kinship and sacred beliefs.
Urban society had opposite of all these features
He believed that any community had a place on this continuum
from folk to urban.
this scale implied that simpler or folk forms of society
would evolve to complex social forms with time.
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
74/78
Anthropologists new consider the way folk and urbansocieties are part of a larger social, political and
economic environment, rather than considered as
separate poles on a continuum.
Robert Redfield was a student of Robert Park.
Redfield (1941) studied four communities in the Yucatan
Peninsula of Mexico, ranging from the small,
homogeneous and very isolated settlement at Tusik to
the largest town in the region, Merida.
on the basis of this study, he argued that the less isolated and more
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
75/78
heterogeneous the settlement, the more it became characterized by
cultural disorganization, secularization and the growth of
individualism.
Redfield (1947), proceeded to develop an ideal type of the folk
society which complemented wirths analysis by identifying the
characteristics of communities at the other end of the rural-urbancontinuum.
Folk societies have certain features in common which enable us to
think of them as a type a type which contrasts with the society of themodern city.
Society folk society > small, isolated, illiterate
and homogeneous with a strong
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
76/78
sense of group solidarity
Modern city -> vast, complicated andrapidly changing world
The ideal type folk society
small, isolated, non-literate, intimate, immobile,
homogeneous and cohesive.
a rudimentary division of labor based mainly on a rigid
differentiation of sex roles;
the means of production were stared;
economic activity was contained within the community
culture strongly traditional and uncritical
it was grounded in social bonds based upon kinship andli i
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
77/78
religion.
its internal coherence derived from custom rather thanformal law.
patterns of interaction were based on ascribed statusand social relationships were personal and diffuse.
there is no place for the motive of commercial gain.
the work of wirth and Redfield exhibits two main themes.
- the first is that patterns of human relationships can beconceptualized in terms of a pair of logically opposite idealtypes.
Redfieldswork : variations in patterns of human
relationships between different communities are to
7/27/2019 Urban Sociological Theories
78/78
p
be explained in terms of differences in their size
and density their degree of internal homogeneityand the extent of their isolation from other centres
of population.
the value judgment that folk societies are good
and urban societies bad.
folksocieties are integrated while urban societiesare the great disorganizing force.