Post on 04-Apr-2018
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
1/70
Lecture XIX
Insurance Companies andPension Funds
PART I
FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS
INSURANCE COMPANIESTrimester II
FIM
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
2/70
Insurance Companies and
Pension Funds
These two non bank institutions also take
funds from one sector and invest them inanother, like other financial intermediaries
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
3/70
Insurance Companies
Insurance companies assume the risk of theirclients in return for a fee, called the premium
Most people purchase insurance because theyare risk-aversethey would rather pay acertainty equivalent (the premium) than accepta gamble
Insurance benefits peoples lives by reducing the
size of reserves they would have to maintain tocover possible loss of life or property
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
4/70
Seven basic principles applicableto all insurance companies
1. There must be a relationship between the insured andthe beneficiary. Further, the beneficiary must besomeone who would suffer if it werent for the insurance.
2. The insured must provide full and accurate informationto the insurance company.
3. The insured is not to profit as a result of insurancecoverage.
4. If a third party compensates the insured for the loss, theinsurance companys obligation is reduced by the
amount of the compensation.
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
5/70
Seven basic principles contd.
5. The insurance company must have a largenumber of insured so that the risk can be spreadout among many different policies.
6. The loss must be quantifiable. For example, anoil company could not buy a policy on anunexplored oil field.
7. The insurance company must be able tocompute the probability of the losss occurring.
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
6/70
Adverse Selection and Moral Hazardin Insurance
Asymmetric information plays a large rolein the design of insurance products. Aswith other industries, the presence ofadverse selection and moral hazardimpacts the industry, but is fairly wellunderstood by the insurance companies.
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
7/70
Adverse Selection in Insurance
The adverse selection problem raises theissue as to which policies, an insurancecompany should accept.
Those most likely to suffer loss are mostlikely to apply for insurance.
In the extreme, insurance companiesshould turn down anyone who applies foran insurance policy.
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
8/70
Response to the Problem ofAdverse Selection in Insurance
Insurance companies have found reasonablesolutions to deal with this problem:
Screening of applications
Risk based premium
Health insurance policies require a physicalexam
Pre-existing conditions may be excluded fromthe policy
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
9/70
Moral Hazard in Insurance
Moral hazard occurs in the insuranceindustry when the insured fails to takeproper precautions (or takes on more risk)to avoid losses because losses are coveredby the insurance policy.
Insurance companies use deductibles tohelp control this problem.
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
10/70
Types of Insurance
Insurance is classified by which type ofundesirable event is covered:
Life Insurance
Health Insurance
Property and Casualty Insurance
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
11/70
Growth and Organization of LifeInsurance Companies in the US
The number of insurance companies grewsteadily until 1988, and since then thenumber has fallen steadily.
This can be seen in the next slide.
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
12/70
Number of Life Insurance Companies in the U.S., 1950-2002
Growth of Life Insurance Companies in US
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
13/70
Organization of Life Insurance Companies
The previous slide also shows that Life insurancecompanies may be organized in twodifferent ways:
A stock company is owned by shareholders and hasa profit motive
A mutual insurance company is owned by thepolicyholders and attempts to provide the lowestcost insurance
At the end of 2002, only 83 of 1159 Lifeinsurance companies in the US were mutualinsurance companies.
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
14/70
Life Insurance
Life insurance policies come in many forms.Some of the typical policies include:
Term Life: the insured is covered while the policy
is in effect, usually 1020 years.
Whole Life: similar to term life, but allows thepolicyholder to borrow against the policies cash
value. When the term of policy expires, theinsured can get the then cash value of thepolicy.
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
15/70
Some more typical policies
Universal Life: includes both a term life
portion and a savings portion.
Annuities: pays a benefit to the insured untildeath, to cover retirement years.
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
16/70
Expected Life of Personsat Various Ages in US
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
17/70
Basic Principles for Investments
Because life insurance liabilities are verypredictable, these insurers are able toinvest in long term assets
Property and casualty insurancecompanies have to keep their assets moreliquid to pay out on unexpected losses
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
18/70
Life Insurance Companies: Liabilities
Life insurance companies have two primaryliabilities:
Life insurance payouts
Pension fund payouts
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
19/70
Life Insurance CompaniesInflow of funds and Investment of Assets
Life insurance companies derive funds from two sources: They receive premiums that must be used to payout future
claims when the insured dies
They receive premiums paid into pension funds managed by thelife insurance company
The next two slides show the distribution in US of
the typical life insurance companys assets (2003) in various
classes, including mortgages (the term represents mortgage loans& direct real estate investment; and
trend of assets invested in mortgages (from 1920 to 2004). Thedecline therein reflects a shift to lower-risk assets (as aconsequence of losses suffered by some insurance companies inthe 80s) and the decline has been offset by increased investment incorporate bonds and government securities
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
20/70
Distribution of Life Insurance Company Assets (beginning of 2003)
Life Insurance Company in USAssets Break up
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
21/70
Percentage of Life Insurance Company Assets Invested in Mortgages
Life Insurance CompanyAssets invested in Mortgages
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
22/70
Health Insurance mostly through Group Policies
Health insurance policies are highlyvulnerable to the adverse selectionproblem. Those with known or expected
health problems are more likely to seekcoverage.
Thus mostly health insurance is offered
through group policies. Individual policies are priced assuming
adverse selection.
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
23/70
Meaning ofNamed-Peril & Open-Peril Policies
Property Insurance: protects businesses andowners from the risk associated with ownership.
Named-peril policies: insures against any
losses only from perils specifically named inthe policy
Open-peril policies: insures against any
losses exceptfrom perils specifically named inthe policy
P I & C l I
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
24/70
Property Insurance & Casualty Insurance
Re-insurance
Casualty Insurance: also known as liabilityinsurance, protects against liability for harmthe insured may cause to others as a resultof product failure or accidents.
Motor insurance in a combination ofproperty & casualty insurance
Re-insurance: allocates a portion of the riskto another company in exchange for aportion of the premium.
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
25/70
Insurance Regulation in US
The McCarran-Ferguson Act of 1945 explicitlyexempts insurance companies from any typeof federal regulation.
In the US, most insurance regulation is atthe state level
Regulation is typically designed to protectpolicyholders from losses, or expandinsurance coverage in the state.
Who takes care of regulation of insurancein India?
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
26/70
Indian RegulatorInsurance Regulatory and Development Authority
Composition of Authority under IRDA Act, 1999
Section 4 of IRDA Act 1999, specifies thecomposition of Insurance Regulatory
and Development Authority (IRDA). TheAuthority is a ten member teamappointed by the Government of Indiaconsisting of
(a) a Chairman;(b) five whole-time members;(c) four part-time members.
INDIAN INSURANCE INDUSTRY
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
27/70
INDIAN INSURANCE INDUSTRYHistorical Background
Insurance industry, as on 1.4.2000, comprised mainly just twoplayers, both state-owned:
Life Insurer:Life Insurance Corporation of India (LIC)
General Insurer: General Insurance Corporation of India (GIC) (with
effect from Dec 2000, a National Reinsurer)
GIC had four subsidiary companies, namely (with effect from Dec2000, these subsidiaries were de-linked from the parent companyand made independent insurance companies.
The Oriental Insurance Company Limited
The New India Assurance Company Limited
National Insurance Company Limited
United India Insurance Company Limited.
Th t f i t i
http://www.licindia.com/http://gicofindia.in/http://www.orientalinsurance.nic.in/http://www.newindia.co.in/http://www.nationalinsuranceindia.com/http://www.uiic.co.in/http://www.uiic.co.in/http://www.nationalinsuranceindia.com/http://www.newindia.co.in/http://www.orientalinsurance.nic.in/http://gicofindia.in/http://www.licindia.com/7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
28/70
The story of private insurancebegan in India during 2000
Life Insurance: 10 New Entrants in 2000 & 2001 Non Life Insurance : 6 New Entrants during 2000
& 2001 (largest sub-segments in descending orderinclude motor over 40%, health, fire & marine)
26 companies have entered the business of life(12) & non-life (14) insurance thereafter
Two of the companies which are in the non-life
insurance business are exclusively providing healthinsurance
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
29/70
INSURANCE BUSINESS: BASICS
Life Insurers transact life insurancebusiness; general Insurers transact therest. No composites are permitted as perlaw.
LEGISLATION: Insurance is a federalsubject in India.
The primary legislations that deal with
insurance business in India are: Insurance Act, 1938, and
Insurance Regulatory & DevelopmentAuthority Act, 1999
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
30/70
Insurance Products: An Overview Life Insurance:
Popular Products: Unit linked Insurance Policies (ULIPS),Endowment Assurance (Participating), and Money Back(Participating) are the popular products. Various otherproducts have also been launched by life insurers
Money back policy provides for periodic payments ofpartial survival benefits during the term of the policy, aslong as the policyholder is alive. They differ fromendowment policy in the sense that in an endowmentpolicy survival benefits are payable only at the end of theendowment period.
General Insurance:
Motor Vehicle insurance is compulsory. Thereafter, Fireand Health insurance businesses are predominant.
Tariff Advisory Committee (TAC)
used to earlier lay down tariff rates for some of the
general insurance products
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
31/70
CUSTOMER PROTECTION:
Insurance Industry has Ombudspersons in 12cities
Each Ombudsman is empowered to redresscustomer grievances in respect of insurancecontracts on personal lives, where the
insured amount is less than Rs. 20 lakhs, inaccordance with the Ombudsman Scheme
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
32/70
APPROVED INVESTMENTSExhaustive lists are given in the guidelines issued by IRDA forinvestment of funds by the insurance companies.
Broadly, the various categories of approved investmentsinclude the following:
CENTRAL GOVERNMENT SECURITIES
STATE GOVERNMENT/OTHER APPROVED SECURITIES/OTHERGUARANTEED SECURITIES
APPROVED TERM LOANS/BONDS/DEBENTURES RELATED TOHOUSING & LOANS TO STATE GOVERNMENTS FOR HOUSINGAND FIRE FIGHTING EQUIPMENTS
APPROVED INFRASTRUCTURE/SOCIAL SECTORINVESTMENTS
CERTAIN APPROVED INVESTMENTS SUBJECT TO EXPOSURENORMS
CERTAIN OTHER CATEGORIES, OTHER THAN ABOVE
MENTIONED APPROVED INVESTMENTS
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
33/70
Approval of Products by IRDA
The products offered by the insurancecompanies are approved by IRDA
For every product/rider, there is a UIN(Unique Identification Number) allotted byIRDA
Micro Insurance Products (MIP) offered byvarious companies are also approved byIRDA and a UIN is allotted to each MIP
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
34/70
Insurance Agents: Training Agents are not on the payroll of the insurance company.
The insurance agents get a fixed commission on each
policy they sell Composite Agent is one who sells both life and general
insurance policies
The applicant has to undergo at least 100 hourspractical training in life or general insurance businesswhich may be spread over three to four weeks, wheresuch applicant is seeking license for the first time to actas an insurance agent. The training institutes arerequired to cover the syllabus prescribed by theAuthority during this period
Once the training is complete, the candidate is eligibleto appear for an online examination conducted by IRDA,and would require at least 50% marks for qualifying
The agent is supposed to renew his license after threeyears, by putting in another 25 hours (and 50 hours for
composite insurance agent) of training
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
35/70
Comprehensive Regulations: IRDA
There are comprehensive guidelines issued by IRDA,
in regard to various aspects, including: Appointment of actuaries
Insurance Agents
Training of insurance agents
Corporate Agents
Ombudsmen
Surveyors
TPAs for health services Submission of annual and other reports
Insurance awareness campaigns
Grievance cells
Insurance Companies and
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
36/70
Insurance Companies andPension Funds
Pension Funds
Trimester IIFIM Lecture XIX Part II
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
37/70
Pensions: The US Perspective
Definition:A pension plan is an asset pool thataccumulates over an individuals working years
and is paid out during the non-working years.
Developed as Americans began relying less ontheir children for care during their later years.
Also became popular as life expectancy
increased.
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
38/70
Types of Pensions: Defined Benefit Plan
Defined-Benefit Pension Plans: a planwhere the sponsor promises the employeea specific benefit when they retire.
For example:Monthly Retirement Payment =
(50% of monthly average of Last 12 monthsBasic Pay plus dearness Allowance) * (No
of years of service / 30)
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
39/70
More on Defined Benefit Pension Plans
Defined-Benefit Pension Plans place aburden on the employer to properly fundthe expected retirement benefit payouts.
Fully funded: sufficient funds are available to
meet payouts Over-funded: funds exceed the expected
payout
Under-funded: funds are not expected to meetthe required benefit payouts
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
40/70
Some other types of Pension Plans Defined-Contribution Pension Plan:
a plan where a set amount is invested for retirement, but thebenefit payout is uncertain.
Benefits depend on the returns generated by the plans
Private Pension Plans:
any pension plan set up by employers, groups, orindividuals
Most private pension plans in US are insured by thePension Benefit Guarantee Corporation, which paysbenefits when the plans sponsor goes bankrupt or is
otherwise unable to make payments Public Pension Plan:
Any pension plan set up by a government body forthe general public (e.g., Social Security in the US,
which is the largest public pension plan)
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
41/70
Distribution of Private Pension Plan Assets (end of 2003)LOOK AT THE PROPORTION OF FUNDS INVESTED IN
STOCKS
Investment of Private Pension Plan Assets
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
42/70
Worries on Social Security in US Social Security System in the US is a Pay as
you go system, where current funding is used(partially) to pay current benefits
So, in a way, the current retirees are receivingpayments from current workers
Projected number of workers is falling whileprojected number of retirees is increasing
This is receiving increasing attention becauseof the fear that the amount being paid into thesocial security system in future may not besufficient for the sums to be paid out
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
43/70
Past Social Security Assets: 1957-2003
Social Security Fund Assets, 19572003
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
44/70
Projected Social Security Trust Fund Assets
Projected Social Security Assets: 1998-2038
Big Jump in Pension Plans
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
45/70
Big Jump in Pension Plansafter a Supreme Court Ruling in US
A major U.S. Supreme Court decision in1949 established that pension benefitswere a legitimate part of collective
bargaining.
The number of plans increased after this asunions negotiated for such plans.
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
46/70
Regulation of Pension Plans in US
Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974
ERISA established guidelines for funding
Allowed plan credit to transfer with employees
Established vesting requirements to gainplan benefits
Increased disclosure requirements
Assigned regulatory oversight by departmentof labor
401(K) Plans IRAs and Roth IRAs in US
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
47/70
401(K) Plans, IRAs and Roth IRAs in US In 1978, the congress amended the Internal Revenue
Code by adding section 401(k), whereby employees arenot taxed on income they choose to receive as deferredcompensation rather than direct compensation. The lawwent into effect on 1 Jan 1980
In the mid-1980s, there were fewer than 8 millionparticipants with less than $100 billion of assets in
401(k) plans. By 2006, there were seventy millionparticipants with more than $3 trillion of assets in 401(k)plans
Section 401(k) plan proved popular with workers at alllevels because it had higher yearly contribution limits
than the Individual Retirement Accounts (IRA); it usuallycame with a company match, and in some waysprovided greater flexibility than the IRA
The other variant of the IRA account is the Roth IRA. Incontrast to a traditional IRA, contributions to a Roth IRA
are not tax-deferrable. Withdrawals are generally tax-free
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
48/70
The Future of Pension Funds
We can expect their growth and popularity asthe average age of population continues togrow.
Variety of pension fund offerings mayincrease as well.
Pension funds may gain significant control of
corporations as their stock holdings increase.
Lot of big companies in the world
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
49/70
Lot of big companies in the worldalso in deep waters
Japans top 278 companies were a combined
21.5 trillion yen ($235.7 billion) behind on theirpension funding in fiscal 2009, a 50 percentincrease from the previous year, according tothe Daiwa Institute of Research in Tokyo.
Hitachis unfunded liabilities totaled 1.1 trillionyen
The pension plans suffer from two decades ofslumping markets, an aging population and adependence on packages that are immune to
investment performance. Japan Inc. stuck with defined-benefit plans
even as the countrys stock market has slid andinterest rates have hovered near zero.
JAL Pension Shortfall May Prompt
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
50/70
JAL Pension Shortfall May PromptJapan Inc. to Change Its Ways
The news about Japan Airlines Corp.s$25.5 billion bankruptcy a year ago may bethe impetus for companies including HitachiLtd. and Toyota Motor Corp., Japans
biggest private employers, to shore up theirdeficit-ridden pension plans.
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
51/70
Worldwide moves towards Private Retirement Systems Driven by fears about the un-sustainability of their social
security programmes, many countries have initiated thedevelopment of multi-pillar pension systems, whichseek to integrate both public and private components.
This has led to a rapid growth of mandatory as well asvoluntary privately managed pension funds and reducedthe reliance on public social security systems.
These new private retirement systems are oftensupported by the state with tax incentives.
When mature, they will control a substantial portion ofthe financial assets in an economy and exerciseconsiderable influence over the allocation of capital andthe financial well-being of a large section of thepopulace.
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
52/70
Present Indian pension system
The present Indian pension system islargely publicly managed and tightlycontrolled.
Proposals have been made over the yearssuggesting introduction of privateparticipation, in order to:
expand coverage,
increase returns, and
improve efficiency.
Absence of a social security programme in India
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
53/70
Absence of a social security programme in India
India does not have what is commonly referred to
as a first pillar social security programme, thatprovides significant income replacement for themajority of the population, as is common in mostadvanced countries.
The central government operates a variety ofpoverty alleviation programmes funded out of itsgeneral tax revenues targeted at people below thepoverty line.
However, there is no public system run out of thegovernments budget to which citizens contribute
and receive benefits.
Mandatory Occupational Plans for organized sector for
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
54/70
Mandatory Occupational Plans for organized sector forprovision of Retirement Income Security in India
Mandatory occupational plans forming what is typically termed a
second pillar are presently the mainstay of retirement incomesecurity.
These plans, however, cover only the salaried workers employedin specified industries and classes of establishments that arenotified by the government, which cover most of the organised
sector. Such occupational arrangements utilise a dual benefit structure,
with each employee generally being a member of a DC plan that
is not annuitised and allows early withdrawals for somespecified purposes (called a provident fund), as well as a DB
plan that pays a life pension (called a pension fund). Rates ofcontribution are high, ranging from 20% to 24% of salary.
In addition, most of the salaried workers in the organised sectorare also entitled to a lump-sum retirement benefit calledgratuity, generally computed at half-months salary for every
year of completed service.
Third Pillar for the Un organized Sector
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
55/70
Third Pillar for the Un-organized Sector
The majority of the labour force consisting of self-
employed workers, casual workers and most of thoseemployed in the unorganised sector do not havemandatory coverage.
For them, voluntary individual saving (the third pillar in a
multi-pillar system) is the only means of providing forincome in old age.
The government and the insurance companies offer long-term savings plans that are aimed at enabling such
workers to save for their retirement. These individual voluntary plans as also the mandatory
occupational plans are supported in India with strong taxincentives.
Mandatory coverage for salaried employees
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
56/70
Mandatory coverage for salaried employees
The total number of regular salaried workers in thecountry is over 6 crores.
Mandatory coverage for retirement plans in Indiaextends only to salaried employees who can becategorised as follows:
Government employees who are covered under the
governments pension system, Salaried employees in establishments covered by the
EPF Act,
Salaried employees in establishments covered under
special Acts, and
Salaried employees in establishments not coveredunder the EPF Act but have equivalent voluntaryarrangements (such establishments are mostly in the
public sector).
Regulatory Framework for Pension System in Recent Times
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
57/70
Regulatory Framework for Pension System in Recent Times
Until recently, regulation of provident and pension funds in Indiacame out of three sources:
o Income Tax Act of 1961,o EPF Act of 1952 (or other special Act governing the fund), and
o Indian Trusts Act of 1882.
Every provident and pension fund trust, as also every gratuity andsuperannuation trust, is required to obtain approval under the
Income Tax Act for its income to be treated as tax-exempt.
Such an approved trust is required to comply with the provisions ofSchedule IV to the Income Tax Act.
The chief requirement under Schedule IV is compliance with the
investment limitations prescribed by the Ministry of Finance. The effect of this provision is that a common investment pattern
applies to all types of provident, pension, superannuation andgratuity funds in India, whether or not they are governed by the EPFAct.
The above is not applicable to the recently introduced NPS.
Need for Unified Regulation
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
58/70
Need for Unified Regulation The EPF Act governs the EPFO and is also the chief
source of regulation for the Exempted Funds
The Indian Trusts Act applies to all trusts and deals withthe rights and obligations of the trustees and thebeneficiaries
The legislation governing supervision of provident and
pension funds has thus been fragmented and there wasno one regulator who supervises all funds
Pension reforms in India needed to establish unifiedregulation affecting all retirement funds and an
independent regulator with jurisdiction over all funds A major step forward has since been taken with the
establishment of Pension Fund Regulatory andDevelopment Authority (PFRDA) by the Government of
India on 23rd August 2003, which is dealt with later
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
59/70
Employees Provident Fund Organisation
The Organisation functions under theoverall superintendence of the policiesframed by the Central Board of Trustees, a
tripartite body headed by Union Minister forLabour as Chairman.
The Chief Executive Officer of the
organisation is the Central Provident FundCommissioner, who is also a member ofthe board and its secretary.
EPFO O i l S i i 31 3 09
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
60/70
EPFO - Operational Statistics: 31.3.09
No. of covered establishments as on 31.03.2009: 573063
Membership of persons as on 31.03.2009 in crores:-
In Employees Provident Fund: 4.71
In Pension Fund: 4.49
Cumulative contributions (Rs in crores):-
In Employees Provident Fund: 211677.37
In Pension Fund: 98242.05
Employees Deposit Linked Insurance Fund : 7457.69
Total Contribution 317377.11
Trust organisation for managing funds
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
61/70
Trust organisation for managing funds
All provident, pension, superannuation and
gratuity funds have been required to be set up asindependent trusts.
Exempted Funds are set up as irrevocable trustssponsored by the employer.
Trust deeds are required to be registered andfiled with the EPFO for obtaining exemption.
The Indian Trusts Act of 1882 governs all trusts,
addressing many of the agency issues. Thefiduciary duties, powers and liabilities of a trusteeandthe rights of a beneficiary are defined in theTrusts Act.
PFRDA
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
62/70
PFRDA
PFRDA was established by Government ofIndia on 23rd August, 2003.
The PFRDA Bill, 2005 is awaiting approval ofParliament.
Pending passage of the Bill, the Governmenthas, through an executive order dated 10thOctober 2003, mandated PFRDA to act as aregulator for the pension sector.
The mandate of PFRDA is development andregulation of pension sector in India.
Current Scenario: Standardized Plans/Portability
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
63/70
Current Scenario: Standardized Plans/Portability
Employers are granted permission, by the governmentin consultation with the EPFO, to set up Exempted
Funds if their contribution and benefit structure are notinferior to the EPF plans.
In practice, the contribution rates, benefits and therights of beneficiaries including vesting rights are
almost identical across the country.
Due to the restrictions imposed by the investmentregulations there was no choice regarding portfolios tothe employers or the employees.
Portability is an important principle of pensionregulation; it was made easy in India by the dominanceof the EPFO. As most of the employers subscribed toEPFO plans, relocation of workers among those was
handled by a simple declaration to the EPFO.
Earlier highly Restrictive Investment Regulations
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
64/70
Earlier highly Restrictive Investment Regulations
Investment requirements and limitations are thecore of the regulation and control of provident
and pension funds.
The laws of the country had imposed what wasoften viewed as a highly restrictive investment
regulation regime. Funds in India could not earlier invest in stocks
or mutual funds.
No investments were also permitted in non-tradable investments such as loans or deposits(including bank deposits).
Investments were mostly directed to the
government and its enterprises.
Non-sustainability of the earlier System
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
65/70
Non sustainability of the earlier System
While the model may have worked in the past, a virtuallypublicly managed system with administered returns
could not be supported in the liberalised era The government has so far implicitly assumed
responsibility for all retirement savings by directingsuch savings to be channeled to itself or its enterprises
and paying what would be considered an attractivereturn
In effect, the government had underwritten the pensionsystem with tax-payers money
The government had also assumed fund managementresponsibility, with more than 70 percent of the corpusof provident and pension funds being under the EPFOplans.
Huge contingent liability for DB pension plan of EPFO
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
66/70
Huge contingent liability for DB pension plan of EPFO
The government has assumed the huge contingent liability for anydeficit in the DB pension plan of the EPFO, which is unsustainable.
Pension plans all over the world have tended to migrate to DCplans from DB plans. Where DB plans do exist, the liability for themrightfully belongs to the employer and not the tax-payer.
Inevitably, the DB plan of EPFO will need to be reformed into a DCplan or a privately managed DB plan for which the employer
assumes liability.Central Government Employees Pension Plan
The governments own pension system also has
evidently been in need of reform.
The solution was transition to privately managed andfunded plans based on defined contributions, which hasnow come about with the move to NPS for the newrecruits of the central government.
N E l f C t l G t t NPS
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
67/70
New Employees of Central Govt. move to NPS
The New Pension System (NPS) reflects theGovernments effort to find sustainable solutions tothe problem of providing adequate retirement income.
As a first step towards instituting pensionreforms, the GOI moved from a defined benefit
pension to a defined contribution based pensionsystem by making it mandatory for its new recruits(except armed forces) w. e. f. 1st January, 2004.
Since 1st April, 2008, the pension contributions ofCentral Govt. employees covered by NPS are being
invested by professional Pension Fund Managers.
The Basics of NPS
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
68/70
The Basics of NPS NPS is the lowest cost, portable and no-load product
that is possibly the best in terms of its structure,
across the world. The account-holders contributiongoes into a fund of his choice out of a universe of sixfund managers, offering a choice of three funds each.At the most, half the money can go into an index-linked equity fund, the rest in safer debt products.
This account is locked till the age of 60. On maturity,the person can withdraw up to 60% of the corpus aslump sum and the rest will buy an annuity, from anyof the insurers.
If the account-holder does not want to choose the
fund, the default option puts him in an assetallocation that is linked to his current age. As theperson ages, the allocation will change in favour ofdebt.
Some more basics of NPS
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
69/70
So e o e bas cs o S A Central Record keeping Agency, National Stock
Depository Limited (NSDL), which is the sole CRA underthe system, acts as the backbone of the NPS by hostingand facilitating transactions.
The CRA allots a unique permanent retirement accountnumber (PRAN).
This number is portable across geographical locations,
banks and employers. Costs is another area that puts NPS ahead of other
competing products
Portability across funds, once a year, also allows greaterflexibility to the investor.
The regulator has also launched the Tier II account,which works on a similar backbone. The only differenceis that of flexibility - you can withdraw anytime you like.Both contribution & maturity are however subject to tax.
Budget 2010: NPS
7/29/2019 Pension & Insurance
70/70
Budget 2010: NPS New Pension Scheme Push
A renewed push has been given to the New PensionScheme in the last Budget.
Till now the New Pension Scheme has not found muchfavour from the public due to teething problems related to
its implementation and certain other factors. Budget 2010 had proposed to give Rs.1000/- as a starting
incentive to all accounts of NPS opening in the next 3years.
This is a welcome measure, as NPS will possibly becomethe key Contributory Social Security Scheme in India.