Post on 07-Apr-2018
8/3/2019 Mixed Scanning
1/16
Click to edit Master subtitle style4/27/12
MIXED SCANNING
APPROACH
PLANNING
8/3/2019 Mixed Scanning
2/16
PLANNING
4/27/12
INTRODUCTION
The mixed scanning model tries to involve thestrengths of the rational planning model andthe incremental planning model and to eliminatethe weaknesses.
It is based on bounded instrumental rationality. Sociologist Amitai Etzioni found fault with both the
rational-comprehensive model of decision makingand the incremental model of decision making. Hismixed scanning approach considers both
fundamental and incremental decisions.
Mixed scanning incorporates a broad-basedanalysis sometimes and an in-depth analysis atother times. It considers the differing capacities ofdecision makers. Etzionis approach is not very
specific about how mixed scanning could be used inractice.
8/3/2019 Mixed Scanning
3/16
4/27/12
The RationalComprehensive Model
The rational comprehensive model is based on the reasoning ofeconomists, mathematicians, and psychologists.
It assumes that
the decision maker can identify the problem,
the decision maker's goals, values, and objectives are clear andranked in accord with their importance
that alternative ways of addressing the problem are considered
the cost and benefits or advantages and disadvantages of each
alternative are investigated
alternatives and their consequences can be compared with otheralternatives
the decision maker will choose the alternative that maximizes theattainment of his or her goals, values, and objectives.
8/3/2019 Mixed Scanning
4/16
4/27/12
The RationalComprehensive ModelHowever,
problems are not always clearly defined; problems have to beformulated in a way which enables people to make decisions aboutthem.
Decision makers must have vast amounts of information in order tomake use of the rational comprehensive decision-makingtechnique.
There needs to be an ability to predict the future consequences ofdecisions made.
Also, problems confronting decision makers often embodyconflicting values.
In addition, it is tough to ignore the sunk costs of former decisions,these may foreclose many alternatives.
Moreover, this model of decision-making assumes that there is one(unitary) decision maker, when in fact a great many people,
8/3/2019 Mixed Scanning
5/16
4/27/12
The Incremental Theory
Attempts to correct deficiencies of the rational comprehensive modeland to better describe how policy decision makers actually behavehave resulted in incremental theory.
Incremental theory holds that the selection of goals and objectives isintertwined with, not distinct from, the scientific analysis of the
problem.
Decision makers only consider alternatives for dealing with a problemthat differs marginally (incrementally) from existing policies(suggesting that they do not completely remake policy every timethey make a policy decision, but instead refashion existing policy).
For each alternative, only important consequences are considered.
Problems confronting the decision maker are continually redefined.
Constant ends-means and, means-ends adjustments are made tobetter manage policy.
Seldom are there ever single decisions or totally correct solutions
8/3/2019 Mixed Scanning
6/16
4/27/12
-RATIONAL MODEL AND
INCREMENTAL THEORYA rationalistic approach to decision-making requiresgreater resources than decision-makers command.The incremental strategy, which takes into accountthe limited capacity of actors, fosters decisions which
neglect basic societal innovations.Mixed-scanning reduces the unrealistic aspects ofrationalism by limiting the details required infundamental decisions and helps to overcome the
conservative slant of incrementalism by exploringlonger-run alternatives. (Incremental decisions tendto imply fundamental ones) The mixed scanning model makes this dualismexplicit by combining (a) high-order, fundamental
policymaking processes which set basic directions
8/3/2019 Mixed Scanning
7/16
4/27/12
MIXED SCANNINGAPPROACH
8/3/2019 Mixed Scanning
8/16
4/27/12
Central assumptions
Many incremental decisions may lead to fundamental changes.
The cumulative effect of those incremental decisions is influencedby fundamental decisions.
8/3/2019 Mixed Scanning
9/16
4/27/12
the planner
The planner is considered to be a bounded rational being,reducing the complexity of the world to an easier modelbut to a lesser extent than the incremental planner.
Overseeing the whole situation he or she has to consider
few solutions in greater detail.
8/3/2019 Mixed Scanning
10/16
4/27/12
Role of the population
The civil society is active in planning. Its needs and wantshave to be established during a consensus-building process(strategic/functional participation)
8/3/2019 Mixed Scanning
11/16
4/27/12
Planning process
Planning is carried out more decentrally than in therational planning process. Both the population and moreagencies are involved in planning. Important features of theplanning process are:
1. Objectives are set under consultations with the civilsociety.
2. Incremental decisions are made under consultation withthe population while at the same time also fewfundamental decisions are made which mark a huge
departure from the existing situation.
3. Thus, planning is considered as mixture of scientifictechnique, intuition and experience.
8/3/2019 Mixed Scanning
12/16
4/27/12
THE MIXED SCANNING MODEL- ANADAPTIVE STRATEGY
Mixed Scanning is guided by two questions:1. What is the mission to be fulfilled?2. What decisions move us towards our mission and policy?
The features A broad goal, mission, or policy guides the decision
process. Decisions are made incrementally, but with the broad
goal in mind. Consequences are assessed in terms of the goal.
Decisions are made with partial information. Then further small decisions are made if progress is
good.
8/3/2019 Mixed Scanning
13/16
4/27/12
PRINCIPLES OF MIXED SCANNING
1. Use focused trial and error.2. Be tentative--proceed with caution.3. If uncertain, procrastinate.
4. Stagger your decisions in stages.5. If uncertain, factionalize your decisions.6. Hedge your bets.7. Be prepared to reverse your decisions.
8/3/2019 Mixed Scanning
14/16
4/27/12
MixedScanning
Broad policy guidelinesare set prior togenerating alternatives.
Decision making is
focused on broad endsand tentative means.
The test of a gooddecisionis that it can be shown toresult in a satisfactorydecision that is
consistentwith the organizationspolicy.
(Adaptive satisfying)
Limit the search andanalysis toalternatives close to the
problem,
but evaluate alternativesinterms of broad policy.
Classical
Objectives are setprior to
generatingalternatives
Decision making isa means-ends
analysis: first,endsare determined,
andthen ALL the
means toobtain them are
sought.
The test of a gooddecision is that it
isshown to be the
BESTmeans to achieve
theend.
(Optimizing)
Engage incomprehensiveanal sis; all
Rational
Objectives areusuallyset prior togenerating
alternatives.
Decision making is
typically means-endsanalysis; however,occasionally ends
changeas a result of
analysis.
The test of a gooddecision
is that it can beshown toresult in a
SATISFACTORYmeans to achieve
the end;it falls within theestablished
boundaryconditions.
(Satisfying)
Engage in
Incremental
Setting objectives andgenerating alternativesare intertwined.
Because means andends are notseparable, means-
ends analysis isinappropriate.
The test of a gooddecisionis that the decisionmakers can agree analternative is the
rightdirection when the
existing course provestobe wrong.
(Successive comparing)
Drastically limit thesearchand analysis; focus onalternatives similar to
the
existing state. Manyalternatives and
important
Comparison of the Classical, Rational,Incremental,
and Mixed-Scanning Models of
Decision Making
8/3/2019 Mixed Scanning
15/16
4/27/12
REFERENCES
Mixed scanning a third approach to decision making Amitai Etzioni (Columbia University Press)
Mixed scanning revisited Amitai Etzioni (GeorgeWashington University Press)
Humble decision making Amitai Etzioni
8/3/2019 Mixed Scanning
16/16
4/27/12
THANK YOU