Post on 18-Feb-2021
34 F. CaroM (1982) Meditacions. Dietari (1936-1940), Barcelona, Alpha.
3S R. Bendix (1977) Max Weber. An Intellectual Portrait.
Berkeley, University of California Press, p. 462.
RMb TaMHp
lIHBEPAJIbHblA HAIlHOHA1lH3M *
IlPABO HA HAllHOHAJ1bHOE CAMOOIlPE,llEJIEHHE
O,aHa H3 nOCTO.ffifHbIX lfepT lfeJIOSeKa, nOMHMO lfHCTO
~H3HlfecKHx, COCTOHT B nOTpeoHocTH OOJIa,aaTb
cBoeA COOCTBeHHoA YHHKaJIbHOA HCTopHeA, He
cso,ajJIr(eAcjJ K HCTOPHH Bcero lfeJIOBelfeCTsa, a
TaK.lKe B TOM, lfTOObl coxpaHjJTb H KYJIbTHBHpOBaTb
HMeHHO TO, lfTO lfeJIOSeK ClfHTaeT ocooeHHblM
,aJIjJ ceojJ H HaHJIYlfmHM ,aJIjJ ,aaHHoro MeCTa H
BpeMeHH H lfTO OH ClfHTaeT pasHblM TeM YHHsep
CaJIbHblM H MOPaJIbHblM npe,anOlfTeHHjJM, KOTopble
jJBJIjJlOTCjJ OOIr(HMH ,aJljJ scex.
CTlOaPT XSMllIUHP
XOTjJ npaBO Ha Ha~HOHaJIbHOe caMoonpe,aeJIeHHe nOCTO
JJHHO OKa3brBaeTCjJ B ~eHTpe COBpeMeHHoA nOJlHTH1.leCKOA
pHTOpHKH, ero TeOpeTH1.leCKHA aHaJIH3 - JJBJleHHe ,aOBOJlbHO
pe,.QKoe. 06bl1.lHO 3THM 3aHHMalOTCjJ Cne~HaJlHCTbI no Me)l(
,aYHapO,.QHOMY npaBY, Ha 1.lbH pa60TbI 3aMeTHO BJlHjJlOT npaBO
Bble H nOJlHTH1.leCKHe npe~e,.QeHTbI. nOJlHTH1.leCKHe 4lHJlOC041bl
06bl1.lHO TjJrOTelOT K TOMY, 1.lT06bl BblBO,.QHTb co,aep.lKaHHe npas
Ha caMoonpe,aeJleHHe H3 nOJlHTH1.leCKOrO 06YCTPoACTBa B npom
JlOM H B COBpeMeHHOCTH, npHXO,.QjJ Ha :noA OCHOBe K BblBO,.QY,
1.lTO rJlaBHOe B Ha~HOHaJIbHOM CaMoonpe,aeJleHHH - npaso pe
maTb, "CTaHeT JlH (HJlH OCTaHeTCjJ JlH) ,aaHHajJ TeppHTopHjJ
He3aBHCHMblM rocy,aapCTBOM."1 B HHTepnpeTa~HH, KOTopajJ ,.QOMHHHPyeT B nOCTKOJlOHHaJlbHYIO 3PY, OCHOBHOA aK~eHT
,aeJlaeTCjJ Ha TOM, 1.lTO "Hapo,.Q, eCJlH TaKOBa ero BOJljJ, BnpaBe
06peCTH He3aBHCHMOCTb OT HHOCTpaHHoro rocnO,.QCTBa, HHa1.le
rOBopjJ, C03,aaTb CYBepeHHoe rocy,aapCTBO Ha ToA TeppHTO
PHH, Ha KOTOpoA OH npO:)I
)l(eJIH B nOJIHTHlIeCKOA ctlJepe: aTO npe)l(,l:Ie BCerO npaBO
OOeCnellHTb HCTOpHlIeCKYro COXpaHHOCTb Ha~HH B KalleCTBe
CaMOCTOHTeJIbHOA H OT,l:IeJIbHOA OT ,l:IPyrHx KYJIbTypHOA OO~
HOCTH. 3TO npaBO COBceM He TO )Ke caMoe. liTO npaBO HH,l:IHBH,l:IY
YMOB caMHM ynpaBJIHTb CBOHM cy~ecTBoBaHHeM H YlIaCTBO
BaTb B CBOI')O,l:lHbIX H ,l:IeMOKpaTHlIeCKHX nOJIHTHlIecKHX npo~ec
cax. B aToA rJIaBe MhI pa30BbeM O,l:lHO H3 ~eHTpaJ1bHbIX ,l:IJIH Te
OpHH JIHl')epaJIbHOrO Ha~HOHaJ1H3Ma YTBep)K,l:IeHHA, a HMeHHO,
Te3HC, liTO Ha~HOHaJ1bHbIe npHTH3aHHH - aTO He TO )l(e, liTO
TpeOOBaHHe nOJIHTHlIecKoro CYBepeHHTeTa.
y KYJIbTypHOA HHTepnpeTa~HH npaBa Ha Ha~HOHaJIbHOe caMOOnpe,l:leJIeHHe eCTb ,l:IBa OCHOBHhIX npeHMy~ecTBa. Bo-nep
BbIX, OHa nOMe~aeT aTO npaBO B ol')~HA KOHTeKCT npaB, KOTO
pbIMH OOJIa,l:laroT pa3JIHlIHble KYJIbTypHble rpynnbI, TaKHe KaK
aTHHlIeCKHe MeHbWHHCTBa H KopeHHble HapO,l:lHOCTH. BO-BTO
PbIX, OHa. nO-BH,l:IHMOMY. JIYlIwe npHCnOCOOJIeHa K peaJIHHM
COBpeMeHHoro MHpa, r,l:le cy~ecTByeT OlleBH,l:IHOe HanpH)KeHHe
Me)l(,l:IY HBHbIMH npeHMy~ecTBaMH TpaHCHa~HOHaJIbHOA aKOHO
MHlIeCKoA, CTpaTerHlIeCKoA H aKOJIOmlleCKoA Koonepa~HH,
C O,l:lHoA CTOPOHbI, H paCT~HM oecnoKoAcTBOM 3a coxpaHeHHe
Ha~HOHaJIbHOA H KYJIbTYPHOA cne~HtlJHKH, C ,l:IPyroA. oecno
KoAcTBOM, Be,l:l~HM K TPeOOBaHHro 0 pa3,l:1eJIeHHH, 0 C03,l:1aHHH
aBTOHOMHblX H~HOHaJ1bHblX CTPYKTyp.
H,l:IeH, COrJIaCHO KOTOpoA npaBO Ha Ha~HOHaJIbHOe caMO
onpe,l:leJIeHHe YTBep)K,l:IaeTCH npe)K,l:Ie Bcero B ctlJepe KYJIbTYPbl.
OCHOBblBaeTCH, rJIaBHblM oOpa30M. Ha nOHHMaHHH H~HA KaK
onpe,l:leJIeHHblX THnOB KYJIbTYPHbIX cooO~eCTB. nOaTOMY Ham
nepBbIA war - OOOCHOBaHHe aToA MO,l:leJIH.
HAUHH. rOCY.llAPCTBA H KYJIbTYPHbIE COOBI.QECTBA
nOHHTHe Ha~HH ,l:IOBOJIbHO paCnJIbIBlIaTO, TaK liTO JIYlIwe
HallaTb C nonblTKH YCTaHOBHTb, lIeM Ha~HHHe HBJIHeTCH. HanpH
Mep, Ha~HH - aTO He rOCY,l:IapCTBO. TaKoA BblBO,l:l MO)l(eT nOKa
3aTbCH caMOOlleBH,l:IHbIM. HO, K CO)l(aJIeHHro, B nOCJIe,l:lHee BpeMJI
nOHHTHH Ha~HH H rOCY,l:IapCTBa Hepe,l:lKO HCnOJIb3yroTCH ,l:IPyr
BMeCTO ,l:IPyra. .lloKJIa,l:l 0 H~HOHaJIH3Me, nO,l:lrOTOBJIeHHbIA cne
~HaJIbHOA HCCJIe,l:lOBaTeJIbCKOA rpynnoA H3 KOpOJIeBCKOro
HHCTHTYTa Me)K,l:IYHapO,l:lHbIX npOOJIeM, onpe,l:leJIHeT "Ha~H10"
KaK «TepMHH, 0003Hallaro~HA oo~eCTBO, HMero~ee e,l:lHHOe npaBHTeJIbCTBO. CJIOBOM - CHHOHHM ,l:IJIH TaKHX TepMHHOB, KaK
"rocY,l:IapCTBO" HJIH "CTPaHa". 3TO 3HalleHHe TepMHHa "Ha~HH" He npOCTO OTpa)KaeT ero caMoe pacnpOCTpaHeHHoe pelleBoe
ynoTpeOJIeHHe, HO BCTpellaeTCH TaK)Ke H B TaKHX OtIJH~HaJ1bHbIX 4JOpMYJIaX, KaK "3aKOH Ha~HA" HJIH "JlHra Ha~HA"».3
TaKoe OTO)l(,l:IeCTBJIeHHe nOHHTHA Ha~HH H rOCY,l:IapCTBa
HaxO,l:lHT O,l:lOopeHHe Y BeAJIH, 3aHBJIHro~ero, liTO ",l:IJIH onpe,IleJIeHHH Ha~HH He cy~ecTByeT ,l:IPyroro cnoc06a, KpOMe
HCnOJIb30BaHHH aToro CJIOBa ,l:IJIH 0603HalleHHH COBOKynHOCTH
TeppHTopHA, Bce lIaCTH KOTOpoA npH3HaroT BJIaCTb O,l:lHoro H
Toro )l(e rOCY,l:IapCTBa." 4 B TOM )l(e ,l:Iyxe BblCKalbIBaroTcH KaK
.lleAlI, onpe,l:leJIHro~HA Ha~Hro KaK "HapO,l:l, 06JIa,l:laro~HA ro
CY,l:IapCTBOM" s. TaK H rep~, oTMellaro~HA mHpOKYro pacnpoCTpaHeHHOCTb OTO)l(,l:IeCTBJIeHHH Ha~HH C HapO,l:lOM e,l:lHHOrO
rocy,l:IapCTBa H YTBep)K,l:Iaro~HA Ha :,noA OCHOBe, liTO "Ka)K,l:IOe
roCY,l:IapCTBO oopa3yeT Ha~Hro, lIJIeHCTBO B KOTOpoA npHHa,l:lJIe)l(HT BceM ee rpa)K,l:IaHaM."6 no aHaJIOrHH TepMHH "Ha~HOHaJ1bHblA" OOhIlIHO HCnOJIb3yeTcH ,l:IJIH 0003HalleHHH "lIerO-TO, liTO
rOCY,l:IapCTBO KOHTpOJIHpyeT HJIH 3a liTO OHO HeceT OTBeTCT
BeHHOCTb - HanpHMep, Ha~HOHaJIbHbIA ,l:IOJIr HJIH Ha~HOHaJ1b
Hoe Me,l:lH~HHCKoe CTpaXOBaHHe. "7
3TH onpe,l:leJIeHHH MorJIH 6b1 npHBeCTH Hac K 3aKJIrolleHHro.
liTO nOHHTHH rOCY,l:IapCTBa H H~HH JIHOO nOJIHOcTbro Hepa3
JIHlIHMbI, JIHOO no MeHbweA Mepe npe,l:lCTaBJIHroT ,l:IBe pa3JIHlIHbIX
CTOPOHbI O,l:lHOro H Toro )l(e HCXO,l:lHOro nOHHTHH, TOJIbKO nep
BOe H3 HHX OTHOCHTCH K acneKTy ero YCTpoAcTBa, BTopoe )l(e
K TeM JIro,l:lHM, KOTophIe YlIacTByroT B tlJopMHpoBaHHH H ,l:IeH
TeJlbHOCTH aTHX nOJIHTHlIeCKHX HHCTHTYTOB. Tor,l:la MO)l(HO 6hI
JlO ObI O)l(H,l:IaTb, liTO H onpe,l:leJIeHHe "roCY,l:IapCTBa", B CBOro olle
pe,llb, OY,l:IeT BKJIrollaTb KaKHe-TO napaMeTpbI. KOTopbIe 06Ha
PY)KHBaroTcH B onpe,l:leJIeHHH Ha~HH. O,l:lHaKO aTO He TaK: B onpe,l:leJIeHHHX rOCY,l:IapCTBa nOHHTHe Ha~HH eCJIH H ynoMH
HaeTCH, TO TOJIbKO B CJIOBOCOlleTaHHH "Ha~HH-rOCY,l:IapCTBO". 0603Hallaro~eM O,l:lHY H3 B03MO)l(HhIX tlJOPM rocY,l:IapCTBeHHOCTH. HanpHMep. "5pHTaHCKaH 3H~HKJIOne,l:lHH" onpe,l:leJlHeT rocy,IlapcTBO KaK nOJIHTHlIecKyro opraHH3a~Hro oo~ecTBa. Y CJIOBa "rOCY,l:IapCTBO" eCTb ,l:IBa oo~enpHHHTbIX CMbICJIa: nepBbIA. caMbIA 06~HA. 0603HallaeT BCro cOBoKynHocTb CBH3aHHbIX HM Jlro
76 77
.lleR, a BTOpoR, GOJIee qaCTHbIA, OTHOCHTC.s! K HHCTHTYTaM yn~
paBJIeHH.s! oGmecTBOM. OT Bcex npOqHX aCCO~Ha~HA rocY.llapcTBO OTJIHqaeTC.s! CBOHMH ~eJI.s!MH H MeTO.llaMH HX .llOCTH)KeHH.s!. HaJIHqHeM qeTKHX TeppHTOpHaJIbHbIX rpaHH~. B KOTOPblX .lleRcTByeT ero BJIaCTb, H cne~HlllHqeCKHM CYBepeHHTeTOM. CYBepeHHTeT COCTaBJI.s!eT HaHGOJIee Ba)l(HYIO ocooeHHOCTb rocy
.llapCTBa. nOCKOJIbKY HMeHHO OH BJIeqeT 3a coGOA npHcymylO
rOCY.llapCTBY MOHOnOJIHIO BnaCTH H npaBO Ha yCTaHOBJIeHHe H
npOBe.lleHHe B )KH3Hb oGmHX .lln.s! Bcex laKOHOS.
naACOH CqHTaeT OCHOBHOA qepToA rOCY.llapCTBa cne~H
CPHqecKHA xapaKTep npepOraTHB SJIaCTH (HHaqe roBOp.s!, TOT
)Ke CYBepeHHTeT). HCKJIlOqHTeJIbHble no CBOHM MaCilITaGaM H
pacTymHe pecypcbI cpH3HqeCKorO MorymecTBa H HaJIHqHe qeTKO
onpe.lleJIeHHOA TeppHTopHH.8 HanpOTHB, .llJI.s! nOH.s!TH.s! Ha~HH HH O.llHa H3 3THX ocoGeHHocTeA He CqHTaeTC.s! cymecTBeHHoA?
YnOM.s!HeM eme CTaTblO 0 rOCY.llapCTBe B "CJIOBape HCTOPHH
H.lleR". HanHcaHHYIO .ll'3HTpeseCOM. B KOH~e 3TOA paGoTbl aBTOP npe.llCKa3blBaeT, qTO Ha CMeHY Ha~HH-rOCY.llapCTBY npH.lleT "HOBoe Ha.llHa~HOHaJIbHOe rOCY.llapCTBO". 3a 3TOA rHnOTe30A Y Hero CJIe.llyeT HHTepeCHblA Bonpoc, Ha KOTOPblA cpa3Y)Ke .llaeT
C.s! OTBeT: "Ho 6Y.lleT JIH HCqe3HOBeHHe H~HH-rOCY.llapCTBa 03HaqaTb
H HCqe3HOBeHHe caMoro rOCY.llapCTBa, ero "OTMHpaHHe", eCJIH
HCnOJIb30SaTb H3BeCTHoe MapKCHCTCKoe Bblpa)KeHHe1 O.llHO He
nO.llJIe)KHT COMHeHHIO: .ll0 Tex nop, nOKa OY.lleT cymeCTBosaTb
opraHH3a~H.s!, OOJIa.llalOma.s! cHnoA npHHY)K.lleHH.s!, cnOCOOHa.s! peryJIHpOBaTb BnaCTb H laKJIlOqaTb COlO3bI, OHa He oY.lleT HH qeM
HHbIM, KaK rOCY.llapCTBOM:q
()
TaKHM oopaaOM, .lln.s! .ll'3HTpeBeca HbIHemHHe CB.s!3H Me)l(.llY
rOCY.llapCTSaMH H Ha~H.s!MH - Bcero JIHmb HCTOpHqeCKOe COBna.lleHHe, KOTopoe He .llOJI)KHO MaCKHpOBaTb KOH~enTyaJIbHbIe
pa3JIHqH.s! Me)K.llY HHMH. KaK npaBHJIbHO nO.llqepKHBaeT CeTOH
YOTCOH, rOCY.llapCTBO - 3TO "npaBOBa.s! H nOJIHTHqeCKa.s! opra
HH3a~H.s!, oGJIa.llalOma.s! BJIaCTbIO TpeGOBaTb OT CBOHX rpa)K.llaH nO.llqHHeHH.s! H JIOA.s!nbHOCTH", B TO BpeM.s! KaK Ha~H.s! eCTb "qeJIOBeqeCKOe cooomeCTBO, qJIeHbl KOToporo OObe.llHHeHbI
qYSCTBOM conH.llapHOCTH, oomeA KYJIbTypoA H H~HOHaJIbHbIM
C03HaHHeM."II B qeM HCTOqHHK nYTaHH~bl Me)K.llY nOH.s!TH.s!MH Ha~HH H
78
rocY.llapCTBa1 MO)KHO Gblno GbI He Ge3 OCHOBaHHA 3a.s!BHTb,
qTO no KpaAHeA Mepe qaCTHqHO OHa 06b.s!CH.s!eTC.s! npe.ll
HaMepeHHblMH YCHJIH.s!MH 3aTeMHHTb pa3nHqHe Me)l(.llY YT
Bep)K.lleHHeM. qTO Ka)K.lla.s! Ha~H.s!.llOJT)KHa HMeTb CBoe rOCY.llapCT
BO (HJIH, CKopee. qTO Ka)l(.llOe rOCY.llapCTBO .llOJI>KHO BbIBO.llHTb
CBOIO JIerHTHMHOCTb H3 cymeCTBOBaHH.s! COOTBeTCTBYlOmeA Ha
~HH), H YTBep)K.lleHHeM, qTO H~H.s! - 3TO H eCTb rOCY.llapCTBo.
3TY TeH.lleH~HIO K CTHpaHHIO Bcex paaJIHqHA Me)K.llY nOH.s!TH.s!MH
H~HH H rOCY.llapCTBa xopomo HJIJIIOCTpHpyeT nonbITKa npe.ll
CTaBHTb Ha~HOHaJIHCTHqeCKHR JI03yHr "O.llHH HapO.ll, O.llHa CTpa
Ha, O.llHH .s!3bIK" B KaqeCTSe He HopMaTHBHoro, a onHCaTeJIbHOrO
yTBep)K.lleHH.s!.12 O.llHaKO mHpOKYIO pacnpOCTpaHeHHOCTb 3Toro
HeBepHoro OTO)K.lleCTBJIeHH.s! Bp.s!.ll nH MO)KHO 06b.s!CHHTb O.ll
HoA JIHmb C03HaTeJIbHOR HaUHOHaJIHCTHqeCKOA nponaraH.lloA
CY.ll.s! no sceMY, OHO oTpa)KaeT HCTOpHqeCKHe npo~eccbl, KOTO
pble cOnpOBO)K.llaJIH CPOpMHpoBaHHe cospeMeHHblx Ha~HR
rocY.llapcTB.
naBaATe BHOBb oopaTHMc.s! K BpeMeHH, KOr.lla 3TO npoHcxo
.llHJIO - K KOH~Y xvm CTOJIeTH.s!. HMeHHo TOr.lla rocY.llapCTBO CTaJIO OTO)K.lleCTBn.s!TbC.s! CO CBOHMH nO.ll.llaHHbIMH, a He
npaBHTeJI.s!MH - 3TO COOTBeTCTBOBano cpHnococpHH Pycco
H OTpa)KaJIO ee BnH.s!HHe Ha nOJIHTHqeCKOe pa3BHTHe. B OCHOBe AMepHKaHCKoR H paH~Y3CKOA pesOJIIO~HR ne)l(aJIO y6e)K.lle
HHe, qTO rOCY.llapCTBO .llOJI)KHO GbITb "HHCTHTY~HOHaJIbHbIM BO
nJIOmeHHeM HapO.llHOA BOJIH" 13. 3TO 03HaqaJIO Ba)l(HbIR C.llBHr B
nOHHMaHHH JIerHTHMHOCTH, KOTOPYlO OTHbIHe CTpeMHJIHCb 06
peCTH nOnHTHqeCKHe HHCTHTYTbl: OHH HCKaJIH ee Y)Ke He B
6o)KecTBeHHoM HnH .llHHaCTHqeCKOM npaBe MOHapXOB, a B Mac
COBOM .ll06POBOJIbHOM cornaCHH. OTCIO.lla BbITeKano, qTO rpa)K
.llaHe HMelOT npaso yqaCTBOBaTb B ynpaBJIeHHH cTpaHoR
H qTO BOJI.s! HapO.lla - OCHOBa BJIaCTH npaBHTeJIbCTBa. 3TOT C.llBHr
nOCTaBHJI B ~eHTp nOJIHTHqeCKOrO MbImJIeHH.s! 3nOXH .lleMO~
KpaTHqecKYIO HHTepnpeT~HIO npaBa Ha nOJIHTHqeCKOe caMO
ynpaBneHHe. B CaMoonpe.lleJIeHHH CTaJIH BH.lleTb "npHrO.llHbIR .llJI.s! Bcero qenOBeqeCTSa .lleMOKpaTHqeCKHA H.lleaJI."l4
COOTBeTCTBHe Me)l(.llY .lleMOKpaTHqeCKHMH YHHBep
CaJIHCTCKHMH H.lleanaMH H 3apO)K.llalOmeRc.s! Ha~HOHaJIbHOA
H.lleonorHeR OTpa)KanO CO~HOnOJIHTHqeCKHe peanHH Toro BpeMeHH. AMepHKaHCKa.s! PeBonlO~H.s! .llaJIa )KH3Hb HOBOA Ha~HH.
79
http:Bp.s!.llhttp:yTBep)K.lleHH.s!.12
BKJIIOl.Ja8meA 8 ceeiR JIHmb Tex, KTO Y)f{e nOJIb30BaJICR nOJIH
THl.JeCKHMH npaBaMH nepe~ no~nHcaHHeM ~eKJIapa~HH He3a
8HCHMOCTH, H HCKJIIOl.JaBmeA eie33eMeJIbHblX eie~HRKoB, )f{eHIIlHH, l.JepHOKO)f{HX H HH~eA~eB.lS npa80 Ha caMOOnpe~eJIeHHe npH
3TOM nOHHMaJIOCb KaK 3K8H8aJIeHT npasa HaJIOrOnJIaTeJIbIllHK08
Ha nOJIHTHl.JeCKOe npe~CTaBHTeJIbCT80. TeM caMbiM npOH30mJIO
$aKTHl.JeCKOe C08MeIlleHHe nOH.HTHA rocy~apcT8eHHoro rpa)f{
~aHCTBa H Ha~HOHaJIbHOA npHH~JIe)f{HOCTH. OHO OKa3aJIOCb
CTOJIb CHJIbHbIM, l.JTO COXPaHHJIOCb 8nJIOTb ~O HaCTORIIlero Bpe
MeHH: B Coe~HHeHHbIX lliTaTax H cerO~HR nOHRTHe "Ha~HR"
OTHOCHTCR K $e~epaJIbHOMY rocy~apCTBY.
~pyroA npo~ecc, XOTR H CO CXO~HbIMH pe3YJIbTaTaMH,
pa3BOpal.JH8aJICR 80 paH~HH. B TO 8peMR, KaK B AMepHKe Ha
~HIO C03~aJIO H080e rocy~apcT80, 80 paH~HH ee onpe~eJIHJIO
TpeTbe COCJI08He. YCTpeMHBmeeCR oeipecTH He3aBHCHMblA OT
CTaporo KOpOJIeBCKOro pe)f{HMa HCTOl.JHHK nOJIHTHl.JeCKOA JIe
rHTHMHOCTH, OHO C)YKBaJIbHO "H30C)peJIO" Ha~HIO, 06bRBHJIO ca
MHX ceeiR ee HCTHHHbIMH npe~CTaBHTeJIRMH H nOTpeC>08aJIO npaBa Ha caMoynpaBJIeHHe. B HTore rocy~apcTBO c~eJIaJIOCb
O$H~HaJIbHblM BonJIOIlleHHeM Ha~HH H O~HHM e~HHCTBeHHbIM
nO~JIHHHblM OTel.JeCTBOM. KaK nHCaJI B 1790 r. AJIb6a~ BOJIb$HYC, "HcTHHHoe OTel.JeCTBO - 3TO nOJIHTHl.JecKoe coooIlleCTBo, r ~e Bce rpa)f{~aHe 3aI!lHIIleHbI O~HHMH H TeMH )f{e 3aKOHaMH, oC)be~HHeHbI O~HHMH H TeMH )f{e HHTepecaMH, nOJIb3YlOTCR ec
TeCTBeHHblMH l.JeJIOBel.JeCKHMH npaBaMH H Yl.JaCT8YIOT B O~HOM
H TOM)f{e OC)IIleM ~eJIe:16 B HTore Ha TOM HCTopHl.JeCKOM 3Tane Bonpoc, KTO COCTaB
JIReT Hapo~, no~~aHHble rocy~apcTBa HJIH l.JJIeHbI Ha~HH, BbI
rJI~eJI He HMelOlIIHM 3Hal.JeHHR. Ho OTHblHe H~HR, OTO)f{~eCT
BJIeHHaR C cOBoKynHocTblO rpa)f{~aH, CTaJIa nOHHMaTbCR KaK
"MHO)f{ecTBO Bcex, MHO)f{eCTBO HH~HBH~yyMOB, KOTopble MOryT
npeTeH~oBaTb Ha TO, l.JTOC)bl npe~CTaBJIRTb onpe~eJIeHHYIO
TeppHTopHIO B COBeTax, ceAMax HJIH napJIaMeHTax, JIHOO
H3C)HpaTb CBOHX npe~CTa8HTeJIeA. M CTaJIO orsIllenpH3HaHHblM,
l.JTO • npHH~Hn CYBepeHHTeTa BOnJIOIllaeTCR 8 Ha~HH H l.JTO HH
KaKa.H rpynna H HHKaKoA HH~HBH~yYM He MorYT ocymeCTBJIRTb
$YHK~HA BJIaCTH, eCJIH OHH He nO~KpenJIeHbI H~HOHaJIbHbIM
CYBepeHHTeTOM"P Ha~HR c~eJIaJIaCb YHHKaJIbHblM CHM80JIOM
napTHepCTBa Me~y BCeMH l.JJIeHaMH nOJIHTHl.JecKoro YCTpOA
80
CT8a H O~HOBpeMeHHO - BOnJIOIlleHHeM CBR3eA Me~y npaBH
TeJIRMH H HX nO,lt~aHHblMH. B HTore nORBHJIaCb HOBaR no
JIHTHl.JecKaR HopMa, nO,ltTBep)f{,ltaIOIIla.H, l.JTO Ha~HOHaJIH3M RB
JIReTCR JIerHTHMH3HPYlOIIlHM npHH~HnOM nOJIHTHKH H $Op
MHPOBaHHR rocy,ltapCTBa H l.JTO HHKaKoA ,ltpyroA npHHUHn He
nOJIb3yeTcR 8ceOC)IIleA nO,lt,ltep)f{KoA" 18. TaK 3aBepmHJICR C,ltBHr
OT onpaB~aHHR rocy,ltapCTBa, oa3HpYlOIIlerOCR Ha ,lteMOKpaTHl.JeCKHX npHHUHnax, K onpaB~aHHIO rOCY,ltapCTBa, OC
HosaHHoro Ha HaUHOHaJIH3Me. C,ltBHr OT yC)e~eHHOCTH B npa
sax rpa)f{,ltaH Ha caMoynpaBJIeHHe K YBepeHHOCTH B npase Ha
IlHA Ha caMOOnpe,lteJIeHHe. B03HHKJIa HOBaR nOJIHTHl.JeCKaR
TepMHHOJIOrHR. MaCKHpYIOIIlaR B03MO)f{Hble BHYTpeHHHe
npOTHBOpel.JHR Me)f{,lty ,lteMOKpaTHl.JeCKHM H Ha~HOHaJIHC
THl.JeCKHM nO~XO,ltOM.
B COBpeMeHHOM nOJIHTHl.JeCKOM CJIOBape npaBO HH,ltH
BH,ltYYMOB Ha BbI60p CHCTeMbI npaBJIeHHR OCTaeTCJ!I OCHOBHbIM
nOCTyJIaTOM KaK JIHeiepaJIbHoA. TaK H H~HOHaJIHCTHl.JeCKOA H~e
OJIOrHH. O,ltHaKO C KOHua xvm CTOJIeTHR XO,lt HCTOPHH C)blJI OTMel.JeH MHO)f{eCTBOM COObiTHA COUHaJIbHOA. 3KOHOMHl.JeCKOA
H nOJIHTHl.JeCKOA )f{H3HH, TaKHX KaK MHrpaUHH. B03HHKHOBeHHe
HOBbIX rocy,ltapCTB, OC)be,ltHHRIOIIlHX C)OJIee, l.JeM O,ltHy HaUHIO, H
BOBJIel.JeHHe 8 nOJIHTHl.JeCKHe npoueCCbl paHee HCKJIIOl.JeHHbIX
H3 HHX rpynn. Bce 3TH COOblTHR nO,ltOpBaJIH OTO)f{,lteCTBJIeHHe
rpa~aH rocy,ltapCTBa C l.JJIeHaMH HauHH, TaK l.JTO Tenepb Y)f{e
HeJIb3R npHpasHHBaTb npaBO rpa~aH Ha caMoynpaBJIeHHe H
npaBO l.JJIeH08 HallHH Ha CaMoonpe,lteJIeHHe. BPR,lt JIH Ha 3eMJIe
OCTaJIOCb XOTR C)bl O,ltHO HallHOHaJIbHO O,ltHOpO~Hoe rocy,ltapCTBO, O,ltHaKO nOJIHTHl.JeCKHA CJIOBapb eIlle He ycneJI npHcnoco
C)HTbCR K 3THM nepeMeHaM. B 1960 r., KOr,lta C)bIJI COCTaBJIeH npoeKT naKTa 0 npaBax l.JeJI08eKa, Y)f{e C)blJIO RCHO, l.JTO nOH.HTHR
"HapO,lt" H "H~HR" HHKor,lta He C)blJIH TOl.JHO onpe,lteJIeHbI, B pe3YJIbTaTe l.Jero B03HHKJIa nYTaHHua Me)f{,lty HHMH H nOHRTHeM Ha
UHOHaJIbHOrO C)OJIbmHHCTBa.
nOCKOJIbKY HauHR CTaJIa e,ltHHCTBeHHbIM 3aKOHHbIM HCTOl.J
HHKOM rocy,ltapCTBeHHoA JIerHTHMHOCTH, Ka)f{,lta.H rpynna, Cl.JH
TalOIIlaR ceC)R HaUHeA, CTaJIa HcnblTbIBaTb CTpeMJIeHHe K
npOB03rJIameHHIO CBoero He3aBHCHMOro rocy,ltapcTsa, a )f{HTe
JIH Ka)f{,ltoro rocy,ltapCTBa oC)peJIH H~e)f{,lty, l.JTO OHH nepeCTa
HyT eiblTb npOCTO HaCeJIeHHeM H CTaHYT HaUHeA. OT npaBH
81
http:HH~eA~eB.lS
TeJlbCTB CTanH Tpe60BaTb ,QOKa3aTeJlbCTB, tlTO OHH npe,QCTaB
Jl5IIOT He npOCTO HeKHe MHox
npOBepIKe I)onee He
nepeIKHO Ciblno Cibl HallaTb C co
BpeMeHHoro nOHHTHH HaU;HOHaJJbHoro cTpoHTenbcTBa. OlleBHJ,l
HO, liTO nroCible C03HaTenbHble nOnblTIKHbl HanpaBnHTbCH OI)I.QHMH npeJ,lCTaBneHHHMH 0 TOM, K KaKO
MY pe3ynbTaTy CJIeJ,lyeT npHJ.lTH B HTore.
KaI< TonbKO Mbl 3aJ,lYMbIBaeMCH 0t5 3TOM, cpa3y >Ke J,lena
eTCH OlleBHJ,lHblM HeYCTpaHHMoe npOTHBopellHe Me>KJ,ly caMoA
nocTaHoBKoA 3aJ,lallH npeJ,lHaMepeHHoro cTHMynHpoBaHHH
pO>KJ,leHHH el.Qe He CYl.QeCTByrol.QeA HaIJ;HH H npeJ,lCTaBneHHeM 0
HaU;HHX IKJ,leHHH OTHOCHTenb
HO MeCTOHaXO>KJ,leHHH H HCTopHlIeCKHX I
YCHJIHA no OObe.llHHeHHIO CTpaHbI H npeBpameHHIO ee )l(HTeJIeA B
e.llHHOe HaQHOHaJIbHOe TOBapHmeCTBo."28 TaKoA H.lIeaJI HaQH
OHaJIbHOrO opaTCTBa CHMBOJIH3HpyeT Bepy B cymecTBoBaHHe
OCOObIX CBjl3eA H B3aHMHbIX OOjl3aTeJIbCTB, OObe.llHHjllOmHX
tJJIeHOB HaQHH B e.llHHOe QeJIoe. HaQHOHaJIHCTbI BH.lIjiT B 3TOM
H.lIeaJIe eCTeCTBeHHbIA HTor KOJIJIeKTHBHoA CY.llbObI, oomeA .lIJIjI
Bcex KYJIbTYP H CTOJIb )l(e oomeA BepbI B Oomee 0Y.lIymee. no
3TOMY OHH .lIeJIalOT OCOObIA aKQeHT Ha TO, tJTO HaQHjI npe.ll
CTaBJIjleT coooA "3aOOTJIHBOe COOOmeCTBO", BHYTPH KOToporo
OT.lIeJIbHbIe HH.lIHBH.lIYYMbI OKa3bIBalOTCjI cnOCOOHbI COTpy.lI
HHtJaTb BO HMjI oomero npOQBeTaHHjI, npeO.llOJIeB CBOH
3rOHCTHtJeCKHe HaKJIOHHOCTH.
nOHjlTHe HaQHOHaJIbHOrO CTpOHTeJIbCTBa TaK)I(e HJIJIIO
cTpHpyeT paCXO)l(.lIeHHjI Me)l(.lIY CYObeKTHBHbIMH H OObeKTHB
HbIMH onpe.lleJIeHHjlMH HaQHH. fllO.lIH nbITalOTCjI OOOCHOBaTb
cymecTBoBaHHe HaQHA nOCpe.llCTBOM CCbIJIOK Ha Pjl.ll xapaKTep
HbIX ocoOeHHOCTeA. TeM He MeHee, Bce nonbITKH BbI.lIeJIHTb cne
QH!flHtJeCKHA Haoop TaKHX KatJeCTB (OY.lIb TO oomHA jl3bIK, HCTO
PHjI, KOJIJIeKTHBHaji CY.lIbOa, peJIHrHjI, TeppHTOpHjI, KJIHMaT,
paca, 3THHtJeCKHe tJepTbI H T.n.) B KatJeCTBe HeOOXO.llHMblX H
.lIOCTaTOtJHbIX KpHTepHeB HaQHH HeH3MeHHO TepneJIH HeY.lIatJY.
XOTjI 3TH KatJeCTBa H npHCYTCTBYIOT B xapaKTepHCTHKax MHO
rHX HaQHA, HH O.llHa peaJIbHaji HaQHjI He oOJIa.llaeT BceMH HMH
cpa3Y. n03TOMY HaQHIO MO)l(HO ObIJIO ObI OCMblCJIHTb KaK "nYtJ
KOBoe" nOHjlTHe; HHatJe rOBOpjl, .lIJIjI Toro, tJTOObI CtJHTaTbCjI
HaQHeA, rpynna .lIOJI)I(Ha OOJIa.llaTb KaKHM-TO ".lIOCTaTOtJHbIM
KOJIHtJeCTBOM" onpe.lleJIeHHbIX ocoOeHHOCTeA. XOTjI pa3JIHtJ
HbIe HaQHH MorYT H He OOJIa.llaTb pa3 HaBCer.lla 3a.llaHHbIM
HaoopOM oomHX .lIJIjI Bcex H.lIeHTH!flHQHPYlOmHX tJepT,
BCe)l(e HenpeMeHHO cymecTByeT HeKoe "!flaMHJIbHOe CXO.llCTBO".
flHWb O.llHH !flaKTop HeOOXO.llHM (XOTjI H He.llOCTaTOtJeH)
.lIJIjI Toro, tJTOObI .lIaHHaji rpynna MorJIa CtJHTaTbCjI HaQHeA:
HaJIHtJHe HaQHOHaJIbHOrO C03HaHHR COrJIaCHO KoooaHY, B
JIYtJweM CJIYtJae MO)l(HO 3ajlBHTb, tJTO "HaQHeA jlBJIjleTCjI JIIO
ooe TeppHTOpHaJIbHOe cooomecTBo, tJJIeHbI KOToporo OC03
HalOT CBoe KOMMYHaJIbHOe e.llHHCTBO H )l(eJIalOT ero coxpa
HHTb."29 K TaKOMY )l(e BbIBO.llY npHXO.llHT H CeToH-YoTcoH,
oTMetJalOmHA HeB03MO)l(HOCTb H300peTeHHjI HaYtJHO TotJHoro
onpe.lleJIeHHjI HaQHH. B JIYtJweM CJIYtJae MO)l(HO rOBopHTb
86
o ee cymecTBoBaHHH, eCJIH "B .lIaHHOM cooomecTBe .lIOCTaTOtJ
Hoe tJHCJIO JIlO.lIeA CtJHTalOT ceojl npHHa.llJIe)l(amHMH K O.ll
HoA H ToA )l(e HaQHH HJIH Be.llYT ceojl TaK, KaK eCJIH Obi 3Ta
npHHa.llJIe)l(HOCTb HMeJIa MeCTO. "30
MbI.lIOCTHrJIH CTa.llHH, KOr.lla CTaJIO Ba)I(HbIM npOBeCTH pa3
JIHtJHe Me)l(.lIY .lIBYMjI TeCHO CBjl3aHHbIMH TepMHHaMH - HaQHeA
H HapO.llOM. XOTjI B JIHTepaType OHH tJaCTO HCnOJIb3YIOTCjI B Ka
tJeCTBe CHHOHHMOB. HaQHjI - 3TO Bce )l(e COOomeCTBO, OC03Ha
IOmee CBOIO OCOOOCTb, BbI.lIeJIeHHOCTb, YHHKaJIbHOCTb. B TO )l(e BpeMjI nOHjlTHe HapO.lla OTHOCHTCjI K TOMY )l(e ceMeAcTBY,
tJTO H nOHjlTHjI ceMbH HJIH nJIeMeHH; HHatJe rOBOpjl, Ha
pO.ll - 3TO O.llHa H3 Tex oomeCTBeHHbIX aCCOQHaQHA, tJbe
cymecTBoBaHHe He 3aBHCHT OT C03HaHHjI ee tJJIeHOB. OTClO.lIa
CJIe.llyeT, tJTO .lIJIjI nO.llOOHbIX aCCOQHaQHA .lIOJI)I(HbI cyme
CTBOBaTb OObeKTHBHbIe CBjl3YlOmHe xapaKTepHCTHKH (CKa)l(eM,
KpOBHoe PO.llCTBO, paCOBbIe CBjl3H, TeppHTOpHaJIbHOe e.llHH
CTBO HJIH tJTO-TO eme B 3TOM )l(e pO.lle) , HaJIHtJHe KOTOPbIX
n03BOJIjleT BHewHeMY HaOJIlO.lIaTeJIIO H.lIeHTH!flHQHpOBaTb
HX oe30THOCHTeJIbHO K MeHTaJIHTeTY tJJIeHOB. YCToAtJHBOCTb
HCTopHtJeCKoro cymecTBoBaHHjI HapO.llOB, B OTJIHtJHe OT
YCToAtJHBOCTH HaQHA, He 3aBHCHT OT HaJIHtJHjI HaQHOHaJIb
Horo caMOC03HaHHjI HJIH )l(eJIaHHjI HH.lIHBH.lIYYMOB BH.lIeTb
B ceoe tJJIeHOB o.llHoA H ToA )l(e HaQHH.
B HaCTOjimeA paooTe Mbi 0Y.lleM paccMaTpHBaTb B KatJeCTBe HaQHH TaKYIO rpynny, KOTOpajl, C O.llHoA CTOPOHbI, OC03Ha
eT ceojl rpynnoA H, C .lIpyroA, ocrJIa.llaeT .lIOCTaTOtJHbIM tJHC
JIOM OTHOCjlmHXCjI K .lIeJIY OObeKTHBHbIX xapaKTepHCTHK,
nO.llOOHO oomeMY jl3bIKY, TeppHTopHH HJIH HCTOpHH. ECTe
CTBeHHO, tJTO npOH3BOJIbHO COOpaHHaji rpynna HH.lIHBH.lIY
YMOB, He OOJIa.llalOmaji HHKaKHMH oomHMH xapaKTepHCTHKaMH,
nO.llOOHbIMH nepetJHCJIeHHbIM BbIwe, He MO)l(eT CTaTb Ha
QHeA no CBoeMY COOCTBeHHOMY XOTeHHIO. O.llHaKO eCJIH
nonpOOOBaTb OTBeTHTb Ha Bonpoc, tJTO COCTaBJIjleT .lIOCTa
TOtJHoe tJHCJIO pa3JIHIlHblX xapaKTepHCTHK HaQHH, TO npH.lI
eTCjI npH3HaTb, tJTO MbI He CMO)l(eM nOJIaraTbCjI Ha O.llHH
TOJIbKO OObeKTHaHble xapaKTepHCTHKH. npOtJeptJHBaHHe
KOHKpeTHbIX rpaHHQ HaQHH BKJIlOtJaeT B ceojl C03HaTeJIbHbIe H
ynopHbIe YCHJIHjI YMeHbwHTb Ba)l(HOCTb OObeKTHBHbIX BHY
TpHrpynnoBbix pa3JIHtJHA H O.llHOBpeMeHHO nO.lltJepKHYTb
OCOOOCTb .lIaHHOA rpynnbI no OTHoweHHIO K aYTcaA.lIepaM.
87
http:COTpy.lI
HHTepeCHbIA npHMep npe.nCTaSJI5IeT espeAcKa51 HaU;H5I . .llJUI
eBpeeB H3 H3paHJI5I, POCCHHH, 34JHonHH H COe.nHHeHHbIX lIITa
TOB XapaKTepHbI JIHmb HeMHOrHe of)Il{He Of)beKTHsHbie xa
paKTepHCTHKH, TaKHe KaK paCOBble lJepTbI HJIH U;SeT KO>KH, XOT5I,
no HX COOCTseHHbIM 3a5lSJIeHH5IM, OHH of)JIa.naIOT of)Il{eA peJIH
rHeA H HCTopHeA. MoA cOf)cTBeHHbIA Hy.naHlM seCbMa OTJIH
lJaeTC5I OT Hy.naHlMa 34JHoncKoro espe51 HJIH JII06aBHlJeB
CKoro peoe, HJIH npHel>KerO Hl )laTBHH, HHKor.na He COOJIIO.na
Bmero HOPM Hy.naH3Ma H .no He.naSHero BpeMeHH .na>Ke He
no.nOlpeBasmero 0 HHX. COMHHTeJIhHO nonOMY, lJTOObl
BHemHHA HaOJIIO.naTeJIh CMor YCTaHOBHTb Of)Il{HOCTb eBpeeB
KaK e.nHHoA HaU;HH Ha OCHOBe O.nHHX JIHmb of)beKTHBHbIX
xapaKTepHcTHK. A SOT naJIeCTHHCKa51 HaU;H5I npe.nJIaraeT .nHaMeTpaJIbHO npOTHBOnOJIO>KHbIA npHMep. naJIeCTHHU;bl
HMelOT MHO>KeCTBO OObeKTHBHbIX 06Il{HX lJepT CO BceMH npo
lJHMH apaoaMH. He HCKJIlOlJeHO, lJTO C HCTOpHlJeCKOA, KYJIb
TYPHOA, JIHHrBHCTHlJeCKOA H peJIHrHOlHoA TOlJeK lpeHH5I Y
naJIeCTHHu;eB OOJIbme of)Il{ero C Hop.naHu;aMH HJIH cHpHAu;aMH.
lJeM Y a4JHoncKHx eBpeeB C yp0>KeHu;aMH HlpaHJI5I. TeM He
MeHee naJIeCTHHU;bI f.JYBCTBYIOT, lJTO OHH COCTaBJI5IIOT OC06Y1O
HaU;HIO, B TO BpeM5I KaK 34JHoncKHe eBpeH H eBpeH-Ypo
>KeHU;bI HlpaHJI5I BH.n5lT B ce6e lJJIeHOB o.nHoA H ToA >Ke
HaU;HOHaJIbHOA rpynnbl. KOHelJHO. TaKHe lJYBCTBa MoryT CO
BpeMeHeM MeH5ITbC5I. HTorOM lJero OKa3bIBaeTC5I pacnall
O.nHHX H pO>K.neHHe .nPyrHx HaU;HA. Hau;HH CYIl{ecTBYIOT JIHmb
nOCTOJIbKY. nOCKOJIbKY HX lJJIeHbI pal.neJI5IIOT lJYSCTBO
KOJIJIeKTHBHoA npHHa.nJIe>KHOCTH. B 3TOM CMbICJIe peHa
HOBCKa51 MeTa4Jopa HaU;HOHaJIbHoA COnpHlJaCTHOCTH KaK
·e>Ke.nHeSHoro nJIeOHCU;HTa" 31 TOlJHO OTpa>KaeT Ba>KHYIO pOJIb
">KeJIaHH5I npHHa.nJIe>KaTb" npH onpe.neJIeHHH HaU;HH. XaMnmHp
OTMelJaeT Ba>KHOCTb COlHaTeJIbHOrO aKu;eHTHpOBaHH5I CXO.n
CTBa H CTOJIh >Ke COlHaTeJIhHOrO npeHe6pe>KeHH5I pa3JIHlJH
51MH B OCOlHaHHH Hau;HH CJIe.nYIOIl{HM of)palOM:
"C03HaTeJIbHOe H npellHaMepeHHoe nOIlf.JepKHBaHHe
rpynnoBblx pa3JIHf.JHR B nOBelleHHH H HHTepecax HBJIHeTCH
CJIellCTBHeM paJlleJIHeMOR npHBblf.JKH OCMbICJIHBaTb 3TH pa3JIH
f.JHH HCTOpHf.JeCKH H B TaKHX TepMHHax, KOTopble lleJIalOT HX DO
JIee BblnyrK.ny HaU;HOHaJIbHblMH rpynnaMH Mbi MO>KeM no
JIaraTbC5I Ha HaU;HOHaJIbHbIA xapaKTep, OlJeHb Ba>KHbI .nJI5I
nOHHMaHH5I cospeMeHHoro Hau;HOHaJIH3Ma:
"HeKOTopaH rpynna HHIlHBHIlYYMOB (HanpHMep )[(HTeJIH
onpelleJIeHHOR TeppHTopHH HJIH HOCHTeJIH onpelleJIeHHOrO H3bl
Ka) lleJIaeTCH HaUHeR, ecJIH H Korila ee f.JJIeHbl TBepllO npH3HalOT OnpelleJIeHHble BJaHMHble npasa H ODH3aHHOCTH, BblTeKalO
lIUfe H3 CBoero f.JJIeHCTBa B 3TOR rpynne. I1MeHHo ODIIJBe npH3Ha-He CYIIJeCTBYIOIIJHX B3aHMHblX CBH3eR H npeBpallJaeT HX
8 HaUHlO, a OTHlOllb He IlPyrHe ODIIJHe f.JepTbl, KaKHMH Dbl OHH HH DblJIH, OTlleJIHIOIIJHe JIeHOB 3TOR rpynnbl OT Tex, KTO K
HeR He OTHOCHTCH~ 34
KYJIbTypa - :no H eCTb Ta COBOKynHOCTb cneUH4JHlJecKHX
OC06eHHOCTeA. KOTopbIe n03BOJI5IIOT HaUHH Of)OCOf)HTbC5I OT
88 89
http:3aObIBlJHSOCTH".33http:TblCHf.JHhttp:COOJIIO.nahttp:HHKor.na
JlPyrHx HaUHA. BOT !.ITO no 3TOMY nOBOJlY nHlIIeT YHJIbSiMC:
HKa~~oe qeAOBeqeCKOe 06~eCTBO 06A~aeT c06cTBeHHoR f/JopMoR. c06CTBeHHoR ueAblO If c06cTBeHHbIM CMbICAOM. KaJK
~oe 06~ecTBO BbIP~aeT ce6R B CBOlfX IfHCTHTYTax, IfCKYCCT
BeHHaKAOHHOCTRX. C03~aHlfe06~ecTBa - 3TOHaxo~~eHlfe06~ero CMbICAa If HanpaBAeHlfR, aero POCT - 3TO nOCTORHHbIe cno
pbI If nonpaBKH no~ B03~eifcTBlfeM onbITa, KOHTaKTOB. OTKPbI
Tlfif. .aa~e 3peAoe 06~eCTBO nOCTORHHO 3aHOBO nepe~eAbIBa
eTCR B C03HaHIflf CBOlfX qAeHOB"35.
KYJIbTypa 3JleCb nOHHMaeTCSi KaK BceOXBaTblBalOmaSi CTpYK
Typa nOBeJleHHSi. Si3blKa, HOpM. MHlIloB H CHMBOJIOB, n03BOJISiIO
II{HX ee HOCHTeJI.RM pacn03HaBaTb JlPyr JlPyra. OTCIOJla CJIeJlyeT.
!.ITO JlBa !.IeJIOBeKa npHHaJlJIe)[(aT K OJlHoA H ToA )[(e HauHH, ec
JIH - H TOJIbKO eCJIH - OHH pa3JleJI.RIOT eJlHHYIO KYJIbTypy~6 no MHeHHIO AHJlepCOHa, co06mecTBa H~HO OTJIH!.IaTb JlPyr
OT Jlpyra He no KpHTepHIO HX nOJlJIHHHOCTH HJIH HCKYCCTBeHHOC
TH. a B COOTBeTCTBHH CO cnoc06aMH HX MblCJIeHHOrO npeJl
CTaBJIeHH.R. HauHH - 3TO co06mecTBa, npeJlCTaBJI.ReMble !.Iepe3
KYJIbTYPY. HHa!.le rOBOp.R, "KYJlbTYPHble apTelllaKTbl" onpeJle
JIeHHorO THna37 • COBpeMeHHble HaUHH CJIHIIIKOM BeJIHKH, !.IT06bl
Bce HX !.IJIeHbl MorJIH 06maTbcSi HenocpeJlCTBeHHo JlPyr C JlPY
rOM. n03TOMY pacn03HaBaHHe CBOHX COOTe!.leCTBeHHHKOB, HHa
!.Ie rOBOpSi, npOBeJleHHe rpaHHU Me)[(JlY !.IJIeHaMH H He !.IJle
HaMH JlaHHOA HaUHH, JleJIaeTC.R npOJlYKTOM !.IeJIOBe!.leCKOrO
Bo06pa)[(eHH.R, B OCHOBe KOToporo JIe)[(HT YBepeHHOCTb. !.ITO
Bce !.IJIeHbl HaUHH HMelOT Heme 06mHe !.IepTbl.
OnpeJleJIeHHe HaUHA KaK KYJIbTYPHblX coo6mecTB, BbIJleJI.Re
MblX CHJIoA Bo06pa)[(eHH.R HX !.IJIeHOB, C03JlaeT MHO)[(eCTBO
CJIO)[(HOCTeA. B MHpe cymeCTByeT MHoro BHJlOB KyJIbTypHblX
rpynn, OT rHraHTCKHX, TaKHX, KaK 3anaJlHaSi UHBHJIH3aUH.R B
ueJIOM. JlO He60JIbIIlHX. nOJl06HblX 06mHHaM aMHIIIeA. 4HCTO
HHTYHTHBHO MbI He CTpeMHMCSi Ha3blBaTb HX HaUHSiMH, XOTSi MO
)[(eT nOKa3aTbCSi, !.ITO OHH 60JIee HJIH MeHee YJlOBJIeTBOpSiIOT Ha
II1eMY onpeJleJIeHHIO. KaK )[(e TorJla npoBecTH !.IeTKYIO rpaHHUY
Me)[(JlY HaUHSiMH H npO!.lHMH KYJIbTypHblMH rpynnaMH1 Y Hac
HeT YJlOBJIeTBOpHTeJIbHOrO OTBeTa Ha 3TOT Bonpoc. CTpeM
JIeHHeK 60JIbIIleA TO!.lHOCTH, Jla)[(e eCJIH 6bl ee H MO)[(HO
6blJIO Jl06HTbC.R, 3aCTaBHJIO 6bl c6poCHTb CO C!.IeTOB 6ecKo
He!.lHOe pa3Ho06pa3He COUHaJIbHblX lIleHOMeHOB. npeTeHJlYIO-
IJ.IHX Ha THTYJI HaUHH. npH3HaHHble HaUHH !.IaCTO YCTaHaBJIH
salOT KpHTepHH, H306peTeHHble JlJISi Toro, !.IT06b1 He n03BOJlHTb
JlPyrHM rpynnaM TO)[(e npH06pecTH CTaTYC HaUHH, BblCTasJISiSi
JlJISi 3Toro Tpe60BaHHSi K !.IHCJIeHHOCTH, TeppHTopHH HJIH
.R3bIKY. OJlHaKO HeT HHKaKoro 06beKTHBHoro cnoco6a pe
mHTb, JlOCTaTO!.lHO JIH 6JIH3KH JlBe KYJIbTypbl, !.IT06bl HX
HeJIb3Si 6blJIO pa3JleJIHTb, H JlOCTaTO!.lHO JIH 3Ha!.lHMbI pa3JIH
!.IH.R Me)[(JlY HHMH, !.IT06bl OnpaBJlaTb B03HHKHoseHHe HOBOA
rpynnbl. CJIeJlOBaTeJIbHO, eCJIH !.IJIeHbl HeKoeA rpynnbl o6JIa
JlalOT KaKHMH-TO 06meHaUHOHaJIbHblMH !.IepTaMH H noaTOMY
npOB03rJIaIIlalOT ce6.R HaUHeA. HY)[(HO npH3HaTb HX B aTOM
Ka!.leCTBe. !.IT06b! OHH He CTaJIH )[(epTSaMH HeOnpaBJlaHHOA
HecnpaseJlJIHBOCTH.
HaIIle onpeJleJIeHHe HMeeT CMblCJI. HeCMOTpSi Ha TO, !.ITO
npH ero npHMeHeHHH B HeKOTopblX npOMe)[(YTO!.lHbIX CJIY
!.IaSiX B03HHKalOT HeJIerKHe npoi.'SJIeMbl. 3TO BepHO. !.ITO Tpe
60BaHHSi HaUHOHaJIbHOrO caMoonpeJleJIeHHSi 06bl!.lHO npo
B03rJIaIIlalOTCSi rpynnaMH. !.Ibe npaBO Ha cTaTyc HaUHH JlOCTa
TO!.lHO CHJIbHO. npeJlJIaraeMblA B CJIeJlYlOmeM pa3JleJle aHaJIH3
3Toro npaBa nOKa3blBaeT npeYBeJIH!.IeHHOCTb cTpaxos
OTHOCHTeJIbHO B03MO)[(HOA lIlparMeHTaUHH cospeMeHHoA
nOJIHTH!.IeCKOA CHCTeMbl. Bbl3saHHoA npHHSiTHeM CJIHIIIKOM
paCnJIblS!.laTOrO onpeJleJleHHSi HaUHH. 3TH CTpaXH CTHMY
JIHPYIOTCSi nOJl03peHHeM. !.ITO 3a Ka)[(JlbIM Tpe60saHHeM
HaUHOHaJIbHOrO npH3HaHH.R cKpblSaeTC.R cenapaTHcT
CKoe HaMepeHHe C03JlaTb He3aBHcHMYIO HaUHIO-rocYJlapCTBo.
Ha JleJIe aTO COBceM H He BcerJla TaK.
APT'YMEHTbI B 3AIIU1TY nPABA HA HAltHOHAnbHOE CAMOOnPE}lEnEHHE
B HameM CTOJIeTHH oc06eHHo )[(apKHe cnopbl no nOBOJlY
npaBa HaUHA Ha caMoonpeJleJleHHe B03HHKaJIH s TpH KJIIO!.Ie
BblX nepHoJla: no OKOH!.IaHHH nepBoA MHPOBOA BoAHbI
("4eTblpHaJluaTb nYHKToB" BHJIbCOHa); nOCJIe BTOpoA MHposoA
BoAHbl H B nocJIeJlYlOmHA nepHOJl JleKOJIOHH3aUHH; H. HaKOHeu.
BCJIeJl 3a COUHaJIbHOA H nOJIHTH!.IeCKOA peBOJIIOUHeA KOHua
80-x rOJlOB B UeHTpaJIbHOA H BOCTO!.lHOA EBpone. Ii Ka)[(JlblA pa3 aTO npaBO YTBep)[(JlaJIOCb H 060cHOBblBaJIOCb B pa3JIH!.IHbIX Tep
MHHax.
90 91
http:KJIIO!.Iehttp:BbIJleJI.Rehttp:HOCHTeJI.RM
npaBO Ha HaQHOHaRbHOe CaMOOnpe~eReHHe HCTOpH4eCKH
HHTepnpeTHpOBaJIOCb ~BYM.SI cnOCOOaMH, Ka)l(~bIA H3 KOTOPbIX OTnpaBRSlRC.SI OT CBoerO COOCTBeHHOrO nOHHMaHH.SI HaQHH H BH
~eR CBOe OnpaB~aHHe B 3alllHTe CneQHq,H4eCKHX ~R.SI ceo.Sl HH~HBH~YaJIbHbIX HHTepeCOB.
COrRaCHO KYJIbTYPHOR BepCHH, ~HaQH.SI~ Onpe~eR.SIeTC.SI KaJ(
cOOollleCTBO, pa3~eR.SllOlIlee HaOOp OO'beKTHBHbIX XapaKTepHCTHK, npOXO~.SIlIlHX no Be~OMCTBY KYRbTYPbI H HaQHOHaJIbHoro C03Ha
HH.SI. COOTBeTCTBeHHO, npaBO Ha HaQHOHaJIbHOe caMoonpe~eRe
HHe nOHHMaeTC.SI KaK npaBO HaQHH (HRH, T04Hee, ee 4ReHOB) CO
XpaH.SITbC.SI B Ka4eCTBe OT~eRbHoA OT ~pyrHX 4eROBe4eCKoA
0611lHOCTH H nO~~ep)l(HBaTb CBOIO 0611leCTBeHHYIO )l(H3Hb B CO
OTBeTCTBHH co CBOHMH coOCTBeHHbIMH npHBbI4KaMH, Tpa~HQH
.SIMH H QeHHOCT.SIMH. HanpOTHB,l(eMOKpaTHQeCKaH BepCH.SI BH~HT
B "HaQHH" rpynny HH~HBH~YYMOB, nO~4HH.SI\OlIlHXC.SI npaBHRaM
onpe~eReHHoA nORHTH4ecKoA CHCTeMbI. noaTOMY npaBO Ha ca
Moonpe~eReHHe nOHHMaeTC.SI 3~ecb KaK npaBO 4ReHOB OOllleCTBa yqacTBOBaTb B ero ynpaBReHHH. 3TO nOCRe~Hee npaBO nOKOHT
C.SI Ha npHHQHne, Cq,0PMYRHpOBaHHOM BO BceoollleA ~eKRapaQHH npaB 4eROBeKa: "Ka)l(~bIA 4eROBeK HMeeT npaBO npHHHMaTb
yqacTHe B ynpaBReHHH cBoeA cTpaHoA Henocpe~CTBeHHO HRH
4epe3 nocpe~CTBO CBOOO~HO H30paHHbIX npe~CTaBHTeReA. ~ 113 aTHX HHTepnpeTaQHA BbITeKalOT ~Ba He3aBHCHMbIX no~
JCo~a K q,YH~aMeHTaJIbHbIM npHHQHnaM q,OpMHpOBaHH.SI H pa3BH
TH.SI rocy~apCTB. B TO BpeM.Sl KaK nepBa.sr CneQRaRbHO aKQeHTH
pyeT HaQHOHaJIbHYIO OCHOBY npaBa Ha caMoonpe~eReHHe, BTO
pa.Sl BbIBO~HT ero He H3 HaQHOHaJIbHOrO MbIIIIJIeHH.SI, a H3 RHoe
PaJIbHbIX H ~eMOKpaTH4eCKHX H~eaJIOB.
XOT.SI MHorHe cnopbI 0 npaBe Ha HaQHOHaRbHoe caMO
onpe~eReHHe OTpa)l(alOT nYTaHHQY Me)l(~y aTHMH ~BYM.SI BepCH
.SIMH, caMoynpaBReHHe H HaQHOHaJIbHOe caMoonpe~eReHHe
~Ba paMH4HbIX nOH.SITH.SI. OHH OTRH4aIOTC.SI B CBOHX HH~HBH
~YaJIHCTH4eCKHX H OOllleCTBeHHbIX acneKTax, OTpa)l(aIOT paMH4
HbIe npe~CTaBReHH.SI 0 4eROBe4eCKoA nORb3e H BbIBO~.SIT CBOIO
QeHHOCTb H3 pa3HbIX HaOopOB 4eROBe4eCKHX QeHHOCTeA.
I1H~HBH~yaRHcTH4eCKHA acneKT OOOHX npaB CTaBHT Ha nepBoe MeCTO RH4HylO aBTOHOMHIO H npaBO RIO~eA Ha
C03HaTeRbHbIA BbIOOp. ECRH pe4b H~eT 0 npaBe Ha caMO
onpe~eReHHe, aTOT acneKT OTHOCHTC.SI K cnocoOaM, nocpe~CT
92
SOM KOTOPbIX HH~HBH~YYMbI onpe~eR.SIIOT nepCOHaRbHYIO H
HallHOH&RbHYIO H~eHTH4HOCTb. HanpOTHB, B cRyqae npaaa Ha
C&MoynpaBReHHe, OH q,HKcHpyeT npaBO RIO~eA ynpaBR.SITb
cOOCTBeHHbIM cYllleCTBoBaHHeM, He nO~4HH.SI.SICb BHeWHeMY
,lXHKTaTY· ECRH oOpaTHTbC.SI K oOlllecTBeHHOMY acneKTY, HaQHOHaJIb
Hoe CaMOOnpe~eReHHe 03Ha4aeT npoQecc, nocpe~cTBOM KOTO
pora HH~HBH~YYMbI nbITaIOTC.SI nyORH4HO Bblpa3HTb CBOIO Ha
QHOHaRbHYIO H~eHTH4HOCTb. noaTOMY ero 4aCTO onHCbIBaIOT KaK
npaBO HH~HBH~YYMOB Ha COQHaJIbHYIO cq,epy, HMe.Sl B BH~y, 4TO
Te BnpaBe c03~aBaTb OOlllecTBeHHbIe HHCTHTYTbI H CTPOHTb CBOIO oOlllecTBeHHYIO )l(H3Hb cnocoOaMH. KOTopbIe oTpa)l(aIOT HX
rpynnoBbIe QeHHOCTH, Tpa~HQHH H HCTOpHIO. Kop04e rOBOp.Sl,
HX KYRbTYPY. OOllleCTBeHHbIA acneKT caMoynpaBReHH.SI OTHO
CHTC.SI K npaBY HH~HBH~YYMOB yqacTBOBaTb B onpe~eReHHH Qe
ReA H nORHTH4eCKHX KypCOB, npHHHMaeMbIX nORHTH4eCKHMH
rpynnaMH. K KOTOPbIM OHH npHHa~Re)l(aT, HHa4e rOBOp.Sl, J( npa
BY BRH.SITb Ha cepbe3HbIe peWeHH.SI OTHOCHTeRbHO nORHTH4ec
KHX npoQeccoB. BOT n04eMY 3~eCb BO rRaBY yrRa CTaBHTC.SI
npaBO )l(HTeReA Y4aCTBOBaTb B ynpaBReHHH CTpaHoA.
TaKHM 06pa30M. eCRH HH~HBH~YYMbI HMeIOT npaBo Y4acT
BOBaTb B 4eCTHOM nORHTH4eCKOM npoQecce, eCRH Bce OHH
HMeIOT paBHbIe B03MO)l(HOCTH npe~CTaBR.SITb Ha cy~ ~pyrHX
coocTBeHHbIe B3rR.SI~bl H arHTHpOBaTb 3a HX npHH.SITHe. TO MO)l(HO CKa3aTb. 4TO OHH peaRbHO OORa~aIOT caMoynpaBReHHeM. Ho aTO ellle He 03Ha4aeT npHH.SITH.SI 4bHX-TO KOH
KpeTHblX B3rR.SI~OB Ha Bce CRY4aH )l(H3HH. B nRlOpaRHCTH
4eCKHX H reTeporeHHblX cOOOllleCTBax, KaKOBblMH .SIBR.SIIOTC.SI
OORbWHHCTBO COBpeMeHHblX rocy~apCTB. HHKTO He B COCTO.SIHHH HaB.SI3bIBaTb ~pyrHM CBOH B033peHH.SI no OORbWHHCTBY
BonpOCOB. TaKHM oOpa30M. Ka)l(~IA HH~HBH~yYM B pe3YRbTaTe
4eCTHoA nORHTH4eCKoA ~HCKyCCHH MO)l(eT OKa3aTbC.SI B
MeHbWHHCTBe, XOT.SI npH aTOM HHKTO He CMO)l(eT HaB.SI3aTb
~PYrHM CBOH HOPMbI nOBe~eHH.SI H KYRbTypHble npe~n04Te
HH.SI, H HHKTO B TO )l(e BpeM.SI He CMO)l(eT nO)l(aROBaTbC.SI Ha
HapymeHHe npaBa Ha caMoynpasReHHe. CRe~OBaTeRbHO, eCRH
RIO~H nORY4aIOT paBHble B03MO)l(HOCTH Y4aCTBOBaTb B no
RHTH4eCKHX npoQeccax, He3aBHCHMO OT HX pe3YRbTaTOB, TO
TeM CaMbIM H ocymecTBR.SIeTC.SI npaBO Ha caMoynpaBReHHe.
93
http:ocymecTBR.SIeTC.SIhttp:nO)l(aROBaTbC.SIhttp:nOBe~eHH.SIhttp:OKa3aTbC.SIhttp:B033peHH.SIhttp:npHH.SITH.SIhttp:CTaBHTC.SIhttp:peWeHH.SIhttp:rOBOp.Slhttp:caMoynpaBReHH.SIhttp:rOBOp.Slhttp:nbITaIOTC.SIhttp:oOpaTHTbC.SIhttp:OTHOCHTC.SIhttp:npe~CTaBReHH.SIhttp:OTRH4aIOTC.SIhttp:nOH.SITH.SIhttp:MbIIIIJIeHH.SIhttp:nepBa.srhttp:q,OpMHpOBaHH.SIhttp:nOHHMaeTC.SIhttp:nO~4HH.SI\OlIlHXC.SIhttp:BepCH.SIhttp:XpaH.SITbC.SIhttp:nOHHMaeTC.SIhttp:Onpe~eR.SIeTC.SIhttp:nOHHMaHH.SIhttp:OTnpaBRSlRC.SI
'I'f
npaBO Ha HaL\HOHaJIbHOe CaMOOnpe,lleJIeHHe, HanpOTHS, 3a
SHCHT He TOJIbKO OT pea.nbHOR B03MO>KHOCTH BJIH.fITb Ha KYJIb
TypHYJO >KH3Hb csoeR COQHaJIbHO-nOJIHTHtIecKoR CHCTeMbI, HO
H OT pe3YJIbTaTOB 3Toro BJIHSlHHSI. KaK CtIHTaeTCSI, HaQHO
HaJIbHOe caMoonpe,lleJIeHHe peaJIH3yeTcSI JIHWb Tor,lla, Kor,lla
KaKHe-TO YHHKaJIbHbIe HaQHOHaJIbHbIe oco()eHHOCTH Ha
XO,llSiT Bblpa>KeHHe S nOJIHTHtIeCKOR c!Jlepe.
aJISI HJIJI~CTpaQHH pa3JIHtIHR Me>K,Ily caMoynpaBJIeHHeM
H HaQHOHaJIbHhlM caMOOnpe,lleJIeHHeM npHBe,lleM HeCKOJIbKO
npHMepOB. npOQeCC eBponeRcKoro OObe,llHHeHHSI MO>KeT co
BpeMeHeM 3aKOHtIHTbCSI C03,1laHHeM e,llHHOro rOCY,IlapCTBa,
Bce rpa>K,IlaHe KOToporo, BepO.fITHO, ()Y,IlYT OOJIa,llaTb nOJIHhlM
Ha()opOM rpa>K,IlaHCKHX npaB. TaKoe rOCY,IlapCTBO n03BOJIHT
BceM eBponeRQaM peaJIH30BaTb npaBO Ha caMoynpaBJIeHHe,
HO COBceM He OOSl3aTeJIbHO ,IlaCT B03MO>KHOCTb JI~,IlSiM Pa3
JIHtIHbIX HaQHR ocyxqeCTBHTb npaBO Ha HaQHOHaJIbHOe caMO
onpe,lleJIeHHe38• HanpOTHB, He,lleMOKpaTHtIeCKOe HaQHSI
rOCY,llapCTBO JIHWaeT CBOHX >KHTeJIeR npaBa Ha caMoynpaB
JIeHHe, HO He npaBa Ha HaQHOHaJIbHOe caMOOnpe,lleJIeHHe.
Bopb()a 3a HaQHOHaJIbHOe caMOOnpe,lleJIeHHe He TOJIbKO OTJIH
tIaeTCSI OT JIHOepaJIbHO-,IleMOKpaTHtIeCKHX YCHJIHR no 3aBOe
BaHH~ rpa>K,IlaHCKHX H nOJIHTHtIeCKHX npaB, HO MO>KeT ,Ila>Ke
BCTynaTb C HHMH B npOTHBOpetIHSI. 11 S caMOM ,IleJIe, KaK nOKa3blBaeT HCTOPHSI, JI~,IlH Hepe,llKO, ,Ila>Ke QeHoR OTKa3a OT
rpa>K,IlaHCKHX npaB H CBO()O,ll, CTpeMSlTCSI ,Il00HTbCSI ,IlJISI CBO
eR CO()CTBeHHoR HaU;HH cTaTyca H npH3HaHHSI. n03TOMY Ko
MHTeT no npaBaM tIeJIOBeKa COBepWHJI OWHOKY, YBH,IleB B
npase Ha HaQHOHaJIbHOe caMOOnpe,lleJIeHHe Ba>KHeRwee yc
JIOBHe cO()JI~,IleHHSI HH,IlHBH,IlyaJIbHhlX npaB tIeJIOBeKi9. Hepe,llKO CJIyqaeTCSI TaK, tITO HaQHH, ,Il0()HBWHecSi caMO
onpe,lleJIeHHSI, yCTaHaBJIHBa~T y ceoSi pe>KHMbl, OrpaHHtIH
Ba~IqHe npaBa tIeJIOBeKa. B TO >Ke BpeMSI JI~,IlH MorYT nOJIb30BaTbCSI BceMH rpa>K,IlaHCKHMH npaBaMH, ,Ila>Ke eCJIH OHH
>KHBYT no,ll HatIaJIOM npe,llCTaBHTeJIeR ,IlpyrHx HaQHOHaJIbHOC
TeR. KaK BH,IlHO H3 npHMepOB, npHBe,lleHHblX BbIwe, HaQHOHaJIb
Hoe caMOOnpe,lleJIeHHe caMO no ce()e HMeeT MaJIO o()xqero C
rpa>K,IlaHCKHMH npaBaMH H YtIaCTHeM B nOJIHTHtIeCKOR >KH3HH.
ECJIH BOCnOJIb30BaTbCSI onpe,lleJIeHHeM BepJIHHa, QeJIb HaQH
OHaJIbHOrO caMOOnpe,lleJIeHHSI - He BceooxqHe CBO()O,llbl H
rpa>K,IlaHCKHe npaBa, a ,Il0CTH>KeHHe onpe,lleJIeHHOrO cTaTyca;
3TO OOPboa 3a npH3HaHHe, a He 3a ·paBeHCTBO ~pH,IlHtIeCKHX
npaB" HJIH 3a "CBO()O,lly nocTynaTb no cooCTBeHHOMY >KeJIaHH~",
XOTSI ,IlJISI HeKOTopbIX 3TH npaBa MorYT OblTb tIpe3BhltIaRHO
Ba>KHhlMH. nO,llO()HaSI oopb()a OTpa>KaeT >KeJIaHHe >KHTb B Ha
nOJIHeHHOM CMbICJIOM OKpY>KeHHH, r,lle tIeJIOBeK MO>KeT oxqy
maTb OJIH30CTb K CBOHM npaBHTeJISIM HJIH ,Ila>Ke OTO)[(,lleCTBJISlTb
ce()SI C HHMH, H He Ba>KHO. peaJIbHOCTb JIH 3TO HJIH TOJIbKO
yrewHTeJIbHaSi HJIJI~3HSI.
"I1MeHHo CTpeMJIeHHe K B38HMHOMY npH3H8HHlO 38CT8B
JIReT JIlOtfeR notffl8C npetfnOfleCTb C8Mble 8BTOpHT8pHbIe
tfeMOKp8THHH H8H6oJIee npoCBelI1eHHbIM OJIHr8pxHRM. no
ToR )l(e npHflHHe )l(HTeJIH Hetf8BHO OCBo60tfHBIIIHXCR 83H8T
CKHX H 8r[JPHK8HCKHX CTP8H BbIK83bIB8lOT HHOrtf8 MeHbIIIe
HetfOBOJIbCTBa CBOHMH HbIHeIIIHHMH )l(eCTOKHMH npaBHTeJIR
MH-3eMJIRKaMH HJIH COOTefleCTBeHHHK8MH, fleM 3TO 6bIJIO B
npOIIIJIbIe KOJIOHH8JIbHble BpeMeH8, KOrtfa HMH ynpaBJIRJIH
OCMOTpHTeJIbHbIe, CnpaBetfJIHBble, P83YMHbIe H tfo6po)l(eJIa
TeJIbHble 8AMHHHCTP8TOPbI H3 MeTpOnOJIHH. jf Mory OII1YlI1aTb
CBOIO HeCB060tfy B TOM CMblCJIe, flTO BO MHe He npH3H8lOT
caMOCTORTeJIbHYIO H cnoc06HYlO npHHHM8Tb peIIIeHHR JIHfl
HOCTb. Ho R Mory HcnbITblB8Tb Te )l(e flYBCTBa Y)l(e B K8fleCTBe flJIeHa HenpH3HaHHoR HJIH HetfOCTaTOflHO YBa)l(aeMOR
rpynnbl; B 3TOM CJIYflae R 6YtfY CTpeMHTbCR K 3M8HCH
naLCHH Bcero CBoero KJIaCC8, H.l1H CO o 61I1ecTBa, HJIH pa
CbI, HJIH npor[JeccHH. jf Mory )l(eJIaTb 3Toro HaCTOJIbKO CHJIbHO,
flTO CKopee COrJIaIIIYCb HMeTb CKBepHoe H Hetfo6poCOBeCT
Hoe npaBJIeHHe npetfCTaBHTeJIR MoeR co6CTBeHHoR paCbI
HJIH 061I1eCTBeHHoro KJIaCC8, KOTOPbIR 6ytfeT npH3H8B8Tb BO
MHe fle.l10BeK8 H conepHHK8, HH8fle rOBopR, p8BHoro ce6e, fleM nOtfflHHIOCb cnp8BetfJIHBOMY H TepnHMOMY npetfCT8
BHTeJIIO tfaJIeKoR H flY)l(tfOR MHe rpynnbI, KOTOPbIR C BbI
COTbI CBoero nOJIO)l(eHHR He npH3HaeT BO MHe Toro, KeM
R CaM XOfly ce6R BHtfeTb. B 3TOM. H HMeHHO B 3TOM COCTOHT B HaIIIH tfHH CYTb npH3bIBOB K npH3HaHHlO co CTOPOHbI
KaK HHtfHBHtfYYMOB. T8K H rpynn - npOr[JeCCHR H KJI8CCOB,
H8LCHR H pac." 40
n~,IlH XOT.fIT, tITOObl HMH npaBHJIH HHCTHTYTbl, He tIy>K,Ilble
HX COOCTBeHHoR KYJIbType, nOCKOJIbKY 3TO OOJIertIaeT HM
94 95
yqacTHe B ot5ll\eCTBeHHbIX ,l:leJIax. Kor,l:la eCTb B03MOX
HH.lIHBH.lIyaJIbHbIM, ero Bblpa)l(eHHe Ka)l(.lIblM OT.lIeJIbHblM t.J:eJIOBe
KOM 3aCJIY)I(HBaeT YBa)l(eHH.R H nO.ll.llep)l(KH. KaKHM ISbl orpa
HHt.J:eHHbIM OHO HH 6blJIO B Tex HJIH HHblX KOHKpeTHblX cJIyqa.Rx.
4. CYIl\ecTBOBaHHe 06mero .lIJI.R Bcex 06Il\eCTBeHHoro npocTpaHcTBa Bblpa)l(eHH.R HaQHOHaJIbHblX t.J:YBCTB HeolSxo.llH
Moe YCJIOBHe caMocoxpaHeHH.R HaQHH KaK )l(H3HeCnocolSHoro H
aKTHBHoro co06Il\eCTBa. lIeJIOBeK. t.J:YBCTBYIOIl\HA PO.llCTBO C
OKpY)I(eHHeM, OKa3bIBaeTC.R B COCTO.RHHH BeCTH 60JIee nOJI
HOQeHHYIO 06Il\eCTBeHHYlO )l(H3Hb. JIHWb B 3TOM CJIYt.J:ae
"HH.lIHBH.lIYYM cnoc06eH nOt.J:YBCTBOBaTb, t.J:TO ero )l(H3Hb npo
XO.llHT B co06Il\eCTBe, .lIalOIl\eM B03MO)l(HOCTb CB060.llHO pa3BH
BaTb H ny6JIHt.J:HO Bblpa)l(aTb HMeHHO Te t.J:epTbl JIHt.J:HOCTH. KOTO
pble npOHcTeKalOT H3 t.J:YBCTBa npHHa.llJIe)l(HOCTH K pO.llCTBeHHoR
rpynne."42
5. B CHJIY 3Toro HaQHOHaJIbHOe caMOOnpe.lleJIeHHe CB.R3aHO co CTpeMJIeHHeM 06pecTH TaKYIO 06Il\eCTBeHHYlO 4l0PMY. B paM
Kax KOTOpoA t.J:eJIOBeK He TOJIbKO paCCt.J:HTbIBaeT COTpY.lIHHt.J:aTb
C .lIPyrHMH pa.llH Y.lIOBJIeTBOpeHH.R CBOHX t.J:aCTHbIX HHTepeCOB,
HO TaK)I(e Ha.lleeTC.R HaRTH cnoc06bl Bblpa3HTb CBOIO CO
npHt.J:aCTHOCTb coot)Il\eCTBY. TeM caMblM B QeHTpe npH3blBOB K
HaQHOHaJIbHOMY caMOOnpe.lleJIeHHIO OKa3bIBaeTC.R cnoco()
HOCTb OC03HaTb onpe.lleJIeHHble Ot)Il\eCTBeHHble H nOJIHTHt.J:eCKHe
HHCTHTYTbl B Kat.J:eCTBe npe.llCTaBHTeJIeA .lIaHHOA KYJIbTYPbl H
HOCHTeJIeA HaQHOHaJIbHOA H.lIeHTHt.J:HOCTH. Te nOJIHTHt.J:eCHe
4l0PMbl. B KOTOPblX 3TO npaBO peaJIH3yeTC.R Ha npaKTHKe•
.lIOJI)I(Hbl OTpa)l(aTb YHHKaJIbHOCTb COOTBeTCTBYIOIl\eA HaQH
OHaJIbHOA rpynnbl, ee caMOCTO.RTeJIbHOe MeCTO B HCTOpHH. ee
.R3b1K, KYJIbTYPY, t)blTb MO)l(eT, .lIa)l(e peJIHrHIO - HMeHHO 3TO
H .lIaeT B03MO)l(HOCTb ee t.J:JIeHaM Ct.J:HTaTb ee nOJIHOCTblO cBoeR.
6. npaBo Ha HaQHOHaJIbHOe caMOOnpe.lleJIeHHe MO)l(HO peaJIH30BaTb .lIO KOHQa TOJIbKO B TOM CJIYt.J:ae, eCJIH. Bo-nepBbIX.
onpe.lleJIeHHa.R HaQHOHaJIbHa.R rpynna npH3HaeTC.R KaK CBOHMH
t.J:JIeHaMH, TaK H TeMH, KTO K HeA He npHHa.llJIe)l(HT. B Kat.J:eCTBe
He3aBHCHMoro HCTOt.J:HHKa .lIeACTBHA H TBopt.J:eCKHX CHJI. H.
BO-BTOPbIX. eCJIH 3a 3THM npH3HaHHeM CJIe.llyeT YCTaHOBJIeHHe
nOJIHTHt.J:eCKoro YCTpoAcTBa. KOTopoe .lIaeT ee t.J:JIeHaM B03
MO)l(HOCTb CTPOHTb HaQHOHaJIbHYIO )l(H3Hb C MHHHMaJIbHblM
BMeWaTeJIbCTBOM co CTOPOHbI. BOJIee HJIH MeHee 0lSIl\enpA3
HaHO, t.J:TO .lIJI.R 3Toro .lIaHHOMY HaQHOHaJIbHOMY coolSmeCTBY
98
Hy)l(HO npe.llOCTaBHTb MaKCHMaJIbHO WHPOKYIO aBTOHOMHlO, a
HMeHHO, npaBO Ha OCHOBaHHe CYBepeHHoro rOCY.lIapCTBa
HIQHH. O.llHaKO B CTeneHH npaKTHt.J:eCKoR peaJIH3aQHH :noro
npaBa He MO)l(eT He HrpaTb POJIH TO, t.J:TO HM .lIOJI)I(Hbl B paBHoR
Mepe nOJIb30BaTbC.R Bce HaQHH ()e3 HCKJIIOt.J:eHH.R.
He nO.llJIe)l(HT COMHeHHIO. t.J:TO HMeHHO HaQH.R-rocY.lIapcTBo
S COCTO.RHHH ot)ecnet.J:HTb CBOHM rpa)l(.lIaHaM MaKCHMaJIbHYIO
cTeneHb HaQHOHaJIbHOR aBTOHOMHH H caMbiA WHPOKHR cneKTp
S03MO)l(HOCTeA HaQHOHaJIbHOrO caMOBblpa)l(eHH.R. B TO )l(e BpeM.R 0t)II\enpH3HaHO, t.J:TO npaKTHt.J:eCKoe BOnJIOIl\eHHe JIIOt)bIX npas
orpaHHt.J:HBaeTC.R Tpet)OBaHHeM oOecnet.J:HTb BceM HH.lIHSH.lIYY
MaM paBHYIO CTeneHb CBOeiO.llbl. nepBblA npHHQHn cnpaBe.llJIHBOC
TH POYJIa XopOWO no HJIJIIOCTpHpyeT: COrJIaCHO eMY. Ka)l(.lIblA
lIeJIOBeK ...lIOJI)I(eH nOJIb30BaTbC.R paBHblM .lIJI.R Bcex npaSOM HMeTb
caMhle WHpOKHe OCHOBHble CBOOO.llbl, eCJIH npH 3TOM H Bce npo
t.J:He nOJIyqalOT TaKoR )l(e .lIocTyn K 3THM CBoC)o.llaM. ''43 nOSTOMY
MO)l(HO YTBep)l(.lIaTb, t.J:TO CBOOO.lla lIJIeHOB Ka)l(.lIoR HaQHH Ha
peaJIH3aQHIO npaBa Ha caMOOnpe.lleJIeHHe .lIOJI)I(Ha orpaHH
t.J:HBaTbC.R Tpe60BaHHeM, t.J:TOeibl H npe.llCTaBHTeJIH Bcex npo
t.J:HX HaQHA MOrJIH BOCnOJIb30BaTbC.R CBOHM npaBOM. HacTa
HBa.R Ha 3ToA npe.llnOCblJIKe, YOJIQep YTBep)l(.lIaeT, t.J:TO
"HY)I(HO CTpeMHTbC.RK TaKOMY MHPOBOMY nOJIHTHt.J:eCKOMY
YCTpoAcTBY. npH KOTOPOM Bce rOCY.lIapCTBa HMeJIH 6bl CTa
t)HJIbHble rpaHHQbI H npH 3TOM HH O.llHa .lIOCTaTOt.J:HO 60JIbWa.R
rpynna He t.J:YBCTBOBaJIa ISbi ceei.R O().lIeJIeHHoR."44 OH YTOt.J:H.ReT, t.J:TO npeHMYIl\eCTBa, KOTopble npHoeipeTalOT HapO.llbl,
nOJIYt.J:aIOII\He B03MO)l(HOCTb C03.l1aTb CBOH colSCTseHHble ro
CY.lIapCTBa, ".lIOJI)I(Hbl CTaTb OeiIl\HM .lIOCTO.RHHeM."45 O.llHaKO
He Bce HaQHH MorYT .lIOCTHt.J:b TaKoR CTeneHH aBTOHOMHH,
a orpaHHt.J:eHHe npaKTHt.J:eCKoR peaJIH3aQHH npaBa Ha
HaQHOHaJIbHOe caMoonpe.lleJIeHHe JIHWb KpyroM H31SpaHblX
HaQHA He MO)l(eT He BeCTH K CHJIbHeAweMY HepaBeHCTBY. OTCIO
.lIa BblTeKaeT, liTO HY)I(HO HCKaTb .lIPyrHe peWeHH.R.
.llJI.R peaJIH3aQHH npaBa Ha caMOOnpe.lleJIeHHe cymeCTBYIOT
pa3JIHt.J:Hble nOJIHTHt.J:eCKHe MexaHH3Mbl, n03BOJI.RIOII\He JIIO.lI.RM
YlIaCTBOBaTb B HaQHOHaJIbHOA )l(H3HH CBOHX cooeiIl\eCTB. 3TO
MO)l(eT 6blTb 4l0pMHpoBaHHe HaQHOHaJIbHblX HHCTHTYTOB,
Oeipa30BaHHe aBTOHOMHblX cooeiII\eCTB, JIHeiO B03HHKHOBeHHe
«Je.llepaTHBHblX H KOH«Je.llepaTHBHbIX rocY.lIapcTB. He HMeeT
99
http:JIIO.lI.RMhttp:CTpeMHTbC.RKhttp:cJIyqa.Rx
CMbICJla HCKaTb BCeOXBaTbIBalO~HA PYKOBO.zlSI~HA npHHIJ;Hn.
n03BOJl5l1O~HA Onpe,lleJlHTb, B KaKOM HMeHHO cJlyqae npaBO Ha
HaIJ;HOHaJlbHOe CaMOOnpe,lleJleHHe OnpaB,llhlBaeT ,llaHHOe
nOJlHTHqeCKOe peWeHHe - B Ka~,llOM KOHKpeTHOM cJlyqae
JlyqWe BCerO ,lleACTBOBaTb no 00CT05lTeJlbCTBaM.
H3,llep~KH JllOooro peWeHH5I HY~HO scer,lla cpaBHHsaTb C
ero npeHMy~eCTBaMH. OTCIO,lla CJle,llyeT, qTO B cnOCOOHOCTH Ha
IJ;HA C MaKCHMaJlbHOA nOJlHOToA SOCnOJlb30SaTbC5I npaBOM Ha
caMoonpe,lleJleHHe Ba~HylO pOJlb HrpaeT npOCToe se3eHHe.
HapO,llbI, OOHTalO~He Ha OOJlbWHX H30JlHpOBaHHbIX TeppHTO
PH5IX, HMelOT OOJlbWe WaHCOB ,llOOHTbC5I aSTOHOMHH, qeM OOH
TaTeJlH nJlOTHOHaCeJleHHbIX paAOHOS. Ba~Hbl TaK~e H TaKHe
cI>aKTopbl, KaK npHpO,llHbIe pecypcbI, npHrO,llHbIe ,llJl51 CeJlb
CKoro X0351AcTsa 3eMJlH, ,llOcTyn K MOPCKHM oeperaM, YMe
peHHbIA KJlHMaT HJlH y,llaqHOe MeCTOnOJlO~eHHe. E~e O,llHH
B~HbIA cI>aKTop - SeJlHqHHa yqaCTSYIO~HX B Hrpe COOo~eCTB:
qeM OOJlbWe JlIO,lleA nOJlyqalOT ShlrO,llbI OT npOSe,lleHH5I
onpe,lleJleHHOA nOJlHTHKH, TeM C oOJlbweA JlerKOCTblO MO~HO
onpaS,llaTb OpeM5I, nepeJlaraeMOe 3TOA nOJlHTHKOA Ha ,llPy
rHX. KaK nO,llqepKHSaeT PaJ, XOT5I HaIJ;HOHaJJbHoe caMoonpe
,lleJleHHe H onpaB,llbIBaeTC5I HHTepecaMH HH,llHBH,llyaJlbHbIX
qJleHOS cooo~eCTsa, RJlHqHhle HHTepeCbI Ka~,llOrO H3 HHX
3TO e~e He OCHOBaHHe, qTOObI HX YBa~aJlH OCTaJJbHbIe. .llaH
Hoe npaso nOKOHTC5I Ha OO~HX H S TO ~e BpeM5I OCOObIX HH
Tepecax MHorHX ,llpyrHX.· 46 HaCKOJlbKO HX ,llOJl~HO OblTb MHoro - :no y~e ,llpyroA BOnpoc, O,llHaKO H3 3THX paccy~
,lleHHA BbITeKaeT, qTO qeM WHpe ,llaHHOe cooo~eCTBO, TeM
OOJlbWHM HaoopOM npas OY,llYT nOJlb30BaTbC5I ero qJleHhl. O,ll
HaKO Te3HC 0 Ba~HOCTH pa3MepOB npHoopeTaeT CMbICJI TOJlbKO
Tor,lla, KOr,lla npaBO Ha HaIJ;HOHaJlbHOe caMOonpe,lleJleHHe
nOHHMaeTC5I KaK KYMYJl5lTHBHoe HH,llHSH,llyaJlbHoe npaBO. ECJlH
~e K HeMY nO,llXO,llHTb KaK K KOJlJleKTHBHOMY npasy, TO OY,lleT
HeJlerKO nOH5ITb. Ha KaKOM OCHOBaHHH oOJlee KpynHble
rpynnbI nOJlyqalOT npeHMy~ecTBo HCnOJlb30SaHH5I :noro.
npasa Ha,ll HeMHOrOqHCJleHHbIMH.
n03TOMY npe,llnOJlaraeTC5I, qTO pa3J1HqHbIe HaIJ;HH OY,llYT a
pa3HoA CTeneHH OC~eCTBJlmb csoe npaso Ha caMoonpe,lleJle
HHe. .llo Tex nop, nOKa 3TH pa3JIHqH5I OTpa~alOT TOJlbKO Hepaa
HOMepHoe pacnpe,lleJleHHe onHcaHHblX SbIwe cJlyqaAHbIx cI>aK
100
TOPOS, Sp5l,ll JlH MO~HO rOSopHTb, qTO no OTHOWeHHIO K KOMy-TO
t'SblJla ,llOny~eHa HeCnpaBe,llJlHBOCTb. B HTore MbI Mo~eM 3aKJlIO
qHTb, qTO see HaIJ;HH HMelOT paSHble npaBa Ha ocy~ecTsJleHHe
HaIJ;HOHaJlbHOrO CaMoonpe,lleJleHH5I S MaKCHMaJJbHO S03MO~HOA
creneHH, ,llOnYCTHMoA S HX KOHKpeTHOM nOJlO~eHHH.
npHH5IB KYJlbTYPHYIO H, CJle,llOBaTeJlbHO, HH,llHSH,lly
aJlHCTHqeCKYIO KOHIJ;enIJ;HIO npaBa Ha HaIJ;HOHaJlbHOe caMO
onpe,lleJleHHe. MbI nOJlyqaeM B03MO~HOCTb BseCTH e,llHHYIO WKa
JlY ,llJl51 OIJ;eHKH npas pa3J1HqHblX HaIJ;HA (OY,llb TO rpynnbl
OOJlbWHHCTBa HJlH HaIJ;HOHaJJbHbIe MeHbWHHCTsal H OOOCHosa
HH5I npas, nOJlyqaeMbIX 3THHqeCKHMH rpynnaMH H KopeH
HhlMH ~HTeJl5lMH. qJleHbl 3THX rpynn ~H3HeHHO 3aHTepeco
saHbI S coxpaHeHHH cBoeA KYJlbTYPHOA H,lleHTHqHOCTH.
qJleHbI HaIJ;HOHaJlbHbIX MeHbWHHCTS OOJla,llaIOT HaIJ;HO
HaJlbHhlMH npasaMH, nOTOMY qTO OHH 3aHHTepeCOBaHbI B COX
paHeHHH csoeA YHHKaJlbHoA KYJlbTYPHOA CY~HOCTH. B 3TOM
CMblCJle TepMHH "MeHbWHHCTSO· ,llOJl~eH OTHOCHTbC5I He npOCTO K npOnOpIJ;HOHaJlbHblM KOJlHqeCTSeHHbIM pa3MepaM rpynnbI.
HO CKopee K CTeneHH nyOJlHqHOrO np05lSJleHH5I ee KYJlbTypbl.
llHHCTaAH OTMeqaeT, qTO nOH5ITHe "MeHbWHHCTsa" He CJle,llyeT
CBO,llHTb K KOJlHqeCTSeHHblM XapaKTepHCTHKaM, H onpe,lleJl5leT
ero KaK rpynny, HrpalO~ylO "s ,lleJlax CTpaHbl He CJlHWKOM
3HaqHTeJlbHYIO pOJlb''''7. Ho TaKoe onpe,lleJleHHe Mo~eT BseCTH s 3aOJly~,lleHHe, Se,llb OHO B paBHoA CTeneHH npHMeHHMO K aMepHKaHCKoA KOMnapTHH, K ~HJlaTeJlHCTaM. KO MHorHM ,llPy
rHM rpynnaM, He Ha,lleJleHHblM TeMH ~e npaBaMH, qTO H
HaIJ;HOHaJJbHble MeHbWHHCTBa. XOT5I H cnOCOOHblM HrpaTb Ka
KYIO-TO nOJlHTHqeCKYIO POJlb.
KYJlbTYPHa51 HHTepnpeTaIJ;H5I npaBa Ha HaIJ;HOHaJlbHOe
caMOOnpe,lleJleHHe OTTeH5IeT sa~HOCTb Mep. HanpaSJleHHblX Ha
3a~HTY KYJlbTypHOA, peJlHrH03HoA H 513blKOBOA H,lleHTHqHOCTH
MeHbWHHCTS. OTCIO,lla ~e CJle,llyeT, qTO MeHbWHHCTsaM ,llOJl~Ha
npe,llOCTaBJl5ITbC5I B03MO~HOCTb paBHonpaBHoro cocy~ecT
SaSaHH5I C HaIJ;HOHaJlbHblM OOJlbWHHCTBOM. "KOTopoe OOeCneqH
saJlO ObI COTpY,llHHqeCTBO Me~,lly TeMH H ,llpyrHMH, HO S TO ~e speM51 OOeCneqHBaJJO ObI OCOOble Hy~,llbI MeHbWHHCTS H coxpaH5IJlO HX CneIJ;H~HKy.''''8 B 3ToA CB5I3H ocoooe oecnoKoAcTSO Bbl3b1BaeT CJle,llylO~a51 ~opMyJlHpoBKa H3 YCTaBa ~OH. B KOTO
poA npaBo MeHbWHHCTB Ha HaIJ;HoHaJJbHoe caMOOnpe,lleJleHHe
101
CSH3bIsaeTCH C rpa)l(,llaHCKHMH, a He C KyJIbTypHbIMH npasaMH:
«8 MHpe, r,lle npasa JIHtlHOCTH nOJIytlaT nOJIHYIO 3aIllHTY.
MeHbWHHCTBa co speMeHeM HCtle3HYT, H "HaUHOHaJIbHaH npOOJIe
Man nepecraHeTyrpO)l(aTb Me)l(,llYHapO,llHoA: cTa6HJIbHOCT.I+>. XOTH
::ITO YTSep)l(,lleHHe SHeWHe 3aIllHillaeT npasa MeHbWHHCTS Ha
HaUHOHaJIbHOe CaMOOnpe,lleJIeHHe, Ha ,lleJIe OHO MO)l(eT ObITb
HCnOJIb30SaHO ,llJIH 060CHOSaHHH nOJIHTHKH aCCHMHJIHUHH. 4g
Tpe60saHHH KOpeHHbIX HapO,llOS npe,llOCTaSHTb HM
CneUHaJIbHbIe npasa CJIY)I(aT ,llOnOJIHHTeJIbHoA: nO,ll,llep)l(KOA:
KYJIbTYPHOA: HHTepnpeTaUHH npaBa Ha HaUHOHaJIbHOe
CaMOOnpe,lleJIeHHe. TaKHe Tpe60BaHHH He TOJIbKO B3bIsalOT K
cnpaSe,llJIHBOCTH H KOMneHcaUHH 3a npOWJIbIe 06H,llbI, HO TaK)I(e
OTpa)l(alOT )l(eJIaHHH ::ITHX HapO,llOB 06eCnetlHTb nOJIHoe Bblpa
)l(eHHe cBoeA: KYJIbTypHOA H,lleHTHtlHOCTH. QtleSH,llHO, tlTO MbI
TOJIbKO JaTeMHHM CYillHOCTb np06JIeMbI, eCJIH OY,lleM nepeBO
,llHTb 60Pb6y KopeHHbIX HapO,llOB H3 KYJIbTypHOA c«pepbI B
rpa)l(,llaHCKyID.
KYJIbTYPHaH HHTepnpeTaUHH ,llaHHHoro npaBa, OCHOBaH
HaH Ha pa3JIHtlHH npaBa Ha caMoynpaSJIeHHe OT npaBa Ha
HaUHOHaJIbHOe CaMoonpe,lleJIeHHe, npe,llOCTaBJIHeT HaHJIytlWHe
B03MO)l(HOCTH ,llJIH peweHHH HaUHOHaJIbHbIX npOOJIeM CJIe
,llYlOillero CTOJIeTHH.
102
DpHMeqaHH.R
1 A. Margalit, 1. Raz. "National Self-Determination". Journal of
Philosophy. 1990,87, p. 440.
2 Y. Dinstein. "Collective Human Rights of Peoples and Minorities".
International and Comparative Law Quarterly, 1976,25, p. 102.
3 E.H. Carr et al. Nationalism, A Report by a Study Group of
Members of the Royal Institute of International Affairs, Oxford
University Press, Oxsford, 1939, p. xvn.
4 S. Weil. The Needs for Roots. London. Routlege and Kegan Paul.
1952, p. 95.
5 K. Deutsch. Nationalism and Its Alternatives. New York, Basic
Books, 1969, p. 19.
6 F. Hertz. Nationality in History and Politics. London. Routlege
and Kegan, Paul. 1944, p. 7.
7 TaM )l(e, CTp. 3.
8 K. Dyson. The State Tradition in Western Europe. Oxford. Martin
Robertson. 1980, p. 591.
9 TeppHTopHH, pa3YMeeTCH. MO)l(eT paCCMaTpHBaTbCH KaK
O,llHH H3 JIeMeHTOB, KOTopbIe onpe,lleJIHIOT nOHHTHe "HaUHH". Ho
npH TOM ,llJIH «POpMHpOBaHHH HaUHH He 06H3aTeJIbHO, tlTOObl
rpaHHUbl TeppHTopHH ObIJIH tleTKO onpe,lleJIeHbl H npH3HaHbI.
B CJIYtlae C03,llaHHH rOCY,llapCTBa onpe,lleJIeHHe rpaHHU ero COBepweHHO HeoOXO,llHMO.
10 A.P. D'Entreves. "The State". Dictionary of the History of Ideas.
1967, p. 318.
11 H. Seton-Watson. Nation and States. London. Methuen. 1977, p. 1.
12 C. Geertz. The Interpretation of Cultures. New York. Basic
Books. 1973, p. 315.
13 M.G. Forsyth. "State". Blackwell Encyclopedia of Political
Thought. Oxford. Blackwell. 1987, p. 506.
14 R. Sureda. The Evolution of the Right of Self-Determination.
Leidem. A.W. Sijthoff. 1973, p. 17.
15 Y )l(eHIllHH TOr,lla He 6blJIO H3fSHpaTeJIbHOrO npaBa.
HO npe,llnOJIaraJIOCb. tlTO OHH, KaK tlaCTb HaUHOHaJIbHOrO
coofSIlleCTBa, HX KOCBeHHO npe,llCTaBJIHIOT OTUbI HJIH MY)I(bH.
16 H. Kohn. American Nationalism. New York. Collier Books.
1966, p. 326.
17 E. Kedourie. Nationalism. London. Hutchinson. 1985, p. 14.
103
18 A. Smith. The Ethnic Origin of Nations. Oxford. Blackwell.
1986, p. 129.
19 G. Hegel. Hegel's Philosophy of Right. Oxford. Oxford
University Press. 1967. p. 279.
20 Burke B COOpHHlKe, CTp. 218.
23 A. Smith. [{HT. pall., CTp. XXIV.
24 TaM >Ke, cTp. XXX.
25 AH.llepCOH npHBO.llHT Qpe3BblQaAHO HHTepeCHbie npHMepbl
Toro, I