Post on 13-May-2019
ITP730 – Thermal Processing of Foods_____________________________________________
1
_____________________________________________phariyadi.staff.ipb.ac.id
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
Alternative Processing Technology Eqivalent to Thermal Processing
Purwiyatno Hariyadi1, 2)
1 Southeast Asian Food and Agricultural Science and Technology (SEAFAST) Center, Bogor Agricultural University ;
2 Department of Food Science and Technology, Faculty of Agricultural Engineering and Technology, Bogor Agricultural University
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
• Electromagnetic wave f = c/where
c = speed of light (3 x 1010 cm/sec, at vacuum). f = frequency (sec-1) = Wave length (cm)
The Electromagnetic Spectrum
• Energy (E) = hf h = Plank’s Constant (6.626 x 10-27 ergs sec)
Radiation?
ITP730 – Thermal Processing of Foods_____________________________________________
2
_____________________________________________phariyadi.staff.ipb.ac.id
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
105cm-1 1010cm-1 1015cm-1 1020cm-1
Frequency, f
3x105cm= 3 km 3 cm 3um
3x102cm= 3 m 3nm3Å
Wave Length,
The Electromagnetic Spectrum f = c/Radiation?
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
105cm-1 1010cm-1 1015cm-1 1020cm-1
Frequency, f
3x105cm= 3 km 3 cm 3um
3x102cm= 3 m 3nm3Å
Wave Length,
4x10-10eV 4x10-5eV 4eV 4KeV 4MeV
Energy, E
Radio waves Infrared
VisibleLight
X-Rays and -Rays
UV
Microwaves
The Electromagnetic Spectrum f = c/Radiation?
ITP730 – Thermal Processing of Foods_____________________________________________
3
_____________________________________________phariyadi.staff.ipb.ac.id
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
IonizingRadiation=Irradiation
105cm-1 1010cm-1 1015cm-1 1020cm-1
Frequency, f
3x105cm= 3 km 3 cm 3um
3x102cm= 3 m 3nm3Å
Wave Length,
4x10-10eV 4x10-5eV 4eV 4KeV 4MeV
Energy, E
Radio waves Infrared
VisibleLight
X-Rays and -Rays
UV
Microwaves
The Electromagnetic Spectrum
Food Irradiation?
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
IonizingRadiation=IrradiationSources of Irradiation
4x10-10eV 4x10-5eV 4eV 4KeV 4MeV
Energy, E
Radio waves Infrared
VisibleLight
X-Rays and -Rays
UV
• Cobalt 60 - 1.33 MeV • Cesium 137 - 662 keV • Electron accelerators operated at 10 MeV or less • X-ray generators operated at 7.5 MeV or less
Microwaves
Food Irradiation?
ITP730 – Thermal Processing of Foods_____________________________________________
4
_____________________________________________phariyadi.staff.ipb.ac.id
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
Irradiation doses are measured in gray (Gy)
• Absorbed dose [Gy] = joule/kg absorbed energy
• Applied dose = energy source x time exposed
• Absorbed dose = f(applied dose and other factors), determenined by dosimetry
Dose of Irradiation
Food Irradiation?
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
Food Irradiation?
ITP730 – Thermal Processing of Foods_____________________________________________
5
_____________________________________________phariyadi.staff.ipb.ac.id
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
Food Irradiation?
High-dose irradiation
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
D10 : Dosis irradiasi yang menyebabkan penguranganjumlah mikroba dgn faktor 10 D10 dose
•Kinetics of microbial inactivation
1.0
0.5
0.1
0.05
0.01
Fra
ksi o
rgan
ism
a yg
mas
ih b
erta
han
Dosis (kGy)
D10,yeast
D10
bakteri
Food Irradiation?
ITP730 – Thermal Processing of Foods_____________________________________________
6
_____________________________________________phariyadi.staff.ipb.ac.id
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
•Kinetics of microbial inactivationFood Irradiation?
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
•Kinetics of microbial inactivationFood Irradiation?
ITP730 – Thermal Processing of Foods_____________________________________________
7
_____________________________________________phariyadi.staff.ipb.ac.id
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
Food Irradiation?
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
Food Irradiation?
ITP730 – Thermal Processing of Foods_____________________________________________
8
_____________________________________________phariyadi.staff.ipb.ac.id
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
•Kinetics of microbial inactivationFood Irradiation?
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
-0.6
-0.5
-0.4
-0.3
-0.2
-0.1
0.0
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
Waktu iradiasi (jam)
Ln
[C /
C a
wa
l]
1,30 kGy/jam 3,17 kGy/jam 5,71 kGy/jam 8,82 kGy/jam
-1.6
-1.4
-1.2
-1.0
-0.8
-0.6
-0.4
-0.2
0.0
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60
Waktu iradiasi (jam)
Ln
[AA
T /
AA
T a
wa
l]
1,30 kGy/jam 3,17 kGy/jam 5,71 kGy/jam 8,82 kGy/jam
(a) Phytic Acid (b) Antitripsin activity
(a) (b)
Change of anti-nutrition compound in soybean during Irradiation at certain dose-rate
Tanhindarto, R.P, Hariyadi.P, Purnomo, E.H, and Irawati, Z. 2013. Effect of gamma irradiation at different dose-rate on the anti-nutritional compounds (phytic acid and anti-trypsin) and color of soybean (Glycine max L.))
Food Irradiation?• Kinetics of Quality Changes
ITP730 – Thermal Processing of Foods_____________________________________________
9
_____________________________________________phariyadi.staff.ipb.ac.id
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
8
10
12
14
16
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35
Dosis radiasi (kGy)
Asa
m fi
tat (
mg
/g)
1,30 kGy/jam 3,17 kGy/jam 5,71 kGy/jam 8,82 kGy/jam
5
10
15
20
25
30
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 65 70 75 80
Dosis radiasi (kGy)
AA
T (
mg
/g)
1,30 kGy/jam 3,17 kGy/jam 5,71 kGy/jam 8,82 kGy/jam
(a) (b)
Change of anti-nutrition compound in soybean as affacted irradition dose at different dose-rate
(a) Phytic Acid (b) Antitripsin activity
Tanhindarto, R.P, Hariyadi.P, Purnomo, E.H, and Irawati, Z. 2013. Effect of gamma irradiation at different dose-rate on the anti-nutritional compounds (phytic acid and anti-trypsin) and color of soybean (Glycine max L.))
Food Irradiation?• Kinetics of Quality Changes
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
-0.09
-0.07
-0.05
-0.03
-0.01 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60
Waktu iradiasi (jam)
Ln
[nila
i L /
nila
i L a
wal
1,30 kGy/jam 3,17 kGy/jam 5,71kGy/jam 8,82 kGy/jam
-0.06
-0.05
-0.04
-0.03
-0.02
-0.010 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60
Waktu iradiasi (jam)
Ln
[nila
i L /
nila
i L a
wal
1,30 kGy/jam 3,17 kGy/jam 5,71kGy/jam 8,82 kGy/jam
(a) (b)
Change of color (brightness) of soybean and soybean flour during Irradiation at different dose-rate
(a) Soybean grain (b) Soybean flour
Tanhindarto, R.P, Hariyadi.P, Purnomo, E.H, and Irawati, Z. 2013. Effect of gamma irradiation at different dose-rate on the anti-nutritional compounds (phytic acid and anti-trypsin) and color of soybean (Glycine max L.))
Food Irradiation?• Kinetics of Quality Changes
ITP730 – Thermal Processing of Foods_____________________________________________
10
_____________________________________________phariyadi.staff.ipb.ac.id
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
50.5
51.5
52.5
53.5
54.5
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 65 70 75
Dosis radiasi (kGy)
Wa
rna
(nila
i L)
8,82 kGy/jam 5,71 kGy/jam 3,17 kGy/jam 1,30 kGy/jam
79
80
81
82
83
84
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 65 70 75
Dosis radiasi (kGy)
Wa
rna
(n
ilai L
)
8,82 kGy/jam 5,71 kGy/jam 3,17 kGy/jam 1,30 kGy/jam
(a) (b)
Change of color (brightness) of soybean and soybean flour as affacted irradition dose at different dose-rate
(a) Soybean grain (b) Soybean flour
Tanhindarto, R.P, Hariyadi.P, Purnomo, E.H, and Irawati, Z. 2013. Effect of gamma irradiation at different dose-rate on the anti-nutritional compounds (phytic acid and anti-trypsin) and color of soybean (Glycine max L.))
Food Irradiation?• Kinetics of Quality Changes
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
http://www.fda.gov/Food/ScienceResearch/ResearchAreas/SafePracticesforFoodProcesses/ucm100158.htm
ITP730 – Thermal Processing of Foods_____________________________________________
11
_____________________________________________phariyadi.staff.ipb.ac.id
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
Emerging Processing Technologies• Microwave and Radio Frequency
• Ohmic and Inductive Heating
• High Pressure Processing
• Pulsed Electric Field
• High Voltage Arc Discharge
• Pulsed Light
• Ultraviolet Light
• Ultrasound
• X-Rays
http://www.fda.gov/Food/ScienceResearch/ResearchAreas/SafePracticesforFoodProcesses/ucm100158.htm
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
FDA Questions Technology
Ohmic Heating Microwave
Process Description Well described Well described
Mechanism of Activation Well described Well described
Critical Factors and Quantification
Well describedHard to predict cold zone
Well describedHard to predict cold zone
Process deviations As in conventional thermal processing
As in conventional thermal processing
Organizms of concern As in conventional thermal processing
As in conventional thermal processing
Indicator organizms As in conventional thermal processing
As in conventional thermal processing
Main reseacrh need Prediction of cold zone Prediction of cold zoneand Uniformity of heating
Status of the Report on Technologies (1)
ITP730 – Thermal Processing of Foods_____________________________________________
12
_____________________________________________phariyadi.staff.ipb.ac.id
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
FDA Questions Technology
Ultra Sound High Pressure
Process Description Well described Well described
Mechanism of Activation Described Well described
Critical Factors and Quantification
Suggested Well describedProposed Models
Process deviations Not identified1 Well described
Organizms of concern Not identified1 Identified
Indicator organizms Not identified2 Suggested
Main reseacrh need Multiple combination with other technologies
Validation kineticsInfluence of synergistic processing conditions
1. Lack of critical process factors quantification does not permit suggested responses to process deviations
2. Must identify pathogen of concern before indicators are finalized
Status of the Report on Technologies (2)
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
dipantulkan oleh metal diserap (diubah menjadi panas) oleh dielektrik : internal heating
(Molecular friction).
PEMANASAN DIELEKTRIK (& GEL MIKRO)
Generator(Oscilator)
+/-
+/-
Bahanpangan
H H
H H
O
O
-
++++
-
++
“Perub.Orientasipolarisasi”
Ionicdisplacement
ITP730 – Thermal Processing of Foods_____________________________________________
13
_____________________________________________phariyadi.staff.ipb.ac.id
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
dipantulkan oleh metal diserap (diubah menjadi panas) oleh dielektrik : internal heating
(Molecular friction).
Generator(Oscilator)
+/-
+/-
Bahanpangan
PEMANASAN DIELEKTRIK (& GEL MIKRO)
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
PEMANASAN OHMIC
S PowerSupply
BAHAN
elektroda
P : laju jumlah panas yang diproduksi per satuan volume (W.m-3)
E : kekuatan medan listrik (Volt cm-1)ke : konduktivitas listrik (ohm-1/m, S/m)I : densitas arus listrik (amps/m2)R : tahanan listrik (ohm-1)
P = I2R
- kecepatan pemanasan tergantung pada nilai ke bahan pangan- ke bahan pangan =f(kadar air, garam ionik dan asam)- ke bahan pangan cair >> ke bahan padat- minyak dan lemak mempunyai nilai ke sangat rendah
P = I2ke-1
I = keEL-1
ITP730 – Thermal Processing of Foods_____________________________________________
14
_____________________________________________phariyadi.staff.ipb.ac.id
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
r
Arah perambatan panas, Q
÷
22
0 R
r1
4k
PrTT
2
PrQ(r)
Kenaikan suhu maksimum
Kenaikan suhu rata-rata
4k
PRTT
2
omax
8k
PRTT
2
0
k = konduktivitas panas
PEMANASAN OHMIC
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
Perbandingan: Pemanasan Gel Mikro vs. Ohmic
Kriteria Pemanasan PemanasanGel Mikro Ohmic
Konduktivitas listrik 0.25-4 0.005-1.2(siemen/m)
Generasi Panas untukmedan listrik 20 V/m 1-16 0.02-5(W/cm3)
Kenaikan suhu 0.25-4* 0.004-1.2*(oC/sec)
* kenaikan suhu di permukaan kaleng pada proses pemanasanretort adalah sekitar 0.2oC/sec
ITP730 – Thermal Processing of Foods_____________________________________________
15
_____________________________________________phariyadi.staff.ipb.ac.id
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
Mirip dengan pemanasan gel. Mikro :
konversi enegi listrik menjadi energi panas
Penetrasi panas/daya penetrasi : tidak terbatas
Suhu dalam bahan pangan merata (T 0)
Tidak perlu “pengadukan”
Cocok untuk memanaskan bahan pangan cair dgn
partikulat : sop dll.
Perbandingan: Pemanasan Gel Mikro vs. Ohmic
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
(Ultra) high pressure processing
High Hydrostatic Pressure
ITP730 – Thermal Processing of Foods_____________________________________________
16
_____________________________________________phariyadi.staff.ipb.ac.id
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
Historical Timeline
1895 H. Royer uses high pressure to kill bacteria.
1899 Bert H. Hite at the West Virginia Agricultural Experimental Station examined pressure effects on milk, meat, fruits and vegetables.
1914 P. W. Bridgman coagulated egg albumen under high pressure.
1990 First commercial products like fruit juices, jams, fruit toppings and tenderized meats introduced in Japan.
1995 Orange juice commercialized in France.
1997 Market introduction of guacamole in the US and sliced cooked ham in Spain.
1999 Oysters introduced in the US.
2000 Range of salsas launched in the US market.
High Hydrostatic Pressure
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
High Pressure can kill microorganisms by interrupting with their cellular function without the use of heat that can damage the taste, texture, and nutritional value of the food.
High Hydrostatic Pressure
ITP730 – Thermal Processing of Foods_____________________________________________
17
_____________________________________________phariyadi.staff.ipb.ac.id
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
High Hydrostatic Pressure
• Use uncompresable packaging material
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
Styrofoam cup subjected to 40,000 psi, and fruit pack (with juice) subjected to 80,000 psi.
High Hydrostatic Pressure
• Use uncompresable packaging material
• Use water/liquid for medium distribute pressure!
ITP730 – Thermal Processing of Foods_____________________________________________
18
_____________________________________________phariyadi.staff.ipb.ac.id
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
High Hydrostatic Pressure
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
High Hydrostatic Pressure
ITP730 – Thermal Processing of Foods_____________________________________________
19
_____________________________________________phariyadi.staff.ipb.ac.id
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
High Hydrostatic Pressure
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
High Hydrostatic Pressure
ITP730 – Thermal Processing of Foods_____________________________________________
20
_____________________________________________phariyadi.staff.ipb.ac.id
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
Food safetyElimination of pathogens: e.g. Listeria in meat products, Salmonella in eggs and poultry, Vibrio in oysters
Hypotheses for vegetative cell inactivation...
- denaturation of proteins and enzymes
- damage of DNA replication & transcription
- solidification of membrane (phospho)lipids
- breakage of bio-membranes (cell leakage)
Spores are very resistant to pressure, but can be destroyed by combining pressure with elevated temperatures
Applications for High Pressure Processing are found in the areas of...
High Hydrostatic Pressure
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
• Juice tests have shown that food pathogens such as salmonella and E.coli 0157:H7 can be effectively destroyed without changing the fruit juice's fresh, natural characteristics.
• A pressure exposure of 80,000 psi for 30 seconds can achieve a 3-5 log reduction of all of the pathogens of concern in fresh juice
Fruit Juice treated with HHP
High Hydrostatic PressureApplications for High Pressure Processing are found in the areas of...
ITP730 – Thermal Processing of Foods_____________________________________________
21
_____________________________________________phariyadi.staff.ipb.ac.id
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
• Another example of food safety is the destruction of Vibrio bacteria in raw oysters without destroying the raw feel and taste of the oyster.
• A pressure of 200 to 300 MPa for 5 to 15 minutes at 25C inactivated : · Vibrio parahaemolyticus ATCC 17803, · Vibrio vulnificus ATCC 27562, · Vibrio choleare ATCC 14035, · Vibrio choleare non-O:1 ATCC 14547, · Vibrio hollisae ATCC 33564· Vibrio mimicus ATCC 33653(from: "D. Berlin, D. Herson, D. Hicks, and D. Hoover; Applied and Environmental Microbiology, June 1999“)
Oyster treated by HHP
High Hydrostatic PressureApplications for High Pressure Processing are found in the areas of...
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
High Hydrostatic PressureApplications for High Pressure Processing are found in the areas of...
Oyster treated by HHP
Pressure shucked raw clams. Pressure not only destroys the vibrio family of bacteria that can be found in shellfish, but also detaches the meat from the shell, saving labor and increasingproduction efficiency.
ITP730 – Thermal Processing of Foods_____________________________________________
22
_____________________________________________phariyadi.staff.ipb.ac.id
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
Guacamole & Salsas
Avomex (Keller, TX)
Commercial High-Pressure Processed products marketed in Japan, Europe and the United States
High Hydrostatic Pressure
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
Commercial High-Pressure Processed products marketed in Japan, Europe and the United States
High Hydrostatic Pressure
ITP730 – Thermal Processing of Foods_____________________________________________
23
_____________________________________________phariyadi.staff.ipb.ac.id
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
Jams & Fruit Toppings
(Japan)
High Hydrostatic Pressure
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
ULTI / PAMPRYL (Groupe PERNOD-RICARD) -France freshey squeezed fruit juice Fresh pressed
ESPUNA - Spain –sliced cooked ham
Examples of products commercialised in Europe and treated on HYPERBAR installations supplied by ACB
High Hydrostatic Pressure
ITP730 – Thermal Processing of Foods_____________________________________________
24
_____________________________________________phariyadi.staff.ipb.ac.id
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
Examples of Food products in the USA
High Hydrostatic Pressure
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
Examples of Food products in the USA
High Hydrostatic Pressure
ITP730 – Thermal Processing of Foods_____________________________________________
25
_____________________________________________phariyadi.staff.ipb.ac.id
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
Figure. Change in inactivation of Zygosaccharomyces bailii with pressure.
Note that 345 MPa = 50,000 psi. (Enrique Palou, GRA, BSysE Dept., WSU)
Effect of pressure is very similar to the effect of temperature in thermal processes
High Hydrostatic Pressure
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
What happens to foods during HPP?
ITP730 – Thermal Processing of Foods_____________________________________________
26
_____________________________________________phariyadi.staff.ipb.ac.id
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
What happens to foods during HPP?
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
2009
FDA accepted an industrial petition forhigh pressure sterilization of a low‐acid food
• Only thermal lethality was considered• No credit for for pressure lethal effect was
considered
Thermally-assisted high-pressure lifts quality of shelf-stable foods
High Hydrostatic Pressure
ITP730 – Thermal Processing of Foods_____________________________________________
27
_____________________________________________phariyadi.staff.ipb.ac.id
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
Pressure(Mpa)
Thermally-assisted high-pressure lifts quality of shelf-stable foods
High Hydrostatic Pressure
Purwiyatno Hariyadiphariyadi@ipb.ac.idITP730
High Hydrostatic Pressure