CatholicsinAmerica

Page1CatholicsinAmerica

Copyright2016,NCHE

Source1

WhoHadReligiousFreedomintheFoundingEra?

Part1:ColonizationandCatholicismInAmerica’s“CreationStory,”thePilgrimscametothenewworldforreligiousfreedom.Othersfollowedorspreadoutfromtheoriginalsettlementandestablishedmorecolonieswherecolonistscouldfreelypracticetheirreligions.EventuallythirteencoloniesrevoltedagainstpayingtaxesleviedbyaParliamentinwhichtheyhadnorepresentatives.Afterdeclaringandwinningtheirindependence,theyformedagovernmentbasedonaConstitutionthatrequiresnoreligioustestforholdingofficeandaddedaBillofRightsthatguaranteesreligiousfreedom.Allofthestatementsabovearetrue,butasinmostshortstories,somuchisleftoutthatthereaderorlistenercanmakeaseriesofincorrectinferences.Ifweadddetailstothisnarrative,specificallyaboutCatholicsinAmerica,wegetaratherdifferentstory.AmericancolonizationinwhatwouldbecometheNewEnglandStates,beginningwiththearrivalofthePuritansin1620,wastheresultofforcesunleashedin1517intheProtestantReformation.Formorethanacenturythisreligiousmovementinvolvedpersecutors,persecuted,andmartyrsandanever-increasingnumberofreligiousgroups.Somehistoriansentitlethisera“TheAgeofFaith”becausereligiousfeelingsweresostrongthatpeoplesacrificedandweresacrificedfortheirreligiousbeliefs.Inthis“AgeofFaith”therecouldbenocompromisingonone’sreligiousbeliefs.Todosocompromisedyourlife,yourdeath,andyoureternity.TheProtestantReformationwasaprotestagainsttheCatholicChurch.ThecolonistswhocametoBritishNorthAmericawereProtestants,peoplewhoseoriginswereinthisprotest.Someofthethirteencoloniesweresettledbydissenters—peoplewhorefusedtoregardCatholicsasareligiouspeopleworthyofnote.TheCatholicChurchwasviewedasafraudulentfaith.Itwaslabeled“theWhore”becauseithadprostituteditselfbytakingmoneyfrombelieversbuyingsalvation.ItsmemberswereviewedasnotChristiansbutPapists,because,asthereasoningwent,theyhadsubstitutedloyaltyandobediencetothePopeforloyaltyandobediencetoGod.ThesebeliefswerefirmlyheldbytheProtestantswhosettledAmerica.CatholicswerenotallowedtovoteorholdofficeinmostoftheoriginalEnglishcolonies.ThePuritanscameforreligiousfreedomforthemselves.Theyestablishedatheocracyrunof,by,andforPuritans.TheybelievedthatthepresenceofCatholics,aswellasAnglicansandQuakers,wouldtaintthepurityoftheirreligion.WiththeexceptionofRhodeIsland,allthecolonieshadestablishedchurchesthatwereProtestant.InNewEnglandtheestablishedchurchwasthePuritan,soontobecalltheCongregational.Inothercoloniestheestablished

CatholicsinAmerica

Page2CatholicsinAmerica

Copyright2016,NCHE

Source1(continued)

churchwasusuallytheAnglicanChurch(ChurchofEngland).AlldiscriminatedblatantlyagainstCatholics.OnlythreeofthethirteencoloniesallowedCatholicstovote.MostoftheNewEnglandcoloniesandtheCarolinasprohibitedCatholicsfromholdingoffice;Virginiawouldhavepriestsarrestedforenteringthecolony;CatholicschoolswerebannedinallcoloniesexceptPennsylvania.Marylandstartedoutastheexception.EstablishedbyanEnglishCatholic,CecilCalvert(LordBaltimore),itwastobeahaven,orsafeplace,foraCatholicminoritywithprotectionsfromtheProtestantmajorityguaranteedbyTheActConcerningReligion,passedbytheMarylandlegislaturein1649.ButMarylandsoonbecameaclassicexampleofthe“tyrannyofthemajority.”WhenProtestantsoutnumberedCatholicsthirty-to-one,lawswerepassedthatpreventedCatholicsfrominheritingorpurchasingland,imprisonedpriestsforlife,prohibitedCatholicworship,anddeniedCatholicstherighttovote.In1715theMarylandlegislaturerequiredchildrenofaProtestantfatherandaCatholicmothertobetakenawayfromthemotherifthefatherdied.OfficeholdershadtoswearallegiancetotheChurchofEngland.SomuchforasafehavenforCatholics.PhiladelphiahadtheonlyCatholicChurchthatwasprotectedbyacolonialgovernmentinallthecolonies.ItwasherethatJohnAdamsattendedaCatholicmassatSt.Mary’sChurchwhileamemberoftheContinentalCongress.HisattendancewasnotindicativeoftolerationfortheCatholicfaith,butaresultofhisreligiouscuriosity.In1765hehadwrittenthatthe“whoreofBabylon”hadfalselygrabbedthe“keystoheaven”andsurvivedbykeepingsubjectsin“sordidignoranceandstaringtimidity.”Afterattendingmassin1774hedescribedhisimpressionstohiswife,Abigail:

“Thepoorwretchesfingeringtheirbeads,chantingLatin,notawordofwhichtheyunderstood.TheirholyWater—theirCrossingthemselvesperpetually—theirBowingtotheNameofJesus,wherevertheyhearit—theirBowings,andKneelings,andGenuflectionsbeforetheAltar….ButhowshallIdescribethePictureofourSaviourinaFrameofMarbleovertheAltaratfullLengthupontheCross,intheAgonies,andtheBlooddroppingandstreamingfromhisWounds...HereiseverythingwhichcanlayholdoftheEye,Ear,andImagination.EveryThingwhichcancharmandbewitchthesimpleandignorant.”

JohnAdams,likehiscousinSamuel,wasrearedasaPuritan.PuritanshadrevoltedagainsttheAnglicanChurchbecauseitwastoomuchliketheCatholic.ToPuritans,Catholicismwastyranny;itwasanenemytoright-thinkingProtestantsandtodemocracyaswell.

CatholicsinAmerica

Page3CatholicsinAmerica

Copyright2016,NCHE

Source1(continued)Part2:TheAmericanRevolutionandAnti-CatholicSentimentBythetimeoftheAmericanRevolution,therewereawidevarietyofProtestantchurchesinthecolonies—Presbyterians,Lutherans,Mennonites,Moravians,Baptists,Methodists,Quakers.Colonistscelebrated“PopeDay,”anannualfestivalinwhicheffigiesofthePopewereburnedandspeechesmadeandnewspaperarticleswrittenattestingtotheeviloftheCatholicChurch.WhiletheAmerican“creationstory”typicallyfocusesoneconomicandpoliticalcausesfortheAmericanRevolution,therewereconsumingreligiousissuesaswell.LeadersoftheRevolutionusedreligiouslanguageandfearofBritishmeddlinginthereligiouspracticesinAmericatoarousethecommonpeople.SamAdamsisaprimeexample.IntheBostonGazetteofApril11,1768,Adams,writingas“APuritan,”portrayedthethreatofCatholicismbeingimposedonAmericaasworseeventhantheStampAct.Hewrote:

muchmoreistobedreadedfromthegrowthofPOPERYinAmerica,thanfromStampActsoranyotherActsdestructiveofmen’scivilrights:Nay,IcouldnothelpfancyingthattheStamp-Actitselfwascontrivedonlytoinurethepeopletothehabitofcontemplatingthemselvesastheslavesofmen;andthetransitionfromthencetoasubjectiontoSatan,ismightyeasy.”

InaletterSamAdamswroteonJanuary12,1768,hewroteof“theconqueredprovinceofCanada,wheretheexerciseoftheRomishreligion,sodestructivetocivilsociety,isallowed.”FearofhavingtheCatholicreligionimposedontheAmericancoloniesintensifiedwhenParliamentpassedtheQuebecActin1774.HavingtakencontrolofCanadafromCatholicFranceintheTreatyofParisof1763attheendoftheFrenchandIndianWar,ParliamentdecidedtoaccordreligiousfreedomtotheCatholicslivinginQuebec,allowingtheCatholicChurchtoremaintheestablishedchurch.WhilethismayhaveappearedtobeanactofreligioustolerationbytheAnglicanParliament,totheAmericancolonistsitappearedasyetanotherthreattotheirliberties.InSeptember1774,SamAdams’closefriendDr.JosephWarren,wroteTheSuffolkResolves.TheywerequicklycarriedtoPhiladelphiabyPaulRevereandpresentedtotheContinentalCongress:

Great-Britain,whichofoldpersecuted,scourged,andexiledourfugitiveparentsfromtheirnativeshores,nowpursuesus,theirguiltlesschildren,withunrelentingseverity...ItisanindispensabledutywhichweowetoGod,ourcountry,ourselvesandposterity,byalllawfulwaysandmeansinourpowertomaintain,defend,andpreservethosecivilandreligiousrightsandliberties,for

CatholicsinAmerica

Page4CatholicsinAmerica

Copyright2016,NCHE

whichmanyofourfathersfought,bledanddied,andtohandthemdownentiretofuturegenerations.

Source1(continued)MakingreferencetotheQuebecAct,TheSuffolkResolvescontinued:

thelateactofparliamentforestablishingtheRomanCatholicreligionandtheFrenchlawsinthatextensivecountry,nowcalledCanada,isdangerousinanextremedegreetotheProtestantreligionandtothecivilrightsandlibertiesofallAmerica;and,therefore,asmenandProtestantChristians,weareindispensablyobligedtotakeallpropermeasuresforoursecurity.

TheSuffolkResolveswereapprovedandpublishedbytheContinentalCongress.TherewasnoseriousevidencethattheQuebecActposedarealdangertotheAmericancolonies,butrevolutionsarebuiltonemotion,perhapsmoresothanonreason.Thecolonists,intheirdistrustofKingandParliament,believedthatEnglandwouldusereligionasaninstrumentoftyranny.TheFirstContinentalCongresschargedthattheQuebecActwouldcauseCanadianCatholics“toactwithhostilityagainstthefreeProtestantcolonies,wheneverawickedMinistryshallchoosetodirectthem.”HatredandfearofCatholicswassowidespreadthatRogerShermanandothermembersoftheContinentalCongresswantedtoprohibitCatholicsfromservingintheContinentalarmy.ThePennsylvaniaGazettesaidthattheQuebecActwouldallow“thesedogsofHell”to“erecttheirHeadsandtriumphwithinourBorders.”TheBostonEveningPostwrotethattheactwas“fortheexecutionofthishellishplan”toorganizefourthousandCanadianCatholicsforanattackonAmerica.InRhodeIsland,everysingleissueoftheNewportMercuryfromOctober1,1774toMarch20,1775,containedatleastoneattackontheCatholicreligionoftheCanadians.Protestantclergyfannedtheflames.AlexanderHamiltonjudgedtheQuebecActadiabolicalthreat,asking,“DoesnotyourbloodruncoldtothinkthatanEnglishParliamentshouldpassanActfortheestablishmentofarbitrarypowerandPoperyinsuchanextensivecountry?Yourlives,yourproperty,yourreligionareallatstake.”OnOctober21,1774,theContinentalCongresssentanappeal“tothePeopleofGreatBritain,”expressingshockthatParliamentwouldpromoteareligionthat“disbursedimpiety,bigotry,persecution,murderandrebellionsthrougheverypartoftheworld.”OnFriday,October14,1774,SamAdamswasappointedtoathree-membercommitteetowritealettertoGeneralThomasGage.Theyweretoenumeratetheviolationsoftherightsofthecolonies.AmongthegrievanceslistedwastheQuebecAct,which,thereportsaid,was“notonlyunjusttothepeopleinthatProvince,butdangeroustotheinterestsoftheProtestantreligionandoftheseColonies,andoughttoberepealed.”InapetitionsentbyCongressonOctober26forBenjaminFranklintopresenttoKingGeorgeIII,AmericanscomplainedoftheQuebecAct’s“establishinganabsolutegovernmentandtheRomanCatholickreligionthroughoutthosevastregions,thatborderonthewesterlyandnortherlyboundariesof

CatholicsinAmerica

Page5CatholicsinAmerica

Copyright2016,NCHE

thefreeprotestantEnglishsettlements.”Thecolonistswereconvincedthatpoliticalandreligiouslibertywereconnected.

Source1(continued)Therevolutionaries’scruplesagainsthavinganestablishedCatholicChurchontheirborderdidnotpreventthemfromsendingBenjaminFranklintoFrancetoobtainaidandtrytogainatreatyofalliancewithCatholicFrance.AftertheAmericanvictoryatSaratogain1777,FranklinsucceededinsigningatreatyofalliancewithhisCatholicMajesty,LouisXVI.GeneralBenedictArnoldwastheunsungherooftheAmericanvictoryatSaratoga,butweknowArnoldbestforbeingtheforemosttraitortothePatriotcause.ArnoldjustifiedhistreasonasalegitimateresponsetotheprostitutionoftheAmericancausebytakingmoneyfromandsigninganalliancewithCatholicFrance!JustastheexigenciesofwarresultedinacceptanceofaidfromaCatholiccountry,sotheneedforsoldiersmotivatedGeneralGeorgeWashingtontodemandtolerancetowardCatholicsintheContinentalArmy.Hescoldedtroopscelebrating“PopeDay”inCambridge,Massachusetts,callingita“ridiculousandchildishcustom.”Possiblyasaresultofhisexample,thepracticeofburningeffigiesofthePopeandnewspaperattacksonCatholicsdecreased.WashingtonalsodiscouragedCatholic-bashing,seeingtheimportanceofnotantagonizingCatholicCanadiansonthecountry’snorthernborder.SomeGermanCatholicsbenefitedfromtheContinentalCongress’seffortstoenticeHessianmercenariestodesertfromtheBritisharmy.Theywereabletogaincitizenship,fiftyacresoflandANDreligiousfreedomiftheydidso.TheofferappliedtoallHessians,ProtestantorCatholic.Part3:CatholicsintheNewCountryTherewasoneCatholicdelegateintheContinentalCongress.CharlesCarrollsignedtheDeclarationofIndependenceandlaterwrote,“WhenIsignedtheDeclarationofIndependence,Ihadinview,notonlyourindependencefromEngland;butthetolerationofallsectsprofessingtheChristianreligion,andcommunicatingtothemallequalrights.”Carroll’shopeswerenotrealized.Asthestateswrotetheirconstitutions,onlyNewYorkandVirginiaallowedmentoserveinstategovernmentregardlessoftheirreligiousbeliefs.NewJersey,Vermont,NorthCarolina,Maryland,andGeorgiaretainedtheirbansonCatholicsholdingoffice.Manyofthestates,suchatConnecticutandMassachusetts,usedtaxestosupporttheestablishedchurch.TheConstitutiondidallowCatholicstoholdnationalofficebecause,intheonlyreferencetoreligionintheU.S.Constitution,therecouldbe“noreligious”testforofficeholding.In1791theBillofRightswasratifiedandbecamepartoftheConstitution.TheFirstAmendmentguaranteedfreedomofreligionbutthisguaranteedidnotapplytostategovernmentsuntil1940!IncasesdecidedbytheU.S.SupremeCourtin1940and1947itwasruledthattheFourteenthAmendmenttotheConstitution(1877)“incorporated”

CatholicsinAmerica

Page6CatholicsinAmerica

Copyright2016,NCHE

theguaranteeofreligiousfreedomasonetobeprotectedbythefederalgovernmentagainstviolationbystategovernments.

CatholicsinAmerica

Page7CatholicsinAmerica

Copyright2016,NCHE

Source1(continued)Part4:BeliefsoftheFounders

Intooldage,JohnAdamsstillbelievedthatCatholicismanddemocracywereincompatible.JohnAdamssharedhisthoughtswithJeffersonintwolettersoftheirretirementcorrespondence.JohnAdamstoThomasJefferson

QuincyJuly16,1814

...cabballisticalChristianitywhichisCatholicChristianity,andwhichhasprevailedfor1500Years,hasrec’d.amortalWoundofwhichtheMonstermustfinallydie;YetsostrongishisconstitutionthathemayendureforCenturiesbeforeheexpires....

JohnAdamstoThomasJefferson

Montezillo*February3d.1821

IhavelongbeendecidedinopinionthatafreegovernmentandtheRomanCatholickreligioncanneverexisttogetherinanynationorCountry,andconsequentlythatallprojectsforreconcilingtheminoldSpainornewareEutopian,PlatonickandChimerical.IhaveseensuchaprostrationandprostitutionofHumanNaturetothePriesthoodinoldSpainassettledmyjudgmentlongago.

PresidentWashington,ontheotherhand,expressedamoretolerantattitude.WhenAmericanCatholicswrotehimaskingfor“theequalrightsofcitizenship,asthepriceofourbloodspiltunderyoureyes,”Washingtonagreed,replying:“Asmankindbecomesmoreliberal,theywillbeapttoallowthatallthosewhoconductthemselvesworthymembersofthecommunityareequallyentitledtotheprotectionofcivilgovernment.”*In1819AdamsbeginsteasingJefferson,wholivedatMonticello[Italianfor“littlemountain”],bywritingfrom“MontezilloAliasthelittleHill.”

CatholicsinAmerica

Page8CatholicsinAmerica

Copyright2016,NCHE

Source:LesterJ.Cappon,ed.,TheAdams-JeffersonLetters

CatholicsinAmerica

Page9CatholicsinAmerica

Copyright2016,NCHE

Source2

CopiedbyPaulReverefortheRoyalAmericanMagazine,October1774.

©TrusteesoftheBritishMuseum.Usedwithpermission.

CatholicsinAmerica

Page10CatholicsinAmerica

Copyright2016,NCHE

Source3

UrsulineConventFire,Charlestown,MA,1834

Imagelocatedat:http://www.newenglandhistoricalsociety.com/know-nothing-party-takes-root-in-ashes-of-destroyed-charlestown-convent/

CatholicsinAmerica

Page11CatholicsinAmerica

Copyright2016,NCHE

Source4

AnAnti-CatholicpetitionfromNewYorknativiststotheU.S.Congress,1837TotheHonorabletheSenateandHouseofRepresentativesoftheUnitedStates,inCongressAssembled:“...TheeasyaccessofforeignerstotheelectivefranchiseintheUnitedStates,bythepresentlawsofnaturalization,andofforeignersofdoubtfulmoralsandhostilepoliticalprinciples,isasourceofdangertoourcivilandreligiousliberties,towhichyourMemorialistswouldhumblyandearnestlyinvitethespeedyattentionofCongress.”“...Ifwecherishcivilandreligiouslibertiesandesteemthemaboveallprice,wehavearighttodefendthemfromforeigninvasion;whetheritapproachbyopenwarfare,orinsidiouslybyobtainingtheprivilegeofcitizenship.”“...YourMemorialistsviewwithdeepconcernthegreatinfluxofRomanCatholicsintothiscountryfromthevariousnationsofEurope,andtheiradmissiontocitizenshipwhiletheyretaintheirprinciples,aseminentlythreateningourcivilandreligiousliberties.”“...Ourconstitutionhappilyallowsthefreetolerationofallreligions;itisforthistolerationthatwepleadagainstareligionwhichrefusesit.”“...YourMemorialists,unwillingtoencroachfurtheronyourpatience,earnestlypetitionyourhonorablebodytoinquirewhethertheprinciplesofRomanCatholics,asheldatpresentaswellasformerly,arenotpoliticalandhostiletocivilandreligiousliberty;andwhethertheirreligionisnotessentiallypolitical,requiringtheunionofChurchandState,andthesubjectionofthelattertotheformer;andwhetheritdoesnotrequireallegiancetothePopeofRome,holdingtheobligationtoobeyhim,asparamount....?”“...[petitionyourhonorablebodytoinquire]whetheranyamendmentofthelawsofnaturalizationcanmorefullysecureourfreeinstitutions,ourliberties,civilandreligious,againstthedangerofsubversionbyforeigninfluenceanddespotictyrannicalprinciples,evenunderthecloakofreligion.Allwhichisrespectfullysubmitted....” Ninety-sevensignaturesfollowed.NationalArchives,Washington,DC.

CatholicsinAmerica

Page12CatholicsinAmerica

Copyright2016,NCHE

Source5

Immigration,Politics,andthe“Know-Nothing”PartyItsoundslikeajoke,butthe“Know-Nothing”Partywasanythingbut.Americanswhoopposedcontinuedimmigration,particularlyimmigrationfromCatholiccountries,begantogatherinsecretsocietiestoopposeimmigration,immigrants,andCatholics.Whentheywereaskedfordetailsabouttheirgroups,theyresponded,“Iknownothing,”hencethenickname.TheburningoftheUrsulineConventinCharlestown,Massachusettsisnottheonlysuchactofviolence.InJuly1844therewereriotsinPhiladelphiainwhichNativistsfoughtIrishimmigrants,andtwoCatholicchurchesandaCatholicschoolwereburned.Atleasttwentypeoplewerekilledintheseriots.InNewYorkCityin1844,anti-Catholicmobsparadedthroughthestreets.TheArchbishopcalledontheIrishtodefendtheoriginalSt.Patrick’sCathedralonMottStreet.TheIrishwererumoredtobeheavilyarmedandthemobsdispersed.NoCatholicchurcheswereburnedinNewYork.ThenativistsemergedfromsecrecyandfoundedtheAmericanPartyin1849.TheyadvertisedtheidealAmerican,awhite,Anglo-Saxonyoungman.Theycontinuedthepressureofearlierpetitionerstochangethenaturalizationlawssothatitwouldtaketwenty-fiveyearstobecomeacitizen.AnAmericanPartydocumentstated:

theobjectofthisorganizationshallbetoprotecteveryAmericancitizeninthelegalandproperexerciseofallhiscivilandreligiousrightsandprivileges;toresisttheinsidious[evil]policyoftheChurchofRomeandallotherforeigninfluenceagainstourrepublicaninstitutionsinalllawfulways;toplaceinallofficesofhonor,trust,orprofit,inthegiftofthepeoplebyappointment,nonebutnaïvebornProtestantcitizensandtoprotect,preserve,andupholdtheUnionoftheseStatesandtheConstitutionofthesame.

TheAmericanPartyrancandidatesforofficein1854andhadsomesuccessinlocalelectionsinthenortheast.In1856formerpresidentMillardFillmoreranastheAmericanParty(Know-Nothing)candidateforpresident.HelostbadlytoJamesBuchanan.FillmorehadbeenaWhig.ManymembersoftheoldWhigpartyhadgravitatedtotheAmericanParty.OnenotableWhigwhodidnotjointhenativistswasAbrahamLincoln.Whenaskedin1855ifhehadbecomeaKnow-Nothing,LincolnofferedthefollowingreplyinanAugust24lettertoJoshuaSpeed:

IamnotaKnow-Nothing.Thatiscertain.HowcouldIbe?Howcananyonewhoabhorstheoppressionofnegroes,beinfavorofdegradingclassesofwhitepeople?Ourprogressindegeneracyappearstometobeprettyrapid.Asanation,webeganbydeclaringthat,“allmenarecreatedequal.”Wenowpracticallyreadit“allmenarecreatedequal,exceptNegroes.”WhentheKnow-Nothingsgetcontrol,itwillread,“allmenarecreatedequal,exceptNegroesandforeignersandCatholics.”Whenitcomestothis,Ishallpreferemigratingtosomecountrywheretheymakenopretenseoflovingliberty–toRussia,forinstance,wheredespotismcanbetakenpureandwithoutthebaseallowofhypocrisy.

CatholicsinAmerica

Page13CatholicsinAmerica

Copyright2016,NCHE

Source6

ThomasNast,Harper’sWeekly,May8,1875Source:http://www.harpweek.com/09cartoon/BrowseByDateCartoon.asp?Month=May&Date=8

CatholicsinAmerica

Page14CatholicsinAmerica

Copyright2016,NCHE

Source7

UlyssesS.GrantSpeechBeforetheConventionoftheSocietyoftheArmyoftheTennessee,

MeetinginDesMoines,Iowa.DeliveredSeptember30,1875

AsreprintedintheNewYorkTribune,October1,1875

Now,thecentennialyearofournationalexistence,Ibelieve,isagoodtimetobegintheworkofstrengtheningthefoundationsofthestructurecommencedbyourpatrioticforefathersonehundredyearsagoatLexington.Letusalllabortoaddallneedfulguaranteesforthesecurityoffreethought,freespeech,afreepress,puremorals,unfetteredreligioussentiments,andofequalrightsandprivilegestoallmenirrespectiveofnationality,color,orreligion.Encouragefreeschools,andresolvethatnotonedollar,appropriatedfortheirsupport,shallbeappropriatedtothesupportofanysectarianschools.ResolvethatneithertheStatenorNation,norbothcombinedshallsupportinstitutionsoflearningotherthanthosesufficienttoaffordtoeverychildgrowingupinthelandtheopportunityofagoodcommonschooleducation,unmixedwithsectarian,pagan,oratheisticaldogmas.Leavethematterofreligiontothefamilyaltar,theChurch,andtheprivateschool,supportedentirelybyprivatecontributions.KeeptheChurchandStateforeverseparate.Withthesesafeguards,IbelievethebattleswhichcreatedtheArmyoftheTennesseewillnothavebeenfoughtinvain.Source:http://chroniclingamerica.loc.gov/lccn/sn83030214/1875-10-01/ed-1/seq-1/

CatholicsinAmerica

Page15CatholicsinAmerica

Copyright2016,NCHE

Source8

PresidentU.S.GrantandtheCommonSchoolsIssue:YouBetheJudgeOnSeptember30,1875,PresidentU.S.GrantdeliveredaSpeechbeforetheconventionoftheSocietyoftheArmyoftheTennesseemeetinginDesMoines,Iowa.PrintedbelowaresecondarysourceaccountsofGrant’saction.TheauthorsofferdifferentinterpretationsofGrant’sspeech.Readandsummarizethepointofviewofeachauthorandwriteaparagraphinwhichyoutakeapositionanduseevidencefromthereadings. InterpretationA:

Sensinganopportunityintheanti-Catholicsentimentoftheday,PresidentGrantwenttoDesMoinesintheautumnof1875andcalledfornewconstitutionalactiontopreventaidtoparochialschools.“Ifwearetohaveanothercontestinthenearfutureofournationalexistence,IpredictthatthedividinglinewillnotbeMasonandDixon’s,butitwillbebetweenpatriotismandintelligenceononeside,andsuperstition,ambitionandignoranceontheother.Encouragefreeschools,andresolvethatnotonedollarappropriatedtothemshallbeappliedtothesupportofanysectarianschool....Leavethematterofreligiontothefamilyaltar,thechurch,andtheprivateschool,supportedentirelyprivatecontribution.KeeptheChurchandStateforeverseparate.”

JonMeacham,AmericanGospel:God,theFoundingFathers,andtheMakingofaNation(NewYork:RandomHouseTradePaperbacks,2006).InterpretationB:

AthirdareainwhichGrantdefendedprincipleinvolvedtheseparationofchurchandstate.Theissuehadtwodimensions:publicfundingforsectarianeducation,andreligiousexercisesinpublicschools.ThequestionpittedProtestantsagainstCatholics,andGrantsteppedsquarelyinbetween....WhyGrantwadedintothedisputehasneverbeenadequatelyexplained.ButonSeptember30,1875,withoutwarningorpreliminarybuildup,thepresidentoftheUnitedStatesgavebothProtestantsandCatholicsasternlectureonreligioustoleranceandtheseparationofchurchandstate.Grantcrystallizedtheissue,capturedthepublic’sattention,andredirectedthedebate.SpeakingtotheveteransoftheArmyoftheTennessee,asettinginwhichhethrived,Grantmadethemostemotionalspeechofhiscareer.

Forthepresident,freepubliceducationlayattherootofthenation’sliberty,andwithremarkableevenhandednesshebeltedProtestantsandCatholicsalike:providenoaidforparochialeducation,butkeepreligionoutoftheclassroom.“ResolvethatneithertheStatenorthenationshallsupport

CatholicsinAmerica

Page16CatholicsinAmerica

Copyright2016,NCHE

institutionsoflearningotherthanthosesufficienttoaffordtoeverychildtheopportunityofagoodcommon-schooleducation,unmixedwithsectarian,pagan,oratheisticdogmas.Leavethe

Source8(continued)

matterofreligiontothefamilyaltar,thechurch,andtheprivateschoolsupportedentirelybyprivatecontributions.Keepthechurchandstateforeverseparate.”

Grant’sunexpectedinterventionintheschoolquestionreverberatedacrossthecountry.TheNewYorkTimesandtheNewYorkTribunejoinedinpraisingthewisdomofthepresident’swords.TheChicagoTribunesaidthespeech“setthenationagog....Mostimportant,perhaps,thepresident’sdemandfortheseparationofchurchandstatetookthewindfrommilitantProtestantsadvocatingapro-religionamendmenttotheConstitution.

Grant’sinterventionintheschoolquestioncausedeachsidetodrawback.Hisemphasisonfreepubliceducationgalvanizedthemovementforeducationreform.Hisemphasisonseparationofchurchandstatemoderatedthedebate.”

JeanEdwardSmith,Grant(NewYork:Simon&Schuster,2001).

CatholicsinAmerica

Page17CatholicsinAmerica

Copyright2016,NCHE

Source9

ACatholicforPresident!–TheElectionof1928“ThelargenumbersofCatholicswhopouredintoAmericafromeasternandsouthernEuropeduringthelatenineteenthandearlytwentiethcenturiesgaverisetoanewpoliticalbattleovertheplaceofreligioninAmerica.ThecentralquestionwaswhetherAmericanProtestantvoterswouldentrustthenation’shighestofficetoaCatholic.ForthePuritanFathers,Catholicshadnoplaceinthe“CityuponaHill,”anexclusionthatmany,ifnotmost,Protestantscontinuedtoapplaud.AndwhiletheFoundingFathers’banonreligioustestshadmadeCatholicseligibleforthepresidency,onlyProtestantshadbeenelected.Supportingbygrowingnumbersoftheircoreligionists,CatholicsinthetwentiethcenturymadeseriousrunsfortheWhiteHouse.Twice,Catholicswontheirparty’snomination,andbothtimestheirreligionbecameacentralcampaignissue.Opponentsofthe1928DemocraticnomineehelpeddefeatAlfredE.SmithbyraisinghisCatholicismasascaretactic,implyingthathisloyaltywastothepope,nottothepeopleofAmerica.”FrankLambert,TheFoundingFathersandthePlaceofReligioninAmerica(Princeton:PrincetonUniversityPress,2003).

TheKuKluxKlanbecameactivelyinvolvedintheelectionof1928inanefforttopreventaCatholicfrombecomingpresident.Oneleaderproclaimed,“WenowfacethedarkesthourinAmericanhistory.InaconventionruledbypoliticalRomanism,anti-Christhaswon?”

! !!

!!"#$%&'()*'+*,-./'("*

!

!"#$%!&g!'#()*+,-.!,/!01%2,-#!

'*342,$)(!56&78!9':;!

Q2*1!()%!9%A!h*2M!?(#(%!],G2#248!Z#/D.-2,3(.!#/B!?3%-,#+!'*++%-(,*/.!!

0%1/(.*2\**

!!!!

! !!

!!"#$%&'()*'+*,-./'("*

!

!"#$%!&`!'#()*+,-.!,/!01%2,-#!

'*342,$)(!56&78!9':;!

Q2*1!()%!9%A!h*2M!?(#(%!],G2#248!Z#/D.-2,3(.!#/B!?3%-,#+!'*++%-(,*/.!!!

0%1/(.*22*!

2_@G*R/.)'5.+#'"&*9&.(#'%+*6.)1&#)**

"2%.,B%/(,#+!'#/B,B#(%!

\,-%R"2%.,B%/(,#+!'#/B,B#(%!

"*+,(,-#+!"#2(4!

"*3D+#2!\*(%!

"*3D+#2!\*(%!v!

;+%-(*2#+!\*(%!

;+%-(*2#+!\*(%!v!

:%2G%2(!:**H%2!

')#2+%.!'D2(,.!

L%3DG+,-#/! 5&8_eP85PP! OgE5_v! ___! geE7v!

0+!?1,()! a*.%3)!L*G,/.*/!

f%1*-2#(! &O866P87`g! _6EPgv! gP! &7E_v!

9*21#/!S)*1#.!

a#1%.!Z#D2%2!

?*-,#+,.(! 57O8Oge! EP5v! 6! 6v!

F()%2! RR! RR! `O8e`e! Ee6v! 6! 6v!!

!

CatholicsinAmerica

Page20CatholicsinAmerica

Copyright2016,NCHE

Mapfromhttps://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:1928_Electoral_Map.png

CatholicsinAmerica

Page21CatholicsinAmerica

Copyright2016,NCHE

Source12

Whoarethetwo“Johns”depictedintheCartoon?HowdoesthiscartooncomparetotheAlSmithcartoonfromthe1928election?WhatdothesecartoonssuggestaboutthefearshouldaCatholicbeelectedpresident?Whatinformationismissingfromthiscartoonthatmighthelpyoudetermineitsreliabilityasasource?

CatholicsinAmerica

Page22CatholicsinAmerica

Copyright2016,NCHE

Reprintedathttp://catholicjournalist.blogspot.com

CatholicsinAmerica

Page23CatholicsinAmerica

Copyright2016,NCHE

Source13

CatholicsinAmerica

Page24CatholicsinAmerica

Copyright2016,NCHE

FromTheodoreCaplow,LouisHicks,andBenJ.Wattenberg,eds.,TheFirstMeasuredCentury:AnIllustratedGuidetoTrendsinAmerica,1900-2000(Washington,DC:AEIPress,2001).Usedwithpermission.

CatholicsinAmerica

Page25CatholicsinAmerica

Copyright2016,NCHE

Source14

ACatholicforPresident–theElectionof1960JohnF.KennedymighthavebeentheDemocrat’svice-presidentialcandidatein1956,buthewasCatholic!JamesFarley,chairmanoftheDemocraticNationalCommitteefrom1932to1940andstilloneofthemostimportantpartyleaderstoldpresidentialcandidateAdaliStevenson,“AmericaisnotreadyforaCatholic.”FormerDemocraticPresident,HarryTruman,quicklydismissedtheidea.PowerfulSpeakeroftheHouseofRepresentatives,SamRayburndismissedtheideanotonlybecauseKennedywasCatholicbutalsobecausehedislikedtheSenator.ButKennedydidsucceedingainingtheDemocraticnominationforpresidentin1960.Hislongtimefriend,speechwriter,andspecialcounselobserved,“Thesinglebiggestobstacletohiselectionwashisreligion....Youshouldhaveseenthehatemailthatcamein,bothfromrednecksandfromliberalintellectualswhoshouldhaveknownbetter.”Ascanbeseeninthepoliticalcartoon,“TwoJohns,”AmericanobjectionstoaCatholicpresidentin1960weresimilartothosein1928.Asthecampaignprogressed,Kennedychidedjournalistsfortheirobsessionwithhisreligion.“IthinkthevotersofWisconsinobjectedtobeingcategorizedsimplyaseitherCatholicsorProtestants....Ithinktheyobjectedtobeingaccostedbyreportersoutsideofpoliticalmeetingsandaskedonequestiononly—theirreligion—nottheiroccupationoreducationorphilosophyorincome,onlytheirreligion.”KennedyalsotriedtodealwiththepoliticaldifficultiesresultingfromtheCatholicdoctrineof“PapalInfallibility”withhumor.SpeakingtoagroupofnewspapereditorsinWashington,D.C.,KennedyclaimedtohaverecentlyspokenwiththepowerfulArchbishopofNewYork,FrancisCardinalSpellman.Hejoked,“IsatnexttoCardinalSpellmanatdinnertheotherevening,andaskedhimwhatIshouldsaywhenvotersquestionmeaboutthedoctrineofthepope’sinfallibility.‘Idon’tknow,Senator,’theCardinaltoldme.‘AllIknowishekeepscallingmeSpillman.’”InthepresidentialprimaryelectioninWestVirginia,pollsinDecembershowedKennedyleadingHubertHumphreyfromMinnesota,70%forKennedyand30%forHumphrey.Butinalaterpoll,hissupporthadfallento40%andcomparedto60%forHumphrey.Whenaskedaboutthehugedifference,theKennedycampaignwastold,“ButnooneinWestVirginiaknewyouwereaCatholicinDecember.Nowtheyknow.”Awomaninterviewedproudlyclaimed,“I’mnotprejudiced.Aman’sreligionshouldn’thaveanythingtodowithit.”Butshewentontosay,“ButamanoughttobeagoodCatholicifhe’sgoingtobeone.Andtheybelieveinchurch-and-stateandIdon’t.”AnotherwomanclearlystatedherviewofAmericaanditspolitics,”We’veneverhadaCatholicPresidentandIhopeweneverdo.Ourpeoplebuiltthiscountry.IftheyhadwantedaCatholictobePresident,theywouldhavesaidsointheConstitution.”

WouldKennedybenefitmorefromtheincreasedCatholicvotepossiblein1960ascomparedto1928orlosemorebecauseoftheProtestantanti-CatholicsentimentsthathadexistedforoverthreehundredyearsinAmerica?WouldvotersvotetheirpastorlooktoanewAmericanfuture?

! !!

!!"#$%&'()*'+*,-./'("*

!

!"#$%!57!'#()*+,-.!,/!01%2,-#!

'*342,$)(!56&78!9':;!

0%1/(.*2P**

“Recent Studies by Dr. Gallup report a big backswing of Catholic voters into the Democratic Party in the congressional elections of 1958. The report says that 75 per cent of Catholics voted for Democratic congressional candidates in that year. In twelve states of the industrial East, the Gallup analysis says, the number of Catholic Democrats in 1958 actually was greater than that of Protestant Democrats. A breakdown of the Democratic vote in these states into religious groups showed 48 per cent Catholic, 35 per cent Protestant, 13 per cent Jewish, and 4 per cent other religions. The 12 states were the six in New England plus New York, Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Delaware, Maryland, and West Virginia. These states combined have 153 electoral votes.” !

!?*D2-%b!S%I(!%I-%23(%B!C2*1!>U,++!()%!L%+,$,*D.!<..D%!?(*3!c%//%B4!,/!=76i@![T;%A5B1%\%W)#*.%75C)#$N%?%3(%1G%2!P8!&`O`E!</C*$2#3),-!n!X&`O`Y!V#++D38!</-E!0++!2,$)(.!2%.%2H%BE!S)%!-*/(%/(!,.!D.%B!A,()!3%21,..,*/[!)*A%H%28!V#++D3!2%(#,/.!#++!2,$)(.!*C!2%3DG+,-#(,*/E!! !

CatholicsinAmerica

Page27CatholicsinAmerica

Copyright2016,NCHE

Source16

PresidentialLeadershipRelatedtoReligiousBigotryReadthestatementsbelowfromGeorgeWashington,AbrahamLincoln,U.S.GrantandTheodoreRoosevelt.

CompareandContrasttheStatements.PresidentWashingtonrespondingtoAmericanCatholicswrotehimaskingfor“theequalrightsofcitizenship,asthepriceofourbloodspiltunderyoureyes,”

“Asmankindbecomesmoreliberal,theywillbeapttoallowthatallthosewhoconductthemselvesworthymembersofthecommunityareequallyentitledtotheprotectionofcivilgovernment.”(LettertoRomanCatholicsinAmerica,March15,1790)

AbrahamLincolnrespondingtoaquestionabouttheKnow-NothingParty:

“IamnotaKnow-Nothing.Thatiscertain.HowcouldIbe?Howcananyonewhoabhorstheoppressionofnegroes,beinfavorofdegradingclassesofwhitepeople?Ourprogressindegeneracyappearstometobeprettyrapid.Asanation,webeganbydeclaringthat,“allmenarecreatedequal.”Wenowpracticallyreadit“allmenarecreatedequal,exceptNegroes.”WhentheKnow-Nothingsgetcontrol,itwillread,“allmenarecratedequal,exceptNegroesandforeignersandCatholics.”Whenitcomestothis,Ishallpreferemigratingtosomecountrywheretheymakenopretenseoflovingliberty–toRussia,forinstance,wheredespotismcanbetakenpureandwithoutthebaseallowofhypocrisy.”(LettertoJoshuaSpeed,August24,1855.)

UlyssesS.Grantspeakingaboutissuesarisingbetweencommonschoolsandparochialschools:

"Now,thecentennialyearofournationalexistence,Ibelieve,isagoodtimetobegintheworkofstrengtheningthefoundationsofthestructurecommencedbyourpatrioticforefathersonehundredyearsagoatLexington.Letusalllabortoaddallneedfulguaranteesforthesecurityoffreethought,freespeech,afreepress,puremorals,unfetteredreligioussentiments,andofequalrightsandprivilegestoallmenirrespectiveofnationality,color,orreligion.Encouragefreeschools,andresolvethatnotonedollar,appropriatedfortheirsupport,shallbeappropriatedtothesupportofanysectarianschools.ResolvethatneithertheStatenorNation,norbothcombinedshallsupportinstitutionsoflearningotherthanthosesufficienttoaffordtoeverychildgrowingupinthelandtheopportunityof[sic]agoodcommonschooleducation,unmixedwithsectarian,pagan,oratheisticaldogmas.Leavethematterofreligiontothefamilyaltar,theChurch,andtheprivateschool,supportedentirelybyprivatecontributions.KeeptheChurchandStateforeverseparate.Withthesesafeguards,IbelievethebattleswhichcreatedtheArmyoftheTennesseewillnothavebeenfoughtinvain."[AsreprintedintheNewYorkTribune,October1,1875]

CatholicsinAmerica

Page28CatholicsinAmerica

Copyright2016,NCHE

Source16

PresidentialLeadershipRelatedtoReligiousBigotry(continued)

TheodoreRoosevelt,speakingatthetimeofthe1908electioninsupportofWilliamHowardTaftagainstWilliamJenningsBryan:

“IbelievethatthisRepublicwillendureformanycenturies.IfsotherewilldoubtlessbeamongitsPresidentsProtestantsandCatholics,and,veryprobablyatsometime,Jews.IhaveconsistentlytriedwhilePresidenttoactinrelationtomyfellowAmericansofCatholicfaithasIhopethatanyfuturePresidentwhohappenstobeaCatholicwillacttowardshisfellowAmericansofProtestantfaith.HadIfollowedanyothercourseIshouldhavefeltthatIwasunfittorepresenttheAmericanpeople.”(InresponsetolettersreceivedattemptingtomakeTaft’sreligionanissueintheelection,November9,1908)

Whatdoesthistellusabouttheimportanceandlimitsofpresidentialleadershiponasocialissue?

CatholicsinAmerica

Page29CatholicsinAmerica

Copyright2016,NCHE

Source17

ThomasNast,between1860-1902,unpublished.Whatisironicaboutthelabelof“foreign”reptilesinthiscartoon?Source:LibraryofCongress,http://www.loc.gov/pictures/item/2010717281/

CatholicsinAmerica

Page30CatholicsinAmerica

Copyright2016,NCHE