Post on 07-Apr-2018
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 1/53
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 2/53
i
Abstract
There has been some interest in the field of strategic management in broadcasting, but
little attention has been given to local television broadcasters. Therefore, I tackled the
issue of business strategy of local television stations in the UK. The system discussed in
this project is a hypothetical adaption of one that does exist in the US. Organisations like
United for Local Television, along with Jeremy Hunt, Minister of Culture, Olympics,
Media and Sport, have raised considerable interest in developing a sustainable local
television system. I have set out to present pertinent information about the strategic
positioning and the development of strategy for these potential local television stations. I
have used previous studies to structure my argument and present useful data thatcontributes to the discussion. Data was collected from government reports concerning
local television in the UK, as well as, case study materials- collected through interviews
and other reports- from nations with strong local television systems. The results yield two
models that managers can apply in order to develop their strategic position and create
strategic goals and actionable timelines for their organisation.
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 3/53
ii
Attestation
1. This work is composed by me.
2. This work has not been accepted in any previous application for a degree.
3. The work of which this is a part is done by me.4. All verbatim extracts have been distinguished by quotation marks and the sources of
information have been specifically acknowledged.
5. The word count for this work, excluding appendices and bibliography, is 12,978
I understand the nature of plagiarism, and I am aware of the University’s policy on this.
I certify that this dissertation reports original work by me during my University project
except for the following:
The model discussed in the literature review in Chapter 1 and included in Appendix 2, Figure
2.1, was taken from Chan-Olmsted’s Issues in Strategic Management (2006, p. 176). The models discussed in Chapter 3 and included in Appendix 3, Figures 3.1, 3.2 and 3.3,
respectively, were taken from Porter’s The Five Competitive Forces that Shape Strategy
(2008, p. 80), Lewis and Lawton’s The Four Functions of Organizations--Where does the
individual fit in?(1996, p. 222) and Schein’s Cultural Model, found in found in Küng-
Shankleman’s Inside the BBC and CNN : managing media organisations (2000, p. 20).
The model discussed in Chapter 4 and included in Appendix 4, Figure 4.1, was taken from
Chan-Olmsted’s Issues in Strategic Management (2006, p. 175). Signature:
Registration No.: 1919502
Date:
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 4/53
iii
Acknowledgements
I would like to thank my advisor, John Izod, for the guidance and perspective he provided
throughout the development and completion of this project. His constructive advice hascontributed a great deal to my work. It was a privilege to interview local station managers in
the US, and I owe sincere thankfulness to them for their thought provoking observations. I
would also like to thank my classmate, Jördis Güther, for continually challenging me to re-
assess the focus and structure of my dissertation. I am thankful and indebted to my good
friend and former colleague, Andrew Busam, for providing feedback and support.
Additionally, I would like to thank, Neil Blain, for helping me brainstorm and focus my
research. I would be remiss if I did not mention and thank my former employers, Herbert
Greenberg and Sandra Smith, whose passion for local television and continued support has
been an inspiration to me. Last, but certainly not least, I owe a great deal of gratitude to my
family for encouraging and supporting me through my many endeavours.
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 5/53
iv
Table of Contents
Abstract ...................................................................................................................... i
Attestation ................................................................................................................. ii
Acknowledgements .................................................................................................. iii
Table of Contents ..................................................................................................... iv
Introduction ............................................................................................................... 1
1 Literature Review ................................................................................................... 3
1.1 Media Market, Scarcity and Strategy .............................................................. 3
1.2 The Local Market ............................................................................................ 6
1.3 Defining Local ................................................................................................. 7
2 Research Methods ................................................................................................. 9
3 An Overview of Strategy ...................................................................................... 13
3.1 Defining Strategy ........................................................................................... 13
3.2 Models for Strategic Planning ....................................................................... 14
3.3 Organisational Structure ................................................................................ 15
3.4 Resources ....................................................................................................... 16
3.5 Core Competencies ........................................................................................ 16
4 Strategy and Broadcasting .................................................................................... 19
4.1 Developing Strategy ...................................................................................... 19
4.2 The New Media Market ................................................................................. 20
4.3 Resources and Diversification ....................................................................... 21
5 Strategy in Local Television in the UK ................................................................ 25
5.1 Need for Local ............................................................................................... 25
5.2 The Shott Report ............................................................................................ 26
5.3 Case Studies ................................................................................................... 28
5.3.1 Local Television in the US .................................................................. 28
5.3.2 Tawain Satellite Companies ................................................................ 31
5.3.3 Local Television in Basque country, Spain ......................................... 32
5.4 Strategies for Local Broadcasters .................................................................. 33
Conclusion ........................................................................................................... 35
Reference List ......................................................................................................... 36
Appendix 1 .............................................................................................................. 412.1 Strategy Map by Chan-Olmsted .................................................................... 41
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 6/53
v
Appendix 2 .............................................................................................................. 42
3.1 Five Forces Framework by Porter ................................................................. 42
3.2 Organisational Functions by Lewis and Lawton ........................................... 43
3.3 Culture, Strategy and Environment by Schein .............................................. 44
Appendix 3 .............................................................................................................. 45
4.1 Media Taxonomy by Chan-Olmsted .............................................................. 45
Appendix 4 .............................................................................................................. 46
5.1 Determining Strategic Position ...................................................................... 46
5.2 Firm-Level Strategy ....................................................................................... 47
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 7/53
1
Introduction
There has been renewed interest in developing a local television system in the UK.
Jeremy Hunt, Secretary of State for Culture, Olympics, Media and Sport, has led the drive to
develop a new and sustainable local system. The recently published Shott Report discusses
the viability of local commercial television which will provide services to ten different
markets in the UK. Previous attempts to establish local television have fallen before they
could take off, or the organisations were unable to develop appropriate models to sustain the
venture (Department of Culture, Media and Sport 2011,p.13). Cost, lack of interest and
commitment to public-service are a few reasons why local television has had trouble in the
UK. The Shott Report presents its answers to these issues, but a gap still exists between the
answers and the solutions to the problems of local television. Many of the issues can be
managed if appropriate techniques are applied. Business strategy addresses resource
management and the development of long-term goals that considers internal and external
competitive forces that an organisation will face (Porter 1979,p.137). Renewed interest in
local media will not relegate the issues previously faced. However, a commitment to
business strategy will prepare managers and organisations to better deal with these issues and
build sustainable local television operations.
This project addresses some strategic decisions local station managers might consider
in order to build successful media organisations. Data has been collected from a government
sponsored report that discusses the viability of local television in the UK, as well as
information collected from cases in the USA, Taiwan and Spain.
The literature review, in chapter one, presents previous studies and themes that
contributed to the development of this project. I discuss the influence of media economics by
focusing on the unique characteristics of the media industry and the need to develop
strategies that account for these elements. However, much of the material does not addresslocal economic characteristics. In order to address this, the review moves on to discuss some
firm-level strategies, as well as cultural considerations that can affect local media systems.
Additionally, I discuss important business strategy materials that provide vital framework
materials for the data presented later.
In chapter two, I layout my research methods and discuss how I collect and present
data. I focus primarily on how I collected materials from the Shott Report and compared the
information to the data from the case studies. I have carried out interviews with station
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 8/53
2
managers in the USA, and I use this chapter to address my selection of managers, markets
and their application to this project. Furthermore, I discuss some of the variables and
limitations of my approach.
Chapter three highlights strategic models and structures used to create a strategic
assessment for this project. This chapter presents a definition for local media strategy. I also
use this chapter to discuss elements of an organisation that contribute to the development of
strategy. This chapter does not address local media strategy, but the information presented in
this chapter will move the discussion towards specific strategic devices that can be applied to
the broadcasting industry.
Chapter four will draw from existing studies and literature to highlight the
characteristics of strategic management in broadcasting. This chapter addresses shifts in
market power, technological capabilities and resource allocation and discusses how they have
transformed the media industry. Furthermore, I look at how these elements affect strategy.
This chapter leads our discussion to our main section of analysis concerning strategic
management at the local level in the UK.
Chapter five utilises the data from the Shott Report and the case studies to develop the
premise of this project. This chapter combines the material from previous chapters, as well
as data from the report and case studies, to present a model for strategic positioning and for
developing firm-level strategies. The strategic positioning model is designed specifically for
the local system in the UK. The composition of a firm’s strategic position- along with their
competencies, competitive advantage and long term goals- form the basis of a local
broadcaster’s strategy. The material presented here can be used by managers to develop
strategies for their organisation.
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 9/53
3
Chapter One: Literature Review
The objective of this literature review is to present some primary sources used to
develop the theoretical framework around strategic management of local television. A main
theme throughout this project is the interconnectivity of the television medium in academicand professional fields. Although this project focuses on a specific sector of the media, we
widen our approach to gain insight from other industries and apply business principles that
may be transferable or modified to fit our setting. It is important to note, incorporation of the
different approaches was found to be necessary to understand the complexity of local
television. Reliance on business or economic theory alone would not supply us with the
proper structure to identify trends and themes within the industry, nor provide adequate
academic knowledge.
There has been extensive work in the field of media economics to explicate economic
principles that govern the media (Picard 1989, Doyle 2002, Albarran 2006 and Einstein
2004). However, many of these works are fit for application within globalised markets. This
project is concerned with the economics of local television and cannot justify the application
of some of economic principles without assessing the potential harm it would cause local
stations.
In this chapter I have set out to identify the theoretical concepts that are interwoven
throughout this project. Mainly our focus will be in and around the economics of television
and strategic management of media firms. There has been interest in building a
commercially viable local broadcast system in the UK. I have set out to address some issues
local stations will face and how managers can develop strategies to stay competitive and
sustainable. I will discuss key contributions to strategic management and media economics
then some of the unique characteristics of local media systems.
1.1 Media Market, Scarcity and Strategy The traditional approach to media economics has been concerned with the dual-
product nature of media products (Albarran 2010, Napoli 2003, Picard 1989). Broadcasters
manage programming, audience, and distribution markets concurrently. The ability to
capture the audience will determine the levels of success and control a broadcaster has in a
market (Napoli 2003). However, this approach does not account for public service
broadcasting. PSB is based on responsible broadcasting that provides important information
services to the citizens it serves. The BBC is a highly regarded and easily recognisable PSB
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 10/53
4
and has shaped the television system in the UK since its creation (Curran and Seaton
2010,pp.105-107). Aldridge discusses some of the issues around a market driven broadcast
system and those of a PSB system (2007). In comparison, local broadcast systems in the US
have been successfully working in a market driven system for decades. However, there are
concerns over this type of system in the UK (Aldridge 2007,p.79). Aldridge analysis of the
UK broadcast system sheds some light on the historical and current problems a local system
in the UK would face. Her work provides useful framework for understanding the issues a
commercially driven local system would encounter.
Christophers (2009,pp.10-14) asserts that ‘artificial scarcity’ must be created in order
to control the availability and reproducibility of public goods. Consumption of public goods
by one person does not affect the availability of consumption by another person. Once a
public good is produced and put into the market, in theory, it can be consumed infinitely
without affecting the scarcity of the resource. Television programmes are naturally public
goods. Therefore, principles of scarcity and supply and demand do not naturally occur.
Exploiting the potential value of these resources is difficult without market or regulatory
intervention that creates scarcity. Copyright laws are the most recognisable forms of
artificial scarcity (Christophers 2009,p.10-12). Garnham lays out four strategies to create
artificial scarcity: control of distribution, selling the audience and their attention, hardware
provision, and creation of content that requires constant re-consumption and are used to
commoditise products and realise their potential value (1987, p.30). Garnham asserts that
audience maximisation is the best way to achieve profit maximisation (1987, p.30). With
high investment costs, television programmers often look to exploit the economies of scale
and scope to attract new audiences. His research highlights one of the major economic
concerns for local television that local programmers are not necessarily focused on expansion
into new geographic markets. This raises questions about the perceived value, investment
potential and profit strategies that are necessary for a local television station to be successful.
However, scarcity driven marketing and economic planning does not address the main
challenges for local broadcasters. The landscape of today’s local market is marked by
technological changes, consumer power and brand value. Managers must address these, plus
many other challenges that go beyond the scope of traditional economics. Strategic
management helps develop systems to manage and promote growth throughout the entire
organisation. Business strategy provides the framework for managers to address the multi-
faceted issues, from economics to human capital, in a highly competitive marketplace.
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 11/53
5
Sanchez-Tabernero and Carvajal provide a summarised overview of strategic activity,
they say, “strategy always involves establishing priorities, backing some objectives, at the
expense of others” (2002,p.1). They go on to argue that strategy is concerned with decisions
about the direction and focus of an organisation, based on internal and external forces.
Growth potential and resource availability are factors that drive strategic decisions. They
explain some of the risks that come with strategic management. They claim that strategy is
associated with growth activities; without proper management, strategic growth can cause a
firm to lose focus on specialised services and may result in production inefficiencies
(Sanchez-Tabernero and Carvajal 2002, pp.2-3). However, strategic growth can decrease
disadvantages associated with smaller firms and strengthen a group’s position through
diversification tactics (2002, p.4). Traditional media has had to diversify and expand their
products due to the influx of new media and a shift in market power from the producers to the
consumers. Sanchez-Tabernero and Carvajal, help identify some of the qualities of strategic
choices and is useful in developing generic strategic frameworks that can be applied to media
organisations.
Porter’s Five Forces that shape competitive strategy (Porter 2008) works well as a
complement to Sanchez-Tabernero and Carvajal’s assessment of strategic activity. Porter’s
seminal work on the forces that affect rivalry has been a mainstay in economic and strategic
literature for the past decade. He identifies the five forces that determine the competitiveness
of an industry. This is a useful strategic device in assessing market elasticity and potential of
specific firms. Understanding external and global marketplace helps local media
organisations define their roles and strategic position in the markets. This positioning can
lead to specific tasks that will help them establish and maintain their place in local and
regional markets. Porter’s work is useful within local markets as local economic conditions
and levels of competition are different from national and global trends.
Chan-Olmstead explores strategic management in detail. Her analysis covers the brief
history of the subject and how strategy is applied in today’s media economy. I found her
strategy map- about the formulation and implementation of strategy- very helpful in outlining
some of the main concerns within local television (Figure 2.1). Chan-Olmstead argues that
strategy is not concerned with the creation of scarcity, but rather, with resource alignment
within the firm (2006, p.164). Strategic management is mostly concerned with resource
management and the alignment of resources between and across departments within an
organisation. Barney (1991) and Das & Teng (2000) define resource alignment as accessing
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 12/53
6
resources not currently available but necessary for a firm to maintain or establish competitive
advantage. Chan-Olmstead argues that the benefits of resource alignment are motivational
factors that drive firms to diversify their product, whether it be in geographic or product
markets (2006, p.174). She goes on to say that, “the dependency on local
communication/media infrastructure may also lead to a strategy that is geographically
related” (Chan-Olmsted 2006, p.174). For our task, this resource alignment plays an
important part in the strategic decisions of a local station.
1.2 The Local Market
Aldridge’s work, Understanding Local Media, has been an important resource for my
research. She provides a broad overview of the different elements that make up local media
in the UK. Her research into the local and regional press has been useful in helping develop
frameworks for my research focus. She addresses some of the issues around academic
research into local media. Aldridge asserts that academics in the UK are caught up in
international flows and pressures to maintain recognition at a global level (2007, p.7-13).
Research has reflected this drive towards global recognition. Part of this ‘preoccupation’
with internationalism in academic research, may be a result of a non-borders lifestyle (2007,
p.7). Academics tend to think and live globally and their research reflects this trend.
However, as argued by Aldridge, most people live locally (2007, p.8). It is interesting that
scholars have tended to boil down globalisation and the international flow of
communications, and have developed measures for working in those markets. She covers
many of the important issues around local media including culture, management, and
economics. Her work is not all-encompassing but does provide significant information about
local media.
The academic work around localism highlights the complexity and dynamic nature of
community spheres (Paranjape 2007, Kavoori 2007, Oberholzer-Gee and Waldfogel 2006).Aldridge pulls from the Future Foundation Report, which asserts that people create regions
through their interactions with the ‘people, places, and activities’ around them (Aldridge
2007, p.10). Therefore people’s interaction with media will be a dominant force in
developing their perceptions of their community. Local media orients consumers to the
activities of people within the same geographical spheres. At the local level, programmers
depend on the community to drive content interests. (Paranjape 2007, p.462). This
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 13/53
7
orientation creates an attachment to the community and media organisation. Local broadcast
strategy should consider the implications of these local interactions.
1.3 Defining Local
One of the tasks of this project is to define the parameters of locality. What is
considered local, and how do we assess the local qualities of a large market versus those of a
small market? Additionally, where are geographic lines drawn and how far does local
television reach? The range of locality, from national to ultra-local, will have direct impact
on economic capabilities of a broadcaster. How a broadcaster defines their operation and
how trading partners view their organisation will have a significant impact on their ability to
create and exploit product potential. However, technological advances in DBS and internet
transmission has eliminated many of traditional spatial boundaries associated with terrestrial
broadcasting (Albarran 2010, p.86). The economic impact of technology and exploitation of
economies scale and scope has created pressure on smaller media firms to diversify their
products and expand their reach (Christophers 2009, p.76). New definitions of localism are
concerned with the cultural boundaries rather than spatial boundaries.
Kavoori defines localism, as it relates to internationalism, as a set of standards that
has evolved out of global trends (2007, p.295). In Kavoori’s opinion, local has been
portrayed in contradictory ways either, “as a residual category overtaken by development, as
a haven of resistance against globalization, or as a historical or cultural context” (2007,
p.295). The conceptual breakdown of localism is shown by Kavoori, to create a gap between
global perspectives and local knowledge (2007, p.297). The intricate and multi-layered
dimensions of local are left out of the mainstream flows of communication at global levels,
which is eventually reflected through local symbols in a community (2007, p.297). Global
products are developed and packaged to meet expectations of a global audience. These
products lack cultural symbols and definition that define regions and nations. Local flows of communication create and transmit local culture, which has become an important part of
communities in maintaining cultural identity in a seemingly borderless world. Kavoori
provides a contextual assessment of the assumptions about localism. Her work shows that an
evaluation must draw upon the complexities within the area of analysis. However, her focus
revolves around redefining the culture of localism and its application to globalisation. She is
not concerned with spatial boundaries of localism. Dependency on Karvooi’s analysis alone
may leave our definition of localism lacking the economic foundations and geographic
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 14/53
8
specifications that separate the local television economy from the global industry. The
cultural implications highlight the importance of local media systems. However, we must
consider spatial and economic implications, as well as cultural assertions in order to develop
appropriate strategies for local media firms.
Paranjape goes further arguing that local television is defined in the meaning and
‘dynamism’ created that sustains local culture (2007, p.460). Her work asserts local
television is dependent on geographic scope and on the reflection of locality in which the
local station is situated (2007, pp.459-463). Paranjape claims, “in a globalised world
increasingly dominated by ready-made images, people easily fall prey to the ‘options’
produced by some propaganda machinery” (2007, p.461). Local media is defined by its
ability to communicate with and be a part of the community. Global media feeds people
information and ideas about the world outside of their local spheres. Local television is a
system that can reflect and respond to the fluctuations within the community. Differing from
imported media, local television is able to actively adjust to the dynamic culture in the
community (Paranjape 2007, p.462).
Although Paranjape does not discuss economic implications of a dynamic culture, her
work highlights the importance of local culture. There is a clear need for local media systems
to sustain these cultures in an increasingly globalised world. Cultural implications are
significant, and local media plays an important role in developing and maintaining local
culture. Reviewing these issues led me to develop the ideas presented in this project. The
resurgence of interest in local broadcasting in the UK calls for a fresh look at the industry;
local media is lacking an assessment of firm-level actions. I have used the information in this
literature review to develop a research paradigm to produce strategic models for a local
broadcast system in the UK.
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 15/53
9
Chapter Two: Research Methods This chapter is focused on identifying the methodologies used to define and identify
management principles of local television in the UK. These methods have been used to plan,
develop and carry out specific tasks designed to provide data and supporting information,which will contribute to the topic and field of study. I will justify my approach by explaining
how these methods have been formulated to fit this project. Furthermore, I will address some
of limitations of my research and some different variables on the outcome. Qualitative
research is the main type of research used. The information available through government
and industry reports and inquiries into other local media systems provides a wide range of
issues and topics for us to build a case for local media in the UK. Some of the findings are
based on data collected from local television station managers in the USA. I will explain
how I collected this information and its application to the rest of the project.
Data collection and processing can be a time consuming, confusing and frustrating
element of any research project. Choosing how one should collect information is only the
start of a process, which must be planned from the outset and modified as the project
develops. Determining what questions to ask, how to ask them and how to pick out
applicable information requires in-depth knowledge of the subject and a clear vision of
project outcomes. The focus and argument presented in any work is based on the evidence
and support found during this process. Therefore, one must spend a considerable amount of
time developing a research strategy that will yield the most accurate results. Much of the
theoretical framework presented in this project, comes from existing literature on media
economics and strategic management. The task of identifying issues within the local media
comes from government reports about the local media. These reports will help address the
main concerns around local media in the UK. The framework theories help determine what
approaches are applicable and acceptable for UK media.
The best way to answer the questions of this project was to uncover the unique issues
and themes within the UK’s local broadcasting system. With a recent surge in interest, new
reports and analysis have been published that assess the UK’s broadcasting environment.
This new information allowed me to define some of limitations of the system, but also, let me
address the economic structure of the industry. These reports gave me a clear picture of the
economic structure of the local broadcast system in the UK. The bulk of my work is
concerned with identifying strategic techniques and devices that are applicable and necessary
for the successful operation and sustainability of local television. The topic will be addressed
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 16/53
10
using a three step process to: give an overview of relevant strategic literature, discuss strategy
within broadcast system, and develop strategic positioning and action models for the local
system in the UK.
The issues with this type of research and data collection are concerned with the bias
of the researcher. Although the research questions are clear, the researcher may fail to
recognise shifts or alternative approaches presented within the data. This means that the data
may move the discussion in a different direction, but the researcher may fail to recognise or
accept the alternative discourse. This can create a theoretical gap and leave findings lacking
proper support. It is imperative that the researcher compare information from the reports
with the theoretical information and work hard to rule out any personal bias that may stall the
discussion.
One main issues around the local broadcast system in the UK is the lack of truly local
television. It was difficult to find relevant material that contributed directly to strategic
management from a UK perspective. In order to overcome this lack of evidence, I collected
additional materials from three different nations to create a comparison to draw some
conclusions. The challenge with presenting information from other systems comes from the
regulatory structures and cultural trends that make each system unique. In order to address
these limitations, I have carried out additional research to provide grounding and support for
the data collected from the Shott report.
I carried out telephone interviews, which were designed to reinforce the qualitative
research and highlight practical management techniques of successful managers from stations
in the US. I conducted a total of five interviews and have included materials from three of
those interviews in this project. Two of the interviews were left out of the findings as the
information was irrelevant to the discussion. I have selected two similar markets based on
size and number of local stations within the market. Market size is determined by Nielsen
market research and the stations in this report are ranked between 25 and 50 in the US
system. There are between 700,000 and 1.3 million homes in each market — roughly 1
million to 2.5 million people (Nielsen 2010). These market numbers are similar to the market
size of potential local stations in the UK, as presented in the Shott Report. I have set out to
identify trends and themes and will present the results as a case study, which prioritises their
importance in relation to the research topic. Many strategies and economic characteristics in
the local broadcast system in the US can be applied to the local UK system. One of the
respondents asked to be kept anonymous so the interviewees have been labelled as STM1,
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 17/53
11
STM2 and STM3. Information concerning names and organisations for the other two
interviewees can be found in the reference list.
STM 1 operates in the Greensboro-High Point-Winston Salem market in the state of
North Carolina. This station is located in the city of Winston Salem (population 230,000),
but provides news coverage for the whole market. They compete with two other local
stations, which offer similar news and advertising products and are located in Greensboro
(population 270,000) and High Point (population 115,000) respectively. STM1 has been in
television for 40 years, and has been the general manager of the Winston-Salem based station
for nearly a decade. STM 2 manages a station in the Raleigh-Durham market, which covers
an area reaching approximately 1.1 million homes in North Carolina. The station provides
local and regional news coverage, as well as local and national spot advertising opportunities-
and competes with three other local television stations that offer similar services. STM 2 has
been in management at other stations around the country for over a decade- and has been at
this current post for two years. STM 3 also manages a station in the Raleigh-Durham
television market. This manager is unique in that she has been at her post for eight years but
brought little outside experience to job. Instead, she has spent the entirety of her television
career at this one station. She has worked up into the position.
The interviews and case studies present a unique challenge for this project. The main
goal is to gain knowledge about strategies, techniques and methods used to manage internal
resources and adapt to external forces around their organisation. Some of the issues- raised in
the interviews- revolve around very specific management and economic concepts. Many of
the interviewees did not use academic terminology or definitions to explain why and how
different methods work. In order to overcome this, the questions were formatted- to the best
of my knowledge- to reflect professional terminology and phrases that still maintain their
academic application.
Additionally, I have included case studies from Taiwan and Basque country, Spain.
This information helped identify common trends amongst local broadcasters across national
boundaries, as well as characteristics unique to each system. The Taiwanese case study
looked at competitive strategies in a market driven satellite broadcast system. The case from
the Basque country addressed the balance between market driven and public-service oriented
local television. These two cases are different in their structure and approach to local
strategies but provide a unique cross-dimensional mix of ideas, which have been applied to
this project.
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 18/53
12
However, there are a number of limitations with this comparative analysis. Legal and
economic conditions around television are drastically different from country to country.
These differences, if left unexplained, create a theoretical breakdown that fails to highlight
the uniqueness of the different broadcast systems. In order to explain these differences, I
have tried to take each system and draw out similarities and transferable elements
respectively. The Shott Report was used to identify characteristics in the UK system. These
characteristics were compared to material from the case studies. Elements that matched were
used to develop the ideas presented in this project.
This chapter outlined the methods used as the primary mode of data collection.
Information obtained through reports will be applied to existing frameworks and processed to
support the discussion. Supplemental support is provided through comparative data from
interviews with local television station managers in the US and case studies from broadcast
systems of Taiwan and Basque country. Some limitations include the differences in
television systems and markets from country to country. However, the different systems
give us a multi-dimensional assessment of the strategic actions at the local level. The results
from these different cases provide the basis for this project. This methodology uncovers
some key strategic management issues with local broadcasting in the UK.
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 19/53
13
Chapter Three: An Overview of Strategy This project is focused on providing information designed to further the discussion
concerning commercially viable local television in the UK- specifically looking at the role of
business strategy within this system and its application at the local level. There are a widerange of approaches proposed by management and strategy by scholars that can be utilised to
fit the local broadcasting sector. The literature review covered some contributions to the field
of strategic management. This chapter focuses on specific models, definitions and strategic
tools applied and used in this study. I will focus on organisational function, structure,
resources and core competencies; then explain their contribution to strategy development
within an organisation. I highlight the strategic models and structures used to create a
strategic assessment for this project. Information presented in this chapter will move the
discussion towards specific strategic devices that can be applied to the broadcasting industry.
3.1 Defining Strategy
Before this discussion can move on to highlight the factors used for this project, there
needs to be a definition of strategy as it applies to this research. Some scholars have
proposed definitions of strategy that are broad in scope and provide generic solutions to
common market driven problems (Porter 1999, Ansoff 1965). For example, the Ashridge
mission model defines strategy simply as a firm’s competitive position and their distinctive
competencies (Campbell and Yeung 1999, p.287). Distelzweig and Clark claim that strategy
is a road map from a current position to a future position (2006 p.837). While these
definitions paint a picture of what strategy does, they fail to deliver clear solutions that
organisations can apply to specific organisational areas and problems.
Another group of scholars have tailored their definitions of strategy to fit specific
market segments (Sanchez-Tabernero and Carvajel 2002, Chan-Olmsted 2006, Mai 2002).
For example, Chandler, an early strategy scholar, says that strategy is, “the determination of
basic long term goals and objectives of an enterprise, and the adoption of courses of action
and the allocation of resources necessary for those goals” (1962, p.13). Definitions, although
useful, must be weighed against other factors and applied as part of a larger strategic
framework. I have pulled characteristics from a different range of strategic theories in order
to present a definition that encompasses aspects of the media industry tailored to fit locally
managed firms.
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 20/53
14
Strategy balances internal assets with the external environment to determine the long term
planning and prioritisation of an organisation’s resources and duties and their application to
the markets that firm serves.
3.2 Models for Strategic Planning
“The implementation of strategic planning tools serves a variety of purposes in firms,
including the clear definition of an organization’s purpose and mission, and the
establishment of a standard base from which progress can be measured and future
actions can be planned” (Mayo 2006, p.837).
Porter’s seminal work on strategy and competition is often referenced and utilised to
assess market variables and a firm’s strategic capabilities based on those factors. Porter’s
Five Competitive Forces framework is particularly useful and can be used to plan strategy
and assess a firm’s potential in an industry. This framework helps determine the intensity of
competition within a market by evaluating the five factors that influence levels of
competition. The five forces are: potential entrants, buyers, suppliers, and substitutes- which
combine make up the fifth force of overall competition (Figure 3.1 models Porter’s Five
Forces). This assessment can help firms: identify threats, map their position in the market,
and assess overall competitiveness between firms (Mayo 2006, p.836). The model is useful
because it is transferable across many different industries and firms of varying sizes.
Another planning device that can be used in conjunction with Porter’s Five Forces is a
SWOT analysis. The SWOT analysis is a generic planning tool that can be applied across a
wide range of organisations and highlights a firm’s internal strengths and weaknesses, as well
as their external opportunities and threats. Panagiotou says that organisations operate in an
environment of uncertainty and complex market conditions, and understanding that
environment is essential for strategic planning (2003, p.8). A good SWOT analysis considers
implications of environmental factors and their impact on the organisation. Threats to a firm
may not require any intervention, and strengths may be dependent on external forces, which
an intervention may disrupt. An internal strength may lose its value and become a weakness
if it is not evaluated and managed appropriately. The SWOT analysis aims to exploit external
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 21/53
15
opportunities by utilising a firm’s internal strengths, and minimise the risk of threats and
impact of weaknesses (Panagiotou 2003, p.8).
The planning process is an important step for strategic development, as it provides a
useful benchmark for strategic assessments in the future. Managers must select the
appropriate tools to assess their current market position, benchmark their performance and
develop appropriate strategic actions to meet long term goals. Planning tools like Porter’s
Five Forces framework and the SWOT analysis allow organisations to chart their position
and benchmark performance.
3.3 Organisational Structure
The function or purpose of an organisation is a major factor in determining the
strategic direction managers develop and implement. An organisation’s purpose drives a
manager’s decisions concerning resource allocation, distribution, market entry, customer
care, financial resources and human capital. These elements and decisions naturally define
an organisation’s structure and culture. When developing a strategy, managers must
understand the functions and culture that govern the organisation. Strategies that change or
alter this structure can affect the balance and natural grouping of a firm. Models have been
developed to help firms assess culture and structure without disrupting them.
I will use the Organizational Functions model, as presented by Lewis and Lawton, to
assess the functions of an organisation and how these functions depend on the industry in
which a firm operates. Moreover, organisational culture affects the structure and strategic
actions of a firm. Managers should be aware of the underlying cultural assumptions that will
affect a firm’s strategy. Schein’s Model of Organizational Culture highlights the importance
of cultural elements and their impact on organisational strategy.
There are four generic functions, presented by Lewis and Lawton, which an
organisation must carry out to be successful: performing goal oriented tasks, management of their environment, keeping people working together and establishing ways to deal with
outsiders (1996, p.223). These functions must be performed in tandem, and in order to
succeed, an organisation must meet a minimum standard of quality for each category.
However, the tasks, resources and standards applied to each category depend on the type of
organisation. Lewis and Lawton developed the Organizational Functions model to classify
firms based on their activities and where they may fall in relation to each category (See
Figure 3.2). Their model highlights different elements that firms can focus on, depending on
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 22/53
16
the markets and customers they serve. Managers can use this analysis to create a profile of
their firm and identify basic goals and tasks, which are necessary for survival in an industry.
This analysis is a useful tool in the strategic positioning process.
Additionally, there is a strong relationship between the structure and culture of an
organisation. Schein asserts that culture is made up of underlying assumptions that relate to
an organisation’s functions; these assumptions drive strategic activity (found in Kung-
Shankelman 2000,p.15). Kung-Shankelman says, “culture, therefore, plays and important
role in determining firstly how environmental developments are perceived by members of an
organisation, and secondly how members of the organisation react to the strategies designed
to respond to those environmental developments” (2000, p.16). Figure 3.3 is Schein’s model
designed and tested to understand culture and how it relates to strategy.
3.4 Resources
Resources are a crucial element of a firm’s structure. Resources form the product and
service lines of a firm. They are the main source of value for an organisation. Managers are
tasked with controlling and distributing these resources within and across different segments
of the organisation (Porter 1999, p.88). Broadly speaking, resources can be put into one of
two categories: tangible or intangible resources. Tangible resources are the observable and
quantifiable assets of a firm; they are physical assets like property and equipment (Hitt,
Ireland, Hoskisson 2007, p.79). Intangible resources are unique, knowledge based assets of
each organisation and are difficult to monetise; brand value and inimitable skills are
examples of intangible resources (Landers and Chan-Olmsted 2004, pp.6,10). Physical and
knowledge based resources are complementary forces that require cross-directional
management and co-ordination. Strategic planning requires firms to choose which types of
assets they will build competitive advantages around. In a highly competitive industry, with
many substitutes, competitive advantage develops when specialisation in a product or serviceemerges (Porter 1980, p.50-51). These advantages can be developed into long-term core
competencies.
3.5 Core Competencies
Development of strategy can be a long process. Managers need to forecast growth
potential, risks and environmental factors that may not exist now- but may drive the industry
in the future. They must also identify, enhance and co-ordinate unique elements and
activities within their organisation that create their competitive advantage. Prahalad and
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 23/53
17
Hamel have termed these sources of competitive advantage core competencies (1999, p.221).
Core competencies focus on inter-organisational relationships between individuals, groups
and equipment used to carry out tasks. Work flow processes, application of technology and
resource management build a set of skills that can be turned into competitive advantages
through unique products and services. Developing and growing core competencies requires
careful synchronisation of communication and a commitment to team work across
administrative boundaries (Prahalad and Hamel 1999, p.221). Hitt, Ireland, and Hoskisson
claim that core competencies are one of a firm’s most important sources of competitive
advantage and should drive strategy formulation (2007, p.77).
Strategies are developed to drive performance and growth over a long period of time.
Current skills or products may be obsolete in the future. Failure to develop sustainable core
competencies will result in strategic mismanagement and a loss in market position (Prahalad
and Hamel 1999, p.225). Therefore, not all capabilities or competitive advantages can be
turned into core competencies. As a result, strategists and managers need to separate current
capabilities to identify and develop a firm’s core competencies that will drive them into the
future. Prahalad and Hamel provide an assessment for how these competencies can be
identified. They show that multi-market access, benefits for the end user and difficulty to
imitate are elements of capabilities that can be developed into core competencies (1999,
pp.224-230). Managers should build competencies based on these characteristics.
Sustainability is another important factor when considering strategic action- and core
competencies must be developed as sustainable, long term strategic devices. Hitt, Ireland,
and Hoskisson have identified four characteristics of sustainable competencies. They show
that value, rarity, costs to imitate and non-substitutability contribute to the profile of
successful and sustainable core competencies (2007, pp.85-87).
Cannon makes a case for management development and training as a core
competency (1996, p.277-279). He argues that highly competitive, business driven markets
are crowded with similar property based assets and brands. Competencies based on physical
resources will leave a firm lacking clear competitive advantages. Markets driven by
technology are highly volatile and physical resources are easy to imitate and therefore not
sustainable. Instead, firms should commit to hiring and training managers of excellence
(Cannon 1996, p.281). Competitive advantage comes from quality of work, commitment to a
firm and experience these management groups have attained (Cannon 1996, pp.280-287).
This focus on intangible resources and human capabilities highlights an important element in
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 24/53
18
strategy formulation and firms should consider how they manage and promote the intangible
assets of their organisation.
Core competencies must be developed and managed carefully in order to promote
growth. These tools of competitive advantage are built from a firm’s internal resources. As
we have seen, these resources are based either on tangible properties or intangible assets.
Strategic direction is dependent on the development of these competencies. Managers must
choose to focus development either on intangible resources or tangible ones. The direction
chosen is dependent on market structure and the functions of the organisation. Core
competencies are not short-term solutions to resource based problems. Rather, they are
strategic devices that drive the future potential of a firm.
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 25/53
19
Chapter Four: Strategy and Broadcasting In chapter three, I analysed some important features and models of strategy planning
and formulation. The material presented is important for this project. Chapter four narrows
this strategy research to focus on the broadcasting industry. This chapter will draw fromexisting studies and literature to highlight the characteristics of strategic management in
broadcasting. This information will lead the discussion to our main section of analysis
concerning strategic management at the local level in the UK.
Most research about media economics looks at the normative elements of the industry
as a whole (Albarran 2006, Becker et al. 2009, Picard 1989). This research has shown the
importance of media economics as a field of study- but has been limited to cumulative
analysis of networks and trends across hundreds of firms. However, the firms and
organisations, which comprise the industry, differ in size, structure and purpose. These
differences can limit the focus of research. This writer does not contend that previous
research has been insufficient or lacking, but rather, a need exists to explore media economics
within specific segments of the market. Strategic media management addresses external and
internal influences of an organisation’s strategic actions (Picard 2004, pp.1-4). Strategic
management allows us to apply economic characteristics, unique to the media, to individual
or clustered firms to assess how these firms operate. In turn, results yield information that
can be used to further the field of study and create formulas useful for similar firms. Media
scholars have started to look at firm-level operations and have addressed some strategic
principles across similar firms. (Chan-Olmstead 2006, DeMars 2010, Dimmick 2003, Picard
2004, Slocum and Albarran 2006).
This section will address some unique characteristics of the media industry, as well as
strategic literature that can be applied to the broadcasting industry. Many elements are
crucial for strategic management, and managers should be able to identify and understand
them in order to develop appropriate strategy. The economic topics below have been
sufficiently covered by other media scholars and do not need to be rehearsed in this project.
Therefore, I will dedicate time to connecting economic elements to the strategic elements
discussed in the previous section.
4.1 Developing Strategy
Strategy is concerned with the long term planning and allocation of important
resources that create sustainable competitive advantages. Strategic management addresses
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 26/53
20
the process and alignment of a media organisation to its environment (Chan-Olmstead 2006,
p.161). The previous section highlighted the importance of structure, resources and
development of core competencies. This section addresses some characteristics of media
firms and products- and how they can be utilised to develop strategic positions. I will
examine the consumer’s role and changes in market structure- then address how resources
affect strategy. Finally, I will talk about strategic tactics that firms employee.
4.2 The New Media Market: Consumer Control
Media firms have diversified their products and expanded their potential reach
through technological expansion. This shift has given producers the ability to share and
promote their products across multiple platforms and markets (Majoribank 2003,p.59). Lotz
says, “a confluence of multiple industrial, technological, and cultural shifts conspired to alter
institutional norms in a manner that fundamentally redefined the medium and business of
television” (2007,p.20). However, these shifts have also reshaped the way media is
consumed. Users have access to unlimited amounts of information from just about any
location. Additionally, switching from one device to another, or one channel to another, has
relatively low if any switching costs. Consumers can multi-task their media usage and are
less connected to traditional forms of communication (Vahlberg 2010,pp.2,9-10). Walker
and Bellamy show this change in power. The first generation of television users were known
as viewers and simply received the message from the producers; the new generation are
known as users, as they are no longer just receivers of information- but participants in
influencing content (2010,p.41). These changes have ushered in a shift in power from the
producers and owners of media content to the end user or consumer of content.
As a result of these changes, firms have had to re-tool and re-focus how they brand,
market and distribute their products. Traditional advertising supported media are losing
market share and must develop alternative revenue streams to supplement losses in theirprimary funding models. Ferguson claims that media supported entirely by advertising will
not thrive because audiences are more empowered than ever; they are able to avoid
advertising and spend less time with one outlet (Ferguson 2010,p.61, Picard, 2004). On the
other hand, users who access content across multiple platforms are more active in their
consumption. Pitts and Zeng claim that this shift creates new opportunities for advertising
and niche-casting (2010,p.23). Additionally, strategies have been redeveloped to support
nonlinear, cross-platform expansion (Lotz 2007,p.20).
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 27/53
21
Strategic direction of a firm is highly dependent on the users and consumers they
target. Unfortunately, it is difficult to predict consumer behaviour. Managers must adopt a
level of flexibility so as to not get caught off guard by changes in consumer preference- yet
must be careful not to over commit to high risk investments. Chan-Olmsted says, “as
technology shifts more control and power to consumers, media strategies and competitive
dynamics should be evaluated based on consumer, rather than industry, factors or definitions”
(2006,p.174). Managing this volatile environment requires careful consideration of consumer
interests, and managers need to adopt models that measure and evaluate shifts in consumer
preferences. IBM published a report addressing shifts in consumer behaviour and the future
of advertising. The report claims that the future of the advertising market will be shaped by:
consumer attention, creativity, specific measurement tool and revamped advertising
inventories (Berman 2007,p.2-5). Marketing trends will need to shift with consumers as they
move into new platforms. According to Pitts and Zeng, producers and managers should be
trained to recognise and adapt to changing usage patterns- and consumer expectations
(2010,p.23). Further complicating the development of appropriate strategy is the valuation of
different platforms and products presented to consumers. Investment into state of the art
mobile technology may create an attractive selling point, but if demand from advertisers or
consumers fails to meet operational investment, then risks and costs outweigh the benefits of
an added service. Chan-Olmsted has proposed a media product taxonomy chart to determine
risks and involvement that products and services require from consumers (Figure 4.1). This
chart classifies consumer involvement and risks- dependent on their time and financial
investment into media products. Data collected from this type of assessment can be useful
for SWOT analysis in the strategic planning stages. Implementation of this type of consumer
usage chart simplifies consumer activity and gives firms the ability to design plans that
reduce risks.
4.3 Resources and Diversification
Resources that make up a media organisation are the tools that drive product
development and are the main sources of value for an organisation. In the previous chapter, I
talked about differences between physical and knowledge based resources- and the need for
cross directional management and coordination. This section addresses some unique
characteristics of media products and presents Lander and Chan-Olmsted’s Related Product
Diversification strategy.
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 28/53
22
Media firms have often been described as offering products that have multiple
functions (Albarran 2010,p.66, Doyle 2002, Picard 1989). Picard has termed this unique
characteristic as the “dual” product nature of the media (Picard 1989). Media products
function in two distinct markets; the content market where the product is presented to
consumers, and the advertising market where the product is sold to advertisers- looking to
sale their product to the consumer. The dual nature of media products plays a significant role
in the development of strategic elements in a media firm. While media firms are able to draw
revenue from products that operate in dual markets, technology and digitisation has driven
the industry towards multi-platform consumption patterns (Albarran 2010,p.72-74).
Consumers seek products that are easily accessible through different devices and on different
platforms. Coupled with the explosion in television channels, broadcasters are faced with
extreme competition from new and old media outlets. Moreover, market boundaries are
becoming increasingly insignificant as consumers are able to substitute and switch media
products. However, media products- which are public goods- can lead a firm to develop
diversification tactics in order to exploit economies of scope and scale. (Chatterjee and
Wernerfelt 1991). Technology provides traditional media outlets with the ability to re-
package and deliver products in new ways.
A study carried out by Landers and Chan-Olmsted set out to determine which
resources became more vital to a firm’s competitive advantage as markets changed over time.
The study found that property and knowledge based resources contribute to different
production capabilities and effect strategy in different ways. Knowledge based resources,
like human capabilities and multi-purposing, became important as markets became more
volatile, while property based resources affected the performance of an organisation (Landers
and Chan-Olmsted 2004,p.21). While the results are applicable to all media firms, the study
highlights the importance of resource management in media firms. Effectively coordinating
and managing tangible and intangible resources can lead to the development of core
competencies. Managers should build strategies that emphasise and exploit those core
competencies (Hitt, Ireland, and Hoskisson 2007,p.385).
Niche marketing has become a normative feature of media firms in the UK
(Datamonitor 2009). Specialised programming and products are designed to find particular
groups and exploit demographic gaps in the market. Niche-casting or narrowcasting is a way
to reach these groups and deliver unique products. The audience should; therefore, drive the
type of advertising that firms seek (Napoli 2003,p.25). In order to be successful, firms must
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 29/53
23
clearly define who their audience is, or who their audience will be, in order to develop
objectives that will help them meet their needs as an organisation (Pringle and Starr
2006,p.14). Niche marketing drives product development and advertising trends. Managers
need to clearly establish what groups they will target; much of this is dependent on
organisational structure and purpose.
Corporate strategy seeks to exploit resources across different firms by promoting
firm- level strategy tailored for that firm’s market segment. According to Dimmick, some
media conglomerates have implemented the niche-breadth strategy to exploit firm and market
specific resources to diversify their products- and build niche segments in multiple markets
(2003,pp.68,75). One example he gives of the niche-breadth strategy is a corporation that
owns multiple daily newspapers. The strategy of a local-suburban based daily will differ
from the strategy of a large metro-daily, yet corporate strategy should exploit these
differences by facilitating firm-level strategy through supplemental resource allocation
(Dimmick 2003,pp.73-75). Although the niche-breadth strategy is designed to exploit
capabilities within media conglomerates at the corporate level, the principles can be applied
to individual organisations. Dimmick suggests that strategy should build on the aggregate
potential of the different groups’ and firms’ unique capabilities. He delineates four
characteristics of the niche-breadth strategy: scale as defined by revenues, diversification,
economies of scope, and multi-national operation (2003,p.70). I have omitted scale and
multi-national operation from this discussion as they are not applicable to this study.
Diversification spreads risks and increases potential access to new platforms and
markets. Economies of scope can help firms diversify. Conglomerates can easily diversify;
however, smaller firms must work harder to diversify. Scope economies occur when
production of one product lowers the cost of another because costs are spread across those
products (Picard 1989,p.63). Additionally, Landers and Chan-Olmstead have suggested a
firm-level strategy of related product diversification that may be useful for firms to extend
products into other markets and across formats (2004,p.173). This type of diversification
exploits economies of scope. Media firms can extend the life of their products and introduce
them to new audiences. Similar to the niche-breadth strategy, related product diversification
seeks to exploit capabilities and available resources across different departments and
platforms. Moreover, related product diversification may be useful for local firms to develop
appropriate diversification techniques.
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 30/53
24
This chapter has addressed some unique economic characteristics of the broadcast
industry and assessed how those elements affect strategy. As aforementioned, we have seen
that a shift in market power, technological capabilities and resource allocation has reformed
the media industry. Firms must develop strategies that account for these changes. The next
chapter will address how firms can develop strategic processes, at the local level, to deal with
these changes.
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 31/53
25
Chapter Five: Strategy in Local Television in the UK With the information presented in previous chapters, it brings us to the final section
addressing needs of local broadcasting firms in the UK. This section presents strategic
methods that local broadcasters could implement in their operations. The Shott Report hasbeen used to assess needs of local broadcasters in the UK. Additionally, case study materials
have been included from interviews conducted with local station managers from the US, as
well as strategic profiles from local television companies in Spain and Taiwan. Data
collected has been used to create a model for strategic positioning and a model for creating
firm-level strategy.
5.1 Need for Local
Technology has led to an explosion in the media industry. There are more channels,
platforms and content available than ever. Consumers are given countless options, as a result
their usage patterns have drastically changed. Globalisation and conglomerates rule the
media space. Local and regional media market space is dominated by products from the
media production centres of the world (Sanchez-Tabernero 2006,pp.463,468). Television has
evolved as much as any traditional medium; it has been redeveloped to meet the needs of
fragmented audiences (Lotz 2007,pp.4-6). The competitive landscape, which was once
clearly defined, is blurred and confusing. Not only do old mediums compete with one
another, now they compete with new mediums. Audiences are spread across hundreds of
channels- and across multiple outlets. Some have argued that the current media landscape is
too crowded and competitive to support new local media systems (Smith and Hendricks
2010). Bailey believes that investment costs will be too high and returns to low to support a
local system in the UK (Marketing 2010,p.13). Robertson argues, on the other hand, that
globalisation and the internationalising process contribute to the development of local
markets (1994). Additionally, as Esser explains, popularity of local content and programmes
increased in the mid-1990s even as an international television industry emerged (2007,p.163).
This writer suggests that globalisation, deregulation and conglomerates create the need for
progressive local media systems. These local systems provide an important outlet for cultural
definition and expression lost on a global audience. Television can meet these local needs as
it plays an important role in our understanding of the world around us.
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 32/53
26
Ashuri says, “television offers the resources that human beings need both for
positioning themselves and for understanding and respecting others. It is therefore not
just a form of media but a format through which a society articulates and maintains its
differences in relation to ‘other’ cultures while at the same time searches for some
forms of commonality” (106).
Although this study is not focused on expounding on the need for local media, it is
important to establish the basis for this project. This chapter presents applicable strategic
positions for local television firms in the UK based on information gathered from the Shott
report and data collected from case studies.
5.2 The Shott Report
A recent report was published addressing the viability of commercially run local
television in the UK. Commonly known as the Shott Report, this review explains how local
television could be possible, as well as addressing some issues a local system will face. I
have used the report to highlight key components of local broadcasting in the UK. These
components will be used to develop strategic positions for local broadcasting firms. The
following section will discuss: brand identity, sustainability, content, revenue streams,
promotion and competition -as presented by the Shott report.
The report expresses the need for local stations to develop a strong brand and long-
term sustainable business model (p.2). With the help of the Steering Group, the report lays
out the conditions they deem necessary for local stations to accomplish their goals. Local
news and information is considered the best option for local content and production. Content
tailored to the specific locale will provide an additional source of news, which is difficult to
replicate by regional and national news services (p.3). Audience research has shown that
there is a desire to have more localised news offerings (BBC Trust 2011). Furthermore, thereport suggests that local stations should seek to produce a minimum of two hours of local
content per day (pp.9,37).
For a local station to be successful, it must be able to sell its audience to advertisers.
So, it is imperative that local stations work hard to build consistent viewership. In order to
build a consistent audience, the report suggests some promotional activities that local stations
can use to engage with potential viewers. Cross-promotion on other channels, prominent
positioning on the electronic programme guide and an automatic re-directing system --a
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 33/53
27
system that would send viewers directly to their local newscast with the option to switch back
to regional or national coverage --are ways to promote and build a repertoire with viewers
(pp.3-4,24). These methods will generate interest and drive viewers to the new service.
Napoli refers to audience measurement as the “coin of exchange” or currency of
media products (2003,pp.19-21). These measurements create value that can be turned into
revenues through advertising. However, there is no system in the UK designed to measure
local television audiences. One of the major limitations of local broadcasting has to do with
the lack of audience measurement devices (Shott Report 2010,p.4). The inability to deliver
consistent viewer statistics means that local firms must develop alternative currencies in order
to evaluate their products and sell advertising (Shott Report 2010,p.29). Additionally, the
report emphasises the importance of alternative revenue sources- claiming that local
advertising alone would be insufficient to meet the long term goals of a station (pp.4,37).
Local stations could generate additional income by providing news services for national and
regional news firms. News gathering would be primarily for the local station, but if local
news had regional or national significance, other broadcasters could pick up the stories.
Furthermore, the report discusses some operational tasks that will build a local
station’s position in the market. The proposed local broadcast system would be supported by
a national network that provides supporting services, access to national advertising and
network content (p.6). Jankowski and Fuchs discuss the importance of networks for local
broadcasters. They say, “the distinctive aspect of a network is its ability to integrate local and
national services into a continuous, balanced flow” (1995,p.62). The report stresses the need
for owners to develop relationships with other local media groups and build upon the
capabilities within their particular market rather than subsist on national content (p.6,33-34).
The size of the organisation is an important factor in strategic choices. Economic fluctuations
affect firms differently, depending on their size and external capital (Picard and Rimmer
1999,p.6). Therefore, managers must carefully consider their level of dependence on the
national network, and they should strive to build local connections with other media firms
and local businesses.
The report identifies some of the major hurdles and obstacles local stations will face.
For this project, I will discuss issues that can be addressed from a strategic stand point-
mainly concerned with competitive forces governing the market and affecting local firms.
Local broadcasters will be competing for viewers and advertisers. Competition for viewers
exists between the broadcaster and other television channels available to the consumer.
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 34/53
28
Additionally, viewers have the ability to supplement and substitute their television viewing
with other forms of media. Furthermore, competing for local advertisers is where local
stations will experience some of the slimmest margins and toughest competition. The report
delineates some of the challenges local broadcasters will have in attracting local advertising.
Established media groups-- newspapers, radio, outdoor advertising, direct mail and internet
search engines -- will control much of the local advertising space. Most local businesses do
not have big advertising budgets and will find it difficult to switch or increase their
advertising spend with local television (Shott Report 2010,p.24). Local broadcasters must
develop attractive products, promotional schemes and creative selling points that highlight
the distinctive nature of their products to attract viewers and local advertisers.
The Shott report presents information it deems necessary for the successful branding
and long-term sustainability of local broadcasting firms in the UK. Content and
programming should be tailored to the local market. This will separate local broadcasters
from regional and national news providers. Content should be promoted using cross-
promotional schemes to generate interest and establish a presence in the market.
Additionally, local firms should develop multiple revenue streams to reduce dependency on
local advertising revenue. Management should work to expand local networks and limit their
reliance on the national network. Lastly, stations must find ways to deal with the competition
within their locale. Station promotion should highlight the unique nature of their products.
The following section will contribute additional data to the discussion by examining
management principals and strategic positions of local stations in other parts of the world.
The information will contribute to the strategic principles for local broadcasting in the UK.
5.3 Case Studies
5.3.1 Local Television in the US
I have gathered additional information from station managers in two mid-sized US
markets. The US has a strong tradition of local, commercial broadcasting, while the UK has
thrived on a national, public-service oriented system. Although the UK system and the US
system vary greatly, there are some shared characteristics. Most local stations in the US
operate with a sense of duty and mission to their viewers. In 1999, Hurricane Floyd left a
trail of destruction through much of Eastern North Carolina. Flooding and power outages left
many people stranded for days and some were displaced for years. During the initial
aftermath and weeks following, local television stations stayed on the air continually. They
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 35/53
29
provided crucial information to people and provided an outlet for them to connect with the
proper authorities to assist them. Many of the stations lost revenue and spent a great deal of
money to provide around the clock coverage. This coverage and commitment to public-
service was seen six years later when Hurricane Katrina devastated most of the Louisiana
coast, and many have referred to the local news coverage of Katrina as admirable and
necessary for the people and nation (Rogers 2006 and Powers 2005). Similarly, the 7/7
bombings in London, were covered by the BBC, ITV and other news organisations with the
same fervour and response (Lorenzo-Dus and Bryan 2011 and Douglas 2006). On-going
news coverage, beyond the scope of regular coverage, highlighted the importance of public-
service responsibility and provided a crucial service to families and people affected by the
attacks. These similarities show that the two systems share a common commitment to public
interest.
Strategic positions of local firms in the US will provide additional insight into the
direction and focus that managers in the UK should consider. Four elements were persistent
throughout the interviews: brand value, human resources, research and development, and
multi-platform management. I will discuss these elements and the strategic components,
management styles, and organisational tasks these managers identified as important
components in a competitive and volatile media market.
The broadcast market has become extremely unpredictable and highly competitive.
Technology moves faster than firms are able to keep their equipment up to date and
employees trained on the latest innovations (Slocum and Albarran 2006,p.147). Additionally,
power has shifted from producers to the consumers. As a result, traditional media
organisations have been forced to extend their operations across platforms and cut expenses
for seemingly marginal gains (DeMars 2010,p.259). Transferable brand value is one way that
managers have created long term value for their organisations. The brand, as defined by one
station manager, is the value and image a consumer associates with a product, the first thing
that pops into their head (STM1). He went on to say that branding builds trust and can relay
a sense of community service. Additionally, the brand should be based on principles and
values, not on a platform. The brand must extend beyond television. Therefore, the brand
must be adaptable to the consumer’s choice. Brand value is an intangible or knowledge
based resource, and according to Landers and Chan-Olmsted, less affected than tangible
resources by market fluctuations (2004,pp.6-7). Intangible resources tend to be stable
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 36/53
30
investments in competitive markets; developing these resources, such as your brand value, is
a necessity in today’s media market (STM1).
Another intangible element, which is an important feature for local stations, is
human capital. Station managers talked about the importance of employee development,
training and management. When asked about the value of employees, one manager said they
were the most valuable tools he has (STM2). The people in an organisation shape its culture.
The culture of a firm is more important than the right equipment. Culture can foster growth
or stunt it; it affects the way people work together and how they think about the future
(STM2). Another manager said that his role is to, “make sure everyone who reports to me is
successful…If we are successful, we reach all of our goals” (STM3). He went to say that a
lack of success from one person can hamstring the entire organisation.
One of the biggest challenges managers face is investment into technology and
innovation. One station manager says that investment in innovation is necessary to maintain
competitive advantage, but notes that determining the level of investment is extremely
difficult (STM3). Innovation encompasses investment into technology and research and
development to optimise resources. One manager notes that operational excellence is the
cost of entry and massive investments are required to find out what works (STM 1).
Operational excellence is a strategic concept that simply means performing operational tasks
well (Haddock, Mizuno and Ngai 2006,p.3). As a result, stations have to spend money on
technology to find out what will work. Managers invest in developing services and products
that are higher quality than their competitors. Broadcasters must continually invest in
technological upgrades and invest in future growth. However, these investments should not
lower the investment or value of current products (STM 1). In other words, investment in
current products should not be lowered in order to spur growth of new products, especially if
the new products produce marginal gains. STM 2 says, “from a technology stand point,
we’re looking at ways to get out in front…I still have to do a better news cast, I need to do
that because that is just the cost of entry. If we don’t have a decent news cast than forget it,
but while we’re doing that, we’re looking at things that are going to be important to us in two
or three years…technology gives the opportunity for stations to grow if they can strategically
figure it out and then they can move forward”.
I have talked briefly about the shift in television from mass audience to niche and
specialised groups. Lotz says, “although television can still function as a mass medium, in
most cases it does so by aggregating a collection of niche audiences” (2007,p.28). The
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 37/53
31
station managers I spoke with echoed this shift. They identified their organisations as a multi-
platform media firms, and their job titles reflected this shift- as they were listed as multi-
platform managers rather than broadcast station managers. One manager addressed this
change and referred back to the value of the brand versus the platform (STM1). Part of this
shift is actually an inter-organisational proposition. Although digital services make up a
small percentage of revenue, you have to find a strategic balance that fosters growth in that
sector (STM3). You have to invest in and recruit people that understand the multi-media
aspects of the business without abandoning core revenue streams. The consumer will choose
the next technology or the next platform; we have to be flexible enough to meet the consumer
where they are instead of expecting them to come to us (STM1).
Information collected from the station managers showed a clear commitment to
development of intangible resources. Human capital and brand value are essential in a
volatile media environment. Managers can build core competencies and strategic positions
based on their commitment to their people and value of their brand. Additionally,
maintaining competitive advantage requires continual investment into technological
capabilities.
5.3.2 Taiwan Satellite Companies
Mai analysed the satellite channel system in Taiwan. Her findings revealed thatcompany size, operational type and ownership structure influenced strategies that firms
develop (2002,p.145). The study applied Porter’s three generic strategies— cost leadership,
differentiation and focus-- to the Taiwanese satellite system. Mai found that Porter’s
strategies were too broad and did not fit the Taiwanese system, yet the basic concepts were
still transferable to build a new set of strategies for Taiwanese satellite companies. Company
size was found to effect strategies of satellite companies the most. Smaller firms adapted
lower risk strategies and focused resources on specific segments of the market, while larger
firms differentiated their products and spread their resources (Mai 2002,p.161). Concentrated
or focus strategies, seen in smaller firms, are characterised by efficiency and competitive
advantage- developed through the narrowcasting techniques (Mai 2002,p.150).
These strategies are a direct result of the competitive nature of the satellite industry in
Taiwan. There are multiple satellite service providers ranging in size from small, single
channel broadcasters, to large conglomerates that control most of the media space. The
industry profile is similar to that of UK broadcast system in terms of company size and
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 38/53
32
number of operators in the industry. The results of Mai’s study highlights the importance of
firm-level strategy tailored to each station. The size of the firm greatly affected the scope and
capabilities of that firm. Smaller firms developed strategies that capitalised on their unique
market positions by focusing on the potential value of a single-product.
5.3.3 Local Television in Basque country, Spain
Another study analysed the role of local television in the promotion of the Basque
culture and language. Arana, Azpillaga and Narbaiza. discuss the current system of local
television in the Basque region of Spain. The system was first developed as a public service
to promote the culture. Local television was a way to reinforce the identity and language of
the Basque people. However, a lack of regulation has muddled the system and threatened its
existence (Arana, Azpillaga, and Narbaiza 2004,pp.89-90). The local system suffers from a
lack of organisational structure and proper planning. Arana, Azpillaga, and Narbaiza suggest
ways to revitalise the system and turn it into an important device for cultural expression in the
region (2004,p.91). They say, “the objective of local stations should not be to compete with
more general channels in regards to geographic coverage and content, but rather to serve as a
complement in their search for information and for subject matter of local, cultural, social,
and historical relevance” (Arana, Azpillaga, and Narbaiza 2004,p.89). New models should
be developed to spur future growth and match the objectives of the society and country(2004,p.92).
The case from Basque Country is a good example of how a lack of strategy and poor
management can threaten local media systems. Local media services provide a useful
cultural outlet, but they require appropriate management that understand the cultural
elements- and are able to develop strategies that exploit these unique characteristics. Arana,
Azpillaga and Narbaiza offer constructive strategies for local stations to operate as
commercial broadcasters, but maintain their role as agents of public-service (2004,pp.108).
Local culture should shape the way local content is produced and transmitted. Strategies
should exploit these unique local elements when developing core competencies and
competitive advantage.
The Taiwanese case study shows some strategies that have been developed based on
the size of the firm in a highly competitive commercial market. Local television structure in
the Basque region stressed the importance of building a culturally relevant product with less
focus on commercial interests. The local system in the UK will have elements from both of
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 39/53
33
these systems. Commercial viability with supplementary support from public interest and
government regulation means that the local stations will need to adapt strategies that address
the needs of commercialisation and culture. The Taiwanese study shows how a small
commercial operation can compete with other media firms, while the Basque study highlights
the cultural significance of local television.
5.4 Strategies for Local Broadcasters
The Shott report laid out some of the normative elements that may lead to a
sustainable local television system in the UK. The case studies explored some common
themes of local broadcasters in the US, as well as commercial elements from the satellite
system in Taiwan and public service system in the Basque country, Spain. This section
introduces strategic methods that can turn these elements into strategic positions and actions.
Stations should understand their position in the local market. Picard and Rimmer
found that national trends do not necessarily reflect local trends, and local media managers
need to measure local economic trends apart from national (1999,pp.4-5). Strategic
positioning identifies internal and external forces and assesses the impact they will have on
strategy (Johnson, Scholes, and Whittington 2009,p.14). As mentioned in chapter three,
Porter’s Five Forces model as well as a SWOT analysis are ways to assess where a firm
stands in comparison to their competitors in the market. While these models are useful and
should be considered- capturing all of the intricacies of the local market is difficult. A more
in-depth model designed specifically for the local broadcasting system in the UK would paint
a clearer picture of where a broadcast station is positioned. Resources, competition,
organisational structure and the national network are four factors that contribute to the
strategic positioning of a local broadcast station. These factors make up the forces that
contribute to the development of core competencies, competitive advantage and achievable
long term goals. Positioning models eliminate unnecessary factors and keep firms focused ontheir capabilities. I model the effects of internal and external factors on the development of a
strategic position for local stations in the UK (Figure 5.1). This strategic positioning model
charts important forces from the different internal and external factors that will directly affect
the strategic capabilities available to a firm. The model has been developed based on
information gathered from the Shott report, the case studies and the strategic models
presented in previous chapters.
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 40/53
34
I have identified four categories for firms to analyse and identify their strategic
position. The first two categories- resources and organisational structure- are concerned with
the internal forces of that organisation. Management style, organisational culture and
business models make up an organisation’s structure. Resources are the intangible and
tangible sources of production and value creation. Non-scientific evidence from the case
studies suggests brand value, content and human capital are primary intangible resources of
competitive advantage for local broadcast organisations. Organisational structure and other
resources should be developed to support the growth of these primary competitive
advantages.
External factors can be categorised into two groups: competition and the national
network. The level of local competition must be assessed in order to determine how
accessible the local advertising market will be. The national network will also play an
important role in the strategic position of a firm. A firm’s dependence on the national
network, or lack thereof, will strongly influence programming decisions, resource allocation
and local market penetration.
Once a strategic position has been established, a firm can develop a strategy and
implement an actionable timeline. Developing a strategy requires three steps: development
of core competencies, establishing a competitive advantage and setting achievable long term
goals. Once these steps have been taken, firms can create an implementation and assessment
timeline. This timeline sets short term objectives and periodic assessments, while
maintaining focus on the long term goals of the firm. Figure 5.2 models these steps. Short
term objectives should address immediate or situational issues; these outcomes can vary in
outcome and material (Slocum and Albarran 2006,p.152). Long term issues such as shifts in
technology and changing demographics can be addressed as part of the long term strategic
aim. Landers and Chan-Olmsted say, “managers also may revise strategy decisions in
accordance with the uncertainties they face and in response to the information gained
from environmental scanning and resource evaluations” (2004,p.8). Recognising and
planning around external market fluctuations will keep a local firm flexible and able to adjust
their actions without abandoning their long term objectives. The composition of a firm’s
strategic position, along with their competencies, competitive advantage and long term goals
form the bases of a local broadcaster’s strategy.
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 41/53
35
Conclusion
My aim has been to provide information that contributes to the academic field of
business strategy and local media systems, as well as provide information that professionals
can utilise in the day-to-day operations of their organisations. This project has suggested
potential strategic decisions for future managers of local television stations to consider. The
models have been developed based on information gathered from previous studies on
business strategy, the Shott Report and case studies from other local broadcast systems.
Shifts in market and consumer power demonstrate the need for appropriate strategies that
exploit a firm’s advantages and minimise their weaknesses- in a world where marginal gains
and losses can result in success or failure. Resources and organisational structure should be
evaluated to establish the internal networks that contribute to organisational culture.
Additionally, managers should consider the implications of local and national competition, as
well as their dependence on a national network. External factors will greatly affect the
strategic capabilities and position of a firm. Strategies for local television should be
concerned with developing core competencies, competitive advantage and long-term goals-
based on intangible assets that are less prone to market instability.
A limitation of this project has been the non-existence of the local system for which
the models have been designed. The information is based on an ideal system that has yet to
be established. There may be a significant number of changes made to the structure of the
proposed system between the publication of this project and the creation of a local system.
Future research into this type of business strategy could address the topic from a cultural
stand point and evaluate the role that local culture plays in local television systems.
Additionally, local systems in the nations of the UK may require a modified strategic
approach. Research could compare audience expectations in the nations to that of the UK as
a whole.
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 42/53
36
Reference List
Albarran, A. (2010) The media economy. New York, Routledge.
Albarran, A. (2006) Management of electronic media. 3rd
ed. Belmont, Thomson Wadsworth.
Aldridge, M. (2007) Understanding the local media. Berkshire, Open University Press.
Anderson, B. (2006) Imagined communities. London,Verso.
Ansoff, H.I. (1965) Corporate strategy. New York, McGraw Hill.
Arana, E., Azpillaga, P. and Narbaiza, B. (2004) Local television stations, Basque and
minority language normalization. Mercator Media Forum, 7 (1), pp. 86-111
Ashuri, T. (2009) Negotiating distances: the cultural economy of television programs.
Television and New Media, 11 (2), pp. 105-123
Barney, J. (1991) Firm resources and sustained competitive advantage. Journal of Management. 17, pp. 99-120
BBC Trust (2011) Performance against public commitments. [internet] Available:
http://downloads.bbc.co.uk/annualreport/pdf/bbc_exec_sopps_2010_11.pdf [Accessed 10
May 2011]
Becker, L. B. et al. (2009) Is more always better? Journalism Studies, 10 (3), pp. 368-385
Berman, S. J. et al. (2007) The end of advertising as we know it. IBM Global Business
Services. [internet] Available: http://www-05.ibm.com/de/media/downloads/end-of-
advertising.pdf [Accessed 16 April 2011]
Campbell, A. and Yeung, S. (1999) Creating a sense of mission. In: Segal-Horn, S. ed. The
strategy reader. Oxford, Blackwell, pp. 284-295
Cannon, F. (1996) Developing competencies that drive business performance. In: Hussey, D.
ed. The implementation challenge. West Sussex, UK, John Wiley and Sons Ltd., pp. 277-288
Chandler, A. D. (1962) Strategy and structure: chapters in the history of the industrial
enterprise. Cambridge, MIT.
Chan-Olmsted, S. M. (2006) Issues in strategic management. In: Albarran, A. B., Chan-
Olmsted, S. M. and Wirth, M. O. eds. Handbook of media management and economics.Mahwah, N.J., Lawrence-Erlbaum, pp. 161-180
Chatterjee, S. and Wernerfelt, B. (1991) The link between resources and type of
diversification: theory and evidence. Strategic Management Journal, 12, pp. 33-48
Christophers, B. (2009) Envisioning media power. MD, Rowman and Littlefield.
Curran, J. and Seaton, J. (2010) Power without responsibility. 7th
ed. London, Routledge.
Das, T.K. and Teng, B. (2000) A resource-based theory of strategic alliances. Journal of
Management. 26, pp. 31-61
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 43/53
37
Datamonitor (2009) Media in the United Kingdom: industry profile. [internet] London,
Datamonitor Europe. Available: www.datamonitor.com[Accessed 13 April 2011]
DeMars, T. R. (2010) Local market radio. In: Hendricks, J. A. ed. The twenty-first century
media industry: economic and managerial implications in the age of new media. Plymouth,
UK, Rowman and Littlefield, pp. 251-268
Department of Culture, Media and Sport (2011) A new framework for local tv in the UK.
[internet] Available: http://www.culture.gov.uk/images/consultations/Local-TV-
Framework_July2011.pdf
Dimmick, J. W. (2003) Media competition and coexistence: the theory of the niche. London,
Lawrence-Erlbaum.
Distelzweig, H. and Clark, C. (2006) Strategy formulation. In: Helms, M. M. ed.
Encyclopedia of Management . 5th
ed. New York, Thomson and Gale, pp. 837-844
Douglas, T. (2006) How 7/7 ‘democratised’ the media. BBC News. [internet] Available:http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/5142702.stm [Accessed 05 August 2011]
Doyle, G. (2002) Understanding media economics. London, Sage.
Einstein, M. (2004) Media diversity: economics, ownership, and the FCC. NJ, Lawrence
Earlbaum.
Esser, A. (2007) Audiovisual content in Europe: transnationalization and approximation.
Journal of Contemporary European Studies, 15 (2), pp. 163-184
Ferguson, D. A. (2010) The obstinate audience revisited: the decline of network advertising.
In: Hendricks, J. A. ed. The twenty-first century media industry: economic and managerialimplications in the age of new media. Plymouth, U.K., Rowman and Littlefield, pp. 61-80.
Garnham, N. (1987) Concepts of culture: public policy and cultural industries. Cultural
Studies. 1, pp. 23-37
Haddock, R., Mizuno, F. and Ngai, P. (2006) Achieving operational excellence in China:
strategic need and practical solutions. Booz, Allen and Hamilton [internet] Available:
http://www.boozallen.com/media/file/Operational_Excellence_In_China.pdf [Accessed: 05 August
2011]
Hitt, M. A., Ireland, D. R. and Hoskisson, R. E. (2007) Strategic management
competitiveness and globalization: cases and concepts. 7th ed. Mason, OH., Thomson andSouth-Western.
Jankowski, G. F. and Fuchs, D. C. (1995) Television today and tomorrow: it won’t be what
you think. New York, Oxford University Press.
Johnson, G., Scholes, K. and Whittington, R. (2009) Fundamentals of Strategy. Edinburgh,
Pearson Education.
Kavoori, A. P. (2007) Bring back the local, work the divide: two curricular recommendations.
Global media and communication. 3(3), pp. 294-299
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 44/53
38
Küng-Shankleman, L. (2000) Inside the BBC and CNN : managing media organisations.
London, Routledge.
Landers, D. E. and Chan-Olmsted, S. (2004) Assessing the changing network TV market: a
resource-based analysis of broadcast television networks. Journal of Media Business Studies,
1 (1), pp. 1-26
Lewis, R. and Lawton, J. (1996) The four functions of organizations--where does the
individual fit in? In: Hussey, D. ed. The implementation challenge. West Sussex, UK, John
Wiley and Sons Ltd., pp. 221-227
Lotz, A. D. (2007) The television will be revolutionized. New York, New York University
Press.
Lorenzo-Dus, N. and Bryan, A. (2011) Recontextualizing participatory journalists’ mobile
media in British television news: a case study of the live coverage and commemorations of
the 2005 London bombings. Discourse and Communication, 5 (1), pp. 23-40
Mai, L. (2002) Company size, operational type, ownership structure and business strategy: an
analysis of Taiwanese satellite channel companies. In: Picard, R. G. ed. Media
firms:structures, operations and performance. Mahwah, N.J., Lawrence-Erlbaum.
Marjoribank, T. (2003) Strategising technological innovation: the case of News Corporation.
In: Cottle, S. ed. Media organisation and production. London, Sage, pp. 64-75
Mayo, D.T. (2006) Strategic planning tools. In: Helms, M. M. ed. Encyclopedia of
Management . 5th
ed. New York, Thomson and Gale, pp. 831-837
Napoli, P. M. (2003) Audience economics: media institutions and the audience marketplace.
New York, Columbia University Press.
Nielsen (2010) Local television market universe. The Nielsen Company [internet] Available:
http://www.nielsen.com/content/dam/corporate/us/en/public%20factsheets/tv/2010-
2011%20DMA%20Ranks.pdf [Accessed 02 August 2011]
O’Riordan, T. (2001) Globalism, localism and identity: fresh perspectives on the transition to
sustainability. London, Earthscan.
Oberholzer-Gee, F. and Waldfogel, J. (2006) Media markets and localism: does local news en
Español boost Hispanic voter turnout?
Panagiotou, G. (2003) Bringing SWOT into focus. Business Strategy Review, 14 (2), pp.8-10
Paranjape, N. (2007) Community media: local is focal. Community development journal.
42(4), pp. 459-469
Picard, R. G. (2004) Strategic responses to media market changes. JIBS Research Report
Series, 2004 (2).
Picard, R. G. and Rimmer, T. (1999) Weathering a recession: effects of size and
diversification on newspaper companies. Journal of Media Economics, 12 (1), pp. 1-18
Picard, R. (1989) Media economics: concepts and issues. London, Sage.
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 45/53
39
Pitts, M. J. and Zeng, L. (2010) Media management: the changing media industry and
adaptability. In: Hendricks, J. A. ed. The twenty-first century media industry: economic and
managerial implications in the age of new media. Plymouth, U.K., Rowman and Littlefield,
pp. 23-39
Porter, M. (2008) The five competitive forces that shape strategy. Harvard Business Review,86 (1), pp. 78-93
Porter, M. E. (1999) What is strategy? In: Segal-Horn, S. ed. The strategy reader. Oxford,
Blackwell, pp. 73-99
Porter, M. E. (1980) Competitive strategy: techniques for analyzing industries and
competitors. New York, The Free Press.
Porter, M. E. (1979) How competitive forces shape strategy. Harvard Business Review, 57
(2), pp. 137-145
Powers, S. (2005) Media coverage of Hurricane Katrina: implications and developments inpublic diplomacy. USC Center for Public Diplomacy. [internet] Available:http://uscpublicdiplomacy.org/index.php/newsroom/specialreports_print/050909_media_coverage_of
_hurricane_katrina/ [Accessed 05 August 2011]
Prahalad, C. K. and Hamel, G. (1999) The core competence of the corporation. In: Segal-
Horn, S. ed. The strategy reader. Oxford, Blackwell, pp. 220-233
Pringle, P. K. and Starr, M. F. (2006) Electronic media management. 5th
ed. Oxford, Elsevier.
Robertson, R. (1994) Globalisation or glocalistion. The Journal of International
Communications, 1 (1), pp. 33-52.
Rogers, J. D. (2006) Hurricane Katrina and the critical role of the media in shaping policy.
The Geological Society of America. [internet] Available:http://web.mst.edu/~rogersda/levees/Rogers-Katrina-Critical%20Role%20of%20Media.pdf [Accessed
05 August 2011]
Sanchez-Tabernero, A. (2006) Issues in media globalization. In: Albarran, A. B., Chan-
Olmsted, S. M. and Wirth, M. O. eds. Handbook of media management and economics.
Mahwah, N.J., Lawrence-Erlbaum, pp. 463-491
Sanchez-Tabernero, A. and Carvajal, M. (2002) Strategies of European media companies. In:
Media concentrations in the European market, new trends and challenges, media markets
monograph. Pamplona, Spain, Servicio de Publiciones de la Universidad de Navarra, pp. 82-112
Scott, A. (2005) On Hollywood: the place, the industry. NJ: Princeton University Press.
Shott, N. (2010) Commerically viable local television in the UK. A review by Nicholas Shott
for the Secretary of State for Culture, Olympics, Media and Sport. [internet] Available:
http://www.culture.gov.uk/images/publications/Local-TV-Report-Dec10_FullReport.pdf
[Accessed 05 April 2011]
Slocum, P. and Albarran, A. B. (2006) Strategic planning in local television newsrooms.
International Journal on Media Management, 8 (3), pp. 146-153
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 46/53
40
STM 1: Price, Hank. (2011) President and General Manager, WXII. Winston-Salem, NC.
Telephone Interview. [Interviewed: 16 June 2011]
STM 2: Moses, Brad . (2011) Vice President and General Manager, WNCN, Raleigh, NC.
Telephone Interview [ Interviewed: 23 June 2011]
STM 3 (2011) Station Manager, Raleigh, NC. Telephone Interview [Interviewed: 28 June
2011]
Vahlberg, V. (2010) Fitting into their Lives: A Survey of three studies about youth media
usage. Newspaper Association of America Foundation [internet] Available:
www.naafoundation.org [Accessed 10 April 2011]
Vukanovic, Z. (2009) Global paradigm shift: strategic management of new and digital media
in new and digital economics. The international journal on media management, 11 (2), pp.
81-90
Walker, J. R. and Bellamy, R. (2010) DVRs and the empowered audience: a transformativenew media takes off. In: Hendricks, J. A. ed. The twenty-first century media industry:
economic and managerial implications in the age of new media. Plymouth, U.K., Rowman
and Littlefield, pp. 41-60
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 47/53
41
Appendix 1
Figure 2.1
Chan-Olmsted’s Strategy Map of factors that affect formulation and
implementation. (2006, p. 176)
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 48/53
42
Appendix 2
Figure 3.1
Porter’s Five Forces Framework (2008, p. 80)
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 49/53
43
Figure 3.2
Lewis and Lawton’s Organisational Functions Model (1996, p.222)
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 50/53
44
Figure 3.3
Schein Model for understanding culture, strategy and environmental
context (found in Küng-Shankleman 2000, p. 20)
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 51/53
45
Appendix 3
Figure 4.1
Chan-Olmsted’s Media Product Taxonomy (2006, p.175)
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 52/53
46
Appendix 4
Figure 5.1 Determining Strategic Position
Strategic Position
Resources
Intangible: HR, Content, Programming,
Brand Value, market knowledge
Tangible: Facilities, Equipment
Competition
Local market forces, other local media
firms.
(Porter’s Five Forces)
Organisational Structure
Management styles
Culture: mission, purpose, community
involvement
Business Model
National Network
Level of dependency: funding, content,
structure
Regulatory structure
8/3/2019 Business Strategy of Local Television in the UK
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/business-strategy-of-local-television-in-the-uk 53/53
Figure 5.2 Firm-Level Strategy
Strategic Position
Develop
Core
Com etencies
Establish
Competitive
Advantage
Set Achievable
Long Term Goals
Actionable timeline for implementing and assessing strategic decisions
Firm-Level Strategy