Post on 10-Apr-2018
8/8/2019 Bucknell LTF5 Appreciative Inquiry
1/38
Appreciative Inquiry: AAppreciative Inquiry: APositive Means to TransformPositive Means to Transform
an Organizational Culturean Organizational CultureGene SpencerGene Spencer Bucknell UniversityBucknell University
Maureen SullivanMaureen Sullivan Maureen SullivanMaureen SullivanAssociatesAssociates
Living The Future 5Living The Future 5April 16, 2004April 16, 2004
8/8/2019 Bucknell LTF5 Appreciative Inquiry
2/38
How often do we
think about howwell ourorganizations
are working?
How often is theorganizationalculture anobstacle tochange?
8/8/2019 Bucknell LTF5 Appreciative Inquiry
3/38
1.1. 19931993 Refocusing Computer ServicesRefocusing Computer Services
2.2. 19971997 Merging IT and Library functionsMerging IT and Library functionsinto Information Services & Resourcesinto Information Services & Resources
3.3. 20022002 Reorganizing the frontReorganizing the front--linelineTechnology Support GroupTechnology Support Group
A Tale of Three ReorganizationA Tale of Three Reorganization
Efforts @BucknellEfforts @Bucknell
8/8/2019 Bucknell LTF5 Appreciative Inquiry
4/38
http://www.isr.bucknell.edu/About_ISR/Staff_presentations_and_http://www.isr.bucknell.edu/About_ISR/Staff_presentations_and_publications/Road_Less_Traveled_Paper.pdfpublications/Road_Less_Traveled_Paper.pdf
8/8/2019 Bucknell LTF5 Appreciative Inquiry
5/38
1993A very top-
downreorganization
process
The old culturewas in the way
and changewas imposed.
8/8/2019 Bucknell LTF5 Appreciative Inquiry
6/38
1997A grass-roots
process calledOpportunistic
Evolution
When the staffrealized thatchange was
necessary and
becamemotivated to act,things happened.
8/8/2019 Bucknell LTF5 Appreciative Inquiry
7/38
Top Down
hard to getcommitment
Grass-Roots
slow to getaction
There has to
be a betterway!
8/8/2019 Bucknell LTF5 Appreciative Inquiry
8/38
8/8/2019 Bucknell LTF5 Appreciative Inquiry
9/38
AIAI -- A Positive Description of anA Positive Description of an
Organizational CultureOrganizational CultureOrganizations are, first and foremost,Organizations are, first and foremost,centers of human relatedness andcenters of human relatedness andrelationships come alive where thererelationships come alive where there
is an appreciative eye, when peopleis an appreciative eye, when peoplesee the best in one another and thesee the best in one another and thewhole, when they share their dreamswhole, when they share their dreamsand ultimate concerns in affirmingand ultimate concerns in affirmingways, and when they are connected inways, and when they are connected infull voice to create not just new worlds,full voice to create not just new worlds,but better worlds. By making itbut better worlds. By making itpossible for every voice to be heard, apossible for every voice to be heard, alife giving process is enacted.life giving process is enacted.
(from The AppreciativeOrganization by Harlene
Anderson, David
Cooperrider, et. al.)
8/8/2019 Bucknell LTF5 Appreciative Inquiry
10/38
What is Appreciative Inquiry (AI)?What is Appreciative Inquiry (AI)?
Appreciative Inquiry is the study andAppreciative Inquiry is the study andexploration of what gives life toexploration of what gives life tohuman systems when they functionhuman systems when they functionat their best.at their best.
This approach to personal changeThis approach to personal changeand organization change is based onand organization change is based onthe assumption that questions andthe assumption that questions anddialogue about strengths, successes,dialogue about strengths, successes,
values, hopes, and dreams arevalues, hopes, and dreams arethemselves transformational.themselves transformational.
(from(from The Power of Appreciative Inquiry byThe Power of Appreciative Inquiry byDiana Whitney and Amanda TrostenDiana Whitney and Amanda Trosten--BloomBloom))
8/8/2019 Bucknell LTF5 Appreciative Inquiry
11/38
Appreciate and InquireAppreciate and Inquire
ApAp--precipreci--ateate, v., 1. valuing; the act of recognizing the, v., 1. valuing; the act of recognizing thebest in people or the world around us; affirming past andbest in people or the world around us; affirming past and
present strengths, successes, and potentials; to perceivepresent strengths, successes, and potentials; to perceivethose things that give life (health, vitality, excellence) tothose things that give life (health, vitality, excellence) toliving systems 2. to increase in value, e.g. the economyliving systems 2. to increase in value, e.g. the economyhas appreciated in value. Synonyms: VALUING,has appreciated in value. Synonyms: VALUING,PRIZING, ESTEEMING, and HONORING.PRIZING, ESTEEMING, and HONORING.
InIn--quirequire (kwir), v., 1. the act of exploration and discovery.(kwir), v., 1. the act of exploration and discovery.2. To ask questions; to be open to seeing new potentials2. To ask questions; to be open to seeing new potentials
and possibilities. Synonyms: DISCOVERY, SEARCH, andand possibilities. Synonyms: DISCOVERY, SEARCH, andSYSTEMATIC EXPLORATION, STUDY.SYSTEMATIC EXPLORATION, STUDY.
(from(fromA Positive Revolution in Change: AppreciativeA Positive Revolution in Change: AppreciativeInquiry by David L. Cooperrider and Diana Whitney)Inquiry by David L. Cooperrider and Diana Whitney)
8/8/2019 Bucknell LTF5 Appreciative Inquiry
12/38
Do you recognizeDo you recognizeany of theseany of thesepeople in yourpeople in yourorganization?organization?
Which is anWhich is anappreciative view?appreciative view?
8/8/2019 Bucknell LTF5 Appreciative Inquiry
13/38
Appreciative InquiryAppreciative Inquiry -- Simply putSimply put
If we look for what isbest and learn from it,we can magnify and
multiply our successes
If we continue to search for problems,we will continue to find problems
8/8/2019 Bucknell LTF5 Appreciative Inquiry
14/38
The 8 Assumptions of AIThe 8 Assumptions of AI
1.1. In every society, organization,In every society, organization,or group, something works.or group, something works.
2.2. What we focus on becomesWhat we focus on becomesour reality.our reality.
3.3. Reality is created in theReality is created in themoment, and there aremoment, and there aremultiple realities.multiple realities.
8/8/2019 Bucknell LTF5 Appreciative Inquiry
15/38
The 8 Assumptions of AIThe 8 Assumptions of AI
4.4. The act of asking questions of anThe act of asking questions of anorganization or group influences theorganization or group influences thegroup in some way.group in some way.
5.5. People have more confidence andPeople have more confidence andcomfort to journey to the future (thecomfort to journey to the future (theunknown) when they carry forward partsunknown) when they carry forward partsof the past (the known).of the past (the known).
8/8/2019 Bucknell LTF5 Appreciative Inquiry
16/38
The 8 Assumptions of AIThe 8 Assumptions of AI
6.6. If we carry parts of the past forward, theyIf we carry parts of the past forward, theyshould be what is best about the past.should be what is best about the past.
7.7. It is important to value differences.It is important to value differences.
8.8. The language we use creates our reality.The language we use creates our reality.
(from(from The Thin Book of Appreciative InquiryThe Thin Book of Appreciative Inquiry
By Sue Annis Hammond)By Sue Annis Hammond)
8/8/2019 Bucknell LTF5 Appreciative Inquiry
17/38
A Cultural ShiftA Cultural Shift
The work of leaders changesThe work of leaders changes
Old work: leaders are responsible forOld work: leaders are responsible forfinding and solving problemsfinding and solving problems
New work: leaders enable others to findNew work: leaders enable others to findthe possibilities, energize the vision andthe possibilities, energize the vision andcreate a new futurecreate a new future
8/8/2019 Bucknell LTF5 Appreciative Inquiry
18/38
Facilitating an Appreciative View!Facilitating an Appreciative View!
Ask the rightAsk the rightquestionquestion
What do you see hereWhat do you see here
that would be useful tothat would be useful toyou?you?
8/8/2019 Bucknell LTF5 Appreciative Inquiry
19/38
44--D Cycle of Appreciative InquiryD Cycle of Appreciative Inquiry
Positive Core
DesignDetermine
what should be
Affirmative
Topic Choice
DreamImagine
what might be
DiscoveryAppreciate
what is
DestinyCreate what
will be
From The Power ofAppreciative Inquiry
8/8/2019 Bucknell LTF5 Appreciative Inquiry
20/38
Applying Appreciative Inquiry toApplying Appreciative Inquiry to
Improving Organizations?Improving Organizations?The choice of what we study is critical.The choice of what we study is critical.The questions we ask will define what weThe questions we ask will define what we
will learn.will learn.The words we use create our reality.The words we use create our reality.
We can appreciate the best of what isWe can appreciate the best of what is
already happening and multiply it.already happening and multiply it.Imagine focusing this kind of attention onImagine focusing this kind of attention onyour organization.your organization.
8/8/2019 Bucknell LTF5 Appreciative Inquiry
21/38
20022002 The Situation @BucknellThe Situation @Bucknell
FrontFront--line Technology Support in crisis modeline Technology Support in crisis mode1993 design no longer worked well1993 design no longer worked wellTechnology had become mission criticalTechnology had become mission criticalStudent employeesStudent employees first line of defensefirst line of defense
10% of problems resolved at first point of10% of problems resolved at first point ofcontactcontact$30,000+ for contractors for summer installs$30,000+ for contractors for summer installsMajor backlog of problemsMajor backlog of problems
Unhappy (but supportive) customersUnhappy (but supportive) customersCompletely reactive modeCompletely reactive modeWe need more staff!We need more staff! 5? 7? 9?5? 7? 9?Low staff moraleLow staff morale
8/8/2019 Bucknell LTF5 Appreciative Inquiry
22/38
20022002 The ApproachThe Approach
Staff wanted change and our leadershipStaff wanted change and our leadershipsupported it using the techniques of AIsupported it using the techniques of AI
Energy for change came from the bottom upEnergy for change came from the bottom up
Guidance came from the top downGuidance came from the top down
The staff asked me whats important to you?The staff asked me whats important to you?I outlined my 4 key requirements (and got out ofI outlined my 4 key requirements (and got out ofthe way)the way)
What happened in the middle was powerfulWhat happened in the middle was powerful
The staff developed their dream within theThe staff developed their dream within theparametersparameters
AND, the results far exceed my dreams!AND, the results far exceed my dreams!
8/8/2019 Bucknell LTF5 Appreciative Inquiry
23/38
4 Simple Requirements from the4 Simple Requirements from theAssociate VP of ISRAssociate VP of ISR
1.1. Better service for the campus communityBetter service for the campus community
2.2. Happier staff with more rewarding jobsHappier staff with more rewarding jobs
3.3. Stop using the term User SelfStop using the term User Self--SufficiencySufficiency
4.4. Say NO much less frequently and thenSay NO much less frequently and thenonly thoughtfully soonly thoughtfully so
And we recognize the campus freeze onAnd we recognize the campus freeze onnew positions!new positions!
8/8/2019 Bucknell LTF5 Appreciative Inquiry
24/38
The 4The 4--D Cycle of AID Cycle of AI
Positive Core
DesignDetermine
what should be
Affirmative
Topic Choice
DreamImagine
what might be
DiscoveryAppreciate
what is
DestinyCreate what
will be
From The Power of
Appreciative Inquiry
8/8/2019 Bucknell LTF5 Appreciative Inquiry
25/38
8/8/2019 Bucknell LTF5 Appreciative Inquiry
26/38
The 4The 4--D Cycle of AID Cycle of AI
Positive Core
DesignDetermine
what should be
Affirmative
Topic Choice
DreamImagine
what might be
DiscoveryAppreciate
what is
DestinyCreate what
will be
From The Power of
Appreciative Inquiry
8/8/2019 Bucknell LTF5 Appreciative Inquiry
27/38
2002 Outcomes2002 OutcomesA new model developed by the staffA new model developed by the staffCalls to the Tech Desk are differentiated (students vs.Calls to the Tech Desk are differentiated (students vs.faculty/staff)faculty/staff)
Student employees (and a small staff) at the Tech DeskStudent employees (and a small staff) at the Tech Desk
focused on supporting studentsfocused on supporting studentsA new Call CenterA new Call Center takes all calls from faculty/stafftakes all calls from faculty/staff
80%80% of problems resolved at first point of contactof problems resolved at first point of contact
Procedures/handProcedures/hand--offs simplified in many casesoffs simplified in many cases
$30,000+ for contractors no longer needed$30,000+ for contractors no longer needed
Minimal backlog of casesMinimal backlog of cases delays measured in hoursdelays measured in hours
ProactiveProactive modemode fix problems before they are noticedfix problems before they are noticed
8/8/2019 Bucknell LTF5 Appreciative Inquiry
28/38
2002 Outcomes (continued)2002 Outcomes (continued)Delighted customersDelighted customers
The campus now believes that we are much moreThe campus now believes that we are much moreCustomerCustomer--FocusedFocused
High staff moraleHigh staff morale
People are matchedPeople are matched to their strengthsto their strengths and interestsand interests
We eliminated one staff positionWe eliminated one staff position
Several other people were redeployed to the right workSeveral other people were redeployed to the right work
We rarely need to say noWe rarely need to say no
This effort received a Bucknell Maxwell Award forThis effort received a Bucknell Maxwell Award forCustomer Service, Extraordinary Effort and EmbracingCustomer Service, Extraordinary Effort and EmbracingNew Directions!New Directions!
8/8/2019 Bucknell LTF5 Appreciative Inquiry
29/38
An Example AI Process:An Example AI Process:
This illustrates theThis illustrates the
Discovery stageDiscovery stageof a Formalof a Formal
Appreciative Inquiry CycleAppreciative Inquiry Cycle
Appreciate What Is!Appreciate What Is!
8/8/2019 Bucknell LTF5 Appreciative Inquiry
30/38
Provocative PropositionProvocative Proposition
Imagine that you return to work and find aImagine that you return to work and find atransformed organization. Everything workstransformed organization. Everything workswell. It is a highwell. It is a high--performing, customerperforming, customer--
focused library. It blends its service missionfocused library. It blends its service missionand its leadership role in perfect resonanceand its leadership role in perfect resonancewith the needs and aspirations of thewith the needs and aspirations of the
community. Its value and contribution arecommunity. Its value and contribution arewell known, openly appreciated andwell known, openly appreciated andfrequently celebrated.frequently celebrated.
8/8/2019 Bucknell LTF5 Appreciative Inquiry
31/38
8/8/2019 Bucknell LTF5 Appreciative Inquiry
32/38
The 4The 4--D Cycle of AID Cycle of AI
Positive Core
DesignDetermine
what should be
Affirmative
Topic Choice
DreamImagine
what might be
DiscoveryAppreciate
what is
DestinyCreate what
will be
From The Power of
Appreciative Inquiry
8/8/2019 Bucknell LTF5 Appreciative Inquiry
33/38
A Positive Description of anA Positive Description of an
Organizational CultureOrganizational Culture
Organizations are, first and foremost,Organizations are, first and foremost,centers of human relatedness andcenters of human relatedness andrelationships come alive where thererelationships come alive where thereis an appreciative eye, when peopleis an appreciative eye, when peoplesee the best in one another and thesee the best in one another and thewhole, when they share their dreamswhole, when they share their dreamsand ultimate concerns in affirmingand ultimate concerns in affirmingways, and when they are connected inways, and when they are connected infull voice to create not just new worlds,full voice to create not just new worlds,
but better worlds. By making itbut better worlds. By making itpossible for every voice to be heard, apossible for every voice to be heard, alife giving process is enacted.life giving process is enacted.
(from The AppreciativeOrganization by Harlene
Anderson, David
Cooperrider, et. al.)
8/8/2019 Bucknell LTF5 Appreciative Inquiry
34/38
Some Closing ThoughtsSome Closing Thoughts
The questions you ask help to create the realityThe questions you ask help to create the realityof your organization.of your organization.
Trying to magnify the positive builds energyTrying to magnify the positive builds energy
and enthusiasm into organizations.and enthusiasm into organizations.Appreciative Inquiry can be applied to virtuallyAppreciative Inquiry can be applied to virtuallyany aspect of an organization.any aspect of an organization.
Organizations need to regularly ask questionsOrganizations need to regularly ask questionsabout the structure and quality of their work, andabout the structure and quality of their work, andsearch to find the best ideas among them andsearch to find the best ideas among them andtheir customers.their customers.
8/8/2019 Bucknell LTF5 Appreciative Inquiry
35/38
BibliographyBibliography Appreciative InquiryAppreciative Inquiry
The Thin Book of Appreciative Inquiry, Sue AnnisThe Thin Book of Appreciative Inquiry, Sue AnnisHammond (Thin Book Publishing Co.)Hammond (Thin Book Publishing Co.)
The Power of Appreciative Inquiry, Diana Whitney &The Power of Appreciative Inquiry, Diana Whitney &Amanda TrostenAmanda Trosten--Bloom (BerrettBloom (Berrett--Koehler Publishers)Koehler Publishers)
Encyclopedia of Positive Questions, Vol. 1, DianaEncyclopedia of Positive Questions, Vol. 1, DianaWhitney, David Cooperrider, et. al. (LakeshoreWhitney, David Cooperrider, et. al. (LakeshoreCommunications)Communications)
The Appreciative Organization, Harlene Anderson, DavidThe Appreciative Organization, Harlene Anderson, DavidCooperrider, et. Al. (Taos Institute Publications)Cooperrider, et. Al. (Taos Institute Publications)
Appreciative Leaders, edited by Marjorie Schiller, et. Al.Appreciative Leaders, edited by Marjorie Schiller, et. Al.(Taos Institute Publications)(Taos Institute Publications)
The Far Side (various publications), Gary LarsonThe Far Side (various publications), Gary Larson
8/8/2019 Bucknell LTF5 Appreciative Inquiry
36/38
http://www.isr.bucknell.edu/About_ISR/Staff_presentations_and_http://www.isr.bucknell.edu/About_ISR/Staff_presentations_and_publications/Road_Less_Traveled_Paper.pdfpublications/Road_Less_Traveled_Paper.pdf
8/8/2019 Bucknell LTF5 Appreciative Inquiry
37/38
Other AI ResourcesOther AI Resources
The Appreciative Inquiry CommonsThe Appreciative Inquiry Commons((www.appreciativeinquiry.org/www.appreciativeinquiry.org/ ))
The Taos Institute (The Taos Institute (www.taosinstitute.net/www.taosinstitute.net/ ))
A Guide to Appreciative Inquiry, Bernard J. MohrA Guide to Appreciative Inquiry, Bernard J. Mohr(Pegasus Communications)(Pegasus Communications)
Second International Appreciative Inquiry ConferenceSecond International Appreciative Inquiry Conference((http://www.aiconsulting.org/conference2004/http://www.aiconsulting.org/conference2004/ Miami,Miami,
Florida September 19Florida September 19--22, 2004)22, 2004)
8/8/2019 Bucknell LTF5 Appreciative Inquiry
38/38
The End!The End!
Gene SpencerGene Spencer gspencer@bucknell.edugspencer@bucknell.edu
Maureen SullivanMaureen Sullivan -- msull317@aol.commsull317@aol.com