Post on 07-Apr-2018
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 1/247
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 2/247
bkhti d gr thri biblicl tudi
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 3/247
m
g . , g
Editorial Board:
r t. b
t- b lw
j i . rw
r
F F. v
k
c V
M. Ww
m 63
bkhti d gr thr
i biblicl tudi
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 4/247
bkhti d gr thr
i biblicl tudi
r b
f b l
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 5/247
bkhti d gr thr
i biblicl tudi
c © 2007 f b l
v. f w m m fm
m, m, ,
m f fm v m, x m x m-
1976 c w fm . rq f m w r Pm ff, f b
l, 825 h M r, , g 30329 u.
l f c c--P d
b / r b.. m. — ( f b l m ; . 63)
i f x.
ib: 978-1-58983-276-3 (. : . )
1. b— —c. 2. b, M. M. (M Mv-
), 1895–1975—c. i. b, r, 1961–. ii. f b l.
M (2004 : , tx.).
b600.3.b35 2007220.6'6092—22 2007035329
15 14 13 12 11 10 09 08 07 5 4 3 2 1
P u f m -f, fm i/i Z39.48-1992 (r1997) i 9706:1994
f m.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 6/247
Contents
v .......................................................................................................v
i: b, g b r b .................................................................................................... 1
ssays
d m gM J. b ................................................................................................. 9
l: r fm g c . wm ......................................................................................... 19
Pw, Eros, b gc M ........................................................................................ 31
x l: t c f J v f dv
b g .............................................................................................. 43
l, l, l: tm J cJ F-Wm ............................................................................... 63
d Fm cm: ix r f lm Pm f lm
c Mf ........................................................................................ 69
P P: l d 1–6dv M. V ............................................................................................ 91
t cM . V.........................................................................................109
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 7/247
Mw’ g : b MFm cm
c c. F.................................................................................119
b’ dm cv r f J M d: x vc J
P . ....................................................................................... 133
l ? r b b t t M’ Beloved
b M ...........................................................................................161
responses
b Fmm: g f b txk b ..............................................................................................175
u b’ Lexicon Dialogicae i c, ,
w tm, t MV k. r .................................................................................... 187
W c ............................................................................................... 205
c ....................................................................................................... 221
ix f ..................................................................................225
ix f ................................................................................................ 235
v ctt
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 8/247
Abbreviations
b b
b b rf l ABD Anchor Bible Dictionary. dv Fm. 6
v. w : d, 1992.t tm AS Aramaic StudiesBib BiblicaBibInt Biblical Interpretationbi b i b b
BTB Biblical Theology BulletinbZW bf z Zf fü m W-
fbZW bf z Zf fü m W-
fCBQ Catholic Biblical Quarterlyccl c cm: Ftl Fm f tm l
HBT Horizons in Biblical TheologyHUCA Hebrew Union College Annual ibc i: b cmm f t
Picc i c cmm IDB The Interpreter’s Dictionary of the Bible. g .
b. 4 v. v: , 1962. JAAR Journal of the American Academy of Religion JANESCU Journal of the Ancient Near Eastern Society of Columbia Uni-
versity JBL Journal of Biblical Literature JCS Journal of Cuneiform Studies JNSL Journal of Northwest Semitic Languages JR Journal of Religion
-v-
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 9/247
JJ m J f f JmJt J f f w tm m
JSOT Journal for the Study of the Old Testament Jt J f f tm m
cb w c bNIB The New Interpreter’s Biblevt m vm tmmb tl tm l PMLA Proceedings of the Modern Language AssociationPRSt Perspectives in Religious StudiesREJ Revue des études juivesRevExp Review and Expositor blb f b l m bbld f b l d blm f b l mm bt b t
m m SJOT Scandinavian Journal of the Old Testament tM f w tm M P tt t tx Wbc W b cmm Wut Wf u zm tm
v bbrViti
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 10/247
Introduction: Bakhtin,
Genre and Biblical Studies
Roland Boer
T vm g g mg g M B, g Sv- R . T g S B L’ A Mg S A (2004) - “B G.” I g m . A gg, g g M
B q g x.I m p, B . H p g p m. T v S p pp W g Sv U. O p pm , m VVv, g m mxp x Mx pp Vv’ m B’, p 1920, Marxism and
the Philosophy o Language (2006). B mp, Rabelais and His World (1984), Problems o Dostoyevsky’s Poetics (1984) Te Dialogic Imagi-nation (1982) m m m m, . M p - “B Vv” g , pg v m m, p v Mx , g v q g.
B I p, v, m p mB , m pp . W m -g g gp m: p v; vp gg ; v p m. A , monologic dialogic v. A gg, mg v ( ) p g
-1-
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 11/247
2 BAHI A GR HORy I BIBLIAL SUIS
m v, g v . H m xp g m q
“v” “v” p m m x. T mg g v m g R Pz’ m H (1989; 1990; 1993). B, v, g, gg mg g g gm.
T pp m p - chronotope. T m “m p,” B “ mp p p xp ” (B 1982: 84). T -p m p . y m m p-p v. T pp m p.
T gp m q gg. g, polyphony, m mp v x. T mp m m , m pp . T
g v unfnalizability , m g. H m p , v v mp— p g B’ homo absconditus. O , z p pp x. L , pp g, B mheteroglossia gg m. Heteroglossia, “ g,” g mm xg - gg, g, m ppv.
A fx, gg pp p gm-m, p gg. A m—z, pp, gm, g—p m p p -p x, pp gg. O , , m p mgg p.
A g v mv
pm . y B m v g. H p , gp m . I g carnivalesque xp v m mp m I v v. T vq m
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 12/247
BOR: IROUIO 3
Rabelais and His World (1984) p Problems o Dostoyevsky’sPoetics (1984). I pg mv v, p
m gg v; , vm , , vv p gz. Ap m pp Marxism and the Philoso- phy o Language (2006), R B’ m v p. I v grotesque, g, pg, g, x ; p-g, vg vg — v v v.
B mm m.Ap m g , g f p m, g m, vm . W f p “ pp,” “pm- pp,” xp B’g p g m m. T mg p B’ g m m g.
Fm m g q g g (x) g, m g v vg p. Sitz im Leben m G’g gj pp g pm,g m pp x’ p g x g q. I , g p, p p -, v -p . I m , V R m xp q-
g m ppv (1990; 1996).B m m m v
m g: g , , m g. T vm pp m m. R vm mv — —xp g pg: , xp B’ mg v, v v, mp g
. T, B m g mp v g m - m mvg B’ m . Sq p gg B q g p x,xpg p B p xmp.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 13/247
4 BAHI A GR HORy I BIBLIAL SUIS
T pg g , g B . T M
B m, , g gm m, v p g. B p-p m g H B. G, g B p p m v g H B. B g p m—G m, m m, —B m xp p p, mm xp mp H B. H - v m . I ppg g between pp B p p p g v .
m vv m m B . S mp g p, gg m m ( G,, Bm) g “ ” 1970 GPj S B L. I p, xm “p-p,” g g m p g
m vpm p gg, p,pgm, m-m , x, pp, gv . M pp . T B . T pv x - , p xp p v B’ x.
T v H B p (M, G, F-W-m, M, V), v p g g
pp J (V), m (F A). T (M) xp ppp m-p x.
g m B’ mm, - M g m m m.g B’ p g, v-p p g g g ,
mg p p p (F) (z). T pp v mv B g xp ppv F, z, Hg, L.T xp pp xg xmp m .
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 14/247
BOR: IROUIO
B G m B’ g g xm vpm J 1 Sm 20. H J’ v
S p’ ; G m xp . H q p -v, , v, J, S. B g xg, J’ . I g “” J, G gg, g, ppp.
Ug B’ g p, J F-Wm xp G 38 p v pv pv g g v.B m m gm, G 38 “p p” g g G. Mv, g v,mg, p m’ m ’ g Jp’ .
M G B ,g m pv -g m (g). F G g,
p m g g pp. Fxmp, mp, gvg, , g- pm, m. F B, g mf. H g Lm 1–2 p. S - v “m pp” “
v” p yhwh. M g p “” v pp .
v V Am x , gg gg xp ’ v
q g, , mp. ggg xv B, p p pg, V x .
I m, M V vJ ’ m “pp.” H ’ m, , gv B’ mm, V B’ p mg g pp m v m p.
Bgg B v m- M’ Gp, p F m p p g gg, g m (m, R, R, B). I mg p, F g x
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 15/247
6 BAHI A GR HORy I BIBLIAL SUIS
“g .” H p , mp- m, , , m,
mg pmg.P A v J m-
g g. H g B’ v mg pm. H xp “pp” x, , m, p-, g m J x. Hv,A g g x, g B’ g, , “ .”
T , B M, p , B mp . I pg gg, M M’ Beloved . xg B’ gz, xm pp A mg mg v. M g-g m gg- v— vv, A p-, B—
p p, p - pp “mm” A mg.
W gg vm B m, gg, , -
v vm. W v mg , (1998), B (1990), g(1992), (2003), O (1998), W (1997), m v - B, p x (R [1993] xp ).R Pz, I , z
mv g m (1980) Sm (1989; 1993). g m vq (199),B G gv , g B(2000) 1 Sm (2003), v g - . T mgp m m m B’ M (2003). A , v v H B, vg m (Bg 1999), Pm (Lv1992; M 2002; 200), Lm (M 2001), J (m
1996; 2002; 2003), p m 1993 Semeia vm z (M 1993; M 1993). F, B m, , “G Sm” (2004). T , , - mv v.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 16/247
BOR: IROUIO 7
A , F M, pmm g vm, Im Am,
g.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 17/247
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 18/247
Dialogue in and among Genres
Martin J. Buss
O th t pt t bb tt , p th t t ph b p t th v -t p b th . wht xtt bb t ht q tht th tt tt- qt, bt tht w b th h b. T p pt th ph wth th Hbw Bb.
T t pt t b tht address orm is a basis on which a genre,or speech type, can be identifed . S th w “” th tt-
t, w bt wht I b “.” Ntv (tG), I jt th t tht hv “,” tht , th thtth ht w w t tz . It, tth wthth t tht, I pt th vw tht w tt t ph tth. I ptv t, Ipt G’ th t th tt : tt (Ip t “p”), t tt, vb . A thth t b t t ttt . F t, t
p, th “t” pt , tt whttt pp tt wht xp . Fth, p tth t tt, h th- vt bt th wth, pt t . I t, v G , t ph -t (h p, wth pt, th t) b tt,thh h hv htt t. T, tv—tht , tp q t— f tt th b th t
. G w t tt b vb t t Sitz im Leben t
t pt; hwv, vb pv h vt té (
B 999:247).
-9-
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 19/247
0 BAkHIN AND GN HOy IN BIBIcA SDIS
, thh th hv v tt p t .
T th t t— p, tt, vb —t wth h th t t xtt, bt t Gp. T t t p bt bt t .F t, t t, t tb tht th tt xp pt tht th vb th p tht p. yt th tt th vb pb b p th t.2
I th pt txt, I w wth ptt th pp thph th Hbw Bb. I , I w b wth vb tt,p wth , bt I w v vb ptt t
vw t t wth tt p.M t xp w b tp ph tht bb t f
“w.” w t pt b thttv tht t t z pb. Wth th t,v vt b btp, whh thv hv thbv.
I btp, th pb th p th -
v w (t th tt ). Athh p b , th t pt p , tht p vv thp.
I bv th tht pp th D, G pt I th t p, thh M t G’ thp(x 20:–4; Dt 5:4–5). I th bb txt, th t—t whh p -p , thh th ptv th th tv bt— G’ “w” (debarim).I t hw th t t wth tt p, Ph
pt t tht t hhht th p ht bb w tht vv t btw pp G t h- b t t (Dec. 36–39). I t, th “w” qt v h p t p ppt. O
2. M pt ( ph tp), wth whh I hv pt 969:
, w: () G b t th b t t,
tht th t , b b wth, h th. (2) G pbbt,t tt. (3) h tt bt tt t h p-
th th t zt t, thh ttt t th
t t th t t . (4) G ptt
th tt (t t) p bt (t -
pt) bt t pppt t tt.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 20/247
BSS: DIAOG IN AND AMONG GNS
: Wht t t hv th “b” ? A ptt t “whp” th? Wht ttt “w” tht
phbt th Sbbth? Hw “h” pt? Fth,, thf, t, wt w b t. T -ttt jt , jt t, t., wtht p t wht t jt ( t, bth Jwh cth t-t, h p’ t b t thf). T, ttt w t v pt , wh t f t th txt.T tth t b ppt t pttvb p, bt t t p x ptth t t ttt.
I th btp -p tv, G M,wh t p th t th pp t A th pt-tv th pt. T tv th t p. Qt w th t -p th w thv th b tt pt b w ( th B 977).
I Dt, th t vb t t Gbt M, wh p t th pp bh G. M qt th ct G’ t w t I, bt thw h v
tt tht f hv xpt htt ht, tht .3 M th xhtt ht th ht, btM t th It t xtt th ct (Dt 7:–5).T, b xpv th tt v w, th ph,t, hw t t wth tt p.4
W w t ptt w t th ,whh w tht pppt th p tp ph. v jt w xp: Pvb t v p.Wh th , th th - “ptv” th vb, whh
z tv h th v t v. At th t, pv-b w p, p t b q bhv whh h b t t t b th h. Bth pp p t v’ t t w-b, - -pt, jt t phph f . T tt ’ hv p wth - v vt p tt tv. Wh th p pvb t-, t pt, wh pt th b S (:) b ’
3. S th vt th ph v : 835.
4. Wth th b H, , ph b G p th ph t
t ( B 969:60–69).
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 21/247
2 BAkHIN AND GN HOy IN BIBIcA SDIS
th (3:). Nvth, p w, php ht G, t (8:4–36). T th t wth t, thh
t p th w.I tt t Pvb, Qhth phz th tv t-p
“I,” wth t xp. T “I” pbb t p tht vwt bt pt t w t t.5 It - t p Qhth wth Pvb w tht tht th hv pp. Pvb f v t tht pt t. I tt pp, w ,Qhth pt t , tht bvb ww bth wtt t.6 O Qhth v v, bttht v t tht j , tt t ph hvt (2:24, t.). B t b v jt pt ( Fx:2–3),bt th h v tht h t ht h bt (7:6–8; 8:–4; :9). I t th qt hw Qhtht t th Hbw Bb wh, t h b z tht thhth Hbw Bb qt t th t tt, t v pt h p th pt hpp. Sh pt
pt th th ct p G 2 Qhth(2:). Fth, Qhth’ v t j t ptt th th ct t t wth (2:26), tht, th pt t t, Qhth t tt th tt thHbw Bb. M t , t b , th th b,whh t t Qhth’ t-p ph (2:3–4). I thw, Qhth t t th-t bt th I-t, tt t. yt t pt tt pt .
Dt , th S S, h v pt --
t, t btw v, wh j h th. T b t Qhth tht v vt . I t, G t v p th th p. I tt tht, th Sb Qhth tht t tt jt, t th. Hwv,
5. h pt ppt b th t tht “I” t “” :2 (th, ht,
Shb: 65). A t M (07), th “I” pt “
t xp th h.”6. c. . ht Qhth’ b wth I php
b ppt b th h t th P 39:5–7, 2; 62:0; 73:2–2; 90:5–6; 94:;
44:4; Pv 5:8, wth / (thh th txt h t
t), b th bvt tht b Qhth’ t th th
“” It w (Fh: 37–39).
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 22/247
BSS: DIAOG IN AND AMONG GNS 3
t h th pt v ptv th th tv t. I t p tt, th S ppp th php pp
(wth th “” t tph ), wh Qhth pt t b tt (wth ht tht b t p-I-t J).7 yt, pt th , b hv b t tw wth bth th , w b tht bzb S.8
T t th Hbw Bb b z t tt. I t wth h vw, t ptt t t tht v , wth t p vt tt, pt th. Sh pt t p tv. T th-p t v ttv t-pttt whh th pt thht b ht ppp tv .
pt t pt, th, b whh b t, t t pt.
M pt tht the Hebrew Bible is largely arranged according towhat appear to be culturally signifcant genres, which each represent a dimen-sion o lie and which engage metaphorically in a dialogue with each other .
I, th zt th Hbw Bb v t hw I-t t tz txt, th t tht t txt p tthpbb t th b vw t h th. F t,t wht w “h” “p t” t tth b. S, thttv tv t tth p. Pv-b, t t, v h p tth.St bt th th w, ht, I’ ttt ( th “tv tt”) t -pt t t G x.
T q th t tht v bb b, -t p b, wth p pt It . I bvth ph, h z tht h q, t t pb, vt p. At v h b ptpt th, thh t v w t phz th q. It tht t , t pt t b t pt th tvt bh th. T, t bb
7. h ph “ wh w b ” w t ph (Sw: 24), bt
t tht t p-It “J,” xp t, pt
vw (. G 4:8–20).
8. Abh b z t p bth pt, wth
v t v pt.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 23/247
4 BAkHIN AND GN HOy IN BIBIcA SDIS
w tvt ptv b , pt, ppht, -“w”— “”—p, thh th “w” pbb
wh w t hh pz. T zt th th v t, tht v pt t tth pt, v ppht pp th, vt b t th ph th t w (p, ) th , wth tt.9
xtt, th v p pt wth th, th t b t t. F t, I t h wh hv vv t pt tht h h th qt t wht xtt h w p h t whtxtt h w p j . b , p b b.Nvth, th h tph b h btw th t pt th btw th whh th xp. Sh t hv t b t-th h, .
O w whh th btw pp th HbwBb tht w G t h b, hhht pt th Bb, pt w t tw G th pt.
G h b, -t-, v wth h th. Nth thtw th vt p t th th, thh thzt th pv v vt.0 I t, h thj t tt wth t t wht tp th tt. Sp, th Ptth, vt p t v-t, t wth G p— th phpp th Hbw pt— th b P .
A ptt qt w whth t pb t t th -
tt th pt th pt. At v b v,th t p w-h v h. Hwv, thp t tht pp h pt w v t t t. O th hw th bb ptt wthI . F btt w, w t w th w t th qt, t h t t bb wt. v t t tht th wtw t tt h th t t f th tt
9. h pt th b D th th v b t th (
bth) tw : () th ppht w ; (2) tptt
vt hv tt w th t v vt.
0. F th b I Abh, H. W. b, Wth
Z, c Wt, Gh v , B 999:375–79.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 24/247
BSS: DIAOG IN AND AMONG GNS 5
th Ft p, t pb v tht th ptt . It w b t w th ht th , bt bt
t b t bt th -ht vt t p ttt tth ph p tht t t th ptv thp t.
A th p t ptvt tv tvt. I t z th , t hp t tht ph t. I A p t B, A t B. I tt, t t p-t ptvt. T t p pv p, , th th ptt ph “tv t,” v tttt, v p, th th.
Stt t h p, v w th Ptth, thPpht, wh ppp xp ptvt th pt h. A, th t vv p pvt; th, w pph- pt p t tvt, h t th t t.Hwv— jt tht qt w th—th t tp v th ht th vv b p, tph t tth th.
I tt, p t pt h tvt,
p, t t bt w t p th vwtht xtv v vt. yt th th b whh h tpp—P, Jb, Qhth— xp p G. P pp G’ . Jb Qhth v v t b xp t v p, th th t h t t t t hv . T, ptvt tvt twv vt bb b, thh tw.
O b, th S S, t tht t
tt btw pt. T w’ v wht xtvth th ’. It bth p th S, tht th t-
v pt v pt t b th w. ytS’ pp th p v, th ’ v tq xtt t th w’.2 p ptt, php, th t thtth pph th tw t h th pb. I t, t pp tht hh tt v qt htt—thh, t
. Mt p t tw h t th t th, whh th
w “G” t v pp th th p, thh G pb t
th b.
2. I xp pt b, th p th bt
w b h th (3:).
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 25/247
6 BAkHIN AND GN HOy IN BIBIcA SDIS
b , t v t— v pt. T ph w -t tht th v t t tw qt t t tt, v
wh t ptt hh.W hv th tht p btw .
Fth—th th pt— tht dialogues exist meta- phorically within genres, t t h.
T w t th bb txt h ptt pt p-t x. I t , th hv b t t ttv b th Bb t pt wth th b htt. I p, th t p. Wh w t
b p, w t t t , wtht ttpt t -tt tht bh th b tht p. I th , “-” x. yt, t bt tht t t tt b xt p ht wh. It pppt t z v wth th txt t p th v-t pt t wth h th. Tt , w h vw vb t tht h xp t th tht t pptv b xp wth tht .
T ppht b H tt th tt. It h b
z t tht hpt –3 ttt px tht wht t hpt 4–4. O xp th ph t t th t w: () tw j th vv; (2) th twpt t t p H’ ; (3) th tw pt wttt b t . Hwv, v w w b t twhh th ttv— php t th — t, hw w t h t t th b, xpt b v tptt t vw pt t th th. Fth,php ptt, th th tw j px pp t bt h. p t th w pbb tht t p th v pt. T ttpp t t b t th b Jb t wh thh ph.
D t h txt hv v tht bht thvt t tth? I th bt t. I pt tht th w tpt th t th v t tb th hp, thhth jtt. I th w, bb txt h-
th tt w . Af , th th w t pv vt ht. A q pph h th v pt h t tt t, jt w w t xpt th hh-qt pt t b .
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 26/247
BSS: DIAOG IN AND AMONG GNS 7
T t t Mh Bht’ v- t-ptt Rabelais and His World (984b).3 It t, hwv, p
h h. th, th tt pt ptt tht h , tth wth whh th b . T th th pt “ph t” whh pp b th v vvt .
I hv, th, t th th ppt. () A , whh b t t pt , b whh b t,t t pt. (2) T Hbw Bb t ,whh b t t t wth h th. (3) Wth h, th v tht, t, ttt .
A th pt tht I wt t t th b w: the HebrewBible enters or can enter into a dialogue with other literary complexes. T - p t p b . Wh h t, t w b tht th t tht pp th HbwBb t, bt t qt t wth, th t tht p-t th tt. I t t th p tht hv b t Qhth th S S, t v
jt xp.
T H h wth th Jwh Bb t th j t . Hwv, th H pvh v w b p h th t vt pt th , wh th v t th Jwh . T t wt th t pt tht H t t vt.T, th wth t.
I h p, t f tpt t w thtt p b t ’ w. A , hwv, t t t whh t b p. th, t t
tt th th ’ w t whth th tht b . Attv, ht p t t t bth v-t. Fth, p—h w , — twth tvt, f t t btt ’ w tt.
I, th p th th Hbw Bb wth th th t t pt tht pph. Bb b p vt wth pt- ph.bt, j wh G’ bb b
3. S Nw 2000:26. A vw p t th pph;
th tt t t “t,” t Bht 984:6 Nw
2003:26.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 27/247
8 BAkHIN AND GN HOy IN BIBIcA SDIS
w pp tht h b th w tht hhht p- tht t wth w xt.
I ht, w hv w whh th t b j t th Hbw Bb.th, th hw t btw .Bb G (2003:4–59) h, v tt w, pv - t btw 2 S.Php, thh pt, — — b xt t t th wh th HbwBb.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 28/247
Spying Out the Land: A Report rom Genology*
Carol A. Newsom
B ss s , s s, s s s s. F ss vs s k s s v- s. A Gk s vs svss (.., sss, Gs) s, . Ds s, k s , s s s s ssv vs s . F -
s, s, s s s Gattungen xs. I s -s s s vs sss s s Mk Bk (986) s s “s s” ss, s’s s s s s Gattungen. M s, s’s Sitz im Leben s s s s s s. I, s s k
k R Jss (982), Ksz s “ ss,” szs - s s s xs. Jss ss v s ss ss s-s v ss “ s s s s s,” s k Gk, Ds, B. Ds s ss,v, s s k s ss s “ s,”
ss ss (Bss 999: 25, 255, 259).
* R Ns 2005.
. S Bss 999:227–28 sss s Gk.
-9-
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 29/247
20 BAKIN AND GNR OR IN BIBLIAL SDIS
A s ss s “ ” ss 970s s
SBL Gs Pj, R Fk. Gs ss vs s , s, s, , s. Rss s s s vssss Semeia v q s sss s s.2 S , s, vs v s-s v z s (.., B 992; s995), vs ss ss -s s.
I s ss I s k sv v s s ss sss ss. I z s sss I x s As G SBL s s Semeia 4, Apocalypse:Te Morphology of a Genre (979), vs sss, s, qss s s s. M s ss s k As G. , v s-v s , q ss s sv -
k s ssv s ss v. B ss, k ss s s, s sss s .
s ss , As G s sk s ss, s ss s s “ xs k sv ss s z ” (s 979:). s s s “s” , xs
“” , ’s “s.” I sv s s s s vs s xs s ss xs. s s s k “x.” Ov s q -, v, ss v s sss s s s ss s. T js sv ss. D ss s s s s s . As
As F ks, s . “Is s ss s, ” (F
2. S Semeia (978), 20 (98), 22 (98), 29 (983), 36 (986).
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 30/247
NwSOM: SPING O LAND 2
982:22). Mv, ss ss v s,s s . Ts F js s-
s s s s s, s k s (36). “M” ss ss v x—v s s xs— “ , v, v, s” v s s (23).
T js ssss s s D , ss-, v s. I s x s D s “ x ” “sk s — k , v s s” (D 2000:224, 230). I -, s s D’s k x’s s - xs s s k xs s , vk , s , , s , . w s ss, ssf ks xs s s ss s -
. I s s k x ss ks xs.
ss s v s s , f q s ss ss sv s vs ss . Ts A Rs, Te Power of Genre, s s s k s s “s ” s.D s . . G’s “ k s s-
, ss,” s s s s xs v ss. Ts s
x xs —“s wss B” “ wv”—s s k , , s.… w s s, , v, ss k s [] sk ss.… ss x, , s v- k sks s s , , s
. I ks ss ss, ss s -s . (Rs 985:2–22).3
3. F s , s 986: 203–8.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 31/247
22 BAKIN AND GNR OR IN BIBLIAL SDIS
Ts s s s Rs, “v” s s s
s s ’s ss .T s Semeia 4 v s s
s , s sv s apokalypsis ss s “ .”R “ ‘s’ s s ss ‘s’ ” (s 979:2). I s s, j ss s s s s s . Nvss, s s s Semeia 4 s s s v s sss k x sss s ss s. T s s, I j s s s sv s sv . I s s, s ss v ss.
v ss v ss, v, s vvs s s
xs ss v s. M ssssv s s s s ss. O s s xs s v ws’s s. I Philosophical Investigations ws s qs s vs s s:
s, s, s, O s, s . w s ? … I k s s s all, ss, ss, ss
.… w s k ss v ss-ss: ss v ss, ss ss .—A I s s: “s” . (ws 958:3–32)
A z F (4–42) s s k , s s s ss sss ss s s s . O , s, ss s s s s ss s-ss
s, s s ss vk . F sss s “s ss ss” “ ” (4). I ks “ s” s ss. I, s s, s s ssv
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 32/247
NwSOM: SPING O LAND 23
s sv . B v s s s s . F x, xs A
x s , , , B x s , , , x s , , , s . O s f - s s xs s s ! As J Ss(990:5) ks, “ s k s.”4
A s - ks vks x. J (975:39) ss s k ss xs s -s: “A k s xs, v s s ssxs k s s v s.” O ss s s sss sss q ss xs. ’s s s v - s ss “ s s k v xs v s -
v s ” (47). I ss As G s s x, s xs s v s ss . B s s ss x. ’s s s s v s x’s vs. s , v, s s s, s F s s ’s “,
v, v, s,” s v xs s s, s v s s s s (F: 23). w A-s G ss ss, x s F s ss.
As s v x , s s ss s
q ss , s s s sk
4. S s x x s Dv Fs-
v 993:53–68.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 33/247
24 BAKIN AND GNR OR IN BIBLIAL SDIS
s ss. O s s vs x z s s -
v s s v s s . S s s s , s s s. Tk s v s s s s s sv s ssss v xs sv s s s ss ss v.I ss xs 970s Rs (975) s s s ss . F s, v s,ss, ss, s, s s, s ss s “” s s ss s s “.” Ts s ss s “.” T x v s (.., s s), s s s s v ss. s s s s. I s (S-
2002:86).O vs s vs
ss s ss ss s v s . A s vs s s , s v s v s q s (Ss: 52). As s, q xs ss v s ss ss .
s j As
G? I , s v k s k . s s:
s sss ss s - “” s xss - s s s ( k) Jsks D (s. 7–2), , 4 z 2 B sk Rv. s s xsv s s s x s s. (s 979:3)
ss z s “,” s x qs sv s s . As s s s
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 34/247
NwSOM: SPING O LAND 25
As G “ s [] s v k,” s, s s s-
v ks (9–0). Ts s s v s s .
s s s s - s s s. B ss s . s s s s s vv v s k k s. T - s s ss x(S 2002:93–94). B , “” s “ .” B ks P, z, Ms vs s . T s s-k s ss s ’s s , ss sx , vv ( ) . O “zv ” s “” k ss.5
T s s ss v s s “-s” s
Gestalt s svs s z v . Ts s k ss . S Gestalt s s -s, s s ss s, v xs xs s s s z s x s “ s x” (S 2002:96).
s As G s v s k Gs s ss sss “ .” As
, “ s k sv ss s” (s 979:0). S, “s-” s k ss, k v, xs v , s s, s. “T s, , s v s xss s s s- sv s v” (). Ts k
s, s s s, vss s v xs (
5. “z v ” s Lk 987:68.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 35/247
26 BAKIN AND GNR OR IN BIBLIAL SDIS
k Rv). “” s s ss (.., s ) , v,
Js ss (.., As wks s Lv2–5) s s (.., v k vs s sv s ss).T Gestalt s ( z v ) zs zs xs ss s .
P , v, s ss . ss, , s . Ds x ? Ds s ? k s xs s s ss xs -s (S 2002:92). I M-L R (98:8)ss xs “ ” “ss ” xs s “ k s s s s - s s, s qs-ss vs s qs, s .” T s q- v s, s q k. Ts
s ss vs k Js S v sss s s s ss ks s - ss.
O s s , s ss ss s s . M S, s vs , s , s s- s s v F,
s s. T s s - xs s s ss x s s “ s v s ,as a genre, s ” (S 2002:93).6 , , As Gks s sv s “ s, s v” (s 979:).F ss , s s js. B v ss s
s. S s s sss s s .
6. S s s Fsv F, sss .
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 36/247
NwSOM: SPING O LAND 27
T s s s ss v . Rs s
s s s s “” s v,sv sv, ss s s (s D 2000). Tsxs vs s ss s s-s s, s, s, T Bz’s s J ss. Rs’s s s s s- s v s ss xss ’ss ss. N ss, s ss s s s D’s v,v s F Bè’s L’évolution des genres, -s 890. A v s z, sv Dv Fsv, s s D s s s s s s v s x “s,” s Fsv s (35–52).
F ss s v, s s x ss s s, s s ss ss (s b.c.e.)
s Js ( f B Kk v), s s s, ss. Mv, s Js ss ss s , s f . T ss s s v q x s s, s, svs, s s s v s s.
A s ss sv s s s s s
s. T Rss Fss, , k qs v s s s vs ss s .7 w s s S , s Rss Fss s v-s s ws , s qs. B s sk s ss v, s-, , , , k, s s S . w s s?
A s s s? A s s ss f s
7. s s v Skvsk v.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 37/247
28 BAKIN AND GNR OR IN BIBLIAL SDIS
s f B Kk v? Sk-vsk s s s
v f ss, , s s, qs v v s (D: 7).
v Skvsk s , s s— k’s v ss s s—ss s ss v . w s q vs s s sss, ks s s ss .F ss ss s ss “v - k s s s . Ts s vs s s. T s v k, v s ks svs vs, vss s , ” (F: 23). F’s sv s s Mk Bk’s (98:28) xs s s - s . N s v q ss v s s . Ts v s s s ss s
s, s-ss v s s.T s s v .
Bk, v, z s s s s svs. I x ss “ s s s s, s ss” (Bk 984:06). Ts x s s , s s s. “A vs s,
s remembers s s, s . G s sv v ss v.” Bk’s ss s s (Ts984:35).
w s s s sv s s s s s ss, s s . B s
ss - ss. M ss ss, s ss, s, v ss. Ts, , v s v s xz s ss.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 38/247
NwSOM: SPING O LAND 29
As s f, Bk s ssv ss. s sss s s, s -
q, s As G s “xs” s v . v s s xsv ss v, s “ ” k Gs F Mk (2002). A s s x s , I js s s ss, ss s v k s - s s ks “ ss.” Ts s, ss, k s s s s s. T xs s s s ss, s sss s s (S 2004). Nv-ss, v s vs, s, vs s, v, sss, s s v -z s ss. O, s s s ss ss v
s xs s.A sv s s s vs-
s k Bk .F Bk s s s s . T vk Pv Mvv s s s s: “v s s s s s z , ss .... ss s z s sv ss s .… T s s s
s ” (Mvv 978:33). Mvv s s z ss ss , s s v.Gs s ss xsss ss vs. Ts x -s s qs k thinking s qua .
B qs? Bk’s k
v v s s , , s , s s s-ss s (Bk 98:85). Ts v v s s s ss (js, vs,x s, ks, .) s s s s
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 39/247
30 BAKIN AND GNR OR IN BIBLIAL SDIS
( s s, vs, ss ss sq, .). B s,
Bildungsroman s q v s ss . Ts s v s k s s s. I, v s s s.
A s s x -v ss, s s s . Ass, , s v ss . T sv s v k s s v s ss. s svs q s k, ss Bk’s s ss s v.
O , s, , I s s v s s vs ss v. A s s z-
s q, I ss s v k x k s Bk s s v vs v . N v v ss Bk Mvv v , Bk ’s ss s s ss s s v v s s. Gv s - s ss, s v s k s s
v ss .
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 40/247
Power, Eros, and Biblical Genres
Chitine Mitchell
What Is Genre?
B g g gv.… W gv p . (B 1986:119–20).
B pp g gv: gv . T -
g, , vp pp g. G p . T p v g , - Np F (247–48), p g. W , T B, g v g p: (1) -g-R “p-” , , “g ”; (2) , g g g g, , “g p”; (3) - , g g, , “g p
”; (4) - , g g g , / , , “g v”(2–3). I , g g p, g g vp g( pp pp) q p. B jpg -g g (..,g -), vv
g , p g v p, g , , g g- (C 2003). I v g
-31-
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 41/247
32 BkIN N GNR Ry IN BIBIC uI
g B ppv, B’ - p g g v.
T I gg p q “ g” gv : g . . T pp g W g gv p ; G R, v pp -W B. I , v, g g pp -
v pp, pp g g vpg v g. v, , R : v g v g; z g v - pv g (26–33); , g “g g v g pp v” (: 203).I p, , v g B v. u p, . I I p vp g v. g I I pg v, I p v g , I pg v, g
(pg) p gg g. g p B (v),
g pj g g. I , g ’ g v (. :73–74,93; g g g -, I g ). I , g —
“” “p” (. I). I gg, g J , - g v g p, “ g -” (204), , I M. M. B p. g B’ v g ’, v B’ . I, vp g (g P) , g J, g , “
, vg p v p” (17).I , Pblem Dtevky’ Petic, B ,
g, v , , “” - ’ vp. pv g g
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 42/247
MIC: PWR, E, N BIBIC GNR 33
achaic. , pv enewal , , pz.
g , -.… g v p, emembe p, gg. (1984:106; p g)
T q p g z q gg pp. T g B g.B g, “F g g,, ” (1984:106). B
“ Nv,” g v p p v g g (. 1981:263–65).
v B’ g . C g , ; - . I eade p g (1990:305). “[F] p v,g p - p ( - ) ” (1990:306). I , B v p, . v, , g . I “ Nv,” Bp g g - v (1981:259).
v g B , g v B’ . I
“T P p G,” , “[] p p ” (1986:63): “g, p g.… p pp g p p ” (64). , “W g. T g , g , v gv g” (66). ’ p p g p pg .
G, B, :“T g p v p p, ” (C: 326). g g;
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 43/247
34 BkIN N GNR Ry IN BIBIC uI
, gg (B 2002:163–64). I, F ,
B, “ g g ” (188). ,g G M, B’ v g g p v: g p v.G ppv, g “ g’ ” (410–11). I , g, gvg -g , , p - . , g pv p (B’ p). G j gv: .
q B’ I gg , g gv gv . T p g : p q— . y, “ pg , g g p p , p p” (B
1986:79). I g , g p: B , I , v , . I g z g.
p, I p C,2 C 13:23–15:15, gg g ( p- kg). T g “I ” (2 C 13:23); J M p v jg (81; . W-: 259; Jp: 719), Jg 3:11, 30; 5:31; 8:28. T p
pp z 2 C 15:3–6 p jg, “F g I … .… I p [Mwl#] g .… p [wttkw], g g .” T q Jg, p Jg 17–21; P’ g gg g g v p- C (138). T gg p jg g p p pp , aheim,
2 C 14:2— p C, pp Jg (p Jg 6)— v (15:8) g z’ p. Jp gg pp , “ -g g” p C,
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 44/247
MIC: PWR, E, N BIBIC GNR 35
’ gv C kg (707). T ttk “ p”
v g g (2 kg 18:4; 2 C 34:7) pg/pg (I 2:4; M 4:3;J 4:10); g p/. I gg, , C g Jg p-p g p g p jg (pp G). z pp p pp “ yhwh, G I, g , ”(15:4); gg v’ g 1 C28:9 Jg 10:10–16 ( q p ’/’ [Pz 1980:176–77]).
T gg Jg, p, z’ p 2 C15. B g gg, C. F p pp p gg g g f, p I gg. Tg g C, g Jg ( g ) f g
: pp g T efect g.v, B g
q v g g v g. I vg p , . I B g, I p g . I g p, p p g g g .
What Is Power?
[P] p . I pp .(F 1978:86)
B g v p. T xAko pp , g G. Pp v p, G
p. T M F “le Puvi ,” g p p : “I ‘P’ gp v z gv … [] jg , v,
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 45/247
36 BkIN N GNR Ry IN BIBIC uI
… [] g gp v , , g v v,
pv ” (1978:92). R, p “ p- p p … g ” (92–93). p, , gv, .
T p p, ,g p , .B v , v p p , p : p . B, F v , g p , p p p p; F’ p g (B: 85–90). T , p p g pv p, p v. F’ g g gg p v p j(1983:221–22) ( p ). B g, pp p v— p z g.
T p g , pv. I g , g p, p g p-. g F p p (le puvi ) v pv p-g p, p p p p, g p- p. G p, p p. g gv g g p-. I
C p-.T C’
kg. T kg : Mybtk Mh-)lh …-l( “ …” (1 kg 11:41; 14:29; 15:7; 23, 31; 16:5, 14,20, 27; 22:39, 46; 2 kg 1:18; 8:23; 10:34; 12:20; 13:8, 12; 14:15, 18, 28; 15:6,21, 36; 16:19; 20:20; 21:25; 23:28; 24:5; 2 C 9:29;12:15). T C : Mybwtk Mnh …-l( “B, ….” (1 C 9:1; 29:29; 2 C 9:29; 16:11;
20:34; 24:27; 25:26; 27:7; 28:26; 32:32; 33:18, 19; 35:25, 27; 36:8; 1 kg 14:19; 2 kg 15:11, 15, 26, 31; pg -p C). I , j , “,” g kg C. I kg, : h#&( r#$)(-lkw)—yrbd rtyw “
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 46/247
MIC: PWR, E, N BIBIC GNR 37
X () ” (1 kg 11:41; 14:29; 15:7, 23, 31; 16:5, 14, 27; 22:39,46; 2 kg 1:18; 8:23; 10:34; 12:20; 13:8, 12; 14:15, 28; 15:6, 21, 26, 31, 36; 16:19;
20:20; 21:25; 23:28; 24:5). T v p , p : . I C, : Myn#$)rh—yrbd (rtyw)Mynrx)hw “ ( ) X, g ” (1 C 29:29;2 C 9:29; 12:15; 16:11; 20:34; 25:26; 26:22; 28:26; 35:27). g, v p . Cg p kg C, v . T lxx ; g, p J B’ g v p lxx mt g/ (265–72). I mt, v, v- p . I p g ppv I g p gp / v .
T C -kg p v . B v C , -
, v C , f (, .g., kpp: 126). W g p p v p. W C ( ; . : 119) W v- W v- -kg gg v (.g., g J 2 C 10) I
v q v g - p.
I g gv. I p p g. T p v, pv Mybwtk Mnh “ -” (W ’C:40.2.1) q Mybwtk Mh-)lh “ ” (W ’C: 40.3). - q p g gv: “
B kg I J” p- ( g ) : “N, , .” B : “, B kg I J.” T p. , p“ X ” kg p
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 47/247
38 BkIN N GNR Ry IN BIBIC uI
g’ kg, . T , , -
p v p C: g f. B C ; “ X, g ” ; g’ , p g g’ g. T C , g , p - p C. W g -kg C, C g v: p vg , . T, I g, p p. T q g : kg , “I v , ;” C , “I v , ,” v C, ! T p g C.
What Is Eros?
“F , ,” , “ , v.” “W, ” “I gg gg .”(P, ymp. 206, . B)
P e (P, Phaed . 237).
f , e g ( epublic ). P g p , g, p g “ , pg ,” e (12). gg p g, e g , g p ; j e p p (13). u, W e P, p ympium Phaedu—
epublic . I ympium, - e: e v — v, p ; e v g— — I v q. E,, , pv , .
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 48/247
MIC: PWR, E, N BIBIC GNR 39
E v W pp : g, Nz, F Ig,
F. v, g p e pv, p G z. I f F’ , z :“T , M , , g , I deie; v , I p g vg = , p.… F [z], p ; gv” (189, p g). I v e, p: g, ; v .I , I g, v p( z: 186: “p .”). epublic. v e p, e v v p— p — e g. E v p ; e v g . g, p g, v e, p- e pv . g gv g g
g p- e, . , I g, v p p.
I p p , gz p . I , , v g ; v v ( I v). I , I v - p pp
. g I v g pp , p g g .1 I v
1. I p B ( p; . q: 188), v
, F R Pz Cpv
pg C uv, p g . I
-1990, p “ppg” , pp , “y pp . g
g .” Pz g
, p g-
vp g
. I p . M’
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 49/247
40 BkIN N GNR Ry IN BIBIC uI
, I - . M pv p
p F p, p g; B g, F p, z .
T p p v, 2 C 32:19, : “ p g J g pp , .” T p v q Ml#wry-yhl), “g J.” T v C’ v ’ v J, v kg. T v gg pg 2 kg 18–19 I 36–37,gg p pg, p p gg 2 C 32. I p yhwh p g . v, 2 C 32:19 q p. I p p: g g. B g , gg p yhwh, yhwh p J
( I ethn) ’ p 2 kg I. T p, g (. R), v p p, p . T C, pp (1 C 16), p, p, vg, g . , , p e . I p e p, F, g, . v . B z g v; “z” “ g pp, G, , ” “z”
“gv p [] p -p” (G: 196–97). W, , p e v g
p p, ’ v J, p g, pp kg C, “gp,” I, “pp.” y 2 kg Iv v ,
, “ v gg - g …
g g g , , g , -
” (289).
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 50/247
MIC: PWR, E, N BIBIC GNR 41
I kg, p- “ ,” (.g., Bpp: 461)—
I, p pg v 2 kg, y ’ (377–84), B’ g, p p— C v. M p, C “gv” kg I .W I p , v . W v g g g 2 kg
18–19 : (C: 69–103; Cg : 240–44). T kg (, .g., G 1–2 , 1 17; 2 21), pg p v pv : g p . T g- kg pg g- - C. T p :
p g p, g , C’ v g 2C 10, J pp p f vg 2 C 1–9. C pg g kg, p g - vg pzz . y p : 2 kg I. W v p I , e, gg ,p, p p 2 C 32:19: e yhwh, ,p, . T e yhwh v g-p p p ( gv p, z ). T e, , p ( , ), g pv, pv g-p .
I B, p - g , g
, g p . , , g g. , g p , g C f-- b.c.e. ,
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 51/247
42 BkIN N GNR Ry IN BIBIC uI
p, p yhwh g v g p g g.
G, , , p. P p g v g ; p v e. I , p p p; vg e p e. G g p p e, p v p . B g gg , vg p e , v g g g g.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 52/247
Experiential Learning: he Construction o
Jonathan in the Narrative o Saul and David
Barbara Green
T questions J’ : H I ? H I ’ , -? H ? H J , S D?
M thesis J q , .I S 4 -z S S , . I ( S 9:–7),J D; ( S :7), J - D’ S. T S : J S’
(:) (:4–4). T J’ , D S, , “” . C , .
A sociohistorical context . G q , D H , I
. S’ J
M. S G .
-4-
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 53/247
44 bAHIN AND GENE HEy IN bIbLICAL SDIES
, P-- y . E b Z
D H , . I , ? I , - (b Z: –5)? M S “” (J D ) - .
elevant Concepts rom bakhtin
T theory z M b (895–975) . b’ “dialogism”: . T b ,
“ ” (b 986:4–6,7, 5). T , -’ , , . D - , ’ . b “” , b - , (M E 997:64–66).
T . I , , . I , — . I ,
. I
. S G :–9 ( )
.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 54/247
GEEN: EPEIENIAL LEANING 45
. G , , . T
q , , , , . F , /. A b D, .
W , -q ?F, , . S, - : T , q , “ ” (Hq 99:8). W .
. T, . C - ; , . T .
A b’ utterance. C M Hq
b’ , H - b’ (C Hq: ; H: 9). “b ”(C Hq: 7). b . H : ,
. F , M E 99:–9. b’
“S G” q;
(986:6–75 -
).
, “S G” q .
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 55/247
46 bAHIN AND GENE HEy IN bIbLICAL SDIES
. A , . A , -
q , ; , , , , .b : , , ( , - , , ’), (b 986:6–). H : “T ( ) , , -” (b 986:9; H: ). T . P j -, .
V -
. A , ; . A for , to ( - ) (b 986:95–99).A , - , . , M E(99:). T b
“ ,” , “ -” (Hq99:6–6). ; . S ; . A q , ’ , .
G : F, b’ . - I q . S b,
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 56/247
GEEN: EPEIENIAL LEANING 47
f ( not , )
( is ). I , J, S, D — I— . W “ ” , , . W , z .
F, plan z - J S . W , J .
he Experiential Education o Jonathan: 1 Samuel 20
Pz -. H z J, S, D, . J-
ï , S ,D S . Pz : J , ’ . S’ , D’ . Pz D z, ’ D’ , S (87–9). Pz’ : - , , ,
( ) . D J ; ? Pz () S? J D , Pz D J (9–94). T J,
S.T .4 I :
4. F
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 57/247
48 bAHIN AND GENE HEy IN bIbLICAL SDIES
S D, D . b z
S D J ( D), S . J S ’ . -— — . E . W : , - . ,
( ), : D ( J-, ); J ( D ); S( J, ); - J “ ” ( - - ).
David and Jonathan’s First Six tterance Pairs: 20:1–23
A D’ q, “W ... [#pn]?” D’ q q : S’ D . I , . Aq . S D’ , , S D has S (.., 8:–, 9; 9:, , ). T q, z D. T
’ yhwh’ , yhwh’ S D (6:–4; 8:–9;9:9–, –4). M G’ - “z”: S’ D ( ) : S’ (8:–6, 9), (8:6–9),S’ (8:–9, 9:–8), J (8:–4; 9:–7), - S’ (9:8–4). I , D S
J’ .
(95.) E
(5–9).
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 58/247
GEEN: EPEIENIAL LEANING 49
I ( , :–), . D S
D , J’ 9:. T , , S D , - . A S j D’ J’ (9:6) D ( . 9 ). SS D’ . D S J , (8:). T D . W D’ - (-) ; S ( z S, j), . S , D’ ( ) D’q. T S J 9:–7 , 9 .D J’ ,
.S J D’
q, D’ . J z S , . T J D, , . b J’ S, D, q D J. T S
D , J S’ . T J - , , . J D’ q q : W S ?b q, J D’ . S D’ D’
J’ . T S’ - D S, q .J’ S, , .
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 59/247
5 bAHIN AND GENE HEy IN bIbLICAL SDIES
I :–4 ( ) D J’ ’ q ’ .
H S - S J’ “”: “D J , ,” D , S’ ( q ). D J , J.
J D , S D , . J q D : “W , I .” T : “W () [#pn] (), I .” T J’ D ( 8). T J (4:7), - . T ,
, . J’ -, P (4:–5). D S (6:), J (8:4).F J , , , S D. W , q?
T ( , :5–9) D, z J’
’ “.” H ’ , - — , , . P q z S 8, D J . D z S: . W D: S’ J’? W : S’ J’? D -
S J. W S D ( ) S’ D b J’ . D S “ ” “ .” H , “ ,” “ .”
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 60/247
GEEN: EPEIENIAL LEANING 5
D S : “,” D’ ; ,
.5 D S , J’ , H J . D J S “.” T J, D’ , S .T D’ S’ , D S , , . T — -, “G!” (bw+)— , S (5:8). T , S’ q. “” D J D. I S - éé? D q, . W D S
J ( ) “” . D . M S— (hlk) , J S. A , , D’ . D J : I , ; ? A q? I D
J ? J’ , q D’ : “I I , I ?” D J .
I :– ( 4) ’ . D , J . T , .
5. Pz q (88) ( ) S’
D. H (9) J
, D’
.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 61/247
5 bAHIN AND GENE HEy IN bIbLICAL SDIES
I , , D ( ), .
I q . I S?
J :–7 ( 5) , - ,6 ,- - : - S , S’ ; J D S - ; D D’ -
J’ . T ’ . J’
. J D D , — - — 8:–5. J’ —G — j D.J D, , , J- . D , (
), D J j : J D . W J - D yhwh , . P J D’ , , (8:9), S.J’ , S . W - J 4, S
’ . H . D J ? J D .
T ( 6, :8–) J D’ :5–8,
6. F (8–9)— D J
; S’ F q
(94). P (4) ( D’ )
S’ . S C (9–)
.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 62/247
GEEN: EPEIENIAL LEANING 5
’ D, J , D , b
. J , q , . H q D :: W ? P f , “G”! T , , .7 T “ ” , . T .
: I D S(G :67–4), J . A S D S’ , D -. S J , D J — D—J . N, J- ,
S D; , . S -, D J- G’ .
Saul and Jonathan’s Four tterance Pairs: 20:2–3
T :4–6 ( 7) , , S . T
D J j , ’ . S , J A , D’ - , : , —D, from S ——D for . S , J, . H q, D’ : “ , .” T q q,
, S , , D J. S
7. F (,
9–5), .
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 63/247
54 bAHIN AND GENE HEy IN bIbLICAL SDIES
D’ , D q- .
T (:7–9, 8) “ ” q. b , : I , S q J— ’ / .C D ( ) J’ , S q, , . H q , -, q , . T , D J. S’ D ( ) D , S’ D— . T j G (7:55–58), , G , (N.b.
7:5–7 8:8 ).J’ , D’ (:6) -
, : “D b”; ,J : “H , ‘S , , , — . I I , I [+lm], , I ’ ”( ). J q- q , : “F
’ .” J D’ D’ , . H , — - , D S, — S : / D, S, J D, S, J; D ; D M;
, S .
8
J
8. F (–) ;
q J’ , b’ .
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 64/247
GEEN: EPEIENIAL LEANING 55
S D -. S , .
I :–4 ( 9) , S .S’ , J, .9 I , S J J’ ( ’ ). A, , , S J D (.., J’) . , , “J’ ” S q S :–4 5:6. T J, . S S’ , , . T, -
, S J D— ’ (:9)— S . J’ D’ (9:4; :): “W ? W ?” I (9:4–7), J S
D, .S’ , ( ),
, “,” D J. S’ . T , J S D’. N , J , D, D :;
, , .
9. A (7) “ .” F
J’ -
(4); ,
, b
. F - ,
J (78).
J L A D’ 5:4 S’ (–8). S G S: 59–6.
. S (59–6) M
J, D, (D
, ). , “”
’ .
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 65/247
56 bAHIN AND GENE HEy IN bIbLICAL SDIES
A . S , , D. H , ,
D. I , q , .C D , S D . I f J j . S , J , D ; S’ , . , , q . I S, . S S . J’ .
Jonathan’s tterances to “he bo”: 20:3–2
T J’, “ ” ;D S’ (6:),
(:4). T , J D (:–), -. T , ’ . S J ( , 5–6) : “ ...” D q 6. A , , ’ .
W , :7,
J , J , “I [.., ]?” T , . T : : “yhwh .” I , S J D , G . S - G, , , . T , , .
. E.. C (9–7) ; F,
, (8.) . I
. I .
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 66/247
GEEN: EPEIENIAL LEANING 57
“H, q, ,” q (:8–9, ) ,
. A , : , .
“J , ‘G, ’ ” (:4, 4). A 8:4, D S . S’ . S G, ?
T ( 5, :4–4) J’ , - yhwh’ , :–6, J- D . D , f . A , , D J, (mt :) D J , .
S “,” , -
z j . I D ; , D’ . A D’ , . D - , , J , , J D’ . D j: , S, J, yhwh, . T . , ,
. T , , , 4, J , G’ , S’ J’ . A , , , . D , ,
. A , , , . J S ( D f S :), D .
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 67/247
58 bAHIN AND GENE HEy IN bIbLICAL SDIES
Converging the “Jonathan” Scenes
I - “J ” S. I - 4, J - S; ’ , (4:45). T . b ’ , , , z f; , .
I , , J ’ D (9:–7), - (:7). J , , D. T , . b’ .
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 68/247
Location, Location, Location:
amar in the Joseph Cycle
Judy Fentress-Williams
T J G . T v, v, J 37 g J. J’ v v g . , R
J, v. I g v J, L J v v. T J, gv , v J, g, “/recognize ’ .” F , J v. “I ’ ! A v . J ” (37:33). T J g J P . W J? W vv? W v v ? I
g v g g — vg J’ J.
S z G38 g v:
Ev v J gz J gg . (v R: 351)
v v . I J. (S: 299).
59
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 69/247
60 bAkI Ad GERE ER I bIbLICAL SudIES
, x. I v g. (bgg: 307)
G 38 “” v J . I g x v
v g v v, 38 v. 37 g , 38 .
T , g x, g v b. T x . I g x
v . C g v g v v v v x. u, x b.
S g v g 38 g v. I Te Art of Biblical Nar-rative, R A G 38 G 38 v g
J v “” g . T g “ ,”v “ x ” (A: 4).
M g , M. M. b, g g G 38 , g v, g 37 39–50. S, g G 38 , , g g v. Mv, g g
g 38 ’ g v v . T, I , “,” g g
v v.F , I g
gg “g” b’ gg.C b’ g gg g . Ev g,
g
g x g I g I g , v g , :
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 70/247
FERESS-WILLIAMS: LCAI, LCAI, LCAI 61
gz ( , x
) … . A
gz , … , g , . (b:1990:22–23)
b’ v . T , v . S, z g. Mg gg v , gg g . E
x g g in dia-logue . S gg inherently g.T g gg gg g. T z.
F , / v . Mg v ,, gg g g . F G 38, g
g g g v. g J 38
b’ gg, , gg ; v “.” . T v g v. IG 38, J v, x “.” J ’ g x gg
gg . T b .
b’ “” g x . T chronotope , “.” I :
gzg v v v.
v .I q g g
v. (b: 1981:250)
b v g g . W g v . W x g
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 71/247
62 bAkI Ad GERE ER I bIbLICAL SudIES
v v . T . I .
b , g/g, /q, /v, g/g . , meeting , recognition/nonrecognition (b: 1981: 97). T G 38 v g v.
g gg v G 38. F, I g . W ? W v g g? W v g? W g xg J? S, I x g G 38 g J v . T,I x x v g vg g.S, I meeting recognition/nonrecogni-tion v.
A g J , 38 x x : )whh t(b yhyw “ At that time, J A . T J g C S.” , b . T v v v v . I v 1–5, J E, , S.
T , , x, v
. I v J “v” “” . I v 2 “,” “,” “ ” b S. F , v . S v .I v 3 J “.” I v 4 b S v, , . I
v 5 v, , .I v 6–11 v
E. b , . E, , “” “g .”
v . T waw g v 7 . “b E, J’ , g G, hwh .” V 6–11 v v1–5, v . T , g g , E. I
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 72/247
FERESS-WILLIAMS: LCAI, LCAI, LCAI 63
, J v . levir ’ . J ,
v g . I, v levir “ g.” ’ g hwh, . I v 11 J g, . I
v 8 “g.” v 11 “” . v v 6 E. b v 11 .
u gg g . T v v gg g . T 11 v x g , v 12, ,Mymyh wbryw “ ,” , “ .” I v , . F b S, J, . I J g g
g. T g g “ .” W S? I g?W J ? W ?
I v 13 “ ” (dgn) gg g. v ’g, J g . ’ g g q . S v v , J, . j E, xtpb
Myny(, , “g ,” . V 14 ’ , , v v. S g , “saw [h)r] S g , gv .”
C v , v . A g x J. ’ , vg g
g , ’ v . J ’ .S g. J
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 73/247
64 bAkI Ad GERE ER I bIbLICAL SudIES
, g ’, ’ . I g,
v, v, S. S, gg , g . S . T x , “ v v v ” (Py(cb sktw Pl(ttw). Cvg g. ’ vg , g .
A g J v, g v , , v, . T v v. I J, gv v g v, v J v ’. u g J’ , J , g g. I Eg, P’ J’ . W J P’ v , J’ . S, ’ g
J, , hnz. ug . W v J ( g ) ( v). T “v”(Py(c) I R. R “v” (Py(c) I. T v g. T v ’ gg g, vg
g, g, possibly . T v . v g. T x’ v 16. W J , “” ((dy) “g.” “g” (hlk) . g , g J “gz” ((dy) ,
know .T g v. T v g v v . A , J, g g.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 74/247
FERESS-WILLIAMS: LCAI, LCAI, LCAI 65
v g. u v 16 J , v v. I , J’
(38:8, 11, 13) g (38:11). I v 16 J , v . v x g .
J: C, .: W gv ?J: I f.: gv g .J: W g I gv ?: g .
T g v. J v q (38:17). J j (38:18). J q (38:19). T xg :
J q
J q J q q
J g, v xg. Mv, v xg v 6–11 . T hyl) )bywwl rhtw, v 2, v 18, “ , v .”
vg , g g,
vg v g ’ g, g .T g v g.T , “ , v ”(wl rhtw hyl) )byw) g ’ g. T g , vg g. Lgg , , g, v gg . T g J v g, , g.
T g v J’ “.” A, . T
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 75/247
66 bAkI Ad GERE ER I bIbLICAL SudIES
h#dq. T hnz, . T
C . v, q vv. T , , , g (J: 104).1 W , “ ,” J g. T v , g g g (104). J gg.T J g v , v . I, “g ” g.
I v 24–26, xg J . “ ” “” ( dgn) J, v 13, v J. I g . I v . I v 24J ’ g . u J’
, v . J’ g, “ g.… /recognize, , , g .”J’ g v g J’ J’ . J g . J g, , recognizes “ g I.” J v g g
. I v 27–30 x g g . Pz v J’ . T z g J.
’ g v v.T v g v . V 24g : “ .…” T
’ g v v.
1. . S G Cg
S’ (1997) hnz h#dq.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 76/247
FERESS-WILLIAMS: LCAI, LCAI, LCAI 67
I
v. F x,
v (38:1–5) J , , E v g . v 6–10
g E G g
levir G . I v 11 J
’ g ,
“ S g .” I v 12 v “ g
” J’ . v
v, v 24
.T v 24
v 27, “ gv ….”
T g x v. T , Pz
Z, g
J . Ag
g, g,
g v, J
. ’
, “ [Crp] v ,”
. T
. T 38 v
, v.
T J v, G 38
G’ . J’
G’ A , , x,
v.
I , G 38 g. I G 38 ,
g
v, g . F, g
g /J g J v.
I g v /v v.
S, v g. T
g v v /v
v. T, / v v “v,” rkn, ( gz) “,” h)r. F,
v, J,
v . T
G G’ .
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 77/247
68 bAkI Ad GERE ER I bIbLICAL SudIES
Mv, , g/g 38 38 g v.
T g/ J, gz v. T/J g G . T g v v. , J I, , z g. T /g x gg g. J gg, gg. A v, g/ g g. T xg J xg g recognize perceive xg gg.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 78/247
Dialogic Form Criticism: An Intertextual Reading
o Lamentations and Psalms o Lament*
Carleen Mandolfo
M B -v. I , H- G’ , :
I v , - G , . O , “H - , v ?” (1999:415).
B’ , , B . B G B / , G , B . F G, , , (B 1999:259);1 B, —— “,” , / /. A B, “S ; j ,
* 3 Daughter Zion alks Back to the Prophets: ADialogic Teology of the Book of Lamentations (SS 58; A: S B
L, 2007).
1. A B, G A v
v “” . M G’ -
v (B 1999:255–56).
-69-
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 79/247
70 BAkHI AD GR HORy I BIBLICAL SDIS
v” (1986:87).2 A , v , .
C (V L: 74–75). I v “” , v v, z v . v :
[] “” , v
, , , . , j . , z . (2003:12)
I v vv ,S B Zv z ’ :
F- v . R - v v v q .Mv, v ,- v . R, z - , , , v
, and they will study the means by which genres are transformed tomeet the needs of the particular communicative situation of the text. (2003:9–10, )3
A, -: “[] v - ’ ‘ ’” (Fv: 8,17). I I L 1–2 “ ”
2. B B “
” (1986:79).
3. 1997:327 .
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 80/247
MADOLFO: DIALOGIC FORM CRIICISM 71
587 b.c.e.4 - , “
v .” I , , v, - I.
A v : I J 2004 M vv q,5 I B . Wicked , Te Wizard of Oz .6 I z -
v —, v v, , , v , — / . T v , j (), v Wz, v
, . T , v v ,“,” jv, v v Wz / . T v , v , - A . I , , A . T
v ( vv, ’ j, .) A . A v q .
4. F v J
B, 2 S-C 2002.
5. I v CrossCurrents j I C F.
6. I Wicked , v ( G. M-
) 1939 v v Te Wizard of Oz
(Te Wonderful Wizard of Oz ) L. F. B ’
Wicked , , .
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 81/247
72 BAkHI AD GR HORy I BIBLICAL SDIS
A , -v, v
v, , . I, v v. Wicked v v v . I , ’ v -z: , , vq . S v, Wicked v “” . L, L 1–2 - D Z .A I , L I. I , v z v . R I , v yhwh , v jv - .
he Set-p
I ( ), , v -: v ( ) , . S , L, v, , 587 b.c.e. A L, v, - , ,
. T , - q: W ; , ? v v vv :
v v . Mv v q- : How does the text conform to the conventions of the genre, and
how does it depart from them? It is in these departures that the text reworksthe ideology that intrudes between it and history. (y: 26, )
I L (bat Zion)
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 82/247
MADOLFO: DIALOGIC FORM CRIICISM 73
. F, v
“” v 587 v . G v B’ :
v v ( “” ). , , , , ,
.… I . (1986:91) 7
I , I ( ) L 1–2 v D Z v v , I .
I “v” L , v
v . A I v (M 2002), v , , - -v. I , f ’ v I v “ v” ( DV), - v , , G, . T DV v - v P. L 1–2, v , v— , D Z; j-v - v— - v - ’ , v v L. T , v, . W DV - vv j, v L 1–2 v
7. I, B J I A, 1920
Poetry and Religion, “” G’
(B 1999:375).
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 83/247
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 84/247
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 85/247
76 BAkHI AD GR HORy I BIBLICAL SDIS
( ), v . B “” -
, . T DV’ v , , ’ , , , v . T z , q , L 1–2 v v.
W , - v , v DV, “v” v, . T , , v G’ . I , ( v ) “ ” (B: 71). T , v , v, v. H, z yhwh ( M 2002). T :
’ , jv, v. Cv, DV’ v v , - jv . A M v ( ),“T [] ‘z’ ‘’ v’ , v ’ ”(M 1990:164). M, L 1–2 v v v. T DV’ -
v - bat Zion’ . R, v v v
v v v : Z v.9 T DV L 1–2 q .
T , I v L 1–2 type , L .M L —qinah ( )
(B: 23; D-A 2002:54)—
9. B
D-A 2002, .
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 86/247
MADOLFO: DIALOGIC FORM CRIICISM 77
L 3 5 . T qinot v, , -
L 1–2, .10 qinot v vv B; v (.., 2 S 1:17) (.., J 9:9) . AL f M , .11 D ( z , v q ), .T M v . T j- S I L, (D-A 2002:11). A , . T v - ,12 L, , yhwh ( I z ).
Wv , A B qinah L (
) , “J ” (24–25).13 B v J - qinah (25). S z v : “T - [ J] ” (25).L v J , , . Mv, , L 1–2
v B’ . W z 587, I 587 - I v ,
10. H (v) L 1, 2, 4 , , v
.11. D-A (2002:9–11) “”
L. F M ,
B: 27.
12. C A .
13. O J P 44; 69; 74; 79; 102; 137.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 87/247
78 BAkHI AD GR HORy I BIBLICAL SDIS
, v ,
.S v qinah I,
L 1–2 vv , D-A (1993) v L . B L 1–2 v , I v , L 1–2 . I j , v, “ ” .14 I , L , - j, v, , , (.., ), .15 A, , to yhwh about yhwh. T L , v - B, v, ,
L ( L P v ; H: ).
he Reading
M L 1–2 vv / . A , L 1–2, , -v . T “” , v/
q . I -v—P 22 L 3— I .16 P 22 v DZ L, L 3 - v .
14. S F
, . I q B(24), L qinah v v,
v “” .
15. F: 61.
16. j (M 2007);
v - v.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 88/247
MADOLFO: DIALOGIC FORM CRIICISM 79
L 1 (hky)) , v Z
. L 1 - v v. W Z
v 9. I , , P 22 : “M G, G, v ? W v, ?” “W” q v v: “G, v v? W -?” (74:1); “W , ?” (44:25). v v, v G’ . P 38, , z D Z’ : G’ direct vv - .
yhwh, !
F v , . (38:2–3)
S :“y v , , . y , v v” (88:7–8).A q , v, bat Zion’ . A D Z q , yhwh , ,
v q G.17 P 22:20–22 :
B , O yhwh, ; , .Sv , .Dv ’ , .
17. z L
B’ J .
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 89/247
80 BAkHI AD GR HORy I BIBLICAL SDIS
D Z yhwh , ,, yhwh P 22
v , “ ” “ .” I , yhwh (, , j
j, , ) L 1–2.18 T q G v — v — G v - (1:21–22). v DV/ L 2 G (2:18–19), G, , (2:20–22).
L -v ( P 7 ), - P 22:4. T v , v DV P 7, z - : G “” “.” L 1–2 . P 22 —“B I , ; ” (22:7)— bat Zion’ - L: “L yhwh, I v !” (L 1:11). P 22:12 “ ,”
bat Zion’ “ ” (1:21). I , v . B G ’ , P 22 ( 22:16), L v v v Z (1:12, 13, 14, 15; 2:20–22), f / ( . 2). F v 23 P 22 DV v( v - 22:26). T v
, , , . O - L 1–2 P 22:25: “F , , , .” M v, — v, — - L 1–2. I Z’ v 1 , , - -
v Z’ v-à-v G.
18. A D-A (1993:30) , G
L v “.”
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 90/247
MADOLFO: DIALOGIC FORM CRIICISM 81
Z , ;
yhwh J ;J . (L 1:17)
W 1 DV’ Z’ (1:5, 8), DV L 2 v v DV. A, v , q, q .
H yhwh Z!H v I; .
yhwh J; J; . (L 2:1–2)
I yhwh’ v Z’ 2:22, DV L 2:4–5 yhwh “.”
T ( ) k, yhwh “” , q Z - yhwh “ ” 2.19
P 22, , DV “T !” (22:29); yhwh:
T v ; yhwh .
19. D-A (2002:83) . X
(98) “ .”
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 91/247
82 BAkHI AD GR HORy I BIBLICAL SDIS
T j ,
. (22:30–31)
A - , DV L 2( Z ) , v:
M ; ; , .
T ,“W ?” ,
’ . (2:11–12)
yhwh v , , “ v .” T P 22 L1–2 L P 22 , 587 G I , z - .T , f B L (D-A 2002:105).
I , L 3 , , , L 1–2’ . C 3 , . T v -: 3:1–21 ; 3:22–42
DV ( 3:40–42, v); 3:43–66 , , yhwh. S z z, -
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 92/247
MADOLFO: DIALOGIC FORM CRIICISM 83
.M ’ G 3 -
D Z’ v .
H , ; ; ; . (L 3:10–12)
I jv DV/ . I v 22, q , DV : “T v yhwh v ; v !” TDV v v 39. T -v v , ’ , z DV’ . A
- v . T DV L v - D Z’ . I v .
yhwh , nefesh .I q
v yhwh. (L 3:25–26)
A j L 1–2 v . I L 1–2, jv v, v G’ D Z’ .20
20. I ,
L 1, 2, 3
3 D Z
.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 93/247
84 BAkHI AD GR HORy I BIBLICAL SDIS
yhwh Z;
; . (L 2:8)
L 3 J’ , v q bat Zion .
I L [3] v v (L 3:1–20) v (3:21), v
G (3:22–24).… Cq, - (3:40–42), ’ v v (3:43–48). J’ - v v .… W , J… . v v , L 3:43–48, . ( 2003:137)
T - L 3:40–42
. v DV D Z’ , , vyhwh’ v . L J, Z’ v- v . I J, v, , v L 1–2’ DV, Z’ .
I M ’
DV. I L 1–2 , “’” ’ .
, ; H
;
H . (M: 296–299)
S, DV L z , - , q -
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 94/247
MADOLFO: DIALOGIC FORM CRIICISM 85
I , qinah, v v .
z , L1–2 -v . T . A , v, v j .W ’ (Z’ , P 88 ), -z - 180 . T DV yhwh’ j, , , . I L, v, .T v v ’ -v, z ( ). W , , v v , v , v ?S v
v : “ … [ q] ” (S: 67).
Bat Zion and the Prophetic Marriage Metaphor
L 1–2 DV v v. Z
: v/ v. G , . I - DV v — — ; “ ” DV/ v . T v Z v . I v z
v ( v S I21). I ,
21. P G’ v
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 95/247
86 BAkHI AD GR HORy I BIBLICAL SDIS
v G Z’ . I v
’ . A v , “-” I . O y, q . I , , L v , D-A L .
[I] , -
, ’ , () j J’ . y - z , - . (2002:63–64)
D Z v -
. F , v J 2 z 16— — f ( M 2007 ). B J , yhwh . I J 2 yhwh (2:2). B v “” q “I v!” (2:20), q “ ” v , D, B (2:20–28). I z 16:15–20
hnz yhwh’ . A yhwh, (J 2:35), , q , “ [ynnh], I j for saying , ‘I v ’!” G’ “j” (z 16:39–40). v Z v; -. B ’ Z’
jv: “A I
S I, v L. S
1997.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 96/247
MADOLFO: DIALOGIC FORM CRIICISM 87
v , q v B
(2003:23, 25). T about v v; v, ,v ‘’ yhwh, ” (B: 125).W , G’ ’ - .
[sic] , second-hand , lie
, “ ,” , “ .” (B 1984:69–70)
I L 1–2 bat Zion - yhwh’ . A , v (L1:18), , z
.22 —“,” “ ,” — L 1–2 (B: 171). Gv yhwh’ J , Z L.S v, , . A v, “,” L 1:18 B’ -v , “’”
z ’ ;23
z (B 1984:189). A
22. I, , v B’ “ v,” Z
G G’ v . ,
v , .
23. (2003:28) -v : “I
’
. ’ v v. O
, . I ’
v
. W Z
,
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 97/247
88 BAkHI AD GR HORy I BIBLICAL SDIS
v ,Z -
.24 “[] v v . W ” ( 2003:30).25 Gv , .R, . yhwh’ v .
yhwh j H ( “” [hnz]): “I v.… I .… I v , … ” (z 16:37–40). S - v v . I L 2:19 Z’ , “
v .” Z G’ : “T I cherished and reared ” ( hlk, ,, [2:22]). T G Z’ . I , . B , jv ’ z v v , .A DV, v v,
. R L 1–2 , v , B ,
Z, , , ;
Z .
24. F , L 2004.
25. v -
/ , J “ ” (2003:131). S,
,
/ . I , D Z -
. H . qinah
.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 98/247
MADOLFO: DIALOGIC FORM CRIICISM 89
: “[] , -, G, q
- ” (2003:24).
T G v z DV v , , j L 1–2.
W I , , D Z?
I , I , v D Z?F v ; ? (2:13)
T DV , , v . F , G’ v v j. I v -
z P 37 D V. I v v v.
F , v , , .
yhwh ,
v; v , v . (P 37:1–2, 18–19)
S L 1–2. I j D Z’ —
L, yhwh, ! v ?
S , v ? (L 2:20)
yhwh ; j . (P 37:3)
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 99/247
90 BAkHI AD GR HORy I BIBLICAL SDIS
— DV L. C Z’ v G’ j-
, P 37’ DV v .
I Wicked v z v, L 1–2v I , z , jv. , I - , Wz G, v.
T G D Z , , -. T v Z .
[C] … v- ….I , v: v, , . H , , v .(D-A 2002:38)
T Z v v . T . S -
v , , , (, .., “” ) ( , v, ). B DV v - , v .
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 100/247
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 101/247
9 BAHI AD ERE HEOR I BIBLICAL SDIES
. T . T
b Hbw A b . Hw R-B - w D . H A b , w Hbw b - . T A , ,
b , b, -. T w Hbw b w b, -b ().
T Sé R-B b z ww w , b , B (B 98:9).H , , ,
(V: ). B “ - - bw , bw , bw - , bw , , , , b ” (98:9). I , w H- J, w - (J: 7).C w (M: 7). M, , , Hbw (Abb). I b - R-B’ Hbw b . T H b . -, z . L b .
A A b
. B . A Hbw A (99:–). T w -z ’ w, D. H D
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 102/247
VALEA: POLLOSSIA AD PAROD 9
’ w w . F, , b Hbw D-
’ D . S, ’ D’ :8 ’ bw Hbw :7 ’ w w D . T, ’ , b , w Hbw b . T w , w, D . F, w D w J , D b w -Bb . S, w w b . D :4b b w w bzz, w w b b q. W ’ b , A-, , . T w A :4b ’ w . T w b -
. T b Hbw A, w , b D , b . T w D . T w b w.
Bakhtin and Polyglossia
A B, w -
, - (98:50).B b . T b b b w (98:75). T , z I D –. A B, ,
/ w b
. F , V 005:09–4. F -
, V 007.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 103/247
94 BAHI AD ERE HEOR I BIBLICAL SDIES
, , / . T w w b
D. T , .
M z b (B 984:9). T - b - . L b z b w w.T , ,
(984:). L w b . B : “L b b w w w - b w ” (984:). T b b’ . L b - . A B : “[]
w , ,, , [ ] b w ” (98:59). T b , , , , , , b . W D – , b . Cq, - D – w b
.
he Multivoiced ature of Daniel 1–6
M D . F B, . T - . D Hbw .
T , , , - , , , w b , w . T , , - w . T Hbw ’ ,
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 104/247
VALEA: POLLOSSIA AD PAROD 95
, . T -, , w
w , w bq, .
D j .T , b , , b Bb. Mw, . A w b w. T j w. T w-. T b , j bw . T ’ b . S ’ , Az A, J. O, C D D , w . T b . T b.
D D w . D’
, , .T , , w -, , , , w Hbw .E D w J, ’ - w.
w. T w w. D, , w w. E q D 5 w . S w, b . M,
. T , w , z, , - , bw D Az D, w , , D , w b b .
T b D b b w (S: ). T b w . T
. D w b J b Bb w w - b .
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 105/247
9 BAHI AD ERE HEOR I BIBLICAL SDIES
. T b w wD. M ,
. O, w, b , D , w D ’ w.
T . T - A’ w w w bw D . T .F, w - w . H , b Bzz’ - D 5. T q w . I b j . F b, q w w . T .
T b w D – , B, . E b
. M, b ’ . D
.T b D – b
w. T ’ b , w, . A, w w. H w w w
. T . T bb . I , D – ’ . I intentional w.
Aramaic in the Book of Daniel
T E b w - b H . A S b , A S . A b lingua franca w (C: 70). A A
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 106/247
VALEA: POLLOSSIA AD PAROD 97
P (: 74). A q A- , b lingua franca, b A, A,
Hbw, . T H E w -z b .
L , bb , b. P b w . P w . A S-A b Ab’ b (C: ). T D C b S Bb b (F: 5–80). L -A “ w b A(w w ) b W S ” (H: 0). I P , w A w -Bb b.T w b (B 98:78–79). E b M A w
b L - (Wz). I , w , w .
W Hbw Bb.A b Hbw :47 J 0:. Ez4:8–:8 7:– , , A Hbw Bb b D. M w Hbw Bb, C 9:7; Ez 8:7;
7:9–7; D :5–7 (95–9). A w bb . T , w, b .T w q w. W D (4–8).
B b b
H , b . Tw w H w. I , b . B H -, ,
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 107/247
98 BAHI AD ERE HEOR I BIBLICAL SDIES
. T bw j w bj
, - , b- (V: 4). T Hbw ’ - w w . I q b b . Tb D .
T A w
A E b b Ez D. I . I b Ez, A b 4:8. V7 Hbw: “A A, B M b w A P.T w w A .” T w b A, w (Ez 4:–), ’ (4:7–). O A w . T S-bz D (5:7–
7), D (:–), A Ez (7:–). A qé bw P b Ez. Ez w w , P. , w A w Hbw , A(4:8–0, –4; 5:–; :–, –8) qé A, C b (:–4)., Hbw A b w Ez.
T b D A, q, w w . T A - w . T A D w ’ q. T ’ q D : , w, Hbw. I
A w , w A b w ’ q. I, b w ’ . D S-C ’ w, “O , !” (yyx Nyml(l )klm), D
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 108/247
VALEA: POLLOSSIA AD PAROD 99
– (99:5). E w w b . T
A j ’ w . R, A- b . T A w D w , b - .
Examples of Wordplay
T w A P w - w D. H w b . T - w q , , ,
j (P: 5). T w w w q. T w bw. T w q D .
Daniel 1
A w Hbw, b w q A . T w . T q Leitworter , w, w w (A 000:). I , (Klm) w . T b w, b
b. F b, bzz b , b ’ b
. O D :9; 5:0; :7, .
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 109/247
00 BAHI AD ERE HEOR I BIBLICAL SDIES
b Hbw b w . T - b (Ntn) , w
bj w w , w . T b -w, b q .
I D , bzz q b w J J . T . T b ’ , . A w, b w b. Hw, D w ’ bj-. M Hbw ’ . W , , , w b. T
q ’ Bb b. T , w S w b b b w (). T b w b bw bj. T w b-, Hbw b b (D :0–). T b
b w b b. T b ’ , w qbj w. T - b w , .
T w , , . D :–7 w b,
’ , w (C:–9). I 7 Hbw w . THbw b My#w, w .D’ w ’ w , w w b
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 110/247
VALEA: POLLOSSIA AD PAROD 0
b w , b . D w
, 8 w, My#w, b D’ - b w w. T
b w w w q . A w , bw D. T patbag (gb-tp) , b D (Fw: 9).
Daniel 2
I b w q b . W , b w ((dy) , 5 9. H w b (hwx), w . T - . O b
, b w . T . T w w . A w w (r#p) (zr). W -, D w w , bw w w . T
, w w b b. D, w (wlg, :5) w ()lg, :9, , 8, 0, 47) (Mw:8–8). F , b q . T (:, 0, 7), w (:), (:0), w (:7), (:40), (:4) (: 4). T q D.
Daniel 3
D b z b b - (A: 58; Fw: 74). T
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 111/247
0 BAHI AD ERE HEOR I BIBLICAL SDIES
, , (C: 95). T
w bj w b w. T b Hbw . T - z b -bz (:, , 5, 7, 0, , , ) b (:9, ) b (:0, , ). T b b . T w q w . T , w w . I w“” (Mlc) , bzz . T q (S-C99:). L 9, (Mlc) w ’ b w . M-w w w (48). T b b D, w (Mlc) . T 7, w (lk) (lq)
(lk) . T w b b q, b w (:–8).
Daniel
T (Hz: 99). T
(br) (Pqt) (4:8, 7, 9, 7, ) (Klm) (+l#) (4:4, , , 9, ) b . bz-z b , b w w w . T b ((r)) ()ym#) (: 85).T b b w w . w 7 9 bw , -
. (T ’ “ ”[4:7, )ym#l )+my], ’ [4:9,)ym#l t+mw]. T ’ “ ” [4:7, )(r) lkl],w ’ “ ” [4:9, )(r) Pwsl) (M-w: 47). A w
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 112/247
VALEA: POLLOSSIA AD PAROD 0
w q D 4:7–4, w z , . F w
, b w q b b A D L (47).
Daniel
C 5 w, w-w w w. I w , w w b (A 99:48).
T Bzz b b , b .T b w w w. T w b b b (qpn). T b b (qpn), , w 5 w b “b ”
w w. T w bw w b b. A (Nyrt#m) (yr+q) ’ bw ,w w b b D “ ” (P: 5; W99b:9). I q w D-’ b. T ( D: 47). T b b
(B: 5). T w w –8, w w ()nm, lqt, Nysrp) (hnm,htlyqt, tsyrp) j (W- 99b). A w b , w b b, , w b w, w (lqt) ’ (ly+q) !
Daniel 6
Mw b D (94). T , w .
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 113/247
04 BAHI AD ERE HEOR I BIBLICAL SDIES
W w D , w , w q (:
4). A w “” (h(b) “” (xk#) Leitworter , w (99:48). D’ (h(b, :5) (xk#, :5, w :) .T 8 –4, (h(b) . T w w . T - bw w D w . T z b - (xk#) D 5 b . T 4 D . T bw D. A w b w w (td) b w (:) w M P (:9, , ). T - D, w w w , b w w, . T w q .
Wordplay and Ideology
T A w ’ w b w .T A w - . H . I w, A - D –. T w w
’ . W w , b b w. T q b - D .
w b Hbw A D –. T w- Hbw A D – w
. M w w. I , , w, , w, , ,, . S . A A Hbw
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 114/247
VALEA: POLLOSSIA AD PAROD 05
w , b b w D – w . I
w wj D . T A D .
T w w D - . T . H w . F, - . J J w “” , . T w D – - . T A w w j . T w b bz z (B 98:–75). A F D, w b w (4).
Implications for Daniel –12
A D – , b q :W A b D w D ? I A , jb D :9. Ob w b Ez - . T b . I b, w,
b w -. A b b .
I w b , :5 ; w D :–4, w j , D b w Hbw w b A . T D b w A w b Hbw . T - b . I w, b, w
b. I D, j .F, D “b.” A
b -w , , , bq ,
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 115/247
0 BAHI AD ERE HEOR I BIBLICAL SDIES
’ q, ’ b, D, . T A,
w w. I D 7–, w, -w b . Hbw w w w , . A Sé-, b , Hbw w A . I , Hbw -w w w .D – A b j . D8– Hbw b j .
Ob, . D 7 w w . P D , b’ -, w Hbw reversal b . T w D :4. I D – w A D
7– Hbw, w bb b q . D 7, , w b. I , D –7, w D . I w D . T D 8 w j w . T :5/:5 b b.
T w w bwD – 7–. W b D 7–, bw wj b D. F, D 7– Bzz (7:; 8:), D (9:; :), C (0:). S,D’ -Bb , Bzz, 0:. T,D , , w 0:. F, b ,
:5, :8, bz 0:, :8. F, D 7– - b. T b (7:–4) (8:–4) . S, D w
w . D
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 116/247
VALEA: POLLOSSIA AD PAROD 07
w -. T D b
. F , D “ w b” (7:). H “w
” (7:). A , D , “ w b w ” (7:5). E -, D , “ , ” (7:8). A, D “b ” (8:7). D b (8:7).H , w 0:8. T D, “D ” (0:, 9); (0:7). D 7:. I D 8 D (8:5). S b D “ ” (8:5). I b, w D, b D (8:7). b D “w ” 9:, w 0:. T “ (w) D” 0:8 b. b :8, . D w b (9:),
b w D. D : “ … b ” bzz (8:). S, j -, , D 7– w –. T b ’ w (8:4, 7), w w D –. T w (8:0), b . T “ ” “ - b w w ”(8:; . 8:), D 5. I
, “ ,” bzz b j (8:). M, b -b w b b (:; :). A w b b :4 D . A b w :7 b D 4. T w (:). A b . T w ,
w (:–7). E, (7:0). H (7:9), b b (7:), w D . J M H (7:) D 4. A ,, w w
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 117/247
08 BAHI AD ERE HEOR I BIBLICAL SDIES
(7:4); w w b (7:4b). F, b . D w
(:).T w j D . T w
A b Hbw . T :5/:5 j b. Cq, b D b - —and .
Conclusion
D – , , , w A, , , Hbw,A, , . T - b , , . E (H: 55), b w S, . T j w . T
. I . I b w . E b , b w ,
j b . B’ -/ D –, .
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 118/247
he Apocalyptic Chronotope
Michael E. Vines
I b w-v SBL A G b v x: Apocalypse: Te Morphology o a Genre (C1979). I v, J C v vb . Hwv, -, C’ v . T v w B v .B x w w v
w , w q v - , w b b b v x v .
I b b b b . I 1859, L Az C L, b, mammalia quadrupedia b Systema naturae. I -
, Az L “ Cetaceans” w “ F” (211). Az’ L b wb : W , w ? I L w . O b bv b ’ (vb!) b x . B, w w, v b . T w w , w bv bv .1
1. b A, w w v b b
q (op. 101b35–36, 10214–16).
-109-
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 119/247
110 BAkHI A G HO I BIBLICAL SIS
A b v b z w b v v b -
w. W b . W -. Hwv, , w w bw . W w “” b ( b w !). I M B . B’ v x w b .2 F B, b b ( v). G - b w’ - : w v. B bv v v w w v v , w B w’ “ ” “- .”3
F B, -
.4
B v w w vx w vw w. T ’ x vw v w . L , bw x bw w v bj. Ov v w bv - w bj b z b b w w .T v -
.A B, “z” w
’ v. W b v
2. F B’ , V 2002:33–68.
3. B “ ” (1990:269–70) “-
” (1984:82–83) . A b w
, b , b B, v b V. .Vv [M. M. B], w “ w refexions
reractions in the human brain , x x b
w, w, sign” (1983:98 . 5).
4. B x
“ Pb S G” (1986:60–102).
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 120/247
VIS: H APOCALPIC CHOOOP 111
w; b ’ v -. W , ’ v
w w w v.A w v v
v, w v . I, w b v “- -” v . T x w w (B 1981:288; B Mvv: 129–30, 133, 134). A v, w w : x .
I, x b-v w. x, w w w , w v “b .” T v b x w . I v w, - x x, w w v. B v v , b x x -
vw w w. T x b x b . T w - x x. T w,w b v w , w b v - b (B 1984:135; 1981:388–89). S w v, q b - ’ v, v w v, v w. T
( x v ). T v w q - . F B, v- q w, , (1981:84–85).
x, v b , v vvv . F v, b x b
b v v w B “ ” (1986:4;1984:106). T, , B w . x v , b w w w x. T, w
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 121/247
112 BAkHI A G HO I BIBLICAL SIS
w, v b w vw w x.
W b w , , vw , w vw (1984:82–84, 88). A w , -, v , v w b . Hwv, v w x - w v v b (1981:50). Hwv, w , v -
v w x v .Hwv, v w x . T x b b w b. T w w w. b , w b w w w - (B 1984:157). T, w w
w w , w b w w , x .
Hv b w B b , w w x w -v b .I C, w “” v q b
w . Fw B’ , w b b z bv : , , .
Chronotope
T w w w ’ v . T - b w b
x. , b b . V x b -
v b . H v b vw v b v b. T b b q . b b
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 122/247
VIS: H APOCALPIC CHOOOP 113
b x ’ . T b v. A ,
w v x, 2 . 2, b w v w . v w w x (.., 4 z), v x b v.
S, b b. T w v j v v v. I , w , , bw v. F v b j v, v v . W b , v, , . T v . T
v w b , v w b. T ’ b v w w j x v.
T b b v v v. T - w b G’- vw v. I w w v, w w x b . T b q. T v I’ ( , - H, .), , G’ v v G’ , .5 I, w
b v b w w v G , w , w G’ - w. T b j . T b w v, v , w . Wv
5. I w B’ bw “” “v” -. H b v v : “
,” “ [] v ,” “ b
[] w ,” w
“z x w ” (1981:11, 13). I bv -
b bw .
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 123/247
114 BAkHI A G HO I BIBLICAL SIS
b x w b j .
Author and hero
T v. I , bw I’ : , Ab, B, . Pb, b b b w . I, w bv, w b v, b b v .B , b b , b v b. T b v G’ b, b . w b b v G w - w .
A ,
v. T - G w v. T v v v v. T b b v b x v, b v v w . v Ab, w Ab w b j , Ab’ - v G (10:5–12). T v b bw
. I bb , x - v v . T v b “w G” . I , x v , w , .
, . “C” z
b . T w - w. T q : Hw w ? W w b q ? I ? T - w b b b x
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 124/247
VIS: H APOCALPIC CHOOOP 115
. v, v G wb , v j
. F, v w b-, , . I , j G v G’ v j.
ialogism
W , v v j w w -w . T v w w v. Hwv, v w. T w v b , w v w . Hwv, v x . T v w x z v w w b. T , w
v w . T -v w b v. T, w b w b j.
A v ’ x w w b . A b, w v q. F, w bb ? T q b w
bb b b q bw w . B - v w b v v b . w v v. T b b , b , w . T “w G” , b
w z v. T b -b, w v w G’ w, w v b .
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 125/247
116 BAkHI A G HO I BIBLICAL SIS
A q x v- w . C b bw
b v, w b I, vv v j, w II (1979b:22). I v, w b w w vv w . B B vw q w I II b w. I . T - bw w b , w w .
Conclusion
I , J C “Awvw , - wvw x b ”(1997:8). A B b b . T w w w
w . T b v w w w, b w b b v wvw, , .
I b v , w “z” : x x v v j. W w b
j. Ivb, b , , fw.
A b v . W w x w v G w fw . T w b. W w G b ? T v vw G’
vw G’ . T w v b v, v j. W G ,
w b .T, , w - . I w. I v v . I w
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 126/247
VIS: H APOCALPIC CHOOOP 117
w b . W b -
, w b w v .
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 127/247
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 128/247
Matthew’s Genealogy as Eschatological Satire:
Bakhtin Meets Form Criticism
Christopher C. Fuller
Introduction
I I M :– p v F Gp . I b p - b b B
x p q pp p .T B
v. I pp b p-p z ’ . H , “M ’ ( p pb ) pv p” (990:0). I p . T -p B xp p p.
T p B’ v p. I , b v pv q - . H b “ p p p xp ” (98:84). F B, p v pb. Cp “ z v v v.T p p v .I b q b p v” (250). I p z p, v x. A M E,“F p … b - p p, p b ” (990:4).
-9-
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 129/247
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 130/247
FE: MAHEW’S GEEAG 2
p p , p bq, v pp
” (254).S , p v ,
b f p px b . T “x b p x p” (B 98: 252). B p p q . Tp B b Gp v v , v v v , bp bp (99, 6).
B pp pb .H z . H “ , -. G b v vp v v v ” (984:06). G “v” “.” T pv “v,”b b . T b - p . S v p
Gp. T xb q bp b p “v” (b; A; B; b; V).B’ pv pp v Gp p sui generis b v .
A p p B, x p b . F b v -; . T xp ,
p , q .“G … p p p ” (B 986:5). Gb v, , q, “ v p v ” (98:32). M pv p b v p. T v xp -b ’ p p .
B’ p p v b v v. p -b-p b , , -- . I , v, v
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 131/247
22 BAHI A GEE HE I BIBICA SIES
. H v x “ -p.” H pv :
() v; (2) p xp p; (3) p q “-” p p-; (4) pv p -p b (: 28–9). M p pq f p x x v x p b .
eading Matthew 1:1–17 “ike” Bakhtin
A B’ pp p F Gp. , v b pv p p x b x . Bb G p x “” B. I -, “ p b p b
p vb v” (G 2000:0). Tp p b v b b pb . T p-v p, v b p v x. W , vb . T pp p p B’p “v .”
Cv p’ p v, p x (.., ’ -
xp), p p xv p. A B, “Creative understanding , p , ; . I , p p b located outside bj v — , p, ” (986:). T v B’ zb b p - x -- p. W
, v M :– “” B.M p Gp “ J
M, v, Ab” (:). H J Ab b M. A
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 132/247
FE: MAHEW’S GEEAG 23
- b , b b Ev’ xv Hb
Bb , , , J. T Ev p G , Βίβλος γενέσεως, v b G b Hb Bb,p Sp (G 2:4; 5:). I I p M p Ev p . I, I v M’ v. I x p M’ M p p.
G p’ p. T x E- p Hb Bb. T, p HbBb. T pp bq x G Ex, I, p Bb x 538 .c.e. (
2 C, Ez, ). b W . T , p p (G 35:22–26; 26:5–5). T p v b p b z pb b b . T b p b xp , p, p , p .
T . W “ v - b p p ”(930). G p p v -. T b p’ p, , v .
I v f, p, . T f -
b p p p pp.G p p (C 9:39–44) v (9:4–6). W , b , b x b , C 6 (930).
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 133/247
24 BAHI A GEE HE I BIBICA SIES
M J px p z p- J pp v
: () pv v J ( Ez-); (2) p b M ( P.S. ; J: 85). Ez 2 J H x. T b v b v p pp p (2:62). T ., b x: () I,p, v (2:2–42); (2) p v(2:43–58); (3) I p (2:59–63). J- v p x ’ p v b I. T x -. T, S pp p -. T I’ p
p p, S p, p p bzb .
J bb - b (93–95). W x bb b p p, M’ b p p S pp v xp p.
A bj p S p p M. J , “v M p b, p M pbb J-” (6).
I 2 S :–6 G pv v I v. p Hb Bb v
J 58 .c.e. v xp J S p p v, G’ “ ”(), xp I’ v I G p. S p I G’ p- I (S 4:22) M
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 134/247
FE: MAHEW’S GEEAG 25
v (4 Ez 2:32; P. S. :4, 2). Hv, p v. x
p v p M v A (QS 9:0; C 2:23; 4:8; 9:0). T f v M J S p p.
A W’ J’ , x bb x p B p p bb v. T q p v p . T b p v J’ -. F, p p p. A p , M v p p pv v J I’ M.
T p M’ pp. I b Ab p J pp
v J I’ p. T, p v I pp, v’ p, p Bb, v p J’ b. TEv J v p M v’ .
T Ev pz p p - b v p . S b b p (:2–
6) (J: 89–208). Hv, b v Hb Bb S p - p b pz v pp G (.., G :–2:4) p-p G I’ (.., Jb, E, 2 B.53–4). M’ p M p (Wj:2–3).
T, M’ b x . xp b pv 3 x 4 (B: –9). Tb b Ev’ v (C2000:53). A p Βίβλος γενέσεως, v
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 135/247
26 BAHI A GEE HE I BIBICA SIES
Hb Bb b J. I M :– p q -
S p p b J G’ p v G’ p Ab (G 2:2–3; z). B p p Hb Bb, Ev p P P P “” (b: 3–5).
I v p M’ . Hv, p pz M v : p . A q v I’ v M, I’ v pp. T xp Bb p M :–2. Hv, v p p .G Ab v-v v b fp (G 2:–). B G’ J b fp Ep (46:–2). Ab pp I’ - x. b v Hb’ H
(J –3). I J B-, bp v ( S 6:4), J (M 2:), J, p b M 2:5. F, v’ p J b p I (2S 5:6–9) F S p. G b J p v (2 2:).
T, M’ p -x I’ v . T xp p q b
p p p I’ . M E bv, “I p , p - xp; p -p v” (990:36). M’ , p F Gp, p b I’ - b G pp, p, J M “ v.” Hv, f p bv xp.
B p b, , p v p x.W , pv p M:– b p b , x, .
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 136/247
FE: MAHEW’S GEEAG 2
M’ p p J v
v v b Bb x. Hv, Βίβλος γενέσεως M :– - Hb Bb, p v. . G Hb Bb v b (..,G 0:), (G: 3). Ev J, p M’ , p v .
A M p b bv p p I v v (C 2000:58). W -b .Hv, M’ I, Jb, J, Pz, v, S I’ , b p G pv I’ .
F, : (:3), b (:5), (:5b), “ ” (.., Bb [:6b]). I v , , pp Hb Bb. H-v, v Ev M’ b p (“A B”; H 99:32; v A: 84; W: 66–6; C 2000:58). I , Bb pp M’ pb , C –2, b pp Hb Bb.
T b M-’ . T xp v b f . S xp b . () T , p J’ (J: 8; Aq: 62). (2) T - x v . T v G’ p p M b J(S: 94–05; A 983:9; P: 22–36; H: ; H:
32; B 993:42). (3) T x v v pv J b (v: 65; Sb). (4)T G “” p v v J f (: 8–80; S:
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 137/247
28 BAHI A GEE HE I BIBICA SIES
38; G: 4–5; S: 4–25; C 996:23; z: 00). (5) T v : G p v J’
, , p , b G v , M (B: 48–50). (6) J- p b P xp v M S xp vM (6–9). () T G, x p M b J. T, xp b v v v I (Sb: ; v A: ; P: 9–20). (8) I v , JP H v , b p- p ’ v. J’ b M S v ’ (H: 544–45). (9) T p G v p b v xp-. T p pp M, b J, p Jp p (Wj:26). (0) E W p p
p p I’ v . T p p p . T v pp q p b v - (60–69). () A-J v , b, , Bb xp “ .” T , p - p - ,
p . T v I’. T -: , p p, , p.T b - (340–4).
S xp b -. T M b . I , Hb :3 b’
( J 2:25), G 38:28 ’ , 4: p . (Wj: 205–30;v: 0; C 2000:59). I b M, b .
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 138/247
FE: MAHEW’S GEEAG 29
Sv pv J b. T
x pv v J’ b. M , p v (J: 48; H: 32; v: 340;Wj: 29).
C x pb xp p . Hv, p :S, b, . T, pv xp- p , b, , Bb (: 9).
J pp p M b b v’ G, p Mb. I 23:3, G M v p “ Mb b b ord.” T-, v b M. T P b G’ v I’ q xp . A pp pp, v A v b -
S p J p (). I bb .
F, b G, Bb . I 2 S :3 Bb - E, I G (23:34). Hv, M :6 bBb “ ,” H- G. T Hb Bb b .Pbb J b G (P, Virt. 220; Jb.4:; . J. 0:). I p G ,
z p J. F xp, b v p I’ G (P, Virt. 220–222). I, p M, G.
W - J’ b , xpf b, p, p.C p xp
, , (2000:6). Hv, v B’ v . I, . H M p F Gp v b -
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 139/247
30 BAHI A GEE HE I BIBICA SIES
p .
W p p p p xp I’ p , p . W’ v’ vb p, ’ . Hv, p - . xp v xp Sp p. I b I’ M v p v . , Gpp I v -. T p xp v p b p b M, p p b b Jp (M :9).T, M’ b pp I’ v . T , - p, p p. T
b Gp, J’ J v p (M 5:–; 23:25–26).
Hv, B xp G pv I . T v v p bv p v v , p p b v ,
, p. p, Ev p J - Gp p p p I pp (M 4:8–0; 2:6; 20:–6;2:2, 28–46; 26:6; 2:40, 5). T p b v Gp. F xp, M 2 Ev b J “ H ” (2:) b b b J. T b v’ v’ .
A p M’ p b p p. W’ p . S “-” “” “ p” z pb
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 140/247
FE: MAHEW’S GEEAG 3
p p . C ,W b
p v ; p p , pv p bb v (65–6). T p p p ’ q b b .
T v p xp p B pp . B , “V pp , bv, ppp p p, , v p - v b bv q, p” (984:4). S, , pp-, v p M’ “” B. T Ev p J’ . T M :– pp v b J’ G’ p I . I
p b v vxp v pp .
Conclusion
B’ v v pv pp- bb , pp ( p) x. B p -
v M’ xp.
B’ p b pq b b , , x, . T p bb . , x-z ppp p x.F xp, I p v M’
v (:22–23; 2:5b–6, 5b, –8, 23b) v p- v b vq M M2:–2 (F: 28–3, 53–6). A , B’ pv p - p p . .
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 141/247
32 BAHI A GEE HE I BIBICA SIES
B v B’ p- p pv x
p b (995:9).W , I v pp p -
p bb . I , MV p p Gp M G- bp (V). H v b p M’ pp p H J v. V Bpv b , (6–64). W , B f - Gp p b how . I xp, B q- H , b q pp :
pb H p pb q. , - -p q v, q b x, q , v ’ q . A pb q : q v , ? (98: 69)
I b v b , pp FEv .
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 142/247
Bakhtin’s Dialogism and the Corrective
Rhetoric o the Johannine Misunderstanding
Dialogue: Exposing Seven Crises
in the Johannine Situation
Paul N. Anderson
O w R M B, w - . O , B b “” - . Bw z , w . O , B w “.” B b w , -, , .O , w ,B w :
“ ”—b , —w
. N, , J 6 (A996:67–25). H w E’ w , w , JC , w w . O
, ’ w ’, B’ w “A Awb” (990:–3) “A H A A” (990:4–256) ; , B’w w b (98); - , b , B’ SP (V 983).
-33-
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 143/247
34 BAHN AND ENRE HEORy N BBCA SDES
z w . C — , , ,
— w w - . (98:64)2
W F C D, W, S M, j- J b , w, b z , b P, w b J “.” H
, b J’ -w , b . j J J, b w itsel
j, J, , .A P’ , w b b , w b — b .3 T . J, J ; is w . A,B w, “S () w -: w ( f )w w z w w” (984:403).
T b , w, w - w b w b . T w “,” “-” ( B’ w),
q b . W -, , b
2. O , M E 990:42–45, 306–65.3. A (996:94–97). N bw P’
b 7 Republic J : () b , w b b ; (2) b “ w” w-
; (3) w , j w; (4) b (b ), ; (5) w (S/J) b j , b P’/F E’ . , / ’ .
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 144/247
ANDERSON: BAHN’S DAOSM 35
so do the persons and groups in the audience they represent . w, F ’ J’
P’ S’ ï - . b P J w w -
— w b— - b w .
A B’ w , w J w - . T J - b E . D w , J b w
b. S w -z F , c.e., w w b w J C b J’ . W , B’
w w, - w b ’ .
F, w, b B’ w - . W bj w w C w w w - , w B () w , w w w w-. B b S b
q . , B - j b.4 H w w , ,, , w .5 E
4. , B , b ,, , w. ,
w b w - (A 996:37–25; 2004:27–48; A, E, Fw 2004:247–76).O B , M E 990:72–230; -, Hq 990:4–39; , J 987.
5. O , V 983,M E 990:23–7; Hq 990:40–66;
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 145/247
36 BAHN AND ENRE HEORy N BBCA SDES
B w , -
(/ ) , b .6 T ; - , . w, F E S J .
A J’ w- - b E’ --- C, w w J w. R bw /w C, b/- , J’ b w E. , b C. . B M B same passage Teatetus (89–90) bw w w (B 972:49–50; V 983:34). J’ C-
, “T D T S. J,” B J’ J’ :
F b S S . S — , , ,, b, , w , b. A - .
S. “D b ‘’ w ?”. “W ?”S. “ w w - .” (B 972:49–50)
, P 985; S 992; Hq 990:67–06; - j bw , S 988 Hq990:07–48; , D 99 M E
990:23–68.6. B’ (B 993) ; (98:84–258) ; (98:258–422) w bw b .
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 146/247
ANDERSON: BAHN’S DAOSM 37
T S bb , , J w,
b B w . A b E , w, b J ’ . J, E -
w (). T F E-
b w w b w J- C. A W M ,
M , b bw ’ b w w b b . (M 986:45)
w E w w J -, wb b w J. A b , w w b , w - J . E , wb w J “ ” b w J ( S w, N,
P, M M, Ἰουδαῖοι, .) w w w. b j; bb w b! C, , J .
he Dialectical Johannine Situation.
W J b ,
w J, w J E, J b -. J. M (2003:27–43) b w w J’ w
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 147/247
38 BAHN AND ENRE HEORy N BBCA SDES
, w w J . R
j , J C w A M , j . T w , f , w w w F w b . b , w J w , b b b , .7
, b ’ J . T - w, b . T : () w- J’ b Bb (w , P; . 6, 5–7, 2; BD w b , Jw/J R/C
- - - );8 (2) J E ( / b w); (3) - J A (w R b w , J -, b b w); (4)/ w S ( bw J M b
J’ , bw J’ M b ); (5) b w J 6 ( b
7. b R B 998: w , . H b b w J M.
8. O b, ’ (98:46–54) b b. A w, J (80–85 c.e.) w (00 c.e.) b , w b b J E (85–95 c.e.), B D ( A 2006:93–95; b 2.5 64).
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 148/247
ANDERSON: BAHN’S DAOSM 39
“ ” w- , b J6 J b ).9
, J j w w . A (- w ) , w- J’ — w J — w:0
An Outline o the Johannine Situation in ongitudinal Perspective
P : T P , (. 30–70 c.e.)C A D w / (/J)
C B R w J B
T oral Johannin tradition dvlops.
P 2: T A M , (. 70–85 c.e.)
C A E Jw
C B D w R
T rst dition o th Johannin Gospl is prpard.
P 3: T A M , bw (. 85–00c.e.)
C A E z C
C B E C z (D )
9. W M w J 9 w J 6 (A- 997:24–57). H, , w J b, : () J’ ( w S ; (2) w Jw “b” M () b b J; (3) b, R
b J 6; (4) “b” , - z C; (5) P b D (3 J 9–0). “” w q bw .
0. M b R Bw 2003, w ( A 2006:96–99).
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 149/247
40 BAHN AND ENRE HEORy N BBCA SDES
C C E C J (
)
T Epistls ar writtn by th Johannin Eldr, who thn
nalizs and irulats th tstimony o th Blovd Disipl
afr his dath. 100 c.e.
- w J-b - b w w J B, b w - J
. T b b - b J . W w w , : () - bw P (, S, b) J (J) ; (2) b ww J B J M; (3) b w Jw J; (4) R q b ; (5) b
, z C, R D; (6) - ; (7) (M S) J ( ). E J b -
J. F, b
b w , w w b J J. A , w, b J .
. W J 6 w , J M/S w w w . O , - , , j w M .
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 150/247
ANDERSON: BAHN’S DAOSM 4
he Rhetorical Function o theJohannine Misunderstanding Dialogue.
T J b w , w b w w . T . V J J’ / ’ , (J3:5–7). S, J B, w w J, P, J’ w (w), w J C, w , , , W .2 , ’ b , Leitmoti (20:3). A S S :
F w J. , w, b - J’ - b b F (7:6–8) w b J (0:30;4:9–) b (7:8).3
A w w ( can F b w; 6:44, 65) - - , b. F, z w B b , . N
groups Ἰουδαῖοι ( ), “w” ( ), “ ” (- J’ w, w-b w) , b individuals N, P, P f b E. B ,
2. P -, : :–8 ( W w);
5:5–5 (J b ); 0:22–39 (J J);:7–45 (J M/M ); 2:20–50 ( J’); 7:–26 (J ); 20:0–8 (J M M).
3. S 982:39. N, w, B : Nw 996 C 2003.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 151/247
42 BAHN AND ENRE HEORy N BBCA SDES
w - . R, E’ b
w w J J, b E J w.
N w w f - . F, f ’ w -. H “-” J, w j ’ J, b b . W J, b q, b b b b JJ. A w ( J J 2, b w J’ “”), b J’ q, - b , . T, w w :
he Form o the Johannine Misunderstanding Dialogue
() T b.
(2) J, q , b , ’ q .
(3) J , b , , F’ w, , .
(4) T () b , b .
(5) J’ (f) , Cb “” , J’ ,’ w, S, .
(6) T b w
.(7) S ()
w : b w , b , w j .
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 152/247
ANDERSON: BAHN’S DAOSM 43
B , w f - b w “” w ,
, , b , , , . N ’ j, b B D-, “H ” ( “D N,” 98:39). , “ q” Te Brothers Karamazov b Q , b b w- J (J 8:32) - b w (6:32–33). , “” b D, z b B, ’ J. J - f, - w B “F S ,” wb “ b, descended ” (98:400).4 T b b J w . W f, w-, J ’ , w (M, J B, W ), b -
. C, , J’ b P J.
() F, b (J 8:28–32): C P , P bj J b R , b J b Jw . (2) P z J “ Jw” (8:33). (3) J P, q q P’ w (8:34).H “” b , -
P’ w w J’ b . (4) P j J’ J’ w w b (8:35), “ .” (5) J’ : , “” (8:36–37); w . (6) P’ b: “W ?” (8:38). T -
4. N J R w D , b - w cosmos - (A- 996:22–24; 997:7–24).
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 153/247
44 BAHN AND ENRE HEORy N BBCA SDES
, w P b q Jw, J. D j
J w Bbb, w j . T P w J , b (8:39–9:6) b w J . A w’ b (“W b C!”) J w b. (7) F, P w w , w w b J: “H was Jw” (9:7–22). A , w, J’ w P w w J P-. , w b w R - J , b w w w w w w .
T J “,” , w b /
J. T q/, ,, J . W ’ q b ’ - , b w : w , w w . T w J’ . W w J j, b ; , w w J , - w w. B , E :
H, (w ), another’s speech in another’s language, b w. S - double-voiced discourse. w w :
w , .(98:324)
A w b , E, J -
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 154/247
ANDERSON: BAHN’S DAOSM 45
J .
Seven Crises ithin the Johannine Situationand heir Dialogical Engagement the Narrator
W q, - . P w, , J b . S , w -. F , J q S- ( - J5) , b . A, . C w - bw q-- A M . T w - w R w “
Nz” w Jw , - w . T, w D. , C b b bw J b w C , b C. T , , w b z - , b
b w -. H, J - w , b w b . W w , J — — b .
() T b bw J Ἰουδαῖοι -
bw J
5. S A 996:48–65. F J’ , A 200; 200b; 2002; 2004.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 155/247
46 BAHN AND ENRE HEORy N BBCA SDES
.6 W Ἰουδαῖοι b J, j J
. T w “ Jw,” J, B D, w J deeply Jewish. D J b bb b- -S, J Ἰουδαῖοι b -S. , w S M, w w b w jb . F J , w, - J .
A Ἰουδαῖοι J, w-w w J J. W b w ( 3,bw) b J (9:22; 2:42; 6:2), - bw J - J.7 Fw J-b’ q J B w w C, Ej, P (:9–28), J J . T J f -
(2:8). J —b “ ” , f b — , w - j (2:9–2). T - b J’ ’ w (2:22).
T - J 5 7, w Sbb b J’
6. R - (J/J -/S ) w : :47–5 (J N); 2:3–25 (J /J ); 4:4–42 (J S w/S); 5:6–47 (J J ); 7:25–44( J: P/J J); 7:45–52 ( , , P, N); 8:9–24 ( J). S A- 996:94–25; Bw 2003:57–72.
7. A, j w Jw
J w , J . b Jw-J , w w B w “” (98:34–55), - b J J, w Jw b b .
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 156/247
ANDERSON: BAHN’S DAOSM 47
. H J- Ἰουδαῖοι w . F, b ,
J Sbb, J w F (5:0–8). , - J J 5 b w . A, q 2:8 J . T w-b -b, J’ b F (D8:5–22) b J 5. C, J
, S , - w - J, w S w (5:39–40). W , J w M w (5:46).
T b w J , , J 7, J6 b bw 5 7 - . R J 5 , J’ J b b J’ J (7:–0, 25), b
Sbb (7:9–24). J j j (7:25), q J b w . F, Ἱεροσολυμιτῶν (J) J w w b C. T -, , b w w w C , b J w (7:25–27). H “w”bj (πόθεν) . T J wJ’ “” b (ἐκ τῆς Γαλιλαίας), w ( j) b F (7:6–8, 28–29, 33).
J’ (7:37–39), b J w J - , b C. T J, w, b b C b w C b
D B (7:40–43). T - z J’ b D J M M J . W P J, b b
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 157/247
48 BAHN AND ENRE HEORy N BBCA SDES
b w (7:44–48). W N , w’ q b j
, q w — J . T J w : w J --M D 8:5–22 (A 999), - , w w J (J 7:50–52).
T - b J b w w S. N b J, b b J b b J . T b- , b C w R C, w ---b J . F, w, - , w . S w’ q, w w w w J, b b w
M z. R, b S - , w w b . TF w w w (J 4:24).
(2) T w J B b J w.8 F, J J w J’ . ,J’ b w, b J J was b , w— P. B , B
“b ” (M E 990:353–55;B 98:38–85) J b - - w. J b w, “P w !” S, B w ἐγὼ οὐκ εἰμὶ (:20, 2, 27; 3:28) b ἐγώ εἰμι J J (w , 4:26; 6:20;8:24, 28, 58; 3:3, 9; 8:5, 6, 8, 37). W J’ w
8. R w J B J , w : :9–34 (J J );:35–43 (J J’ ); 2:– (J’ J); 3:22–36 ( Jq J); 4:27, 3–38 (J’ J); 4:46–54 ( J). R Bw w (2003:53–57).
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 158/247
ANDERSON: BAHN’S DAOSM 49
J M w w , w . J b; J b.
T, w J’ w w -w . T B’ w J (:35–5) w : “B b w w w!” T w w J bw J: Aw P. T w w w - . J w w, w B( F E ) b .
T B’ w . T b b w J, b J b J w J w B. A , J w -. N J M J , b J b J (3:30). W B’ , / . A w-b w J B w b : J, M. T,
b b , w B j J w w J M/C ( A 2000:0–3).H “” w .
(3) T b w , bb 70 80, b J’ .9 V w Jw - , w Bw (2003), M, Rb b . w
b , w, Nicodemus, w J b —bb Jw , q (b“ ”), b. N, w, (“ P … Jw … ”) . , -C-
9. R w Jw Jw C
A M , w : 3:–2 (N J);6:30–59 ( w/ Jw J); 7:–24 ( Jw J); 8:2–58 (J J/b Jw/P); 9:8–34 ( b b/ P/Jw ); 9:35–0:2 (J b b/P). w J E ( J 2:8–25); A 997:32–40; Bw 2003:72–75.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 159/247
50 BAHN AND ENRE HEORy N BBCA SDES
(w R Bw C b w b f w C)
b J J. N , w ( w J 6) J’: “Rbb, w w w , … b w ” (3:2). Hw, wJ , “ b b, bb b” (3:3), N . H J b. A J b b w . O b b b (ἄνωθεν)—b
S— . (3:5) P w -C, w b b , b w ’ w S j, ’ (3:–2). T .
w, b bw J Jw J C .Ob “ w” z - J - , Sbb w,
S , M Ab, D , J( ) , Jw ( ) , - . T 6:32: “ M w gave…, b F w gives you the true bread rom heaven.” B - , w J w . R, , w S . , b z . T w,w, b conventionalism. C F , E :
N, w, Jw b ,b b P , b (ἀποσυνάγωγοι γένωνται). F . (J 2:42–43)
A , b, B
b w Jw z. b— bw. T , w-, w - w . B’
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 160/247
ANDERSON: BAHN’S DAOSM 5
(- ) b J w. T “b q”
Jw w J J-, C, S’ , J, b J’ . B z z, E ’ b Jw C b.
(4) A J C R bj w C b q b .20 E - , bb -- 80, w b J P . A b w (. 43–44), J is , b . T , w w J’ . P’ q “W ?” - w P b, , J’. (8:28–40) H b , wb , R z
. O , P , b b.
A , P w b J: “D w w ?” . J b , “, w w b F w .” w , P’ b b w. H , b- w w J, b
(9:–6). F, w b b. “W b C!” . w 80, J’
20. R R w b b pax Romana w : 6:5–5 (J
/ w); 4:–3 (J : , P, J);8:–9 (J ); 8:28–9:6 (P J). D D( C 99) 8 96 c.e., D’ R w - w “ ”; b, ’ b J, “M !” w b R (A 996:22–3).
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 161/247
52 BAHN AND ENRE HEORy N BBCA SDES
w J .R b ,
P’ , , .
(5) A f J - w J’ C A M 80 90.2 J .T , b w z J 4:–3 2 J7, - J 2:8–25, , q b -. T Jw - AM C. W w , w, z - C w b , b b . W R bb C , D- w - q b w ,
, C w - . P’ w j w (Ep.0.96-97) .
W S, B, w J- , w, bw ’ w J C R. P, “ J S , b C .” A M w
w ’ q, w C , w b, . T w- , b w - J ( , -) S , z . C
2. R w z C b A M , w : 6:60–66 (J’ J); 7:–0 (J’ b J); 6:7–33 (J’ J); 2:8–22 (P J). w J E ( J 4:–3; 2 J 7; A 997:4–50; Bw2003:75–80.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 162/247
ANDERSON: BAHN’S DAOSM 53
w ( ) R “w ,” w
w J E w “” “” w w b w . T w J’ w w J , b J .
T J b ’ z b J
J 6, . A’ , j : A’ , ; J 6, J. T w Jw b w, b w - w J J’ . T b . , f J ,“ b, ,” w z. W b b b - q
6:5, “T b esh, w w.” W , b ’ w . b J b w w , ’ z. C - w J R w b F E, - . f . b b b, q Jw 6:52 b b--E b. T J ww , , w z J C Jw bjb w R ( A 996:0–36, 94–220). Tat w “ w” ww, w.
T w 6:66. E J’ b- w w . H E
b. O Einmalig (M’ “ ” ) , M (967) . T --M , J’ “w” w
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 163/247
54 BAHN AND ENRE HEORy N BBCA SDES
. T , J 6:4 66, b b J
J 6 w z (bb 90). O , q w:“W b , , w b ?”
(6) b b J -- .22 T J, , P. F, P j B D w b P’ , w B D w w w. 3J, w “D, w b ,” b JC w w , w . W , w j bj —w w F E . H J b H
S. J 20:2–23, J q M 6:7–9, Jb () b , “R H S.”T “z” (“A F , ”) them () b b . F-, P w , B D w , b , . B w w b - P .
F, P w J b “H O ,” w w q ’ b f. J j : “ chosen you the welve [
22. b w ä 968 j P B D J. R
w z (P) C , w -: 6:67–7 (J w/P); 3:–20 (S P J); 3:2–30(J /B D/J); 3:3–38 (J P); 2:–4 (J ); 2:5–7 (J P). F w w C, D (3J 9–0), A 99; 996:22–5; 997:50–57; Bw 2003:80–83.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 164/247
ANDERSON: BAHN’S DAOSM 55
, w, ], .” T, οὐκ ἐγὼ ὑμᾶς τοὺς δώδεκα ἐξελεξάμην…,
q, “H w…?” b - b, w b b “” . T w J’ P’w - . B J - “H O ”— b M :24—P J’ .
A bw P J
J’ w P’ . P - b q b, w- w . Af P’ , J . B - - , P : “, , , not …”; , b w : “ [ἀπόστολος] .” P M
6:7, b , J 3:7, b bw ; , b - j J.
T bw P J J 2 f . A w b -bw S, B D w P. b b , P j w J q. T , J P , f ( , b ). B b-. D Bw’ w b ἀγάπη φίλος , P J’j ἀγάπη . H (ἐλυπήθη) J q , b w P’ . P , -
w b E C: b w C .W b , j J’ P, b b, w P. T
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 165/247
56 BAHN AND ENRE HEORy N BBCA SDES
w - J J 6:7–8.
C F ’ , bb 90, J P. H b , b . W M b w b, J S-b . T b b J’ , w J (6:7–8, ):
, , “W ’ : ‘ w w’ ?’ A, ‘A, w w ?’ A, ‘B F?’ ” , , “ “ w” ’ b leaves us absolutely clueless!”
F B , w , w w bw. T -- q / /. T , . J 6 b w 7, ä . W J J, w P . ’ b b , J J
b . B - q . T C J w b w -, w b b w b. Ten w w b .
(7) E w S b , , J .23 H , q, b -
23. R w S J’ , w : 6:25–30 ( w J); 9:–7(J’ J); :–6 (J ); 2:4–7 (J J); 20:24–29 (J ); 2:8–25 (J P). O J -
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 166/247
ANDERSON: BAHN’S DAOSM 57
. O w M z w w, w
J b J’ .T J w b w . W J b (“P …, ” [20:27]), . “B w ,” J J, “ b.” A , b b, T , “M !” B b J b -
b? T E b, T’ J b j w . S T J.
w w b b J J J6. B , C J “-” w. Af J’ , w
, , “Rbb, w ?” q: “W ?” J z w : “y not b w b b w !” T b. J w b, b b b . H /- w , b b w : J’ b
F , . N - w b J, b J’ . “A w -” all fve Synoptic eeding accounts, J , b J J j . R bw b , w bb C J’ , b S , b b J J. .
w M J’ , A 997:24–32;200; 200b; 2002; Bw 2003:90–4.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 167/247
58 BAHN AND ENRE HEORy N BBCA SDES
W w , b, —
— b . T b w J — b —w J’ w. T w -
w - C , J J .
F, , - M ’ S M w b . J’ J J w B D w ( b F z). R, P, “W .… w !”(2:8–23). , , -, b J w . B F , J w b w b- .24 B- , J J; contributes .
Conclusion
, M B J . F, b / J , ’w E’ b w —? A B,w. F, w H W w
. b , z .S, B w b - q , b b w w . A- C Hq:
24. S Te Fourth Gospel and the Quest or Jesus, w w- b S J , 4 (A 2006:27–73). H , b (A 200b), w b w bj -.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 168/247
ANDERSON: BAHN’S DAOSM 59
D B’ w … -. D b
, b bw bw , b. … Dialogism liberates preciselybecause it insists that we are involved in the making o meaning . (C Hq: 348)
F, w B w bwJ’ J E’ , q-- , B
w , b . Hw , w, - - ; wb, w b , w w . F, w w ’ w . M , w ourselves w w J J, ’ w
w, N, T, Jw, P, . W w, B w:
w w. w . .E b w b , w w b w .A , b w b -
’ w w b w . F b : w . (C Hq: 350)
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 169/247
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 170/247
Liberation Story or Apocalypse?
Reading Biblical Allusion and
Bakhtin heory in oni Morrison’s Beloved
B M
W , , “G”— , — O , — ’ F O O R j J—
Allusion and Bakhtin’s heory: Double-Voiced Discourse
B B’ : m w . B B . T -, B , (B 1981:294).I , “ .” I , , : “F , … . S ” (280). B , . B’ , “
” ( 1984:52).W B - ’ , - ’ , (M E 1990:146). D-
-161-
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 171/247
162 BAI AD GERE EOR I BIBLIAL SDIES
, “” — , -, ’ . S
, ’ .
B . - , . T B j B , J ; J. S , : W ( ) M’ “” z - . I J, , ’ I J , I “” ’ F ,
O “”
“ ” () (B-P 1976:107–8). T B’ : , — J J J J.
onversation between Languages: Dialogized Heteroglossia
D B’ -, . T B , - .
A , … - - , , -- , , , , .
(1981: 291)
T j , -, - , B “” “” . “T …
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 172/247
MADDISO: LIBERAIO SOR OR APOALPSE 163
…; … ” (278–79).
B :
A , [] m f w , . (361)
W - - , —
B’ — “m”: - (295–96).
B “,” “ ,” I . J -
, - , I , -
m .I B , , (288–89).
T ’ A A z (.., 1997:43–44). T “-” , S, , . M -
M G, (39). L, A (43–44). T - B - — - 124 BR , , . I , -. T : ,
- S P D, , , , .
T B - A A ( P: 115, 116). T
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 173/247
164 BAI AD GERE EOR I BIBLIAL SDIES
B I A A ( G: 207). A A
’ A E j- , , A . T , G’ J G. I /, , I - , , ( , ) () . F ’ R, B, .1 I B , /: I —
he Exodus/onquest in African America
T A A - , P L , , , , (R: 351). S “G D, M” M’ P, “ E ,” M’ , “ P, L .” “D’ O P GL” P’ R S. “R, J, R”
: “I I J .” P A , z MA, “D R”: “I , , .” T j J’ j J “R O, M”: “R M, J,I .”
T A A .S. -, J O R,
1. /, ’
G S S . F
, M 2005: 73–104.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 174/247
MADDISO: LIBERAIO SOR OR APOALPSE 165
. I B , M . A j I
, I G B S, , J , S P, O, J. I D, M: , . B :
(J) “G” B S ( )
M D ( )
R S [ _______________________ ]
J S P ( O; J)
J O ( )
S M’ R S,
A -. I A A , O R J P L, A - A, M P. T j , ; E A . T “S M- ” M .
I B, M z . S M P, A’ j . T
j A .M - O, , A A; j j
M P(.., z: 108).T B
B M M P (1994).B M P, :
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 175/247
166 BAI AD GERE EOR I BIBLIAL SDIES
A AA.… I [] -- …
A , A A , MP A …W , , , . A A, A A, A A (1997:366)
, “ … A W. S A ” (367). B A A , :
A , , , .… I j, , z , . S I , “ .” (366)
A-A , A.
he Exodus/onquest Dialogized in the ovel
G A A , J — B S, S’ , S — S “” O. T - J. T J , “.” M ’
J, “T L ” ( 13:16). M’ J “ ”
’ . , ,
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 176/247
MADDISO: LIBERAIO SOR OR APOALPSE 167
. O, , W ,
’ . (184–85)
I , , L; . W J’ , - . P 2 -B , S, ,D, “” , 124 B R (: 337).
T O J S P , (M: 184). I :
[ ’] . R , . , . , . (180)
T , , : “D , , O ” (66).
T - “ ” 124: S S F SA. S j --, . T S
, . BS P , “-” .
E , , - , “B” . W , :
, “A ” (50). W S --, : “S .… T
. L , .… B ” (51).
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 177/247
168 BAI AD GERE EOR I BIBLIAL SDIES
T S , - , S , D, .
T , -. B B , . S -, , :
A I I - I . (210)
I , - , “S M ” ’ . T -B, “ [] ,” M P.
I M P R S — - -J M M R S. O,
’ M’ , , R S , . B . M P . P M’ M P , I . T R S , —-
— . T A - z B , .
T , .S D S , , , . A , , . ,
O. “T …, , , , S’” (84). T M , P’ (E 2:1–11). I
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 178/247
MADDISO: LIBERAIO SOR OR APOALPSE 169
, P’ “ M, … I ” (2:10). I M’ , ,
-, “S’ I . W … .… S M A D” (85).S A , D, , , .
W , D 124 , S D , , B:
[S’] [ B] , . E , . (239)
D , . “I ,” “ ” (239, 241).B S , D G B ,
“ ,” , “G . G ” (244). T - - (, .., : 103). W D , : , “ . O . A , .… ‘M. L W’ -” (249). A ,
“-,” B (256., 261).
ime and Space in the ovel: Dialogized Chronotope
T . B “M’ ‘’ [] A A- ,” (1997:42). R “
,” . R, “ , W- , , .T ‘’ W ‘’ ”(45). B , D “ : ‘I’
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 179/247
170 BAI AD GERE EOR I BIBLIAL SDIES
.… W ,
, , ’”(45). , D’ : z “ [ ] , .” I D , .
A B’ , - - , (/), - . “ … ; ” (250–51). O , -: / “” , , (M E: 368). S B : “ ,” “ ,”
, “ ,” “ … ; … , ” (243–48). F B’ , A- “” .
L P, , S D :
“S . P . S j . I
. . S . O .B ’ . P, . I , ’ , — —, j , . W I . I , I ’ , I , - I , , . R .”
“ ” D.“O, , , . S
. S . A ’ . A . B . I’ . W I I , . I’ . E — . ’ ,
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 180/247
MADDISO: LIBERAIO SOR OR APOALPSE 171
— — , ; ,
. S, D, ’ . . B ’ — —’ .’ I . .”
D . “I ’ , , .”
S D’ . “ ,” .(P: 186)
, P , , “ … …
.” A “ ” (186).J B - ,
; :
, -, , , - .…
. (252)
B D Qx, “z ‘, ’ ‘ ’ ’ ” (1981:165).
I B , M A A A “” ( W)
, . S S P D, , , , , . S B - . T , A, P L, , , - S ( ). A -, . A P G “ :
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 181/247
172 BAI AD GERE EOR I BIBLIAL SDIES
z -, [ ] []
B” (36–37).I “ ,”
: J B’ P L, , O ’ .I W , . S , E, , . B ’ A , , S “ .” T .
M ’ - , 124. W , M M G S . B , ’ A , , D’ : D ,
“ ” , D .
J P B “ ”: “P- [ ] .… T ”(141). S B , P : “T B , ” (145). W A , .
S ; . P , I - , . T — B , , — z P G .T
--- — ’ .
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 182/247
MADDISO: LIBERAIO SOR OR APOALPSE 173
onclusion in Polyphony
I B , . - , B . G:
G , — ,
. (1981:366)
T B m- . .
T ’ / AA. I M M P
A R S. T A - . - , S B O, “” . T , M P- B . D,M , A M. I M A ’ , M -
S’ : “ z” ’ (M: 261). I - S’ I , S P J: w j . S … / “”
T B, ,
. . “O : [] ’” (267). A - , : “L, 124, , , , ” (267).
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 183/247
D ’ L J,
’ F (M 15:33–39 ). D ’ A , / “ ”
T : “I ”; “T .” T “ ”(, .., : 260). O , “I ,” . . “ ,” : “I ”; [], . I , ’ -. T ’ z— - — . T , —z— , “ .” W
B’ , I : I A
A ’ : “I , ; , ” (R 9:25). G ’ “S M ” ’ , : A T ,
R — — : w A , — — A — A A, A F
B’ , A A .
174 BAI AD GERE EOR I BIBLIAL SDIES
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 184/247
ResponseBeyond Formalism:
Genre and the Analysis o Biblical exts
Keith Bodner
T I g g . F, M. M. B . I B gzg g g gg , .
S, g ormalism.T , - g g . Y g g genre , g . T, ,
.A g, g, C-
M I g S’ . S
C, I Kg .T g R 2 S 4 - g de rigueur . H, C q , g q C g . S g- , g C’ I - .
A M’ Kg A 2 C 13:23–15:15(mt). A , D H, g - g . I
-175-
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 185/247
176 BAKHI AD GR HRY I BIBICA SuDIS
M’ g “ g ,” Jg Kg A
. T ( -g-) g, . T g A Jg , M - g .
T C’ Jg, M , A “ G.” T g. G, A g , g -. F, A, G, (g - -, ). A, , I -, M’ g: “Tg g C, g Jg( g D H ?) g : g?” Gg (2 C 13), -g g g . I
2 C 13:4–9 :
A A M Z ( - ), , “H , J I! D’ ord G I g g D I , ? A J S, D g . [Myqr My#$n)] B g- , g R
S, R , , g . B , g gg g ord D’ , g g J g. H’ ord A ? A g -g!”
I G Jg A 2 C, ,g g J’ Jg9. J J g A “ ” (Myqr My#$n), A
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 186/247
BDR: RSS—BYD FRMAISM 177
J I g D A . ,
g (J “” q, A gg), . T A’ g, . J “” (br)m) 2 C 13:13, A (br)m) Jg 9:35, ggg .
T , , 2 C 13–15 Jg 6–9. I g , M- D H: “I gg, ,” , “ C fg Jg g g A g ( A G?).” I A G, A G’ J. A Jg - g J A g D H, fg
J C. B g Jg , C- g g g , g . S C M g C g .
Ag R z, B G g g B . H ( Mikhail Bakhtin and Biblical Scholar-ship: An Introduction; King Saul’s Asking ; How Are the Mighty Fallen: A
Dialogical Study o King Saul in 1 Samuel ) , g g . Ig , G 1 S g -, “D H” J 2 Kg. , DH , G g , - g .
G’ g g g -. B g, : “T g g q , , , ,
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 187/247
178 BAKHI AD GR HRY I BIBICA SuDIS
.” I ’ g , , g g
“,” . F, G’ 1 S 20. T ; ’ , “ ,” G .I G :“ B, g ( not , ) gg g ( is g ). I , J, S, D I g . W ‘ ’ , , - .”
D H, J g . 1 S 20 g , g g. , ( ) g
D g . , g .Y B G g -’ . W J , I J’ ? - J . F f , J ’ .
I D and S g J g . J
site , J-’ , . I , g J D , S g . J g q S D .H S’ D -g (). A G , J’ D. J g f (“!”) D’
g S g - q: “W [S] ?” F G, D’ J’ -: “B g q, J D’g .” T g q,
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 188/247
BDR: RSS—BYD FRMAISM 179
g g q g. , , g only Jonathan
speaks in the feld . D . J , 20:13–17:
“A ord . I I , ord , I , , ord D’ . A J D, ord D’.” A g J D
, .
B , J’ S’ . A g G’ , J’ g -. g, J g D beore S f g ( 20:30.), “” S’ , g- D. F , J
I g, g .W , : 14 , “ D,” S ( G gg). I , , S g J’ , J .
W J q, (?) ’ . A S q, “,” : I J I, ? A G , “I f,S J g J’ g g ( ’ ).” G, B’ , g g J B Jg 20, g S . Cq, J D gg “ ” “ ,” S ,
g ( ) J’ .
Ag J’ 20:42 (“J D, ‘G , ord, g, “M
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 189/247
180 BAKHI AD GR HRY I BIBICA SuDIS
ord , -” ’ ”),
g g g .I , , J’ / g. A G , “M S ‘’ (J D ) g - .” T J g D g .
T J F-W’ , I , . T . S , , . F F-W, G 38 g .
S , G 38 g g , F-W g, g g , , . A F-W ,
clothing , g ( ) “, , , ” “ .” Cg . , G 38 g G. WF-W “” g G 38, g g :
R g I , . A
g, g . B R J, , g, “B, I g , g, ‘Bg g, , I , ord I.’ S , , I g . g , g g [Myz(h yydg], I ,
. g , .” … A R ,
, , J, g . (G 27: 5–10, 15)
F-W g g G 27 . T g
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 190/247
BDR: RSS—BYD FRMAISM 181
J - and g .F, “g” (Myz(h yydg) g
g. I , R . A , g, g g 25 : “ .… g.”A F-W , “T /J g G .” W , , G 38 g - . J g g- , 37 J g g-.
G 37 , R A , measure-or-measure J. A g -g J , J J. I g ,J g g g (Myz( ry(#&). A G 27, .
J J g g g g, - .T J ( ) -g, . H B, g g 38. A F-W g, - () J. Hg H A B-, J
, g--, g g . T , F-W- , “-g” J . T g g (Myz(-ydg) ’ , J g ( g g ), - .
Ag . A. S G 38 -
g , J F-W g - g. I , J/ g g J , “ ”
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 191/247
182 BAKHI AD GR HRY I BIBICA SuDIS
g . A , G 38 g g g . A
1 S 19, S’ g M g g g’ (Myz(h rybk), I . , I F-W’ g royal .
C M g S B - “B ,” B . T - H B H B g : , , . I , g -z g g (g ) other g . T, I , g .
A g , I g DV
( “ ,” M ). T I g. , I g gz DV “,” g - S. H, I DV -gg g / g. , M g, “T DV Yhwh’ g ,, g g .” B, , : “W ,
g, g , , g - g ?” , B g q. I g B gzg g g ? W this g -g ( , S D M, q )?
F “ ” , 22 . S g- g , M g. I 22, M’ g.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 192/247
BDR: RSS—BYD FRMAISM 183
F, , g (“M G, G”) q H B. B -
g , G, g
g. W g, , 8 (g ), q : “R ord! . , g !” I M g DV 3 g DV . B DV, q “” , gg DV g. I , DV “,” , , gg ’ DV
g .S, 21, , M-
, ( ) DV. 21, , . I “ ,” I
- , “ ” (yntyn( Mymr ynrqmw). A g g g g , “” 21 . S , , gg ’
. T , DV. A
, “” g gg .T g D “g ” .
T, -g . A ,g , g
g . - , I ! T “ gg” q , g “ g , !” T DV
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 193/247
184 BAKHI AD GR HRY I BIBICA SuDIS
, g . A
, DV “g ” g , g . Tg M’ , I I g g , q .
A g D V SB A Mg g, I I D “g, ” q . , g gg D 1–6, “” . I g I g D, -. W , : - g, ï. J z A , g .
M V
g ggg q , , D. , I g D 5 g g . F , 2 g “” -, “-” . I 5, , g g . A
, g , g kjv:
, g g, , , , , . I g ’, g g’ : g . g’ g, g ,
[Nyrt#$m hcrx yr+qw],
g . (D 5:4–6)
“F g g g ,” V, “ q g .” A Bzz’ g, “” ,
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 194/247
BDR: RSS—BYD FRMAISM 185
g “ ” g G J g . B
. , ( g,) g gg, (Nyrt#$m hcrx yr+qw), “ g.” S z, g g, , q , . T , g g , q , g g ,
g, : g , - g: g, is g; g g , g, ; gzz , g, I , , g, g, C, ; F - , g, g, g , g , g [ Nyr+q )r#$mw],
D, g Bzz: D , . (D 5:10–12)
Tg D 1–6, V , “ A gg g .” T q ’ , g . V g , q
g Bz-z “ g.” D’ vita Bzz, q g, “D” gg g . D , , “ ” ( kjv ). H, V (g A. W S. ), : q D
“g ” (Nyr+q )r#$mw), . S q .
F , Bzz g -g g D. Y g
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 195/247
186 BAKHI AD GR HRY I BIBICA SuDIS
g . H g gD’ g ,
, D ()r#$ml Nyr+qw). S, D , J A gg. , Bzz g - , g . I D g g g - . T q R g D 1–6, 5 Bzz’ g, g g . , g’ g g . A D V , A gg , g- Bzz’ g M Hg G.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 196/247
ResponseUsing Bakhtin’s Lexicon Dialogicae
to Interpret Canon, Apocalyptic,
New estament, and oni Morrison
Vr K. Rbbs
W K Bu u u 1931, u - “L Rhtr” (1968:123–83). W M Hqu u M.M. B’ T D Imt 1981, u j , u u, x
B v v x u u (1981:423–34). T u u d u u rhtr Bu u -u (Bzz Hz 1990:897–1266).
T u vu u u u 1981 B’ ( [428], [: 430], [: 426–27],
v [434], [425–26], [: 431], uz- [: 426], [428], z [427]). T u u , vqu, B u u T D Imt u j Rbs d Hs Wrd Prbms f Dstyvsky’sPts. B u, I v v (Bu, N,V, Fu, A, M) x -v u . T u B’ v x
T D Imt.O u u u S
Su vu Hqu u 1981 x u B’ , u . Bu
-187-
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 197/247
188 BAKHIN AN NR HOR IN BIBICA SUIS
x , u x x , , N , M
uv B ? W , x, u v B’ u u x . F , u z - u , ,v u , v u. T x- u M’ Bvd . U u v , u v v vv u u . Bu u u u x .
M Bu, “u ,” uB’ , v, u u u - H B u x: (1974); H (1996); “I R F S” -
“B P” Bb Frm Crtsm (1999:27–30).W Bu u “” , qu “ .” H u u H B x B d. Wu B’ “-
v u” ( ) “u-v u” ( v: 1981:324–31, 354, 434) “v u-” (1986:95–100), Bu “ .”
T u u, Bu u, -u z B: (1) u; (2) u ; (3) u u ; (4) u u . T HB , , (Bu 1999:27). Bu v : , , v, v, v u, u J Q. T v , u,
u . I1999 v “ v j ” “ ju ” (27). I u v Bu v B v “ ” z u uu, “
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 198/247
ROBBINS: RSPONS—USIN BAKHIN’S LIC DILIC 189
u,” “u u,” u u (1981:272–73, 425). A u
v u u, B’ u, u u, v u, , .
T u Bu’ , v . F B’ v, v u -z “v ‘’ ” (1981:425). x u B’ -u u u u v , I u, v v u “x” u u , , u b.c.e. “” (, -, ) N . I u Bu H B u qu, u B’ -. J M u ju f , u A , “v ” (2001:41). T, N -
M : “T J -qu v” (41). Bu H B u “u”? I .
Bu’ v u v u u uu u HB . H Bu B’ u u u u. Bu u uv
u u u . Bu B u ? Wu B u u , v “ ”? T u u u u u B “” “u-” (1981:429–30). I, B v uv u
? I vu Bu B v- v H B u u u, u, .P B’ x uv v u H B
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 199/247
190 BAKHIN AN NR HOR IN BIBICA SUIS
v u , N Qu’, Hu, Bu -
u, u, .A Bu’ u, u B’
“v ,” 1981 : “ v, u ” (428). Tu Bu’ “ ,” u’ u “ u,” . T - v Bu’ u u u u u “” - “u z,” , , . A j u “ ”Bu z u u . R u “u,” z ,, v . T , v u , , . P B’ v “z,” , “ u - v,” “u u by v” (1981:434), Bu’ . B u u z, u v
. Tu, ’ u u z “ ” (434). I Bu u uu , , “ u ”? M, u u, “ - u x, v v ” ( J 2003:245). I Bu “- u ”?
Hqu u “” 1981 B x, x Sph rs d thr Lt ssys (1978), (1990), (1993). I , j B’ d- u u u u u . Bu u mtphr , u v “u” u x,
B’ u u.P Bu “ux ,” u “ u,” . I x z v , Bu u
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 200/247
ROBBINS: RSPONS—USIN BAKHIN’S LIC DILIC 191
B’ v- Rb-s d Hs Wrd , . I
Bu v u u u v . S , Bu’
v, x , u x .I x , v, u v “” u. T v B’. I , Bu u, , , , B’ d . T u , u, v u B’ . P u . T u Bu’ rhtr B’ d. I u Bu x H- u, u H B u.Bu B , u x u B’ x H B.
W C N u , x u B . W “” , “,” I v u u B. Ov u ttu, v u B’ “ .” A v “” u-, u “ ” u “” ’ “u.” C Jqu
u x’ “ -,” u A R’ T Pwr f r (1985), . H. ’ u “ ,,” “ ‘v’ u’ ” (N).
Ov vv “ u x,” N W’
A F’ u (1982) J- Cu’ xu (1975). I , u B. R, u x’ B’ u u u. T
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 201/247
192 BAKHIN AN NR HOR IN BIBICA SUIS
v v - v u “” u
1970 R (1975; 1978). A u u “ ” “ ” - u H B N , u “qu-” u z “” . T, MS (2002), v , “ .” I “x ,” , “” u u. T , u b.c.e. Ju f B K v, v u u C .
O f u u vu x N’ u B. I , u, F’v “ uu ” B’ “ x u - .” C B’ “u
v” , u “ , uu” (B1984:106). B’ , , . I , N u B uv . F , v , “ -v” “u ,” u B’ . Tu, uu N u B u u
“ ” u “” . A v , u “” , “ x v uu, u uu u.” Tu, u uu u u , u N v . T ,v, uv , u, u B’ “ ” v
. I v u u “” “” vu .
M V u N , v “T A C.” A , u ,
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 202/247
ROBBINS: RSPONS—USIN BAKHIN’S LIC DILIC 193
, B’ d , “- ,” v
Mkh Bkht: Crt f Prss (1990:367). T u M. M. B/P. N. Mvv,T Frm Mthd Ltrry Shrshp (1978) M. M. B, rt d swrbty (1990), V v v. T , u “,” T D Imt (1981:84–258) Sphrs d thr Lt ssys (1986:25–54), u u hrtp x. T V “- ” T Frm Mthd j rt d swrbty: “Au H A Av”(4–256) “Su: T P C, M, F V A” (257–325). I , u - “ -” “ vv x ” “[]v … u v u ”(B 1981:429), V’ u
z “ v u , , u ,” “, , , ” (B/Mvv 1978:3). I , V - “Su” (B 1990:257–325), “” “u.”
Tu, V “ ,” B/Mvv’ u “ uv u ” “ ” (1978:45–46), u u u ’ “u z v -
vu” rt d swrbty (1990:304). Au “,” B/Mvv : “A vu , u v, v vu-x, , - , ” (1990:270). H u v , u I “ ” u .T u , , v -
u M J T Bdy th Md (1987). I , v B/Mvv’ x uu u u () (.., Fu u 2002; J 2003:243–76).
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 203/247
194 BAKHIN AN NR HOR IN BIBICA SUIS
W V u “- ,” -u B/Mvv’ “ z
. A , , .… T … v u x ” (1978:154). I x, V “ ” “x ” “” “x,” “ , ‘x’ ‘’ , , u, u ” (154). V’ “- ” uu “” B’ “u” B “A u uqu v -v v u,u u v uu u, v, uv uu ” (1990:8). V’ z- u “- ” v rt d swrbty u T Frm Mthd . T u B u . W v B V , u “B” Mvv B v
u T Frm Mthd u T D Imt.
W V u , B/Mvv’ : “T uu v - vu” (1978:158). V u v u “ vu” TFrm Mthd . I , “ vu” “ u ” (149). F B/M-
vv, vu u . S “[]v u ” (120), “[] vu uz u u -” (121).
T u “” B u V , , u - u “ - uv ” (1987:130).
I T Frm Mthd , “, , - u” (152). I rt d swrbty, “” “,” “” “,” “ u” “.” V u frm, tt , mtr u frms, ms,
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 204/247
ROBBINS: RSPONS—USIN BAKHIN’S LIC DILIC 195
rt dts f mmut. T v Vv “-u ,” “ ,” “-
,” “,” “,” “ u,” u u. I , V’ v u B’ “u” u ’ u th th u th .
T B’ V’ u (. ). Bu u - u ju v. V u . I , “ , vu u v x v .” T - u V v u x “x” v u - u . T u u , , ( -u) u u.
V u v u B’
(1986:62), x v M (V 2002:55). A, B’ , qu , u u b.c.e. T vv , “ u vu u” (V 2002:55). I x , “v x u v . W , u
vu” (55; . B1986:62).
V x v u . H v u “ v v v u -.” A, v u “ ” x u . T u v : (1) v; -
v; (2) u u , x z v ; (3) , - uu.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 205/247
196 BAKHIN AN NR HOR IN BIBICA SUIS
“v u” “”, , ?
V u v u x uv .Su v - u (W W 2005).Suv v v v u . A, u . W uv ? W u uv ? W u uv ?
u “ ” - ? O v x ? P uv V’ u J C I ( v) II (v ju). V “ ” x “.” T,
: . Cu , , -? Cu I ( v) v uv ? u I , I u - v I uu? Av, ju u II , II ju
uv u v I uu?
O qu “uu v.” O “,” ,uu v, v u ,“” ? W x u , “uu v,” , “” ?T u N’ . W
z, 1 , , “ ” u “ u”? W Rv J uu v ( “” ) C, z, 1 , “ u”? 1 “” f
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 206/247
ROBBINS: RSPONS—USIN BAKHIN’S LIC DILIC 197
Rv J? T , u vu, -
v . T u u . V’ v . M- B’ u u uu u u u x uu x u v u. T u, v, Bu , u x .
C Fu u M 1:1–17. H , B, (B1981:252). T u “z ” v “z” “ x” - . A u u x, , “ ”
“ x .”Fu’ “ ” B’ “ rtv [] x u, u v ” (1981:254). O Fu’ “ .” A J “ ” (1999). Fu’u z M .
Fu u M
, , A M I. S u , , , u “ M’ .” W u , “M v ,” v u x “x” x . O
M : I B (M 1:11–12, 17). A ( v A , v Ju , , H , B, Ju I F S
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 207/247
198 BAKHIN AN NR HOR IN BIBICA SUIS
) x . Tu Fu, x B, “xu”
“xu,” “ ” x. I u u , , , u u Fu v M .
F Fu, M u x M u , , u . F B, Fu , “ .” , u , u . T , , u “ u v x.” H u , , u z u - . U-
B’ vu , , ju “ u” ( ) z u , , .
T , , u , B, , u u.Fu u u “ ” M. T M u u u uv u. T uv v “
vu u u v , .” B’ (1984:147), “[], , , uu v M’ ‘’ B.” T u u, v, u “vu uu v x u v - .” I , B’ vqu.
I , Fu’ u B’ u - B’ u u B d u: , - , - , , , . O qu Fu v u
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 208/247
ROBBINS: RSPONS—USIN BAKHIN’S LIC DILIC 199
M M. O , Fu -
uu F . T u u v M. T
v u B’ - x. O , Fu “” . S x , M v u M? I , u J ’ v u x B’ u . B , x ,“ u , ; u ,u u . I [ u] u, , . A
” (1981:252). W vu “ ”? I -, v u, , , “ ” v . Bu B .V’ vu u B’ , , B’ v . W, , u “ -” ? A ,
, uv u ? I v “” -u u x “ ” . I , B, “ -,” u x u x. A qu -u B u “ ”? O u u B’ ? M x
u u -B- u , B .
Pu N. A u B’ , B -
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 209/247
200 BAKHIN AN NR HOR IN BIBICA SUIS
u J u u v v J u, u u
B u. T u “ u-” “v” “uv” u , B u Cv v. , A u, C. K. B u, P’ S ïv u u- “ ” v J u u. T u S u B’ v J u u. I , u u B’ d. R B v- , u vu P’ u S - N B u .
M u - v J u
-v . O A- v “F S ,” v, “S S ,” - (B 1981:399–422). Uu, A v S u v .T u v u uv u B J u u v u J u u
B’ F S S S v.O , A’ u , “,” , “” u u u F S S- v T D Imt (1981:399–422). O , u S v x xu FS S S u-
u J. R u B’u S v, - S v u N - .
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 210/247
ROBBINS: RSPONS—USIN BAKHIN’S LIC DILIC 201
I , x u A ,v J u u u
u u J u B u v F S ( S v, 1981:400) S S- ( qu vu v, 1981:406). A’ v “u ” J B’ “S ” v. T u B N - , A , J u u B’ v S v A -u u “v, uv” u J u u.
Bu M vu u uB M’ T Bvd . Bu u-v, (B 1981:294), , v u -u- (291), z “z ,” u
u “” (295–96). B u - x, B’ u z (305–15, 358–71) u u u v v . B u, u x u T Bvd , v : (1) B; (2) A A v -v; (3) v v ; A AA : (4) A ; (5) A
A xu qu; (6) . T x u v“ u” (v ) “ A ” ( ) u “ ” “.”
I J P’ v T Bvd v, M v x ( )
“ u u ” . H “z ” v u u-(: x) . T vu u - x N ,
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 211/247
202 BAKHIN AN NR HOR IN BIBICA SUIS
u u xv qu “u.” I , qu
“u-” B.P, x, M j u , “ u” “ u,” -x u “” “x” u M. P u u u v x u , u- u u-. A “” . I , , v vv ?O vv , , u-, u, N u u H-R ?
W qu , vu B.
O j v v u B d - u .T u, T D- Imt (1981:423–34), uv (v)u, , z, -u, , (z), u, u, v , ,, , (u), u, -, , , , u, v, z. I u
B u , u-v, , vqu, , , u , , F SSz v, z . T v f u u B’ -u , u - , , . , u vu v B’ -
u, u , , , , , u. T v u . K Bu, , u - u rhtr
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 212/247
ROBBINS: RSPONS—USIN BAKHIN’S LIC DILIC 203
, M Hqu u j x M B’ T D Imt. O
S Su vu, vu u B. Bu u vu, B’ u , v B’ x uv u u v u u uu u - u .
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 213/247
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 214/247
Works Consulted
A, Dv. 1998. Revolutionary Hebrew, Empire, and Crisis: Four Peaks
in Hebrew Literature and Jewish Survival . N Y: N Y Uvy P.Ay, P R. 1973. I and II Chronicles, Ezra, Nehemiah. B
C. L: SCM.Agz, L. 1962. Essay on Classication. E y E L. C-
g: Hv Uvy P.A, R. 1981. Te Art o Biblical Narrative. N Y: B B.———.1999. Te David Story: A ranslation with Commentary o 1 and 2
Samuel . N Y: N.
A, J Cp. 1983. M: G Rg. Semeia 28:3–28.
A, P N. 1991. W F Evg Q? Quaker Reli- gious Tought 76:27–43.
———. 1996. Te Christology o the Fourth Gospel: Its Unity and Disunity inthe Light o John 6 . WUN 2/78. üg: M S; Vy Fg,P.: y P I.
———. 1997. Sitz im Leben J B L D I Evvg C. Pg 1–59 Critical Readings o John 6. E y
A Cppp. BIS 22. L: B.———. 1999. Hvg-S-M F—Ap Agy, Iy,
E J F-S Rp. Semeia 85:33–57.———. 2000. Navigating the Living Waters o the Gospel o John: On Wading
with Children and Swimming with Elephants. Wg, P.: PH P.
———. 2001. J M— B-Op Gp. Pg 175–88 Jesusin Johannine radition. E y R F . P-p: W J K.
———. 2001. M, J, Ay: Ap Iy S F Gp. O: p://-.g/J/SBL2001-A..
-205-
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 215/247
206 BAKHIN AND GENRE HEORY IN BIBLICAL SUDIES
———. 2002. I, Fv, D—A y J’R Syp. Pg 19–58 Für und wider die Priorität des
Johannesevangeliums. E y P H. S 9. H:O.
———. 2004. Cgv Og J’ Cg Uy D-y. Pg 127–48 v. 3 Psychology and the Bible: A New Way toRead the Scriptures. E y J. H E Wy R. W-p, C.: Pg.
———. 2006. Te Fourth Gospel and the Quest or Jesus: Modern FoundationsReconsidered. JSNSp 321. L: & C.
A, P N., J. H E, J W. F. 2004. Cgv-
C Ay—A Wy F S Ivg Gp . Pg 247–76 v. 4 Psychology and the Bible: ANew Way to Read the Scriptures. E y J. H E WyR. Wp, C.: Pg.
Aq, . 1926. Summa Teologica. y F Eg- D Pv. 2. . V. III QQ XXVII–LIX. L:B, O & W.
A, B . 1993. Wpy Nv q D 5 6. JBL 112:479–85.
———. 1996. U A H B: A L B-g Ez D. JNSL 22:1–16.
———. 2000. W Py Cz D 1. Pg 231–50 Puns and Pundits: Word Play in the Hebrew Bible and Ancient Near East-ern Literature. E y S B. Ng. B, M.: CDL.
A, Dv E. 1987. Te New estament in Its Literary Environment . LEC 8.Pp: W.
Av, H I. 1991. C F E O-
I D 3. CBQ 53:580–88.B, A. 1998. Wv Hpp Dy? Pg 91–116 Bibli-cal Studies/Cultural Studies. E y J. Cy E Sp D.M. JSNSp 266. S: S A P.
B, M M. 1981. Te Dialogic Imagination. y CyE M Hq. A: Uvy P.
———. 1984. Problems o Dostoevsky’s Poetics. E y CyE. y Hy L 8. Mp: Uvy M P.
———. 1984. Rabelais and His World . y H Iy. B-g: I Uvy P.
———. 1986. Speech Genres and Other Late Essays. y V W.MG. E y Cy E M Hq. A: Uv-y P.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 216/247
WORKS CONSULED 207
———. 1990. Art and Answerability: Early Philosophical Essays by M. M.Bakhtin. y V Lpv K B. E
y M Hq V Lpv. A: Uvy P.
———. 1993. oward a Philosophy o the Act. y V Lpv.E y V Lpv M Hq. A: Uvy P.
B, M M., P. N. Mvv. 1978. Te Formal Method in Liter-ary Scholarship: A Critical Introduction to Sociological Poetics. y A J. W. B: J Hp Uvy P.
B, J A. 2003. Not the Righteous but Sinners: M. M. Bakhtin’s Teory o
Aesthetics and the Problem o Reader-Character Interaction in Matthew’sGospel . JSNSp 246. L: & C.
B, J. 1968. Comparative Philology and the ext o the Old estament .O: C.
B, C. K. 1972. New estament Essays. L: SPCK.B, R. 1998. J R M. Pg 147–71 Te
Gospels or all Christians: Rethinking the Gospel Audiences. E y R B. G Rp: E.
B, G. 2003. Love and Violence: Marriage as Metaphor or theRelationship between YHWH and Israel in the Prophetic Books. Cg-v, M.: Lg P.
B, Dv R. 1996. Ly g F G-gy M’ Gp. Pg 129–60 reasures New and Old: Recent Contributions to Matthean Studies. E y Dv R. B M A P. SBLSyS 1. A: S P.
B, . 1994. Te Ideology o Genre: A Comparative Study o GenericInstability. Uvy P: Pyv S Uvy P.
B, D. 2002. Michel Foucault: Form and Power . O: Lg/E-p H R C.B, S, . 2001. Plato’s Symposium. Cg: Uvy C-
g P.B-P, Zv. 1976. P Ly A. PL: A Journal or
Descriptive Poetics and Teory o Literature 1:105–28.B Zv, E. 1998. Lg Py (H)y Pp
B Ly/g U F Ey S p: S C. SJO 12:26–43.
Bg, Dv A. 1999. B Rv Dy: Nv y Dg Ev D 31:2 34:7. Journal o Hebrew Scriptures 2. O: .../JHS/A/_10..
B, A. 2002. Lamentations . OL. Lv: W JK.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 217/247
208 BAKHIN AND GENRE HEORY IN BIBLICAL SUDIES
Bzz, P, B Hzg. 1990. Te Rhetorical radition: Readings rom Classical imes to the Present . B: S. M’.
Bpp, Jp. 2000. Isaiah 1–39: A New ranslation with Introductionand Commentary. AB 19A. N Y: Dy.
B, M. 1974. Sy, Sg, D A. Archives Europeenes de Sociologie 15:55–81.
Bg, P. 1965. Bread rom Heaven: An Exegetical Study o the Concept o Manna in the Gospel o John and the Writings o Philo. NvSp 11.L: B.
B, R. B. 1995. Ivg Nv. Pg 79–87 Bakhtin inContexts: Across the Disciplines. E y Ay M. Ev, I.:
N Uvy P.———. 2002. A Sy Nv? Pg 161–86 Bakhtin and the
Classics. E y R.B B. Ev, I.: N U- vy P.
B, Ay. 1994. W’ A F C? W’ A B H? C O Fg R HB. JSO 63:38–55.
B, Ry E. 1993. Te Birth o the Messiah: A Commentary on theInancy Narratives in the Gospels o Matthew and Luke. 2 . ABRL.N Y: Dy.
———. 2003. An Introduction to the Gospel o John. E y F My.N Y: Dy.
B, Ggy C. 1990. Rg B: E Cg. Lit-erature and Teology 4:347–51.
Bgg, W. 1982. Genesis. IBC. A: J K.Bz, My, . 2004. Language and Woman’s Place: ext and Commentar-
ies. N Y: O Uvy P.
B, R. 1971. Te Gospel o John: A Commentary. y G.R. By-My, W. R. N. H, J. K. R. O: B.B, K. 1968. Counter-Statement . By L Ag: Uv-
y C P.Bg, R A. What Are the Gospels? A Comparison with Graeco-
Roman Biography. Cg: Cg Uvy P, 1992.B, M J. 1969. Te Prophetic Word o Hosea: A Morphogical Study.
BZAW 111. B: öp.———. 1974. “ Sy F.” Pg 1–56 Old estament Form Criti-
cism. E y J H. Hy. S A: y Uvy P.———. 1977. D Cv C L A
I. Pg 51–62 v. 1 Proceedings o the Sixth World Congress o Jewish Studies. J: A P.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 218/247
WORKS CONSULED 209
———. 1996. “H C P.” Pg 79–93 Prophets and Paradigms: Essays in Honor o Gene M. ucker . E y Sp B
R. JSOSp 229. S: S A P:.———. 1999. Biblical Form Criticism in Its Context . JSOSp 274. S:
S A P.Cp, Ay F. 2003. 1 Samuel. FOL 7. G Rp: E.Cp, R I. 1992. Lgg (A). ABD 4:170–73.C, W. 1996. Matthew: Storyteller, Interpreter, Evangelist . Py,
M.: H.———. 2000. Matthew and the Margins: A Sociopolitical and Religious Read-
ing . B L. My, N.Y.: O.
Cg, M G. 1992. U Sp C E: AB. Annual o the Society o Christian Ethics 1992:263–76.
Cy, R J. 1991. John’s Gospel in New Perspective. My, N.Y.:O.
C, Pp P. 1997. O Ng Sj: P Rg D1. Jian Dao 7:17–36.
C, Bv. 1967. Isaiah and the Assyrian Crisis. SB 3. L: SCM.C, B. 1994. L S g R.
V. . V. M L. S A, C.: S Fg Sy.
———. 1997. Bv, S’ O. Narrative 5:36–49.———. 1997. Fg Mg: Beloved. Pg 363–70 Female Sub-
jects in Black and White: Race, Psychoanalysis, Feminism. E y Ez A, B C, H Mg. By LAg: Uvy C P.
C, K, M Hq, . 1984. Mikhail Bakhtin. C-g: Hv Uvy P.
C, L. J M. 2003. B gy Dg: Cg Cv M B B gy. JBL 122:127–44.
C, R. 1998. Christianity in Bakhtin: God and the Exiled Author . C-g S R L. Cg: Cg Uvy P.
Cy, Evy. 1988. M B’ P G y. Genre 21:321–38.
Cg, M, Hy . 1988. II Kings: A New ranslation with
Introduction and Commentary. AB 11. N Y: Dy.C, Rp. 1986. Hy G. New Literary History 17:203–18.———. 2003. I. New Literary History 34:v–v.C, A Y. 1995. G Gp. JR 75:239–46.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 219/247
210 BAKHIN AND GENRE HEORY IN BIBLICAL SUDIES
C, J J. 1979. I: Mpgy G.Semeia 14:1–20.
———. 1979. J Apyp. Semeia 14:21–59.———, . 1979. Apocalypse: Te Morphology o a Genre. Semeia 14. M-
, M.: Sy B L.———. 1993. Daniel: A Commentary on the Book o Daniel . H. M-
p: F.———. 1997. Apocalypticism in the Dead Sea Scrolls. L: Rg.Cp, J S. 1992. S, S. ABD 6:231–34.C, P W. 1986. “L” G Nv Sy C
D. JSO 35:95–121.
Cg, K M. 1995. Reading Esther: A Case or the Literary Carni-valesque. Lv: W J K.
C, J. 1975. Structuralist Poetics: Structuralism, Linguistics, and theStudy o Literature. I, N.Y.: C Uvy P.
Cppp, R. A. 1983. Anatomy o the Fourth Gospel: A Study in LiteraryDesign. Pp: F.
Dv, W D. 1964. Te Setting o the Sermon on the Mount . Cg:Cg Uvy P.
Dv, W D., D C. A. 1988. Te Gospel according to Saint Matthew. ICC 1. Eg: & C.
D, F. 1997. B H: A C Sy A N E. Scriptura 63:415–24.
Dz, G. 1997. D P. y D W. S.Pg 183–92 Foucault and His Interlocutors. E y A I.Dv. Cg: Uvy Cg P.
D, Jq. 2000. L G. Pg 219–31 Modern GenreTeory. E y Dv D. H, U.K.: Lg.
D L, A A. 1981. D 4:7–14: P Ay B B-g. Pg 247–58 Melanges bibliques et orientaux en l’honneur de M. Henri Cazelles. E y A. Cq M. D. AOA 212. Kv-: Bz & B.
D-App, F. W. 1993. Weep O Daughter o Zion: A Study o the City-Lament Genre in the Hebrew Bible. BO 44. R: E PI B.
———. 2002. Lamentations. Lv: W J K. D, Dv. 2000. I. Pg 1–22 Modern Genre Teory. E
y Dv D. H, U.K.: Lg.D, Ry K. 1990. Te Persuasive Appeal o the Chronicler: A Rhetorical
Analysis. JSOSp 88. S: A.D, F. 2002. Rg : F B Ap. Pg
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 220/247
WORKS CONSULED 211
187–219 Bakhtin and the Classics. E y R. B B. Ev-, I.: N Uvy P.
Dy, J Fy. 1991. S Py Ipy Iy.Style 25:616–35.
E, D V. 1991. King Saul in the Historiography o Judah. JSOSp 121. S: S A P.
F, G, M . 2002. Te Way We Tink: Conceptual Blending and the Mind’s Hidden Complexities. N Y: B B.
F, D N. 1991. Circle o Sovereignty: Plotting Politics in the Booko Daniel . 2 . Nv: Ag.
F, Ivg L. 1980. Bg C Fg. JCS 32:65–80.
F, A A. 1977. Skepsis oder Furcht Gottes? BZAW 247. B: Gy.
Fv, Dv. 1993. Metaphors o Genre: Te Role o Analogies in GenreTeory. Uvy P: Pyv S Uvy P.
F, J P. 1986. Te Crossing Fates. V. 2 Narrative Art and Poetryin the Books o Samuel. A: V G.
F, M. 1978. An Introduction. V. 1 Te History o Sexuality. y R Hy. N Y: R H.
———. 1983. A: Sj P. Pg 208–26 Michel Foucault: Beyond Structuralism and Hermeneutics. E y HL. Dy P R. 2. . Cg: Uvy CgP.
F, A. 1982. Kinds o Literature: An Introduction to the Teory o Genres and Modes. Cg: Hv Uvy P.
F, M V. 1989. Qohelet and his Contradictions. JSOSp 71. S:A.
Fy, Np. 1957. Anatomy o Criticism: Four Essays. P: P-
Uvy P.F, Cp C. 2004. “U C F D…, M I D C…”:P Ip Gp M. P. D. ., Gg U.
G, Dv E. 1993. Reading Matthew: A Literary and Teological Com-mentary on the First Gospel . N Y: C.
Gy, P. 1993. Te Black Atlantic: Modernity and Double Consciousness. L: V.
Ggy, J. 1989. Daniel . WBC 30. D: W B.
G, Pp. 1996. Deleuze and Guattari: An Introduction to the Politicso Desire. L: Sg.
G, Dv B. 2000. Hg B S: PypDg Cgg Cy? RevExp 97:443–66
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 221/247
212 BAKHIN AND GENRE HEORY IN BIBLICAL SUDIES
G, B. 2000. Mikhail Bakhtin and Biblical Scholarship: An Introduc-tion. SS 38. A: Sy B L.
———. 2003. Eggg N G: Rg S MA. Pg 141–59 Relating to the ext . E y y Sv C M. L: & C.
———. 2003. How Are the Mighty Fallen? A Dialogical Study o King Saul in 1Samuel. JSOSp 365. S: S A P.
Gy, R H. 1994. Matthew: A Commentary on His Handbook or a Mixed Church under Persecution. G Rp: E.
G, H, J Bg. 1966. Einleitung in die Psalmen.Gög: V & Rp.
G, Dv, D N F. 1993. Narrative in the Hebrew Bible.O B S. N Y: O Uvy P.
Hg, D A. 1993. Matthew. WBC 33. D: W.Hg, D J. 1991. Te Gospel o Matthew. SP 1. Cgv, M.:
Lg P.H, . 1993. Epg Svy N I Ig. Pg 330–41
oni Morrison: Critical Perspectives Past and Present. E y Hy L G J. K. A. App. N Y: A.
H, J P. 1991. Nv R W M’ G-gy. Bib 72:538–45.
Hz, M. 1999. Te Madness o King Nebuchadnezzar . JSJSp 61.L: B.
Hgg, E. 2001. Religiosity, Cosmology, and Folklore: Te AricanInuence in the Novels o oni Morrison. N Y: Rg.
H, D. 1972. Lamentations: Introduction, ranslation, and Notes. AB7A. G Cy, N.Y.: Dy.
H, E. D., J. 1967. Validity in Interpretation. N Hv: Y Uvy
P.Hp, K. 1999. Mikhail Bakhtin: An Aesthetic or Democracy. O:O Uvy P.
H, y. 2005. D 1–6: A B Sy C. Pg 149–66 Ancient Fiction: Te Matrix o Early Christian and Jewish Narrative. Ey J-A A. B, C W. H, C S. SBLSyS 32.A: Sy B L.
Hq, M. 1990. Dialogism; Bakhtin and His World. L: R-g.
———. 2002. Dialogism: Bakhtin and His World . 2 . L: Rg.Hv, B. 2002. M. Pg 254–60 Postmodernism: Te
Key Figures. E y H B Jp N. M, M.:B.
Hg, J. 1992. Lgg: Iy. ABD 4:155–70.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 222/247
WORKS CONSULED 213
I, Wgg. 1978. Te Act o Reading: A Teory o Aesthetic Response. B-: J Hp Uvy P.
J, R. 1987. Dg S. Georgia Review 41:415–20.J, M S. 1997. Early Judaism. Upp S Rv, N.J.: P H.Jp, S. 1993. I and II Chronicles: A Commentary. OL. Lv: W-
J K.J, H R. 1982. oward an Aesthetic o Reception. y
y B. y Hy L 2. Mp: Uv-y M P.
J, S P. 1990. Te Women o Genesis: From Sarah to Poti- phar’s Wie. Mp: F.
J. 1959. Commenarium in Metheum. CCSL 77. : Bp.Jg, Dv. 1998. 1 Samuel. Cgv, M.: Lg P.J, M. D. 1969. Te Purpose o the Biblical Genealogies with Special
Reerence to the Settings o the Gospel o Jesus. SNSMS 8. Cg:Cg Uvy P.
J, M. 1987. Te Body in the Mind: Te Bodily Basis o Meaning,Imagination, and Reason. Cg: Uvy Cg P.
Kä, E. 1968. Te estament o Jesus according to John 17 . - y G K. Pp: F.
K, Sv A. 1992. Lgg (A). ABD 4:173–78.K, Cg S. 1999. A Commentary on the Gospel o Matthew. G
Rp: E.Kpp, Gy N. 2004. I Chronicles 1–9: A New ranslation with Introduc-
tion and Commentary. AB 12. N Y: Dy.K, M P. 2004. W W V Wg? Ly, E-
, S C P G S. BibInt 12:145–74.
Kz, L. 1999. G Svy: H Rvy M’ Beloved. Pg 107–25 oni Morrison’s Bv: A Casebook. E y W L. A M Y. MKy. N Y: OUvy P.
L, Jy. 1999. Fg O Cp. Pg 212–26 Critical Essays on Mikhail Bakhtin. E y Cy E. C Ey W L. N Y: H.
L, Gg. 1987. Women, Fire, and Dangerous Tings: What CategoriesReveal about the Mind. Cg: Uvy Cg P.
L, Gg, M J. 2003. Metaphors We Live By. Cg:Uvy Cg P.
L, R. 2004. Language and Woman’s Place: ext and Commentaries.2 . E y My Bz. N Y: O Uvy P.
Lv, J. 1978. 1 S 25 L Hy. CBQ 40:11–28.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 223/247
214 BAKHIN AND GENRE HEORY IN BIBLICAL SUDIES
Lv, Ay-J. 1998. M. Pg 339–49 Women’s Bible Commentary. E y C A. N S H. Rg. Lv: W-
J K.Lv, H. 1992. Dg D P. Pg 145–61
Hermeneutics, the Bible and Literary Criticism. E y A L M ML. N Y: S M’.
L, B. 1971. Behind the Fourth Gospel . L: SPCK.———. 1981. Te Gospel o John. G Rp: E.L, Y. 1993. . y Jy L
Ay M. PMLA 109:377–84.Lg, P. 2002. Eros and Polis: Desire and Community in Greek Political
Teory. Cg: Cg Uvy P.Lz, U. 1989. Matthew 1–7 . y W C. L. Mp-
: Agg F.M, B. 2005. Te Word Dg: B A B’
y Nv. P.D. ., G g U.M, Ez S. 1993. Cz B L. Semeia
63:3–227.M, B J. 1981. he New estament World: Insights rom Cultural
Anthropology. Lv: W J K.M, C. 2002. Fg V: S Sv
P L. HB 24.2:27–52.———. 2002. God in the Dock. S: S A P.———. 2007. Daughter Zion alks Back to the Prophets. SS 58. A:
Sy B L.My, J. L. 2003. History and Teology in the Fourth Gospel . 3 .
Lv: W J K.MC, Dv. 1993. C By: B’ Iv-
y B Nv. Semeia 63:29–42.M, . J. 1995. Aramaic Daniel and Greek Daniel: A Literary Com- parison. JSOSp 198. S: S A P.
Mvv, Pv. 1978. Te Formal Method in Literary Scholarship: A Critical Introduction to Sociological Poetics. y A. W. B:J Hp Uvy P.
M, Wy A. 1967. Te Prophet King: Moses raditions and the JohannineChristology. NvSp 14. L: B.
———. 1986. M Hv J S. Pg 141–73
Interpreting the Fourth Gospel . E y J A. L: SPCK.M, D. 1992. Te Rise and Fall o Jewish Nationalism. ABRL. N
Y: Dy.M, P. 1989. Te Lamentations over the Destruction o Sumer and
Ur. W L, I.: E.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 224/247
WORKS CONSULED 215
M, J. 2001. Christ: A Crisis in the Lie o God . N Y: Vg B.M, C W. 2001. Rg V: P, Dg,
R L 1. BibInt 9:393–408.M, My E. 2003. Reading Ecclesiastes. A: Ag.M, Sp D. 1997. Hy y? B S N
H. BibInt 5:289–99.M, . 1987. Beloved. N Y: Kp.M, Gy S. 2003. Ap: Fg B
R. New Literary History 34:409–29.M, Gy S, Cy E. 1990. Mikhail Bakhtin: Creation o a
Prosaics. S, C.: S Uvy P.
———. 1997. E Heteroglossary. Pg 256–72 Dialogue and Critical Discourse: Language, Culture, Critical Teory. E y MMv. N Y: O Uvy P.
M, Sg. 1962. Israel’s Worship. V. 2. N Y: Ag.M, G. 1992. Lgg (G). ABD 4:195–203.My, J M. 1965. II Chronicles. AB 13. N Y: Dy.N, C A. 1996. B, B, Dg . JR 76:290–
306.———. 2000. B. Pg 20–27 Handbook o Postmodern Biblical Inter-
pretation. E y A. K. M. A. S. L: C.———. 2003. Te Book o Job. O: O Uvy P.———. 2005. Spyg O L: A Rp Ggy. Pg 437–50
Seeking Out the Wisdom o the Ancients: Essays Oered to Honor Michael V. Fox on the Occasion o His Sixty-Fifh Birthday. E y R L., Kv G. F, D R. Mgy. W L, I.:E.
O, D . 1998. B gy Pv Mgz: A
Dg C, Bgg B. BibInt 6:162–80.P, D. 1987. Te Gospel according to Matthew: A Structural Commen-tary on Matthew’s Gospel . Vy Fg, P.: y P I.
P, Dv. 1985. Journal o Aesthetics and Art Criticism 44:131–39.P, A. 1984. L’évangile de l’énance selon Saint Matthieu. Rv. . L
B 17. P: C.P, S. 1992. Dg “J” Ep D 5:6,16. JANESCU
22:121–27.P, L. 2000. oni Morrison. N Y: S. M’.
P, Ly. 1994. Reading Dialogics. L: E A.P, Ay J. 1991. Lexis Ludens: Wordplay and the Book o Micah.
N Y: Lg.P, X Hg . 1999. Mourning in the Ancient Near East and the
Hebrew Bible. JSOSp 302. S: S A P.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 225/247
216 BAKHIN AND GENRE HEORY IN BIBLICAL SUDIES
P, J. Dv. 1992. S-Sy S. CBQ 54:29–38.Pz, R. 1980. Deuteronomy, Joshua, Judges. P 1 Moses and the
Deuteronomist: A Literary Study o the Deuteronomic History. N Y:Sy.
Pz, R M. 1989. 1 Samuel. P 2 Samuel and the Deuteronomist: ALiterary Study o the Deuteronomic History. S F: Hp & R.
R, G v. 1961. Genesis. OL. Pp: W.———. 1962. Dy. IDB 1:831–38.R, P. 1927. Primitive Man as Philosopher . N Y: App.Ry, L. 2002. gy Ly A A
Sp. JAAR 70:347–63.
R, P L. 1999. Daniel . NCB. S: S A P.R, W L. 1993. Dialogues o the Word: Te Bible as Literature according
to Bakhtin. N Y: O Uvy P.Rg, Dv. 1988. Johannine Faith and Liberating Community. P-
p: W.R, M. 1997. Ip. Pg 173–84 Reading Eco: An
Anthology. E y R. Cpzz. Bg: I Uvy P.R, V K. 1990. Ancient Quotes and Anecdotes: From Crib to Crypt .
S, C.: Pg.———. 1996. Exploring the exture o exts: A Guide to Socio-rhetorical Inter-
pretation. Hg, P.: y P I.R, E. 1975. Cgv Rp S Cg.
Journal o Experimental Psychology (General) 104:192–233.———. 1978. Pp Cgz. Pg 27–48 Cognition and Cat-
egorization. E y E. R B. Ly. H, N.J.: E.R, A. 1985. Te Power o Genre. Mp: Uvy M-
P.
R-B, Hg. 1996. P g D.Pg 145–70 Mosaïque de langues, mosaïque culturelle: Le bilinguismedans le Proche-Orient ancient . E y F Bq-C.P: Mv.
R, P. 1996. Allegories o Contamination: Pier Paolo Pasolini’s ril-ogy o Lie. : Uvy P.
Ry, M-L. 1981. I: O Wy, W, H G y. Poetics 19:109–26.
Sg, J. 1995. Te Illegitimacy o Jesus: A Feminist Teological Interpre-
tation o the Inancy Narratives. B S 28. S: SA P.
Sg, A. 2002. Erkenntnis als Problem: Qohelet und die alttesta-mentliche Discussion um das menschliche Erkennen. OBO 188. Fg:Uvävg.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 226/247
WORKS CONSULED 217
Sg, R. 2002. Te Gospel o Matthew. y R R.B. G Rp: E.
S, S. 1982. W F Gp R W Cpy C. BB 12:35–45.
S, U. 1992. Antidocetic Christology in the Gospel o John. y L My. Mp: F.
S, J C. 1990. Domination and the Arts o Resistance: Hidden ran-scripts. N Hv: Y Uvy P.
S, D. 1998. Matthew. ANC. Nv: Ag.S, C. L. 1997. Ecclesiastes: A New ranslation with Introduction and Com-
mentary. AB 18C. N Y: Dy.
Sé, A. 2000. H Aé B. REJ 159:345–55.Sv, M. 1992. Dg Nv B’ y C-
. New Literary History 23:747–63.Svy, V. 1990. Teories o Prose. y Bj S. E-
P, I.: Dy Av.Sg, M. 2002. A D: G, Cg, Cgv
S. Genre 35:181–220.———. 2004. Cp Bg Og G. Pp p-
Cgv App L S MLgg A Cv. Pp, 28 D 2004.
Sg, A. 1988. V Hy/ Sj Nv. Novel 21:173–79.
S-Cp, D. 1996. D. NIB 7:17–152.———. 2002. A Biblical Teology o Exile. OB. Mp: F.S, D C. 1980. Wy I A I B? JSO 18:32–51.Sy, J. 1991. Prospects o Power: ragedy, Satire, the Essay, and the
Teory o Genre. Lg: Uvy Ky P.
Sp, E. A. 1981. Genesis. AB 1. G Cy, N.Y.: Dy.S, Gy. 1996. H S Dv Nv. Semeia 68:55–79.
S, K. 1960. Q U? A Ay M 1–2. Pg94–105 Judentum Urchristentum Kirche. E y W. E. 2. .BZNW 26. B: öp.
S, G Cg. 1997. Te Strange Woman: Power and Sex in theBible. Lv: W J K.
S, J M. 1990. Genre Analysis: English in Academic and Research Set-
tings. Cg: Cg Uvy P.Sy, Mv, E B Zv, . 2003. Te Changing Face o Form
Criticism or the wenty-First Century. G Rp: E., C H. 1977. What Is a Gospel? Te Genre o the Canonical Gos-
pels. Pp: F.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 227/247
218 BAKHIN AND GENRE HEORY IN BIBLICAL SUDIES
, Cv. 1984. B’ “y” G. Studies in wentieth Cen-tury Literature 9:29–40.
v, zv. 1984. Mikhail Bakhtin: Te Dialogical Principle. y W Gz. Mp: Uvy M P.
, My A. 1989. Sowing the Gospel: Mark’s World in Literary-Histori-cal Perspective. Mp: F.
, P K. 1997. Remember the Former Tings: Te Recollection o Previ-ous exts in Second Isaiah. SBLDS 161. A: S P.
———. 2003. R C By S I. Pg 326–34 Sy B Zv 2003.
———. 2005. B’ C S-Ag P L.
BibInt 1:41–55.yyv, Y. 2000. Ly F. Pg 29–49 Modern Genre
Teory. E y Dv D. H, U.K.: Lg.V, Dv M. 2005. C J ? R S Ry
D 1–6. PRSt 32:309–24.———. 2007. Lions and Ovens and Visions: A Satirical Analysis o Daniel 1–6 .
S: S P P.V Dv, H. J. M. 1999. W Ay “P” P S?
R Q (M) D 5. Scriptura 70:241–51.V L, Ry C. 2003. F C, W, P 111–
112. Pg 65–84 Sy B Zv 2003.V, S. 1997. Introducing Bakhtin. M: M Uvy
P.V, M E. 2002. Te Problem o Markan Genre: Te Gospel o Mark
and the Jewish Novel . SBLAB 3. A: Sy B L.Vv, V. N. 2006. Marxism and the Philosophy o Language.
y Lv Mj I. R. . Cg: Hv Uvy
P.Vv, V. N. (M B .) 1983. Bakhtin School Papers. y N. O. E y A S. R P 10. O: O.
Wj, H C. 1976. Ggy Ky Gp g M. JBL 95:205–30.
W, U C. v. 1990. Te Johannine Commandments: 1 John and theStruggle or the Johannine radition. N Y: P.
Wg, E. 1991. owards a Feminist Critical Reading o the Gospel
According to Matthew. BZNW 60. B: Gy.W, B K., M. O’C. 1990. An Introduction to Biblical Hebrew
Syntax. W L, I.: E.W, F. 1997. Wg By C. Teology 100:163–70.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 228/247
WORKS CONSULED 219
Wz, Sg. 1994. Macaronic Sermons: Bilingualism and Preaching inLate-Medieval England . R: L L C. A
A: Uvy Mg P.W, J-W. 2005. Ly N B D
Lg C I A. AS 3:241–83.W, H.G.M. 1982. 1 and 2 Chronicles. NCB. G Rp: E-
.Wg, Lg. 1958. Philosophical Investigations. O: B.W, A. 1991. R S D 5. HUCA 62:155–77.———. 1991. Uyg Kg’ K: Pygy W Py D
5. JBL 110:117–22.
Wg, Bj G., III, L M. W. 2005. Conicted Boundariesin Wisdom and Apocalypticism. SBLSyS 35. A: Sy BL.
Y, Gy. 1998. John the Baptist in Lie and Death: Audience-Oriented Criticism o Matthew’s Narrative. JSNSp 167. S: S A- P.
Y, G. 2003. Poor Banished Children o Eve: Women as Evil in the HebrewBible. Mp: F.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 229/247
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 230/247
Contributors
Paul N. Anderson P B Q S Gg F
Uvy, v Dp Rg S-. H Christology o the Fourth Gospel (1996) gv-y y Gp B g y J. H Te Fourth Gospel and the Quest or Jesus (2006)p y J-Syp v pp q J F Gp . H - J, J, Hy Pj - v (2007). H Quaker Religious Tought p Ly g gg .
Keith Bodner P Rg S A Bp Uv-y M, N B, C. H David Observed (2005) y 1 S (2003). H g- g g y C, yg pvg p y gg.
Roland Boer R Cpv L C S
M Uvy, M. W yg g -v, , p g, g. H , v y . H Criticism o Heaven (2007), v g Bg,D, G, S, C. H v U S, D, , T N, Bg, S, Eg,G, A.
Martin J. Buss y p Dp Rg Ey Uvy. Rv p g y Te Prophetic Word o Hosea (1969), “U-g C,” Encounter with the ext (. B, 1979);
-221-
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 231/247
222 BAKHIN AND GENRE HEORY IN BIBLICAL SUDIES
Biblical Form Criticism in Its Context (1999). A g ,g g, y p.
Judy Fentress-Williams A P O Vgg Sy A, Vg. Jy py - g v g . H y, “T B Dg,” pp September 11:Religious Perspectives on the Causes and the Consequences (2002). S -y g y R.
Christopher Fuller p gy C Cg H, M. H g p-, gy , I . H y “ T Y Syg J: H F P’ Gospel M’Gp?” p Te Passion Story: From Visual Representationto Social Drama (g). H y g p , “ ‘Udiste che u ditto…, ma io dico che…’: P Ip Gp M.” I g, gv y pgp
Barbara Green P B S D S Ppy Tgy, G Tg U, By, C.S v (R, Jp, S, J) y ( Mikhail Bakhtin and Biblical Scholarship: An Introduction [2000];How Are the Mighty Fallen: A Dialogical Study o King Saul in 1 Samuel [2003]). S y g Dy B- . S D S.
Bula Maddison Vg A P Eg M Cg,O, C, Aj I Rg S SMy’ Cg, Mg, C. S B, B , B . Ag p “A B Rg B A Dvy’ Crime and Pun-ishment ,” Perspectives in Religious Studies 32.3 (2005). O B B p://..//., pp SBL
gp B B Ig.
Carleen Mandolfo A P Rg S Cy C-g Wv, M. H p L, g g
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 232/247
gy. S God in the Dock: Dialogic ension inPsalms o Lament Daughter Zion alks Back to the Prophets: A Dialogic
Teology o the Book o Lamentations (g). S y g p .
Christine Mitchell P ( ) H Sp S.A’ Cg S, S, C. S -g B p y g y y. S C, Hgg, Xp. H pj pvp g Hgg, Z, M, P pp.
Carol A. Newsom C H C P O C S Tgy, Ey Uvy. H Te Book o Job: A Contest o Moral Imaginations Te Sel as Sym-bolic Space: Constructing Identity and Community at Qumran. S y g Q Hodayot y D O Ly .
Vernon K. Robbins P N Cpv S Dp G Dv Rg Ey Uv-y A, Gg. H pp Wp Dg RP 2001 P Ey Uvy S- S Tgy, S A, 2006. H Jesus the eacher (1984) N . he apes-try o Early Christian Discourse (1996) Exploring the exture o exts (1996) p pg g pp. A F
, Fabrics o Discourse (2004), y pyg - p. V 1 Te Invention o Christian Discourse: Wisdom,Prophecy and Apocalyptic pp 2008. H G E Ey S Ey Cy.
David M. Valeta (P.D. B Ip, Uvy Dv/I S Tgy) I Rg S Uvy C, B.
Michael E. Vines C Dv H AP Rg S L-MR Cg B E, NC. T Te Problem o Markan Genre: Te Gospel o Markand the Jewish Novel (2002), -
CONRIBUORS 223
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 233/247
224 BAKHIN AND GENRE HEORY IN BIBLICAL SUDIES
p g y g M B p.
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 234/247
G 5, 13, 59, 123, 179–801 121:1–2:4 1252 122:4 1232:26 125:1 12310:1 12712:1–7 126
12:2–3 12614:18–20 13 . 725 18127 180–8127:5–10 18027:15 18031:47 9735:22–26 12337 59–60, 181
37:33 5938 5, 59–62, 67–68, 180–8238:1–5 62, 6738:2 62, 6538:3 6238:4 6238:5 6238:6–10 6738:6–11 62, 6538:7 6238:8 63, 6538:11 63, 65, 6738:12 63, 6738:13 63, 65, 6638:14 63
38:16 64–6538:17 6538:18 6538:19 6538:24 66–6738:24–26 6638:27 6738:27–30 6638:28 128
39–50 6046:1–27 126
E 13, 1232:1–11 1682:10 16920:1–14 10
N
13:16 16626:5–51 123
Dy 6, 115:4–5 107:1–5 1118:15–22 147–4823:3 129
J 177
1–3 126
Jg 34–35, 176–773:11 343:30 34
-225-
Index of Ancient Sources
Hebrew Bible
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 235/247
226 BAKHIN AND GENRE HEORY IN BIBLICAL SUDIES
Judges (cont .)5:31 34
6 346–9 1778:28 349 1769:35 17710:10–16 3517–21 3420 179
R4:11 128
1 S 6, 18, 58, 17713:13–14 5514 43, 57–58, 17914:1–15 5014:7 5014:45 5815:26 55
15:28 5116:4 12616:13–14 4816:21 50, 5617 4117:25–27 5417:55–58 5418 5018:1–4 48
18:1–5 5218:3 4918:4 50, 5718:6–9 4818:10–12 4818:10–29 4818:12–16 4818:18 5418:20–29 4818:23 5418:29 48, 5219 49, 18219:1–7 43, 48–49, 5819:2 48–4919:4 55
19:4–7 5519:6 49
19:9–10 4819:10 4819:11 4819:11–18 4819:18–24 4819:20–24 4820 5, 43, 47, 57, 17820:1 5520:1–2 4920:1–23 48–5320:2 4320:3 5520:3–4 5020:5–8 5220:5–9 5020:6 5420:10 5320:10–11 5120:12–16 57
20:12–17 5220:13–17 17920:18–23 5220:20–23 5620:22 5620:24–26 5320:24–34 53–5620:27–29 5420:29 55
20:30. 17920:30–34 5520:35–36 5620:35–42 56–5720:37 5620:38–39 5720:40 5720:41–42 43, 5720:42 179–8021:1 5723:17 43, 5825:43 55 . 931 43, 5731:4 56
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 236/247
2 S 18, 411 43
1:17 771:23 574 1755:6–9 1267:11–16 12411:3 12921 4123:34 129
1 Kg11:41 36–3714:19 3614:29 36–3715:7 36–3715:23 36–3715:31 36–3716:5 36–3716:14 36–3716:20 36
16:27 36–3722:39 36–3722:46 36–37
2 Kg 40–41, 1771:18 36–378:23 36–3710:34 36–3712:20 36–37
13:8 36–3713:12 36–3714:15 36–3714:18 3614:28 36–3715:6 36–3715:11 3615:15 3615:21 36–3715:26 36–3715:31 36–3715:36 36–3716:19 36–3718–19 40–4118:4 35
20:20 36–3721:7 126
21:25 36–3723:28 36–3724:5 36–37
1 C 1231–2 1276 1239:1 369:14–16 1239:39–44 12316 4028:9 3529:7 9729:29 36–37
2 C 123, 1761–9 419:29 36–3710 37, 41
12:15 36–3713 17613–15 17713:4–9 17613:13 17713:23 3413:23–15:15 34, 17514:2 3415 35
15:3–6 3415:4 3515:8 3416:11 36–3720:34 36–3724:27 3625:26 36–3726:22 3727:7 3628:26 36–3732 4032:19 40–4132:32 3633:18 3633:19 36
INDEX OF ANCIEN SOURCES 227
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 237/247
228 BAKHIN AND GENRE HEORY IN BIBLICAL SUDIES
2 Chronicles (cont .)34:7 35
35:25 3635:27 36–3736:8 36
Ez 98, 105, 123–241:2–4 982 1242:2–42 1242:43–58 1242:59–63 1242:62 1244:8 984:8–10 984:8–6:18 974:11–16 984:17–22 984:23–24 985:1–6 985:7–17 98
6:1–2 986:3–12 986:13–18 987 987:12–26 97–988:27 97
N 123–247:69–71 97
E 6, 15 . 11
J 6, 15, 16, 27, 74, 84, 1888:3 74
P 6, 14, 15, 787 74, 8022 78–82, 182–8422:3 18322:4 8022:7 8022:8 18322:12 8022:16 80
22:20–22 7922:21 183
22:23 8022:25 8022:26 8022:29 8122:30–31 81–8237 89–9037:1–2 8937:3 8937:18–19 8938 7938:2–3 7939:5–7 12 . 639:12 12 . 644 77 . 1344:25 7962:10 12 . 669 77 . 1373:2–12 12 . 674 77 . 13
74:1 7979 77 . 1388 8588:7–8 7990:5–6 12 . 694:11 12 . 6102 77 . 13137 77 . 13144:4 12 . 6
Pv 11–121:1 115:18 12 . 68:4–36 1231:1 12
Q 12–13, 15, 17, 1881:12 12 . 52:24 127:16–18 128:11–14 1211:9 1212:1 1212:13–14 12
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 238/247
Sg Sg 12–13, 15, 17, 164 . 13:11 15 . 12
I 40–41, 77, 852:4 3536–37 40
J2 862:2 862:20 862:20–28 862:35 869:9 7710:11 97
L 6, 72, 76–77, 82, 85, 87,1821 77 . 10, 79, 83 . 201–2 5, 70–74, 76–78, 80, 82–85,
87–90
1:5 811:8 811:9 791:11 801:12 801:13 801:14 801:15 801:17 81
1:18 871:21 801:21–22 802 77 . 10, 80–82, 83 . 202:1–2 812:4–5 812:8 842:11–12 822:13 892:18–19 802:19 882:20 892:20–22 802:22 81, 883 77–78, 82–84
3:1–20 843:1–21 82
3:10–12 833:21 843:22 833:22–24 843:22–42 823:25–26 833:39 833:40–42 82, 843:43–48 843:43–66 824 77 . 105 77
Ez 19616 8616:15–20 8616:37–40 8816:39–40 86
D 5, 14 . 9, 98, 1961 92–93, 95–96, 99–100, 104, 1061–2:4 911–6 91, 93–94, 96, 98–99, 104–8,
184–861:1–7 1001:7 1001:8 93, 1011:17 93
1:20–21 1002 93, 96, 101, 102, 106, 107, 1842–6 1062–7 1062:1–4 1052:2 1012:3 98, 1012:4 1062:4 91, 932:4–7:28 912:5 1012:6 1012:9 1012:10 1012:19 101
INDEX OF ANCIEN SOURCES 229
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 239/247
230 BAKHIN AND GENRE HEORY IN BIBLICAL SUDIES
Daniel (cont .)2:22 101
2:25 1012:27 1012:28 1012:30 1012:37 1012:40 1012:46 1012:47 1013 95–96, 101–3, 105, 1073:1 1023:5–7 973:6 1023:7 1023:9 99 . 33:11 1023:15 1023:16–18 1023:17 1023:19 102
3:20 1023:21 1023:22 1023:23 1023:26 1024 102–3, 1074:7–14 1034:8 1024:14 102
4:17 1024:19 1024:22 1024:23 1024:27 1024:29 1024:31 1024:33 1025 95–96, 103, 184, 1865:2 1035:3 1035:4–6 1845:5 1035:6 1035:10 99 . 3
5:10–12 1855:12 103
5:16 1035:26–28 1036 95–96, 103–46:5 1046:6 1046:7 99 . 36:8 1046:9 1046:12 1046:12–14 1046:13 1046:16 1046:22 99 . 36:23–24 1046:29 1057 1067–12 24, 91, 105–77:1 1067:2 107
7:2–14 1067:9 1077:10 1077:11 1077:13 1077:14 1087:14 1087:15 1077:16 107
7:22 1077:28 1078 106, 1078–12 91, 1068:1 1068:2–14 1068:4 1078:7 1078:10 1078:11 1078:12 1078:13 1078:15 1078:17 1078:26 107
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 240/247
8:27 1079:1 106
9:3 1079:22 10710:1 106, 10710:2 10610:6 10610:8 10710:12 10710:17 10710:18 10710:19 10711:1 10611:4 10711:7 10711:11 10711:31 10711:36–37 107
11:38 10612:5 106
12:8 10712:11 10712:13 108
H 11 . 4, 16, 174, 1881–3 164–14 16
J4:10 35
A 153
M4:3 35
M 5–6, 198–99
1:1 1221:1–17 119, 122–31, 1971:3 1271:5 1271:5 1271:6 1291:6 1271:11–12 126, 1971:12–16 125
1:17 1971:19 1301:22–23 1312 1302:1 126, 1302:1–12 1312:5 1262:5–6 1312:15 1312:17–18 1312:23 1314:8–10 13012:6 13015:1–11 13016:17 155
16:17–19 154
20:1–16 13021:12 13021:28–46 13023:25–26 13026:61 13027:40 13027:51 130
M 132, 138, 158
1:24 15515:33–39 174
J 6, 134–39, 141–46, 149, 152–54,157–59, 189, 200–2011:1–18 141 . 121:19–28 1461:19–34 148 . 181:20 1481:21 1481:27 1481:35–43 148 . 181:35–51 1491:47–51 146 . 162 142
New estament
INDEX OF ANCIEN SOURCES 231
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 241/247
232 BAKHIN AND GENRE HEORY IN BIBLICAL SUDIES
John (cont .)2:1–11 148 . 18
2:13–25 146 . 162:18 146–472:19–21 1462:22 1463:1–21 149 . 19, 1503:2 1503:3 1503:5 1503:15–17 1413:22–36 148 . 183:28 1483:30 1494:4–42 146 . 164:24 1484:26 1484:27 148 . 184:31–38 148 . 184:46–54 148 . 185 146–47
5:5–15 141 . 125:10–18 1475:16–47 146 . 165:39–40 1475:46 1476 138–39, 140 . 11, 147, 150,
153–54, 1576:5–15 151 . 206:14 154
6:20 1486:25–30 156 . 236:30–59 149 . 196:32 1506:32–33 1436:44 1416:51 1536:52 1536:60–66 152 . 216:65 1416:66 153–446:67–71 154 . 227 146–477:1–10 147, 152 . 217:11–24 149 . 19
7:16–18 141, 1477:19–24 147
7:25 1477:25–27 1477:25–44 146 . 167:28–29 1477:33 1477:37–39 1477:40–43 1477:44–48 1487:45–52 146 . 167:50–52 1488:12–58 149 . 198:24 1488:28 1488:32 1438:58 1489 139 . 99:1–7 156 . 239:8–34 149 . 199:22 146
9:35–10:21 149 . 1910:22–39 141 . 1210:30 14111:1–16 156 . 2311:17–45 141 . 1212:4–7 156 . 2312:20–50 141 . 1212:42 14612:42–43 150
13:1–20 154 . 2213:13 14813:17 15513:19 14813:21–30 154 . 2213:31–38 154 . 2214:1–31 151 . 2014:9–11 14115–17 13816 15616:2 14616:17–18 15616:17–33 152 . 2117 15617:1–26 141 . 12
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 242/247
17:8 14118:1–9 151 . 20
18:5 14818:6 14818:8 14818:19–24 146 . 1618:28–32 14318:28–40 15118:28–19:16 151 . 2018:33 14318:34 14318:35 14318:36–37 14318:37 14818:38 14318:39–19:16 14419:1–16 15119:17–22 14420:10–18 141 . 1220:21–23 15420:24–29 156 . 23
20:27 15720:31 14121 138, 155
21:1–14 154 . 2221:15–17 154 . 22
21:18–22 152 . 2121:18–23 15821:18–25 156 . 23
R 164, 1749:25 174
H11:31 128
1 J2:18–25 149 . 19, 1524:1–3 152
2 J7 152
3 J 1549–10 139 . 9, 154 . 22
Rv 24, 26, 138, 196–97
Extrabiblical Literature
Apyp W 26
2 B 2453–74 125
Cy R (CD)9:10 12512:23 12514:18 12519:10 125
1 E 24, 125, 196
2 E
2 113
4 Ez 24, 11312:32 125
J 26, 12541:1 129
P S
17 12417:4 12517:21 125
p S 26
A10:5–12 114
J
10:1 129
Lv2–5 26
INDEX OF ANCIEN SOURCES 233
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 243/247
234 BAKHIN AND GENRE HEORY IN BIBLICAL SUDIES
S47:22 124
A, opica10135–36 109 . 110214–16 109 . 1
P, De Decalogo36–39 10
P, De Virtutibus220 129220–222 129
P, Phaedrus237 38
P, Republic 38–397 134 . 3
P, Symposium 206 38
P, Teatetus
189–190 136
Py ( Yg), Epistulae10.96–97 152
Other
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 244/247
A, Dv 92A, I 14 . 10, 73 . 7
Ay, P R. 34Agz, L 109A, D C. 127–29A, R 55 . 9, 60, 181A, P N. 4, 6, 133–59, 187,
199–201A, J Cp 127Aq, T 127A 109 . 1
A, B . 92, 96, 99, 103–4A, Dv E. 121Av, H I. 101B, A 120B, J A. 6B, J 37B, C.K. 136, 200B, R 138 . 7B, Dv R. 128B, L. F. 71 . 6B 86–87B, T 31–32B, D 36Bg, J 75 . 8B-P, Zv 162B Zv, E 44, 70Bg, Dv A. 6B, A 76–77, 78 . 14, 79 . 17Bz, T 27
Bzz, P 187Bpp, Jp 41B, E 2B, M 76B, K 175–86
Bg, P 152B, R. B 34, 131–32
B, Ay 103B, Ry E. 125, 127, 139 .
10, 146 . 16, 148 . 18, 149–50, 152 .21, 154 . 22, 155, 156–57 . 23
B, Ggy C. 6Bgg, W 60Bè, F 27B, R 4, 19B, K 187, 191, 202–3
Bg, R A. 20, 121B, M J. 4, 9–18, 19, 69, 73 . 7,
74, 187–91Cp, Ay F. 52 . 6, 56 . 11Cp, R I. 96C, W 125, 127–29Cg, M G. 6Cy, R J. 151 . 20Cv, Mg 134–35, 200C, Pp P. 100C, Bv 41C, B 163, 165–66, 169–70C, K 45, 158–59C, L. J M. 6, 141 . 13C, R 6Cy, Evy 33Cg, M 41C, Rp 21 . 3, 31C, A Y 20
C, J 4, 5, 20, 22, 24–26, 91. 1, 109, 112, 116, 196
Cp, J S. 97C, P W. 102Cg, K M. 6
-235-
Index of Authors
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 245/247
236 BAKHIN AND GENRE HEORY IN BIBLICAL SUDIES
C, J 23, 191D, C 27
Dv, W D. 127–29Dv, E 183D, F 105Dz, G 4, 39–40D, Jq 21D, M 4, 19D L, A A. 103D-App, F. W. 76–78, 80–81 .
18–19, 82, 86, 90Dvy, Fy 134, 143, 200D, Dv 27–28D, Ry K. 37D, F 34Dy, J Fy 136 . 5E, D V 48 . 4E, J. H 135 . 4E, Cy 44, 45 . 3, 46, 76,
119–20, 126, 134 . 2, 135–36 . 4–5,148, 161, 170
F, G 29, 193F-W, Jy 4–5, 59–68,
180–82F, D N 101F, Ivg L. 97F, A A. 12 . 6Fv, Dv 23 . 4, 26 . 6, 27, 70F, J P. 47–48 . 4, 52–55 .
6–9, 56 . 11
F, M 4, 35–36, 39–40F, A 20–23, 26, 28, 78 .14–15, 135 . 4, 191–92
F, M V. 12F, Sg 39Fy, Np 31F, Cp C. 4–6, 119–32, 187,
197–99F, R 20G, Dv E. 128Gy, P 164, 171–72Ggy, J 101–2, 104G, E. H. 21, 191G, Pp 40G, Dv B. 195
G, B 4–6, 18, 43–58, 122,177–80
Gy, R H. 127G, H 3–5, 9–10, 17–18,
19, 69, 75 . 8, 190–91G, Dv 101Hg, D A. 127Hg, D J. 127, 129H, 167Hg, G. W. F. 4, 27, 39–40H, J P 128Hz, M 102Hzg, B 187Hgg, T E. 169H, D 77 . 10, 78H, E.D., J. 32Hp, K 45H, y 108Hq, M 39 . 1, 45–46, 135–
36 . 4–5, 158–59, 187, 190, 203Hv, T B. 174
Hg, J 97Igy, L 39I, Wgg 32J, R 135 . 4J, M S. 92Jp, S 34J, H R 19J, S P 66J 127
Jg, Dv 55 . 9J, M 124–25, 128–29J, M 190, 193Kä, E 154 . 22, 156K, Sv A. 97K, Cg S. 127, 129Kpp, Gy N. 37K, M P. 6Kz, L 165L, Jq 4, 39L, Jy 120–22, 197, 199L, Gg 25 . 5, 88 . 24, 190,
193Lv, J 55 . 9Lv, Ay-J 128–30
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 246/247
Lv, H 6L, B 138, 152
L, Y 41Lg, P 38Lz, U 126, 128M, B 4, 6, 161–74, 187, 201Mg, G. 71 . 6M, Ez S. 6M, C 4, 6, 69–90, 182–84My, J. L 137–38, 139 . 9, 149,
153MC, Dv 6M, . J. 101–3Mvv, Pv 29–30, 111M, Wy A. 137, 153M, D 92M, P 84M, J 189M, C W. 6M, My E. 12 . 5M, C 4, 31–42, 175–77
M, Sp D. 39–40 . 1M, 6, 161–74, 188, 201M, Gy S 34, 44, 45 . 3, 46,
76, 119–20, 126, 134 . 2, 135–36 .4–5, 148, 161, 170
M, Sg 75 . 8M, G 97My, J M. 34N, C A. 4, 6, 17 . 13,
19–30, 70, 84, 87–88 . 23, 88–89, 141. 13, 187, 191–92, 196Nz, F 39O’C, M. 37O, D . 6P, D 128P, Dv 135–36 . 5P, A 127P, S 103, 185P, L 163
P, Ly 170–71P, J 172, 201P, Ay J. 99P, X Hg T 81 . 19P 10, 129
P 32, 38, 134–35, 200P, J. Dv 52 . 6
Pz, R 2, 6, 35, 47, 51 . 5, 177R, G v 11 . 3, 14 . 10, 59,R, P 12 . 6Ry, L 164R, P L. 91 . 1R, W L. 6Rg, Dv 149R, M 40R, V K. 3, 187–203R, H. W. 14 . 10R, E 24, 192R, A 21–22, 32, 191R-B, Hg 92R, P 126Ry, M-L 26Sg, J 127Sg, A 12 . 5Sg, R 128S, S 141
S, U 152S, J C. 85, 95, 100S, D 127–28S, C. L. 137Sé, A 91–92, 106Svv, M 135–36 . 5Svy, V 27 . 7, 28Sg, M 24–6, 29, 192Sg, A 136 . 5
S-Cp, D 71 . 4, 98,102S, D C. 91Sy, J 32Sp, E.A. 59, 181S, Gy 55 . 9–10S, K 127S, G Cg 66 . 1S, J M. 23–24Sy, Mv 70
, Hy 41, C H. 121Tp, Cv 28, My A 121, P K. 6, 70 . 1, 85–86 . 21
INDEX OF AUHORS 237
8/4/2019 Bakhtin and Genre Theory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bakhtin-and-genre-theory 247/247
238 BAKHIN AND GENRE HEORY IN BIBLICAL SUDIES
, M 29, 193yyv, Y 27 . 7
V, Dv M. 4–5, 91–108, 184–86V Dv, H. J. M. 103V L, Ry C. 70V, S 92V M E 4 5 98 109 17 121
W, F 6Wz, Sg 97
W, J-W 97W, C 14 . 10W, H. G. M. 34W, L M. 196W R 123 125